Federalism - Wikipedia
Federalism - Wikipedia
Federalism
Federalism is a mixed or compound mode of
government that combines a general
government (the central or "federal"
government) with regional governments
(provincial, state, cantonal, territorial, or other
sub-unit governments) in a single political
system, dividing the powers between the two.
Federalism in the modern era was first adopted
in the unions of states during the Old Swiss
Confederacy.[1] Federal states
Examples of a federation or federal province or state include Argentina, Australia, Belgium, Bosnia
& Herzegovina, Brazil, Iraq, Canada, Germany, UAE, Mexico, India, Malaysia, Nepal, Nigeria,
Pakistan, Russia, Switzerland, and United States. Some characterize the European Union as the
pioneering example of federalism in a multi-state setting, in a concept termed the "federal union of
states".[5]
Contents
Overview
Etymology
Origin
Political theory
Reasons for adoption
Examples
Europe vs. the United States
Constitutional structure
Division of powers
Bicameralism
Intergovernmental relations
Constitutional change
Other technical terms
In relation to conflict
See also
Notes and references
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 1/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
Sources
External links
Overview
Etymology
Origin
In the narrow sense, federalism refers to the mode in which the body politic of a state is organized
internally, and this is the meaning most often used in modern times. Political scientists, however,
use it in a much broader sense, referring instead to a "multi-layer or pluralistic concept of social
and political life."[8]
The first forms of federalism took place in ancient times, in the form of alliances between states.
Some examples from the seventh to second century B.C. were the Archaic League, the Aetolic
League, the Peloponnesian League, and the Delian League. An early progenitor of federalism was
the Achaean League in Hellenistic Greece. Unlike the Greek city states of Classical Greece, each of
which insisted on keeping its complete independence, changing conditions in the Hellenistic
period drove many city states to band together even at the cost of losing part of their sovereignty.
Subsequent unions of states included the first and second Swiss Confederations (1291–1798 and
1815–48), the United Provinces of the Netherlands (1579–1795), the German Bund (1815–66), the
first American union known as the Confederation of the United States of America (1781–89), and
second American union formed as the United States of America (1789–1865).[9]
Political theory
Modern federalism is a political system based upon democratic rules and institutions in which the
power to govern is shared between national and provincial/state governments. The term federalist
describes several political beliefs around the world depending on context. Since the term
federalization also describes distinctive political processes, its use as well depends on the
context.[10]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 2/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
According to Daniel Ziblatt, there are four competing theoretical explanations in the academic
literature for the adoption of federal systems:
1. Ideational theories, which hold that a greater ideological commitment to decentralist ideas in
society makes federalism more likely to be adopted.
2. Cultural-historical theories, which hold that federal institutions are more likely to be adopted in
societies with culturally or ethnically fragmented populations.
3. "Social contract" theories, which hold that federalism emerges as a bargain between a center
and a periphery where the center is not powerful enough to dominate the periphery and the
periphery is not powerful enough to secede from the center.
4. "Infrastructural power" theories, which hold that federalism is likely to emerge when the
subunits of a potential federation already have highly developed infrastructures (e.g. they are
already constitutional, parliamentary, and administratively modernized states).[14]
Immanuel Kant noted that "the problem of setting up a state can be solved even by a nation of
devils" so long as they possess an appropriate constitution which pits opposing factions against
each other with a system of checks and balances. In particular individual states required a
federation as a safeguard against the possibility of war.[15]
Proponents for federal systems have historically argued that the power-sharing inherent in federal
systems reduces both domestic security threats and foreign threats. Federalism allows states to be
large and diverse, mitigating the risk of a tyrannical government through centralization of
powers.[16][17]
Examples
Many countries have implemented federal systems of government with varying degree of central
and regional sovereignty. The federal government of these countries can be divided into
minimalistic federations, consisting of only two sub-federal units or multi-regional, those that
consist of three to dozens of regional governments. They can also be grouped based on their body
polity type, such as emirate, provincial, republican or state federal systems. Another way to study
federated countries is by categorizing them into those whose entire territory is federated as
opposed to only part of its territory comprising the federal portion of the country. Some federal
systems are national systems while others, like the European Union are supra national.
In general, two extremes of federalism can be distinguished: at one extreme, the strong federal
state is almost completely unitary, with few powers reserved for local governments; while at the
other extreme, the national government may be a federal state in name only, being a confederation
in actuality. Federalism may encompass as few as two or three internal divisions, as is the case in
Belgium or Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The governments of Argentina, Australia, Brazil, India, and Mexico, among others, are also
organized along federalist principles.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 3/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
In the United States, federalism originally referred to belief in a stronger central government.
