Mixing
Mixing
Mixing is the process of combining two or more ingredients so each particle of one
ingredient is as close as possible to particles of the other ingredients (Perry and Chilton,
1973).
Blending is another term for mixing.
Demixing or segregation is the opposite of mixing.
Mixing leads to the random spread of different particles in a system.
Why Mixing is Important
Mixing is an essential step in many processes, typically done to:
1. Control heat and mass transfer - Helps spread energy or matter evenly.
2. Ensure uniform composition - Ensures a small sample taken from the mixture
represents the whole.
3. Improve single-phase and multi-phase systems - Makes systems with one or multiple
phases stable and uniform.
4. Promote chemical and physical reactions - Speeds up reactions like dissolving by adding
movement (agitation).
Types of Mixing
1. Positive Mixing
o Occurs in systems where materials mix spontaneously and irreversibly, like two
gases or fully miscible liquids.
o This type of mixing does not need external energy but adding energy speeds up
the process.
o Positive mixtures are easy to form and maintain.
2. Negative Mixing
o Happens in systems where the phases separate quickly, like emulsions,
suspensions, or creams.
o Needs continuous energy input to stay mixed (e.g., stirring or shaking).
o Negative mixtures are harder to create and maintain.
3. Neutral Mixing
o Occurs in systems that do not mix or separate on their own.
o Only an external force can initiate mixing.
o Examples include mixtures of powders or pastes.
Types of Mixing Equipment
Different equipment is used depending on the type of material:
Liquids
Semi-solids
Solids
Liquid Mixing Mechanisms
Liquid mixing relies on four main mechanisms:
1. Bulk Transport
o Large parts of material are moved from one place to another.
o Simple circulation doesn’t mix well; there needs to be a rearrangement.
o Achieved by paddles or blades moving the fluid in different directions.
2. Turbulent Mixing
o Created by turbulent flow where fluid velocity changes randomly.
o Turbulence leads to effective mixing, where fluid motion mixes molecules
randomly.
o Involves eddies (portions of fluid moving against the main flow), which break into
smaller ones until thoroughly mixed.
3. Laminar Mixing
o Happens in viscous fluids or under gentle stirring.
o Mixing occurs in layers, where shear forces stretch and fold the layers.
o Without enough folding, laminar mixing takes a long time to achieve uniformity.
4. Molecular Diffusion
o Mixing at the molecular level caused by the thermal motion of molecules.
o Works along with laminar flow to smooth out sharp boundaries between layers.
o Based on Fick’s first law of diffusion, which says the rate of mixing depends on
concentration differences and molecular properties.
Liquid Mixing Equipment
Liquid mixing systems have two main parts:
1. Container (Tank) - Holds the material.
2. Energy Source - Powers the mixing process with devices like impellers, air streams, or
liquid jets.
o Baffles, vanes, and ducts are also used to improve mixing by directing material
flow.
o Batch mixing is used for small volumes, while continuous mixing is preferred for
large volumes
Types of Impellers
Impellers are devices used to mix liquids in tanks by rotating. They are classified
into:
1. Propellers
2. Turbines
3. Paddles
Impellers create a flow pattern in the liquid, preventing "dead zones" where no
mixing occurs. There are three main flow directions:
Radial: Moves liquid outward from the center of the impeller.
Axial: Moves liquid up or down, parallel to the impeller shaft.
Tangential: Moves liquid in a circular pattern around the shaft.
Types of Impellers Explained
1. Propellers
o Propellers are similar to screws, with blades that create an axial flow, moving the
liquid up or down.
o They are effective for low-viscosity liquids and work well at high speeds.
o Commonly used with three blades angled at a pitch that often matches the
diameter of the propeller.
o They create intense turbulence near the blades, which helps mix liquid from all
areas of the tank.
2. Turbines
o Unlike propellers, turbine blades don’t maintain a constant pitch along their
length.
o Radial flow turbines have blades set at a 90-degree angle to the shaft, pushing
liquid outward by centrifugal force.
o Turbines are effective for high-viscosity fluids and can handle fluids up to 1000
times more viscous than propellers.
o Variations in blade angle can create either radial or axial flow, depending on the
mixing requirement.
3. Paddles
o Paddles have large, flat blades and rotate at lower speeds (typically around 50
rpm).
o They are suited for high-viscosity liquids and semisolids because the large surface
area of the paddle blades can scrape and mix along the tank walls.
o Paddles primarily create tangential flow, which can cause concentration gradients
to persist.
o For better results, avoid adding layers of ingredients at once, as they might stay
unmixed even after long mixing times.
