0% found this document useful (0 votes)
327 views259 pages

How Language Works

Uploaded by

laurikovac
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
327 views259 pages

How Language Works

Uploaded by

laurikovac
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 259

"[Crystal] succeeds again and again with clarity, wit, and

enthusiasm .... A marvelous ride." -The New York Times

n
0
How BabiesBabble,
Words Change Meaning,
and Languages Live or Die
How Language Works
How LanguageWorks
How BabiesBabble,

Words Change Meaning,

and LanguagesLiveor Die

D vid Crysta I

/\VI 1-/Y u rrwmbn of Penguin Group (USA) Inc, New York


Published by the Penguin Group
Con n
Penguin Group (USA) Inc. 375 Hudson Street. New York. New York 10014. USA Penguin Group (Canada).
90 Eglinton Avenue East. Suite 700. Toronto. Ontario M4P 2Y3. Canada (a division of Pearson Penguin Canada Inc.)
Penguin Books Ltd. 80 Strand. London WC2R oRL. England Penguin Ireland.
25 St Stephen's Green. Dublin 2. Ireland (a division of Penguin Books Ltd) Penguin Group (Australia).
250 Camberwe\l Road. Camberwell. Victoria 3124. Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd)
Penguin Books India Pvt Ltd. 11 Community Centrr. Panchshrrl Park, New Delhi 11o017. India
Penguin Group (NZ). 67 Apollo Drive. Rosedale. North Shorr 06"32. New Zealand
(a division of Pearson New Zealand Ltd) Penguin Books (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd.
1: 24 Sturdee Avenur, Rosebank, Johannesburg 2196. South Africa
List of figures ix
Penguin Books Ltd. Registered Offices 80 Strand. London WC2R oRL. England
Preface xi
Originally published in the United Kingdom by Penguin Books 2005
First published in the United St.1tes hy The Overlook Press 2006
First trade paperback edition published by Avery 2007
Published by arrangement with The Overlook Press. PettT Mayer Publishers. Inc.
Introducing language
Copyright"' 2005 by David Crystal
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduc_cd, ~Gmned. or distrihutrd in ,rny printed or 1 How what works? 1
electronic form without permission Please do not participate in 01 encourage piracy of copyrighted
materials in violation of the author's rights. Purchasr only authorized editions 2 How to treat body language 5
Most Avery books are available at special quantity discounts for hulk pure hasp for salr') promotions. premiums. fund 3 How we use the 'edges' of language 11
raising. and educational nt'eds Special books or book excerpts J!so can he created to fit specific_nt'e<ls. For details. write
Penguin Group (USA) Inc. Special Markets. 375 Hudson Street. New York. NY 10014

Library ofCongrt'SS Cataloging in Publication Data Spoken language


'I' CrystJI. David. datt.·
How language works: how babies babble, words change mraning, and languages live or die/ Dctvid Cry~tal
p cm
4 How we make speech sounds: phase 1 18
Includes bibliographical refercrKcs and indcx. 5 How we make speech sounds: phase 2 25
ISBN 978-1 58133-291 7
I. Language and languages I Title 6 How we transmit sounds 32
2007028115
7 How we hear speech sounds 39
Printed in the United States of America
8 How we perceive speech 44
13579108642 9 How we describe speech sounds 51
Book design by Rowland Phototypesetting Ltd. Bury Sr Edmunds. Sujfolk 10 How we describe consonants and vowels 58
While the author has made every effort to provide accurate telephone numbers -1nrl l111t·111t't ;1ddre~~eo:, .it tlw time of 11 How we organize the sounds of speech 66
publication, neither the publisher nor the ~wthor assumes any re~ponsihility for <'I n11.., or IOI t h.111~1·-; th.11 O(n1r after
publkation. Further. the publisher docs not h,1vt·;my control over .rnd doc'> 1101 .1'>'>1111w .111v 11",11011-.,dHlity lor .111thoror
12 How we use tone of voice 73
third party Wf'h'iiH•s or their< ontent
13 How children learn speech sounds: the first year 79
14 How children learn speech sounds: later years 85
11, I low sp1•c·1·hcan go wrong go
Written language Discourse
41 How we discourse 260
16 How we write 97
17 How we make writing systems: early times 105 42 How conversation works 267

18 How we make writing systems: modern times 113 43 How we choose what to say 275
44 How we can't choose what to say 282
19 How we read 121
20 How we write and spell 127
21 How we learn to read and write 133 Dialects
22 How reading and writing can go wrong 140
45 How we know where someone is from 289
23 How writing and speech differ 147
46 How to study dialects 295
24 How the electronic medium differs 153
47 How we know what someone is: the ethnic issue 302
48 How we know what someone is: the social issue 309
Sign language 49 How we know who someone is: the stylistic issue 316
50 How we know where someone is: the contextual issue 322
25 How sign language works 159
51 How dialects differ from languages 329
26 How sign languages vary 164

Language structure Languages


52 How languages die 336
27 How the brain handles language 171
28 How to investigate language structure 180 53 How languages are born 343
54 How language began 350
29 How we mean 186
55 How language changes 357
30 How we analyse meaning 192
56 How language families work 364
31 How we learn vocabulary 198
57 How the Inda-European family is organized 371
32 How children learn to mean 204
58 How other Eurasian families are organized - part one 380
33 How dictionaries work 210
59 How other Eurasian families are organized - part two 387
34 How names work 217
60 How the Inda-Pacific island families are organized 393
35 How vocabulary grows 224
61 How African families are organized 397
36 How we study grammar 230
62 How American families are organized 403
37 How words work 236
38 How we classify words 242
39 How sentences work 247 Multilingualism
40 I low Wl' learn grammar 254
(n I low multilingualism works 40l)
64 How we cope with many languages: translate them 416
65 How we cope with many languages: supplement them 423
66 How we cope with many languages: learn them 430
67 How we cope with many languages: teach them
68 How we cope with many languages: plan them 444
437
ures
69 How not to look after languages 451

Looking after language


70 How to look after languages: recognizing principles 457
71 How to look after languages: recognizing functions 462
72 How to look after languages: recognizing varieties 469
73 Teaching people to look after languages 477 1 General arrangement of the vocal organs 19
2 The main parts of the tongue 30
3 Movement of a single air particle 33
Further Reading 485 4 Sine waves of equal frequency but different amplitude 36
Index 487 5 Waveforms of a vowel [a:] and consonant [s:] 38
6 Anatomy of the ear 40
7 The International Phonetic Alphabet 54
8 The cardinal vowel diagram 63
9 Vowels in Received Pronunciation 64
10 Egyptian hieroglyphs over time 110
11 Sumerian pictograms related to cuneiform 112

12 Some alphabetic systems 114

13 Anatomy of the eye 122


14 Two-handed and one-handed finger-spelling 169
15 Different views of the brain 172
16 Surface areas of the cortex 175
t I 17 Lexical isoglosses for -r in Britain 298
I
18 Some words for father in Inda-European 366
19 The Inda-European family of languages 367
Pre

Publisher's note: For this American paper-


back edition of How Language Works, the pub-
lisher has retained the British spelling and
style of the original hardcover edition.
I know an artist who has spent his whole life painting a still-life, in
innumerable versions, in order to get it right. I know another who continu-
ally repaints a scene, in various lights and circumstances, in order to
obtain fresh insights into it. There is no end to the process. It is always
,,I the next work which will achieve the longed-for resolution.
'I
The study of language is no different. I have lost count of the number
of times I have tried to introduce this subject to one readership or another.
There are, I imagine, only so many ways of telling the language story, but
one goes on looking for new angles, new insights. The present book has
been an interesting exercise in taking familiar ideas and rethinking them
with a focus on the 'how' rather than on the 'what', 'why', 'where', or
'when'. I have quite consciously incorporated material from my earlier
expositions displaying those other emphases, but I hope I have managed
to present it here in a fresh and interesting way.
It is not necessary to read the book 'from left to right'. Each chapter
is designed as a self-contained unit, and there are many cross-references
to associated chapters. This is the distinctive feature of any 'how'
approach. The section in a car manual which tells you about its tyres can ·x
be read independently of the one which tells you about its lights.
This is a book about how language works, not about how the study
of language works. That would be called 'How linguistics works' - or
rwrhaps lwttt·r. 'I low linguists work'. I am a linguist, so you will see from
these pages how I work, how I think about language. But there is no
attempt in these pages to represent the full range of opinions - at times
often very divergent - about the way language can or should be studied.
This is above all a personal account. Nor is there much on the methodology
of linguistic enquiry: while I talk a lot about child language, for example,
I do not say anything about the range of methods that linguists use when
h t WO k
they are investigating child language. I have therefore included a short
bibliography of further reading for those who reach §73 and wish to take
such things further.

David Crystal

'Language', the title of this book says. But what is meant by 'language'?
Consider the following expressions:
body language
spoken language
written language
sign language
computer language
the French language
bad language
animal language
the language of birds
I,
the language of cinema
I,
the language of music 0
I, s
Ii
the language of love
Plainly the word is being used in many ways - some technical, some
figurative - and the senses go in various directions. If a reviewer were to
remark, after an impressive orchestral concert, 'The conductor and the
musicians were all speaking the same language', we would interpret this
to be a comment about their playing, not their chatting. And the same
point applies to other linguistic terms, when used in special settings. I
have sepn books called The Grammar of Cooking and The Syntax of Sex.
Tlw first w;1s ;1 nillt·<·tion of recipes as was the second.
How Language Works is not about music, or cookery, or sex. But it is Terrestrial observers also need to be able to answer them, as a preliminary
about how we talk about music, cookery, and sex - or, indeed, about stage in the study of language. If we pick up a manual called How Cars
anything at all. And it is also about how we write about these things, and Work, we do not expect to find in it chapters on bicycles and lawn-mowers.
send electronic messages about them, and on occasion use manual signs Nor, in How Language Works, will there be much space devoted to the
to communicate them. The operative word is 'how'. It is commonplace to use of facial expressions and body movements or to the way animals
see a remarkable special effect on a television screen and react by exclaim- communicate. Why not?
ing 'How did they do that?' It is not quite so usual to exclaim when we
observe someone speaking, listening, reading, writing, or signing. And yet
if anything is worthy of exclamation, it is the human ability to speak,
Modes of communication
listen, read, write, and sign. Because not all of these forms of communication are language, in the
An alien visitor to Earth might well wonder what was going on. It sense of this book. Communication is a much broader concept, involving
would see humans approach each other, use their mouths to exchange a the transmission and reception of any kind of information between any
series of noises, and - apparently as a result of making these noises - kind of life. It is a huge domain of enquiry, dealing with patterned human
cooperate in some activity. It would see human eyes look at a set of marks and animal communication in all its modes. Those who study behaviour
inscribed on a surface, and the eye-owners then behaving in the same way usually call this domain semiotics. Linguistics, the science of language, is
- going out of one door rather than another in a theatre, for instance. just one branch of semiotics.
Rather less often, it would see some humans using their hands and faces There are five modes of human communication, because there are
to achieve the same results that others obtain through the use of their only five human senses which can act as channels of information: sound,
mouths. In each case it might think: 'How did they do that?' And in each sight, touch, smell, and taste. Of course, if you believe in telepathy, you
case the answer would be the same: 'through the use of language'. would need to recognize a 'sixth sense' available for communication; and
But our alien would also observe other kinds of behaviour. It would perhaps there are life forms which interact using still other modes, such
see humans smiling and frowning at each other, or waving and gesturing, as the non-visible areas of the electromagnetic spectrum. But the five
or stroking and kissing. It would notice that the effect of carrying out traditional human sensory modes are all we need to put the subject of
these actions was similar in some respects to that produced by the use of this book into a more general perspective.
spoken noises, written marks, and manual signs. It might well reflect: can The information we send and receive using these modes is usually
these actions therefore be called 'language' too? called the meaning of our communication. But the five modes are not
Our alien would also see apparently similar behaviour among other equally relevant for the transmission and reception of meaning. In fact,
species. It would see a bee find a source of nectar, return to a hive, and two of them play hardly any role at all in human beings - the olfactory
perform a series of dance-like body movements. Other bees would then (smell) and gustatory (taste) modes. We do not routinely emit smells in
N move off in the direction of the nectar. Animals of all kinds would seem order to communicate with others (the controlled flatulent behaviour of m
to be sending information to each other in analogous ways. Is this the some small boys notwithstanding), and there is a very limited amount of
same sort of behaviour as the humans are displaying, our alien observer information about the outside world which we can receive through the
might think? no animals also have language? mediums of smell and taste. Ry contrast, the use of sound - the auditory-
Tlwst· q1wstio11s involvt• 111on· th;m hypotl11·tH;d t'Xlraterrestrials. vocul mode - is fundamental tot ht· not ion of' lan~uage. and t lw propPrt il's

,,
of this mode will form the major part of this book (§4). Speech is the
primary manifestation of language, in all cultures.
The tactile and visual modes fall somewhere between these two ex-
tremes. They are often technically described as being channels of non-
verbal communication because the way in which we use facial expressions, \ re
gestures, and touch behaviour seems to contrast with the words and

'i!
sentences we describe as verbal language. But ordinary people do not
talk about nonverbal communication. Instead, they simply refer to body
n a
I
language.
Is this use of 'language' the same as the one we use when we talk
about speech, writing, and signing, or about English, French, and Chinese?
Should large sections of this book be devoted to how facial expressions
and manual gestures work? The answer is no, and to understand why When people talk about body language (§1),they are referring to those
we need to briefly consider the differences between what is involved in features of bodily behaviour which are under some degree of conscious
nonverbal tactile and visual communication, on the one hand, and in control, and which they can therefore use to express different sorts of
language, on the other. We shall see that these differences also enable meaning. The meanings involved are all fairly 'primitive' expressions
us to disregard animal communication, as well as the other figurative of attitude or social relationship, such as affection, aggression, sexual
applications of the term. We shall be left with a trinity of mediums - attraction, greeting, congratulation, gratitude, surprise, and the signal-
speech, writing, and sign - which manifest our concept of 'language'. ling of attention. Both tactile and visual modes of communication are
employed.

The tactile mode


The tactile mode of nonverbal communication operates when parts of the
body make planned physical contact with other people. A very wide range
of meaningful activities is expressed by such contact, as this small selec-
tion of terms suggests: 3
s0
dig, embrace, hold, jog, kick, kiss, nudge, nuzzle, :r:
pat, pinch, punch, shake, slap, spank, tickle
They operate within a complex system of social constraints. Some of U"1

11
I the acts tend to be found only in private - notably, sexual touching. Some
are specialized in function: examples include the tactile activities which
we permit from doctors, dentists, hairdressers, or tailors. And some are
restril'led to certain ceremonies or ol'Casions - a handshake which signals
a formal agreement, for example, or a laying on of hands in the context ing their message, expressing such meanings as puzzlement or disbelief.
of religion or healing. We use our body posture to convey our attitude towards an interaction -
The communicative value of tactile activities is usually fairly clear for instance, whether we are interested or bored. Several kinds of social
within a culture, but there are many differences across cultures. Some context are associated with specific facial or body behaviours, such as
societies are much more tolerant of touching than others, so much so that waving upon meeting or taking leave. Ritual or official occasions are often
a distinction has been proposed between contact and non-contact societies associated with gesture and posture - as with kneeling, standing, bowing,
- those that favour touching (such as Arabs and Latin Americans), and and blessing.
those that avoid it (such as North Europeans and Indians). In some cul- Some visual effects are widely used in the cultures of the world. An
tures, conversationalists touch each other two or three times a minute; in example is the eyebrow flash, used unconsciously when people approach
others, no touching takes place at all. each other and wish to show that they are ready to make social contact.
Related to our use of body contact is the way we use body distance Each person performs a single upward movement of the eyebrows, keep-
and orientation to communicate meaning. There are norms of proximity ing them raised for about a sixth of a second. The effect is so automatic
within a culture (distance zones) which can inform us about the social that we are hardly ever conscious of it. But we become uneasy if we do
relationship between the participants. Latin Americans, for example, not receive an eyebrow flash when we expect one (from someone we
prefer to stand much closer to each other during a conversation than know}; and to receive an eyebrow flash from someone we do not know
do North Europeans. In a traditional caste system, such as in India, the can be uncomfortable, embarrassing, or even threatening.
acceptable distance zones between the members of different castes can Most gestures and facial expressions, however, differ across cultures.
vary greatly - from less than 2 metres to over 20. Sometimes the differences are very noticeable, especially when we visit a
society which uses far more gestures and facial expressions than we are

The visua I mode used to (e.g. Italian, compared with British) or far fewer (e.g. Japanese,
compared with British}. We even coin phrases to express our sense of
We use the visual mode to communicate nonverbally in several ways. We these differences, as when an English person describes Italians as 'talking
can gesture, vary our facial expressions, make eye contact, and alter our with their arms' or Westerners refer to people from Asian countries as
body posture. Each of these behaviours performs a variety of functions. 'inscrutable'.
Movements of the face and body give clues to our personality and emo- Even when a visual effect seems to be shared between societies, we
tional state. The face, in particular, signals a wide range of emotions, such have to be careful, for it can convey very different meanings. A thumbs-up
<
as fear, happiness, sadness, anger, surprise, interest, and disgust. Many of sign has a positive 'all is well' or 'I am winning' meaning in Western
6
:r the expressions vary in meaning across cultures, and we have to learn Europe, the USA, and other cultures influenced by its use as a symbol of
how to interpret the sometimes very subtle movements in the faces of combat survival in Roman times. But in the Arab world, as well as in parts
people whose racial characteristics differ from our own. of West Africa and Asia, it is a symbol of insult, equivalent to giving r---
In addition, the face and body send signals about the way a social someone 'the finger' ('up yours!') in the West. As a consequence, it was
interaction is proceeding. We use eye contact to show who is the focus of never entirely clear, during the aftermath of the Iraq War of 2003, when
our communication, in a group, or to prompt a pt•rson to speak next. We Iraqis were seen on television giving a thumbs-up to American troops,
11st·/i1ci11/
cx1m·ssio11s to givP feedback to ollwr\ ;1lill11Ihow we are rerciv- whPt h1•rl his was Ihe t radii ional gt•stun· hPing used as an insult or whether
'I1.1
I 1
I,
1: it was the Western version being adopted as a sign of cooperation and a attach another piece of utterance. Similarly, there is no limit to the number
I,
symbol of freedom. of words in a language; new words are being invented every day.
Conversely, a particular meaning can be conveyed by a variety of By contrast, there is no productivity in tactile or visual body lan-
different visual signals. To express humility or deference, for example, guage. The number of tactile or visual body signals in everyday behaviour
Europeans tend to extend or lower their arms, and they sometimes bow is very small - a matter of a few hundred only (compared to the million
their heads. But in other cultures we find more profound bowing, using or more words in a language such as English) - and they do not increase
the whole of the upper half of the body, as well as crouching, crawling, very easily. We can readily invent a new word - I can do so now, and talk
and prostration. We also see other kinds of hand or arm movement, such about 'bodylinguistic' behaviour - but it strains the imagination to think
as the placing of the palms together in an upward orientation (as in the what we could do if we were asked to invent a new facial expression or
Indian subcontinent). bodily gesture. Nor do these nonverbal features combine to produce a
wide range of varying sequences, as we routinely encounter with sen-
tences. Only in the world of artistic expression, such as in the various
Properties of language forms of Indian dance, do we find a significant expansion of the body-
Body language is evidently an important means of human communi- language repertoire, in the codified hand signs known as mudras.
cation, and when it comes to basic emotions and social relationships, it is Another important difference between language and body language
a familiar experience that a gesture, facial expression, or piece of bodily lies in the far greater structural architecture of speech, writing, or sign.
contact can 'speak louder' than words. However, the potential of body Language makes use of two fundamental levels of structural organization.
language to express meaning is very limited, compared to that which is At one level, we find the use of sounds or letters - t, s, e, and so on - which
made available through speaking, writing, or signing. Language, as we have no intrinsic meaning. We cannot sensibly ask 'What does "s" mean?'
shall discuss it in this book, displays certain properties which enable us At another level, we find these sounds or letters combining in different
,1 to express far more than any piece of nonverbal communication could ways to form elements that do convey meaning - the words, phrases, and
I

I
,I
ever do. We can express our surprise or anger using our bodies; but if we sentences. We can sensibly ask 'What does "sit" mean?'
'' ',1
I I

want to explain why we are surprised or angry, we need to use language. This property is called duality of structure, or double articulation,
i 11,, ✓,

II -"'
C) Probably the most remarkable property of language is the way it and it is not present in body language. The movements which form the
1!
'
s signals of body language always convey some kind of meaning. If I raise
enables us to talk about virtually anything we want. And if it lets us
'!'; down, by not immediately providing the required words and sentences, my left eyebrow significantly, or smile, or give a thumbs-up sign, the
·1;1 we change it so that it will do so. This is what is meant when we say that action automatically sends a meaning, and within a culture this meaning
11
11,,! ~
remains the same whenever the same action is used. We cannot build up a
!
:r::
iii T
0
human language is productive. Productivity is the capacity to express
and understand a potentially infinite number of utterances, made by wide range of body-language 'sentences' which mean something different
1i:I
,,
'' combining sentence elements in new ways and introducing fresh combi- from the meaning of the elements they contain. Body language cannot be
\ I' 00
'II nations of words. Most of the sentences we read in a book are original, in analysed into two levels of structure.
11
I'! the sense that no one has used those particular combinations of words For the same reasons, we cannot call 'animal communication' lan-
I

and constructions bcforP. Nor is there any limit lo I Ill' l1·11gl h of a sentence: guage. The facial expressions, gestures, and tactile behaviours of the
;111ys1•11l1·1K!'
1·;111
lw l11;11k lo11g1·rhy ll';i111•.
e1111/ (ll1 •,,ll111· s1111iLn word) to ;111i111al
kingdom lack produl"I ivily and duality of structure in the same
I

way that human body language does. Even the most sophisticated kinds
of behaviour, such as bee-dancing or birdsong, are highly limited in what
they can do, compared with language. Bees can 'talk' about nectar but not
about much else.
There are several other important differences between animal com- w
munication and language. In particular, language enables us to talk about
events remote in space or time from the situation of the speaker: I can
talk about what happened in the near or remote past and speculate about
d
the near or remote future. This property of language - often called dis-
placement - is something which goes well beyond the capabilities of
animal signals, which reflect stimuli (such as the presence of danger or
the direction of a food source) encountered in the animal's immediate
environment. The contrast between what counts as language and what does not is
Despite some superficial similarities, so-called 'body language' and usually clear enough, once we look for evidence of productivity and
'animal language' are very different from what happens in language, in duality of structure in communicative behaviour (§2). But the boundary
the sense of this book. I find it clearer to avoid the use of the term language is fuzzy at times. In particular, some non-linguistic forms of behaviour,
altogether, in fact, and to describe these phenomena in more general both vocal and visual, can be adapted so that they take on some of the
terms - as body communication and animal communication. There is functions of language. There are also some features of language which are
nothing wrong with the 'language' metaphor, of course, as long as we decidedly less complex than others, and where it is unclear whether they
realize that that is what it is - no more than a vague approximation to should count as part of language or not.
the structurally complex and multifunctional behaviour we find whenever
we speak, write, or sign. Making vocal noises
The vocal organs (§4) can be used to make a wide range of noises that
!,, are definitely not linguistic. They express only a biological state, and
communicate no cultural meaning. Examples are coughing, sneezing, and
snoring, as well as the various voice qualities which signal a physical
condition, such as hoarseness. It makes no sense to talk about 'snoring in
English', nor do we expect a foreign language course to teach us how to
S' cough. But a phenomenon such as whistling does something more than ;::

just express a basic biological or psychological state.


When we blow air through tensed and rounded lips, we form a
primitive musical instrument, and a note is the result. We can alter the
pitch levl'I by moving the tongue and cheeks to change the shape of the
inside of the mouth. We can alter its loudness by blowing harder. And we and the utterances are short. They are most commonly heard when people
can alter its quality (making it soft or shrill) by altering the tension of the are at a distance from each other (e.g. when working the land}, but they
mouth muscles or putting our fingers against the lips to make the sound can also be found in a variety of informal settings. Although women are
sharper. It does not come naturally. Children have to learn to whistle. And able to understand whistled speech, it is normally used only by and
the behaviour is subject to social factors: usually it is boys and men who between men.
whistle. The whistling is a substitute for speech. The whistlers stop whistling
People most often use whistling to carry musical melodies, and some when they are within normal speaking range of each other, and talk in
professional whistlers have developed this musical skill into an art form. the normal way. For this reason, whistled speech has been called a speech
Some people are able to mimic birdsong or other animal noises. But replacement, or surrogate. Because it is used only in certain circumstances,
these imitative abilities have no more linguistic significance than the and can convey only a limited range of meanings, and is not used equally
phenomena they imitate. We move in the direction of language only by all members of the community, it does not really correspond to the
when individual whistles are used conventionally in a culture to express complexity and functional breadth of a spoken language. But it is certainly
a specific and shared meaning. Examples include the 'wolf-whistle', the a step in that direction.
whistle which calls sharply for attention, the whistle of amazement, and
the whistle of empathy ('gosh!'}, which is often more a breathy exhalation
Being paralinguistic
than an actual whistle.
We see the communicative potential of whistling at its most de- There are a number of vocal noises which can be 'superimposed' on the
veloped in the case of the so-called whistle languages, found in some stream of speech. It is possible, for example, to speak while sobbing,
Central and South American tribes, as well as in the occasional European crying, laughing, or giggling, or we can introduce a tremulous 'catch' in
community, such as in the Pyrenees, Turkey, and the Canary Islands. our voice. The auditory effects are usually immediate and dramatic -
Conversations have been observed between people standing at a consider- though the meaning conveyed is sometimes unclear, and always subject
able distance from each other, especially in mountainous areas, carried to cultural variation. A giggle can convey humour, innuendo, sexual inter-
on entirely in whistles. The whistled conversations deal with quite sophis- est, and several other nuances. In Britain it is most commonly used in
ticated and precise matters, such as arranging a meeting or selling some joking; in Japan it is more often a sign of embarrassment.
Q)
0£ goods. We can also change our tone of voice by altering the quality of the
cu
Whistled speech closely corresponds to the tonal and rhythmical sound we produce in the vocal tract (§5). Normally, the sound produced
patterns of spoken language, and is especially complex when the whistlers by our vocal folds yields a vibrant voicing which we hear in every vowel
speak a language in which pitch levels (tones) are important, such as some and in most of the consonants. But it is possible to speak without produ-
languages of Central America. With very few exceptions, each 'syllable' of cing any voicing at all. The phenomenon is called whispering - and whisper
whistle corresponds to a syllable of speech. Ambiguity is uncommon, conveys meaning, usually a 'conspiratorial' effect of some kind. A related
because the topic of the conversation is usually something evident in the effect is breathy voice, where extra breath is heard on top of what we are
situation of the speakers. However, it is important for both speakers to saying. We produce breathy voice after exercise, when we are 'out of
I
,, use the same musical key, otherwise conf11sio11111;1y aris!'. breath'; but it is also possible to introduce a breathy voice when we are at
Whisllt·d dialog11l's l!·rHI to nmL1i11., •,111.tll1111111lw1of l'Xchangl's, rest, and ii thl'n convPys a nwaning. I onn• heard two neighbours talking
about a woman who had returned from a holiday, saying that she was notion of 'alongside' or 'above and beyond'. Effects like giggle and whisper
'brown all over'. The words 'all over' were uttered in a breathy tone. It are said to be paralinguistic in character, and some scholars include facial
seems she really was. expressions and gestures under this heading as well.
Several other tones of voice can be consciously made by altering the
way in which we make sounds resonate in our mouths and nose. We can
Using manual signals
round our lips so that everything we say comes out in a tone which we
associate with baby-talk or talking to animals ('Who's a lovely little baba/ Many gestural systems have emerged to facilitate communication in par-
'!
budgie, then?'), though we also use the effect when addressing those with ticular situations. They are often referred to as sign languages, but few
whom we are most intimate. We can add a nasal tone of voice if we want have developed any degree of structural complexity or communicative
to add a mildly 'camp' effect to what we are saying - something which range, and it is therefore important to distinguish them from sign lan-
the British comedian Kenneth Williams used routinely. And we can make guage proper - the natural signing behaviour which has evolved for use
our vocal folds move very slowly, to produce an effect often called creaky among deaf people (§25).Nonetheless, they are a definite advance on the
voice or vocal fry. This was something horror-movie star Vincent Price 'basic' kinds of body language that are seen in everyday interaction (§2).
used to do when he wanted to sound especially menacing, but it is also Several professions use sets of conventional signals. Sports players
associated with such attitudes as disparagement and doubt. and officials can use hand and arm gestures to show the state of play, or
These effects all add an emotional colouring to the voice, and their an intention to act in a certain way. Groups of performers (such as acrobats
sound quality and use are conditioned by the language and culture of the or musicians) use them to coordinate their activities. In casinos, officials
speaker. When we speak French we have to learn to round our lips to use them to report on the way a game is going, or to indicate problems
express attitudes in different ways from the way we round them when that might affect the participants. In theatres and cinemas, ushers use
we speak English. When we learn Portuguese we find that nasal tones of them to show the number and location of seats. In sales rooms, auctioneers
voice are used differently. And when foreigners learn English, they have use them to convey the type and amount of selling and buying.
to do different things too: Finns learning English have to stop 'creaking' People controlling cranes, hoists, and other equipment can signal the l.j. ..
0
i j
their voice so much, for otherwise they give the impression of being direction and extent of movement. In aviation marshalling, ground staff
i: perpetually disparaging. These effects all seem to be linguistic in character. can send visual information about the position of an aircraft, the state of
On the other hand, they are plainly not like vowels and consonants, its engines, and its desired position. Firemen can send directions about
or words and phrases, in the way they are formed and used. They do not the supply of water, water pressures, and the use of equipment. Divers
show the productivity and duality of structure (§2) which we associate can communicate depth, direction, and time, and the nature of any diffi-
with the rest of language. In many ways they are more like the facial culties they have encountered. Truck drivers can exchange courtesy sig-
expressions and body gestures of visual communication. This suggests nals, give information about the state of the road, or show they are in
they are not really linguistic in character. trouble. Environmental noise may make verbal communication imposs-
We need a way of talking about vocal effects which are on the boun- ible (e.g. in cotton mills), so that workers start signing to each other.
dary between the linguistic and the non-linguistic. showing some but not Race-course bookies send hand and arm signals about the number
all of the properties of language, and the tn111 11u1,1lt111111""1<' has been of a race or horse, and its price. In radio and television production, pro-
devis!·d to fill IIH' hill. The p11m prelix 1•, l10111 !;11•c-k.c·xpn·ssing the dun•rs ;rnd dirt·!·lors ran signal to performers I he amount oft inH' availahlP,
instructions about level of loudness or speed of speaking, and information of human communication. All children with their sensory and mental
about faults and corrections. Religious or quasi-religious groups and secret faculties intact learn to speak before they learn to write. Only in the case
societies often develop ritual signing systems so that members can recog- of a child born deaf is there a natural opportunity to learn a non-auditory
nize and communicate with each other. Some monastic orders have system. Moreover, all languages exist in spoken form before they are
developed signing systems of considerable sophistication, especially if written down. Indeed, some 40% of human languages (over 2,000 in all)
their members are vowed to silence, as in the case of the Trappist monks. have never been written down. For their speakers, the topic 'how language
But in none of these cases are we dealing with systems containing works' could mean only one thing: 'how speech works'.
thousands of expressive possibilities, as we are with 'language proper', or
with signed sentences of any complexity. They all lack productivity and
duality of structure (§2),and they are meaningless outside of the situations
for which they were devised. A Trappist monk would make little headway
signing at a football referee, and vice versa. These signalling systems
are highly restricted methods of communication, invented to solve a
particular problem. They are a step or so above basic body gestures, but
not much more than that.
There are only a few cases where the visual and tactile modes have
been adapted to perform a truly linguistic function, providing alternative
modes of communication to that which we encounter most commonly in
11,I
I
the auditory-vocal behaviour we call 'speech'. Most obviously, the visual
I:
.I, mode is used in writing, and there have been several writing-based visual
codes, such as semaphore and Morse. Writing can involve a tactile dimen-
sion, too, as when visually impaired people receive written information
through their finger-tip contact with the sets of raised dots known as

tt,
ru
braille. Tactile codes also exist, in which sounds or (more usually) letters
are communicated through touch; and touch is critical when deaf-blind
people use their hands to sense the movements of another person's vocal ~
~i
91
QJ
s:.
&;
::J

I
organs while speaking. Finally, facial expression and gesture is crucially QJ
s
'
$'.
involved in deaf signing - which, as we shall see (§25), is very different C
.,.
from the signing systems described above or the everyday gestural
'-£ behaviour used by hearing people. i' ~
Speech, writing, sign: these are the three mediums which define the
conceptual domain of any book on language. /\nd the natural place to
begin is with speech. Of all the modes of rn1111111111i1;111011 (~1), the auditory-
vocal medium is t lw mw which has h1•1·11 lllll',I w 1dl"iy :uLipll'd for purposes
18
J
I

*
...*.;F
i i'a u:;_"q

t :l
it'F

flT\
6 3t
rls'irIgEigElti
z1* isa i Ile 1
1
ilgg
igtEII1'lEEi 1E !&.
i€i tl ro

111iIlgglirgggig[[it
q

'n

-
po
$*giegFEg
T

a
-o

rD

a
q

o
I
r-
::
'-6E

vo
@ = '
I 89 GP Fq K
ID
B sE s.d fE 5
o
-Pi # T eY :
3K i ?2=F s E 3i
= E
+
cla P o o
q'!

!.

r9 H o w w e m a k es p e e c hs o u n d sp: h a s e1
20 riOr\. l-.1lrg l-,.igc f!'':)ikt

q '€1g
igrg$glg?rEl+ril+aii;ur+
=1
a +
+agg[[iitiia;r$ggl9
:gc*tA?Egg**l*EEgi
11Eg1EFEiEFi[1g
Z=iEEiil€'u1EiglIE
rIrllA €Fg
+*r+'cf
1;i €isisu
5

iiegig3 s *+[gglsgg
gr+tii g;i1g
: I i Tfr{
s
t{l ssFlFF F IiiEFEggilE
:ilgI[;1g!53fIgEiifFfii
i*€sii +ei;iiffigii
:;i fEs q igiEiH*s
i€isEEiggii$[ii$$i:*
as;ri*F$F3F*sa+BfIg
H o w w e m a k es p e e c hs o u r d s :p h a s e1
22 Hou,'LanguageWorks

i IrIlIIrsEggEe;fggg
III;;lll
1?E ElEBEE€gi
il tgg Ilg1EiiE1EiEliiEg:
:i :i I 1[lEggg
Ilggqgg
ris]rr
;i EEgI1[1 gIFg'[1iEE1I
7 8. qE'5
iu*r*uu€f
1i lEi**uf
Fgf*
*i;F+ae
i.], z
-: r-. -=
^=
=r.- i3rf F3u$gFgf
asA=€f
-!{
giFEF i;FF€H
==."_
a=_
-^.
;FgqaTr;e[+1c€3:.t;
[€ E.lF E;i i;- H;P${.
-D

=-.
f;iiElE3rFgFF*isif,EE;E
:F.tg3;€€f cE*1F;€rq,sgE* s
5 €Eqf!F
H i iTii ssiqi sr +;a: FiEF F iEp5i;
e' *1Fr*fFg
a-
#€Ia+sFi#ggfq *b E.,n+1e,
J4 [333;7i:?i=FB *!EaP?sE [9E3Fg
iX

=:- #ra+g*ifl*ariH Ii:Bti€F i rr=FB;


," sEFHss
f ;73935;fi:ItF f ;tiFFE:
l-

-a iEEFg$rFrrIni
!D
gEsgi€F3E€geg
sil€€g;i€ 5f+1$
;f Fgiiif iErrE$
3^
a-
Fr,nEasli€5+ap
$;g#afiE r€EsH
b\

:.- i;iEr+pg rrsg;


ao
:'X
;iir3*ts;aF€r B"3s;;ErA
firEggi;gi]€s
o)+XP9.D
;AlEa
,qrE.>
so
.-;s-s*i3gIif F ;€ggP3Ei
't:
d
F3;r *E*rsrs*$agg3gF$i[[gi
23 H o w w e m a k es p e e c hs o u n d sp: h a s e1
24 I J c w ; - . ; igr i l r t i r w r , ' i k q

gqgE 9 =?,n E
= r
556 31= 9 E . 3 .
:r'-i'=
aF*E1i3frr
3P. -9dH =r
a3"3ln€ e;
6+o;s. I €;
Eie; 88 gf
g?s gq3 de,
Eqg*gr 8E
F gG rE = :a
r'<b€Fda;fr

jJ
i1T 3Ti c1 -
T+:Y ci -.5

i 2i Ar i E*
s!6q,8'= ;e,
F e * +: q- I +
;?83s gi
i i i; qsg t I
B!1 i Fri
Es*PF gE
v gJ;:3 ?g
* H + J; ! - 6
H f;
erir!"Af
: g E *; ?H

=7;;; *++eiiH,gcE+$u+glf
1\1sE
Ii IE[*fE1i
[1if€$E
tfl
*Y*X
I
r?'
iil t!

f1-
1 i-j

ii
*ii **ry*
f
ii iE*l-B
i $l'g-€s
- i ;
^*!***t
it
gggggg g g Lll
U
q t."t

k** t
5-i-*;
EiI
; 1 i liE*i i i i./ ; *3 fl
)h"t-*d
1
""Y\ {*r
;3Egciaii:gEf,;5il [e$
=AEq =Y, raf +='68=gg# *#.; 1 L'! ;a"**j*
pry
f ;i
H o w w e m a k es p e e c hs o u n d sp: h a s e2 K \ ldt
i-iow iiirgLl;190 lit3f k5

_!Figg#FS gii;E;sTg 5 ilHt€tH; Jr€s;


liia:liE$ cAirr;gil; ig3AiiisgiE
=.iHE*'*$$
-=il r: re E?1iF[;E$ n gE+E*g
E€3?
-
.ilsitt;$
j L E*i iiil*
;E3$f a ts3etr*te
'E3fI+EI
*E$giEi*
Eri+s
i: *ilE'[c g
x
iii e[;giigE Err;E;sA;
€ri€Eri3 gitF:€Eir
itrE
: ii[Fs; €?:E*i3q gEg$1qF
=:EgiggEE*[BIFlE
i;E3gIir$;E1$1f [;+E[Er
l*E

iiiFs$iiii3ii$gFf-E's
'iiEFi$gEFr$ ggg'$F
gggFS gg
+
6
+!i$$$iiigg;es FF
i;lgfg
i3**ggg's'gelrrigg;
;rngglsiggsgg*gi$
H o w w e m a k es p e e c hs o u n d s p
: h a s e2
z8 ilcw |anglrageWir.ks

,ii;[s$
{5;$lF*r$ g${rgI
Fi*gaEag
gii€EII
EfFgiIigi
lEBs'i$$?siFlgi 1 E$i
3afa$ [tglri$
FgsFlFE ; +;EEia$Eilr
:1*;;tEF E Fsf9[E;E3u
1gilEiiliigE'rs+s1[rEl
IIFiiiiEEi
i
[
;eulael[EIifl
rsgla€ $$iEi $$3$'flnf;f
P

;ggrFgg
e!liigg$'iFll$
eregl
iisgggsliiisgggli*s
pgiEgFFflgiiii$E$Er3$;[
F$$$FigFFigf$gif
t-ig€= ;3
qrl
F$$FgEgiEEIi$gii
H o w w e m a k es p e e c hs o u n d s :p h a s e2
l'1cwi,arguageWorks

- A I Y
J ;.,i:_ x /
?B' rDt'o)--
-
3e3+:
='*E*FE
:
H*F- j;: ==
i*aag€€
€ir = T! I F = 3
J5 nB( o3f t =
j*g
H{
?lg€I;€ *r3 i ig=E
€ NL; +F
F+
7*n?iEi *F3 i sI s F 3 *
5i{rFt---

7E:€€Fqtai i LY
[ ; H' : F o o
-*H
d + 0 -

.-oo'o+re
;3:r 5F
qo?; :
?1 a31**?i E
6 rF
lE tie r:E? d3+3 ?q
=e 3;36'+13 Hdo6o!r
B E q 6 S.E
;:Z;E3E H3 FE E # 3 H
=:-oo6.;5'g F
AN
.JD b F A
ttU.

5 ap
E h l ^
E'
J F FI '_ a 3 5 5H
o
v : o - ^ . x \ P4 X
?-1icrr *E
=: i; F=. =o
o 6 o
= ? * 6Tq E 9E
o xo9,.
Y_
7r ;Ii; <=';.
Ei o:o
gI gorJ
g;"** O+H
@
ls
3 € 3.q3 9 q." o #ilE

E:g€fH*i
siFFE
$iiE $s
ii,F$[gE
iEEFF;Figg[
ls*F€1fE*€ii
:jcelig$iiF[[f1
igiEiiiiiigEiig
H o w w e m a k es p e e c hs o u n d s :p h a s e2
)2
Lil 4

i,

k*J
lo*
,**-{t

ii
i+llgt{3E
r'iI$Fg
IEE1!i ***'*d**

f
1*S I
rsi

,j"'*Y\
c#
11iEI[r[1EFgl1glliilE fl-*.tr
fr, l
&l*-E

11EElgE liEiEE lqJ ,

**4
' **[EElig
;xiE I EEE II ru
€{
iiE€ lEIEEi
?Aigg*Eg1BEElE
==vE;2=e
===7=eo;j
-
]* v ==; A E E QE ^F
''
: ;i oJ -

1:;FFia F Ef$+fHig€fi
ri+i;Bg s
rgrDgl. ; 3
6 =9*2, h
?5
s
=slEsE18
3;;F**q
f
6 :I
*$igflgF[[[
+djiHr;
o;; E,
-o
d ' ; S - E a ij5d 6
+5sr= 3. EFggEF
a '.;FEqi *
r#!3iidf ;
aE$ErFfli$if
E'3 3': I F !'
656H;es.
;#T;nsf
?: -H5'4 t
'afi€='*'s'
g 1=i T fr r
o+^.5;ig)
; rg: rfi q i0 1 F#s*i3f;ifFg€; #
v9:BteE
q I5 3 E:E
'dIq.-fra
E

ESTij =3f
AA
rJ

i''0!1 !,,/a t :'; n:r.l: :l !ilt.l i:rj.;


icEfFi$$
- ' ' . ' , r ' i . " ' I - 1 ,l ! - - r\ I I <

=i+i lgg
iE
lgiIli*gq'g
*s} Ig[€gg
g
Ia;t
ilEF[1['E
$i*gEsEir*iIIllE
;aF;€liiEi$ga *
t€$ii:i€
?E' i*FEs siue,A
=i ulFFeE;ElEtIta?ssr
iF!lti*legEEIIgiagE
a= F
=.o
;? 3
;i$*r+€;eiE*fi+eliEig
gigE; E?ri''F
aiaigi$lgEF?i
i| *sFFe
3; Ea*;$E ls$gise;IiFi*
*[EEESgEgIEgEI
1ilIFI -
FlFIIIlgi
IEEEIFigiEgfiEEg
ilgslllE'Eg€iEFI
1aEsI i lEiigFgE
iisii1l g+iiE
?+1gIgFF FiElE
igliElagaFraE€i[Ei
l8 Flow language\ftorks

3+ifrsH'ufi=
tq'oE6+HoBe3
3g;?. t;ro'rl:-e 6'
e*5ti*iiEe3. ;
3E?1.3+lii*i ;
E
i
s 3#i BErE; 3 +
;5:4a
ii oi
?-fi: 9ts5e'n q
5o=d'i;:lo'3cJ
giti3"i38J;E E
Ed d
=;t -
BSaJ Ft;8;B
=*.!.r - 6-
9" I I
fxii.H==X_N-*f:
Eiqaifra +ai+ 3
Farfri? ;=$ e
E;3iPI
'=rr+* -=Hn E
pd_&i6# iEq
-;i i=
6; Ea:! gFil o
= s;3 .-
d . g E E a [r F'o -
gZ6ef H **s
- ' . t r i
A I Y - J
*^
* P A a T O V Y
oH<r;=
=xo'ofSorI
Sianf E :rs
i'=0gr)='T6s"
Ei 3E ; =.g
?
{r Est:
FF&5

=7e? # Eisii
lqi+EiI1g€s
1iiii€[EgIEEi
11qli
illa$r$EFi
uag li13e *J.*
itiiiIE*E11EE111$ \t

tf[€i
:?1
i1;+;
ein[FiaE
==r?z
Fi FEHa[E;i {#
-*5*

rt/
\i
f&"L.J
sEEg}gElgEg3$lE
i"1arl.!-l,.i f1ELI;i8t i'i or 1.5

@/Do.)-tJt:r€:'FI PE
+i:tFXE'SJerie' -x
o-<

=<a
+:n3:+i3 nFEEq
T
o\<
,=l
IeeFg+ iEEfi a oo
=iirgFBq F+;is ?
1jilaerl'E1' { ='-

= @
€ ,
:7.\figl lesa n
Er i
71iegq+ 'gcg€ +H
1.-;)i V;* e6l
x;o-
G <
arl

FI
3 E'?qR 3qf d E:g
=.< x ; =-;
o' + =g'= E6+ 5 EE
=9P o- iio
'e+H r"o
lii i ; sl
=^6 xPi'6a'
i !; f
6gilp e
g
. S
, , c ici r:
C ==
d+i R
=
eE
Or ;H 6- d;s
Bg I 5F
- r

o
I
$e Fi[s
ii f FE
.jlii€
i ; 3=r sligsi lJilg+18€ ; il5t ; rFss
=is.e*, i3 s3Ai ?[ i i,i5Fa1g3flg?Fa;* r
si 1s
atif 3i; *$;E€s; it FErsEriE igr+i€r
i; i+31e;r{ i3++if iE+;l*[€:
at15f
rs aH l ef FE
; FlarfliiE
E i +f *Fe* +si s
q$i:
art E31+
i= Hi4F
+iEf
1;s3+q fil it$igsIi
IF+
sg;$lt+igigi1*;
€iEsii+EE1fE €tiFe+[€E
i*+35i
1fBif Ag*iFit l$rEE€E$FEIsE;
InfigE= $i
il?Eu €Eri;g$] ]+3ii ?* f+
?:a gBI' 1!EHI eE4i =er;,13i i i +[s
iElFfii3ggt3 r:iil r+1iI s?-gc*
#:;;s
qHdn+i3[IEFE q.g]gi; =si5[ r*Ea'-I
*rfq=F53tf.fi r ftSFgFH is3 3F
41
f lo$r i;rr'r{!.r,itf Yitf fi!

siEgTdTgr EiFsi$ lsErE:F r*1gf r #


r ; 5Er Es +EsEg€; $f FaE$; [ $f r g[ * €r :
il?tg+!+.'Ps;+
iraEHrEiEE'+iiii*[ii[c+[rge;*gi
: EPlq*t€is$slfl [E :q
igf,Bi+ii*+
1s *; s6 s ri H i! SgrEigl: iigi*=*1s*= Ii?
i: Hx + '' $ T a E;; E
1; + * IE= * 3 * g:,i 3 i€ i
gEFgTflE[eI
ggF$i$$r1H
=33E€
EsasI Ir1Ei+$
sEEB;
+ [ii1+;ilF;tEig
: ? f D .i l {
;5;[;+q[$a
EEiE€c a
seEir
EEsiiIe
i;zi:E[+i;
IsgiEE EEE5rEs1i;g3
1;EsF€iE5iiE5fr5E3Ef5E*fI;E16
?-'H13:;*Eqil :aci+$ ;Ie?iEg Eilii.^5
ggF*FBis;3iEr[+ r+sisr+ raf,i+

igggigiFilgriggi I
*iirii*ia= I
;'';i$rrgi
E5E$lI€?iFgEf
$rFgii'iiiFFF
glIfiiEigF$F
43
Hcw i,ar-iguagc
Wr;iks
t"f1
-*rx
f*'Y":
.1 tl
/l\
\3
*""qE**
J

illIiFg1gi1EEIEg;g
ti31$'-3susE[ilfiE

iiiiFiiiiiiFgigiFEiFiF
*igiiii
liig ir*Egi i
silii E$rii'
iiFFEiEfFiiiiiiiiFiFis
46 H0'fi langu3ge Works

1aa;1;
eallrfi$g
fi [stilta*l1[
i*EE*gllliiiig
*
zilell lEiiiiligEg
z11E€lIrgagEl*laatiitgitEIgl
z!1
tglIIag1tiEE +*EgIEIggi
i'
?1gg[lgf} ssif,e'sneIgll
i

tIrei
47 r J t W W e ' ) a r c e i Y eS l l e e a n
' '
-. -. :.- .l. ..=':.

48 i-iii'.nr I : rrlt-]3lie vvilii(':

;''=
ii; i Eil€:sFEg EeE**lliu
,s:
€a=
q$ii$si $E 1111[!5ir+sie
e iriiEt ;iiiir iFnrfi$IcE$gt
!1i'ilEiBqE*[[ilEii*g
Ft$|[i[iiErs
lij; -[glEeFFriaueAre
lzze
1-=" E
aE
;i e -tE*liIEgia;
=-
?= sIrE;
:=-= gilEt;; F[g*
7i1 ;Ei*E Ei E[IEII$
gIEEEgi ,gea*ftFi+Fi€E
ii ;

iEi*''s,lB*E*i ' I F
IE**'
;ilgeg? i'E*** ' 'i
g*Eig$lEil+Filii$ +
:iEsEiiEgEIEiiEllEEi ggeg
zalgg gg
* ig lgiEg
lglEig r: g
l€iEIFE€[l$EiigEEBiEEiEgIII
iii\,'v 1,r,'ate .i:frVa Sil*aail
-= -==.-.1- :.==:- ::= :.--=_.r.1-::.:.=.-- r - : :,=_ =:l
__

rl.w i;iiraua!ie Wof k:,

5'6 H H s 5 € E il'
* igE
E i € E f, E H e B s€ r s +
igB3E1+:+ii;*gE=
6-r_5 3 ", r;= E I F E E_e
: =P1qEH'EiH*6"x. '
eHo=.dnEgf;*S1;or
HgmlHtaE{3;;fqg
E q E f "r E:A s fi I H E F g
€tBqH8.:*>d:Pqa-,
c?eE 7 x,ia*i gElfr
i.sifig:e:HF:€3:
HB.e?6rjX'q;HHg:
H. o. ^ H. =6'nl-g: S*Ai
: E€t€ g;r TFi'r F F
318 $ a ; lgr f s s ;
?dli;sFgTFFT
j;r*F;iil*i*i e
e**33l*€fii;F e; 3
t f; tr1s E;e e F * &
E;f;r;:31s;F;
sFdlgSagi;bi *
3
i:f#i;uiPEf
qq$s*il;f;;TS a
A

ti;igf g ;3fg F sF;!'E=


8I;*
iiiiHsi frl[g;E$E
srissaFfrit$5[gEgiii
'a$gl;+$F r

lff3gu
Ii$ Lfi

fft
gEfgIgigfr3E;ri !;J

,'*n
!Ll

f*=j 1 ',*f

'f*\
!,.3:"?t ,d-f\
1iiFggIeFFiEiEI
igfFr ar FssEaii; {'*J
rilJ

rfl;
il ii

*:"
{? 4t
rr+e+a*['€lgfai
51
itr1 rT1
1Lj
52 i1Oy,ri.; 11g;1;;g9 \,trlr ks

?:ti'f €r*$ [1Fr !ilii


*;ti 3Egii iEIi
frii i['= t3gi
iiltf,E issit t;ar
ivls*rHss$ i€i- aE!i$
?|s+ff ti* ;l 1gi$ iE
ligirg rfi E; i3l$ F=;sFF#
rtci
==:rr=E3 ?EItE IFEEF
==1f5*
n+ :s
zii5i$ {E
s*
tr lii Ire *[;
€i
=EEg13 H* +Es Esr *i3
,;*EF# $* ;H f5l t+; g*g
,,issg Fa $E Hss gi;
C
=:-= g ? : 9.
=
A = : 3 f 6; .^A ga
=Eelir n
-F
f
(D
'gggiggg;r
! € H H 5 E
E-33'hi d: Y 0 =
r+
Fl i 6: r rD
XorO.o:!-i.! @ f
@
;.sts=E-a OJ
=
>: 3 5 F F t-|
o
#tr--+o =
q qJ
aHfqq;
!
*3+rAA
-rPa:5;'
-
6
o
f
l*?iscailnl
q f
J 6 H l *
rD .)0=? >n o
+, -r
Fe [: + A
q ^ !
n'
oq o
-:<o< e
iP=
2 ' 6';lU 5 E
(D

3:l qd E f
:.Fs&=-' l.)
f

C'
giigiggiF
6'o*dl I
o
r+
EtrSIi rTJ
I N F : ii T
>a)-t
J - 6 <

n
8.93+3E r:
grgirgsri,
53
56 l-ll!'v ia trt i.r; le'!fu rtkt

'1l*;lE1'*i - e*
1;siaiEftlil;'1[[
i1l gglg E
lIgiIiggEEEg1
[g
liEggE
rii !
I
+zEElegI!EEggElEllliIgl--
:=
:iiiE€t3,=;#ig{irTiilEi?
f;cE
;i;EEEiFiEEElEgE
:iii€riErculglggE$
;
ic**= E€
*lEl3iEli[g
sE
F1[F1i
UE
gE1iE1EF3i
57
iE'FEI
H o w r r y ec e i c r l ' t e 5 n g i . 1 1 5 ; r 1 . 1 1 i 1 i s
58 H l , l L a n B L ; ; g cW c r k l
{ 1i

It
\*J i,
3gf i s 1F FF -F :
lFx; S s{ i; _q
F; id = ;; Errr;d
"-;e:;: HH i i,
{d:
e;:F;c:: , t'' {1
3+3H
\av:! E 39oiB \^h" cro
3 :;*
i.gr
TT Ete
F=EP rD +3 ;aIl*
f ;?rE :3 qairi ir; 8
LJ-J
g
\x$
rl

;;ai aq f;aie Q o -*1


u^ -5 I^ :; Ie:Eq ! =
E ' L*.3-*
?xB'5 !i., :1 + qi6' tt
tEIf =-q ;5 =
E" t3r ' ffr
1^U
-o=xe. J- ' ! €F ;E - 6+x5 L/1
ii5;-XC55
rl;1E i; 1)<
B H1r ; tr\1
rfr
ki*-J ij
",='-.,+\o_.+(Do5
tr[=:
-=F.H='Erg + eE= i gEL e : 1

<^Y'
7e3+3 *E r i;F
q@.+''€
=d: -d- 4p 'Q3 ;"++O
$ ffi
f-ir
I L*j
EaEX EH I E 5
iXqI
iq6; -[v
3? ;9 + f
35F 6 E r
eBe H ; 3 g
69.3r-,*
J +E I- 6' n
f.
;o
d6? {
lXI R H E g
d=?-gl=pl

=s ==P =
5€p t!s' .D-
S
=
- '=i +s
i;EFil 77TF VF3 9r ;l t!
qrN r6' @='
?il$ 9J-
F
=dqcs
e.=+=XctXTRPxi
s?;$ r7{-
o.o 6'rll=_:arDg9o
d$
o = 5P-6 ;H+-s HF
t(D ==?=.or=.oorrl
d :iE
r.)
g. E g: FtFd
ppB"5. ^*s { o
-
. l ; l
:€gq HB- d
qa g G o -
!'i.; + r-:;6
E- 9o
= 6.do -
E
:-6-
= =oa = - r s ?
rDe x
a33; rfi*F #*
!:i'Xtr.,:XY--Y .)
oa \ +;
- J40a g
?:E- ' =
73 A
(D B <=' ,.1
!=.' d
:r.;. i;F.
!tr . - - <
-A t
qq .1
d

n <:1
rirt s;;
H;3
{
;:|.)
:Hio 2 d
n
H;Y-;5='oo
J v ;;' o# r. o
€ 9e . ;
EH[F r-H'y-O
F+Y ;
€ ei+girD=* €
-
(!
Ffa=. -
j'EF o
t'7
+
o -
'X^^'o J
0 iip r; R *
r0J3A;i -
tJ
'o r.t
--6 r E =fr fr b
i#=3':oo ga
6qU :9H H Hl
f.O*rD;s-- -
a* [ qEF n'
qa 3F -
;
1xt
lrlhOa)+ F
F ; 50rD:oo ir
-
_
-g PE1 E= 3 -
3 *r *3 I
59 i i c v . i w e c e s c r i i , . ec o l ; c i r a n i i J I i d \ . , i -ri !' e i i
r l a r , n .i , i r E , r l q r - i r , . l. ,

E q=s
+ S +€,f
gPlg f F 1sIf f A Bii T=f a g=€ FFS
si!$+q Fis+; a Fssi f i=t+ g[+
t*lE[ *fE[-: #tid EFt Fr'E g5-
=-<< oE
;s[g i aElf fgE gs
ie+s: :q5t gF
+$ a3
eEes +ig
€ B:sH 3 qse H"xi; i
*5ii
ggHV 1
e.*1d =
iEF ae* [i ]?D
F:3V
g3i[
iiaH r Elid Hi: El s
rggg e:gi
f+3f orr P53 r
H["B
J*
's a
?+gl i_Eqf r* i
=;Bs n=i3
gF[:
q E*sc-
q ii f; f
=r+s ',Ln 0'.
Et= E f E
rc 0
1X z
=.5 = i
r) t B" :6

;-E+ egif e-:=33 3[ g€


Fs #
iib: gr$a ; Fs; 3F
qe
E
ig;F ;t;[ rri
gifl # ;
- v ) p A
=F*i Pi=; 3$ € F
?tii
lleE ;?ii
r€;E *rs
i+E
si
SS
E
I
r
H

{l
: I ssirl
rEA lri-l glir,lgglig
€r*t* I iEg+ gr:1+ Eigfsf
F[[gglggll[iili.ggg
iig gB;3 EFE
;IF€[ I ; :rg3
+ Es33s
**i*r d ;i i
;[iii;igslg-FiE
*$€v a si s*+s s+FFr
6t
6z r l r ' " 1 jL an g u a E r v V 0 ! ' k e

=iEf *FE+*g€r*;' '. " gE i;ESs


)Er
El$E3rE;ile+E5ie++r[
*g+i€EFi€ir
gE
7EiEIEEElEfiIEE[$ 3; if
1?EEEIilgEEIEIEI
=,i3Fil*BEien3;I*te*;]g1[ Eg$*
i
:il tE i6Elgi3ei3i$3+Ei:
7iila t[[E
gipf€1g
zlit; iBis*uglg t giI+
filer;36ii [€$E;F -[gg
11$e$[r1r?gglg?Ei]
=:F== E9; gE t E = =
-ZF'4-- €
= - = = = ' : - Y = =
;=i3i3I .o -
F ;=a=q=
.;:i;;P:?. s-- = -i 3.3 e Ff
H e6"t I eo 3l*8P-s ia:.ii-,=
== !; oi;{:I

=1gvga39.g I * e; 3 n e s F; dB
.7 E x ' a E : F- ! E' =36'3
-7oa-Sg:'ocL ;: E: ; {
:: ?
i 5 crbd<HH oT: p g U b I
4;7 a g-* g 3; I qq; iEs'5F F : ?
<-f.io=HVb6'F
lieilgae+{ t : r; . a=a Ha 3 ;
: iE E3F.F€: * 1so, E. ; T'n HEr *
*5r=: i e a 3
a i=a#3:
c_g,il*olg='F?
?d :
qa,E*++n*1b
.-+oH=.=.<g
=*ra=;Hi! E :o=E+
3i:sfF
^076-==+o:
qs e
i'[;i;E;sT; -E=;.EEd' 6+ H
? gEF; + E?i1;3 a-! 7
i rs Bx $s; XP6-H=F
KE{. ; s; nd b
A-@=- 3H i
E-Tee
6iH.RF'6
Is EI +
, *cgg€:t !l-o.<!
# E
1 i,+sltE; d
3
r 5s+3
2 6 i
Pd6
{H €X
3:=EHHa -vX + i ' i = ' i d X
5 {d6 d -
;n 636qi:d \. -
F J - f r - "o
o t =. A 5' E

: g;HsEe'3 ; ErSi ; 6
_K+ii{3.cP
axtoooL.
t 6 E F rf ii ?!ior;5?+

63
64
o
a

o
s
g
1i5EErFtiisigr:3gEE o

;1**liElEagalEii*a+ o

^l a\/
*H I irl s'a
*o '/ o
:i? ?i;Fi*gliEeii!;- o
\
1iat€s lo
I
lo
iig?lAiq
1gE
l1} 'i o o

G
?18F
;=,s€aFiiFXtieE
1i :i;+eEiglEi
?[:l
i?sg
.eItgteBgeF
:1 te*tgi'Ellg
i" Eifl3
g$ -; q;.;-r,,; ' :-AlRil+F+itr*H
ce;
iaEilisiri*iii3i eiaFlE E
a**
1E
Ii'ril€ililigigi
iilEEE
tEa-1iIElgiiiiis$i€
aEtl*fEiE1*E-[g
g
s i I
g * [ r E I
s' iIegssa
F + i g E g 3 s€;Fr*gtF
6S
tc*[E3F*igfiFlg.iE$
I'lo!i.i!.;e ie5aIr3P acfltali';I|! 3ia; va**e:5
66 ilovr'l:nqu3gc fvorkl
tl
{

g1
qLj
i fl

{;
{
Iggi;iqa ri1
1Ld
:lgiagg;i lEEg1 i1
qgfIxteE if1
LJ
:*YYA
+1g i;g5fi;!
lgpg {}
.*&*€ 3
i"J,"-1

tqf Jn!
i'=i3*-fIEElgi
iErFEEgEE
, i'" :*:.
i1 $"N
qLr f]}
71i
!1iEEE $
IifrgE
[E Ea' 'i*ltr
L,'

ii
iggEggligggglli+i -:

:ii ;iFii
:+ietiiigBsi

izz;' igig 1 g
1gI*rig
ii cif g igg g,gg
iligE
z{tlggigligg; ;
'EiF ig*iaI$[i
iiiIgilgglligilgiiigligi
ggEg*ieir
lgea3gl sFrg$g[
67 i-lt:r*;
vrc crganizethc:lrndl of sp,:rrir
l'lt\\ :,r'rlr.1pF Vr.r."q

Es#EEFgsEHf
F F#e Hg
JggaS€5Flpcg

€i1iigiFE 1EiEEiF IFIE[Fi E


Ei+€i ;s i ts*iHels sifl*r i 1 i
E
. IiIE
f[+P ;
lglgEeiliaigg;i+*$gI
?z=*q
*i gf$ii: *:iFg=;€
iAi j *i is
/;eiursrigtE[;ialF$*gie itidE
;E$sEeIs$[Fg;}EFi;iHE 3Te s
E1;iIrii:irac;gE:;E1[ii fiiI c
:=!--
=i;?;iigilii;illiEiilpE
--a=:-
t;* e
=
-= - o = aaa
o-
=- = x o
a 3 3=-3=-9X> €! f
'., = ?. A= fD
+ J_'\o\O:.< n *
i'' Fic,do!'8' a)! -
-- o
a< =' d o A: 8. d'e5+F
arn (.: n E
a a oa - q o =
n o :. l:F*\eg{ oi€ n
-_ qJ N o ga
E + ==E8:geE ga
:E f x .) l.\
LX
q r1 6
= ' r xE
' + 5+: +i: Fg oaq N
=8 fr T
a (/t'
J d0)
-
q
q e'5; a
- .D oo q, -.:'l
3 d I 5': d T-' *
q a -. F J
;i u< o w -
{=: ' q
H a=v,;+E='
iX'i
n
c- r-l-
q9. €
o - q
t)
6'+ "33riis-a; Aq
n - o |1 F ga
0 D;+(D5rD.)+ rD
ga o*;
h T; d -n
'irD oJl T : " 55g e*F q < € Int o
5 -, q?<
€ ..) o FA rD
€ c 49.
rg d .J
r€ {8 FE H F Z H A ?+
{ € G
6y c
-!
.+ o. (, _l lFe,F6+9
fto -r6
- S-
(u o,P!;6"- o
rD o iJ. r ai
- 6 - J+ (n
0
X -r tt *x o r) 6a' F6- H*- bF
5o
gd o @a
a 6'
f) E. + (D-
K
g ^ ' i o 6
IT d
qr ,€ =:HFE =d'
-; .: l!' g o.D
6 5= il
ho. o
q
qq o z'3rilK9.
@ o
+ + 9qs": 3 HB
€* Od K .tt
X5 a ? ^ , r D i ; o . D 6 -' q
- -
0= t+ -l oh;.<6-b =< o
11 { v.)
O-q |) q o ^: o, P-9. -or
g)@ 6
t€ (!
ln :s Ua(e. L.
.) 6o :.cjS"=cro_
.) - o h'35o,o HrJ
-- ' {x F
< rT:
F>
lu. <, rD ^l-*:--\
cE o :t:N5^,
rDo - o:+5q.Fd. pJ oa

69
zlre 11[1[sligI
+s ert;ggi-
I€lEEE
*gg
;gEE Eleglg$g
ligiggi
'iglg-g!6ptliaaelcst
if**ig
'1a;g g$FrIfi g$Fi?iIu'
Ii'*EgggiEglliEgii

lL-
i 1rw 1..1
r: ;-:L;'r;i: l.;'Ji(!
72

$gFaI
iFAiHi,;irs
eg1g?
EAA{ FgAHgI
gE[$?Eli
ifiIttF
€ d F E f i 518'3

iggs
igi
iiii'gi'gi+gFi
g**h
EIE+EIEi{$*Fig$g
'iEFEfigg$ig$iFli itj

t:
I
*--?1

EgFFE$giiiEFiHi {t'
i,

ss :r si;eifgF ri i ro.
rn
! i*l
iirL'. I -: ,4' j ..r- \,\. ' .
74

ilE[[i=*r*iEI
s EgBlIEEE *
:EEEE1ia;i$
g
r*gga# ilglE
EggliEiig
lilEiiggigiigriEggii
ilgglgeglglgggigig
? [gr*

ili 5iiFiEF;flEsgiFFiiiiE
:=."+6,
?F6=ii-eisli*Fle$!$
=i3'ii*iggeagi$i
=a'
iln iFegBge
+sag
+uaeF'*[c*E*'F;;-*i
r';s;*ru
;E iEiil$ggf ggfi
gi,i;g;gggg [+$F
ci;i,$,eFii$Eg-riFIIF
q;
l9fFEFir€gFFFigi
r l c ' . , &v r e u 5 e t c t . r f o i ' v o i c e
li)w l.ar E n ;.'iECtll,*)r'(!

rEilinss'i€
ii1l[t
;E*$EEgg1[Eis!$ *s
ii*iErsEEFE ee€
IggiIiilEEEliE'
?iaslgigeg3gIg-lts
lli
=: ? i e I +i;[:
19i:IFg1[[rr;F*gEie
?v ="
:- t
1==
TEgr€iEgIlic''u*iF
=a5
L^J-
ila[iiiEleglt*ggt[[ge

iirsi$i$iiiiiFii$giiiiiig
iEitl$
;giggEiiiiFgiiiF;gsi
igiiii77
78 i i i : w i a n S l r a g cV l l r k r

s$r'E+i;uEl'rIeiit ; se[$*
g $
I Ei i E; FE+$+
3ti€F i n$ f rsI
iiiF3e-EqilgI[;1
r a$a
ileF$g13riitrIg€$E
*;EgcITtf;* $ fEfFi
Seglgst
d *r;e€
EEEgfFEli*€E ifisil
[gri+iHieE$EfiEii
Bsacill*cargfEfE
7.;7if ;eF*ufi,
_E3;;gf
i
43

r
?iIEg-FFgigEiEFg {&
\Ji

i'3lg
gE:gI
iiF€ EiFti€ig giEr€+sE r?l
I L"1
13

srig€ 5 d*T1

ab i'
**ry*
x
j
iui** Elrgis+E
E3A*' **-i
{n 1 ;;t
*-1
Eg$sgFIEE+[FIsiii {"ll
r*"{*
*"**
\-*1-o tTx
x t4f
?;r$Ff;iFSl€lgEIi fT:
*3 f\1
&,i-d
;raF ;rargFr+ Isrrg b*i-- *-%
kti rfi **5
71F €
i--
1ra rIglgpfg
1$
F$1Eg*g
1g
iIg

11tlg! iataEggg I1
i11g
1gI}ig1a 1i'
Z'l
IEi
AE Ei1lEiiE
lEEE EE
lElilI*l
T?
a= l !t a!
.J' r: !,
.1 %> o OJ i
(t) o
E 0 egt
rf! ? €
or { g>t -l
o lD * -l rD
9.a .D d
{ d
xx d = ci6 rn
<:
.D ,v + o
X^
+
o' r.t
|.) 0 o d
=F
a- :n a d n
rO ii5
x- )3 o
d
=H d o (lq E a + ,r, FK n
o^ K 11 q
F q 0
o .l P ; a q
{g d ^; 6
4 +
a XX h G
r: + (o - .)< d
6_J I (t - '' { n
o a a cra
6-o o - r.t nFt
a q - !-t
r) ? -0
$- xo ,..1
tP .) o< oa '| I f):. q $
I 6 ii+ -
? N a Y r.t
xri d o { ? q
!.
a) :: d
n
(D n a xx
H nl il v)
0 a) r.t d
- -' oa q95 0
r-t a 11 a)
JD .) uf; I q
€ - d
a =
d6 .) .! 0 =q
I< o 0
x9) X
0*
.) r) o{ K a -
6
qrX r.,t q 0
OO
ti. q a
5 (1 (D ill (D
{ < * . rv ofD - 6
.D K 0=) |D + JD <
n ,1 a
a) a q a
rDX ts 2l o< 5rD
.) -l a 6
E5 - h f)
a)
.) 0 0 r!
|) vS o oA o.5 €
Xr" - .n h\< r.t =
q
6 - f!
0a >< t)
€ (Do + nt
I xq) q r.t
I
c r c | r D -l
tE ta i
;
7o @
tuq=
n '+o N iio 5
tt d
n
d Xo: x .) o x +
K 0 K
0q o 5;-i
rDT I >.1 o + o r) t\
v)(D 0a -
0 i,n @ 2a
f1 7X q +
q o S
5= { - -r<
0J ,i
a) E
x0
- d
9d 5O .) o d + lD
q oT o lD d oo :a 64 o

8r
8z rlr:rv i,; r'rgrt a e,t lirilik I

r
E
ii5iFgiaE .
*FH i
rE ;*iiiiE+E
IfEEEE
ii; 1e *
ig.friF$, g e
Ig;gI13E[
gi
;ir i I iEEga? 1sg!;i
fI i*gBg =
[!;IIfi[;!!
g*;gE
fr EE fFf
='z;Eiag, tegg
FE gE
iFE1[[as*g€ Fac
2=r-'l?iFE1iE$iilgSiE
=zre; *
;+AF F[$6
iI9l 1[?IFE-,EEgEl[
:=:3 a
dc F=E
+ I -.
=4s 3 o G ao
=- r;5 iF lCx
e' c-e- 0a c.O -O-,1 - fD a.=.
- F
fi- oQ=\: OrE d 91 o
7a"a = tD iJ. ='
r.) <+ *l Ii , q a HiJ
-e- 5 = Fv q - ll h n
:--J, - lD - P . Y U
F dYY+
o 9)5o o "3=it n oa@
-v"
o H V Y n 'Eta ; +FE I ,^Y^O
I ogJ ; .ri :+ c *=0
!Y+J
o ;; s# q
==tr(D
a t.H o |1
5rr a 3frsq €re3 € +=.
c:d;*
oa ?o v:-x oooo
H
o O.) >+=r5 NF.+
5 6 a =3s t+
6 o o <9 ^ 6 A F .
r-v3 q B q g# q + l: ;-i ot
o =o i
?.60 0 =d e € +*ii U
' A : H Al^- =.O 5rDJo l':'-l
=vn
oJl! r- -.v+v . = o --,OoJry )oJ i+
=g;i EO I PF
€ o ilt1E '' =Y-a
rDo.;+ o E
i;;i3 o .D zt d
l!F x55a 0 R ^
:+ ^.-:t o € <=
J9J (!v- w xF9 o rD:^< TD.b
S€ 3 3 o € + 6 p
a 'a + xQ4 .sNYJ
F F IL
r-;:r
(DlD
F
rD € +=5 o o - -o i: oa
I
T - ^ o ga qa
=+ F.ET=
FJ.=r + tssJ RdA
F - +v:.rD a n orDc
d o
ioE :vv p + )qa
K g'; q
X ct
F3r9 I
V H € o fHr<
@ aO - 6
q5,i6 0
0 H : ov *
+ o lD!.^!, - o) :.:
(D !D ;-'-:< I H
.)^ ix rDx;i
l^J |.) - € + :s u o >.1
:q5 0)x i'vx - .--
iP
=+-o) T P5. ^rA
a
=a nFJl =o95 g)=o
elD OQaqrO r.t F J '
;-ooJ €+5 5= t')
=o gq x +X o XPOJ
:<:t -l q qql - f.)
9q)v Q d f-aF
6 Y v <s r
OO =5H n Flv*
o -0ad !'+
c i( lt E. . -l f3r.? -^qO ;i. 4
@ ? o I CHJ€ Ont
5rDi6 n o "+ tr;9R q €
4 i-:. d
qO) .) qfEr Ftvrr
d o d' o-+
a x<d 015
'+Cro-l a)
P q A- t - q n cxa
:<= (D o = ^ d. n hXg
AE OJ '':6 o-;- - *
6
:FYba F7'- rD
+ 0' 0
O ts' t-
q E s <'o
Ytx 6 Qo) EOOQ *98:"'
-x e (\0 oo ,.1 fD3
- - F l (D=9J €=. qo:El o - sr5ffi
) J q J oa rDO Pqq
lD(D\ (D -6 K q- 8.:"*3. p)+q e6

83 i - l o r "cvh i i d r e nl e ; r n s p e e crfs o l i n d sirl e l r s t y e a r


8+

sEil;;.dgigF
iggI6+si
EEEEFg
$iia=c1€*E
;lEiltgilE
fi * +i ?EFf E3q r r q;
gIigr+[c
til;S i;a;-EIFF;i*g*g
==sEd i8f 1i
g
tt'fEegiilFFi*g[€EI i f\.
FiFa*gpt1lir;11 *T*T
6 tl
itlf 1 iL/

{#
1J
*Y
iiiEigg€g?iFiFIeliF tu $

r**"
{ ;s.
"r*l j

i. -"p
'i:M*
*e''?
"
iiiinlfg$$6iii$!ecss
=ir1 ;EiElr;;iiiia[ l*T\
a,

ini
bJ j {

il1
i-"f

&r""n
3!i-"d i*x
ifr:i H;t3ae;; +iFgg **t
; f'1
85 ;,*1 J
:Eei laa
raE+a iEa€:€s!EEE
zilEgE $E1g;
i*1
Ii;Egglli IEi-i
=l1lglgii+aEgii i'**
Fs-E +
g'glE**
g1a*l

-
.o -
ae €- =<=a
€ =a'\{ 7.
av =. o =tr-ije- 5
;
o' = A o
g; o
J 4 o
F^q n
{ ;q .J
=T
:r 6Y .)
Oh n F o
93=.F l@ a
-|- + d { rD!J X
rDO € {
4.tr oo|D =2=;:+
^g) d qa
n € +
w n o !ri o
^= :x q { K ii@ -
.- 'o6oo ' o
rD =.6'E' K
Ft
fiFt n o_ .j 69.32 o
{ q
:F a-o so'oP o d o
; . 6
6' - c ii+1 5gq
oJ ;:. 9*A- !- a
o aV+ir' F q r(D
rr< a rt
:;i = oo5 =
.) oalDe
l+n - + - 5 n q
Z-a o*
-r'gx
(D
0.J ti =t.* -l
!-r o * ab
a + .) -tyd(D 0
o5 + o q =-6^
ltP € 2* o2r
5rD
yF0 9"o (.) + A', 7
-@.\-o g n <o -
6X - xO
nid 0 Q =
^..) od <R + 6' 5\* EF',?"* oa q= a)
ro i'ri -xg o
o. xY .o@ - =6
rFJ.r)< {
Qh q - ='q
g€ q + :boE'+ 0
tP.) o qAX l!- - n
g)O :r.V qJ
i:' {3 <5 X € r- 3 I a {
.D X:a cto {
fD € a) a) fDL{
t.€ =0 €Y o
(Da { #3; F { o
orD t+ 6
-
6'(D J'-Eda'
2n :s 6 ^ )
€o. O5 r..t 6"t J - I H. d o5
- t= .q { € TD+crq {
I qok='
n(D s:I
q0 o- P.-'i* n
A-^ a ;+ r-t
Oni .) (D F*.; q
I d
98. <* a) X-o €
;E' O. .i- =o 3*?o- -l -:
o
q
(rEl Y
+
a a) { o r)-
q.t oox n gv)
- xi E r) F'.D..-B (1
= .D'
tn d l+ tt') 6' K
='e 3< -o'- . :t {
J -+ a,',5 0J.) Ft r-t ,.1
loO oo ;' *3 :f
c(t

8t
i - l c wl a n g u : g e W c r k :

zlliEEr*gE3tIEaE i s til
€=-'
-=ilul*$gigit;gggg
} $g
::Eiggggigg1iga+
=,1iB1gEfiIi$EEIg
Z3l
IgEBgIEEi?EFF
1aiiEi1[E E
iFlgFFriE
-iig$igg3i
s;3-Egg+t;e;*f
ii$Ei€ggiI
fiEfitag$ii
gFF
;gF[€$FF$gi
89

L*.,.. .' *- -
9o
t nl ]
\*J \.4
**L*
r fl}
$$
[;l:egi=!grfi i =r 4
v. a 8'\
L-s i
ii
-iFiiiiiglIiiEiEii i*;

r#
: !i
\ i*r

1i

ft
Lt-$

iglEgIl;EgEF€[i
3
=t
=3 ;€: ,- € I { 'E
G = It o
=:_ C- 0
E g a- I
o
-o
l7 --:.aJ F t! r') t.) F5'= -cr .D
: . J A X:' @!t d ='
-F ')o a) a .D
n Ea) H cra
q v0J5 -hi F-n
83 a) l')
Jo=o) q o
<= "dE q 4V q-.
T:; r) a)
.:<'vfr a I o c
L< t1 rn0J + d
= rT^ iiJ!
dtP< a)
- '- 9 fu7 . x t ir:
$A
i= ' r * i r
90J<' {
/- + t u v () 26 ++
O'O'n+ iio o >+: J ? K
='+ i o90 r.t a -'
v= ^<
o F
-o q*:
-(D :s rD
>0q- o
-- IP O.+ IX o id ! e. li -.1
G AH
AnB: v
0Jtt .l q
iH oo a) r1
9.=rx' =<o (D
:^:i.D (D 0+ Y ;iq =xri? €
r.t (DJ
t< . xo a $t@
-=€ * oq qO 9J^ {
6
q P; 6Y tv
X'@<Xi Kr
-- q; ( D a' g. 1^ cra;rD
ry : c>+ +
o^ 7t a) ; . P ;
r.t q d n; 0
;-5'g -l =+
-x .{ g) i+(D r-t
w o:; fr
i8.3-x ?i+-i i.:h tV .D- =
K n r.t i.,
=T <i'i q t9 -oIt€ JA
"_LSOa; ): !)! p jhi:J ga
1A-=r o =oo - +
6 V P f) \<+ I
()< K
.) {
a a <p d?X
'oxpJo 3 e: (Do q
{
r= x ,vN €
<5 ^ K o
q Y!)o -v- o
9ffi !6 {
S-: { n
^< K OEr \lf: ?.6'n q
nP +x d
^:A i o
!*Hf :t|.)h q
o
nqi o
a' F 6 = n
A H o
-.4 HpI <s' q - J *
o
x * i:'< 5
= H a)
0: - vi- q.c f)- { E: qI
o i (D< u!,-
€ ,l
'5 q e o
39-3.: d ^e r. D = (. 9= n
ci='2. rD ga 6 aqi -
fD o'
'Y ^ - a) .rJT5 (D (1 o
=< A ;i ^(D (!' :'=<
d a
- 169r= n -+l tD-=' m
:a o d )^:

-- j;+-(:, :) p J r, q :6: rD I
sj= n
^r + 6 o X<s K
o {
JXx. lLir i' € x 0
X= o (D !+ ='
P / n (.)
eg8tr I
92

='=;H
rEF; ' *i*r-FE+gi+iFsggF3g

,ii + FfEFiiiEiiiggiifF
icsarsEralgE$ig+$€af
-ga
lilii;$$f6gg;,i!gggg
a
=1s 6{€;ier€F3:5
iigg$tEfat i
:ri*lfil*Feril;le;'rEs'i
iiF
=-1gJ
=€6 EEuIg;Eg$r
fr'il'ugFfisg
:EiiFiglfgi{Fg$FEE
==7 ?=-==
3A'i
t!
:f
:== a3
i^ F aaa E*,
q) ir: o
* 7 9 = 0 Fr V)
o 5'1?g
sErix6ox.o
€ ts € FF+arilG; F* @l
1 = .x=a )3
saiJ
d .l 6i Fl :/ Fl
A'A
€ - +< ^: i 5E
!J F rD $r =.6=iri6po@ od6
--4J I q
'-.D o >.1 r5 Qo.R;:Pr>0 A; r i A.g.E
JA I a
Y (D
jvva f)
-- 5E F a H?ge E; : d
=OAX' o *g - P =5'o€{
eq a) ry-<+aD *d
- o
F A 6 V p ^-
*
q'r
d' += I
=AoJ- o
-=irq a :!o,o6o= d.3EE"&?Eq xP
vC,r<; :' -' .*i 6; -l0b B E '
Ani s;E?Air33
o A:
=-o= q I
t,ij
^i, A
rD-i € 3rf 3 sft { s
.-X,i F .-t+.-srQ-
,r
--aJ
i. @q
d
(1 d
g$;gi:*n
@E
=-Xoa
:-+
K X OrD
q
JO
5.3*F38
;J J; -rA yP - : i
Pi
<o it
o.) o'/
iru3Ersr
o € aap+,
- ^-A
?Z E; rD |1
--3trX
)q- /-r-
$(D <;-=.q
= " E'6 YX A\O!/
^n Fnq=gr
I o JA -
* l^J
= ;-.i. fD -'
(D o-rhgX
i ! F:9. ;HsE gi
* s-
z e P-'o ^ rl I
--2+1 Flg=[
PITIU6
a^v --6i

+r;E - rD rD
X O .i' -3p*
P^^l
f
'gtH* i. I
q a rD ,=v
aoo Y ' -
o ;t E
-;dii {o. --
=o) rD rD o o='0:n'
o a
7X9:' A:
- E-Hr = ffs
re ^
€;gs + I
i + r.t
9.< n
" ^i .7\ =
FPg
- x ^V
-: o-J=^ ltD + -
Y H
(.) :f
Y A A -
J o O
(D I R
'"?Trd q 6-X |.t r.t @=l
F J
iig+ :a
i3T3 ie
3
Q
=-P.er (D q IL
v+-q)
- o 5o-7 \l R
-v-{o o
=q.^ fD o \
-.+C: - E6' - o os
'- 0)
i.3
r) rD i;7 b i
a a J ' - @ tD6 u
T5q ?
;F FI Fi
€n Fq +
ji\,1' '.
93 il::ir'

#ffir*H1
l-{awLanguageWorks

D Etl
a at a=.
H

3 3 It ru I o vt
o o = a D F p 6' 0, o
Fl
&8
o 6
D f E E 6 9, Fg F
Fl
x ID Ut 5 i' It 5 g:
G d (D .D 9J tr c' Fb o
i' (D o rd o 5 tA )r o o
F 3 o o 9. o 5 5 93.* o x E€ X Y ct o.x
r? 9J I t('
X E) o o fD K 'oV) !'+. n nEr rD
€ F o Ht n s)
hl 9. o o cr Eg o ito S) o o
x S) fD 'o € g rd { n 33 r-l
*s
3 |1 (D o E j u, 3 €
o 5 \5 fr ch yb
|) .S
v: 9) tn 15 8J o
o 5 g o FJ o Ctts
9. (D \s I gJ o F FiFlS ofD o
= Fl
o 0. o r) v,
Ut
o K - o ( v, (D 5O iD o
o fd o TP E
Bg
6't
fD o. o 5 g F (DH.5
F "g Ft 8 q
rno P5 o f: 9r
n o u, fD o o 50
o H. u) 5s) U,
0)
S) OJ o g) u, n ri' sr \J
9) v, o ! . . l H o o
s)
(t) o ts o o otJ ql
f) (1 cr g o X P.o u, o
? 0J (D n o o o vt s)
n o v, 0) F Fl v, o o +=. o Fl +H
V) n o
o tD E o n |') F *€ F + 6S (!
a q.
tv, o E(D
o o .J E'O v, q fD n E.8
-(rr F g. F 9) o o o trd V) t) At
hl
r!
9)
9J F o rt o
v, JD r)
ts o. o 5 ' FJ o o i lf,
a o oq
s4 i+EH F E C' P; >t g)
o o o o o o FEE F o
o E5
95'
0J 4 o.o s) o
F o. ; pr S) K o vr

(D Fl
w n
o0) 5 f6 d6E
t Vt 5 o. 9J F
o 5 F F (D o I o s)1 oq
a 0l g b 0) \t v, g o
Fl
Sq H K t) Vt o
u, 9. Fl) oo o u,
o (D F 9J H' p) o
o o 5 o oq 5 o F 0) I F) o 9l )-t Eg
vt o fD tr" 5 o o 9r !-t:
qH' g, E Fl ttt -vt $5 tsl
o. 5 n AVt
O. E9r (a o
o s K o o !1' crQ
9)
'& o o (D 9r H o F v, 3 0l Ilo
€ o € Fl
SJ o o F Vt o 0)pr !.+ a'= (') !" n 5
a qa o v) o 5 H Evt F '; : 0) o
l-f: o 9) v) xE
o 9r g v, n 9J Ft p EE' qq E)
z, a (D € Fl
ts S) Ut F. ra uro (D t-1
FJ I o 9) fu sJ s et o Fl
o b o o tn ? Fl o. ltt Ut ET
,ri ? 5 g) 6I tD (D U, \J 5Fr o
g o Eu, g) I F ll, r.t o
(D 0. o o U FI
,f gl5o
ts €o OJ
OE o
gJ o o r) Ff 0J cr
o X o o 5 E o o o n o o E_E v) 5 o H'
FT
(? g, € I Vt
o o
(') 0) p) o oB-
9l o 5 lt e F Fl v, o n n
H.n 5Ff
I o Er-l
O) 0) o pFJ o st v,
Vt o o) \t ; o o o 9l
,,O o K 6" OEor Ut
.5 !D o F] 3,F
r! @ o I
o oq a i-l t
gq n +)ctFl o {? X . )-l or F og
o o o
g o
jn I { tr g) o s) F o o C' FI i+ !t G o
gJ JD 0) s) s) o +oE {
(D o S i'r' o qq ut tsB
v) gq n oq o 0J trd o :r (D 6i,' g.g
oa o. q0 F [iq Fl
E o E ts o o
ttt o Ut
v, o o rD T oa E9r o E o5 qa 5 i'rD
o' F tD o 3 n fD Ogl vt
E F) o s rl o u, o Ft u)
n o 9J € t-l o o
o o 5 n hl !
9) oq 3E',n g
g. E'
tr (D tD'-r \J g)
o pl o FI ttr.l c o 9) o (D
g o 0) tO- o o o :+ E. o V)
Ut r-t 5 ts o-tshl E-r) ut sq v, cr
o o v, o s) F 0) o o ct o
oa o I v, r) f) t --. (h u, Eb H -
FJ qa 5 gs
V! C,i J5 o F 5v) o cr oq
f) o { o fD E v, o
t-l $ :'r5(D o o o o
-c' 5 o 0) o 5 ;+ l-l
9) o s) \t s5' FI n
0) o f.)
(o o o o () F doo u, OJ $l
EE
FrO 5
r-l o F n F6' P)
fr1
Et I
r) o 5 Io € o I
o o gl 9r s o cr
rFE. r$ I i6T ga o
Frl v, hb gq g*
hi

95 How speechcan gCIlvrong

\_
l-'l*w Lang*ageW*rks

aE-E:E*a,93il
$Hrra.E=EEgg
iitagB$;HFE
PH=e'aHeg&H' s
=gEFF=gr=,*eF.
E:gi:3q!Eg;
$lEE$6
$+igiilE;gE
e ? * f € gmH3$E
$ i 2 g * s; z H$ 1
a,]H H € a-" I s# f
il g [$ T; HF FE H
rBf,srr;gE
EiE[{E*lr*il
FFE*fEIEfsL
breb€;;etT
-? r:
F El
- ;t3 g5
't
T5
r|O
s9 - l
c_ gF
t'!
td ID rdg
Xut s6' .3it Ja ta (D hl u,
a o F'' |! vr5
as = Fm
F I YK q5' F*o r-)
!E hl
X €
t-l ga oP
d 3
F+fD
1€ E:n= 55 o
ga 'o
590, .st
5 \. Or
E.T n= o v, ;-:
€ 5tr ta x€ S HO'
i
!4d F E X.d ia 5 qJ rd. SJ
't FI o?
3r -o'r it v,
€ nt gHs S_ o o qaq
5s r
o:
ttF o)F{ o 5+ oE,
€ v) () Ro
oo 8F E"E** o 9l 6o Ff)
s g s)
o oq o oi
o o5 t-l
€ gq \v) 'f)
v, oc ts Ts. e € r-t o
F i, n .
3^€ \J P) F+ OJ 9) 8E
€ I 6tr g ts c lb i-r ;s. r-t
oq
E gb
()oi nO n S'r i+P o
v)H t{!
f; (D o JD 3;
50 5 Fr Oq v,
rD 9J Fl) =FT S) o o ox
oPr !IJs p) vt :0. fE'
:! v, F "B *y*
=o if0) Ygq F 5 tD
ca VrH hitro. g) )J
€ o i]
F1Oq i+$H.
o. oq =oq S)
Cf ef o v, sts iF9 d*
oi' e8 5'q 5 Ut 0)H
xu)
o 5 u) o o r) ri# { u, ffb
a F .
I l g rqq
wtA $ H H 0l so *F
a1 go Y f ) \#
fDct o 5 K* oe) " E'2 v, $5
2E (D.) Ff Ff o F ro
'4
.) Ft V)
tsa
o r)
at) q'g ttt
0) CI. C' 5tr
H o6' o 10) v, It
0J
3 1 ? o t? x<
-r a. fn 3
Fl Td o .qrJ
e fD11
trd
ht lJ) 69. 6g - cra
't n oq 6o v, E
v) l) o) v) 0J
o
ga oJF
OV, 0r o r) E
;:.
{? €5
o Rta Ft
iJ (o eF o;F Ft Ut
rJ)
8 q .EE' o) qs fD U5 € fig
"o FtO S) no.
v, olfi qF o Ut gJ i.J. o
5 o vt3 !'4. +5
H. VV
r V)
ES +{ v) 5s.
0r u) Fl xg. n oo
.r O p) OJ
ao OJ o €$ (! fln
o lF{ O o c&d
trd
gs o:5
t)
g' H. (,:
ga H ngl ir5 € EE
(D
(') H 5 '
6o 9FF
gs sv,
u, o ol 'd
'a FF |D o (F I?E 3
fD6
€3 r$ 5 0)H
9l
x; +€o tsl
u, ,{ otr att n rA
9. nt7{ Cor oq _ = r D I .?! EI
v'5 v, t+*wH{$
Y9) rD FO
R .jC o q -vr ^ P \ PT
Fl
ho 0J !+ 5tr o o vt i]) n Fl o)
n $) t crcl ztf H5' HR. rc
rD T< F)!. 5 v, s)
oo at u, r.t o .%
oA qs (D b:s {ff\
-*&*
$$

97 Hr:w urc write d*h


{Ld
98 How LanguageWorks

111EEE1EgE1?
lqaEE
E? ?BE
lE1Eq
??elFaEE
*Elgl*t1a11aa
aa?EEtg 1*14
t t € } r-l
F
ra o
o n=
ht o g D ryH
\J (D d o 6ts
o X ta o FF 6s)
G. Vt oo
t o vtx
t
\J
o v, \S o 8 T
giE tE*EgsasE=s ER*Hg+a[E*
FTn t$ E F :. * g B H F e € E'2 o o o E) €o E+ nt 5d
P-
: . r s=- X hl s s3
Is8,tr'n'qigi*€ g A ,-i6 ' E^1 c -a a o o" c t r o
Frt v)
iaFHi+* 3.9 e H &d H:
vt vt o
FT: It o E.s
.'o) d5
'-{' l. = s !qq
(') Fo
$gfrsE'.$ f.a.BgeH' Ef;g o o gt 0) E5' FI LJ
7.8s,3HF v, 5 o g) obD
v,
; s gCF= B q s ; d E . a 3
?qdFii$f FEEsg:5EA* = p 6'F i i c B Io"rrqt =gE.f o o
& q
=' s, i-F
tr V, n
? D fD o€
8.9"EEtder o +F' IPd hl (D 3 OJ
e'o;+ 5 X g = 6' itd.#E' 3 sr pJ ao 5
o ts 5 $ r' gt q
ct
5
gq FJ Vr{ o
E 3F?Eng S) 1'+E€;fiE3fr 5F)
E'6 p 'e':q'8 v, 5 6. o (D
=E 8"8 F FI b\t
[ * 5x F
v<
i J ' v 9
x: O F !' $1^,X=Fut
n #i.*E."HEg16 F)
ll @ it ='v: o diF-.5 5'"o R v, g
o otr
H6's.3?F. f f * o F, F
Vt g)
tg
Hn
F rD H o
-(/l F
$) g 5ro
6' Ats p) o
g'H,+" qE q f i e s
3; E q qE q g q 5 $X r,
F F o $ g
d o, € f; 3# fi g q
2qHrs= AgFs;? Vt v, Ft
n o vt V)
€E o
FI v, o (,) o a g
H tfo
E (? hl (t, 5
E n
'oK(DF!=.(/)
+ A +s *E 3 qHB
f; o.t d6$
r, +e s u: +Ef H33 3 *,9 E o € o ,H 5'
Fl hl vt s)
H T[** g o F ;45
F i . g g . t $) o
n;alJ-=oo F o 5
ts H 3 F Fg= + il 3t EE$3 v' v, fo F vt P'l
! *'o = 5 qq p)
E-qF'EH"'1A;e I o 5';r UI
J D o 9)
v, F 'oB
o rd' g v,
X vt v)
r* H.3a; 5I r' = - . EF . iT; He 3 H i H F s t [ ? H.ts Fi :f, +-s, E u, € t 6+
hd o
vt o (D
Fi5'+H"a3e8&
'- i s
iHsF€s LT.(!oA=F)rr
S.*'d /D r a5'= o o T 5 q*. 15
p ooq F
g) tt) 9J
^E 8;6 S.rD 9J b H.; t rd F -i
v\. 3L qa
liEEgr
TH
qH'oir.:Ft'
;s=-s7fdail
g
Efi H E f r g n
S)
g
v)
0l
Ut
V)
o
Ut
-s6
ct 15
T
o
n F
H V ) F b o 7l tr5.
E - . i . V ta
5 r*He rr €* Es o= . 63 e qU ds I
E 5 g Ut
5 ct o o
o K
=" EE H9"3 T€ T + E o
o o { { F{
t * iE gs Fgd:F g B;af;;"H3+ 5 w i' 5 o €6 rD

H*w we writ*
100 f-l*r,vLang*agnWnrks

F
atl |D
ooa ?, FF
(D o, v, 5 o
9'
x(D .D
89 5q 3 [' tsl U) x HsA o ut
s) sg o' tJ rD
o 9)
qq 0-a z (a o
= ? E 5 9E 0) et ga-
,_t o (J{ F,ct €HE o ,-t
,-. ct 3 r-l 9. (-) Ft Fi(D g
o ry o o n @
g o oq { { .D 'lJ n S)
FJ g 5 o o g)
Ut o O. v)
i3€FsF F) gq
o'o-on+€ o f) o/ 0J I t-l g)
v,
o t-l
o s, o o o I|t o
n D) o (a
A
gJ
ii.o
f FE a
= z I I6 Fl S"'1 crq
€ 9) d (T. lo Ltl v, o
hl o -(rt o o
= € 5 F S.8 ar r-l fD OJ \o
(D SJ oq rD rDH r) 3 v,
;H S H H 5 9J o0l 9J
,-t
:f z lo 0J
;Hi P) qq
F = = . g. v,
o .j v1 H6'
oq o g o 0) o- |D (.) u)-
E at) gq o o
=
?=€+ =at q;'q Ut u, fo o P A) K
€ hl r.)
o o
o E To nqE 3
Vt v) () o { gE' 9) {
o g) o s)
t_t ro I
E: X d E E + o o !.+ f-) fDcr A
-o t5 x (jl B€d6 a. N
= ; *8.8. o r) . v) (D (? oO 55?, vt
o p sr qa (D o o\ (.J F) I
v, r_l = . N oo
a , F9t x oto.v? Z € p F ,'| oq i:
x \t',
Fl n ra ga I AJ =o
o ct o AJ A v,
4+3.pE.E Vt (D o -ul qq
r-r 0q rD5 B 3g S) v
-d=o o E p) ,-l A qq a:
s) (J.1 3s)
= a€ 9) rD Ho+ o'
€ E o g) o * ''
{ { Fl hl
== o f o 5 0) O. rD
o
gq vt v) vt 5no o
= o n d
F rD d o 9.
: T- o € Ut
o 0) 0" ut o rD AO Ut
rA s) E a. AJ a n -ttJ (a
-+9E'5
= a.
o o-
U) r! rD n
so ' F36
9
9.n 1 ts o (tt Fio ll F: 9J S)
., S) qa FO ? (Jt .-:. F
s
E. dq8 € F r) g A) I lo XE
o v,
o Vt (a r-O !l gl Frt o-
6o o :f p) o F l \ )5tr o.
(A
== - s : o c 6
= F r
tu, FJ u, r) vt lT
rD S
o rD Ut o 0) ,t6 =,(o X
o o ct l,! o o
* E n€ o IJ o o' U) ido e E€
(.) rD r! FJ T F TD n %
(? o { C' X Fl u:'O
FE.rDFt o o F) trtrr-{ v, o {
o
f_l F ( { o o
# d e5' t5 to
o o o. (o
od'JOq o r5 fr ES
o g) (t qa qq
+ = =o 15 g) o
rd qq .) - oq
;o5fr 9) r-t v) $) (D rD u) *l'F o
-i5o pr F 9J \t o- r) c' 0)
)v)fr rD 0q
5 ' q(o € 9)
!Y, (tt ,)
d
o rD 9) v) - rD € oq
rF ff 0)
Ft!-t5fD o Vt
n o v,
$- € 7t n FJ (a ont o
il -qr r< n (D o rD g.
;- HlJ pr 9)
r.) Ft F) (? {
Fl-
b; 6' xF
gs P)
F
o €
u,
o (t (A
rD A)o
Esi
et,3: o g g)
V) 0. qq o
I
6 E :3 (o
0a .)
I €H & 8.6 r) o
rD o
ry

1o1 l,i*w we write


102 How Lang*ageWorks

ggg1
ataaa:ata,g
Egg[1[[13
EFgaEgEg.E
HE HB IE-E
EEE[iE Ig
gaE
gggggaEt gIE
tE E
a IgcE
t-
F}
SJ
o !' o o
r-f
E t I' I Fl cl
o Fl
5 o o t.l { ts o (D o
o OJ o t, r) \i o 5 rd
v, F FE g |1 5 o o 9) (D
o hl
tn
t? (D Frt o o 5 F JD H'o o fb n
; -l 5 Fl: 7t € o 5 LA
rD ts 5 O) tr v, o oa o o a.E (D- F
oa o F o U) g) \J o u, o o
(a
€ 5 g
fD 5 oo o g) 3E zt v) s,
t o" g n
o
o (./l
r) F o € s vt F
OJ (D g 5€ { n o J-l o g
a g o o os 5 5 o (D E) rD o 9C S)
oa fD t-t) r-. JD F o E# o o o ru rD
o 0q v,
g) f) 5
tr fo FI r_. \t F) X AE E
a) o € 9) tu (D 0)
F) o FI 5 iJ -u, I p f)
$ s qq
sJ 5 Uq 5 € fD 3 o J? 5' 9r
9l E) p 9r 9) o 3
hl g
3 3 ro (D
Fr f.)
s*
otD o E
o F
oq
5 s5 'o
q € o Fl
(n
o o t.0 F) o 0) ga
o Fl o o o "g v,
v, o Es 5 Fl
ts 3 v) c) o H
ga EH 3 pJ g) oq o qq (s 5 o s)
9) sra 0q llli. o U] s) F s)
@
o s) T pE € o 5€ fD s) 0q p) 5 o o 5 hl
n 5 Vt t4) 15 o 0) 5 0) trl cJ g E'E o N
Clt I g 0) Fl Kvt v, i u, p v) s 9J
{ v, o n o BB o JD g 9) t 6 T n
g) v,
\o fD S+ g) 0) (: ( o
fD o f 5g o rJ
5 o s)
3 o v, F+r p) o f:
(D v) id d i.+fD u,
ct 5 o c sr S) o F o
s F I 5 l..,rr
p fD g5 o o 3 € o o ct O fD .)
o o I
3
o (o 3 I g o Fh
F FbF o' v)
w o (D F
F u, F tr 5 5 P) 7f o H o
rD o .J Ol B9' v) | 3 c t vt o F 9J F
(D
so xp 5 o F Fv'
F €
g) o @ o €5 tr
v, rD 9) oq
0, o Fr: *s€
s) o o o o s 9) o o o
= o P rz A+! ri .) o 0) F c v, !? o H) o

Ut o 6' o. d s v, s o o o H EE
rD {D .d 3 3 15
p 0) qq a oa Ft 6' f6 = o
fD F Hf) 5r, r) g) )_l
9r g) o o 9l o o o \5 I
() hl n g 5H.
d
F 0) o o p Ja tr out gq
S) { (t v, o
g) s) o ts HH o fo ,f o 9) u, rs a
o fD F o BF n (D V,K JD Fl
Fl
s) o n
ts tu3 F
:' o sg
F 5 $5 o S@ 5 p tr 5 9J \JH 0) x
F6 o F o v, O. 0t ts
p o r) N v, 5 F F 5 fD H + E F \ (a
\o f..!: fD (D (D q F 9) s) S) (D
Eg r{ o F E o tDo U) o pJ
o o\ r) o o o \r o F ct F 5 x
o o € 9) Ht i d l-l q.q o o
qq dv)
s) 5
g
? o S) o o o o 5 v, r-t o Ja o p €
o ? o u, F vt (D g)
-l -j f6 0) F'3 o ir ,ct €it o o
{
gr v, n \l o
3 3 s) n o t) o
\o o Fl
o o o o g 7r' o v, o tDo v, o
lJl vt c) g)
H'r s
a) o n o
s+
(t) i o 'uto vt s) o (D Po. N o
o v, ct tr o r) q
FO ct crQ p FI Ut
sUt Otrl r)(.) o
o r) Vt o v) 3 Ut HV, o
t
? E 5 o 9rO
so o (D o €
(o n F) o v, oq
o 5 (D 9) d o 5gr F €
o n F gq t-l
8F
..+ f)
u, o G. o 5 o o 9l
o tD o s. o o o FI: o5 Fb x fd
€ o o t(D sr E) olr o utr)
5 6'q U) 0) "6 o u, o 5
Ut o g g o v) |.l p S) s|. f6 o rJ o 0)
o 3
F6 F 5 v,
? o" o v, t n
o 5 ==' o t-i o n S) 0) o
g ta H: fD
o o g r) g o t Hd
F{ d (D s o r5 o o o
hl
0r E o F o !'(D p o 9l o ?a tr ; g 3 B,
o o
,-l
o
r-b
r' E:s P. F g o (D 5 C' E -vl 0) s)
s Y { n 5 o
€g o fi'€
HV, E)
gt N o \o o fD :r o. sJ ont g 6
5 go Fl o 4
o
g o o F o
{F)
u, o 5 5 S) og FJ )-l o
d I o 0. vt I
o o B'+ o o E F s o I o v, u,

r03 Hcw we write


H a w L a n g u a g eW o r k s

$F I r
tse'[a
EE 6.8
Fitt
o o qY
H)(71OS)
oqoSl

"ERi3
Fd0a=o)
ilHE
dss g
srqA
TfEE
H n 9'E

€EB
fi *F F
EgfH,
F+Ef |
Ft,*O
+ H

IJ
i$E
5T,Dfr

!t
5
FFF t'E'
ft tld -l
A gl
' e./ 5
o Ent
I H o, hl rr i' fD
6 3 dg fD
5 Jat fDfD o G r-i =r d (D
=.a Fl x ro;i s15 r-l E
g) E V (D FgA OJ
e =6 (l
o
p. u) 5(D 5 v7 OH
* T' 6CI" 8 B ' !aE rD 5qq E' o 6'
A Y(t, ? u, oa q !a
,< v, n o oKX n
rD 5 or+ t o s
B F'E V) F g \s 3 o o o
(r) nto rDo (? r-l
3J 3 F} H. (,r') Fl
o v, q9. o 9.
* Eg Ft vt ts 0) | J l *
orD FSJ o 3 gE P)
Ut
o v,
f.: Y-' ' 1 R v' v) o 5 g' -' sa qq
F) SJ
u) 9) = E =.; v,
-o) 5 o
qq 50 s oa
-v, $Fr: o € o 9" s' E" € #ddddl
; 6 i Ff
5 o P)
(a
-{ oq F 6' 0) € sF9 ts o a
r) cr 9) ooFr f.)
H5 OJ 3!s €g o ^l o (.)
F) ds= I.v) 3 F I \J
3. e-'r, u, o u,
n 5\s tD (D
F . -
0a rl PB p. o
gIs'
utoH'
G rc
ffi&l
*T*
9€ + F 86 v, ut
f JP oq o o F I r J o
n+Y o (a JD **&*
rrO o it n n#*$*
&
oa Ut v, ffi
'vsf rD5- l o FJ SJ o OJ
Fl
5 q.-q + E |rq trs
9) r. 0J o o \"*d
agfD E o sr b6 sr o u,
yi'H F. s)
l] HE 0)
o d,##
A r 9 o I \J l' E o
gq v,
o=ol g g ta
E H'g g
JD S) 506 K 0rurif @
f) H FT. K ffi
FFE o
u) o
0r
ct o a o
o (/'F 5e { o xtrr)
-v) o 9)
oq K
a.
ro m.
ffta \Jt"{
J.t b*u
s eE { vt
Eg) O Fl: l r R- E X (D o
A. :t fd o. ct o *n @dN'
oo :1 v' \ qgt
2 q T s o !. rc o
{ 5 ' E \5o
,) $) o { o
Hqq FI ltt t-l
Ft
5
,J
E8 $or fr. v, L#**
g)(D s, Eo d 8\ 9r ;.i o vt d* d*h
.ur. E ut hl ES 5 u,
n o € o *Ld
.g 5g
oq (tto 0)o !a r) o
cr;J 5'E a SJ
FI IJ
EE''q o o
d Fh 6-A E2
9ro o q#e EFl Ir-l (n
w}
**{*
sH 5 o nS ; {$
tn v' oq OJ ;io o o *
t1l H.
n 0. Vt Fd tr E 3'E rJ ffi
H F ' 7f Fl V) rD vt **{ flT\
(! Fh l.\ 0?E vto u, X o € t $"d **)
(D' \J
o o
aE3 u, FI Irct ? FE€ **d '***S
o P. ch s r o o o l\r
E EH Doo v, o cr **J fs.,tud
vro(D o o oaY o5 0J o o o s
rt '3.i@
HEr. 0. vt *d
**J
ffi q-r-}
1o5 Hcw we rnakewriting systems:*arly tin"r*s tr?\
ffi TM

\
106 H*w Languag*Wcrks

g
?ilt1aglg ?Eaa
Eg
alTlgglaIall1al
Allggl
l-aaagggq
aggqaallll
"-
a
f FT o
at
n v =F ot r-l
Fr a" 7 d E ts-{ 8 qq €
n| d5 nt ? i+ g. Bgi=
o 5er -i o fD 0)
$= 'r' =i, fD F) tr*'5t
P !' I 5 -l f+ o E'3
v, g) 5 F) F s) F {
tD
{(t) . 8 o oq o or' oq v, o
ltj -(a pt
3 tD v, (n o F * 0) 5 o" It tr o r5
OJ orD o o 0l = v) (D o
utO o fD
U) t K F u, (D F) nu, 0) FI
E FH HFag$
FF5+ipr F F fD oq
3 3 o 3 g. oFt O. "o o If sr = 5 o ='
c Ut o C' o hl F f : $ fr q c)
,t ct o V) p) o o 5
E+ (D o sr E" B oo t (DX o w g 8.8 p F 9. A. oa
.!' o T oor F t-t OJ o o F (? o u,
6 P E V) X 5 9. ok F vt gFF..,: 0) v,
VrX .(/J 0) 0) a.F r) tr
() E) r) C'
hl o n o o o
t{: tsb
t-
3ct o
Fb
o
FJ
rt,
o
n
() € H. ca
5F
u)
ul ts.8
rrfD
o o o
trs3.a p
Vt
o gq
o
o o Vt s v)
7t= s g 0) F 5 0. i-] F
g-* vt g o tr)
q
T 0r "!') o \,(D
:. f? a
Fl o 5 rD 8 ,8 0)O (t) x| g) o
F€ FI a HFg
G
Vt u) 5 r-l u) 5 TE E+) o o o F c'
5&;8 5 o o
r) v,
o
hl 9 o vt
or 6iD 6' E 3B g
Er oa o r) !') 5' { ho
5 g):]) FJ V) o o oq qa F
G o o o d9 V5
1q83 F)
(t, o l-l o F 9,8 o 0) 101 o
:o r-l u, ;o v, 0)
o g) o lJl
fD o o (D o 5 o E
G =I oJ $) x H"r38 o 5
ta o PJ -ul Vt o F
;b cra g ( D
gTFg 0)
€ rD g, 9. (Dt.t Fl pJ O) 5
=g) SJ o o 3 5 o $)
Vt OF ? Fl. ho ht v, g) g
D, =' F cr g E,E.Al E r-t
n o n tr 513 p 9,) \5 otr [;-rf hl
oa(D o o r)
5 o6'
F) o E o,
g tr 'g o 6 FJ
v, P) FI 0)
su, v, 9" E
9l Fl- O) o FI EH. E. 3.
9J (D *F ts v,
;3 o 9) g o 15 oq 0) gVt
5 U) 5 € F t-t
v) (a F fo 89 o fD ot Fl o d o t-l
a. O) Ft'J
G Vt
3;Hq f $ ts
hl
5 g. o € o
o a o F u, oq g o r[gF 5 '.- qq
eo 0) o ht 0)
Btr o F) =Oq.rr o o
( \o td o F 5c' x'o F o E tr oq t
0) s o o gq FI
n ut o
ta o Fl o vt F-b .l F
tD v,
o 96- (t 5 frH.5u).
H i* € 3 E€ F o 0.
EF .(/J n 5 9r v, o 9)
O,< v, ..+8 Fi rD o o n 5 cf* vt { tu,
€ v, d s, r) *j 0) 5 0roii
(D (D Frt t rJ 5 I s,S* g
(? I
o (a 9) ga cr o Jr':',5
o 9,, + fl6' n U' E) q, o
g. I 5 o 4 o 0)
&F ii5 g, E F n
J o sr o Vt v, E g H q (D
ca I =.5 o ,\i TN tDtst pl 9J ur. rD Vt o oq Oa0)dthr oq o FJ
:JK v, C' EE.gg gq
rD o cl pr
E. E. o p F o
o 5 (Dtr o 3s 3 F.3 o 0) Ut g,
o u, C' po o. s) ra .cJ S)
g Vt
\,
vt
foE fD .(/) f:1 o ut ct u,
-tHgE E g. f (D
(D (Dtr 0r E) drr oo o
(tt d r) gq o v,
= o ct (t) ts. I o
.c' v, Ptd 0. FJ 5 fo o o H3;E Ft o td ta
o c t-t ct i+ u' d o 9J
o o 5 v) o)r' i.:H6 g o o
o h" !') C' 5 o T H o o hl
€ F (Do tr
g)
o
9)
I
3 rD
o o Fl
o o
(D g
o
vt
(t
s g sl sr
o ge o
tv) F
o g #.:
o gd
E€t s
a;aE
^r$.OH.
9J v,
5 5id vt rD K {, crq F h r d r
K o o. o
ifi *; o

