Introduction To The Theory of Complex Systems Stefan Thurner Ebook All Chapters PDF
Introduction To The Theory of Complex Systems Stefan Thurner Ebook All Chapters PDF
Introduction To The Theory of Complex Systems Stefan Thurner Ebook All Chapters PDF
com
https://textbookfull.com/product/introduction-to-
the-theory-of-complex-systems-stefan-thurner/
https://textbookfull.com/product/introduction-to-complex-theory-of-
differential-equations-savin/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-complex-systems-
making-sense-of-a-changing-world-tranquillo/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-complex-systems-
society-ecology-and-nonlinear-dynamics-1st-edition-paul-fieguth-auth/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/widgets-the-12-new-rules-for-
managing-your-employees-as-if-they-re-real-people-rodd-wagner/
textbookfull.com
Microbes and Enzymes in Soil Health and Bioremediation
Ashok Kumar
https://textbookfull.com/product/microbes-and-enzymes-in-soil-health-
and-bioremediation-ashok-kumar/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/r-graphics-cookbook-practical-
recipes-for-visualizing-data-2nd-edition-winston-chang/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/educational-psychology-developing-
learners-11th-edition-eric-m-anderman/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/my-own-devices-essays-from-the-road-
on-music-science-and-senseless-love-dessa/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/nate-1st-edition-tijan-tijan/
textbookfull.com
Introduction to the Theory
of Complex Systems
Stefan Thurner, Rudolf Hanel, and Peter Klimek
Medical University of Vienna, Austria
1
3
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford, OX2 6DP,
United Kingdom
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship,
and education by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of
Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries
© Stefan Thurner, Rudolf Hanel, and Peter Klimek 2018
The moral rights of the authors have been asserted
First Edition published in 2018
Impression: 1
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in
a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the
prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted
by law, by licence or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics
rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the
above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the
address above
You must not circulate this work in any other form
and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer
Published in the United States of America by Oxford University Press
198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Data available
Library of Congress Control Number: 2018947065
Data available
ISBN 978–0–19–882193–9
DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780198821939.001.0001
Printed and bound by
CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon, CR0 4YY
Links to third party websites are provided by Oxford in good faith and
for information only. Oxford disclaims any responsibility for the materials
contained in any third party website referenced in this work.
Preface
This book is for people who are interested in the science of complex adaptive systems
and wish to have more than just a casual understanding of it. As with all the sciences,
understanding of complex adaptive systems is reached solely in a quantitative, predictive,
and ultimately experimentally testable manner. Complex adaptive systems are dynamical
systems that are able to change their structure, their interactions, and, consequently,
their dynamics as they evolve in time. This is not a book about complicated systems,
even though most complex systems are complicated. Indeed, over the last 300 years,
scientists have usually dealt with complicated systems that are neither complex nor
adaptive.
The theory of complex systems is the theory of generalized time-varying interactions
between elements that are characterized by states. Interactions typically take place on
networks that connect those elements. The interactions involved may cause the states
of the elements themselves to alter over time. The essence of a complex system is that
the interaction networks may change and rearrange as a consequence of changes in
the states of the elements. Thus, complex systems are systems whose states change
as a result of interactions and whose interactions change concurrently as a result of
states. Due to this chicken–egg-type problem, complex systems show an extremely
rich spectrum of behaviour: they are adaptive and co-evolutionary; they show path-
dependence, emergence, power laws; they have rich phase diagrams; they produce
and destroy diversity; they are inherently prone to collapse; they are resilient, and so
on. The theory of complex systems tries to understand these properties based on its
building blocks and on the interactions between those building blocks that take place
on networks. It combines mathematical and physical principles with concepts borrowed
from biology and the social sciences; it uses new computational techniques and, with
the advent of comprehensive large-scale data sets, is becoming experimentally testable.
The goal of the theory of complex systems is to understand the dynamical systemic
outcomes of interconnected systems, and its ultimate goal is to eventually control and
design systemic properties of systems such as the economy, the financial system, social
processes, cities, the climate, and ecology. The theory of complex systems builds partly
on previous attempts to understand systems that interact in non-trivial ways, such as
game theory, cybernetics, or systems theory. However, in its current state, the science
of complex systems goes well beyond these earlier developments, in so many ways,
in fact, that it can be regarded as an independent scientific branch, which—due to its
quantitative, predictive, and testable nature—is a natural science.
Even though it is fair to say that the theory of complex systems is not yet complete,
in recent years, it has become quite clear just what the theory is going to look like.
Its elements and structure are emerging. The current state of the theory of complex
vi Preface
systems is comparable perhaps to the state of quantum mechanics in the 1920s, before
the famous Copenhagen meetings and Werner Heisenberg’s book. At that time, quantum
mechanics was a collection of experimental and theoretical bits and pieces, which
had not yet been seen within a fully comprehensive framework. Nevertheless, it was
clear that, one day soon, such a framework would exist. The present situation can
be compared to an archaeological project, where a mosaic floor has been discovered
and is being excavated. While the mosaic is only partly visible and the full picture is
still missing, several facts are becoming clear: the mosaic exists; it shows identifiable
elements (for instance, people and animals engaged in recognizable activities); there
are large patches missing or still invisible, but experts can already tell that the mosaic
represents a scene from, say, Homer’s Odyssey. Similarly, for dynamical complex adaptive
systems, it is clear that a theory exists that, eventually, can be fully developed. There
are those who say that complex systems will never be understood or that, by their very
nature, they are incomprehensible. This book will demonstrate that such statements are
incorrect. The elements of a theory of complex systems are becoming clear: dynamical
multilayer networks, scaling, statistical mechanics of algorithmic dynamics, evolution
and co-evolution, and information theory. The essence of this book is to focus on these
components, clarify their meaning in the context of complex systems, and enable the
reader with a mathematical skill set to apply them to concrete problems in the world of
complex systems.
