PS 114, by Drshukuru-1
PS 114, by Drshukuru-1
PS 114, by Drshukuru-1
Political Thought ii is the course which will enable the students to understand and realize the
political situation in the past and the contemporary situation. Students will be able to examine
how the politics was it since the occurrence of socialism in the world in west Europe and the
non- west Europe
MAJOR CONCERN.
Topic 1: Socialism.
S t. Simon
Fourier
Robert Owen.
Karl Marx & Engels: dialects, class struggle and Marxist economics
Page 1 of 23
PART II: CONTEMPORARY TRENDS AND POST-MODERN POLITICAL
THOUGHT
2.2: Conservatism
Edmund Burke
Habermas
3.4: environmentalism
• Green politics
3.5: anarchism
Mikhail Bakunin
Albert Meltzer
Confucius
READINGS.
Page 3 of 23
Ahmad, H. M. G. (1996). The philosophy of the teachings of Islam. Islam
international
Alan, W. (1981). The supreme identity. An essay in oriental metaphysics and the
Christian religion
Curtis, M, eds, (1981). The great political theories: vol 1, New York, harper
Collins publishers.
Curtis, M, eds, (1987). The great political theories vol 2, New York, harper Collins
publishers.
Marx, K. (1867). Capital: a critique of political economy. German, verlag von Otto
meisner.
Russel, B. (1945). A history of western philosophy and its connection with political
and social circumstances from the earliest times to the present day.
Page 4 of 23
Sabine, G. (1973). A history of political theory. New York: Henry Holt and
company
Socialism emerged during the 19th-20th century. Socialism was the result of social and
economic result which brought about positive and negative changes, also the impacts of
industrialization was the major concern for the outbreak of socialism in the world, for instance
mass unemployment, poor working condition, dispossession all of these influences to the
occurrence of socialism. Socialism was also involved peaceful movement like humanitarian
movement, philanthropic movement.
UTOPIAN SOCIALISM
In 1930 the term socialism was coined for the first time. The word utopian socialism was coined
by Karl Marx and Engels to refer the group of socialist scholar who did not considered
themselves as socialist. Utopian socialist did not believe in class antagonism
SAINT SIMON
Was born in Paris in aristocratic family
Page 6 of 23
Fought in American war of independence
Founder of Christian socialism(1825-new Christianity)
Dissolve Christianity and life of the society
Desired on unindustrialized society
Believed that “all men are equal” and to solve the problem of the poor one should
develop the spirit of association coz it eradicate egoism, antagonism exploitation
He developed:-
Labor value theory
Class struggle
The nature of economic crisis
Need for communal ownership
The role of proletariats
Page 7 of 23
ROBERT OWEN (1771-1858)
English socialist
Owned factory industry(text industry)
Instituted industrial program likely to put socialism in practical(tried to put utopian
socialism into practical)
Believed on social welfare or workers
Believed that “man’s character is the result of many circumstance which has no control”
Argued that “in order to develop proper character a man was to be placed on proper
environment”
Believed that all religions are perfect b’se reject exploitation( all religions are in flow
b’se they offend exploitation)
Proposed changes(as his ideas) like:-
a) In industrial place there is the need for having education
b) Universal health care
c) Evening classes to adults
d) Restricted child labor
e) Advocates life of working to mothers (pregnant mothers) like reduce
working hours, give maternity live.
Scientific socialism is the method for understanding and predicting the social, economic and
material phenomena by examining historical trend through the use of scientific method to the life
Page 8 of 23
KARL MARX(1818-1893)
He was a Germany philosopher
Developed the idea of socialism which was the foundation of communism
Considered his theory as a plan and motives for social revolution that should free workers
from poverty and exploitation
His major books were;-
a. Das- capital ( a capital)
b. Communist manifesto
c. Origin of the favorite family, private property and the state 1884 by
Engels
MARXIST THEORY.
MAIN ASSUMPTION.
1. DIALECTICAL METHOD.
Is the way of establishing the truth through reasoning method argumentations (dialect
materialism?)
Page 9 of 23
Tries to attempt the origin and development of the society from the materialistic perspective.