107 i-'{owwe mak* writing syst*nis:e*rly times


108 it*w L*ng*;g* W#rk:

F} Fg
dg tE eEEHFE aE
o ct R ts ':'
E d fDFIFI A 3 AgE
ssE ?:FF#X{3$gEg $'
c q9.olr
F =z r) g F d.D sf*[€tfi€EEF
H il E E 3 E FH E t H * ,J 5fDd
p
n qq ,E=* 5r*H'rgiE€E+
o *l o Ff(a
* F F

p) o pr' [[sqFsi?ir Yt'


Fl
E
qFqE[[qig: Fl
=s 5 v, q!f,5
v, n
EEE$[[EEg3EEE$E
[{ 33ltasEi iI e f
Hs s B f 2 r * X.Sfr s I F E
x Ecio
E'HEilgEFsr
o
o 0q
n3#' 3;9Hnn+=u,5
E I (? i€E g.#sjSE?3r=
to v, q =E'
EI 5t "[.3r a a $ t l. $ ?g F,
fr t P F +;6 ? o -, E : tD
u, FT $.FlP HqgStF*E.6s
C fE g E 6 sq o e ip.; E 2. ho
-r*$35lBsPgEE o o g r{
$ V) oq ht lj. 9, s 13 il
o o J-l' h q
Fdtr*ggR:fg$E
$ $ 3 6[ gE
o
E H ]E H E &d
ct ;€3 H 3 = d .4 e' =
i s 7,
* ; r^-.a E o sr sr
t-{
:l
l-.
s)
H
.3 F{
nirrd
i €gEE g =
$ i r H..*; g Fr. E:E8i3EEFg
+lsinH E=HHi H 9J .4rDF +g = rfiE e E +#
5l.t
o o
qq u, i.E g
v l-{ ti
sisqg[]silS
vt /J g
SlEEti rD 1o = FX F
Odf
s;sEa EE
€d6-u:-5 o iJdo)
l3f; o O.Ovt
rrElSiiEEE
r-l o 8t :EcH'*FF:=.
HH++[F frfiiCr * 'oo ct bg s
fe3[FE sig?'s f Fi
o sEdS=fiiTEZ
rD
rr) p
rD oa
GaSsqF igrs: E 5H€ :TERfl3Ei3;
dc.+E'Bg Sggg€ +
Gd;eE=: fr r) )
ncF
€ (D
H € € I5 € Egqg;
5 PIE a Fl o o
€igi$HHHgs
9J'
r);-j
E1
F. -. I
H h
9) 9 V 1 9
rJ)
f33*EH g$3Ff + ooq ; ag$i $s$EH
Hnr,vwr r*akr: writing sy*tenr*; rarly tlrrie*

.
110 How Languag*Works

N,x EI)-i
d
l!.r-
aili Er5r3[E€€$"F tsHE vl B @
r\ l' )
F
RS
i[i[;iiqs€eE* F H6'9
oY J
g @ -\
(D
o
G oa
iqgH*4, asiARiiSs k I-r#
-gF L @ ! l- 3 -P '6

al
o
r--Jl
atc+ipgggEtF.
iertrEgqi€ig E
E R N I I 9- BE
o
SJ

*!! f:f, ,J\J


zxa'af"-irtE.sEa x8y 3E( ! I q N
)
|1 cl-) Hieroglyphic
E1;€ Hs t i aSBE.i xE -0 GJ = bookscript
r T o
i ; "*E Ax : F I x Fa .l
\n
xS *t - ] \
;ai*uigirg[[ d F Be o
== ed $E; f)
T
-<t gv o
€sqaeHF HB rlr e { 0)
o \ n
=E3x
7 F,fig _q*F
I=-t
(:
xB
o
rt
E$ 7 \
+ 5 a i tEHEg n $k F
*g'.i; gFEEEgH zv<
-tl ilt \ Demotic
tv
t,
*g? K
!?9t EeE*Egi r
?D
B
fD cL t! !'
3g =Ft
rr cr l-t 66r {:t ..)
c| o v,
]' .s F.o tr
HP - -l _fa St g. E o
(tt Fi, :.- lO \ 6it tD (D = (D
A=. fD FtO o q tr
(a o s fD E =b (D
ts
Fl o IF $
5 g 9J o 9l F €sF E
o o A, n g 5 ctF S) FI F. o
=- A] C' t.) o. F) .VX o g T g. O.
f! 0l 0 r? o H o U) o hl € ?
A] u) € € 5 5qq o v,
rD {: FO AJ fD vt € .1\. ?8. o {
t-l o
q Ft C) 0. 3 =. (D -l
Ftr I u, PJ
A-o € qg a o o. n o u, + s r-l
rrF o A. ,\- o x o
o (? s PrD o E-o {D o 3 fD o
=u, g) v' FO r) 5 p ta nI
n € o ta gJ
id o
o (A o oq F u) tr qs o C) 5 U)
0a 5 gq - Fl
NT A { g) =o n 5 t-l 3
:r o. ( Al F6 o AJ A) o FI o o vt 0) o tr
AJ o
u) 5 tn
v) FO I ! SB o rr o o
€o J" Fl cJ v) i }o o 3
d -q€ tl .DFl o FJ o a
r.l . Eg v, F o X o
t-l
qJ A) fD (D o, \o o tr
AJ .) vt $) u'= o 0J
o- U' o 5 o
n Ut € €5 F (D I SJ
fr€ q,g Ut 0a FJ v, Vt 0) ts fDo
5 € Ft
(AF n g) \J n Vt hl Hl d
r) (A
F FI o F
tD
E d 0) €
YrD 0a rD o It o o i+ v, $) o4 u, rd
,J, .D 0q o tr u, fD o H T
= rD' (a fD o n v, 5 o oq
{? J+ (A
).1 os t- qa
F' (uD) o v) n fD o 9J FE. 0 d o
Fl u) *, H F
o rD l-l o FI
U' o 9) E E
AJ € Ir s g 5E' F G
rD (n v) Eii (D o 0) r)
A)
c) (1 F o
lt) o 7f o ? OJ
qe o 8.6 (D 5 (D
{9 .) u, o OJ HA Fl
o oq (t,
|-l
o F
(t s f1i' { j V) oq
tD JD { v, vt t-l
99 (tt a { F'a FI o 9 H
-fr!) 0)
a.(o rD o o ! Fl Fl 'o0r E
tt) se) sJ F| (?
i orP
9o a- |D p pr fD oa o st
(! (! g o
hl
H6 ts Ft
s
;g F) Fl. gq
(,tt i. u, 9) o v, oq 3
,o o o o "o w w dF o f)
CO rD' I E F 0)h o I JD
o. AJ A)
(tt u, Er_l FI
g. -g
Flx
r) € U) p"
;' s a) cp o
r.t o |<
F v, 0) o 0)
1I H. \t (D o o s ut o v) g) o
Fd o so 9) =O vt v, F
o o hl
0) E
o o.
0a AJ € oa r) p) r3 o "o cn
F ? r-t E o FI
rDt -9 F.(D p n FE 0) 7ri g)
:50J 0) (h ve g) SJ o o v) v5 fD oVt o
FO to 0)9) 1C'
;E. 0a (? o. o ? v, "t 3
g? tr o P Bil Vt oq ;d o 0)
. AJ. 15 o t-l hl H(D o (D fD
( € o o p 5 hl
(D (t o o o PJ E"E f)
fD v) o pr 'o p o F u,
,Do .J
ta
sa n o 86 q o
to 9) l-l F $) n
Et v 6 - rD rD vt 9r vt €€
hlH o (D g 5
oa 5 CN c! n H. r. o a.
FI
o io gq FI o Ff+ 9) to
.rO (? rD v\] 5. oq 9J
f lH ' tD _u, v, G 5 hl
s+
+q€ E E orf o(o
a" 3 v,
€ 0) 50 FI s € s) v, F
3 v, I FI F) ts) o td
v, 9) r) (D ant n .(t 3 cr oq o
o16 rD "(, s E tn ,o o E o H f'i t
a) fD v, pJ s cr + + o o
€E
ont 7 c) p o oo o
g t.l Vt
on O. {, 5 F5
rD 0q I o triD o ? 3ts o (tt o (D (D n o

How we rnakewriting systems:eariytirn*s

L-
H o w l a n g u a g eW a r k s

orrrwjg
16. * fr: g E'o
- r-t
6 6. E O + O Frl
E!'ilEg- 6' ( 4<<< D- E.
P $ W; 0 x {t "g
3L
E.G p ts I
gilFIBH H
hi I =o ) F E
fi€.8$[F E F ,
E o
+v
o ; ":
F
o
+
\C/ >>
v *t g v *f d
ArdHFE E t
..,gH6EE v gagE
. - - l j v ,
E b,
! v
g< \O X
I"qt s)
t ,fS Ebv
';a#;E qE oi!
r 3 N/ p<
L OJ

Fef+H ;
s uy v + I H+ .T
fr rx. 3n i3 v)
v,
Ft
2 sa d5
i a +t & x{ {.
0)
i; Yi H ft ti l11 A
Aili-a ffi
$sH"gr
?-FrTg 5d d g9o
o o v)
,-+ O 3 6 8 69. () oq
t_i
o 5
q oq
It o v,
oqS g X xo o
ggg
Ft
"H'€ E F o5
sf H E 8 0)
6 &F
eBE
€oq
*'g rEE i g€ G'
=

e -

4
- :y (l T'
gs
t} 5 (D i' E9
- H 9. ct (!
9 -
gt v, J hl €
:nfD I o. 9] fD .-: oa
Vt oa vt € 9. 3
A Psl o ! vt
v - J o
SF r e ' ?qq- E E
v,
A * V
E
X
d
o
9) n Vt
oa _u,
H'€IP JD
55.
E3
6, gi.
-6rD o ct E'E g E B ]J rt, 5
(h o U) 9r gqfD t)X UrO
n v S) o
r-b
qq
.a'o' U) c' K(a o Vt
A l . \ X o rD g FF
H:B 96 6
J A F n o o Ogri' 5vt
* - o ..) Y
-(/J
"c \< F o o o q5 *l
o5'
ct F) 5 Ou) EE H s8
o Vt Fi $h{
-ul fo 3 ? hr -v,
= I Y 5 0) E o 5
ga r-l o ni' 3)rBv) g s o u, r-l gq
=' o gE o g o Ff
€ u,
5 o v, v) 0) 9,O
o X =o v o.
16 * 7t !J sJ g)
-t--. Ft € o Vt o o $5 Oa
g) v, Fq o
a tt) o v, o
:sE
o:Jo Y9. JD
v,
F o o 9. ni5 Fl
-vt
; a € o 0) g€ F;, sr 2.
.- ,+vt vt o k
t v ! €
/.\ r+ - 1 b l P (Dv xo
-a fD
(D o v, d ?i o.
o **ru **% w d i

J F I | < o 83.
A
r v J
o o o o tro) Ef 0) *,e*
o i I
Ut u, o o, x5' Fo5' H
vt vt fD.t ff4*
v o o V) o g, sa . i J F I
E *# ffi
x y
9) r-l qo o ft
o o }r.(rr''
? cL c,)
o' o
0) o 9r v) x ? --f ff\
E G
\*#
q *
=?{t. K \J H(D 6I
a 53 951 \*d
tX5 o vt (D v)
q
o v, K n
+rq )'t +g ffi
F o E SJ
F

c-5I o
r.l
Vt
V)
o qt
o
O)
FJ
t-l
o
u,
g)
o
o
*E
6v)
o9)
nt
Po Er H ! H
y€
sr= .h
OH
e- 5'
et
.h***{**
m"
tep ? 9l o oct ffi ffi
-vtO 5 cto q96 s 9,8
-ut u) {[J ,-!dd#
d g) 0. qt
iqo t"l o. o. r) gs cr o ! t
-l wffiG
-i=Fh
-5Ff
: cr o o s8 o
rF' o g€' R
oq ) J | r {
o tr t-l o oq 9) €t-
o tsr v) ut
tn1
r 9 5 v,
€ OJ o g. K(A U**.
o v, u, oq
ER' 6'fi rc
= - ss: *""r#
,J) (+ Ar g) OJ g o
3rt r
- F
o oqo p 5g fm
o5 ; rD 0) S) o. o q S g'
o P)
'(t 0ln or F Lfr
31 5 + n
o o
V)
o Ja 5'E sg f_*4* **_&*
"of,6 o FJ $) E' =n o
ht {T $g
)r, o g) S) E€ H HO 3+ re
HV o qt g:r
5 0) 33, .9 96 trh 4
Pd s v, F oq u, o 5ir €F c&J
g E H *J
6tv) JD o E q o tJ
gJ o o 9,9 $ E9 ;I *-wf w&#q ***-**
6 # +
!.
i
A Y
ry
v, r.: 0r
o
Vt
9)
ct
o
d
o
qq
o
o
s)
s)L SE
H H .
rr s
s
gJ
s' t OE"q
a=
re.
#
\ 1
b F v, r-l U) o $) 9. -*
FI
ffiJ
*trS@
1F e [* rry\ x ##
{#
r13 How we make writing syst*ms;mccl*rntimes ffi
Lfi
f,&
114 l"{*w Langu*g* l4lce"ks

7 A | € S g E F SE
iIFFi$€H3E o
3
qq o-rJrra o
3 A ?',+€ .o qe ': s. r i { ^€- I .d-r4.ru } -rvft
3 i I E s F i f fi.q ;
q€!Er€gEE F
= 0 3 d o'oq F E (Da
=dEt sz H5 3 g X t 9 4 J o \1.\, Nur.J )'-:.-<rir-a'r..o* C':.
|D*
T'
3qtr'; IRqB rHi + €
E H & 1l€; : F,
O rsl
3 $* HX -8
g€i Ei A 5 { -J-"r-a € J O J -l -::e J, st >2 o p ;H
*
+fi +5 dGE* E 9q
+QSFEE'HE
€€FeIEEEFH
3 i.F P-sa t = id '-t
(^)
qr 0)
N l,l {-'{htr 7oz))x -- erqD-ro> 6a
Z ils*Ei ; ' ; 'gF ' -**F
!r -'.
PE
; i.T A
:.;TgFlgE Frt
E
+liiEgq;b 'Ei (+..r..oOJOJl-ro -S lu \/ tt,
n
S)

jI;IsiE€:
3 p -z E =. B EF-
14 Fd
t;5f,F€5:$ (JwDofol,3.x -= \tono) $sr
5<
i=;1fi[gE$
i; + [ $s Es F
E-i*oshiSI Z
3gHE.;;9FF N'€r 5 5 t HEry9.5g 3 = n= = Fg EE'gS SB ax8
5 .
;:;-;4Fq-E Eq

I
i€SsJrfrFs"Hl3F=r=gFNs,Bssrg
'o i
.:98sFgeFAf fE
r=xAHFSfHH- o rt
gE .D
a
E
-F € g# E.T
iF-H rD
:ZEgdHPFFSJ @
r, 7
xEEggF'FssE$H
=. w H
tgFgg3-isfl5 5 A EE p J - E : b j E r f Fg
o
i i sE$FF; s g s 5=Cltr1 >,\*,
fEsY$rfFFfFFS=<f'r-
?iEFlsHgF< 5 Y f' 5 S tr 5 tsFH'tnF? F g (-)
f K
S,^ 5
i=stris*:Fe 5c
.i (,)
- = E Z g , . - g3o aF:
3; _€ t F3 F
:t E q', -v rr-o-y
T
--t
Uw? rr . c a<-t-JJr-t11 o-
., J 7 Fll
i I EgI : r #F
:l=cggrEHaf; J

Si E- g. !,,o u,
=:4Ts5:+Fo :t
-t
=;dtrEF3HSe gJl
"1F " H€'F
i' Jv
*E.flF$,flgFsg=u,E
HFE $i

=E-8.9.i €'B -o. s -€ ;it iJ


6 "f Eis
g
s. F E
j{
;g;F3df,q$g rD $i o
ot
rf: i

=f F+ *EFg* ('- - c'r Lt:c,L.r.o.rnb


btt\.qr-. L .,.Lrr.rrfi("
(,.( _ o-
H
;AiF EFSFg
i{5t.€s,5;s ,-l
g)
;: tr€ F.[:.5 .s EEilEggq€ilF,qr,
-agYE rg.ggEgr, o
FF.F.sH S$isS
fiS$sE-,
o
115 n*w wr n:*ke wrili*r
systerns:r**rj*rn t!rn*:s
r6 l-'l*w L*ng*ag* W*rkl

;gaEaEsr[-*rE Ht-F [[[


IIIfi[FEg.gH
sEds;$BHrsiF*RF€-s g[q
+g;.ttEr+rgeig,liiEg ggE Bss;
i*rrtgi$r;-ta
e'E: r:eaa
aa8:+r+:EHs:s;$gr; ;gg}Hqq o H
g;[ * +li
isE*FHIEEt[$g E3FAe F
dE6++38-s*fi[ir*ltFE ?F-,
;Fsf,ig-;-;;gEs"r*ri
3E-s5{E EAi €iF
rF$Eri itgisiFt€i* uHi ?g+ fr1s
IrissI1iulg iE3 **E
sie
rEtNag
HEH
Y
H}EEa4liFF
l-r
^'Pr-tI;€ag s*[€a gg*
*r gIF
f
6TssEF€fisHHH€?H [t Fsl
Fgs
ii:?E ?EE+ a ts.-e [*

F
n
tu
Y 3 g a 'E 3D 5
ESgs
g xFl vt o E
Vt $E 9rF It ht
(n oo
-Ft a,
5 5 aa V)
ro s$sF
9) o - t(D rD (D v, (D vt 5 o =
N
;'rD
50 l.t o \s S) v, OJ
n 3 s. o, E(D v, 5 d p (D p -u,
d p o
I o o
Eo =t r. 1E. H
E.
o |! o qs. fDH.
o oq 9 sJ F) D)
o rt, 5 o) 11 Ut
FJ E u, a o € (D c) s 0r-
n o tt) 9r o
o * i- ut rD F s
+! -5 p
F tC a8g,
(!$v,
o o Vt 5 3 o o oq aa'
F d
F o @p vt o .)6
o 0r o o F 9J 5 F o D
(..) ao € = 1g) E g o (t- rD
qq o 5 ! o o siiE
3 F o (n g € il o
o o tr9 ft: v, V, 'i { (n
Y 9) € r) F -o o S)
q, 9J v, o o = $fi
{+ op F o o
ri) o t-l F F H r O
!'l 9) C' f.) g) r) S) rD
o (') E g o o E Qo .j-r
$Efis Ft
v, ct 5 o r. 5 u, t+(,D
O 9 5
n 5 o H3 r o o
g) o 0) (D 5 v,
o o 3 do 0l 0J F TA 5 o o I $ 96'
>f N o 0) B 3
pJ
9)
o o 55 o o- i' FJ N ut
o 0l o 9) 9l
(1 g)
r) FP ,f 5 o v)
n v, 5 r!
o rD $n rD o g
s) o to) Fl =n
E FB sX
(t)
X v,
o U) (D F o (t, F o n E E€
E rd 5 o 5 crq 4) Vt o qq A)
0) Ut 3 FE, ts
9l
pJ a" 5 5
o O) v'.
V2 o n
o At 0. 0e
i' 0J
s ng) F t+5
H.BEE
0. o o o o 13 o r-t b ? A) 5aJ r9R8
N o xd FI
o o s) 6" o o -l o 5 oJ A)
o. F iig .J 0a
o 0. u, a, v) O. o rD
o € F) o F o ot o X
pJ o g JD fk u)
g F $ C'
s F H3.
o o o n
0)
(n qa 7l
o
tl 5 Fl
rD FI T r: o
JD
0)
9, .d
o
sJ
v,
n
0) 0 a ( o
Vt
5'P
F; aI
F r< RB. o 3 o 0r o H i'e T
o 9) 9l hl F F =. if,-
s 9r or o JD o .) r D 6 E H
F
3 qa 0r F
U8 o
-( oq s) v,
vt
I' gq o b o r) o fre !'0jJr
o o g }o sr Ut o
vt € o tr { fD F oq to o t) o; H3H I
= p) E Ut tr A)
o X ? 9 o vt $r --)
\ t FI G oa 0) E Ni,.
g v, Vt A) o N
(n T JD $ o f) o u) 5' lT
vt Fol N
H ct rD
ta \ 0r it € vt o o o
fD
qJ 9J !D
F
o.
favt
g) o (D d F
st o
a" (a n dd,
e3Sl
qq ta qR SJ 3,€.FH
d F v, F g o s= (o
Y eJr oq I -l o n E d a':"
s) q il I o X :5 atrrP
S) K o tr b, o u)
V) F) F o s) (a ro +r:td o
5 e s uv
(^l U o AfD
g Frl 3 oq tr tr X qq v, 5 N t (J O.
?J JD $J Sl Fl
5 v) oq o \s A)
v, < n o (a o E o 5 S) = g E{/
o :-' r-l F) r_l g
a 9-l R v) r td "CJ a, F \fD
o 9) o v, si g
b (t s. N;J 3
sl v, fD o a vt
o ts t5DF5 F -(/J a n (,) s v)o
*T+EH"
117 Hsw lve make writing syst*ms: m*dern tirn*s
118 l-k:w Languag*W*rks

1lagegag$gg*gg

iE+'g
*E
3flai* r*$$
i$$$$ $I
i$$$[
gl**$F*gu
iEEigi+ggF$ggEI
Fi$gFigfEEgEFF
t1g F"{owwe rn*kt: writing systerns:nrcc**rntirurs
120 H*w LanguageW*rk$

{
.f U
3 'o E
CL a! rD B
ct
33 F
= (D "e' (D F
t' cEl 5 I' 5 o (') -. vt (t)- S'sF
(D o t vt v) dqhoa
ja o o { Aq)
5 ut 3
fi F c(tt o € I
$o Ja 0) o o o fD o 5'€1
5 5 ,o 5 o o o etrt+
F 9. ga -. tr o o o
5o o oq rD o oq
oaD o CI,
.(r: 5 n f5 o ' rD
r-) 5 F) d gg
pr
g Vt o 3
€ n v, o 9) 3 Vt
j d F t A
a D F rD o o o 5 0)
s r. g
J -
oo i' n o p {
v,
{ o
r) o o o U)

9) 0l oq
v,
ots 5
H E H 8:
K (/: (? o sJ (n u) f1
(t) 'o Vt
o n o sr a. 0) ut
O s F V) o oa f; vr'
v, l^J o
o v) o t)
r
ct ? 9) {o
a o v, (a € o !D F BE
tJa vfD pl a. E 9)
-('Jcr 9) -l 9) s) € o €
-o j J | . ( H .
=x x-
rD
(n r) FI o
Fl oti5
0) o o
oo o o l) v, d
,a u, o 9) 5 -(/) o o o
rD o n o € 6'T
;PO o oq 0) pr tr 5 5 o ou)F
3 o o' o F v)(DO.
gq o o" gq r) 9r
w b-e o' o n g o 5 5 F) ****
o E) o F 0.
€F o g) V) o oa
o sl T H p qa 9) -FffD
HHA' ffi
a, v, 0) 5 v) tr rJ
F F v, rD ga
s $J p
al r) (t o qa iro k_J
6o o 5 o 3 o or ti'
(r') f 0) rD o 9) JD 0.
(n U) 0) o
Fl
ta hl 5
o o 0) v, o 5 o
O n n o
Fbo ) Ct Vt 0J d o i' 5
o op o o 9J w o
+€?
$tJ:i
et
o sJ a. E Gtif
o 0r
ar o o v, 0)
5' :r f.)
K
{ o o o d
r{og
X ,r 5 oq o o K X.vtrr
x o F o 3 o :+gH
o FJ n ; o
o o 0) n o o v,
s)€ 0J o o o g
(AE o g F p) go
u) "9 E flT\
th
seqH
? F) o o o € n o
3pr o S) gl oFb!+ *&t
oqt t F o n F V) o o p
€ - c) (D fD
g o F o
Oo) o" r3 vt € sn v, ct EHe,
$ :r) w v, o o o ;*$ **q
o o o F o € {?
ct)
X v, o sJn 9) **u#
5S ct o co 5
gq d#ry\
o € F+5 o
o crq o5
F.l
Vt s:# !
o v) 0) Vt *#
o o 0J
r-l o t f-\
sa o o F n ? H R
H- 5 H) ,t (D 5 I rD 5 g FJXS \u**t
9" JD o .r. \
ffi"*
ffi
121 l-{cw we read k**{-*

j
122 Hr:rruLanguageWork*

-l Fl ut !'+. g) f o ' o = ' q-p I L ,


O+CIrcr: Ho BB
H v - . - 9 Fd
=XFtfD-.
re < 9.
t-l vt i' t
Ot.:
qD 't
= A 3 6" 8 f6
0.
z E
= H F 6€ 6= =0
{>..)
3#rr€HFr
7 3.Ers,E. F i

=1f ss&
o o
h 3 g [E g iE E
f TA 5
, F t' Io *:f,[€nri
: d Fi'E
? 3 FIi*H3sE
- Api : R
E d' S H g
r))}.l*H)
:
t 3 5 g o.5 F v"f
:: ' + ira +o' HE 5 .E -F.
IEg hr
i$ 9. F $)
- ; FnFIP
= g =.4.9";
HE;EH
+I s6
:q3 +5EE
C F t { 9 F '

+ -1 9! +Es r g
=; ! o a
i- v q ; A';
= A v, =. :,
gtrt*
a q
rb
-1 ,-=.=H'(D w
n
c+
f,
'g
R e6.
-r. O E' Fi ;)
a)
= _.;t 6. + e tgD i g P o
9)
-==ie-l-o
Ft r.]
==-5.Ft
.i-:tdosr o o'
= ? €
f Fsi 5 [s
s.6- *6'T

fco.oqrc
E gc fiT$ * i
=
",.e.F^ = +r O- = FU 4} 5> (.r cE
H?DI. c,.o = yQ G
? d6u -5v, .d r 1
ll
Put ts. Il -'5
€= rct.a:o',.
g€i il g E!
o U i6 qE
=' v2 S:+ 0l
F
9E F
.l
E
f,l: ct F
oq v
a E{HE g
)= a*sI€g*
--y"s
{D s-€ f, E
o, od6' Fgsi$FE.gEgF
=1 .o ei'€=r
o
o- EP{=F B; 'e"A; E1i= r u,
o
'IJ = 5 6' Fl'6 $
:i;gFgggFgss3B o
ga 5; Ro.* *HFgFg;iiE';
.5
fu ', E : t
$€6H.
8 €
FJ
3*1F*F:gFTFEII lPFcrs
s$EsdPEtflEe
o +.:;,-gr
o o
qJ
j3Ji:6xEgerH"il5 d€iier= fsEscsBgg
.) a 9:s.2 o
o FX P H.'+
o H Fqq S + 6aE!#FgEF;;
FtFF=.
rD
4 u
:FiigrrjssEgft
i?iNrHgE:EB:+P o 3.Sf;::. pFFESRlis66
1,fr; +ii Fg 9,++[q# g a. O T Fj5 9
rD e EdE s,
3iE:is1gg:l'
= s Ai E F .Fs s I g g; q o rD "iiErr15F
4i=€+T;$EgFEg* u, fEEEH
5'63. o- Isff*FsFri
? E 4e g ; t E ; s,3 E g l oq 8";3gH
oq g;gEsrsS$il
?i5i+yufi3F$rFq o E1;qs
Ar5=5ut
i:3" F 5 s H l; ? g E 3.7 g) 5d'ogi' fr'gfifFtFdi$
eril$ifitrEIHflE+ ii'x'f€ ,f
o
+ *uEt-
Arorgr sxFF**s3ig
=s;ilsg[g[?€fi (t, 9 J.15 - d
- \2 X ' c t F s
E q E 3aE*EiF13::
= E 3 FF 3 F * o g@ B li:
9r ;h.
3 ? i R .)
o ;'a 5' ;t5 * fiE EF 3 Es € 5
(h .Ef$E;gH::6
9.Oq
is$;!ssggtgiFt E 5 Hg ' iFl Ts -
SJ E'il"J d i
Efg'gE:sr+E$giS n o' :ar !o t r f o-q. rt=Eg$gEh€
o.
g5E1 3gH =*l; s"Es H
F3EgqFgE€s*ERH c/,
oE
Ko;5
E X E'
ssFrFH*;HH
Haw w* r**d

L
124 H o w L a n g u a g eW * r k s

+
$E
- [EEi
i'gEFIEEgEEEgia
EEiIsF
iEEEIEEgaEsEig
IEIEFgEEEIiiiEE
VI

$
iggjfiflg,glgfgijggg
F
s
flgFgF{FF$F
iff'gigF $
iggFrsggrrgTisgT
r*Hs*6n
sugF
$fF$
$$*u
125 How l^/e read
6*$ ss
126 Langr"iag*?V*rks
l-"i*rru

qaF S?E-s*q=
= F ii E = I nE I.a'
FE3.:?FE3 Fl ggFE
qBA-=g;Fer
TgG 17
21;iiEF95-v'= *Tg:
; ?FHs+g€til I'eIH
+
badEf iiEa' 5t
E+Es HB1:il-+a €x' 2[ a;
I i ? T t 3 * gE : a Hi $
*;utFIRF+i
EE*;
qq
Fg$ArgilF*r
Erti
C; 3 q g $ E Ae lE 3 E
6l3?--dB'*ryF i.F;l
Hn?gE$*;L E;*g
ilE$r€t=.U " E.gE
EA'.HEg3gfrE 1+s
i€ff;;Ff, Bi giE
x'E? 6
E ; $ E'E F P f;
!P g*";€ s! f; E
*c,"
snE;€+;EF
BqHX-*8.=i €=r
E3F,
A;[3g€#eF" FFe

!
g:' il

o Fl 3 It v,
'u FF f?
o. fD
(D J g5' ta X
Y 9) Vt Vt
e: tP-]
r')
o
F Fl v, fo
no gq (D
T_ !) { sa= t-l
't 5 o + F.5 rD q) o 9r o
oa u) F 15
?r; 0J H ;X. o
A1 J a"
-ut n \J
;o
+P o F o60 fD "o €[ rJ o
o K
0 o € '.1 oq 5
a a TJ ut
s =' o 0) 9.3 o o) hl
crq o
h H E Fh
't a v v v )-l EO
o o o 0J Ff oq
OrDP )
Ft-
o n
7: €3 w
o o oA' o o
0a (a o o.E V)
:J V, o I gt C' o
ga 9J -.O o
P{o F) o (r) d 5 o rD o
F o E v, !'+ 5 ,-l
t!r)Y V) o o
o OJ T 6E o o F) OJ
(D
(t) E I 9J o"
r5 r + f Db - E o € i5. rE r5 hl
oq v,
-6r
o o o 9J (.)
lJ ,) ? o 0) 9) 5
A F
n rt) T oq o *T*
o o
o o 0J o o tr" rD
"iO t + ( D
3 E.ForD g, F.l
E E'a o. V)
v) o sJ E
H o € oq JD t €
= n :F v,
5(,D1 o ; € f*\
-qJ 0J o o' F F) q**Pt
o Vt 5 o
BH o{ pr
v, F'3 n
ia u? o cra i arq
t/)FO V) o v) 5
{5 . I,
o E'o { JD 9J 5 o
9)
€ 6 o o ga o
n =.'o €
H oq
ET IJ
tr" v)
r o a rE! ' o o TO S) € $l o o
o o S) hl o
?. v, F x
+ r+ CtO rD 6 9F F 5
fD=Fi
o { o oH' gq o
F n 5 E r5 €
o 0J rD o/ qq o
d' sry
dftf € F o ffiJ
,'h u, .) IJ rD
'16 € i R FR 9) oq **q k
nE H (D Fi r) o
o E 3b' :r $)' $
oP-o v) o V H
o o Eo
IA A Frl (n
ct d%
oa 5 v, o to
lE6 o I 0q_ o € o vt fl*\ e&d
qq fi Ef rD fD 5 hl
E-u'3 F o ;' o o o h*=*&*
att o o t5 v,
tr €
>t o g fD 3 {e 9)
- J
Ja K oa 0. hl
= !r+ 8 9H o g) o o o
0) o5 rn Vt
Ft xb o ,f
R fD o F LdT
{ o pr o o rD
;\><-
€ -E H u, N o
pJ o
'-r E' :i
o I
:E ag r o o
a. o 0)
u U w@#@

\
tu
o
oa
ffi \#
a o { o o o Ur';r'i'r*{:rt'
B"*g c -(n o )-b fD
u, I' F n utt*,r*nl
F" *fi o o o ffi\
I s&d ru
127 fJ*iv w* writ* and sp*ll ffi\
qhJ
r28 How Langu*geWorks

EggggIg$g$gggg

.l
o 9 B
tD=
'E = l.<;
rl ed te
sr=Ia ut
(D{+A
€ $F€ t_t r-l Ut $,
o

FFE
!'r ts. =
o
E T FF E it d
o
R $'g
-aF PH''v, 5u'E' o rd (n
EFJ OJ(D'J v, E o.) "9 !a Ft C
2; # l+."6Tv' E63 AP €v, g
4(DFi o v) (DAFr.)s) o
6gFF
F H o
=*'r,
J TE. q 5 5 3 iF
H F I 5 HE 86"
e-o 5 o f)F{ o_
a g|.
=B qH'a 6 q ,- 5'F:3ts q$ t=9
5A. € 915 H.
trF o o rDo
(? rtt O
3vt
;.\ 5'-a qq 9.5'B n orE +
X oE'g cr o 9{ =n x\ JvEt
\J U'
n 9 +q o tr 0) o q E
Fl Fl
f H sAB
iaQoC11
ss
dE EvrCo K 0. caE n lJ(D FIH
gt +€ ''t FOq
5vt o :' gq c
=,fD FE F F g EE
#F oa (9 iJ Ut ut =o) sca
o El o v)F F
E \ f.)o *n'
qt F,-€ s EEFA3A* "q'6 o Pd c' EA ||.) iS: ;HF crg" o
Y =.D E ft; ga n 6S oFl E f r i- Pg g. .q ts(D qa d6
o g) O0)
. 3 8 ETqF;
:aB-9,3 E.ES vt ris €-
."o oq dE o:(
oo S) o L:. O)
E'on q .-IR ; F . H
* FE 3 ? nt lJ o) vt o € €EEEb
6$=rri'
35 Kn B+
a aa+!J '3F o ,;9 E oda go
5'R T5 Fl hl 5
oav
r.E H E g o gxt
o ,F{ gs o :o oct F)
5 fFFaI
o o€
o 0) oa o
= j'E rgf v, 8 -'
. o tl) -
r-t eR
= = a +1: + t sfD
v
is TE.E oa FI
d6
F Ssf
(D^ { F1gE"B !RO v, Oa
$(a
'i
q3 C/'S \J
F O g PF
-:oi.Xo) XE ao"
ut o o f"S s sE (D
rH H s) 0) SaDa.oo g+ o
(t U, Ft sFrfr'54 o FIB
o. H B a, Fl
tor
o u, 6FEEff rD ( ) o )'rr
0. T
o XoJFf €€e
floq
g H.€ g.? Fsq o
! l r-l o0
;F ! 5nt
5rDH o 6- Ff o $5 r
EO :g€oEp. i'+ EE
I S) 5
xF5.6'H qH.H P. )J
ES cr : H.Fi.: o
Fl
a. !H Ea
c) A. g) Ft o
xX oE . sH ' H oa
n ffi;F s Fi€
F d.T f: v, C'
*€.9 E r) v ; EH+F$ { oi+
IF ) J H o sg o Fg + E 6 R x V. d' o
B u,
FaFE
.t) E' E. v'
u)o ooo od nt o
FI tr
(h h E . 8 F € 6E
o -: vtj F !-+ E.
v,
Y- v, o" FIo 9 r
U . I V H
Hg
E. n
8 iE E"€EF. a oq ct o:, r-t S) -EAXdi 8q' 6B
o ' o =o iJ FI t9 ;E o
o l X "?" E r) wo. )-l -(D
o €A)
o.x FJ v, cl
H 8 8i t e g;s
5 ^dg G { o5 o Ft
r-t FJ u, b" n It
rD 50 ts o=
vt
g€ R€ r;.4Hg Fb
YO (D 9"
x f- hl I
# -s E'E s $F o€ o !'+ RE e
6H F H H . I {
i'rf oIJ o q =a
3? cr o.o
'u, }.l
i+ +9 6 8E HF
H#€ g [? F a. o O. Or) o ? a' 6 da S)
S9" p *5'
129 How we write and spell

-
\- ,
130 How Langu*geW*rks

ID t 'E
v,
-ct 3
Fl
6
IFl t Ft
(D : q,
o
Flf |D 7 ii-l
(D ct v, o i$5 5 $ H s g q H,F E ; s I B.x ; + s s: =
-v, !) 9' = F] ot t = F(D
v) sJ o
:' t ga (a
gE vt vt o o s HT
o (D \/l
lJt oq Ut o a?, EfrrsfiggfirSrqiFEqFF
(D hl t w
tD ts rD o o gl o:f
o 9)
t_t
0)
a
fD
o o o" o o
3
Vt
El
v)
fD
6
ht
u , 0J
g
i t srii r $rEr ++q+il$q#
3 d F o F I
7t 'oo
'oX o o = o f) R sD^
v, r-t v, F S3g,EfiETq=aII3is€5[;
v, o J 9)
Fl 0) rD o o o =
FU'
o o v,
r, 9)
s tr E) 5 o
I cl (n p v, gq p 8q $*+Ft[{€$ilHI:€)Rld
9' o d or ?5- = 5't Sg. F :
5 0) o vr o ifi'E*5:Ef € So
!t o v, (D I E
o o 9r o d r+.
0r n o o
= o F F ct o0)
n
{gt o FJ
n td
o
oa
fD
v,
ut
o
v,
s63,s;lli[$$$ir
fii$kil*ss:FrAE: l
lPf
*i;
v) $ F \5 g ut
F) o 0)
0) 9) 5 o 8H
a qao p r_l o
5
g F s FJ € )gJ
F v) t_l
3 o) oq F)
(D E (D oq o €
o
5
o
d'5
*r*r;s€fif 6q$i +.il
o (D o -C)
o. v, hl
o s) $oa
Ut
5 v, F u, 0)
gq v)
o o u, o g) f)H
€ € v, 0t
F
o
C o
o (D
g)
i
r)
o
F
tlj
u,
o
Fl
f1
tr d
(D p
EEg#*€;3F
igF$Eig
v') Fd ul- F €
ga
3 o oq
hl gr Y- qq
F, C's o o' o Ut
F V) r-t FJ oo
a
o
v,
o o
rrt
gq
hl
a
o
tr
qa
o
o
ct
u,
dv)
t9
HX
0;r
-gii[-lgglgi[g
€ F vt r) o gq = .o
ct5
f ;ErEF[;'dFIFg3$F
o a o ts 9)
3ff$F ;Fo
0"
F o 5 o i€fi: ;3N$FF
F € Ut 9;
d o FI g o *3ET gg;
{ 5 FE ...fia8fi [gi
E o
{6 5 5 o S)
Fl
Fl

rD I qq qq Vt ta
o HF EB$fi*aE* F$FrFi$
r31 How we write and sp*ll

l-
132 H o w L a n g u a g *W o r k s

gt
+ F aeq
aE E *+g aEAg
1HgiH*e#[EE
r E 2 E i $s; FgH3g*g6
gIfl
$
sr[3[;E€*[ +*$
*[f 3flfigg[*r:
agtgrsrEF=tii$tsgIir $ig
iqF
s; tFgE
e€€Fa;EB[EIrft i*A
a+agtlE*g$[gg-ilF-
r[EEEt
i[EEa6EiEr[*cgq*aIe$ E,!E
E'e tr*g Iifr
rFlrtnH; eEeu*EE {fu
snEE F3B
ir:q g[5ggE*E3 Hti €A;
ggET q gg?E
3EiE t E sr$
nrE*tB r:;iEi
tsEEI
-s?*t* *A*rIeEl*l I'*
rBinsI E*[;[*E?bsEEFFs
8. r*+ .sBiHEgBiFEgB AeF

*t
o
5 I G} I
.Fj Ft
,?' q. CL -l r-l d
t! = G tD tD
a tc I 3 ( Dr E
8 x
r) erO fD F
tD o 8 qs s) (Drt
g 9l o,
(D 9.= g (DFt o o o € 3
5 0. V, 1 H
tr |? { oa
55 5 oa
o
Eo -g?,
F) to 9) p) :1 9J
5 ga sE tvt ct ,+r a"(D f.)
s, oa
Ut K qd rDn F (D
v) -: \<- a) f6
rD 'o 9) (D !'
o € F.{ i' ht F 0) o u2
(1. o) o u, 9J o o fo
fD o u, iti I v, !J O. o. (-J
o Fl 3E O.n F
oq w o
v7 o 5 o ! F ga g)
D. Fr o o q8 o
vt E) oa o >r
F s o s
T' o 5 o .J ? i' 5
(n
0) o
0)o) Vt E gq v, F a1
F *Y-
* o s1 5 0" € oq
o o A) o oa S) p) lJl pr
5 p,2 vt d hl
rD 5 3- s) x hl *e*
o 5 d o o vt r) o { o o
o v) ;v, $) (D s.
€ f) o S) HE 5 u)
EH 5 o F gq vt tr\
t Ja o N+ g o r) i' o FJ w
hl vt 5
oa d E* o. o sg
h (D o o tr
rc
'o f) a 6 tr Eq
f') o g) 40. i' o
gJ a FTI Fb o rs) 5 o o
J+ V) P) p 0) flffi
? o o) o gl
hlE s) oF
r-t CN
g
d
o g IJ o
O Eq o
vt
o o { o F
o o 5 oX r) ; o oq ffii
a o 8H 'Aoh t H o a" o gl
I'- TO o o o CI. o g)
o ca T 0r 0) 5 f)
(t, -ca 5B O. 5 9) 5 ffi*
r-l ( D, oc
n o o v o
o Fl
o FJ
o o. aiO 0l (D o Ft Fb 5
?o o i-r U1 rD gE fsq E o (A oq
9) n o (t, O. v,
F n s)v, F ?
9J E o o 5.)
ts Fo q
!'0 \ZIf, o 9J g F
o FJ T6
U('l 1)
5 c5 o 5 o F
ffiJ flb
o 0) o -o 0)
IJ T o o o o
o vtg v7 tD H1 OJT F)
o Vt
o o q6 It 9. sr n v, ffi
o FJ ad 0J
7 ov, u, 5
5 hl 0. o
! F v) Y;O qq $or q (D s 5
S) O ai'
r-{ o
5 gq -o p gr tr S) o s + )-t ffi ro
(,1) o 5 . q fP. O) |.< o (,) rD o v,
o F) g. F? fD o F o
5 F o SE o o 5 fD o
:'+ g) 0r= I r1O !-? p v, tu
p s = 0r. o o
H: o v, ffisffirys
v, SJ 9) -l
f+fD
oq
€ B of ;. 5= - FJ tt hl o E
o r) FI(D p) =. v, o,g 5 g. 9)
vt E o 6u) o V) o
oo tr o o Fd n K o 5
o
o FJ o o U) -o o o *ryq
hl Vt 9J ffi
p v, *'? fD o =9. qg OJ o" o fr#
d 5 q @ *
9) Fa o o F F
o sr oq u, Ft vtO BE fD v, o K s+ ga *t*r*$
rd* f***
133 H*w r,velearn ta read and write fm \*#
134 Hc>wLangu*geWorks

E
iEEiEiiiEE[EiiEEE
lgE[[[EEi
glgg
iEggEiIigglEg'Iallg
7
Eg It
=B ?l
i' gt
o 5 OJ H.fD
5 9l = Fl
5n' oa o = (D @ o o B 0-r:g F 0l fD 3 v,
-o€ @ tr (D o H.o fd St 5 a = HfD
0. o U) 4+=qa
oo l-t o o € JE Fo 15 s+ o oa or
a o t') iJ (D
T 9) 5 E F E: g o
ct 5
IA o- 9r FI $0) € ct o qq 5
(D
:l
v, xn 9J o gq gs)'
3 o o qq Y Ut 7t o
r) o n { iJ F 'O.
a ) ;..|.
E E g.gE F v,
a o Vt \ 9) o o"
rD 7< hl I r) (/r(D oq F) v) (a
X o o s 5 . E E o r S . gKg F o
F ts o. V) ia o. o o OF. P 6? o v, o o o5
x- 9J1 oq o g) EFt T g. o
=
v) E Jb gq s o r.t: oP
g d.o F ts v) € v, I'
FJ !' gr ) ) F , ? { vt o
r) s o g g (,) o n oq o o
6H o 0) o v, tr-FdttX FJ i' vt
o oq o o AJ o)
(1 o JD F 5 $@5V o o o s) E o
pJ u, n o oq pr F ga x v1 0.oq rD 9. Vt v) o5'
(D 0J
s$ 9 . , o
F @5 V) s r+vttr5 o 5 o +
(t F qa FI OJ w
Ft V, 0) F o SJ Vt tfH0r':+ o F HF
€ 5E o. v, T 9r SJ
',t g. o v, FN v, 5 o ir o oq fo o b 5 0Fb
v, H: nPJ o.
x o s) o sl s {r-l o ;+ v,
5 e;qt & F tD q 5 oo. o n
oaF 9) a. S) B .J s 0r a.
++O o o 5 P) }-,g) ;sABb. -l r) F g CA
F o
qt qq6
€ o 9)
:5 0) i' o r5 tr
0) no o 5 { rio B o 5 - !'-!: 5
OFt o !a S) (DD ga rD
n H F H
+EF l B -5
tO o o ? 0q 8o 9 T fD' n
,& o O) .c'r
\5 o gq 5oa =tT5=qq € 0) o S) (
Xv, o
JD (,
o 5 -] E o oa q9 9J
:l F) U) ga 5 ro 0) rD (D in€ l-t 5
V) o r) qq foo
E ' P g . -hru ' r r
o !.+ o 5 -
d .< o C) E td 6 E 2 + o" 0r o.
ttz .+ o o o o 5OJ 9.5 *l fr oa
JD 5 9r ^.P8Eo o (D t^ €
;. F) oq o r:. -fO F F >t o o 5
o) t-J o w .) g o o H H06 r-l f,)
oa ;.+ o o oa c' 0)
a. $ o 0) o
K u, s) € g o 0) v\
a
F-
o ) -v) C' gq
rE 5 . o E . H 6 ir o o o
f) E'6 o :s o t
9r 9r tr ut o o FJ o f5 r-b
o n Fl o
tnC X 5 o u, H r'+ \qeaq r) q S) {
o. 7l o 9) o o 0) $ 2 'D H.F 5 o 5 o
9,0,
6'
hl v, !-t FJ (tt o v)
v, cr v, Fi v,
/rrr n o oq a" 9rg, =. o € o 0) o.
-; o o v, ut
o o N 3 &x E + V)
n F V)
o S) o o 5 qH s- o) ='ti t w o U) $)
n o
$t 5 o F (,) Fl O. €
s) to o (.) 5 qq F
xu, iiv) stgtt) 6 H o p fo
o FI Sl
IA Ls=E'Srv, € u, o r.)
o F F 5 gtp9 s) S) o
E{o 0) 0r rD oq 8 6 = o u, o 0)
o F o to SJ x Vt
5p Lr'9. r-t q P) (-J
a) oJ
S o o u'
g- g o
N o o 9" 0r (oOJ F x
5 o I v, o
,.t
s, 'ooX
o f.)
o oq F o d F E) o
(,) o o € o o o 3 o v)
R6- 9) o E-d i F v,
i^n
o o ,.o t { 3 . ; E'H g (/)- oa S)
UrO o q tr { r+E o n IN
o
@ d 9) o
5F+ FfE'EI FJ F)
r$ $)
o o o o o.
gq F oq
v, 5 € o € a"
o o fD Fl O n SJ g cq)
orF vt o SJ o fD o F)
q, v, g) F 5tr F o 5 o
in Oq Iv) o D o (a tn s
oq ost s.5gFfi v) o" u, oqI
(D g

135 Fl*w r,v* learn t* r*ad and r*rrit*

'-.
86 [-.lowLanguageW*rks

gggEIg
tgtlg
illiigiEtglg;
iiilEEiEiEEiEgIAIi
* * 6 (D 6.€
gxf iigf F F sE=EF#Eq
gf;Ff,Eq=i
E€$6$€* q'fi.i$3sr; j F€rFEEFs
$€6€5€g
rxArHPd
rrFsi$EFsHfsg;$;
,-, s-i ci o. R d 6' Frfif€gf
=
=9+, * v,8*
;9e5. nRstrbbA5isqigg g*sfissI
32 8sa + q:4HFqf I
€t o,F$8 ErsF5gg 5 EsF+FerF
it sEEFP HEEfIEH
=E 7;! ;glgF;Fq €f#ggHg
ne gFE A
F.sg+b'Eg
F$Etr3{r *gqE:rr = $FH.5;E.3
:i Xgv)Ja
Bfrrf gH F Frs!d6 o
ZE F Ss b
F3#gtHq rfrifF$g
='d, E rpS F'
$
15
E
q5a' 6 ' d ' a8-. 6 .
$ Pd
E
I.
H;;sFbF
EX.E ]Hts 1
FFffl*rgs
I a '; I B'FF E
gsEfEgF*i
5
3 r€t 8;a
B
s
OJRLJE
* E;
=gtrd,g$F €rgffga FsF;€Er
iig.+)J psegf*s
€ a q$ P Fi tv SE
g;g5Fsi $sH;r$$
F u' g[
s' g ;$ TIg;H;H
Fro6E gF$f,F€F fir{,FF*
r q pF' lTFEgF;
137
ere?s;s e;e;g#f
F.l*ww* l*arn tc read *nii $rrlte

\
138 How LanguageWcrks

g
glEggIgEqIEggtg:
EEag Eg
EEEgEEEEEEi
EigE-igEgEFEEE
..| t d F9.
gE =r 'F It l{ s'F} H5 H. urOi'
-rD
t! tD 5H. trJD F.
g. o) o 3 ia. v' 3H
.D 5 Ut o .D F 3E g
:* o Ft dflit ts. Ect
\J Fb o !' 5 a. @ l4
a 6\<
AfD a Fl: (D t7t i u,
:"*, R B +F A.E F? -fD
6; g, Vt o P) th +0q H.

o .cr! E d ;i ct
lo € v,
AE
|<H. FJ o" l{ H. FifD U, tJ
JJ
gq
cr J2. r3 F (A E.E
F} * o ' - r E. Fl. tg

OJ € 9! FH 36
tr FtE
9) E i'@ d9. o5(D F": E"
EE oa o f) oa o dg
0) Fl H8H" T€+ t-{
#ost r
Es o r5 6'; >f
hl
ut o ,f 9"H gE5' HtJfD g'*
g) EE o q
On o o
r.l P) vt 0. o r Bqa 6,tr 5
"; ,E
n oit
9) n 5 9. {s t<fD EO uto
o. P- o o 5(D oa oFI oa X ht F.f d EE.
U2 F 5 d9" B.E l* ,+ FO
E -1 Ut g) F fD 26'+
t? Fg
v,
o5
5- 6'
o
v,
x
f.0 v,
o.
9'
oFt
+r E' -i v) €
s)
A. F E
F.
Fl
o€ es t-t
o
=
i.j.
!ut rJ F) r-l 5 >t s.fi s)f H.H; 5 l!p
gr o o o -U) EE t '-t g (Doq
v,
K -P nt E.Oi H H5 6. qut
SE 5
u, o w5 go.*'
9J5 F) )J Fl-
*[€ F irj
v" "EH
F) oq oq o 0) 0)T sl
3-c/l
FI o cr o o hl
?og ;oI.
8"' (D FI vt g. sF
oa o o (D E,J Efi F. CI, oI
o E ra
{ ( v) o $E a o E€ O ''l
5H $) n ha o o FF rg6 vt E'
FrD o o (D FI n n '-
6.O Fl
E*
:< \J
Hs' o r o
ER Hrf qu tto
PT vt r) t1 oo" # $F' ,iX
€ F o s) Er. oa 5!
co' N FI a.o
F|. a
o
g
*F 0.oo o t
2tr EFH sq
o.,
dt o 3d
Fl Fb
5- r) v,
o
o
a; o o F-d q
H'83 P
-,+ r " r 8 i+ 9l
v,
v,
5 Hq u, 'o 5g o o f o.
F'f .J fD o Ffn Ft v,
gt gq |D
9) l-l
o FI Fl
a& o Jr i'o tE 3 FI
E f fv'i
vi
f3
vtR
3 f) o ;P -s)gti
F.
f.). o o t-t
a €& Ld
ag * t.) ir.
o. ota v, p o F9 BEl o5
* OJ
(D n o' o d6# v,
|?
3 fDr-
(DF
as
u, 5rf
FH'
gK
rA A"
N
O. t'+ gB
o 9 t'+ E 0)
68. q)
o)
ar
o € 0) o t.^)
glvt
fD
5 0q
o
q
Hr r-l
g)
oa af
- ua- do
Fl
t s . d
1ss
FJ sr o 0) tJ
g..goatFr7dr o)
qa o u, 0J os
o a.
o
0. v,
o
r) oa
s!'
Fi f)
E
F)
' O l-t
ggE _PO
o o I
3[ oad 9,8ts gs TS
139 How we learn to read and writs
H*w Lang*ageWarks "rd#-#
*T*
***d*
ffi{
ft
re \**l h'#
M $
rr E#FeERfF eEcIgFBCtH .4@
"**"&*
a t ruJ
=i -rg $ H[ 7$€ F# 3 s s a,'sP
+F# *
= 3 * n; g ;qiE q e 3 Hr r = 1B 3 A + Bi I s ffi
m" n
ffi f*Y\
aE +Ef L# \"4 rLd
ftts
iEF€ at$g $E F+i iEsEsF s F HI H ft
qF
UJ
* **{;s dq
ftl L.:t,.
h&",f
iIiEtEEFg
F * n n$ sE +Eee g[ **5
M
-o-?q
= eq I E rFlgF.r$ [Fg
ifi
+[a[gil
Fa 6 i qFT m.
fYrl
\J \'4
+- tgCfi if Fa+H sE ii3.igFH
? i's ffi ffi

?E +$FE;* $Fg TJ nr
g €i€FF€F[:
= j =t- a H: g d ; H I 5 6 fi E o B € g k-tJ
*-&#
-?FE
; HiEi Iqgt gIEE iEEi I re
***J
**q n
&**"-fi*
1ii l1lrEiE.F rIm*B;EF1
15; [$.5g.iFFi Esariss+} ff\
rE
\**l
ase
a16l$*gf ;3BIf FEgg
*d

i,,w
3+.H 1EFa$fEEg \J Ld
lgI $EE*EITE
; F* si3 tr$BI
?=
--3 ?
+i $
7:Li.riFiF
i.E'€aEFgB6
ra e,gEgEF€

o ii
<t -l o F} {D
It h| r-h It
F i' |D F} 6 gt
B |.l
(D F F F F O) o
.} tI r .
v, rE' !'gt G fD EFl Ut
; FI = oa d it SJ
o q 0) tO E H 5 |D v, € F €
9' tr o dE
9' o F
tD
h| fD 9, ,-t
fD
r{) o
g)
tr 9)
cr F Sll-l
€g s
5 s l ) JF l
-.
NfD
Ar v\
to 8lr
oq
er g)
F
-l o Fl
o {tt z< hl r-) cr v, + t1 r) s) gr.
5 v, oq >t
JD o (D t o o o o s) 0t 5 o v, oo € 0) o
= o FJ K (D hl
fD n 5 Sl n L
9) € o o p) n \J n o s (D
a 9) d g. o o 3 o (Do 3 v, S)
cr 5 o S) c ggH -(rt hd
gl 9. K o F F o FI o s 5 v, v, El OJ
o Fl
o o vr!l o F.l
o o) F) ga o 9) FI
T s o O. F) 5 H; o
hl
g) o r-l FI f) s F o 3 o
d () vt 5 5 o or o FdE IA $) F c) o 9r
9, gl tr 9 (D t.0 ooq o u,
OJ O. g V) E3 o 3 o
o 3
0. 0. 0J S) o E o (,) Fh s
€H.F+ Fl o
s) co
st (D tt't o o n
u,
o. a" Vt v, thl € o o v o
PJ v, tD o
hl o
Ut g: - r-t o o € 5
,(D V) .n
{ 5 € \Jo 9l F oa F8 tr (D sJ 5 cJ
"c'
Fl
o o ct fD (D ? v,
5
n.oa ts s E' F8 or SJ 0.
a n' o o o s) Fg c'|. 0J (D oq
0, v, o. ut V, \J U) F o -l s S) pr
0J @ F' fd o. 0) o v) d Vt (D 0. s..+ t v,
t s) o. (a p o o 0) o d n Vt
o 0. o 5 Vt IA Ja 5 rJ (D p) (D
v, ctt $'+# o 5
o s) SJ Ut Ku, n o K o H ' v, o o 'U Oqogr oq ge. tr f)
c lt)_
n (a (a v, nt' o o 0l 0q
O) Fl o T (t) i E: o 5 F o F)
F |t) 5 s) F t6
9r o o 5 o 5 3 n 5.8 E fD o Ew v, F v) s) o
o t r-l X vt F 0l
o
S)
tu,
€ Ut o o € 5 FJ HOI E o z< o
v,
ts O.
fD o t) € (D gl g o r) =8 o g t9
!
3 o o
(tt 9) o € r)
hl g,
o o 5 qq w FI n
o o E o hl € o -(/J
o (D o o t6
n o 5 q' (D o o2 G Fl
Fl
n o o F)
r-l o
hb F n o 5
o o F '15
E 8.3 L. F F d
t-l
}o
I,
it qa o. o il' Fl n 5 J+ 5 o !
o ;J hl n o cr o
hl o o
sg. o o o f;E o
r-l
o 9) o s) { 8s1 o (D E
? o 0" o rD € f o oq (D ct o cvt 5 Vt st p
a FJ v, d o qa g qq gq
Vt tD 9l G o Fb o rd E' n 3
I
a p) o o n P) v) 0) v,
9r
o FI o 5 0) o o
r-l 0. 9) Vt o
n o ct oq o (D n fD F 0) o r'd6 o
st Fl
7 'd Fl
5
o Ut :s E i
tD
o hl
(a g
U) o
r_t
3HF
(DO=.
vr5v
u, o o o. o
0) r_l 0. o K F o 9) o r). ov pr 0)
ta S) S) o FJ r) sJ C' o X o ta n
o = E qq H t Fft 9) hl I
.o Fd u, oq 9) fD g C'
n |o o
o g (D FI fo
f.) n p d fD F (D o o
o o o o o hl
o (D $ s) sJ q
Ut o o v, 9) Fl

d
o
fD t X o F o o 5 o oa o H
fD
€ ig fi s
S)
€e 5
n
oq >r 5
0q
nr-l
(a
tr" € o o. 9) o n EF* u, S$ r) OJ
o F o Ut 11 €
o F o" o o E
o ct S) o x
'o C' fD o =.. r-l g :q3 A,E o o Fb oq € &
Fl 5 ri F F F Fr: o ts glr 9J o
ta o (D
€ o o"
o hl
fD (t) F SJ (a I o
v, FI (D Fl
hl FJ E
o tr" o oa o 0. r) r-t FH fr qd o
Fb o' (D v, g)
o S) o F) F s) N tD o o o
tr :3 |) w o s
n (? *g 5 o r1. u) 5
o Ut 9J F E) oq q € F g
g -gl
0) (D
s) K t
Fl x'5 0
(a 5 F c !J tr
(-J
o d tr
Vt
f o
v, @
r 0)
t + g a. € )7j Ut 5 fi'E Ez vt
tD o
t, 9) o oq fD rD r) o o 5 tr
oq I
o o g 5n f') C' n ct
I
o s 0. o ts rD F] I o v, E'F.q oaI' o o o
p
K 4 o o

141 How readingand writing can Ss wrCIng


142 l-'l*w LanguageW*rks

g[
EE?
EElEE gE
EElEE aEEF
E{EEEE
EegIgiFEisEiEi
lEgalltggal
laalgl
IgEa1ESE
.E C}
H'
itg
g v,
g to p (o n
o! u o \t (D { e. =" o
= 5 9'
0t
5= r z(D r vt @ o 5(D E
s, d E) gq x rf r v, = FJ oq a"
o ,s.
(D K v, (D Vt s
+ S F o F tl-l r.t s) o 3 o n n
Ft! 3 F .t,l Fl
6g C' cr o OJ 9J Fl' 5 T) ? t.) o g)
to "Is v)
o sv, cu, F' e' oq5
o -o 6i Fl \J oa o g o d o o o=
o vtI o v,FJ u, o 5 tr {r-t o g
Ffr
s€ F E' qq o o 3 FJ
s
CA
S) ct o 3
fD TN
Fl Sl goE ct E 9)
fo o v, f.) o 0) o o p
i . (5' 0
o d
3F fd s Fl v, F) 9)
0l q o H.:r n o
qd FJ € f) OJ oq 5 o SJ s C'
o 0) S) o Ff o E)
;+fD 5 o !) n :5 $ ttt p tr o
5 cra o gq
o w -If v, n g E.E. Vt c
o Ow tD oq 5 H"o o s o 5 $J
o s) oa n
v) ldK n
o o .vl \J ( F b-=_ oJ
o 9r 5 E r) Ss 5 E T o g
+s
*8
=s
F
\OH
x"E
5
o
3 0)
o
sr
s o Vt
s) r)
tFI o a.
Fhd
l oa
o s
ts
,,O o pJ
gq o
E
st o fD
$)
i
v,
o
o
t')
q g rD { (D 9) Eo
o C' o ti o o_
o 9r 5 .aA V) s 5 F v)
u, F -l tr 5 g o FI Y o o 3 o o p n
o5 ut :]Eh |.t o F fD Fl E ct o, 9)
o (:l o
v, s
!5Bo
(D s) € F o
=E xq oao3 o
-! -O 9. gFf o o p u,
dx so g f) sJ 3 o9. i
o n C' o. p) $J 5 V2
o .(/J
H o o gq o o
=o qi it o o g 2\i E a' 5 9) tr = HT
5 Hg) gJ v, F
S) o 5 g t, u, oq o n Ut o
9'€ g) n o o
F o o o S) E ; o
Fr= o o s Fl Fl
Ut o. n E € 5 5 oo o v,
V1 o HO. o vt o vt
S) tn o E s
tlr gl
si
3 s8 tu (t vt o
-(/J
v,
o € F
(D(D s
sn
o
Fl
E]
,6 Gi, u,
:r o
P€ V)
(D
o v,
s) Vt s.. v, r_t Fl) f.)
Ohr hl
tr (! ltt + EE
ct g o o F (D f.) (D
igE
6' s) FJ 9r t-l 0)'o o o 9) 5 + 0)
F qii FI (a Ut o rt cttD Fl U' -t X
v, 3 9) HS
€g
9J or) g
c o
ts.
P xo. v,
E o o O. ri g
( D" d
6 qt o o d g) v, o n n (D
3 t .s. o tr
v) F E v, {
d fD € o tD n v, o
EE' r: F) x l -ci =v) (D sJ
E$ (g? o g) 9) F o o o 3 g o
5 o La u, - ct € g
&r g OJ vt F
hl
o d 9r 0) SE: o 5 o
v, FJ
o su,
E3 SFts t hl F o o vt o
o sJ g o E s :J r') \s o T o sl o Ja (D
n o S) r,,.r O (D O. o F #E trct
EH 0J !a. tf o o s :s r) 5 ra vt o g
t ,f o5 'ct
d o o
Fr o o o F Eh6 F)
F.
vtt o
(h
gE r-l
o r) o oq F V,
o F o o o
F € o F u, FI o o
F)ii' o tr a. E oq Fl Flol fD v,
o o o Ut s) v,
-r+
g . H ;-F g) s) v,
8B E $ !) cr g 5 o u) o ttt 6 F)
g
o #H
'dg o 50 FI o o o o o 6= 9) g E o cl o
hl o ct
(D hl (-l li p rD (D ur5 oq
ito o $o) p) v, 0) (D -vr' O) s o o v, € H
o v, JD n a. 9) 6 7\i '..t o g) rJ (D
O.r) tr F Fl rrl hl o g)
50 0) - 5 \l o BB K
Ut K o v) rDC o
gFr "o Ft) s F (D g v, o
;8 tr OJ "o V, r-t o 5 o o u, v) qE' C' o
crq g 9J
K?J1 Fl \J o FI hl o Fl)
Fl
c) Fr. O 0J 9) o F o3 0"
o o X it '6 5 5 0) p o
o 0) vt o Fr- 0) 9r
ta. C'
0. I SJ I
s, 0)
5 oo I I (D I
gq
df;. F+ o5 5

143 l-Jawreadingand writing cafi go wrong

L
'144 H*w LanguageWorks

aaaa
at'al
!ga[[|[[l[[1q!
1q [fi1g{
E\lIEEgEIaIlg
gglllglg
g
srtga
al
tl
5c = t g
a Gl= @ fD
0) KO, fD tt, r.t
o- o
rD
hl
o $
o" E'; o.) g) Fl
E
0)
9 g a g rg-H s s * F F.E'=s r i HE $
9) Ft(D s) i.\ a a
a =X f 5 J-(D n
Vt 5
5E' ut o_ oa
r-l "(J
vt
9J
o .qa v, oa
-l td p)
5 5 u,
(D 5E)
o n)
OJ
o- o
a)
o
o
3
E= <q
n
0)
'.U
3+nr:
;Ei;I;f $Efi$E
o pr E' s)
o F n
oq ;o OE r5
tE' o . u, o g::.9
v)
o2
'dX C'
rD
tn
qJ
r) f6(D
9)
0) o
,,o 9)5
F S)

o
fE[;gi$gria[3Es
-#: I p s 3:1 IF.FE E = F g I _E-
* F ]; s
tt7 FT S) 5
tr F(D iJ n t ;. F $ fi [ + e 5 n
aH € 5 cr FfD
tr.5 v, Ut
x o -) tD
Ord o Ff U,
n
(n 5
rD K o
r_t A.
td
$ 0)
;giF.Fi.BEaErs?i3EHF
6 ft tTJ o
I fgt o 5 o oo o
idri
fD F)
a { Vt
$5
Vt

x
Io
=t
o-
+ v)
0)
o
€ s5 a cS)
E*g[c +1gI sEFi $+$*s
g
: 5 il s l{ H s s H H q I E t 1r
O+ ftr P
to {3 a)
do rD a F
gq 5E S) 9)
f) (r,
5 ob' Vt
H .H o rD o u, g o
Vt o
Ex;s['gEfi;st i;fi;gF+
ID :+gq o
vt = t 8;
5 €*, ':5 n { o"
otv \3
o fD.+
fD \0 n
FJ
F
3
oo
q o
l-l
ta
o
eE"rFFrr#F:s*qs
g[+E gt
v\ { 9r 0) o
oa o.E fD vt P X $,Eil ap: Ii5i;
p o f.)
o E + r<
-(,1
g6 o
g.
o
Eo E
(o o
;:: € ; E s E Hs H3 $ Err s F
v, ,gE o
+6 o u,
Fl

g) F< It
ct
v, v,
H
o3
B S)
o xEIEBFine**3ET+ EH
o
o9) f.) gq 0) Ft- o FE?;5rfH':;[F;ii : Ag
o (D
55 g) o F€
BH
grg v, sLiBe[xrggf$H€Hi
-5
o 5
srD
o ct
g) 6-o o oa
9. o" gt n
5
o $ FI
o
gsfgr: &[g:E$F'r aE
fD ?? a. t)
FE f')
fD EEH€fi-FF;gBs;;F. sE
145 l{ow readingand writing (an gCIwr*ng

l-
146 1-{*wLanguageWorks

+;$ g[frgIgg*tr:
i g$[$tE*i s{ilF1TH
EFFEtIfi5IgE
q?,ElIg*[s=rr iI3
rE* HtB
SSAggHH;4t56
EB: +#HE3frf;[i Hsr
g*rEge$
A;f * EEHH*lr;fs
g*g3 *H3*#EEfgq
E!+$+[gIE
nfIu ;trHfsnH H+?

;Effi IIFF6F
r+qfDfro
F I F B g E ; g -. F 8E€ E'it
;SiFgsf grFHF;EF#EtE 9E EH ' qF qH
E 9 d gI
? I FEF€=sq + t q F $ s f; EFFsSq
sFggHH: fiEHTEFi ggE: F +fr
HFsob
F. il
=?=€-.FrE , J i l H ^

=dtE?frH, €EgF;*=E:q E "6 S L E


k$oJFr
P

Ii#I{ qP ? 5E "d ry
*-***
H . F
;F&$?
;afFsa; gs$#Ei$ia,4 6*.4;;adFb-=
slo,6g ffi
S $ E 5 R f ;.- 6 F o , r { o '6F-bx5= #ts6sp#
?s;tT=H OqOa= %.
: il F d * q r AE t 5r 5 5s= .gs + i E q
iir:grq g€ ii g 5t H g$ B.E 6 = . 9 . i l Lfr
*ry*T
? 3 S 3: E x F, B H d# 6.. d@
u-6r
efiFFlgB:E* .lvtFrtrd. %"-d
o9re5.F.
oJ-1 Furg
=+96 [ss 6;Fsq.:iFsF
E=iFgEsE =E! g ru
s I O.5rDrD\< re
g E H "E F S d?5
M *

.379€gsi.F: ;F :8
trF.FfFrZ'
. ew fl-S
;aeFg;s Fd EF;:gSE' Fd'.€ Tr0 tr}
8;HX* m*
lEig+ir ;.egfrfiEE€:€xsEl dx F E H rD'q-x Fi .IlLoogr
m.
=?ildPE# ,,,%, ffi%
ft
sE. 'E
r;H s.f \#M
FEE € FEi )a. i 6 - ; F ' FgHrFi
sewss&se
5 qo H
irstEgg
dFg.q9!.+.!+
;ddE'a.6f :3
*EE13gF fi; f\,,n}
E[ $$:IF; qf; q-s F -ry$
ruffitu {.**u&#
147 t-j*w writlr"rg*r"rdsp**ch diff*r
ru ffi*

L
t-lowLanguageWorks

aai aFgEI;g$[g
g**i-g*ggE€ I[gfig
IsgpgllEF i3
;r E
EifigE IIEgEgEEIF lgE
E EEf E
F;s *a; rc
*EEs
r-1+E$ei tF€*g
[*E?iE*
gI?E.IFFgIaF
rEElg i
ttEr[Et+[rt11giE€Er
$B +Esr;iFs
'$IIEg* [ il€ iFiE€ qE fi B€ rg F-i 6
irlF
q r+$rl*raqgsgE
F.' iIFlItIgqIg* lgggF F
1ggE$gEg
EEI*l3;s
+*aEgF[[Fga;*+[1cr;
gea[Eg11a[[a**
*- !
E ft
*t n ra
tr I o It -l g o et 5
rD
i! FF J-t >+t (! n Fb F)
cr qq
F+E:gFF (D \t tD 9. FI (? o o o-
F 9J ct g
FI E1 Fl s) o g (D E u, H ,{: X 0r
rE gEIx o 5
g, o o o o
FI
3. p o { E =
sr C' Ut
O. g, o 0)
Fl
ts o'
o FI
E hl
9.
+
t) oLi. o rD
E o. tr oa 9r 7f o rD d''
rD F 0) FI o U) r (a
v,
5 o ts Ut ! |D o 9J Ih o F a" Ut
rE FH;I E fDFi oq S) o o d' o v) E (?
v, E vt v, o (D
H 3 fd o fD
(D5 (D 50) u, tD (a Fb F o FR o
pJ v, E n SJ F|
o o (D' =
? f 3; H.F E o (,) S) o E tr S) F o FI
F n
v, g) 5 9r v, 7t o oq r) 5 o n
o zt gl € cr o 5 n v, Ut n 9)
T +FE.B :8 F) F o o r_t $) 0l F € o G F 0)
o
o JD Fl vt n (n
n ,_l hl r-t t21 e
E TE o (' c, f o o |D o
EE.gE€a+ FJ oI sr v,
! Fl S) Ot cVt v,
n Ut $) F F.! 5 il'
F dr+ o o sl n Y o o
ct sl () g v, o Vt cr Ut
o v) 9l v, vt € fD o fD o
{ f g o o Fl
n f') tr hl
€ \
9) F 0) tr Fl 9) €
o E v, a) s) w
€ n|
o a
Fl
IiggFFa p
v) Fr.O F E
v,
o
(D
r-l
tD
0 n g, (? o n
6.
tr o
:5
o
o
n ttt
o
(D irn v, o o v) F o qq o
os .) t s, qa Fl: o 5
s o FJ hl o F
S) ; o a o r_l tr 9r 0)
\J o pr X o { u, vt g)
o
$ggFf,gE
*g'gesHe 5
r)
x Br't
ii
fd u)
f)
t:
OJ
n o
o t
o
o
5
Fl
F)
!
vt
o.
f) F
o ch
gr
9r
o
t-t'
gq
F
Fl
s
s o
V)
LS
(a
o ct
o
v)
sl
o E O. r) tD r-t o oq
v) (D o ; v, r) o o E ,-l g
6' o. FI t-l K o o f.) o o
o -\ s
0J o
1V' o o v, o 3
iJ ! vt n o p
V) .6 C' { E
eE o
\s oo
Fl 0) tt)
B ggil*
#gH:8SE' H.
r/rF
SJ pr v,
o r)
FJ
o v,
F)
B
o
v, n ; o FJ
o o $) o p o
o € o g 5 qt %
F) o o EpJ (D s \J ct F
ht' F
,E =.E * t = l'' V, o I o o" r) qq V) Fl JD
zO o A' o vt o s t)
o
:r ctots no.F
cr o Fl
\J o fo sr h Vt
=.3 I 0q o f) o
TA
o o^
i6 l + Ffi g hl
o o o v, 5 o. oq o o o €
Ht ro vt o w
o s K
5+ o Fl o n d s oq tr
o g p) o o. v, sJ € ta
s)
'-l
() s) S)
Frr u, :3
FHfdAH,E
fD i5 Ff 0J 9J
BE rd F
g
p. ,f
o nl g)
p
o
T
0a
o tl)
o
o rD rt 5
E
o -
o s) o SJ ; v,
;E$TF8 E. 9A Vt o I r) g,
;Fn t 9) g s o 5 9J o o -ut
p) n 0) 0) K o \5 o
$) Fl F
a =€' o. { Sl oq T o o
q a 3f
+ i r a e#
f r E3 F o a" ! o (D
o. f)0) a Kon sr
s6' ti) 9J O. 5 v, -vJ 5 *
ta @ 3 u,
ER g) o F r) ;R |,) v, v, g) ni' tr
E E '3 ilJD r P? Vt
{r-l l-t \t FI FI Fl
u2 Ut u, o
q
' € st: o S) o o
,-b
trg) o ts g) o (") F' o 5 r{:
cf v)
o 9) FJ o F 0l
g V) 5 fD rD o fD g)
o t.l r) sJ
FF,$E-$H.Fs d I o I 5 (D F
5 0. u) v) I
E
o v) o I o. 5 I

149 How writing and sp*ech differ


How Languag*Works

E
iiEr iililEEEEEFgE
G}

ir; F!t
G} F
D ttt It o 5"fD
n v, 15 d o 3 {
hl g) Fr,)
F 5 g, \t 3 vt x i'r 0l
EF gF .3Ea
vtE E
o A) olA o (a E =
t? @ FI 9) o o o. o
g € Ut F
zo v, It FI 13 o r-l o aH. oFt P 3E
o I o.(D V) fD Fl o {
3 9) V) 3 fr| 5 o H { HrD
AJ Fl \J E
-0 !t E I { 5u, JD oa o o o
F
FI F
o o
hl
g"g +g'5
oq s) fDA L o E fD Vt F pr p" xs)o
ct 9) t.l vt gJ o o oq 5'r
(! d o' ct \J o r{ Vt
o 5 v, n F g) FE
:+ FI o r) ta F)rD
o !) u, t .5 € - H
o n rD g) F. v, o o tD o oq 3 Do. 3B
r< gqo o o o Ff! vt vt c o 3
Vt oo.
5 G (a cr. i' X o a
g El s) 9) o
Fr:
t!n s . 9lr
-u, 5 (? U) X o\< 9)
{r-l tr d o 0a K 5Il
fD qa rD FJH $
C' v) F T P u, 5 gF rD o o o ; t1 0"5 o(D' . H .
ag
(D (D gt |a a. 3 FI o
H.(! (D (n r) o t- O)
vt o
_?J 9) A) 5rt v, rJ PJ € 0) n
5 v, 5 \t o 9. o € 3 =v, SE 96 B
o qa A) rD 5 o F Fl
o ?o) g5
(-J e. l9 n J! o 3 r)fD
5 tr e v) E*cr o o FJ
{
ht
o rc 0) f 0) o V,T
-(D
to V) d 5
o 5 o ta o o o F O -?J
E r8
=r)5
o n 6'H *l r5 E (D Fr-td
(A E oq { "o F o. o F< ++ Vt f! l-t
g) o. >r v) t o o o o 0. o n o - a Ao)
Vt o pr o (D t-l o 0) FJ !'+ o. P
FI o o
gJ D ET
FI S) qq o. n v) u, NJ
FE 8 s:+
-ca
rD N H (D u,
o o ? 9) n tD o (a tr5 u)o Ei-st
vt FO (-) o
.DJ o o s 9J
3q :i: =' gr
JD rt p V) n U ot-l Vt gJ o =o PH H . F . H
5 tr 5 s ) hr o Ol vt H' n
o F 7t
0. U' F
r) ga Fn gq E o ga o fx xo oPnt
0) tt cE) n o iJ |1 o o o
Vt o brF o B. tr o 3 5 o' c F HO sr5 Fts.
fD F gq (D FI U) g o OJ hh$
9) Ut qq n sr2
F Ut H H
u, cr rD oo 5 o JD 3 o € 0) 9r 9.
o FJ
o qqo
fD (D ut' 5 \5 E 5 q€ dt g.
pJ X ?o vt € c o oq gq
SJ A) i-b o Ut o 9l
9) o o -l g)
o g o 5 5 tr d
Fl F f-)
u) s in vt
o X oq o 0) 0) 8'g OFr
o 9J n o 0) o O. 0J oq >ti'.
Ffr
ct s(-) qq o I"O o.o
Fi o 0q (t F o) ;. o o HrD )o
gq tD SJ g oq d
o o F :E o T tr
S) 5 o 6E' st J r) F€
v, o E F.
Pri o th H
U) P oq tr sl 9) Fl € .vt oa
o o o o 5 v, ,f H'O
tsb f.) -(D 9l td cnq o
tr p fD r.r u, o ga a D 88.
o' T Jrl ^\ AJ
pr= 5 o o
u, (a
o o o oq ;* 85'
r) o. t-lv, o5 ,ri (? € 5rD g6
5 CA o. H. o ro !
o $) o a1
V) o o 0 o o t)
o F 9) 9r =. JH
ga 0 (-) * 5 o i J
o AJ vt o o tr o O. cr
rD vt o f') o E'5
5 F) o r) v, pJ E o 6*
o EO 5
o o 0J o
€ d 15d g € o oq K € dP d o
crn v, 0. V) 5 s) v,
o
F{
It gq o !-t) |.j. C
opJ
>r' oqr
o E =v, 0)
ta do 5gq
$ o rD F o F i.+ hl
v) p o o SJ Vt o o 8H
tr o v,
o ct A. s t E g ='P
I (D
s, K I JD g. 5 p 5 50

151 H*w writing and speechejiff*r


H a w L a n g u a g eW o r k s

zt1i
aaa
'g1 iei t
EteE i
*iE' A[aII
iBq
B
:IggEgEt*e EEIE
e*EgE**
eEn'E
aEElEEgIE
EIEEI HEEi
EEeEEE
iieiiEgEt ili
aEa;E gE'i+
qE;
G D
a e
-
:! !t gr o -l FB 5(D
F : o r:F
=r f? ct ;' 3 st fD g
r) ovt
Fd,
F 0a fD 6-g F) u, or
gr o (D ng
?o rD FffD p F hl
e. n o F og d 5 - 'd
3 v 6' 96
vt -l o p) d
=6 t (?
=a. € r) € q6 3 n o
E S) 5 o F v) q6' 5r) fDH
o dEF
g. g) rD v, u) n 5 o o
u, tD o o .5 **J*
YrD rD U' o o + o
g do5a ' o 5 Fb
? ds. n E E v) g € 7,. u, S R
0) { F) fl\
o cl 5 =' PJ 9 o f 0l
>t n (1
\#
dB o o ,f
(D 5 6€ .urH
5 F s) o v) g)
'-t (D o 9H U) o =o)
r) ? o o >+ Ff 4
5 vt = rJ)
:tc 5 p Fb Vt !r€ p F)
ts o 5
v, O rri <j
g fD 3 (Dt<
It Ft o. 5fD ,f 5 V5 n o *ffi
Ft =.
s) F K Vt oP u)o
rDr) F F 0) O) p) B
€ {H (.) co op p)
sr oq p ;rp
o o o o o
SE Vt V) !t s FB o q a Fr
FO 3 pr V)
o fD oa fT} fl*f*
6= F 5 o *=' o o o o og. (D(D
o v,
(D t 5 fD:v
,v)vt
-. 9r 0r SJ g) C'
o n ts !-t: n
o . xo) tr\
k-*l*
ffi-
o F EF r: o fD
x H J qq X s 33 o 5 vt s o dg
oo tr "o g, o 3 p n5 9. \< flffi
J'1.+ o n 3 o 5 \J F t.0
FJ E o
oq r: FI: o t-t c V)
4'i= 3 9o)
o sr v, ?t o 9l i.iF
==F a' fD Fl r-l F.fD
aFrD 5 F'g o u, nt
o 5 n
rD o
: . r - r ) c' **x
o o gJ g-E qq E ou,
2. {D s p 5 3 o E) -q
$ A t sr _ o FffD
"o
m"m
o v) 5 o OJ
Ftj 9J
5 9) o H5 I' 5 € ***"#
oq o o o. o g) o ct F I L r _
g
5r+ €' r DR -
g
-7?H
A'
-r 0)
Fl
o o.
'lJ
3 qFt
€ o
n
o xv, o crq g r o
o Fl Ot{
ru
o 9) 3 o v) 5 o" 0. f,}
E,vro C'
uo'u hl o 55
5 0) € t6
f) o o g. vt
EE" ffi
? $
r,D 6 FJ v, Eor o ct ry*-
6 o oo *re
+:
3 5
q)
F n - cr' F € o n oE 5
iJ
X
H. o () o' JD )-t o)
v, T '6 o r_t on ffi
3 =5 o E' qa
so o o { ffi
A. 5 !'+. { 15 o $x tD v',
*rT& I
E r) 2ci p 5 'a!
U r#
s o € ci' E ***q*.
8' c/q e iri t hl oa fD dtrh
r) o o FH gM
5 d rD o 7I ***.*,*-;,':3i$
I Fl
*q B F 1 5V,
o. HS T(D ffi
**% @ *

,&
s9
153 Hcwthe electranic
m*diurndiffers tffi \#
---:

iS4 l*ow Langu*gcWork:

*EEF
*E-E-
l*EIeIgEIi
IEE
*Es,leagggg
*egga*l
A1EEIEEIEF'EEi
*EIEEEiEgIEE
ilgE'li[*g
eEEiE iE[[
I'II*$'Ea€i
tt :l.
ct hl q|'! 't5 Ff
o |l It ?i rl FI p n
it F t-l 5 g OFI
Fl ga F} I o
.D o = 5
fD ta i' Eer =€ E F
r+S
o o
rd o Fl'J 5r
Ht r tr g5' o a U'H
:- E b<s a $nt 3 vr FFO E .s. o tr
(! n x 9J o BH Ff) e.5
-t :\, g) (D 3 ts JD l-l $Fr oo ;8 o*
qq (D lD t-t (D o K
so s gq5
Fr |6 tt Eta o o 'oF) o n
.t! tR Fi g SJ o 5 Fl a5 9J gt A, TD cF)
6 o o o V, ,t
a o" x B P o o
(a Fl Hs) o 5 F 5G. o HH p o F tr
9. S) f6 5 o= a 9J
O
r.i tsl F $) o5
tn zi @ o 5. Rd tD o o r) p ,..rJ
Y o -('l
3 a" F 0q 0) ga 0q
o ts vt € 5:i r-t 4 |1l o e
6s ttt =ij -.
r-t
' 6o.
g) v, o I htrD o s,d p :( FI
CJ Fb P; vt r) o ,\i o vt vt
o E o 5 Ft o 3 u,
ts
Fl gl E Fn u, oJ 9l -l ah
o O) o F tr In
A. v, sl xs g. S+ o € |..l gJ
r) E o v, t g 3 fE o .-r 0) il (D d6.o
o Eq ,fO H.o € i55 ar (D d 5
o F v, nrt I f)
s o 9S
a o
o r.O !t F o d€ o v, Ja
s ga X o o
Fl
;t $
5 tr.o (D o o o
s 9)
rH
Ff|5 oE' fD' fD r-. g tr o p. SJ 5
oa tD x o g
P
o
E. fD oq o 0) d
4 rD s OJ o.9 (D o= o EH Vt o tr D
oq 5 9. p 5 IJ o' FI o o Fi fD 8+
a s F o op u) ,f FK (D o i'; tr
r-l vt F o
o o Fl
0. r-t u) oa o r) ur ;a p OJ dE 9)
o v) E 3
o g) o Ut g) Vt ,f F I
3 o P "6 5 g) oo
v,
fo Q= 0) 'o cr 9)
gq
F) o.
o tD
5',tr
lA i.{
o
Ut FJ
3 o, 1
Vt (D o
g ;l(D o oq 3H e,d s) o J.+ f.) o 'rS
f') =(n tD v6 ? r
o F 96 6r >i F SJ o
o o 0) on E6 Vt t-t !? o F OJ
o' tr i'ti o !rfi t! o 0r
L P) u, ,-t o 9) o Hq 5 { Fl ts
o Ov2 o bIr (D t_l oq rO
rD (a o U) o f1 o 5 tr v, p) or
Fl o 36
o it Ft n o { Fl gr r-t X 9) o
x n
co F"
o p fr )o
g3 78E
6
o o Fl
€ o t
o 'I'
hlfD ct
9J
9J
rd
ci'
r-l = +r
g
u,
rr
o
gF o
F o6
F)fD
$
5 OJ
n
o 5
U, (,)
o 3f n
F5
fi Y o oIJ v, v, vt
tsl cr ! *o" ta r-t rat E E o 0) o vt 9) o
vt (D ? ts ss tnH 6 + ct v, F+J
(n o o o Ft'O o id qg pr oq E 5 gq
i6 OT rD cr u, E E F o-6 ;-l o n' E ut o"
u, E 5p oa (? tA5 n o o Fl o ro'S
o F 5If o .( o
oa 0) o" S) o tg o o. A' o n o :3 gr
rD
n $0q o F p o
a ER
x o I
o cr
a oqg)I' €EE s . o o o
!-b o
0"
FO
o E
g
tn t+ o
J
o
C'
o
=6-
5ct €
p) o
6tr F o FS 8: -' Ftd
Vt
F 0r
o
o o
o'
= o.
o or
q, o oag K
&H fD ilE' c'fD o qqR
tr \5 Sl hl o or o
vt 0) \J r) p S) to
(A 5 g (D riH E gl d o" o o o
t+=
o
3 .i tr
r) OJ sr J;O P) 8" o s3 ) p ,f
o
9 v,
5 n 0) € r5 -oE 9) a
r-t € o
r)
sH
oo o
6"
r-l dtr x E qH o' o 'oo q6
(n 0r Vt
tv, 5 g. 5
? vl(D fD o do (-J g. JD g F) oq o g)q
vt cp) ;i' g) F $e o 0)
.) trl o o -v! v, tr u)P oq t-t d
v o 0) 9-o = FJ S)
X X vt v, (D
€ o
F p) ''o ct o ;E V) 66 o o I oo
o Vt FI: v, FIA (D H+ 0. 9) -
{n E a?
9.8 o 8s o qg. o tsl E.5 'o 5 F o
o o '5w0E
t6 o g F) FJ ct v) 5
0) 0l
8G o 3 ++€ F hl Ut o SJ Fi" o X t) €
o E $o .5( D o Ut 0l K o { o
o 5 oS o ><o T r) n| {D 5' 6-
o
xVt V) 0. I
E 5 o !) 5 tD
I
a" K op (o 5 ; " o" I.i)
ET
u)rD u, CnC v, Ut n o ctH
o r-l o @o

r55 H*w the ei*ctronicrneeliuntdifers

\ .
156 H*w LanguagcW0rk5

gggggIgg$igfiggg
s Ee

iEgggggigiEEggg
F5E : F FF.=- 'o a dt =p
o\{.(nB
=
=9 g FrgFgrng
; oa'.o 3t3Hpgs o oi s r R 5's #5
'o
5 PJ
,v, *ff:iH r l J H H .
Fi
E:- E FtIsEEf u, S)

Fl
o g EiffnF€ ^rIrHqrrT
H 9
F1$Egbii sJ '9J '-) R V,t r g
gs3'ddSF 'n
:€F
drQ o >r'
$f F5FF FFgfs*sf; E nr: 6
oloe
.Tk€EgFH -l sBssP.
;tFtF ,, ot_b
0t
o S)
E B F"E.*
2 E fi ga EsbH:
C'
=trv) ;FpisHt o OJ o
i[figFiFF fFirFFfi;E s$;
r € 6.6d66
<'E q , F , = g V q F # Jt oa ,fo
JP
cr
;$s
TiH1$[i; F$gFFET€ *E i +
s)I(D € a
) t-l
H. I
gIg$ggR n o
o
$3riT;s $E * G F 6
= F

P.5 S6
o n
Fl
F) X
F]
I€€ [gggE
xrF-EsgE* . E6grl:
6' da . n le E;
;#Fs 5gt$gi$ O) o
?E Y
V) FJ E
Y v)
J-l
o
a A p, gE.Hi;f€ r)
:*r:EsE$' FHEHfEfl E * fr6 - 6s 8 '
96 E
o td EEEOJ?
3 at, HsEIEEFs Ffr*FFbg gilEF3
=9)
FiOagqoP
Ftltvt=
€38 ,f T
o
I
?6s
#'HFg:
HgF o o :;*frfsz: g
F{:
F;FrFFs.$gf,#
9JJ--1pF
ss;EFgg fD o
x o
=o-\ u, X o
u,
;+E E$+FIF3, F{$$sH$$ €$$E;E Ff.FB-il
v, .+=nI=
f;E g 0r
<
ry E ; E$A $
€AA € o
g'e qH
;E
-+9) $ $. :5 T .g.g;:
ii;€f
6F.9, n
oi S) eF 'i
Fe$;erg 3 r $! ' iQ oq
gqtrgi !:'r.
Ftr d
I Fl
6'5
HE:i'P
SsE
rD O. ?' FFf;f,HBF urt oi
gt
gaIggF$F
FE'qF+sfE
s$fi#gsHgEg oosllB
157 How the electrsnicmediunr differs

\
158 l-"lcwLangucgeW*rkt

H€ s=H=-
&E A +E E *HF:
[.F.E
i1a [ 3g.xFi*€
rlg1g[;Es
' Iig
IgE ?
tceEIggfi$f,
H le'E
r
IiI 4a
IrBiIaggg[[E
E1gi
sEsiirtag1E
gFil3
g:Eg€' E
irEiE:ErgB i
ta= Aa
'n--[BEE
IE$3[gI
iE
Fr*FR
$1rEEEA$HEI
'!l5 E
c ts|!
\t(D
T' F{
{E- o 75 rD ! la Fi. =9. o
o fDfD X'-)O g FE. t':
9* I vr v _ \J 9) iJ9
ilo) ( Ff L.:. t) FI rJ Fl
PT o PV) o oq
(t rr' L < 0J t{ H. )e o $5
o c) d
)-b 9l I 0J r-l Fr Fv,
O o 5 0t S) d
E) tn qs d6 o S) r-l
F. 0) ga +3 Pvrvt ct 9J
vt -vJ = o oa o
' I J 5 oa f) .r+ L dq' 9. K iJs)
-l (D 50 v, F5oq gq =.:
Ovt v, t-l vt6 H . H qq
><A P) o i'0 u, J o trF)
o !5t) 0J (t
vtE V) rD (a (A 9)
n EqA F
rD H.O o o o 1t 6-
' F f
o o {6' X 15 a"
0Jo o (J H: 0) 3 #O I J -6- ' # n
-lo
TFt o fDFr v,
35 o Fro n
n rD qqE i o)Os) o o
FF o Rit oq OJ
o FO Y,(D
.t, - o hl
qq c) SsF eq
Ut ,) = H.
Oq H. -X
o5 oa o f} 9J SJ F gq V,O
E $)x = o
oq g) v)oP SJF
tu
N o oq ga o
H6
rD -+ JD G'$* V) FJD I
g) Yd
o
oa v) qa € 5 aE-a r)
ffi
OJ (a o
=v1
€ o
TE o
o
FbrD 0)
=r: n a $,q g)
9r 0)
teo Vt
o 66 'oo n
e. g € E
cr H-g o
ffi
a'B !) c' 8 ? [i gtr o.
o s . 3v, o 5 o o ffi
o X oq n F { H
o to n
FJ pr Y r , H o
6:s 5r , ' 1 r a H5 fl\s
rD (h 0J o v, J-o
rD o v) FOE' kJ-J
55. o C'
ry
5rD ts
Fl
S) €;F
oa g) Ft F o o (dDo X
H'
9. rJ o"5
0) € o i€ + ffiK
5E I o o I o !r6 $J n
ut- v) 0J
o ctir.'X o KU
o o. V, rJ FfJ o _0 os.'ie Vt
reffi
FH I c+ s) o fd
o #"sddd
{ o 2.8 d' o O r+. qe$-
tt, = o pr Li 0. o OJF
',o H 50 o 3 8sr H:fD FJ # *p
0J Fl %h"q+{
o9J o g Arn v - J rIE
\J (D
5 HR *p
rg o6 o €oo 3. \J
t R o V)
o o o
ut,
o. tO vt
o 0) ;. o
o o E' 5' ga v, n =I .ut oq o
{i o.5 \o v) (A
oFt OS) gF; r) v) ts.
i.'''-]
9J
AB v)
b" o
Vt o
ffim.
*%ffi li ;'r.ii4:Jit+
rD 9 . < v, (D o r i a l i
o qe 5' '\.**;LiI
I ;J (t7
E6 H. t? i
ry\#u-4
159 H o w s i g n l * n g u a g ew * r k s
ffiffi
r 60 H*w Languag*W*rks

gg$6[g ietcaa
ggggl raric
+risc
1ggggg
1

p
n v, it
19 F.. lrlt H .oq
;ilFFFE 6tO
r-i'
r+ 6 Er6 r t 5 g 5 ga F EA S) '5
6 OJ r-l
lRqi.FH.E 5 fDr) ; v,
=sr5=.='C.ot FS 5 u5 Ut o oq
$E''i gq tru oq Fb- o Eo)
6 ifD
F{r) F fD o vt l't
t
F;€f sq5
E 8 E ' ?sdH 5 E *H -fds)
(n o
r-l s) oq
PJ F) ad I
T'
@ct n o FI gq n 9,
EOJ FJ tD iitr
oJ !'t Fl H
o o FI
AF[ilFEE sE; s,FEA F Ffi 3 qe
t v r D?'
od 6 E A.tstX
c
n o r-l
u,
cr w
o
F dfD 3
n w
=fgBF+s (D u) :i; 0J ga 5' g,
+:p6"$) r<
15 8ai P u) t J H
o EEo,E c u, o. 2fD K
o o F) oq g5'
iia;E;s o ts E 9.6'
5
8Ef
559
gH#f, rD q. 9)
Fb o.
Ho. 0,
aim
HS F oa
di *E U) o g. q' o 0r IJ IA
F) #tEg 0)
F'f
ifr i *€ o
gE$F r -?l
u, v)
F
H(D
oq oa oa
o
O.
oX'
r'+
Fvt=. 8H!;F
:qE Ed
9)
EB ("0 ct 0J rD
v) ut r.l (A
H ;
R6.E F fD vt 0q X 5;'
f tr+6€[
{-EBHo+q' gq
Hr s'E [s E3 s"
rD JD ut
ltt *B
F HAE o ,t= o 15
E Fs) U 30a
0r o FJ ? F+fD
E .K
gF 8g-E 5' F
v,
s rg FB.H; 0)
gE;FEf tr E:93 gE ct Lo
-T! vr
o 9,6 € rD5
o Fl s
19 v,
F.ff
E . d 9 F g.Hil
ilf. Ut U) o 3a.
* F E * F.; Ut)EFr
6-rH. F EO 5
+()-\
s . p 9 t Eo o o S) oq Act
v, JDT'(D+ :! dtr $nt o ?r 8qe da- P
F H vt
v, o$i5 o Eni pr
t H E H sE o n
F o
Fl
6-H 5. OJ 8.H
n o o H. V,
o OJ
*t;6ee" S) F) F| SJ r-l m st Po
-g3es.g sg6E.H3; o o ov) (o r_l
FJ
q*i
; $r€ o" F
pr
Fl
o 9.O
2 F gq qa Fh
E'g *€ € rDY
o. o gr
(t
o 3 a
!] +
'.o $$$€. Ut HE 0)
g i;E'E' n 5nt S) E6
u, E Is o fD f:
F,E'3$ FI b p. K H€
r)
#af Eg; e-d
EBT 0)
v, +F o
v\
(A H9J

o
E F i 65: O. U) gB o o. HK
F3F€ o o Eo
o E€q E o o ('rtD
r€slF; oq w5 o o
f) { v) I o€
F) pr g) F) s) 9.
F+H3 F; 3JDfi o ,*
ygq
9.
(D ,f (D
$s 0. oF
$f f c rHEilffig
t6r How sign languagr warks
162 Works
?-i*wl-angr-rage

*BEg
eH9$E:
Er1$19H3 $ +r$*[$[Eifl[
+s Er+s
r[gF fiE1*
racE 3iEa$F
FEfi *$sE*usEs
lE*tEI1g
g [ [*E'
'f H5gE
*EI*1*uF1EE I
6ilEsr
ril pEfaf graa
1 g
lFi e$egggIEl* ag
g *r I;Ee i [[;E
sI E €r t r * i $i Es; 5Fai v$Fr e#

efi.$gFE
€$fit tg1g11
6gpg 3iasat sE
E
[; EEt
, E;
f g6[1};I$
ir i a;;$#
1E ;Ei E*F
t (4
'E o s( DP
)rr
E o tlx-
f! Vt 3HF g @ \oJcr
a =tfvrp Fl $H' K
e 2 ts € G |-t i'u, o o-
dHz €E 5 F o F (D u) $!]
. 5o o ' r ) g *.n6'+ a1 8E =.
oJ g w f) i$ *5 =. $9r
-q+fi o(D r)
o 9) f') o v,
-ur+=
rrtDo v, gtv) E"g o =
oJ ht rt) o n F H' Jra H 6 # f $ crq dE sq
5S) p ;g gq o Po n O. o
KoFr cr
ts3 v, v, tr o K 6v'[n
)-t
oqFhE n Vt FJ F 60a
ocro. nfD oq u) OJ
Afi H
q5
E F oii o
o rD- o
$ € I 9) oa'
sl s JD T
r v og hl
5O n,' 1#
€ o o 3 xoq ir o :f
_(r, v) r:o) if,0. e B f g oH.
sHs a& F o OT $o 5 g) r)o)
0J a1 v, ea'E; qoq o
srg 8E <
o -N ut 5+ V) 5D a g.o og!
-3o o rDH o o
3d C' d o o qa *€ n Eflf o Ho
5 5'X rJii s) o v) o n
tz,SH 9)
xd
v, vt so g u)
ol' - o
hl
r s, dBE3. 9"5
p FI o F{ :r {. v,
50q { o v) o F] !-F. ?
ip
Elg gv' S)
o 9r ct) B 8'"' fi I'H
g F o HSH6 3 otr
F o g
Eq6
:< o
o o HA r0JE v, / o
5Ig 2.6 o o 5 dO or: v, r_h
o o o6 JD ts) L. €s
E6-u' fDr) o v, OJ gd .(
HF|FJ o ut B I6"3 X' gj u)'
o oa ,f o o.X 5 o
X o YiJ
=rO o" H.6 sf $) € 6'
oFl
EFl tr
(,) g; o. n oJ5
H.
sE I
- H .
V)
rD rJt
9 3
l+o = o
rD E o
E€ v)
€ ut o AHsE .r 0)
Vt g6 n5 o q H5
o $H ni F. (h
v)
;Ffi 5 tr
- o q3gil "o
o vt S)
v, iJc
f.l
;ry o r D th
(D n o v)A *5(DP 9J rD0J
g gH i;6 g o. olt irH o S cra
ct) 5o s) F] 'o o E2 (D rD
H 9J
o tD
o v)
, J H V )
F o
r)q :<n V)
o=
Hige o g; XF)
PgJR r-+ O" ut o oq vt dR
n rD o or' Vt (A PJ PJ
V) i9, E
g6 (oH F E o $) v, f) 6 f H - * V) 5-5
gq
oa rD
V) =oq 0r xoq s)
Etr$3
trvr:bro
- . U J J
F ?
nrD $)ti\
:a o (D 5 o5 (') Ovt
; OJ 3 oq K 6 F?S * Oq ..+
€.s 5 O
r-t
rr (tt a
E . E 9' sq o .D
o t+ 6P 9)
qq C'i X' ,A t
T (D F1 =. oq Lic r.O $rtf 55
rt) JD Oo) E .R "
-oJ
Fg 6o gE o (a
o o g o I!E
0r 9r v, z S H' ?r
o tr €oq B. g, Vt FrO o)
? it v, F frt n
o(D o. oq o F!' 3+i,3.
Fl hl a. O5 € C' :t
;ao
5 5
(D qa
ii oq 0r(D(oo
E"' oq o oF 0J 90 o * * J
- 9) oE'
OY

r63 l'"1*wsign tangr,lag*


warks
t64 l"{owLanguagnW*rks *y
ffi *J*
ffi,
g E

strsr SiEs[7 E[EFgS$sEf ffi w il,*


rg gf gg ffi
wF \wq u*3*t
ir i i #-,!;gPH7
e Ei* Fe H
g s F *
€B=.;
frE
i iIP5 H &5 ffi
=F6*;E gfi IF{ ; H HHi I+g E + ffi
ffii @ g

gft+?gFlEqs*s rEs$3[ifl ffi ffi


\# ud UM
@m
\
ru *#
E*i*fiEE6lgE
I EI$FEF5g1
T iFg Fefr;F;i Lll
E Efa;5iHE E
e s qs +E[[ i i Hi H F I t,f s
o I
;7 frHg
d:s A H f Fi E q y FF H fr1
";51F #h&$d

ffi@&*

--b
;i=E
=F
==
=-+$ei=Bf
i f ; * g f
j+8Itr3*[[T s BF I
a
ulfg'lgl1
EE; oEH:s I F W
g*fgEB$[g
7E;6;E+ggHii gf;H}$[F€
gJ*
i33fi
F3€;i*Fi EaErE ;[*f
*lt*E
i[;qr
$3*lag
FTitEE aeiiiE€E;
IFf Igg6i€ qIsFsg F=.s;qTE#H
?lic=
tt
!
I tr r' H gH Fb
'(t l! E F {? oq ol
q3g tr X gr i-t
u, o :! rD F) 9)
F f') (D d F Fr
|D 0)
E= hl p (, fr :< H' OFb
P =(D hl
3 gg g z< o 9J F
o gqo
it Irm 0. tD rt (D f FE r-t
t E,fi'
-
5 Vt o K sJ 5 o oa 5 FJ
tn o -h s) p. v, !-r Vt d Fo
o gq 6E d :s 9. v
o 3 Vt o F{
0, @ u) .PS f) o' o r) F 5F (n FJ i5O rD ts.
I o s)0r (D' o tr o Ut t cFl 'o 0) Pgg)
v) o 5 I, 0) vt
EIr vt rD oE'
EF
( . ) F f
F ga o Vt r.) n 0) 5
a. 0J Ut (D g
oa' (D E;E (D
CJ') o cra g qa o cl ar5 o
rJ7 E v, F o 6E :) hl oEg ra r)
fD ; tr 9J l{o F ara 'o
FJ
o r{ tr 5 o
8qgH'
F . A
o V) FJ 7T oq o l gr r 1 9
gi F o u, € V)
o o 0q pJ o OJ F Cf g) PO-
o
r.t '-l o SJ
o g tr o o 9)
ca o $o Ut Vt :l EHS :5 o
FJ
HF F o Ja V, Ft
o tr i+ohl o
ttr gq 9r 9r o gq o. o rD
d E) f) o
w U) 7r LS v, s + o
gB 3
F|-lUr
(t) o E' o q; r C
3 o
Fl
E.HH
o 5 =.o g n n t21 =u' 6' { s 6E (D v,
s o o o SJ lJl
o 9)Etu' (a E' p) o
o f.)
{ o 9. s) s 5 X lJ) o 'O
gE E
o 5 (/) oq n oq 5 FtJ cf
q
o o. :5 OF p)
v) o, F ta T o
f6 5? rD # [s v, o tt ,v 9)
EB+
(D oq a r5 ur$fD
o o oa
rD $) s (t o S;H p
Vt v, tr d6 s I
g) o xv, g il
qa
HB ct v, (o Fi o r) e €
o hl
'o rl 9) vt w > J 5' la tqr
Vt vt€ o 0) o X id;
FJ o o
td v, o F)
UHr 5 9)o o
hl v,
v) o F|. Vt
5 5 ;u,g I o o V) Lrr H.
FO _(a
o tr cr€ -1 (D o .(a g0r5
o oq o o \5
u)o 9r vt U:X
v,
tr sE qE oo5 o Vt (DH
v, H)F g) o o v) s) v) 5 5
o o H 5rD o, o.5 0 qq 9r o ) o s I
\0 o s)E' F n J- F gq P ' H F . n
Ot H o $ v) o !'55 tr 5 oOqF5t t')
8r.p
q o 0) Ft
-l 8" p) o
Ot E6 H (D 5 r+F)i5 ga sl
v o
r-l r-t Vt
.('J
o 0)
gq OK n rE o oq o o v, +6 i
5
qq ll) vr. 3 v)
3
v)
o $) rFE o o 6t5
o v, o. o V)
g ;r Fh a1 5 it s)FE'
rirD 5 0ro
l= €5
0. 5 it r,.r| o s) o oaoqS
r) U) nt' o oE' otrr.
oq 3 o fDu) g)
H Y
.(t, qq rJ7
v)
E NH 9) d
tr Vt
o 601 o
(tt
o
p o
v,
1c It d
$) o
o
q 3'q
o E'y Vt 5 oF o E S f)
Hfi I
o tr Ia. rr 'U o a !!o
9J
d 7t o
V) n 9:
g*f o d crq
o 5H o rD !-. F 5 =v) th:
p) qq !-!' 5 qa 9) o V) =9.rD gq
0. ? rD o iJ o o i. H c
o F T T o 9) F' oa n qq (D tt tr
o o ac tr o E5 3H ffi
VE r) o
o sl tD E E.g3 o 5
g )-t
\o oq o 0J ,;g oa EsJ .+
5 ts tr o o o o F E o oq !J o SNct
9) Ol r) U) ov) g) 5
8 5. o ? oq qEa. ' so o o rD1
o o ttr o .'F H)
v) o tf* { s) P. it 16 g
Vr O. a *l 0) I'o5 e. g 9
(D v\ o o H.o o 9F
tD OJ F ra o v,
rD q:q
g h{ Ft a.'1 9) d
-gl F oqI o o. tl) 8.6 o o I F fD + qi' (D F ) v ) t s6'