The book is written in mathematical language because this is the only way to
express facts in a quantitative and predictive manner and to make statements that are
unambiguous. We aim for consistency. The book should be comprehensible so that no-
one with an understanding of basic calculus, linear algebra, and statistics need refer
to other works. The book is particularly designed for graduate students in physics or
mathematics. We try to avoid ambiguous statements while, at the same time, being as
general as possible. The hope is that this work will serve as a textbook and as a starting
point for journeys into new and unexplored territory.
Many complex systems are often sensitive to details in their internal setup, to initial
and to boundary conditions. Concepts that proved to be extremely robust and effective in
non-complex systems, such as the central limit theorem, classical statistical mechanics, or
information theory, lose their predictive power when confronted with complex systems.
Extreme care is thus needed in any attempt to apply these otherwise distinguished
concepts to complex systems: doing so could end in confusion and nonsensical results.
In several concrete examples, we will demonstrate the importance of understanding what
these methods mean in the context of complex systems and whether they can or cannot
be applied. We will discuss how some of these classical concepts can be generalized to
become useful for understanding complex systems.
The book is also a statement about our belief that the exact sciences may be entering
a phase of transition from a traditional analytical description of nature, as used with
tremendous success since Galileo and Newton, towards an algorithmic description.
Whereas the analytical description of nature is, conceptually, based largely on differential
equations and analytical equations of motion, the algorithmic view takes into account
evolutionary and co-evolutionary aspects of dynamics. It provides a framework for
Preface vii
systems that can endogenously change their internal interaction networks, rules of
functioning, dynamics, and even environment, as they evolve in time. Algorithmic
dynamics, which is characteristic of complex dynamical systems, may be a key to the
quantitative and predictive understanding of many natural and man-made systems. In
contrast to physical systems, which typically evolve analytically, algorithmic dynamics
describe certainly how living, social, environmental, and economic systems unfold.
This algorithmic view is not new but has been advocated by authors like Joseph A.
Schumpeter, Stuart Kauffman, and Brian Arthur. However, it has not, to date, been
picked up by mainstream science, and it has never been presented in the context of the
theory of complex systems.
This book is based on a two-semester course, that has been held at the Medical
University of Vienna since 2011. We are grateful to our students and to Kathryn Platzer
and Anita Wanjek for helping us with the manuscript.
ST Vienna January 2018
Contents
References 407
Index 425
1
Introduction to Complex Systems
Physics is the experimental, quantitative, and predictive science of matter and its
interactions.
Introduction to the Theory of Complex Systems. Stefan Thurner, Rudolf Hanel, and Peter Klimek,
Oxford University Press (2018). © Stefan Thurner, Rudolf Hanel, and Peter Klimek.
DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780198821939.001.0001
2 Introduction to Complex Systems
Physics deals with matter at various scales and levels of granularity, ranging from
macroscopic matter like galaxies, stars, planets, stones, and projectiles, to the scale of
molecules, atoms, hadrons, quarks, and gauge bosons. There are four fundamental forces
at the core of all interactions between all forms of matter: gravity, electromagnetism and
two types of nuclear force: the weak and the strong. According to quantum field theory,
all interactions in the physical world are mediated by the exchange of gauge bosons. The
graviton, the boson for gravity, has not yet been confirmed experimentally.
Characteristic
Matter Interaction types length scale
is relevant. We will see that this is drastically different in complex systems, where a
multitude of different interaction types of similar strength often have to be taken into
account simultaneously.
Typically, physics does not specify which particles interact with each other, as
they interact in identical ways. The interaction strength depends only on the relevant
interaction type, the form of the potential, and the relative distance between particles.
In complex systems, interactions are often specific. Not all elements, only certain pairs or
groups of elements, interact with each other. Networks are used to keep track of which
elements interact with others in a complex system.
where t is time, x(t) is the trajectory, m is mass of the stone, and F is force on the
stone. In our case, we would hope to identify the force with gravity, meaning that
F = gm.
2. Once the equation is specified, try to solve it. The equation can be solved
using elementary calculus, and we get, x(t) = x0 + v0 t + 12 gt 2 . To make a testable
prediction we have to fix the boundary or initial conditions; in our case we have
to specify what the initial position x0 and initial velocity v0 are in our experiment.
Once this is done, we have a prediction for the trajectory of the stone, x(t).
3. Compare the result with your experiments. Does the stone really follow this
predicted path x(t)? If it does, you might claim that you have understood
something on a quantitative, predictive, and experimental basis. If the stone
(repeatedly) follows another trajectory, you have to try harder to find a better
prediction.
Fixing initial or boundary conditions means simply taking the system out of its
context, separating it from the rest of the universe. There are no factors, other than
the boundary conditions, that influence the motion of the system from the outside. That
4 Introduction to Complex Systems
such a separation of systems from their context is indeed possible is one reason why
physics has been so successful, even before computing devices became available. For
many complex systems, it is impossible to separate the dynamics from the context in
a clear way. This means that many outside influences that are not under experimental
control will simultaneously determine their dynamics.
In principle, the same thinking used to describe physical phenomena holds for
arbitrarily complicated systems. Assume that a vector X (t) represents the state of a
system at a given time (e.g. all positions and momenta of its elements), we then get a
set of equations of motion in the form,
d 2 X (t)
= G(X (t)),
dt 2
mv2
p(v) ∼ v2 exp − ,
2kT
For non-interacting particles, these predictions can be extremely precise. The predictions
immediately start to degenerate as soon as there are strong interactions between the
particles or if the number of particles is not large enough. Note that the term prediction
now has a much weaker meaning than in the Newton–Laplace program. The meaning
has shifted from being a description based on the exact knowledge of each component
of a system to one based on a probabilistic knowledge of the system. Even though one
can still make extremely precise predictions about multiparticle systems in a probabilistic
framework, the concept of determinism is now diluted. The framework for predictions
on a macroscopic level about systems composed of many particles on a probabilistic
basis is called statistical mechanics.
