Lecture 3
Lecture 3
Franz Boas (1858- 1942) is considered the founder of American linguistics and American
anthropology. His major concern was to obtain information on Native American languages and
Edward Sapir -Boas' student- (1884–1939) did first-hand fieldwork on many American
Indian languages, contributed to historical linguistics (in Indo-European, Semitic, and numerous
Native American families). Sapir defended the perception that each language has its own sound
system, within which a determinate set of speech sounds are distinguished by specific features.
The Whorf (or Sapir-Whorf) hypothesis (known also as linguistic determinism/ linguistic
relativism) holds that a speaker's perception of the world is organized or constrained by the
linguistic categories his or her language offers, that language structure determines thought, how
one experiences and hence how one views the world. Whorf (1956 p. 20) claimed that “ people
who use languages with very different grammars are led by these grammars to typically different
Procedures’ (Immediate Constituent Analysis ICA) which are rules and principles that would
enable a linguist to discover in an exact way the description of any language. This book showed
that Bloomfield was influenced by both De Saussure's thinking and behaviorist psychology. He
defended that language study should deal objectively and systematically with observable data
Mila university Center
Linguistics third year
Teacher: Dr. BENNACER Fouzia
and describe what is being seen -external not internal-, hence, linguistics should focus on form
not meaning. Henceforth, Bloomfield’s ICA was criticised for neglecting meaning, not being
able to give clear directions in the case of binary cuttings such as: (That nice, efficient, old-
fashioned secretary) and the problem of pre-position and post-position, not being able to show
the relationship between sentences (passive/ active, affirmative/ negative…), not being able to
words, the psychologist can account for mental states through observing behaviour, the linguist
similarly can discover and describe language through describing already produced patterns.
However, this linguistic model was rejected by Chomsky who clarified that the corpus may
contain errors as it may not include enough illustrations of the phenomenon under investigation