Case Law & Meetings
Case Law & Meetings
Case Law & Meetings
Nature Definition and characteristic of Company, Lifting the Corporate Veil, Kinds of
Companies, Formation and incorporation of a Company, Promoter-status, position, function
and remuneration.
Leading Case: Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airports Authority of India –
AIR1979 SC 1628
UNIT-II
Memorandum of association, vaurious clauses, alteration therein, Doctrine of Ultravires,
Articles of Association, binding force, alteration, its relation with memorandum of
association, Doctrine of Constructive notice, Meeting-meaning, kinds, resolutions, quorum
and voting
Leading Case: Shabbir Ahmed Safedabad Cold Storage & Allied Industries (P) Ltd. 2017,
NCLT, Kolkata 80
UNIT-III
Directors: position, appointment, qualification, vacation of office, Removal, Resignation,
Powers and duties of Directors remuneration of directors, Role of nominee directors,
Compensation for loss of office, Managing Director and other managerial personnel,
Secretary: definition, qualification, position, appointment duties and qualities, Auditor,
qualification, disqualification, appointment, tenure, Re-appointment and removal of an
auditor.
Leading Case: Sridhar Sundarajan v. Ultramarine & Pigments Ltd., 2016, Bombay 167.
UNIT-IV
Majority rules and minority protection, Prevention of Oppression and mis-management,
Winding up: types, grounds, who can apply, procedure, Powers of Liquidator, consequences
of winding up order, Liability of past members, Receiver: power, appointment, duties and
liabilities
The Supreme Court concluded in this decision that if a body is a government agency or
instrumentality, it can be an authority under Article 12 regardless of whether it is a statutory
corporation, a government company, or a registered society. As a result, the International
Airport Authority of India is a State under Article 12 because it was established by an Act of
Parliament.
The Court concluded that the following standards can be employed in an illustrative sense to
establish whether a body or agency is a government instrumentality. Justice P.N. Bhagwati
administered a 5-point test. This is a test to see if a body is a government agency or
instrumentality, and it goes like this:
The government’s financial resources are the primary source of funding for such an
organization, as the government owns the whole share capital of the corporation.
The existence of a deep and extensive state control system.
Such an organization or agency’s functions are of public importance and are closely tied to
government functions.
Unit-2
According to Section 166 of the Companies Act, the first meeting after
incorporation of the company must be held within 18 months. Subject to the
exception of incorporation, there shouldn’t be a gap of more than 15 months
between two annual general meetings. Except for in the case of the first
annual general meeting, the Registrar has the power to extend the annual
general meeting for a time period which should not be more than 3 months. A
notice must be given for annual general meeting specifying details such as
date, place of the meeting. The notice served must specify that the meeting
is the annual general meeting and the time and date assigned for it must be
during business hours, and on a date which isn’t a public holiday. The place
of the meeting should be the registered office of the company and if not so,
then it must be within the town, city or village in which the company is
officially registered.
According to Section 167 of the Act, in case there is a default by the company
in conducting the annual general meeting and any member of the company
files an application for the contravention of the said default, the Regional
Director of the Company Law Board may call for a meeting or direct holding
of a meeting and then that meeting would be counted as the annual general
meeting. Where the provisions of Section 166 and 167 of the Act are
contradicted, then in such a case, a fine can be imposed on the Company and
every officer of the company responsible. A notice is to be served in advance
of 21 days for the annual general meeting but in case the notice is not served
before 21 days and all the members who are entitled to vote in the meeting
agree for an annual general meeting, then the meeting can be called with
shorter notice.
According to Section 186 of the Companies Act, Company Law Board has the
power to call an extraordinary general meeting but not an annual general
meeting. Shareholders of the company are empowered to convene a meeting
within 3 months if it is not convened within 21 days of requisition by the
Company Law Board.
In an extraordinary general meeting matters like alteration of clauses of
Memorandum of Association, changes in the Articles of Association, schemes
in relation to share capital are usually discussed. Any matter which needs to
be discussed upon in urgent also calls for extraordinary general meetings.
In case, the extraordinary general meeting can’t be held due to some reasons
then, the Company Law Board may call the meeting on its own initiative. A
notice is to be served in advance and it should include details like the cause
of such meetings, the interest of directors, managers or shareholders in the
matters which caused need to call for the meeting. The special resolution
which is passed in the meeting has to be filed to the Registrar within 15 days.
In the case of Sanjiv Kothari v Vasant Kumar Chordia, it was observed that if
a meeting is convened by the Managing director on requisition by the director
on the same date at the registered office to discuss the same matters which
was brought forward by the director then, the director must attend that
meeting and should not arrange any other meeting on the same date at
some different place.