In the classical mechanics of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, prediction meant
the exact prediction of trajectories. Equations of motion would make exact statements
about the future evolution of simple dynamical systems. The extension to more than
two bodies has been causing problems since the very beginning of Newtonian physics;
see, for example, the famous conflict between Isaac Newton and John Flamsteed on the
predictability of the orbit of the Moon. By about 1900, when interest in understanding
many-body systems arose, the problem became apparent. The theory of Ludwig Boltz-
mann, referred to nowadays as statistical mechanics, was effectively based on the then
speculative existence of atoms and molecules, and it drastically changed the classical
concept of predictability.
In statistical mechanics, based on the assumption that atoms and molecules follow
Newtonian trajectories, the law of large numbers allows stochastic predictions to be
made about the macroscopic behaviour of gases. Statistical mechanics is a theory of
the macroscopic or collective behaviour of non-interacting particles. The concepts of
predictability and determinism were subject to further change in the 1920s with the
emergence of quantum mechanics and non-linear dynamics.
In quantum mechanics, the concept of determinism disappears altogether due to
the fundamental simultaneous unpredictability of the position and momentum of the
(sub-)atomic components of a system. However, quantum mechanics still allows us to
make extremely high-quality predictions on a collective basis. Collective phenomena
remain predictable to a large extent on a macro- or systemic level.
In non-linear systems, it became clear that even in systems for which the equations of
motion can be solved in principle, the sensitivity to initial conditions can be so enormous
that the concept of predictability must, for all practical purposes, be abandoned. A further
crisis in terms of predictability arose in the 1990s, when interest in more general forms
of interactions began to appear.
In complex systems, the situation is even more difficult than in quantum mechanics,
where there is uncertainty about the components, but not about its interactions. For
many complex systems, not only can components be unpredictable, but the interactions
between components can also become specific, time-dependent, non-linear, and unpre-
dictable. However, there is still hope that probabilistic predictions about the dynamics
and the collective properties of complex systems are possible. Progress in the science of
complex systems will, however, be impossible without a detailed understanding of the
dynamics of how elements specifically interact with each other. This is, of course, only
possible with massive computational effort and comprehensive data.
This is radically different for complex systems, where interactions themselves can
change over time as a consequence of the dynamics of the system. In that sense, complex
systems change their internal interaction structure as they evolve. Systems that change
their internal structure dynamically can be viewed as machines that change their internal
structure as they operate. However, a description of the operation of a machine using
analytical equations would not be efficient. Indeed, to describe a steam engine by seeking
the corresponding equations of motion for all its parts would be highly inefficient.
Machines are best described as algorithms—a list of rules regarding how the dynamics of
the system updates its states and future interactions, which then lead to new constraints
on the dynamics at the next time step. First, pressure builds up here, then a valve opens
there, vapour pushes this piston, then this valve closes and opens another one, driving
the piston back, and so on.
Algorithmic descriptions describe not only the evolution of the states of the com-
ponents of a system, but also the evolution of its internal states (interactions) that will
determine the next update of the states at the next time step. Many complex systems work
in this way: states of components and the interactions between them are simultaneously
updated, which can lead to the tremendous mathematical difficulties that make complex
systems so hard to understand. These difficulties in their various forms will be addressed
time and again in this book. Whenever it is possible to ignore the changes in the
interactions in a dynamical system, analytic descriptions become meaningful.
With these extensions, we can derive a physics-based definition for what the theory
of complex systems is.
Generalized interactions are described by the interaction type and who interacts with
whom at what time and at what strength. If there are more than two interacting elements
involved, interactions can be conveniently described by time-dependent networks,
Mijα (t),
where i and j label the elements in the system, and α denotes the interaction type.
Mijα (t) are matrix elements of a structure with three indices. The value Mijα (t) indicates
the strength of the interaction of type α between element i and j at time t. Mijα (t) = 0
means no interaction of that type. Interactions in complex systems remain based on the
concept of exchange; however, they are not limited to the exchange of gauge bosons. In
complex systems, interactions can happen through communication, where messages are
exchanged, through trade where goods and services are exchanged, through friendships,
where bottles of wine are exchanged, and through hostility, where insults and bullets are
exchanged.
Because of more specific and time-varying interactions and the increased variety of
types of interaction, the variety of macroscopic states and systemic properties increases
drastically in complex systems. This diversity increase of macrostates and phenomena
emerges from the properties both of the system’s components and its interactions.
The phenomenon of collective properties arising that are, a priori, unexpected from
the elements alone is sometimes called emergence. This is mainly a consequence of the
presence of generalized interactions. Systems with time-varying generalized interactions
can exhibit an extremely rich phase structure and may be adaptive. Phases may co-exist
in particular complex systems. The plurality of macrostates in a system leads to new types
Components from physics 9
of questions that can be addressed, such as: what is the number of macrostates? What are
their co-occurrence rates? What are the typical sequences of occurrence? What are the
life-times of macrostates? What are the probabilities of transition between macrostates?
As yet, there are no general answers to these questions, and they remain a challenge for
the theory of complex systems. For many complex systems, the framework of physics is
incomplete. Some of the missing concepts are those of non-equilibrium, evolution, and
co-evolution. These concepts will be illustrated in the sections that follow.
αA + βB ⇋ σ S + τ T ,
where α, β, σ , τ are the stoichiometric constants, and k+ and k− are the forward and
backward reaction rates, respectively. The forward reaction happens at a rate that is
proportional to k+ {A}α {B}β , the backward reaction is proportional to k− {S}σ {T }τ . The
brackets indicate the active (reacting) masses of the substances. Equilibrium is attained
if the ratio of the reaction rates equals a constant K,
k+ {S}σ {T }τ
K= = .
k− {A}α {B}β
Note that the solution to this equation gives the stationary concentrations of the
various substances. Technically, these equations are fixed point equations. In contrast to
chemical reactions and statistical mechanics, many complex systems are characterized
by being out-of-equilibrium. Complex systems are often so-called driven systems, where
the system is (exogenously) driven away from its equilibrium states. If there is no
equilibrium, there is no way of using fixed-point-type equations to solve the problems.
