Data Driven Banking
Data Driven Banking
Contents
1 Introduction 2
4 Regulatory Aspects 10
4.1 Data Governance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
4.2 Regulatory Compliance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
7 Conclusion 19
Authors 19
Bibliography 20
Introduction 2
1. Introduction
The pace of development and adoption of new tech- industry internationally is shown by a survey conducted
nologies has accelerated in recent years. Companies by the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance. Their
can no longer delay the introduction of modern tech- report shows that 85 percent of financial institutions
nologies but must react quicker in order to be able to already use some forms of AI in banking (Cambridge-
maintain their position in the market in the long term. Centre, 2020).
Two key future technological developments that busi-
nesses will need to respond to are the increase in avail- However, financial institutions are not among the pi-
1
able data and advances in artificial intelligence (AI) . oneers in the field of data analytics and AI but large
Both trends have already received a lot of attention in technology companies such as Amazon, Apple, Google,
the past years and according to several studies will con- Meta and Netflix. They have harnessed these concepts
tinue to have a significant impact on our daily lives as to be amongst the most valuable publicly traded com-
well as the global economy. panies in the world. The established financial institu-
tions, in contrast, are lagging behind, even though they
According to PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), AI could
have been operating in one of the most data-intensive
contribute up to USD 15.7 trillion to the global econ-
sectors of the economy for decades. Yet several drivers
omy in 2030, with USD 6.6 trillion resulting from in-
exist that drive widespread adoption of data-driven
creased productivity and USD 9.1 trillion coming from
banking. A visualization of these drivers is given in Fig-
consumption side effects (PwC, 2017). Data collected
ure 1.1. First, technological developments in particu-
by McKinsey & Company show a similar picture. The
lar influence the use of data and corresponding anal-
potential annual value of data analytics and AI across
yses to generate added value for banks. Three of the
various industries is estimated between USD 9.5 trillion
most relevant technological drivers in this context are
and USD 15.4 trillion, with the retail, consumer pack-
developments in cloud computing, the emergence of
aged goods and public and social sectors driving these
open financial ecosystems and the already mentioned
values. The results also show that the banking (po-
advances in artificial intelligence (magenta layer). In
tential annual value of USD 1 trillion) and insurance
addition to technological drivers, data governance and
(potential annual value of USD 1.1 trillion) industries
compliance with existing data- and technology-related
are expected to benefit from these technological trends
regulations are also considered important influencing
(McKinsey, 2020). A great future potential of AI is
factors in the application of data-driven banking (dark
also confirmed by Gartner. According to their assess-
green layer).2
ment, the plateau of certain AI technologies will only
be reached within five to ten years. Data analytics and
Only by taking into account technological develop-
AI are expected to further grow and be used to also
ments and the regulatory environment can the poten-
determine essential connections and insights, to help
tial of data-driven value creation by financial institu-
predict demand for services and to detect the chang-
tions be fully exploited. Depending on the application,
ing patterns of customer behavior by analyzing data in
the added value can be generated through concrete
near real-time (Gartner, 2021).
use cases in the levers for cost reduction, risk reduction
The fact that AI not only has great future potential but and revenue expansion (blue layer).
has already been able to gain a foothold in the financial
2 Note that social and economic drivers can also play an important
1 For the purpose of this white paper, Artificial Intelligence (AI) will be role in the implementation of data-driven banking, but are not
understood to include Machine Learning (ML). specifically discussed in this white paper.
3 Data-driven Banking
Open Financial
Cloud Artificial Intelligence (AI)
Ecosystems
Data-driven Bank
Figure 1.1: Drivers and potential of data-driven banking. Source: Own illustration
The rest of the white paper follows the layer structure described in more detail. Subsequently, specific use
in Figure 1.1. After an overview of the current state cases for banks are derived and described for each of
of data-driven banking in Switzerland, the aforemen- the levers to improve business success, i.e., cost reduc-
tioned main drivers, technological and regulatory, are tion, risk reduction or revenue expansion.
The State of Data-driven Banking in Switzerland 4
4
Data size
0
0 1 2 Today
3 4 5 6 7 8 9The10
future
11 12 13 14 15
Figure 3.1: Big data and information overload. Source: Bloem et al. (2013)
Technological Drivers for a Data-driven Future in Banking 6
infrastructure and data management system that col- • Transparency and collaboration between institu-
lects and stores data from various (internal) sources tions and cloud providers with regard to mea-
and uses computational power to process the data. A sures ordered by the authorities and the courts
key difficulty when dealing with big data is to separate • Choosing a cloud provider and its subcontractors
noise from signal. Figure 3.1 illustrates that the propor-
• Auditing the cloud services and the cloud infras-
tion of irrelevant data in relation to the relevant data is
tructure used to deliver them
expected to grow in the future as more and more data
is gathered.