4. Hybrid Paddle Mixers (Dispertron)
o A Dispertron has two sets of coaxial blades for macro- and micro-mixing.
o This hybrid design, with counter-rotating blades, helps mix extremely thick
materials or those with high solid content.
o Produces high shear without creating a vortex and limits air entrapment, making
it ideal for emulsions and homogenous mixing.
Jet Mixers
1. Air Jets
o These use a jet of air (or sometimes another gas) to lift and mix liquids.
o Suitable for low-viscosity, non-foaming liquids that won’t react with air or the
gas.
o Draft tubes are used to guide the flow, increasing efficiency by directing liquid
circulation from the bottom to the top.
2. Fluid Jets
o These use liquid jets under high pressure to mix the contents of a tank.
o Acts similarly to propellers in generating axial flow and creating turbulence, but
without creating tangential flow.
o Fluid is pumped back into the tank through nozzles, allowing continuous mixing
The way semisolids mix changes depending on how much liquid is added. Here are the stages:
Powder State:
o Start: When a small amount of liquid is added, the powder begins to form
clumps, called pellets.
o Mixing Difficulty: The mix is still rough and not uniform, making it hard to mix
well.
Plastic State:
o With More Liquid: Adding more liquid makes the mixture smoother and more
uniform, but it’s thicker and harder to stir.
o Action: Shear forces (pushing and pulling) help make it more even.
Sticky State:
o More Liquid: The mixture becomes sticky, like a paste, and flows more easily,
though mixing remains slow.
Liquid State:
o Fluid-Like Consistency: With even more liquid, it becomes a thin, fluid-like
mix, making it easier to reach a uniform consistency.
Different equipment is used to handle the various stages and consistencies in semisolid mixing.
Sigma-Blade Mixer
Structure: Has two blades that rotate at different speeds to pull and knead the mix.
How It Works: The blades break down clumps and spread solids evenly by generating
forces within the thick mixture.
Planetary Mixer
Structure: The mixer rotates both around the container and on its own.
Benefit: This double rotation keeps the mix moving continuously, leaving no "dead
zones" where the material could sit unmixed.
Mulling Mixer
Roller Mills
Structure: Uses three rollers set close together to crush and shear the mixture.
Process:
o The mixture goes through the rollers, which gradually make it finer and smoother.
o A scraper removes the mixture to prevent build-up.
Benefit: Produces a fine, smooth mix by combining crushing and shearing actions.
Colloid Mill
Structure: Has a high-speed rotor and a stationary part (stator) with a small gap between
them.
How It Works: The rotor’s high speed creates strong shear forces that break down
particles, producing a finely mixed, smooth consistency.
Best For: Commonly used in making emulsions or other semisolid pharmaceutical
products needing very fine particles.
1. Physical Properties:
o Density: Heavier or lighter materials need different handling in mixers to ensure
even distribution.
o Viscosity: Thick (high-viscosity) or thin (low-viscosity) materials need different
mixers. Viscosity determines the strength of the shear forces needed.
o Miscibility: Materials that mix well (miscible) are easier to blend, while those
that don’t (immiscible) may need extra help, like high shear forces, to become
uniform.
2. Economic Considerations:
o Processing Time: How quickly the mixer can produce the needed batch.
o Energy Requirements: Mixers vary in power consumption; some need more
energy than others.
o Mixer Cost: Both initial cost and maintenance affect long-term expenses.
3. Viscosity's Influence:
o Key Role of Viscosity: The thickness or thinness of the mixture largely dictates
the mixer type. High-viscosity materials (like pastes) need stronger, close-range
shearing forces, while low-viscosity materials mix more easily.
Scale-Up Considerations
Changes in Mixer Size, Shape, or Speed: Scaling up from lab scale to production scale
often changes mixing effectiveness due to different equipment sizes, shapes, or speed.
This is crucial in maintaining uniformity and quality as batch size increases.
Challenges in Theory: Unlike fluid mixing, solid mixing theory is less developed. This
gap is due to the complex nature of how particles interact.
Powder Behavior: Powders may look like fluids when poured but differ significantly in
behavior. Fluids stay mixed when handled, but solids can re-segregate.
Mixing Example: Imagine mixing two different colored powders. An ideal "perfect mix"
would have each particle closely contacting a particle of the other color, but this is nearly
impossible. Instead, a "random mix" is more achievable, where particles are randomly
distributed.
Specialized Mixers
Continuous Mixers
Drum Dryers
Design:
o Consists of one or two rotating, steam-heated drums.
o Material is applied to the drum surface, which dries by simple evaporation.
o The dried layer is scraped off by a scraper.
Usage:
o Common for thermolabile materials needing a short drying time.
o Made from stainless or chrome-plated steel to avoid contamination.
o Often used for drying suspensions, e.g., kaolin or zinc oxide.