When the U.S. Constitution was being drafted, the Federalist Party supported a stronger central
government, while "Anti-Federalists" wanted a weaker central government. This is very different
from the modern usage of "federalism" in Europe and the United States. The distinction stems
from the fact that "federalism" is situated in the middle of the political spectrum between a
confederacy and a unitary state. The U.S. Constitution was written as a replacement for the
Articles of Confederation, under which the United States was a loose confederation with a weak
central government.
In contrast, Europe has a greater history of unitary states than North America, thus European
"federalism" argues for a weaker central government, relative to a unitary state. The modern
American usage of the word is much closer to the European sense. As the power of the U.S. federal
government has increased, some people have perceived a much more unitary state than they
believe the Founding Fathers intended. Most people politically advocating "federalism" in the
United States argue in favor of limiting the powers of the federal government, especially the
judiciary (see Federalist Society, New Federalism).
The contemporary concept of federalism came about with the creation of an entirely new system of
government that provided for democratic representation at two governing levels simultaneously,
which was implemented in the US Constitution.[21][22] In the United States implementation of
federalism, a bicameral general government, consisting of a chamber of popular representation
proportional to population (the House of Representatives), and a chamber of equal State-based
representation consisting of two delegates per State (the Senate), was overlaid upon the pre-
existing regional governments of the thirteen independent States. With each level of government
allocated a defined sphere of powers, under a written constitution and the rule of law (that is,
subject to the independent third-party arbitration of a supreme court in competence disputes), the
two levels were thus brought into a coordinate relationship for the first time.
In 1946, Kenneth Wheare observed that the two levels of government in the US were "co-equally
supreme".[23] In this, he echoed the perspective of American founding father James Madison who
saw the several States as forming "distinct and independent portions of the supremacy"[24] in
relation to the general government.
Constitutional structure
Division of powers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 4/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
In a federation, the division of power between federal and regional governments is usually outlined
in the constitution. Almost every country allows some degree of regional self-government, but in
federations the right to self-government of the component states is constitutionally entrenched.
Component states often also possess their own constitutions which they may amend as they see fit,
although in the event of conflict the federal constitution usually takes precedence.
In almost all federations the central government enjoys the powers of foreign policy and national
defense as exclusive federal powers. Were this not the case a federation would not be a single
sovereign state, per the UN definition. Notably, the states of Germany retain the right to act on
their own behalf at an international level, a condition originally granted in exchange for the
Kingdom of Bavaria's agreement to join the German Empire in 1871. Beyond this the precise
division of power from one nation to another. The constitutions of Germany and the United States
provide that all powers not specifically granted to the federal government are retained by the
states. The Constitution of some countries like Canada and India, state that powers not explicitly
granted to the provincial governments are retained by the federal government. Much like the US
system, the Australian Constitution allocates to the Federal government (the Commonwealth of
Australia) the power to make laws about certain specified matters which were considered too
difficult for the States to manage, so that the States retain all other areas of responsibility. Under
the division of powers of the European Union in the Lisbon Treaty, powers which are not either
exclusively of Union competence or shared between the Union and the Member States as
concurrent powers are retained by the constituent States.
It is common that during the historical evolution of a federation there is a gradual movement of
power from the component states to the centre, as the federal government acquires additional
powers, sometimes to deal with unforeseen circumstances. The acquisition of new powers by a
federal government may occur through formal constitutional amendment or simply through a
broadening of the interpretation of a government's existing constitutional powers given by the
courts.
Usually, a federation is formed at two levels: the central government and the regions (states,
provinces, territories), and little to nothing is said about second or third level administrative
political entities. Brazil is an exception, because the 1988 Constitution included the municipalities
as autonomous political entities making the federation tripartite, encompassing the Union, the
States, and the municipalities. Each state is divided into municipalities (municípios) with their
own legislative council (câmara de vereadores) and a mayor (prefeito), which are partly
autonomous from both Federal and State Government. Each municipality has a "little
constitution", called "organic law" (lei orgânica). Mexico is an intermediate case, in that
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 5/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
municipalities are granted full-autonomy by the federal constitution and their existence as
autonomous entities (municipio libre, "free municipality") is established by the federal
government and cannot be revoked by the states' constitutions. Moreover, the federal constitution
determines which powers and competencies belong exclusively to the municipalities and not to the
constituent states. However, municipalities do not have an elected legislative assembly.