The mathematical difficulties in dealing with out-of-equilibrium or non-equilibrium
systems are tremendous and generally beyond analytical reach. One way that offers
a handle on understanding driven out-of-equilibrium systems is the concept of self-
organized criticality, which allows essential elements of the statistics of complex systems
to be understood; in particular, the omnipresence of power laws.
The life sciences describe the experimental science of living matter. What is living
matter? A reasonable minimal answer has been attempted by the following three
statements [223]:
Life without self-replication is not sustainable. It is, of course, conceivable that non-
self-replicating organisms can be created that live for a time and then vanish and have to
be recreated. However, this is not how we experience life on the planet, which is basically
a single, continuous, living germ line that originated about 3.5 billion years ago, and has
existed ever since. A Carnot cycle is a thermodynamic cyclical process that converts
thermal energy into work, or vice versa. Starting from an initial state, after the cycle is
completed, the system returns to the same initial state. The notion that living matter must
perform at least one Carnot cycle is motivated by the fact that all living organisms use
energy gradients (usually thermal) to perform work of some kind. For example, this work
could be used for moving or copying DNA molecules. This view also pays tribute to the
fact that all living objects are out-of-equilibrium and constantly driven by energy gradi-
ents. If, after performing work, a system were not able to reach its previous states, it would
be hard to call it a living system. Both self-replication and Carnot cycles require some
sort of localization. On this planet, this localization typically happens at the level of cells.
Living matter uses energy and performs work on short timescales without signifi-
cantly transforming itself. It is constantly driven by energy gradients and is out-of-
equilibrium. Self-replication and Carnot cycles require localization.
Figure 1.1 Schematic view of genetic activity and what a link Mki means in a genetic regulatory
network. (a) Gene i activates gene k if something like the following process takes place: the activity of
gene i means that a specific sub-sequence of the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) (gene) is copied into a
complementary structure, an mRNA molecule. This mRNA molecule from gene i, might get ‘translated’
(copied again) into a protein of type i.This protein can bind with other proteins to form a cluster of proteins,
a ‘complex’. Such complexes can bind to other regions of the DNA, say, the region that is associated with
gene k, and thereby cause the activation of gene k. (b) Gene i causes gene j to become active, which activates
genes m and n. (c) The process, where the activity of gene i triggers the activity of other genes, can be
represented as a directed genetic regulatory network. Complexes can also deactivate genes. If gene j is
active, a complex might deactivate it.
‘on’ and ‘off’. If a gene is on, it triggers the production of molecular material, such as
ribonucleic acid (RNA) that can later be translated into proteins. A gene is typically
turned on by a cluster of proteins that bind to each other to form a so-called ‘complex’.
If such a cluster binds to a specific location on the DNA, this could cause a copying
process to be activated at this position; the gene is then active or ‘on’; see Figure 1.1.
Genetic activity is based on chemical reactions that take place locally, usually within
cells or their nuclei. However, these chemical reactions are special in the sense that only
a few molecules are involved [341]. In traditional chemistry, reactions usually involve
billions of atoms or molecules. What happens within a cell is chemistry with a few
molecules. This immediately leads to a number of problems:
If there is no law of mass action, how can chemistry be done? Classical equilibrium
chemistry is inadequate for dealing with molecular mechanisms in living matter. In
cells, molecules are often actively transported from the site of production (typically, the
nucleus, for organisms that have one) to where they are needed in the cell. This means
that diffusion of molecules no longer follows the classical diffusion equation. Instead,
molecular transport is often describable by an anomalous diffusion equation of the form,
d d 2+ν
p(x, t) = D 2+ν p(x, t)µ ,
dt dx
“Tierra del Fuego,” meaning the land of the fire, exclaimed the
followers of Magellan, as they saw the wreaths of smoke ascending
through the frosty air. It was merely the signal fires of the Indians
dwelling on one of the islands of that remote southern archipelago,
when they beheld the strange white-winged vessels of Magellan sailing
through the Straits, since named after him. The name has clung to the
group of islands during the succeeding centuries, although thousands of
white people have since placed foot on them and the name is known to
be a misnomer, for no volcanic fires exist there.
Beginning in Alaska, a chain of gigantic granite vertebrae extends
clear to Cape Horn. It clings close to the Pacific coast throughout the
entire distance, and ends in grandeur near the Antarctic Circle. Some
say that the lower end of this backbone of the American continents was
shattered by a convulsion, in which mighty masses of rock were thrown
off into the ocean, thus forming the numberless islands which lie at the
southern extremity of South America. The better theory, however, is that
they were formed by the submerging of the lower end of the Andes
Mountains. When the land sank the stormy water beat through the
valleys and chiselled the shores into incongruous shapes and labyrinths.
Between the islands and the mainland are the Straits of Magellan.
Some of the finest scenery in the world is found in this intricate
waterway, especially in what is known as Smyth’s Channel, which
separates Southern Chile from the group of islands. Smyth’s Channel is
very narrow, so that most vessels take the broader Straits. The depth
has never been fathomed. There is a grandeur in the serrated peaks,
and cliffs, snowy crests, cascades and the glaciers under a brilliant sun
and deep blue sky that is simply overwhelming. Numerous mountain
peaks reveal themselves, of which Mt. Sarmiento is the noblest, and lifts
its snowy head to a height of over seven thousand feet. Its beauty is
enhanced by numerous blue-tinted glaciers, which descend to the
waters of the sea like a multitude of frozen Niagaras. Floating glaciers
are common in the Straits, and vessels, unequipped with ice-making
machinery, often tie up to one while the crew chop enough ice to fill the
refrigerators.