165 l-lawsign ianguagesvary


166 How LanguageWorks

gagggalEtggaqg

l.l
E' t -l GT |D EE.
G
iD 5 td9r Fl $Fi
r| (D 3' (D oq o €€
'oO 'trt Gil o ir= f'D hl
E) r5 er F) o
GI FI Fl
or a
Ot 'd fD d sDH. (D T o E f.)
"sg g v,
DIor
o (D p '.l g Ta' oa o C' FI
(D (! gt rtJ t (Dpl pJ l-t) (D o
@
o 5 V)
o 0) Fl tr o u, g o irB
(D tDO' 0) F v, JD o
=t
sw F (D o
Fl E 5 5 fD 9) o o JD # ci5
fD (D Su o X5 oa Ut v, F8 r-l
fD g Ut o 0) u, D)F{ cr (D fd
Ea o F t_t (D o Fg
F o p E.H o 3
o 0. 15 tD Fb .T oq 3 o (D Fl FIfD o oF| Vt
+€ F o V, Fi.
F o 5 € 0) (D 5 sr \J otD
sl 11
5 F F o9 to" 5 q s. 0) 9J
5s o
9' 5 f) o
Fl
g ci' 9J F o 5
p oq o Fl
u, o tr Fl p m JDb n o t'D
n o o o =F E so oq tr on E
(D gH (t
St I v, 5 (a o o q c o S) EZ
F-
5 tD o r) FF' vr o) o 5 F 50. n)
a) S) {(D 3. p) o 6sa o gl gq n (-)
hl ? o" S.
o 0) ct d Ctq ./ F v, oa o .'rfD i.
o o o fD o sr5 FtJ a
I f >t
F FJ FI
-C/i v, ra o o s u, !b o o I!nt
F o G ?o eg CI" *l (D F)
X v, ga ry 5 Ft'J 5 Y-O g fD o !s 0)
5 s o gq F t:
{o ET oo 3 xz
0a F o o\ s u)tr o o o Fl
o 3 s) o go
o o o F ).1 ,f v, (D 9a { +j
,-l Os) ;.v,
s o I (D oa n $t 5 hoo
o ct v) + p5 o v, l-l
r-t C' 5 V) o E.e or v, FU 9) oq 5 0q F Ut
U' (D oq F € ol EV, o E 'ov o
t " o o s) o F 5 qa ga F''
v,
cra E(D 9) fD 5 o w tr w tr)
oa
r') 5 o
r-t Ut E P8 tr o s { qq p F qq 3.= o 5 5
0a s, p v, o gJ F p) 0q o* St
= o o o o o oq5 o d 5 5 g Fl .?r rD 5
V) I g E 9 F v, o o gq
I o" I { b oq (D ga E g) K 5 'q
o o vt Fl 0) oq "6 r) 5 €* v' 5'
0q r.) (n 0r 9J \ o u, 5 p 9l
F) 5 E = Kra #H' o fo \J U) s n RS u, GP
ta o
so
g o o 9, U) 9) o o ct
F p o r-t n
9. t
ta gr -] vt v, OJ
(a o o o '.+ 0Q r-l F) V2 5 r)
d 0q U) o 0q o Fri O r_l sd
5 LA 5 oa d o rD € p
o € o tr o 3 r-l o 9) 6a. ro
$ o tD a) F) ts
o S) v, s EH F) o g E v, Vt 5 o =t
5 o o od6 5 s) n o (rt F)
E o 5 s o) o 5 o F 6'o
o F g)
u,
€2 oH
; o tr 9.8 Vt E 5 € F s 9) o 5 v,
v, I D n r) vt iti E v, HU'
o o a (D
n ? cr tD Fl JD CI. o 1C' € oa o
o n E6 E6 tD to I hl B(D o gE
H) o € 0) Ft r) F|
o gr Fr:
9J tr K F F) (D o s)
o 5 o cr T d n
Fl
o F
3 ;' .g e6'
(D oa F Fl F v, T q S) F td oq n
o g o o i5 hl vt E) 0l o o
Fl FT: o tr o = g) o
ts og gg
5 F d0J o 3 vt
I
Ut ga s p sJ 3
v, F € 5 v, S)
o d o o o=3 g vt cr f1 3 3 5 HR
5 E pJ EI o tD Ut (1
ts
o o FI t.) X F F o o g. g) g e.E
E cl s9, (t) t-l
ts pJ &- p po.
t-l o g s X p) o o 5 oq'r
d o) tD tUt o € E tr 9. 3 o.
r-t vt fD s€ d d tD 9) 'cJ n v, or n
o
hl
o p o ; o 0) o &* sJ
o qq o FJ s S) r-l o E )-l Fl t-l
o p tr o oJ F*
oa o F Fl BF o u) o o o tr Bg o
o 0l o oq tD g. it 0J € I
o
F.f:
r) o
I
a" J5 $ 5 p Fq
167 How sign languagesvary
r68 H o w l a n g u a g eW o r k s

6)
= \>t3
F

+'
)*$
i l( /,2

F NN FqP
N F
4W
JilNNZEEd
Ni\,"'i € E\ --
)'/ ' \€ \t yA\ --.$-
,/
o-
P F" FBD 14

- -.<. o
I
.-s _---tN
%@Gp /il /d)
R lq
o // //
H

oa
P l-l
v

Ft

ut &@w@ \,7
,/ zl\\\
o
)/
R- b
/17
cra P
p ,{
\\ \ --\
\\)- . - Nl
5= @ &z G N)
-w) / L}I
ll

D '.2 \t //
d Fd

\\
*e\ ---:
S s= \tr \t-=' N R B
t(
169 l'{ow sign languag*sv;iry
F{*w Lang*i*g*W*rks

E*s-ttglEsH*ff
E.:EgiIiEE
gellEsE1
gc.FiEtiEa
rFtFBsiEsi $[5ssc
Ers$tEI$15
[*gti$
EEgEEE
e*: F;
gg
f*sf lfi3*
ig+l*il
ggri$erl[
#FEf q-a H;f HEF?';e

:,FJ
+crTgF '=: o 1g y
G \E 3= =PFl!+.F
er +E S 96
(D r 0 g 3 x 'T E 65 e g+. g H.r rE F
9) o
= *€ ; f Ut ? o I5 3 \o 3 +* a- g
-r-x (D tr? ts8 3.
-l !
v,
6 E.:+
sgg . ; t ;€ f g
X nt
i<6 yr,
= +-o.E;
=5aE- rD r) E
t-t
Vt G q6'= SJ
;'F,a9i6 3 €E'
+ r)
eXFsrs
o oqTEro -
=i a t a) l=qdR E.
: E stEp
^.)Dr+ o Fro KO ilS3es;
F?r t'trt
l a H v Y 5 f E g tr P 6d<
rcr]Ffo u' H. i $:;'g E.
- F | l
o ;:gHR FP3
,,n H 5=. !? F. Evt
- J Xv)
(-rD FTFifE#
6-o[r d P a r'3
o xb'g.B'g 0r l't trfi
= 36 Q: :P
=6:5F v) r)
a.d
PfD
d F E H E ' ;.1'-l $F***d
3 ., 3a'Eg o
r-l R X EP F o
=.ot!1 Xorv'".6 XsJ Ut
!a
er gq h F S ;
FF* E E. FrfD
= F 6 a
- !i l seB-s; i'x
q sg,
- l A ra fD ..+ € =: Fh
tg f DsgP E 65 0 '-t uo )bF3 Ffi"3d*H
A -
\ A
E E R
\ A Fg5 R5' co
{ f\ :q Far n
; n o-96 ' 9 , 9)efVS
v F . H
H J - J
E' ,t (.)v)
SrrEgB
L. ,) ;a H. r'l
F e3s#38
9 = E. o OI
ao
-==D= istfP (t)
v,
:trE 9;' r$ ig-3rs,+
HE * H o
'oo s$Fsi >-. rd 50
- 4. o o = FJ e.€ g B q.E T *
= 6': X E sr
T;EE5
u)-.HfD -,.lDn!3 g
P:d5 ' $ F H s iro.
fD
tr' -. 3P
!tt)rdDS a-5j+d s.q E
5 0.O
D :r.l
ISE = o. o f) 8_F:aE3
o ri .:: =lu=.v'PFr
K 5 g = g av )
sTFF$ o o 6'ij 8R 5 ' t s of : s cR
j o HF
. H "; #
vt F Fgr g
d I H.{ i Ut F.lv) oo
(V l-. HF$8AE
VJ ''
FEo'SE (Jl

FE o H C P:tve F SF H E ?
Ovr0rrDT. U) f :l\ =,H =-J
Ea i+q q qF fD FF r? g r
171 i-'k:wthc brain handl*s |anguage
172 H o w L a n g u a g eW o r k s

3
6q
) G
3 Eq S
6'r' e 3
( /')o( D
=fD ry 'd=
n
fD
EK'l,e/: fg-\ r- Ftu
; /-Jp.-J (Dx
HgH, 6s
-t i 5
Fn - -r4 \ r\r1 :16 =
EF ' &
Fl
tHE65, 6 '
V,i g
t''\ i - 4

d d6'
5it
P f r

U) E'8
V H

-: u, f( n! ci r

o
W 6t
o
!j

3
o

oa

A\ n

q
.)
q
e

r {D
q EF 9
'trtE.H o D r+, 5 E
Eg x|
o t I
K |1
rtFFgff$ d 8.3 F
f,c :. +!) 3 V)
x = F H o
sr x' 5
n fD
o o o a 9) o
E
gd o '3t | 'q tr
g* HE t1 o OJ rD
6.s o o (') o Ut
Rq' RqB 8.H 9) o ut f o
F 1.F5
o g)
Eg
o=
d E'5
r+-H
-- |<
.\
-)
P)
rJ
o (A

o
H:
hl
fD
n
rD
g)
E 0)
t n
9J (t)
EefgiIFs*tHsa'
>t Fl i' o. o
OJ
o.t €: 68Bi
H ( / t H t J
o n o !'
o
v7
o
SJ a, 3
g$[fi3$nEE F.aU1
A\ Fl i-Jr
5 o o o o vt ir 6t -)
g) f,)
\o v, o \J F) i 5 o.E o
o\ V) o
Fs El3 -g v) o n 5
HSJ hl
o' z' 6" v,
o rf J/:
iD 5 .fi'E * o 5 o'
o50. o 0) I' o- ,-l

v,
11 +5
F-.fD
g) Fl
5i+9.5 o o
(r)
g
V)
Ut
F
o-
o o 5
5 9.
oq
o
T" H
9)
gflf$$FlII R++*
ti # 1;
(tt
s 0J €
i\H rD o
E€
o1
Fgt
-/ fr o
a, r)
o
o
Ft o
o S)
'oFt!5
[$Fd
o);)
o FF Vt
pJ tt) C'0)
tnf o o o
:&HH { o +J r) oq C'
$q xEo- (/t
$)
o o d o o E. z E
+-l F) o o o o -r.)rD-
o
X
G
(o
; = . vt
cr 15.
J'gF,Es
.2ol"ct
o
v, 'o
o
T
o
u
0)
o
v,
v)
o
qq
EHEF€*g F.

rv)t
|'i Ly

F< (! o 9r o f 5'eH
o s" n ; i'. Fl o 0q
I
5 o v) g oq
V) BI EaSE s- E) € rD -rrD
o c) vt v) rD
iut N € o 0.
v, o 5
o
F.l
E.='F$o s o g)
o
EiIFiE[E3 $s H
Ro =.F 3 vt
oi P Ut
n o o o o o
u, "5
o (h v, H' E fl€ g vt
o o F { !
o
(t)
o. o
o
tgtEtif*+ ESs Hso
rD g) g) o. rn S) r_t
e H v) ar\ EbE
(" f ; tr o o o E sJ
ct JD
D3B
5+ 6 d
(!
a 6 n s vt
V) € 5
rD
r-t rD
oa rD
rD
Vt
u, SJ

g o,
rFig8sFrH . N

6- a= S.
9a ; z 6'E o x rD
o v)
o gq F) \a
(r)
o o U)
H rD5 o o JD or
5oa
sPss
o-Far
ll) F. \J € Vt
qa o r)
F)
rD
5+srg[ s$E ff{2
5 oc o o
g) Osr cr 5 o 8il3,
\
t-l H A
FgBil rD do
oo5=' o' o o F) th
Ft Fl
tVrr o( Da
Fl- ) F qq 5 tr xo 0) sH S
il[FEg*g5E F-fDo

173 L{*w th* brain han*11**


languagr
How LanguageW*rks

gfligigFgglfggg
gF$$ggf,Fii$fF
gplsf,dggbss
ssr€g*$HE
-{
+ :t C'
3t
o o i' o
!' gt
!'
9' *qr
It p OJ

oq (D'
ut u- rn '6
t dq r<g
!i or '-l a') r-t +q
H'.
P:J o g
Ft ltt (,) r-l
\t o.
tvt o v,
t(,)r or-l
o-.
t- j I
9) i

;- e' (D il
;iisfF1igEiFlf
=aeFi;:EIF1
FE$ E A;&3'3 $ E6' :-r

I
i
i1

H H
gT+;E s Fl r-t
o(D
il3[E;€i=+r .-(,) r)
j9 qE
A F H -
- t ' l i h (

;el ;er.
ii
El *FigE+3EF
E5E5$+Esrg;
EiEl$ f
?frss $ e-
V H
A J
iD
t-l

4 1
O0)
=;q;,ss;EfFH IlIH; g,
cl)
4 -
Y '
6 *
sa#frs F=ilTi
gFPHr E*$sI .' \
' v -
-,..,,
- a
A ! r

u,
isFFI x#€EF ..
\..
\i r -"-
94 'U Cre€
t r o(r) <l-!o
= s:
c i-i t: i'j
ii* ; gf t€ g1gd; Ga(D .-'rD
R H
Bsr I
.Fl + *
i r-l
-t; € [E 'g €EIFil Oq (/l
I i
ii F6 (/)
ip9,
! -

3d? <tr EH gg
g€E =! oo ;-.1. (D
q'
(D g) |- +-!
H
O t'!'
+ iH ggfrEeIi g ; . r)t €!.r H
x LX
5 H
r9 9)
r-t g
oq I
free€$ v,
*g
?E e-: rF
iiFf rf sfai E[
H * l v t h * h r * i n h a n d l e sl a l r g u a g e
176 Works
How Language

olb
-l
:c; Fl- |D x
!tE
(t
tr= (DOl
fD (D
(i0(! o BE
6rfD r) d fD gn'
tr 39il -l o (D EE r-t
HFgq
-jo-? a'E A) n
0r ro 3.3r aa' o EFJ 5+
5
trF € O oE'
qqx
f i'E'3g Er
(D nop 0) n! F'F
=' P) fiH€ o 0l 9) FJ o
i$c0) r) sJ SJ =v,
1ilE H =. F a F 6 { o F F a. p c E
=v, I gr.
-a :(D
o r) o :+5 fD F p 6' o o
6 o ;'r:
u,
I i $ 5 [.9 3
KodH.E.E'T
3 d I ou) o t l/) t{
8.H H 0) p o 9 8 R p F fD X EE o = ' P* G-5'6':6:ia
85' oq 6'F 9) w 'O
p 5 -- G E l.tl
5
N 3 BEFr B * "s FI 0r n 5
: oE. 35' o5: o o r+C? N o E aq oa go Gh lt
Ft 0) sl 5.J8' E 5 5T
q E tsl fD r€
v, o i'E- o
5'= d6g 0) 5 0) o p o n0r
g$++E3
Agr o o${ (/ri oE OH
Vt +
€R*T € qEE
?ng € H {9 o
Fb hl f) 5 v) r-+ Eo o g
rt r-)
5 cFfr o !t
o { +vt 0r Vt H. O
+ t I5 xOFJ g t ox(D o
l - . Fl
"cI5',*
os)E v,
ts o) ca. om E
S H E.s $ u,oa
d a vtd
FI o q 5E' .
o
H = F: T E E o) o F
3-'E- d I F E.i _Tf g
=. o o_d s* o v) o + 0 rv) q ov, Fi T.
v, Fl r)r. V) i{
ci d' X oq tUt 5
= 9)
?:-': H F o
g tr € t5g s) E'n {q!
ovt N
d E# F
gq 5
o 5
ga 9er
Fl '6 H . Y
€fi o E
rt H :1 \ g o
g o r)
. t ga
E'
o
€:
5tFE ['
E
o E Ag
E9
6', e. E . = P
3 ti T u,
o 5
t6
0)
I
v,
s6* o o

(D
Out
srP
o
v, FI
o5
9J
Er
$€ggxfI
3t $t as3 [
o.d ogl- o s.Fq I rg
;:?v)g' !. o o vt 3.s o
oo y g;F E'o s$ f
pJ
trf.r H5
' XdFof 6 E'5 F o {
^: AE Vt
HsgS H-oX o g o)F vt
99, g6-
OFtH) qR F? 3 .ssr$:E fi
ESOFrOo
i 3
H-1 u, vt r) t )iJHts
Q1 ,J+ ; u)
Fe+WX
rj'x i o xq; *0. o 6g nto
PV' F=8. (D ,a .o F! V'
? !t a v) q9. 3+AH+c
fDFr Fo=r
- o 't^ F 9) 15
: ts €s
o E)Il Frq:nE
3Hs lV H. At g lY Ft
g)a
x. - t 5 Eti' g
€ fD FJ o i8
diE' vt Fi0lor € o +6
oqa vt 5 (t) -K fi$
i-i. ()
\<i gq X Flg F o n n
5 EEg8fi;
(D F'J o FEF H(D
&H g v)Pin v) FI t i;'q o HffiA
€R
='o.) F' 3H-
o tutr) € \t s sr SJ
o) Ho.
6FrrD o FJ BB OoJ co H9,F FH
o o 509 Yut 5 el Ff
R 9 v) F_r
E n n *oe 9) s6X F*
S) g7i
gr3 I o
qa
9) o
f-l
clio
H.
o
ga o E 3 5
g.
a o p?
g.
ssg trt 5 F= o r* !'5 E. B B
3EE o € gq cr vt OF
g N
o o 59" 3FE' E F
9 8fi g $1F fD 5 HBE 5 9J *[ o io ;F.
o o"i'-t
l-l r.+ v, 83 o. 0. u, 5 s)
vt# trH o tsid A[p f *
177 i-{crr.r
the brain handl*s languag*

l-
118 l-law LanguageWot"ks

f a.l
it !r €
o o
5 vt
Vt *l o o
oR o n
5 9r o d
3H oq o
o $
s7 i 55 '
o o+ tr
(D 4 s
F. 0J o
Eg v,
T5 ,oc
64, 5 o'
t-l
Ar U, U)
f) L.
ar o
o
s
nm V,P
ooq o=
e,(D tr u,
;- vt 3o v,
ovr 0l o
o
O H
Fb(D
oq €
o rD F
r+(.)
2f 5I' s) oq
5 o o'
9. V) |+ o o
v) g)
$6
AlQA
o
Fb
9)
o= 5 w
v) Ft: o
o o
5
qa rs
()rD € a
o
v, 8* rD oa o
=.F s)
r) NE' 9J
o
Fl

I
&* o o
v,
g rA
f)
Eq o o E
5 IlrD or
9) U) o
o= o o H
a.y g
gr,d pJ
5 D
o v,d o o
v)
o qa s
p.l r-t
rD
v, S. o rJ €
o EO o
ga 0J
o
H
g oo n g
o 8H' n
v, 0J gq 5

179 l""lawlhr brain l-r*rrdles


i*ngu*6*

L
r80 l*{*w Lang*ag*W*rks *Y-
ffiJ &
fs, t
ffi it16 E
\# 5 e&:s9r'
FE * F ffi
E. .-+rt,.,.{
ffi
ffi tr@
E S

r ffi tr\
FE;[[FEE
eE#*i;srFf $i;;rs$[
I iE[[
:-2sr +r rErEH$E=$6H,q€fi ffi
\#w
\.*J
: sx f i +.FafrF ru ffi"
k-ffi
*
#**,"&
RP flT\
*% e&d
sFEtEi*11Esiii$E td\
?i;Fil $BE ffi #**&*
AB

?I 3ep*F; $* air iEsE f,\


\-d \-d
f-*fo ffi-
i;;$e$$tf;*€ fagnIrI it=q R'.9 u)#: ffi ffiJ
**% r***fu
&8
agf i#[ ffi
flffi q M
ggt$g1g$aIt$*g[[
s+T
?:ili; :ig ?i n:E

:t rt!'
o cr 0
-t Fl 9l
Fg
O) o g Fr: w qE'
It r-l Fl qt
{D H
r+ ,i (DFf 0r
TA ar tJ 5 €
fD
o
n
='d Fi
€5agFls $.Ei3rilE
E : F B. [ "a'il, K rE 6_s d _<r F
oq o. Ff O) o sr
(DH Vt o O) ^E66 gFasiH;F+H
0J o {o T qF H';
tt7 o
v, fD
EEP
o 9J o. :' $' o
q,
€ o
!' oa i+ v, oqo n tr 3.HE
rD JD sr5 9J 9) I r'E9
o- ct i u,
Ft 0) o v, ga o
o (! o F'g 6-v'J
E FJ o 9J
o o { o >i" (D
hl g. w o gq vt F f ! . {

o V) o E 'E o v) o
f,fa
A A
$E'FFFrfiFI
{ Fr: o 5o p t6 + a1 p:a *F i_ H7EF 5 EF 8 =EH
-u) Ut HU, pr o
0J 9J
gag
I' sr-
o 5 f) 9)
g H
gq t P 8d' 0. o a 1rO it re $sE a.+fia$
r!) g K0) r) A{ tt) \' 3tr;
9) fo v, tD
oq ;j o 9.
o vt 9J F - \J t)o
=. g s o. n Fl
o JD g)
d F q ' Ts E[ $t $z E;EHs $
x
o oa sr o
o ct { (n o s) C'
:!r|.) o qq
"d o
L)Ff pr
5 f E FB;Figig
o.H'5
E*rFEfi
F F :< 5 o
o o rD r+.
Htr t+-
3
v)
oq v,
g) o o
hl
o o g*EIlEF3
o X;' 0) 9)
: nE
ct oJo v) o pr cr o F( F.
HTI3EI
o F octv)
i' 3o V) a 55Dr
rD rl
r Dt s o j'f)o
v, E o)5
0) g) v'
J-f
C'
o
6' o
r5
E& (D 0J w
9) 0) 6 - P g .
r) gap{<
$ i,q€
A'gsXqd
*en $
*A'
$+l E$;
H6q; H l
€ n bs .+o u, :s x'
-ut g) f.)
o o o (? bj +R
H ) 4
Fl
F
o F|
-B
€5
v)
6
tt) ,f o
o
t')
crt
FfiiggiEF
€ o F.r) o o'
fD n o cr €
o H# E
oa
u)
o oa o' s)
(-l Hc/t
qE
v, o ld
;-t g)
r-t

o
g E# sF$Fa€; 3$$giE
g$f$gs
o o ET o tr
o V) !^ S)
FJ oA! gq n FP:
o P.e. -l S)
^ o. FEhfi€g=
:tp (D
0r o n Dd
rD roO. o 5
{ ie
oiDo E;EsEnF +iiq;E
7f< oa t) +=)+) :*fif FH
o g)
; E) o
10r S) 9)
€F q eE
rD 0r o ga (.) 3 g $ 1.i * H a E + 3 F q
Ut VrO rD (? fD
I :r Fr 5'Eg ;,ESFF#r FBE€ks
r8r l"-l*wtr: ir"rvestigate
l;nguage struct*r*
182 f{*w Langr.i*g*Works

Eiglll
i
IgiEIgaiitgggagEtl

EIaIEBEIiEgEIE
p fa
= H!fi trct o !t
o $, @ $FE€ A'
FI :' 9l
5*o O.
3
o v, v, E9; o o €EH'gd#
rD G' i, o X o-o.v'H*e
cf, 5 F} o
F o oa g8i 5 fD
p, o cr tD u, giEq-SF
E 3 6 Ut 0. c
gFF g[gF
lEf *r$+ p
o
F o
o
K
w
v,
(ttr A
rDtJ tr
n fD o
d"'45gFs
;E.NFR::'
0) o t-(
ExEF6A
o
go, H Fi
(n
T o=g
o
tr o
o o
?'-$E:F-s:EEi$ o
hl
oa
9)
E# g, rDI
.-i
5
O 9)
F)
tt)
o o,
vt

o
F
cr-bvt$i5
3 rd € g ?1D
3 H E;
5 s E 5 o
€ N pq5'
c € v) raIesF
o *+ zlF"iHr€e
O. f1 E
a Hds o g
AFr|'
F cr #Fig+e"
o ut 9. *5 !
o tr o .
o
to
638 3o o 9r ? E' s. j'E
"ro*,
€$FFFFFg1fl$Fg t.:
o F.
SEg r)
5'O
o
V) FJ
w o
FJ
o F: S 2 E E
oa - u ' 9 E S
9)
E * sil +
o V)
sr18 ! E
9) Sl
A \ J H o N
n O)
eFr[€$grgfIigi
sfIfFg$HFfi$3gf oq
0)
oa
q8;
Egf;
v,

9J
zt
o
u,
o
F
I
=
i
F;,.FI
E# i F
il=o
o o(Do
Hl v, v,
v, o sJ €
AFt
|_l , t H n
oq 9' . tE E 5'
n s** \5 9)
F l r H qq H iltr: fi
rJ =
F
€EJ o
tJ
oFr'5
ts ii
!$
o 9)
5
qq
H
5
3 a iq
:.68 l a qH
s t.)
t H x r &9.
v, 3E.F 0)
o o cra
r+g$g€$51$$[ oq
I e€_
^i

:i 5ro
oo;t
rJ o
o
o rD

0q o
fi
E
E Fl
€gEqB
qd
T
i+Fg*EgFgf,+ 6'+
r 83 How t* investigateiariguag*structure
184 H o w L a n g u a g eW o r k s

5 gg
d It F
!f oEd
FF (1
o
Fl Vt $
o s) r:S E6
d 5Ff
5 o o o
€ Fl 11
o t.) 9$ €1
0J fDvt
v, A6'
0) o BF
3 9) ca Ft i\i F
o U) glr
.FJ
tut
q F 0J
gq
ct o 6 a o € 3
o !) >i Fir
oq F)
t-t E oq
5 oo
o n
F ctra s v)o o -,F
tr 0J oo. EOJ
5 a HO o=
gq t T gH
Ut 69,
c(-)
o n
s) v,
+o
o 0J
ga o o €E'
9r
5 V) x( eoo
o o =o
52t
v, o :TE
X
o o oo
n ( rrrl* U'P
0.
v, 'gB j5
E cg n
o ;9J
t
V) TO
o o V) F5
oo
{ $) 8.8
o
p)
3 tu'
o
p g) 9l 8g
F oq g o
E FE'
qq F FJ oi Jq( tD
qq F f . )
p*
u, E
o -l oi'
XO 6' <'
o 0) "6 v,
o F) 88 5'E
P)
F w 5O
3
F o FJ Bh 5E
oq to. ,to

185 Haw t* investigatelangr-lagestructr";re


186 i-law LangirageW*rk*

'9"r,. .(,i
'*"-""*,"t

-EE L..t*#
* gggg*gggE
I$::3B [ [Eg [[
*tF + i ii€$
I i
s
*i$ gps rE H
gd
=E r EaI Hl ig Hn a
Il+e*.rEEIgggt1lg
iE #il1[gEHi'€igiHE[il[
gF
:=Vre€ [: E[c *l +r* *i sq:r
?=.

i? -#3eigE*E$s[E'glgH A
iE sHfiAi3EHsEar+f*g;*
;; iflt;eEi;F:E
=s HE#sEFi3;[gE s?pFH
1F$lE
ltegIqEgEHiIEFigEI
g€ s t
v 3 H nl
3
q. o
=-E
-ts
v = -l E' o
r)
F3s
; cra
: d' 3
. J
o
r) n
Vt
fDH r)
o tr o o
{g 5
r+
.rt il
$grgFrE
A HE#roq'=
)I € nP .o gEf:3H)a'sq
E €F$Hfi?$$+r
F r ) o
o fD
{D ? ; 6E'
g) 0J o
r+P -l o.
t) 7 8 5
5 Hro s) c
p.l
SX
o ol c)
o fr5JHEEfr
3{ _(/'
oo u, o o3 'ro (h
{a
+ s-H$tEii i
t- hl
o g) oI
- (t 6g o o
o (1 €o
F,v) !'
(g.
o o J
(t)
r+ Vt
iJ. E
o (D
o 3T g EFi€ $frFid
q,o oq F65 3 o.q
oo -(/, o(h o !)
zt
c,
(tt
, - .ta
F
rD >
r+ oq
0)
5
o
vr

l'r
Ff

Ol
0r
o cra
'oo
o
C'
o#
J^
F$llE};$* f + ili il€'i
lH'i4 f SqiH
o(') - o o o B.1
D o U) $€ ?€ $ $ H$ F
to i' a) o
H o v, (-J
P / T" (r) x FT
(t) ef
-.
H F '
PJ
o
9)
d
o o6'
$Flf€;t+ U+ t s{: i d
rJ l.{
U) f d ! 5 ir€
J o' 5O o g
. h - . € qq la v'
FF{ H
v v 5 0) $ T
FO V) Ff o _?J PJ
;tfrFr+ e l.HE;* $$dE:
o J v, so gq v,
s' oa v, NO o 5o
o 4 fr
9) 5 EE. o fD n mc EsEg Ssi $
FE
- . i
F n o 0)
I
o 5
E5
taiD 5 ctq n 0)
o o{ o n
o o Vt BP
gIi*E;
0)o g Fl F/o)
6"9 € F) 9) s
o E' ct
;:lE: XFEi
s!1 o n f0. F o
JD n 5 I { oa ?D
o :fv, o
=d
E5
F
FI'
{o o
rD Ho €
o
hl
hl
rD F)
5

o
O t-,r
3[ i;
qs 3
sr
lEE€$*
ESEF ES x,'\'
s s o, qq €
;( o
!H) 0J ro Ho rn d,
;vt
sE . €h'E
P'q'*
g) q
{ +6
g'l 5 g{ fo cr
o I 5 g.H
(D oq rzrE
Ets;.lI H:+{:i
EE 9) (D o
€s ' H o 9J r) +6' H
3 u) (a
o^ 9J trtr
6 tD c' o -r-S o \S vt Fl B 3 .H
o€o n o srD € K s FF 9) EF.
o 0t SJ aa) = S
IE TL 9r9 F! to
5o. I v, 5 E? 5 5 - I
s .:3
fl$FE1F + FH
t87 H*rw we mean

'_
188 H*:w LanguageW*rks

--J
-i' 6 (! r] rt F {D
u FL !t ro tgt rt
6'q = (D Ft
8Lr o t? Ftl ht
t+ 3 o () Ft
d=. I t? d d* =o F5 o € K EF.
ltt c! F 8 5o.8. o ?_tD oC} d E€ vto Hhl 6 o
(! =t I' o fD :< (D o. 5Fl o
v, H H.E 4 S)
6-* € FI FEH ; ': tD 6E ; F
(D Fl
o (D *E nt s€ {
ts o
=(D o Ft! =. F|
s) E. FI rr 6' P) u, F r<5 pv, 0) 5= o g.
= gq 'U, rd vgJ fDol
5 .9
F 5 g. hr V) o :+g
ga r-t E E I r) 6:S vt
n { tD =oo FI o o Fl 5 o i'tu
\J I{
E5 v., s
3H g) o F' F tdX
hl €E /ts o E3 d
ei. o Fl =-l s)
x7 E r) (1 oH |.Do g vt
foo g (1 (D E. o o it F
f.) o o o vt !'+ F 0r € E) f.)
= o v, o g6 E €B g *o o:t g 5 o \5(D $q
F € xo I E v, J?
EE ga 5 ovt g *s f) 3 € ;i 0) 0) tn
n o o FI vd fD s) o H o 'ct € tr H6 i{ U,
ag g3$ o FI
€ 6 g v,
c o Ho) FJC E o o F o
Fl o idH 69
3A tv,
X o,'i* v, JD g g HF 96 c o Vt E' v, o o
lD tt) r.l'.)' o g,g o 9r hl 3 ,tn o sl'
o E v, ox- tr u,
9)rn * pJ
o E< s 6B zlD FJ (1 0;6' {S) OJ
5 (t vro *6 F) gJE { Ut
F€
aH) n o o v)5 -
p F o
a,ErHF'oo !'+. g 5 tr tr +3 o Hl
3
;€ () O F fou' X :54 r-t fD r)Fl E ;g p) 6F o
Fb 16 € g oo o o {
3ro rD o) v, o) g.e 5 \J =ro su, 9r F o on Fs;
(n g o
b $E F) 9) s) oFl 8 .8 5;r Vt g Hn oq €
*fD O t-t coE' Jb g hl cr 5 o
tt, 5 F Fl v) u, o. o.o Sl FJ Vt c r-l
o f.) r)fD 9J tsl
srd
o (D- o o 0ltr ro€ F g) o 0J
qa a
e'F =g) 6H ff tt )*' € Fl o Frr
c F
H vt
t+r) o o ct 5 vt o €q
v) o I
HA 5
=o 5 o hl
Eff o rD >t o € S
fDFf n |D qF
s' 5. €
t6 €
(D
0)
hl o tto. v, hl tr 3 :, s
(D
o {o
o-a
rD Ff: 9) s5 t-l
|) 5o
0) 69 co fD Sl *,d
q3 fH:. fD 5X Fl ER
LN d :s 5 o € -l o SJ F
o vt (? f) Ja 5' o Eg
d'€ to1 ooFt o G E f 'o f-b =0. F o
(, € AcL Sg) s qF 9) o F grE u, 9l
hl
o,E qt o
Fl
i6'S o 5 o er o E o o. Fl v, F
o
FI
Hvt o. p fD o oo $ 6H
=2, ,do : O E t)
€€ 3 6 F 8. 5' tr = Fl
* 7l o 9l t-t w o 0.o o
35. € P !-+ o s3{ lrl o 5+l v,
o ' od F Fl fD
=5 o gq nt Vt o5 9r s 9[" 2€ F
hl o gq Fl
H; Eea
fD hl 9J 5 3 o
(D Hf € F E H.o
o.= sv\ hl € o 0) -1 =E F
(? 8ts o .('J o o F F s EPJ u,
r-l 5r sl o
I X .A6- H X Elr
c.9r Ut
as F o rd Hd {
Sl =Flga f) € o Eg o
FJ
=lt.0 o rD o
(D (D
dv,
13
Ft
o F 6' Vt { Fi
{fi
;s 9
cL F € ra O H r FI
s$
gt 8 qq €3fi g o o ur- {D
q3 o vts p 5 Ox S. Ft)
:" 6- o vtg 6 '!-|
r) -lq A o
*t-b (D o 0q n co g
o d
qf; o o 5o) o
u, n F rO N
o. o- l' }{ |f) D) E s BF
u, -€. = 9)
r)
g g O. N
o E6 Hl 9r-
o
g S
€=. sJ s$ ra H 9J
€ cro aB o F€ o
5 os o 9l
o. o5 5 o s) ?g
r')
*F $ F r) sE. fD v, qq 9) o
gqg" 9) G=. o tf r) OB u, 5
o ?#T o o K I $ cnr v, 0) O. rvrD o Hq v1

189 How we rnean

L.
190 i{ow Languag*Works

iEEEIEiEElEgEE
al rlf
t.D
Ots c' 'E
|! gt !-l a !t T trt 0t ql € 3 o
H)
tr .|! ctD v, *l
(D6 0. fD € o t 5
}}. 9r =b fD 5 Bog
€ U) o p F g F v, cr
v, ttt ta rig S l-l F ts aB FJ
o (D gr g € o ga o o E"qo €
9.rD pr =.o 9) s E5 tr o o
Ov, ? ^P p. o Vt ? :s v,
3 ;F
o 3e F 9) 3 s' €
5 o 5 Vt
sS . Hoa t.)
5(D 9J I n U) s v, v) RSr4 o
Fr.€
bt-t r-l = o tD o o
s I o
g?, K(a n oo fD
5 $ o
Fl (D
w
o d
SH ct d 5 v, F F8 (t,
tD o € o FJ 0r ; 8g v, 0) F) (D 5
Yb ut fD 9 X ! o
w
K v, K tD $H o
au) 9J JD o o :s 5 F
Fl
ug 3
& Gos.
n v) s
e :{ o 5
n v) N t t
i
co 3 It f) 5 3 F € s SH o s o o
^o o 5 ho € E o o o o >U vtx o f? v,
Xs) FI o S) o Vt ? 3H 3
x.s H . s
ri TL o 5 :< { CI. E
0) q o = Fl
o X -l r)
JD 5 8g PJ o o
-('r \s or TO r{
o gl o
r-l .tlr o $ u, s E';tr
€ d F T5 v,
.) qa d
Eo sFJ ' o 5 F
(!E o o 0) zt s F o o S
o r-l Sii so o p ? o
r.l o 6i \J o
Xi' 9. 5r: s '(t F o u) o. 5 h
0) strF
f)u, E H gq *i g 3
V) H' 7i' r') s tr =b vt "tr ooa ts o
g) vt
o 9)
s {o
Ra' f s" F tr
n o F € ='o 5 a1
cr Pg =
qa
(D
63 o 0. o 9) o 0r
hl
f;$ (J.) S Eoq6'
! nt p n LS F id. Ft H
Sd v, 3s o u, Fl € fD s o g) 0) w I
hl
tJ rD
g
q oq r)
s op tr o '-t s 0r -Vt 9) Ut
t1. Sl o tur F
() go 5 o €F $o v, o, o
;5 E 6I o
o € v) o ;J Ut o n
d u, u, n 9) JD {\J 5
o0l € sUT o :s o 6" o FI
s oo U)
o F o 3 ct F (a F fD
3qt o pr
oo) o o o ohl
s f Vt € o s d
xE3
Ar H.
I
3$ sqss9.
5 0r o R o vtO
fx. d a o F o vDd
s Ut G o g. (D S) cr
F& 0J V)
o o r: s) t-l
€ 0.o G 7t X o o o o E 6',6- o
S) $Fl w 5 "o r) d o H H . JD o v, 9J5Fr
o fD qa ta E os v, E
g go
o \ € o o ? .o o H ( - )
d2 * o !oo tD
r) F tr r-t
u, 35 vt r5 (n
u, FD { (D 0l -l a'q o o o
o Ft) 0. E 5g tc' g FFs 9l
g.g F o OJ 15 d
p o n o" ov, cr o o >t 5-l hl vr- \J
sr o. { o JD
8i o
v,
o sF+ vt
u'5 (a JD o I F o5 o 5
0) o o o v, oa vt s
:' Vt v) o n 6'
9ro
\ro
o s f) o o FJ F o ES pJ (t r)"
o, n o Fh Ut tJ
EIg v)
3 o o o d
o € ts Vt E8 ogt (':
o o o o5 s 5 s OJ o \5 E vt
-(,r n g1O H tf o
o o o \J €
OJ o
9) c) o G o 8e {E E ' l j f otr
0)
rD o q V)
3 o = . F+' g 0) o tr Fr T2 o.
p F FU *E (t or F CA o v, FI
t qq o o rF tt) q
O. $ Nar ts zri' c)
!J :J
{o
V) ol: o !)o v, S F \tFl S-l l5 F o
IJ r.) o sit 3{ € r-l oq $*H
LJ
5 5 !l) f) o tt,o S(D FJ5 o Jtr; o
oE' F] .Y s F (D 5o 0)
a' FI :s Ca 5 o o o I (D *E F) sl
o o err
How we mean
l-"lowLanguageWcrks @ryi *T-
1
*"*sd
**-&*
_*J ffi" # .+ )j.l

flry\ L# \-*"-r'&-#
stud
"X
't$r' .$
ffi
**-q
raEisqr
f;Iig;fiigglgrI
g
I$
tglEEE ffi flT\
ew
1EEE
[i1 rB
Ffl ffi &q
k&#
IsFF*arg$c-EiEiEEl$
ffi
ftr
k*J
EF?1gggggIggn
iElsi+ if fs AgE*cri€ ry klr
flT\
a*d
t€FF:FEFiFiE
ifIr$i gf
;r$r*[
**[[;a f] Fs[:g issF xFF:+i[[
uE6ar;
+=H+18
rrrn f;*iF**g
PHHg €11FEFgE
ili!i: ri:i lEElq+ii
) ti G}
r;
5 FT cr u it sS
o o o 3 r) {D OFi Vt SE
ut 7 nts g) lr'rn
gDJ o 5 s 5 E3 OJ o s n i-j. vt
ks
tD S) --- (D s rr tr
*< = OFf )!r vt
:r @ { (D E Th 3 p . 9J (^ o
rr- vr_ qq ci' t6 T5
o X * 3ut s) '-r o + B
o (! (! F or (D ; - sg6
oJ q,
n og. o
5
t
(tt
F
o
rD
o
o
E s
o F
u,
to
o
6E
ET
{.) g 6
5
rD o
p
{
htr)
*E
P,i
!',
Vt
o €
X o
o q"A
€Ffi*+
o 9J ;J ,J V5 oX' iio
s) ci' o g o
H o: ts 5 83 q9
g o o (-j o- o s.5 o- K9J +g
lritligi E
tn t-b (n TC' 9) 3H
v) 9) 6# (D- *3-
jt F
io F
(r:
€ dg P
n qq 0r €6 F Fr'
€ po
N -r+
N o oq =
o N
r) o ? 5 ( sI t o. € :3 F {
€.+r 3 3 g a H
pr gao E:-' { X 9) 5 ' Eqq
qq o E1 =.o 9J (D F*3€FirF
o o- s. o tJO (D =6- o
o, o V) (o x OX r) .) o
gq V) Ut
v- X o pJ 0J(4
ft: tD E i o v) v)O r1 o,
OJ sJ ntD F g
n v, + F X E 3E 5l v)
I s: qsilFn"
o I g) if,-t 3 ?.o
o F. sL v, r g H sr€ H X s
n o o gE 9J Fr -qr
o € 0r gl
s) o o ) o I
a n 'CJ 5 $E
d i.r'
"a- Ets d8 JD o t r'+ g)
o tr + ch
c;t Ut r) xo
o ga o € ;-+ 9J S) o
o g) o a JD o o o z<
0. rD 5or o o
o K F8 o FI sF' ge
o v" 3 o od o o-: v,
fD g) 0) ftt o c) r)
o F)
o
3
Vt
U)
o
()^
g)
v\
9r
o=
XPJ vt
n o s
prD
o-r:
otr
Fl t)
J
o
X 9)
t-l
F)
4
tsrfD
rl+g
Eg
€Hf;;;$.q
E o o aq 0) v, O) tJ
V) o g o s) o
OJ p T o g) xq
n o cu, (Dt: Vt o IH
ut 6E F F
9r
glf #*s1*
o o tr Bts o- o 6=.
o rt "o tr
t-l :- 5 o 3 .r sJ g ) s )
p) o X 5v X ai' E O
4
F
gq FI f.) o $) o q>+ trH I Frisa$i
o s o= p tro (-j o $o
(t, o pr $ 3 Ioci N
9r tror o *Oq
,$ o
o o nt 9i
F ' & }\ 3v,
Vt +0r t{l
o'
o Fr
o cr F
v, .9 9o q s:
o p -sq 6v' *?i I o Xd
*ril;;rr
o Fl Frl 9r Sc+
9)
X o o o ut
a 6H o o oo d
5 fD r) F o l.A) € = 5Pr E o o =s ;IirAXs
o 15 =(D
(n gq
o 0r
r-l o 9J l+x H$ q trFi !trF'.9"95
t-l "9 3E H.€ r) JD
o- ov, t v oq o ='o o Odi
io s&
9J c' tr v) ts.q X A) glO
o o c5 E
rof
R fll
o I gq(? a (D o o ?B qr/l vr-
#n H eg If EfHi
193 H o w w e a n a l y s em e a n i n g
194 How LanguageWorks

*
IEEEEEFIiE
EIgEEEEE

) -!

= t E p

|D fOFl D I hl *- (D
a E B t/l n n GI bn F
(a 6FI!i o
,t ('ct ct ut o gt d o 5 o Ut
I
r3(D s r'rO rD ats
Vt
XO 9) 5 (D 8+ o x
hrX
(D V) 5 o o p o= =si
g) u, t o r) g o fD oq
t-t EO fD
Ft
o fu oF t'0
{ ui
F= 3 0) o 'Je. n 'gg
d o o hl
o 9) rD X n S) LA H FI 5" r!
v, r) { (D S) 0) vt tD B
d
s) cr o oo
Ft Fl + oF v)
K
; s9
S:FF 6'E OJ 9. Ut Fl
g, sJ t+- o $J
$w
i!- O
0) 3 n to =o 3 6'
v,
o Xs rD
- t p o' 0. o o F :J o5 5 o 0) F \H
v) Fl u, €
ts. v, o S) Fl
;€s gq o S) v) s v, vt gJ
o o o' J5 u, o o o €o
0. o o o;i. € *'s qa^ o o
E "q 1 o) 3 cf ! $) F{ o S) o =f)
r) 5 o :f s) o € FI o tr *; si +o
(n g c o o d 8 i TJ o
ts{ 3
gJ
s H E)J ' e str 5 BF o
F d oq =. C' j< S)
Ut E) 5 .p o fd
g o 9J + (! go. g
o_ J? oq qo E s6-
vt
rD ct X o
gl s d gq
o 9S o E u, 5r< o \S T8
o $g+ oJ
rzr-
- FI oa o o gJ tsl c a oqv
t-l o o
a o d 5 s vt fD v,
o o qg o o EP qi
o
(D qr. o ut ,.o g, V) st si r{! ao
a 3 8.d I t-( o F s 5 o vt g o v, .b o p
oo ;J 55 oq EF
E)
xq, F 9J 3 o od
\G h r v , X
o { F
s : bro { ?
F KS
5
n X 0J )- =.
o o , 5 fDt o o s"
(^ 5 g
dct
X .aH
o o s" vt !-| o € { o o o s) o \ao
r) FJ s o. 3 Sl .8 !t a. p g6- H
n E $:. o v) o o
F.l
o -t 0J t-? o oq €
v, vt gq fo 5 s pr 0r FI o F; F' ot
v, o { A. !t v, o Rt' G .vJ
p € o (D' od r5 5 pl F8
ts" s 6 ' o
o JD E Sq o g) ? s d p) (!
N o E3 S) (D n o u, os
a cr (D ,f v, iv, sl'! o E
oq 5 0
o 'n g
g) o v, o E F) (D
tr ov 0) p o 8& Vt o ? f)
s.€
o (.) ; o I Fl tn ct o
o gro ;o
€sE n t,r $
o. (/! q sr o hl F-E
(? 9J F!: 3rD
o o *s p) aE
oq 8H p PJ rt ;O o o d= F rD E gq vt o
H F Vt f-t qq o a. v,
Vt Vt s, o a ) F trt C o r P 8.
y
E s)
"-i= o
3 €
g) ) - l o= : S N tr r o Ft i tr v, 5 0Ji+ s o5'
o o u xu,
o o (-, € o
v, v* u
9) v)
s ,i
p) gq
OJ P
v, o o oq n t- H S
d do o
l-vrt EF
u, o Ut

(D
r: r r)
o E. 9)
6 rD
F o
tr b'g ,d 6
FJ gl3
(D s
qq 6HE sr tr
FI
pHS
-r I ,-t € F X s n r D!
lra
F J J o 0a D X}l (! G
E*F 5 v) ga I o v,
-l o o O. o ss H € f9 i-a
o o n € o r.l Ff o ,J ti lrr
5 0) tt, o I +5' o OJ
\s oq o, o \3 0)
g, s' g. F6 v) o
o @ \3 o a) FJ H Hv) v, F ag
H: o tr o ga' Os
g
o T F-3, o o FI 0)
(r) F F
FI:F'
fn
€ Fl
tr o o . o '-D g) _(,r
9) o o 9
o0r F
(n r) fD o (D- ..s
o r) FI o)ts. o T5 HH
:r
so rt 5 a.
.y,G€. s. rDK p) o ct, u, O. n ho (Do o
rD 5 F g) o o v)
d r) o o o a-{
t o H sq ct) o r: o o F $s)
v, t-l o a x+ X6 -
Fl
o o F o s Ft 6'
:r F
5sR
io o €a o c' { G,!r
o (D cr lr s
0) o l-l tr o Be
EHS s -6! g5
G F c v, -l 0) o o 0) ;_d
pJ g) oq o
s) zt 5 0r5
ts 57t o H o=
d{rP € T9, v, v, vt V) oq Vt
5 v,
*X.FH - 9.

195 How we analysemeaning


196 F{cwLanguag*Works

:-r
!! 6 o
F+ 6F g ,r
F}
o o 7
o FI
!t s (o d o
r-l E U +8 "
FI
=lg .o_l v, o o
(D ?o (t
e5 rD SF -(/r
s) 5 (Do S. X $t
Ptn (1 OJ
o TA
(D lt a' p
€ A) ?H F oa -6
f- E H To fa
vt FE sE .) o F
(t A) FJ
5'E vt rD f) =6-2Elr
F og. o po rD 5 $J
(Ar
ts.
'o) F 5
a. vto
H 9r 0a r ' 8 v, ssf; s J
sJ F
o 5rD v, *rDrtr5O-
d
E . or-i a)
6e g E qqH o
OJ o 0r 5 5
Fi'ts98s
/|\ a\.
FT)
f.) v) o v\l
r! o 6o v, lX = u) v,
s Ao rD pr d !'
F SB
r-t v, 10 .J v,
o rD 5 F
hl
A)
qii f,sH
Vt dF n E n sr*.ooo
n =g (a o s9
6 ' tr o urt.rtFb=
0)
ts.4
P q'' a(a -.t FJ
v) .D
o .,rO \.{ fD (a :''! F o F to
td Ff:
0q (n rD 0) .*
€ o o' 5 o
oJ s) i 3 , rD €= v, *€ [ *
0)o 5 *o v, ct
Kvt E .X
PrD
E.€ o
X
s o)tD
(t' A) 'i5n o g E"g* d E.
ro ;r o)
(s .) o v, {
A.+ (A $=
xfl o ut
o "i
o
dO ;s Xu, 0)
Ft
(A ; c)
s
Vt
EE r il;:
sa o o FJ
59 g oi' rD t'! H;il Hg
op. F{ o { EF o F n
6fi' t9'o g : +E 3
- d
og) J^V rD €
rD \ L
8"
rD r) o r-t H.-fD+S
Xv, o $'g Fl o
v, E' D) o
O t'+ X
o ql eE p o #;eE"A
X +b- o HO (-r F
6 o F) OJ o ts Fq'f;
V) r-r qq 6 s o E =
0,t c
q rD Ffa :- v, g
gE 5 tC'
H E $9
''a \J F) o v, A) -i s)
n PFI U)
o +oq (? C' 9) o
slo 6rD |a o T8
v, ct
0Jt E
fDH
5 s
.E3
U'fD o
ts ds
V)
;J
r r{ a$
o rJ)
#r bDO E.*$E: H H
fD s o J 4

E{ o c'' o Xroro9.
oa(o 9 o) h: r)rD ?
I
e ?
- or-l
oo r) s 7X s.
yv F' E q
rD s Ff6
$)X o ;(D
E9 s 'orDE:I rD a. xf) s =
SEH H T
(DfDfDvrv,

H*w we a**lyse rneanlng

t-
r98 l"t*w Langu*geWcrks
K
**$**
!r. ? t).

3 6 s, E I g' E 3 t H': E Ftr F t q 3 7 F 3 ffi Bu-".s.+"'o*"j


M
?H e#
ii ?.3 n s i PBil il3$ifsElg
i+ i #F#
?oit
a Ir ts ; sg€ +; +is aEHrE
r e?sr +ii f
13gFgE#i5E3E=ro=;I E3F* i +a€
r*Fq
$&d
=a-=
t I Fsi $gF; Eri fl; i€t * gi I ;
.-=oro;lq
=r B+Fi{ 6n 3s il; qaS$Sii3E
; +il=+-' I ri +r Er I
=; [ ;€ iE F *! il;EE ;igs ; Is flffi
ft%
fus*J
l. i+.HsFs igil.q r*g $g+gd **ry
**%
i*['i 3t ;Lt3.Il;$Fg1EggF g $
s s x d q H* g $ T t; f;
:5t.fr
i ;e
7 s; s: s rE [i; ;€;E [[+r"
i"=i; 3E $ Es33S+iEsH 7€s a
: = r E E.g
;===; F x I f i s: ; 3 3 $.f * [
?;
i [g i ] i * *l *E:i $EHFEg
g'6- + ? d
; i =6i€ H F'adE I
ei si iE F:€p; eE
i=J;HEF;
i? gI1]E€E
E$EFgi$E!;
1[
i=-=? l

rl

!
v) d o
egeEg
9J (D €
€ t(') o I;g*Fa;E
o o' oa E o p € rd o s
(o tD
o o F
o (a
{ n g) qa 11
? o o d
fia[F
f.!
a
0J Fi 5
IA
o
5 o gq
fiFdF3'+1I+as+E'
o oa 5 r) U)
o o oa 9J
e oa o, n
a)
rD o I' o o o E E !I# a v,
€ cra {o X
f)
9) u)
o
(a
3
gq
o
g)
'o
Ft:
g
v,
u,
f) 0)
(D
[EfrfrgTFgFII:3
.+ o X 'u 'Ibj E o
Ut
o FJ
a)
E'. (D
rD
n 9J
(1
F*ri
!) d
o
o
6"
n pr
F 0) o 2X o
(h V) F o o o
o t o pJ gq $
o SJ r) g € I qq
x T "o u,
g o
€ (D o E u, ; o
o o o 5 r_t
,a
X
(.) gJ
5 o FJ o o
€ t :. o
a+Es
vr:H.
o 0.
rJ
o
o
r)
o
aIrgr:g*
:.' n !J q o 3 9) r) Ut
o EgSF sr p o tn
fD or F
.) Vt ? Ft o
C'
o 9) (t)
gJ o tt)
o
r) €
o
rD
Vt
I
o
9" oqF
fD
-l o
Ut
rBEE
vrSrJ*E'
=vru'dE
F o
o
5
o
o
i nf$*E$F
€ tr6 g) o o
't g iR 3
o 0r
ni' gq o ggf6' 15 0)
Ut o tf
€ o o o g) (D'
tr [[l1[==,rr3e
gl p rD Vt n
o *l n &rE.H F o
7 n 9) rl { f 5 € (D
5 o o o o I o
c $ v, o rD Ft
(-) gq
d
o o F Fl r)
7f
!D
+sBr o F
El3*gg€fEira
oq (-l o o o o sl 0)
a F o !? tr fTH* f6 gq
G' it o 5 o
lJ) g, ut t gao-B' gJ'
o 3
o qq o o t { n n o
v, gq o K o gl
0t
(D o () 9)
Br8? gJ o
ry o
9) o 0r OJ o o o
Ft
Vt o o o o o (C
o v)
{
n
0)
o
rD o
X
f.)
9)
d
rD
f-)
0) p3
o oq0)
vt
g

(")
o
g
o
v,
€Fsg
EE3F.
F
T o
3
0)
>t
JD
o'
igg*ritIa
Fqp;Hi$f gFeE
fD 3 v, 'E o
(r) € N o 35 + fD o o
o o X ib oq X
Fl tr € ni' o 6-A s 6
o g o (o o" v, 0l F o 0)
o n tD o I o
5 o v, 5
(D 3 o i, 5
sr o 9) r)
(D n
$ i.E F "o 9) €
o F o o Vt oq o
o S) (D I
(D E v) A;qf o v, ut Eg$rEii
199 [-l*w we l*arn v*cahui*ry
Haw LanguageWorks

OOsr$=O.
',6:,=s ' il€ T.* H F
[E[5if$$*Fg8,ft&qs
:Eg+FiHa:H.TI o$*F+H
a[$$Hi
gH*: E' fl '
5'*6'F'i':
E=ie [ $ix;cae E ;;Ecg6 1g 1 3g; g g; H q; 6' B {
:E A igE $ iE :5 H g
?$gFE
+' ili F€aq Fr$}g $E lEEgE 1 sisBgr E.a1 Ff=

J $[ i [
? I IE
€* A er i i r +B; Eq AsH € i i IJFFSJ
-Egq8*F
B6EF'=6
;^<PtFt
g q EEfiEEIgE
i IFEE1$FiEI dj{t rBE" r
E:FgE3 *
33 h-9?9^qe
-;i*rFgg$$$€€[
I$ttaFE[* x a:
eF.P7,or)
hi;' P
efr353F+€, 3 ;i*rl 3Sqggl*i; ?ff1gF HAeftH?
fDF|.ut=

H \J fr J)

6r 5!-{or$.
FiFIIflixrEEggfsHEiqEft f +; AdE dg
F=i'F*qgliE
#A ,-FE1#
iEF+ef€*F;iH fi qEsq E d
g =E $F
r eft gg =3.3rI
l;!Eg
=;=Ei:eri;; 1=F +IqlEil
1:3.91= iz€ i7- EE E 8 g v

Fl H o r-l C s 3
Flt o cl r) t
c! F it E€ 5,E Fl) (! (D IA
Ft gq
B g |:t
s d F!5HR€ tD Ft g o Ut i-i"
r{! t (a o 5 T
= Fl 9) c) *l 9 0 = x 6 o cr rlo o) o F 5
Ut o 7f =o S r l V H ! tt)
It f) o v, (D F) g g \s F o 6-o
d 5 F
g cl (D Fl g) F FJ Pht
o o It o F gF =q 6€€ F tr o
3 r-t o qq o v, S) o F(D
o o + 5 s) F w s) o d 0) I'st
(t) o @ (A r+
E 2, *3 u, T JD r-l 7l X tDa-
€ FI ct 9) F I q tD ;. o ro
.: E
:s
o p o g 5o" : 3x o Fl € :s C' oq
0) o U) gq Ft 0rtD v) F o tD o
tll
:q E
vt
d 0, o o p) U) r)
7l g 9J d c) g V) { = :- H -r E o v, S v,
t-t vr5 9) 5+ =:
v, F fD o La
sg F
$ fD s 5 (t F ot qq o
a g
o FN Ftg qFil {Hs) 5
tn
tr o 0)
fD F o T o 9l
n 9) Vt 5 cr V) $)
o C' Vt g p lti5itrr o tD
.g B'
o (D o v, F € tr vt (tE
P tr o u, (a o o 9)
fD 5 o tB SF E 7, ra' H' 0) v,
v, Ffr o A o (t r) 5+6
t g) o ohr g a o *l
vt o Vt p 5 p 9J o o o F)., .J
o ga v, g v, o {g) Jl' tr ctG
5
5 r) v, 5 Fl E H' Fo Ut r) FJ G 3 s g) F g F|
qa s) i d Fl COlt-) gt G 5 gq g) qJd
U crq o F p F)
p ifl sU) v) (,)
€ F) F) u, c) i o $E'
9) tn G oJ xi v o ) =5r 'D 1F o E {
r-t 9) cF o v, o r) F 5
vt v, Fb G ! r (D g f) ? o o
(! F s Fl o O P F . F l F . oa oq 0l =l) S{
n F) o o c hl
3 o -(r!
F 0, F 055 vt o { o 5 v)
Dl d vt H '8 Ftm o X p $ d9
p) vt oH o 3 o 9J
o E o C o d'O (D \J d s) t, d ,F
3 p td c 6qq g B, + (1 E ?
vt o fd 9r(D Fl X c, 3
g, o o)
o 0r s o 3 Ut =1 i € o o q 3 i+ 0)
r: r: p
ts oXo o o
5 o Ut
x'do
-tOts. 0) s) 9r (D o 5 c tD E s
o oa o ts
o Fl: V) ' H . F t F 0, !) o o d *l oo
5 0) ? o . H Fl ?l-
gt qa v, =. oa Fl cr o rJ tr o u' E!)
o) {D d '- qF) a (D g o p)
o E|D o 5 v, F 3 ; Vt OF
v) F C' D tD o v, F l-l g 9)
€ p X (D o n o
CA 0) o (') gE o F ga \i
U) v, '
tJ.
o w -(a € F 5 50
d (D 9) Ft Vt (D o
o t('
t o H s) 3 3 eE fD oq
v,
o o5
$
o Fl: € q f-r rd
o n o 88 T i5- g s o o o o 0) ,) lA
(D s) 9) { Vt g o Ft
Vt 3 F o ts p
? F o rJ ta
o
Fl
tn :5
9) qr 5'Eo 0)
Fr crg B 5' n
€ 3
v, 0) 0) d
ss o F E' v) (a o s tf oao
n tr I. v7 5 q ,tO € v,
F h
o v, w F (D 3 -Eo 6. 59 oq o
o u fD S
JD r) o
s
F vt o Ut Vt 0) E.F (? ql
€ F
s n
:s
vt { F o .o o € f.)
sr o + S
9) u, F o -oE
o o to o EFt fD € o s) U r) K
Ft) Vt o r) o F.
+ a oq o
hl
rD FI o t
IJ F
3
(D V) 0) 11 o tn FJ(D
o 5 o (D (D 0r Fl (D o s 0) 8 $
f6 n r) r.l
qa o 3 o
s) g)o 9)
F s s*
tDii F g) Fl o o av, gq5 € O o )
E) Fl o F .l s o F) o 5 9) E)
f)
Vt t *- .o. 1 - 3 s t-t
o F hl d
{0J t cJ fD o o (D
r)
F t
(a Fl v) K v, 5 FI: rD a o o FR
I 0) oa o o tD

How we learnvacabul*rv
zo2 l{ow Languag*W*rks

-'
ii giiEiE['IIE$ii$igg
I: : $i
1+,e,g*1fli8[ei$[
iu€FiFSEEEEaEFI
ilEgliirElgcFr[EEu
(t
GI
Fl
gil o -l
F.

A, u, o g o
orF 8
:;9)
-E" n Vt
5 3 rD o. IP
vv)
FI o
ga o a- xo g (') o
tr Ei rD H
o E) 0l
F 6 5 9) o
(/) - l rg, ro
.E o X
s) .) Ut V, V, o
f6 9) s(/: E. o o
o 9J 9)o. gl T
g E o o
o "t5 g
E) Ut
v)

o
F)
o
5
Vt
so
H t
F
6-P
sI
gs s
o
d
E.g
E8
t,
vt

F'
f.)
9J
1*g1EE
ct
o
F
9)
F.l
o
zo
v)
(a
t:
t ta 6rD F
0)
5'd o |D
V)
Vt
(D

F
$Esg11i$
(a I' o (D
F .) 50 0) g6 o
F I F H
FJ r-t r-d o o (D
5 o 9) 9) o, 5fD 5
X
oa g o5 o o F)
5 Sr otl +{ n
t, v, (DF o o
9) n 0)
@
o
o
s
o
H
F
{ sFi
v,
gJ
-!t
&e
p
o
s
F
*iElFIg$
o o f) oq q a o F €
0r ut A. 9)
r)
F tn
Ut
g)
f6
;
sq
xd
t'9
tr
p)
oq
(D
t
KF
o C
+rD
Vt
tlt
u,
t,

d
:iq*B[*+
i il* tsHs 6sE
E o $o. [i9. 5 9J
oq o o -
3 \v' o H
X o 0) #E {
f+ v, 9) r) co
R8 sr5 v,
v, (,)
o o p oq n
o oF)
n
g) 3 EF gq o
Vt
F FHiF3 r*€
o c) -fD o Rs 9J
d F Xgr v5
tr € X 3clq 5
9J 9) n S5 s+ o
s.o g) E' 0)
E 5 p 5
v, o N. o. d3 (? n
v,
V)
o
g
F
p {=. E i+.
o.
o
r5
t'rl
)-l
OH
5
O)
o
o
o
0J
F
aEfiFEg
o C'
sUt o gr F 5l
g o
g
* rg1El F
203 How we l*arn vocabulary
H*w lang*age W*rks

ru *J-*
fri
fl*\ 9t"-*dla,r;
ffir \*d
iNWS
-b
fr .zu"'*,6;;
-giE g$EE[EE$F ffi
fl*# &$
1r=g
?1
Eg 3 =.+; I 93:FHAssE+ ry
***""#
1€F; HEtiEgrgE$it€E ffi
== s **gd Ln 3eE;3*8fi$t ffi:
ff\
4 A
M*d*
ffi3
**%
iF n iH$ XIg}lEilFgg
:= i 3gE gi+i+fgEFr flffi ffi\
a&d
*re
E
tu
is E sE€ [*[[E$g9Fi ffi
3t gIE s+ssEslg+r
'al
f
;E s$ sH3
€F$
$Efi[FllEet
TglEigsFlg
-68*$$+fi=F
E $ E"F,I
3 € 3Eg Ei6;sE3.rEe"
3 E +sr ilisiiEi$3r
7i=

ll
t a a
g
-trtra (! g
€ o. € -\' rtt h
(D o o
r-l t-t o E
w
o
F*F 0) n tr E
o
o
fD
=J2 |D o g. o
+
H ?a.g o o
x 9J FI, ut fD X K p s
. A N 0J o J^
fD j v, F
p nt' o. 5 Vt n 9) HIH# B
S)
.. {xos o
oa o g d g) C' o o
o s
v)+ H. o o F oq o o g 5 s s n
la
@ d o oa o s n
S) tr
o
s (,:
g) F o s +
o
rEeF s. 0)
^s
\ J R
{ :3 u, -(rt o v)
U) { o o ,.o x g € o
fD o FJ B gl 0) o
+v g o o rr6{ Vt o vr ;Vt
o n
6
: 'S
R
o
d
o
o
o
F
v) o
Vt

PJ
o
U
?
F
o
E
n
o
p
vt
5 tr
a, 5
U)
o
o
n
:<
0)
g
I $Hg
5
r)
o
Vt
g)
o =
(,)
;o
erg$F
*g xnEF* 9r
5
o. K
tr
g)
5
u,
S)
(t)
- +$k oq 9) *l S) =
F V I SJ'
5 5 rD p)
3
o E o €
G (a r_t o n
L o
o d
5 qq o n o s)
gHrsis+ n s)
)-l o oq F) o o f[[g hl K
I
tr[, oq FJ o o
ao 0r
s:s o o 3 J^ o E { v,
o gq V) o o F3.gF o o
*R (D o g) F 0J qg s ga^ (1 rd
0) q )-l F a.
o FI I
tD SJ$r
dR
-q(!
0)
Vt
o
F)
SJ
g
v)
.r o
3 o o
"9 o
0) n
f 3 i+;Eg o
U)
9.
o
IFl OJ qq 5 o g sBE 7 F F)
(D FJ o O)
o v, 5 g. oa- v, u) tr
a* u, 6-3rD -
rD
Eb
F o
v, o
5 rD g) o R5.
E
s € €
Ft ++?H's =
n
Vt
6 R oI cna u, o o o
-.i
sr X. o
5
o o o
Fl 5
qa o Y
o
;E Rg o 0.
vt
s$ ctsEi oI
so I
s6' 9r 9) 0) 9) t-l Vt € \
6 \ v, o (t
* o. I o I
:5
ES. o o cr - g)
E
5
9J
JD sJ € Fqts Es s$g=.n rb
- s.
I

;S p o o n o
!\
q o s o
a' U) 5 n o o o 7f % F
Fl
JBS oq
o X FJ iJ) fD o
H+:: fi r)
or
'Ei l$$sR r!
v
o o o F' tJ oq oq tr s ss s
X X Vt o g N
dF' \o o vt JD o c)
n E T' rD n S) $
€tvE o
6 o o fD F) -R "tr
PR
6.S
o
U'
F Vt
o o
tr"
(? Ut
cr 5
tr
FEE5
8 3.* o
5
{$FF- 5
o
6S H'
g n 5 -vr
r0 R:s :r
0J
o rD € $, f)
\ o (D o (!
q FJ o U) s 5E rD
-' se.s. ) o g
gE+F c 3
=o o 5 F . - Y
f')
s--R $ 9J ;
H !
o S) o u, P g.:!
:5s tr T
qq
o
o tr o p o rl
JDJa IA 5 i ID Fl F
0
Fr:
9l 0J
a 5 Hq o 3* $ o "tr
205 H o w r h i l d r * n l e a r nt c r n e * n

\ ,,.
How LanguageW*rks

+ g E FE
sa,EE.O E,€E + #
:* EBFiqFsEFEi *E€;e ss€ iSHi-
+EFE$F'
Tg q Si r
;+rs=1
N E F HH FHil.qE#s *g*ln1ggg*argf
;5*
€; =.=sq FE$;i66 gag sF;ig :qFri F5; senTi ;$gGEFlE
f : '? { 3 i fl t:F
=A?{+:
Tie.t€[
=€ .; * Fx
Eg IHF5sE
1fF
€F €f5+$E$
g[F$irE*$EgIF$I €,E H';:FE: i5: f gE=.$sC H.;;o.
ilslAF
zi; F€ + ii
I s.Eg E H 6 F ';H Bg tB! +FEils;$ Hssa
t€ i; ; ; cg i+f 3ili;$ts tEEF
Ei aCge
a5o'+=i.
*il igt
irr EF igg gEiH E;.* frH*E
E = r; g v, o g
C -.5 E . H F 6 .'r iL S o F C F H''o
+i I r
q "oa F; : $; i93
F rrg g; fIF flEf$g:
qF;$E$$ Ersfi
F*Er
F Et;
isiias
€'=;a= : =E?Fsi?f E3iEiE ?i!e
U.{ -i €
F F} g! o
D:T sr (D Fl it FI
-|rtr' tD fD (! g)
; rD o s
E 3 =P F 9!
V ! @ tD AA p)(D = q !J s€ s o
F fD o R o
:igq x oq tr + o.F o n F -l so Fl
so s
I l J t)
':oo o o la o =p 3 -l rD Fl o u, o
o |!
F€ ta' O. fD s v:- rrr-
F v, ro o o 9) U' o
E O5 3 $,
F 3 ga 0) (D g. v, a) s€ 9) I
o vt o o -5 (a
s U)
H E'o p K u) 3 r-r o 6 f-l T €
gJ--6 a o "o o Xo n o 3 fD- n 9)
o
g) rD trr s
tD o 0J rD oJ 5 N *
oa 9) tr o s \, r_l s
{ t-l =H) F OJ FR F o oq I
w n.
o)(DFt
o t) 5 S)
3 E 9J gq o
d 5F |.1 oa s) TF FI p o c s S
(D 0) o oo E 5 n :) 5
C)
{U) F :t 5
f.) s+ Ff) fl'i 5.5 f) sJ s J0
i?q E fD g p
=qFi d 6P X n F = trFF g
u, o b=: € s. w
a
F o eoq Vt E o
u, o ,-{ g) fo oq v,
a) (D o r) fD t J ( D
t1 gq o
l-l
()
3 o go) 8-E nt rd ra-
r'oo o 0J s) o o o t.r| S
V)
:=3
FI F o5 o F*9 9J o s
v, o 5h F qq o o qa
3 fr (Do o E'O E qn' f) s
ha o I F) |!
o s s
9J E 6 9) |.)
- o Fl o
v - o F{ v, o 0r € (Q g o v,
o n q; i-a ts d { o o _sr .ar
A9 5 BFI
o o Fv, o o o
o p g)
€ (') F
tr or-l
PB 9) o g(a T F 5 vt 5 v) ?
oa (h o 0r g o P v) v, o
do o tn
o v' o pJ
5 (D vt
oo f) g) =' € o € o s.5 g €
3 F) .) 3 r) F (.) \
(D il) 5 (,) 0)
o
TX o JD K 3 R o I n "o o ( ! ! ' r+. v)
qg vt (D s) n to F tD !l)
o 0l o o - 'w g
5 d g o F 5 r) o. v,
a. g. H a n 5 € (D 0.
hl
o F 4 cr (D 9J 5 o
9) t-{ g X o s g 4E tr F
A 0) o o 5
gq (D Fl
o o
u, to tD g (D S)
ut o F
5 o ) Fl'
Sl
F v,
o
r) o (D v, o tr-t H
o o gq o X Fl F o
"5U
rD Vt a
B:r oJ s) ? o Ut
o fD Vt 9J ?D5 o Fb
{g v, cr gr F's qii E .) V, Ff 15 o o =l)
Fl 5
E.
'Vt ? F o E
ro
ts tr
r5 n F
fo oP- { cr { r)
(1 p
t
:F r( Dq zo FIr o tr
o o OJ 5 }.l |.)
o o JD o o oq r'+ fD o d oq {
r) F EH E F
(A 7v, u, o o
3 pfD u, o $ o pr
0r oa 9) o E) o o
o o Fl Fl
gt vt 0l : -'E -(/) s(tt i
o fr (Dlt o 5 o r) o d v, n o v,
Ut { t v, vt x5 Fll 9)
'o F o hl o F =' v2 0)
Ut y4ci { o (D g o d
g) o hl 5 v, Vt
,{' ti
p v, g a ! ? tr 9) o o
rd o o 3 v, o I
5 E o 0) tr o ta t)
o 0) dE o u,
o .c/J Fl o
5 o FO
3 H 3 9)X ro o
€ X+ v) o o o rD r D s E o
€6 o
Ft € 5 o o
FI o g
{ (a o tO
o o { Vt Ar- pJ vt
=.
) 9) (D F) 5
Er n d 9J o F r) E 5 gq
9J F gE p p o 5 gq
I o o dg oq oq u,

How childrenlearnto mea*


!-lowLanguageWorks

i
IiEEEEEEEEE
EEEEiigiF
E
gEiggEEEgEiEE
gE
o r+. S
Fl r-tFsr &
o qw v, BR o
H5'
fD H
Rog.
ta tr w t t 50 r.fD Fl
4
F Fl
o o 3 oa F+i
f6 :F s) H F6
F g o H.L
88 Ut € FfA.l
o il *+ oq Vt n $=- F
0) 5 5 Vt 'ro ts Fl :fci>
9. g v, fD rDpr:J
tD o o OJ E
\) !.rD X
v, 5
o vr9 FJ € 9r
E's H' a" o 9)
o oa v, oq g vll s
o
€F HI ' 5g q E$ ts ,.o
€ € s o 0) F o H.
F l h
E E r5 o o.R
o o 0) B5 3d o tr oa tdX s) o . 3 V)
?
njoX
-S o g€ o
o S : F crq Pr F) F.o o FJ PF
gq E- vrJ
Fil i' H.
o \ b
H)
HN o o Hf t ' 0l -ct o ? F. cl ni
o s) vl
; s o Eo I 3 3 e9
i' otr o 9l Fl iJ ts.
9r ;'ih 0) o) gd
o FE oq =o FwfD
F
oS 5 { 3 *
aa ? fD
o
s F cna v)€ o
tr 5 vt o) w rf o
r) v, s ER o (D Fe .(t) 5
gT o 8-[s
=.x fDFt i o o
o o
$ JD F I'
o v, vt o F€ o' qx *o
)|.(Fr
ES O) € 3 roSFr
T 3 o Ut
v, Hn .+- 9J o) g)
0) 69 p F) (a v, HV fHD f D
Fl JD a st
G a:+ o o=. 0) i' o c 0)F{
g) PE p oq qe X
o vt =. o 5 9) €F o
t p fD =r (D ut EB=
tJ. hl :r
o =t o
n 9l 5 o o ' + Fr 9r x'l gl
o f: ile € HrD (D
v\ 3 d6 er o crq
sT vor s s
tr F o
Fl
d
q o
FI rS. a d ^ko VrE
v) g o C'
o'
g)
nt n &€ q
nd :ij o vt F
JD svr gq o xE .EB c rD o- !r(a
F 5 :g S)
.Y
v, 5 5 9o o o
n o € o .o Vt Vt
*Hs
g)
gE €
ttt
Hd 9r rJH
o 5 ox tf-
o 8 F:
o .o a" :5 o Vt
o o F \<o
3n n
SE s ct c r { w e F' $
h I'
9^ s. K do gq oq
F o v) o i.8 g) o '. IvJt ,- 'r D
o E ' S 13 o .<
ga sFt sn ;'
s o "15 5
o 9) c d n g;E
Fl Fl
Fr (a r) f
vi 5 o 6P
6H (,)
s) o- s 9l o s g 0J v)
o fv D) HH
o Ou'g
v) s Fni V, Ft K O.
u)Jl. Ut E' p) n
3 c(1 N It )J
I',d F'
Ut F) v, o o
o o
NE Lt .Y
X
s. g s s) : 5 h!n
oa- F Fo=
o "p
E o o :5 f'! EH R€ =
o S. 5
s o,
{ 5 o *o O !-l
v, \0 ? FH
o
g o Ol or o srC. s. o
38$
E"s €E" a' 3i. !-(D (! I

209 How childrenlearnto n'l*an


210 H*w LanguageWCIrks *@ *Y*
**e*
ffi FaU
ffi rE
f3 k#
q**jt#
\*d
-*ry frg

gig gE ggl g ffi


\---#*J
&
*ili
; ii *
ql i
ss€ l
+[;gs
g+gigtg g; {cet}
5H+E r lfi E h**i*
g€g ; 1f rfi
e.5r lFeFiHHFFs; ro.
; sssbgggE€ []
; i siiseEnH eEg ***&
In
€ H E =c t:sfi AE e'Fr f Fgi;EFFE
;ffi.
g; i r aFFF$e LJ
**x
:g;f
i i FFeF' * ig ptr[iE
[*r'[=n*a a$r$EIi **"#
Pr, t
KLJ
1s rii IiE
lEBg IEEF t$[*gF x.
ffi\
6&d
i +E$sH$gE* Ht 3$i E$Fsg€s
qes q B a q a 3 $.Ee i 7 g I f g il ; H+ R rfr
A [igiq I sI + 'i li: 3g H*
r€Fy1H$*
EFg; Ht e:
=/rfi5d
3F g[ t.6 E'3
a esE[: t; i€F
= € Fs H
=c
+[sgElEE
+Hs*rrrEg€3;
: =o?:=??LAe ior=+= i /?=- =

5 ri 7t er
I 3i -a It r5
G it o it c Fl
N $ t Fh fD (? F o sJ
(D
a6 tE sE o o o.) H: g d
vtd fct tr
d H -(rt F v, o
o vt
v, p) 3 t s dP F u, o
E9 )8E d o 9r
n ta d o !?
o o Vt - vt o
€ o X p (tt € :J o'
JD o
OJ = s2, t 3H hl
!J
H n F) o f.l
w s€ 0) o F Ut 5 o nY o o o gq ts
f') hl o { fD o o
p u, oJ A)
3 E o o 3 v, t f) o \J E g v,
o 0)(D FI 15 o o o oq 9) o- ct
(D o I 5 ;.j. o ct r) 3 5" 3s 5 (D v, (.)
r) d o fD o o hl tr E
g) o o ga d o 0l
g6- { s {D s) o E hl f.)
o v) s n' o
f) d F r.l s
*u t8o s. r) r-t
o E o
a 5 pJ 6o.
"ES o * tld
o (D I n I oa
F. p { p F € o o 9J
o r) (to
Ol hl
s a.iq
g, O) o u, o o Ft El. o
fD d Fn hl o (a o
E x\ o
F 5
,r) gq o { g oo a fD o =
91 o E'7 I
lD (n
n. ts 5 o FdE 0) gJ O) {
€ @ € o 0r g) € s) o vt gr FJ FI
o o 6P { aq q o o FI r) s o U) o
=(D rD 5 sJ 9J o
(D fDH fD 5 5 s, o Fl
I 0J o o o v, E o n
qq5 p) Ut v, vt n rD ? sr rD s €
fD B S F 3 (D o v, o n t1 5
vro tsF o u, r) o o F -l LA o
o d tr v, o 0J 5 Ja S)
a I g o o o U) o o i
ta o € op F| hl Ut
S o F Ft o F o fD n g
= 8 gr $
o {0)
=' G sJ n F) S) g FJ 5
o F
(D 9! o 0q
FHs) n r-t n
g, irq F6 o oq o cr o o
!a Fl s o s) c p 3
o o o X o S) 16 o
9) FI r) {o |! o 5
u, F o
9) hl -F" 9r F) 9p. o) p cr
Hd U r) FJ flJ $ :J a Vt v,
cn q 7t
o crq 5 o
o g u= tr b o f)
F 5
gq ti' H o g o o
r) o V) o € g o s) o p) g o
qJ 5 F q ,g B. J^ u, tr n o t
{ I 5 It o p
qsr o sr Fl Eg g) o fo
5 g 6P o 0q g. 0) tr tD C' v)
tr Fl Ecf 5 Ut o o
o o F c) 5 F) o u, o
gt o 0.Y c) F) g F6 5 f) o
F g I o F !h vt € o
Fl
oq o Al+ 5' Fr € 5 oq F o T AE o o o E o
:< Oq u, o s) J,) ga Ut
o $) o 5 oq FI
'(t 5 ? o n
l-l
o v, r8 tr6 t.0 tr CI. o
gl 5'9 o F hl F o F)
o sJ o hl
KP) gl hl 5 o F
t') 5X. o Fr) o
F d ta JD 9)
a) o r) o 0l \J K
tn v, {ql F g N v, rq 'ct Vt o
r-l
r) €a s) o
3 ct o o
o o 3 o
fo Vt o. o n E) a
o t O) u, $) g, p)
r.l o6' Ft
fD g oa s) c n € hl
rD
AJ g) a
t-l X' o 5 I o 81 w
Ft o u, I tr 5 fD K o
o vt oro ; 5 v,
a1 s 5 H9 -(,l
o tr tr
r-t
r') o oo 5 o o
(,.^) o 9) 9) €
pJ o o
S)
ilt.) o s, 9) 5
F 8 '8 o tt o g o o iJ) -6{ iDt o o
o.A gq o g F, LN F 3 ttr Fl 5
gq
o
Ff)
trH tsl
so
€ Vt Fl -9 o hl o F ? ts
o o oq rD o OFf oq 0l
Fl 0) (a o o o 5 tr
n (D e. Fr s 9l tr o 5
3 o C' o tVt o fD 0) v, (D o0 9) T fD
Ut
SE ( D" Fo . ts vt
I
oI o o Vt
sV) ("0
F FI
s) o o s o ;' F.E o o

211 How dictionarieEwcrk


:_:--- -

212 How LanguageWorks

Ffl FJ n 0)
v, Fl
U a€
Xor o
L
X (,) lJr 0)
g: i E I
(t)=StY tr so (, Ff
BF g) =l) o v,
o Ho 6' -l
U o o 3.
lu. H) E o l-l
q1i iE:c€fri t F$i3 F rE € F
E
;3 n,=BF o so 8 l l ' *
U) K V)
{ EU o.Z E
l.i o o o v)
e.rfF3: I ge) o Vt gr o
'.O
;r'Dq
!cl
tt
g)
v\
g 6rD
)-t'
pg[;a:*r*[:ifH#EF: ;s v > 1
E +€ a \ ) r J
E'E -s:
Eo A. (? \5 \t 6r
it o x v, gE =o X
3H1snE' fD5 o 9) =b
;Ttr=Hi vto € 5 rJ =u) F.E
€ so
s) !-r fD
F.;F i H-':
5 E'A oq
[*u) 5 g F
qg e r.A'* x.s
g3
)o
o
€ 0)
v,
U oa
o o
rD d. )6p *r
0" o $ .
9J
fE$1[Fga€$lIg E 8 E.F H ) g

(') i'O 14. At


7fiFE&H
q'"'x'7sE fb5
oid

o €
f
o
0)
d
o XF
$ffls$[rEp]; F; r)
oN-3,,9
o (D 116
tr 5'' g
v,
g3 E Hi lE o
sJ
=- a5;0": o,H
v, Fi.
{
o X .o
g
(D 5 r o$
o6 EFE$F+F18 ; a$ €.Hss[ E.B 'g jF S J
-t gp \J Eb x crq i$ E"
Vt
Fb f D l
trE F rDn t{' o 5 qa li =5
=.qa-u'Hg i.i. Er q FJ sr 1[r*[s a +fi T a
$E K (D'O
so o e rE*s [1
=\< o o h
= G' E Z 5 E
.ul 5
i=.3Fp.5 F .o 9J
Vt tr5 ii;
igrtFEHs:HFgI 6+[Ea o.P.-Ff
oo o
ut o sro
!rH E HHle.a
7 =S H P il (.o'cJ Fl 0) s) o 5'$ .ffEH5esf;i5[3e
v, o (D
9J r-t E E H =p
A 1x 1+ R 8 F 5 tD = 5 Vril
xo
)* g. gq o o -F,l u,
E h i ' crDr C;+' o €
t7aEiT3
pr F H: a '5 -rrO
!'
o
5
s
pr
9J o
f!(
sa
+i$r$ 3+[ [t $+i e. H 5 FH.
Fr)oPn
vt
7
6'
il E 9.:
E o
E)
v) 38.
r)
= gx.! = u ttt,r i '
o
o
w
o
w
-v!

o
v, €
o o o
gaHgI3f€[*E$* Frg.H,H
3HH:r'E
s: EG *d t F
!J tr
(a v)
:+ o 9E B E s
o u, p)
tD o 0.
rD o
;fi
3; E- AI Hg
+* E' v) g Ft
Vt
garsdaEE
1a+E
f E= - -B i r . 7 , a
o
o n € v) #HgHg
1' = tf - '5 A
== =
*:: i-t=g ? E igi;+rgl1s9gF = ' =;.-
-EE=Z;====E==.

fD -l 6
- o s t n Fr
€ CD a; g
o llt d o o
s o
hl
gt I tD o 9J
o sr
g (tt E f.l FI FI 9Fd € ga F F' vt
F 7 0. E$ (D F.(Dtst o g.oq F Vl tA1 (' { F
r') a o Fl Fl -l r-t { o 5 g
fD 0J r) 5(D g o Ut
G
o p o € Vt
o 0. r) o SJ E e) 50 oq
o o o I $(.)
I E)
o H 5 Vt
F gts 5 r) E vtO
q qao€ ts oY
F] FJ 9) I oq o qa o. E
q) o g) o >)
Ef, 5
ig FT
5'hd v, g5 F .?J o 5Fl o" (D s
:s
v) 5 5 =. tsl 13 o =r .|1 oa r-t n
$. g) sr 9J o vt v, vt
G o I o Vt |t
:s U! o 5 p o g= V)
Eq I F) n' rJ g 0) -Eqoa \ <
5 u) OJ
s)
Fl !J rr o o t
-j @ ct o 5 F qE OJ (D 5 F u) 5 %
I ><
hl
; fD^ X o qq
gl 0.
o tr n
o € o p) .J
$?5 OJ
r-t oa (!
'o o h6 o a gi o (a Had o w E PO
o @ o F 9) o g) v, o
N 5 o d o 5r' { o F $
o
(r)
r 5 o 5'F qq ta
6.r.r s) s) n v, v, -l
(D s) o € 5s) (r' v, o 5 o Sl
r) r) o oq o % n A)
t1 .'rB o S) s S) v, pr
o a r) o v) 9. u) hl j-. 0) o 5 o
o5 H€ $ tr p"
co o
E o Ut v) v, o ,tj o g p) 5'= o
F ? o tD o fD 9r v) €
a o o r-t o x o €€ o g o
€ r) 0) g 0) F €F -qi X F€.9 s) a 5 ? F io o
o v) \J s FJ v,
o K (tt rJ o otD 5€ r) 5 tD ='-f, o o
= F K $) g EU' ?t, pl -l s) 0J (D Vt
o oa r+ tr o.o F ci H.€ o r) 5
5 D 0r HTO o F T5 u, o
t u, "ct 9) o f oq F) 3
G r) p o d o :qs € I' p5 o p E Fl
o o o (t { o Ffl !) o -u] \o o o
fD
o -l
;v )Fn vEt " F 3
9' o p o cr F oq 0r Ut T o v Cht o
F Ot n o c,q 3
oq g F E 5 hdg
F (,) $ g) g s) 5 o
n o o 5-8 s#=. s $ n 0) S) E' it o
o € o € qq u) vt Hi Vt E
F f)
to ; 5
{ 0l T 0) p n 5 $ d o oqrD
tt, o €fi1 E cra I s)
r) }I i' rD 5 oq otY o (D 0) rD o vt o f.)
o a" r5 frf; tsl ','E€ 'ii v, '.6 €3 o
P ? 9. a) N Vt
€ iJ
p o
oo o
d 5 g tr o U) o oro o n S)
q r-t
O. o
9) -l o r-l { n
l'Px n oF o
o qq a. o (Dn o € v, o c o r) E
Fl T o o;o Vt 9) g rD v ).Et D gq o F
") td {D E) (D p :rg € v, r-t q El
; o o g, o o u) ;
fD o FI H o Fi. 6 6-
Fr) th o o o r.O
F) 5 oFl'J F+o
.(/J s
0) Efig o. (D
o 5 (t vt s s) f') o U) u)
:r 3 =l) F +rD v, p Pl oq O) o s o
9J {
SJ F) (tt
g 0r 8N o fo o o
qt
o Vt 6'$ I :s F p { o
v, o 5 5or.i tr n Eq
qq 0. 9) F+l o $. {o tr o CT o v,
o fD s, CA oo r) g R F E tr
tsl
oa s) = n
Ut -i n D T l-l v Ff
H5 g)
o IJqq o 5 oq fD o
u, F) FJ(D o FI 0l { 5 v)
I trd X vt 9J o F Hg o E
n o o o Vt (D g.o
n € o g v, gq Vt fD
o r) ox r-l u, nF) l-t
g F) sJ 3 o Ff;f FJ (,) 0a $) v,
F o Ft Fl g) oq 2X € vt -. Fl 0) v, 0r
f.) € F T I A if 'o d r5
fD F) g) tD o o EH 5
s o o sr FI 5 FF il5 o o S) n o o
I
Vt $ u, u,I I (DoF
r) 8H o u, v, u, o V) ut Oq (,) nI

213 l"'l*wrJicticnariesr.v*rk
214 Haw Languag*Wcrks

Ut fDfr i+ t9 -l fd 0.
Fl n :, q)
o Fl 5 €
o ,.o ta 50 o rD o qF- o v,
o
ii 6 # r) rD oq
t qa T.H $ OJ 5 n
g
s f i rP
(-j
3 rD FI oFl rD F'oq v' 9) o 36'
oJ !-+. E;\J H; n @
t-5 E E o V'F o !5
o B= * 86 o
=o S) fe .
Tx gBl o. 6'P
o a (a = =€t t^\
is .F- H s<
o 8ss+H o gq gir5. tr H' 6- () ov, cr 6-E
B's O.(hOoP o X o H= o
Ft 5o. o
v1 y. + EE lr--PA n Ni. o o trH'
o tr r) oa F 33
rD 5'3 v) o 5fD o rD :.qq v, 5 og (Ds
T Ffl oa o E' o FflF)S 9) 9) t
-l o I5' Eb X. qB \J E' Eg'
(t) H
5 ' 6s^i -i F
gq 9J
to FJ v,
Frl d € a,9 o o il Er.
o r o s) F * cr a€ n r)9r v, r) vt 5o o
0r v, oq o o o s) IJF
g 6'= gq FT + 5' i+ 9)
xo e8€43 5'9 H -
H.
o o { q6
n Ut R.6 € E ldo o v, oq E
o E'6 o I.
FhrD
rd d xr) 6 s) $)
9) 5 (A
5s) o) H6 hl Ff F:b
o fD ='|i
F';81+ o
Ft
v, o rD 5 o o)Fl
e Fl (J
{ '8FbH' X TJ ;8 E 6' :i' 0) rP € ;+q
q) t o VrO o rD F
'lJ O.fD
xu, 5 bc.o o
Ft {D F vt o
E + H o oq r)
o rD a.Ja o
s)!tr v, 6 ia., F o i6- c oa Y' g. I., 3 o to
3 E do
t, 9) g = o
EE O, |ll'c'
v) o 9) (n '5 a. F)
IfFt sr Fl
6q tr d E E
5 it ct n o.6
)-r V, alo T !4\ Frl o
o o o (D (/tX 5 2oq o $u,
+ ld o o n =.n
X r8 + -ul oa oE Eg. r) f6 o uttr Ect
0l
#o l6' ' u,
Rsi -l H+ u, 53 o o+ (r D
tr oa o
< H cr 5r! u) plE' $'o
= ;; P X gd rD v1
::o "6 o Fb p) o v' u' er
gi (tt
8g .<tts
C L ! { gR o 5 d 6-
?) o r{: o o 5 r-+ o 6' 'dg
0) u, q Pr ga qE
tr!t s 6= n o !t ; a1
OFi r) F oi' 9r F 6 lJl o dF
Fb F'
o E'o o € o (/l X \=.
Fl |l,o rJ : 4 H H3
Y (D
;g €
o $oa 81 o 5 tt_lr E n s.g
9. Vt 5 8$) sl o 9a \o $) o Re)
pt o FI t-l gq
(a OO FFO F
FJ 5{ S. ci ?
sl 6g hl vt v) 9) (D
ox oq o TN O+r o p)
a o 1o a9 H 3 n
H .A 0)
oa F JD go Vt srO s) 98 \5 u) |-.
= € o HFt
o 5 sJ) 3
gJ v, F d+ v, 5 fD
iF FJ S) t\O I o tD n
9J Vt O s o5
0a g6 qs) I F+J a HE i1) o
o f,) gq tr OJ $x. tr
vta o tro
o vrx o o OO S) FJ v, w
o 7 9J o F ?,V FJ
a 5t+ €
o r) DE "5 l-l 3q o
0) o x'o v,
- = Fl ga (D d -q) o o
"dtr f) 9J to
o OO 0,
o oa 5'8 cr)
Xo) € e. { Xr:
G o ct 9. aJ
€ 0a r:' Y
-) .1 7 !.1 3E = :t:
= = :- 3?
I
; =

C
ID r{
= .-l 5 E
o T D |? ut
Fl
a r'l st
D =D
Fl
|D hr 5 -l
(D hl ]' E5' o G
ro s
.E =. 0. a-i = (D
€ vt ?a 5 d f'0
|! @ ga tD |D ?3 ts r. !a v, o o Vt
o
hl
o (o @ o I 3 .r H. I
(!
o 5 ? 3S FI FU &e h g gJ,J
o os 0)
v, 0. ru olo o ?s tq. fD
3 0) H.o ,-l o U) s)
v, o ot o tO F I 5Ft x s HtO r) I € n
o- (D € t 3 p ;b (D rD N p) 5.O s (D cr o p)
9J E) qq JD o { o. Fb cr-l U K or- JD o o r-t
v, oa $F{ o F FJ o 9r o
f) *' 3E hl 3
g Vt s 16 ;i Ja
o o oo .E 3 u, o
fD s) o N
SB 6{ o
lJ A
o
zo
tr o ts L.l o w@ n o ;ct € E H
o f)
UI o oa 3 e$ o" o FJ
o fD o o SJ oq o
o 0" o
(a F z+ 5 EF
H5 p o o \0 v, s {I o o o
Fl
OJ 0. lD
o rD F (, F o r) b- 6' F n
vt vt r) o F o 9J o (, o * ;s 9J
o)o w 0) o
FJ o i^i r{: \o s € v,
Sl 0) v,
s.E o o 6 o 9J
0. 3 r: Ut
'oc) o o F ; l.tl o q (T *4. K (t g F
o o o o € to F -vl gq F:* OF. 5
fD H8. I $) sl (a oq
X l* 0J o o o o € o At)
o n 5p pJ s
F () 5 !J F g) 6F: 0) Fi) \J € 5i. Ft o
3 v, C' qq S) € p, o 3 2f a" o Fl 5 o
9) tao 9J tr s) u, 9) o oa e Fl
tD g) t o F o s Vt OJ ,-t p o€ v, o tr
€ op f.) o E tl) FJ Ut
o. F) o 9l
gt !
o
0)
r-t 5 C'
fD go) F F
Ja
F
xa
gro 5 (o g) tr O) t)
n
{
l.tl 5
o
p"
4 r') 0) oq o o v, g. o o p o
4 o n
!.1
€ o t 33
vr7 o 6 qq
N g o o i F ER I \o F A. rJ P
tr tr I o
o I () u, o $) S) o5' o ? 5
0) s) @ fo o ; F E I
(t) 9J E2 s d O
o o (n v, p T 'o E3 b 0) o)
o P) n o o o' tr c' 8F o o
r-t s o A
-(/, 3 F v, oi € Ot o tr8 tJ') o !J
f -(, g 0) c o 5Fr
f) o E € o *€ oq F o € o o Y b C' o s
v, qq V) o5 o r-l g)
o t .) s 6 - !J o v, EH (,) F) p o
n (D v) o € rD
o F o o I o5 € o o o o 5@
so 3 n 3 tr
F F g o 0) (t str o u, o (a S)
X 0l E s X o= U) F oN hl o
5 oq I' ;E p o vt .o 9) \t
o' 9r cl n gt o t H.@ o r-t o
F oa o v,
"6
o tr6 0) s n {D FI
o E
'o o tsl
p 9J ,t V) F 5 s) (D o 9r o o
o qa o n { tt p s 11
= o =Fl FJ g rF FJ E 8 5 p)
El) JD vt qa o T fD o Vt f? 5 v, t5 ltt F o
u, o) n !' 5 n ;o o E o o rD v, u) Eq o" €
E 0l n I Fl 5 F O o 5 0l
0. n s) (D 6' Fn o FI J 0a o vr. o qa O)
g a d o -l o O @ :s
o, I o o v, r) qa p o 5 Fl
s E
:s o P5 F) o .X ts)fD o F
r') P. vt v, F gJ 6's v, 0J 0) I
€g *j 5 o ro 5d v) o (a v) Vt o U) oo s v,
v, Vt v, ts' o s ) I ' o FJ
o 9) o r) F o g f'l vt D 91 9)
s ts oa v,
(D C' € f') 9E o F
fs r'f ;
o tD o 9J o S) o 0r
Fl
E lJl 3 s $)
FT fD 9. oJ' 5
t no :ss
Ft) oa 9) t, v, o A. i.a E (Dht $) o
o F I g)
&g Ut s n .o o 5 g. r)
; 'o 5 5 ta E 0) o "9 H 50 (D o
5 50 g) H' 5'5 $ o 0a N
s o 5 gq t .) o o rrO ; r.l s.tr 0) s) w
F{ Fl
f FJ !', t f v!
.N5 F o o o :r 5 o Vt
o (D o |D o I
o I
U 5 o g. o. (D o
o I
E3 o PE. o o. o

215 How dicti*narieswork


How LanguageWorks

1c' tr
{6' v\ 9F 5T
9o o fD
FF F + ooq Io
tr
o X F p
H: nt r) fr#f i : i
o
a\. v, 0) x
q's o .H
9J S"1,F' E
o I fror !L$
F)o) OFt
F
tt {
I Ef. o po
= .o FJ HE
r)H p rD3 0qs
p g
*er n UE' EF
v, o
_F. O" tD o
urJ o 5 d€
r)
tE g.fD
fD E
F Hr: o X 9r,
(D -,sJ
u, o ?
(n t F$ OJ-,
gq Fr
C' oo
t 3
tr -vO

o 9
pr E Fh{
."< 5 5F.
r{ f) H€ q. !t
o n o
g 5O
X sqE
rJ o
ro s) Fi
o
gq (D 3 : E oF)?
hl s o 50
FJ a) 9)5
,.O n gs sr Df ia -
5 oE.
5 o
7r o vr5
€8.
? qq
FJ Ff Oq 9 8
Ut *l op) O.
V, Fr
T o o) E 'o Ft F)
o o o (D0)
tD
E
3 d
Vt
|'+ gs g)
3E fDv,
F 9)
tr
v) Hg
V) :ry qH'
o Ut Xo rDr
o
o a{
= =- 4 == =
ta-

T E
!' Fl € F ll 'ct
g ht =it ID
= ar Cf lD v, o
F
a (D 3 o x gJ 9' p
.ct Fa 6< H) o t.) +
Fl (D o (D o S l, f.) 5 (D -f, t6 Fl
Fr€ s, o5 o (D F
a €
o
-o 9'
5 t) fc,
ae -vJ FJ (D It
Ut g Fl
x9) 6 r .g. p) o sJ F
o tD s 9r 6"# g) o p g
v, g 5 d F)
rt) 5 n ox Fl
-d qq 39. o v, v, u, *T*
0) tD *# ? .l- o rr (D
G Ftr 9 r-i z< o OJ o v,
o. JD ?j t)
F) 'o o o
(D t? F S" x' o **&*
Fl E' 9) oa {
fD t H
Ft€
' o E p o d
r) v, 9) cn5 JD \t o B't p ga tr
o o cia u) s) € fr
g F (D fr*
a t
a. 9)
t r o v, rtI o d F t O E 6
hl. 6. u, g. 0) o F w
o s u, s| g F + n l-t 9)
o'i' r-t o
v, o 5 !r€ o (D hl
(t, -o (.) o o fD
o o a o Ut F H8 { g o "e#
0l l.t trtr fo EFb o 0" 0)
t6! FJ
r5 -ouHl .
v, 5 9J o o It 3 o F o @#
f) FI gl o 3 0,
FI EgJ X q c, € 9) o
5 9J oF p { FJ0' 6' S)
gB V5 €
(1
TH. , * F 5 v, fDFt E { o o
t) o 0) o 3
Fd Oht o
(t 5 or 3. E o 5 I o 0J --rc
5 oq JD o9r ctQ ga I $E d F
cs$#
(-J o O. ol I r) o gq 5FJ g o
Ft hl
F g)
5 H -o Vt F
9l v, E+. o o o E= o & u
vt oq ?a X r-t n pr tt I
E-S o U) 9) oo. o o E F ,"bLJ
(! o vr n F F F Fl
€Fd -o u, r) o
o tr o Fl
ttt) 7
v, Er rD *T
(0 (D Ut crq H! F crq 3o 6H 5 5 E
tsl r) r) F)
o 0) +F o o € H6 g) o v, o Fl r) --q
a F u (t 5 g€ o o
o, H 6: o
t-l (D
to E's \5 Vt Eo 3 o 'ct
|a n rJ fD Eo 9 |D. ***t
S) T' og 0) (.) so dR g FI tr
rd H(D
5 r) d
o w 0) p) rJ o
s o5 Vt 1J n rn
ta 3: _€ o Fl o o Vt
1&d
S) 5 q 0) 3 5 ?
(! o 9) (D '9oJ xr : tD
a v, rF o e)
3H F $) r5 o $ fr
Ff n Fl F.t \dt
tt, o 0) F)qi o € 5
o o gq $J N tn o pr qa
a o 3 oa s \ -6t . ) !r. (D F RV o ga
tr t< oJ E F
o $ sl \'(D
g o d g'o F g hl rD s ed
5 N s 11
0) n 6.€ o o \5 o
hl sl Er p
o o o.o r) F) v, r) f)
Fl 9r 0J N
so o
v, qq Es s+ o
n E{ s s FE o (D 5 3 L#
V) o 9) tD E o H?. p r) (! 3 F
o o F 9) A
p E3: g ea o F fD oo. (a- ht g
F cA
o s o Ft
3
F.5 v, S S g"E o s) H
' i li D o o o (? \*#
v, o I'0q I f) H: o 5 Ft) F Ut
F
re
__fu
wgffil

217 How nameswork


How LanguageWorks

g
w
r: t, gFiHHS
EqHi#3$fi Rs o d Hil9ssHEg si
tJ) F
u,
g tr x = E ?
c E'E'€e€F5.Ffi€ u, *Ee-iFE
rEEI30.O
IJ
o
E€FRfg$r5i+ o 5
o
H
0) HL.BELig+BrF
t [$:$FFag#i3
$**HT d 3 Ff { [E'F
J
o o
0a F
(- cJ 5 f x'H
AT
gJ
9)
r Fi u s'H
ta
a
a
$il;iFEgnfiH 9l tr
H&6[is
=Ets€gHgFEu o o F"srn.gi
-
A ! F Vt
i
F
o
t-

a
F
* Es g HeE n: € f
=4$;irlFiil$ 5

o
C'
0)
3
HH
*sE8H3
H ='='
1E T
sr 6'=
Iggrrgili
gq
-1 o F
;6 d,r E o i*EiIEEE;*F
-vrt'=.-rF
- €3ExEt?*igg g o
g
H6a3F+ETEF
o v,
-E3 H E g t F 6 Hq
-i
1Z iE E
A E
E
; E
H 5 € ;ge$ i; id=c9' ."; 9 5
! 3 E= F * + E o
F
i'$H
:B.re {a 6 HiH E: id €
r) n
o
E X EE
&:E fF o€ E
istlfgEqs F
i a'r T fr g f $ g
6 ?E v,
g
3 E'5-;A+B
to
i3.HA$€.tiF 3
H $.
ol
P 3 ,.' :i er-E [ 6' ^E n 3 r) 9J
Ft
-
-l 5
E3Ba; i"e$= S
5 qq
3 0)
a o) il s 3nHI Et s s
sBgi 3Eir tsq 3 $I€s38 p
t-t o
A
: ffi=€# v) gq
F
FEi3l;iqgsE
s$;[$sr$iuH o
r.)
g
F)
iC H ! fi #
o n oq x r ; F J g * 6
g rD
li
5 .ul
frra[$i;Bi3
+l i:H"HFF
F! l:.1g)
v
TpE:Tif;F,y; 0)
v, T=OLt,F, cfrTgsgEr
a
E = E = -"s-
g E € B- 2. =i E rD 5 +F 3-
I .{ : -; aE : =
-o = 5q=: -
3.:EI;' iEE :5
= = =;? G-?F - !: = 5.==F e = ; z; =: ; = i

o
{ r{ 7
ct- I
rrlrl h. ..P
o o u 6 at, vl
i *O rD I- SI rD o 3. !t r) g ga
hl
g, a an I! o
qq o 3 a = +r FO.
E
trL
Ahl
l(D hl tD v s)
-<. A) rg 9) s n ix(! g
o tD o T Sr 3 o D g) s
3 oa f: F) FX
= Y 3 o
HAE
d6'o)
ir+ vt i{ t.] rD
E dH E
t\
H;
S'
(/: oF a- 5 f6
Fl
fD 3$
vt 0)
oq oF
SK n
oa oa o
X v, .D ut
69. = 0. (!
t S - I on
I
€ E;H v,
5 s)
qq ta r) o hr o F 9)
I' (?
p s. g $r
(! tr
3 o tD uo)=( ' o
o o 9" rD A) Vt fD X 3
clQ 4 9l A) o F 5 -(/l t-t o 0)
+ E q ' Ig' dF
o o
rJ) 3 -. Ei. o I ots 5 ga u, o Vt v,
o s) \.N v,g) Vt v) R-6 !?
tt p) c) g o w
JD ox 0a s o. +n' (t' ta oq o)F{
o g)
n 5gr o 5 5 9r n SJ 71 F
g (A 3 r) s
H q , >!r S o oq 5 q
c (tt 9) rD H7, llYb F '\ o it o o g o #n ;J F
(D H gq S' fo fD VE
o EE J
-d :5
s F o 0r 5 (a vt 0)O o cvt
0. o B ? € N v, v,
H ) F t
I5 0 )
a (A s. € o € H F Ysr Vt
0) o F!(D!r g s, fb Vt tr I :5
o €1 I. 0) o o 9)
rD lt 0) 5 s v, o ='F o 0)
0J nr s n s o V) Vt
(^J ga V) Fl' I or E 3
5 $;7 o FrJ o F FJ
o
sX (D r'g 6H v, ;
o (n rD l! n rfifD L
Hv) u, n
E 6-9 o o 'tr
v, o o s vt tD
oq 9 S vt ro o V) sg o)E,. o gr
@ E 9r=' o V) o cra
'v) p 5 \s g no.
V' 9) I FJ $t o o 9J o 5-
EE o % rt)
hl
I fd
8 6qq- o () o tsl .(,J r5
5 FI t o Ovt (
Fl d h H z F o qq are 5
ra v, F
to E
o SJtao (1 oO s'q Vt o, !!3 v)
o F F OJ g o o
-(a o o 0)' o oq o v) o v) o €s vt o
r} s 5 (D X G (E^.op ts g Hd po F F
o \ tr sm+ ito
tr o f
I rij o (D I d (D
to € rrt o o
o o (a 3 (a vt Vt vr ih l0' )r r €
,* n 5 A) os sa. o c rrl -vt' t ,td
o o p 0 Y
o Fl cr C' ^r o o OH I
o
€ d p R SH .D r+ (D t o o 0l c F tr
FU v, ttt 50 E= 0)
o \ .(ti BX' a3 v) a)
0r >8 JD vt F F rD F o v, =rD o
o I

g
s 5 .ro 6i s !? g TJ qq Ha.
.) v) rt t ,f o FJ V) o € f)
ct
o sE I 0J X v) r! c ta 5 o o
o () 7s" hl
o t 33 o"
gl
o F E) o o &8" o ><
o g TqE o rD .D o 5o 0Oq $F
SFh
5 F 0) 5 I'5' vt o
X o _c/J 5 5 G
gq € \J F qq F
SJ
F d F i gq I
Hv, E o
o o \5 o rD Jo o n o o ga^ F F 9*a F
rD 0) E'q pJ
JD E ; o €
3 v, 5;fi r! n € F l
Ja o oHF El o t{ FJ
-o o 3 FJ ts'Er-l
S) (t TA
T 3 r d O t-r:
v, o A)' o= vt S) c) F fD s 3
a U] OSFi' o oo s v) rD 5 9 , 9)
o c 0J AJ
s 9) S,. JD n o 5 5 v)
v) f) o Hl,/, rrO v, o 5s)
v, 5 F -u, 't 9J Orn cra
;"8 to 0)y 5 n 5
l- ( u) gl
v)
o Fta s.
s o
o F{
8q ? o Ff s
o 0) 5 rD S) F) ts
v, 6r?H',
F A o 9) o el s (/l TJ o rrl rji' n5 o E 5
5 o t) Fr Ll
v) 6 R \J 'g p 9) t6 Vt Oio o
oo C' @ n oq 50 9)
o t-l^ ilr:l- o rD oq 9H t_l Fl
Fl o
o F fa o 6-+
s o 0l rD u, 62 F.: !t Fl o n
3 ! p FJ s) qq5
w s. t,
v, ga Ur. Fl
q6 s, F
o I V) kB 5 I vt 5.r s|. E I o v, V) Vt hl d

219 How nameswork


220 l{ow LanguageWorks

EiEiIEEEiigEiigss
o l} s, €
r+ :l o
'sE3 p (} -f of) X it n F|
|D p) c)
o vt Y Vrg (D
G-g H: 5 o g) rD t-l
1-l 9J
d E;+o , u, fD o g) trt
)'l 5 Fli 3 3 'H 3
B dd" € \i r cr 5
ra F) 5f,) E E E.E o =
JD 6. gEsgg o G' 6 o
s Y t o a 8 o Ut
o d IH tr tix JD 5 € o.) o
gE 0) *8 s o oVt htO lnl
r)
o
C vt E.8 S) o o
o roH ts. I F F] ct o 3 n
v,
s. ?. :;.i$ 6v, o
Vt o ctq F H o Fh o
R. d6' 0) 9[ o 5 3,d id o E rD 9) p
gr 5 ts v) v, C' F{ t o ( u,
H L.
o io r.d .1 9)
i- =n
iF3$s €
g
g v,
fDu,
5 0)
cna r o
w 0)n SJ
oq o
v, !-t S) * EO rt o
o v) z €5 9) c) F fD F o tD
f)
9
a5
8
5n
giiaE E
vt o o *s
*F 0r
g
o a
+JfD
o
5
g)
F
o
o EE"
s) o
F EE
u,
o
o fD
5
pJ
o s F oY 3 Fl n o
JD SHIeH o fD $ F 9r a o o
ra o o
S.
!a 9) S 3tr o € !a =q \t
v, g f: o 3 o o rd Fl 0)
I I =slr ,Fl o o D rD rDvt Fl
(D Y o=F n r.X p n
(a o o
qE €6 v, o r-) n
gE9SH K s) d (D v) oc o o o rl, !.{ F,I V)
(a \t g r-,t v, o 0ro
gd;HIlr (D 5 .(ti o fl v) o
Ft g) c c! :U a. g o
vt ES Vt
SB s) 5 J r -v) F
o o0. s 5 o 5 'g v)
zv, o tr o 5 go t-l
v, H. o
s 16o sf)
aoa lO o s" u, F) (D u) rd hl o o
H.S$"F tr5 so rD
RP
tl! >a'
0. o Rs E) IA s ut ox s 3 E lrt
! g a o
)-l s) vt 9.H 5 o o rD(o
(/) n u, tr9 q gq ct J 'o5 g IJ E
o gq
ut o gp s n *Fv, 9)
;o
i!
gJ o o U, i.+ F
8S w o o? qa t
- F . ?+ o 3 (n o o -o o fD Vt
pl. 5 d
siF
- F
:J
r$$fi vrif
o ?
o
FE
F
tri
Bin
o td
o
X
v,
6tH ht
U)-
)5:
!'+ O) F E
Vt
F
n I
rn
.(/J F &B FJ t F
Ft I'i+ Fl
7!i o o o .oo) 0) o rD rd(?
Aor p o -i. A. - ,f v, F ;g 5
E$+i f)
;F:t f D to 5 U) fD f') It
9) 5 n ,1d X5 s ,<
-9 o. n o o t-l rD g s
c qq g) 0r gq pl :"o (D
c/r n o o F E' qq o FB n € JD -l RZ Ft
5 FJ
5
gq
sI' t $;H o 5 o F idq o 0)
Ut e6
o CT 8c w c
oa o o 3 { 7{ o totr HE o tr {
sri gr oo 9l o
E5'$$ (D S) o 5 F E6 v, ? FI
E X g s) ; €
'^iv)
er tC' o EE *l p
a s.s o' a o )u' 5 Ots o tr
|-l SJ
E'3 o SJ i$ F rD o p fD
Nro o 0r v) u, F) o n sE o o
as E o FI V)
€ o:. fD o Fr: X -t, (D o 0.
(? -sr 6 E
$qq
ot
€ 3c $)
g :r g o
,aU >U d 9 , sr sFt u,
}g o o ont r!
q.q € c 5n o rl o
ad 9J X' sr o o ss. Ig H 16 o cr
o
o w
HS r) tt) o
.(t, i' o x v)
o s q9 u) o
a-+. * Eg NF Ffi o

221 H*lv nanresw*rk


222 f{i:w L*rrgr.rag*W*rks

gggggggg grrirl*gg ggls$Esrsg$ sHEFFigs;*c


i Fg*u[Eg[=nr I fiIFFq; r EEf$*$$f5$
rEEsFtgE
rEslr$g${f$ EEHEgI
=u€;i isg$€51**$fri EraF$
g rli$r $
gig $
EiEE$ggii$$ i€F IE$
$F€ $6$gFgF
FI
i|g FEnsr n*: i [* $r *s-F
gH 1- gE$$s J^5

iEF
$ PgFg I
fFli$FEE €s' 3* tF' F
$r $F eE g
igtIggEFIgEI9ggiEE
R*3+$ i; F

ga
(D
ggs
o 0)
?
o H#S
H N
I r^) )|.l6
o $5*
o
f.t
A
\rt
(D H.E 3
(/txal
o65'
oq o 5 R oq
o FF >!
tL
.)
o o
k - H .

ooil
FJ
V) Sctq'
-l
gq Fo q
H.

rD rD iihtFt
0) n|
o
5 o.
u, 0.5
o
so 5E
F{ td Fl
V) H.