Procedure of Meetings
It is the responsibility of the director of the company to ensure that the
procedure followed for conducting the meetings of the company is valid and
in accordance with the Companies Act. The decisions that are taken in the
meeting should be according to the sections of the Companies Act. It is the
duty of the director to ensure that the members of the meeting are notified of
the details of the meeting like the place, time and date of the meeting, type
of the meeting, the business that will be considered at the meeting and the
notice should also include motions and resolutions that will be put forward to
the members during the meeting.
Notice
A notice of a meeting is served to all the members of the meeting to discuss
the business at the meeting. A notice is to be served to the members of the
meeting in a manner which is prescribed under the Companies Act. Notice for
the general meetings must also be served to directors, auditors, and to any
such member who is entitled to a share in case a member of the meeting
dies. In case, a company accidentally fails to serve a notice to a person who
is entitled to receive it, the meeting would not be considered invalid. All the
members of the meeting are entitled to vote in the matters raised in the
meeting.
The contents of the notice depends on the type of meeting which is called for,
if the company has called for annual general meeting, it will include all
ordinary business which will be discussed in the meeting and if extraordinary
general meeting is called by the company, then the notice will include the
special business and resolutions which will be discussed in the meeting.
Annual general meeting needs a notice to be served to the members of the
meeting in advance of 21 days whereas, in the extraordinary general
meeting notice is needed to be served in advance of 14 days.
In the case of Parker and Cooper Ltd v Reading, it was observed that when
the notice which was served to the members of the meeting is improper but
still the members of the meeting attended the meeting, then the notice can
be made good and the meeting can be considered to be a valid meeting
irrespective of the fact whether notice which was served for the meeting was
proper or improper.
Contents of notice
The notice must contain the following contents:
Quorum
the minimum number of members of an assembly or society that must be present at any of its
meetings to make the proceedings of that meeting valid.
Section 103 of the Companies Act lays down the Quorum which is required
for the meeting. The quorum refers to the minimum number of members
required to conduct a meeting. According to Section 174 of the Companies
Act, one-third of the total number of members to the meeting constitutes a
quorum for the meeting. In a meeting, a minimum of two directors are
required to attend the meeting but where the company is owned by a single
person then, in that case, the condition does not apply.
Chairman
A meeting is chaired by a chairperson. The chairperson is also known as the
chairman and is responsible to control the proceedings of the meeting. He
introduces and concludes the meetings. The chairperson has to ensure that
proper notice is served to the members of the meeting and has to go through
the minutes of the last meeting in the beginning of each meeting. He ensures
that the meeting takes place and gets over within the time prescribed for it.
He keeps order and facilitate the meeting. It is the duty of the chairman to
ensure that each member of the meeting gets an equal opportunity to share
their views. The chairperson receives motions and puts votes on such
motions. The chairperson also has a right to cast a vote in the meetings. In
case there is a tie, the chairman can cast his final vote and declare the result.
The chairman of the company is also the chairman of the Board and in case if
there isn’t a chairman in a company then the directors may choose one of
them to be a chairman.
Voting Rights
In case, there is a matter which needs to be decided on in the meeting, it is
done by the votes of the members of the meeting. According to Section
50(2), every member who is limited by company shares and holds equity
share capital will have a right to vote on all the resolutions which lie before
the company. Section 188(1) states that the members who are entitled to
vote shall have voting rights on a poll in proportion to the shares held by him
to the paid-up equity share capital of the company.
The members of the company who are limited by shares and holds
preference share capital have a right to vote on polls in which the resolution
that is placed before the company directly affects the right of the member
related to his preference shares. The members of the company also have a
right to vote on resolutions such as winding up of the company, for
repayment or for reduction of the company’s equity or preference share
capital. Voting polls are conducted in a meeting to pass a resolution. The
procedure is preceded by the chairman. The common methods used for
voting is by showing or raising hands, voice votes, raising method (by
standing for votes in against or for the motion), ballot, a proxy or postal
votes, etc.
The postal ballot can be used for voting in meetings except for when the poll
is for deciding on ordinary business or in a case where a business in which it
is important to attend and hear directors or auditors in the meeting. When it
is decided that the resolution placed before the company will be passed by
postal ballot, it shall send a notice regarding it to all the members of the
meeting annexed with a draft resolution in which reasons for the poll are
explained. They are requested to send their votes on the motion. The method
of postal ballot includes voting by post or through any electronic means. The
vote shall be sent within 30 days from the date on which the notice for the
passing of the resolution was sent to the members.