Few places on the earth’s surface within easy reach can compare with
the Straits of Magellan. This channel has become the great trade route
between the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. Few boats, except sailing
vessels, now take the longer route around Cape Horn, because of the
storms that lash the Antarctic seas into fury. For several hundred miles
the Straits furnish a succession of beautiful scenes; green shores
alternating with the eternal glaciers of the mountain peaks, blue waters
contrasting with the shimmering crystal of the floating icebergs. These
masses of ice are as imperishable as the glaciers of Greenland, and they
add a feature to the scenery that is not to be found elsewhere within the
ordinary course of steamers. It is a region of marvellous sunsets as well
as rugged scenery, when the weather is clear, but mist, snow or rain
often dim the view.
IN THE STRAITS OF MAGELLAN.
Punta Arenas is the business centre of the region extending from Port
Desire, on the Patagonian coast to Cape Horn, and from the Falkland
Islands on the east to the westernmost limits of Chile. The little
settlement that originally was established there was called La Colonia de
Magellanes. On the 21st of April, 1843, Chile first planted her tri-
coloured banner at a place near here, which was called Port Famine,
because of the disastrous end of the Sarmiento settlement, which had
been located there a couple of centuries previously.
Chile had a double purpose in establishing this post. One was its
desire to hold the territory as a national possession, and the other was
to establish a penal colony which would be so far away from the capital
that the prisoners, even if they escaped, could not return. Several
hundred prisoners were generally confined there, who were kept in
subjection by a small company of soldiers. On two occasions the
convicts rebelled and took possession of this settlement. On one of
these the governor and many of the guards were killed and the
mutineers boarded a ship that chanced to be in the harbour, but they
were overtaken by a Chilean man-of-war and overcome. The men were
hung, and it is said that a man was seen hanging from every yard-arm
of the war-ship. After the first revolt a new settlement was established
on the present site of Punta Arenas, which was given the old name. The
tongue of sand there, however, the English-speaking people called
Sandy Point, and thereafter the name Punta Arenas, which means the
same in Spanish, was given it; at least it is entirely known by that name
now.
In 1877 the last revolt occurred, when the convicts revenged the
cruelties to which they had been subjected upon the commander of the
garrison and many of the soldiers. When a man-of-war appeared they
fled into the interior, where most of them died from starvation and
hardships. The establishment of the Pacific Steam Navigation Company
was the cause of the abandonment of this place as a penal colony. It
proved to be a convenient stopping place for the steamers to take on
coal and supplies, and this gave it a new life. Later came the discovery
of gold, which brought many to the settlement. Still later a Scotchman
brought some sheep from the Falkland Islands, and found that the
region around Punta Arenas and on the island opposite was well
adapted for sheep raising. Others took advantage of this experience,
until the neighbourhood around became noted for its sheep culture.
Some day, if a freezing establishment should be established here, Punta
Arenas will become a still more important place, and it is undoubtedly
only a question of time until such will be done. The town itself makes a
poor foreground for the magnificent setting of nature. It is laid out on
the usual checkerboard plan, with several streets running from the
shores back up the hills. It has a plaza and the streets are unpaved. The
beach is sandy and the streets are either filled with loose sand or mud.
Across the Straits the green hills of Tierra del Fuego may be seen
rising, and over to the south the snow-capped peaks of Mt. Sarmiento
and its neighbours appear above the horizon. To the west are mountains
which are ever green and rise boldly up to the western edge, while to
the north the hills are generally bare. At one time it was thought that
coal had been discovered and the mine was opened up; some track was
built and an old locomotive brought down. It proved, however, to be
only lignite, and so the mine has been practically abandoned.
A considerable trade has been developed in Indian curios and goods.
The Indians from the pampas and islands come here to sell their furs,
feathers, bows, hides, etc. Passengers passing through the Straits on
the various steamers usually lay in a supply of these goods, some of
which are genuine and others are prepared especially for such
passengers. One wonders at the number of palms and plants which are
seen in this town so far beyond all other settlements, for even wild
flowers of certain kinds seem to grow in great profusion, while ferns and
lichens everywhere delight the eye.
South of Punta Arenas there is only one settlement of any importance,
and that is Ushuaia. This town is situated on the Argentine side of Tierra
del Fuego, and, small as it is, it is the capital of that territory. It stands
nearer to the South Pole than any other civilized village in the world.
The barriers created by nature are almost insurmountable. To the south
is the unknown Antarctic, to the north the impassable barrier of snow-
clad peaks, and in all other directions are the fathomless channels
separating it from the other islands. Established first as a mission
settlement, its site was selected as the capital of the territory. The
Argentine flag was first unfolded over the first building erected for the
use of officials in 1884. Shortly after that work upon prisons was begun,
and it became a still more important settlement. Here, in this isolated
quarter of the globe, guarded by a few score of armed men, are
confined several hundred men, many of whom are the very dregs of
humanity sent from Buenos Aires. These unfortunates work on the
roads, dress stone for new and stronger walls, or make the garments
worn by themselves and their fellow prisoners. Few attempt to escape
and fewer still succeed, for the loneliness and desolation alone would
keep a prisoner where human companionship may be found.
Small and unimportant as this town is to-day, and wretched as it
would seem to many people, yet it has a full complement of officials
with their secretaries and servants. There is a complete list of judicial
officers and police officials, even though the police have no patrol to
beat and the court has no docket. About the only part of the official
equipment that has any work to do is the culinary department, for it
takes a great deal of cooking and preparation to provide food for every
one there. Out of a population of several hundred to-day, made up
principally of prisoners and officials, there are only a very few plain
common citizens who dwell there.
Most of the buildings in Ushuaia are frame structures, which have
been erected near the bay that bears the same name as the town. It is
situated on Beagle Channel. The houses consist of plain unpainted
wooden walls, with a roof of corrugated iron. The governor’s palace
itself is not much better than the other buildings. A few of the buildings
have little green patches, enclosed with picket fences, in which they are
able to grow a few vegetables. For a location so far south the climate is
not so bad as one would expect, as the snowfall is not as great as in the
same latitude in northern regions. In the winter time the nights are very
long and the days short. The mountains just at the back of the town cut
off the sunlight when the sun is low, so that the town only receives
about four hours of daylight. It is certainly a cheerless sort of existence
that the people lead in this southern capital. There are still one or two
missions that are conducted by English missionaries on this coastland,
but they have had very little influence upon the natives. One of the
missions consists of quite a large ranch, where the minister in charge of
the mission lives and employs the natives to do his work.