5 o o)r)n
o g vtoSJ
o g'
Vt 0r
oq \J gJ
o 9r
ts a#
o'-t=
€ n €
u, o
o
H.v,0
g) Ut
5 9) v)
H. _.
a,
sEa
o ga a.gl
U)
o I
g .E v
o
o s) fD Ei s
X a.
15 o Bg F'
o o o' 50>'
9)
tr atq -cr: e
p
o 9r FE{
5 o
r-t
o t) F 3*3
9) 5
F) gH
(a vH
E'
! o o j;'{
pJ d
n F
o 0J BSe,
223 l{cw nan:eswcrk

\_
How LanguageW*rks *-T'*
ffi**ry **J*
fl\
HI$HH'f Ti I Hf E*H,gEE#eF #% \*d ts-#
UJ #d
-d
+g$FH F'g+:fi9*$Hsfl d# ffi
d@ \e
iia o es
iE€ + 7,rilg = = €.6iFE l.38
-
ge,fiEFHsE oa n: i1**:sitE Lfr d#

ffi.
' B
{ i
E*3*$aEf;
T6
Y o r d E!x.6*;
+t:Ia*F'$Fr
s \#
.4rt,+rh
a l
i;$F+H$?;EI gT
ns$rEig
i=#=xE$E3 fT tEr
.b&"d
I
6=': f€is+ftEits f**ry
\*J
?E*[.lr*E
=F;[$F$E tiH+E€**;iq ry
M
s
: r
==5grF:E gt3+g[;;FHo
i1q*r$r€ii+ tu
=rZHHdt€ {il:H'Bl:IFqc'
=SggiEA: ;s;iEEEr+3
e,E+E"EFtF sirIsgFE$H q
=Ffls'=E{q
aii;;E!BH *sB;S;?3 i
SrBF&Eg g [i;;g.FEEE.3
FFgS*HhH;Fi
i a.qf, a = g$,E,ggFnEi=
+x=* 6s=i.="-F,F"
e f FEE 3
i*r*IHE€_e He p aE[ + 3 il fr
't 5 r ii r E d FgFfEf ;,mfg
{ !a ; d iq F.o rE
=,_? H
:- ? =g= ' fo € = F' = + H
S=':€*i
; q H ;F,,F
€t i?
#
=-

Ft
{ hf F}
F
:t s ,,El :t x{ w fD 5 :s- v, Ft r{ 9)
|l |a la ii =. o s F Vt F
FI r-l ctt o
F'6 d H:
s,. E tr) oq
I'D |! |D to v, Fl tr s
h FO qq o s
o ga-
sgIt
_vl (? 5 +- o€g g o H' tr u,
d S)
o s Ti i 58 € f.)
r) I d
sfD s ; O. o
€ (r:
o K F s o (.) FJ =.€ gq
+ v,G t t.0 o s) $ zt 'dg o t-l 0) fD o
o H) sl r-t 0) o 5
s5 u' 8
t
v, o r-b
; t" n vt
trr C' g 8q o
o. -(t' F oF p o ov, o s g
o () !)r< .xs
O) oa J^ o E gq o ta
sv) o (D
s) F g) s n
g P .s s o o
5 F
5 gq or I 0a 0) X n,* ts
@ (D o Vt E Phl 9) ts, FT s) s) F)
Ut r-{ { o 0) O. 9) (D v, p N FI + () p
t j Fd .s gq (Doq
Lo =.8 vt g, p) 5. K o o dH
It
-l Vt o (D o F' S. {Do
ga g) o :s 69 s" {A JD tr o o E .) 0r r)
rD qa 9) g s ;s F ts o H: o
o .) o €o .9 v, Fb s o tr F o
C' ,-. Vt o Fl oq X(o
?tt il (A ro 5 0) ao
Fl C' t" ct) oq
rrt tt7 o o 5g o s o fD
g) p s o p b' o -fD o w ^r g) o v, BH gq
Fl o . ( o €o p og crq v, + + tr ,t)
o oa \5 tr \ o tr .o tr tr R ; F o 3 , s €o (1 ,\i E
TO I € tn q)
:s F) o E" 9J
tr0) tr tD Vt P F) ?
v, o € o 0) o o=
5 -l F r.* Ct I Fs oq
(D
o qq z =F sis I
o s(0 p o o |ri g r)
hl
g Ft= trt
0l o'o qq u, s S s vt Ja Fl Vt F
o (? .s + F = T1) s) 3F c} :J p o (D nH'
o Or{ r-t pl Fb ta s J^ r) 0) oa
3 fD ;t, r) F 50 v, o (D n cLZ 0) s 0) o N v, € o
(D 0l (D o g $) 5fD vt
F |\ g) n Ur 9) hr F F tsl o
o 9) T 5 Rd
|4.
7c' z s 9) 5
0J F fD 0) F { o 3 d s.
Vt (D o Vt
5 cnq p =E (t) 5 s* r-f
s) ga (o vt frl VrS
f.)
5 X :s lo o o hl
s 9
o o F Ut s o o F o H.fD
0) "+ .h € a -(/j gt qq o gF) v) ; oq 9l
0l 5 tr \J .'r€ € 6P o s
tsl
o F5 v,
v, F) vr) 5 o) tr Fl
t ga F v! o n gJ
5 o o 5 p s) o U) 5,.8
d o F) Bg
u) )J #€ 0q
r) ov) s o F v) 5 F
o n V) Ft o rD5 o gCI =' F)
;p
o o oq F) (D s (!: Frl -", v) d
ts o ?
+tEr s o5 P
5 5 F 3F' 0) o o t-r Fl F t-t Q s F ot
s oJ rD sJ a'q *l -l s Fl 0)
F od o 0) 5 Fi' 0) b4 oa
:J F o 9) q. 6 o Fb Vt
E, (! FP p) Ftr g o 5 o
Vt K v, s o' F S + ao o o v, Fb
s. o O. o v, gs d
7f FI 9J F X N
s q6 (D g) o
s ts
t" sJ (D 0] o Ll(D 5 ; o s t?
{o
Fl
5 o K 9)
p Vt
0l
t,F F o n H|..t 0) 9J
hl s H s
o ; 5gq
sqc F
I g H"O ts GP P o fD o F v, FJ
u, ts € o \Js s o E s, p)
:J F) g 6H h 9t p EE s) s o r)
LA s o *6 I Fh S.
o
FO JD o gq 8
5 LS 5a} rgt tr o iro f1 0a
s s nr s trr o ct 9)
rt :s rd gr I 0) oq
Fl g) 7t o o n
a
t-l o € (a o E Fl o q
s-| .b F o F) Es fD|< Frt o F.
sJ fr $F' F
s H ;J cio o Fl OJ 5 H 9) acj
+ 9J F s
O. F|' g) F $ s F F F p) €H
hr V) 3 Fl qq oq g
!a
>sr g) 0. o
hl
FE g) v, v, 1C' gl
s t, r-l E s 5 !-+ rD t
€ s V) Hg r:
a s8 o v, o s s oq v)
p 5v, n
;J \J St- € u, F 0)
o E) g.L s F sqt v, Vt \5
s) o
oq crq o
o U) o o oE'
b tr
ri F S) O. \5' O' op v, dv' fd o F FJ
la)
(D g Ff-
s r) g) P las € ; vt o o 0) F
s)
t6- n yo (! o s9 o o E .H F) E s o s o g g 0) oq 6 o
S 5 3' rJl FT: vtrD p I FT: v, I
fD )-l
g r- Fl
0) + oo

225 How v*cahulary grcws


226 H*w LanguagcWork:

s d
d F} t'ct lrt
I ir s p = CD -l o
fD (D rl fD d o X'u' 9 6- bvt zt
E sE
€ Qrt o
Fl
q9. (D f? p so F) .t (D 3 ''
o o u, il g. S) ; € FI
'in', sc a( OD wg)
s) o
trr H' |a
sr5 9)
o (,:
OJ n tsl tr O. \J
CN
+ LSS H o v, g Gf o {+r
3 tD o hl
o ga 5 fo $) d
€ fD
Vt
o
t6
E 3 so
v, E o
Ff: o
343fr o
S . H .s. o I Fl o o
$ .P
= ' 3F? \J
hl
o
o : 6 to
tD f6 SF. o o o
o o F hd A)
= fD vt
o EfFH stp F N o xo
o o trt F o v)
3 d ht I 5 n v)
o E e t;' ( tr Ov, o o 58
Fl 9) o rD o v, \ n $ tD
v, g) o N rDFt o F :JO v, v)
htrD 5 SJ ta t- o o u, tDct
9) u, g) v, ?*81 .s., E Sl R'* n
Vt o d o= 3 :3 ,d o = SJF = o o E 3 -g 0) Ho
K
-5
o g)
E r) 9) vt F o o o FE' 5 (D
NH
:-tD o o (D = EP 5 o r) tD o
o J g) C' 5
9) o (n F) O' C'
p gq '-fD
e.€ s o 50 sl"
OJ a) If v, V5 o o"5 o o
5 (DJ o (D (,) o Fl r)
Y
o
tt) Frl s
t)
o
FI ct
o
o
v,
*tiH EP
:5
\J

o
tst
o

tr
F
CA
o
Vt
0J
IA
o
:s
x 5' I
o7t
o p n ;rEI q* o 5 o xo
o q9 o o oa a o r g) o go o SE o r! g)
5 o 0r g o Ut o F
s (n C:r $5 o' I
t* il l'(D
0) (.) vt - q o F o \s f.) s :
p o vt tA o 's o o \J. €
:s r< d o 9) - Zoq
Ut I s5.=D to
0,
n € E P o
o F)
F
v,
o
$[iF r: F, 5o
O.x
{ 3
FJ C:r v,
vt d o9
rt! o
JD€
OJ n tl |D rD (D s. 5 5 r_l $O
F o o F 't F
r 5) FI o g) v, ga
vt rD
$BEA wrD
g ., FI n d o F s a 5$
(D F 9) Ov,
o (D hl v,
o R =. o BT :J
$J q aH. F rl o 0) o (-} c c r
fD
a oa59r X
V) o \> o) Vt Vt o s I
!D hl
x.5 Ut o6
o
X
g) o :-€ o
4
o u,
p)
r [:: (.)
o
v,
!'+ o g
C' o
u,
o a' e"
F g o r) *E F s s b v,
' <=r .) g, g >u 5 eo s
d 3
'lJ o v, F o -;r ' rFaHS = u, o :s tD s v)
o X o 9.r o 5 T tao S. s,, s (a N,B
hl *gE H S o
JD Ri $) { o o r) o s o 5
-o( , )g RE.
;s Fl tD H f I \s sr 3 5 it
(a Vt o p s' 6' o \J d out o o $0q
o 5 v, t Vt
o o o o 6' F,, o E:HE wd n (,) oo S)
FJ
X v, s 0l Fr
:5 d -= E o v, o E E ga :t
o (D Ut v) Fl
cr n
a
g F ci5
? o o o 9J 5 (r: !)
hl
ro 0r r ta O
5 o o f3F +R. s" o F F tr o.
E) q3
€ ta (D 0q Ho K g + rD g cr 5 D
9J (D { €. F @
Vt r! o o (Dg fo o t/r I Bly', o JtF
ra rD o t-) n
Bo FJ
s V) o F r) tD r-f 5 0) o Ci F. u, 9)
o no o o u, :!r Ut 9
ro o Y3 9J oq
3.H"ilvs. Vt o n F rSo .
t(t, V) o S rr. 0) v, ct €
gl J il F o Fl
#1s. 9) d2 d
o) th o $ o 0) F) o 5 u, € o
p o ht hl 9) o5 H s n (D s.5
g N Fl o o H 86. F
o I Ut P oo FI f o b T' crq o tD Vt o 5 F9 5 8q
227 H*w vocabularygrows
228 H a w L a n g u a g eW o r k s

igiiEElEEEEEiEg
igBEE
EE$gEF
tE
tl F
|'
hl ri
t'D
v, t? hl
I o o Hl gq F r) o F o
oq o .d FJ r.E
'ttX (D F u, F o o
ct i' Ut ., o l-l FJ o ts
tr 3 (!
i(D
(D d tD tD t) (? d o (D rD v,
JD v, FI s) (D 5 vt o
o th F E 9) u,
U) @ p pJ o gq r,O (D
5 o !J 3 v, 0) nl o s E 3 s)
r-t
o' g 5 o 3 5 n o € 15 0) o
n il' o E oq r-l V) o
9) E qq 5 o
F+)
9) 3
E rD rJ
E K
p) s+ oq F o o 3 o o sJ K K s)
5 o $ n
o gi o o E o 9)
o € v, F o o V) ga o € 5 0) 5 rj
v, vt o ct o
o o o o n F El sr €g 1(J { SJ F o o V)
o
f) u, I
H d tr too gq x o € o
0) s) o FJ r-t I 3
o w Fl p) $) E arq
0q o Fl o € o E o' Fl tc. 9)
sUt Fl o $ Fl
o S) g o 9l o 0. o o (t, o o 5 5 () o F
F !.1
so o
p) o o o o >r: o o .(/r
() n P s F O. {Fl { @ \J Fl 5
t6 u, 9r v, o o € €
9J
OJ o (D o o o F p "d o (D o
S) c(a 5 o o K o
CI'
5 o (D € Ft (D r-t o vt
g)
o
(: o o"
o qq o p cVt o 5 ,f q s)
(a s) v, rD oq
o € E V) g
ga tD f.) crcl o o 0) 5 o 5
v) g o 5 S $) ut F
o v, 3 o o v) 5 o
n g q Fl
q rd tD' o gJ' o (D o g)
p oq oq { E I' Ut
ao
C' 5 o E 3 9) F 6- Vt v,
5 Fl = o oq s tr rl
9) (a (,! 0, o € ts LA € o
rj o
Fl 9) o
Fl o F 5 o E gq tr o S) o,
7t 0r (D
ts o (! 9) o o qa ga o o o F o
o gq o) vt € o -ul |a € tD :- s)
r.l Ja 5 (! (r:
u, o o. ir
o 5 9J s r-l "o (-l ? o -l -l s) 5 o s
v, Vt € 5 o
g tD o s E { v, tr s
€ D 5 o 9) (D v, v, o .s o o o o s) o
o 0a o 9) Vt o F
H n FI v, T5 16 n
g rD c) o 5 F L) s qq o c) -l K o
e0)
v, o E F 0) u, 9) (-, o.
5
o 15
d o p (D il o I E
o E q tr I qq s (a 5 o F o o 5
Ut ga o (') t1 U1 0. s
S) o s s) OJ
H tr rD € ro e ts
g) v, ta
€ F oq n
o + ta s(,r o
€ \ p) gq
5 g
fD I FI s
t 5 .) o (D o ,q' €
9r 9) o I ' o s pr
o g) o h
o E 5 o (D \s s g 0q
F o
tr oa 15 s 9) o s
ts ts a5
9. f6 o (D s - ts
o gq rD FI o
u, o oq fD F 9) Jb
p v) p) 5 d v, (! o
€ co s) v, 5 9J
(D v, o 3 o n ts o € F) I ,f
I
o o o tr o
q o s F
ra F,l o o € o |a 3 tr Fl gq o
ib o F o o V) v, :5 3
5 o rD o. n I t o o o p)(,)
s rl)
fr 9J € oq 9: p 9l
€ ? +t o
Fl
gJ (a oq it o o a" =
o € oa Fl tr v, t$ I tr
o -l g o !) o o tD s) 0l
o
r-t g (D
o" o f1 s) v, OJ o F
o p u, o (a
V) u, o A. S) F o v7 .ul T rt fD oa a.

l-tcw v*cabulary grows

\-
230 How LanguagcW*rks
ffi
\#M *J**
5tE qggsHz *q
ffi
dr. sr v: itd.o $T 4**L#
a %#
rE. F'P3.gFo tu
cE'$oaFs) F.b Y-:.A,F:tiFr
K;rbr ='H d $i
*rc
# o Fct B 5 8.+
= -
r+.<
E
v ) ;r. 1 #*t
a-ef;=.;i
H+$s $* T E d 5 B'S 9.g nif
='5 € rgHF6?
g r l5
#.9*38^{ g A H 3 . E E E €
o ut6
m d"ddd

EE; i * $ l B E t 3 f i #eg[8fr re
c€3s=Ft FO5
o
"gs = q d 5 H L
o)P o
ti t-r TFgr A
gEBE€:
J F . *
[;;q5 g,
or I 3 E r) OFr
O ;l
: HE; H Ft
m flr\
irtQr+Fr'+ 5;irF+$r .t rLr
B E Fq X 5 ffiJ
E ' 8 r t E ' q B oo ts.5 F F R 9=6' **x
5'oi5re IJo. vtoqEo=
3€s:F8 6 -
H.E P 6 = v, H' i .'+ 9.
C' q ? :-'8' t"ffi
s8;E q I o ;s ( D C 4 f D $ HT {
..1
s 5 5 rE I4 E6 6'g?3v'X' u'**d*
q t
6 ' g/ .;( D F b O t Dq F { qqFP^q rD ocKi
I o 2 i'oa P 5(D
oan ? AH. igHFE* ffi
=5F=E1 o O !-'r. q -d
c -= vtP ^c@+'
2I d EEE,q F:
tx.'O (DH
H
3 i* ft
b-tr \o k_*&*
5'= H F
- os g Ot
= J EEilA 5 : d o !qo HF HFH
o H d '- i$ k***
v' tr q -(n G3
BLa s-^ontg3
o). At(J
tDiAiLg) g +5'5S o ;PJ *As3trg
g =. dq r') n.H i5:rts.
g#$='Ff
2 o'6-P (Dv,
-rht-O5O' * E
J ( D;P S E ] € X a'-)
E-oRt-r o 0J
? = * sF. I { ? 7- T tr
g -co i1s)n.-F
$tqEil#
I9 PA sr 6=F0,da
Ftl
F te"F.,F 8
+ *i F ;3F v , € 9)
qa5 3: 7 E I *
'.ct o ooq
i 3 FEH H T6.ia,'
cr 0J vt
I o v)5
8 P H o € tt,
[ $F$* s
;F 1
='='E p *c-FgF5'
o'cJ
=..s-'=oX;;
#r I i:
=
)#gf9 I V g E Z 0) '=g o
J
q;
= =o, J = IrA 5 FE i:
1=.== :a=
;f-Bai' ;16Eaz

{ =D-{ qF
o iili'l' trD;i
F.F hl s -vr' 6"q
; i€ t\ 7r € E tx
r,5- I vt- o fD ao
oatQ v, Vt aP H.2E
5;$ tDo t Fl t.] 5 fD
oaoc F)s TA $l 9)
v,
9J E 5
rD E o . 0) n tJfD
E9,+ E z F*F?E
S. F lG w 3
ag$FF$E
3n )sr 3s
3s F
vt
eg tD
v, cr
(D
rD
t.r)
A. ct
o n
qH il E . E F# *
658'
rDg,+ FE? nO
€E RS. t g H.
o
ag'LQ iLa H"3 o F
rD
T F{O
t
.pt5
€;Fqs;f EE o
oo (D € o Foo
Ut o OY eo.
51 ER=rty=8 3 50. Vt =o
s 50r g E o €B d l3
H)
gq r) g"B o o
qa vt
9)
p 5fo i'p5
b P6-
r+ ts. V)
E E xp)
p € G r) qt8. r)r
(:ln $.o V) o OJ g) o 0r i:
FgF.niHg a\ u, Fb
P ii. o ct FS) s$s,
at! g:H -. ;ir) o 6,,
Fl o -c/l |Dx
H ? rra J
- \ J v, E. 6E 3 r) 5' g. tr s et
Fl
- $H, F a o)(D
t- ii. g) (DFJ J+
a i F dd 6+ g e o s.€ rd 3H'd'
==. == o
FI
3 p) p) x)4hl
da"6r0 TE' s 5 0) o OJ 5 v,
qrD Fl 8ts 5F]
Q 9)ga 3 g) o ,.O 5'E +
6 f BgEH B (D@
:!o
?d'
ht'ri
o
p)
p
gal'r ts 0l
to
o P
H)F
Otr
o
6 st E g6
FO)
HEE gg.sE gs fr V) t{ tD
3
9)
t-l
o fo 5 =H v,Jq
5Y E F) Fl O/* Y.rD
o v, u, o qHi H l
*' ' - -qi 3 H3 giFl$sl #o 5H o
16
8e t(o o FJ
(.l
trc
H. 9) {9 5 9)
vt l-t 0); #f o #3 E:..6
o TD Ja oqo
YY 'i( D rD oq o s) E or E' r-r O
*6' p O-+ !rx
H HT
|f)0) o
Ft'.OH
+:$s[€
3E.F:EEg ;E'e ,& S.o 5 g) 5
v,
s o
F
o
Fd
tro
.'+ Fl
ot' FEJA
Ffr, o r)o- r) v, Os)
i. 7, F', o. ii I, o :t
Ft u) v) o TE o o gro r)otr
E E ' B.=E
(a
5' g. F o Ut
Ft or ro 5
P
#isir3i o $E o
u, o o
€ H:3
nto
sld
o 50
P F6 H S 6'H Ut o g F 6F poi-
I< u, PO) s) F F.E'
E 5 ofiq AE 5 4 o 3q'
i#
H . 1
a
F l
3 = * b lp .E s) ct o o o 0J =.H
H (nH Ed EH :
E \s Fl
6- 3 6 F trl o
F [:F; (? q q B r! t5 ro q 3. s) K
s. o t{t o q
r-t
B H 5'H
?fi: o 0, s ut oH'
I J 5 s Elr € o9' d 7 6
q € E LA ga'
nfigetE 5gr Ft r-) 0q ct oa
Y',,fSE'12 H' v)
{ ;' 5 tsl 6'
r-l Fl
qE H
E$B oa F9)
R LAo o 9J V, 0) 'r5E
8f
g.e 5' o o o o5
o0J s) ts oFI ?o. oorx l -
V, Fl. 9) rf;
:s Hqo Egi r Hf; a aR'
231 How we study grammar
232 f-towLanguageWorks

tt) Ff (a Ut gq
"ono arfD
$t I F)
o u, H
5 r5) o sl
d
a . x rl p € T
o oo G o 0) ?;
t- Sr:F
A(aO5 Li. <tt so rE gF, 3 i [;
B^{ fSEBHP{E
ss
$ g'16 (a o i;+a:83Fi{3
oaAgr.B
='€ = + gH
F) gor o v)
n5'SHEXH'+ V;J

qt F o
FbE
s to
s fD o
= E ts o
g-iiEgsE3s[jF F H
:5 (D
H I F ff 9 g h
it nt oa g q d o .
Fl n ut H A'6--d ; I
tal-x
" -F, ( r-: E H o
r-t il E.o o
(o
(n s) I
F€fi & +B H
o =. sl I T
:;i$
ss
= FO ts 3 8 F ; o Fi5 E l=-sgE [: HB3 H
5H Fl
6. E *orq
= eS'o 9J ut ld
i$H+aB?E FFE;P3,sEFIH
8P c) { vt
ts Hfia eo
tsl g
fi g' Rfi a-€ w *E f
qqE giiF,-
8E i:5'F
s : HEHEE f 8_,:.&iE€ib+[
o ' Jo F
- itevl)3vO $) qq ilq
e .B g p qd
--;rj Sr: v, o
= gl {-) !'+. s5 o
fDv, 3 ;fi F a\
s Fl

v,
=o
.S*
e5 H* s $r
HE}93i;EgHL; E ig H
7E $ r -9 -+ o
v, 3e t s ctcl v,
€Eg3[fEI
=H33 ^0) E sT3*1Efg q q
!? ,f
E lGo 3 6o € fi;* G 5
ga
H f g I + s B + 3
= i6 o Ho^1 5tr
s6 s = +,iirE
\J F{ ;
Ea Y ) q $ E ' Ex! ot o s) H' 6' iF
'U{ o F ql
= 6;?
=gr-^O
oo g i,E a v)
o
$ 6
i'O
€*.lHAEq:
i.EgEqsNo
ieasfl:riig
ry t-t
EF. o nEE n o F;4F.eStiF sI E1H$t $iF i
g F o E r_5'
-Qoq
. g P o )V)
o g F p)
g)
-r g fi',8 o.
(tt 3 vto
Fi Poo o 9) E'o 6 o
igntiRfH
E id 6"E v1 o OE
v, .g;g !
F) o
EqgH Vt
u)-ra=A o
-A='9,
Y) 5
qa
w
Eo6
R s :s o
3
I
Esl t s=.
=v2
gr.
#x iE
F 95' 06t, 0) ?rj
\''3 q-o 'o htr)

{ a
= o z Ffe
q I
* 9.
n
tg

o
E
5
.E H
N'O
2
\J r{
5
0)
vt
tr
E
v)
v,

50.
Ih.
Ti: ai$€6
qs€frFigrHEEtr+tr [$FIF
.': I oo |D ct,
E-
=;I= C
,':
$gs€I FH :*ilHEiEgFE
r; = E 3i €€r ?: =iilg;9EIs?

g 1C'
LA
F o E
o € 3 J gq qqE 5'€ N F)
=F d
rs o SJ 4 o .F 5
a It I (a = s) r21 t v, ;+
) Fl !'+ 5 F = tro g o
@ 5 t! o 0) e) o
o hl s o o 3 5'd S E. g) Vt Fl
I 5 oJ :J V) o- sd
o o irE ct € o oa
o H
7r H 0) s n s) o
9r !Yt! g) F s o v) s. )-l t-t
qtr f.)
it o s
o sJ gq g f 9' F 5 sf'0
7< 9r rd Fl
o t-t
ts: + o o s CA o g
= = ='c' 0)
s g Y (D a rD E*
ht CA p 9J o
o 5 9) 3 vt K cl
o. oa
F oo Vt S.. 9r o v, fD FH F
n 9' = h l tD TD u, o o p .) o 3 € F ii o F r) 0r s)
$o F c s(,) +J 0r o E E' lt cna o
ro o o hl SJ 9J oct s tr
so
"U 5 6" o v\ -tJ o tD p $ $o
g qa 9) o r) 9) s) € o 5 9r o 5
Fb crq U) o. 5 '9) o
5 o ta o n \S
Jo o ='n ga rJ u, o
IT o r) Fl (D s f 9) E f)
n H€ o 5 r.) s o Vt g p) F v) (t rD o (o
7 v, o h d o' dB' }..ft €(D
-gt o V) w o oa p fD o o
(D p) C') o o o s" (D o o g r21 oH e6 F) F) 5
ql F] 3F S) p o o s ts 7f
o g Ffr vt OJ ni; 5 o
(D o
n X F
n Ut 9) \o
5 Vt E
' v ,* (o s fD (!
s s) E (1 o v)
tr* SJ
oa 5 5
F fD 5 o rt H H fD o
iJ o 6 ts { o 5 *J E:I oq (Da F) (9
0) o o r) fD s o .u o ct) o 5 gq q,
o (D o) t it 5
= =o v, (! a p (D
CE v, v, "o v, o gq tsl
o 9' o h (n 5 :jg sa' E
9J G 0q o ? o s. FI JD 5 o v, o $) g s)
I rD tsl c) E F io [J
= n ga g) r_l o g ro f.) o EH' F)
9) fD n (D o p o 16 cra ts og
u, F o s.. €
o t'+ o ? r' OI' o-
a) st V) 5 v) 5 t \ -j o 0) co 3 tr
CA 3 F) () (t) )-I 5 v, El n
€ 3 0) o) p o 3 Vt g s (t Fb x , o Fl o
o 0t H 5 3 c) o (t Fl
r) i3 vt o so .) E
'a an 5 Ft
0) 0) F o o il Ut Ut o $
p) 5 ct 0) F) fo o
st (tt F (D I L . Jb o Xs)
F
9r 16s) v, o fD 9) u, vt o v, F od' v,
a vt F v, o Ut c) 3
o g ? -vr H s s o' o n u,
Vt t/: o. "d H 6 ? tr
EFl E too
K (D (t E d o o EH o F'O
c' 9J w
5 a
o (t, o o d FtgJ 5
cta (D v, vt
o
g) 5 o g LA o o v) trrJ a)H q
s) g o oq
0, tr r) (,) o 5 5 s E Fl oo u) tr
o !J) ts) 9J (! o o 9) E pg n o
ct (? g (D o $,
=rl E) vt
s o gq
? g tD ;:. Vt ,Pa 5 @
o r) E o (t u, o l-l
gl o in o s. :s s F 16 JD
o JD F Fl s o s" F o oa *o 5 fD s)
u o ,vr w F JD Fr:
vl
E o) I H 5 TF
! 5 o E 9) hl la 0J o h 9) n gl t')
3
u, FI
s) o u)
0t nr p o q v, G 3
g) F 9) ga fD
rD 8 5 o o
FI g o Er (t, s.o
6 tr tr oq v, o g (D -l i i F gl
rD (D fD h o i o5 v) ts
o g) F) tr to (D n vt
5'
r) 5 vt Fl 9) 5 = 5 Ut o FI
o (a o o) -v, I n
s(r) . s
d o o oq o Ft a* F s)
tD ;O I s ta o |! o o o; oq Ut
0J JD 5 F o ro F tr r-b o n
v, oJ qa o) I o r) t') fD qF fo
(tt U) hl F s. o o 5 o F g o
v, tsl o
s. JD
o € G
o Vt -l tr F o !-+. hl o 5
El { tD o p ft ct 9) o 5 o
ta
(? c) Fl n o o 9) o o 0r J/:
(D (! v, (? o o o :- 5 H ra
V) o I

233 Haw we studY gram{T'lar


234 F{owLanguageWcrks

EiF?gEIag 'g
l*geg*Elggg,
lgl
D iF
.E iFl
vt r5 -
. F ( -I Ff eEFHFAf
o hl o qt P
Sl o=
w iUH.
o Eo
gr o 0) +6'll SJ v,
r-l vt qq Fl E'
\J FI $t
,F)
O'r (D a \J
H
ts n
fD oq o
3
S) 9J U) s6 3 5 EgFFsI
F-.(P=O9r
o o n E, O.r 5 5!?d fD H
v, FJ O.
rD - . * H
{
FJ
oq ,-l
E a o
E E. # o+ € E = 8.5.6
r: v) o F) 3 gu, 5iDts
Fr5 € tro *.r..€r:5=
d ' $ )Ut $, o io 0) !r = I.? oo t'f
fD gq 62 o 0J* E!q
K n A) ? € n ts. v2+q) v,
g) o" l-l
! K o 0) o tr6
\t ! 8A' Fl
a
,-\
'6t trr
o nh
€g3H€F
o Fl o (D -o OJ
vt ! ,o ,r 0J
o o tr" r_t EsgF
0) F) o dH d 1J srF EltPr5r'.6
o n u, C' H / \
z< o € 3 8F 0) 0J 5K
Fl o
u, oH
;O dt - lR s)Q
p s.E'E-E a'
x *
o t)sr T C' o T5 o" -gi ;o
gssFg.E
F) B o aor (a
3 E 6 EF]ov;=li'
19 H 0r
o V) ct 0r fD o 0q n
o :+ ''t
FJ Otr
t) o K -l xE'sg5'
o o. 0)OJ
o o tfr)
oq 0. o cr v) € dE ga ricrF;'cq
o o o o 9)
o E 9B q I p Eo)
oq F.l$ O. Cnz HO
Fl
a
r-l 5 o. o m
o o 0"
5g
$f e o 54. -
E T ePg
u, lri iJ
o oq td Ct rt, FI 88= oq
x Ur- ta n C' v)
0. 0) z o o o o o d'=8=c'
o tf OJ v) cr g+ fcDtt€l F! ft H
oct
r) r5 o. H Ft ,) (1X'
SJ T o o
FI o ooo
S) o (D
o |) S) tF ci or
Eb 9J ?) o
T-EI v *
r?.fg
€' S) B5'
o :'r hl s.+ ur oa T6lFojFt
o gq tD o 5og5q ' K {j
s, -l FIo d g, HgE
o S) F o o"5i
'e.5' --rD=56
N oq o
! o q
Fl
ry o o { o od6
a sg v, Fl
oa n
ss Sgqsn
9) rf o a. o
'-fJ o t ra
I
n Ft a o
iJ Ol \J H E o Fb g H E 3 9E
n
o F o Ci 3F xI
o O)
Fl o E)
o
hl
5a o
$i+ ;'! fl =.o F
Fl OJ FI (D F- q-,:rH
-(,r fD o
!) v) F 3 . "
o o Ut !fr - o . 6 (t) nq (D s r E : FB8
o K0l
g E , gq v) Ut € SJ
(D
E. a'- S)X ;Hoc r
o r qa xo v, $FJ
.v,
v, r) ; o :-+ gs *g PF3
hl o F
;g.tr9
|.) fD o € E d* ng
g" 9J g) 'o
E ;rt'+ sr yoa ii+$ 5"9
9) o o o oI'
F€ a. d, . g EFE
235 How we study gramnlar
46 f-lowLangu*geWorkt *ry*
-*-$*

= t' qfiE[fi ffi


7 E

d i: F,E#
*EqSHS *nu"**r**"_..a*
HR€ $
E
= E
iq ?F:iFEEtFB
IF E E R'B' o K'.-EB* ; ; H3 n * o
=:u.aE;{
F rS3"FtE :+:XS g3?g:?;B
i E' :i"lElaI**lHi
er r: HY) A X iD I *.id:>g r 3 F- 5 6'Y P
p
aei*;i]
=F:Fiit * nil:i*gsgE:IH
grEHfi€$s+isa ffi
\*#
td x **%
t* ffi
aEefi s il [i H;=';SFsq+i
*&s**6"*
;B$icg;
C=
?.,+; T'}oq ij P
+ + - ;. I 6.5' qfr
= dTnEE* r iil;ti$rpr$t*
rt, Ef;r?+E*g_3
cgg;;]i*[rrt
iEiHI ;€ [PeEFF'[frf
li=€FBHi: F+e ffi
zHficn F€ F rag*;5gfriqFE LJ
g;33iR & B'F€eE
= = *=, HE+rqRs re
=EsssBs $HHIBil,Eg;= ffi
-o-86'
_8Eg *=:
73;i 3, :FFg*HF3E€f H r gSiits2 SAYbHHgv)
e;33i4;E
t',q\q*x. €
ip*sass3ilE&6
3g';H:i5fr G.Anq
€iftEFgFHaI16$E3[$*f,
E
ilEli: 1ia-s+:== =v7
o
'= q= (D p E
J 3 K v, 3 o
Ht
g,F
rttto+o 3 .d
tD
qa p € 8 E.TF
fDt=.
o Fvtut+ 7t 95 g.
F 3 5 o fD o H5 sr gS- H . H
O. E g
0. =3 e o $
Vt F
q) rD o v,
r.d Fl = {s.
o o gq €o:t-
rn =g 3 r)
g) fb o €i. oFo
5
(?
5rD=
p)?+
thHv,
o o V) v, +
E 0"
o F
OJ
9r
5
Ei$t$s'+
F,g$i+* E
sqfiiESR
F
o 5H
o
B8

qF fqB
H | . { \

a rD '15 o. 5 o ER 3 6 s
ct) r?/+ 5 ril
xrD 9) T ag (a
o s) Ut 5 ,o lrr. 6,{ 6
q tr Ol
6 DsR+++ 3 3d o- gi'
:g € oa
ry r) Y -o v, o orS (n )r qi
=-€t
o + p) >J fD s)
r) 3E' gq O) 5 gF ' {R' pXB'
ed6 3 3 € ct
-o Ut o
zo
tr o
6€HHH ; F -g i- ,F'
5 Ft 5 o qq 8"q
$)
3 tra2P t E'€R
+
o F
O.
rn
o E
o
E-* E E E E.O
$F5 n a) vtH
o oq g) o n+ #6 d HF ( . ) H .
; s?
=i:o Ut o v, o\
a.5 q o tr o
rrd t-l o 5 .+ ;.(t =q. BgE ;. H.
FtO o V) v, o Fl F ii
+ o s EBq ;*S 3; !?
J 5 o Fr ! € Oq o(o
oaE' rD JD io 1-r
it r) o $) rs'
{t.d6 5 SJ FI qla E"9
9J5-r o o $
g+ s=- s E d)-l' H
fDftirD
v) a) V) F
E: HD
p. o FI
e Vt €
g6 iE i E$
r-t 3g 58=.
:)6) o g X sJ
(a s) 5
v, b)
o d€ o r) *$ [j E j4F
!s I o nY)
.F o tr
Ft oA $E
*6E F f H
r) v
Ftf
-
;=tns+. x
o o (D E1 AH ; l)R
g s i)

= d =. R € ar 0) v' 6F O?Do
n € E' LJ(!
gJ Ivtv'
-t 3{ ; tD € Vt to Fr' 6
9 $6
3{ 5"doq
tDo 5 rD o # 9"S to
V) l-{ !- g o 0)
tt)
OJ qE
..'9.T € 5 H.$ n €s !-t O
o S) E+ tt\ Bg3
Ev'"' F $ o vt o 5' H 5r)',i
onT o o ga 5' s. g,s
l$.) -th o H5' 'o oE E'
F.l P; I 5LA
o' E 5 H 0) T I o
odI o [.F *Pr E lHd6
0J 9J n a +5ef
n -v) (') o f.) 9) 6
rt)
Avj
5'o u 0) o o T
o o EJ g Hf EH ; w; g,
r-l
,* sJ55 $ pr u,
o5 tHr
s S.a
Fp) pJ oq -Aao? o
ItT
o fD I o JD crq iH 31 g FE.F
237 l-'l*w w*:rds w*rir
48 H o w L a n g u * g eW o r k s

i fi H€ 38
tS
lQ
i[f,gg-s +
.
L - p \
TSLA(QSS
.,
\ v
]J
ggEc*E ; E
i[ [ i $5*Ri $s
; ?,E sFil r r t l l

0)0)A'^$.;
4 i il F H$ 558r'6
g s
[[[ lc t+*:
s( D ( Ds= ?
.o
f E =E € H
-, o,
*T: R f{a 3 3
fltD'o
t
, J > ) Y
r+
3
H X
r+ Ft
**iE gg
E I$ rI
g[E
g
rqs ooo
sA; 'X
dEX 'XO
E
Fl Fl Fl
gil+t +e
es E-$lEri s$EE
Fr:ftE fDofD
ut v) v,
3.9.
H t-{
S
Ft
9 9
= F f6A
7:8H
f 3 FH oa oq oq
u€r $=gr$gi; EfE[ $iEE*t ;
$* H
?d
E' 9.
A. ha
fd.D
a-O o
qsiF * E
=u)-6'r)q r-t
33ElrE33
en
o
gE:gH $ p

5
vt

0a
1E EEE1
gigigE Err
I
*ifi
B"e # l*€
;;apf!
OJ
BfiE$[ieiHI
si;is; T* iE$$lEgilgE
€ EF,3 gEEgSrSeg
E * 5 Ff P
;ei3gi gif+HB$ET
rETFfE$BIT
Ctt
crt i' o gt
5 F E5 "E'
I-l
€ l-l vl Sr =
o t trl
xF' F' EE d= E
9J 8o (D F fDH t-l p ,-l
Vt v, r) r) o utH 5 p. rD
(? 3 5 p r:H' o JD { oo
o o
8.S SRq'
$ "CJ o" E \J v, oq 9) 0)H s ; o o o
9. a (D
rg Fl
E ;F t-l oq v,
o o qq
5 ' qFr' o JD hl
oE tr o F# d tD E o 3 rD
5 F 5 Fl o c 5 v,
= u)|f 0) t+ n es 0.9 o ct 5 o L. v,
o V) _?r 0) 95
o Eq tr oV) f)
o Os) ts o o (D 9r S)
-lJ vt
c5 o o o" o tD o E'g lr ut X rD
s)
v,
t E o t6 3 ts JFi+ oE. g E"F t_t 5 ru 5 3 o
r) .v: o. tc FO Fl J{
v:o E o
sr) o
(r: (D v, Il.n f') 'E ts ! o o { ct |.l
\ Fr it P) o o .) F o o o ts
$ 1R qE s) F)ft o o ut
v' (D fD E
F|'
o o ni' vt F !)() u,
FI o o$) C' o' FJ
o g*
g $5 \5 O. ?g TA o o o o
I(n |! Fl o (D o gq '(J p o o F
F ut
-. 5 P) oq 0,
o tosr FJ 6'$ ;
o(D .F of.) F o5 crq r) o o 5 F 5 p €
9J 0) o ::r 5rD ?E g p)
qt F K o
Vt u,
u, o E E $) x(! u, -(J
p { o 0) 69. F8 Sl r-t t o 3
0) u, r_l !+ ut
s trF' (D5 o o o O.
o 'U E 5 € s 9) o
EJ F fo vt oq ,t o
o E
es
noa E
oq -vl
Fl
3
o o FJ
p F FJ
E'
qhl
tO s)
p o
g)
tr do E o o
v, F
9) g o
d o g
Ut
u rD 56' (D o
g
o r5 o
t1 EB
H9.

(t
gs o
Fl
Fio E hl E
p)
U' v,
{ o ct t
fo
F
Ed
s) 5
u, t.) E Fl
qed p (t, 5 (D
F o E (D a 3 Fl $o E o o o 0q
o HE g g F (D o
r-l
,iut o IJ v)
Ft o 9A ca fr, F) o B
69 o X 83 F) r-l 3 r-l
0r p o \J oa fttg s Rv, F 'vD Fl
o o F F6 t, o
"o 40 qa vt '}J.o o 6 FI
5 tD
oq 5 f1
I
0) 5 iu o
g) vt oq I 9r o (a
o oE vt 5 hl o o ) o r-l ut
B- 9"
f)Fi s o r-tl o Ut
o 3 Ut gr hl o vt
i o t, € o -H' ut It hl
o -{D o
o s)
Hg s(') g^ t 5 p
5 o 1 ta 5 H.g 6' tD p. tv, o o E(!
o v, o Fl Vt gq
a 88 . * n| er v, Fl
EF oF fd hl
g) n
tD if .d rt1 \= 0) tt 5 o Ut X :3
v) u, o o 5'8 vt Ft E' d o
g - p oq o gq o o
9l v, fs- s, €
Fl
oq H' €5 tr q1
'-s) 5 t'D o cr so. o 6p g FI o € s o ED (a
El o vt 9l H)
o o Ut 4r rd 5 S) E)
v)
u) tr
o Ft
n E3. o o K oq
sg oq' 9, F
@ o
o I
0l SJ \5 n o r-t o P5' o H" o. o5. s p
F H: FI 5
o tD r.) o n g) o o :s €
o i-t q€ o f.) u, sJ € r) o o o
g o o F) !t -l HE 0) o s
o v, 5 H) ra tr ;H o Fl F 5 F S)
hl $g u, g F s (Do Ft gA 6" * o " g, 5
s I 9) Ut Ut o
rd rif n fo 9) € vt s,. rd
p p) 2f F q 0) F
o qq (D s. E o ig;r vO gs I F
\s o g$. o5 Ffl 5 g)
€. E" hl Fl
o o 5 oq
ta ttt hl ut Ft o X !)
ra g (A (! s 0)
ooJ v, o 5 V) f.)O o 8S. o U)
o hl v, o n
o t'0 l-5 E c ,ag oa o Y € n Io . o oq "o 7t V)
s +. O. F)
E F o o F s. { o
t-l lt)
9) F| |-t w t-l tr 3 € 9) s Ll
o hl hl
9) 3 o o
(a o g) O) 5 + o c'
(a g
{D t Ei; I I I o g 9) b
9+ .g "H' 5 \ g. FI 5 o

How words work


240 H o w L a n g u a g *W c r k s

o-
rD
=
r+

f
ga

o
o-
(n

EEg
i$lEFEigEgEE1E'F
195
g

\O.D fD
9l o
+)6 Vt
(D sr
p
r) rD o
t,) o
rD (t)

H
; (D
{ 9) 5

o
agatg
r) €
gl
tr
o
9'
s
rD
F
V2
9)
o
3 3 S:5
EiiEEEE
lIE1$ffi
i $*3l a [ig
o
I'
s)
Ut
rD
rD
o
gii l e$
ig1
(D tg

v, 5 o
q
iiHssE; iFgiic
:s7*lfg!lgl$siH€E3g
fD
o
-ul
o o
C' o
9) o F
v,
g) E)
o
o
o
(-l
o
o
n
oq
33EtFE
rq*E[1 gIggtegglllI
9J.
F
F
io 'tIEgggiIIgg
r) N
o 9) + F
ga
f) v,
o o
9J €
to o o
o
Fl
O) o a
v,

F)
v,
V)
FJ
!-
c!
F
F

5
o
lgiEtEtitgii
tr t o F
ga
oa o €
o g rD
v, g v,
o
9.
o
o
Vt
0) o
(D
g*EIEB
EIgElgiiBiiiliilIg
24i H*w words wolk
242 l-**w LanguageWcrks -##ee ry* t
$
75', AF? {.ffi} tr\
\# Lr.***$u*,*E
€rFiEFS \**-d
ig g''s*\p*tu
IrEH ; & 1'r*g-\..#
=eFs E# SFln igE 61 F;r ffi
g:'u BE L}
;*kes{gd#

i;*qjHgf'ei q+g $ffi


\J$
:e 6i IB+Fs€Hg gggg$Eg 6 H
6 v, u, u, u, u' 6 E
gF
; ; 3 g E H g t E €; rry\
AM
FFI iE 3$*na s+iEiEns € E€ ffi
a*
$ ssEc€*i$
t+a Foq o =
E: r *J
i€:riftii;lgq"
3EE 6' sd" -s
if :o;E'81 : ;A g
s E
E
[];
Ff F'.
E Fre ffi}
=;?*. Egg* s= * u+F ffi
1c ? F:H-r.f g s WS

7 5 aP o !+.r -*+\$
irdldssi r $EB L*#
=;v,
c- qE v'
reF*q F s + E.E E 3i[
;= €
€HstE: *- 6.E E.frr
E g $H[ 5 6 r I i s, ,J
fiFr-*Flf* F tE
sva;Ssrs EE
FE
s;l::'-€+=E
;E
€zidEFs"S
=e? #3
=T= !-31 s'a
tE

ftt-l
= (a t6 tD
o € g -; X
'gc* 9) s; E ;6 ix ; ,; o .:F € (-) E F g) p)
g)
3 o
r-t 65 o $ g o_ o
3 =; o g F yfD o
g. o Ff S)
5 s) vt
V) €
u gr o N.
o
oo-- x d u, orD 5 sJ o5 rD- F
J / o XFgrir€ rsr T oq Ff Cnq
oq €
5 T rt) 9) t_t v) { F JD
n u, 7f oC
?BE o fD
o AF F) =oJ rD 0)
)(?o H o I' 9)
o
rn t1 (D n E' rd F s € lt o
50x o S) v, o €
o o o o pJ v,
o o I'v)
o=straBFh.SB F
o'oX
o.9':
n
0) o o' x F
$frFagBgBie
iD did x:hj
X
C'
o
VF ro
C'
v)
o tr
5 r3
? l-l
6€
lt5
r) o go
o 'C' H)
v, Fl o o g
o -*j o
E rd ta ; 9) /) ll: sE' s ov) F
]500q o gd
C' 0r b5
n x o o o
J ^ i o v, v,
J
i ^ Y € 9
o
iJ:FsEFigS oq
8+
F v)
o
cra X 3lr
pr? gq
5 o
a)
V) 3
*eid o '() v) = Vt > o
-oD o p o" EESIF$EeEE' o gq
€o s) o
N)
o v, 5
rl1
.0r 6',9 o o0r
E T 9 N) o : F s i€ 5 Sv, 5
9J
so
V) { cr : dF $ H K o V) 0)
Y 9)
15r F g AR
:/ - C' o o s . H cra o o
o U)
o T
u) rD i.:.
x o 63
(1 € o F 5 E
o=o
- l * o if) o o
?+ o o
j-i'3 o oa IIro € o
-6 9
E o F
9) o
Fs€$ti*$es
F +A a q i X S E S o cna 5
Ao o
0) q 5rD
(iaX
vtH
ct>
o €
p 5
g)
g pr PS- E B = T i I 5" { :.1 3 x a' o n
o I I n gq
oq r Vt
o tro JD o
Fa,i - l r
E 1!Ds o :s € cr dE o
n g o
(a
E i : * q i l 8r D
q o
r-t o F +Q o o o J? t'IJ
o o
v,
. oq 3 g d- F'€ F n F g
5 tr oF "F= ,r,' g Ja 9) rzr5 0)
$ 3a- v, o Foa =" 0) ur. =. s Fro o
.! 5 0) E R v,
p r)
"o E
cr oq p)
a o
EA. o ? 55 .,, i Ut hl
o' gqp 0) o
7\s5 r-l s) o sr qq 0) 5 o
R E Vj n f)
V P tr
o Vt
e; " $ 3 -ctl S. o. p o o (!
'R tf o. 5 ? gr -. S S O?D o X n 5-<
+ S= H
39, n 9" P)
€ tr o- a. c)
t! H fD ,fv fD
E 5 FE:r L I oP 0l Ft
o o tr ! o r..) E'N oq
fD f6 o
s) 8€ i Fi. P a >t oaB
4 F
; s V)
,JD o ? Frg.= JD o ;
-l o H o :",'9 € s) 5
c
b
o
Hx o A I F g) ut o o :+ F !r
c] Vt gq vt o :iVt P)
vt \J g 3 Xll Fb
H.
A
f6 h'F a H o f]
0r v) s 0)
o v) vt n
Vt o F p o F)
d€ F) g 50
t" SHTSE v, o 5 o)hh o :s
\ g rl) ga rtB :5
o o I rD F{ s
Fs;;fi o oo E) X o

243 How we ciassifywards


244 i-"1*wLangr.iag*W*r'kr

=iqg rgF J J
F G
*EEd€ +Fq1*Eq$f Fg A Fu
o
r'o
+ €x5
rdO
*t A
aiE*aErfi '€
?; e* r $* H =' ,o
:IEfiHi3A Fr)
R
q

?aagFEg* i+gIlIatigg*i
EHIFg*HHrg + {
X5l"
:rD
I
i;3i tr[i"E cn
=1- o
-it EigIE n
o
5
= HFi fi F El1rEEl€Egg o
X
lr)
9l
lt')
i z;E iS 3 i
;IEgegtgIgIls (D

o
tur3oi.5
7EE+1EgH rcEFrriIr?geHii t
e+EHa FS
OXroO (! frrF6[gEqBi3s=EI
€:asB eq o

ieEgige H$FFgR*FEi
EF!f
rf
.FEDC
EEBs it
o
OIfD lD rt *38 - i t ! . t - 3g
n o (a I sl i3tr39
E iEE o ).t n
o
Fl' T s *l BerHi
tFrg $) 0)
(,
(t)
n =; F OJ
t
@ soee g o o F
sr ?d5=F=g,!i!.F v, rc| u,
o
g t3, 6R- s^=*AH w t q gF =
E- vt -CiJ>t
g tl) o
i;.8 s+ 9) 3 g. o
B- e tF " YqH E O Ip
0) S.5
g)
gqx"s sHgggg o o A ct 9 6 v' -1,
?e+ ; FnTfr EFEEEE € oqo o SFEE Jgiss€
F E E { s vt o 5
F-!. o o o + tr p; fi R fi'H E E v) t-f tr
4 o \5 s o $.s+
g o. w 0J
'tDo
S+H ts ;T;1 v;
I x €H s.; {
.rt
o oa rd t-h
H 'IJ o !'
S!-v) zt 9)
g$Es $ E-P E t' =
o
g FEft $€+F++
q$V o o
r-t
o
oa H 3fl.[6Ea g O. F 1u8 8 " 3 "
Fl 3
tr o 3 r5
FE 3 p o 9r SJ
; s H s ; F H F€ ;
ordt t FFg$;F€;ra (D (') 6.=FlHg
o
h| \ o o BHaE
p c' 5
'-r5FF;6
vt o
ial tr o n Fl
FB;fi
0)
SFX. E
€sE; $ig:[3 o E o T'7
6 5'='qq
sidu) 9J n n ts.O
T5 o d o
q+€ F
g*S+ + sS$g 5
n o
fD FI
o o o o -
7E-g nn #X Ef i'E
F;As g €tFr pr v,
OJ 5 o -5rlhl
Vt
B.rF B "iE5#E*
Hqs
-.
/
rh.)J
"d
o
F
o
g FE; E::E+ f) x g) f)
F)
(rt
H lsF = s
H d
<. E;. s,
u) r{
o o. o 9r
ct
h'3Sg
g
ErI H F
;{ rflF=
jii T
g BR v,
rD 0. o
3.n 3 xilfitEE
ga € o v, or3f;g
HEq cv, v, (a oq P. = LJD
l,l A r H
€o
dE d lh FI s- p) og "*[HEHg
r tr' s o 7f s"
o
g Eg E $ i;-
E o o 3€E I B E 13 3 E
H.E 5 c OJ cr o o
T E F[ $ o p) 5 5 E FF' = g
EF8 5 € n r) FJ
'.o
'r gE s G' 1a'E s ',
pJ o $
E'.$ 3 (n (1 6 P;'e. q
g.
i Y blsn
= r uZ 5 f
o o C' 0) 6'#3E'
ft nE$ €o o
() o
Eb fD
r) ct 1#sHlt '?'+
E td SJ o 0J
E HnF
c
*S . s =. Ff
5'nE 5 = i1
5 o V) $,
rD at $ oq 3rfr $;BfHg
HH:, +i t tt,
o, o
€ 9) rD o E
opo o #7 S 5 r.) (D
I
tr
r-l
s*a$I E;3 q Hqg -<
z4S f{ow we classifliw*rds
246 H*w Languag*Works

gaEgggelglgegg[
EEgI
gEg g
ugrEeEEglEI ie
egIEEIE
ig EE
giiEEiEEilgB?gg
guE'alEsulirsea
3 al
f) E |! p Ft
n FI ut d E
o 9) K1a (D u, (D-I
o. oa
F
d \
(D
o K g) (D €
o 5 5 o d 5 F (D V)
r v, s,, id E. o #F
FJ 9) o u, o Fl) vt T
F v, n .6 gq =\< o ;= f5 Fl
s { *fu*
= 5 (D o FJ
a hl o g
X
Ct
s E
Fl
F a6' u, h o
3 v, F) u, gH X o n
o
ni o o rJ xF) 9r ; tr\
o s) 3 o F| OJ p Fl 0. (D g 5 € \*J
a llt ro II n o5 r) S)
3 o o (D
(D ts C' v) o o K
g. s! € st rD v, pl
b s
G o ta x rD e r E t) or Ctq X o
ta cft 5K \3 4 5 p
o o gr Er_t o o
(a u'rt hl o o
D o ^r p o oq v, 5 o n
g) o
tf o {
Ar 5 v, Fb o"o o v) 2ri (t)
F) o #H u,
v)
o v, Eo
G p (t tr o vt d o
ts)J f)
9 * PV,) ox
\ { n o oU) , soJ g" o o 3
o a o u, 0) ffi
v) o ile g (D
o, -u, F a€ €
s3 * vt
oa o
gq 6-o o oo. U) o trh
FJ g v, 5-f
s'. sb a ts FI {tl
o ui 0) $t r) o o g vt o
o n (a g
FJ v,
g o oq o oTa5 $
o' d- o v, 0) cra ;r o. t'?- (D { st
FI
o F] 9r g cl F)
F Fl
n F Ut c' Ut
(D o
s# h
s J.+ o 9) o
o
ffi
:.t q E 5
s Itr o B3
I F) v, ga pl
o F v, g gr ofD o €
o FI
\G (s
I o o 0"5 o (D 4
r) F rD r-l € qF sr
V) r o cr f1 o5 s o 3 F fln
ZW
€ -. o o o o 9) oq o gq
0) u, o 0.o F Vt
ut,.t |^l o
o rA v, hr o o € 3B o :t o
.0) 9) f5 s) o o v, O. )
o 5 h v, dg U) F
o 5 ,f s" tr 0) E5' fD
n H' u) o ft
Fii o 9' ct 6' A. 5 p qI
o v, 5 o oF v) ut >. Ut
e' r) 5 o oq *l 5 F)
n
F f) 5 g) vt gqo o sr+ ! n o
JD .s o F o o o ? o fh
o C' Ut o x rLt
9J 5 o o or) gq 9. 8', n *j €
o 0) t'a (D v) C' sI F) U) t-t
I a) tr s rJ 59 o (D 5
o g o Sr r+5 o o tfr
vt pr E n v25 5 (/t- 5vt tr
(t n ga FJ
o 5 tl ofo o o.
r) { o rD o 0) 6' g) o
o. 9J 5(D 9 F 9r (D FI *#
o g -l v) o vt o
o o s) v) (A
i .) (D o6' n rD =l F|.
tD JD o. Vt
F o o (D b a
r) n
€ V) hl
o s o €
o o A,H
|'l vt
C'
o
€r
?(1 FJ g o rrU
La-,*
t-l E o u, Vt ft
n r) u, € 7t o 3 .,'. CI" (s H9 n *,
tn (t (D o Vt Ol H. o ts
o o Ut t- ?l) 0) ts .(/r I 9r o o \"d t-#
5 Vt
*-q
l-"lowsentenceswcrk
,&
h{*w LanguageWorks

F
E *iE-aArg1;if
E sfi* [H'rq r[;**a;;lgB7*r
1EFF EEFlgEIgEFf€g [1
$€[
EIp$*rsl;iIFH$EHlg$FE+
ng*Fllnai1
a**#ea[+1[11*
it+-+Tre F
1*1EF*+r$€€[c
€gF fgIiEEFI
IEg$i$$lE
[F EeFE64i;geg g
ESaggFEAE*F
I
tc$gfanesag[[[gg
]T
EF1gEIIEaEgrII
I E =
ff
7 E fit I =
n
*u, V5 It 9l hr
'(tv,
=.r p 5 15 5
=gtgr cr O-Fl 6ut v, ca it Fl F) oa
rJ't J fDSFr ; 5 93.8 st =''05 t6 8= qa F g s5 o c
o o=Ft a-(DsrD (A f') q Ff
tt, In
tr 5 o E u, Kv, O. 9)
f') - P) (n'
V,
5 o H\ (D o -vr' o
5 oaoH
f\ Fl.
= Fd H o fD
o n F. oo- g o
oa - g o H H,; r+ HXin 5 ^ ; F $'5 *
S.=r o v, I
n t o 9) ut 5 fiE oq o oFi o E) -u) (D n
q,
F o- tt) n o (D
H:*,o
zo
o 5 {t1 9) K 0J r) F o
5rv€ vt o6' 9)
!. r+ t. f) 5 a E o e= o .:R s SJ
r) H F fD n g € Fb
*t f E
p'.r
J o F OJ E
Ja F o o gq
cr)
Oao5. o riFl0l fo it oa o o A.f)
O F o s) tr o o o n E
,,' l+. Ft p o tr F 3 tr
Vt
o o BF 8' p $ ! 0a F U) =D.J t,
H o s)
o oI'L 0) gl
a n g h{o o Vt
-PJ05)
o
Uct{ = h l o q Vt o o
0
H
5X 7t o n tr (? Pg) 5 OJ
o @, (.) b ( D n o v, -(/,
o k r) 9J u, o r) 5' n
v, o tD (D F o
o{ v, OY € € 5
o F o 5
:< .) o o p cnc o
-t fD 56 o v, ct, g u, fD
5 5 d i'
a sH d o o o
o t' V) o 1aO o (D n Ft f') (
rn H)S (D-
5
5 qa or) F o
oit
I o o o o t (^- o
cr t-t: 5 o,fl rJ 5
o a lro 5(D o o
o o o g) 0r
tr 9r ?-l sts
F o Fr 9)
vt =F o (D o o 5 o ott 5
- Va oE. n
u, n F :J(D t
o Ft V, V, g) o V) Ut o
5
{O 9
H g)
g) trp o o V)
tr n hl F
tlt :oJ s Ala v, RB
5 r) 3 E€
fD o 5
&s fD o o
ct) H0, j
o )v, s) oFl l F U) o
p o N Hs € o
oq OH Vt .o
IA
reo o ( H
d ) E o
g o Fd { o
o 5 e) 0) JD o sl o r') n 50 r{: E
o fD o O
3 |1 o19 9) 4F|. n
p o ts + 9 . o o v, i.5 o t
hl t o
E o f) F rJ r) O !'+
n $ v, ;JfD g) 5
o o g o o s)
o s 9r = 3 v)
sq E'
F F Ete
p) (o FJ u, 5 0tO g o
q
fD
9) o F t') g 7t (D u, o t rE fD
lt) oq a ?a .)
9) v) o E p
Jt 5 o 5 n sl o
gq
Ut fD f1
E= o {ts oq o
o hl
o p
5 o 5 vr o I!. sJ g o F gq
o d 0J g (D v, nv, r-l o
f.) 5 o 16 F v, p N
F)
-s) o p 9F fD
o qq
r) lo. F
Fl o ctt F F o p
t gq n o o g) Hogq o
Ut o 15 o o HF
o Fl o F
o v, Ja oq € 'o3 (a
o g
t+ foo fD $6
o o |fI
o (D S)€t o o .9 v, fo s
9) .J 5 n
> o gq n F ts g1) oB o o o o
s) s) g v, ^r S) 5
o 0r ts r- € g) 5 r)
4
cr v, u, o s) 5 tsl
o o ='E
u) vt
d
v: o rD rD o ;'5 o v, 55 $

249 Hcw senteficeslvork


Haw LanguageWorks

ts.F
p t.l o nw vt6
tr 3 + {9cr { c F9€ = Fo p
.v, 5 o3. o
hl
5 =Ft F xg 6r
V, H. Ft.
:Sg o (D :f
G E 3 q o v)
o5 'C' 8I Fci
rd Y. 1S
Fb
hl
-l o
;-f:
&E. FP
t da € Vt v, 3. 3' * AH go= :5.
\-og o
Fl Fl
o
FI g o = =o
o p) 3 e\. n 9) d6T o ga 'rs Fr d3 &3
v, ra :r oq g; d,E:
Fl Ar tJ tf 6 dS
'= g H
t) o :FF o { g) o Eb Y F r
u, s o t-l E.o :Hoo
ailE r) F o t.:-l. x
.5 il. Ut 5 0g v,
o E) I \ o Hu)
g5' F es
g,B,g Fb 5sg 't ;
g K g PEd r) (D' 0lt5
9J (o o Y E.qe
o 6 n K q.\ I |! Es,
o p) t OJ =F'aj
*r Do; oE :
+ o s JDd E qq 985
ET f x-x
s + F Vt o FA pfD5 t-0))
rrt r= (n F SH tD ta v)
IA o (! n {o 9 n SF :- U,o) qR t3
,.+- o g g o. o=
sxE tsl { vt HU, o C. l.1 0)
o F 5 o o BE U5 5 +9.
BE8 o E.ns tr s Oats.t.)
ST s 5 sai I fi'R o F i+ g)
tD r-l _o s g (\ 0)
fi, F g v,
E 3:B 5 g (a d F to V' v''
(D-lq, fD$, o
o Xg o o 0) Ft 3"HB SE
'$6' n o 3 9 F
g, o di+
rg g o) o F)"O n t)
E) vi F o r-f |')
tt) {1l o v, g 3fl9
o= o rd C) F o
o 6,r v, Ccl
Ft o F Ja o t{ V,
o $ s ? ElH F 3rB
T H
itt ro r) gJ )JfD 0q ong) n t o (a
o F H. (Aoq
) o:, o o g) o OJ
5
F o
;cqc '
it' s Fl _.89ffi u,
B v) ta p u, r.+
(1 :+' o
0, I' 9H o t
11 fD o
q, !a o
\ 6 ' Nt.r) p
F s
a 3H6 FX* H
tD Fl BF *l o o
=F 5 n s" o:t 5 a
' F
o (D il9r r) € H'qE
s.$ (D l.{ Fl'
sE I p -i* v) o 9. s) F o
it vt Fl o Ja ta Fr' v, 0q €
o ta o o H.
f)
rg o hl
o d 5i' I FTH
wp9l p
rd + o o o
B
t!o
"< tvt (D
p f1 F) orH fD Eq
l-l
H
Fr: (D (D o
gH g F)
fi o
o
o
t-l
g) €
ts
+ u, )

xg 6d 6 7r -
cl F
,m H6- v,
ts
tD
iv,
o
ch
€ 13 Fi, o o 9) ii oa (.)
(D
iE E H. tD
hl
q* -(rl o 5 a
Fl o
Fl Z g
g g o 9) s#E
, J j > r 9)
EB o dit 0q hl
d ( s hl
fd=,F
Ft Fl hl o tD vt
d o Fi+ o o
H 5F) o \s 5 F '!fDFi
- (D oE 11 tr 5
;{ Fl F cr o -tr Vt bE F
'-'P .D N 9) e o
== E' 7s gEe -a
i_r

-r- t-
o
ti
E
s t' -l
F}
E- o
FI, tDI r !t
I |! s.6 (D
v,
(D
o, GI !D { o ; E
.D tc' hl Ft) o s.e cl
t!
=. D' o I
5 F @
o oq ga *E** E'd o
FI FI
o.
3
o
= d v, 3 S) o F (D &
(D H.o 5
(t) ga (D gl s)o) FI o
r'!! S) F
I 5 5 o E il j f =. H s H E o r) lg) a:
(D tn 33 9) o d o
Ft 5 o Vt o o
3 u, u, t
rD 9) rl
o f(o d o Ef;
p g) 3o) o F)E. o g
a. o = cr g o fD 5
o S) $ .s Fl tr 9o)
c)
(D
D
G I
o o @
o r)r:
gg v,
g FI
tr o{
*E
rE Hgrga OJ
(')
3
o
p
o cr
o
X
cl
o
5 otr
n
vt
o
v, = Ut tr o ct
o o (D t! (D gH o o o rr- o 3 rD € 8
v, o g n ? :s F F rJ
rD { PJ F. Br3B l-l
TD
o (a w 6 F v, o s x-t.) (D
(D 5 JD i+o
r) (n tr 5' o t\) 9) n o
(t, f.) t.) t.r) 3 F
!D Ut its o
Fl
s ;F s) { fD o g
I o PV, tv, o { r:
o ) g Ff
Vt v,
n € c 'oo o U) ]{) g 5 g o
(D w o p orF Ja
n o vt vt @ o s)
FI
t(D r+ Fl F trrO
p) Fl tr ct
(-) IA o dF g) K g v, v, t
o c o i'q o E] g fD o
vt
s€
0) r-t 3 F) g) v,
a
Fl v) r-t E
€ Fl f) F.r
o € o 5
dO
p o o :< 3
g) OJ fD tD
it gl o o o o H ir'
u, F vt {{€€ o OS) s
v, EJ O. F o n 9 9 J
o
u, \t 5 5 3 F g6 g
aDo o 5 0) 5' E' 5' E' o cr 9J
o
0r 9) \J !! i5 5555 o F tD v,
ah
? rl7 g o (D o
(D RK F ut$0)$)D5 o ts 5o
t? -l p s) OFt. v, T C' o fid
gq hl n
7 f.) $Fl tr o € E E sAE.e r E q o o n 5 {Ta
o fD g) 0) t-+: FI o
tD tn vt rt u, tr $) tstn o
(D F Fr' Fl E.E H E $ T q E E o
v, f 6 tn o oo
r) E) 5 Fl Fb F
|? E
16 o tsl
o oit H&s&A8.*&g
V ) F F F F
F (.)
nK Fl
BE
p tr o a :l 5
j' Fl n V) r-l ooooi; 0r E) S o
n w r-l
b n +H
o o u, 5o 3 ddctct tr (! F
Fl
9) 0) tritt u, t-l
{1 vt o K v, C) 9) o ===* r) o s"
v, 5 u, ggo.o. v, o
o FI o o
tl "d |.]
F hl
o € ct1 € fD E E
o 3 6'R p)
E
i cl
€3
v) o
t-l .r S) 'tJ 9J
o 5 o o Ed
tr Ut
o 7l tr) o o cr gq 9)
Flt v, o n 4 oE'
o I u, F+: Ft
FH o

251 How sentenceswork


252 How LanguageW*rks

U
o
F,'q
il'-s H.\
r *FFE
6
hl
\z
\o
\tr
.5

sz-F*
r.s
gtg*q! * eF,*+ i-ai'g'
$-i' -o ,/ 4
= r-{
o,
rt
+o
\ (/n
I
EHglliE
s igg
iIE IlfFE
+sF IIa
ReF
E-0\ *
;'r)
lr:cnr Hr$$i$ €Eite
t B
FO
\=,
-p \
H,/A\
=-_=.t
+- o rd \:f
= Ft.
reg€

/7
/4

sl
9l
/91
>/(tt (D \
\ I
I
I
sgglEEillilitIat
F.

*-3 I
a?rlgtg;raHa=g1$[lggflft do-
* \ *n?.qF+rgil* i sF?;
o
Fl-
xt
OI $=H
gl
(1

z
o)
(D
I
vo ?o.
.+f;
aiae? g*3E 3gi
J-'i r. J
I**6 F
.o H
Y
\ r lr f
|-.
50J
*g'FEH;[[ fr [ s Es
F Ft Fi iO
: _o.
L H \ I
/
R 5\ /
s \z' '|.\ o rp:s.3: !' a+ $
tt
'2---= sErg gi gq:-
==
eFgggg*1[[$[ a 3i E T T

Fl
5,B=
o 5 Fl
5 v, 638
E tl I fD Ft Fl Ft
o
t?
xIt (D E 8 vt H *t 0.
91 g, o J J o viE a'
0t t FF o g
tv rr o3 gl E
Fl o Ff Vt ooo E) 5
m Fl) tD 5 3 ut vr o o n
? r-t o fd o p 3 +g+ hl o
o & 9) H gE o o o F|
cr C FE'
F] g gq € v, 9=- + G g
to { JD € o qE' tg. lJ fD P
o o F (D tr 0r E o do= 5
Vt T' d Fi)rO
E Ut ir o P, td o o+o o
5 5 s qa o (? ooo $) n o t(n
o gr vv, Fl Ut (?
0)
ts ts pr n o ?-O '\' F o o
E o 9) o.go er v, z L*H
0) o F .(/J s v, s) o ct { ut p s
ut (t 9 S Fl
o'u 4a.0. JD o o Fg E
gJ
S) o - 3 f+5 0) ooo FJ Fh
SJ € o vt Fl. {-f -} TN
ct o 9) 3 o :5 FJ {P. OJ$OJ
+ a F +gv
o F 9) o 9r o € 5 {s} r)f)r) o E
E OJ 5 B X o (D
o 0q oq F t5 FJ
55!' 5 .)
o g p) @ o o F
qq 55 p ooo v) 5 F3F
(a
tr u,
F) o 5 F.fD rgo 9)
v, c g (? o H F I
5 0a
o or o g) 0) F + F!t
o" v, ct 0)
$) (D
o o
o FJry (h oq
(D 0l p o 5E s) € /o o € o n ct (a
h E€
K o 5 v, 9 ,o H H o rD
"o o V) o. € trO 5 (DN = (a .r) o 7
o o. u, Vt oa trfDtD g o -('J
K F
(1
n 0J o s o o 5id €A n 5 P.E.dq
(D 5 Ff:
o. v, IS) o v, 6'?
3 0) o o qq 5 ou) e€ o tvtr v t v ,
g p
0J
Ft r5 IA o
ra SJ
oa g. ()
5 o fD tr
o o a q o o o 3 5 H.F
$oqi+
FJ 5 v7 d H F .
; o Fr: rD
o 9r
rll F u) o
s
o, €
9) t.)oq o o n gr o
o hl o
o ;3. 5 o a = '*g
a { Fl fD JD 'o s Vt 8 { o o o0.
n o 9. r-t Ja a. R 0r r) H. Ft
o }.l = cra l.O
Fl E o O"E - v)
tr o r) o lJl 5 li.
v, 5 o u, €
zE
Fi
F F'o
o oq o
sr) o o o
9r g s q 6 xfd
{o
s)
3 + o
5
o ga (D
U o i' tr o t-l
r5 .(/J
9)
Fl
t(h o 0J =g n
€ 9J ro oH. o
F o Ut
n
o o v, qd6 FtS
o
s- { X p
HE#
5(DH.

oq I F o' 5 rt o 9) o o = o \fD
o 9r gq
lD 9J H. ( / .r o
5 tJt
c
n
oa v,
o p 5
= 0q Vt
9r
r) JD s (D
v)
grE
c 7 H
v, gq o o o
hl o g) F vt { ts Fl
o O) \S o 5 EB. € o
9) f)
n r_l o o o Fl o F +6
v, 0) n
sUt E3:
P r-t O. d.€ s) \ (D
9l (a 2o n 0r
o
Ft otr 0)
3&n
o = 5 tsb s) AX OJ o tr F
g) cr (t gq € 0J 0)
V, pr o v, € 3HE
a zos FJ r-l
o KOJ
o r) o v! fr
v) t) p) 5 E !a 9J 9) u, v,
9)
0r { 9ro € o
(a € Hq E
o E d vt 8€ (D FJ Ut fD
o o r.+ O.
fD ut 9) F o E o
gq ts P8 5 a. ct
fu q (D s) S) AF o t3:e,
o 0l o v,
cu, F fD o s v, F
9) td .HB t- Ut r] (o
tt, o 5 o o o $) 9)
hl
I I V) v) o u, o. r)t d 5
i' o. !Dg FE o I HgF
253 How sentenc*sw*rk

\
zS4 How LanguageWorks
flffi\.€
\J -**J**
*re ,ffib

r1
f&,&rJ KJ @
d@6t
F*SEAgF ;ar$sHE? FHFEEg e{dt6*
d-*%
1,i$ n -{ L#
**-*d
s$E$,F*g3Ei
r#sgl:iliE liFHf
ssEiI€ A* lFeiF -**EE dx&#6

*4
**J
fL ! \ 1{ d"?\
ggFEEE M
rE,J
ry
lFF IEfg i
i; fign f*s ?reB i11i1
f F$EEg : $s; B
rb
nt
+[ AHr r * 'asqi f qF; +ga*F
F: H E li BA Ef ** g E"[+ E" +=H H F
r hJ*,
H *;:FcrFr :FcsF HEt i
= **qx
9iO'€
=iF.,;E trFAEEFs 3EH; q fg 3F
*J
sTE ssHE[*
tfiEEgIg
srE;"s5.E I[gig
gFiiI
i1r*l=[[
;*Fifa3q ;€.lge
ilgF+6H18 Er+csb3
Fa:;esE =f FHE
Igg+t1rgllE[1+igeH[F
FrvlagvF
gi $fiFF€i fixa?E
t==tF+i i#F;: s,I EgggH

3€
ii
* o #tD E
g pSrgr Ut FJ IE F 9)
lTa n -r r ) hc' Fl t.) s
a rJ3t o f1 (D
Fl o v, v,
6
t5rTg o ='
(!0) fD p
o o s o o g
v,
tsl5t r
Fl 9r E'kk Fl t6 ga
€ ,ul { ..+ Fi FF v, d *E o o o" 5'
0, oo Ft3 H. F. (1}
$t Hl d o) o o s) o o Eo to 0a sr g 9--
Vt
I'
t o t.) o =H
.RE €9 x 5 u, tD
5
i3s Fl
g. 9{
tD
€ r)
hl
Fl
E)
p
u, H . F f d
ae gJ o
FI:
o 5 d f D (A chglo o g f:
E.B'S U) o ct
a
FI
f)
o Eff
CI' = o g) E. F g o g) o 3 l.:
(a
o o g hl
n
R " 1 Xg . Fl
si 5 o o
€H
t{ E irg (D o I vr d o v, x o- o 3
"6
r-t
Etr+ 9)
0, €o F|
o (D gaFl o g ? u, cJ $tI (n
o F N ag P
f =i 5 C' o o
Fl!
m r.t Fl
s EE
o o (D 0) O *l .:@ r-t n
F E YFo) s
I.i. o 0) o ts E)
ss F g
x o
tt1 6H € gs frrr5 o p tr H g tD o 0) v,
s Vt (D gq gq v, o
o H. V, 3
ct
I
g)
o o
Fl F
o
FI
g)
9l' o
5 H6 F tsK
!T FI
q
o
n
Fl
o
asE
gsB
'oE.
l,g
5
F)
= o o v,o
a
Fl
$ irF
g6
o \5 o cl o EJ oa p oi'
fD g) g)
5 r') E.F 6' (a o :€ ol
F .$
9o) FI € p5 5 ttr.:r
n O, 5 JDo g OJ o g
o fD n cg F it F.r @
o € F
= o U) o o o gq o c EO
6S 9) g) tsl o 3 3 o n
s' v, 6B $) o u, o5
- 3 v, hl v, Fb €3 oi
V)
o Fl s (D c $
o o
;H{ o F
p) t
(,t
Ut
K Fl
+ o Fb s)o) F tl
c(:
€ HEP 5 ;s (!
K
E o FJ :F S.
r) m v) s o o o. ct 9)
hr Fl E€ gJ S) 9, Fl 69. g v, o t oa F T '
Vt JD
to
s. F o Ut tff' nt Vt
v F) nt) { N .s. o F oE p o
o p) s sps C' = 3:r
s o!' Fl x $) € o n -'r;' o () o
3 o g
r) dht
$$E (! o F+: (D
gq
Ft, 9J
Cf, tn5
tr o F 0q 5
g)
3 oO
o 3 tro Ja o r5 v, 6H
F 5 o u,
(D
F r-t o
E' nt tD
E A) 0l f.)
s5il t1 9) 3F* ?E F o
Ft o
l t1 orr t
sE
= F f
o
vt F o"xrS € gE p o vl t €
ow
ts
F) o
sI Kv, o
!a el .O vt I(D oa o
t q o a0) 9J F o v, o o
o t) C' ? Fl u, gq 5 Fl
o r6 o 9S u, f) $E { .o ? 0) *g
f) 5 60" o o ; s+E o \5 s) F
s (A ot 5 o 5 fD q6 o F 5 r) (tg
o 5 pt
nt 5' o X v, v, g o o6
ry 5 o "o . 5 s= tn
s {B (D o ]Jil hl F (-l (a gq
€ n 9vt 0) n 6' (D (D
tr:
(D
o
5 r4
E FE o Hz.sqs s s9
a n !r! Ut o
o v,
g -+ €tr (a
,X&. o w n
o o F
gq
rc $ ir ol { o F FJ tr F
gF.
g. hl hl
3sE fF o
t F ts.O v, g u,
u, u, v)H 9tl- fD o
? 5F o F d o o o s
f) FI
= -l o
F o 0) o p)
gq d5
q9 K
ESn
ltuq o
5
vt
.(/r tO\ trFt
EE n 7r' o a1 F) 8s)
E w sl o o Eg hl 3 N
s t-l EF d R.2 F) !J
Ftr)
o
o 9) o vt o 6'g
c(: Fl Ut p
6 * g) F
9) qt Sl gq }J
Y 5 o +g (D +9 + s) [ * s) Fq

255 How we learngrammar


256 l-low LanguageWorks

iEEEE*iii
IEEg
lEFE
EIEEEEE

gl
g tr f:
p Va
e8 (D E. v, o S 'x
T
frr or = oq tr
s?' g = ts o $$$ o 8E
,iJ
o ^r g) g
o
Ff) oa o 5 oH'(D $E (D
5 o F T
Ei 3Ei l 8
Esi q g, E?
(D o tr5 r o +o 3C
V) Fl' :ts) F F;s
F o o F (S 0J o
v) 5'< F o 68. o+ s
EE € Ft gl
x' 5T o u, vtF
r)
€ E:F r)o ?6 E?TEil
o,+ = o {Fo P $e| $, Fr Sr. o
5 B9 5 ; nn hl .Hg4o'5-
J o 9) o Vt EO
-a Pg F !-!' 0)
oq $E o gq g) rJ o
n!f g o o. o 4 tst ;*asl
gJ v, i.r (h
€g n 0r fD s9fD nt oa 5g
o 6-H {
: il# oo a E.+a
&w s) o =l) s) q a 5 gq Vt *d 6 e s
(a
;; 6'* 3 P ,to Fl
oFr oq o .OQ 0) 5 P; I
rDhl
aR6 5 s FA
5fD a5 3 "o o s"5 d ts. I'
o Vr- F -IJ o Jo t6 9r ao 0Jx
Pgq F) eE. 3 Et* f6 to 5
qq F 5 Ft
u, ct g . c r H
5
g)- gs o o, Hg ts o
o rD o tr 9) = E r . o
ri+4C E)
q Fl g* H;
!, X r) 0. sooq (-lg)
B'r
;i. o r) o o oo,il E) 0) r) o a t D c) IrJ
J
7 6E ,.) Fii H -
os) s ;+ F !A5Ff o o 0) o
.v
E
rn pF t, v, o tots 8 F oh6 r v-
{0r
[* hl i'o.!' Fl F r) v
J
qa Vt o
F6 o o at €3 d o
tt Ft d6€ o
tr Ut 55 b" o 9)
oo F -l F a Fl
f1 ta Yx'g rE o
v, =:i o ts o v, 0r g
Vt io"
E o o o +86- Vt s 6rD t
9FF E F :s 0. (/l EE. v,
(t xt 5 o tr
n Hg o
i+6 o g) o r3* oo
o !lo Vt u, -. q: s o5
n) 5'q V) v, gq s(1 1j|D o E6
7r
vt
p o (a
1€ tsl f! 5 5'J o
tr s) ;9€ Vt
JD= Hfi -0J
€ n ht v,
O. 5 V)
o Eg 9E s UtH
g) o o) fio o
;o
o o Ut fD r-:
p) E, x ts 5 o o
€ 5o o OJ s
(? v, €
E F p) f ff tr o s
i=tFE
qq n fiE F
€ 9) to g) T o .)
tO E'.18 o
F
E vt
o) o 7
tt
bs g5q ' s ,Eg to
o go 9r o 5 -vt 0) n
9)
EFgI r/r*
u, r) S) Bd H . * r) F o fD o
r-t
nt Fl)
;$H
- o o o o o o
F0) v) ct r{:
€ 0) { 5 urohl =.f o 5
o rD u, 5 .oso H Xv, E.B
o n 5
gq +P q 9l d
o O) Fl
€E 7 8'o r) o
ctt = r)
H C' K rO € o
5 rar 36- u, FJ v, $. H' o E€ 9J
(D a IRH s5 C f)
9J )-l 7f
Fl
cv, t | '
gF fi' E. OFrfd
- S) (tr) 6'
o o 0) o il p$. o 5
Fl rDry gq
=€ o 5 fD =6JD o ri+ U, lD lt) 1 r I

257 How we learn grarnmar


258 Haw Langu*geWcrks

s€Etn t:$+
lglE'gug[gIgggggg
il-elailegg$![{[1[[g
ElEEIgEIEEEIE*'
tE
p \t € t
o o o (D
o (a 5 n'unldf.) X
g t F F
g, vt 3 ' o l Fli r e l ).S
i-. ''l H. (a (.)
t s v,
6 @ JD Eq Eq E t! o S) o
Hs:qRi#eFEe+C
. . 1 s)
oq 5 3 p F)
o o sl Fl 4
ta gq o s p
(D Fl

-. v, fr€6pF o to o o
FT 0) o F
d tE*i B d arq
o tD fD OAHFTFI ts
g) o (t)
0) s)
vt hl
tt-i 0) o I6-i tr
v\ t I
,9r o
vt

o
7t
o
o" \Jo
3j=Fo
hx 6 Fs a
F
s) ga
o
FI
o
F)
f)
o
n
FElEIEgfF
H. q tr tr
N
F.
v, v,
6" '; ; E SrD
a
hl
oI
a 9) o
s)
lH$*s;issg tE+
5 $l 3 n E o $
K 'oX 3 5
gq to aE 3 o 3 o ? g)
F. F - 0) gt F
E -il o
I
S+ F to E;H 3 8 r)
E) o :sdeBtr o F $ o

E
o
o
g
o

q
o
v)
v,
tsl
Ao.
F' o)
g

{
5
gq
o
o
v,
F)
f)
o
t4
E;eEE***+ *g
S C' id :! 9l v, o V)
ts. '\' ts'
o o p n g) n JD
F (D o
oq o oa Fl
.v 9J
FI n -l I FI o F
v,
Fl
o
q
(D
T
r-)
F
o
s
F
g)
F
o
r)
[*1*fi1E$Fl33
v,
tv,
o v, F o o o
o n vt o F) K
o It ,o
o 3 o 5
Fh
Ft
o
9J
3
o
).1
qa
9r
o
it
o
5
o-
FI
Ja
$
S)
o v,
5
$Ing[11ni
Ut o oq g o
f1 5 9J
oq v, o
(D 5 p,
o qa r) gq
:r tsl
Vt (D s)
FO gq p o
sr
5
5
o
{?
g
o
Fl

vt
g
9)
('
o
v,
tr
F
n
o
5
F
Fd
tr
p
!"
Fd
EFEEgf
g) FJ
r.l o
n
F6 o
o
v,
n { FI
o
.Ri HaE
9) o
F
s
o
fr F
o
tFl
9) F
o
tr
Vt
r) 5
-(,
H$g il+
€r aE€ F; fr*$
How we learngrattn:ar
z6a How LanguageWorks **?**
_i"*
P4s.
5Ed ffi
d *
q *
$'%*.
EEEE ,F;98:fr$ \""#d -,"*$-*".k
#@'#
$H1+ p ****h
lf ftrE*€lile
*HrEii;$gFFF
z$E€;
+$lga 3Eq
i3r€FF$+$$*i
", lq #gEr
fBeFg rn
rid

-dffih
5 1

\*,*,L*,
EilrfE g
q F -i;gq€
1*g3i
f, E.ggFdF
tE E gx Il B *]i fi g f;#€
7E tr m'
:giH E g[Eili $ €A[ ft
IFgiFIg {t
;EqisiaFf *+i EgHT* E:AL f"&
\J
l
zEieE Er[;d Fi €iY ge [E fE
Eg=Ei[:P{FPF:ar =3 *f Fd b**
gi $i ***q
I€3Eggls+qsRn
= i t i;sF
{J-'}
rT\
€i.E?rHrEflE-rg E+ 6i es:i t l.l
. d j.qSt6,e
i*;eF*rifr+Fs
EE*[ E$HH
sFF$[&6*$il*E; F; a€H
iEa33 i:t3:8,
?:;it s ;H EFs =. s; 9ia
7ri+?i

ro
rf ctS
t Ft nl t1t
(D s
w
9l =6
C 5Ft
itg
(D 52t
ri i spss sis o o .vi
.,, FJ n F'E
ru.,q€. |D v,
=gE- =-F l{ sr+ilE v) Trl o c rJs
5 Vt Yr' E' ,.o FJ SJ
o fD tD o p o
vt
o p p)
t ::.
: o ct
(D Fd o :l
o (D u, 5 g
=€g g[EH$Esrilf I sr
o
€g o 5 7t o
T E], a)
o
ga
t€ E'F (D ., o F
i+i E{S
sEE 3Eaff,Eg T p 9) o o BEF o OJ
o
oq n Vt o s 2, H.
p o o { v,
rIi rIF pEE€rst$ ;* o X o o €
t5'g 6-9 V,PtF'stg F.= P.R Ff) 5 € p rD
*t t ,f
o
Fl
o o F
o 9)
X
o o o
gas tD
rEr ets FE*[Ht +s F$ S) 5 F
o o r) f)
v! F HFI o S)
IN H EEF E$€R3f o 5 o s) o Vt F
Vt o
gE fl"3 o o sl FqH g) o"
F a o v, c, F)JP
g) F) p) o v, o r0
F + X o
iE!i ass €3$E+[ ae
g v, vt
I5 6
X:^ v,
d E o
EF v, o g i + . . < u,
+iE ier Eqdise nE Il 5 d o
o s E ='
I v, HFt
6' st o
FEFggF F+ Bg vt o FJ H. /rt
F]
7si Fs: o
hl
0) g rn o
7:g 0) o 5 S)
s- . 3; o
g.+ o too IO
t J F f
16
E A1g*H X {D
p
ts
fD (D
ro F F
g
fE ;fi
! F sg?FH (? o
qq
ta o p o o il$E €
o p 0)
oq 8EE a)
tE s* S) F F dt< E'
o gq
rE HFii[
d SS€ s o Fl

F]
.6
FJ c o o9roq o
Vt
o 9)
r ;6,u
E a f..g E. d v) GE H o o
o rD 5 HSJH 5
F*E€ o o r) o
E Fh Fl o
s, \t9) 9dB
g F E '15 a gr F
o o o (D g)
+E () 5
= F * r)(D o
Ft
Fl
F vt
o v, 9J
o FI € o"vt- (1
o
F rt[ sr cra o
F € o
(h o
hl g F'B O.
v, s
N o E E
FI o F
o (D v,
q g o F 9) $t s)
I I
r +5*
H'? T
a[
s'ro O. F Ff F K

z6t H*w we disc*urse

..
262 Hcw LanguageWorks

gEgEgggE*S
u [Egg
g-i
igaaggEgli

g
,,e, 3
Fd
ItD tr € Fl
o h|
+ E d
Fl
gr o H-l
sr vr $) € t?
so o 3 v, v, S
75 i fD
.) FH r56 v) r: o 7
tD Ut OJ F o S+ qq F| o
tDo td ; $, ,-l I (t, rD o o vto
rr S) o F FtiJ
{ F 5 5 tr o
fD-+ € o '6 'ct g) o (D "o o
o 5 { g, \t o Fr0. {o fD
@ oq
€ \tFl
o 5' q'
5 o 5 gJ o cr g [fi o Fl o
t? Fl g) )rE U) LS
o . 8 oa 9)v, 0) ra v, ga 0) v) s 9) vt
P.H 5 o 9 5 o F 3 u, o vt o
Fl o o o gH
oT o 5 t r f: r5 (D v, t, (D tD H9 o o F (D
s) q+ t! vt vt F v, (a :o
o o ttt S)
X o
Ei? 3 o
0r 9) 9)
rr{ u,
ts Fo FJ
€5. o s+
K E) Vt ''9 o o t 5 F
u, F tsl F 5 9J Li3
{o
6o o E FtO
F o o o \5 E
g 3 n o orB ,f 5 o oq € E) (t\ oq vo o fD F H. A.
o9 o F o 9) !.+ 9 , f l tr g
(D "o p oq i o I ct P) o U) o ah
o FI Fll { m td fD o) v) w
Fr' F v, fD 5 o v, Ut
E -€ 6so v)
5 fD F vt o tD g o o 5 oq 15 tr S.
oI'. o o n n o I 3 o
rfD v, -l t o 0 g tD EF+ r') (o o r) o o s EF
CL Ff
9 E .@ XE s 0) fD r) 9) 0l s) n
o?D \i, 3 so
s+ p c) vt o tr 3 5 o:SI
v' ta g) Fl A .' o 7f
7r V, o 0t tr o (a s) fD !1 0 o
l-fr o K (D E rs ao
ET o. g (t F) o i'
oFl F) Pro g oq r) e"g JD 5 o 3E r) o
oa F 0" o F o F 5 g o Fl 0) o o
3 0a gE tr o 9) o w o !^
CO H6 o o vt g 0J
I 4
o t F v, o € t-l
!r
F Intr ? iri
9l fd
U' ga o oP g {o Ut p) 5 s u, o fD Fl t-l
EHo
o F 8F o qt o. €
sJ F E g) 5 o o o "o oq Fl n o
=b o 0) r j € ,f g) 8 v, ga € 5 g c) c €o 3
Ft)
ts oo F' ' vo
, 5 9) Fl
s t€
)o E o (! F 11 p] 8E tD v, o o tr o ,,rg
o Fl sr gq { o F g 0) oI v,
o tr (D 11 oid { {o
G FJ
n 5
q, o € g) U' 9) fD ar '6 tD g .-< o o
g F
co 5€
(- g) S E s) tr Fl 5 9) vt vt
ls F F o F fD o o F o o &E
o FJ p qF' vr o 'dth $) u) F oq .n
:+ 0) 0q Ll E rD v, o H
t
Fl g F) t1 r) s Fb o !t o s l nt' v, 0) o t ofi
F9 F) pl o o o r) o Ff)
hl o JD
EH ':o
, o v, C' f') €s) o 5 o
6'9 F g) fr g o o F cJ sr t.
fd o 8 |fFt 5 o o
3 o o v, 5 o t-t vt o FI 5 o F 0J
o n| n oo v, o 0) { (t,
g)O X n t6 ? rtt H E hl p) FI o gr
5 vg Eg) 0) J? v, HH
t "o (t o o o o Fl o g 9J Fl s) o g p
o
r-l
gl gro
€ hl
n d o (/r€ F d @ cf,
6F
oq$ ct7- OJ Fl s) € qB o u, r: K
.ct (D n it g
c.0l I o F o 5 V) o u,
tD EX o
6-o F o Ut o s (D gF ro s p or-t o vt F EF
o) d o :3
5 o E |c'v p F F o 9'
ga F) 9)
(a 3 ? tr 9l -5 n o o go
(D n o 6d' o o o I
tr v) p Fl n 3
o tll o F 5 x' E2 v) H ii o tD U'5
o) o o.o (D Ol oa 3 9J Fl
E g) p o i' 5 o o v, C" n ;'E
t + v)
(D
s0) 3 F
E E o5 o a + r-l |D o 5 (D
o F
o o tr K9) p r+
o F hl o (D PE tD tr
I C' € E
F' o 0J t o $) o o X E F) oq
o Fl Hg
cr oa Vt v, d
EFl
5 o(D 9J vt € oq
9 +o
I € o o PH g
3 (D v,
Ut E 9Etr !) Ut o o n o $) o s o ohl
o. !- |D r-l o ta v, o ! l: tt)
€ o v, n sFb u (D (D fd t 3 o r) H)O
Fl fD ? tD g F o gq o (D
o 5 r) o= 5 F o o=. p o sv, c' -(a
zt t ;h ot E K 9) n o 3
0) o o o o
g i' (t) o o o (,) Ev' s) 9J ? oq gE
fD 5 o 5 Fl
o s) F p .) ttr s) tr g)
gq I tD 5'8 g I, r-f: X AE o I o E 38 (D o
t+: F (D Vt V, r-

263 How we discourse


How LanguageW*rks

c
;trl [[eleitlE;gggg
ggggg

- D l {

!r- 5
.+ F Fl J. S?
5 5 o
(t -1 (D -l oq
E o
t-l gr .4 d FFEEFF fD Prd H 8 tr o ho
hl (Dg u, ct
g'. fD o hl o Eo
FE g ' o F
F€ E l€ F w 6H vt F o 3
vt !) o trl.\AAO. gl $
so o. € o
!t fD o tD v, ,aO fD ( .o) ao J
gE: o 5 F Fl 7< 0J 9)
(D ('D tD -vj F5';3aa *F 5T o o
r-l o (D 9) JD5
5 0) =. v) oO f:
rD o E
v, S) (D S)
v, € iF
Ft € FJ F o o g
0J v,
€gB
(D11
vt
9) o
{o ;,r3F
g y:e: s3 f ord td -+ p
o o p tsl
Fl
H
cio
H
v, -@6 0) FA a E Ut U1 E)
8 g 6 o hl 3 hl v, FO O. o crq g
9) .oFA=6- E)
F o Osr o [= v, oq E o
$JH'XY 9) o S) qq F3
= 5'* o X o 8"s T5 o s+
ur^/d { 0r n ? E) g H 3 i; $J
H , v, o vt
g t
0) n
.+ E tT lJl oq 9) o cl
tr E'E.6 raSo F jXdv H
E (a
.o gq o gl f.tl g
3E n
ts EE s d6 t5'd 6x IP g) y o 5 s 9)
o- F.
o V)I lJ tr g:1q'? o 5 OJ 'oF) Fl
sE
Vt t6 rD o= o e E F g€ g H'8 cJ C' f5 o fD
ntP u, 9 g 0)
ga n (D aD"ijo,Oa oq 53 '(t t-l to o o (D o
,.r SJ pvt 9J o o o
v)s+Fo Fl o p Fl
Xg, o o At ;g ;r =
= oq r-l: o € E
6P' (! € ;=;.tD}-, o olts o F o o ? n 9J F'f
Vt fd 9.
F g) '-r g ,tO o ,ad
o o o o ,Eo o s)*
$5 fDri K (o E z o
f1 I € t*dHPt cr) : + e
EH ga^ o
Fl
ltt =sq =5ttr F o F (') tn sJ
6 fD o o s 0) n
a
o o0)
o fD f ! B = o EF A) p5 Vt p)
5 ts 3 q fi v, r5 "6 Vt u, v)
E6'
3g t6 € E =g qI g st g nt o (D o sl (D
uzO o elE
E) o 5< E 0l o SF
A H 5 fD o o 8.d CN Fl
qrx (1 E : iq E; o
qq r) Ov,
zi. (o o 5 Ho
(D (D q 5 (1 Ut 9)
=ht HS
j E 5'? c aco o Et Fr' o0 v) E
9lro
yv, v, v, E 6 5
o OirFt=)H o sl FI o
pJ hl ; FE.
F ts F& T r5'*ur=. 0) (a 8[ o nr F f.) 5 o
(1
E
- tE
uE o g+ € rDosrr-E tsl o o g) Vt?
€ o FI
o ;e
r-t
o
p o r z<
FI qP F O. I
FI o o d il iqx V, id. (.) T $
0ro o € o
(A $Ft:v tr p, 9) € *v oH E o o Es
-u)
iJqa sU) II { 5 5
oq (D o g 5E FI o
qa Fl ti. o o o 9)
o fdo g o o ?3 Fl s1 gq Fl o o S)
o. Bq
i+ v, + 9) tD 9fD o o ?
v, Er -FC o o
6? o- o) 5x F s (D o vt o zt Fg
r- ?1, o Eg, s) ts \5q r-l o o
ht :*6
gq 5 tvt (D p o o o
5 o
g
v, nE hl o S)
€g 3o p (') .g
6' F) v, v, fd v,
o I oo o
*o{o o *l On
F o EF o s n o gl v, Fo F r, F o (D
vt F) (Drt E
o n Ut 8El
F

hl
68 o 9) x o0) Eq o \tr-l a 9J
r) o
p ct o _l/J g
{0)
o d 1E o zr SE
E.g rD tD t s tlt o1
sa, rD or ct 6' E' F g) F) s)
ts ?
o 8s
-l 5 8'e o n tri 5 o -l
9J
I o
p 5
Fr 5 r-r' If 5 5 o
fD o gq 5 tFI Ut ofD oa @ FI
u, (D o o E9
Hcw we discourse
266 i-lav+Languag*W*rks

F e=q68F
E b-a' A 9" F+6
3 ? H;IAE EE
F
F$a,EF31F3r
a6 s -'r I n: .f F FEAg
g
sFt! g; F2€n$i
HH
P.6
q H E H = fr
"rJ nt I

$+FEgEg $ gEEt
g { df
eH'{n-qEi
iHTfEfr[ F 3 F3
F+lsg?3 ' f Fs
f,[regfg F H;
ErH3EHE
E Ei
7 EriH. ; $[ i ss
fiE[s$
E$F #E== E E!
i$Braic t 3E
n+'i;er
e€FAgi: F 6r
ili $€
SilEgg.'
= j;
;- sF
=
;; = =-

f: ii
D ql
9U
r I .o :s tl tt1 !'fD
o tr6 o r) G
ht
o trl Fl t
ttt
o o 6o o 6H
$) El g, o
q, o
v, fD o F E) 3Eq 5 o g 5
N tsl
(D o' F oq ipl56
A' (1 H vt o o S)
(D n Fl
? r) s.
L F l
(tt
o oa o
P)
5 o
HEE
p5 ta
0)
s)
p w I OFF
rD Vr{ 9r 5
5 (? rD e''ro *Y*
a F g o Ut Xn tD f') 3 (/rfD
o (') qa Hga iirD F o o 0l
U) s 5 fDvt
f v7
u, o q a3 $ 5 T ***&*
"o p F o o 9J J': Po
5 Y; g. oq 9)
€ o rl) v,
n o
i+H
=.qE ga gr €
S)
5 ri< tffir s
G 0) p)
o
E
o I v,
H 0J' sB
T A) 8 ts5. o u, d KJ
n o 5 E r.:t rD o o r+I
(D t+ o qa 6' *l n ?
o o FF 3 tr 9 3 rE
IJ a u' -(,l 5i
F p o ,gE v, op) o 'o
I o Fl v) n s)
(a
- o \:- o o, s) v) sJ F.1 t') u, 0) o t
o gF ! gr d,H
i-t SJ
(D r3 o fr = d '- F o Eo
ni' -l E n t)d o (F d*\
g) 'oF V) r) r) r-+- X 6'o d o (o
o o o X n .J o t [$
o o p (a Fs 5 o 5fD ffi
K g o U) rJ F) fc st
v, 5 5Y FJ sr q tr g H
o' qq g ts.(! p o o g+ \*#
o F 'g
r"{ O fD
o 0r ct I'il gq tr fD Hs+ *X
o o rl E tr 5 B v, oq F tr
g) r \5
rD FtE € gH
9J o E€ gl #
o 5 r.rJ Ft
t6 o p) rd
o o S-g
o o F oq $jr o oaX F
o s)
9) ta (A E' tr) o s)
o n 16 n o Y
€ 9lo o € EJ vt
o ttt o . ) J 5n sl 0r 5
0r o o Vt F Vt F
U) Fl E F)
r, 9) g dg o flry\
o d p) o
o. E" BW
o Ut 0) { fd
g) o € r' o v,
0) s) F o Er l' O5 (a :t? { o *re
Ut > 5 r, rt' _(ti
fD o o cr p F) o
Ff: Sl
-vr' t! 5
(n v) o S gq oq 9J v)
5 o oa $Ft o o FJ o
V) i' n hl-
FE 9r F) 9. or bry
!) |D o o 5 o oqS O1+ o F v,
n qq (D o o o V) 3 d (Do l\1
o G(b o fD o o ffu&@d
v, 5(D 9r *6 v)
JY Hr . ( / t o rD o f**.n"
'es...
o 3{ Fl F) A
o F FJ X o:r e er o v, o ffb
gE *d*
rD € € \o o vt p ot F tr {E *h*
s Fro u, \"#
-('J - o r) HE
o o s t o S) Fr gL 5 d @
5 5 hr o 0J )- 50 qq 0) 69 *-q 'ito.
9) sl r{i vt *"u";f :
a) F ) - o Ft oa o
,f cl V) 9J q& I
o La (D I' vt a)
o o o fD o tr5 o ffi.
\**d
ru re
tfr *d
267 How c*nversatianwcrks

.',"*
HowLanguage
W*rks

EigiiFFEtsgsggiig
J s -
I O tD
tr at € F G
3 lD 5 rD d E aB F} g, € g
? = I gr 3
F
;l ' F
0
E F Fl d Hr3
c(D 11}
ro t! fD
o
3 i' (D
; st i' d 5 5 o f.)FI
o f) !' cl g, F gPH tD €E F o
T (D v, o,
tv, q E= tu) sJ 5 o ,gw (o O ' + o o hl
(D 5 oq hl HO. o
)€ a ? fo o a
hl I gq v, o q : s -qd o 3 F 36 3 o o
=jo K n € 9) o =o o
(Jl)F 5 vt 5 p F) o Hg hl { s)
9)
.t o o Vt 5 € o o i' F)
r-t F 5 o Fl
o-* vt ra, 0) 5 F) EJ o R S tr I TD- F o € o o
i v, Fl v) G o p ta Vt
o gq o F6 X E) (D 5
Z.-i(D Fl \5 d sr =. v, 3u, o
v,
EH €e
a C' o (D Fl
F F (a Eq s) tr s Fh
o== t 4 o o 9l o o ro p E d s sl
go H F o 5 v, o o !) € :5 p o
3 o 'o Fl s) r) o € o (.) i+ OJ s. p
?=d Fl cJ rA 7l E o Eg (D g) #H ta o
r) tr '.O (D sJ to o o
vt F sl E o tr 0) =:s cJ 5 o
3(D o o o I F E) o v, 7l E Urd F = = {fb
o € (a o t6 o $l F )\ < 5 X
5 g) Fl 0) o X
5 E'd o Eo o g f6
sa v, .U) 7r s o tD Ft ota s
v (r) 0) (D v, g g)o F o ; 8?
d tr o o g) Fl fDo s n
0r o Fl l-l r) ct € r-t E 0l 50 f1
v, o o g) o 5 F)
ta d o oa K o 9r r) v, 9t s
ts. v, F Ut 5 5 o) o 6fo
5 o F p v,
Vt
o
qq cra 9J g) HE. F o € Fi' B s F
ts
fo
rD o vr r)o F o s) v, g +l o vt {g $r 0q p)
c) c) 4 AE: hl g E 'i+ E',f s Fl
g
5 X
Fl
p o o a5 o 9) o K5' o
rr g d v) o FT: € 7l
c) 5 € 9) 6 v, Fsq o € 5 o o
}!c'
o v, K(D
o 0q E' Oq f.l
Fli d gq o 0r 5 FJ o
hl (D o rlo g B 8 tn
9)
o F
g
(.) to
0) -0) r) 5s Ar€ :- o Ut
o 9J C' q 2f ? o o v, v,
5 G Fl T, ct,:J 6. !t d
:5
o p sJ 7r d
o 7r F o 5 E fD\< 7(!
p X 3
gl
o F o F 'q sl pJ o o
o qq tD ::€ dF *i g
o Fl
() oq E ow :.r X HO ts r) €
qq v, € 5 tD nC r) P .-r.
o p) l-t G o o p
PJ s (D B A Vt
9) n o 9) F 3 P'd t 9) 0. Br o oa
a o :f o L rJ Ut
LA € 5 E hl (D 3 oo F r-+ Fa f6
5 (! 9J
xo
fD Fl o o
{o o Eb o 9)
@ o P)
o v, € (n tr F o
g F r' o o v, Vt !t -o o g s) 0)
3 t-l qJo o v,
&h, rH Fto
o o o t o o to p ,f
t-l o Ft st d o F| i+O o g) 0)
o H d o ct o o 5 o o
(t)
8n p
Ft
o 0l o H.E o vt. 5at € (a
v, o o 5 n o Fl
r' S os) o
n 0) $) )(D f Ja s E f6
0) o o tU2 P d :s o 9) 5s tit
Ft o X (D
F o o (D 0) o O
5
n t o ga g o 5' tr 9{ E $ I
F S)
o ; F g € v, v, K €I F
F $ o "d o Eo 0) Vt p
;(D d $x GtO E) o
Fl
5 s q) s o cJ o (D
E n'
:J 9r tA 0r o o o 86" 9) p
o v, o ; Fl 3
,!d o Ut
LA oJ p E o oid tr F
a € g o Vt 9) Ut & vi 5g oa
ro o v, (a F o €5 o 0J 0l
Ja E E) tFI
t |D Fl ts
a Ar
o n g FC' o 121 Fr.l n ct
F o vt C' o 0q o EJ) € o 9) tr o
€ 9l U) o F F t*) 4 El F F Ft5
ts g
5 o. N o c)
o 5 o to g) v5 ts. o O) 5 ot! Vt
g. g o 3 I o (D I 0l v5 V,F
s