Moving-Bed Systems
Vacuum Tumble Dryer:
o Double Cone Vacuum Dryer:
Rotates under vacuum, drying materials uniformly and rapidly.
Typical rotation speed is 6–8 rpm, with heat supplied by a heated jacket.
Effective for granules, reducing drying time significantly (e.g., 2-4 hours
vs. 18-24 in ovens).
Not suitable for waxy solids, which may aggregate.
Pan Dryer:
o Used for small batches, often pastes or slurries.
o Consists of a jacketed pan with rotating plows that scrape and mix the material to
ensure even drying.
o Can operate under vacuum or atmospheric pressure, allowing solvent recovery in
vacuum mode.
1. Rotary Dryer
Description: The rotary dryer is a modified version of a tunnel dryer. It has a rotating
cylinder that dries particles by moving them opposite to a flow of hot air.
How it Works:
o Rotation: The cylinder rotates, which turns over the material, so each particle is
exposed to the air, drying it individually rather than as a large pile.
o Slope: The cylinder is slightly sloped, which helps the material move from the
entrance to the exit, allowing for a continuous drying process.
o Baffles/Flights: These are small internal blades that help flip the material as it
moves, increasing the drying rate by exposing more surfaces.
Advantages:
o Continuous drying with minimal clumping.
o Suitable for materials that need constant movement.
2. Turbo-tray Dryer
Description: This dryer has a series of rotating trays in a vertical stack, creating a
"moving bed" that dries materials continuously.
How it Works:
o Tray Stack: Trays rotate slowly (0.1 to 1.0 rpm) with heated air blown over them
by fans in the center of the stack.
o Material Movement: Wet material enters at the top and is spread by a wiper.
After each tray completes nearly one full rotation, the material drops through
slots onto the tray below.
o Repeat Process: Material moves down each tray until it reaches the bottom,
where it exits as dried product.
Advantages:
o New surfaces are constantly exposed to air, making drying faster than tunnel
dryers.
o The continuous process reduces drying time and increases efficiency.
3. Fluidized-bed Dryer
Description: This dryer creates a "fluidized" (boiling-like) effect in the particles by
pushing air upwards through them. This effect makes drying faster and more efficient.
How it Works:
o Air Flow: Air flows upward at a speed that partially suspends (fluidizes) the
particles, making them mix well and dry evenly.
o Mixing Motion: The particles continuously move and mix, allowing each one to
be surrounded by drying air, which speeds up the drying.
o Temperature Control: Air temperature and speed can be adjusted, so heat-
sensitive materials don’t get damaged.
Types:
o Vertical Fluidized-bed Dryer: Suitable for batch drying; air flows from the
bottom, drying material in a chamber.
o Horizontal Vibrating Conveyor Dryer: Best for larger-scale drying; materials are
fluidized and conveyed horizontally by vibrations.
Advantages:
o Uniform temperature and fast drying.
o Good for drying granular materials, especially for tablet granulations.
o Efficient for pharmaceutical products, offering better thermal efficiency and
shorter drying time than tray dryers.
4. Spray Dryer
Description: This dryer is unique as it only dries liquid materials (like solutions or
slurries) by spraying them as droplets into a hot air stream. The droplets dry quickly,
turning into fine powder.
How it Works:
o Atomization: The liquid feed is broken into tiny droplets by atomizers, which can
be pneumatic, pressure nozzles, or spinning discs, each suited to different
viscosities.
o Heated Air: Hot air dries the droplets, evaporating the liquid quickly before
droplets reach the chamber walls.
o Solid-Gas Separator: Once dried, the powder is separated from the gas using a
cyclone separator.
Components:
o Feed System: Delivers the liquid to the atomizer.
o Atomizers: Break the liquid into droplets.
o Heated Air System: Provides the hot air required for drying.
o Drying Chamber: Holds the air and droplets.
o Separator and Collector: Collects the powder and removes exhaust air.
Pharmaceutical Uses:
o Drying Heat-Sensitive Materials: Rapid drying prevents damage to sensitive
materials.
o Enhancing Flow and Density: Produces spherical particles, which improve flow
for tablets and capsules.
o Encapsulation: Can encapsulate flavors or oils, useful for taste masking, stability,
and controlled release.
5. Spray Congealing
Description: A method similar to spray drying, but it uses cold air to solidify (congeal)
particles coated in molten material, like waxes.
How it Works:
o Material Preparation: Particles are mixed with a molten coating material.
o Cold Air: Droplets are sprayed into cold air, causing them to solidify quickly.
Advantages:
o Useful for taste masking and creating sustained-release formulations.
o High ratio of coating agent to material, so it’s suited for creating thicker coatings.