The Swiss Bankers Association (SBA), the banks indus-
The three main technological drivers of data-driven try group, has worked with member institutions, audit
banking, described in more detail in the following, can firms and providers to draw up a set of guidelines for
help financial institutions generate maximum value the use of cloud services and to help banks migrate
from data. their data to the cloud more easily and securely (Swiss
Bankers Association, 2020a). The main reason for this
3.1. Cloud was that there were legal and regulatory uncertainties
that needed to be clarified in order for banks to use the
To benefit from data-driven strategies, the data pro- cloud in a compliant manner. The working group has
cessing infrastructure must become more open and focused on developing a legally non-binding guide as
accessible to allow flexibility to integrate and scale an interpretive tool for practitioners. Uncertainties are
new banking product and services. New requirements rated as high or hindering migration to the cloud in the
can no longer be met with the traditional on-premise above four areas (i.e., governance, data processing, au-
model. Migrating large parts of IT services to the cloud thorities and proceedings, audit). The clarification of
is an integral part of any digitization strategy. The the regulatory issues in the guide allows banks to act
undisputed advantage of a cloud strategy also requires quickly and flexibly and provides pragmatic and secure
a comprehensive cloud governance as well as new skills, solutions. Even with this guide, the assessment of the
and offers the opportunity to strategically reposition risks of migration to the cloud remains with the indi-
the organization (Burger, 2019). Leading financial in- vidual banking institutions. Therefore, each bank must
stitutions such as DBS (Hire Digital, 2021) are already decide for itself to what extent and with which provider
transforming into data-driven organizations, largely op- it wants to use cloud solutions.
erating in the cloud.
A representative survey of the Lucerne University of Ap-
Swiss Banks are following the trend to the cloud with plied Sciences and Arts, which was conducted as part of
caution. So far, they have been reluctant to migrate the IFZ Sourcing Study 2022 (Blattmann et al., 2022),
their data, especially sensitive customer data, to the shows reasons for and against the use of a cloud infras-
cloud. However, a development can be observed re- tructure. The main arguments in favor are the available
garding the shift of the operation of the less criti- software and functionality (71%) and the low prices
cal environments (e.g., the development environment) for computing and storage services due to easy scal-
without customer data to the cloud, while the actual ing (43%). However, the data storage abroad (71%)
production environment continues to be hosted on- and perceived insufficient data security (46%) speak
premise. against it. In addition, the survey shows that for more
than three quarters of banks, IT (77%) plays the cen-
Four areas are of critical importance when it comes to
tral role when it comes to moving banking services to
migrating banking solutions to the cloud (Swiss Bankers
the cloud. The management (43%) also plays a signif-
Association, 2020a):
icant role when it comes to bringing the topic of cloud
• Processing data on bank clients in compliance into the bank. This may have something to do with the
with banking secrecy fact that cloud computing is now no longer seen merely
7 Data-driven Banking
as a way of optimizing costs. Rather, cloud computing end customer, who receives a financial product or ser-
is becoming increasingly important as a technical com- vice, as well as the providers who operate the front-
ponent of future business and operating models. The end to this customer. The third layer describes those
study concludes that the time has also come for smaller providers that are finally responsible for the execution
and medium-sized retail banks to look into cloud com- or settlement of the financial products or services, as
puting, and that quite a few banks seem to have more well as the custody of the corresponding assets, while
or less concrete ideas or plans for shifting workload layers four and five relate to the technological infras-
to the cloud on the table. One reason for this is that tructure and the handling of data by these providers.1
cloud computing is also becoming increasingly impor- In open financial ecosystems, all five horizontal layers
tant in connection with open financial ecosystems (e.g., are to some extent interconnected via an API environ-
open banking), another technological trend with impli- ment (lines shown in magenta), which in turn defines
cations for the Swiss banking landscape. the security of the system, its compliance with legal and
regulatory requirements, and the certification and iden-
tification of approved parties.