Hsw conversati*nworks
27o How LanguageWorks

o.F g? tr
= sE
o'x'oo.
tr gFtf F,,,,-,
' E
* J6a-Pe;t : 9
,,b E**9
FF'HgaF trF s t FtrF HgH;
bF'bgiEA dEd [*ggEE
EEsiH,H
e; E 5 E HEES E e*e raFg.HF+
E +AE i Eg grr-q i€ F.i.ke EqE sFs *g3HTI
P + P Sg
AE T?tr ;tl srf tEaE[H
F$*##E9[ i ;is
9 FE P.H
SOvt
i:-E's E.g F t3; ^€f s qs3 ${*Fi"E
E€zlF
g$aq? cFH= ni
F€ s s;f 9ii Egi EfiHEAg
g€EEqA
e{aa*q EFs€ E 3tE
R E5t FIE Fqn i 's-- 5?H'
€gtE + F[;5'sH
i o Fg,F qrs*;*5ilFfa
E'I=HB FgEE P*'xfis
iEisE
iF'"
6pe€F
H$ kg:I F$+; g:ggEEE g F €
t$o.s
H [ +f F[g
r a*
*i6gs
E.g+gS
€ ag;:E
= Eg 6 E
*q E ?=
*93"5'H
fstg# aglg1lgrrtgg
flt0)FtH'
: t re€
a tr I I p
FIEE
ng;s E.Fl I[6EI gFfiEE
i€
e==o
= Z €Es
=='t
asg FE; =5?ei

l||

l- C
5 r .l ?, F 3 F}
B5. trE| F} (D
p F} : cl I
lrl F} ; p t,
(D {D !t F €
cx (D
Es l-t I' ah g) Fl
(D oa vt 5': u € 9) gts o o o o f:
fD(D n F r) v, o Vt Ft! g o
d o rD r) n X ts s f)
gr o o @ o -0) 5 o (n
qB g 5 ht F :i o o (D 0) u, o
qt
o
Fl o p o
H) 5 o g fD
od o
so
(! (D- F (A F) v) o s g
rfrO gq Fl (D rD E vro F fD FI
ro v, fD F p oq E 5 o 9;
5 f) x
{9)
F| 4
(n F| s) o F) I 3 3 iP o 16 I
gq FI FI: l-l o F fct o (D o
aE = (D EL(D F 9r
E' 7, gq Vt Fl ct v)
FI v,
EE top s) €
9) qq ,{ ' 6 + o) o o JD F o o o 9) o
t.) o v, t o ta
F gq f1
i;
-(r g o 9) o 5 co gq p)
,t oq6 o x o ov t oH o u) o d 7 5
H € g € 5 n P v, F 5 € 3 o 0q o
vt hl
tr 9 . 5 o vt
sl +d g o 0 s o
F v, 5 oq F c''C' C' 5 S) { 9
v, r) o
j2'r (a f:
q-s oa zo g) s 6 , B - go t o = o 6-E o o K o 9)
Fl
(D
K
fD tr o 5 tr 5
a5 oa FI F r) 5 F p
gr 3 F o
Fl 9) F F g 5 $ ts g oq
g6 v, 9l rD dA g o F qo 5 g) !t o 3 g)
o H F o o S) o (D a
3 () o o v, f) oa 5 aK
rd; (D g) =o u, tD Vt 5
Fl g)
ge 0, tn FJ fD o o o s)
-gr a* 3 d EE w w g) OJ 5
o g o tD o.) o -5 ta - 5 o X
o6' 9l sl (D (D tD p € 9) F E) 5 o F 5 X o
p 5 o * 0r n qq o g v\ i v,
5 5 {a tD 4 s SJ
o5 v, o o d K o o v, U' F !-+ 0l
$ s3 *A Fl fD o o u, t-l {
"c' F Fl $F) U) w F 3
H'o ct r) luF)
:crr C' o o fD r-|. E o FO t+ Fl
F frg ct p c, 0) f) (D FI o K o v) oa
E9 tD (D F s Fl n tn 0)
g H.tD ga FJ o ]15 3 TE
tvt g ro o TA v) tD v, JD
I
o. e, o (D 5E 0)
Fl E o s
d s ) E €X o Fl v,
F
o o d r)
oq d
o €8 p) (D J-| 0) 5 c
5 g s.6 o (t, F u, v, ,f
qa 0) vt g JD 0l fd o FJ
=;. 3 5 0) o o 5 F {D 9) FI
.DF? g d ga Fl 8* 5 qq { o o C' F FJ
JD tr { F o 0) 0q I o K
r-rH g) @u, o V) 5x o € F
)*o Fl oq ;-l s)H F o
g o $ U) (D 5 I 0) f.) f?
Fl
oq ct { g 5 ts $) u, Ut
|D FI gl F| o qq o d
o HfD o :s E 8 4Ft o g)
go o 9) r) o 9l Ut o (t E 4
0) € n t l Fl' C' d hl g) 9l (? o
@-3 n g 5 V, o o 9J 5 o o
n ; E6 It v, F tr ts fD
9J p) o Fl (D Ol o o 0)
fDF! o v) Xp) p 3 o ir Fl p F
o o ta pl
.(/j Fh
{o o) 9) (D o t6 5 (D
FE 3 -rt,
EP g
(D (D (D 5 s)
E v, I ct n o F|
vt 5 € vt 5 0J OJ g t1 €
(? F *8 g Fl
(Ax s) tr ts € { .) F oa n
f) 3{ K o F5 o tD Ftl t FtD
F 5 (D o o o oq o T
o Fja o fr 5 o (D p
o Fl 6' 3 5 hl
o0 v, F
o r-t o v, v, hi
tsF OJ o €r
p5 o o Y'l (a 0) 3 9) OJ
o FJ (D Ft
tr rJ
o tn Fl
F g FJ 0J v, o
s ut I q, oa hl JD o
$5 qq 5
tu,
E C' p o t, Ut (D po o 5 s+ d o { V) o
o FI o
Fl
s) n FlfD o Fl Fl)
{ 5 T o o o sr Fl $ E
?3. t: td t) Sht v) 5 o gq
rP o. 5 € c g o Fi! tD
nl
Fl 5o FI sJ o F)
o 3 3 o
E o m n 5 r-t o F I' OJ (D F)
hl
Hg S)
o ttD
0)H. 0) (! FI
o sE F o
fD I I
p c) v, g 6t (Do (! I v, @ o F F tu p vt I H:

How ccnversatianworks

r
272 h{*w Languag*W*rk:

i€EI$ EBE
E
'i$,iIEFEEEFEiEgI
ggla'clalla;eete
EE,6!
EEEEEEEEEEE
r
3
a tsl
I c o Ft- S) FtJI- o (1?n
o sI it € 3 3 Q (D v,
PtD - i -
a v'6 v, F) lJ
o
rv @ fD o 5 oE. rt', ra g'ffg' F. Y H.
rX 9 a-r r: 5 9J G
(t) o = (D oq 5o. o) F o.7p
ffD o o ui (D
=;-6 = o gq EE
s o Y o 3v, o
d .9 5ai o- FFIH
p o - d *..v
d 13(! o o +6 0) ? E3g gr tD
n o z =F 99.7f 3 o A'g
oq 3 Fl 6E
pJ o o -9 v, o HrD 5 g o o
H.
. r DV,F -.'+
(D =i; o '9)F;' "o D
ri -(/, o V) 0. F1 o)0) n O-'\<
(D o o5 x6 € o g) 5s) 55.\.
o o o
tr ,Ho sr ofD T f,F yo. F.
o o
(n o -f. o 5 + E
r) :=' -O o t-(D - i i
ta o 6a o !Jlt6 F Vt H t J
o € !.+ 7 o) gq o= p =. ol
€o o o u, OEtr
Fl. l-l o - F t
hl f) n TD E. t H. O' V)
K 5F
9- t:o A L . H (h oa
F.
a" rD FE Ku, o FC o (a oq 0"
o v, 6- f 5 o
6H n
o.; (D I s) i-i 0) o
Ff X' q $ K"6 H'g
FJ o o o-J tr fd5
s € n OFF T
o T g- v, 5 v, € n I
? v7 o !-t r,o o o -+I' :1 o o o
g o5 is
ot v, a VEI s) 'o d 3 F

rD o g 0) CLtr tro
+(D o .< o v)o T
o 0l ts9, €
n o n=. f1 o
F (D 6u) $) 5 G fD o o v, o {(D C' i r 5 ts.
T v, V) 5 5
5 S. I
5 V) g rF(D
F g rD
K A o -t
oa ts. -l
o io
wa o
u'{ cg q
o
FtfD
F 9) s) 5 .Fr !D v) sR"
l-r o
r-l tr f) =
o or -l o o O.I' fD o
o pr 3 OoJ E n n=
g) o o o o T
t (a 0l tD g)
88. qq H
v, 5 o g E. i; o
t= { Ut H. B FO
€ 5 ctq 9) F E. u, E' nj o v,
o ri=
vt
|? 9n l 5 F 6P p
|D 9) to A .'
-.O oa H ga 6E g YO
g) q'5 c fD s hr- st
g) o 3 r) d5
q ):l 9) o 50) o
F) g:o gq F 5 $ fDH
og
o (D v, H o tr o o
s rg6
@ I cr 5nt gs f)
tr 5 ' ;
o =s o gq o E'O v, (D
F gr Ehl
F) o- c) O-
o o q5' |.t 8E oq o' F)
t+t, !? gq
d So.
€ o5 F C' o o o5
-vr' o o 3 pz
o i' v, o gE
o oq o E po =.o 0r H
) od
o o o (D
fd n qE cr rr5
o ts o 5(D n
o rr(D t o 5"s v, c
F o vt X 304 rT
(D td 5
o 5 "6 d5' a1 o
(a
Fl
htfD
o gq (.) +8. I'5 F
l.
F
s) v) Vt 5 )
it o FE IA gq E6 s? sl o o

273 How conversatianworks

.''
H*w Langr-rage
Works

R! r +Fl'd
3 H5 6 E d
Ed
S 5'd
j'! 1*
d o 5
s9H[ffH
IJfDFlXt
P.5o-X'6
E'€ r E a i5
HE'8tra.e
d..gH F E H
F 4 6 er 3"P
6 ' F: H H t
iFrxq
f;5'X n E
= p ur +
' 6 &g ' E ' s )
o
ut i.i
H
Ft ;J ,t Ft

$sgsqB'
=9.v,

if
3 Eg H E 9 F
-l
e
= (D d
Z .d- +
or:
OiFlSvt-d
1P[ : ] t=
F =t i' i 1qF 5 q,
:: EH A
# FH-ol
v Y ! . t s V + ,
o;2,? o ro
o
'-b=H
f ) ' r. - F a g q

? +€ =='o
d € #
'. -d 6 $
:(r rd I
E 6'$rd
v. q -F H I
qT n € d
o' ca=' H
. - g: ^d<F r

D
ET -
= .tt d
a Ft st it
:i, g) TA
o gl v, Fl
ett rn FI
d fr
f.}
H5 o3o
= € oq (! o
lg o tr g)
0a 0q O. {? vt a € 3
x p ts 5 g € o ct
u)T o FB 6" o v, p) 5 g) (D
AJ
f;. v, ts fD 0) o (D v, hl
;o
0a 3 g) X i.) F U' o o E
ht o tr r: g o (D o f)
v) _c/l 9J 0) 9)
s?, rDp o a) S) F)
gq v, ts F Ut F, 5 o 5 x ra 5
t6 n
,tad t o o o v, o I S) o v,
Ut o n
8g
(r) Ft o) 0) 5 o o 5 st
(D Qsq JD -u, tsl
r o 3 E)
gJ 5 F p) v, F* (-J 3 o
:fl Lg o v) o- o 5 o q o
s# F) 9J { r-l
o)F{ o o p)
F
g
r) 4
o t *r
FIF hl vt v,
5€ Fl gt (D {
nE o tD € rD v, -r,fu
{0) o
.l .|'s) 5 v,
: g6- o F o K 0J v, -l
"o 9J
n U' FJ o o
Fl o sl o 3 c,
^
dvt o
#E
56 FI F C' tr oq
? o
fd
3 o o FJ
tr\
\tl"d
o o;+ F 9)
oq c p u, F
oq (,) o 0) o #@N
.x '6(D l-f) F !J
F cl Hl tr fD t €ou,
(a o E) o
oa Fff o o o o
=-r o 5 F o p
(n t1 5 o
63 s) o
rt t.) o s 9) F
-(a F tD s v, o @
#5 0E p) q9r v,
tV) o o o o F o
9J tr s d
P6 ;lf) $ OJ 0) ts o F F{ 3
o K g e F 3 o q
FO F o n 9) € U) I **Y
v, U) F F) Vt E
t5 o (n F o r) F
ci' u2 o oa FI o o g n Fb ***# q
Ft 6v, o o
r-l
o rD
f)vt
6" \ hl o (D n v, E
v, (b v) r) ? o o o u, &r
o6 o H'q 3
g) o { a r) F kt# fl&
Vt l5 n s
9t o o o q o fD
tsa o ft 9r Fl F p
o E
o v, O) f) 9l
o5 0) (D a a ts c Vt 0) fl*"$*
=n F K v, 9) 5 n
(? H{ f1 5 o 5 r)
(a
r.s o 0q o fl}
!'g F) 3. sJ
ga 0a F r)
6x Ut 8F o w d F) r" ***
J-< Ft fD o JD 6 p
rD B9 Ja s) o F 5
f1 o) \t (D s oa qa € s 0) 5
ra V) s I F o € gffi*
d o \J (D
2) (,n 0) o o o n \*d ffi
Xo E" v, ar 5 o) J/) F
gq F o o
v) t ' o = E. tD a \*#
rrt O)
\< w 5
{a -ut 5fD 5 o cra gq v, t $) (D vt
**ffih
=v) I'o n F|

.D o5 (D F tr
g, 9) o v, x E o ft
0a Fh sr 9H gq n o o 9J { tfr \# q*-"p-"-F
E' sl F 9) 3 oJ n c Vr
(a Ft o g (a I C" F{ gq Vt 5 9,
FV o vt rD
s-
ffiJ Lf,
\*d
275 How w* chocsewhat tc say ru
276 W*rks
l-4*wLanguag*

ilggg?EIEEEEFE
;l V5
s v, HiB
l+ 0J (a p 9'=.
at o vt gq SciS
d r.l 0) F6 p s
(!
g:
H-l 0) H F) s
0rIf, o (a o .ll o v'i5
t6 O+J $) 0r N g.h 6' 6'
5O F t' s) o F o ts\J o \
o q86 s -o o (! (,1 o
h
oJF, S o so ' E 5-F sFi$
u' -u) .lf sr(D
sST Fe*
=' =.ST.o v,
g H)
0) oq
P.=
s F
fD
fd
9) S p
:'+
(t) o ;i, I
vt =f
ta Y 3 '6
9)
q,
d5 Ed
(D(Dgs
\ Sp$.
g: dt e o o \S r)(D
6 i$ r$ n .G 9)
qa 0J r: d +.o sqE
d9 v: g, to
FF $J \h r.) 7l o : S.id ts
t6
qT E0 )sr ) o
,6 i;E T s) FJ !' rD' 3 C o >f r+ F) 9'e sqE
V) o ; 4 5
qq o N 5.T
f - S t€ g cu, ' Y tr 'Ho n F
su, 9J o gst ctr -
v, o o f(1 (1 a s.E
E F{ 0) ts FJ a tr 6 E ' , SE '5+
o F'B e o HA 0) ut5 f-
!-h if u, 5 95 t) ts.
or* f6 o F 9) F
ao. v, aY
3rF€ V; a
@' p
io F 5 "(, H \ RP
o () n qa 9r ;J V' o td o 3E 0)o - ,r. i-
0lo g8 Ut o o o 5 r)o. OOb)
3rSFFg, o
P Fr o o o o
X-= !? E tr Fl q5' sF5
€ q5 9H':o -\ fJ o € s, F FJ H 1 Ir 5(D
o o) o (D(D
F ko Ft g o o 5 0) et o a I'r q) 36
# gq 9q o ut n r) o 5 o vta R gr
qs F: f
fi8 to o (D t/t
b
nF,.
'* ':3S; rD+ a 9 s) P
5 (?
9)
p 0r 5cl
o; 3 I ;3 0) v) D)o v)O
g6- € F) o H E'O
;\ o [ ' IE
I B E 6S I FbO 7 5 F) (D}.t o5
o F) rD s) tr d H dO-r+
Fr3 qa n o o $F 5
{ 3F EtF 9)5 g, F o F s)+ v)
AoJ E o v, o OJ r) s
€F', !'!' ;{ o n FtO sr 3
Fi_;ssE 15 F 9) vr' o
E* *E &
ot 6' F tr g S) s) r-t o p a5
Fo o K v, tD s HE) elg
r-+ - n o o o rDH!
v,
6sa
O !-b o v, o 5
H { U) 9* 6', o at V,
iFE o
r
fIE o0) xa 9) .!t s) 0) fo 9J gR
,PH : HS
o 5 Vt
fd
B d (.l *n 5{ X.+0)
sE E S-E 3.: E3 0) n p fD go Fl
F) qH OE XoFt
Jb r H u, (D o o
+s r)o) 5 o F 9. Fr: !g c n o)|) E.
FJr) g)5 s) 9) 0) r) q9 o o- 9J o o Nc)
.E E H B
F) 7q' HF
E- H . ; d t H
€ u) f-) Vt ga^
ne o ro)+
ts o vt ='+ vto B'
s F
i\ J Fg o 5 o 0) 0r tD "3
p6 FrO
6= o vt
o
F
n
o
tt
s F6 H qs)
SL F
o er Fi
&s€
F: o ? F) F) v)
'v) (D
SS F -\ qA
ohl q 7 u, -n ,.o F Vt r) OF .aF eE e\ 3 S2 *
-l EN 5
JD oq
€9. o tr -tD rD 5FJ
Sor n o o s) !?
Fl Fdw
- il IFt EI A? 9;
^€H gfr H d 5 o r'l
iEE
EE. r) Vt o o g vt H 'o H d
s-3 orJ. rD vtH an
o F)
d q: e i i(D !? o € o :I. OJ
p vt
:r H HxB
u)
F. Ct
o F 5 9) SH
F s, F o o G(D
fDH) o 9) 0a- o .t € r
E6
sqrqqo E':+3 g o
{o vt I oo u, F Ja -ut rD gi" sF t"
o9r

H*w we clraosewhat tc saY

'..-"
HowLangu*g*Works

*gI
EgE
iiEEEiig,s$E
rgnFEi$EE
I =
'D :t p
gJ
f6
o trtr O--lX4 =o f.l v, d
9J vt v, itt '-b tD 5
Fl
9J qqf! rD S FE o o o B* :f
fDFr ()tr) I -. S) o o
r) n (nJ55
57segEE.F 5
o +r
(Dv, 0. F{
cv, oa
9' r*o o o 8 8 .
"o 5 v) o o v, tr o € (n
q, o i. \* Ji Ef;i{g€EE p (rt g) 5)
nr' n F Fl
rD fDS) q, o 0) nO E
l=rDo F tD JD
Fl
rD F6 I E I
rrO rD v, 6H
3* ,-\ o € d o o
(D = - .t': SJ -l E o o v, vt
r) (|) P) +€g"E'Ef7 o o r{: o
'6P rr Fi .6 r-t tr Ho.
Ft ll,
= E 6 q v5 P) H.
R P 33 e= o o f6
F) n
a'; g a o v, Ohl
= 'E o \J\f;qre* o o T F,.l' s o 9) o F F8
a to 5Ft g f E E 6
o:(/.. 6lt T o g) 5 pli OJ
g) Fb
=F' E o ? ga
a
'a T '
\rCq(D 9) 5o r) n
r) 5 rD '-t iIFlHsF 3 F v) E
J'giv, tr 9) o
0) r+ OQ E grD gE x. g ro o E '& (n
z, d6 o o o q ) t J Fi ;+ o
o o 'o n E xo.
5fD (D-{ it, Fr a€ g o o o =ht
r+X oa p) E o p '-r O =
o g .v) gr to Ut o
?-6 .J on
af OE r) o o €= ii f o 5 r)vt g
? '' q) ga oE o :9)
0J F{ o o g) I
0) F8E a o n
r-( gJ o rD g g . F:!9 F (n o El o
o' Xa+ g)
,t o
Ff 9','
sJ b o o v, 15 n
=o o 0) o 9 r 5. o o o o
o o fD
Fl € F 5 'ro I
X p o
(a
OJ E. q t h ci' x6
5 TE o 5 o oa o Ut ts
p) q
n o e'5
-o Fq v, v, S H
r-t tt o ts3. 15 g
f5' o n $,
fD Ff o
ts o v, og s) o F Fr
I 'Ti o 5 JD
t.) 2f |!
r) (D o 9)
6 rr. f6o I' OJ s. n
E
$
(D
HH (a r) o 6o
:io OJ o o
I E'x o p)
Vt o p
F
RA
yhl FJ 3rd
'd€ 0) v,
E 3g.
or
0) u, u, ; t-l
--* 5 otr o 0)
p v, t (D
E9
(r) . '.rtD F o ilE
q v, 0l S, -5
rD g)
o E€
t-t n F o 3
oJ (D a o V) o Xo
r-t v)
5' 5
6T p o
F o Vt Kol
ut F{ PH 9J st 0r s
I v, Fg
o lo o o K Hv,
o (D
f 0l F o .)
9 E n oE qa V) o o 13 5'
(Do v,

llcw we chc*se what tn saY


l-{ow Langr.r*ge
Works

ii EEFgE Eg-$F
EilE
,I1llu$g
Fi IE3'*FEl
*3[ EiE
iq; ;g [gg*$E
FFH-.11.ersrl[*tc;
!EigEIE€IEEEEE
a

6 € fD t.:.
Fl h(
TP rc 5 'sR =5!-rF=
o 50ri; 5rolaF
:< o H E
( 9
qq
N3€
0J to€
f6 g) sx o .Kq= 0d)^6 . { B F
Fl !
E' ,J ia
3 g5H u'Ai-+61
oq XEirro-oa
5
3 FJ Ji3o, d
' i 6H*Furc6)vH) '
9J 5 r-t fd arv
cJ F]
T F
X
E9.5'g
E o. *F.1.E gF+
o H.9,fi =p 6'
5 nFFta
o 2I g :.- v
r) o
o FJ =o5' E :+
d vt
out
c F(5
o sJ OJY

{ i f$ ffR-
v
I 3E E
F<(/tFf
(A -.
5q
F
o [i "F.D f.)
9JH
vto
3
c) G:€ €g
r+O
n
o A E'$ o
,o)8L Eg
r€; o
!'tJ
[i"
o o': p.
€ o
FbrDl
=D
nHr
F. Vt
At
H w .,,
E#F v1 h
F v' 8'
F rDF|.
Ffi3 i* r{O
JD 5 =.q' n*
f.)u)-j.
a) Ut
9J oo
Ff
5 Fi Ft
V F .
FHfl (D;t
5 E9)
(D :
5 0 ) =E , T 9 V, (+

z8r l-.'{*ww* chccse what to say

\-
z8z l*low Langu*geWorks #"ffi,
t
a* ry
.,!! * *-
ry
*d 6 t
& T
\sid
fr
trt
tu F
\*l ##
3$f r i igg gs t n3 .ss E* $$#
fr
fE
tt
\e#
-fu
I W3 d##

I$[$1g [1il;
Ig$$g$p$$I Il flT\
ef;d #
fh
d8 { f,,/
rF-HBf
;E[EtiltHagFg; ffi
**ry* {}
-*,-B ,41 t
L"LJ
frFgi€F
1E lEgEE l
['EE $
$E FtE
KJJ **T
-----
EFgi=i fl*fr k
*&
Ee$FFqEnf;HF+$ tt
sR
\#

L-f*
EEEErE[*EglFE tl
f&B"d
E3[1giIFacr*€F'* L*'d Raqlt

+E*xE*ii*g€rEEeegei
3i FEEiF$
iFgCF[+lEBf
F
v,
g
?t
E qr Ff * p Pt
ri D -| F t{
o (!
:' o (:l v, vt g &Fl GO Fl o :J
tD fl fD
so
(xI Ft o F I' 5 |D C' o l-l o O. o o 5
Fl) g t'D o Fl !t glo 3 o. 9l p oa
9r .6 g) 0)
{o F 5 o o
o € ,J gl
st! o
5 t) o o t) I, q.)
o p 5 40 I
F hl € vr o
s) 3 5
(D 5 5 0) oq q5a5t ' 0 5 o ,f o FI:
s, $) F) o OFh st JD Ut {+
r} o o ts Vt
oo { E F g 5o
(D u, 5 { H u) -ra' vt s) oa n o1' E p E
v, g) o SE Fl 5 o (D
9J a
Ft t @ o u, R fD fD Fl 5 (D oa
Fl o rD
g) g 0) p tD d Fl f \t tD
F
sg v, 3 5 (D o (D Fl g gr 0) sd v, p)
(, 3 oq fb o p a6 o 3 g n hl
0r o (n
o (D (D o € co 0) Cf r: 1< 5 q
Fl 5 o F) F E€ u) 3 E qq E o
OJ ga 5 0) g; -(a fD o o F] t o
5 o p o r-l o
F v, 3 i (A 3 3 r) r) tsl .(/J v, t d =
tt t u, p) 5 C' o € o s) =i'
f') n FI
o 6- oq tD g RS gq o 5
5 F o F 0) .J r: :s E3 (n
CE 0l t-l: n w o d s# F g s) TN E F.: o ; o
tD rr'rO
f)
g !t ; o
FJ'
Fl
s fr I o
Co
sr s) 8 EU' F gq o o I cn $
ts OJ
gt G o F pr 5 ;o, 9) r:
;ta Vt H. 5 hl n o Vt o o o gq
r') xo gq JD F l + . Fl 3 (t, g
0a A, 3 o tr I' F
g) v, tD 9r :iE 9J
.fD (? >< 9l o 0) fD JD 0)
o s) o F; o to9) 3 cr rD
w
€o
Vt ir (D t.: GB F eiq C' F o o @
o Fl
ut o € tFI tO1 r) o o Fd o
F) (D o {D t-t f)
g, 4t ct 9J Fl r) E
0J 9. E'
I ct g F';'
5 3(n. 0r H p 9) o
r) o fD o o K p e F o a
o tJro $l o Fl 5 o g o rl s)
o o t o v, FI: 5i' cr d JD 8t o
Fh r) F Y g (DO F) t-l 5 Fl P g
o !-h
r) 5 o o r-t
0. 5 ro 0) J.n g
{tD 5 fD
S E v,
3 F v)o o p) K o t, 9)
Vt o (u
C' c5 to 6-2 oq o o
V5
ro
5 4 ts' o Vt o (D tn 5a o E o gL o) sr 5
tr o o 3 o o FJ
p qq o
F) t1
:'o r)
5 o t.) F{ o dr' o fie v) 3 F F+. P" o o
0) F ts o Fl ts E o 5 F
v, 0l 0) o cl v, g1 :sE to p)
v) Vt
xo
v, o v, d Vt .(/J
8r, H *R o $ g
p (D
7l
o o CF o o o oq !
o ? o 5 iD n 5S F 0q o o o
d F '9J FJ qq o o 9v rd
o o rD !4o) 0) Ff5 o Ft) o 5 o
F o o t1 ct ct (n o o n
rD 3 (D O rr: vt E o (,) 9l
3 r) o 5 F, H)S tsl
o 0r 9) € n o $3
o F) v, vt FI (D o o o r: o
r) o o sl o ct 9r FJ o o ts
t: qq o (.) 5 o 6t e) tdX g €
9J X o oa t) F€ 3 H 6' p 5 tst5 g
o o P n n o tD
a 'c5
o o o
H o FI o o o o o
v, *j o 9) 0r o ct TE tD g) E.H o
o g o vt
F a
o v, o- 9l
t-l o 5 5 3 srE o F o 9)
I
FJ g, p tr C' 3 n 65 g
g u) 5 o FCiq
fD 0) oa o o d' E5. o o o s)
o o o u, Ut 0) I cr (n F 0.o n oq o
v, g) E{ { nto F F o
o Ff: 3 - r o ( ;JD o 9r Vr. o
o (D Ut
o .(r) 3 fr g (! F f * F f) $
0r s p) X a"
ni' tr 'ou, s) u, o oE' 3 T K €o Fl \J ro
9) 5 r) o ;.
€ 9r o 9) o o"u = 5 X= o o o o6 5 o rD
F v) FI
o o F w V) o
gq 9) € Fl
(D g Ut
0) F r) V)
'-l
r- (D 9J ut
o o o F gl $r $ oo E gH cr -j o 5
o 5 p o C' 9J
tsl V) o 9) C' o l-tr
ct E) zt tr o O. v, o rJ rj o o
(D 9J qq E (D 5 ,f (/) fD o. E) o o I o hl v, 0. rD I
E v, H€
283 Hcw we can't rhcose what t* sav
H*w LanguageWcrks

EtErtElllg6gglggg

igIEEEEElEEEEg
7 tl .9
Ftgl E HG
o vr PO qH 3 X 5
9r
FI f') o o qa t') o
hl 3
F tr FI ?tt
9] S)
(D
I!'lE .o.
f! o p d o Hl ID g E i t1 FF'
v, G g BE o 5g o o v, u, s) 8) o o
i-i ov, (,) o Fb IA
tg
t!
p o 3
o F
0)
(D
5
go {
EgHH
8: tsi- 3 $)
r.6
F
cr

s tD
JD
$) fD
F
qq
FI
d NB p
o t p 6: BE P ,-. c) (D 9! 0) vt H
d H'i: o o o g (,r u, F Fl
og
o
tD g,g g DJ t+ 5 Ft g 3 a,,tr9r o
F (D € xq' o g) o ct :5
s g Vt rr. o
v, 0) o hl d oa
o
-v, 9)o 0) t21 5 qr (? 5 !1 0 F
Fl Y b E q o -u!
-+ o cf. s v, I Iu F oq gq sl 0q
=' F o o
!t
TH o3
E5 D(D o OF (t N s" u, 5 !' 3
5 o F t-l s) o g ,t
o o s)
o 3 'F 9) Hhd o Fl o n o o
X
"o T H8 o o o vt o
F6 o Fl (a
t o qtst ta
ar o
Fl
F p ct Ft
E
P€
'o n Odi hl OT Egfil. € -l (a
p
o s) rd
o o o hl o @
5=F)o o F fD { --ut H v,
*ff p v, FJ o 14 oq E
?A r: trd 0) o Vt S Fl
o G gB xs t)
ts
o v, F (! 3 g td aH o
g U) (D B'6 BBsH t-L ,Tj tr o t tr o v, O)
5 o s, (a F r-+ C 9r F Ft s) r<
{D v, roP
hl to r : g FO U, V' 0) q-o It o E s) 5
gl o Os) t_l o
gH ts g o ;.(/J
X
g (D w
P6 cl 0l (D F o o 5 o PoJ 5
o o Fff s
X FH oii
e€ @ n 0) FI o o
o 3 tt F| oq fD o p 'ct o E o
o o
6' € .s5 o 5 v) €& FI
t-l .v,
o E . Ofd C' u, 9) \J
hl
9)
E
9)
F
o
X
6o
'of
z.
c) o 6 '
o
h|

o
3: i E
ntp5g)
oSo)gq fD
(D F)
;
5 o
5
s.
|!
o
r)
FI
!) o Sl F6
hl o ]A
csJ
g) r5 = 5 o (n s Vt q8
hl E'o (D ( D8
tr o Fv, o r.oX-5' o o o o Fb
Fl E 7 V) FI t:r:
(D d63 K pE tD o F)g ID
o vr o F tsl tr o 0) v\ o 5 Fl
-gr Vt o v, Fl p hl ut 5
5 3"d $|1 X v, o
g, Ft(D o vt s) 9l F)
o ovt
H F &T afrp $ 6'E
fD v, H€ c) oo o s] v, o v, 5
E C' Ef. <
gl tf
X D v,
o V, Fl)
€ fD
o
HEgg s K u, E { o td fD
U) o 8 3. 5 E8+A o (D
tr o hl v, €
E E* .r g e 5 q ct p \ vt R O)
v, o FP SJ tD o F hl
o K
o $) fD vt o tc o w ts 5
o u, o tD o n Ja
d o
ts| r: 5 o F p 0r F 5 F o
;H'
5 fDa g . 6B 9) € p U, tJ
o v, o o H o o E s) r) r) st ogl 3
5 $ro hl H I
F (D
X
or o
F
-rF
g.q f.) v,
srI$
=;3s) o v) o Ut s tD
o ttt
9)
F
3 6-
$)
x
ht T OI' F) s) K FI o v, *1 +rH
tD .) F0)
gEfi3 (D X o o vt F p
CI' FI g tr o gq
cl fD o o o r) I
'.6 o
9J.+
E,A 0)s) B;2 € (a t! TP
-l ct + .< fct (D
11 F t-l F { t, F o E.E. $
o gq 9-o o (? tD 5 v, 0r o F E' i+
Fl cr) ad 9l
5'oa 0)
€g
F o rJ p 9) r) o ; v, 9l FI
tr 6: o V) Fl ta (D o d6c-
v, X o Fl
o v, stB s s3g: o o o o n 3 p o
(A hl r) Fl
X fD r) F hl 3 B
r, t Eg Eg 0J EE$B v, C,) 0l o
Fl
0) F
I O.(D v, :-5o.gt I I o o o PF)
v\ I A. ? o

285 How we can't choosewhat to say


.

286 Howaanguage
Works

EgtggEiEl
Iil'ggglggErga

EiiggIgIEEEIigEE
iEEEEEEE
E
=
F
t
CI Ut d
Fl
-l !!
EF (D ;;'9f-
A fi FtfD €
o -6 u, hr= o o
o g :3C 3F F o 3 u, =' r: g n=.
9l 3 u, H' nt €
o (D =f.) S) tu 30 o=' o o n o F
r9 (D g \J 0) vt
a fD
g) F Ja Fl (D 0r )-t 3 F. td
at 7l f!9l
FB Fl tD g) o sJ Ee 9)E o $'g
ttt !-l-r =.o (a Ut .o (a € d 5 o
s,. v, fD r) r) o S) hl g:3
H-o F v2O Vt hl € F ' . o 3 o
I -(rt
:3 .ogsF) s) v,
o f) r) o
Fl ct 9J ,CJs X € :9 5r n 5 p o s
gJ I toA) d @ 5 o
{r) H 6'A Fl oo € 5 F i' HF+
F o o
g ( D s5 p (D \d p g o 0, # tD $ oq p
G Fl 6'I Fl 89 vi o s) S) F F) pJ V,
6E o s) g) :s 5 sJ tr
d
O(.) g'E a 9J (t, o m o o 5 0q c)
o E '15
c) o +rfD o oa F ga e5
o) g cl E HE K Vt Ft o o o :<
{ o
F,3 gs o o E \J o fiE F o F
o 88" ag o 5 o o K E; o o p (D S)
so
|) tr F) ;c9
:E I Ffg o ? "o o V, Ff v, F
c) -ut ftt 5 3 v, "(t Xr) o i!- s) fD JD gt g ts
(D nhO
r) o\ F.l o i'0
I o o o 5H o o'
Ft
I. ov, gr C' o
f!o
5 oa
Ft fD 0) 5 o .) 3
ttt 9) g OJ 9) F) o EA t6 Ut tD 5
?tt Hl. -q€ v) =j 5' w
:'L) v) Td F) o E3
fD= 5 o s b" s Fl
o
fcr o .) g g)o 5 3 o - EH
xo o ta Fl 5? n o n K
!) FE F
tt
FI p JD t 6 o n e'o o 5 I.o
hi' o. =q ts gt o rDF F C' ?d F s) g gq
o hl 5 Fl v,
Hi t
;p
o og o EE. 6 o) p) 9l NJ o t+ o fD
*) +6' s) X s) o
v, Fl v, o d
s p 5 s
Fl
ox r+ "O o Fl 5+ o0) 5
55 g C' kg o f)
v,
36
o .('l o
v,
E to
a
€ wo 9) v, o.o F JD
I hl
o ra o
o o q o 8!i . 39r
v, U) rfi o P F v, F E'E €
(! p 5 9r, gq (D L><
o Eo ho hl
o nti o o p) F) o' o
G 7f tg Vt ta o E '6 gl(D
BA s r.O +H +: o P
E8 o gE o 3 OJ (.0
j € F g) -+
o
ta' 8:r vtJ
9) (D o v, o 6to (a
fo
tt) 5 n o 0r -l
v)
5 + 5rr ovt H aB' F Ftl C' g6' ts - o o v, X s3
o 0l F 5 (D o g) +o
? FI: 8a' o 3 tr :s t , g o p)= 5 r, o
o .?& fD o r) g)B C' o tr u, o ts
1-g Ut
to P.O (D F
s o €(D of n F o tr E o t#
hl
5o f-t) F 5 { p)
o o oF o 9rn K (r, v, o O. r+ E
vtO o Ft
JD v) En
tsl ni' o
s) oF .q ;
Fl 6-fD
3g r-t F) 7t s vtF '0J o o pl p p,g
2f o o 0a O H (D o o vtP
o ao B'g F 0J 9l o 9) o F 9) E o
9) EE ahr s] p p g o p 0) o
p Ut s d t-ii |.+ Ut tr F (,) o u,
(D
o F
5
F'F
-vr
I
V)
grS EE 9)
5
r-t F nl oq
tr
o
0)
v,
o 9,
sg
IS o
(D
9r
n
o p
o 3
E8
id s.
FO
g] o v, FlrD
E.s (.) 0) o 5- !t ct w tD E
v, o 5O. o ta 8E 5 (D
v,
5 gq .J
tr o r-
s 0) o
o F) 6-(D -(/J
F o
E S) =.E s) GF ts v,(D ttr u,
tr FJ hl =b Ft S) o *a
ut (t, [iP 3 F) r-l gq o 5 t-l
o v, 6E 5:s G F) v) s) FI Ut
,\i
fr o € F V ,
;5lD F p g fr 6H F oq o
(n o tsfD o) oa s. Y O o o g - 0) oq gJ HE
n F .- v, P vtg 9) 0, H ;
o Ur= .)E Ut C' F) !t o F ^d
F F) of, s p g st p E 0) s€ fo 5
pJ gq 9) F) E' n l-t F o
9J fD ct o ta p ,J U' g o o 0). oq f1
o Fl f) Fl o Fl o F 9B
I 0. qq g Eq $r F I o |.) g $0) ? I I
5 f? 3 I
(oo I I
o o I

287 l-iow we car:'t chocse what tr: say


288 H*w LanguageVt'*rks

i€ a; Fi trHi q fiF [B
[[.f,8 H HrE:
E$FaiBTisgr*
t;:HfE:pAEsx
E1€$EF:Esq:;
€reig;triF*il
iq ; 5rF;I EH3Fg
E e"ilE 1F:3H HE
E$$g;iFFAe
fEA$iETgS?r
s; g
F * [EEf I B rt
8 e E E E E q e. 5 E' * r i
r H g.;"F,g.Fg *'E q s
*EEFBg+;"9;
HESE:?}SlHFEH
*}gEiq;E*i sg
= i s 6l E i ?7
: = 3 F; ==: =

tr;
7 r !b f-t
.? 'E = r-t tlt gt o
F It fD 3 g o
€ d (t o gF; o o w o vt
o tD 'o @ 0) l-J
s g
fD o ts -€
oa F r) a) o 9) rD
o K r) 9) 3 € o {
v7 +
Vt F s) 0) o tt U) fD
u'1 E
n€ IE 5 BP o
Fh o g5 (D
v) 5 a) $urfD 5 rD qq
(D
F) F) H F T H Fl
o FJ (n fD v, ai ha ;.j.
rDct K
0. Vt 0) H. h{ w o o
o oa o x o 0) o id cto oq p) cra
t-t
o o.gX Vt o Ft (o
n F n pr 0) r)
0) o o o o o rd
oa (') o 0) ,6 ,f
&a 5 Vt
o
o g { qq
o n Er+ n #E 9) o
r sJ o o o Ft al n
:- :- 5 o oo= (D o cr N
-l v) rD v,
qq
5 s) o; o
x o 0) 0) s) g
v, o s) o v, s5S o
d o oq V) t-t
o t - f l G o
€ o d v, o oa
rD n 56Fr €$ ga
B,
o o o\' 9)
rr7 fD o F o 5 ffi **J*
r) v, FF o Vt g
so
at7 d v, OJ FI v,
;dS
(t o o o \t
fr H g E(D o o o
o o g)- 9J 0l v) fl*\
ca rl7 o H v, o *P-9 nrb FI
o
{v, oa Vt o
re \*#
Vt J JD s) o
n 9J o ; ' ET € o o %
v fD ;g) F) 3A Fl-
v, o
o o $ C' v, s) 9J il fo
ga p o sJ v, u, p
Fl F o v) o '16
g) oq tr a Fd:$, 5
tD fD € =g= o oq
f,*
g {
E qFrr
{ n I V)
$ o 5 o NJ
gq .gao p) F qa 0. o o -'"o ,tr v,
0) v, *
g)'o(D x' La 5 (D
0) I Fi hl o sJ qa urs o
(a v, vt q P o a) Lffi
N
o o o 0)
-vt E) o o v, n o n qR d%
5 Efi€. o- o I o
o -v, € n
(o u'ito o o
€ E FJ 5 vt pJ € F 5 U
o FJS 0) $sc@ffi*
ffi
CI. o o o F H :€ I 9) qLt
T 0) n g € o=o o qR o g 1
o r-i A)
o
Fl a (a
X tr ct @ E.L ffi. s
ts JD E;* o SJ
o Fl V H
o o s cVt
r-) v, Fr-
d6 ,r o v) **#
o rD r) tt) E o oa X rd o
o 15 0) o 5 o 5 o **S"u
o o ts| o 9. glE o &F $a {dq,
? 5 5 sJ 5 o ci' € **%
F v, 0J o 9 fr"\*
oa "o
g o
,r E
o o
tr
3
o
P #.qE o
g3 o
(t t
|a (a
o .ffi
ru
tr\ ***d +
"*.4i".**".
FJ o q t o u"d
9. gq X oa g q qurQ. F { ffi
FI o ;rB s EE
0J g0r:' s LJ .{--**n.$'-".$
9) r.t) s FJ \*d
9- 9r o o I t-+ o d.F oq d *X
W
ffi
;
289 $-lowwe kn*w where sofiN*#neis fr*nr flffi
l{*w LanguageWarks

il*Eglgag'gIIt
,filI1EiIF*ggglggg
ig*'$FtIiFFE
iggilggE EEEgFIF
EEf,F
EEEEiIEF€EIEI
=D
9
(n
5 tsl
Fl E 3 (t trt w *
= ttr
ut iJ 5 t-t
F= |!
5 0) oFt
v, t fD .g* $) r: =
=tu 9) o a* Vt v,
g p Ff, (D >+ o o E6 ga
0t ct ts. 9J F F Fl gq
g g) hl o 5
o r) ; ,JO
7f s vt 3 S Fl w -il d g
o v, f! It o o tr o f6 $r) v, g) o C
3F rl ci' F 5 s Fl
F)
F S+
'o o Fl n F og s o o o F o tsl v, er l-5 (/t'
o vt o 9)u, gq Ol 9) Fi FI: v o
o tD f) !$ v, o
A. o o Fl F 5 o o 7l o o
Hl t.)
o C' (D 16 F '3H F o
H'3 p F ; Fq v, l-l so 5 0) FI
Otr 0 v, a Ir o Vt ofD
sg z s
,') 0) ri' 5 o o (D oq o o
Fl o o 5'
9l I6 0J OJ o g !) Str FI 5 -l r5 0)H ga
r-t i o 65 s) x6
68 o (a F o u)|D c) H) g l.l o
g) o 5 o $ o o gq
3
5 jo I
g) E
s0) It 5 F Ft { F o o.Fr c) o-
o Fl
o ; o4 5.tr o 6g 9) (D d 0)
o o !) gJ 0) 5 o Ou, o o
9., .J xd6 5 d o u, H& pJ oJ'
t- o3 ct n Fd
7l
(D tr p$ n (a 3 q6' d 'ct
7 1 o p r) pa v, 9. o vt o (D
o g o5 v, S tr OF+ fo
EO o 9) o
do t F o .ur g# 9) f)
ts o
g) v)
Gt) FI FO o
oqfD F v) ct o {o € :F Fl vt Ftt
n
o g (rt o Fl o cr t
o o o F o K 19, o r) 9) o v, d o (n
g3 g) C' gl ,f o F o E s o
a:t 5 v, o gl t.)zt vt
B'E (t, I'
o o Fl n -O H6.
sl :- 0) orE o F p) € Ut oa o OJ
3 I ct o FI f.) s) 9l E eHo
0) g g 5 FO r-l v, s
; o 9J ts o rDo o E
n F JD (D F ( / , r d :J
J o € FI 9) P€ |! p) o
n
sU) 0J
o ut U) o o 9) F o s 0) v, 7f #$ o-
o :3 F ts
o F fr'€ 5 s) v, ni!J 5
ht oJ
o 8) t) g tr S) o o 9) 7l :5 o rs 5 o o
,f v, o p p o v)
=H c) F El Ev, 5O hl V) oq J ? S 'o s)
'i'r 7. o o 9) o { rDH -g Ut
o p s o
o sl w 5 0) o o S hl =
@ 6Z o o) Fl o 5 .o o v, F. { Ut Ftr)
o. H oo Fl r) g tsl
t) o
I .l o o n FIH o o o
>{) n q it (D oq
o p tr U,F{ o o $(D pJ o C'
v, vt F rd'
hl Fl
aFi' o c
o X 5 tU)
H€ o 5 F tr €'t! F) o o
gq 9l o 7to v, 0)t o v, € o fe tD OJ
$r u,
sv) o 9)
q t-l H: HH Vt )-l
s r) tD o
)-l i' 9)
Ut g O.r g F ga
oct E o (D gq ru U' o n o 9) u, o 7ri" .q
Fl o 5 n u'U 0) v, r-t V) o o o
o tr (1 0r o P 5 u, o oL.
o tr o
Fb F €g o f n rc o H s, o L,1
cnq T$580 (,) g (a tr fD Hq a1 5
F \tIJ F v, c *l (D BB r) fJ P) o o Vt tJl g o €
? o gl o gq ;t o o t) 2f f) 5€ o
,f bo S) o 9r a)
(D oo € F (D fD o v)
n cna r-t g) o F *s 15
U) o
{o t \ to oFl
o v, i-{ g) gd6 oq r-t a) € o
o Ut g o o o
vt 5 El d sJ o 3it o o
s8
OE n € 5 JD Vt H 'S 5 5 gq ru E
tD 0) o 'Ffi c5 9lc)
o o fD U) tr n ; o o FI 5o) (D
0) (,) 5 Fd g) 9" € 5o tr o s F) (D rD o
v,
o 5 gq tr oq g) FJ r-( f) rd e.ft
E gq g ga v, s) sE' u, oq Vt v) V)
ir-il E Ut r.l
o o s tg) F 5 5 s) rD r+. "C'
6 Vt tn 0) ga € o p o9) S) o 0)I' ct o
9) ta 5 U) o r) qd I'
(,) no
F tr o Vt tf o o 'i' g o tr 9J
0J
o v, v, Vt 9' 5< I 7t
I o v, 9' a) i'l e o3

zg1 How we kncw wh*te $onlr*ne is fr*m


How Languag*Weirks

EE
EglggElggggEEE
EEggEgIrgggsgE
3llt
c :t5
ft ra, qi
0 fa -l o rD
5 (!
F I H s 9r 9) (n
FT (DrD c v, o (tt
h| Vt U:1
C (r! d (D r) s€ d
7 v, fDF) !) td 9) (/) fr K 9.
U' i' :s t?d FI o d =
fD cEr o r) tD, r) @ 5 9t Ut =
n d
-l o
V)
t
@
fD (Doq
5rD 5 o
Ut
T
hl
S, o
a
rs ro 9J $
E E F 0)3
;9 F Fd
cra
Ro
1v,
o "FF r.l i 9J o
Ffr
o (DO
o fD c g 5 ts fd u, F) o
Ft r/rS
gq
ss {v,
o oa o o o (-' F'F 3 f
(D F) tD g)
E c B o .aa ru 9) o o o
0q r) tr P S. I, qo rD o o o o € 3 F H) €
{ (D 5 o hl o dv' o
r] r) v,
d Evt E g fD EF
o I V) o oq o o Vt F
F o o Fl o 3 z.o fo E Fl rD o5
0) 9n F r| 5 JD o E d i'i 9r (D o
Fb (Do
s) ;
(-J
E ' go 3 6"
o n F) o v, o fg
o €
rD u, o .( F f ( . )
o t-l
rl
r) v, hl
o
Fl o o
'D F) F6' € 5 o (D € td r) s) rD H z
Fl 9) r-t 0 ld
o v, o
hl
-o
5 6-a o Fl s, FI E) g: € tn
e) o { u, (D
q- 0) g E'{ ct F o
Fb
o
F o rg $, o o so rlt . gF rD o o H,=
F {o - (D g { 5 F o 5 fD :tr i
e sr o o;' g n i+ p o o K o
et, vt 5 fD ii
0, €H' o Fi Fl IJ v)
o $
€ 5o p
ht
3e 55 o 5 (a 5
rD o € o o €a F. 6" 3
.D
3
fD o) CDE a) !b Ft $) rD
p a
f $ ;f
@ r' rd (DF|. I Ft n It o 9"
o (,) tD (t,o 0) 0) (D 0r 3tr F) o 'o"
{ v, o 5i' 01
E I qa 5
9l 5H 3 ga (D I 0)E o :f
v,
o €g € U)
o, o oa 9) Fl n r,'o u, H r_l o
v, Fl (,) o o oa s cto Ut o
(D
o g9 o p o o v, €
o o € 5 n t o5 o o o V2 o
v) t o Fl oif ut i+ ct F o F
o v,, o a : g
9J -d oa f.) F o (} hl FI (n
Fl sr { o t) FIO
p C' g, Fr: 3 (D gJ o o
gt tD it (D F v, oH €
0l Eq v, F fD sJ p
9) (! o fr Fl 3
q9 5 5 Fl 5 d €
qa r-l
9) o o r) o o g O. cJ')
7l Fl oq o o Ut o 5 sl E v, o
F o
5E tooa "
c! o (D t-l o .B p g F t.) F o ir 5
5 Y- 5
€o,
Vt ga 5 o o .g o PJ a
t o ,C' o a 6 ' F v,
sd 5 . B oq r) 5 p t) 5 w 3
FI o FI
(? o o ts 3 gl !h FJ
F
o5 o F) |D
o 3 $E'
o (D 9J
F o t.) u) f) 5 o Ut
r-t (Aq o F 5 o vt tD p $)
o r-) Vt n X sl g € tn vt v, t! o o fto E
v, Vt gl 5 g tr
fDo E g 0r 9J
Ut v, o 5 v,
f} o) o n o o oq
hl
fu n 3 5 o 6# S) o rl
€ 3 EE FFr) (D o n fD ct Fl cJ
d 5 9) F) hc' 5 g5' 3 n o 9) K s) F $) I.
(D o Vt c) tr ts ni'
hl F n o oFl € c' o (D P
v, o g JD E F 3 o V)
9) ' o1 o trfi tD 'o Fl
(D 9) o o E* fd € Frl
1CJ vt eq ; ts qc g
vt 5 r) qJ 9) 9, o vt v5 v, 5
€H {D 5 o F 9) (D F
o FJ F $v, o
o_ o oa
o o o
Fff F o 0) .dX n .ur o { o to v) r)
t o t?, rD o s { t.+l JD sl t)
9) o Fl I g r) €
(tt 5 Hl rrd +< dP o o ;& o 5
o o o v, F o v, v, o o
o gq 5 o o oq r-l o
s) o 6 E 'v, ao tr ? v, tn 5 (D ? €.d 7l Vt F
Fl 0J o Fl F
F : ! l n o
+ v, o oa o X Fl tht !J 0)
o o D gG p o tD g vt
o w
F o oq p
F o F .) v, { oa F hiG 9) g) t
o 3 I l.t (D 9) q.5 o g q v, s+ o X o o p
K o H'R

zg3 How we know where someoneis from


294 Hcw LanguageW*rks

=i li[+E €: Ef;H
HEI r€6i 6[g [ +s
a-ei*i;$g[1
lE[ [grEEu:+:
*rtgj H$* i$il
i
*gggE
HEF[FF+
snfi$$[lgE
;l*+$fI sFE
E[sitE!q
o
?t
ro
tt -s E -t F *€
ra @ tD
ta Ot 9' I c o € s-=-
o CA A T14 t'+- 5 h|
U)
(,: s
(!
n -('r o 5 oa (!
E ' E rs tr E'E
I' o fD € dg FJ
o E6
o. v, Vt 9g olD (t, v, v, (/r $ rsE
3
(a 9) F)
r) o F)= X9J d F) F t! ox'
a o (D r* o HE 5 o
o
5 5 >ln g6' S)
ts oo o F 0" -ta ?
g. o. o o !a a 9' ? dg
hl F E o o n
l) 0) al- Fl H
H ' Ho
o (D o
(D Ut o Y*O Fl p\ ta ES 5 EE
o o
(.) n v, F f:
B, o ttfD Fd So
-gt o € 9)r+ tr s o o.s T lA
n v) u, 0)
50 o \s Fl
9. E S) ? p
o' 0l 9) hl uli u, fr TD ra
faiaE
0) E o, w g gq \t o fi_* Rf n -gq
F
5 E g (o (D
0) g) EB F
Fl
o o 5 Fl' O'
F e,,F €g 9)
r) 0) o lrg 5 o r, !'o Sa)
o o o 0) o o9. 9l 5
n € r-t
*T-
(') 5 svt q
v, vt Vt o o F H;
o o r) qa o s . E otr U , Y
E.E
'a 9J H'€ o o E' E'
o - o FIO o 3
Ft
fl
p o e U. gq E 8
t(D o {o ffi,
n { tD o p o
s =o s) HE'
"d 5 9) pg 9) 5 u, €8 IJ
f.) v, fD
so
o o C' n 9r o iE
o "o o l) p) s xo si u'
-(/l
p FlB o
g3 lte.
€ cr rd o. 9) (D trtr 9J tD \5F
o o 0, o (D Th ? .s5
l-l R8 fD o 3 s
o o -ul n qE o H' 6'
! ts 9) 5
Fl ,g nt/, v)
o F
x,'Eo o r) ;=
; gq o o
hl
Vr+ g, a- AF o v, **&*
o ta E) S.€ r-+ f r q
tr 0r s) 5rO E '
tr tD tt, hl r)f.) o ts S)
S) o cr oa Ft 0J ffi
tf)
CE
5p)
5 ? d, g. ffi,
o o. o fD qq 5 o 5 0q e.--*&*
o l.t gq o Fl F8" o
n v) s It o Ut F)v) oo u, 8 t*J
(t, 5 E u, fo o g)
o' tsl K
o u, g ga oU9;
(.) o 5 r.) hl n s FJ
o o 0)
o #H Ut T 6
rDrv pX
F I E
E€ s.s r{g
q.g}
5 gl g)' v, g) (! =
v, (D ti)H
o o
f;E3 F{
o ) V) m.
SJ o cr (o F 5 o 5* tr
gq tsl T g) n v2 S.
o 9) HE c
c"***fu $.*'a
#4flffisss
rD I o ? o XO ro
o ffi
fD 5 v, o 13g o g, g' H I {M
Ja F ut A" rD 5 tD(D
r{ OJ o o d o FJO ts CF d n tu*
o o 0l g { o t)Ft o s. (,) eL ?' r ff\
C'
n 5 o E t$
F) o g5' s tl q g , oq 59"
(! F{: 9) 5 rD I
s o FT X E
"**-**
{}
&*.e**6
ffin
$ft
\d6
ud
How ta st*dy dialects
296 l*low LanguageWorks

-{ 7 , ' e "s 6 5 + = . 9 6 ' 6 ' 3 E g 6


(lD
FsFHsPg$Ft*fH+o+155 fi€HE
tpfFes o
-t. 1+iigAa€ss+T-i3
q9. FggFf6*EEgeq$[H
g gf g: vl
+erI*1ggggggsEE
Fq lF
I 51i$i6 iE r r F FEil $ EfEHI; o
o_ :Irfid;Hs&Ai3=E-
J,gE oJ' hO
i F qE s ggE a
=. v, p :i b_
H3 H.I r H
<1 ^ 5 p or X, -i:
rD
r; n
r-t (D
E
Ei;iHEilFHgI;FEE
F qsqsE[ +i ]€ F*gi o
f E i FgfrC
$sf 1fl o
ga g'F f & 5.f H g 3 -t ', ", 1 5'
11i$[$*5[f€ax+t Ei. I * I 5
*:Er3sF€q$;[€[$
q i s s Z Ri €
;ie:iH+$ifl5Egs
frH 63f,':$tifilgqfg
i il r a ; E$ F
e*sAIffi$6$3rnE* [ * tE ss
E 3F,g* F f f R r r d H 6
sutrtra bEEc+*gI *rE#$grrssEtrE
$I g $;
6
; s r q 5*' +€ *d f5 :3:o
aIHi*Fl$iHEBa,sHf;rHsHis *[s+[q E sH a $fi

+[i1]a*
;rSi+$1r==z+::iiE=; :; ?
(t! ilD,

rDd
5 g,G
.l rD
S 'E r til
FT ttt P
r{. P
5 = ut
7 t Fl F; €
7 t-l gl € do
Eg fD 6E ( D! t$ !, gA =P t
Ft 5P Ut
5 =' \. ri, !t Vt (A
t(D
g)
B E J fr3 hl gq
o or-b F v, o . g
c FtfD v, 5 -l E.; g) o
?g vt lrl 5 '+ q o hl FI:
ihln Arn c o :3
o 6' :s o tt, o JiJ5 HU' U tr g o .
5 5 = tgt a(D o sq€ Ft (D FTI v,
1 / . ^ s r cr o gs
F& oq q1 v, o sg) .01 o- qit v, (D
+ u, o
Fl
o "o fD 90 o Ko tr 5 ia" 19
n r-f o o EF F Fts o E I a) Ut € 5
Vt oo eE gJ fd o 0r 8F ;g o F* g
ut v, o gl F)
t ro .:1.', 3
6 po 5 o Cnt rd r-b (D o
Li" vt r)
- f r t s v,t? B
rH o o F 0) o P? Fr. F o Ed
v, Fl o g JD O,< F o
69" Vt (A r+ 5 v, a6 s)
€ E o 5 Ut gJ o o o g Hl 5
5'o.
d Fl ?$ o &r Fl v, o oqd
!g o =r Tt p v, pt E g H: o) o v, riq 6 H)
F{ qo ,a6 V, t-{
5F o 5 r) $9 E'O
5€ (D $r+ ? * o € 5
' oH) (-0 gq oFr E p
o v, FJ O. tD rD s o fD g
op to c) IF 33
FbfD Nr{
(D
=€ V, tt
9) Fl tD 3 € 9J d p) trF
FI o z< E,H B6 o o fD
o E* o Vt ori Fl
:E
v, lv,. ! g) o
FI
€g' 5 5 93 vt
a d? v, .) 3 @ +H ga 0) (D ;-l F
7l vt V,E o o (Do E8 sF 6'9
o o rE hl g AF) o
xq. 6E o o o s) (.)4 (D
€ rnF FE F 5 o 5 ut o=
Eo 6E v, F o 5-. s -No ;6"
sl (D t-h 9J -*
:E o o E E ts€ € o' o o rJ F3 9) o
=vt t0) 8s) Fl
S-g o gE o F
-o g € F6 FI El r+ E t.E
6iE 5 o p vt f) p o
x F Fl iJo ( D< o 6E (D 0t -"1 e o g E E PF E3<
rrD
r.) i- or , € ct 4 EF Vt
:1 r o o f $F{ 9) F Fl
J.tD fD F7t o o .itl str qa rD { o )
5 9) s) q
ov,
29E. p) E3
f) z< F x' S) € o (D
-'0,
F gg) o o ri' 5 6 vt g) 3 B* 3 gF
9) o t ' q9 65 - vt s) tr e r* € F o ?
o rg ,d 9{ :E*. ( ' 0 p vt 6.3 o ?D E' tr o
g f ; s e. H' F H. ltl
Fl F 5F o v, $ Ut (D B 9t 'lJ q; -l 5g
tD $ n og. Fl FS F) 9J
o sB o Ft 0) w I 69 v, 'd6
(o o QO 9) ts 8 " 65
v, o o fD
33
EH o F)
tU'€ H.
F o
Fl
i+
(D Fl oG. (D5 vt o) o F TTt E o5 I F
o ga o o $ o ga
zo 'i6'
F o
ao g Or sJ, 5s) Ei o 'q' B' op on d' 3
i68+
€9 o F g 5 f d 9) o s
gG 5
r€ ro o
F o
s) Fb
6.s g5' (a F€
F)x o € 5s) 55 r) JD c) 0) t# i.f s5' o
Fl Vt Fl aR
?H $
rD (D g) o s J o o EE.r5 Vrtr (D d
Fih qc
ES' q9
tJ (0 6- X C o p ta od E) tr*
Br E s (,l t-(1 o o \J Ut
0) dq
{ : y,, o rs
fD Ff ct FI (') qq 5 q 3. s)
FI KO .: og. €
=a tD too o; 11 E p r=Fb o
l-l 5 HE o 5n o tr 6H >) s op' o
\o o qq JD =P n OH F oa .U) o ta) #E
-. (D 6'e F o o v,
U) F plH
g E oo F t.) Et Eh5 F6 Fg
(D-o E)o F o f.) E.{ $ 5 f:
F3o s
sa' P (') o o) r: o 8H g g) F: 8 \o JtA
5 p F o ntF hl o ili g) Fts
o 6H o F) o fD oF'l
g o v, 3
F6 Vt '(oa * ?
F € FE E 3
vr{
Cv, u, vtO F 19
s-+ g o g) g -l o sl oc 9l
s.. f . i l
7r ). ihl g F.l l"o fDv, rs d $o 8[ v) o
fD F.. D o 5
g
{0)
p) FT )'l cf o 3il
H& s)F EE
F o o ts{ g
5oa oq 5I Vt :+ JD 5 0 55 I H tD o Ut o FE s

297 Hcw to study dialects


298 How LanguageWorks

***@
|rl 9q
qq

j
F
o
X
.)
9J

vt
o
m
o
ta
vt
o
v,

T
I

iJ
Ed
FI

0,
5

o
o

!l tgF
o p l-ri @ ut Ft =Cw
€ ta p
o j it P) F1{ o
I 3 at o- tD EU f)
o H6 0) F)
xv\ rT'! t
fd rD r) t)o) o 50 F sHg
Fi! 3 o o F =E o€ gd o
9)
fn fo o
o it F) 9) { F u, v, F9. fD
0t a v, 4 = 0)
Fl o vt t, o F
?a n o g Fl sg Fl
o hl (D Fl qa o €
i 0) 91 t) c) Bg e6 E
g vt 9) o- Sl Ut Vt
9) tr -ur (D 0)
fD
F ,Y 3 p it g) o
3 H6'O 5" v,
Fa€
F (! fD F o o qJ' o s, dgq v) r:
o p (D p Fl C'
oq sr Se, o
gE, F
5 5 F o 9) t-l Ut (D o tsB;
rJ c) X o (D Ut fD c)
r-t
o n ilF F 6.5 d Hl
FI r.) fd n v, N
o f) g, vt o v) .58 t, r) 9J
o 3 n o t fD o v, sf. oo c) F 9 n
E 9) o 5 o n 6 E:3
{o otr
o t+ 9l vt o 5o) s) 0l F BG o
!)
F oc
{D 5 o F o o Ft
Hut g Flr
F F S+ d (, v, ga oq E oq F
F B!t sF"3
|) 9) o -6 o F o oq sg. gq 0l ai'
(D o F v) +f; OF. Fl
E d, ,15 tr C' v, 9) oE 0) t! Hr/t
s o oa g g) o g 3 FI -o o
Ff)
d
oq
I o 9)
c p o o o s) ra o 9J N: F 5
sB2
+sE
p v, q o- 5 p Ft Fl 69r vt qg r)
K o) p Vt F o 5 5 ;iX t1 € o !-f
oq o o 9l v, g) 9o
F f) oq rD' d g m n o6'
o f) n 5 tr s) ol v, 3 8 F v, i.
:.sE Ft
g) o tr (n g (D o oo n o P) 5 r-i
tD o s) I F p v'
o v, $
o o =F F,8 0qo oa
v, +J n F (a r{fD gq g) $
o ct E o oq ct FF o H l-l o o PFJ6
I o o 9) o o o a
n
(D o q9
gq vt fDsJ P v, i+5Fr
F p r) f.: o o o E' t sr€ (t, v) OOA
$ o o $ ,f H tr F F o o o
o 9) vt o 5 w @ F o vl
. f v,i a F3 ?a
Ft @ Vt s ?
FI o o o 9) $tJ
(D
"n H E ,FtH'
o o o o o Fl ? X' o) hl n
Hr F t6 t.) 4 o o o s i p)r) Fl -u,
(a d o ro o t5 €
F g p)
v,
ts
w o oq v, v, i U)
F r) rd 5 *' E'F v) Efl v,
o 9) g tr o o Ut $ r-r o
Ft
8_ 5' I
? d .8H
o rd { € hl
o to 9) H n f) $JD O
9) f) € o .9 o
0) u, ht =. H.
7f rD tr JD o o o F vt o :bt o
(o -Ga F (A 0) Fl oo vt
Fl o g o V)
tr q1 I T ns ( D (a
a Ffr
vt Fb F) g
o A' Fl ra F) o ts. Oq
gq (') n o F -+ Ctq. f) 9J o vtHu'
v, o o "o o F hl g
o o fd
{ g) 6t r_l F rD v,EH v) g) tr 8Ea
o pJ F o t-l
o 7t o :T ra Fl ni- Srihl
9J Ft oq F (' o F o c) o o
v 5 qq (D 0) o? 6- g, o 8o" F) o.HH
g v) o 5 ts 3o cr v, 0) 'o
gl p tr rD r) n ,fD F o 3'd v, rJ '-'5'F
o F 5 s qq tD o v,
oa gq vt r) o vt E H
o I o
tv, Y o v, o o :o
F gT€
v, .J
3 3 o o $ti 6d o F
r o o fo o v, oa P(! H ,-t o
9) p) 0. F) Ut o vr vr trg F)
Vt -l F v) (! ct o (! Alq oit EHF
F v, o o o v) s JD
g X oa Etr v, ovt $Ft
o r) oa o hl n Eo s ei o & *E
Ft
d 0) 3 o u, H OJ s" FJ E.
gt g rJ o v, i\j + ta
o r) o F Vr F
(.J
0) 5 o. o
o v, n r+O t-l
0) p) 0) o o o o n I
H ,ri (t) I V)
t o5
Hil' oo
I l 7 o sgH
zgg How to study dialects
300 l-low LanguageW*rks

EFE
EIiggiEiiggiggggE

ES=
HHf
E€$
g ;E
i8 g
Iu 6 F
rE=

aEi
vrPJ!f
EAo
**S
!n.Lt+

r+gif
r*H
Eq*
*p)o'

19 Fl
r FE
: oFd
=.FffD
50
+ 6' E.
5 q o
$.c9.

.F7\
He: v
tD
g'€
()o
t'+ oJ
Fi a1

9)!.r
.-i

s3
Hcw tc study dialects
302 How LanguageWorks rdfit',F
*r
$"*"1" p
-cc\ **L*
5 **Y tr\
1l
*-""d \"/ -fu
H*FEg 3gi*sH1fis H['gls ro f\c d _*#
Hafig E f-nqsi*;1f,aiiF$s
at:!6HrtFlF:gr KM e@
f,?\ %*
rw #**+*
tss
ig€i + r* *46*#

5- tfi
Errs*g ,dry,
st
U flT\
r !,/
EsqF d
Ea-
o-s
Iref eHiit+Iug#
5i;;'+:+:nsHF3; =='E'l+i€Ee,aHs=E ffi *X
*d w
i5 -5 -*.*J t^t
*oE *q
f?\
rill **J
w g l
*iiF nn ;t [*FIEEgE$ f m. ff\
ft d%
{.d} \**l TT
\#
F*$1E+r1aaElE1 *"\ d#
ii$E
:$EF F;€"{Fl"€lCsFfiFF L"f\ p
$*ft if5S+nrnHFssAg rm ffi
ffi9

g f,*
-3t;r
E a=q u +a IEtIIIEi ++ + rfi
?i=t
c $
$ 5'E$ 1; H $ 4 e * ss3aErssEF+#jg F
7. q. b
s3+g F aE $ e } +i +
g*i I qn'5'o
8e, !F E'g:q$ i EiF
E.1fr"- i3&q$t3;F-= -=--==
FEEs
= -=-= =i7€=e=

53:
*a=
rt r] F}
t D r' o g F p r-l rd-
o !' Fl u, hl
ll! = € tD f 9, v,
p (D o 3 t o j g d
P E g |D FI
o
; *Fg
; T o >l t (XI @ g u,
5 Fl I "ct
F|
(D (D f) U) o
? f
o 7 v, a Ja -rrt o
r-t t o p oLu,
m o o o o o 5 o Fl ; s) n qq
tr fD r-b Fl o r') v, o
Fl o 9) o 0J K 5 u,
It n 3 5 FI 3 o Fl g 5 s) (D
oa OJ o r) fD o g g o o F n Irl p o 9r
tD p gr (D ., o IP p $ F g o
v, OJ
F oF
o o 9) rD E Fl n o Fl
s E
f) r) HEF Fh
v, o fil
o n H
ta o 3
qq o g) t w 5 n oq
Fl
o o o tr
a
Ft Fl OJ 5 g vt P o p) 0) E \o v,
fD (! 5 p hl o p o o F tr o
9) (D o 5 g) -(n o o
q, OJ
n o c 9) E qa 5 o
i? $F
ttt)
o c) o vt o oq OJ
3 5 o F v, o r) K Fl
F) 5
c o F p o 5 j o 5 s F r) F (D 3
5 r-b o p { o o) o o tr (a o E tn
0) Fl H :s f sl o
5 0a
5
oa Fl gq gJ s) 5 o u, r: Fl c o
Vt F) n o tf ga r-t \J p F):s EEA
a)
s9) o (D o 5 o "o- 3 5 o hl
d gq o o F) 5 o .(rl tD o gJ t t 0) t o
fD (D s vt cr o F a c 4 th v, r-l tn r-l vt o F
Fl o or 9) g) E) o o
|! S) ts o o v, qq o r) o (D Pl
0) A) 5 H q, F U (.) o o fiE
F o o o
F o
sff e
0. d o 0q o Ut oq o o p fD o o 5 v, ts cra
o o t g (n i o ts 0) o fD ct
v, o o sl n tr 9) o F g 5 T o
f, n rj 9) o cl 5 f
tr ar
(-j F F o
n crq F E F) o o t.) nI 5 g
? tr (D o o
hl 9r oq o
Fl
o 9) ta P K o s+ € w
1A o F 0J ro (t) fd
c v, E
s)
E
g)
v,
F "6 g
F
g
o v,
(')
I
u,
o v,F K E
3 fD
-cti
E
fD Fd
o
0)
hl
o
o € :s { pJ
Fl
o o
Fl
l.l
+FE
o gq p 9) p) $ o -] o El
tr o J' r-t 0J
9' =
(D
5 s) J^r o
o
v,
r) F F il qt I ts g
Fl
9l
K
0)
o 0a ,f
F F
o
o
g o 5 .J
r€;
girtq
o g o 9) o 0) o o o P 9J o
tr 3 Fl t')
9' 9) o so otJ) *l n rJ oq n fD s)
(a
o o o C' 3 tr ,q tr Fl 9J 5 F) oq 5 o
rn oa 'o 0) o o "d o Vt 9) g) Vt 5 5
Fl p o o qa I
tD
tr.l o V) 0) F p
€ 6 9) n 0r g s i-a o o n tO F) v'OR
BsE
o o ' gt_lr 9) o v, "o o 0) tr oq
f.) t FI
r5 a 3
p) o 0l
(a o 0) s) sr r) E) E v, o
f! st fD o pr F 5 0) P "o
o $) r-l gq gq
o ! C' hl s+ 5 o F
o 0r n o g F ct 9) 0) o g) o gq
T -(/l o o
o
5 Ft
o o (D
JD 5 C' 9) o o
3 I I
ta
lfF i+ .-f
o o
so 'ov,
o o r) oa X tu, :< F F] |o ct 5 f6 v) v, rtFrIr
€ tr H: s € o g gt o o g)
gl I o Ut (D o 5 w
t_l (D o g) o olo
fD x o o cr o o Vt FI o r) I n F
fD $ 0) N 5 v, € tr or oq cr o
o F vt o (D 5
g ,aO o c) 5 s.+ o,
cr o o (D F) o \t ct p o
Fl
cn sF)
o K o. o o qa rr F 0) c) 9) o F
(a e. 0) n hl o p v 3 F) o v, g
Fl ct F) 5 g) n 9J 0a
9r
o t'0 v, €
o t o 9J
9)
g 5
oq
El F
r)
n
rD u,
tD Fl
o
o o o
Ut
t-l UJ o
fD o
OJ
n o
v)
'IJ
3gtr
"d
€ o o FI gq € o v, o oa F H v, o 5 o 5
o Fl Fb rD o tr. v, Fl g 5 o g) t\ v, 3
() t(D 5 o tr
s) a Fl
o o oq g) r)
is
o -i v,
g 0) o o Sl
vr o f) o 9) Fl \J (D \J v,
o n 5 o oq (D t-l (t g (1 F 5 f) tst F
@ F t (D Vt 5 u, € o o gq FJ TEH
o >< fo F) ,.o n 5 gl o !
G
F o o o o Ut 5 o u, 5 vt
FI C' vt
N 5 ct
o tr B
o € s o o F o ? F F fD
n ts tr
sl o
FI Fl o o o oq K
F o 5 9J r: c) €
o o o FJ p o o FJ Fl S) oq E ;gg.
9l o 0) E Fl
E g oq E 9) a
I I
r Fb 5 v, r F F 5 u, o vt o p vt !D o Frfl

l-lowwe knaw what someonsis: th* ethnic isEue


l-{owLanguageWorks

:i_ v,
v) o Etr rt! o ga for/) 0)
H g PO
{o F'
E v, 5 0) I sl s 3 o'o 5 €
fD
(IJ H v,
I= ^ sB 9 g v) xo)
o O) g Fl
(D
=Ft4i\j
(D
3 E)
5
€ ,f
o
o.
O. ga
\o XI F) rD
f#[F
a+--5.Hj-r-{ € o c r_l c 0) o
r) Ot =. rD 6' *J
i\js, FJ o (-J n v) E
9J
E 6o-Ea;
0)9!OOXT-t
oo
EE
Ii
'ug :< so (D
0q
\J
}1 Fl
9) (D F) -s
\t $)
;tK F F
0)
g
d
$s$ {€ o *-oFilH'
gB+4.8F u' o o o i 5 - + F -v,

Fh 3 f.) o E' o n n5$5
c E foo FJ
o o P oq ts
o p F)
r D E ' 6,-t d 5 crq H.
= :! E. 9B F n F @ Fl
o o v,
F$gf SH,HEE
sro o vt n F 5 rd ;-E E q
R P v, Fb o o FI
o
ht f 5.rg 9J
sf $ = l -1) 1 6 tAfD N
v,
.,O 5 tr F qSi Fs':"'ft;
g,5v'sro- g ? FI
5
it rD 3 E gq E EB o i'
OJ o
o" fot. r6 g
a (^J 3 I
oFgFF,. tr F $) 3 9q o t+
6o ,o 4 fr .) v, o i, 9)
o Fl 9J
P*fHr H t 9 E8 gq r_l v) FT C' F E) fF oa
ilH tfr qE EI . tr FTEE{
A J ' - Ff o v, o g-H'g F 9)
o
trS ;tt o 0l \o (D gq v) x n' 6 =ii t)
EE.; 'K H: gt o n o g)
;.'i. r-l =. @. 5 € o E'oE g s
Otr$d
P+ n K o n p) F
FO E' o hl
s
g* E€
-!
qa
o
to
xn o "9 ! A t s
E$+ q .€ggg;
v, o : ! H .
E e'H SF' qt g) n it a o p
g lt o
,.i=v, o cl F o $='n
9 b RE: n n
F tD lio o o v) JJ
o 9)
5 Ed 9) v o
v, o 5 9) Fb } r - . H F F
x 3 d 9o o 0) Fd tr \J F' ts i ! 5 ' F F
OE6g.FJ fD ta F) ar H. tD
;ts idR F Vt H V
o 6 H b"$ o
-p - 3 € a ) A v,
e-x'o
iir5Flr+0a
0 5
F F =o
i+ v, s€ o
ts n
5
5+
g)
F)
5 ttr fr F o o X'H
5.< F
iT
n €
PB.FF 0)
V)
rsnH;
fiEHHE
Fl r-l rv Ft
F)
o w
F)0)
oq vt N r. oq cr o
r-t
B g.;r H-et ."< os Vt o |:lEfu)
{ ig) € 9) o (D E*HF gHFFg
;9 J fr' F iP B
rlO m
G6 t! o 9)
oq O,
9 ? qH tr r) o
co f1 \o 9"
{ +E B o F u 9€ H Fr.i?
o o 'in$ f.) o 'e.os o
Ft
Fg E "g tr
EfriT
!-^ F -t F "g 5 sr 5 I o Fl rJ Fi
U) 9) o
7=948' i-
Ou, E6 o t 0q 5 o F O-E:-
fD H: a) o ts o hlF)
ur: ? Fg (D 3Bg o F (n D (r]r=
: id o €
p F 0) (? qq 5
0l
B € T B.= bh ts5 r rH
V' ,J
0,
F
oq
5+ o o
5 oq
o Fa
tr oq n
$E f w
o
FI
FJ
f,EigF
g.P E'(a6 Bo. 9) 5 { 0) o
qB u, cr 5 9) 5 5
b $5 3 p
V) gq
{o
S.ntFEs S) JD (a
JD5 oq o o +F E 6 gJ
0l
o u, 0J ;.j.
f i€ *
o 3E. tD n v, u, d 3 FI o {
0) l-b
d E 68 . 5G s. i$,n o) E u) o hl
o
g 3
o F 6 Ut 9' Fl o
v, fD o Vt o oo q 0)
I g 2 6
=q5'9* h
r '(o
6s 'E
g
!t(D t
fD
g n 5
a
tr
u, vt
o
r)
!J
FI
o
oq
s€ E v, p
l;rr. :E rr
H. t-i'
,P6 ctt
d o 9J g o sEg 9' d
13BB
i r - t s '
;q:H
g€
o)= €5 o I rD O) !v)g.rl 3 - E
ETAgq b
o= n E-Hg 7 r ? g v
5 t ^ - - \

= =X |: t = n c: = ==a
j-=
= -=
: a= = -= Aa i = = ia E 7: =
=--a--- gf;ai

s:
E
tt
=
{ cD n ;r
D d t -U, =
- o F} I 7 5 Ut
.-.lt r-t F3 g, 3o ah tD .j IA ,d t6
o. tD F ttr'
o B
FT' ttt
n tD o
FS Fl F) 9) Ho
o -u, l'rr o
Hr i' ?n F X d 6-E o o 5 5
e, tD o o rd tr v, qq
o 6B: v, E3 !) d v,
is
3 q vt f.) (-r 'sE F 0) H-l JD t ri.
o g H:gn r) o { nti o s) OJ
$ F)
r)
t eF t) t.
5 o 5
Vt
o q*. ,- oq 5
o 3
(D
JD3 5 () H.fi'ii. o F v,
ts 5g o v, lr
fD 5 s o g (') o ta t.)\o
wd hl P)
H P *'*ts
(D x ol o f')
t r) { q:< o *l
ca Lq $ Lq o ra o + 5 v, g d
5\o
"d a .J 0) X
o o t q 5 5 (x 9r Fl
s) o
o A€ Fl 9d o vt
o ar\ o F g o d F
oa v, vt
€2, e i$ H.9F { F (D OF :-.+
F E a8
o (t) o Eq .) { 89 H f) os v, -@ r+
p E.P Ft rJ qq
lio F € o 6r O'
(D o t{ Vt 0t 5 tr E F ts o o 5 o Ehl
o I o 11 o 35
at, p E vt vt fd P. -g: v, 5 3 ; cr
o G (D F o H.o 0.o
@ o 9)
H|
V5 Frl tr t
E . a trp oq
o F o F eE H: ;E' F fD o oq oa
t p= I tr 5z U
tD Esg o) o) tsl
oq tr
er5
o 3 S{ o o N
F
n ? e) o id o:. u, 5 o Fb o o
(A
o5
s fdpS 8rn v, o
1 . 9 E3 F'O
!, p o F H
o u, (D f5
JD 9J H . V
F r) o 9J JD p
g o jr oq r) t P o
Ft sr
5 r:P oEX g o T S) F) zt rr JD
o 0. t.) 5 !h IA o o U) Ftl
= tr ox 56R 3 8 "€ o v, o 5 FI FI
t) f.) oq Fl #e E ts+
9) o o grD o t)
9)
5 sJ
s) op
o
€o 0q. s) 6' E. I n 3 gl q o b ct
OFI
Fa F
ts cF |1 =q
o tr p Fl
q. o o EH o X5 o 5 f) Oo
o 9J sr r{: 0r F H o 'ct
#g 16 ' o n
o o iJ. a) p f.) ftFH X o 5€
0) FT: 5 oo g'<o 6iD fD Ut 5 Vt 9) CA
OJ @ :< n FJ o tr r) E'o
5 /€ p o v, 0) I |D
(? tr 8-H € fD -l 1* x 55 3 d
o o F' oa 9)=. (D 9) 9) 16 tsl Fl o Frl o
€= gq F. (A ii sl E
d f)
F (D I H J (D \0 v, € o o
, l F () o o { ea
o € c) 6s o r6 JD CA
3 G o s t w 0) Ha' o S F 9) ; 5 H;
p p) 15 5 o bo oq F
er fo tr fD 6o N 3 F
hl g
o
K 5
s)E'
fDF{
o
F
*ii
H'o"t
sl
r) 3 o o 5 P
p .cot oq
r-t
5
U) n
2d
= o o (D o a) u,
F o Fl vt6 o p o
Ff)
E€ .l o Orr s) t 5'o
6'E il 0J n E'd 'F hl p ct g
o s. o hl ut Li. o o o 59) F) S)
tr 3 HrO EJ o E o= g g pJ o eb
o 0J I!.co o vto Vt p)rD (a 5 F g :1 0
o F o. (D i.:+
3 gq r-l
F F F .Fl: ?o
o 0) !t 8r
Fl
H
td s 8o n (.) o 5 oo
g o o f) o s) o 9)9. 3 s)
ho o
d F t v,
F 9) o fD
(D ts."' oq X g) n oq OJ pl hl 5T
r) o Fd o o u, (D 5
p) a 0) ry) tD 5.BH' tr Fl
HE.o F 6" 9' 3 o p
FtP o =- 5 9) t-t o 5 \o g.
FI r) v, r)
(? ptr r) F o v, 0J \o oa
I' o 9) vt A. .+ o r-l rD !i tD p
0r () t) (D oo o o o I o !n5
S) o F T+ *FF
H*w we kncw what sarneoneis: the ethnic issue
Hcw Langu*geWorks

Vt Fl' .bd FT s
Fdi'
o E 6' a'g
oo }F !a E
RF o H'8 x +
d 'n vr 5
=vt
5ct 9. lg+FeE€
F+$ts
LA E)
F
gq
CiHEF
Io u,
o5 6+ q o * 5FrHa3HF* r I
$ lo d.o o 5 E $F 3 3
d3 o
*g5g;a$
ni5$F$ F
5* is
orF
QS 5
f)
hl
o
g.
g
n
2 6'a ? f
I;+$f €.*iiif. r
a5 5-a
ts 0)
=9r .) o
h? N 5
3H. o 9)
-I LA rD Q. 0" F
+$-+1$i 8F
?o
(!-

ig o
(a
o
n
IE$[[
*6rrH
rEE
Es T
lg!
s€
E il+$r
i
il s +t f, i*
I
rq )r Ho gl
sit o
Ei [$ E F6 + g r F s t F I t $E
ht =. =s) a
qu' hl F'
5' u'
sg ;r i F $f)
50
JD
cr t-l
E
s
erEgE
a=.iqT "
EgqgEsExEe'
gi .r g vtH
EE Fg o o
f)
Erl
8g: EFf
;r ;{ Fg EJ OE
g o
r
Ff tr3 vE w p
€ t iIili $sE
+l o s)
$Ft EF
EH s 55 o
t+,
e* i gF
r)o ff& F'
n
o5 v,
$? E3 gf
d= 6F
TO
1 t/)
F,J
oq
.
0r
f')
Vt
tr
qq
o
t-t
?
iHf;3s: 5 F.z i g 5 g: B H g
6ffigE u; Er H
Fgi$[EHlIEE
s I ES 5'& oq
o
-l
FIfD
V) o
gl. o"
fDgt
5H
o=.
o
HI i $Ei
tn f) (D F
?T
H.Ei Aea' ;Hgf*ETxEF
5
tg €e * B Frt H?
s.-; E ="
8 g A E
E. OJ
qs B
.4
5< q='===
['qFaFHEtaE
=='-=.=??:=.;_
L (3
:ir -A F u =Ga=:==r*-=
+E$i s F fi-:ia

oaa
!t .{ .lt E qe
GL EI t: t 9c+cgc
3t El o EG
E 3 ID o
(t ID ;t |D o p Ft rt tt-
ct Ft 6 !t tds ct
srtD
fD = (D o rJ i'!' FI
Fl
ct HBqE

s(t c s, A + vro
THS
-e 6
g -6 (,r- Ut >< € o o o rD )-b rrr e
Fh E o
:' 5 o (! Fb d68 fD 7 rr:- n ht ,+
o ra oa c!
u, d =Ft g o otr: :1 0)
ha
po.
gl g) d o -('' o
F rD o 3 s Fi:a F
= t') 0) 8or o rzr5 v, 5
i o E' u, o o 5s) o o F9 -l il o l? 6
ttt fD € Fl tr S
0) fD € v, F 5 F) o ut
q1 8
€ tn o Eg o q ; Fc qi *; s s . 9 q s
o o) r) o @ ha o vt r+
Fg,
o o E u, FF
tD o r) H a FI
i' p 5 3 gt n1a o TP s o s) oq rD oF =
JtS
. xP ( o R d s d
F 0) I tD o o A) gq
so rs o ^O
ga tJ) ;vY
(a g oo
'39 0 Ftsr -l lra t-t
o cp
fD o F 0) (D
o .q 6' 3 u) 59, { E.S fi
r-l t' FfrD -{ o o dg) qs E
o, g OJ 9) F ut o rr) ts 3 =.;€
c P 5 j A. qF v, trt o F o €
n E o o 5 Ir0r 3 s? so d i E
tu a. gq n I Vt o# E r) F 0r d f l o 5(o
C s, 5 9) 4 o oq ag ga v, 0.
s(D V)
"o v, o o v, (a ,-t'
'o g v, S)
=0tr ts o o vd (.0 0)
9, O) o F
o o
o 9.8 U) o o
F r) \J s5
o
at
SA7'\/
E=r
o rrt r{: 3 as, ba o 5 5 i6^= I
-g tD'
o E 0) o
5 g 8s 9) o FJ
n f) 3 u, E 3 o 9J oH-o
qa oa ii o F"g SF.
€ o 0) 0)Pi FI o
s= tr
.HH.,o .5. S. 6 E , - , ) = p
Vt 0) x 5 5
0) t u) o tt1 o g o 9,f d
G n ET ?, r-l f,Fi o Fl
n € E vr5 ,-l s" oq
t o o) on r) o d { o
o o v, (D v, ts.fD FF o v, Or+ g ESoa
d 9J $ F) o qq{ o F
q. v) 3 v) q9 g c o H: o i 5 FrrD o
o rtt pr Vt
!'+. 5 dP =.$Fr:
s 5 o
o A i+ ct (D'
.9 o o 5 3 oa F d 5 F.t. -=
.l o ilgq { S) str Atq
= O) s n O S)
o o pJ FE o 5 tD 9) :io t'x it)
3 ga p 9r o € Fl 5 n (D
o v) hl E ?-t
o I p) E Fi A^ o
Ut f) o v, o o
a. o Ut rD KO o v) AO) cio 9)
o o ct (D o Fq g, -u, 0)qq an
tr 0J 9J .(r, Vt g) S\d F
o F v) lqt Fl vr frv) irr S -'
9J Ft
EE + o
5 E Vt C'
i+< F !r o € o I 5FS.
(D ga cr tu Frl (1 . F
o 0) F) o o o5 FJ ;' Fd (D $r Hq
5 V) F{ r5 o o 59. f:
o f') E : tiF
v, g 'o fD v, n o q9. F' o H +.q E
o :p € -u'B 9)t
o v,
o Fi$=.
= "o n 9) o o o
(n 0r rD p) g) rD rt) 5 d6rD F o 6' 6- o F OFf
0. rD V) U' 5 ov) o oq s X
16 qq H'S5
o v, FI:
9) E - v) tr OJ 0) u, Vt o d6or:
rD o 0) o bi tl) o o
f] o o Ut o
r.) d E
€ 9) 1r9 '-t o ;=-
r) o o o t, I 'o rD NE !t
o rqt n rD- o oq ;rU-i
-(/j
v, tr O'- ct ga ; o
o vt € o' 35 o s) a. EH F,.sq
C' U1 x n o 5 Sai+
9J r) g 0) 0J tJ t S)
E' 3. os.
o o o Ff 3) F gg. o
n F.t n o n €: 8 Ut S) E'
7 5 i' ,!" 50 sJ o n tsE
p I rD 5 I
(? fD a" oo I V) (D gq ! \ l
{ o 9' 7t \

3a7 l-{cwwe kncw what E*nr*oneig: lhc *thnic i*sue


308 H*w Languag*Wr:rks

P 6' Q
EBH'
EH3
*E q
Pvtu)
&F E
.g; a
E *3
o)tst

3sE
d1+
f EH
EqE
*r;
iio(
5 0" )P
r.r
H.F|{
vrf)=

.ctRd
;H f
3 rE
HH{ H

CH.;i

E=-a
r:
d
g?- ti
?9i
=T

t F :l
G r{ 6
a. !' t n o
o =t 5 t! c! o
=-t !' (u (D
9' E cr :-i F ,1 tD TU 3A 5
r)
o :'|! gl o ? fD (n ? qg
-.4 = nl Vt o, t!
o o. g) r) ar -] (n g<
fD ,lf t) F' i
n o 9' (D s !' t-l o o
v,
o (t oa 50. t! o' s)
f! o
o n g P o El 0',
Fl ;€
o o o fr g) oa o g)
,-t
0q
gq g) 5
v) os) Fl
o v) g
o o htr) o
o o F o
= j F o 5 'O
o € r) gq N
i
rD o o PJ o o gJ o v) 9)c o
f') \J g 5
.!-+
0) o F) 5 o o(,) c.Y fl***
F. p Fd fo o €F
o n f1 vt ,\1 *Y*
-}c v,
Vt o o sJ o a) f&&"d
o 9l o E 0)
3 F o X o o nsr ffi
-l v, V) € 5 F #**d,* -*j*
a' rD o 5 gq ils
t)
(o 5 g o F "6 sg 9r
t7 o o (D tr oq5 ff%
o v, o pJ Vt
f.) o v)
-t a € o r
Vt
tD' o
o
S) 9J F o td
0) 60q
sq
o
6
ru L*J
zG (t z; $ F (D n r) ts"} #rdd
t o J'l o
1) qi o p) ffi
Fl
<. Ut r-) tD S) o s) { (1
o.
o
}E Lfi
ltt
w X 5 5 F)
!' ffi U
9J
C o t 8 w q*J
o o o P € A"
30l, € **-re
-v, o v) Ut
!.o o 5 0) 5 o $
-!n !-+ o €v) M@q
5 F, o 'o n o€ (D
o) o
n c! s o. o *J
g) 9) 9) o o 15(D
tr g o V) :F It o qE
v, g o v)
n rD d
o o Ut
ffi. rT\
r-l 5 Vt Th o, o q$"d
!$ vt s€ v, p) 0J Vt o o v, 8H flry\
'vD 9) F)
r-t w (a q&#
r) o r) hl
o s) xo n o v, o 5e. o
o u, 9J r.)
tr\
\**d
ar ttr
ts ?
d
o
p o
p) v, 5
9J
fD
X
vt
p)
I
r) o
Fl
9)
o 0)ho
OJ
9J
Ff
F
o
m*
\o H o I' BfD ry
u) o F rD o oq gq
*cBflgi*affiH
*oJ tJ.J
F C'
o arq o g 5
S+ 0) 9,
Vt r) o o oE' o
o
ffi 3
f:*-*
rD pr sr 9) g o c
L-ffi flY\ **{;*""i"te
r) n $- F { $v, EM
'l t') 3 { \J gr o
€ o 9) sJ o -v) ffi ff\
,* o o 3 o F 5 HE o 'I,,:ffi
5 o oq o) I n o o o L#
o v) I f) €s r-l
k* dd##
-hh__{e

3o9 [-l*w we kn*w what sornssn*is; th* s*ci*l issu* f,ffi m.


31o How LanguageWorks

E 0l 5gr. lc/r t-r-) 'O 3 o E s F'+ r) *l


:-' Fr D- O o €
5'E cr rV,r o Ff
rD =. F
o5
8 o 0)
tJaoS F) 60. v,
3 ,$ v, ta= og) Vt w
nS *f o n
O. P (A S (: =vt ''u
as&F
E'€ 5 5?r \rFSf)
r\r., Fr- 9) o Ho $ o
5 9)
hl ts X
f-D
5 F+oq I $v, id F. HF F Vt +j 5g 9r s)
t s . r J y - \ v, f-f
F v, Os. o 86
q5
a
vtlX nO u, O. t-+ 6' 5g 7f
v)
L1 9" -l I 3
gf;$#
C 9 FO q
hl
c 5u 6' o,f -16r-rT
Fil 3 Y o-v
6't. 6p) 5s)
o
E
5: 3 6
oJ--* pr r.) o o v, Hltrlo
fio €q 4ts. n o
l+ r*( F. a\ o
v I = v ' :l;'. '6o @ (J ;
F Fl' F|. rD
-- t=v )';2i ) = g €
oJ- a + fDv, pr srD EBE:
a. ory
ht gq '-{ r) -l fdI' o
t(Aa o) 16 o g gOJ g
Ffi o _ F . ' l v ( D( r o 96 H € H
dtSrrX o u) o tJ a)
rzr0J o F Vt JD o.6 *
orP J ; )
n*r g BT h|
(Dv, o
55 (a xa -l hl
$ ,-l o
H.s'Ir O) (v YYt i 05 * H96 Fl
as. o dT {F) (,) 0)
9l
or
Fl
5' o 0) P 3o) o
i-H ggc, vt 85 v) sr o
Vt
H F.
$Fii5
(D.^ t)
to o
n
ch
; +JoH
rD vr. gr 5 x' oq v)
E€ F R
Fq Ft {6 a F
H6 qq to F
v, !a fD
9E i, E 'O hj' 6 6 fr
vt=O
3 o €
pJ rDR 6-g o $qrF
oa !i, Ff o(o =x H P
co-t5 K i+ F) og) Vr. X o F.=[il
o )oq g. Fi ;: v,
sJIf I, oo i. 9J sJ o lu'T 0) '(J .-
# i gP F nE o !' 5 vt 9) € =o 5
ti F) B€ E8 o v)q F o
{+ -x5
(/tXF. v, Ja $E 6 € F
Liq I I F vt Ect v, s) 0ro gl IA n eJg
tY H. H5 ni' Fr V)
d5R F.O
E 9)
. l t *l q'3 (D I $o o €;E
Y
8s*8
!_crr€ ei 5 o)E. r)
a$
trio HE F
o p)r) Fd
o
o v'= s) 3: r p
a-H q; $(D v) v) T P3 9) 9) 'Ut
n
H s6*
$ o Vt ?.9 F Ea 6H
Ut HE'' o o i-i. d $J
=o FF o €o
I
o o s)
+ E.f6
oI. n o)
'-t
.'+ 5 d X o f;5'
o
* s s# v, tj. 0J 9l tr
5 t;t o)
Xsa :ra d9) 9) I . o !l E ' €(D aE0. s
0r r)
oo o 9J o) (D c ct€
6, ' - 1iE
q
xu, o r5 K
o
$
g (Do 5 5$) tr
0.H r {3 sq oE g g. v) 5' 6 am-
* r3; ds) v, JD og !.+ {
0r o x0)
.) {
0r
UgEH >JA stl o i e.6 0) QVt Vt
$6?
e 6'r; o= 9) F sg 9) 9d gs) v) 5$ {
H F o p) F 5 8g
O
( aBo o vtf1
o E >
slE (D g o 'vt
qr se o H -
S € 7f tJ ra
$)o 9JF
r) d 9) rD 9H. H 'O) € qa
XErFr HH o |.((lt 5 oit v, F p
=Fr=O 63 o o qa io 5 Ed qq K:
sJ sh v, tr I
t-+. n .'^{ f :! ct o (to o n n
J-l rD o
n I'
FO 6 o (t) HrD itr r ' ' 6.U
o (D 5 ts.tg) o FJ
?gr F tslY rDH i-a r+ aa qo !-+. ut F V) 5fD
,J
U) (1
g F-' g.
=O(/:'o - v, =v) 5(h u, ls ct) X'
V A 6€ Y
ri;il: o5 -. .) - o lJ)
€ €2. r
.+A =c 5 f,c =
::7.; aG $6 :1 =- = = : =:
= fra E€
:= q D
r ' - J
- A t r

qf
lgr
D

i,. G :
F
t-
!t
:' orri }l =
e 5l E
CL o E |D |! € 9,
; u p = E 9,9 * g FI
f: cr Itr 6 OiD 'Ct
Ep ls |il FCf GI
r.t o d I 9r =.
s Fl v, U o F ! v,
it Vr= t-l r:
g_E tr st t+ u €0, h|
cr d.r
o cr 5 o o o v, u, Ir-t Fl hr
(tt n o, UI I, H! n o g3r n (D 0) l-l E' s)
Org i 5 qtr 3- =
n td r.6 o g
g, tD 9B o. 3"o
7' rJ o ocl (o € fD 5rr 9) ?E F F 5 K
9J
9 .o
Ftr)
3
v, (o I g r) €8 gq o
Fl -g)
tv,
€ fDo) o oq rh H oq g gs v,
gt o 3 n 0) t-lo)+ o 5 6- 3. o €
(rt
d66 9)
E 01 t vt o o fd v, E 8 p
5 {-J vt 5 o o
VrI p ltrrE o 5; Ja 50
|D t) fD K H H o 5 FI 0q
v, o o o 0J
go (D O. ni 0q F o g6a sre r-t gJ€
a v, vt 0J s) F{ I sr) E8 s) (D
o. € F 0) v, o o 5 rJ
o 5 0) 5 *6'9 hl
o
ss) *q
o g)'O I t-l .gi FI fD o
r) s 0) o 8 g 4
q) o hl 0) Fl
o
o' P b ,
:1 I. o n s) v5
o qlL o tr cno o c7i
e 6" $-C O) 5 9) (D F Fs.
ht 0) o 9J f
7< q
o 3 0J a r) - U) $)
o v, o rD t-t
FI
vt
ts Fo o oq 9.
;H * X 95 vt (D r) 5 32 3
E lr o g g) 5 .+
o 7r ){O) 5 v, 6[S F|.i'
€ ="; X o 3 5 9J
qq 121
o s) sr 6t 9r
:tr qJ g s) o o o !D6 - E.H K
FI:
IA t, d6 v,
otu o o N
F I,E r FO
H g
a
B D 6to
h( q)
F
crq g':
+q o 41 o
9' 3 d 9) q )v) n 3 tr Fvt
F efI ru O 3 v) o JD v' n o pr o
o Fb
Hs) F sJ o g Er o r: 0) ET JD Vt sr
g 0l g gq p o to F
6g JD r) Ft 5 Fb $= 6'd E s
g
o o o oaP F) r:
5
f fi E
H4 o o o
tsl o oa g. o D f.)
E8 F)
(tt 91 5+ $) o 5d oa o o o
€ PF o (Do v, fDo hl r) .q. € FT:
rl, € n oq o 0r 5 u, B.E o- o E
Vt
F) 9) oE :3 o B r-t v,
n ''l,' o
Fl Fl 5 -(a r-l
p 9I E
fD F F) ?5'3 {;r 5 o o F
*F io
Fb F!(D f
ga (D9J arq EE
'IJo
r) s(.) o Ut 5 vt € oo Fl
g) tlt h| F n tr o $ o o o V, I
v, g) 9)
Frt qq
E SE 9) E' 9l g) u, 3
ok ga tr F.fD 3 0) F I.cL o (') hl
16
o t1 U) oq F 3 oq o n
oF. 0) 0)
o o
Ft
Fl o 4
sF e)
5
o 5 v, o E
frfE
H'r: 3 9) qo 5 ' s)
€ .) I B Fl
F o
n
o
E ' :l
i.io
(D v, E 0q, "9 g F J? E ) n ts 5 :f)
o -!'+€ g) tO (D gro r) fi 0) IH (D 6g 0l .(/J
o s) qH F p) v,
9) 6rn o fD r-t 9) n JD'r 5 v, FF
5 o I
Fl
g ts 8"9 v oa 3ii; oa Fl ;t-l tr 9)
pr) 9it U)
ro o o p v, o o o erg v, f)
C'
g € o 0r 3 v, v, tru,
tq) 0) 8o JD o Ft H5' Vt
S) o F B6 fo x'o tr
t xo n Hl
{D 5 5 oq$ n s) 0)
g) F . H !
v, () Igs o o v,
ef Fo
(t, .r 9) d CfD g) v,
5 H: t')
+5 o 5 gs 9)
or o f)ii.H
sJvrx o 0)oq
BE 5 F)
8: tD
S)
{o
t+ 5 r) ; FI: tf E o 5 .? o
F o g Vr o o F oF' 5 n o 9 H
5 cr't T (t, C' Fr: E.6L* vt lrH s) o o 0a f !-r
S) .) f's o o Fl $ E v, Snt F Ut y
o !6 o 5 r)g) E o oq F n r- Atq vt I rrtif
(D V) d s o gr 0) (Dr+ p)
o o Hqr F) p o o =. o o F o o H:H (,) {=rr' ( D v, N gr 9)
5 Fl Ft@ o 9J r) p ,C' o 5 f.) 5
v, Ao n '9' F ita qr+ Ol
F I F I'f n r), r) I 5(D o
sr o -(/lI' 5 It 5 o EF
l-lowwe know what somecneis: the sccialissu*
312 H*w Languag*W*rks

EEEiEEEiEFEEa
E$
iEEEEiIEEEEF
EEEE
h
J.F6
It ?;s't
Fl F}
?^{O rlt = p tD
Fl It |D
5 (D ct FI v, FJ
Jg)
st o_ g, r) g o 3 d
o U1
t)
E 5?
:i ctcl ' o
a.5
f) ss rD 9r d v, P o
g vt s 0)
5 o -('J
fi $E
O.Y,J
ta v, n
sF)
CN gr=I F'E 9. o *l o F
Fit.: vr d, F o V) rD vt o o oa FJ o o 5'*E
I v) s) fD X r: p (t o
='o 5F n rD g 0) n s) o 5 9r 93fDoa
5 V) fDn 3 tD F) fD o v, $ tD €
L..
5 Vt S) o 5 v, o s
(D:H.
[# s
g g5 gl
€.5 o
r) fo
o F g
o :< €
o
5 V)
o (,) o
X o o 'ol E,?5
F!' F) 5 v, 6" o 9r PJ
gtF o o hl o S) U) .) ? ga- |n t5
5'# o 9J o gl
;o 8 flr., ) li
o s r-t n v, vt o. o 5
qE.H g5' x0) K C:i 0l 0J $l d o poI
'a tr o o 3 o 9) c g 9r o F T H E J
cr sJ f,) E ro 0) p) E s OKS)
o s) {o u, c p) o
E:d 0lI
Eq t o oa o 5 o
(1 o o o g X L5
E 6:< o .(/J { o Ft, :s a. ro
5 rJ
o -
F F
8*
=8Frr :(D s.q :s 0J 0) o o tr { o
Fl
V) o
{J L- x $ E' psJ (:t n -ut r) H H 3 S
(n qa oq 5 $) 5 o s) o U) $)
9) tt)
F.V
H
or Fr6 (D oa {v) C' c v, PJ
F!fDH
;o {
o v2O H o o o
n o c v, o o Vt o o n o -u,
g. u)fD 9J o) ;v, 0) ga r) rt)
E r O r.t) ()5 vr
g iil
tr rJ o 5 g) qq o ct hl
g-+it $= o tD n n o F 9r
o s g# vt o F
o o F
ct) pJ Vt
o tJ (a
6st F) $, "9
() 9r 0r o o
a
g tr
v, v) Vt
v)
n
o hl o f1
o
o u,
E8R
-ur6q
9' 5 E. H t r i D (DO. o n 5 rJ pr
g g gl € S) tr 5 r-l F t d
So o F) oa o V) v, o 5V) $r o F cVt
F 1 qa 5 o g n S) R{
o o ta (? o ct F o o OJ o g i+ogr
J
s€ v,
o oa Vt d o € CI. o vt
g
9- H Y. t+ o v, tre5
1aO o o
tr o
F) w E) 15 \J
HFg
(D r) o
€g o E t- o'
o .(rt o 0q X o
ro v, o o
3 X \€ o B o o F) o s 91 sr E -vj J{ a
€[s. g s at Fo) Fl X v, tr Vt 7t
5 o 9r
rJ) F o 13 f6 o ? -(/J
cra t i o (,) or o 3 rD A. F g o €95.
Fl. fD Vt = q o w
u, o
Vt o o o r< Fl
p) =' Ut (D q f-!: ci' "o
(D o
rsE o€ rD o FJ,
o
g V) o o { t) rD' t\i g o
gro o o f $) o H 38
d V) f6 o o ct n o 9r
9l *€ tD pr I 5 Vt o 5 (D
n 5 9J
u 5 FJ T g
>< E 3E. 6-F tr (.) lo K i o o 'oFl
A# I
5qE FJ
o d g I c 9l g sJ o v, r]
(!
r)
o 6g € o !, tD sr
(t) p) o
+J n o Ff) v) o u, 5 HHE
9.8'A o) s 9) g o 0l
9J E6 n AJ o
(r) $5i F cJ F ct - o o ;Ep
CF o o o F s $) ,o tsl
rD Lj. hl 55 9) OJ o g o ct E JD 0)
$13 o" oa 5 D d a) F r) vt gq'F
X H ! ! G oE' r) F rD gq rD f.) o ir 0) pJ
I c € Vt o V) vt v, n
5I5 >)m 5 Ssr g) o ro $ o $) 9gs
gq $ o c0l A) 9. o o. o 5
o o c o I' rD 5 o o o o o
E Eg Fhg I 9q3 0q 0r v) gq 9) oq I g o 5 oq
sr 6' or 5 o tJ v, 7t o 5 o g p
*sE
u, o cr v) 9r v) o 9)
qE5 +F H Vt c' o
hl
o OJ d 5 n S) oq
'il p 5R vt o v) d o o F oq ai N
rDht cr o o tt) V5 fD o. 5 5 o. o Jat+T

313 How we knCIwwhat sarne*n* is: the secialissue


314 H*w Lang*ageW*rks

V) (t) n F|.h 11
5 o o SSEE o qE F o6 o F
oq X o o SH '+
I t-l oo
55 S
€= s5
tr s5.
f Hh 3
O C E'$
o $- t€ t I o s t) IS o(D F.W
gJd Vt 0) 5 C.ar=.o FJ i;rP E * 5o JD 5'Egd
v, H ; - J ' l
5ti.,9-tr n
I? BsE
='.= ^-s s) 9, = 3d =€ P.5IJ
I oSoP !n FJ
F .o
2q3 v, \t PHSN n EE prr Or+='O
JD F rD 0) o o $ H o F etH o E3
= o o S- (-, 55
o F H
y d rryE pr d F tr FC F trE' E
3F1A -iS o 0JrD a0r
F v) ;n d o''$" fD v, v)
H ctE.:
I X 5
HrEg o' v) S) Etr I
o. a OJ
HF X v, 9. cto o o
o
g 2 s oo 9r ; a' F e.
F 0) 7t sg -(tJ gd 5 rJ 9)
3
pJ oq
"6 Bt3, -(/J
rt#E V) u) o * E E o €
p n $J o 50 Fb
Ut E 16d X Ovt ,\. I B s€
o o 3 a' 8# H |-) r g "0, (-J F 0) 5o o s)€
H. T d p sr o
o 3
5 q6 o
(a
F
f Fs9
OXor
n € E
g)
o
o o
a
EF; o
* +FrV Ut sp
i.P O)
o
p E
83
vto xH g
r6
)
5 o r hl
aTr
;E';sE
't+i u
tooV 5 3 B F '.6 6'3.6u v, -" X Eqq
o E q o.€' so o
o tsl H+ Vt 58 Frt
Ut o $' o (D :!o s) 9)
it .p
5' pr
5v,
l€8tr v, Ut d'd u, o qq F.gFB
I e; F a.
ss
gJ o o
; iE x s oJ
5 X t6 5 o; ct u' o
5 g) S€8 t o EF) vr;
a
T i *frE
J=i+
9.
o
o V) 6 rp
urNii
xt 5
v,
H sE s F g o 9:g F fD
F gq
d. (2a O !-| FJr/)
E rS g
o o ct oq v, t-r rD SLG E'
t =E'6 g V) (D
tr o Iq i.+
J Y H F 9) o v) oiD DH
v,
Eg)
Y p r g [ $ n's F dv,
o o gq o Fr/'
q n
co g
3 g,H €oo $, o ie s;
v, € qH9 XH' k )'t H& (5o: tO
L E HU
rEt:il o. n s) * EF n ct 0) ;'r
gq o qq o' n o oo" TE E: *E
A) dX A t r, f D,.6 E 0r E=
3q3 '; ? o F ct JD
FFHT U) v, FA. sr if 6Esq-
Jb F9)f)v
€ !.1 9J H. l\
A. o 9) H . v
IEa 58 s(t b 5
o ra Hg gB 0J o sJ
aE Hor:\5o
gqE o$c 0) v, APr 9E
E 9r tr s
Irir
ddI= FJ
F
5
o
o
Ut
s5'
soa
o
v) Vt
o
o o'=
Eo 6
co=+ o v,
€ o FE 3 9) ct Eq is \s 5E
v) s) aFr o o o $EFE
gr F) g ;95 IEEE v, o ?6
(1
v, o 5v)
;EFZ r) ct F H.g oF
o o o 9) 5 ga u, xG rF H 3 SC
P i sg c oq o S g) fD ;. sr
T
(t)
*EH € P:fi: C.Lh- tr sqE vt ArE
[: u n iJ Fi *, rtt o =o \s 5F
{ a.F 5 s o r) FH$E
SJ v H.
qge= aE. .9
o 9) v' o O. 5f c\5 itE
: s.FE v) it tf, h5 rD a') 6 =
Vt
5 5 :, 9) P go u,
Ut n gl T TC' *6 r-
Ff H = B g +y o
F.t L)tr
-t)) o o vt ct)
l- ,t -' t, P-A'rD X
\ J V H
J l ^ r )

a.:-j'tj =.
'4
fiE;
-,rx a' 'tYi.- : =! : --. il9 F A
= = 'aia- : : = = : . j
: -I ='
i== L
3: 3 ST
-:a: a
3 -
- - --==;
rtD lD lor ;

| i l f i

= vv t =r D
=ha
o oO
F+J
O
P trf
I F!f
oa E ' o
c Oq N)
F)
oq t r o (a
o
X'r:
;P
x!
1 6 h l

H
Fvt

5{
PFr
*sq
= .o
t/JE
H.O
Vt ht
c)
gs,

3d
g y'r,
oR
$X
tO tt,
o.)
r6'
$tA

tDo
lv,
=ut
(DFJ

FT
i5t

315 l-*owwe know what s*m*one is: the socialissue


316 l-{awLanguageWorks f*+*
e$

---t*
o5 * g 'p {*t0,"-
-\r,
,SP^$; F E8+ 5 ffi
gt 3
ac\r o o qh*# ,*;f,*"*#i.*
xFlI vt N 9 3.6 ffi\
o i' *519g5
. D' V) 5
HD} v, (/l
\o 'E Ed atu/
u, 'didtr o v, ffi
={ o o ct' c o q Ft +.+
F F) 5 q. u, th
5 Y
:- -,
n cnc rt 'vto FTI o 5'EE L-J
5 g o
v) o
so
=' o tsl o
aD F) F8s o ., o Lffi
i- crq o V) (D pg H! .)
F V) t Cl +€ I
o f gq v, a*9 t $F
tD tC' o !t o d +g
5€ q 5 o 6= o g uT
o tt, ts 6 o \_**w
v, :- 0J 9EH rt rD
g oa6 p
s) in fl*\
d tr6 5v, \**d
f.) o'
sbJ € FJ
190 9J (a tt) o o F) t-+5(D
o n 5 v, ax3
v)= F 0) v,
H.
g Ut -1 o g - ffi **ru dry\
5
g) oq 5 * o rJ F {M
v7 to IJ ts. €9 V /
H
(D
xo
(Doa 0) o
Fl
*EB MH JD ,o oq oa
H E 5 o v, 0) - t J ,-\.+H 0].+t Lffi
F(o T
r) tr
rD o 3. I'
o +a tr m HSXEffiW
Vt 9) tt)
6 o
o 5 'g Ft- o
f.l
o P qa do p ItE
&
o oo (t) o V)
3 3fi
pr o o o
rt
o 5 Ut Ff ,* { p fl FE o o eKr.
ffi ro Mf
fD €F v, ffi
K o [iq F ='?6 flT \**d
Ut
o 5 o o ooq K d,trv) tr\
o'
Ft Vt L. p tr ry
Vt ( g5' n tg J Y v @
) WA 1 \*J
o v, o
gB b s) oa
o o R € o t
5 9l p A d€ 9) -rFE'
=' SJ v, x o{ r-t v, gq ! *
v) o ir. n $ i,+ .i'
t/t
0) -1. o ? a' o HY
H JD f+o. .d "d -) r'+ Fl
Ft H
cra
r? oa g
F
qq 'ct pr
too
-]
o
tvl ? q
= o
I
pJ
F J F J i tfr ru
FJ gq Fl.
o5 E td -,'. P 6
rt o V) F lrB o fl*
TD o H Vt 9o. sr =Hg)
o
. H .