For several hundred miles north of Punta Arenas lies the formerly
unknown land of Patagonia—the land of the Pata-goas, the “big feet,” as
they were named by Magellan. One can see in that city almost any day
descendants of that race in the Tehuelche tribe of Indians who come
there to sell their furs and skins. Out upon the broad pampas away from
the town, the traveller will occasionally stumble upon the toldos (huts)
of the Tehuelches. These are simply made huts of the skins of the
guanaco sewn loosely together at the edges, and supported squarely
upon awkward-looking props, or posts, forked at the top to admit the
ridge-poles. The skins are fastened to the earth by wooden pegs. The
Tehuelches are the native Indians of Patagonia—the so-called giants—
and are well built specimens of manhood. These Indians live almost as
their ancestors did hundreds of years ago. They are still nomads, and
exist entirely by the chase. They do not cultivate anything whatever, but
sometimes own a few cattle. In general they still dress in skins, although
some of them have purchased store clothes at the settlements. As a rule
they are mild mannered, when sober, and do not deserve the name of
being bloodthirsty savages. Their numbers have greatly decreased, since
the first discovery of Patagonia, through dissipation and disease, and
some have estimated that the total number yet remaining will not
exceed a few hundred.
Only a few years ago the geographers labelled Patagonia “no man’s
land.” To-day millions of sheep graze over its fertile plains. It is as large
as several of our western states. It is a land of big distances and
enormous holdings. In the pasture section it is often a ride of three or
four days from one ranch to another. Most of these ranches are near the
coast or along the few rivers. As one travels into the interior a white
face becomes more and more rare; empty leagues surround you on
every hand. One accustomed to cities only would find it very lonely
indeed on these plains. One seems to stand alone with only the wind,
the mirages and the limitless distances, and the blue sky above for a
canopy. The last land to have been the habitation of the greater beasts
of preceding ages, according to geologists, Patagonia is one of the last
to receive its proper share of the human population.
There are three races of Indians who inhabit these Fuegian islands,
the Yahgans, Alacaloofs and the Onas, all of whom are very low in
intelligence. They are commonly known under the general
characterization of the Firelanders. None of them are as far advanced as
the Esquimaux, who build warm igloos for their habitation. Even though
the climate is very cold the greater part of the year these aborigines
formerly wore very little clothing, but greased their bodies with fish oil
that keeps out the cold. In recent years, however, they have begun to
wear warmer garments, when such can be obtained. The Yahgans are
very treacherous, and many murders have been traced to them. They
will mingle very little with white people, but always hold themselves
aloof. Their houses are of the most primitive character, and are
frequently little more than a rude construction of thatch on a skeleton of
sticks stuck in the ground.
These Yahgans live almost entirely on sea food. They divide their time
between these rude huts and canoes, or dugouts made from the trunks
of trees, in which they paddle through the tortuous channels from one
island to another. Should a storm overtake the boat and it becomes
necessary to lighten it, the men show their instinct for self-preservation
by throwing the women and children overboard. They are not particular
about food, as to whether it is very fresh or not. There is frequently a
dearth of food, and then it is that they are driven to eat the flesh of a
stranded whale or of an animal found dead. Ground rats and the fishy-
flavoured penguin are included on their regular bill-of-fare. Their
camping-places can generally be located by the mounds of shells that
accumulate. They are as near to primitive savages as it would be
possible to find on the Americas. As usual among savage tribes, the
women do the most of the work, and assist in the hunting and fishing as
well as prepare the meat after it has once been caught. The Yahgans
are short and muscular and below medium height. Their lower limbs
seem rather stunted, but above the waist they are heavily built.
Marriage is a matter of purchase and sale, and wives are sometimes
exchanged. The marriage ceremony consists in painting the girl in a
peculiar way, and then the husband takes her to his hut or that of his
parents.
The Alacaloofs, or Alakalufs, occupy the western islands and are
similar in their habits to the Yahgans. Their canoes are made of strips of
bark or planks fastened together with vines and caulked with moss.
Their huts look like New England haycocks made of boughs and covered
with skins or bark strips. They frequently row out to meet passing
steamers and beg for food. They are not an attractive people. In colour
they strongly resemble the North American red men, but they are not
much over five feet in height. The only domesticated animal owned by
them is the dog. With this tribe, as well as the Yahgans, everything is
held in common and it is no crime to take of your neighbour’s fuel or
food.
The Onas are a hunting tribe and they are larger than either of the
other tribes. They occupy the prairie lands and open bush of Tierra del
Fuego. The men are active and athletic, and they are especially skilful in
stalking the guanaco of that island. They are expert in the use of the
rude bows and arrows which they make for themselves. The bows are
fashioned out of a native wood cut with shell knives, and the arrows are
made out of reeds armed with a flint or glass point. Horse meat is a
great delicacy with them. The struggle for existence has made these
people inexpressive in features and stoical in actions. A good fortune or
an ill fortune is met in much the same way. Their homes are generally
saucer-shaped hollows that have been scraped out, over which poles
and brush are piled and guanaco skins are used as doors. All the family
lie down together, and the dogs are included for warmth. They are
nomads and wander from one place to another in search of food. Fire is
made with bits of iron ore or flints and dry fungus. Some of this tribe are
now employed as servants by the white people, but most of them prefer
the wild life in the open.