Thus in such a way the distribution of wealth in the society was dependent on what was
produced, how it is produced and how the product was exchanged. All social changes and
political revolution are thought not a result of human brain. Refuted the influence of religion coz
religion and moral cannot be countered as materials rather religion it is the tool used by ruling
class to ensure exploitation. History is the foundation of any science
4. The role of the state, the state is the tool of those of you owned the major
means of production. State is for wealth class and not poor. State is the tool of
exploitation b’se it is favorable to ruling class but not the ordinary people. If the
revolution is attained there is no need of having a state since things will be owned
communally
5. Class struggle
LENIN THEORY
Social political system called Leninism
Was inspired by Karl Marx and Engels
The one organized Bolshevik revolution (1917) and leader of Bolshevik party
First head of soviet state and the first leader to undergoes scientific revolution in eastern
Europe
His major books were:-
Task of proletariats in the present revolution
Imperialism, the highest stage of capitalism
The revolution organized by Lenin ( the October revolution) was against duma revolution
or regime (merchants revolution)
LENINISM
Is the adoption of Marxism to non- industrialize society. It was from there when
he drafted the term imperialism which has significant features
MAO ZEDONG
a) Chinese communist and thinker
b) Founder of PRC (People’s Republic of China)
c) Was influenced by the ideas of Karl Marx and Engels as well as Russian
revolution of 1917
d) His political philosophy called Maoism
e) He wrote the article which was presented in term of lecture and was in
contradictory form. According to him to understand the philosophical problem
one should be able to understand the contradiction which exist within the society,
thus he explained the contradiction by using philosophical problem.
Page 12 of 23
LIBERALISM
It is the philosophy which concern much on liberal ideas. John Stuart mill
is considered as the father of liberalism. And according to liberalists a
liberal man is the one who believe on liberty
JOHN STUART MILL
He was an English philosopher
His philosophy concerned with liberty
Believed that man is the product of the society
Provided 3 types of liberty which are possessed by individuals and these liberty must be
organized and respect that are
I. Liberty of thought and opinion, freedom of think and provide the opinion freely
without the interference
II. Liberty of pursue and test
III. Liberty to join other like-minded individuals
Each of these freedom neglects the notion of the society complies
OPPOSITE OF LIBERTY
According to John Stuart Mill the opposite or opposition of freedom of individual is tyranny or
dictatorship and he was provided 3 kinds of dictatorship which limit individual liberty in politics
as follow
Tyranny of one or few by over many, it is the oldest form of tyranny. Individuality of
individual is limited and denied by one or few individuals who are dominant over the
many individual
Rule of many over one, it is the tyranny of majority over minority. Individual freedom is
denied on the basis of numbers. It is danger on democracy. Ideas and value are always
belongs to majority and not minority
Tyranny of customs and tradition, customs are always high implies to human
advancement…………..
The glory of humanness is the weakness of each individual where by every person a complete
individuality and personality of its own
In order to enjoy the personality of every one there should be a freedom
Mills was against the conformity principle
Believed that individual decision can originate as a value of liberty
Defended freedom of thought on three way
Page 13 of 23
No one can claim pastorian truth (truth is multiple)
People have half-truth not a complete truth
Even when your…… your truth should open to change
Provided the harm principle, this is the only way in which you can interfere individual
freedom
THOMAS. H. GREEN
British philosopher, political theorist
Born 1836 and left the world 1882
His major popular books were
o Prolegomena (published after his death 1883)
o Lectures on the principles of political obligation
Concern the relationship between a man and nature
Believe that man has a self-conscious (liberalism is concern with individualism)
“For an individual to fall on his conscious he or she must be free from external interfere”.