Federations often employ the paradox of being a union of states, while still being states (or having
aspects of statehood) in themselves. For example, James Madison (author of the US Constitution)
wrote in Federalist Paper No. 39 that the US Constitution "is in strictness neither a national nor a
federal constitution; but a composition of both. In its foundation, it is federal, not national; in the
sources from which the ordinary powers of the Government are drawn, it is partly federal, and
partly national..." This stems from the fact that states in the US maintain all sovereignty that they
do not yield to the federation by their own consent. This was reaffirmed by the Tenth Amendment
to the United States Constitution, which reserves all powers and rights that are not delegated to
the Federal Government as left to the States and to the people.
Bicameralism
The structures of most federal governments incorporate mechanisms to protect the rights of
component states. One method, known as 'intrastate federalism', is to directly represent the
governments of component states in federal political institutions. Where a federation has a
bicameral legislature the upper house is often used to represent the component states while the
lower house represents the people of the nation as a whole. A federal upper house may be based on
a special scheme of apportionment, as is the case in the senates of the United States and Australia,
where each state is represented by an equal number of senators irrespective of the size of its
population.
Alternatively, or in addition to this practice, the members of an upper house may be indirectly
elected by the government or legislature of the component states, as occurred in the United States
prior to 1913, or be actual members or delegates of the state governments, as, for example, is the
case in the German Bundesrat and in the Council of the European Union. The lower house of a
federal legislature is usually directly elected, with apportionment in proportion to population,
although states may sometimes still be guaranteed a certain minimum number of seats.
Intergovernmental relations
In Canada, the provincial governments represent regional interests and negotiate directly with the
central government. A First Ministers conference of the prime minister and the provincial
premiers is the de facto highest political forum in the land, although it is not mentioned in the
constitution.
Constitutional change
Federations often have special procedures for amendment of the federal constitution. As well as
reflecting the federal structure of the state this may guarantee that the self-governing status of the
component states cannot be abolished without their consent. An amendment to the constitution of
the United States must be ratified by three-quarters of either the state legislatures, or of
constitutional conventions specially elected in each of the states, before it can come into effect. In
referendums to amend the constitutions of Australia and Switzerland it is required that a proposal
be endorsed not just by an overall majority of the electorate in the nation as a whole, but also by
separate majorities in each of a majority of the states or cantons. In Australia, this latter
requirement is known as a double majority.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 6/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
Some federal constitutions also provide that certain constitutional amendments cannot occur
without the unanimous consent of all states or of a particular state. The US constitution provides
that no state may be deprived of equal representation in the senate without its consent. In
Australia, if a proposed amendment will specifically impact one or more states, then it must be
endorsed in the referendum held in each of those states. Any amendment to the Canadian
constitution that would modify the role of the monarchy would require unanimous consent of the
provinces. The German Basic Law provides that no amendment is admissible at all that would
abolish the federal system.
In relation to conflict
It has been argued that federalism and other forms of territorial autonomy are a useful way to
structure political systems in order to prevent violence among different groups within countries
because it allows certain groups to legislate at the subnational level.[26] Some scholars have
suggested, however, that federalism can divide countries and result in state collapse because it
creates proto-states.[27] Still others have shown that federalism is only divisive when it lacks
mechanisms that encourage political parties to compete across regional boundaries.[28]
Federalism is sometimes viewed in the context of international negotiation as "the best system for
integrating diverse nations, ethnic groups, or combatant parties, all of whom may have cause to
fear control by an overly powerful center."[29] However, those skeptical of federal prescriptions
sometimes believe that increased regional autonomy can lead to secession or dissolution of the
nation.[29] In Syria, for example, federalization proposals have failed in part because "Syrians fear
that these borders could turn out to be the same as the ones that the fighting parties have currently
carved out."[29]
See also
Commonwealth – Term for a political community founded for the common good
Consociationalism – Political power sharing among cultural groups
Cooperative federalism – Flexible government where state and national level cooperate
Democratic World Federalists – Organization
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 7/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
Feudalism – Combination of legal and military customs and form of government in medieval
Europe
Neo-feudalism – Theoretic rebirth of antique governance
Federal republicanism
Federal Union
Forum of Federations
Layer cake federalism
Non-governmental federation – Federations which are not states or national governments
Pillarisation
States' rights – Political powers reserved for US states
Union of Utrecht – 1579 treaty unifying the northern Netherlands provinces
World Federalist Movement – Movement advocating world institutions
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 8/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
17. Deudney, Daniel (2004). "Publius Before Kant: Federal-Republican Security and Democratic
Peace" (http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1354066104045540). European Journal of
International Relations. 10 (3): 315–356. doi:10.1177/1354066104045540 (https://doi.org/10.11
77%2F1354066104045540). ISSN 1354-0661 (https://www.worldcat.org/issn/1354-0661).