o -o o F i i
3 hl
vt
r3.8 "e***
V) 5tJ € o o cu'F ffi ffi.
o I v) 5Ior I
9" 'o+ o 5 o $ ) Fl o
u, ooq o *H e, o pt H#
o FJ t-il
o o v) 3i;= *98
! -

rt) .) 6E
irH

o I'$ S' $ o=
n Ft )rJ 5 v,
+
Fl
fD 0)
o n o H 5'"
gq o E
r+
q Ft o F'-#
* o
Fl n Fi. F|.
(') 3d6
o o r< o :< H.HO
(! t6 JT oFt
r y A
o 'l ' A1 J
Ff
-fD 5 c r g-l' o
r+ lt
o = FF Cfa
:. v
o -/
a { PA € re Fll \r, --
lJ) x *
w c =
a - = "r-
=" a-
:- x - *- = r' = E
3
=
- ;

.{ O
t tD
{ .tt rl E
EI FI
a f' e/
D 7 o t+ (D =
u,
€ il eE r
o p ]'It - a ct
F
1 9 H o "6 fD
Fl € Ut u, FS o 9l u,
tt ( o Vt 3 o o o n
v,
e
o lt)
K {D o
E
d Fl 5
n OJ
o) AJ d3
i'o tr o 0)
:.[fr*n
=.,o o n d vt |! I (D EH F o eB€ j? q
F 9) (') 9) 0J qE
E =. Fd o OJ o 0) o-'o
='6 o n rD 5f') Ut r-t v, 9", 5 oF. € 6
- H)
9)
:s o d U) o ,ad s o
V)
d *
pJ F6 tt o o Fg *F ; o
(h '6 3 5 H& (n o
> o F v, 0) I O
(^j 0)
3. O, cra
o
JD I 0)
o oqH
rD tt) s) F
Va
rD r-l u )
o6.
r) o
FESHx. gp-s.
0) o o go Fl o
o s .(r) t f3 tr
ct' ) 5 o F) v,
r) v,
(o 0J 9) n o p f) vt = VrA
oa l.t g ta (D o"o Fr o) rD
9'j ga r.6
(Do !"0 o p Er o_ s)Fi ; o +ilil
.D !-r. ; pJ o t v, tt) g)< o n "o
o. !t qq 0) o 55. o' f')
(AfD v, qa r) FI
tr =: o o 5 TF-|-'r
o o o tr o o €F
q' :6o oq 9v, gF.B
v, Ut P r) 3 F s) E
,u o
Fb
I o 5 50q 0)
o- r] s)
6; JD 0) U) -] 8F F
.' U) t r) F o = 3
vt
p oJ ct c o o oq
€ o v, 0) d F fDi= o v,
F) )oq OJ 56' 9r tr
= o= € F o F
9FF fr
o F jo ao -sl gq
th o 5 oq o o o o :{' o
5 o rJ Fd
rt) diO rdI rn 4 tt) o E[FF
n r) fD (D- 5 F r) gsl 'i
€o F sr 9J lr, s) o 9) Ut
€ 9J F r) r, S
!rr o v, o o Vt =E x? gq
v, :o €
o g r') v, o ?o €z' o -E:3 n
tr ,*==t
o .+ V) 5 oo
rD t o
o' F H.3 o pr E gq o 5 R s) v, F)
o v, o o (.) ci' s 9 +v, oq
:s Bf9 " H
6o o. tD 9J o F+) 69, H rfl
Jq, o =
-t-t 5
(a n Vt ca v, i' Fr JD
€ (D
O. sJ { o
w
o 3 H8
0) ts. O) o5 ; $)
isFB'
o V) tr €i 5;+ K rr. fD
o o 7r o ro3 o 6' F
qq g "d(D 5 o 5
9) rD qe 6' o v) g tr
X oa FJ h- 9)
gD- n
vt du) r,O g s) :s E 8
a n U, V, s) Fi 0)
FI 9)
Fa
5'aF3
€ < o Ut ag€q
o € i*o \J o
oa = s) o (D o (a o n E,
o
5 l.l 9) Ut 5' SH g S
ta HY 9) n o s t Er-l
5 0J vt
(r't 0r Vt (D lO
sF' e E
(tt
o F6o 0) (D tD o o
5o fi o f6 n
t'9r ut
n
(a F v, s) f.)- *F oX 9) 3 o 5 6'
n oo F o g E r) o
o o
(D tr o gq -6" 5Pr
o E o +i €
o H v,o o vt o o (A 6-a-='o
!J 5 'o 5 o
tt) o €6
s': (D 3 n pJ o s'E o
g) 5
'-an$
roE' o 9) 5 S) +J t) X o +6 rt\ E
d o o (t r) o
i+ crq F o 0) F o 5v) tr
rt) o 0. o *i n 9)
q 5
EE
p-T 9) tro o gsr"H
o o 3 fD
o I F v)
v, s) p
;s tr rco o

317 l*Jowwe knaw wh* scril**ne is: the Etylisticisst"l*


318 Hcw Languag*Works

u, tr gJ
0) o ,\i E 5 9l Fi' dFsd
o fo oE F r-t 5 € R €YFHJ. _ F s=l:
a+ o g YEIJ r-t
o 9)
so
o o o
8F
g qa. Ja "d F ,f E'5 i'e
sIA 8E 0. 3 s) n o g F6 i t{ B E E € HE
AH €v, tD U) |.,hrl Fl
o 0) E i:r 8 9.5 x g"
/. = o v) v, o oq It-t s r:il.!t Sn =. X 3 x' v'
r-) 5
E : - ' q 5 vt
\(rH v, P
E' tr :]. I' E
\r.\, 9. t')
(') o
o 9J o F) o 9J o FqEg H 6.?D - _' t v =5' H o' )1u ' 5
o5. E'E 0) o F+ FS v) (o o (a v) RE B o
5E o 5's o f
;.€ ?: ao:l$o.Ft
-ur 5 .9 |:6 o 9J so x'iD $ag x?i ' o
na r s orP E6 o 9) E' E8.gfq;
o { 9J
9 t3 V)
o o U) H. F) 5e o (a a g) vt Hfsx € 3E oJ+
j a€-' q H)a o
C5 5A 5 o p t.)H
BOJ o oq t.) Vt pr ga f-) i5nt0)vt
i6HC€[
3 't o5. l-t pr tr ?6 r) n V) Tr+ 6
I
o V'F 5 s gB (1
o
fr
9) € 6(D
af; g -. :R6?ocorrd l
! - H r l F ''.
-r )|r*D 9r3 o N 3 BH (D' o gq o 9v, F€ u, !-t F{ t+ ts.
g)
Ff p) o ag. 3d o 9l F o
g€ I: g ,J
xo
t)gr 9) F o o g 1 H
p(n o Fl
H = €€ FE
/. o. z+ v 8
o 6g 0r t g I 5.+lDOJHqq
.(/J o d v, go p 0) iE E,H iDoS -i O,
-\(D s) v, Vt x 2, 15
F I H J:! 5 jH) 5o) s fD F o
5 E v' qq V) ti F H: &H gE6- di'H q
).: Fi o iL n r) o
g? HrD { zt O. 55 U) o
a'r t- rf
g Fi'Id 1n
)< € _v, oo o E 16-& sHs o ^,ni;Ji+.+9
6A v, !-!: qq= 3: E o 0) 5 gTdF. Ffl
/. fo H. F H'OFt-5A'{
(r) r) n (Dvt 0"o v, tD vt o Fl
-\ o a' fE 0) o Ar V, oq R.E O O ; E
- q5 9) E''6 o o E8e" OJ
fg o r-t 9) F i+FJ
=n r,o o eL 6- CvTft
oq
Ut
o oE oa (t {l
lq X r { i + FI .
e ojJl
D(h { o F o o F)
Hs*3 hl Fl- P
-t Fi ,o 5 tr o I
Eq 9.F 0) o a: ctq b.< +<: 6
tr o ;q (Do € EFF)
o'F et Fl oa 9) oJ 5 o ro E'H F
o r+ 5(D g o g pJ tr". Fh al X Vt
EJ o
;- l€r ) xo o
Ja
(D n
U) sJ 3 o
;.+ a-
o (o
v, v, U1 5
E;iH
6- g gE P FE
J ltt
5
.+Ygt--
pr5 oa q v, { o OJ Q.r c)
5'{ g) 0) ro n-. r.t o 5 o aro)o;;
\J5Vt :FEi=€
A rio -q" 6 ro C' ."
lr -- gJ g F ,) gJ tr o o Ut
o Fld = # H dU
o Sl 1'9(uXTOE.
c) (") 0r o
€E x(A o -iO 5 o e qe H + : TF
o $ o o Vt gl it o - F
o
ES o.J o n
fd w
C;
X E 'tr
5 r)
o o s)
d o
H.FEF
u.OF)n
S F+ eaEs+7
no))-=',1-
9 v, o q9' E9 5 rD rl (D vt
r ex r 9{ Fl 0l o 6 3:
$(a JD o E,qR I o E 'F *Ji
.(/J -l i € o S1: 7.EF{(D
o 0) oi It ? io @
H: e. g oa d -l ntO o Ft Vt
irj g
it
s) 6" F B;€ 86H
(o v, 0) HS 5 9) 0J h t d =

o o (D =H
aq oo rD o oltr9r i"EgE€_e
?'.r
Io O. -. r+ioant
q tAu' E
tJ
roiJ qa o s)
g. u) U,
HR c ciq o F o tr
El TA !ttsg F.E
Hvt 0) OJ (r) V) c Frl HOry.cIlhr
E3 \J r) FJ o !4, v) rD
'O -l' i.j. $) v,
s3il il38
9' 9) €JD 5'p F
qq o Ovt5 r:
=-* -vJ u, () € F o BHH Vt ;ll6 n I *
d o (, o \
*e Y= 0J 1{ 9J
o S9lor Fi +Xv)oFtF
lJ) p v, (D r J F I H
5'HR
*v t E
F o. o
ctt a E F H . or-lH ) E ' 5
o 0. oa o NgR o or=o 'i O .v, =* 0)
n (t cq M t v
v v r H
in5 o
.a n € - +
:E .; = a E9 =,. E .n
= E *EE
^:ta
E ]
== tr = = - a - ;='=
i = n€ : t =; =
; F:

*
fib

Jo
d 3
Fl
o 9) o
t{!
g6 hl tr v,
ar} }E o o o
o .u 0q hl Ut
T u D Ht f'D it oJ (D o
!.t rD gEr =' d o rd o 8+ gB v, o +
o tD g 9l g) o
E I Ff! p (? v, o
d
Fl o 11 F ?DF 9)
€ u, (D ht F Fl 6' v,
(D
- o0) r)n
o v, vt hl
vt (t,
Bf E E
rJci
o fo (D v, |D $) c) K n
o
E tsF'l Fl Vt o S) g 9r 0) 6E 5
{ oa F r o 5 (D (1 0r
o F fD F sd too n
5 u, g '6" (D oq 0) U) F)
o, o a
t,i
€ o oq
g) tr s v, o ('. F
(D o 6"
v, 9J V) o 59.. ss qa JD o
id- 3 *F v, o crcl o E o n tD+ v, E)
o =a. € g F fo
o o 3 V) $ o o =qt tpl ro
g) FI
oa o s) o F E b 6' € S)
t o dqr -u, o I o F tn
F)'5 ga o vt
= { OF r'€ F E 5 sr r) v, OH) r) (n 5 o
5 :- o o. p oJ sr o oa o o l-l v' Ft Fto rD w oq (o
-(.,1 r)
o -l g gl € ta
o o F S) Ft5 FU s) tr C'
=t F qG €F o o 0) o FJ
s) Ft ; { p p o'o it 9J
d o -v) 0q €o o FI ttt r-l F.l o p o gq
fDFF o p 9) oq q Uto o 0) o
tD o t' V) 0l E* o
9) :-s o = o s) ol-l R 3o
v) o 5 crq rLe v, Fl 5 K (D
o ss
n Kv, o F)
gJ o pt fD F (a a
@ g) 5 o $ o n s) 5H IA s
g o 9- P F 9o 6 . o v, v, fD F FF F' o o
9) /O () o g o 5
p F orE n Fl o oa ts5 5
ga n o
€ (D
o s € o v, o F o 16
-u, o f) g El F 6' nt F
tro) hl v) c) I 5
p o trs o
ts 9J o o oq +F
o0) s) r) U' F (D
Vt Ev, a qq v, ,ao o o 6'* gq
F (D F|
g 3 I Fb
o o o o
o JD fi gq o tr ot v, o D {
F o6 o o cr o tl)Ff
o o
to u, Fl' (D v)
o d F RA hl o
tr
ro o |D tr o 0) FJ 7<
o .) {2f o s) Fl
o Fl E uut o)X 9)
o dF g FI p Vt V) v) s(D
s) € 9d o 0) F) o q E'.
o ro { o F $ 5 g o tq 0) 5 o o 9r
J' g+ a< oq gq
t .(,J oa o) v, Fl E6
cJ o 9) 9l n v, €
ct "6 c. a9 F r) n \t K eE p o
u, ct 63 n n 0r o F o.Fi F6., n 5 fD o
o o er F{
fn cn Fl
o FI gq v, vt
o o I o (D a)
Ft aE' x"o (D o g g 7,'g o (D 9J
F o 9) 3E
oq BF Fl
v, vt d t) F RH ,Jl
r Vt
o F ; (D F Vt u, o o
-u, '.6 :3
ts qoF o 0) oq
Fh
HB I 3 K tr o
fb
? G
zF . ,r qo, E o
0J s 6'ts Hd 5 o K s) v, o 3
Fl FtE' d 0) 3 g'E vt
F o
o F =0r o)
hl
o ; o F o 85 V'F
o
r-l
o
r) o 5 o o o v, a) Ut o
o t-l Fd 3 p) o 0) o o
o o ;q3 o (n v, u, $ o g) n
fD ?a hl Fl
F 5 g) F v, rF o (r) Fl: T o
gv, 9) o q o FH o
(A o
EF ,f
o 0 ) hl g
-(/r (t go Fl q
(D o o o T o o F Fl ts
F og) oqo
tr-l o fD g \J
t
io ct o p K 3 7f
5 o 0) oo q
sJ o o E) o o v, 3 F 5gr
o = o
f Ft v, FE o ts 0J I X
Fl vt v, 5 o FI o OT ET F crq o
g 65 €

319 l-'{*wwe know who sonre*ne is; the stylisticissue


320 H c w L a n g u a g eW o r k s

rD o E n 15 F) g€ hd vt Of.i$-l
50 s d'g € o FtH"O!f, t /-)
ArH)I E'FE. Fh o o F8 9) F F
lt) Fl A rD q o 0l rD S o o o o
0)
Ed .
SJht
E'4:g n o= s +E f F o C |+ !,
ct) o o sr v) rD -l giD % o n 0) 3
rFF ",5 S."o o Fr r+9 +rEf
gOJH V'
q gsr :< gE * e€ s) (/t
vt o 5)
ost 9)
F
Ut
v, K
o. fD o
E 62f' 5 9) S)
iJ vt !-; I
!
o
V) o Br8 - i
o v, ,o i: 9dOtn (n
;8 R - 9r o 9) o= o 5
: r a Ut s) o o :s o' v,
s) o o.
9. F sfi rD 6- il X F I 3' 9
FF S d3. 9. E Vt o 3 hl
fr.=
dF g o ,PO
-o r n o FFi fr o 'l Fl l-.H)o)
O.F{o 5 o :
Fl
H.
o o od6 (,) ts I € ut v)
oF o E r-) o F' qb A\Dv, tn
+g
J J
{ 5 g b550 g qFi .) o pJ r-t
rD 0r o o f)
A V
o xE HJ d
l + | . l o F 6F o F €6 oZ' C' F 5 Eg E
^ A
vt rD- rJ v, t.rfD n
+-- 9l o p ts' F o tr .J
€ ' Ia=o ' 5 (a v, o dE F5 i' o
9) n Yj-H. tr € oo o H g3:F qJ
Er3 r'+ 6' v' o 5 t, g
4$a !r o 5 I o *s) o
/. -. JJ 'E) o r: p) ii' H (/l oq v) v, tr
o
EE V) fD
.) 9) qx so (E- jH E
5(+o o E o PJ JD v, ?.o o d
OaorK oq o hl o o
V) ir,; 0)
ir Di qH 3 g . tJ T5
o oq g3 a n r-11 HE. E-
au'g) v]- 3 rD o rD g)
r)5 9J o € o g) v, S)
EqrE
=g) FEiE'
1 9 G n cIJ (D 5 €H r5 -'
F H V Y 5 r-t
F" JD o gq 0) F o F 6-g o u, o t , gg ;- OJ
;,sF ='l - U o F rD !-i "o o -O o
o +o F u, E' v, F *h F
g F tt 3I t rT
Fr/)H € (D s) o: Ft\ V) S)
5. d6 61 €
- n; cr-t vt n so
E) 0r gq tr E cts *l ft € $s o
=Fb:9 0) o 5ts ut .) vt trd E'g 5
F 5 o tr os 5 olo oa s r *. 13 =
o F5' s.f E (D p ; F Fl =' o g.a o EFF (n
;9I \J p 9) o *aH.
tra-A otr () o f5
o v, o tr
v, og. tr
€ .qF o o oli o 6? 0)
Ehl q+E,H
tl
='E q ry
o
Ft !o E FqB$ V)
g. BB a) o E o
'i .J 0 5 o
fF
F
(n E ol $ o PJ F @ t (D cr orDv)
o iiP Fl o pr
o (t, vt rD;6 € it r) o a { r+O 4 o
tiH Xi' vt nj' o F
-0) =H) o o
5 E) u, (D 7l v, I
u, o EEg&
s) = o ) o g{ o F g, n H) X Ft ;-. Ff
5 o) oq o 0.5 o o rt> v, gE o e? 6'
F t 5(D 0
isr o FrO 0) oqo p F tr fo trs) o
6!'?= Vt $t
r) Cf o 9) v, v)
F
t) oc s o v,
o o FJ o 5 Fq ? Fr
-'u o u, Vt 0) tr qq v, \JH
og v, o?i
H
o tr
E z<
F{ X
H .q'E v, f6
cv,
9J o o o vu) K
9E
V, V, v,
tr
E5' o o Fl tl)
rD o O5 i+o Vt gq (,) F o
q, ' S H E
q vg) p s o o I'!t rlo
H. /'\
EFl €
r<
65 n o 0) o =:(D € n ';. q+
Vt 6e 3 o) a" o Fa f)
v, 5 0) o €'p o
s IE' j'd € O r: o
o g. 0) o o q$ o Fr) FI F
(,) e, F+fD o
o o tt 2.
O o $) ro FEfI
3EE oq oa n
5.P 9J 2. S. 9) 5 tr $F{ 9r 55 g 9J
6' tsr) EH o Fl
V F fD H'5 fD g.H o (Dtd hl
Cna = 0) vtn
sfD 0l sl Boq {ti6='
F | A ( / ) H
li :s E' o -.+ o'
Fl o g vt F) rD rD o H . *
v, ut v7 r'+
C H r H r) B8 f+
- v ar 5 r+O
-(t, E# o) o 6' i
i - - F o =. E =_
a -,2 - - ) "r) =
.:2= xg
=2
. Y.-
- : ra
cI
T.
= EE=E
==;
-.: a
trr@

D
trr T'
Gt= E
rr} l- F}
I t- o FI(D
J-> if G+ !l tr Fl! (D
5 I5 t! It @
t ID *l {D
o g
a e,
o -fD
(D
g g , Cg Fb
(D ! t-t V) tt
(D S) H
ts 5 tsl i', o v, (D o
Hl 0' rD a .ci
p ttt 6"F - o
t(! o
cl o F 3 tg o n Fl vt g 9)
o v, o o it (D FI o Ut
tD rD E 5 o r) oq tD sJ tr o
(D F v,
o .==r !
JD F 5oq g f6 o (D ? c^
w FI 5 0) o Vt 0) it o
o 6F r) to S) Fl V) o o
5 9) s) € 0) f: oo
{$)
5oq (o fD o 3 t F €
(D I tD (D (.) sr -(r, OH)
OJ a) 0) o o V) F' F o o
o p, xO tos . () 9r 5 oa "6 F g 0) rD
v, Fr' 0J 0) (D o o K { v) U2 tf
.J 5 g F s o @ to o
o g) Fl o o o
FJ (,)Ft o o 9) -('J F) o
a € o o o H
u,
u, 9) o € g g o F o tD F+)
JD o o5 p Fh T o o o { H s o Ut
o € cr =s) Vt
o Ho (h ni' o |1 .9 n q E
pJ F s)
g o 0) o n LA s)
V) sr n o
3 n r) .) a+- sJ vr 3 U) p ..: g
o s) 5 5d o v, s) tst o o n F (,) ,-t o
u, F q 4 (D g) oq
0. o F gq o tr o v,
t(,r hl
9) n
(! v, EH o o !) g. f!
t6 ro P. vt tt 0) $ F) o 0)
5 0) g tsl € o F)
p a) Ft € 9r €
rD s) $5 JD o r) d o o f6 F
gl o { F o o hl o hl o
0) o
Cr. o o "(t g s o F
s
F 5 o o o o t-l
gq g 9)
xo F
fD n oo o o
(,) s Fl 5 v, gq oa 9)
)o) q g ho
s" gq F qq c o tr 5
.(/J
o U)i o o F g'
o o F) Fl Fl ga
Hl o o o o 0) + V)
o ^0J oo o t) !', o o 5 v) v, V) g
H) o gq o v, g)
r) o o v, o tu F ro r)
0) vt ,ad n |') r: o o E v, r) crq
rn o ao tr o F o tD s o E) o
o n |.)Ft E Fl cr s v) d s cf) n Fl Ja 5
tr r-l o o F F s 9r o o o
I
g v) o o 7f n tr ct o € F F) o v,
"o
F)
5 rJ o n o F Vt c) o o
5o o o F 9r t6 9)
o s+ v) o o o d v,
sr
Fl
sJ ,o cn o
v, vt 5 F 3 o
t H3 0r n q OJ N o o
5 o o o o
t-f:
s) o p so r) v, o 5 o g
d o v, o o v) fo s) vt F! o o
o o s (o U) 9J fd oq
Vt s)
p € pJ v, hl
o 65 fD o I v,
€ o tr Ut n o
o o F gJ 6' o $) s)
$) 4 Fl g: (') a.
0) Vt o) 5 € o .) n o Ft: I f-) o _(,:
v, r) s c' o o H) sr p F
o 5 9) o F n 0) Vt o
v, oq (D 9J n o €
{ 5tr E v, g+ F! o o tr o
o c 9) o €
Eq vt F fD s o 9)
o o s o
(D 3 f D / g)
ts) Vt X v, o v, F o o
9J o o Vt o o o o 0)
5 d g) l-t F o F r.) $ "o o
? a fD lp \3 o F) o
H'1 p a v, F 9l Vt 0) tr
pJ s+ o o o tD \J n 16
E' c v)
r) u, o f: o
Vt p
o'
so
F 1.5 g 0r v, Ut F 5 o g) o F
Fn s) g v, p) f.) d o 5
o o s FI o
3 H.tD F 5 6" u, (D v, o 9J (o
qq p I l-l
t) I
EI
v, vt F v, v) o n K o n o r) -(,

H*w we know whc someoneis: the stvlisticissuc


322 Flow LanguageWorks *T*
**'{*
as "rd6#ts

,--fu
d t :F 0) a1
*l ffi
oJ) €-3 ff\ f'-*--flT
T0) F €!
a o l+ 'o lJl o \"*cd
(^
v
€5 $L !:-F vt 9ts =< ,.o
v, n
s,+oa
noqq 5
o6' vr() .gBi lrrgo
n-
ir.
i^
i.:.
Ff
Fh
0J
r) p)F s) F
re flY\
s&d
*4*\
q'*#
Y#.0-+ n0J 5 o U) b
!! { u, I E F F)FtR' fD
og As. q5 a) = ' u) oj C'
aq HS o o f,\ re
*€
=H.0J
H d. 0)o i r!
rDLl F. Fl
T E F ffi
t)
o 5u) $J fln
J j F r - ' i ' _ lH .
oa Ats I r) € L# c&d
o o =o S)
H.ut5X Ho 96i5 11 gq
x(D FI
tJ
F o
I C ga.i t s . H n
?. H. F
;) ta =' alr H o o=
h l {
*g fD i-r o N
o
F F
!-+ I'
ffi ffi flry\
u,
a. s
E & = I- o H
i+rD cr r-*-&*
g* *&t
J 1 p qEH
ao t s J - 's)
H . -
ot- t f*\
8 E.E foE SF qd6 9) \< \*-#
+OqX V'5 tro o
'+-X o *H \J
r-l xo o f,m *ry
V) d;+ 11 o
6 o iiv (D 1 &
2.5 = Iq ,) 38 @eqir
oa5 sqH F o
o-5rD !)' d' M ? re
H H . n 6 ,39 $o
FJ
*#
i5I F. s n*
o o
*iD s 9) ffi
saE u,
oF EH l.r
55 (,r6 n :\, ru
AW
E o 0r q.J
-€F' E ]1 5E E€
F
€ ffi ffi
gq
0)=. H. tJ o o)!. o 5
t-{ Y.
2 6' 3 o a?D F n \#
o qq ;+ E g)
o3ct F€ i F FH
-;. 0r
*%
r) 6o) 0) PJ -< € Vt
o 9)! 3 B' gq ***8
a Vt nFt t1 o 9)
o-o
t-b
#s
V,
F.
5
0J
u,
OF+
ng 5H. pJ

s
o o 2€
cr
Ii. ts.
o
v, g)
m ffi\
etut
rD ,J. A sttt ) o v)
g |d Vt T o
J
#f o 6€'
r-t 9)
0r 9r J5 oq
o ttr
3'; utH 3H 5
Ioa5 (DFf 5 ofD o
cJ n (D € qq
= o .l Fl
Ls:
gn FJ 5 JD g) (t
= F out 9)
=.=o V) o \J
o F) d
nF5 'P5o o" a 0Ar cc . K-
FI o s ffi
E 3i 9r ga o t o f1
FJ
u, 5 0) € - t
vt E tt) s)
6 ' 3F 5 Ft n \<
5 oq rD o o TJ flb
t'= vt rD rD qq o
e d65' o ct1 o r)
a.
r) |1
-s) !;
t1
=
=
n = = 3 =
i = = tu
n= -
€ t<

ql
: v' e
o !t a €=s dfi'
D a ax(D ta ht Fi
E 6
9, ,/ .+
CL o
r-t UI rD
(! tD i40.r) !?5
tl r'! ft ct ; t(D
o Eeq tA/ = gt rD I 3 r) p-vJ
5 'tr (D p o I t+ o 9l rtt € I
=''D 5 it r) rrg EA !-+
g) 0) fD
(D d f) E) tr rTl
€G S Xsi ' o
9J fD * rd 0)
f! o o T =g C" fD o S qte5 \rgA
t:
Ho t 5 = Ix E s
F; s8 no spl (D cr rD Y o s 5 s q '-l C
i{ ii
o € g
o o v,
q ' E H*
/' q) (! K (a oa o F 5
Fb an oor U) -l u, 9r X o vt o
rD v, o r5 >t o5 n o r) 0) sHX . iqt"u'
nX S) 5 I' 0J ]
5 X €o o o :f 9' o>r (n o 5 v, trPi H F
g -t;
Fr 0) o5 vt o. 0) 3 '.O s -l ) H '
-oI -(/t sr )-l F j o o o SFls+
p) '( o 0) F) X
r vv
o, 7f s) p o i' $o
5 (D F I H
o g r) Ut oa X .qg?
"r c o o F r JD Vt fo n
o F6 o a pJ H.H
F n rD cta o p g) srd t-{
6
o g) d tsl v)
fqa o oq -@ o s o I'9J o V)(D cr F o tr-otJ
r) = N o o H vt n cf_
FJ s) 0) 5 o o o I-f) Vt V) F
9J o n :fo o tr o;t E R H
HH v g F r rD s t n E 3 o o t J A oXv)
?€ {u 0r 5 v)H p 5E
(') s rj tr LN { gr ts cra o sr F r.+
H
X
qJ s) "o rD o A cto
rD FI Fl vt 9J n F tv='F
9€ rdiJ
o''U o o
F
gq u, { o, o SJ V) oq (') g s o ts
t?t O o F r) OJ (,) S) s) qf
J= ;t 0) hl t tr o n vt
E(D o
tr 5 n Ho oa { i.j. sI E
oE ciI 9) n = rD I .v) o o o 5 o!? o x' rrl
16i; rD oq 5 o ga oq p) o H P
9) vt F 3'O P vttsF
E € o p hl o N F o f) (t, o
otD ti' o € n qa o c (D 6P 9J
a S) oa o o
-(/) 0J K ,Jr) E) Vt u, 3;s Fb
F o AJ 9J $a = v).
od n 5 p 0r a) o o (,t) o Ff!+J
a6 ,5O ga s) "o ga o l'' (D d
o d oq o
g qaF o
igq F o r) o
o o v, S) 5 5 5 er
g 5 a F o 5 fu Ha)
o!t g? 9)
o HO o 5 5
g o FI $If FE=
o a I 5 o o
v, 9.] o.p F) p E FJ) @
.+O tl N th
o E H]
oo t o o :r H.o g 0) p 0) f)
(D F)
o + foi .9) . T S r D =
H (D g 'F) v, d 9) fD
9. v, o 0) d o ara ,)^ =5
5>1 ta |1 n 9.5 s
' t: t o (DH o v, d o n o
Fl) : t ) cj n Ora c c, o
o o o oq FO qa 5 n 89, trn
r)
{o o 86 iJ c) o 9) o O(a (t)
3 tr {
0)
0r o o
3 e - u,
F.
ar+ F tr :b w v, fD g)
H H&
et fDc+ oa I O, o c o
g \J r) 3 AH Ft
FlrD F o oq Fbr) o u, 5 0) Iro a<
'+O -(/, g o I
5 .CD o 9J19
g Y f)
ts ro+ H'
0)'
o X ts o 0J o 5 g Fi
a-+ O a € F) o Vt o \5 o nn
F rdD o o o o tr v 0) 5 t-(
€ i-l )J Vt
Vt Ft
$H.
g vt o oq (,) n I'U' o 0) 11 n oo o.5
0. .r p H sr F. rDO
F o v, A 6 ' o o r)lr H F I
€-* o o o izE !l) s) t H.
p (D oa o o tl F OF
t)tr ; V) F H o
oq o
hl t fD -h ? o5 tr rD r) F
* a8
U)l o OJ u) I I
B5 _(/) rD Er) yr, -(r,

323 l{ow w* kncw whe re s*fi1esneis: the c*ntextual iss*e


Haw Languag*Works

v, tg f6 0r '-t
o
hl o T o
Fl
o q 3"o $ V)
o o s
Vt V) Fl E
qz I E v,
tD
"u
hl
o Vt
pu)
v,
oo
u)
o o o
iIH'g# 5 H€ : E,s E'I * f f;
o o o 5S p Ut 5 A'38.3e.
\ H -vj
o F rg/'K gJ
\ qHEH
F ( V H € 5 fD rl td
s E Oqq
SorSrE
B
= $F3;€iarstF
o 9 V q.1 o
H) an lJ o
d il) o
.-i
Y
o
vrrDrD 0)
ro
o
Fl
(a
o
o
qI!
a
*g
Ut
F
-l
5 o
o
gq a F3

F6-
F$g[gI$1
'vt F's E € n s) ; i;€
(D z0) (D o sr€
6s) (D Vt o $ A E. PE
,t
r)
o
x
/
E.ng] 0)
o
v,
:r
tsl
o9.
6-+
Ho F
E
o
Fl
v gFtq'6r.
+
# i:*EF;;fr*+
FI EP fo
0q vt
(D
tl
olxo
RT o ts o
9)
p
E
\ r rqDs tr $
o
'ct +E BH;i
l-l'
o v,
F ' E I E 8 . : f 3il8
Vt T=79 € €\t tr o tr
FrE;Es i- '
o O(D Ut *BEiq
n tr r) F 9)
9) F{ vt !)
) o crq cr v
iTi = S.S 3O cr 9)
F. hl 0)
EBHig.F CF
) SntoX $ Ut
o sl r)
H\
sr FI 5 (,)
g -u' F g sJ E I u, S) o v"HFt-Oa
o r) 0)
tr
(!
5
=
rr.s r 9 )o
5 v) o.
F
g cr 9) FI v,
rD fo
0)
: EI*E
*p)tJoo
n d o'{ - o 6-d $
o
o € Vt o
=.rtgo o €t r) o $;HTE 8
Fi t)
v,
J
o
l)
s: 1; 3 0J
3
$)

o
(D
o
0)
o
F 'r tg
Sts
F
r-l
(D
F
.)
vt
o
H:
o
v,
d
5
v,

vt
#*B€'t
fiEFEiE
or5'
fn
* gE q + L F g r?E
/ =o v, ?; E 8 s
cr o Ft)
@ F{
t.)
F o '- ii. f.) tn P e*xg***[is
ql
il FEE
at) t.|
r-l 5 0ro o
i< o o
vt T p)
@
o
apoO F) n 3H
p5 E
v, E v,
FisBl
F 5 FJ
so +:eEg
H Ut
(t)

o
€ 0)
V)
'o
o
v)
o
o
n (D
o o=h0)
fi €ie$€E;B€
0) (D 4 tFl = * F S.qB
r
E6q $;
g€ 3 } r g) u,
= 0l aD'
v vt F
€ Ut
O. gq B'E H'6 d r3sET3[a5g
6
Fl'
o o IO. 3 rd;v, 6-Ea9R
Ffal o I g) H FEE
o g) r)
hl
$) nt F o FJ T i H; I
o gE v) (D Kg n
(A o * t6 R.a t E R
-v
? -z [: 9) 9) o)o 9) o
'o Vt Fl € o
A g f sl oJD 9)
o A :
€ gi;
:. :s + o rD =5-$q
if FEF*EgE
F A'-
a ; b=i IP € E E ?7 i E
EZ: Lg; +:

e
{! 3
IH
a o GI ,',S o E*
a o p
3 cl o s +o)
a-l o. v, ts. Fl o o
Fl q3
€ TA
c(D u,
J @
=t 9) i'.p o f') q
o € t! u, Vt o o o o X vr. Ft'lJ
'6 r.l It ryl01
E o
it d vt r{: r) {
rD r AA o F 9q
fD fD 0t "d o t, o Ut 8) g o 5 o ga 6JD
o (D 5 (? 3 ts' O. v, 9)
o s) o r) r-t r) s 0) a- s) rl F
fcj 5 p o rD sl 9) o (D n o €Fi
v, n (D (D 5 fD p tf FJ oq o o o s+ F
s7
-o g) tH
F) O. o v, G Ft !+5 s) Fl F5'
6- hl g) (rr g. fD gJ t-l
n o T v, {(D rD u5 5h ts (D t?1 Ef;
a td a fD \S g) Ut N p
€ o 9l € F |-, It g) E t!(D 9) a6-
o sl 5 o E o p Fi' 3 o r-l
n t 99 o ,a fD= 0 FT ts,
o o 6 o E o o 6 FI, H 43 gq a d 5 Arl Es
F) tr Fl o v: t-t n _=fD 7t I
J l g oa o d c) Ut s o
trr F o F U'
( 0q 0) o E)
g o {oJ oq \s Ja
so $)
c = o o o $ o o F 9)
til
E E8. vt p f3
{ o F v, s- v, o F qr 0q .+? m o f)c)
(a o oq
5 v, u, S) rD o o
a o o € c o o s gtst
BF FF
o- 16 o g) o o € Jo sl u, F n r5 o 3
f! t-tr
sn (t) E \0 o :J gq fD 85 F) o qt o v) t H H
o., 0) !a Ot o 0) sr F o
:'t T o F o s JD Fl
FI
o o tx s' 7r s) (.) n e . q g
oo
r+ ,f rd i' g o a) u,
o o 9) o v 9) 0) 5
U) rD 9J. rs o Vt Fl = iJ Ft €B iJ o ta oq6 d
o o v, Ut p p)
\5 o n p tr rD
n (D Fd F LA 1 tr :b F FcJ g? (! (D
o t ts u, s Fl o FI 9t q. 8P.
g) o o o 7r (a :J t gq o ra g) B 0)
g \s F Fl (,] (A
qa
d r I r) 9) (!
o o fD f) o o oo E i6
oa o o \J o 0) o oo
d o E o s op o F a 3 0r
hl
0) o U) 9) vt g oq o €
(D 5 tr A*
Vt hl
ct o i o s. pJ r! o 5
3H
o E
n s () *6
o c1 o
F" os
fD
F --r F o ct o o I
m tr o $ $ 9) (D o
,ct .UJ Vt tr:r
Fl s F tr F
r) o 4 { d A r-l ts Ef'
ta p) o S. rD tr
s)
o 9) o ra (.0 q9o tD F n E
f r, t, o o
(D I g) 0) -l o o tda 1
5 fd (? p) o (D o $ o 5 5 F o oci
r) (D r-t (D o ES € o!'
o X Ar g FI g v, vr u, .) Ff) rD 5 sJ u)
o z< g)
rrtt ts v, "6 E o qq pl s F) ql 5 gio
T Vt
o o c)' F o IJE o s &.x
s) g) FI :5 (tt tr
(D F n ':5 o o
c Vr5
tD 3 ry LA n
s,tr
€ 3 ' oo ot r
o o o n 9) s r)
tsl
3 o o o o o ni' o €
c, v, S Fl iJ) SJD r,
5 o 9) o o d $g
J+ o o d tr v, o s FS o Ut 5v,
o o: I
; p t s) o o € \o rt,
5 g o trs
o gq o. oqq
sJ H 0) fD o
Fn s vt $ro vt 5
tD F p Fl F I o K {.q g)
€ v) J.+ v! ;v, cr gq V) 9) =,
pl o o o f.) 6 $) 9) o
H o r-t "6 tr go5 -sH
o o 9) 5 ts 0) o u, r) JD n vt tr
LA o o E sJ ro 0) o 9) o po Ha
zt vt
o 5 o (D o 5
fD o 9) o o o ta 0) o F o
FJ
t o o v: d o oz .t o n €F
ts \5 { gq (! tr ts ? "6 o (t v) o 'o K € H E;
0J
9) F o 3 -l 0q
3
9)
9H o o g8 fDH
o It-q F) o € J*(D o
v, o s o sl A)
o
so
F n o o Fl n F) oq o E gF
Fl 0l pr rt r) o n E
s) FJ (D 9) tD V5
I v, 5!J
o s I
o ; I
tv, I !J 5 v o B.g

325 H*w we kn$w wh*re somesnei5;tha contextualissue


326 l.{ov*Langu*geWorks

ggg ggrggg
gggg
Iiggggggggggeie
g!$$ rFctg
$i;eeeea Ig
Ifi[Egg$g
gggggggggr
EggEgg
Eg ig
t+
rt : t
I D F}
vIt 5r
(D
a: F c EF i' tir d 5 p9 i E
Fl -g' €
F
s( .gd €(! Ot o5 Fl €
rD - 9. R gt o) E o
atc, o
;'g. F r") a. €=. tr
7 ,1 o g 55 OJ hl
(D n o
n rD € Vt 0J g) 5F
Fro E # - = :t (D o oo 9o n o € -o Vt
o o 9! o Ko tr OFr
O8l
(n g 5 v, p 3H) $ (D
v) ga fr..o€ o o o oo Ep) o o
o o o pJ fD u) o
F n
c.r
rD 5 rD F 5 ar) vt s Bt
,r) oa 9) o C-F rD v,
E5'E' d F oq o 'c/r s pr o ot O F I
Io o d3P rs i' (') F FJ € o FZ' € sr
o o tr o s) gq
r) ;'+ o
,=r 9. o (,t V)
3
gt fD o € rD F o ox d
:ao ;g E 3= o 0l o g o o
g) o X
d' o o v, 5 o F =' Vt
g) 5 EH
oE 9) Ut K hl 5 o rD E'
qa il :-r g) Vt o 0q
9.rD .J =: E =
I o ? r- i' o 0) q{ { o 9)
o PJ
o N h€ c oq or
H. { d € 0) 5 pE F
a Fl v, g 3.5.5 F a) o og o o v, 5
't- v, o oq o o F o. o o Ft 5 n oa ild oq
hl qFq' uor qo qa o sg 'o Pn g cr tD o tr
tr o tr s) 5 oit = H tr goaoo
9) o vt Ft o V) T F)
s)
w o 3 n !? gq
o r) to o) 3 H o fo ga
+g o €Jg n 6'{ rD F v, (D o
ca = o $ r)H r) 5 ;a ci' (n \J F)
! - F . 9) oq F ;o o r-l H* (D
r o s Is) E Et (D R'' FO o pr o o €
? 3 H Z's oa s) -(/J
F 9J
-vj F8 o rDH
3 7l :: .:
o o o - tr SJ 9)
EtO Hl s e# o +or F
H.? & s v, o a1 F o €
n 9 9. o o FJ Fr0 ) :f vt K
v, i' o .) 5 F oq F
DOJ
g)
so o $) # ='5' rl u, 9J g
Ee
HVt
'dd
@ s)o ga v, c F
s) $=PF r
s qq
o t -)(+D o o n C E Ut o
5 F F (D v) -l
X n o F
qa ot.0
3. { o tr .E#
H*
o n 5 { ttr s) o o. I
d 5 p) vt o o c FT .) o git o
9J 0)
o
x
-vr
qq
o
u,
x=
V, r+ JD
ga
E3E n o r) -v:
6 'g
oo 0) u,
o
oit tr r.qE ,.o (a tD id Ut o cr r+ v, ,o
-tD o g rD o
F v, ut -l fE tr
s) V) 9) rD 0) r-r o o c rD(! tD
i'+ o Iu,
5 Gi'
tf)
{o F
fD oJ) X n8 $) (D o t =.. F FJ V)
ot ' i+O 0" r) Egs F vt V) o vto I 9*s g
o) (a g
€ =' r-t - F { H
Ea v, rD n r+ 0Q w o
I o 5 u, o o) n P E o o
Ho v, o v) 0)=. V, P. 6 e F
t o 9l Vt s) i+r) 5 vt
o o dA o o F F € -l 6 d
p o 0r o 5 oo o v) g=
5 gq f
E:ff g ,... q 0) o 5\< o o
o I t s . Y L . oq A' o
r-t o Ut o Fl g) s PJ tsl rD H. w v) v,
5
{o
(t) 5 IJ Fl
() 5 s) S) o u)F E 0) S)
o o nP. B &H g o 5 'o i'
€T g) o o n o
sl o o rD o(') i 5 n o 'I
Ft5.E u, oq N qq o t- (') F FI'E |:u
g Psl u) a. g16
F o 0, f) r) O. o
o ntn n '-l i(.) 0) o)o o 5 H
o p)
o o Fb F u1 s5 )-l o 6- 'd o
-v) o o qa fD fD (/rn F
gq vt F? F) vr
o gi.8 Fl o o o
{ 5S. F ? +rD S+
o o + o Er gl E F ts8
or 5 o o 0) 0) o 9) v,
!-) o o 5 n F) d 9 (!
o o o
Vt Y
xv, ["s FI FF # I I o u, a. nt
cU '5f D o. ta g) o. #g s

327 Hcw w* kn*w rrsherescms*ne is;the c*ntextual issr-r*


l-'l*w Langu;:g*Works

a C' pJ $= ov)
EgE € OJ 3 U, t-{
o. t|(D
v Fii rF{ "6 v, o F E5' Xg F Ut F.. (1
U) IJJ V 9r o H 6 F 0) t)1 !+n qq
n Ar) A. H v, Oq oct u, 5 {-,
R f.ia ol ii. v, fD
-u, oi rD o= o g E
iri 0l H.
o Frl 9) E o o '5o0 Ft u) oo F
i{H d u5 ol 0J v, (')
; gqo gT ge ,fg 3H 5 8H
w Ot.r fd
9?6 o 8"s b o a !-!' rD utF r)
*al H 6-
o.p "o v) (tt n To !.(D oq o rD o 8 ;
a o ts. V, /H: hrR 5rt
'oJ
oa g) ? a& =o +{ 9J 5 vt
o "d HrD o v,
o= pJ -vl -l O rK rDF: R ct E H Ut d !?E
t v ,i2 ii.E o
EE
+* {
l o rJ) fD
r';.
$d 16 o 16 (-) Fl'
g) or Oq
5
(f-
-i.
T
-orD nt€ ? rD vo
aFt
a) u,
ct5 t rt) iDo o grO
H$5 5 gx ('rH d
z o
,i td ct "iO
5. Fr ci' n hl = 3 o o -a O.
rv
Et s $E) v, tr
[ict 9r pr 5 o ^= V, € ;io
n a) ci' o Vt
(n
d"E fi t-< iao qH r) o 0r rH
u)6
o
o? hl AF 5q
o
F
f6
c) ytr
rf g a o S) _?J o o 3Ft r) -oa 7i E' pr ;+ s)
rD 15 oA
H rD$ o (D Ll 6o 5o 7f
Ut
H -lr r-{'
tr
v,
F (t 5€ i-i rt oE =. o o
E5 o 5 f EE
o o sr gq ycj v,
d Vt g) e 6 s-I' s) .(/J
v) o 3* g)'.{ 5d HO -c/'
P h I F
Hs+
9x.0, o oJ
E
r-t o
o i' hto 6H 5' g" u) ci' d
o q d oa .(,J
o
5'q o 5 6
gJD gFF Fdo E
-r+ O. q5'
t o g OF Vt 5 (D o
Irr 9) 9. to sq= o)0q E.€
E i i 9r o p FfrD e=. 9) X 0).o
Ovt T Vt g. o. sJ oq
itrrF F 9r o vtrD 5 g vt Fi
r9 (lt g. o o
=E'Ft r)Ft Pa Pd vt
-,, p 0J .v'
l.'5.7 F Fff) 5 5 5 pJ r/rO 5O C
lY o 59) n crq o #l' 5 g) Fl: I E E o oB
Ut og -g) 66 'vvt ,g
t-+ n -(a v\ x5. F $)X JD c)
o =' o n 0r o 8[
H) u, E H:' 0) o E oq 6' P. p n N
v, FF \5 n o B& F r:C or r)
o
s'a 0) F 2!' v d ?3 o0l n F s) 5 . f i
o
Fl SfD o
(a (D g) o 0)
Ft Vt g+
s8 (9 tn ru B$ n (DH d63 o O.
n i'+ v) cJ in 5. 5 cnc
-(a OJ 5o) 5 ?gr
tr E 3€ E tD
g' 'g o sJ o v, F o q o. { s vt
5 E1 Fl u, p B9 n IHov t 5 F
69 F+fD o g gq s.K o 96 c o gl
H* q oq
0) o n 5 v, ll- g)
BaP .
- r D cJ PJ 0r 9)
a 9)
e. ni ! .( 8q o id Ofe F 3 o
l-l
v, fd r+. d n
H. o o FJ o n OfD s P I 6X:
cna FJ I' 5 : +bt r (D o
5o ct .+J 6' o 8 3. v, hl
E-.o r) o p) o.
' n g) 8 € 9J FJF
Fl l! 0J ts s prl =' :l o Fl
-
) H
ID qd nl 9) HS v, id
I'o.
5 -v) gH tr o
fDo 5 rD o -(rt o u) F) a)
F Fi" fD oct ' + (,r
r6r 6 s ts o,o
v'3 g) o :l s) Ft
(Dv) Fo
o x ' \J d o5 n sr oo
t) oa 56- (? 6H
OI 5< o O) a, v7 F# u-= + i ;.i
x o I 9X
J J

6 :G
==
3 =- D
=

F
I
G}
;'
Gr' u D
r
a'r O r! t 5
:-- t{!
I' g.
F 38 r t B It
9r it I $v' o (-!
H) I'
g, g f; 5
GI tr3 H l-5 9)
I3 (D at, o AF s, tr oq *T*
(D ttt tD Ft 5
g !-+ tr
?.tr g) ll1
v,
Ft tD o o 9)
5 o FI Fl
s $."r t-t ^r
E3 H3il 5 9) sr oa *-*-t*
-3g C
) 5 p lrrDg) 5
tr, T v, 8B oq f) F c) o o
a f) (D FBF o $ n .(/J ffi
tD fD O. )+' (DP u, u) 9J
€i o p 1;F 9) 0) (D
ct t-t ts L*J
o
v,
\t { gBB Ur+ o o tn fD o o
o Vt EE; a- o
o F.L E -u, 0) **-&*
p) d u, g
Fl Hx
j- fD d €
o (? o H
,' )+- O
l EJ 8H' F
o
c) F Fl
o (A ***q
4
qeskahh
o I o
2 3 s+ {oo
x o o o
€ut E o o
:r 0a n 5 oa o 9s3 }-| o F
(^J F vt F n Frl cJ d*\
=6 t 6 F) t, o o fD 5
6 *FE n s) o v, oq \*J
(D 9. Fr o Egu' g o **\ fl\
o p F F o &n"-"&*
*B *fr Hs
:=. o qq
gq v, o ut F
9l (? 5 5 fd
2 B'F#
93 5 F 0r F o tr trr *d
0a s) F E "B o
=J a) 5 o $E F oq q
o-3 o o5 (A (D {D o # ffi.
o vt s o
is i z 7 ' 3 F
P H6'q
it7' 9) V5 FI € KM
ttt$l o oxv' n g) IA o
9) F 9) o g o o
? d € tsl F Frl
oo g F H H o tr p F X 5
5 s6 E :is (,) =Eq v) 5 o o E)
or r) F g) oq -'T\
asF d s o *a + JD (D s) sr fG.f iI r S q&t
-+ v, rD o Fr o 3 &a*ct
E. 9) 6u)6 !) o r X f6 F
i. irE. o C' o, A"F Y^o F 'p, Ut o 0q ft
o oq
F
F8tr s 3 F JD I {}
o|T o 95.\ o sl
gq
H "-? = * ; ti, F. o 3 F p n o m
><c/. o o s r) E) o f**
A) cn
p H TF 9d o
l-l €Hg o p o F o 9r
H gq o@ r-t Fl { 5 p
v c t| ' o K o F 6.P o trffi L*
oa tr
g) p) { v, .oi+ v' o
o r: ts s
gEEd 6 - r5 F; JD FI F) 9l g
gq rt o
FJ F g
(.) or E' o5
o s€
v,
o F) ffi ff\
a oo
;ogE rD s9l
e.FS qq s tr 4 t.) cr o kJ*
9J rJ o s) ,3 H.t s o r) ft1
LE'
vt
n f)v, F E..' F X o
o 5g o
F W
5rt g5' oq Fl
qqE o B OH ? - sJ o 3 o '_l gq .O1
o o Fl firun
FOq it H) { X s) F
q, K
o i i s' o :s [ i t ng
3: ts
\J ts ts o
F
gq Lr| \J \d
ry q-ffi
*-f{
#7 g I oo o o F F 9J **#
9, !t tD u,
g,o qF o o. oa I vt
€HF trT\
1&F fro
F'lcwdiaiectsdiffer from languages
w} n
330 How Langu*g*Works

g) Fl Ft Vt Frl p o -l
18.€?+ v) V,F d9 { (D oRr
o € tr
= o 0) H: 6' t-h X TJ - E.q
g) c o q5 o o
Hl
o o
F E g +F oa no
ttl re 5 ni' o o
Fl F) o !!r'
D) g. o 2 o r-t n
-l orF; S) o (o oq r-l I.O
3E*flE q f.) o g) o sJ
F! Ft 0J O.. Vt g g) =ga 5 Iid. 9J s €
K U, Po Ut :€ gd
tr o p T F
r) p) ; n+ w X(a HR 0q rD o = . o ct { v) o
l-l :o
o o vt u, o n)i+ qan tr o o- 9Hl
H F H€ 9 p ZH r+O 7f c)
5 o g) o (A o o
(.) s o 0) x oo gq $r FJ 5 F ;: o.
9) ry v) t-l gq
vt C { fD
6'o E opr v)5 o g o :)
:HEEs o Fl
o dL
(DF nV) o ov, -ut o
6" Eo7l
g
o
g (D E x15
a ) O t1-
;b g grg 0) o
F ' pi4,
.ur ge. 0) U) qq o gq \5 (D ;{ =
iN; F o 9J g)o € ='o tf pro Fl vt p fD 5 5
o )v, € s0. o fi'H
o F F5 ord o o ? 0l o
o oq .L g FVt fTi
F)
E. H. zo
o F 5 Fl vt 6O 5 o
Vt p gq O orfD o f)
:E gEg g oa tr o !.t S Ct R
- f D{ € F5'
oo oq t-{ n .(/J
o\ €
o
o p) (D 0,
u, oq C qtr
n F) o ..3g ct
r) V) o ng' o c U o ltro o o o r-\ o
o v) rD X' s) oq U' F. o t-fHr vt s) v) H!
w 9) f: X p
€fi il Ff; v, 9J av, F) OJ
f.)
iD' U ) cr 0J s)c F )-t p) 9) CJ p
t/)idoag v) 5 s) v) gFr a6' a. = H'H
r-l: a F 5 i-i o fD F 9) ut
I o I lY l-l 5 gq -(,t g!t '.O o ZT ol
f) t.) gnn s v,
o "a o EF o - 9J V) o E (n
v, q)FF q1 6o 3 o Bg
: F'o =: v, 0r t) 'o s)v, C' 5 p) JD F
EEE' i oq.) E *V c p) rJ
E 9J g) o Ftg g o Pg.
qq o s v, u, 'o59 ) o tr I 0) 5'
t! Eg hl ts o tr 8,f U f ij' z 96' s) v, n 9) g r) r-+ 5oq
0) rD o v, gq a) 0) E o FJ E 9r g
5 g 3:s g v, V) oq o x E sr o rD
Vt gB F r.JH crq D S)
d=.'o JD o { o oo r € Ji s) 0) ;6'
F ts Vt v, o F g (D p
qEili oa- Fl o F o 5 'B g)
o oq oq (t, 9r K q9.
5v7 !+ F v, = €
€ 9) F Ut E' ,t S)
F g €8. :s 90)
tn o o o vt oq o o
o 69 F sr f g
OJ U) Ft V) F FCL
g) E 9Jq o 9) v, oa f FF Vt
*l R q I
. F H p o € o x9 n V) if,o o o u, gq r)
o {o v) $5 9 (t o *(o
-? g - o oo rJ d 0) (1
EI rd vt 0J p€ o
> E E. 9l s) o o (t, F n F o JD €
n v, 5o 5
ii h' ? d6' o F 0) 5 . 9 F?) 9J o s Tf,O o o K
5 3 { n
o 7r .(ti I' o o
;JaR6' f.) d R H Fh 0) o :.t
JD o o I.'d U xn n 1s 3 !L
o s) =o rD (D0) F arq t-lo s) z\i o
E o-6-E X o qg F) o x oq v,
5 T 5G 5 (D o r/rx o ct
i:9JFi 5 {
ii( oa5 v, p o. 5
o o ni' o F v) o o 0r tr
T *p rfO B v, 0, o € nID r( )DOB) sr o h
0) 0) o o r) rDE) o F o hl
o
v)Fnt5 or (r) ; dk o (r) v) €
s;2I 9J n = (D
o L!;
.) t)=. o
== -t
= a = ?
:r3 F : = =
t S = :
=

u
!
{ :!
7 g :! a
tc o I ut cr CL
tt
FI p grt GI EL
'D g,q F E ?} F E o r'D fD
illFt 5 (D (t ht Ftd
o (D at *8 s 0 a 5 i'
F fD n8
ot o
8fr o vt Vt
a
Ft r:
835 FI: "c' Et g r< P) o
o ta
F g'z< o ir8
o o tD @ u, F' o fD
t(' f!s)
6o 3 o Vt
€ o (D Fl st -(,r JD 5 tD F
ut (') s.3 tr !)
HF FJ o €a n FJ rt s)
3 :F f.) 'ow v, o'ct Ft fD
S) $) f.) H 5?a v, - .U) v, 7t
t {H F) fD o o 9) (a d o (D
€ o5 I g) E 8.3* o o g, \t € rD o
o F o o 5 f1 F^For o a. o
:Lro g o 7f -(/, 6 o n C o o o
o.5. o n o ;8
H F v) 9.< tr 0r ss ? o \o
F o 5 =. o i' o r) 9J dE \o 5
o Fl 5 6' e) oq
olT !l) -ut 0) tr o 5 -l \o o o
ut 0a t-l o o H o o 9l F o d6 o \o Fh v) 5
ca v,
o :3 o € E'E p oa o'
6 Fl
{3g( D
0r FJ o { t
o o tu
*E o € irlo v, t'D oll p. F w *(A Pl Vt o
't- =ga s) 9J r_t F
gq o Vt
AE FiP
E o (D p)
F n n S) I :l (.) o
o =rD { o E + 6' o E c o o 5 t g 'U E
cn € 9JH o H)fD 0 c 5
r-l o X g 0) v) o o f s: r) o o gq
tr g pJ o p
9) g OJ gq v, p V) o
F: n v) 0J s n hril o (,) tr
Ut o o Eg o 0)
gl F) !-h Vt
v,
H 3 Ho' td
Iv, JD 5 V,. o 0) s) 5 €o o pJ oa
qq o) v, (t
rP !
ts E {s)
0) O. S! Ff o *V, o o o o (!
c 6v
F1
0) o F o g
o gJ' (a 5 o
9l 5 E JD o 0r oHT' r) .J oq 6E
r.) 5 s 9r En o Vt
o 3 5 o
6' v, 3 o gq Ei{o 5 u, o vt C' v, F)H o
e g) € i H. 0) n pJ (^)
P ' d |.1 $) JD o g o o D F JD 5 tr v,
p
c v) {D 5 s) n tD
9, S) o 9)
1u€ tf o
o' 0J n gq V) o ryl 3H' u, Vt
n h? o F 9) (^J q T 8& ct qq o5 o r5 0r
(n Fto o o 9l o
FI n o + o
Vt FH.F. qq o f)
fD
:€a a. ; 5 ' v,
E' o" Vt o o € tr F r,Fi>) =. o) o ia te g g) P
o o o o 5 3 o v, Fl o F a F o
p -9Jo Ff vt t-t a FJ ut r-r ct 9) o o
FJ o o' o o,gJ o u, p U) E
o 0) { o ).1 r) o o
N Hd E J! a o H s+ n 8H F( vt Fl qq
5 Fl o oron OJ o (Do ! d 3
\g_ I ga d o o ou) v, C' 9J
5 . o 0J S) C' 5 € qa
o v, o o E g
v, o vt c o o 6";r g o o €fo g a F
V)r q D I o FI\/H fr 9 o o 9)
o ,-l Fh .+
o C;r o
Ont o 0a 00 F lulOX $)
r-t o F o o c, s)
trsr E) o F 5 .a Fl n s d Vt 5 o vr
tv,
{sJ p F vt t o sr It $& r) F
o @ o (, 5'a'fr gr o @ tod
g v, n n 9) U) o
:3 9)
xl
{fD
dn gq o o TT FJ 7f V) 9) g
Fl 6= |D Vt V' g o fvt Vt i;sq u) 0l 5
Fh U) s) o o o =5 tr I' ltl 0J (! Ut o w o
oq 3 v, v, FJSFJ 9r \J u, v, I,
rg ^. t! fo H: o
a o o o (D o d v,
r.) 5 a 5 oa g 5g 69, o (D (/t o 3
vt
H +(D v, gq o
o tr t u) E- E o gq Eo o { S) t1 o IJ p
fD r) 9, o. r-t *T o
0) 5 ='l+ >l o E F) Ffl
hl U) F o I .J
o ts fD
o o (D o oa3(D o 5 €ri o o 66' d
9) v) Ft g g F. Fa i' 9) 5 o
$x $) Ut Ut hl o o
o I, o I TDnv) I o o I F'? o E.F oq fD I !t v,
t :<

331 How dialectsdiffer fr*m languages


332 How Larrguag*
W*rks

9) *l A
s) *{ o E o o l A ! *
Vt t-t! Fl! + o
3 S )' fi lRLr
g EP 5
9r F |D) tr o o
8
Fn
g qe. g8 9) 9) o
a g) o o 9l br 5P
o E E o v) o
o ?.o o€ *a o 3 5 { FO = Eti'
o -j
nt 6- o $- r) v, o o
o o f) d5 :t5'd
elt -l Vt o o F 5
s, E hl 6v, OH g oa E5'
o v) 3 Vt o
o 5
qa -v,
PS Yts6i o 9) o Fl) F FJ c qt5
lt) o FJ
g) Eo)rJ I t9
o.
rD 5 5
gq o v, g d
o =o- F sr 0, RP' x5(D oq tD
€ o o B
g F sr F 0l == n t ^ or )'t
o (t) oa F o s) oq itn 5 a- V, g) 5 o Ot (}Cl Fr
o o 0to qq ga
t oq t v)
; E b) ? oo 6F
o b o 0) (D
9) 9) 9) F l_r o do
V) oq *g €* o o o 5
oq s) F o
ts €
5 o o FB F+ s) ,J SJ
gq
v: ts oq n P=
o o oq oq s Eqr# q E ' Fr n g o .9 s) Vt 9.
U3 o o rD #45 F
o € d n o o $F 5g o F oq 9J u, v, o s6
a" sb Ut d qq
Vt o sJ rD 0r oqj s)+F,- o O. tr o q'F
ra
o 5 p5 H. 19 C' s. r) tr F) o c- r o o
vt SJ v) g F
rD o o v) !E s, gq
(D 9r F Gu) d
(a 0) o o gJ oq =5hl
n -l r) o 5 ct -fo 96 o fb FI
'lJF.
te= s o v) v, r.l F
o o v,
(A o V)
€p d. 8 S) o
o rD qa Vt p v, n V) :) F=
T o F3F
Ft t-t O o E
t6
'(t
J g 9) ct s gJ 68 s tr
o H 63 or^ SJ (o I 3 oq
crq
e'
o V) € rD p 9) Vt o
F Vt o 0) o7f o p #; I

lJl F) o t! -l p .Ho) o 116 *l o qa


o FI -/a I 9) o o FE
YX F . . F v, p o
N o)
!-t) Ft
o
n
f a'# P 3
g)I'r .vo 0r 0)
o
r) r! gB b'
o g) o n Fh fD Fl. Fr 9r (n
rD- o P(DFf ! g) o 5 C)
,_t)
ttr o 0) 'o o FtfD t+ d) 0r 9) 9) o 5 'ti o
H. g.
r) tr tr o v, (D
vt ut o Ft U, 8q n r- bj o v, (1 F.f:
t 0) o N o p $r5 o SJ o
g o szq o 9) o
r-t ct € n
5 5 0. o E "o 7!io ,*do &s. :s o Vt
o oa o o(D o 5 € o
d (D v)f.) ,5O ga 9) $)
8 k5
Vt F) o € n = o
ct
{o
€ Vt v tr o 9r
5
0) SJ 9J
fFr'3oq. H o 6q p) g n o o s
oq K 3 -0) -tg v, g o 3
O) rD F € o)t+V, o oq o .Y ,r
x
3 cn o u, K9) g3 o g F E 9J SJ
+ E o 50i' O r.+ + iti v, o '.6 F
oa (') d qq;5 s) oq d 5 F.
o o do e.5 o tr5 hl |16 ()
G tr d oa o o F. I V) OJ o if 0a
t
0l lt) S)
o cg v,
F o F) c g)
t16 v, $9)s) E'g o' o tsl Fi
F.
cra sr 7t 0)H Oo v2 t't o g ts o
Ef o qq
{o
w o
ttt
n F tt't o n o 8o f F o o
hl o o lt 6" ' L .2
H=. cj o s F (-J o
o p) X o w ut E
o $) E { v)fD 6s o or i! v, 3 o
E) d u, o E S) C.
o F iJn ct
{o
o Ji' tr c 5 po c o 5 u, g
F n
9 , a;
n 9) (D V) ? oqtr o o o v)
o o 9J q*3. o |o i tr o o o
5 3a 9J Oo) FJ
rt
oa o .g t Y -
P F 9JH E o o 2r F F
5 o ; + } J i )
Ov, oq JD oo u) 0q hl
15 o oq
o F v) rD- Otst gq
o vt r) o FT
EJ n d g) ?5', € o o o
|t 0q 3 q€g d {o o o
o OJ
= o qa o q9. r+
G qr5 1E ,& -r+
tr X 2 ! =
= a ?z .4 - t -
le ?e = € = = .: = ? !

= a s
i!
i

O
-l t
6
F
o I t u It
rit .(t g (t, v,
l- I Fl i' o
o o p d rEr st It t6
! -| EI D gr 7f |r'r Vt an 9,
3 F} C' !' zt 'ct fD hl 0) v,
, (D E o 3 fD l"Al
"tt fD g, |D IF| oa g (D f 0) o F o
@ i' (tl a v, (D o
.t) @
x o rD I, 5 X to gq E oq v, Vt 5
.r.fD cgt 5 Fl
s (D to 0) o -l o o tD o
I st Fl Ut (n !' o (D F v, \5
itt, s)
cp r) a) fD t? (D v, oq tD tFl o (D F v, p
(D s, F) @ v,
3 o v, o 9) 0)
3 o 5 s) v, o o F o 9J (? F ; o p
-vt (D 3 s o o o o g o r.O 16 g) o
9) JD o v) o o o s) o FI
cJo ta o I p Fb oq
d P 9) 9' o o ta X t(.) Flo tD o
r-t F. FI 7r 3 rt Fl g tl
Lo) @ a EO o 7 a+ o n 0 l.{ 7 o r+ n f-t FJ ID F 0
9l o 0r F gq = o 5 o o o 9J 0) @ p"
o c F) o o F qq vt o
fD 5 o OJ o 5
g 0a o € fo (n g (D F tr
v, F F E) pr { gq v, o 9)
iH a d vt oq F v, o i+ tt, o
o o f1 5 o o 5 5 o Ut o C 0)
o 3 gq vt v, E ga {D
c= o o gq F -l o -l F s)
gq n
s U) tlI Ja 0l rD FJ
o gq (D o
-o o F F f fr v, o 9l o I n o
1fD 3 E) 9) (n 0) o o it ra
gq € gq 5 o g v, 5 w vt 9r o
9) a 5 5 oq n Fl U) qq
3
F| fD 0) o t lr1 0) 0J Fl
;ii' I, v, n s) o (-) o tr 9l p o
(D v, p € F p 5 v) n 5 o gr vt 9J 5 v,
"d(D o 9J
oa oq qq gq Ft (D t.)
g 0J oa FJ o V' i-l Tf) F rD \J
:' U'
UN tr 9J
Fl F s)
fd
n n o
g) tn IgJ o
s o v, O s) Fl o OJ o 0J € F o
- c (') ,do o v, o qq o !D F v) o fi' oq Ut s o n
o 9J o o qq o v, "o 4 9)
A) o o o o o ts
5 v, v, v) -l 0) tJ) Ut g o
- p) S -?r 0) (D
3o @ g) s v: sl
A X 0) t I 0r n p o o oq o 0)
(n_ gl 5 n o o :J (, 9) 5 € g v, crq F o
g F) y LA g o o o
F{
o p o 5 o
H: 9J g F
€ oq
o K v, (D
p g
AF 9l o { v, o (a (D rJ P g) 9J (o
7r
o- 3 o 9)
r) o g) 0) tn p) ,f 9r o) V)
o= vt v, t-l G o
F) o T 5
Fld o o
o 3 ts TD v, g o
o g o) o 16 p) q, + c v,
n s) gq p
3 3 o o 0) g o FO oq f.) €
.D vt rj F F 0l d Fl F t
Fl. 5 o F F €' o 5 o o v, s)
.+ U, (-J gq o o -l o r) o) n o EJ ga o
I € !h o vt d S) oq frl
o ut 9) o 9J o
=ro o (1 H d 0) v, to F o 9r
'o o v) {!- o o o o F p I o o g
xs 5 o g s. s 5 Ata s
s) (a FO ? gq (? Ut g s) -ur
th -':. Fl o 9J
0) o o 9l
pr
5 o u, v,
ts o g) -1 tr F ih
sr id o C (t(,) (-)
s) c) qa ?r (D v, o 9l o E o Ft a o'
r-t 3 0J w F
€ t l Ft g 7l oq o oq 4
rDrl 0J o to o o gq Ut .(/J
o o
ro o I 0l Vt
o
p o v v v, g o o 5
F) P. "o 9) vt sl
(Drd s E ryl o o o o ,{ -. o qq v, 5
-l
a
4 a) 0l F a F $ "6 o r- o
-,R V) 0) 4 a o oq o 0) 0)
{ v, v, (D g) € g ,f g ,,6 9) v, F p
o !t (n o F tD E o 9) .J
€ .l
s)
et t (D 5 o o q u, s) o F I
O(?
o o n X 3 F
qq V) o X I
o I fD JD H: (o o
I o F
rD vt F

333 Haw dialectsdiffer frcm languages


334 How LanguageW*rks

5Cr3 d .v, +1 ru qE 9r !t s) g gl cJ
:€ +r 0, 3 6'ff o 5or v, r qE :5 C'
E(D H (D n
"tDo o r'l Ft
5 5 5 5 o (! 9r
(no o, H g n o o t ga t-l f)
= ' H
r-t x H EE oo (Dci 0) E. oq
E'B F di qq h.o g goq J? EE g 5 cr
=r Ft Io F 9)
Cn oJ ::
-g 0) b.x oq P) Ovt FT E. o qt F shr FJ S) r-t
tsxR
id !Z
Fl
H.
o ; H,gF V) oqF v, v, oq c) a
o i. -a oo O.FIF+fD v, oq
'o t, 5 9r
o*
c so o o
oo. v, gJ SH V) o
s)g f1 5 =H 0) o F
3 .H d g :s 5s) 9l Ut 5(D Po) V) LJ
or JD L
no.vt ft V)
*336 xs rDi' 81 € g f)F
2u 5'o€st SJD Frl gqg 0) w Eg € T :.;
I:r o S
o oi6 (/rg) d(D o) Eq s 0r
hl fD n tl
gR Kv)
Ft
oq :5 5
g,. 9r- F) fD o 3F t'l H)€ (.a 0)
3 gb H o e
v, 7l .;
i; *Fb
8 o r+. 9J g
K 4.. s' v) s5 9r o
o5rD Pa 6O w gr F) 5o 5
o* s ili'FE A 1 9 I
6S I: oio to F 0. F
c.9 a 6' r5 EFI
5Ft p 6P 9r o
=x
)v, i-rD V) ipsr ) b o o5 o 5q 5 o 0)
B id' (lO) 0) hl if !n. pr o ga v,
ogr ESEB' os PE. d ito I
\5 o oa
9. 7l oa 6 6 * '-r gr h'? (D o OH t o
o oq ht 5 do. Ut o 53 = 9r o g) o
ie t 6 E g , ao o o€gci I'
gq HV' o ?D JD aoa crq
tst F(
n^H ? ?H.
\<- ttr o d
I H.il iJ 6 v, g og. 5 o n
3S
c+X
'uo S) s 9 oa 5 rr)f i ciH 9J F s o o
3 g e rDFr!
q 5 o p) rD Hga V) o
='o srecE 8S _-Y oq vt qq
E.E'3 o ='F { oa €6 -l do s g t-,l
tt, F o Fl
{ Z€ 5 o v)-
Ft-: 5 gH s)c {+ Y
F'OH E5 g x>' T o oiD LS 0J' o v, o
+=' SH. € Fl
d ['E U o
8 . u(D
V) o F o n
oo F5 FJ H)5 to 9J o
r7,d ;v, ==;E s gq 63 .fvt €
€s, o 3F)
55 pJ T' Fd o
H9, o s
i( Dl .o' , !3Frv'd v)o *-Y K o opJ
H
HE F.E gq
(t p OT 6:S o
g)x o Hv)€ p o H gE o s) s 9)
o s
s)Y 0)i Fl 5 O Yv't ut v, hi s
Fl- Ff frtD FJ v) 5
F. H. o5 o{3 rD 0 =s) o o'
F \ ) r - ( H v, $.r pJ )rO t, r-t tr
oo H . H v, E d v) o
H H (r) ts. H N I J qe+ o s
Y -
o tDo q o 7f o. ll
o i5]5rIo o o o I..t)
;i-. -v) OY hl ooxg. o h6 FU o F 9) o
F.l
r{: V,
o 6-g 35' +t o
(DO' 'o9 g. g q.tr o o o F d Fl
Fl ht 9)
T6' V' 6H 6" ;s € 3-
v
(Dt- {p)
.(/) g str o (D :5 5 0) o
$rC '-L
}TxH F
fD tt, o oa
\"4n s) 5 v, E a a-?r \o) 3q crq u,
F1 TJ s 9J 6)
;i' o w 5 o 5s) pJ q, 5
V) r-t o (D' *5 oi;' tr o cr oq o
o P) 4 ='o (D OJ F+n
0l o tr xl
gE' E€o N o rDE. V) j+J n 5
g tJ (D 9) v,
K'o a Ut ft;r S1 5 o o 5.O
g)
X
)oJ t6 U) 6 o cra n oq oq
o :J
o q rD r)Fb o FJ z tr 0)
rh- H)n 9)ts -. 5 Ut
iR o f D a
o'
E IJ
5 o
0) u, o AFF
On o oq sJ F
3B E H
ivlr)
p5 'oX 5 s { 5
s 9) 9)
l./ rd CA o (D cna : + E
36 - fiiF 5olF.o F x5 g (as H \
AFr Fl i-j. Fl
F TD
!'D u, oa o.: E3 SE' /,= o .O (r) \s
oo 3 v) 5
+Ezs =-P
-€ j;' j. '4 ? t 2 = =
< == , i; - =
t g t t = :? ?= =
= ,FA F
;=
;r ,i5

!f ''!g- p
It Rq trE tt F) o
o 55 hl
@0" o
p o-a ar
Ptsr
3{A .H5 9J
T9 v,
o iDrq nto vt ctcl (t
p $€ sF t r= X (D
rD a 6 (D
X = rDtr 5
{t s o oE. 0)
o E' 6- 3 ct
co F# o
o itp o.g Fg F
FJ =' 6 ') r)o) o
o vtg fD
9r 6'P 5
? EF O. ;+ n
FJ H, v)
H.
CnC v, EE.
odt
o
(a v) o o
n? o
sr9 oE' 91r
ln t-.
o5 o
9H r)(D I

9{ OFt o
5q to
Fio
fo8 .
g"l 5F
ilr F!)
EE i,i i]) 3
*f.) oJ
q*
'p 6' 6' JD
5F
H€ q
u, ri gs, H K
€ q oE. g)
15 q;
81 x"
Se ss rr 5
gq
-oq
E8
oqo
:3
go) 5
"+B 0 ) c +g) o)
r+ gq ts
o
a' o. 9
r-s FHg v,

335 H*w dialectsdiffer frorn languag*s


T6 1"1*u,r
l.;*nguag* lV*rkl ***T*
$
E t s . H n
*e**
JV ! 1
at') oq
E , r ) H . n CLJ
F.R i-' = o
A V FtOo
H
rTFE oq
,) tJ t^l d6"
r! v, fl*r
o. :1 €+ort) !D OFl
oq
SJ o 9F
L./ rD rl) $- fD -j rr) oq
9r$ &il8* F
a , o (h 9] 6
,F(Ut 0) rt o €?Ft ,+ I
-J f,|. Z F I J H. (D o
v i - € \ J E ] i o+
@?.)' H qa
Ar) 5 H95 oq r+. = n (+- fD (D
o1 FlXl0q
o dB g o o rt)
Ft5
o ef-, Xo
CJHO o O .+
J E A
oa gro v)= o
m Y ; ^
v Y *
3;bF rD o
FI
{o o-^r) "0
o rD o C')

A
;
T U NH iq8 o- - ''1 o
tXF't
€ 7ri
qH3 ut
-f
Jw
F
Ut o SFil
o o.e o o. FrfD
.)n
ffiJ
X
v
qFf; 3 o
6 g!,ti+Ff F.l gq oq

o I,;
{ { 5oo r-(
4
H?60
'; Vt o Vt (t) 5 s € ffi
€ 56 E = =q o I
f \ H ni = o5 o o
J +l
rJ1
=6 + Q-d 5 a+ JD (A
o
trrffi
= \# \*{
!9) e 6' d3
H a' I o
H J
E gq f{ 0. hd
}r tJ )4 ir. o erOq'd o o
€ o ;iJD o o
;gtE (t5 n E ,-l
,lHr (tr qq (r) 9r
R d ef cl') oa d
r!) o 6r+ V2
N= g o o o o
Z-rg. 5rfir5
o oo l'l
'or 5o r5D tt, t,
AT
9) Fl
o
v oaolt Ut Ff E ffi#
J r-t
fr o o-l rD
+ v v
M F{
rD oq
u, g) € €
A
Fq2g ct) sl o 6' iD ct)
v) ffi
\. Oqr+ol F-b o o q'#g \s4
- F i..+ (D
o v,
3 0 E 5' rD
F-r,) rD - oq v,
Fotr F H
Y P f A
€ fiq o
E
"o €
r-i|r')n3 o 5q v)
o o flffi
or-ro 9) qa r.d oa o
E 0r5 0J
o
ga oq r) pr F
:l- u) r) H!p 0. rD ; Ut
Ut 'oVt ffi
E o fio OR arq
rDo o
q ? ir' r
-: u-v: +< b o C' XX N
o"o o tsi.
0) 0. s)
15 { a) 9J € oa v ffi
-v) F.
o 0J o tr 5 fD o t,
H P -1.
-.+
E 5E 5 E IJ F{
(') o Ja b*i*
o M 9

.u\ E6 iE tt)
FJ 5' o'
-t Fl
! A
(r) ;E
Fg) 5o o. o
ch Fr qJ rt oq erX th o qq FI
?
- t tt) o F.t i-l Sl
o o
aro O-(, rD
RH€ F r+

-
J f-'
-
rD
oa
FT
n
o
r+
o
hl
ru.
^ ? # = =. =
:-=a= € =' a = ' =
- = !-
- :.:
a L
: :-- ; : =
;:: e

= .|
Fl -o :'
Ot j: 'o :s }Y = a(D
(J ..-n o tsl p (D|D F3P
cta 'o o o (D o (D v,
tt, Fi
o ga 9)
spr o uo o
rD= n E o U) l-t rD l TSJ F (n
n
'o o o o o o Vt F{ o. v1 =vt
o vtv) {
€ v, o 7l
th
oq vt n (D 0. n $Ff
-(, a . f tl{ r o Cl, o oq
o
(? oq o H o o cro n t,:i IJI
o o o y,. V)
o N (!
F H 5 oI. rD 5
.+ (D 0) 3 o
oa rD o $x
o € v) 5 0. F vt IJ *H o vt
o g 5 (t) lr' ln $= OJ F
o (ra ? E6
sF) + ia
o f-t) s)
$) 9) n tr rS, v) o- = o 9) o
r+ o o 0) IJ
gq oa -1.
r) on o o 5
o ta o oq 6P g s) AH
o I T -; o u) o o o Fl
c + p PJ .9 oa
(, o o -3 (A O-r foq c o
n F tr 0) ? o o u) t-{ o G p) Vt
o }-l
pJ
€ F{ :$ oJ
o o -(/, r) Ev o. oq rD
16 o o o oa -1 s) gHa Yga o
a rJ Vt g'6 V,C ;io v) 9)
ch
o o ? rD v7 V)
{ r-t 'o vt!I s) Hoq
uJa o Hvt F
v) o g 9J ga oa v) iJO o v) g. s) (D
9J Ut s)
't. rD l.,l 5 rJ) o v,
o r.) € :r t)
ltt (tt H v) 9) '-b E'
o 9) I s) (t't Fro n 0) o
9. oa Fh
- o F o
oq 'o o
,3t x tt) 0) ga o
(h
vt vt o 0) fH 9oa
't o Ut v, nj5 XH oa {
fD o 9J OJ i+
I
n o n o n r-i f.t
Ft- o o
o o
o 0. n o v) o o NJ
o ca o o \J s) tro s)
(t)
F5 p
0) u) o o 0. o oo
o tr 3 9J|.| s(D g0
o o n o' r-t 5 9J F)5 o
n F K F.l n (a it< cro € Fb
o. i' o o o o o oa v ) n rD o !n
o o o o o 9, 5 o rv d
Xgr
o +j Ut d Fl'
r) n o
n r) o o o s)c c59 r>s) o i.8
o o o u 9) u, = ' r o o o
pr r{ o € o o o 9J E3 =' 0r 0. cr) o o H
o "o 5 i-t t) o =. V)
; V) 0J' 0) n n o o (t)
ct o oa f) (t't { 9) E3 n FFt
gq F s) oUt Ut s) 9r F
rD 6t !-i u2 F
o oq o v) (' 5P. qd6 ga
r) o n'
o 6'3 SJ
o
(/). o o hl 3 oq n po F
a
o OJ, U) rD pr o rD rD U)
o
r6
l-t I oa oo
F|.. S J ? o 0) cv,
$) r.O o T fD o (t, qq
C' o o (D = a. o c i o o ).t
5 o 3 fD rD o (D F+J ir) e o w o
0J o n F Ar F) Ft cnc x
a I rD I rD o qil V)
t Fl tt't o '6
tt) x € FJ
FT (D rD (+ o- o n o 6g {
FJ (D o € o S) Oe. Ogr o s)
v, o 5
x{ 0) 5rr S)
oq o F) E |?
o 0. H) s) g FO o o o rt/) D c D rD 2l o
o v, o E rD t-f 9H 3g rD D
tt F) F F+l ori' o
Ft r5 o 0r rDg v, rt) rD
€ o 9J
Fl
o foo rD o
-l o) EE o rt't
n o t o
E)
O. n v) o. H F I
o 5 o n o rl' : ri
I S)
s 6; qq i' 8F n tjl tJ
v, p) fD o n o o o g)
E0)
5 ? rr/
o o FJ 5 0) o ;- t') 609
vt OJ I o o u) o F-b 5E 3r K SOd

337 l-l*w l*nguagesdie


338 l-{cw Lang*ageWorks

EiEEFEFEigigEE
G
Jt*
F}
!t r}
r |! It -/ ' 2 d o ) rF d !t -t
Fl Fl
fD € = € tE| Vt 5
an v, (o F Fr FFH d
OJ ()=Ft
o d
9,
=' E = ( D
oa / a = u , 9, F) tD h t r-D3 == o vt o
vt f ut t-t 5 o o r-t JD
=sl 0) t) cra I
F) ga (a EH E F++ (D
o 5 o n o d o H s) o o F l t v,
o' r! d6o o s o= i' o F o F sI $
o. 9) (, u, fD g) Ff+ :EE o o
c 5 Vt lr.
F I o g =.H'(D
t., V)
C OJ Vt F J - r . g) rD
v, >f = i Fl U) € v, :b'9 o 5 E 61 o 0) t
fD FJ o rd' s) o . + | . t fDOOvt
o g) I o 9J € F €o o g d
o *€ d
o 5 o o o
cr E{ rD o 5 E FFJ "oH :6-p, o
5 fD
9) F F F'|.llA |-j o
= ot+ o pr o o fDF v) o H.g r-r)
5 0l
v, o d OJ g o fD a"X(D 9l o
n (o o €q 9) =o K o n AE' g
o it d9 v,
tt-t o
-ul 0) ho 8$ I ts
-(t, o rD pJ o EFA N rD
o (.) SJ o Ba t-t 5 tr0r HF i-i. qa x 9J hl
o vt
ES tr
)-l o out 5
qq (1 O) tr orDH F
o = EF r) (,) ca u) Fl o
ll) 9) n o s) 3
rJ) fDo crq o r'+ 5 i-; i 5
ctQ o $R !?
I 5 Ho pJ ,f l5 rtFt},. E F v qq
'o3 v, i' t)
r) u, ild6 c9J
U) o) .dg rD 0)
c pr F oa
$l o oq N t-t' rD
N o o o5 o s)R H. O) !? ct cJ H) g r F i - t o F
o OJ o))J $) o 3 o gJ
C' '+ 0Q o ooq o 'r.'f S)
!-r €
itg o
A) 5 (D ga S) E. e. Vt oo crq
c) oq v, ts Ut
o= o V) Fh o K(r,
J F g o o p E5 0) 6"
(D gq €fi ts E q
g)
{o
tjo r) r.+ V, dr! ilFB A
o oq
qq o OJ OJ H:
? f rJ Vt- Vt
o Ho o F
'-{ W F qt1 I 5 SE o
o 0) o s) vt 'o o fD
o c) v,
I d i8'+ o {
3 it F pr EH 0) s 6' g)
FJ I E E. F v) -J.5 ';+ ! r G Fl
oa t.) qq I'g qa o 0. F { #{ arD F H .
0l n F
,fd ilo o (D;t gq
o F) o tr Fl' Q. f o cra o vt 9JE 5v, =
o E o €5 o F o E v, o o
o v) 9) 0"o F) t)
4g (o r 8 s FU 5
oq F xo tra - H P)
o; r) oq P8
Flo 0) (D qq
o p) F P e-' o S) o o o a 6' nt G
g v, € H , otsf) ri
'i,' o o o
r tr =-
oa gJ'
.(ri E s)H) fD0r ? F 15
ot FI o -oJ G
o o 5 rr. gJ f) P6 o V) €F) o o € o
oa fr o v, F r ' : ot s C I , g o o
F .v t JD s o vto n
o g ga a= H 5 rt) Fl grq g
0l o 6 0 g fDH. a) o o ;
r) t, Fh
5 r't. v)
: sa g
@ Vt o F5
rD o € v) v)
OI'
htrD !J x v, o o ? o F5 tEn
Er5
t 5 v, o 3
o
vt (') (D
o , F. F
o K o v, o trtr 0) 5
(-) Vt Oa w r-f (t o
p :E o o T rD 9 'r =
o Etr F_tJ o 9r5 5 o C' o
3 g, q 1
0) v, o g) (D og
o 9) F nst 5 3 nH. pr s
I
o l5 o o OoJ +sq F
o o "'H ro F € o o cr o I
-(r! ga 0) 9 d v, Fb
K - Vt tr
-(D B=t tt, o o Vt (D
o F Ft E (a= g E*
FF qq 3 &H3 0) q f)
'rJ c
{o
T o { s) o nIf v) g)
i-vt' 3 vt v5 fDoF V) o o o
tn r) n oq
s K ct6
R o o(a o
ut
o hl 9)
o i'o =(D o d o F
9) tlA oo pr ;H9 gq o v)
(D tD Fl 9r o OE n 9. Y. tsr (D
9J B{ tr v $) o
(n F fd= f)D) = sl
(Dv, 5 o aa nt 0" F
I
o oa o F rD -? F'

l-low languagesdie
i-l*rrl l; :rgu;l ge Wilrk:;

?ggiEEEg;=qg
4[1;$$:,a#1lgagg[$ci
+[gE**
:aEr1gllllag
F1ri€F1g
$
EEiiEiElE1Es
iiEiu1g$glilE
igEFEigll
iil-tsl€i+iraEEEIIt
glq1FElIigEEuEg
:1:.?j

s '''
s*,ErH
r=ziE11= ilErrF[gE3
=:i1*E1 iql{E
x EiEl* t:E*F3aE
:igiI*g$ aiEEgIIr*iI+[F
# i*'iEu
-=
?1gg$1* iillEEgIEi Er
?El ga
EgigEilIrgllll*Efie
Eeil;Ei;;iet;aieflta
i[F*EEg+HTE[gg*[[ugns
339 l - 1 0 wl ; n g i l ; g e t die
F{awLanguageWor.ks

OF vt g a'd v ho !,-!: r) K v,
g) o \o 3 Fr:J { € F ) o Fl:
d o o
utz o 6 0) 5 5 o 69 HEg; F)
€ 5 d 9 #8. o 9) o ii3Ft'. o(D Fl
o 9)
E[il#
H !'+ vt o N 5 oo 5 tr(o €
s) :!. v) -l o o 0J r'l 5 n t)E rD Ft s$
9J g)
€fD tr
5;+ o 0r !t v) Fl er
F) OfD
E+ Eqr$, 5 HR N ara 5 x oFt
.h p r) o F ox Ut 5 o 5
-. v,
E -l EE gT 9p, v,
(D
(
fD
o
$ =.cl
o Ed
o 5
d o 3.8 FI'
f E EAT
a.Frtr'O= TO g)
6v'--.H o o 5 Fg)
F pJ
riK 39
o ga
6 ; Fl arq
qN E3 E H H o +Eo 9) (9 (.) 5 B \o
o I g
v) H'
v,
Ho o o q,€ o so o gE [# g i; o+ 9r
() gl 5n 5 F o F fD do
OH oq
iog
.?E E E orq o 0J v, 5 o
€P rD ;F o otD HfD o v,
o V) 4 IF tr oN5
5' B- +H3;8.
5Z 8E;= oq v, { f)
fD 6v, \<,! S) Eq Vt ?K !+- .-l.
t- o
!< 9)
s
6' sl 9) u, U) o 0
9) iaH Eg*H € ci5 V) o tr Tit =o 5
5 d
E rD -oq -<d Fl AF 6-o i-r 0J
E ctF N
srD E FgH$g EFI
it E' f') 0J o ;+o o C' H€ oo >) ttl o ng
q) o
.1 V, rD E+ o ot Oq € o "F o PJ
gq 55 p.:t ct
v7 o r6 o
' vo,
rdO
o trsr
vt
=Fg* F
v, U) g 5 ]'s2
oq F ' o o
Vt Vt
Fln
::r r-)
El,fr[[ Fo
rD
o
o o o € $' ga
-l 2,F
E}fF I o ut OO !'+. tr .n 6 O (n Eo) Fl
nO
gsE L.qg x
.g H'a a) Y (t) v, o i: u, a) o
d5P 0r H,o 9)
€ 9J
oq n ftt u) I gF l.o) FP
t9) Fl { +o sJ
I ZF v, Vt :- v' 8 $ o o rD
o f) (D o oJO o) 5 0r F H
5'q ; . F r nOF {
o u.fD p)
0J I o zB 50 ts
F I J 6-€ o w
Fr t.
5 (h
p s1
F "6 F '0) g r9 N
6B Or1o 5v'+ o Fl s sE 3
o ttr H . O
E;3€* o JD
-o o 5 o Evt o.o o o
€€ F s 3 9) o OJ
(D= 5 tE:6
H
(a q o Eq Ft v) o 5
tsl
9) v) E g€
-l g, o gq o v, :'0 g) tr
d € g) F't 5vro (D o s *€ Fl s) o 0) 60
.4. Vt i5q hl F $)
H\F
-f 0)
dgB (1
!a
fo fd
Fl
o
{ =u, fD o
to
(D
.E
-ts
B'
+
H1$Fl gq
c
5 F!' (a H)
;- gqEN
Fbo
* o o 9J 9) 9)
Vt o V) Hl 8 ; vJ1Cts
3 # ii a
,^i 0) 0) 8;; X G ta r-t P. o rD rr'r(D oq € tr
"o a" 9: z 9) o
F \JT {D Ut o.J o
U) o
o ;
iE o o (a F 96- v, pJ 5 Ja
H$H Vt € .5 rD o
5 o qa o
o o[t Hgrl o F n o
rD 9r(o Fl'
3il g3g o
; o t+ ut c €
o))
'oa I|r $ N ts H.fD (D
tr 4 u, Fh ru 9l FE X 6 5
(D Ut O. FJ rD Vt o
>< i;' o) vt pr .u'H oa
jv) Fh'E P _ 0r Ft { o
9) o 0, r) o E3 o BH *; * o
cra -p.o5a
5 v, oixvrS o .9
E2 T -. o 9) (' F'
>.t F r) U) Eq p 86 o
(rcr c o5 5 SJ 3
lir t-r g o.cia = o o o ;-,,i. gq (' o oI :;q3.h' 0. o
o r-t: 5 o
gi; at i+ Ut 59 +E oJ
*+d F -
o 2. F
9r = ,a' € ='. == -= = a
=1 i= J € E = =i =
't= E 4=:
: -
a

3 I H
E D c' ll
tt F} t
o F t-l U D
st fD @ o
v, E Ffr 8 E F it (t ID rD !' =' v,
tV i a o !'0Gl fD € 9r
v, Fl
g 9)
Fl o a! 9,6 v, Fl tg tf
s xFl @
g
:s F
'tr
r) t |D 5 St llt tst dr=. (D o tD rF td
v, v, o o (t (a 5 g) (D Fl 0" 0, o o
v, o(D os=. Fld v, tt, 3 gq o
o ta Fl t tD o v, ro o o o
o 0) o 9) rd rDIt r-l O ut Fl 9) Fl Ft
o E8 H s) 9) fD 3 tt
F t o F (D O) So) p g rD rdo o 9) ct€l o
F| E
9) g a g 8i', Fl
o (D =l F.
hl
a (D o ?. F]
|.) U o
F rd fr7, _g H H . tr \5 (D o d $ c) o FI o ;.p o
o 5 5 O 5 v) c Vt v, o o u, 5 o
-l @ Fft IE g tD f) 9) o, Ut F €
"t Fl o v, fD
o c r tD o
o !D ;g d v, o o 5 ta
0) € ,d { E 3
o ttt o $ Fl' €g o tD tt o o o (D Al (a oq o
tn t-t FI :s F
r: F o 3 v, p o r)
I p gl
F J F|

o s o
s
o
f1
9l
F
5
0.
F. F+ ( D 1 9
th
I'X
ns*
p:r y -
g
s) 9J
o 0)
7t
o
tr
o
o
hl d
7< E)
p
0)
5 p Fl
aK d
g) g g) r) et Fl o o 0) 5
,' fD o f) FJ 9)Fr 5 o 5 fD o oq
Fl f v, X5E ga o s tr
o !r5 P 0, vt v, :s -ut t 3
o v, (D t F) 5 u)J € hl d o o
Vt hl o(D Fl. n P so o I (D 9) o n
v, g, (D o 5 0) s) |D gq Hl
5 HH3 o !) 0) o Fl: vt o)
Vt gr o Fl o o oJ 5 o F o
cr t to Fl f5 s o d
(D 5 o r) qq i
0 (D
oq F p Fl € oq o "d
hl (D
F) :s
gt fD g, (D
Bg 7f
o € Fl oq fD o o g)
Va
3
(D r)
5 "d A)
= v,
gR -v'' #e' F IEL r+,9 v, o V) n o
'o o Ut 15 o FI
J.
d o gl 9)
'o hl ts* f6 o o OE 0l v, v,
d tFl 9) s) r3 o r+. O. o9)i'
lra
o
Fl s) 5 r-l g) |D qr ttt
3
olJ v, 5 o t,
o o F) o o F o F v) sJ hl
c o o E Svtgq n gq E p o n o 3
v, € n
o K9
s to u, g=
HE 9 € o vt (D u, n o g
o ?o vt ru E. o 3 g s) >l v, Ut
o FT: o 5 o to 9l gq p)
F iJar f.f { !-r,: 0)
= o 5 o o 0) +6 96p_ 3 s, 7r o 9) crq F
ql oa r) qn g) ,s" (D qq lO 5 o g
oq 7r cr r: rD6 o x
0a 16 o o 3 V) o € F) o. s FJ o
r) o Fl o i+ P 0) 5 s o
I 0J v, F OJ o oq -fr
+s s gq 5 s) 3 F -ur
o Fl
o F.t fD Oa F C' fD
F qq
o o E Vt F qq t.D o tr o v) { 0r
5 ttr o r) F 0) q9. 6' q E g o { d d V) E o € F $l
(a Ut (D tr o o o o fD
9)
v, v, t A&2 s) 5 v, o o
o gq o d (D gq n o f)
n c) o
E) o F st 5r o €:3 FF-* Fb o o OJ {D o o (D vt 5
o 'd T
n
0, t6 o EJ gq o o H9 o v,
a cJ tvl Fl
F o 5 qa
CI. oq
F F g F oq o)Ff )-t o 3 s) o F) K o o o
gq o FEE tD o td F!:
s o o r 9) 0. it VrT rfD
o pr (t o € oa F) €
n tr o (F 5 0 .(,J 9l o vt o € o r-l
F 0) 0r
htE) o
hl f.) o rD 0) o 5
fD = o p) , gq gv,o0. € g Vt n F C' o oq
X E o F6 v) o o g
0) g F oa tD { E ,r o g) j
o oa t E H J:J o o I
o o
l? o vt Vt oJ o o >rJ oa o
o F) € Vt
aH i'r B e€ o7r s, Fld 5
n t{ 0r s)o g) u, 5 ct 0J F) to o E
o o Vt o 3o e sR .|-F 5 E o TD FI K o Ut fD I
fD 9)cjg, 5 o
o a o gqrD o
tr 9J g
it $) 5 Fl Ft g o oq g, o X
€ ?'f H. F) tD hl
-ur
ta)r o )ut
U) I
t.o 0J g
s o
E o F x o cna o
o hl $ €[i9 0l o oq oq
o o
d o d d E. o sJ F v, n €
w Vt o I, S) 6!l $d
cv, E o
o 6" to vt- vt
r)
I JD 9r v)
I o U'(D o o Vt o 4
o tr I +o F'? fr
H * w l a n g u a g e sd i e
342 Flclv Langi.l': g* !V*i"k*

H E -l 3:'
9, ) J =*
€g J H r A ArD
50 € JD iD ='
E' rn lJ+
=' oq o F t l a t s . r v
FT - )
t+< i- \<1 5 x = x r)o c a
) v l - (
=oa..r 5
o i-f H V iv
F(
/ o€)
5w qq F v:Fio P
gq Lr Fl tD E --r
v) Fl' o
o X(h (D 3 ro
tsr/) r<r -1
6' 2 fi <
vv*t A
n gq o ox i:N
=o o o rD o g.q I
I . IT \L.'
P e" v)
,r o o
Ft
dis ti H. - =(u
ct oa 9) X)Ft
h
o= r+ ( x6' H v)
tD l, rA otY\- i.; ti
-D 0J Fo 5 -4-
+ro rD fDH
o rJ) H 9r5
FI-J H ad AH.
(ooa
{5f r
XF) d6 arD
x rD
i-; oa o vj P. +5
te
F I | ? ( =
o xrD
E(D rD 2. rD
o. hl gr60)
(DrD o o i i . P Y
.+ fD
g :f
{o
EFl € OrD
;o.< F) -(/, o 6' SJ
rD 6 e"P Ft o d. Vt
tF sa . f D ct) L. rD
F' r+ XFt .r=
o (D o FO5 '.d rq o
6'F o F) 'i
0) Ff O !l
ii.r ,^
-\
v
gro n 55'-r
v) 0r rD o- v)N aoLr.t
FJ rl -ct) rD 6. u tt) fD
o
Hln H
=
t+
= ((t) qq
tD 5 AaS)
Ft g) xb .+=
9) o () i+
o r) o
: oF Vt
6o TA s o H E 5 Or+ g
CA
5t ?
v) 6- € tAOK t P vrr-0
Hfi
5qq I 0) o
o a\ oE.
(o t) v
FI) IJ Y 0)
13 H\Og
o
F) -=
q€ g) o 3 oo F+: 0J
-. o g 5rl o
B !ano
H g { s) oq PC g";
orJ o 9J ag 9)
ppr n o, d8 goq
o o !D n €n arD oq
F (A
C) o ,J- rD r+
r+ o
o' 2 o . J
)- H
oa g=
qP:d'
s = + =- "./a
3 /_
a -'=-- : 7
: =
= i * s

s
Q
7 g' GI
n fD :' -
't I5 ir3 o cl) u,
0J
9,
-' fo H\ FJ
5 cro
B€g, qt gr €; o
q (t) o
oo) (t oq 5 v,
q9. X+ rD E0)Ff rrrO o
q o ,-6 o q 5
= c
5€ o
Fr
; ' € 0) o)
ts coq !-+ Ft o og) 5
o >.rrD () oa
OJ 5? v) v) 5 '.
(r) oH oo =
8F (D =5:€ € 9l
.- = { rt€ o >t
a o v, o
gq o 'FgO ar. 0) .l
3€ o o =v) Ut
*ry*
C 9)tD o o
qq5 pJ Frl
qJ o F
E 8 (h *fu
Fv) Fl
pJ q 5 d'a o
:/ oa s.3 0) o o
rD 'o =(a fl*,r
(, d60 (a "rD vt5 o L**d
- oq a fD FI
gn' o,t o !tn n
rD o? rJ) $) At 9J
=F qq 5 7
FJ
V)
o oq c) o
d
ij #€ o g.rD
=' J:
o FirD ts c {o a. o
€ FI Ti. o 0) K o
< vt oa =5'
rD 5P o po tr
n qgd (n o o
{0) o v) o. g,
J V) OrD
gs o o qq o oq ffiJ
u- (r) Rtr rD o F qq
HgJ 5 o Fgq *"*ry
gq O H o
(r,) o q : 3 0r fts
oO H)U o o tD -t
o oa ?
5 ffi#"
o g.€ FB. g) vt o
(r)
*'6= € o 5ct
or 5o :(tt. ; P
X
o d 3
fDn -r+ o
trffi}
:E"d$ \**4
o 6
c
f6 rD 9J ffir
q) .-\
o oq $w
g) l(a 'ga TA E \
,3R d 6, :+' j
o S) o
oL: v, r_l o o
Yg) o sJ oq Ft
(t- p o) oa oq o € Io € fl**q*
'-{ g) o I \# ffiJ
oq (r) w oa Fr1 n o P"
o rD I n
r)
o E# 9J pr t!
.*%*# flYT*\
9J. rD o 9)r- o X oa
oq o -l-
'\# M
'oo i'
-fD o qJ. o
qBfi o orQ 'ry
- rDn C') v, Fl. o FrrD o 5
I o aO E
**% fffi
fi*w langiratjes *{* T}*tn
tffi
343
H c w L a n g u a g *W a r k s

€ 0t R € 'o oo C' F5 !-l'. r)


F F',*S (a 5 =.H s) ;to e.' 0J
o 888 p 3 o EFI
o H3s tD
5Ftr o r5S o
a) d !-l F. ,) Z HY n 5 6 tFt o qi D
rq qC crq o q) 9 3 H:S
pJ 6 E;EH V)
Fj oH p
E.Fr a c! o v,
rD -s) 6- o d6 € a) pr
r) o tsi F v, u, Y 0) 9) (DF 5'
g) lA
n PorI #;3F 68 tl
.d HE gq Ft
O. d7
o q6 . ( n H.
rD 0l ? 7 J v, o N irF
V) rD Pvt:l s E5-n _{: E 9J o 7,8
o ( 9
et Li coq t)
pJ p) o o F V a {
o o
r il g v, Ar
C 5tr\J Hq i ' ) o Ut Ji'
z; uo, v, g) pJ
geH o Fl- YQ+<
.(n = n -l Yr D u ) 8 E
o I qA '.{ o o f €F 9)
Fl
t) xo 5(D
v, O. o p 9)
o r q F.q x ts. o oa
C L.. F E- Fp v,
H.IFfi 6-# eii o qE5
o a\. Vt F{ rJ
s
iukFl oq !-- Vt o=' €g)o . qq
o rD ti o gq src o Fl l-. 0)
gq
I J . \ F .
5xgH (D g. g) F)o a) -t 9)
HPH.
d 1tfi r o g) ga v, F)
fDFf
+a
-@ hl o oot
o u, q 0J V) o.5 0. ct 5 p)o oH
€ od
Fh0) o t'rD o EE 6 o- o
o ; --. gq (t 5 Ft t* o v, g) €5
gr=
oq r+ts| +
EgSH o b;o o3
H.
F ir Ja 6'
3
o 5 E jl ? c Oa) rj orD+ tr' K= F Ff P)
fDgJ4 9)
n9 xg o 5' 9. vto o o 3 FO o
-l u) /\tia n 5 Fr3q T 0) oa
o - oq 5qq r:E o
F.+)
g5 o o o.)
!t 3 - H o a" crq rD if. iJ (h o)
J
o ir
ez+ ;''H E 8. R8fi. o
o o o o n 0. 9) Ft V, F) o JD 6t
'o Vt Fh g r+ Fl Po
EI
(i tDoT F o kq o C r-t € q6 5v)
3 v)
c 5
=ao 9F S :r' EH) C' oq Ei
F I:do u) g)
;6 ; 8
5 a a - F v). oq fd -e
o r
gq S a
E n I Y sr
H {
i+* F A'EE f
H o s)E
a
-P3g o f.) F3]E 8B o F ( aoo ttGl Ff
f.) o R o F)I' sl .) o 9q
-l' P o 6's nfo og
tn ts. lJ 0) .'rU ta
tt e 6 qA = Fl o Ft
'i g. o )*
. o g) 5
+e 9,
=. A1
H HE - o nF (D v, o q-q 6JD
o o fo P '
T + R B €JD
B 9, E. 9J l-t) E'O g3 5 o=-qr s)
(tt el! 5oJ
n a. 9v, FJ Hl rD
s.r t
J '
;q e o 5rD
#! DHA
t,
ci' oq
do € itl 6' 6 €
i s gE \
50)
E9
5it FO orDx o F o H) g) 5 5l.P
s q\J o Ir o
{ d o 5 A: r ta o.o =orF{ H Oq 9)
OJ
i' 56A ' aOJ iI.i tr-F rD o o nt Pr 5
o $) .i( 5 go. F1 n F gH v, 5 o
1$f^ g) A 5 o 9- trd
o 9) r) p :-+ s € rE ;J o g 0J
5'E 6 0q ii N v, rt) =.
e.
rDH> -c/,
oq r o 8 q Tf; nd "6+: E
v) o o
I frh s 1 g
c A I F ii -x 6-g
rd A1 V r-( !. V,P
€ S+ Fb
P o
-t 9)
0) qqs) )-t (D v, FOc o Fb ts 8 8 . o o
o Vt
V) do I Fjo oagg. d o' Ut
Fr g rD €-.n rl o i Es? 3. g) n
oa o oo v, ir e. 8 f)
x6
O. 0J sJ oJ
(t, ';'g - 5 ga F € A E' C' (tt r-(
pJ
5gI cu,
rD (A E.* x' oq :io A. qq 50
H oe )-t |.t o rD 5H)o sr
1 J o o5 o o€
)nH n *(D cn oa
0a F' 0a ,1 gJO(h n5P lo
€9= 4- o
2
3EF€
A X - a j{
=
--
.-:
= =; 7= ?s I= = = . . i F
- v =
a==" ,E. 3 tr j =:
= t&. g
5 :- ? - : t&, s5 --
;

'D
E
'o !qt
IE E .-b Fl ?1i n z ?i
5 oit @
o
FI:
l) 0t
o at (tt Fi t'D =r v, 9r
o 5 u, 59' 6qE (D o s F t6 g = u,
:ta 5 9) o ts H.K E) rD v\ gq o
9r 5 d cEr 5 o :3 o
FT:
s 5 u,
9) v) p E.5l -U (a g g o. o
7 p o o=' s) o 5
r r: o Eg p qq 0) oa o
o U) v) g rD is5 o s qa fD 5
€ o E:I. gq o .9 9J € (a o F
5 p)
o tl -Y
5 0) s) V) v) 5 9)
oq s: Fh o g) Vt
a o JD o r) ga$ SJ i. o. 5 p fd Vt Ft F r+
o +F Ft fD pJ N
(a o l-{ :a H.
sJ : -t+ oa o 9) o
lJ l9 d
o 5 -l F) o
€ gq w. E' v, -gr
0l o
= o
f6 9J
E q ts cra d 5. oq o € r) o 5
n PF H 0) $l o
f,) ct
Frt €
SJ qa g o g =65 tr G5 \5 o 5 ? o fD n r{ {s)
9) SJ g v, o
o oq gq oqg o s .) -l n 5 Ft
fD F Ut € 56 F E B=.
-rvH o gq ,{i,' o ta o cna €
o o F it s) (.) FU5
:3 .?t p
it 0) g c)
x T o o o 9) 3 tr v,
d c
Fl
{ g) (a FJ
v, o Lt1 F o
n o vt v) F o o o (D o o
9. o) tr v, hl
o (t) sJ o
v, a)
"6
5' q3 0)o
cl;
;qr
. \ H
Y H . i
r) rD F5 (D r) f1
o
o o g, fD
v, o q3H F Fb t{ F) o $ o 0) o g :r
9J ro o 0) o 9J } J H H 5 9J Vt cJ
5 fdqq= (t, w o p) 3 o o v) g EP
o o Ut o X vt o
oa o 9l P 6oa 9) JD o
o c' tsh
@
Sl o s) o t r x v, +z "o o o o
7f n d ot S) 9) o FJ
0J E c Fl
o 9r I' i+ o.. t) gsft rD 6H 5 o oq o
a) o
,aO ct 5 o o ono o hr5 g o Vt
o ct s o o" 9l a
ga oa
fD ? 6'c F o $ V) 0J o
o o o *0) v) o 5or o F o o o v o or q
-l o o o o $ s 9J o
-ut Ut € I v, o F*3 u, E. o 9)
tv, 5 5
fD € 3 FtI ro o o ts 0J
o o o o 5 o o o F,I
9J tsl o
V) v, tr
o Eas € s o gq o X { |.h
o 3
r.t o rD o
ci' o o tr 5 =rl (D 0r gq
i p) F cna o n o
v, =s rJ o T P 0J 9) 9)
€o 5
o 5 v, 8E * o= 5 fd gq 0r
ra v)
X
g g o rJ FJ t.rfD JD v, S) s) o' 5 n
E) pr ts tt7 Ko) FJ fD o
cl) o r) 6
--BE. 3 v, ci' r! o 16
c+ 9J v, 0) Fl o 9) V) F
Fl F gr. o F{ ts .X
o o (D o o o ffi 1A t( nr vt
o 0)
s) n
a 9r o oFi o o o 3
s) .J
tr ts S vt o o
oa o E.;H hl X 9J
o
V) i' F o JD n sv, o ts ?
r) crq
sO)
toX o
gr a H6 U'o o r) { o s.o JD d 3 -l
o o o o 5E) o o 0r p
o r) 9J 6g 2 g E'5+A p o o o \ (a tr
9J K o o F) oq oq \t 3 o F o o
o !) (o (D g dt, F o o r-' \s S) fd
o 5 Ut d $) A) HI o () o
g 5 v't
o
o s.
n oq 0r
3 to qo r3=a H *F
I oa 9)
tr o (D o !J p
9) 5 p 9) F N -O i' o 13z H
r' F € rs o g ga oa
I (,) o 6 F o (t S T g) o
v, o 6+r g) P FI oq o
K ifr s(a Ft t-{9)O E) g) o o Ja t F u, F
o I I s. o9) 5'g
345 Hcw languagesare barn
How LanguageWorks

hl 9J Fl r)
t!t o sl 9' F n r) r)
t-t Fl
i' -J
V' v, r-i: 5 o O) o E hR u, a
f)
o
s)
gs o
p 9) B.Eg Eo o8 o
5H
o
AlE (D v) f) o $5' g o E. 5 A.p
o (D o I o o
Vt
r) 5 . otO
Fr.
0 a o .r Ff
gq ?. E. +6 o
Vt qa 5 85 0l -l
et o -l o o 5 E po o) d6' e 9 b o
o o
tsl o o) 8F 5r+ o o o 5( D0 1) p B9 1fF' Ovi
F Ft ga -vr
p) Fl d o 5o F F .a6 oq o
G ql
rtD
!fH
t co
0l (.) p $
p)
6(D d
I fH o vt g o { 9J
qB o6 $) o
' o) o K
hl Fl
cr 9 B ;g;! f ,
r) :s r-l o Ut F to Hq cr cA o --. @ 3
o o g) g o Fl oE F Xr) o o 9o o P) TD n
*d 5 Fl ga 0) vt 3 =.o 0) o
o o F1 N I :.i vt +r 5 to
o o o o trn
hl s o v, ':o E
; F) F OJ 8 E 0) 6g F.S v,
na $f,s
v, r) o hl qt o Fto A) € o o F. fd Fl
lg+6
Ed ot o5 gl
r-l (n (D o
!i. I i l c
|D -"4 n EO o F ?A(D
g
0) c 9r Frt g A v ,fd S) = 50 -F0S) hl o-(a a
n 9J Fl f.) ;g) F o ii 0l t.r.9.Fb
5 s 0) -vl 86" v, n 5Ft S+
g)
pE CA
F 0) hl v, d6N -t (D oq € o
qq w F) o 58 9) qa gf i-r g)
! H ^.l ( D (r-lo t
oq o Fl o E1. S'f FI 9J
6o Yoact o il' l.l
tr n o
Ftl EJ) F o!1 (D v, oil t1
r-t JDq 9) u, N(D o
s0) o 6tr
o o n 0q o g6 3E' o 3 v, f.)
0) o a v, C' 3F
F
9q EAE o?
{; Fl o I s nv, { pt5 o
o a o r) u C' o d crQ o
o v, g) (D fDH) f') o x (D I E? F r-t
o F
v,
9l o o tD iDt B E.
='"(D 3 Ut 5 !+. S) B3 5 g E
0) =
so
Fl o 5 9r
hl
3 a6 u 5 o o Fl
(1 o n
) cJ
5 ))' r : tU rD o H:o"'- 5tD 4 r)
fd
g E fi 5 #
uto 9) o o n s) Re)
m E
o {ts
9J s) I
F
sI r o5)
f vr oq 5FU t-{ fD
3 r) u,
C 9r o o '.ct 9J Y 9)
g, H(D (D tn o oo E.E o FO vHX o
ttt Fl
ts.s ffr: sr
oq o vt o d
P u' g F s 0ato rDv, vt o6
m 70 g tFO o F| o v,
o t o 't.0 0q 3.q -€nia r!!+ 7l
9rtr F 0) AJ I
F o- fD F $H (?
f') 9.F Eo
v, F?. 0q 5 o n g) Hfi F 3 g) :8L F 5
7 o (D o 5 16 o q + o VJ FI
E T K xx
g, hl r-) H 9) s 9J F -+fD oa gv, N
d6 o -(a Jn r-l tD u, 16 cto F a
Fl FJ \5 ro g6
5 .t v, o o o o s+ v, +v, o
& 0r +, Ff) Fct (a p)6 o
o o_ F o E fr € KT F v)) o od
5
nqr $sfi o s
5n v, v F|
rD s . 3 0) g {.) o fD pr g o o
ts o I
$F o so
|f1 o o (|) o 8 g)
0) r-l 5 FI: gE vt v,
€ -lf) o d o qq g'E F r) o
o r-f:
ts o o 3 |) -O fi#:. 5 { Hg
o s p) n r-l
to *+6 F€ o Fo' €
F 5 s o 5 H o ! r o t'l o oit F
7 3E pJ v, n F) E+ O f! #
tr= oq FI
o o FJ v) - ; 6F )
tD o)F s oa o vt 6' € Fl
o I 0J;
K o o o d
E'g EJ n E .O $E * t5 o
St fd v, cr o p5 r)9) o |,r5 l-l qa
E o sJ o N 5 gr' o
F' g. 5 o0. F]
I -(/J
g
v, ho Fl Vt
;p
o s 9) o pr o 9) t+
o (D d o o !)
Fl
Hg
5
E9 oatr 0a g
F F o Ht5 f.) o 16 9)
v,
3g- g ;5
s'fr€ ncl Fl
E 3 { 9) 5
ga
u, 5 v, vt o a"= Pfo
v)
0J "o 9 d6' 5 Eq o (,) tr €
= 3B vt Fl $) E 5 o U, r< 2u) $
fD r 9 . fD 5 o (! dqF 0) E'o F) $) rD
F o r) (D S $ gq
!Pro 9) € tn g 7l 50r 5
lo :6- -(/, € 0. (,D 5
H . = tt)
= 5 rD € i + = o. fDlt)ct) Ut 5(/t g)
0. F# o. a) E 5 Vt
(-J F a' €E qat ; AQ 4-E
a E F o x t- '4 3
= tr t=
o €3 6 ro *at
= ?;
'ilii

itt
DD t! 1= n g st Fl
vr'o F (D I
u, G-
gt, vr o tD oq E E
g=' -? * o g X S+ v) p o' €
o g) € E o 9J
Ao F (D E o € € p(a F)
€ (D K
5.0a o u,
ts o g o
g?. aF 3 (o th c) 'o Fl !) 5 o
Fl
cp 3 tr 5 [i-ri o tO
€ g) q Vt o Vt o K € o o 5 oq E. o" FI
t F (D E -S) v, n :+E rD
+91 E9 r) .J o5 F F o I o vt E 0) 5 o- TA
>) ut o xb. sJ F
gq H'O v,
.t o o 3 {D 0r n o !-- u, 5 tr (D
s Ho -* F fd n tn o
(t,
\ :"0(.0 g. q9. f)
n
o o p o rD p
9r o o E'
c-3 6g g F TS r) \5 o 0r o q s 5 :J
=o gd p) u, g 5 (D
tn o o g 9)
X 5
- t 11 Ft rs (n
{o oht ; o
"6 qq E p)
qq € o € n
g)
5 o o vt s) o o rD f) o
96- qJ r) tr F, o :5 ct hl a) 3
v, o v, 5 $) o (t, Ut o
ta o Fl
oo'
e) =9. ci' T ts g FJ o cn 5 C u, o tr o n o
Fd 0) tr o = e. Et-l
- vt tr s o o o
vro o B'# s 5 (-) r) o
g n ra s) o o_ o
€o, ts sc o o o v, g) o' FJ v, r)
5r+ 5 o 5
(!
v, f) V) o E o
Eoq cr sJ {! 0) n g) v,
9. (D llt q 2f 5 o t o 0) g vr
{ r+O o v, X o o o ; t-l
*= HB o 5v, to o 5 U) € tr t) rD
li. o (D (! t, o o o o o
Hfd
o os) "6 9) 9r o o u, o F.t E H:
oH H 9) Fl S) € Vt \t tr g c, o
Fl.l= s d n o fD v, s) F o
16 o v) tD o r) o € v,
oq ts o v, g I tr r) .l
o o rD Frl X
H 9 (? #s $l fD (! o n € o (n g E
? u l-t' u, 5 g F o o o 5
vto sFt fd o vr o i-a g)
n(D o u, 6' N o iJ tr (D p) o F o 5 vt o F o td 5 3 o o
16 v) hl fD o s) 9) n q
d=. 5 4S) o rl o H g E 9J o U
x 0) o g) s) o 5 9l
d< o (a o n f) o o
I qe. 6 6 ' U) p o -(,l o o 0) 5 v, 9) v)
p- o - 9J
0)Fi c $ v, o
{(D5 6-{ tr (n g) 5 oq 5 d F 0) 3 D o
u, r) a qa v, s) o TA g) o
(DG 5 o o vt
o o (D F
I (D o EJ (t o (t
5iD 81 o d
nr
r)o)
v, 3
Vt
0) $ H) p)
tsl
t 5 fr) tr (-)
tr fD u, t o ttt r-l
e)
(t, F F
g o o 9r r o C' o rD {o X 3
g) o FJ
59) o5 o o 4 (t t o € E g o $
(D o fD o Vt Fl
g6 o ob H: o F $ o sl F o g 5 I 9) z< V) o
Vt
o vt € o Vt v, gt JD
.r 0) 6 Ftl d tr F o' o r-t F 0)
vt v,
rh
- F ts. C' 5 $
r) E o Ft o El p 3 o s,
Fl
o { JD
S x# o o 0J o tr F 9) o Ftr F
o qa F n o o vt o F o
39 sLc
g)o o 5 o
Ftl o g o s) o g F) B o
E
o
F. V' -f. O n o f.) E F u, $J o o
v, n
{o
9 o 7H) FI '.d Fl F g FJ 3 o
di
dtS v, (D (? o r) 0l Fl
E F € o o
OF( F
9)
F crq o o
v, FO o 5 U) o g) K r) o 5
o (-Jx U) tr 5 tr o F
Fb Ut
2 S
rD(!
&r
o
Fl'
U c
t o F
0) o F o o o
F
9) o
zt oq FI:
p co t6
HI n o o
v) o u,
F o rD o B' F) o
r) ct lb o tr F Vt vt
gry KO o s F o (D fD SJ gq ? I F F

347 are born


How langr.,:ages
348 How LanguageW*rks

!'+- >il f.) g. FE 9l o o @ t6 cJ g, Vt g FU nt


o;. o F rfI 25 Ft
o \ g3 FJ
79r o F o F V) o
(Dn Ftr o tFI g (D .ri fD o g s lD v) l.{ F o
t d o FU 0) Fi' 3 o g)
fD' o 5 ox oq s o Oa t6 o Fl
? 65 tr o d t t o
g l* E. o n Ft
o g
oT o K !
ai r- E5 \J -l 5 5 fD Vt
sl ga
o 4 F F 'g P.F s (D =0)oq o n 5 t)
:to 5 iji' o € o (D s r-l o n 0)
qt o ho
tt u) 3 0, o tr gH. o o .(rl lD
f) + g) Vt g)
ctcl 9)
t
E' S) c) F SJ v, o hl ? v,
o 5
F o s) oq 0) u, FI o 5 Vt
$r EE P5 v, g tt' F o (a {eo
ET fi 9) gq o o
s 9r 6 o r-l o tr g) 0J
=P x' 9) o g| ;' rD r) \J tr to s
fD g' 6: r) v, 5 € n v, f) ?lr s) E)
tD8 x qq .) o X o 8,, g
:.:. o o
ts FE)o
5 Fl o o o ts s o
o I o o 35
.'idH 6p .l € g 0) 5 oq E 0a
o tr 9) f.) tr p 5 FN 9) 9) hl
p 0)
r} f) FU 5
zg o
(a
= t i,6
B o qq
o F fr] s) 0) ?o 0) 3 q 5 o 5
9)
Vt
fi:E 5 a
Fl
=. )vt -u, tr
Fl w u, G rJ E c v) o r:
t 9) o v, "o o X g) g)
it @ v) o 0)
F) o g o g { 9J
'6
v t- o "o { I p r) B6 5 o FI FI g Ff)
i3r vt FI tr
E !ta o'
l-l r: o € o pJ oa 9l
gq
(D c) 5
oj g rJ7 o sl 9) FI E
o
ht ixx t) JD 5 9B n o
Ft)
O, F o L7t vt 5. o ., h|
s) oo ;. vt 3 o oq oq
7s oP gq 0) d oEo r) s) v) E) v, ? o qEF 'ct t € o
' (D o (D F) r) (D o
Ftl 5
g' 6
v, #
Fl o o u, F ;. vt o Ft) Fl
.l
g)
rd o€vt g F gl 3 o
I
o o o o BS n o o
Fl o (D F)
!= o) Hg o 0) fdo id S) F { @ v, pl
=Ft tD
5 v, x \J Ut 5 F o x $) hl
-
Fl r) r') 5 o o ro @ o 3 g
5:$-d 5 v, ct) F
i5(D dtr o o g a 9J F s) qq
0) Ut o 9) Pr'r r) fD Fd tu $ 0 @ o o g H
o= H Ut F .(a E3 F a.l s
(Do v, 0) C'
.) € Fl 5 5 o d 9) X 9l
vtO F Fl
9) t
tTt ca 0) o :'t
E o v, fD sqq o E Fl oq p € tr
5 H . F w o tsl oq
B r8 o
-g. o rrr0Q F g UL' U2 5 5 o 0q f.)
gt Fl -l o
o j5 v, fr tr) o o o E
pF F €
o o (D ts (D FJ o- oq .!D 4
I o v) o E) o
g@ o u, l. E o hl I
tr OJ s)
fDd o 0) F) fD X 3 s'.9 o FU 0)
E& oo5o (D Fl F ?f n 2, sl r-t g) 'ct o l
v, ta
*lD -l i.? 5 F v, g "c' o o
gq rl'!l
o o g vr o C' o Fl o C'
rD Ft F
crg
o o 9)
(D v, Ft f)
o o p u, (D
o Fl
*r ) $
fD
F tr
Fl
ahl hl tD E o 0) oq ,U
tn
tt,
(D
s
0)
EE6
1s.E hl
(a o
5O F. V' r) X F o Sl g
tr ro
oq p
Ff 5..) lTt
o F
{s) 8 $ FI )"t !.+. o v) o n v,
'.d =s \J F o lb E F tr n
= o u, o K E-O f.)
v, tl 7i o sJ s) E o
Fl Ftt o S) o F hl p @ 6is o
g)n E pl o 3 s) Fl 5 v, ci'
ao cr Vt o s) hl
E'
tD 0q o -ul
o 5 (D Fb o 5 g
E= 5 p tn o 3 ; {org !t tr c) o ta o Ft p
td >+F n Vrb o ts o r: 9)
s|D
o) S) o o p o U) r) E) I F hl
tD 0J
o o r) (D o o
rD o Fl
o o "{-
EF org Vt F 5 g) rD o o F [E s P
0.o - o r) o F| Fl i Fb \s cr
9) g .:F+ ct I
vt p) Ut € PF) o w tr +
0a ee. 5 (! oa5 o Ut F U) Ar o o 0)
;i ?'+ fD Fts5 =b 5 o ts g o o
o s n v, =oa o o p v, s
FJ Vt v, H
5 (D o 0. o o I, lJl
(D g 5 o e.d (D oq
I
;e
rfD
fDq)
v, rrl 5
|D
g) o t1 NS)
fD cEl
r) o
5
o 5 (')^
=' 3
bgE
3+ (D P
n o:1 c g)
-a g
3 f| t: (t o .- f5 D
D c = TE =
al rl E* 0
=
3i

'(t
it
I o 6 fD
qq (D vt
t-t o fD o
Fl
o H 5
v, v,
o cJ 5 F
f) o 3
F g)
v,
g o g)
o n hl
hl
7r P
ts o F IA
o o oq o
t v,
cr tD
9) u, o rl 9l
vt I F
ra a 9l
n hl v, $
ro t (D
r-l f) g
o @
5 $)
9) o t'0
F
Fl
V) Fl tsl
g
o Fb ? U) o
5 X o 5
t1 o o .)
o o
w Ut d ?