3.2. Open Financial Ecosystems
Open financial ecosystems can take various forms, with
Open financial ecosystems are a trending topic in bank-
the opening up of banks often being subsumed under
ing and describe the leveraging of seamless API-based
the term “open banking”. In general, open banking rep-
interactions between financial services providers, as
resents a development in the financial services industry
well as non-financial firms and individuals for value cre-
that allows players to share financial information elec-
ation. In general, open ecosystems can be understood
tronically, securely and only under conditions that cus-
as systems between interacting organizations and are
tomers approve of. With regard to the architecture in
enabled by modularity and complementarity proper-
Figure 3.2, application programming interfaces (APIs)
ties (Hakanen, 2021), with data as the main resource.
allow third-party providers (TPPs) like FinTech compa-
An architecture for structuring different manifestations
nies to access financial information efficiently, which
of financial ecosystems is given in Figure 3.2.
promotes the development of new apps and services.
The architecture distinguishes between five different 1 Formore information on the architecture, see chapter six in the IFZ
horizontal layers. The upper two layers represent the FinTech Study 2021 (Ankenbrand et al., 2021).
Ideally, open banking results in a better experience for ready a number of platform providers covering a range
consumers through an improved customer journey (see of APIs for payment initiation, account information ac-
Figure 3.3). cess and wealth management services, among others
(Ankenbrand et al., 2021).
One of the first regulation-driven initiatives towards
open financial ecosystems was the Open Banking ini-
tiative launched by the UK Competition and Markets As a survey of the Swiss financial industry shows, how-
Authority in January 2018 (Open Banking, online), fol- ever, the local banks do not yet feel much pressure
lowed by the European Union’s PSD2 in September to open their interfaces to third-party providers, even
2019 (European Commission, online), which makes the though there is perceived potential for corresponding
opening of certain data to TTPs mandatory for banks. solutions, especially in the area of payments (Anken-
While these regulations do not apply to Swiss banks brand et al., 2021). In order to promote the success of
directly, it still is a strong motivation to adopt similar open financial ecosystems without the need of issuing
concepts and open up to corresponding standards, as corresponding binding regulations, there is a particu-
the benefits of connected or integrated banking appli- lar need to incentivize the participation of banks that
cations outweigh the potential threats like security risk hold large amounts of financial data and to reduce ex-
or loss of control. In order to create good conditions isting barriers. In this context, banks see the greatest
for a market-driven implementation of open banking benefit of open financial ecosystems in the simplified
in Switzerland, the Swiss Bankers Association has pub- collaboration with third-party providers, for example, to
lished a set of guidelines for implementation already in leverage specialized analytics capabilities from experts,
2020 (Swiss Bankers Association, 2020c). and the potential for an improved customer experience,
while significant effort and cost as well as a perceived
One development that is emerging in the context of lack of standards and security related to APIs are the
open financial ecosystems is the trend away from in- two biggest obstacles (Ankenbrand et al., 2021). In
dividual API-based collaborations between financial in- summary, however, it can be said that Swiss banks still
stitutions and third-party providers toward platform so- have a lot of untapped potential in the area of data ex-
lutions for a large number of market participants. This change with third-party providers, although the prereq-
can also be observed in Switzerland, where there are al- uisite for its use would actually be given. Improved data
Reviews
Research
Digital Value Chain
Review/ Feedback
Customer App Developer API API Team Backend
Support/ Return
Use
Figure 3.3: Customer journey in the digital value chain. Source: Google Cloud (2022a)
9 Data-driven Banking
availability and volume would provide an expanded ba- growing number of Swiss FinTech companies, which act
sis for harnessing the potential of data-driven analyt- as suppliers to the established financial industry, that
ics approaches, for example, through the use of data- use AI (Ankenbrand et al., 2022). However, only a few
intensive methods from the field of AI. of them make it a critical element of their strategic
planning. Given the high pace of innovations in the
3.3. Artificial Intelligence (AI) field of AI and the aggregation of data through initia-
tives like open banking, the significance of AI for the
A further change in the technological environment in Swiss financial industry will further increase.
general is the adoption of artificial intelligence in al-
most every industry. The leap in technical possibilities What needs to be in focus is developing AI applications
driven by AI research lead to a variety of new innova- that solve important problems and ultimately help cus-
tions and business cases. The main factors behind this tomers in their day-to-day financial lives. In general,
process are innovations in the field of deep learning, there is large potential for AI and other advanced tech-
the growing amount of available data (e.g., by open fi- nologies to empower people, widely benefit current and
nancial ecosystems) and the accessibility of relatively future generations, and work for the common good.
cheap computing power (e.g., via cloud computing). AI applications need to be assessed, also from a risk
The potential of AI in finance is estimated to add USD perspective, against the following objectives (Pichai,
1 trillion in annual value, of which USD 660 billion is ac- 2018):
counted for by traditional AI (e.g., clustering and basic
1. Be socially beneficial
regression) and around USD 360 billion by advanced AI
2. Avoid creating or reinforcing unfair bias
(e.g., neural networks) (McKinsey, 2022).