S2CID 143608840 (https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:143608840).
18. "CBC on Federalism and Separatism" (https://www.cbc.ca/archives/lesson-plan/for-teachers-d
ebating-federalism-and-separatism).
19. "70_Years_of_Campaigns_for_a_United_and_Federal_Europe" (https://www.federalists.eu/file
admin/files_uef/Pictures/Website_Animation/About_UEF/70th_Anniversary/UEF_Booklet_70_
Years_of_Campaigns_for_a_United_and_Federal_Europe.pdf) (PDF). www.federalists.eu.
Union of European Federalists. 2016.
20. "The Churchill Society London. Churchill's Speeches" (http://www.churchill-society-london.org.
uk/astonish.html). www.churchill-society-london.org.uk.
21. Law, John (2012) "Sense on Federalism", in Political Quarterly, Vol. 83, No. 3, pp. 543–544.
22. Wheare 1946, p. 11.
23. Wheare 1946, pp. 10–15.
24. Madison, James, Hamilton, Alexander and Jay, John (1987) The Federalist Papers, Penguin,
Harmondsworth, p. 258.
25. Koonz, Claudia (2003). The Nazi Conscience (https://archive.org/details/naziconscience00koo
n). Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. p. 72. ISBN 978-0-674-01172-
4.
26. Lijphart, Arend (1977). Democracy in Plural Societies: A Comparative Exploration. New Haven,
CT: Yale University Press.
27. Hale, Henry E. (2004). "Divided We Stand: Institutional Sources of Ethnofederal State Survival
and Collapse" (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/world-politics/article/divided-we-stand-
institutional-sources-of-ethnofederal-state-survival-and-collapse/41306449EF0B2841A5AAFC
CD4F3D6645). World Politics. 56 (2): 165–193. doi:10.1353/wp.2004.0011 (https://doi.org/10.1
353%2Fwp.2004.0011). ISSN 1086-3338 (https://www.worldcat.org/issn/1086-3338).
S2CID 155052031 (https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:155052031).
28. Dawn Brancati. 2009. Peace by Design: Managing Intrastate Conflict through Decentralization.
Oxford: Oxford UP.
29. Michael Meyer-Resende, Why Talk of Federalism Won't Help Peace in Syria (https://foreignpoli
cy.com/2016/03/18/why-talk-of-federalism-wont-help-peace-in-syria-assad/), Foreign Policy
(March 18, 2017).
Sources
Bednar, Jenna (2011). "The Political Forsyth, Murray (1981). Unions of States:
Science of Federalism". Annual Review of The Theory and Practice of Confederation.
Law and Social Science. 7: 269–288. Leicester University Press.
doi:10.1146/annurev-lawsocsci-102510- OCLC 1170233780 (https://www.worldcat.or
105522 (https://doi.org/10.1146%2Fannurev g/oclc/1170233780).
-lawsocsci-102510-105522). Gerven, Walter van (2005). The European
Broschek, Jorg (2016). "Federalism in Union: A Polity of States and Peoples (http
Europe, America and Africa: A Comparative s://books.google.com/books?id=nZ0lIXo53h
Analysis". Federalism and Decentralization: MC). Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Perceptions for Political and Institutional ISBN 9780804750646.
Reforms (https://broschek.ca/uploads/Feder Wheare, Kenneth (1946). Federal
alism%20in%20Europe,%20America%20an Government. London: Oxford University
d%20Africa%20A%20Comparative%20Anal Press.
ysis.pdf) (PDF). Singapore: Konrad
Adenauer Stiftung. pp. 23–50.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 9/10
10/20/22, 6:59 PM Federalism - Wikipedia
External links
P.-J. Proudhon, The Principle of Federation (http://www.ditext.com/proudhon/federation/federat
ion.html), 1863.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0; additional terms may apply. By
using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the
Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism#Overview 10/10