F Fl
o €o r) o
s Ut
u,
c o o
r-t
4 d o
3
p) o FI
o o fD
p 5
a Fl
F
9J o
Fl
s) o F
u,
F Fl
oq o
tr
0J
fD o F
gq 9) v,
o €FI
tD
o o o
gq t6
3
s n r-l
g) fD
p Vt F)
vt
f) o ts Fog )
fD Vt Ut

349 How languagesare born

ir$i
;,lir
35o F*awLanguag*Works **?*
* I
rry
kq""df
**-6*
6V' o rt f,?\
.g tsl q&d tr\
&E
:Fg En gq Vt o o
o E'3q g\-#-*E
fa. H€ F o F \#
-l o;r Fl OJ,
3 Hg ryf%
H. zu
qs {5 v, v, PrJTa \# \*{
E6t *8 i o n F *"*nfu*#h,&
5gO o o 9) VtFt-
t.
I w
= .1o
U R€ F
p
*H Hs
Srir s) F
0r
o
{ ffiJ
T=F
gn
Bei oo 9) F ro E $qq (! ^t6*.
H v €v'9 5 r)g. o v, a" "#3:
\ J - €o o) F
F ts"! ooS r.i A.
v F. Fi
S) v, =oa C' qq
- - F h * -d
;E 6' o l o E
\ do pJ ffi
95sJ O.t+O FIO 5 dI r) 9J { H*g
Fi Ff v) - o3 g Ovt*- 7t o
.- -- o lrt F H d'd ffiJ
rDo oF gq iisq o R sp o o g ga-
6o* E i JF. V) '\,
g o gg o 9. ;t
e€ srx oJ*
fDsr o p) r) ffi
do F :il V) Po o o
rDE'o oO g fo o
eF E.+*, (D 583
Ff oI. H(D -J vt
ts trflft
o SJ tU o q4 u@
ng*
fD '< !lsq ntn o o [{€
gq p)
d8 iD H' o Hct 5 * o o
e H'3 v, 5o ? d
zX'8
}.rfD (D E'O o o ffi
ox H o v, )cr rj JD HE+
Fb ' 7\i
=ut
ir. 9Ffi 5 ;',ji'
rD' E
o
ls 2 o.P o l\e
Ft ht o g 5 fh&"J
nt 9)
E E *ut$ 3
(a E' 5 € a
U' ,J qq o'F fD
o l.t o
o)o c o
rF $
9JR
M
t r 5 ' TH H 5 t s
>) oJ
+o. 9) i'o,.o X o
'C'
- Re.a gq F LJKd
,:$o 8 ,8 o o
@ $ € JD
drD !to
:o s r YAF
:^ €'83
Ot FF i.j' Vt
35
F| Cta
gC
8ta.3 o .t1 5 H . 3 flm
E.P E I c) o x 5 H o d
=g) F o
Lgq 1Y. tr 5'o F 0l F gq
fi f E
\o vt ;: v, gE:
-JD d 3ql F o 5 {
E'o er \ J H
oar = or
l-rts-
5 ts u) 5 9l
t5 $tr o o F F F=6
-u'nH HF.r ga SJ o F
P I J v, 5gq
ut oq
!t t6
afE €
7fF{=
y' 16 o t y g o H'E lr
"*H ?Fg o (D V) -l ld at
1
'+O o E n Vt n 0)=
+S) -(t) g o
: ) - F . o
H
Y H o
(Dd (n-oi 9J o. 9) g
s6 ' qH$ a
cv) Vt
v, rD
F l - 5 r) JD SJ 9.
rE E
=0, trtr o o 9*F
xoa S'Es. o, E. q3E f
=2 =. ='l? a =. o =: ''- = =. ? + iE
o -I;

|{> .rt o
-: !f f')
i o vt
o F' \<' (! r/, \'
v, r{: ot s vo € s
vt o
s I 5 -(a o (t, o oo
I
p o -l fo (D
o € (a 5 Ed o co
o s. tD o vt o !':r
€ o 0) 6E' I
X 9G o Vt v, dg
F o I vt v, = o € *\5
Ut
tr FI E o A) u, o s. ga s
td ftr rj E Vt o I
o
u, fD 0) s) S, E o. vt d
E =. *. o -w
f;* c
t! tr o sl o c rD ra. :3
(.0 5 o o f69J
tr 9) o9, 0r 0) o D o H6 Fl s s r$ r' g
r) 9J p E 5 E g
qq p rD * 5 o F V) E R= .:-| ct
qs
0) 5 o o o F 9JFl so o *r y * ct o
o sU) o p 1H o s o r) ga o v,
0J i !!o
I u, 3 o o' ht,f L!O
X F 0r v, 5
.+ F o o r-t o fd o. !f
16 o iD
9 .S) o F gR
15 vt r) * F o ttt F fD
t_t Ut 0r o o' 9r qa tr s o F tr ctQ
o o
srD o
r) (t) r) Vt € * s.o o fr K
v) o 5 V) ; 5 o ro I o ct) U)
r) o o
co
v) p) (D rlU 5 oFh FJ 5 \'E
gq o n tr o g
ts €5 cHt
FJ 9) tJ)+ fD hl
o F5 S p g 5 oq 5(t F po
o 0t
'15 F
o 5'.l V1 o o s 3 V) o
o gq o' rJ v, E l-t o w oq o
F E) € o fo 5 o -l
$E cr
r=.* Eo) F 5'B
d o c
t r 5\<
-. o o S o vt o H.3
5 9J ut
€ o 9r g Vt o s ga g)
{ rit F 9) n 9) 5 K p) o
o oq q, o o a g o (t) 9r o
V) P BH
F € JD o p5 o o \t o 3 t) o oo) r) F oqo
o p vt o u, d o 3 -r. 5 o v,
o rD € d fD o v, I t+ hl 9J vt (D
v, oq cr o o
to
o fo o Eg o (D [) it o" 5 88
o g
d' o o ct K V) 0) 5 tD Vr o
€ s c FF
0l o tr o E rD V) o d 0) 9) o
Ft
5 kl
JD o g s f) n o o I' o :e u,
g OA Ff i w o 5 €B n o5 F
rD E vt oFf, o o pr s) (t 9) tn Ut o og
o g a tr FI
o g g
0) 0) g)o g o 9J Vt 3 C ;q Pqq
9r Vt o
E s v)
i-a s+ v, oa o d o vt
E
n 3 F
o 9) 5 o n JD 5 9) s) F o o (D
o :< s),g o oq- u) o F r) .r qE F) rt, )-t rO
E () 5 o o ;H 9 . F
v, 0) o 6-F E U' 9l
o o 9) =d ts 0J gq s+
v, rD 5n p) p fD
K
o o pr 9.V V) P 8
d o vt o E) Fb vt qq € F'S o o i5'd
5 o H9 !) 5 ts E o o ga +j
o s) rJ F o
o 5tr f)
I g c E 8d F
FJ o 9. I
o &H rD
t 96-
-(t,
o V) o F € (D rD
n F) F F Fd
0J d .ar o tr s o 5it o o5
ct o F) =(! X
\ o' U9) o o 5.
vr
d 5g)
g
3 qa 5o ' ' q du,o (D o
o 5 o I
g) = I
pr o 6[
o Vt rD rd € q' cJ JD o
n ?7f
t o o tsl .qr H r)
5 o' o F € € S) o 0)g) 0r
5 ga o 9J' c ro o o -r+ O o
o 5 ;i crq
=o 5
o 6' t5 o
4 o (t o 6E g g
"o o r) 5 5'grr o tn .) 5 (DH'
o OJ C tf v, !-l! c, -.O
o 3 o + o U)
o rD
= p pa. -(/, r-l Vt
s) v, T oo v o o B ffi 5 u,
6'
tsl o o s FJ
--9. 0)
I
5 c)
td
E € Ea g 9r r) o ts o F
tr
() $5
g) 5 0r o ='h
Fl .J I I o (D S) I o 9.F
V) .) v, trg s *E
351 H a w l a n g u a g eb e g a n
352 How LanguageWorks

CA tu hl -l
.vt 6 1 9 V m
o 9r$
.fD
9I Ji H' OJ
tg oa o
5K 5 irs
o FU if. oa -l 0r c) Al
€ zH o rDc o
vr vt g, 9 Ab 8S. 5 0) 5 g
E' g €w' F E rD oFrX g 3 o fiH* F
,A 3 f F d ga
s) oE.
q-J utts $lr
srJ) o oq
d 8 gi.
j
3 gF EB 0. 6t rd) qq Ut
-d !' 0) F o
o
or ? 9J v, F+, (DFt 0) qa 3
6v) -r o u,
50 -:R u, o o Y H
Fl X
FU 7t
v,
Ft5
FO
oE tfg zo 5o 9) o o o
r)
5
v,
3E;
F. >l
o AFr o E
hl
H od
t')
o€ s3
e ' Es. {
rE n
*o
go 5 5 ;

o
3; 8. { 6r o
3 o f o eFt {
oq o P_rD g,& B H. /. o 5 o r)
5 rrIf,
*t € 3 o 5 ra'5' f.)
0J n HX $ J H
3 >t
u)
o o n
g.
t-i'. o
xH' 3() 9) !-i. { P p 3
I B d1 rs6 5 FT
xo . Sl
€ I
TI rr 0, 5 €on E9 Eq (D
U) u, o ct a. E d g Vt
E= e Es d9 (tr tst rD o
Fl H EA o =
d o a9 !t v f
1x !i o o XT
*o F o
i q6 $P oEo ru E
Or:
F.F2 oa. ch
o td u)9) 3 (n
dr ut F 5 g €-qg Ft
o
o 8g t:rg !r A-u' rr 9) o vt 0) 5+$ F6
€ E* o o ; !-) g6'
F 9r ots tD 55i E d: 3 H: 5 (D
5or Fh o.F{ € v tr
o vt Fi O., 5 o r) 5ct o
o @ I' '39 E
) x OJ Ut rd
3. s) o 3 otr p F.
6 fttt{ t.)
Hr Vt hl H}<Y
E+ = 6 P J ?H 86'
€ it 0, vr5 3 tt !t p o o
v, Fl fdp )r. o
Fi(D H o o tr. t.r Il
!
o o th *1a 5
s F o I-n g
O -| OJ ; ta a Er 5 o ct H. Vl Fb
i' I|Fl o $) o Th 9)
o qa 5F. o 0. 5
o; el 0) OJ 5
*i x€o
55 0) v g vt oq
- h l
9J ;Jto lo
F8 ;r$ g f)(Dt+'
p 5 o o
(.) 5
3# s ++
5o o
Fr Sr t# s. fo o tr 9' S.r++ o
a vto +o 5!r5 5 o FO !f o"irx 0) 0q
F' E.!+ H .H q clcl t) A 9r l:l r') o
ss+ o hl
7 8 d tD rD o oa
6',{ q8 E
oq d 70)
ng H:e' se.6 v, T a o fD
I vt g o ts E fdtr
o -l v' 3l rf o s o 8 * 8 o
9) dog ts vt p r-l gi. E 5
ga gil rH H { OJ d 5 g
F ger' F 5 t sd K
6 E o
o 5 E'3 td) Frl o o o o
u, z<o v'=5 p T o H aFJ l.t
o qg o o c I' p) idE 7f s
5 =i" o) =f) F
fo g (D
€ € €F !F bsF $ o o v) 5: a
?o c oJovt v, o . 0 X)Hx o -i
5 a.q i
cr. oF d C' s) vt
lr Fl Ut
r) o rD o #8
H . O o hd o
5 f) o
o 5' 'Uto a rJ ) A
fa ro 6
x
F @ o)
5
o
*E'+
FO o
+ il F X *
-v,
oq p ao
3 $) fD o 9J
0l 6 8H JD v) oq vt o n I { 9)or
9. fd vt o o :+xO I IrD
E'r FH i o Vt F o
E) o O.* Tg6 5 o.oo oa
o. A (h
!+
ah H 3* J o 3. 6' €
o {D 7.8 tr
t1
8" 3' E I '4" =
c.Xc L = = =
a = a - : r=-
= .:L
= :c

o I
Fb ) F =f
li. o rE -l CD i+ !t
5= .rq $r fD = s) v, Jt cr
Ut
d
o (D fD 0, bo t?
+3 q F
st! vt !t ga 5 (D ht n u, ut pl (D
9, Fl (t) (D !t FfJ v) oq
E-; Fl Er5 d F a n { O o
dH' gr 5 T g Vt o \5 v) o d
.D'o s s 5$) d E o s) o 3 99 r. o F
o)v) (D o g -(J E o
3F F u,
F.6 o o o I' r) V) 0) EE. o t ts {
g -o S) tu o
5vt 9) F 5 9J -5 F o
S) g) Hct o cr fD F PJ o o v, $ n 5
3r. s F 3 oo o o (D Fl
o F F- u, S) -(/, U)
eI o. €(D 9J o vt X FO o o $)
og o 0) E
E o o s) 15 ?H: 9J
o
-(D -oH F 5 v, o vt tsl 5 OJ ts 3 5 ct t_t
o *E 3 Fl c fD ct
S) Fr: ? V) 3 o 3 rtr+ o
=3 o qq o' 7t s € U) 15 a n zt 3
T o o 3 o
{ F) =o o o o
;d w PC v, ct 5 o u, o 3 g o gq 5 ;
? 8.8 tr
v,
tr g5 E p) n S) rD F o .2 X
to u,
5 o
lo o n
p)
o tsl o 0) (n F ri O
o 9) F)
AP 9) o o 0) n v, o 9)
u, C' vt u, 3 v, gq o € t {
o H 'E f6 o o p 15 Vt 9J FI
Ft
g3 s 8 JD o 5 V)
0) Ut rD g o F) o vt v, 0)
o vt Fl
f)
E p) o tr oq ."< sr 3
5 cr n g) o
RH d
ut 0) T8 n 0) F ;6' o K
F o ct 5 0, (') n so 3 o o 5 O) E
!e OH gq Fl H5 Vt o tr 9J o a o Ft5 fD
Hn g, (D s) T n fD U) C' sr
HH F FI
";s v, 5 cr F g o F o v, o o o F
9J o (D JD p o o 6er r-b 9.
=o oq Ut ct 3 9 v, o ga 9) ta F o fD o
rt tr 3 5 5 r-t
:s t. #T !? 5 |D 0J \J!' v, 9r + p o 0) t-l Vt
E3 o
OH 5 $) g) Ft o n
d o o tdo o oq Ur o 5 o o o o \J
= vr' 9) vt o o€ (D tr glo o o g rcl a.o F qa^ o
g9 5 p o *1 ,o .<E o
qa
O. Sl 9) LA
qq o o 7l vt 5
r-( O C'
g o u) g sr_l
Bg g (D c' 5 F) E OJ
u, o o JD o
(t)
E o qq o
.j
o5 9) (a F o o t-t o g hE' 9) gq n o F
Ft
ts. mo
o
r-h
&a
vt F o
r)
n
I s) 6f; n o
Vt o u,
OH n fD 0) a o o tr o
o9" o E'o f) v, (t 9) p o o @- $)
.i u) hl 5 X IA E) l-l v, o K
Ct )-l
P 0) o 5 =o
o(D s)H F.. O) o I 9. o
o ct r-l
o o o cr
ctF a t'
ts [ i H tr 6' s. tdo or o o
tgr.hol g sl o o o (D F 9) (.]
E€ F
o gr n F)
oa o
9l n
O r-t: O. v, v, (D o ta e'.g o5
ovt (,r
o F st U) o FI F )
Ed PO $ p Fl o v, !) g)
p o € c fd oa trO o o o
V'H g) 5 0" r) o
F (t 5 5's (D s FI FI 9J F lo Vr U
d E. N0) o g (t, o g o5
vtD o o S) o o
Fl: oq a O.o tr o o
E o FI' F n J5 € o o o g
qn 71(D o fD N. 5 o o v) o HO u) r3 5
€ oct tD ,-t: 5 o oIJ ct
o o Fl UrO 9l E) u, o st €
Bg € o €
o FI p o n o.o o t! o 5 (D
iJ tt
7r o 5 o hl
Q
oo. o 5 o o oi' o a. o It F-lf oq o Ut p
oo o O, El v)

353 How languagebegan


354 H*w LanguageWorks

g . , \
vt fo g) 0) 0J cJ t-l
T v) E o q
o
F fo Fl p .o FI
so EB I6''H
I gq H9H p tD
7l FI
tHe o o tsr V, 9) 9J
oJ o o o p o o o o vt
t o trb P Vt o E 38 9) ; E€
9) n 3 go5 ts tD qa { o v, o H.o s+ o 4 o
o 5 F) s) o Fl o o 0) E ;, 5 p
(? o F.l c) F o o
€ r $o5 o tr 8E,H Fl o5 F
n CA
o € v, 5 o vt ut g' E 0)
3 !J o o ? o q vt g o S) 9) oq X C'
i15F
g) F o' v, n E 9
q9 ,-l 9 gEfi, F n o .(,r
o
Fl F € gE p lon o
3 o (D n g 0) o o .o
u) c) ; g +raF
o 5 o 5-o o 0) F) o t) sH o
o u { o o u, Ut r-t
= gJ qq w H.:v, $ 5 p t-t
HaE
g. hl r* y€
o IJ
E) o oq s g5 0J
d F o d F)
d
o -l tD
FI
o o o 'v r n o J v, pl n o g ? ct o
Fl
F+rySJ
o
9or
o d o
HA F:
p ='no sr
o g (D o ooq 5 o sJ
gq Fl 0) u, p H 5. o
3 tD xta .?:
tr so
o F Fo !) F !) rF"E o tr v, l6
= 9l F o t, F)
Ft OJ E o HO N
9J cr 4F. F Vt vt p
d s) u) or. o { o 0l Ut
o'
t-t o
HF C' Fb o o
C g) o vt FI p 9) 5:{ o 9)
q3881
' si " q ' 8
o o F) Fl

3 E S+
H J
F+ cr o
o v, s o o 9)
E+E. Ut
')r
(D
F
tD @ p fD (D S) € o F g) s
s' o F o o F 3 F € P 9)
f1 v, 5o Vt o g) $) Fl v)
C'
U'
r)
o
v,
I o' o'q 5 FcJ s, o 101 o f) s
il *i
trvrH o ?I' o 5 v,
j +rH,
n r3 o ,f tr u, o
r') vt tD s) t srE d o sl
c p o 9)
9l 5
o
p o E o F 5 5 6 0. v) 15 E H
X FS
$D ttt o
5 o o F) f) 5 s,
(D Fl ts p o tr (D g o
S) *g P p o sqF
n o 6 o o { F V)
3
o 0) p 5 v,
o o
o
o
o H fD
tg
f) E € 0r 9) O l.tt H |r o o cr s{[f
o o s o d o o FJ
o v, (tt (-l o $ o o o { F o r) u,
v, 7t (1 E
g, K v, Fl
&s:E
F tr o t o I
E o o o o
@ "q
o 0r vtO ct o 9J p sE5 p oq o o E '6'69
o F p) g 9l v, o ')IvtE
-b g) Ft o o qo U) o vt
hlC n F 7r F R o
o o p) o g g v) o cr o
o ct n ct c ;'+ 7r s u, Ut H to; o F FtJ T:. H E
o () o $ 3 z i+o= 5 v,
tD F) o s5' v, E -ul 0J o (D 5 vt r (D
3 v, qq o o fD v,
T 5 3 o C
hl
F C'
a 7t 0J o
H)
Y- v, n
fr-3 F";
i o H .V' o w
t 9l3
0) OJ p F
zo cr
xo
a ra oO pr hl E g E o o v,
o d
3 o Fl) (D o F 0l o o r) o
ht s U) o -l F F Fl :rH I
Ft o F o hl o $)
$ ('0 F f.) v, V)
s(D
o F =v, g p c) 2E'E n oa u,
9' o o F' FJ o o o cJ'. 5 N
r-t gr f e =H
sl f.) xfd hl \J F p F g) ir. g
o t-t g o € 9) 9l gq OJ 5 o 65"g',.
o. 9) t-b iF +t f oD o o o s F n u, Fb
G
o 0r v, f.) Vt o ;
(D v, r) p) tr v, 9r (D E* g tr o
F{
T
oa
o o ,l tJ
o o a"
o v,
5 € d qor: o r21 o a'"33.
q9 F 5 o rrt g ct \c o cr t+ !-t -g 6 ( !3 s F p-tlBg
it ts 9J 5 o Ut o ga
o 9) hl o (D t tr >f
5- r) "6 o 0r o o FJ d o-o o tr t,
5 'oo o 5 F) 5 E V)
tD 9) o (D o I' N
$(o 3 JD ;*sil'
9J
o e3 5
gJ r-) o
€ 0) o (? o .o r-i y v ^ vr-{ .+ H
€ a (! Ft
lD G ll) ga ltt
G r I
F* o rD $ NrD\JE
v, .! o ?ni 2: o -
-9) a (F =o = g J -

= L
-o = 7 c U
= ?e I a = .F, =at=

;]|'

=l
I'
{ -lll
- F tt
6 gl F F
at o D AA j')
d I rE 5 t o tr tD 9)
c
16
o :t g (a fr f.) g d o d o p) o
ga v
Fl Ft d v)* i-t o
v, g E v,
E v) fD d 9)
,f r Fl
v, o o
C ta tD o tD 0) o Fl Ft 0Jv 3 0l a
r) 5 p) o o : [€ o Fl! uF6 6 f') \J '9
o t v, G s) .J o F Ut
a, fD Fl g o H FU
oq v,
tVt o r) 'rO
0) Fl p o tr:*€ oq o R"9
j tv, a
Fl Vt FfSO o € v, o $) n o I N
o o) fD F fD v,
ag r F
(1 o o v, o
o V) oo= o o I trb(D JD v, o p) sr r) \,
o 0. F) td oq g I P (D o
"rdtoo F
9) @ 0l tr E r) o F
G. v p o hl
t) *sOqu t F tah o 5.o H f6
o w g o € c v) F tsl gJ p
gt g o ga o (D I FE r o Fl "+H o
9'
so -l
e v, g) () o qq F d
o F.5O JD o o g an
5 (D 5 tr Vt o I 5
' F rl FD) 5 it Fl) o
5 q. E) -(, o o K o g d r) vt
o F vt (t, t+
tr o tr
H:
oq oq F)
qEs v, g r-F0)fD p) |-l r) o- 0 ) . sJ 9)
-c t $ g) 5 F o FI
o EJ rD F v) Xt/j(D o v) H . F ' A ts o V,|.l r.l
o F,. g o € ct) (D o f) r-f F
cnc o o b. do 15.s 0: crq "o (D SJ ET
K a)
'5 ra (D o tr o o 9)Sut o F F 9r o tr o)
o o sr -h (D v, 6-?D 4 g o Fl
o C 9) F' g t.) u, v, 3 o g o FtO o
(o d OJ t6 o o g g ts ?
vt Fl sqo6' s
5 o v, o Ft p KO sr I
fD o o + ,t
vt
F
9)
o
s)
Vt
Ut
so 0)
6€t
roo6' F
(D
oq
gq o , . \ F T I J
Y5(+ E o
o
o 0q H
'io
u,
qa I
o s)
9) 5 q a o t-t o o
; (D o (D BTF E Vt o Eo I p v, V' OF o S
a Ko g fD o olr o o F hd t(i o
0r F ? o 0) € X'5 F) v) o o o o o o
? p q o o o oHd ta O F ;E I
o g fD w B
FU V) p tr Evr'' r5 g) 0) o
o Fl
E o 'cJ orj 3 v,
;t E) g) (D F o q crq o F{
x' o oo s
qa c) Fl o Fr) € J.
o $, "6
tJI
o d
o o F o
p
frE:l i- g or,{ tr
0) o F) g p)
v,
.) Flo
o E)
gq
o f)
9J o F o
g to v) 0J h { P H gq X F . F I H $) o
0) tJ F. tst Ft ; Fl 5 q
€ 16 n o ee (A n
o t (D(,)o v, (D o o
zo o
o Ut gq v,
:s rD o ts.q g v,
r gq
o r.) *l o g)
*r o
o o o F rD fd pd YE 9r
F
0) o 5 t, g) F gq ts
l , h F ' J
5
5 o vt € o
fi FF o n
ts 9ug
(D 9E o (1
cJ
? o o Fb srOa$ (D o ts v,
o Vt o
3. o f)
(D
svt tr Ft t Vt
ts A d o 0) o tr P 6 S g) o5. 5 o 0l
F
o v, o I,t H) F 14rD H' K vt (t
(t, ., 5 H . - o 9) rd ;-,, o v,
o $ Fl r) gl Fl .J o
:h o 3 F o 9J o o F nrt F
o oq d o g F sJ FF d.
g K o n
s 0) (D
HH# 5 9) oJ' r-l o
5 g p) 9) o o :36x € o ito
gJ
r) 9) o 5 o c) a1 0) o v,
o F o o 3 "5 o F F t\] Va fo +z o ;(D
5 g sr o g o'
16
FHE o n ts 5 g
F) I
o v) 0) x Hqq o u, R$8 Fi o 5 6E o o F) o
p oq n F fo I f) F.l
o o o (a P o (tt
o
zF) 6 ='€ qg H'6 0rx o tf
p v, F) o 11 vt f) to ct,
E t-!: F ci Fif. o)
ts os)(t
d qa r') g o 9J r) O)
o 3 N
{ 5 p 6q o g)
fD o 9)
C
Fl o n G t€ F o5 9J E 'c
6?o Fo
I
0) o 0. v, o fD
r) g I
F) 9" o
o o I o Frrr
5

355 How lang*age began


356 [{*w Langr:ageWnrks

o f1
9J 0) $5 €
E X = . o{ p FO o v,(D
9r Uq q9c tr o H 3e
F H(t)S i-.
o o g g ;-+
H $
>. tJ 9r 0r 9)it
t s . y €
gq gq o'
I(t)6 "v1R X
Vt o (t r-t
o) o gq fD $)!1
6 B Vt rD n
rD 6'
n'E tr v)
5 0) o 9) ct 5 3 HH:
gq oq o o
hl
tY
*sF Ff
oI
5 o 3:;.P
F i {
4 vt o o
i.* o \J H'30
o FJ 9J
zt tr E)
*i: 6 i+ s o u,
s gl
3 :s V) q 0) "-t (, 0Dr 5
v2
0) F o r.O o 5(D
8 3. r) o o
Fl o o r) ;rc
+ ts
o =6 hl rD 5 o o o E.rDh{
H) o tr g
3 !'
{o
tfD $)
OJ 0) qa
v, (D *cnc I
Ft s) s) hl
o o Flo rD € isEX
? v, o F I
g hl
i= o x3 " ? :rix
F to o 9) v, 3 E
gr F g r) r-t d tD o o aH&
€ v, 9) v, - V, Fl.
o (D o o
3
0) tD tr I 3a -ul H FF
Y V
sH q 9l l{ F.
F F vt s) uqax
ct'q ;.j.
t v t s l g o tr 5
L. '' l',< Va
a qi
6r lJ g n o o E
0l 5 Fl o
rfiOlD F o o 6;s
6 gq r)
g) 3 FJ
g 9) p Vt tr €
^ q H 9)
gq
E)5 ?r', ?n o ENJBE E€
Y.V
5X+ !D fD o 0) q tr s g
Vt o o 3 0. I
OE v, ga o a-. Ft +
v, 7<
ov, o $ d J J
o o) t { o o o Yb
ogr v, 9l o Eo
Vt S+ oq o (tt
3 (D (D
OFt Vt 0) 0J F ;8,3
sq n) o v) F 9) o
,16
3
o o vrfD
o o F o
hl g) o Ft(DX
vt(D o o. E
p s, F Rp,ii
o o 9)
Fi $ o p) I v,
8< o o
o o r)
3Hs
0r='=
r i Y
ct 't J

., = -4
- -_
= -& 77?
=*
,iD _ ;i

t;l
al
:l t (D t! ngr
o
:'ct FFl 'D cl 9' tD o F| 9r 5!t
€ € F| H) o)
(rl t? o fD u 5 K i!, O
a rD g g) qa (D 9) S) o
!C E X Fl
r-t t qa
z< rd v, qBH
Or) F T qa 9) 5 o
rl f.) A)
F= o F) tD @ o o
qg) = o qq
(a o qq a
srD
tD F F c) g) (D
Vt o s) o U 9) ts sr (D-(D
o tD g d 9) C'
,o r) 9) g 9)
3 @ o5
9+ € .?r o o
o VrO
(?
o o oq
x6 v) F o o
Ft F o gq c)
fD ? o o trJ O)
g) € crq r) (D rd X tu
o o crq v) ? v, !-r 6F
F tn € 9) 9) ; ;
d6 sl q) 4 w F *Y*
u, o cr @ F) 9) €8.
9J v) = 0q ct o
3C fo N) o o o
= # rd 5 o f.) o g (tt Vt oq crq E d 6 ***
'& (D o Vt ' ! ? (D
=o o K 0) ffi
9o o Fl o
r) 9) oq
gq tt
v, r) (D oa
't
a o- F \.#
-l o tD o o td8 q vt
v) c) Fl
oq N o \'o X 16
v, g \0 o 9l' n { o5 v, *@
o oF) o OJ fD
r) E) \o E F o l.)
qq r-l g, .) o
;F o tD r) !J o v, €F Ft
ga K v) vt o v, g OH
o (.) g v, vt
H € o 5 .J sl
oo o C cj fD
;Vt H!
:r v) g x.h
s JD
9) SJ o ! € tr -t s) o gr crct
o Vt sJ o g) d U) tt I
o (D o oa F n o 0) g F. O)
so gq o Vt
0l
Fl
tr rD o E 9) oq L o v, o 5dq *J
I Ps)
g) (a F (, o oo ffi
9)
g E) F $ tf
o e (, Q oq @ 3
hl
PJ o o o {o :+ or
rD d o vt Vt o ts ffi
V) o o r) vt f) B . o
x9) v, EJ 5
c 9) o
9) { (D u, {a' F
E g
-: crq = Ft)
r) 0) oq 9)
o o pr o d o (D $€
a c Q r) ga o v, 0) ffiJ ffi
€ ri 5 o- o 9) ct rD
oJ g (t) 0q vt F.
o cra o oq (D (D s) rD ol oq r r+ V)
i o o
9l 0) o- € F Vt r) d 6
d qq o 0q € o o)J (!
0)
o o o
ffi ffi %*d-T
og o € g) o o9) @
ta U) 9l v' (o 0)
o o - g Sl c)
r-+ p g n v, o s
id
'91 € rD vt
o o o' o g o PS ryffi ffi -tJ.T
€ o o o F) o fl"ffl\
d I
g) o + o \d
o o 9) \J
o fl&
w flffi
357 l-iow lang*agecflanges
358 l{*w LanguageWcrks

o t.)0J !3d r< rD


5 € € [5 { g€ € (o' CD 'd
H FJ €= *J l-t 0r
o 0J 9) ir g6 o S) F
hl
j 1 08 P o g 6 o tsE o o v)
,rd =.
F3 n
oJ >.1 iJ VrP
'a
ts v, f) =< o tr o
0JrD w ts o o -l o5 vt H.
Vt
o c) > =: !?v o FJ 16 ol
q- 9 fb o xo v, IU r.O E€ 9)
FFX
!r. P F gq H)
,*iTi.l o o F) o Ot i: o ?1 to
o o=
nt) o 9.
g
! ' I
FT
O. t!
F
o' g
ct
oq o o
sU tr EH {ts
SF.
v:p
€ Vr
s
o
v)
hl

(1
{
$F
grvt
5"U
F.C
or o.
lo o.
ritr
tr v) dt
5
pJ
o
E$$
Fqg l r oF +
fD E o
rt ut 9J ;s \5 (D tr o.c (D
9) 'd 5\ vr. 9. gE .Do
E3E
lI !-
F Fl
E E o E {T. (r) 9) F og oftr an
{0) ;€E,s
oq d
:'o
o 'qJ= 5€ gl a' -a os) gt
9) t o e o € ,*Z c? €
F f') I O) s8
= ? g 9r o d
a a -aP DFf i.+ v, Vt E' GP
tr) 9) o oa g o o
' v)
5 x ! )E o O, HR. 5 5 fD € o f) rF) O
E Ffo o
ct n u, tr X 5 u, tr :6 E'9
5 o Ei Fds pr oE' {o o5 v)
g -6"' E tD pr o p) n o Ed o !'+. v, (D €
||.) s € tss, 0) (9 C/tO
H. F o ,J Ut aiS 3 F) .o o. o
.=F qq nv, \ 5 { to Xul \s too
ry o v, o 5!D oF g5
=rD- FJ
r) o
o
g fD
v,
r) a
o 'Fu, 3o :J
JD
o
r-l F) C'r 8E'
5(D
frBI f
,o F |!o
r0 F E ;sc *5 -- EE 6,, ga9J g S l r X
F o t6 5E r' o ie,
I xsr p 9l p) Fl
o 3d c
=.o o F o5 p F
o €E fd so 0) seta
rD o o o \s V) J5 u,
6o I5 rDX gq
6'r F
ts
q tr rft tt, rD oa fD
u, FIg n=' f \J o Ut
tEPe
t- E1 I
v, v,
c = 8 S P oJ o E S-F 0l
o I
ovr=;
F{ .-l'
o E t o 5x gr: F 5o
n gE t5 (D o tr R o . 6, P ovt w €
/g l o FJ € o F Hs 6' g'' Vt g)b c) o
E v,
o o c) o Fio E o € i+rD o+
Fbl Vt
p r-r X6" X
a6 v, o TH 0rn 9) o o r1f3 u)
r-l h l ( / ) o
so ts
H FF 9) Fo Ut fd e.5
€ o fD o d o 0)
r_t o u) s) = 9 ) gsl F J5
o f) F |.) vt ts.5 g F) E r:HiP
at) 5p o. al
so . - o o
o o vt E. 5 o qa qo htO
Hr(-) o ovt ta sr ,f
+
v, hl v, r) € fD
grs's
;vio( D
) 0J 5 tvo
€ o a" E g . rD r 0 5 o p
qa tsJ o (') Xo' >U oo.
o
o 9) o d5
tsrD $ t-f v, r{ q Bg q
Fl oFl u) 6d 0) vt s
o I €F 5+) o" [ 8
= F t F) n z< p v)
H 5 '.5
\J qq € { tr fi i o
t{q IO o o o ro nr o 5 Fl ;aeB
ia
€6 o 5 o o 0) tr.T FO FJ OJ
a rD o o gq FI (D t't Cf pO.d
Vt n5 'FJ s o
o 0) € s rD o l y A
Sor 0. x F $Ft 9r o o rr F) o X
| J h ( E 0)
H. o Bg 5 F {it 9)
vro o r-l o sLF Pq F
o ; o Vt A(! to .B ilT5u'
v7 hl Oo o JD o OLFIg)
F) (t) o €
o !5v) o 0r5 'o3 F { \ J -
o { 0J /rl F{ o o o r! {
ci :1 n (n o' r-l 0) (b
o r+
:+il JD
:- € x = oc &5 € 0
o 5 ='
.: 't- =. - 9c a. = a ==' = == € F
= =I
2
ns
_,_ a ! v? € t :
= = E. = a :-===
E t
€6

a1D dD
7 t t g o tE ID
t'l .-| O 5 E F Fh ri
|! I t! g, r-f,
1O r .D 3J It 6g fD
o
Vt 1tr' i' d Vt (D
do g) 7 o, 3 :t iJ 3S. xut o r)
(D 0t F) o ra 9r € o tg E,E
A0) ct) o { c'. 0) (n
F.l F) re .) o
3 (D tD E a,o A. u, o
9rrD It F 9) 3 o g
o 9) n v, Ft (1 't^ fi T tr
=. cE rd o oa o trt, P) F o ^he
(D F) v, EF) ,.o F oq 3 'ct o)
€ o ? o o oq tr r\o id co o { o o
j9) 0J -l u, g) o n g rD E =; o o)
9) o rd (D (D qq
sr {t\) € qa o {D
\o I 4 (a
o 9"8 3 q' +8 J? sJ FfO gq
F v) i.i( V) yI oct 5 o F
ot o v, o s sr a 5S
Vt fD n nj' tr rJo F) g v, F FJ5 € o c
s) g) ta oIf :1 q' tt, o
9) () 5 gq Fl
tu, s o 5 0) E o OJ
o (D F{ o (D o o -r+ v' $) ir o gq
o Sr o g6 o
so
u, p 0l 9r w G o F€ o
0) Vt .) o F { o g7t gac X !) v7 o
o $ o ga (D opJ tr o 69 o o
o t "d g I 0) 7r 9) 5 Ut ' o r/) v, o
>{ o n v) flJ +J
= (D or 9. 5 a) g 6r fD' s to o d o
16
\o n
(!
o F F) ''9 € g gq n o 6's p) :'
v) fd o V' g o =€
5 o ; -(/l g) = o H a. og) o u,
rd
o p 0) u) r) v, lll H) r)o F o.)
rJ o g C' o o gq o ^ H€ g o 5 o 0)
n
(') g Fb v, o (t nF) o =
o
u, $) o g o td tD o' to Ft i;9 E o 0J 5 it
Fl JD o ta 5 o
o 9) v, 5 t hl -O r-.r G 7 ir ;R o oa
FJ cD' oa
F € v) 0) r< (D o U E'n c, =u) oq o o t, I
E' to ga s s) w Ut o o F o o o a
Fl FI:
5a g) rD
f.) g r) F v)
.J
FO o o
o o o d o E 9) o dt 9 ,ct) 5 H(1 o o
q p 6 o oq K
o v) r: o o o o o o 'ut Vt =o o o 5 o -.
o € X 5 5 u, 6 H O. 1.
o
i v, v) o g. tr I Fl X vt
!]
(a 0J it ro g g) 9l 4E qa (D OF S+
o
s) 0) € o o o o
F) F F 9l T Gi' f.)(o EN Fl g o €
n s) ro qq oq o 5 F q8 V) gJ 3
p o v, (D 9) o (A ? s)
V)
o t g) 5 ct F{fD F
ci' o v, o 5 7t V) r) n
vt S) o) U) d r) (D :< € 1 o o s ct
v, F o o H# o F) 9S g) 0) o
o o gq o 6 'g F F
0J rd' oq rj V) 3 FJ cLo v, { 3
n o I o 9) v, i+ vtO o o o o5 o o
() o r) vt o o 16rD
rD "o (a Vt 3
o €o On
p) n it s) g $F 0) o o rJ () € ot, (D
o qq Fl 9) o o + o t .5E0 v) o q{ o qt
{ F) F rD' 5 0) $
o o 5 F p) Ft F 3 T E o' o n F $) $F)
9) o 0q o v) E 'urD p) r-f) n v, a
a) o o o o E' € F tr:s v, :3
Itr E) rD € 5 cr 0l t, V) cra
tr g) o E n € o Ol|J 5 (D s)
9) t6 o tr E U) o v, E5 oa fo s)
q€ F) o p { o 5
F o F 69 o p F 5
o 0) 5 5 o o o e. o o 5 V) o 9r
f) iTj o
o oq
n r) n q5 o E oq tr n
(? ga (Dv, o= o 5 v, V)
0) 9) tr fD s) OJ 0) t, rJ
Vt 9) o o o
ts o
5 ga t v, g g P.O gu' FJ o f:
o s) (D o K F tr
o Fl vt r+ o 0 FI
a 0q o o € 0J o 5 i., 0, F oq €
a! s o 0) 5
9) E ,'l n o o F
o f) o 5 I
o o .gq 5nt o I C" Fl 5 I o O.
I
I Ut 5 v, ? U) o o

359 H o w l a n g u a g ec h a n g e s
360 l-iow LanguageWorks

vt5 0) (^ 9r59 E o 0J
v, f rJ
tsl 5(D;L ) i .t F a X p 5H
FI
d 8 €c)
o€ o o.E.q vtO 9l Hd
FA sJ n 0) n oa e '.d n u,
fd ='o
9Jr)
o o gJ
'V,
Vt
Fl
r+
seeBts 0)
F g,
tr
Fl
H =
(:Ds) F
o
FJ Fi
'6 9. rD oF)
vt
H. H. / Fl 0QH.
gR
r-t rD
fgE€ ,r (t) € Out
rv.
n(t E
v,
A K o-
cj' g) o Ut Ff v,
oo. q) H.fD P -
g; opJA
E# fi g g,E. V) F { v, -3 6 -vt' srO F o o
FrI!)
Ho o ?o
lr' Fb
o o o
-:o g,6gq s g o 3-a 5sl rD t/l
iuH o E oor t,o n
B 6; €+ (') v, t OOH6 g o
o
ddo
qg
( - J F a F t
, = I J
pFr.6
83
5I'otr
F

tD
o o
crq
Irfii
g HEi
:d
o
H
F)

o 9 H !-!:
ont
5s.
5'{
a l )

n
@
p
OJ
=
Eo tD N ga
iE 'E
q9o H FFil ,.-l 3 tro 9) r) u, 6' tr (D
rvo Sl
f 9''g o g$ F
E{o 0) c
o trij {T
p) n SJ
5 F:F df;
? H .
fi 3EE {o o 5 E B.f o
S € =5 r8D 8i 5 3 H +E' oq s) nr{
6t FI
gq
r) 5Ff i'0 P d o 0)
a5 crc)Ss) Fl
I od Fr5 rD
a- o € F
>. o
C r+.
rx [g t$ 9)
3 B-; + o€ 5o ct v, po
dts !-. r) o oq
htf F c ES) gir n o n
!Do
s [E g w
gl 0q figEii F € E) v: oq J
fiP8 r.{ 9) o u, 9E rerD 5
E gni c' € o SJ
0) F igEH' o t o g) E'n qt 5
v, oq 5(! 9) =
oFs)
g 1$€ v, 88. lut
B .^r lJ Ft 0) oq v) Ft v, -r. Ol 5
t Fl{ts. gt 3:r o o ga
hl 5
t9 r) ' oO o
(,) v) 0a Fo o 0q
o $u'9 5 6[i
FtU
sg) .!r r# q8 o
g o 0) hrfD €
-FdrJ o
sF)
o TFfr 5 g.
:rig 5r:v, ooq o ;io ,lO
a)
v) o oa
o (a € 8" g€ (D
v, r) 0) ittr
o
n
E € E. #fi:
i';+5 H F sr 3 g[k ooq I rDFr
H3,fuoo I
; TH q7rD p) tr tr 9)(D Fl l! Ft- t r H ' oFf: 5
o o v, '!d rD O o
,dHB o vr _1 FJ 5i' c
ltt FJ* v,
Ut to
o 5r) \tt-l
:s Ie3 o
qq o f)
Er-t5
O
S) g
€ roo
g8 no o
0l il'rE o 5 o V, I o 5
o X (DH X' nt 7f
5 RAH' FI:
g o ii.
s€ E
3E$
F. tr.
3 6=go
r;H+ Ein K Fi E. +o. o
v,
F €.* P' Fr ,s
v, ; f E 9H5 t qq
P3 o 9r d(i o
o vtc (!
T g= ii' =. + 3 5++5€
rD rD :. {o €r o
E f) 0) f) &9,
rD IJ FIO
+
o
rg $sE 8 $0) 0)
ef g,
s.+F
l Y - -
9J r'3S B 9, j ii :r
o =. t =
-€ 7 q t
.B
E *€
=i!!rEa
? 3
FD
8 ii C

3
E'sL 6

o o
g!i c(Dt '
o
u cl
.! t8 |D :1 AsE' m -sr a E,
o, d rt gt
F, ot
3
Et g n
€ oo r-t 5 tD o 5 = F ss3=. s.
g gJ ts
Fp rr o o w =
i'p o oa-=
F F* E tot v, o o
- -1 5 F 9) o ts o o -ut $
F s) -?l B E'3F (D s (n
o v,
I 3'qt o o
f€ F t V) 7 oFl:$ o :'r o o 9) gl (D
l.rl Fl H)og Fl vt UI
't- N o rD r) -j E tD €
Y t')
o o 0) 9) s) o 0r
7t p hl
(n F 9J I o +r 3 o Ut 5
Eefi
Or) v, Vt OIv) v, oq o
tr n
3 n Fh
1 o tr sJ
,Di' o o v,
€,8 e 1
+
d vt F) o fD OJoTII o
=(! r) tD o E) crq F o
Fl 9J
o € v, V)
o o (D Vt
oFl v, r) o
e 5 tr o q
E € +8 3
=v, vt o o 5 $' =E:E+ o
r-|' "O
tD
V)
n fd
o
(D C'
o
frFI o
3 F
o o
f.)
Vt
pJ
G
0)
(") o 0,
n
^a o o o ct o o o 5 *
I(? o d; 5
Vt F
i
x(D fo
5Ht 3 F o
d+ Ut v)
(,) o E 3 cr o
LA
F o J H
Ess 5 F o o o f
(a
rt v,
r) o o
E o $
o oq
g o f6 o
:9 rE
odg6' o
Y E) tr E; € n tr o 5
6B o v, F 0) n d 3 E
qa
o FfO
5 { 0r v, JD o e#; H
oq qa u, tr o hl
9) o JD o T5 q
EAF Fl
o (?
o no Fd
tD
d l5' o
p o (x € aE3 5 $ 9r o

OJ N
ts oF
Hqq g l.tl I r) fD o g)
o o 16
o
vt
. H vt. o
Fl
9l
p
5'e i
dE)!' s JD
t('
g: F
H#gI F
gq
o qq o n o P E F) o JD
o 9J(D s u, o r) 9J sEql
vt g o
\J ry F
sFJ
5 H! Vt o 0) 5 9) p v, o d oq
9) o V5 g F o
o 4iJ fd
oa o rJ r) tr a) s) 9) :+3f
5 riO o EEf; ta 5 p €
(D -Ft o I o .oF Fl
g 5 3; 3 f
Ft.) vt tr @
9l € Vt fD 9) 9l
€ oo Fl tr F) g
tr s) r) o (D o 0) F
'o,6 0l o n r) I o
0) oq
rl p
9J
gt
i:E 9J
r-t
s
q F
gl
rn (? o Esa: o
BF' o s) o o n C'
v, F r€ B o gq
rJ't 8d gq 0) 5 f
0J € gU) o zeE ? gq 0) IE Is rD
59 o 3
pJ 5 -l
n r) -l o oa
{o : $ d +
tD
{0r o o
o r-l pJ F o
o or- ta tr o
Ft Fl o 3 o Fl 5 Ut o K tD u, 5 rR+g o
$ Fa'E
H o w l a n g u a g ec h a n g e s
362 How LanguageWorks

| o v) o rt| u)!) v) v\ vt o o
gil ts tsl F s€ E s a5 o = g,E no H' fo 6'gg E= g5'
c) r) utfD r, r)(D 5'q o v, o Ct0) gq
f! =
E# o 6E It !t3 0) E OFr
H E'
+t$ cv) 5 o
B KF g) "6' * oq g€
sl
ts o q Fg rt 5 F o. :i
n V) rD v r o c € t-l
H $6 o
0) (1o o H Y v, o r)O
v, s s0q
fn *H * o
F5 Fl o o Fr V) (D v).
fiB tD
o w 8a \0 ; (n' Pd Fl
r) F) f!
r)5 u, (D o p{ OH. += s Fl
€ o H(D o qE
FI
:5. BgAH
s PF * 3 rt! gq n !'\S
€ s) ts r9 t) u,
u, n 8 v' g (D O|!
g F F *5
E8 o $A 6oH5
o (D s '9) r) vto g oq H'€
o 5 5s 9) N
6( DEv , Ft E) 5 T5 pr+ o F or=. 0qs
r) o 16 o rf oa F OJ VrO vtO o v, ;+(!
o I p U)
o *d g 5 33I
OJ o Fl oE n 9) n o a' Ft F .€
B1 r-t 5 5 u, 6g 3 gF g)
pr n
h t F , v, =s :+s
o o E* :s ct oo o v, *t EfE o
t-l rJ u, E FI: oo o oa =. E6 v, cLFhr o. hr E'S
g o F) o gF \tFl ('0y
Eo (a (, p O.(!
tr F o *8 E) Pg) qo o
FI
u, o C'
oFfr 0) 5 K 8a; oa ts
p t qE FE o 7r v, t tr S
Xv, o
{9r tr E"t
x v, F) F u, g E f ; 'o sg 5 ga vt
"o
F s E S o o
e''E.H
FTAFI
-VF. I 63
gq r: E o
r-( 3F 5
Eff
H.
H
n
o
o fr Vrd d &{ o
to H
o o tr
v, vt 9)
t ,5'
-vt i, s r)
6v' s) F) gl o
H.g *6 Eo r) H €
iVtd g
3 F qq 5 fD n o 4€
€ og
o.6 fd (D gq FrF F) 0)
r-l
(tt o5 i'9 o
Fl 0l EE o IA Vt rri
d o tr o sqa K ; o FJ R, o w
o
tD 7r F
t€3o
X o f: oq o
l+
F o o 0. cr F 5 o
Etr' 5 vt
r) o du' :ld 9a o i* hCJ
5(D K o € .o S) ooI
p) €#;
.a F. o) uq(D
(DH. OH o v, d FJ
o Fl at ;-r F € e. aDir n g|..I' H p 5
H J
u, o 9) oEl v, crq ifgr n) g) o o
v E) o o ?H.
r-l i.i C r) 7f eo 0) rc, Vt o
o 5'A *F Ut o aq
H'
YA
nt F 5 oo o 3"5F o Fl FUt
9) c) so v) (D5 I 5 ro ,d o
!:tJ
0) o rrF
- o o
Fl
o F gs 5
o Fl s)tD o F +H
#= Q' 8. () v, HH"s 0) a E.o
fD. tD
g ET tr
tc' Fr E 4F oi ld \
Fl g g $t €Bo
o io 5tD o c) t p
F C,:
g :r o oa q t rtt,
o O ro o Ut r) F
+rP EH f.) oq "'P o
- 5 ttr E n tr zn sl FH t
d< t n oFd o e1 s rs FF.* { BE.
tD s) gs) E
p 5O g $ o
9) F o v, OJ
I oq
Ft u, Fl
\
8
rr|.
p) v, 9) r-l c0 5 o s) H P o n
V, a
Fl
(,:- JD Fd Vt (D +. '-b *s)
o (D r) oa
(D C'
\8 { '15 o
8 3 F FI o 6 -E g itg o o { H€
JS) F (D p 5iD tr ci 5f o 3 =.4s' 0J
| i i . - oq 3 to 5
6 o SJ V) ra 'dO q
*g F( ut (D o.d
Fl w G.R tDFfIO o t/) =(D
n o o o
fD = q= n '€ o ia;
3E o) D a
C
Y 9,,
=:

'a!
o 'ct fE lil e*
H! r) Fl (}'(' ct E 9)
o u,
F sr
{s
o o $) 0q S) qa -,F) g
r) o
tr
vt vt ^r d?* a
0r F F Fl E o o
ts c) E oq
5 (1 gq o sn r.!|
F
qq F p o I (D ; ct6 $# u,
o s g)
F qq (D 5
(D ch w sl o @ 55 9
v, 9l ts F qq tr V) 0) I o E
FI gq !t
I
Vt o qa
p) o oq JD (t| F) o sr 9r
l-t H"t r E
5 o hl
s) F o d s ds) 9l o o
rD E hl X $) o o v,
o o d o) ,!O tD g o x fD oa
Fl Fl r)Lr 6.6 r-l
cr o
o o o
r-l
o
gr
so S JN X 0)
Ut f: o 5 9=r g+ f,:
o F FI
? g o (D T
F o o tr) ov, F o o fD; 30 o E
o 3 tD n E s ot- o s€
o s) F v,o o to
o s o r-t O 63 3
o' (D ct F Vt F a c (DS o 9)
g oq {D FI t/t rJ|D H
s OJ FI o F
F (D v, 3 rD
oa V)
g o g) hl
0r d ts
v, qq o c0r 9l ir5 o
r-t FI o rD p \J oq S)
5 o s) ? E)
ga g o E u, Vt 59)
to E ' o
F Fl FI $
vt tr El v, tr o tr1
0) 9l 9)
r:
5' o {o .- \J
tr l-l 5 I .J t-l o G' it
F
Fl
3 6 F E
E
n r) { fD o \t 7.H tso ts F
FJ qq
o 9) {D o S)
fD
o Fl o O)+ A- tr
3 Ft o
v, p oq'd X ts6. o
p) 9) 9J s toX hr li ; v) o 9J
s)
gq
:.r n
o'
r-l F| g)
o rJ 9) ;s g) o p 9J t F 3 E8 o o
g o tr 9) F 0) 5 o oE. \J 0)
p ; s) d 9) (A
ts o€ F) o o n
0) G o FJ n JD
*a o tD
tr o 9J S. qa FI o IE 5
F (o o Ft
gq o o v g lq
I Flr
\tr-t 0. H6'
o F F !a r) o o'
Fl
I f.) o o o
ra g)
9) 9J a
o n 5 Fl 6ct
ga o hl o 5 o 5
rE ts oo5
fD
o tr
t-s
fD o Fl Vt
oq K gB
Vt s.. € g S
Fl o g) I (D o F
v, g) u, o p) Rct
0l 9J v) O. 0q o -
tr p Vt tr
F 5 ct rl ct
s) JD 0) fDA o E; tD
o o fD r)o o p
; o 5
o o o _ Frt o) F F5 E- o ry
o w F o I.o
Fl E OJ o o oq s o
Er
q o
tr c)
3 E '.1 o 5tj O)
o Fl Fl. E 9) €
E o Fl 9J E oqA
5 Ut FJ
F
rD sd
FJ
Fl
F
gq o ct
o I I tr P fD :< U) l!' O. fil
How languagechanges
364 How LanguageW*rkg **.L-
t.t
fq. r *-*[**
L} I
(D0r Lr o t! (+ -l ib&#
€ 9) 0l 0) (') { q 9 { ffi
trr= o lra
Li.
If **rq
5 F F) A
o fD c i g
1< o (') g oa oq t rD KJ Ltr
(? (A (D 3
'o =l) -*-r{t
tr OJ tr 9) Fl
Ffl x
a=-;
s o() = r o
E'* F) 9) ct o q tt, ffro*q
xLr' r) gq o oa o EH **J {
gH fD { o o (D o fD hl e5
o (D FI vt @ d S
k#e
\iq
fv6uo, s a)
PtD Ja o vt o F) o n
gg o. 0q o\ o u, w
l-{
iY. j ' r ! J, I 5 FF
g I
o 1] X € 5
f.) E u, fo fD
v, F vr o rt I F
oXut Fr S) \o g g hl fD o o #E
J5A oqw A fD o t s p
T \5 Fl
JD Fi o Y d o 3 Fb dF*t\
FrE= E P r) o FI: o s
AJ AJ o o cr IU
AH .D
o K
Fl -l o € s, o qFt+6 F) *J
5o 0l JD E F UrO
. - . r o =' 5) 4 s ) r) EP hl n n
Fl o
6 e.oa dn v) al fD o o Fl ta o t*
ir.3$ p F !) o.
Oq u, o (n o ct CI' f) $
)
r+.56 oFt n oq (D 0) o 3 d fd
=sr?D (? oq o o |D u)O
E r') I' vt 3
o)U FJ 3 t1 9) T o u,
l-r fD F tD o v'. Ff {
Ir+.{ x o Fl 0a ,'td o € ffi
gE r!
( 5 5 t:l 5 T p) tD g-6 o
rD o hl
o o p fD g
e.r g a F o tD hl F
4
5 oq
so
S oB n o (D 0q s) Ut ,r*\, ffi
o al v, $ F qa u, tr Ha n
qE 6 !1 vr o o t.:
0 .8 rd r-f: o s) r)5 o L*,
oFt ?ii' (! (t, v, F ri' p g ga o
XH AJ Fl o *-"7
Fl
=Fd
A th3t i 6
?
A] A) o
5
qq
o ;
'ct 6" f.) vt o
Fl
frJ
ofD :'.D vr p) F| JD €
F PdrE,
p
116= o.p
ts F)
F H)
x Ft '{, a A) \o o o o*
{El 9r F 0q
tsl Fl fE R*
UoFr osl Ut
< o
f!
v, o (D
ffiffi
:ra 5 t! A) fD F n
F I \ J F 5
m=''o
Bft o'
v,
f,+ (l
)-l
(D
n
(D
'tt0l I ;-
tr
ro tD v,
(D
s€
Ej
o(n
u, rtt
o9 5 v, F) og o
r-l
F3. 0q { ol o f')
o9:i qp o A) (?
{Sr i E o
Ft) tr o o
{ v, q o (') E) oq g g 3i o
d 3:s 50a rD $ Ft)
o!'F. o F 9) I $
a) (a
: T Hv'
*) =
F ou ' 55 0a 5 F Ft
FO f) o 5 9) @ 5 ct o (D
o.o o F tD o
FI
H g v,
(D
o q6
qF3 9o (D g o €
v, v, $ s) st
ga o
e+O trr X rD n TA o 3 (? ids o
Fl
'o € f- v, a F)
€ gq o o
q3 fo sl tD n i' v, oq H 3 €F
6F A) F v, tsl 0) o o +
fo5
= {Oo qq vt tsl v,
€ F ao
5 3a o €
e'; g. |Dct ar I oq
Fl
0) 1 o v, 0)
9)o 0) ( v tt) Ifa
vt3tr' ? qJ @ o o o g (Do I'
F t ^ -o o F 0) cn
- 0a I
-ct -cr:
3'1
=
-;

g 'iJ
..f t' F
€g FI e'
fl t+ f
r|D :r vt it
€ E Fl ii rD (D a
|D ttr !t
(D (D r' gF o \5
a i It rD EI ra fD :s
Fl o g, =r Ut o
.D 6
5 X st
h3 $t rtt Ft F) vt o
Fl
aa Gl o "(t qa gr tl1 trt fo U'
v, (D t? |! x F o F n i'(D F o v, o
3 9) $ TT v, € o o Fl ga p -u, o (! tr
hl r) oq
.t o d C' w o o p *# (D o 5
5 H! F t) (D tr N o Ut
v, 5 o =l dE (D o tD n v, 0) rd
tp
g
c, F (D f) v) it vt o p \S
x d o 3JD 9) o ta 3 o t! = o ct oq r)
.o o o w o o
Ht
hl o s 0] fD o
tlr I Fl 3 ;o o $ {o
01 r) E .d
sq + St
9'
Fl E tr9 vr s) vt o o hl J/) OJ F Vt o o F
$ o F v, st E)
p (D t d g o o
(D u, SJ >t o at 6' 0) o
€ r) e. F.. r.l o 5 o
fr o 3
(D 5 o o 5 C' gq OJ g) o F o 5
5 o c) 5 o g o Fl = @ 5 V) o o
ra F F
o Eo o gJ 7t o X o o
s) v, g) sr n { oa St |) o s) s trl It
F
o v, u,
o tr 8a'
F'
it Fl 5 3 9l 5 oq tr 3
o tD T cr o o s) gq Fl o E
; GI v) F F Ut 3 s) (t Vt rD Fb o p o
cr
EF o
nj (A F @ \s F) 5B o n
t 6' o tD o
Fl g !J .t) o o
!', 0) € { 3 t p s ? E o $
gr GI p) g) Ho o FI:
(1l o O) o o
Fa o
o
Ft
€ Fl
s) g
oq o 3 o o U od $t ts t
gq 5 (? Fl
t ts o o G f.)
o :3 o 0. (D g) o o tD a 5 Ft r-l u o rD
Fl Fl
s 3 -qJ
FI -(n 5 $ FI F o
a
o
ro
o X o
o)
\5
s
(D F
t.) s
F s) o
r-l |! o
F o
sJ o
5
oa
ia
o= SJ 5 ts o g 0)
u, 9)
Ef o € 5 q o S) v, I' 5
ga u, FJ 5
(.) g t! TA
F o S o Fb
F o g
fd 5 ts (D d |! o o HH tr o Fl
o ]r o r) hl
H r5 o- |1 r: oa o F)i' OJ tr o
OJ o K o) hl r) oa r-l n 5
hl tt o o 9) oq t.) .)
Fb r-|. o
o -qJ o Fs+ Fl
o o sl $) o \o (D JD
u'H r-l (a s. € 3 qqs $!t v, o
o F
o
so
X o o F) o v, o E d o ts JD
S) o Ut o tr F s) { 5 o
u, v, 6€ F € o A] 9)
t-l v, o hl u, 3 (.r s.?
o S+ 0r p) t1 o S)
fD o (D
3&
vr('
5 € ci'
Fl Ut |-t i( 9) o o a) IA
9r ol Ft o
t-fr ( U) Fb 5 F Ft(D
I
o v) 5 F
fr.9 p fD o o ,f v, € |.) t) (t, o
a o a o 9) 0) s) u, tr 9r o U)
3
u,
o |.| s* @ Ut o K o Ft Fl
Fl
5 {
o
o 9) a g a
Fl
o
x o o F.l
o
F K
rE p
( ;rD G o
ta o i r{l E vtx o
tD c) F gq g € n r) ; F p
Fl
5 6T t9r rD 5 n g
r-l i' v, gq 3 o 3 F) v, s oa
o C' (D v, Ft' s) tD o 9J o Eq
t o o o t-l v, o o o o J+ E !J
r: E E vt F r) u, o 5 fd :D o
n 6e= cl o I 3 5 hl 0) F
o
o 5
ga o o
x ,f
5
fD g)
F
o
tr
t()
o ts 0l
3 m
K
s)
F C'
g.
o E
B
o
r)
tr
=v, o I'
o F
g
rD
3
3
o hl u,
rd o I $ (r: 9) o FI o qq o sJ
Vt LA @ K o o 5
a E3 s) o g F
hl ttt
F ts g s) r-t o € t it 5
v, n
gJ
v,
fr
3f; o
U) 5 o tFl srD
V) 9
g F s cr 9J tsl 3 q
p 5* @ |) o n v, (t) &(D o g)
o o (D o o For g)
o I
p o oq d6 o nt (a o (a r5 t vt U) Ov) I 3 5

365 How lang*ag* farnifieswark


366 i-law Langu*geWarks

ga oqF 0r a
3 ilr F5 c0? I E 6' {
9)I;+ 9.o o o
o O '.4 9J
6srH. E3F
-t
?o -t
q35 o 3 o' -l E:
q'$
fn r-l { E'
8 5: J? d' Al F.
aH g qc
9r 9) x
5 =l' tsrD (1i+ts o
o4 t5 JD
g; Hvt fDH o crq S) 90
v)€ B oo (t)
5H:* V) t gi.^ 5
o ' - v F { 6 a
0J t't tn
so ga |- l+) -i o o
o r+s Ft
'5( 5D 5
o Lsfi e g -o'- T o v) (D
E H.$ o H Ft Vt
PJ' vt o at Frt F
tet
95i; 11S)
{S e Er.x € 'oS
;o) g8 T o+ (sX { Fr !+EqJ o o
a - . N rD
t y 1F F
_o; hl !-b e3
o)u) 4.5 u, orDtrt "0. vt
ii V)
E/irFJ ;s) NO) oq v) o
oaES Fr qg i-+ (n' 9J o'
u' oq I 0) p
g f ;';
OFt oFd .a 6' oq i l i o
a
r of i o o g o o
or ool =. rD F I € r) |}
J (,n ?t o 9)
fAio . de
i' 5h Xor o
5
98 n o
rl.
5 p
^ g.o
6' P OJ v) 0l U) o' *
X *rtt' rs)) o . .d
'6
oo raPg) 9
F r-t
a'8
=.o
o
rs+ 0J Ft
sn 8, 8 (u
Or.
td xo o 6 88 g rD3
$E e ti V) o -.
ao .io
\ \>" dx n I
h[ + \3s OJ o o
-i O) hl Fl
T cB= qA 3
{o h Fl
??F Ed o FJq
a' v) i i 5 V) € Ut o
ri: o' V) aoc 'g
A H . )
+E* ! o (D
G u g& Vt
EE = o 0) n
,-i F.
5F (, 5 o iaB 5 r)
!-i. 0) o)v) 5I'
g 6 X o- 9l d
sJO +vtt* !t Ft -l
PrT
o
ooq H(/, 3 rd, 9)
q9 =' F Yq to
rD
Ft Fo FfO
€' r: Vt 0, ts
ko g5as H
:5s) LA o
qt)
o H a \i 5
g) ii o
Hoq . g :
Oa 0r o(.j +Hv, o oq
I o
q6 os) € o Jo I
= t
.n Fg 5
v)
(t) OFt fitd
sH J " *6F 5o o o
Tg n q€ E (D n
i
? EqB 0)? -(/)
h? .u) s
'\? EE 5
s 9) s) v)
E5 HLS H5' 5 ;€E
o5 o5 E *5 o o
'' (a= A
Ar oaF *( H V lJ) €
: E*_ ==' ! ?= ?
=: ,= == = ? =L=
^.:
:= 3C

?9
o
G o
-' l.l o
CJ
3 .se9F
aEs9.5 lF 3 (!
6,F
=a
a - P - a + i \ e) v)
ga !r.E
't rt f
5 E'3
c,Jt a
o
v, HgEg.5
o
IU o
I +usf P H
gt pE.
cl
F)
p

F l-
r+
EO
9l
9) 9J
ri
9)

(,)EE
(a 5
qt(/rnF< gr gE3.
$aag$n$ $
oI

&3[&; o > > > Ei Fl


P r(- g..* 9,
E'r.H.Sq*T p
9)
!4$
IgiE$E*tFiFE*s-;5
H
P E 'F6' d , E.s. H? 5
=lrt -
rrg$E
s$ &k
9Fh EEl.a
ctdlD
Tfi P 5€ HH'
tEFF€gN E6 *
9 . 9 .x F =Et
E . gE I Ffi'E i G
ft
FJ.t)'
Po)

l6t fan:ili*s wnrk


H*w 1*ng1-rage
366 i-iaw Language\,V*rks

*l 0r Fl- r)
5 I 5:S =ut € ,t:H
5 SF il g) r-l
g) o ors
t0 si fI F
srr.o.rD E =|. o o fD 5ol
co OH s) FrS
ESF
F5 |D o' -l 47 rD= R'$
-t o { o) Fl 5'
pJ 9) qq
;FlgaU; p) s) r-f
lt't
E =.9fi B F JD
()* o
oa o
0 o I
o r) w
90
{ Vt o F (,n
FT
(n g
cpJ $
$.lFf i E'rs o gq
=o g ,.o o o
o E) 5 fD
(a e vt pJ ? (o (n
o "5 o t.0
gfHIr?E o rrl V) >< 'o8
s S) OFf €
€ rs o € X
IE F'E H o + SJ Fl
o N o (') o
hl Fh .o. 6S
F Ut oo t
v) FEF5H35 u,
9) ctq v) o
ga a' OJ o'
S q'P 5 g) >.t
o
E
s ti H Fs *E v) o oq
g o
o
g o € tD H) F+
o fD F8 r)
(h Vt (t) pJ
; (D v) o) o o
3t*E"glE n o 5 |.rO. p
o OJ v, 9r n ut o-
gE'f ;B7 ^Bs ag >l
p .o*
o "o 0J (u
o tr T 6,S F

o o () g Or.
q o (D do r)
'oX n o -. ot
+€
g H; EE= OJ o 6" X(t o IT]
g) YO vt
E f f & D.e t r-+ Fl
ara F 5 o H € u, o
o r! o' 'oUt v, no
out r) o tD
€ = o 0) !-r. t) n s)
F; I $E o (n o
o o 6= g r)
pr o-
*q i ,H
f+9tr=c -l
9) o
q)
F 3r o' 9)
oa €' r: Vt p)rQ
(+ o
E (n o o vv, T F
F
gq
V) H. 9) Q
o t1 H u) o
oa
(?
f; s ll j Hh 9r
F { o Jo € u,
ra :s o E T5 o
rD o .t,y g) o r)
fi?fiTgi€g n '6 o o
FEte I H3 g) g) ,tr F -(,r
I'O
o I 9) g) Ut
r) o 5 d o 5
r-t o $ o n
o 3FE 1= s ct) s) o6 5 o
Ai'
o u) € ER
Y9) v1 T
liS = 3 q 2 =
:-== - -i .
== i - = =. a . a =
! a :f
= .<' 6
;E 7 E Z+

C) c}
et o
(D st 0)
6 (D fD
o d - r) cl
GE o 11
3,SFgF hl o
9J
lr)
!.F s.o U2
=HSe.5
F - - + ^
lB 3 = a.+
gf') sl v)
Oa!rEg5 5.) \t
l7t P T
o a
v5 S+ F8*98
o :+I FT<
+
o I* o
!)
g;.3f F
i' ='O
G P H
8s
gR pi.
CJ
F) r:

F F
0l r+
IE
s) 91
F'

|.l

(h
fg $gEa$n$ T
6'9 $
oI

H - , Fa
v . . )
*ggsn 0)
V?T(^rtEtE *g+rex$ 3
g)
3+H&fiE
gn
HB3E H *
H 9 P _ -
nsFg$$'es 5
9 H
! r P

OJ
crdt!
*c @
9Fh
H c/r ii FE$F€$nT€
9.9. X Fl HF =6 *
Eg fi B
eoJ
FEE=Bt B
i tr
5

16l Hcw l*ngiragefarnili*sw*rk


368 h{ow LanguageWorks

I ^. Fa l-t ti.
9) o f.) FFI r) 9) f-' -O pr
sJ I ISntv' o o stD
e5'3 F 9l E s8 \< g
3 E 3=. g s. zo 5
o o Fl
u, 9r
ss F
o r/rE E.r -o r) 5 Fl S gq
o 7v,
FIEFf (t d FHSE o o v, o {83 o 6F
v, tr
'6po
Ehl o (D a 'ts Fo 8 E St rD F €e o 0)
o 0l JD I v) v, E 6E'
o (n A-sF-8.td F [$ e crq x oq
5 o r] r) c) VrO o
FJ q u, E.€ H 3 E v)
rD
tr8 5 Hts VrO rDd6 EF
{ o o o 6 o tr v,
u, ag
o o 7r F o g
8tr 3 oo
3€6' v) $ o OJ
Fl F o FfSfD
o 4
a g&H
5q5o s go v, ''l gq o oo 8E g
= Fil Fl cr gr
trt 3 o oF
Fi33 s o o Ut g{'E Ea s) o
o F f v, E o U\o (D ;g J'+
ra E F
vt
o
FI: Bq gE. ga tFf8
..+FtHH
to
tr t oa
v, s o d 5,q 5
iP tD o. \5 !'< O
tr
v) o tr 0r o F oci fI o
{8F C o Ut o o F
$)
&F G A B
F FI. o O1 gq P { o s i B (D f.) g)
HE.P o E F (.'1' o o E
q € a' P5
3 v, 0r cr r) 5 9l L. oq 9) H-B
o fo v) $i i') (tt v, d 5
Fg; F (a EE I v, tr o u) o
€ 9J 9 tr ()' u, FI Oo Fr gT
n g 5 Vt (DK T (,) {f Ds0 J 9) sr
3v'i o tD av, go n' H. .) iJ
o o € g o Hdi 5
z< F gB n
s€i r tD (D o o lhtr o 9) n
riH E Fln 6" t-l Fl 5o o'f)o $H 5
v, - t-l r-t o I
= =o hl 5 xI'+ V, tJ o
€ FJ OJ 9;*s FI r) n $if n tt,
F H o 6H tn 3 o o o v,
g) o tr og
F
ge o o o (D
t-l
€ oq 9. r^ 4
fD o
)-f) o on
HF€ ? 's
/.' ).{ XH o $
; ss=ntF p o t H
s gqs) o s Eg 5 IFir gq o o
i 0) 9l
HOJ
pg ;xB (A qF, 0) {F)
oIX tr 9) a5 n o g) o b"
€ o o /O gdq F f) vrx
U' o o Y Ft
th OJ o 9) o' =t) o
SF ts
Fl o € F htf)
o o 0) 0l w
;se rv'd
r)
5 6
o 6P F
gq
clH
Fa$F F)
\s o o
ht
O.
Ut
c,H
6 - 2r D H E 9J
d
v { K ts
HP fo
J
9) F)
t-l tr Fd o' F H E.E: EJ 5
v, (D
o ':J 50 EF 9' o +cL f
o o
= i-Otls) F q 6v'
s-8: o +E s) c) F 9{ 3 v, @ s
(,) oF| oa 8 f; s s w Oqi .E.'-
{ o o (.)(D E g.< o E 5 f
o (D t
2 F F o o F ou'
Os)
u, u,
gg*g t/) F u,
o o 6q
i5 g.
5 e^5
r) '
B 6'? v, v) 5 p o. HO o
F Hvt sEHE v) E-- ir. tJ s) niF
o g s? vt+ V) o
I o v) o
F ;=o 0)O o o v, o o 5
€ o n 53. o Egfi Vt r-l
o :-b
0J
FE
H
il' 3 H
F9E v) g 3 F 9JF
o
Fl 3
olH o g* o EH F (D o = oq
di 3 o
o P 5'F3 so
0) o Ho 5Fr oa
g"Iq o o n i'+ O 1r {D F)
(D -i o 9"5+r o tu't
u) =. E
H -
r) !-r. oid |.1
3d qq 3 F st 68
J J 5 @ o o O !'+ l-l o
ga gq 4 tt) (D w 0) () H)(D
a+oo o 6.n o F v, F.
o (D o
g' 5F) o JD ut oq(D o S) hl
o) tr FJ oF g sa tsF a fD!. OJ L.
(n ts.f)
F. tO vt n ro 'otr o r/lts H o
o o n
5-o hl
+o, i
AI E
-l: n :' "o hiH -a - =8
4{
E= =E
g 9€ /,t a
2 ts=
= 3
:r,
=*
-

ut b
'e o o
o Gl
*I 5 d
+ FI n
gt 6qg 35. .(,: 9) !, 9) gv'g€
j hl s () ,s v, (D s(D
Fl LA o o v, g
5 >.i o F ,{ o Ut 9l vt o
; ra rs H o xo s FI v, F
e1 s- *E= (A El 0r o pl r: o
g o Fh o :fj
Vt .i Ut
'o IFl 3 d
H.p Fl 5 X fD ;(D o (D i
l! !1 g)
,f 5 o rd o >t v'' K ( w
v, o s.E
o C r-|.
x€ ga (.) o f) v, (a r) F $ o
V) o
€t a
e [E.
o C' 0) (D 9) ta JD o fi fD +i-jPal
ost 0) EH fD oq F n
F m =oa tr s v, F) o F X
t+t! 15 (D vt 9J g)o s) cra E g o
o ; p) o rD F € (D r: u, 0)
9J oa 9l (! n v, @ o) N (D f A'As* - F '
tp EH. o 0) oq s rDp
(r', K o u, o .('l I aFVrOt
n)9. t o { g o E
OJ (,) \J 0) p) vrs sl 9l gq P
EH. G' F) (ft 9) o o
Fl o gqsl v, {
g c o g
oa o o o r[]fr
vt a. 9) o
3 o JD F r 6 i n
qE g gq r) c) Vt
5 o
vt Ut Fl v, o
9) E) Ut o 96' 5 o €
oa L Fl u, gq c)
.l o o s) o I .!r oq o v) d {
= n gq c) Fl ro E) 5 o 0) tr f) o to
gd € o oq ? FJ 0) o ts
g)
a o FJ o v, V) 0) v, gq (D o FO p
0J
o) at
o
E
gt
69,
qJ o
sl vr .C'
9)
F|
o (D
if
!5
.'+ o o 9r o
gq
F o
w
g'
"-EfrB. F
r) vt n (D n r) n (.) o p o o v, Hg F"'
f) F6 o 9) p) 9) 0r Eq s) o o) vr56
o s) od JD 9) 5 tD o oqtD p
v, F gq w (! 9) F 5
o v, s) n O 9) o n X Fl tJ
o)
o
g u, gq o tr
v, o o
o
F r ) o3
= oF B
n Vt 0) d € o Ft
{(ll o (D P

In 9 .' g 9J o r, Fl r) Efr Fl € F) .-. OQ Fr


|.) (: tH 5F) 0) o s) sE s v) { o
vt
trj
t s) tD V) €g u, tDx I € o s) gqo
€ 3 o o U) o s vt o s o F € H ?, g
-u, o (D o ? to @ Ft o
t 9) o s 9) q Ft|i'tsgJ
o
E1 9.0F 5 g o
OJ 9) n o F
ttl H) o -(,') F o
9) F Vt (D ftE o p) p
u, 5 s cv) d r) "d o FO S o
-r-burX LR
trS la o nJ o o o ts p o
5 qa K H:
{ Ut 9) g v,
gJ F qq o ta vt H. o o o s
9 o n o Ft E Fl o s)
F tll - s8t a
Ft E) g o fo v, o 9F*s€
7< v, S) 36
Ut o tp gl -!f
o -st o gq $6)H
7< = . o 3 5 -(r! o o v,
F FI d o o
6 p) o F gq h g) o g) 2 t E7,'
(D € s O. !h FN o 9l
o 3 -ul p Fl o F
ES oFl
t) r) of) 5 o g u, o
Hl oa X € oq E E.d 8
4 .9 qq o o. fD 14
€ s' g o rD oq Fl F) v, o ov)
d La s p) o F)
o g) tS v, o) o to
o 3 4 F ga a1 o gq
5 ES€q
-Ft
cr F Fl (^) Fl F
5 o '+0Q
*5 Fq)
o p) 9) o o) a o t f
5Fl fD i \t H:
it(D o
9) 9) 9l
5 s)
gq 4 o 9] o
-=' E o
(D o) @ o oq (D (D oa Fl
F I f.) F o d l-t o
m o
€ s6 ro 5 9E t/, o JD w
,f o p) o
Fl o o 9J F' 9) o (a
gEEg
Ig) 5 E5 1 gq tsl oq Y o E) (o 9l r) 0)
? gl o tr o o F v, p F)
@
nt qt €9J 5 v, o oq 5 (o sr E g o o
tt
o F o9 F tn
s) v(a (} d JD 5 E.F€ g
v) 5 g :s o F $[
369 How languagefamilieswork
37o ["]*w Lar"lguag*Wcrks

r) a o0J (n !.l 'o


F s5? vt
o 55 o u, v, Yb 50) Ig' O) ctl
o o.H. g Ior r)
!art
st/r g) rD FJ Fi\ roI 6H F o V) I t'+
ts F) U) o E'w ai Fi5
FJ > ) a \ H T5 n5 oa v,
5
ga
o tI oq=ar t!o
F.C
nr
U, H.
9J
(n
cx
o
oa r ) L i
o tr 0)
OJ
o
|.1 oo
ta (! oa -ui I ci u, F V) tr ryoa r)
Q., v, P5 R5 o o; gl= cra 3 =. :F
$) U2 o o 9J
S) s) r) .) v, H. Ft
n F.fD ^t v = ov ,
v, H 5'3 (t) 0r .Ho U2
i+n s o r) 5 .('J S) dP'
oq s Aoa o) o5 H oo v,
qsr ?? v, s)' o
SJ 59r o
t s i-. Vt ? o h|rD J ;-l
pJ €F)Ff 5S IJ o5 3 S) (J
F) .t/, o ? .oFd o o)
ga I
f') n o6 i
qdE o Ovt
o s. =i+ o E 5o f.) tr Fo. o :s
vt o .:P F.l rc o o -2. ,.O v' 6-
I
o
o OSQ O Et s r) a) F
il ,-r tr @
o vtH v) og 5- 9. g o o 5o o fb5
s r: o = 5
rDo *FJ 5
s)o & ii E. c3 83. gJ o FT *6- 6E
cta v) r) .DHn Ft 0) H' 5
ga v, HI ,f o g) o
o o) .(/J r) 5 o o lt r) 3 ,8
o :5 = 0J nt o
HxP
:< F{fD .vl Vt S)
I F :5 F g
o p S) oo o 5
oo
{ s v, o oF) $vt
o a V) r u, €E n gH.
I irJ $t
H(D
H e 6 ' 35 OA i+ s u, nu, f) Fl-
o :< o
N r) ut 0J o 9rg E
I
* s Es" s
%
.EHf o5 E5' € 'ov) (,) * <
s) $ : P o
5o $ o a)
F+C
i-l
o v) r+r p. w Fl'j 0J
;. 5e) v, +!t t,t o 5o
H Grt v) o sr o a
o o Ho5 €E o 5o hl o oa oiJ
f D F f . ! - o
F i+ FF rt o5 v, p i+O o 0. o
FI- J 9J- V, Ff
:'r B
SJ
'u) 5 (,
6
r-t
\ s. o 5 or IT: T O o E UJ 9ro ii Ft n S)
O o rD5P (a5 -if Eg, o 5 o K o
0. ta n =rD gJ 0J tr o 9J Pf.) u, qa *9J
HE (D dFF- 5 qr5 o) Fl 5()
L [€ ga F rD tr
ct g, pJ fDi'
X H Eq
H. H. t)
|J 0) o Ho oq 9r oa' o
1s o ,[€ Vt o IO () oa
(a s v)5 0)K tr E'o
H.
tr v, FJ \J
ut
Ff,
5 gFf 0r n o o
u)
Fl Er. o V' EG oq o 8pJ
fD o (1 o 9,d
u, o +..F =J. F. it o I gE
as S) SJ HT v) o 9)
ts.O i'rD F t(as + dg ct ht T 5 ta
o
Fn u, v, 9)o o o F9 o 5 o Fl
p
ct
YFJ o ct o
^' H9$E5 F F w .*F rD trE o o m
? 3 5 to hl o v, oqo rD F
0) FF a5 \5 o
(t FS cr't '<fD !f oq Chl o F,O s8
i+% o o o $r) B v)
pJ E.C o { gq A. fs o oa5
F n vt S) FI 5 0) o)o
H FF ooo U) oq
t ir lt) JD 8' r-t H o d 8 S{1
E€
Y^ F+
\i 6€X
hr(t no Ar Oa fr o
€ H !
A= oa o6 € -o n
a- =t a =1y.. ; oa 0Jrr'l
a 1;= = -:: : = .=
*= ; = = 2 ;-= =. = =
T;= : - tj
= i = : -:= .3,
t - a
I

[ "i*

4 G
3r !
rD ct rD :*6 CT 6
G -(tl 7 o x(D 3t (D lrc'
o (D |D (? h|
t(t
+ :- =1 3 6 ts 5 FO tD s
rs
s3 rD w t') 5 F)
J (t) \J 5 o tp-, o p, 3€
qq p
ct' 9' 9) gq v7
V) Fb
a I
o)= p cna 5 16 v,
g (t) FI € P6 to
rn r.) o rD o oq c) oq o $)s
o h! Fi v,
(A oo Vt fr q9F Fl i'
v, t<E
(t't oq 0l
s) FJ
a') o o gq o {e o o9'
59)
() € G 6t p
o fD n o O)
o ovt g 3 " Hcrq pg)
o o ?5 s o)3 q
9gq 9) Fl o a. 9J o
rD (o pc s) F|

o 'l-5 vt o fD
H s ) og tD
U) o S) (t) 5 d a
I oq (! ;r Ft w
o 0" 5 o o cl 0r(D
o hl
EgR o rDO FO ETJ o n
rD rD rfi -*Y*
o fD s) g) di tn 5 7t o ga U'
o *l (D
w o
o { (o(D v, o FF
0r o) o **$**
rJ't '-; Fl o s f.l o 50 to 0J
t E XU o o
€ rD o o 0J o o ao o Vt
f) r) o@ o 5P) oa € o g)
tr\
o o o5 v) =o
o o 9l Ut n o vt FT w
q ov o €g o 5 9)
-l- f)
(t) o nvt cr ut g t(r) ad orX s
o =Fd o t4 (D v7 =. o
F o 5 0)Ar
o o { l- 0J gq ffi.
o Vt FfO o s) 0J
Fl
n 57r (h I
v)E v) j7' 0)
9J
{o v, r+fD o (D
o g (D o r) f) o X o
(1
o g) +) 5sr g OF 5
r) (t, o- oo rA --.
I tD F 13
o JD o 9r C- o ga o { 0)
ffi
5Ft o ^l o hl
o ryh
Vt (t) F d rD R5 r'+
I fD o (,) xrD
s) o) o t( o v,
o - (D 5 o(tx o o Y o
v- C' rDFt o H Frr fD o
r_b
ffi
I
n o X gq
tr d pJ HE o
€ 0ro o o F+) o i rt sJ'
(D o) =91 5 0) o. 6o V)
ffi
;' 9J 5 v, g o' 0r rt ?i o 3
T v) j 55
flw
n o 0r
€| ! hEt
t
o o o (t)
tu
ci' (D qPr 9) to 8 tr. sFf
ct) N 9,
Fl
o
qq rD p $f 9)
rD o
(D o
fD { o o
g' E"frlF
F o q co o
o I fD ?-f o g v, I
o v, ;+
ffi
o t6 o oo s) *?
o E qa tr o @ @
E g
5 o
rD r) s) (r) ffi u4,.,,,,,r
o Ut FJ vt 0) 7r o TE n Y+' O o
FI
oq
I
E o
16
o F J') t F 6{ P tgl ii
U) o g) qq o 9J ; s) gq h# h***$* A$;q+.1.Ary*:,;r+jl
g o 3 P) 9) xo oa.:1
9J n { 0) Fb. 5 o
n S) 9) oq v,
o S) K a. (D o n 0. 0.
o I 5 ru tr\
%-J
fl*\
fu"#* $
371 H o w t h e l n d * - [ L l r * p e i ] 8f a r n i l vi 5 c r s ; r ' ; ; ' "
372 H * w L a n g L r a gW
eorks

-l Hts. .l 0r
€ 6Xr-t d, = o € 9) o5
5 gq F) pr o
v, 5 x5 o gr o o(D 5 0. HPFIH
iFFTHF EE
- 'r, EF =
Ft o
Fl
Sctq no
v, 5 ,-o o
5
)Flhr
I H
cf a. 5 v) rD r)
ilgff
,)rDH.iJ
H /n {)v, svt € O'l 16 l-l Ft
9J OJ-lt o o o gP) o tr
-ot 0s Ji 5(D o o
-. FI 0r o
-Pi f f i A F ga.5 ts oq g 3 cra 2ri 8Er n o' o o.o g orv P += H
o c it 9r t') o
F OJ nt 6' 5 o
ht Ol 9) -l F 5 5 V) =(D ib
-F.r)= qq 0
l-l
r5 o gu' o st F)
o
tt
o,B B s 1*
u, o
{9 +E 0J
6 R ? D FO I o € o, p o r) rD . H rD to
tr ) l : ?r+5H
K=. o.\ 5 o o E+rF
g)I5$F)
g. Frr
T Ft :-
v,
# 9) OE) 5q Ex €q'
Ol ir' ht o v)
s) o Ft o olg
x- o TEqI gq U]
HO tJ5 9) FlOu, o o 5 i-si
AE€F?3 3 F. € n J?€ 5 FF3
6.5 v, 9r oq h.O
n
Flj ID- Vt
; .fT P 9)
pr xv, o 5 ' o. a. sq { +
s)x FrYg. rD w o o CcL
t-l H. o
o 6- Fil* sl
J;:.d 9 5 'E u, -aE tr o o 5vt € o E * TE
'P P Ho g) a" 5o+ H
K
ar9J(/l-P. I 50 < F
g o rd F) iq € A
SE crq fD o {)E E) o 3 nt 5
vt o 5 o F o
=. sr oq
o 6'
g E
to F3 . H. 5 (D 0) 0 I g
if: r E
trgq
-X.,RFfv) d c V' o n 9- € rr' 9J
x
Ft F s 9l 9J
= = = ; o r ri:F
Fl' o o $dr o r) JD a E) F cta f F Z'iD
- i A s) I t6 H.o n 6
V ftl vrgF F n g o € 13
:laJD,^H' F l - \ J t J
F Ect
F? F
.) (D o rJ t(D fDo o
6t
y
t-) tp) cr-t s) F)ox $)
u, F) X 16 o
;F8s r6+
F F i;hrY E s) o o cLg )rr FO fD
9'=. o o sr' 0r
o s ! .uJ ort F o
FP v Fb ts 0) g,f o
=1[8"3F o I
o $g)H 0) € o 0r
a{ r-t
Fg
gJ E'
s''
Fl.
Ifo) 0) o o O
=.6 ? = 6'v, rt Ut Ft i+99.
o 5 o 5 JD oq o o5
ts
9r V5 Fi
He I h6
p FI F.€ TD
=;E-ui'TP 4 u, o 5 gd +R
o fo (D gq € p H qa
F FrS th Fi
g r5 o v H o o)
| F 4
g
e=3.9 i H gH vE) o o o
o glq
r) Ff! r5
gl
€ HA zzE
I OJ 6gt" 3
3 T SE 3 d f:1 o 9) o o 7<
5 qa FO (o (,) o (n 8
' 0 )f g
E.+*
O
c BniS E.e o 50 E'i'
ii5"5il1.= H.g hl Vt g t r) vt
o wp o.il
$' 5 ga €'*B
o T sw6 o g gq E t, ct'
E ' Eg, ! tJ O) niF o t-l o og
F. g) o !J a
? * T f E 3 {
o. Fl o o v, g o ts rq
9) Vt OHP g v, f5 FFt
= i-E 3qE SJ rt) o 5 { "6 19.
5 v, .J 5 Ja g)
Ft .dO
= 5F o =..D (Do Fl
5 B 6'H o o rD F o !i ga
3 e vtg u)
,;O.-rA.)A (1 Fl) p (D x
6" o 3 gq e'E qa o -l F{ v, =.4 5P-rr
rD 9) F. lj.
o
|'i (t g o
sv, n
p Fll ir ;. - o qH5'
o q = g E q _ag 5 o
J | J ) J F I 9J o o w
;- 0' oJ =o' 5o-o; =)' Ft" - Foq qa E rD J.+
o q+s
--\rJ
:< gH € ; o o oJR o- v, v)
1Cu tu q ' : . P
F
L.,S t, =. =:nE
=T = ; ? a- Js
= €= 3 ; =' = ,:- =
-- -- == F
= =.? a
= 7 =T
=
--: E
=-: € 6! f;5-

'!r @
g3
'a qt €:
.r, rr EFl
= tr Fi! Ft (D t+ A
=m ;' r-l =cl Vt Ft
s p vt Vt
o o H6
g dFl
JD $t 5 5 tr €
Ff,
FII 0. 5 o r.d FB
d s9 (? t.) =fD
7 B 8 o o O -F.
€ 9J (Dga t) (D oI oJ' Fi5
€ p sJ' r-t F F5 o
rD o 5
€s Ft ?5 tu d E FfJ €(A
€ "6 g
cr) (r) g v) o = o
-C' oo F o ts.rD
v) ga a) f-l v, fr
v1 -l rD o o hl
v, 5rr
orIf f o Fl.fD 89, o $) € + l.rl
-G
9J .c/J o 9)
9.
5 T --.
(D 9) i'p f6
o 5 F
-1 'a 3 g) o 8P 5 oq 5 o 5 Ft oq 5 oi'
ct vto r-l ct' o tpm ct I
o E' ct ld v, gq o sl tr p) g tr $
u, o :
so o !-) o o 0)
g{ I E il sl 0t
o= fDH. 5 H: oq o E q
o tr L 0 ) Ffl Y F o=
{o g c)5 ga o o
E' ]J oa F Q 6" E' o tsl o. -FJ -l -(/J
O.C
o id. n
g o o = o g
th
t') 5 o
rd I'C gJ X oI 5 n g
0J -l 5- , . o t/t gq 0l Frl
:€ G' o ti Y. o oa5 rh og ,f o
lt) pr g)o fD Ut DJ v) o 0) i+F
s) E.d 5p 9) C v, v, tsl {
:/ o $hl
-;E F 5 o gJ
,-l EF o o o fD crq
9 o r) o6 ,ad 9)
-t (Jl oq fiFJ (-j X F
t.)Ft o F \bg
€ tr Ot o 9) rDT p f 3a o qq
4€ o g) oq 6r D1v , p F F) s 5 o
t) o. v, o pr I (t) 0)
T o oa ts q OJ OJ n 9o
n o Ho v) gq s+ oq
o F o hl
o 6H) v, p o
0)
9J
5
aE
s)i
d5
o
5
V1 7o.
s)
o
tr
0l
gq
.l
o
sI
15-{
K
P {
0) 9)
2.o
?-. q) 5 o Vt 0) o p) E *l vt vt
o o FlC do E oao o o o+ F) v, (t 6 q9.
- 5 9J Fl v,
o P o 9' 9J o \5 o Ho
o) 0r 6= o o 'i9 o
aa ; 6' i. cto 16 V) o o o o ei,
F #E + n t ,\i F
o 3 oo. fD a "g
p) o +o o p o prIf
v, o o (D 50, oa € 0J 5 pJ
- o:P E6' sJ 3 p TrD
F ;t o o oo- Fh v)
so
o FI 5 o O Frl o €r' o hl o nJ
0r 9)hl vt Fl I'6' f) AI
ltt
o F o 0J o o $ 5o
(t F PFF 0, o F{ o5 g)
F g)?
o (f,) oq if s3 F oJ 5 o
!-b (-l $.8 u, o 0
{ @ 9rD ts "+ 5 p
I
o it o oa o p9 s o
d{ H o 9)
Fl t)H
f) tO
rD tFt #( DE- 6 '- 5 F 0) oo FJ g) o
s) o) o ? E (D g o O.r
Fl n 0r Ala 55 F r) o F
rD rD oo JD 9) \n Fj !^'t Fh
o) K e 0"8 9J 0) ov) l-
s. d6 5
ttr 0) - 06 , v) s, g o
qq g) o -o 9) o gs Vt v,
o 5 6JD o dG n F X s) 5
qq \J 7f e 8
rJ oq ro o )r) g5
pJ t 9) rDd o0r -l o 0J g v, o a" 5
5 5D 7f vt OY H B € r)o)
gq 9) o -- O. t o Ut fDH) 9J o
vt gq :s g 9 o gq o 9r rD 'U
o o F 0) *l 7i. I td #E ; r) o) o o
ct :+ Et o 30 o (.)
9) o r+ V, F w
o o oo qd v,
F) v, o t-+
lt) t+! 5 fD :< 5 oo o Bts 5 6?

l-{*wthe Indo-fur*p*an farnily is *rganized


Haw LanguageWorks

\JgS. 0)FU v, o o 9J t-
T E € + H o ogt p :.b F|
=.t-t.t
o rj 50 o
Fl a) g) 9)
Ft
6iE gB 3 ts o
w s o tr
.o5 ct a -5
lrl H. t $ 5 tr tr
r#
=o5
F: 0)
H 8 bj dii
&pg, o
o oo" 9) o -l da
YO. g p) -l
iFf;+sEg q
=?oq F Fi - ?. E w. J5 s F
Fh )) ' F v, o o F o
Vt o0)= r+5 =. (-) Fl g)
> ) F F 5 a 5s) F
A1 H FH F
? - n F qE'
F' o G o 0)
Ffl
E Se + o ,{) v, F,
Fl 6 a 9) gq o14
9lo
qSAHXcor ra
(- lr,, Fl
nt!f,
Ffg
s= o
9) o r-l
o g) f' o
o
{ 5
H. 3 H F) V)
-ry=9) 9)
9EF 0 )o
oog)
F o E o(h c F EO
IgIIgIF
$
3': EB31s, n'
Ft Ft
g. 6' F 9) o n A F v, 9) Fb=rFO
E 3)5 F 8'ts 5 SEE y rfD
oi' ctr l))ht F) gq
ixo $ p) ts.
o 5 g o "6 €
FI
:$u) F t t r 'O o AP o o r)
$FH t5 Fr' O o 9s) o. V) $ !)
tsl U) 9J t {g
:t, :$ q
o rrE 6' !-{ Ut F E 9J (n 7o o oJ
Fl p
llt
7 EF otJ H
6ii
rt- y Q , o
x
rs9, cv,
V)
FE
:+ tt,
o o
o
Fd
?
ct') n
,do 9J v,
F
gq
ipEf;iei
U' II7 F g 0) g) (D o t
H v-' d. = o B3F E o p Fl o F 9J
59r?D FH: g) dq ? X qa
F;3 g u) =. 55t2 F J? I
vt 5 v, (D
vt gt1 0) so tp (a
th
sJ ;3 B
0r 0)
BH g
F
g
E.(D
5hl
o (t)
@
I
Fr
o5
0) o o
t!
p
Efi[ g[En
id o 0) F) 0r
Fl
olg
rH & v, o IOq F)
i/ r-t 9) @
O. E.
*S ti+gO o 7 HgrE Eg
--' i5 oa (h o o g.E F
dg 6' D Ffg U) 9) F
cfr d H
ol. o t-l o o n gq
q) 9) n F $l
5 CrA E
utfD p) 9) g€3$sHH
g' e. 6' 0) Fl qq
'a=X 8 5 JD (! FI rP
0)
*r bfoi ETF. o v)
E F F Cts. o J) FbO
I o o
tD tra F 9) P S)
o 9) HH 5 cra
o.g 0r !.!= f) n a o oFb (D ts 5
\o x a:. x 5 l,:
Fr/,
P -8F tr Fl v| {
t E S SJ
I? -EFF
E 5
-l {D
ao.
rt