3. Be built and tested for safety
On a global level, a considerable number of banks are 4. Be accountable to people
already applying AI, as a survey by The Economist In- 5. Incorporate privacy design principles
telligence Unit shows. The most common use cases are 6. Uphold high standards of scientific excellence
listed in Figure 3.4. According to the survey, the major- 7. Be made available for uses that accord with these
ity of banks surveyed already heavily apply AI for fraud principles
detection (57.6%), optimizing IT operations (53.7%)
To create ethical and unbiased AI solutions, banks can
and digital marketing (50.2%) (The Economist, 2022).
adopt a number of best practices. The following con-
siderations can serve as examples:
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
4. Regulatory Aspects
Financial services providers in Switzerland as else- 4.1. Data Governance
where need to carefully consider regulatory aspects in
their decision-making and continuously adapt to their There are many advantages to sharing data. However,
changes. Switzerland’s regulatory framework govern- due to the often high sensitivity of financial data, finan-
ing financial services activities consists of various fed- cial institutions tend to be reluctant to share them with
eral laws and implementing ordinances (Ankenbrand third parties. The potential value of data sharing must
et al., 2021). Two legal frameworks in particular are be weighed against the implications for customer pri-
the focus of interest as of November 2022. The Swiss vacy, data security, and control over competitive data.
Financial Market Architecture consists of the Financial New ways, e.g. privacy enhancing technologies, offer
Services Act (“FinSA”) and the Financial Institutions Act a possible solution to this conflict of objectives. These
(“FinIA”). Both FinSA and FinIA entered into force on 1 new approaches enable the protection of sensitive data
January 2020 governing the provision of financial ser- at rest, in transit and in use, which can reduce concerns
vices, offering financial instruments and the respective about data sharing and strengthen or, in extreme cases,
licensing requirements in Switzerland. even replace trust in institutions.
Figure 4.1: Comparison of data protection cultures. Source: Swiss Bankers Association (2020b) with information
from Axon Active
In parallel with the data strategy, the Commission clients’ financial data in particular play a key role in this
published a communication entitled “Shaping Europe’s regard. It is important that Swiss banks are not at a
digital future” (European Commission, 2020c) and a disadvantage in the new global competitive environ-
white paper on artificial intelligence (European Com- ment of the data economy. A regulatory environment
mission, 2020b), in which the Commission sets out how that allows the benefits of data use to be optimally ex-
it intends to support and promote the development and ploited while at the same time taking the correspond-
use of AI across the EU. With this work, the EU has laid ing risks into account can help position Switzerland as
an important cornerstone for the future design of the a haven of security and trust.
European data economy, underscoring the importance
of data and artificial intelligence for the entire econ- Whether financial services providers rely on the pri-
omy. The EU’s ambitions are high and the timeframe it vate, public or multi cloud, the data hosting infrastruc-
has set for itself is tight. It will therefore soon become ture and control framework have to satisfy regulatory
clear whether the many words will be backed up by ac- requirements by the Swiss Financial Market Supervi-
tions. sory Authority (FINMA). FINMA defines the supervi-
sory requirements applicable to outsourcing solutions
There are no comparable regulations in Switzerland. at banks, securities dealers and insurance companies
However, due to the high level of integration of the in terms of appropriate organization and risk limitation
Swiss financial sector in international banking, it must (FINMA, 2018).
also adapt to international requirements and, if possi-
ble, align accordingly. FINMA does not prohibit customer data to be held
abroad (Walder Wyss, 2019). The Swiss Banking Act
doesn’t differentiate between domestic and foreign.
4.2. Regulatory Compliance
However, up to now banks have predominantly stored
In order to keep its capacity for innovation and compet- data domestically and prevented it from being ac-
itiveness as a business location high, Switzerland must cessed from abroad. In practice, there is often a mis-
make use of its growing wealth of data. Banks and their conception among banks that the moment data is pro-
Regulatory Aspects 12
cessed or accessed from abroad, banking secrecy would contains requirements for an appropriate organization
automatically be compromised. The Swiss Bankers As- and aims to limit their risk. FINMA circular 2008/21
sociation takes a different view in its guidelines for defines CID (client identifying data) as customer data
cloud use by Swiss banks (Swiss Bankers Association, that contains personal data as defined in Art. 3a of
2020a). One of the main issues is to ensure that unau- the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP) (FADP, 2022)
thorized parties cannot access the data. There are and makes it possible to identify the customers af-
also legal opinions that state explicitly that data can fected.