Thus he need fences to protect the freedom of thought action
The simplest mental acts involves consciousness of self and distinction between the self
According to him to know about the matter (something) is too aware of relation between
objects
Any action of man is defined by hid will
Reasoning of action reveals (indication) of one’s own good
Political institution is the results of society moral ideas and they help to develop the
character of individual citizens. It is important in the society, the form of modern estate
Page 14 of 23
HOW TO ATTAIN THE JUSTICE
Justice can be attained through social cooperation and these cooperation should be
regarded as free and equal
PRINCIPLE OF JUSTICE
Justice has 2 principles that
Each person deserve equal liberty
Social and economic inequality are stratified two condition
i. To be attracted to office and position under equality of equal opportunity
ii. They are to be benefit of the least advantage member in the society, should be
recorded at essential statistic
PRINCIPLE OF LIBERTY
1. Should be part and parcel of political institution
2. Applied primarily to economic institution
CONSERVATISM
Reaction against political and economic changes. Changes occurred include the French
revolution
EDMUND BURKE
Supporter of conservatism
His idea found in form of speech (reflection on the French revolution- his book)
Defended glorious revolution
ELEMENTS OF CONSERVATISM
o Believe in gradual change, human rationality is limited. Ability of human to reason is
limited. Decision making approach rational comprehensive and incrementalism
approach- the science of muddling through, mixed approach
o Traditions or wisdom of the past
o Pragmatism, against abstracts revolution was involved by astracts and not practical
o State and religion, religion is the source of all good. Religion shape the society (burkes’
believe). Religion is the active tools for control human being. Not believe on the
separation of state and religion. By nature human beings are religious animal you cannot
separate human from religion
o Natural rights and rights of men, equal rights and not equal right of things
Page 15 of 23
AMERICAN CONSERVATISM
Occurred to emergence of New Deal by President Roosevelt
POST-MODERNISM
JURGEON HEBERMAS
Most scholar in western political thought
Born in Germany (1929- present)
Influenced by the failure of national socialism in Germany (Nazi ideology)
Aim to understand atrocity and policy of national socialism
Known for developing “critical theory” and his writings are interdisciplinary combine
sociology, philosophy and other social science
Hebermas did not provide the full meaning of the theory instead critical social theory
viewed on the ideas of earlier Germany philosopher like Kant, Marx, Hegel, and weber.
Major aim s of critical theory is to understand ideas such as nationality, modernity,
autonomy, freedom and human happiness are connected as a society changes
Hebermas analysis tried to establish a link between agency (an individual) and structure
(culture norms) within overall historical evolution and social change (structure)
Democracy is still possible to maintain itself and also develop a new form (Hebermas’
believe)
TYPES OF COMMUNICATION
Page 16 of 23
i. Distoted communication, involves psychological impression
ii. Language and verb
iii. Reasoning and action
iv. Ideal speech, for every speech there has the right to listen and argue
v. Public fear, it is where social and political aspect take action
FEMINISM
a) Fourier was the first to coin the term
b) Feminism, is a believe in social, economic and political equality of sexes but not gender
TYPES OF FEMINISM
1. MARXISM FEMINISM, theory focus on class and this class are determined by
economic structure of the society. When Marx develop the theory of exploitation did not
consider the reality that even within the society women exploitation differ (the way
women are exploited by those bourgeoisie are different). In capitalism women were not
allowed to own the properties because it belongs to their husbands. However in capitalist
system women worked at home cooking, cleaning the house, maintaining the garden,
planning for the family. Marx did not consider women in the analysis, whereas the
Marxist feminist put the housewives in the structure of capitalism (criticism of Marxism
feminism from old tradition feminism like Rosa Luxemburg). House wives are vital to
capitalism and in any capitalism, women are vital in industrial and any economy.
Moreover, during the depression it is women who are most suffering. Marxism criticized
family as the source exploitation and oppression and proposed that “if the women works
for the family she was supposed to be supported and when she is dependent should also
supported”
2. RADICAL FEMINISM, Emerge from women conscious rise truth special in America.
Rise conscious by introducing issue focus on gender like pregnancy, childbirth. From this
theory they developed “theory of gender inequality” which goes beyond to
discrimination, oppression and gender polity. According to them the source of all
problems is patriarchy system. Whenever men and women are in contact there is
exploitation and oppression of women which is possessive. Radical feminism argue that
patriarchy is very hard to removal or eradicate because of its root whereas conceived men
as superior while women are inferior and provided the features possesses by men like
coolness, objective, addresiveness, emotional control, competativess, control distance
(these features plays no roles or advantages rather brings disadvantage like source of
poverty, conflict, rape, child abuse)
While the features of women are cooperation, reciprocate, fee and natural, attain to
bodies. For women this values are good because limit persuasion, intimacy, warmth,
Page 17 of 23
caring. To them believed that even men can develop this values if they are mothered.