$
gJ
t.)
;&B
:or5 sg :E ' t E lt
rv' o €(
B
tr
p
o
o
v,
p
F
FU
Fl
6'
0) g,
o v,
o
s;aH*m
o r-.. vt Oq 5
g Fh
tr t r o Fta
dA {e xoo 5 5r-r t! U, o F 7i
F =9rnh Itr ts g p
91
9,t
t-fD It-t IH p tr
m
g o 90
hl 6'tr ra
o
rEi * 5s
= 5'r B F"o
E#6: o OJ oq o 5"o 0) n {
gFr1 Fp) '-l
3=EJ +P S) o
EF E!t tr AJ
E o
t-l 5
?1 9) F o -vl g 5
-. i-: v, E-v) F) Fl
5? vt
FE. + EI o n g 0J o s) or
o9) 6' 7t srX N F FI c v,
ta
+g 6 V, Ff 5 Fl
FIv) OrA Fv, R: o o
I
FFHv (Dt g 5 F
Og)
5 ;H3 gq vt ;E
or 7r n *F
n 3
0)
r)
o
f.)
0) o
{ d, o ;
fD
3ig?EI
;-+qAr) V'O ct't o o fD F r
F5f i s€
= o xoa 7
Eg + t) X
rv fD g) Ut
(h o
bg
A ! = !qJ ') o
ctt (h X
- =. C
t i =o ! a r

a =fc 9u2 = = = =. v
3= i .; ; EE i s j:
=='a:rc:.-t.
?= a8t
= F-6 3 =; s
;;r

r^l
fD
E
-l t- p gt n
I :' c+ I r
tD
(t B E)-l o
6. It
0 (D !t C F sa
iD g) n'
t.) Irt vt tt El. tD o o, tD ctt
o !1 gt v, C' Fl
o r) 5 g
5 t v,
>s o F F6 d oa-- 9) 9 8
o o 9l u, 3 o+ E 3 g F o
o d €
I
s) g p p $) E' {
t{ n to 6 I @ ,. D Or+ o tr5 o
g) 0o K E 0) l,Fr Fl
0q
so
n 5 F LL E p ol.l pJ Fl o DO f.l
Ch !D ro Ut
o o v, ts F *o o
o FI
o s p
rEqr v) 0l o HV' r{5
O. (D >l o o
hl
(D a6rg o o (-j crO
oq o F { 1V) g
v, Fl cl d C' (D
R o glgrvFt o in o P6
Ft Fl T n r+ Yo o H ont
FI
qE 0a o
o. o gr F N o F)
:a o
FO
Eil
KO o f.0 o o $ !'+- 9) !b
Fl o (t O. rJ.
v9
H u, Fl n |t
;o 5
9) (1 5 sf. 7 o Eu' FI
Ut
U) o u, o 0) F *(o)
Fl
T. 3 o
v) s s 0) w6 9) n 0) T' o tn 3
o
g rDOvrO. o
oa
v,
0l
o p F) v)
o
Er.
vro
F|
ig Er r..t) i.+ rD
.) s
p
5
o (.) F. g)
r.rl |D
p
F{ tr 9 { tD
o {3 3 o
Fb
tru'
5
n 5 $) o ttr o 9r !) 5 EF E o (^J
f)r g
o o o g,,u, FArl o p a)
o 3fD H Vrry oI
n 0, 0. a\ Ft H l*, n o K o OJ
ts5 rD ,sf v, o
$ o J? V H . - H rfl
5 r) t) E Fl ;*. 0) K ill Frl 9.
g n lD I (D vt !') v, o F r') 5 €' E. o 3 H c
n o 0) o) Fl
r) Ftj 9J o 5s) v, F EE rtr ts ItI
5 d s o 9J oqF 5 ro
U) o hl o $ t6
o
o JD -l TN v, F (D d K o 6g c o p
0) o tr tr o C' FI
g=3EE (o 7t r-t fD
N E9) p o 6€ o
t s o o Fo g) Fl r) O E 9J
vt o
oa .) n s HN
g Ffi tsl o Fo =F glg \J o Ero
5 f) o F hl 0, o E
u o o 0) a' I Ho Es) JD
9l
o F .) tsl F o o ! !
b o 5 o 5 o o Fl -l cJ5 FI
s)5
0a o € p (D o
c
gE ft*E o o o Fi
o (D )-l oa o S) v, o Ov, r-t o 5ro o
:SE g Fl 0) 0l to
-o o v, sl .o IE rl 5 o o f) o FG
w o 7 ng+d t-t Ft.
g o F' F. o o
,o o r) Fs o o o' n OJ
-, F R li' o
v) t fd o o tr fD 7l o OA
tr €
f) I
o0) s) 0J {E c9r F (-) fDH!
vt $ p PJ r
E.TF3 ts. F. 9) F f-J p .UJ S) (D
S)
\o
H.t.)Ed r-t o v, v, v, g oq o
5 v, hl 5 ti 0. S) 59 -FR
s. w e| Ut r{ 9) d'' v,
K OJ Fl F 5
p r: { g 1 0 0 1 3 :< o V) { d6 v, w g8 fo
o o (D g
d Ft
co
!'-{
rD s o tr
fs a\ Ft ,)
g) o 5
fo o 5 o 5'+
g6
!-,
Ct r-
FI
o
o F) v, 6" o o o -5 $'
n i r-l 5 F g T p 3 o 5 5= 9l
C', o o Fl g gsE$ 5 5 g) 9) Ft,
5 u, o o v, H.O € 9) y'i s
o o d 5 S)
\J
o E) p f' ;Hon .) 9) qq V)
o g Vt
Ig o FJ g o $)
f) ,_r- H) o !') 5 H S g EB' o H8 n
f.) $)
g fd 5 0) o(D FJ r)(D
o 5 o tu I d*
OJ v, v)
*Erq Frt t') F qa JDo (D o o
v, 9) FI o o 5r5 Ut v,
tsl o
o E I v, o
fir
oag
FlE'F q
Ut n F
Fl
o
p o 5 o ttr o 8S v,
o n rrt i' V) o (5 o Vt 5ur F+: |lI
F o lJ o p l + I ' ( DFf fo &F hl Fl
FJ
I
9) € vt c)
o) g 3 nJo n hrtr I
N € o Fl U) 9J € Fl
o
hl
E rD F 83 o ,aO F a zt cJ PH
v, o g) 0) EF K g) - . n t o
Fb o o F 0J 5 r+ 68. u, HO
gl
r) I
g FI r-t
w f) ot ''H
EfXH
iq Fts s r)
ra o
td
5
o
g 5!'
vrfD
5
s Ep o
g)
o
v, FH "o
rD

375 How the Indc-[r-rrop*an


family is arganized
376 H o w L a n g u a g eW n r k s

-lC
a5
#asuugEEg qIJ.: sF+
bp
iEgA Et*isrFEFicrE 3 61
Ft

tNs H
Hz<
F{O
=.
Ev,
gE'
.oR
igaEEcEEiIg$[iFE
-EFFEIgFF[EE og
O;J
E?D6 'Fr
v) "O
"do
a1
x- 8.
PJ vt
no
tlE OH)
!-i
5'C
=
f')

gJd

5E
oq s)
9)91
@
(D5 o'
1ia[rEgEEa$riggE o
Fl
$)

ct
eE#iEEEHgiEEiE =
9)
r)
iieiEiEiEEIgeEEEi
D Ur i' $t^'tD
7
tt
= c) o 8 P8E€ts
Fl o v, o- (D € { ;iirntn--
eJ.
rD r- F €E (t Vt
0) EgF o l.i or- n
5 -ui Vt gidFsg:
oJ 1,, g v, Fl o
zo g
t
Fl -q, 5 Fl !-t. F gt 5 E.H3S 5
,'' o o S) S) q o s, o p o
o o T 5 5qB 5
(1 fr o +5
0) I Hg o
v, o o) p 5 -i *oq
60a q € rrjo v, o 9)
fD
o (D rD F o A od 6
o FI v, + q t o. o 5 r€FiEr
0. s o b' g, o)s) o oa 96F H
*fD $) o n n qJ' o g {HF E EE.
- F f) gq 5.8 o F o 0) n-!-tl-7<
Cqt -v! 9) @ = 8.P. F;
o 0) 0) }lu, t9
a. qa g
,. o o (.el 5 o o o
r-l o 5 ' ;F
I
[| .i{6O ') {e =
+ o q -d'
r;. 9 T
o o 0. 9) g rrl r) q
o o t6 EE F{ 0) o g 6 F =
r) I
0J d6 o g H:
=-t 5
o cd
gfi si F 5 Ai 5 n
:5 o o FI ';-,r.
u) o 0)9l
5 9J 5
:Fr g) s) !-+ o
9) a. o t) o o
=6' |- o n 5 F
gq
AJD o ! -(/, xEq i FSxFo .f4 . E H s
.ul v, gEE 18n .l 5 FJ o
O) tr -('J 9) o
$
p
zrD R"n+&5d
l€ 9J S) s F.(! o F o F
vt (D F qa o 9)5 K r-l
ii gFF
fi'+ 5 *1 v, i$F o -l n E € p,--RI o
H ) PB 3 .
o. 0) o 5o o o o -j P q 5 E
?a r) ? (D Hf:a tr5FfglFr
o PJ 9J
rD o o Vt
q) { rD o -l H) E
FE. 1= ts \J
q=
o o 5 o o r-l o6*fs'F
F)
=.:-' fd o
9J
s A', fuor
o o 0) ct 9) v,
o S# t +..58Str;B
A)=. 0) x i
o o F cr FF
o o 5 (D
o
3 3B's5
X o *a v,
OJ o o g. o. o, o o
Fl
.H
it il- .gt a' U) o r+
x Poq o
N
a-5 ts 9l
o FJ E
g
F9
ts g o {
o Ut o
f.)
-l
: sE6 e;
F0a o FI 9J 5 *A o 7l
o u, U) o)!
o (D
N 0) o JD
)0a
o
g w o s) J.. =e
0J Fl' E'o s
o oq (^J
Erq T f,b.fiFF. a 2. a':
€ 9J F 5 K
TF;AH
tt lfD T rr 5 E o o o o 'd o tr. O)
(a 5 oa S) gq t-( Fh te F.
g t
Ir Alb) o F o"
o Fi o
A{ o FI o 9r vt g. tr hl
=oq'o'x
P( I qq i' F€ 9) o
ggar rf ai |l Fl.
TD p 6F o -(/,
o o" $8 k 5 I
5 6
v) w -l o
o €c it 8"o
I v, P I'Ft 0.
:- 8 6 F{ qa =' o
l-l -u, tr g)
sF;F' /l\J"4crF
o 9r o P, FJ n hl
E) S) ,f i'o.6on
fD
s o (D o
rt) 5 g1 0J F
7f
o (D
; + E€
u' ili
H' o. F B HP oil
L oq o :< { x p:s F'E'v'=K
ooq 0 9) o Yru) +o. o
0J u o €
.\ U) a F oq S) $o O) vt *'B s P gd
9J oq
69, c
FO o ' F i r + , 5= F
o = 5
E sF
E I F p (t) rd FT{ \J 0) o H)
E oq tt ii oa (tt
rDX g S) Vt o4 g) Ei -(,: SJ +6'8 e f
{ -v, ga n t_l
ry)
Fl
U,H ipJ o
Fl H"q E P.fr
ae o o ;€ o Ut 3 F
9) o U) S) 6'a oq g o
a A)H. 5 o o
H 5 o V) o o
fD V) I
I
5 Eg EE 0. !v
$+ifi HiH:E
F 3 g.? rdEBs)
H o w t h e I n d o - f u r * p e a nf a m i l y i s c r g a n i z e d
378 H*w Langr"lag*Works

aIEagiglgiIEiegag

EElalaalEqlgilEgl
s$fl
SAen
3; o v
g e5e,
p+Hs
l{ f e
Ec
gE
ie
IE
rDF+E.
H.a r;
q'JE
I
HgE.F
*ilBF
t iE;
*€5r
TfiBf
ut=-1

a H[€
379 H o w t h e i n d o - f u r c p e a nf a m i l y i s o r g a n i z e d
38o Works
Flow Langr.r*ge
***&E \E *Y-
$ ffi ---**

Oh(N
7 {c,fif;HH' sF+EEE€+# *H rc fln
\#
%*.#**
=
q ru **qf *d@""s
i+ttSEFae;rEFisBP
a; AxF*E€'E +q+H -
iE" ffiJ # {p;}
=g;3
e *B re ffi:
'v= t ; +E
q ?E F I3 + F E F:E.3 B E I $ gq M { F

rPr' ='6.6.9;+3P. EF fl*4* fr


\*"d

3ElE$Eg4 tE.a€+srY €d ffi


fl& tr*-
\*"d
qffi
=Es'iesI egEisfliF +fi ffi 5
ftr
h**l eT)
fl& **q
EgggEirfr
iIEFEE-$ EI -i=Etso+',a c^ ry
T 9l'gggFG re
;iEtE$sH HH f;fsF+33 rffi
gi$gi f,\
\""d
= g =
issEjFqfres7: ee *q
ffi
**q{

ff\r
?3c
i+fiiiE* f;[rEici$ Ei ffi kJ#
i=Ei*EE.ii BE ffi-} m.
ss*gF'E
t+€{tHt{
i'3 ;:i€€?gr E ffiS
ffi ffiJ
R A E
;zq[+igp iq*t.+Hgr q ru$ ffi
*li;gfE: H*Ett;E; s ru
: C.
?=iig?v=I ii=75?r=

\TB HgF;
o ro w r Fl

sJ S E -l 3 )-t -98-r g o- g-l


{D qa g tr-l CN o
1< 9) 5 FJ
o
o
hl F g o E8r o o tJt
u, 9r
F pr
E.o d
A.
a ct' 5
tI.gF
{r_l o { OU-l Fl F )-t Oq 0)
o Vt t-'l o o 0) o F E e5'5-
3 Fd vrog o TC 5
N
3 vt d g -l
.9 €fD o. TJ €6 o oq E 5 X7{
0) g 3 (D o F ii oq F
qa 3; 0r o H 6# 5 c' oE' 3 o
$ $' 0)
s)ln 5 5 $)Flc rJ
o fDv, G 9) F)
v, 6,, r) 7i' gr v, o rD o o 5 x oq E gq Ef;$€.
(/t o v !J Y g .j (D
€"eE
C o o q F 63 0r 7.gFH
+= o g o 15' o 9J -l F 9)
v) o hl \<
=o -l
z9) r) o 3 o. 5 r) p
o o t+ (D o" o s o o
l.r tr hl F) F 5 fo*
*o l" ) oa s) a3 ,f
CnC 0l p s)o 5 vt et Ct tr
o N 5 }-. t r N S o cr oq o vt
v, 8g ti' ga o o o sJ r(D s+
5 I g Ix
5 v2 r)
FJ
5
n
o
o
o tr
s)
pr
F
:E
tP-c,
H t, 9)
o o "9Fl
9)
o 5
(Ds)
fD { €o
9l
Fgsa
g q 5N)
rD c L F
oq o o o o o u) irE o.
G
rD (r) (
o o
o o o o r-rT
0) q o
d T u' 6i
n
o,A S) I = o g,
J-l o Yo r) ct5 cv, o \o
3 n s E,
o ci' ; FJ 3Ei ,) tt o 6 F' * I'
(t o o\J g rD v, 0) 5 o F X or vro "9
n Fl
F
ir.
=
) v, 9) U 5 (t n o
5
g o (D v'r
P s 9) ^oQ F o P F x# o o
rd $) 5 o o tr 5 € arq F c tro o HfsS
o oa F b r : S\.,g
H U, 5 9J
trfD 5 v, H o N o -H) (a
o ut I v, -l s) n F F6' w w 0) 58Ba
F( 0r E Isa o pr p) v,
o 9) \J r-t o 9 Ao'ur
o C' F o 5x t o 5!' o \Jtr g)
o o
(D o sl oq g 9J 0" oo $)
B8 9) .EEH o 0) F
F o 5 o 9J
F 5 9J
; Vt o
F 3 3<.€ 5 o s) 9)
o Ft t't n o 9r H. ut q)
f ii a H H.
I fd n ts 9{ o o o x0r Ff i{
rD w v, F) F 5ct oq o o o qa td'FJ
8 6 n o n 9) '-( ut v, a qq
r< a) O. o
o oIl 5 o 9J tr E c' o Ovt
o s o d o 5 o "9 $) 5
FO o 6EE H)
o 5 9J -l
o tr F . v
ho
o
N o 9)
oa
o
8d p € 5
f;5;F
a\
v
vv F|' tl
3 p € F e'lg 6 n { o V) n vtn r-i:H)5
o to o o (eo
P=
F)
o o €rP ( 0) Y o= 0)
o o o rri P H.
(t) .9 9) o
cn F )5 F( r. ^ ) 5 € E H0):J V) o rr { o e.x o **
tYu,
B 3
|.l
qa 5 v) o F o oa o
r) qq o o -t. O FI
n f6 ; n -t -l
$, o +s n o rD o
r-l
sr
i'+ oq dE.
o Y 5 OA :- g
$n Fi' g) o ffii V) I'o
lOt H
oE
I o o o 5 \rl
o 5 b *fi gJ -l
o I'5 0) 0)
7f 5 o N It
+J so Bq 5
3 r) o oo Fl
ntr p) hl
ilF) f 0. € :irD
o o o -Fl --vt/ o 9^ o >l PF{ 0) E€Eg
F rD (t)
o .9 o
0r' 0. r.) nsJ
I o
rD E : S o o o 8EH € 3o r
o dg6E5
o gq v
0) t o r
hl @ p 0) 6PA o oa o iJ. x pr E d --x
Fgns
t') o o o 9J qJ st 5(D C. VH./
o
qe K o o u, r€q 5 Ut
o o v 5 r) I oo.

38r H * w * t h * r I u r a r i a nf a r n i l i e s* r e c r g a * i z e c- p : r t o n e
How Langr-lag*Works

g) oq gq 9) rtI n n -l (-)
-ga FO o \o € o gF hl l-l o Vt o 89gE€F
5 F oo oq o r_t (D s)
oq ;' (D -9 o 3 ct t o
E'6 o 5 - d69 Ftr o (D E o r) v, r)
g)
fo o o Vt g:? sl r5 fD 0) P NTE:
sr5 o o '-l v, l-l
U) o o EE. o o vt o N
q. = o F 9J (D o
_l o qo vr o qtB oq p) o s) hl cu, g)
ra o o B + 0a !^r 9J
o hl v, o
ST -l ('^) o P o-6 d
x14,0 ) F crq OJ o ;
U 0
4)
i E
6
tx D
t, e€ u
o) ,-tt +
0 T t g
9) lv
o
,3o ;+
$ a:*; rE
1 r-l E E q1
o 00 o0
6(n gt o F o d ?z
tvo (D V) tr {
o hl (D o o
Cg) v, b ol o
6:r ,F 9E o
Or
o
{, o g !
o
s , ;.EFAg
9= F e) o 7 (a6r
Fl I
a 9) J.J
g v,
e 9E8o,q p o o g 6' t) 9) ;' 3+sFdf
g) y 5 (r) { 0q +n -(r!
0) o o 9) 5 9l 5(D "6 9) (f -vr
!t F 0l ro ta s) g o !'
qq o 3 =l =* E
E R
€ Ft 1s o5 o g (h
oa p o o s € I'o € 9 o 0q
I 0) pF o Fl EP
Fl
iE X F
9) t 7l $v, F) o X 9)
Ft
.E
$m oa fr
v,
o
ut
5
g o
o o nt 9)
o
o
(-) I'
o
(-)
g) F)
Fl
A)
FJ
@
o
g)
r)
r
:fiFsge
rD ov) fd _u, 5 o 7.l n o ga
JU' |-t F N(D o E0) o TN g E F s
9l o F- o v, r.) Ut 2,E
E
o i-tl g)
zo 5 9)
9) 9) a !J9r 9) 0) Ft iDC. Ft
o o o
^P (D g Ft g ('rr) tn o 9) 6F$HFF
=dt v, 7r b F (1
o
FO
H' 9) gr oq E
ga tr' ctq 9) Fl 0)
Hg. I
p, s) Fl I ttt
o cd oo or v, $r d s) F
o Vt o F € gE o qq o
5 f6 gq 0q
tVt ov, OJJ F tD o ct 3
ttt 7r tD Fl v, a (n 9)
EHs€6q
o Fl
E3 Ft rJ
o
5 s) o tD I
0)
(') is 0) o
5
n € o
iH p ct H t
oo 7 r: I z< {D ga oq oq o ^p oE
9)
{ o o) E sEto 5 o
I o Fl
tD g) g) o o
V) s #t, o 9) I (-)
ofD N 9J I o r) p f) r) s o)
9l vt l.tl p 5 ; F ra
v, 0) 0J s& i-a (D 0) qq o 16
"d Ft o v, rJ
,trF 5 o o (D v, g) o F o
(/l 9' @ 0q= o 5 gv sl F AJ
;.- 9)
_1, o
d
o r)
(! I
sJ d
b
o 7(
p) o Xci
+C
o o
01 .i3 rD
s)
oq
o
sl
o
o
sr
o)
FO
5
sEHi$[
o?1 Ut
a6 o
5
o @
tD
gr
N
o
:<
ct
9J 3 6' sa F K EZ ; ts
(D v) 9J
n
v')
o
TE
00 9)
b5 o cio { oq o P
+rg d P g 3 @ o
(tt
;9 o (t 9l o I v)
-*h
o
ql
o
Vt
fD
5 g 9) o
t"'l 3(+ o
o
5 FT
o
or
x v,
(n
r)
9)
H
s)
0r
v,
g o
p
o
I
r3$ltF
EgEF6+
s; q F!f 5 F) fD
a o v, N o o o Bg;€5 [
rD F r-) i D o o g
o s I c
= tD o o
rD tt ot :' I

F n a) o o t I
t g;^ (n g
!i n
i7_
: q
e =6
B
F
= t
o
I
(?
g*sst
E'tE-q €
ltc
.-{ = 3
18 ;2 fi E g
5 4=i-1

F}
t' Fg
Oo.
it
u, (D
I D 11 v, tthl
hl
s. o 0a 0, g 8F
d (D o- F 0) (D FI
v,
o 3 D u, (D o
4 i' Ft t
r.i K o 3 g o r5 r-l
OJ gl
o w v,
F 5 a-; F aJ' Ff: g) ts o eH'
rt
o o 5 o
a O) t1
pJ cr
5 7 € ch 9l 8* + tr 5 :s o o. ra o n :ps
o d € art
oI
Fil 5 E6 o 0r 5 d o
t+J Fl
t) o
a. g, 5 rJ, 9J Ft- o. o e) o (D HE
o o K 5 (a o o o v
ct, = hl vt tr E U 5;' 'o 3 f.)
E" ut o
Fb
n oF
sr d tD n| 0.o ++ oq \J 9) it ' a
E @ o gl 9) t) 3 o t'.1 T (D
t >t Fl a q rtt s tao
S) n T5 o F) o 15
t, IJ 3 B g 9) r)
o 9) o
hl 5 o o tD 6 o oq o q F trg
0a |-t FI FI a :r 9" u, Fto 0) (.^) oE gq (: g
o tD V) o o n o { )-l 0)
v r o r'l
9. oo ? o !) g8 o ut 101 o O
v, 9) 0) (D rt )+) ttt 3 o 0) f) yF FJ \,rt (D
c
Fl o o F 9J td
Fl
0q 0) (D
d \J F it gt o 5 o oa v s 5()
{ 9) ta HJ .6'o g. o s) hl o 9J FI
o d ttr (D 0q v,
hl o o v, Fl ro o F s) d (A !-+ b
tD n F) tr o o r€
fD h3 ,-t s+ Fl
o E K
FI it g
gs { 5'r F g o o fo FJ
o sl o OJ Fl 0) gq
o rg
o o g
o
r.l $ g) vt hl ,.t F
0. 6 ' q r-lo sE. E 5 E (D o fD .9
0J E g o o 35 Ut t-.1 F) oq o
Fl
r) -ut 5 U) (') o o G (D o. o
fD o E 3 . 8 o, q u :3 ,{: 9) iJ F) v,
o o i-r (.) g o u, gq (-) o 3E
u, gq 5E hl o o o o
g) o tD F d fD
FtO o -l (D 0) T;
E F u, rt v, a 9J (.) 0) v
€ o u, vt o o o IA qa
o ,aO Hs. o o g, g, n CA gE
o o v, o tr r-l o
o Fi
3* o E ta 0) iA
Fl: o F.* v, 0) 0) Ut o
o o O)
o gqtr 0) o Po vt 0J n o gq sro
(D Fr: o K OJ :< FI v, gl
5 5 !d 7t i3 o5 o € Fr. !3
m o. Ko
.) v, F OFts o (t o 9r o Fb vt
ut o v, 5 v) gr o
o b 0)
!-) v, o g$) o o F $ o o 6q
FI Fb
o s
sr o B gv, lll
0) o v, F v, F!
o q hl
S) { o
t-t
5 ga 0) s, p t Fl o It
ii@ rJ o OJ *[i
g. r-l r-h 3
tD gq (D
o |.) 9 F id o 0. o tD € oa o *5
o g) F 0q tr p, v, FI
I
F
tt
oq FI
o
>1: F o o v, n m K P o
tzJ S) o F' E. Hf; g) 9) 5,8
c) FI d m *l E
p v, F
o s, 5o
tr
'i
o r5
.t I A fr Q F (tf\ ql r+ F
t
dl\ 8 (\ s F $. E \b qR
hl IJ
t\g)
A f) o
10) o o o'
E tt,
$ lro o Fl Fl
sp
o F F 3 ,t
o 9o) 77' ut n a)
(.h !,
:FI o : l Ft o
(^ I os o( ^
H o 8S (^o v, 0q 5 0q 9) o -l g) o EF)
o o u, s) FI hl
FJ
ri, o o.
v, AFi 9J tc' or pr € fD oq o
r5 o gq o
hl
5 tD
oq
(D
ct o 5 o Ont
5 I o 0) oq F o 6
bA) v
*a 3 F, (t) 5 g)
E Fg F a -a a
g F (r) g ;i" o a @ o
(t PJ
9)
{ 1 5 9) v, cJ
F) v,
tr€ E o o. q r)
#s
p9
@ 3 F' r) Fh 7 g a JJ
0) I o ra 69 p6" H t!
cr w o ts o tr o E 9.
o. 0) ctt O) FF'
t! v)
sv, o 5 f! 5 3
o (D o s)tr tr -t r-) o 65
's -- t* s s, { Gr IE
tt $ $l
a $r qo)\ + -a R t o r: .-) o o Fl F)
Vt I !D
o. d o I o Eo oa. o 0) o o v, F o Ut E.g
How other fiurasianfamiliesare organized- part one
:8+ l-lcw languageWorks

f-b -i
+ 5'H c
Fl c €+ FIfqBx:
! q go (DFtsR s) o o i+fD
3 R H. !t i; H OJ fE
r+5!?Fr Io* cH ;EE;fgEgg3
&€1++81,-\ BEF,H:HE=d=€
Ff lf z' 9J :r o) "9EFoi,'\i.-.\.,
tN ii p g) FI
583= o n' rD
:-_ o
r+alv
]5rd.:5
E 9F
H J J
l J -
g $) cr
Yv,
+s[i tiE #
F F H.Tfi$silgf aB.F; g
nr:€ n 0J' OrO
tYo-| 9)
€ & 5 2 E I 3 :.6
i E 8.E o T FEE€7fFg
o5= v, rFg[$EFSEB]
6S E'F Fh F|- FF v,
9"o
Ai-fD
o
iF; s
-q)59r -I t*' 5
5 Kn Fo,
D5
+ r - t r-F. Q- r) o
T Frr g 550- F
sJ F€
+Hs $F1gHE;H'gFHF}iFE
*s
! 9 ! . / E'p f v) q *x
o (a 5i) F [
- E ' 5r o
Fr v) 6v)5 v, g TSFEgF's: Eg
:'. Ut H
g i;
iJqH! u,
= +5 =(DFt- pr
r H
o
o -oo
=. o -: o ;o
. Hd,'5 dr3 o o
g; r.o qa ll* o o T P6 +$ r +3 EFg I f fi
(D
=rD 6 oq
Fl
r i3; .!iEEf B*FF*trEAEHG
=e#s g) r0,
S
t-(.)F|- o
F€€ 3 g HfBEdgqiS;:
H -
?* E i E B,i rt,
jJ o f) hl B6
E'
. X- J :y - v
;dB o rov, 5b
+n
&:
aE i xo ' ' r H i iligHlE,=iFH;
X 6'd Hr=',aFr*59-6
5gq
=;gE =o o pJ gqrD EHgFESAi€iF
1-Fl v v)
"o3 g 3 9) gq t)
Fl o
|1Fln
v) 6
OJ
- €H'
Igg:ET3;
E.6Y F{ hr
= 3q9E€
9 H gq F.
= e s)
oa 5 o oqg
E H g H F'*oE rsTsBE;Ef5€
Vt oP
€ E.EE F O o I E E 1E F $er ? gH
6' € 3 F i-Fb5 € 1 0r
( 9 h |
I
u) !-. iJ
o [;iF#;s .g;
6-f"'il ?.Ero Et.(D TFE ,;; F9H H = -l
l ^ H F l = 'Ov, pJ o n
t 5 n F-F F 3;
F 1 lo
l-l oq
if rd t$o ;;€2ii[F r yg€ a H sF
n d
g6
f0)5 o = + e ' t i - v '
gEEg 5 B6'
g) 9l F# F
:0.
E9
Fr)
F.
o 0lH
- v H o
H - . r i cro
V F . oq g ='q
- t-(
gE g *E g g F f$1:dF.fi;*$;
,t iJ OA 0r
-/ t_( rD
(A
B & B E*#
^ ? v J
5 r a
J J Y
A
3s oa o r)
F & e g!€: E
L
a a t s; I xg :q g il iT .gE,
E I
=; v =i ==i: *g 6 7 i;e
= s/- 4 .,iiiar G--=D-Blr
=== 6;:3-;:-17=

gDrt! td
ul
€c JE$ E E o FSE H
hl
Fl p '6
3 3+
o er Fl
b 6 9) o *l O -.'i o € 5
oo o g
Y#.s) =6
iJ.
n
t- I'
eH*6 g
o P o a I5 O t+) -F)
qq t6 o qE o 5
=F1 fD N ?fB' o
9 q 9J o 36 !p € F o -l
c''HA o o 5gq x' o v,
>I o o E-: o FI
-j v)YYt 7r b H: P,E
EF t6r
pr o :- o oq I F t s , o o o
q I &B
EFEo o 6'!R 5 T5 o a. P TE E a g. :lE'I
f .6 o o o P F{ Sor v, 5 c€ o
ga o ga €t+ *l
2b € V) -l vt B #
'.6 o H
Vt 3 P 9)
to
= Ef
^: . t9
A1 ga o
vt
8"8r o o o' o E
U)
5' E:
!-F F
=o €
o o FgE
r::.
o
Fl o
EegE
$.gF+F
o 0) F o
o o Hsq t-l
HT o ,f 3 F oF t rO f o
tr u 5 E o
v, 7$' H o o 9u' F 8;8v
)-t tJl
=+F'
=
.D
(t) v, o € P65 o vt Fl
o T !x! ii
;o
ii Ft
p 7t
p
E I rD g , E s, l&
? g 6E.o 6F o
>1 P F! ftr o
o rD '"tt t/l € Oo) o pr5 HO oq OJtr=
v't
5 t.^)q 6 |.l 1..' € 9r fE,i€
o = H . H 4
= aB v) o K Ov'3 0J o ox s)
F.l
F o
rd .9 o o o- i' F E b; ga gts 5
7f v) 38'a o 5gq FI o 9r sT$g
;q3 o t E o oF Vt o5 cr
9J
F 5.* vt F
jo,H F o vt 0J o oo. v g tvrOr
o E F
-vtFF o o (t, f6 6f) :H 6 r{
.9 p) FJ 9)
: E 8 o n o o fDH o) =- g) 'o
v 'rPd 0)Ft \J N
o =XE
Y A o SJ T' 5 5 f6 !n
0) E 9) 5
gq gq
EE* T
H. gzt oa s
iPa E
*t'i 5 rt o
o 0) 5 o FJ o 6sE v)
EE''r o
vt
fi+F o. o F u
s) gr 7f5 cg) o 3 q'F3
E oq U) F2 gq gq oo oq v o 0)vttvE'
z €6 3 o !f , E F 9' ir Ft
o Ba gq K cra
c X 3 tr o 6g 'i5l € o
(t) o q v, ) H.T (D
P F..
9l o vt 9) Vt fd
,f OJ :'YErq:
p oq s'€ € v oq fD s)
5 o oH 'l)A) oa ;Hf o
o) a o A 5 6' € v)
f; I 5vt 5 $) H F5 ' S
V) 3rD o
gH € 0J gq F
o";Y 0)
g 3J? sr 5v, trO o E*tS o
3 Vt o F F'-r5 o gggs
9g) F o
Ef 6" H v,
o z 9prd o $) e rE 3E
-1t i Fl (? o 7* O, r-r t oa 9)
N d9 F
v, :SF 3 F 5 hl
#0 ) v )s€ o
q FE
6' s) o 5 OtzliJ
a.o r{: :
a H.
o o vt r< 0l o
oif o f) 36 vtP HE. s
oq K g F)
E 6' 3 v,
) v, 0) Ot 5X P{ o rt) ) ,to ; sfi e 'lv
1H.g o o o =. a 6-
E) fDO4 o q'H 5 H'rdo p
v, os)+ o i' =f= o
o v Ft X
id H. o
vt Fl H ' H . A .9 F 0fD
S) - 7Of 5H sr a
pr o OE € 9J E g Y"q
EFo o s
5 € o 0. p H' oo) H F;3s.
E g o g o o g) =F Oo) o
frv, g Eef rrt Fl oah S)
3 l.{;o5
4 H
(D
x-
r-+ 9)
F 9)
.9 o
H..B;
Ni+
v)d co vt !J qq
/tJ N o
o' .g b- 5 A E H
o F B.rH 9) s) F 8:f,. YA K F
v Y
cO. Oo o gq o F,_F'PF
5g # FX o
v 5g
gE =P 15 i
. H
g- P)
r{
{ gr gJ g F € o /^t €P OJ € =$Eo)
F ^
€ o l-{ H V,
5 t ;-o
cLF FJ
HHE o
tr o
rE o P.tr l o. o r) v)fD ir< o v, t€fi 5'E 6' E

rBs f{*w r:{herf *rasi*n {anrili*s*re orqanized- part cne


386 How LanguageWorks

ras*EIt*prI+t
t.+[gg;riEi$Ig*
$EE e+s
ar[Eacsgf,serit
e*a;
$1gIg€iEr€ I1[g
lEg*g;aliglgIE
*[EgrEre€{ q;EgB$Es
.EiF;5g$.ar;rtssa
ss€H:
c+aPresTggfIg++
E*EIgEE;E$1
!le*EE;FFIqi
E*eiE
fifegiEfiFsgtisrr€

I
E p 6 rn
-l Fi o d o -l OJ Fl Evt
I

75 7t
(D
o
g t t(a jvt
so
rs o
oo 3 (t r_t = H'q _(a *-h
5 o !1 rdo 9)
I I g) "i o vtG s) Vt
Iol o o F!' O) gFF I u, ft,r
C' |D F F Otr tt r
sr it
9) OJ n irt H' &*"d
o 3
V) 5 o
(n d u,
='l g OJ o **5 -.*&*
o F o
T o 9r Vt Esg 9. vi ;-. pr
X ,to Ft v, F) g6
gl5 o 5 E t4
OJ $ sJ @seqf ft
o s) F ct FEE st (o
d * 5 \J
0a id 3 hl il' o = FP) gl $ *J
{ o -l Vt ts o pl n lx oq *r#
!J ir T sJ o 0r 3 qs. + bfi {.>U( 'D 5
0) = 5 c o :
c/ ?aFtt r o F o .) i-. O o re€
Ft {
gE o
5
qq
3 9)
p
5I o u,
HEsi cr €
o o 7t o
p 0) 9J 7( 9) v, E's i^
ir
F. 5 hl o v, ffi
=> 'o u, F F o }Jr Ut o o (! r[l
3 v,
rD H .H R
ay o q rd 3 i+(! >< \*d
pJ E 5F
o o
ts 3 9) o d p 5 LN
F Fl fD FU
E g o o d*3 o 9J
5
o x 5 gq o FR 0) fl*-F
rD F) fD w Fl 5 o:. qH€ { oq r)
= p tr K o ; g fl\r
hl
f tld *n&d
I t hl F 9.9) Fl
9)
F
v)
p 5 "o F o o oq ..) 5
: 3 *H ae a o Fl
() €:. o E v, E'
9) Of .(/r 0t ga n /ry\
|D fD 3 o 0rtD Fl i-a ffi
ho (rt
P)
zo
Fl
5 o p) 5 pJ E
Fl o f< ; *E o o
6 n
I
I
t !.J {u
*T
9J F g E
F o F f$F att
16 o I
I o r) ga og IA 5 m,
o F 3 3 A' oq H A5 ts
Ut FJ 9) p tg)o sg o 0)
v, Fl 9r rDhl 15 -*r-T \'d
-!'o 5 E) Fl s oa 5o
o gJ tr F *X r*r*!
9) p a sifl \rrdf, trr*
! f 5 v, -ut g) o SF cfnt O o 5
o gq o o (a 9J
r)
(D f[t ffi
vt o -l P I c 3€
rD tr \J 3 o HJ U L"d
vt 9r 7 o Fl
F =o gl
o ffi
oq 0) f) OH)
(tt
o 0) o
s) 0)
xo o
n
o v' Ft
ss+
€'eE o F ts &s
M
H F o v, o 5 o OH)g .ol.
Hl F s) 5rD *q
oa @ o o o f**"[* f\r
1? tr n o E F =E knJ
0) 9l 9) T6- 0r *J
d x
oq fD o No E5 FJ a
tD 3 (D F tr g. oa IfF r-t Vt o
F ffi
v) qt 5 oa P 0)' ts. o 5 cra f**T*
@ o F'{
ng ffiS
g o 9) ts go) d8
o s tsl 0) 0) o *l FOa E;i s vt c9)
0) t! gq
S) (D 0) 5
o
v) t tD 5g EF T s. F o
ru"trl
rY\
{&t
ffir
b*-d
L#
,ft
8E
n
How ather lurasian farnilicsare organized- pari twc \*./ k-*I** x
388 H a w L a n g u a g eW o r k s

IEElE€EEEEEEI
s$5F$gg6*+r*tel*tF
g*$Eg$ *s
$Fg
grgggFiiggfg
iggigsgigii
i;FFEF,ggiggggigi
l8g H*w cther Sur,;sianfanrill*sare organizeC_ part tw*
390 Haw LanguageWorks

g) U) .) l-l -l .qt d @
-IJ
€ o o V' tD
{ o 5 o OJ oo
w
F . - H (,)
o.
f?
o
Ft I
*l
$'gf
t s F . Y FI
o -l
p)
5* o
o
Fr $Er 3F ilEtsil*$68$
SF*5fiHt-*:F., q
oaI g sad F
5 € o lJ
p
9 i'ri H.=rZ 5qE
9) oa o t+ hir o to IFl
; r_t v, ut
5
F
oa o E.r.B 3 $€ 'ct HE
hl
X A!.O. o
o t o
o F F K
o 9tan
-l
$) oP o
Fl

"p
iIE
e
*s
Es H*g
I
g o
0,
€ o
(D

n
p v\
o
e .r,g
o)O5 0)
5 s)
*s
ht(D
F

Fl
o
o)
$EIist€[
E,;EiE Eil sEF;$"EHgsB
fD g) *l ts sP F p
r') oq HO p
c) -'. V) f)
gq
-qJ
ff 8H c) t dF
HssrFEgg.*sH' dE+HrE f r t
s) i.t qr A. F F)
n qq gFi i
g) g
6 =;€ G r g
0) FJ
F
g o F)Fi o hl
.EE i s= q
3 c F {5P Vt oq
F 3 f FE s E.E
o, p 0q o 55 (D
o X 9) v'E o
F 5:H |1
F
0)
o
Ut
-l
zo s
s)
oq
i+crit o
F
Fl
o 6Er Ut
o
Bee$rggE *rEsifi#iE
e g q;l
0)r-ltD+p.\-urS(j6
o 9) 1E E d E
(D v, ;qH o 86 .3f;;EEFAEI
o OJ
r' F) F ?o o t!
Fl gq
Vt F o
cg
E
ffra a
tr u, E
o
F 5 o
o 3
;fg I r [Eig
v, o F n
x o
Ut g o 5 $ [ r* csE
ta t u,
:' 0) $: * v,
I
F
*.Eefi E s;; g
ra gFH I F tsl
v q o tD
*E tgg.s
"6 K o n p)
G g SJ Vt o
€ g) f$o v, o hl ga
o
o
7<
(D € tr
0)
d
o o
3r€agEsI FsB € IH€E'g g HH
o Fl g 5
Fl or (D
vt I
FI
c(a
o o o
t-f:
Hggr4E'55.8
h) g o ut
At
-6 o ct
o
*rE ut 9r
(t,
o
tr
c'
Iqg;c3g3 H'€"e-+f; g $3
o o F THH':Fhl o o
F 3 5 gcl o * s*ei [ €E R H g 5 i€ 3 *. E.
o oq o ca n
3 o
5
o o F P r) 3 ?
* E;{ [ fr i F F
(! 9) JD -l
f €i o o 5
o E.ae'8;FF';5
a a Ja d Vt rD
t 5fi r 9J o
:-= g
v, gl HEI f.E q geE
2
=
{- =3=c=_EEE
)>)xir-)l
$gEHFtg€
D =
I E =E E i AE e E
= i€=€€ i I = g F HE B n I E

E
,x r|l
g fD SJ
H-3 q E g
11 5
rO t:? {ir FH
(D
s,
€. ( DFr!, *u t
'AEgFFrggr o I
rD 0r! o
.o
: 3o) 6 fD J g-.
E : Xi q €$ # -r+ l,- o €EE.9F
Hl '9) l-.
tl 5 3 OJ sdgqF E
v, o g € 9eFg
.v, r(D (D
o. tu, o
'a , f o
(h l a

ol >
(D
,o
'v,
0.; o 5
u,
pra 5'6. d: g g'
OJ f') r
t)
dd H E g s.E$$sg
x. o
o
q) oa
oi f D
. 9 ' r_l
5
iggFr€ F3E;g
g 9)
9l hl

i< o gq o
t-l €
3gFH.s
6Ffsf
F'IF'HH
c 5 fD q8
v,

gJ
o
fD E
Vt
lJ
o o
o ct
o
o
v,
FgEfFFF$g
g B; f E EF Hs n
F
?qjg
!PrD5
5E r
6 E
l;
E'E qq
E
0) f{:
o I t so =' \t 2 iJ
01 n ;o'|5F
m o o € sf iEE+
0. rO
o PFiai=r d 5 tr d
q, v) o F. E'd rr (D
qa g) { 6 :
o
-
o
tt
0,
T
o (:!o
n
o
FJ
o
;eaflF;*tr C
" . .It F
r n si .
3
$ =He
SHaE.
n tD
d X Fio-?f
ut o v.)oxiH
\J o o Fl
o
(a Fl
o o F
G'
F o
\t 9)
u, g)
o
q
oa o
It
ggri;FFfE g- Foe
E sd A s
q iHss
9) o 0) n (D 0l
ro $fIE'
gl Ut r.: X E r -E a 55(D,)
o f o \J oa v^Po
-ta@t+11"+
c,
; z
o
hl
d
o
fD(
5 :< o
0)
n
!-+
5 1 oq
0)
(D
Fgrg[gggF ^C,TE5
u0JrD;riO
' qR l-;t
EffE
0. gJ
g g6 a E ' xu' ,b; '-r
v, t-l 0) FuJF H
(t
F
9Jl
gq
t 0" K tr
e$€ErFgIt
jEfr:-gEiF e
- o 6 X -rr y
+,,,,F E€35
)H.H'
(A; td &!. vtr gtr ar H. H.
I
t r L t t
2 . r (! t 5 i
; =.o=$F ,.+-=5
P( (/f t.
3 c ol 5i K: o RSFS&
,( Or r / r |t :d ; IHF3
-t o.i !fl o ol HFgEs
)!
t!l 9) 9- i;J E t;' E'6 F I
tDi UT tD I r) t'i6 H =F
FEg 6sE"H? aREg
ggIatE
391 How other f urasianfamiliesare organized_ part twa
H n w L a n g u a g eW c r k s

$agEFIFEg[s
* $;€
d
.$E[[E+EgHgB B fl"iE
3Hs
iif5 qrsss:I
-$iFEEEIE
n BEESEi 3; s
tlFBS*#Flfi *x5!+*
$E i i +g3EHs
1+agtggi3; EI 3
gr,E
f : ; iEg fi3; n
prEgrEi$+[f
atgt €qE;I rrr
ii*i $aBiE ecg
FE
Ir1+E
EIEF
# A=:" a=;a-" ;=

).{
,7 ?i
;D
AfD CI. d> rD c
F ID hl

d (D n i' x t.r|
(D- 9' I 5 H
v, oa o rt) o) g gq t 9"o
Xoa JV ro F Vt o o Vt
o g o g fD o ry* ff
'.: ? (D oq Ut o o i+i'
v) ct .F,b s) tr 5 9) o *#*
V) = 6q
c+ o a 7f 0) o (t o F
o q o gq rJ r-l o rD ffi
.4, 5 n (o Ft o pJ 6' €3
'15 x o rD 9r o o vt !s
J] OJ (a rt) V)
F 9. \-*d
o F ? F lrl 9)
tis'
(-J gq
v, o X t21
5 FJ F OJ
g) F (/l 5 o v, E. H,
e- p) o ie :f
o "o
pJ o :l o s) -v( tD=
=.; o E
gq 5 v { m.
Vt o 15 !t o tr ..'j
n U) o) v, C' v) oa ry
o U 0l o H: o o S) n c cra
5 0)
JD qq S)
o o o € F)
0) oi fM\ 3 4
7 o o o p H o p oa
s) o H:
o)v)
.u, v, F o f*ry
aa tf o s) 0) v, o I hl *ry
o o
Fl g h6 tu o.o re
oa 9) rD SJ
p gJ' **d
w o o o qB *"*""J
(D 9J
0. F!: -.
r-l s) o o
oa ci' t ,ri )_f! 5v) g,ro
1
>t o (D o v, n PE'
-= V)
vt
v, rD
Ft
F
(D h**"6*- trtr\
q$J
9J o S) F u, o tr o o
oq g) v, u, t)
Fl F E s
o o T oJ 3 o q;
r) 16 o t5 9) 0r -l
o r-l p) o *.&.*n
-;
r+ 9) o 0) o F +6. E$
5 H o r) 9r v,
o € 0r d g F 69 tr
n o o F
{$) 9) f&&"d
v,
o tno o 9) s v, F) p ffi
Ut
o
hl
T 5F
O.rl ffi
fD 9) s) ss .ffi'.
t v, o v, rs
:o 5 $r 5 o E {t\] 5 o F $ If) \*d *
s) W
o E g o {&s*d*
g o o $ 5f)
ux {o F qq **q
T\
€ o u, s
L- V' 0" V' 0) ffe
vt
d $ ts o E o fler
-o 0) d tD o OJ o
(n o o o € ut f) ffi
o s € oa ox U
Y*, -"t g) (D t o 0) tu
a rD F v, F o o 0) ks \-d ffi
t+O c! o p t6 pr fi
tt) 9) r-t gq @ { l
=o o 5 f') 7 *Y*!
E o o o tr o St sr 9J ffi
XFn r) u, o v, ffiJ
o o € Ut o n \#
n o v,
F oa o 0) nH
gJ o g o' o" rD zo **x {w
U) v) og l\1
H5 0) 0) o o s) 5 € s) f&*.&..d
o p g ut qa a6'
= !J v, g o o s g)' oH N o pry
w *'**t3-*
t"r*f- i
oa o rD 0" v) o o P
g v, o' pr
a' OJ d FJ {$
Vt
ao"
ts 3
0) o o Fl o rD sr 'Vor n
aE. oq o ;-a l\r ,ry%
5 5 9r o XE
r.) T
ffu&-d
o q o n p o o
56 v, fD (! fD U' fD v, I
o
H)
w Vt F T o flPi ffi %-*#I
t tod, $1
***"*t 6
ru"rc
i%.
.}
{,&**** trH\
qild ffi
H*w the Indc-Pacifrc
islandfanriliesare arganieed E,T
393
394 How LanguageWorks

- gEgggIE'iggg
iIgg
;ggggggIggggggg
iirFuEuuEusFTuE
*
u
.D qr
nt
c f? rt EH=S
Lrr F --r!-.! iJ
= r+ I. (D o t! F
r.l- K r-l vt o
oa -b + o Ft) ;n oq o) 0J rD Fl
o g)
E sr o
Ft Fl
6 in el fD
=B; fxg
=o rd v, OJ o :p8 zt o o o
5 ug. v,
";= (hfD
)rE o s)
E
(D
9r qJ' (D N
t s l tA 6 F
F.:
Eo
ts 6 grH r-
'Hu.rgOarl Y
t v* )O
c 5
F
o v,
3 ;-l
tF i
FEEE
r
b3 'oo a i ' ? o o o. € o gJ 0) g
ot 0" o hl
v, OJP 5 u' F|3 hl
O) -lq 6'
9F rD Fl u, o ts o F E F
P) n g. 9r v, o
vt s, -l f., 9. Vt
E.E P 6
3€ o 9 o (a (t .J
H B =4 s rd+ ;- 9b
F o F o
E o < o (D F.H Ts
o= q. E 0q a
o w o ta r.l
F.l r-f:
€R FJ=
xF F)
8s Vt E
9'
ts ;gg
E ErFel g
9)
o EE.hE
oF gq o rA sJ € o
:r o 0) o 0) X sd6 37gHs ! IJ'
F
=.o 0) 6H tsl: (n 9r F o a.
Eg C' J/, -o 56 9 € n Fg o o o
=-? 5. oci 0) EOJ I
!-'t r) o cto o v, K E' ctq F p \J
g (? n
8 oq€; o tD s) 5 s;gF
o 'ofD fi9, Scoi(D vt n E)
.'E 9f F 'q 8J Frt: E E'g 9l ? o n
t\) $vt € (t o 5F) ? E o
l./l -\J o (D E BE.F8 0) 5 !b
=rD o sl (t 6g E o Fl n
60q o (D !P)PorI
rehtOAF=' 3 v, o p)
EIFg
l-8 o Fl S) o pr
lt q g g o sH gnt p o g
p
o s'J' OJ gqF v, o d 5
15 a Fb o ct z a ['6 'r
GqJ gq E'E'=i: g; F o o (.0 @ v, :. 5
'a oA g 9) o 9r o c
g5' > tu 5 { s) !F(q
0) g 3
cA ga ?d5 oa E
EE"lE?'86 g) F crq
Vt (D o r) PJ o o
o fr q o g 5 o .l (A
= ,:
E"E r=. ; E l # c
- - {o F) Vt 9J o 9r u, E5' F{=.O-O i f)
oq r) o F o 5
9l (D N cr 5' s) o (A s) &ig$
=r+ hl 5 0) o
o ? d JD K 5 f1 u2
fD o P o
o. o € irEq; cr (? o cr
FI hl ttr q
o o PJ o
Aa |1
sr
o
Fl t 5
qH = A H . F ? s)
ta
u,
-ut F
\J
tr o
o
H[ga
v, 0)
FE FT tr
3
!t
F v,
cr o E)
sI € AF H $ Fb
€ F O)
FI
5
(
t') o o
B 6 o F'8
Kg) B L
v, o 9) r) (a
Fl' F F .U, 1 9J 9. 5 5 O. tr !-r ).{ O o
g {
fE
gE (D
o EE {
FI
9l
v)
9)
oa. aq ='25'5? o
p 3 o
o 5
oa
g

F
ai Fs
F.de+
n(a-fi F.
=fD f< ch P EE.r: o u, g) Vt t-a H.
F+j t o Fg
+ o .) rD o Ir. €' e'F56-- o zo v, o 65't
. a oFU oJ s) o F o Vt
hoq d v, olw { d
otD tD n o 0) sr ol n o
rdo v) ts o o
Fl o o HO F H
,l v) n =b gHoEH l: o o '(t F *E.
ga p crq F'O o cna
g t o
P:r 3 o5 o -'!-fD'iO)
:o 9l n o SJ t, 50 C' o SJ F cl OJ d gg
)q) F sd g K SA 3 o .+K5
-(F
ts .UJ
o) p o aoli.o o
p oa o tr
o r-l o
H t v, F8 5 v, a
"P o d q1
395 How the Inds-Facificislandfanriliesare orsanized
H c w L a n g u a g eW * r k :

iiEfaE
el;E-'E-eiIFl?EFEEE$gE
Iiil
giigiggglaggiEgI
iFE$Eg 6IEEI*FEEi Egg
EIg$E1 Egi?EEiigEIEFB
tl
FF
-rl
(t
vt Vt
o g E EFEg
o F EF (Dol
F 8$ FJ Ff
p I F| U, Fd I;d gq o
H: 5v,
I E E'3
P rD oq
rD x EI 6F) oi.O
cr) q'B oE(ED -ut 9r "g 39, H
-l
oa € = ri' v, Fn
lio Vt o htn 0ao "*fu
'ut gH
rD o =. o) 5 i'5
7rj +3 f) q6
:a ord 5) $v, Fh 9tr FH.fi! fln
o 5o ; do o' \**d
Fl
o.s #s X n
F€F.H AT
o (,1, o. p o e6 g +E boX
r) $F H'o rD
5fD pJ oq (tE rII rDH ) F
6'sH o x rD
o .- p HfD
itd g
.9 o n 5 =. F)
.-t 0J
-': i 'n c0. oq .g=F
-FH' fDu, F o q
o r.ii o (t) v,
=i 5 (€DF o a o u, ;.i
v) ftt' )r' 9) qa k
ory \o oc s3 5 ' Pg)
rr
q7 a g oq 9) 50, s) ctq ##
= o 5 S) #E
LT Ftn r, 0) o P 5 E8 xlD **4**
vt
o & +s
o 'v,
v, g
$o
o 1 vt3 )+ u, &* a$
a 0l Ed 6v)
'-r (D
t1
= F E ryJ 50) E &F' ffiJ
:io 9J
o
H)
P -r,' g Er O,.i o9)
Yb i.i 0) rd o tsqH @*sffim
|+r Fo =6 Fl s
x.
o d6 s. 9r Ftn
o n i'F FH A >.5 g)
n o 5 o kl x t-l
fE. FFO V,t-5
a@ r94 N
o g5'
o 9) EFJ
5.t J l-{

x o c J? r_l
o
urfD 3q flffi f,}
6-E 9,q v, H g, *< ge
a) (r)o o) gqI'
ffiJ
o E I F € tr\
oa qg o) t h g Fl' o, F g
?o + v t ! +) H
\*#
2 H s Eq
Et - OI
9)
gt bP' xE' oq gF o o 9) cna n ffi
=Ft sqY HC, V) B 8.8 oo **%
oa F) rDt 5 v) =.5 Fi
u, 'vt
9t fo \Jf.l (Jr
o =oa SJ
'.2 Ut 0JH rD fD og. "**&*
H S) Oq Fr p) F, NF'E ffi E$
o E' B& n 0, v) 0)
d 5 g6 L#M
o) 6r o. FnOJ 9) F
o s *v,
,J' FO F,P Ft
Fi o u)o Ct
T F qq
n
r-l
d
o EP
qffi
o
v)
*ryry
o o c =. o B o Cl
o v, oJ
ffiJ ffiJ3
X €F =o 5 p FJ
9r ?D -ctt o "P vt ii. v)
rA it 9" v, $)
() (/l g -u, ! P o v,
o E.H €
rD ts ni ,-r 5
ffi ffi
w{|
Yo i+ u, lY Hl v,
EgH sqHo38
n o) tr
n' v) r) 1A o 6g
Li,
sYbg E' -N
L.,rD o sr r-f ffiJ
vt
=o E3 0r
p) n h,$ ffisr

fD tt,
5 v)
I
gad g) 5
g p)
on gilF rdoo {F.r
***3.
€F 5< v, F+ ?+ Ut 9)ol' r,D .9 ,F46aL
re qw
397 l-l*w Afriran fanrilies ar* crgaari;ed ffi* tfr
398 Haw LanguageWorks

*,I
ieEEEESg€EiEE

iiEEEEEEIEEEFE
A ts -

u
rt e3 [
E
Fl
; 9qe d
vr !t 9=' o- -t t -l $) -l
o I
9' fD I Sr b
ggeF Fl E5 EI 5 o g
r) oa @ 5 oo (, t8' o o cr F
FF s u, o g 1c' o o
9r ov, 0) FI FI F 5
;i=rH' o v)
td
I
o 3 Eoq
OJ
5
v
E 3 o fD
n
F)
gr X z (D o
G u,
;,fr
sz
g s p 9": S) T gr
gc) tdo
o o EO OJ t:It 3 p qa o
Fl (D o
o 0) o
r-l
v, 9r 5 Fl
fD crq
=,Egg z z< n (D $ Frl H o 1E.E
F. 6€
H . V fD 6" c)
Ut SJ B5 o N
ct 9r E
qa P Fl
- O=Xa o 5 OJ qq E gq o
tr .) I
o
g F) 6'+F'
o @ = 7l € Fl IA Fb t F6P
$) o
sg K
X
1 I
9) v, o 0) o v, cl "5 E
rl O,' ga t-l 9t
E orD
o tD fF) .,'rg t f.)
oq 4 o z t^) o rd o o C' s E' cta tr'
;s3+ Fl F oE C tsl o v, Fl o oq
0q F g oc L o o c) € g)
j- (D 5
(D F
ts o
g.PiH o Ft r-rE 3 o Fl hl Vt i8"e
o 5 ,tO v, pJ v, 5
I rJ 0) fo o v, F (a
= t6 o vt o ca
o o BS 9) o 0) fi o s) Ass
o FI tf 3 g) u,
n E. 1r o 5 F o o Fl
p
sg$E z o o gr sE' 5 Fl @ $ o o
F g) o p 5 3. :- o
Fl:
g 5 0) o
g) Fl) o # f i
q r-l F OF- g) |+J 3 n
JD v, vt
3 5 ct o FI
o 3 $) o o) U a
hl oa o 5 (D
tn r{ s) o g;
fD u, Fl r-l
9) tr z=. o tn 3 n o
F
F U) d r)
v, H. V, r!, oq tr d I
o v,
o o
F
tsl
o
H
g
0) g o oF) { oq
Fl o u, sE
p g) tr !n D
0.
stil+
[F:Hfr' o
c)
t n
o hl

o
dF P
poa
o 0) oq o f) o
5
g
o
o
X o
tr
3
o
5
o gq S)
hl
O"r-5
5 g 5 !D tr Vt Fl o
z F 6 v , g) s s) o ro tD
o
E
fFB
Fl qq Fi 5 vt
F 5 t-b r-l 5 o Fl @r fi E'g
9) e o o o ' v,
v, ts. u, vt o o E
ga 9;o 3
o
oq o 9)
ts
tD
;u, $ o
o FJ v, Hl/)
t € g o
Fl
c x' sE+
q Fl E E) ro gq oqo
+€;t
=.: o
s) do ts
F @ iJfo pl gq o o o
ol n g v, v, tsl vt Fd o
g)
{o 6a
EE *o o o o
Ff,
pl vr 3 o
tr 5
P :s o H. 7l F U' F 5 o Fl
E)
D) (afD FE (D 9) w oa p
€ p 9) 0) oq o o
E H TE 0) s) F oq )r 9J 3 v, gt g, FI H v,
5 55 tD 5 v,
r) g) Fl p
o g "o t
@
T v,
o 0r 5
@ E
o
v,
o v,
rd o
fEH
E o
o
€ f, Hfi 5 o 0)
Ff) hl 9) H5' E JD g) v,
9)
ga q gF ' o (D
o hl fr E o 0)
o I o Ut Fl
v, o
0,
IE.g; Fl
Fl
C'
r) n
c) t
o
-(/l
gd sf (D
n
4
v) f6 t -ur "o
o o
0q
oq
o
7t
o
F xo o
P
tE s
le 6.8
Vt
Pz 9) o 9) vt r-t (t, E
F! Fl 7r 7f 5 o
IA 9) € ).t fD F o Fl (t
hl (Dq) o o 9) o
F) (D p -(t, d B
FA$s hl
q g 3 t! 3 F o - s +E;
a
Ut o o o r: cr S)
p t.) v, H,$ 9) C' o 9) o (t
r a EE .5G
'il, tD H F F hl
# o 0q o oo 3 p f
F
u, o eT g
v) o o d o € ot
F F +
o S=.E ts s) tr o"tr c 0) o c o r) Vt
tr
p o
= H F I b / H . hl t-l O) o
C' 5 o u,
I
$!f9.i v,
o o v, os 0) FI
fiI 5 u, 0. 5 *Hr
399 How African farnilies *re *rganired
Holv Languag*Works

il
$gEiEE1EFEE?
i38
g?sB ?EiEE

iAIEiiiEEEEiAEIiE
giEqgggEEigEEE
ara

rr* l-' ;
t F} D {r+ll
3 ) G 5 ;.1 FZTii'
F A - '+
!'+. if
t,f
:t o (') cr o x rD xoa H
'a -l
o (D lrt o u, s sJ
+r; ! Vt gq ESF SL -l o) so
9) F
o 'o K o5 N F)r+ Vt p. CI.
P JD FO (D EsF+-, E.fi "E
q€ g p) vro o 5c' v, 0J FJ
f) I v
3 Vt o. 9.E u, rD r-t
'd p f.)
o o {Es o F|- E F) T €- = ' E +r H€) v ) o .u 5to
c-q ut o 0) .53 '0J o {SJ o
o v) 5rf[;' 6, o P*
o) o J5 o a\ _i o vt >t ; FittO.rho H. ta
0.
x(D s) rE
- r/. o Fl V) 5 o v, o d, in!
hl
B.G T v,
= ts o ' t s Rg 6 s
-- d o r-l ? F
rDr b - rJ r)
E' C' o ,-l o
9)
tr o : F ' o g F :
T s {8. 3 o o' 0. !'cxFhAia
c@ 0J (^J o o ? ,= w ,-\ ir
9J -l o ni9p, hl ho "o o x5Ftll
r.+l o F 0) o v, o =o 0. JD
E:iu, oF 9J Fr
o
!') at6- vt')
q) oq OJ -gJ v) 5E o o { V) $)
g$r15
FI o = ut 0) S) -gl .-+ -@ z'o
ct s) U) r-. 9) TJ (n =
Ff tJ l-i 50q rD o)lJ ! rdH
F F. n t+ o F ! FE
rD n UJ ! v 0) 0r H.fD |*(D
l. FT sl o s)
o F) v) $. o -l cr
o) o
o
8g u, H'r)
ai A p F qH.' FF Crq r) Fq F n ooq o Y OF
p A crq o o o o ob,xXut
s Frt,fr F { v
o 9l E o Fl $it T JD xv)
ta X o H ir. l.{r l.{ I o qr-i,/ )J
o g5 0a
t-l o H o o ut
o. B9
u) ri g 5 9) OJH
o v, tsF' H-a o Fl € T E E. AT la
-! tJt -. ''6 o ooa oq l:'= O) o 0r g.
o 5 o * p) 0) \JI rJ o vt (t') v) t s 8E E; E8
o o Oq
F FrE 0, F Vt ?
o d5 € tu H F

Y frl o o gq H(D 0) +g;c'!-+


=€ w V) o.
Y E
6 - 'oE e5'
) H
9) + ge
fnFt)
tr gJ p =€ o 9r o 6 dT sil
s) o 'i Eg . 0)
qa u' H. s) 50 a. o 9J u,
9. v) $l o u, o
;g o o A\ d € vt 6i
O. g) vt= hl t-( U)
E FJ rD o cra
F !+='tr q :6= .J
HCE.Es H.
9J t-t- gax
0) g o r) o er 9J o FJ ( - v
=0) >J
.) ftB fD oa ao o o o
-O. n o tt)
oq $ o o FJ
(D tJ U) X ii' 5 hl 9J E,trF T'E ! - r H r
!-. O" lrE' o fD;+ E( e5
rrJ o v, o v, o F) o P tl)
0) ; 9J
Eoa B 3E r-t v) F P-iH(A;r
n o o 0) Vt o (D *E'
v, o = rD n r-J o
L.
0 r oX l'1 €E oa
9 oo FJ5 o V td.g d 5E
SJ 0. FJ v, N F t A
o o *< "o V) !Jx F
ti) d 9) 5
It o o 0J OJ v, E' s. qq ()
n 6g I J o g g3:
.(.)
Ut ,t
o n Vt
c)
i-. F\ G
)-t
o trP rD o o
E + H +€ -vr'
-l rJ) o sr oaxS o OH. 0J $Ft
fo
,r V)
g.
s) o. i' - 5 v, o z;
9)
i' rD 0) \J Ft
:o
9J
gq FJ
o
hl
0. 8 Eq 9r
n v) sr o o o. o
fi[afrs - O.
6'g
a"a
fD PJ
FC.
goa E g) N i:i 9? 5
:{ P v) Vt 6'P tD aDPou'Et 0J
gq (D Vt \J o a.
=rD .B:€ oa 9J J5
F a Ut u, o o 33
X o n v) ad )J
0r s, 0) ,f Vt E' or !-i H. H.
o gq !) F, o5 €
oo= 0q r-l 5A
o u, u,
o.d o oa g Eoa
9) ri H. .-.i
o F) ,-: E 0.5
rra o |.1 9) c
d . qv ,t oF . =Ho ag
o o 5 .qo cr o b r o SJ ;. ld
H! cr S) P F.3 F g -ha o o [ l P l r-l
)
6'q Vt e o. *eoE.9,
rvry:E)tF+ oo

How Aflic*n farniliesare cnsanize*


4o2 H*w Languag*Works
Fl qN!'
5
'o o P (D F F t H .
v) o d $ F . h
+l o F\ lv
;o o Ft' 3
cJ ts
(t, )li
o v, v, o r) oq ctO
o o n 9= E g F) ooa
/(D o gq @ F) o dH tD -l 6' = H H
:i 0, r< >9
ln rr tD C' fg
v, g) o o e i6'
(t) P *l
v, Ut E ov, rDU"d
!-) o o ro gt fr E OJ F
gl o
o
g n o o ts-l oo. 0) F) 6F
d Ft
TJ F6 o n-a F.: F
o 5 (a o (D o
9J o € c) rd E (A qq E # I
d.N n Ft f,{
5 vt o 6 o 0r' fD 9J ntt V J
.) o o fo n o o AJ c
E F ]Jsr f.)5 6 o oqq
(D o o !') o A=q
9J
rD OJ
.) 0) qo E) I'E:
o 9) o fD-
r< € 9) 9r !D ii *€'
g)
o ga qE
o o d H.O
v, o o o Vt
I oF a v, s68'
>!: V) (o 9) o 'ct ? H - H
9r F{ ir?
o o ge g) 0) bFl
-v'
o Ft o fD o fid -l FtO
o pl V'B E '9
I o o sl >< o
o ?n o v, v' itt a oEs)
fr: o o 67f il o g)oP
v, o g) X g_o ; ro WE. vtH.S
Ft
0) o € g) v, g o OF
o 9J o s o Kc) EX, or) o +1"d
9l o 5 N E o
g) |1 (.tl o ' E5
) F*l -t 'ct +; 6 0E
K E n o o o rtl o eFi
v,
*1 S 0) o o ro Fl .Y
0) 0J 9) g d E)
P cl gq FT d
$l o Fl o 6r) 3 En H FN H
g { Fl: o o 9)
o 16 Fl or g Fl os) E X' 0r ta
v) g o 0) oa 5. fJ Ft Fl
o o qa o Eoci o Cq
[i6 p) g. \oli5
H o o n
o tg) F6 5 59
P 6'E
Fl: F gq
o Ft hl
F v) s ) . . | or e* B
n o o F# o K g,H
sl o
g
o o
5 v, o a gao E F 6g ea' n o
Fl qa
(? Vt () 3 o o
ta
9)
,{o v, € '3 5' a 5a
-igE
Ut o o 8{ oq 9. tTl FlHr+
o s) sr F{ P g (D
g) 7( gq s I o w P6 (D TOq
o g B g
vt o 0) 9) 8' 0) gl
o E
oa ovt g)o (-j )td
9J Ja FO
5 o H g)
o u,
;5 - r )sn
-
u, o 3 o VrO s
o 0) "6 q. KO 0) r) oo-t
tsl
P "o
{(D o 3 7( 0)
o o 9) gl gl oFl
Vt o
s o
vt d 7< *g crcl 6' ? 3
o Ot o o 3 G qE'
o rl o F) 9)
g) o o EN, 9J
tig qa (o o qq 5
fd = - \ )\-
v, o FJ Ftt o o o n
(t') r) n (--:O
(! E= o:- -u) = i ,
€ oa G aFa
c o = ra ! = ?==
= c- g = a = E ;
E c
ID '!D=
* ,ql
J' {e tu

F -l
E =t a
(D
Q , 2rD
r.+! F} it tr b€
qt ET r) |D eo
fitr* a3 I u, v, 3
I= 0) C' ; E.g H E
rJ1
@ t! FJ o
Fl
Fg o it cr nt gq
o 1o hl
0) ct
ij?
o
o o
p o
g vt
o F
€ o
Fl o
r{:
K
FJ
g* P6'
3
rD
El 6-ts \o
-E H IJ p o tl
p 0q 9) 0a
-. =F) g fd
;i. q 0)
tr
Ut o (D o) id Oo) n'
u, o TD sJ 9) SJ
$ oq o s)
3Y fD € 9J p F 7f o
l-tl
zo
p) 5pr v, o Hpr
(a F o Fl
tro 7f
o 0) u,
(a
g, tf 3a 9) u, o u,
7r F
FF q9,
$* g) $ r) ga € 1€
Ee. "P d F g s) 9) 5E
d n 0) o o o $ V) F DO sb"
Or(? 9) f') p) o ro v, 9J (D Fh H:
iD 2, o (D qq o
F Fl € 0) r-| 9l {-rr
v, €
bP 0)
p
ge. ; f.)
o
Vt
v,
.n
o o
(D
d
o o' F o
Vt -?- o
K
$) p o o q6 ;o n
9) g 3 \J
e?. "P p) gl 0) o =01
g) r) o +F
o 3 qq *8
EH' 0)
5 68. F o Fl
o od6 6F qq *-*t
ttr o g o g rn
cri o $F qq o 9)
F
5 o Ft o o 0) **qq
c) u, Ctq o { Ft u, d P6 cr b,
Ft 5FF 0, o o
€vt r: o o El
tF rf (oDq ffi
o cra oq o v'
o )-l 0) 5 -9 EE t-+
o
B o oqov, tr\
5 vt p v, v, o 3\**
IrD vt F r) tr fo \J
sqE € hl p o 6'
gJ F{ $) 9) ffi
.,'h 0) ; FN o 9) **x '"&f
O tEl F n vt 9 *J
HA) (-) j+ (a --T
F (D F TTJ g) (D t/l
$H ero
d €? ,ad o o rB
d 0) FO g)
vt o o (D ffi:
o oi s) 5 e -ts o o F g .9
$ o ? F.g wt
(D 5I'
:nqq v,
'jA o
9)
ro qq
o ; o
F
o
o o H"3
ffif r \ *5
I
Fl
H> € "d o 5 F Vt 5 !f+ hfu,t
oF) oa(D p) v) U) o g I E* f*
v, OA o clt tsl o g ntP ro
I
.rD a) F)Ft K 0) s)
& 6--'
v) qA H) F F ffi
o v, o n 0J o o p 3 o \o tlx :"
ffi{P
F (ttF ) H o u, qq o o @ Se
do gq (t) =. E) (D o o Eq3
Ft
o EX
F.o sJ o
o vp 3 g

o -(r, F g -F. 5 ru fl1 ffi\
F5 o
€><F v, oa o s) Fb
50 ffiJ
3 o d p 9J o
g€ g i ,
IJ z< (D
o
(t) oq p (r) o 5 5 Os) fl* ***{ ffiJ ru#
H*w Americanfamilics are organized
ffi* ru _3
403
W*rks
[-l*wLar:guxge

ElEE
EEiEEElgEFE
EFgIIEE
Ei
ge 8 rD
+*- q l: t-T
=
3[Etg
gHFF* f f r HaFf n €EilFgF3-3
=o-' beHE;ssF€dbE, F g r F g f; s E =F F *; s,
OJ
=E
. l -
5 i; a € 3
='0)i ;e 3 *: E: ! i
:^6: - - ) ro
- I
F9FgF$gEgiE.H 3
=. # -' qEF.ndFEl'Hss ssldlg'aEf3EEF rD
=?. sr 6-H-lg: E sq# E'$*[ErFg3'E
n
OJ
F 8 3 Bq il tE
:trG
$s#r1Fe$r3FH A E fl 1 $ a
-17
4
geEEr€g;a7*"s' geEi€aS5$F
si s sGi F1$€FF E F t Afi $ I H i; E E K s
-i oa
Fe.E
*:ifl€$;sI
4o $$+EgFn$Ffi$[ FEF3ggf
r:€ as€TsFgSIH$; F+1f; H.q,1aE E*kF H
-o srS6Essi"uEfiE Esfia;€tFf;EHHr;
; e # Bq
l F i =g € g gF
xn EFf;E$t€[EF;EBE
iri 5 ;6
+g$ils$ia€ici I A A E
pd g-p [ s a.H ;
X H =rD,-r:Ai =H
'trg [58
4,5
f [g* FE3':rr
5.r
8 I * g H fi 7 F E F E E F ]
EFHFE$ga*friYssFsc;raFtg$3
How Arnerica*familiesare organiz**i
4c6 How LanguageWorks

@ u) p) 6)-l n |: V F .
FtfD d (Di.+ ts F) q'fi
HtE € s 5 * o *r 5Fi s)
p
g
to o
p H€ s E F Xe s fi q $
*l FT 0r =E v,
E
t-t IsI g
(! o oq =.H o
H H 3.5 EigtEgr"dff;EF
(D
=9'o=du' 6 O
fDgOsJFr$g) t9
i$ s i aHFo p ! 4- 0 gB
fD> o H 9r
I Fl t 'i o
FU R6 F* oq (D
g) 5
n
s) g
id E
E +q Iga8FFr$r*t
F F (D 9; o $)
o qq vt P+d FF
I
F
f i i.3ni€ () t
sl
v5
"eEflgH EJ
qq
g
3F$itfe 0)
hl gq o
H) ts s) Fg s*
igIFEai$$F
o vr Eq' o oq
,* g C' .v, ro 5E T F (?
gq gq Vt r
E [ =: S Ft
o etr f 'E P"
F) 9J
E i':5 dE r
*P.EHsz6- o
g o
,f
(D
ed o
gl
liEE$
F3fr$ FrH$E€
Fl
16

o
d
o
-(,) 6# v,
g
o F'#
iqE++iF+€iH 5D
q8
5 F; I, E E.d,4 H) o 9) o
gs, ct I
q tr
oo aE -
5 5 qq 5 o
F s o s t+
o Ehl v, g rtE' fD
c) o
3qHsfi[i
:d;8TfI r-l o
FC'
o
o
fD
Fl
E5
o+
v6
$aI t
E
g

o
H:$:;
6 -=
qf ili;; f Er;i
=" N (n 0) b 3E p t H
g o !-r Oq a " o v, d gq d
g E, (a o B E FE.
tj-E g, r,t
EA Fr' ;
5 9,
? e E q x oo E)
ut o {
9J Z € lr o
F '(t o
F;3sqEI gq
g
9)
s) F
o
ds SFH
gs [ ' 3 ; r)
oq
fD
FlHs
IF$3ag
oq .
o 5
o Fl! o)
;:sFEqI Vt g)
o
Fl
o
lf Fil+E u,
v,
=
0r
gq
o
8s 3F g
6q
9o)
o
C'
o
0J
0)
ngEqfEE
E
=*g g'i'f ;B n o ?t,r tD
Fl F
q+F ? = o
7t
(D
o
n
I
(D
X
F' 5' qt
F)oaq
H

p
3
$*H
8F"2,9,
I 1:uEgFgts
F Effi +
F r< V,
g"sifF. o (D
(D F ntt
O) n
(') rD
U' g3 gr O. a
f 3?I A A
ig
€E+E€
E; P; 3 . = ! €- t €q- ; t = E] o
F-3 **
1FgIEIE
*=53-=i6A==

OT
-tl
7cl
ar}
:t E q# r} p
qF
tD G o, o 5 € vtU
@ st N w w
Fl
o p fD
+
rD
p
vtH *o o $ tr
Ei' 5 l.tl o (tl
H#
atD 5d
olO E o g s) p F)
g, HFh fDz o Fb
v, o tn I' hl E o o o .9 "9 3
oz Fh 5 tD
o z -St n (D o o\ Fl
o oo o (D o E FJ5
o fD P Fl u, 3 vt FO
r-t Ll Fl
H 0) o I o
t6 a o o o o o $F
9) o o (-) gl o
'--. ga F g) g tD FI 5
O E3 BE ct -l o o o .9 F)
E I u, .o'rg qqH
o
(a )-b $it g o Ft qa 9)
0J o oq gl
qH ki u) Fl fD i + z {
tsl r) tsl $tr
EF o lO
o F o tr E ts o o d Frl
,p .EO N o r) o, g 0) o S) oqI
3 o(1 6C o
o 3 ;. ts o 0a c) FJ 77', 9. rO
ot
o *A vt+ 5 0) c) F st ct s) v, E o x (o 3 Fl
.(/J o (D
r-l 5 5 gl ru !) F
l+) 0) 6F F ru o l.+ r-J
v, t) g
@ n o/ H (a o 5 o
3: S f E
F 5F H: F 0l it tg oa Ev,
\: 9] oq F0) g Fl FI: s) g o FI
O !.!' '15 F o p F d o 5 o 8g
g 3 9) o o @ hl hl o
g,
!t Ig) UX F oa o n o o 0) g
sl 9) gq g Fl t o 0) ils
ta oq
&E +ts
6q o K 3 d (n 0q € v, Fl f) to
.V o tEl r')
5 o F I
o) o be o P E Aq
(t, 5 o v) o 1 E
5 €01 s5 q t s 9J +l :s fD |!d
5 o o j5 o o =o
o E H 0) o 5 g 9l E qe"
7 d TE F g 0) fD o F o 3
o)o g, 9 -vt
g. F tD fD F
o vt oq Vt C x" f-j o g 5 g:€ ;6
o SJ Fr g P) o (D { o o hl tD )f.)
v, o Ut
OF p v, p o tD o n
0) !) (tt tr o v, 9) go xFt
Pl o FF . o) Hl
pt F-J
8 7oq oa F 5 € cl
o lo 'ou, t\) -v,
b" Fl o :- v, r) p g) g u, o
v) FI 0q g o o
v, g o 3
o o o o
P FtD
$.o 9) X 5 o g, 5 9) v,
cr p) FS 0J 5 oa o n b ov, 'F
o Eo Po go r-& o qq
K o p c) 7f o "8H u,
gJ o rr o o F t o
Ft o S) tr o o o fi=.
o Pa sl o F) x o tr { o
3 5 E' vl,i E Fi' ut 0l tr FU v) v g E Fq
ga s vt {: o 5 F w E 3 Ei
o ts gq v, o I' o
Ll F g 0)
hl
o
+l
w (D o Xo) b)o
Ig) o 0) rl. Fl g hl
ra
-6
ro ; H5 r) o t g)
OJ s) g5 iTi 5
cra o o aB o 0) 0) F o F n 5 Fl
9) oo
o t-l (BDr fu , $+ X gq 5 v, -ul F fD gg
v o € o tD m |o (t
oq 0q v, (-J ID F) 5
o Ur€ g6 3 0) o i oq
o!t 5 I F 9) I g 5 o gq 9) F S. .N s+
v, 5 OH f.)
o e. $ FI o 9) tg)
fo o o o r) t N
o 5 Ur: u, Fl U) @ , o € o d gq gE sq
o P o5 I Vt fD @ u, 5 g o
7l 89 F cr tr p P o FOJ
v, vr5 € t o v, € $)-u, 5
o 3
g) o FtIf o F) v, 6'8
f.)o) o P o llo o H gq
u d o 5 p) F
oor F) d € FI .9 s { a# q6'
o 5 oo o o o ii' o v) r-t tr
9J tr v, F S) FI I o5
g) FF) ga 5 t o o 3
$d F) o f.)
o + FO
o tD Fl 9J G q 9r E F vt 9) s#
Fl Fl
Ut r) o o o
F 5 ;s u, g 9) - o o hl 3 o >t FE
oa € @ o F) qed 9) P 0) fb $)r v tD H8
@ 5 hl p 3 F o
o tr ? o o 9) r) o F) o
5 c) 0) 63 {gJ o 5 ri
oq .HE cr ttr o o F 5 F d |.) Pg 0)
tD |D TI (DO. (DK K tsl 9) g { o) oo. v, o o o JP O.

407 How Arnericanfamiliesare organized


4c8 W*rks
H*w Langi,r*ge

ta*HEsi
dlissiEs
g E F 6'6 E H
"6*FtEl
E r F€ g F
g ?eB v''c'
BsgEf?
a#5l€ e
s$ sgef,
Ai iEs i
ff$6EH= ' 1
P € 8;
i*E dt?:
5 [ q : F.E
BEfEfi+
EsF.:sE
XE.€F;-
g5s l;r
1p Er f i
H*sBE+
35THi 13
iiIF n F
.:-;-;=t

g) r.O
- g)
S-1 t)
5 u, di Fo 59) tD 9)
9l 9J o 5
5 v, i. it o rc' o o F *T*
T {5e
aF o 9)e 8E F|.o qq
-z @ iiq 3 5
o ='d
oJ rfC FI
(D .xo
tr)
o t wF) Fl 9) ')Fb F rDfD aD hl a'3 0) t9) *"*"*
-(rt
g) 3 (t o
Ft 5 ga
oq otr 0J vt o oJ ;+ p :-'{ orE oa o
o $vt 0) o qq Fd ffi
(t) vt 5 >i
3 \J u) o
o Fo o qB6 !'o fDo f \**J
FJ
o UrF E' Oq 9)
s)g Fl
6o v) ut € Ov, 5 #!#@r
@ o *6- 5
o' p) qE rr'6 n=. o
rDtr o $o
BE or p)+ s v, 0) s o
ts r q 6 r-t O Vt
i{ts fDr. o9)
0 Fil F v) o. o o
o oJ)
g T o o
r+:
o rh >) € E *%
g oa oq 5 9r 3.F o vt
E ' +=.
oq p) g!?
ala og tD 5 tD
$] ga o 6' i' *%
0) OJ od6 #F rD
a !4 = tr o x |-1 9) 3B :3 ***d
5
-i
p o 0a cU) tror 9)
T qq pr F p) tDO otr cr €
6? 5vt g crq
9) Vt o tPo p :et t o
F' v, g ctO Fl ry
rD Frl crq =E S) o ?ti h'**
o oq hl
E$ Fsr ) oq5 $
I gqo o F
cpr qH oa F
o F)
(-j oq
o
U)
o
t H6 5 o$ tr o +o F6 $F o 0r
f) 9) o 0r
E(tt 'os, r) 6F rl) F I o
n x(/) JD Vt
F vt
9) o 5O oq {E s
Fl
o tr fd FJ g ' c J H6' 9)
E.F 's)
= oH (? r) 5 No .qo 0r 5
0) 9) 5 fDtst
n ; g o) gq oH. {
o
o 5
o
6'H
t'',, o
'o0)
.ct 5
-<:

r+. O
hl xo U)
E
t)
o i t -r,' fD
o
ctg
pr o
FJ
F{
o
H) E' tO
b-
ut
F'-
o)
5
ffi
ffi.
o o 55 9) 3 tq o a'H o 5
lt't 9J o5 U) g v, **
o o, tr Vt E ? 0t .:o 5
gJ
(r r+ 9J r)
o 10 3 E o H H (hI ffi
v, o ; 9)or 5 € o5 o
$be F fD 5' d' 9r o tro
,.lFI
p 9J' \J \"{
F{ v) !a v1
E'o o g.' oq oq X
n "dH a)
X o f+r =o tr s) e1 i; o 3; F' o tr*
o v, o (Jl +, 0)
F.t 0J 9r ,r 'oo g) k*
e+ (D -?d o SJ
o :o X o = v) Ut of) frs
9) '6 ts+: Fl oq ts.tr o E B t l

o ii vt H H a' rO E
o h&#
o +.+ € 5
F u)€ ? F
9' 'ocl) o H € Vt rD frl 0) 5' ;'r g Ost
5 ,m
€ n rfl A. r) ct
(n o o a N X ,tO o ffi -,il#-\
F)
{\"d}
5 r-{ E) o \?tD JD 5= g) Fo n
F oq r') )t) (D 0r
0) ,35 FJ n orH g w
oq o
>.1 tr d p 5 'g
g'ni o s?o k
gr E'O o u) tJl -{*F#
o v7 o u, 0. V, hl I
g< o *ffi
;? o *X
f\ --*d
$&
409 H*w multilingualism
works \J$ *p
410 Haw LanguageWorks

EEEgligiE*EE'iiE
t +E
5
m a. s5 56 '
9)
EFg v, =
0a o gq .g' 6'
IE s v)
? d6'o o rrO
OIH) g FrH)
5
5 o o 5
Flo
A
s="s H r v s =
r1g $$$E
d 9.
7
# =tr
t-
= - . F | .
Fl.
5 F
ga
c
ff $g *F*i F
f+Bg x6
;'o
Y F . SJ Efo
J | . { gq oq
'\, g
IigE
t7a _ d6 tr i;o-
ixv, sl 0)
€ J . + F .
G 55 v)
o
n
Vt
aieI+eg
F i;*rfilggE
=ffgF+s-HF6EEs;
IrI s5 0v '
n€
€ U) tJ
SB i o sv, n
F ! F '
o s,
Ut
o
3 fr r
ta$d
p) o
o
(,1 v)
o P-
|<\J
rx
?Y
-. o
o
o $
aleEi I+FEFEE
I$gI1+ggE 5
gq
v,
x 2E s
HD
5
fs*g[ [$F$iFE
F+!sri E$ilg C'
tr
@
i'8.3
gfr:E:FFItE
#HeEEFtE: 5 il$i
A3.S 5 v) T
oq
tr o 9)
c) V'
H8Q.',
i5 o, v' H H .
(
o
g$g g)
Vt
6 U; E
;*isiIisEIi FFF*gg
is'HEq** o
€ 8 a 0)

o d
59) 5 o o
p
o€P.
'6o)=. A (t) Hc*'l*1
[f f fili*[
€r E*uu T
E
0)
A Fl' i)
g)
ctc)
iEg iF b.:H1 r)
o
g
I
o I
ta Vt
Fr3
+ !? s" r) n !
PJ g)
5;F" rD o
fr?[EHlEalgIE€ o

411 l-"lowrrru lti ii nguaIism vr*rks


412 How LanguageWorks

r) cta r) tE Ct rTl O
:J) € itp) a" sl € 9ro o
o OF F' 5
qq
H*qa5gqe5
ds =o
te E
o, $ =o o () oa o BE;
EJ
t q -l 5E ts9) 5
J o
s'= }.t E
€ H Q€
o 0) FtrD v) P
= q o v\ fDH. 5 $ Fq'
FFa 5
[+[s Fi =[ +' sfi+Ftfi +
o tr Ut 5 H o €
v) oq FJ
J - \(
o q
85 9)
9ttr-v; g
5 qJ a o u, o
o
><
o oq
o tg) iJ.

Fq
5 tr 5 5
gl Y FfI
(D
o I [+
htfD
iagegaI $ gi s H3g $ i
v) drD U)
$=

o
o
o €EE
: F: HE H5 n ; E * i e f d il e {EEFd#11 +.os
d o r+; sE"o tD
p crq 5 9) E: f ; li s H e s: { E-
o. 9q i' v, 6 o
FtO
vt
o (a s3
r) 0) qAiHEtArei
_ii ga d [t 5
g o oH: o o
If,o)
gsfr'$iFE;.if
g5 vt H:F
rD (D
5
tg) Ft oa (a Ft(D pr 5 [:E :g:e-siFH'Efe'
o 5Fl uo o
o o 9r FSi;H
3s. Bd 5'8.3 q g*6
Hl OF 9vt
pr H g
=oa c F) o o oq E
'B 8"s +
5 9) o tr
.o d LOA vtO g) v, *E B
o ? $ o gq a
€ 6{
fB ^C 0) J? n
€= ; F3a f fi6 $
9
fE Lt
=
; sF€€ riH t {
it K u9 gq 5 9J H ifi
9) qB 3
sJ n ' fo FtD rD Fv, C'
=-fHit3iilAe
tt) ft)(n 5
i+fD o .) t, P & : F ' sf; flEfiEf;
5 9J fD9) K 5 g) (D 9X
€Ft
sJnn
Fln r) vt p 5(D
a) d o d6' sr sE H 3 HEHgFq;-c68Y+ts
Ff(D
= o v) v) XF{ o qa
3 A'tD iJ irH o
v5 F p t fD6 H:A$ F$E5+HH
x6 qa r5' F a F
r) 3
I,
tr
gr
s
o
ir Oq oa g €
9) F
o so o :B
*
z 5 qV E: FP-{qe
E[s Fr Ft * i I B
5 c 3= p V) PFr g sJ
v, gq 53
I !'5 F ds t1
5 tr o + E ' o o AE f, iEF*HH+qfiE
; r9 f IA
d
r,D
F1
n
O

v,
o)Ft
H9J
o
v7
5 I B..:F; +frf [;
EiEn
IEi
H6 n vtH gq5 o o
5 o '5 7f Ft P;-"
83H [€F*u?a ggH-aa6lgsE
f6 5 rd o;+ (n ,^
9e FJ gq Fl
; oa n o 'o t =< >r
= -(/r 6 o t I F
oJ v) E' 0) o F) o €;Eegg#€s3
(D r) C' Po. 6r3[sii
'g Q.t: n v)
ct F F I d T + ] E E ts E
fD O.
0) o p o t) fD (t) H"-E tro,
o O .ni n FrpJPJ
o st 6' 0) n o Ut (D
;(^ o
= ; 't-i .;_ 5 v, gl n 3H1
= o e(AG
= € =- :
fea*iEi 3i ?$iEE;e
<
FiTE: ig r=*5EEB';E

$l
; (! g F E F t r \J
=
E H
o 0) |.t Fl
t!t
g 6 ' B q . # \J
D Ed cr 'o (')
fi t5 n OFI s' E.a' 6'E o
F *fi $Ft K 0l o v) v'g"P
= 6 ,-l o o 50 E5-JDOs) S)
d tro o E' l* ;+o f)
5r+ E 5
H v, 0) fD 0) TP+H.
Pg. g E'Y.d a 3 e6;;E
5tD FtA!.{ ut (D o o-5 0)=, rD Tt'-r6g-ja
fD
3 SF =u,
o t-. )*, n Ut xFl
m Fl n oa 5(D0r gq
o F'1
t(D5 Pi.i. E . d 6 9, e, g3ge d
0) a dd ^ E S 8 = cq'
OJ 5p) o (JFiF
t) 8* B s cr gq oq 9J Fni E + E I
o Ft()
Ct
Fvt ge) gl o =
F. Ut o HE= tD
9) ito i'fD ,f o
1t 6' f, 8. 6 2 F B
tr Vt
7< E
o; oqs
H Fg €8.
g.p,E ga
o
d
3
o F P g r-t ctg ga
0)i) 'f6i " 3
.;€ o FI
g8 .ci
F . ' B" a (D
v, o 9 o o o r) c
s9 p5oa ito Fl 0) € o o
F srg E O.X |.1 3 _rt o OJ FI
o gl oF+ n € F6 SJ 99 ct = g;F o
68 Aro:: o o ga o hl ;J.
9) rdE $F 6g oxo s< 5 v, g. .HEr >t as. r)
fDo oo -c/J o P) F . ;9 # 9J
g 89" IJ FF (t H.

o rur5 it5 arH.V o Sl (D


E8
o" u!- oaln(?q)
H H ctB o o v,
o q6 =v, hl X 'O) o
9d hlo
r3 9iE^g
.r >i r-l ; r].
(D
rd. (D
o V)H r-l o o ;E r 0)
rv) d
/D. .1.r 3
fDFIn 5v, oq F)
hl
6trD' sr
€ vt oJ CT OJ g) o (D qq €5-o
5 o qq H"* E3 $) ai F
5rf nrr qa r.) o E ,, B = o
vt elo oa vt og
Oq Fr €u' 9r s 5.9"R3
o=.A o
v) hl:
-c/J e pr sr o FI*.U n H gFq !
m tio (D
H ol+) irO gq oq o
u, oo o
p. c)o o (D o E'E:g+ ,-t
0J fD OFaonr s)s) l-t o ,-l
5.8.8 FJA
FI e.B 9J f) € ?t) OE oa ;,i a'
v, to EF f)
o g n
F)t
€ o
o
0)=
qqo
o0)
lF
OB
8- rE
o
IFg
*e,g O.J-
o n
o 9r
{ o 9$Fr
o
o *E E vt
Elss
Y F t | : . H .
5ou'F
y J+
ct
F Fq
Fl aF* E5' fD F I - F }
H
r) gr-'o)
xE H€ u) Fi 9J Ut 9. 0t A P r-i tr o r 0J
fD Or{ v, C' 6E 6-F: F)
E) ii lH rr /o) o
sd I 9) 0) o ! r-l ct q5RE.
o (o ;ts rr Ft Ir FI g8 r.)
5 9) 15 v, o I
!t 0r vta 0. 9) o
Fi
vt
9J [i
*s
(! L5.
fDi+ K o'
0a
g6: =.F E 6 E' 8 0"
o F fS s13 q -r= n $ a.Lt n
oq I'5 o c' oq
E 9 { o
o =.9' Aoa o o 0) 5E.il o E a,F# tsr*-a
gt
tr ? q E,"*.E o
9) 5 o () OJiJ ts E'9 it r'.1
oa sEq o) Fb p EHg g,J6FJ
OJ (? H$ 5=e 9. ;- o o o
s+A vrdS o gi{s S) 5v,
oa oH gt o 26
n }( )ut q s8 F) o v, cr o
o,a rDn hl hb
9q rD :S H. 6p
F) 'SJ o (D 0)
0) v, ct o vt
FE 9#
oq fD i +E nto o o. 5.$E ct
o v, o* 0r o a {o &SF6 o
+FgI g u, o FB. E. cr (D E:O
f 6 d.:
413 H*w multilingualism
warks
i-'{owLangu*g* W*rks

ggtIigg
ggg
ggatatgaagrgagg-
-
FsEss;
?f1lg€eeElg$EEE
agua E
ggIEEEaEtgatggIi
G f'altara
oo)c(DF €
9J EFtr5o)
F) dY56' r) $*
s) 7\i c* !e! P 9 6-3-r
€ Fl
o qg.8 E
v, o OJ
oa fD rY.,o
v,
(D o
F.ET'
9)
v,
Tgs F*
o 3sro)
u, tr x ;- 1s g.o o F . 0) *.5 t
E S) 6 =F |D 515
o vrii$F-F) vr@=
oq rp g tr6 g ct ! [F+
oa o o F;|l=lggo o
Fl v) o E e'y-
v, A at ? gR
Vt
o E o H 2: V)
FE X
t{'P
r) 7+;9tr u r . o Fl
o o {
€ X.+r 6
v J - H 1
tr 50
v)oH:
H . - r J = r.)
a b v' G a.+
o $5S'i;'E' @
o OJ F-F'E'3l' EFE'
n
9J o g rEH
o f.)
E l"e q F)
n r+.+d 96
o 9l
dEs r) tJ l{
vt ilqd A S o ;A rJ
19
o d' o F
!-. t g H.
. u - $\ . H o YOq
9) utnFt $>)9.
o
hl
v,
? € : . " , ' 5 N ' +( D
=5 0 x s) € d ' 3 .
o o ttr s iP
vl
o o H S.:F
ct
t-
g E.H
$=!1
Fl
Ft
F Eg€f
or'<Roa
qq gq R dx 2; rEe'
T
q oord
g) ==?= 5' o (.)
qENF T . H Ft i-i
qq 0J HJ
rJVA!

0) vt 6ErFi fo ots=
o 5
9) (D o 9Pl-
0J g;l6r
r) o F
n qsd
.) o
0) -. o
:r 6-
3€ t E?i
".d6
s R#
415 l-"lowmultilingualismworks
4t6 F{*w Languag*W*rks n@
*K
*-% ffi ***fu."
*-r-r*3
frr fln
w ffi w
wrfi{wlB
aO
v) t
{3=-
=oF
,il''..*
mttirwws+rr}
; #FleEeElFHli$I$HeE ffi
5
-fOit
H'S k4
p)?o
i5Ff
'-
ffi fl\1 lW
orH Md
t- 4
X5 *.****$*
al
LI
ts(
gEIEEEFEgIiIFt ffi
iJiJ
rl
E E'E € E
ru rry\
6M
-
o)
l-l
ffi
J
M J
l-{ M*
fl$
ffi
VY tr\
t - -
-g)
0J
**w ffi \#
ta *"d
-=
$ $ 3{ H ffi
ar flT\
aiaui*uiFEt$iEEgtl%
r&d ffi
H.
fis"ry"
F"

F
-rO
;EF' ffi
ru
EIgE+EI[g$El$€ElEI *%1
#
O(+
J a i

l-
l+t[1fi*i[ ru ffi
€?- h\

FT
1 - . -*
L J

t',to a
gl
On
Ft=
(ng
++
A1 -'
EIEEiTaEEEIE1-i ffi
r</
Jl+
a

'Ae :
?=
.1
=
d; -t<r

F aI
I,I$EEFEE[IEEIIa
EIEEFIggEElggEI
r*EgIEEEiIE'EF 417 languages:translatethent
fi*w we c*pe with r'!?#rly
Works
How Language

f: rt) gJ 9) v,
E'O Hl
o (Dvt 5 Fl K
EFl
p) () FI' E 0) F o
F oq n
H F
*6 ca
$* $ g
} J h . , J P 5
t,
H-l
q8
"6
{
o Fl u,
oq, o) o o x ' g a s) t') hl Fl
s is i a+* e
3 P 'r) o z< op o 5
= G o AFf,8 K o) X9" hl
1 E
= 9
. o* F
o ha
A SI t - *
>)g r{ V, o N
tsrn F ro o r
F t)o) E+ OJ H)
9) tD i'+ DO €g
ts.E-H
oa vt
He 3 B
gl" Fr' r,rO vt o 0l
EE[[F
5 9 r v, F) ; t tD FI
t+ o Se o E o
-l+ Ea -o q9. o v, o t
OJ sl d
6o
o
p
qaTi
F E'96
Ft
oq
o
€H
E.p EE s) (a
o -o
d
fD
g
6I,H
I*E$eEgl
lataIait I g
,! 0) 9) F
98 FI (tt
TE Fl!i 9J
o9) n 0l xrd p 3
BE E.i o
?H
ov,
oFl
F
gq
F
!d
fDO.
dv,
fD19
v,
0l o o 3
cilsIBiE€
v,
-tD
O 'r
n
0J Oq
Fg5E
f) r+ '+.
9)o!'p @
9)
E.B
gH
t* o
r)
o 3
o
(,)
Fl
EEgAF+aI
Ff: fD gJ -vr' o o a rD F 5
Vt
F \t
s€$$r I Fg
5. s) -l s+ oJ -('J
ur@ V5
p -(/J
EFqq;:ff3
Fl o)FF
gr
ro.
F)
Fl t{
cJ
p B$H$ o :io
F.X
H'6
FrD
o
s)
f)
o
4
0)
o
Fb

[{EEgi
rFilrT;ge$
vt= pJ Kr.+ o
g FIqF*a$sT 3.? H E
vt 0J fd
E
s
)'ts
#! I a 5
FOJ
v, o o 5 {9)
F pl Fl
nv' 9) F| sgJ_€E*qs
90, giFs o
*E € o
Fb 0, g a *
ll: q
f"'
Ft gl Sd o
5 : ;BE #
3€sgftrI
qd o Eq T o Ft u, trr .1 a
Fl
Fl ", OHr o v,
(")
B*FaAHqq
30 p $ 9r- 3 X Fl
FgE f f ? 3s *
aI
Frg o E
x vt S) o d
FO
35' nl
F
vt
r s€s
ssgS v,
.ct
gl=
v, l-
Pfi'
q4
3
f6
v,
d vt
o
F
FF}iIFg
Hg gl g) o o $gs*iIBI
rfD F'd u, o F
H S.E $ roo =; H! v,
o.9 o
Ft
oo N 9J
R g,og o . t (D Vt n r)
oi vt o
=t<H)fD o dd d Vt r) c)
o) g) 16 o o E
sE f) H 5"Ft go E) o
a = 7 3- F o
g$f; 1[rE +gEf q s 'i *
(Do. (D: L; ' o- rDFt
o =.-J o o
-v) O(n-- I t+
z = € qe.
:1 :
o'
nt'
T
j-+
=
tD $E+BgggF : +sr t * +$
o t4
= IB ft g
= E : i i =: E:HPEi€ i 9

=
') r-t'
p ET t: o
gr tl F
|.rl
-t
!' o !J FI
(D Fb d x U' F
cf:r Its -\J
t > d rt |! o s g o r) g
o fD
it I H w v,
o 0) fr
o H F
€g o (lt
Fl p F) Ff-) d tr o oa vt
FI l- g) Ft F. o x o Fl o
v o o a FF G r+
AI
Y
A

vt
Fl
o
- Gn
5 F
r+ o
o
o
F.l
)
o Fb p p ta
H H
FJ Fl
l.ti
th
v,
g) 5
(t)
ff F ?
n)
EFf E o
rf
5f II
& tt 0J F. r{r 6
@
o o
o o 5 gr o g
0, $ n t F) iD d o ,F Vt
+ fD g
F .ca o F o o cJ (.) s et F p
Es; =
J
o n 16
3 o (D E
Ut
o
Hl p o r) P65'*
v, \J Fl o p E n ga
|3 s sr o Fl f) p € -c' { 0J o
g) o F) 3 x $ F,l 0) hl
s)
|!|
a u, cr (? F o o o o q
F o o v, { o -ur 9r
a E (D o fD 13 o o o
v o Vt o o F) FI
, E v, o v) o 16 FI 5 Vt f) (D 33E€
- C v) to g u) It o g) 3 r: rtt
o 9)
t'& 0 0. F) s, E o (D rD r) v, 9J F o, OJ o -9 ttt
t g, o OJ n. tsh (D
'-t vt (a tD v) (.) tFI s 9r n fD Eq F F r.t
F o
- o (D a 5
g tD
tD
hl 0, (D
9)
fD
g ? Vt E fD
Fl ta ,t F a 5
€ a'-c3
' H -
x0)ofD
fD o o .(/l
tg)
a v, € (D Ja 5 C' g o o (.) =' 't,
o F n ct 5 3 o t y
et, { 5 f') o F F o. g fD vt
o a) 9r o o Fl f.) o C' to
.o
r {
Vt
o tD g) 5 o o v, o o o FI
J -9 o F 5 F u,
E 0l
q !t
E)
u, g g. (D 3
FO
v, 0) Fl
p -u, Ut t
d o 15 cr o 5 H'.F
T g
o
r*)
Fb Vt V) ct o S oq n
F o 5 o v, X o $) rD oa
Fl
OJ
t S) d E tD o o FI 5.
E
o hoo
0)
o
v, E Fl
F) p Vt
tr gF:.F
{ r) o € o o X tn 5 9J g) rt, v,
J o n o c) t-t: 0r 3 s p 7r fD o p)
fD
_(/) o{
.9' o (D 9J o fi o 5 o 9) o
t .ct K n o OJ hl gq r)
5 o { {(o
F o g o v, \J o o
o o o gJ r) (D rD
v, o X gr tr o 5 F o o u, o o o 9J
eitr$
o F s ts o EJ F F X
gJ Fl f € 3 s fD 5 o g o o o
r-t u)
o o 0l g Fl
TE H #
6 v, o g) A' 9) |D g) (D F o
o o o F t.) F 9) o,o € o c) oI
F
{ n Fl v, { o oJ p v) 0) o a
T CA r| O. o o
Ft g) o o ]-t Ut o I o o F
OJ o
o ct H H 0l
Ut
o
o tC' 5 o v, sJ p o o F
u, rJ)
E iF fi
o vt 9J 3 -u, 5 3 s 8F.FF'
ra ! o o 3 o 7t Vt o g) s o qq o n
f (-) o n u tr o 3 gr FJ cna rD 0) O. F ro o
Fb 5 9) I E'lt E'
(D F o a v) Ut x
o gq tr tr p n o (a E) 4 5 o
qt I F vt o 5 o tsll
F F g o $) t5 oq o (a o 5
9) -l o v) ? J gr oa r) o 5
F. A. 91 f.) 0) s
{o o o crq
o or JD r) € I o to Jf.' lE S 3
P Ja 9r 5 E) o 5 0r o !
(D I o 3 FO tD 5 ,.o S) qq o z; v, Ft r) ts Fo
ct o rD ga g 9) v, o gq p)
@ FI F{ o t v, o 0)
d s _?l F u, fD
tr (D 5 (D o F o n (D u, ct, n
o ttt i-a E o gq l+j JD Ut 9) Fld
e lE g
ct 0) o o o o 5 g 5 F rD
o 0) (D r-l Vt o o 3 o n o v n o o
5 o o
(rt 5 v't o o € u, o 5 (D o ? (: p
F F 5 9J S) ctt fd o q o
oq qq v, fd 5 o rD 0) (D
9)
F v o F JD { o o
9) o o ga n o Fl:
Ut
ts tr +:
V) 9) E 3 o T -j t-l p
9J F) tr -
4 6
(,
9
J
IJ 9 P
n a I
Ef
+ fr t- o
(a
I g1E
::99 n g;
(n
i U n 'J g f,
6 oo 4 al 5
p r-l 0r {, o a H. H I
o o o o o o o o I g g FI Ff I o p o 6 5 ri F F K I s 5trL
How we copewith many languages:translatethem
H*w Lang*agnW*rks

1+ ts' $0) F) v) oa o
r_( \./ rD
v E) g) qq 50
-t o o tD
oqF EFfT + g 5 { 6i6 + TE F *
=)(D to =5
-l hl 0) =. v, o
qq s. o u)F =. oq RE: o q
='dFl F V)
Ft F+ o 5 ; 3 ;.* t I F a s E
'or9H <
X JD - o tf F) 9H EF*E-
r-f gl ho o € si .o
xg. a
16 or 0)
0l o $sffl : H [E 13n H i i P i 3
;':; 8 wFo 0J
Foo
tA sO J' E
o) o 9) no) € o 5.d
J crD 5 (D rt
rrrD o 5in 5 5'6'TE
=' s v, S
--oo \J3 o6 (b){
Og) F Ooa
. ? 5 F l : I
;s) r n o rF*FElEIlF
I
- ! F t :1 5 tJ Ur. 5 siH
r_f)
rD
U) Ft "'
€ 6.r o
:i' 5
E*[* r3 EsggiFF
:rT o tD 9J utY o = -"
\ t -
TD
-'^ 'O
H i5cgt
F H' u; ;, ' FF: E'; f i E f;
I!v) 6qq
-t1
v, OJ
+ tY Ft ; Ell i.
ir-\O sr F v, v). rD =a
tjl
A t v
r+ s th
Fi
s 5 ' qlgE
EF
afr'Hr s=' tE q EoEq "E + Hs f q
rD;o =ooe-
* ; \J pgAd
F|l
= .
g, 6 E- t gERF d
(h 3 DO.
!-,t o o s)
ero ta
- J F o ijo ;-r 5
0)H 3
\J 5 5 A
Hr F. 5d 5 llo
tr o C 0) F o
+ L 5E E E T g As $ *
=
)
v, t 9 l.t
O EH tr
- o E F o
'.rE
EF$ [f F
3I E r t g;
t4. tv g
:f3 z d Vcr 5 o a6 E 5' a 'fi
F o o q 0) -5 2. o
=6F' goo .J o. v$) vrO
5

0r t9 0J o
Fl o
4 6- o .5' N 9)
ilTE.fiEEH'5ss;
J' V)
F
o >d
ho b;*qr;.E[$€
+ t6 o bR o to
i v, o v, F 5 5
= \ <
lJ) g) o ol
AT
5 !-b
=' 9r
Y X oq
JD i<
ts.o
Fl
o
Fh o
x
6'q
ft,s:H
[8 B',q
Hq€$Af if rE*
o o
ta Vt 3 o'
i5p. o ?.H
N .J
s) ,-. i6v) fi t [fi $ r E s H"t
^q9 H. gr
-o 5 F IF'tr9
ts o tJ) F) (D 5(! g:
;Fv' tD fr Fi;
ga o F
(a d F Edg
+r[E a:
- T o €+Fn
9rDt) pJ rD
'-(tO 9r ; e6 V)
v Fd
A .-r()
H.
o
E
9l
o
Fl
nFr
FF
qa 0) a 6'
tsEIngTfBg
v H . o g:f o t-h (D
(r) F $ Ea:
tn d 9r v)
- '5 oa oq o 9)
9) o n g) /.
*tq H
o o
cfD
(t)
tn {o
-(/r rD Ut
r: 3€gfrE3
J r - ( i N o
i-r
^r JD =d
g tt7 T
o.o
l-
O.
[:tsF o.
xX:a o
g[ E*FE
'u-
w -- XHHE 3 il Ef F
a f = € X
= =a
€=i?
=: : =
= E i:i?53:iE:
,=G= .9 sg;5

5' :' (}
-| vt
0" -l 0) =
r+l \t(D
f! I
o p) dg ' g 3 , tr o, n
3 5)
g F€ H3
$ (D ?a o ht o f1 n
, v, ts g 6 qE '-X o d E)
Q
FtrD
3 Fo. 9) a u, +
t 5 tt7 o =
d o f) 5 o F F ;io
PJ o 5 vt V) o !l)
= v) vt r..t) n o 5'E i+!' oa ' X € It
a v o g
ht
t)
€. d 5
s) qa AF
S)
;
9) o S) 9) € ()
0)
F
oq HE d
6o .o
o
= # 3 F 3fi
' - ! = = F { rD a
t, "CJ 9) f') o g? o ='o
o o' o o rD f) vt 9J p 5 5 ,E:T:F
V / ' g. x S) (DH
{ =b
5
FT o o) R 8 U) ESgtr=
?CE ctt g t 3& F(! o
r) o 3 AS)
. : A
o { (| € U)
s) o oo o r-l Vt n i: Ft o OJ o gB
o o o (D g sJ
rd=H
- 9
0) hl Vt ov2 o v,
o { o s" g)
- F . it =
JU, (n (b fD o o gq .) o o r)(t 5o 5 Hhl o p H 6' 15 $ if
'7_ Ft

You might also like