be stored and processed abroad provided appropriate
safeguards are adopted (Laux Lawyers, 2019; Walder
The existing regulations in Switzerland do not prevent
Wyss, 2019).
the outsourcing of business processes, for example in
FINMA Circular RS 2008/21 Annex 3 regulates the reg- the area of data analysis, or the storage of data in the
ulatory requirements for handling electronic customer cloud (even abroad). The prerequisites for data-driven
data from banks and securities dealers. For these, it banking would therefore also be met for Swiss banks.
13 Data-driven Banking
ID or passport Biometric Biometric Check address Check contract & Yeah! Done
identification identification transmit information
Select your identify- Check and validate Take photos in The address is Accept legal framework You are now a
cation document (ID the document with different poses to checked by conditions (AML, AIA etc.) using customer!
or passport) and scan a fake check and verify that you are comparing it with a confidential signature system. Your account is
it. read the a real person. the address data of Your data is stored and verified open and ready
information using the Swiss postal directly in the system via a core to use.
NFC. service. banking system connection.
Figure 5.1: Account opening process screenflow including KYC. Source: ti&m (2022)
would recognize a match with the victim’s stolen • Step 1: Generate data using bots: Setting up a
document. fully automated search bot that scours search en-
gines for a specific PEP, generates a dataset of
• Step 4: Address check: The address is checked by
relevant public information.
comparing it with the address data of the Swiss
postal service via a simple API call. • Step 2: Analyze data using AI: Artificial intel-
ligence is used to check the generated data
• Step 5: Sign contract digitally: Accept le-
for controversial content and verify whether the
gal framework conditions including Know-Your-
search hit is actually related to the person of in-
Customer (KYC) information (e.g., Anti-Money
terest. Whether a person is tested positively or
Laundering (AML) or Automatic Information Ex-
negatively can be done either fully automatically
change (AIE)) using a confidential signature sys-
(considering the ethical aspects in Section 3.3) or
tem based on a trust service provider (TSP). The
in combination with a human expert.
data is stored and verified directly in the system
via a core banking system connection. A digi- These introductory examples show that also very
tal signature replaces the classical signature on customer-facing processes can be optimized using
a contract. data-driven approaches. These automations are inter-
esting from a banking perspective, particularly because
In addition to customer onboarding, there are also of the potential efficiency gains, while customers also
other data- and AI-driven opportunities to reduce costs benefit, for example through an improved customer ex-
in the area of screening (potential) customers. For ex- perience.
ample, banks can install automated processes in the
area of politically exposed persons (PEPs) to screen
5.2. Use Case 2 - Risk Reduction
them for critical reporting in public sources, such as on-
line newspapers. Such a process could be implemented More recent FinTech-based banking approaches do not
in two steps: completely remove the human element from banking.
15 Data-driven Banking
At some point in the client relationship, there is a time tion of different scenarios for the development of the
where a personal interaction is required over the phone relevant drivers. Scenario analysis is highly relevant for
or in a branch. Such interactions are normally around risk management in banks. Typically, it involves highly
the sale of new products and services, and usually with complex, large-scale simulations that generate billions
some background checks or risk assessments involved. of data points. Traditional on-premise hardware solu-
These essentially still manual processes can be sup- tions have limited capacity, which is why such scenario
ported by data-driven practices to optimize risk assess- analyses are very time-consuming. With a cloud infras-
ment on a client-specific basis. tructure, such data-intensive risk management can sig-
nificantly accelerate decision-making. Potentially valu-
One area where data can be used to mitigate risk is in able input data in this context could be, for example,
the lending business. Banks currently use a number of the following information (Sigrist & Hirnschall, 2019):
techniques to mitigate the credit risks to which they are
exposed. For example, exposures may be fully or par- • Financial performance indicators from balance
tially collateralized with cash or securities through se- sheets and/or income statements
nior claims, a credit exposure may be guaranteed by • Repayment history
a third party, or a bank may purchase a credit deriva- • Loan characteristics (e.g., amount, maturity)
tive to offset various forms of credit risk. In addition,
• Public data (e.g., from social media platforms)
banks may agree to offset loans owed to them with
• Data from third parties such as credit bureaus, in-
deposits from the same counterparty. Non-financial
surance companies and/or government (e.g., tax
companies also continuously monitor and analyze their
filings)
credit risk exposure to avoid potential counterparty de-
faults. Besides assessments by rating agencies, credit In addition to the advantages for the bank through
default swaps are commonly used financial instruments optimized risk management and the resulting opti-
that provide information on the creditworthiness of a mized allocation of available financial capital, data-
counterparty. However, the underlying pricing dynam- driven credit risk management also offers advantages
ics often remain unknown and demand further investi- for clients, for example in the form of more accurate in-
gation (Roeder et al., 2022). Moreover, such risk mea- terest rates based on their individual financial situation.