They argue that men are likely using physical violence to show their superiority
PROPOSAL OF RADICAL FEMINISM
Women should stop having sex with men
Women should form their own groups like university, institution, academy
Page 18 of 23
Tradition of concentralizing human affairs that originated by Prophet Mohammad S. A in
17thcentury Arabia. The basis of centralizing were two which are the holly book (Quran) and
sunnah. These two provide the way of organize justice community. The way of organizing the
community led to:-
a. Justice (achieved through reading hadith or narratives, Quran, subsequent political
test)
b. People (umma) or community
c. Struggle (jihad)
THUS, throughout the history Islamic thought has (aspects)
Modified
Incorporated
Challenge (Jewish law, Arab custom, Persian state craft, Hellenistic philosophy or
ancient Greek philosophy, Christian theology, European and American culture
Islamic political theory includes multiple discourse. Contemporary Islamic thinker are based
their analysis there is FQH- Islamic jurisprudence hadith, Quran
2. Moderate view, stressed masilha, maslah (public interest). Argue Islamic leader to
acquire justice and public interest as presented in the sharia. However, it rejected western
liberal value in favor of Islamic liberal view
A. SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY
COMPONENTS IN SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY
I. Believe in rituals and music, ritual means time after time. He insisted the importance of
music because make person desire and transform the person character. Thus to him music
and rituals transform the society and the individual character. Believed on ancestors
sacrifice as the symbol of respect to the ancestors ( only way to respect the ancestors is
through sacrifice)
Wisdoms, avoid bad behavior, to know others what they wants and to respect
others
Page 20 of 23
B. POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY
a. Conception of ruler, a ruler must have a certain characteristics include be wise. To him a
ruler is the one who possess moral, trust and respects to the elders, which he called filial
piety. Ruler should treat his subject fairly
b. Morality and law, virtual and morality is the primary in shaping human behavior and law
is the secondary, this is because by nature human beings are good and are corrupted by
negative behavior from the society thus no need of having law because man’s nature is
good
c. Good government, according to him a good government is the one that brings the best out
of people because by nature human is good, thus, the function of government is to work
hard to bring peace, order, love, treat society government. The function of government is
not to hurt the society
C. EDUCATION PHILOSOPHY
During Confucius period education was given to noble class only
Confucius provided the changes that education should be provided to all, meanwhile any
one with the desire of get education should be given a chance to get that education ( to
him no relationship between education and class)
Believed that all human beings are teachable and improvable
He emphasized the education because education should be used as the instrument of
develop goodness
Argue that “human development and perfection can be achieved through education (man
is good by nature)
Develop education curriculum aims to develop self- discipline
iii. Music education, concern about sound and rhythm. Mean to get pleasure.
Confucius was a big fan of music. Thus, to him music is sweeter than meat
iv. Education on Li, it is associated with music and poetry. Encourage individual to
express their inner feelings desires and emotions, thus, once you write a
significant poem should be come from inner feelings
Page 21 of 23
v. Education in language, according to him there is 2 languages that are official
language (used by ruling class) and popular language (used by common people).
But Confucius suggested that people should taught official language so as to get
services of the ruling class
vi. Education in I Ching, to him education was mystics and superstition. He believed
that People should be given a chance to understand their superstition
TAOISM OR DAOISM
Chinese philosophy
Founded by Leo Tzu or Laozism
Central political idea was anarchism which is basically contrary to Confucius
Taoism do not believe in ritual
Want small government and non-intervention
BUDDHISM
Founded by Buddha
Religion philosophy
Started in India and later spread to other parts china, Korea etc.
No any stated of the religion
They have different believe values that are:
Equality of all human beings
Social cooperation
Rule of law
Active participation
Moralization of political power ( power should be exercise in moral way, thus no
relationship between power and morality)
Non-violence and peace
Good government (is the government that makes people happy and it is the
government that led ruler who is justice and good, impersonal who enforce the
law, ruler does not hurt his subject)
HINDUISM
Indian philosophy
Major concern is religion and government (religion and government should be
separately- secularism)
__________ENDS OF SEMESTER _____________
Page 22 of 23
By: Shukuru Boniphace- political science student- UDSM, JKN Campus mlimani
Page 23 of 23