The vote can be sent through a registered post, courier service, speed post or
by electronic means such as email. Postal ballot can’t be used in a case
where the company is a one-person company or in case the company has up
to 200 members.
Electronic Mode
Voting for a resolution by electronic means is known as casting vote by
electronic mode or electronic voting. Voting by electronic mode includes
voting by punched cards, optical scan voting system and specialized voting
kiosks, telephones, private computer networks, internet, etc. Section 108 of
the Companies Act includes the provision for electronic mode of voting. A
company listed under the Companies Act, 2013, having 1000 or more
shareholders should provide to its members, the facility of casting vote
through electronic mode. A member gets the right to vote even if they are
not physically present in a meeting through electronic modes. The electronic
mode of voting can be used in place of the postal ballot. The electronic mode
of voting is more convenient and time-saving.
Kinds of Resolution
A resolution can be defined as a decision which is taken by limited company
directors or shareholders and is legally binding. A resolution can be passed
by the members of the meeting if a majority of votes are received in favour
of the resolution. There are three kinds of resolutions namely, ordinary
resolutions, special resolutions and written resolutions.
Minutes
The minutes of a meeting is an essential document in which all the points,
discussions, decisions which were taken in the meeting are recorded. It is an
official document and is mandatorily referred to before starting a new
meeting. Minutes are final when it is approved by the members of the
meeting and signed by the chairperson. Minutes are written in a factual
manner which gives the gist of the meeting. It generally comprises of details
of meeting such as the date of the meeting, members who attended or failed
to attend the meeting, proposed motions and amendments in the meeting,
the proposer of such motion and members who approved it, details of the
procedure of voting, recommendations and decisions taken in relation to the
motion, etc.
Section 177 of the Companies Act, 2013 deals with the Audit Committee.
It is desirable for the Audit Committee to meet at least 4 times a year. The
meetings are preceded by the chairman. The quorum exists when the
chairperson and at least one other member is present in the meeting. The
Group’s Chief Financial Officer (CFO) serves as the secretary of the meetings.
All the members of the Board and the Chief Executive Officer of the company
are entitled to attend meetings of the audit committee. It is the Audit
Committee’s responsibility to prepare a schedule for an annual meeting. The
schedule prepared must include the main issues of the agenda that is
decided to be taken up in the meeting. The financial statements and interim
reports which is related to resolution or matter discussed in the meeting have
to be given to the members of the meeting at least before 24 hours from the
meeting. Minutes of the Audit Committee’s meetings are required to be
drawn up without any delay and it should be signed by the Chairman and the
secretary.
There is not much of a difference between the board of directors and the
board of governors.
*Foss V. Harbottle*
Foss v. Harbottle lays down the basics of the non-interference principle. The reasons for the
rule is that, if there is a complaint on a certain thing which the majority has to do if there is
something done irregularly which the majority has to do regularly or if there is something
done illegally which the majority has to do legally, then there is no use to have a litigation
over such thing. As in the end, there will be a meeting where the majority will fulfil their
wishes and make decisions.
Dividend
Companies rely on funds to manage the affairs of their business
successfully. Shareholders in a company play a vital role in raising
funds, and in that process, they become its stakeholders. They
exercise control over the share of profits in proportion to the money
they invest. Dividend is known as the share of profit by
shareholders. Shareholders are also considered the owners of the
company; therefore, they are entitled to get a dividend. There is not
an exact definition of the dividend in the Companies Act, 2013.
Under section 2(35), it merely mentions dividends as “any interim
dividend.” With a view to distribute the profit among the
shareholders of the company, the Declaration and Payment of
Dividend under the Companies Act were enacted.
Meaning of “Dividend”
Dividend refers to the reward a corporation offers to its
shareholders, in cash or otherwise. Dividends can be given in
various ways, such as cash payment, inventory, or some other form.
It is determined by its Management Board and requires the approval
of the shareholders. A dividend is the distribution of a portion of the
company’s earnings, decided and managed by the company’s board
of directors, and paid to a class of its shareholders.
Sources of Dividend
The basic principle of a declaration of dividend is that it shall be paid
out of profit only. As per the Companies Act, it can be paid out of the
following sources:
The company can declare the dividend out of surplus reserve in case
of insufficient current year’s profit subject to the following
conditions:
Wrapping Up – Conclusion
Although, distribution of dividends acts as a booster to the
shareholders and indicates that the company is doing well and has
generated good profits.