surement and hedging tools exist for large companies
but are not available in the context of small business or
5.3. Use Case 3 - Revenue Expansion
personal loans.
In addition to measures on the cost side, optimization
For such kinds of loans, in particular, data-driven meth- on the revenue side can also have a positive impact
ods can be a key concept for identifying and quantify- on the business success of financial institutions. Rec-
ing potential risks and can therefore be used to support ommendation systems are a well-suited tool for this
and justify credit decisions but also as an early warn- purpose. In general, a recommender system uses the
ing system for existing loans. Although some banks al- process of information filtering to predict which prod-
ready use such methods, they tend to be rule-based and ucts a user might like and rates the products according
therefore poorly adaptive, especially in times of uncer- to the user’s preferences. While such systems are al-
tainty. The use of dynamic and self-learning methods ready widespread in other industries such as entertain-
from the field of artificial intelligence can further in- ment (e.g., “people who liked this movie also liked that
crease the forecasting accuracy of, for example, loan movie”), there is still a lot of untapped potential in most
default probabilities and thus improve risk manage- financial institutions.
ment at banks. If a scalable infrastructure is available,
a wide range of internal and external data can poten- Specifically, recommendation systems can be used in
tially be used for such modelling, including considera- banking to provide existing customers with additional
Use Cases for Data-driven Banking 16
Week 2-4
Set
Define goal Identify functional Design Build Run
of stage deliverables success solution Validate
environment retrospective
criteria
Bank & Bank & Bank & Bank & Bank & Bank & Bank &
TPP TPP TPP TPP TPP TPP TPP
The incremental creation of such MVPs and their scal- such cooperation, but also gain relevant experience,
ing and linking ultimately leads to the realization of the build up internal competences and get used to a new
vision of a data-driven bank. culture of innovation.
One obstacle for many Swiss banks to develop such In general, the technological and regulatory conditions
MVPs and thus to move towards data-driven banking is for a transformation to a data-driven bank would be
their limited innovation capacity in the IT area (Anken- in place in Switzerland. However, in order to practice
brand et al., 2022). This can be countered by work- data-driven banking successfully, Swiss banks need a
ing with external partners. Such a service is offered by fundamental change in mindset. The often prevail-
various providers in Switzerland, typically with strong ing compliance mindset, which in many cases prevents
IT competences, and usually includes the entire pro- or at least slows down innovation, must give way to
cess chain for creating specific MVPs in a short time a technology- and data-friendly culture in order to be
using specialized teams. Banks can therefore not only able to exploit the full potential of data-driven banking
achieve quick successes in data-driven banking through within the given legal framework.
19 Data-driven Banking
7. Conclusion
The present white paper aimed to analyze and discuss Great potential in many areas of the banking busi-
the drivers and potential of data and corresponding an- ness model. The application of data-driven banking
alytics for the Swiss financial sector in a structured way. can have a positive impact on the business success of
The core findings are summarized in the following four banks through three main levers. First, concrete use
statements and theses: cases, such as fully automated customer onboarding or
checks of potentially politically exposed persons, can
Comparatively low penetration of data-driven bank- reduce costs for financial institutions. Secondly, busi-
ing in the Swiss financial industry. Most Swiss banks ness risks in banking can also be reduced through the
have not yet explored deeply into data-driven banking. use of data-driven insights, e.g., in the area of lend-
This is despite the fact that the potential of data ana- ing through more accurate default predictions. Thirdly,
lytics and artificial intelligence for their business model in addition to potential improvements on the cost and
has been generally recognized by bank representatives risk side, the revenue side can also benefit from data-
in Switzerland, as existing surveys on this topic show. In driven banking. Concrete applications such as recom-
order for Switzerland to remain one of the world’s lead- mendation systems can help financial institutions to
ing financial centers in the future, the industry must, increase their revenues through up- and cross-selling,
however, continuously and dynamically adapt its busi- higher conversion rates and lower customer churn. But
ness models to the changing environment so that it re- customers also benefit directly, for example through
mains competitive in the long term. This increasingly better personalization and customer experience, lead-
requires the broad and consistent use of data and data ing to higher customer satisfaction.