With all the hardships that seem to fall to the lot of these Indians who
live so far to the south, they seem to be fairly happy and are contented
with their surroundings. This is truly fortunate. People who live in the
temperate zones are inclined to think that they are the only truly happy
ones. By travel one’s view is broadened, and at last he realizes the truth
expressed by Oliver Goldsmith in the following lines:—
The trip across the continent of South America is now made very
comfortably by train. The start is from the very pleasant station of the
State Railway of Valparaiso. For a number of miles the tracks run almost
along the water’s edge, and thus afford many beautiful views of the blue
bay of Valparaiso. The trains on this road are very comfortable, for the
Chilean State Railway is one of the very few railroads in South America
that provide Pullman cars for their patrons. After leaving Viña del Mar
the line soon abandons the bay, and threads its way through the coast
range of mountains. One gets many glimpses of the higher Andes
through the passes, and there are also green glens where advantage
has been taken of the running water for irrigation. Cacti become very
abundant, and one is reminded of the plateaus of Mexico, for these
silent sentinels seem to keep watch over the herds of sheep and goats
that feed on the slopes. Any one who has seen Southern Chile first will
notice the difference as soon as the train leaves Santiago. The
progressive dryness of the climate has a pronounced effect on the
vegetation. The cacti are frequently from twelve to fifteen feet in height,
and their entire surface is covered with stout, curved spines.
THE ACONCAGUA RIVER.
After creeping along the shore and then through a valley, the railroad
soon joins the Aconcagua River, which leaps and foams along, thus
forming a series of diminutive cascades. In the winter time the change
in temperature is very marked as the upward climb continues. In places
the valley spreads out to quite generous proportions, and one will see
haciendas that are well kept up and which show evidence of careful
cultivation. Contrast is afforded by the sight of oxen drawing one-
handled, wooden ploughs. How powerful must have been the Moorish
influence in Spain, for these ploughs are exact duplicates of the plough
of ancient Chaldea and Egypt, which was carried along the coast of
Barbary into Spain, and left there as a heritage to the Spaniards, who
introduced it into the New World. The general impression left with the
traveller over this route, between Valparaiso and Santiago, is one of
comparative barrenness and desolation.
Viña del Mar, Limache and Quillota are three quite important towns
that are passed en route, the latter two of which have some important
manufacturing establishments. Llai Llai (pronounced Yi-yi) is about half
way, and this is the diverging point for the two routes. One leads to the
capital, and the other is the continuation of the transcontinental railroad.
Llai Llai is a pleasant little town of five or six thousand inhabitants, and
is situated about twenty-six hundred and twenty-five feet above sea
level. A number of fruit sellers are sure to be at the station, and one
who does not purchase a few of the delicious pears or peaches, that are
sold so reasonably, misses a great treat. They are grown in a rich valley
below which is a sort of agricultural Arcadia.
The through cars are switched to another track, a different engine is
attached to them and the traveller is soon bound for Los Andes. The
journey does not differ greatly from that already described. The city of
San Felipe is the largest town passed and it is situated amidst well
cultivated fields. It is a city of about twelve thousand. Soon afterwards
the train reaches Santa Rosa de Los Andes, which marks a break in the
journey. Here it is necessary to change trains, and frequently to stay
over night. It is at the foothills of the Andes, and one can find many
pleasant little excursions into the foothills here, if he has the inclination
to tarry for a few days. The climate is good, and the physical wants of
the traveller are very well looked after at the hotel. A few Americans will
be found there, for the railroad is operated by that nationality.
LOOKING TOWARDS ACONCAGUA.
If it is the summer time one will find Los Andes a very pleasant little
place, with quite an abundance of vegetation around it. The altitude is
about twenty-six hundred feet, which gives it a delightful climate. Fruits
grow abundantly, and the fruit-canning industry has been considerably
developed. This is in the province of Aconcagua, which contains some of
the most notable elevations in the entire republic, and, in fact, in the
entire world. This province is about as large as Connecticut and Rhode
Island combined. In addition to the eastern boundary of lofty peaks
there are numerous low hills, between which lie fertile valleys. Through
the use of irrigation agriculture flourishes in these valleys, and there is a
considerable production of grains and wine. There are also a number of
silver and copper mines in the province. San Felipe is the capital, and is
distant about seventy-eight miles from both Santiago and Valparaiso.
“Vamonos,” says the conductor of the narrow gauge train, as it pulls
out of the station on its way to the limits of Chilean territory. One will
begin to take notice of his fellow-travellers. The passengers will be
found to be of many nationalities, and of many shades of colour, for,
since the railway journey is continuous, fewer people take the much
longer route via the Straits of Magellan. There will be Chilenos, with big
hats and ponchos, and Chilenas, whose faces are coated with powder or
paste. There will be priests in beaver hats and black gowns, which reach
to their feet. Soldiers in uniforms modelled after the German army are
quite likely to be companions as far as the border. Americans, British,
French, Germans, Italians and Argentinians—all of these nationalities go
to make up a potpourri of nations and national characteristics. As the
start is generally made in the morning, one sees the stars disappear and
the dawn break over the mountains. The gray skies turn to a steel-blue,
then to a rosy pink, until, at last, the highest peaks are illuminated by
the rays of the sun. One may leave Los Andes clad in its summer
plumage, with myriads of butterflies and moths flitting about, but these
characteristics soon disappear, for the upward climb begins almost
immediately. In the next thirty-five miles this rack and pinion road climbs
upward more than seven thousand feet. It is a much steeper ascent
than on the Argentine side, for it requires three times the distance to
reach the same level on that slope.
The track follows the course of the Aconcagua River. This river is at no
time a great stream, yet the total volume of water carried down in its
swift-flowing current must be considerable. Many glimpses of the simple
natives, and their primitive means of conveyance, are afforded on the
ancient highway that threads the same valley. On the mountainside an
occasional mud hut may be seen around and over which climb creepers
and flowering vines. The scenery is beautiful and full of variations. Every
turn of the tortuous track reveals a new scene of beauty, and there are
few railway journeys in the world that will afford a greater variety of
views than this overland route to Buenos Aires. The mountains grow
from grand to grander, as if Ossa had been piled upon Pelion. When
sunlight and shadow play upon the rock the contrasts are dazzling and
the senses gladdened. There is a prodigality of colours such as even the
Yosemite, the Grand Cañon or the Dolomites do not surpass. Guardia
Viega, the “old guard,” is one of the stations, and is so named because it
was for two centuries a guard station on the Antiguo Camino, or ancient
road between the two republics. The vegetation becomes scanter as the
altitude increases, but, scant as it is, it is a pleasing change to the
traveller coming from the other direction. Juncal, which for several years
was the terminus, is passed. One of the most beautiful views afforded is
that of the narrow gorge, known as the Salto del Soldado, the Soldier’s
Leap, through which the tempestuous waters of the river foam and toss.