analytics, as is already common in other industries and
is also more and more practiced by the Swiss FinTech
sector. Just do it. Due to the perceived high complexity and
long implementation times for data-driven banking,
Technological and regulatory developments are smaller banks in particular are discouraged from ben-
pushing banks. Important enablers or drivers for data- efiting from its great potential. However, the trans-
driven banking can be found in current technological formation to a data-driven bank can be done step by
and regulatory developments. The former relate in par- step with an organized approach, also in order to con-
ticular to the slowly emerging transition towards cloud- tinuously gain experience. An approach via the devel-
based IT infrastructures for Swiss banks, their opening opment of minimal viable products (MVPs) in cooper-
to third-party providers via open financial ecosystems ation with specialized technology providers is particu-
(e.g., open banking), as well as the continuous advance- larly suitable if the required competencies are not avail-
ments in the field of artificial intelligence to generate able in-house. In a short period of a few weeks, this
new insights for banking based on internal and external can already produce initial results in certain use cases
data. Relevant regulatory aspects in connection with that the bank considers to be particularly value-adding,
data-driven banking relate in particular to data man- which in turn can serve as the basis for further devel-
agement and compliance, which, like the technologi- opment in the direction of a data-driven bank. The
cal requirements, cannot in principle be seen as an ob- banks should simply dare to take the first step, because
stacle to the use of corresponding approaches by Swiss the necessary conditions are in place in Switzerland, be
banks. they technological or regulatory.
Authors 20
Authors
This white paper was prepared in collaboration with the following individuals who contributed in the form of text,
discussion, document reviews and other forms of feedback (in alphabetical order):
Bibliography
Ankenbrand, T., Bieri, D., Frigg, M., Grau, M., & Lötscher, D. (2021). IFZ FinTech Study 2021. An Overview of Swiss
FinTech. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://zenodo.org/record/5109653#.Y1AJtnZBzZt
Ankenbrand, T., Bieri, D., Frigg, M., Kronenberger, T., & Reichmuth, L. (2022). IFZ FinTech Study 2022. An Overview
of Swiss FinTech. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://hub.hslu.ch/retailbanking/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/2022/
03/IFZ-FinTech-Study-2022.pdf
Ankenbrand, T., Dietrich, A., & Bieri, D. (2019). IFZ FinTech Study 2019. An Overview of Swiss FinTech. Retrieved
19/10/2022, from https://blog.hslu.ch/retailbanking/files/2019/03/IFZ-FinTech-Study-2019_Switzerland.pdf
Blattmann, U., Buschor, F., Estermann, F., & Ettlin, J. (2022). IFZ Sourcing Studie 2022. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from
https://drive.switch.ch/index.php/s/n3QZPfyCqFmzYxT
Bloem, J. W., van Doorn, M., Duivestein, S., van Manen, T., van Ommeren, E., & Sachdeva, S. (2013). No more secrets
with big data analytics. Sogeti.
Burger, K. (2019). Assurance according to ISAE 3000 for ti&m hosting. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://news.ti8m
.ch/blog/en/Assurance-nach-ISAE-3000-f-r-das-ti-m-Hosting.html
CambridgeCentre. (2020). Transforming Paradigms – A Global AI in Financial Services Survey. Retrieved 19/10/2022,
from https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/2020-ccaf-ai-in-financial-services-survey.pdf
European Commission. (2020a). A European strategy for data. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://ec.europa.eu/info/
sites/default/files/communication-european-strategy-data-19feb2020_en.pdf
European Commission. (2020c). Shaping Europe’s digital future. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://ec.europa.eu/
info/sites/default/files/communication-shaping-europes-digital-future-feb2020_en.pdf
European Commission. (online). Strong customer authentication requirement of PSD2 comes into force. Re-
trieved 19/10/2022, from https://finance.ec.europa.eu/publications/strong-customer-authentication-requirement
-psd2-comes-force_en
FADP. (2022). Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP). Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/
cc/1993/1945_1945_1945/en
FINMA. (2018). Outsourcing – banks, insurance companies and selected financial institutions under FinIA.
Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://www.finma.ch/en/~/media/finma/dokumente/dokumentencenter/myfinma/
rundschreiben/finma-rs-2018-03-01012021_de.pdf
Gartner. (2021). Gartner Identifies Five Emerging Trends That Will Drive Technology Innovation for the Next Decade.
Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2021-08-23-gartner-identifies
-key-emerging-technologies-spurring-innovation-through-trust-growth-and-change
Bibliography 22
Google Cloud. (2022a). Customer journey in the digital value chain. (unpublished)
Hakanen, E. (2021). Ecosystems and anti-rival goods – Greetings from project ATARCA. Presentation at HSLU.
Hire Digital. (2021). How DBS Made Data Its Culture. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://hiredigital.com/blog/
how-dbs-made-data-its-culture
Laux Lawyers. (2019). Use of Cloud Offerings by Banks: Admissibility under Art. 47 Banking Act. Retrieved 07/12/2022,
from https://www.lauxlawyers.ch/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Swiss-Banking-Secrecy-and-Cloud-Computing.pdf
Molenaar, C. (2022). Demand-driven Business Strategy: Digital Transformation and Business Model Innovation.
Routledge.
Open Banking. (online). UK’s Open Banking to launch on 13 January 2018. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://
www.openbanking.org.uk/news/uks-open-banking-launch-13-january-2018/
Pichai, S. (2018). AI at Google: our principles. The Keyword (Google blog). Retrieved 05/12/2022, from https://
blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/
PwC. (2017). Sizing the price. PwC’s Global Artificial Intelligence Study: Exploiting the AI Revolution. Retrieved
19/10/2022, from https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/issues/data-and-analytics/publications/artificial-intelligence-study
.html
Roeder, J., Palmer, M., & Muntermann, J. (2022). Data-driven decision-making in credit risk management: The in-
formation value of analyst reports. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
S0167923622000410
Schroeck, M., Shockley, R., Smart, J., Romero-Morales, D., & Tufano, P. (2012). Analytics: The real-world use of big data.
Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://www.bdvc.nl/images/Rapporten/GBE03519USEN.PDF
Sigrist, F., & Hirnschall, C. (2019). Grabit: Gradient tree-boosted Tobit models for default prediction. Journal of Banking
& Finance, 102, 177–192.
SNB. (2022a). SNB Annual income statement. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://data.snb.ch/en/topics/banken/
cube/baerfrechua?fromDate=2010&toDate=2021&dimSel=D0(ERZ1,WBZ,BEZ1,ZDK,ZDH,ZDF,ZAU,ERK1,KWA
,KKG,KDL,KAU,ERH,UER1,ERV,BER,LER,AOE,AOA,GAU1,PAF1,GEH1,SOL,WAV,UEB,SAF,GER,AEG,AAU,VRB,STE
,EGV),BANKENGRUPPE(A30)
SNB. (2022c). SNB Securities holdings in bank custody accounts, by security category. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from
https://data.snb.ch/en/topics/banken/chart/bawebekatach
Swiss Bankers Association. (2020a). Cloud Guidelines. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://www.swissbanking.ch/
_Resources/Persistent/a/4/f/b/a4fb72f65d7f039abe516a40a078554523c31f90/SBA_Cloud-Guidelines_2020
_EN.pdf
23 Data-driven Banking
Swiss Bankers Association. (2020b). Data strategy –the path to digitalself-determination. Retrieved
19/10/2022, from https://www.swissbanking.ch/en/news-and-positions/news/datenstrategie-der-weg-zur-digitalen
-selbstbestimmung
Swiss Bankers Association. (2020c). Open Banking: An overview for the Swiss financial cen-
tre. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://www.swissbanking.ch/_Resources/Persistent/8/8/2/8/
88286724aa4fdc3dd8bb8ecd9b9c0d7af659a803/SBA_Overview_OpenBanking_en.pdf
Swiss Bankers Association. (2022). Swiss Banking Barometer 2022. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://publications
.swissbanking.ch/banking-barometer-2022/
The Economist. (2022). Banking on a game-changer: AI in financial services. Retrieved 19/10/2022, from https://
impact.economist.com/perspectives/sites/default/files/aiinfinancialservices.pdf
Walder Wyss. (2019). Permissibility of disclosure by Swiss banks of bank client information to agents in foreign countries
under article 47 of the Banking Act (BA). Retrieved 07/12/2022, from https://www.walderwyss.com/user_assets/
publications/190216-SBVg-Gutachten-Auslagerung-durch-Banken-V020b-EN.pdf
Wu, C.-S. M., Garg, D., & Bhandary, U. (2018). Movie recommendation system using collaborative filtering. In 2018
IEEE 9th International Conference on Software Engineering and Service Science (ICSESS) (pp. 11–15).