There is a tradition connected with this strange freak of nature of which
the Chileans are proud. During the war of independence it is said that a
Chilean pursued by the enemy, leaped across this chasm and saved his
life. Owing to the width it is an almost impossible tale to believe.
The traveller may be thankful that he has not been obliged to traverse
this pass in the winter time. Nothing can surpass these vast ridges clad
in their winter dress. White and cold, they form a veritable valley of
desolation. It is the cold of death, the white mantle of annihilation—
something that the brain can scarcely compass. The feeling of solitude
in the midst of the whiteness everywhere almost overwhelms the
traveller with despair. In places the snow is frequently as much as
fifteen feet in depth, deep enough to bury a horse and rider. Sudden
storms are likely to overtake the traveller, and he would be snowed in in
one of the casuchas. These are shelters that were built at intervals along
the pass for the protection of travellers. They are dome-shaped
structures which remind one of lime-kilns. They have a small door, but
no windows, and will accommodate as many as twenty people at a time.
The interior has a brick floor and is absolutely bare. Although protected
from the weather, woe be to the traveller obliged to spend a day or two
there with a group of arrieros, for filth is everywhere and the stench is
almost overpowering.
Although fewer travellers ventured over this pass in the midst of
winter, the mail service continued uninterruptedly, and there was seldom
a day that some one did not attempt the crossing. A capitas, who was
generally a man with a little capital, would undertake to carry the mails
or other freight over the pass at a fixed price. He would then engage his
force of porters as cheaply as possible, agreeing to furnish them with
board and lodging so long as they remained with him. As time was not
specified in the mail contract, if a traveller came along the capitas would
dump the mails and carry his baggage at an exorbitant price. Everything
was done up in packages weighing about sixty pounds. Some of the
porters would even undertake to carry two of these—a terrible strain on
a rough road. It is little wonder that this and unrestrained dissipation
usually gave these men a short life. Sometimes they slid over a
precipice, or were hurled to their doom by a falling stone. There are
many graves of those who met an untimely end along this route, and it
seems almost marvellous that they are not more numerous. After the
highest point was passed the porters would toboggan down the slopes,
seated on a sheepskin and guiding themselves with pointed staffs. In
this way the descent was quickly accomplished. The packages were
simply tumbled down, and oftentimes reached the bottom in a very
dilapidated condition.
The Trasandino Argentino Railway threads its way out through the
valley of the Uspallata, and follows a small stream which gradually
becomes larger as little rivulets of melted snow join it. It soon becomes
more of a stream, and is given the name of Rio (river) Mendoza. At a
distance of less than a dozen miles the station called Puente del Inca is
reached, which is so named because of a natural bridge of stratified rock
at that place, which is very similar to the Natural Bridge of Virginia.
Underneath it bubble up boiling waters which are claimed to have great
medicinal value. It is said that the Incas in pre-Spanish times knew of
the value of these waters, and their chiefs came here to receive the
benefits of its curative waters. Near here one catches a glimpse of a
marvellous freak of nature, called the Cerro de los Penitentes, the Ridge
of the Penitents. The scattered rocky peaks and points standing up
through the sloping debris of the ascent, with their remarkable
imitations of toiling wayfarers, must have greatly impressed the Spanish
pioneers when they first came upon this scene.
The route continues a picture of desolation, caused by volcanic
upheavals and the erosion of countless ages. The Mendoza River,
coloured by the various metals of the rocks over which it pours, tumbles
along near the railway as both follow one pass after another. Las Vacas,
Uspallata, La Invernada and other small stations are passed. About
thirty miles before Mendoza is reached a change begins, and poplar and
larch trees, alfalfa fields and the grape enliven the scene. Irrigation is
utilized and the melted snows cause the land to bloom with remarkable
fertility. At last the train runs into the creditable station of Mendoza, and
the second stage in the transcontinental journey is ended.
THE CHRIST OF THE ANDES.
The Cumbre, as this ridge is called, is the highest point on the old
trail. Travellers and baggage were transported over it by mule-back or in
carriages, if the almost springless vehicles could be called by such a
name, during the summer. It is a very zigzag trail up which the carriages
wound, where as many as twenty twists and turns can be counted. On
the downward trip the horses ran and jumped, until the timorous
traveller began to have visions of disaster. Accidents were rare, however,
and seldom was a vehicle overturned. Corners were turned on two
wheels, with only a few inches between the outside wheels and the
edge of the precipice.
“The clouds have voices, and the rivers pour
Their floods in thunder down to ocean’s floor;—
The hills alone mysterious silence keep.”
One of the most striking aspects which impress the traveller crossing
the Andes is the terribly bleak and desolate outlook that they present.
Blades of grass here and there, or perhaps a few stunted shrubs, are
the only signs of vegetation, for of trees there are none. There seems to
be no tree line, as in most mountains. A huge expanse of yellow sand
and stone spreads out everywhere with peaks rising up on every side in
clearly defined and rugged stratification, whose many-coloured hues are
almost bewildering to the eye. Great torrents flow down the middle of
the valleys, the water being of a dull brackish hue. The fording of these
streams is a very dangerous task for the explorer, as the torrents are
exceedingly rapid and full of deep, treacherous holes.
On either side rise high peaks, and the traveller is always interested in
knowing the names of these peaks. If he asks the average native which
is Aconcagua, or which Tupungato, he is likely to be misinformed. There