Building The Smart Business
Building The Smart Business
Connecting People,
Processes, and Information
! "#
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION 1
Brand and product names mentioned in this paper may be the trademarks or registered trademarks of their
respective owners.
BI Research
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
INTRODUCTION
$ % Companies are under constant pressure to boost profits, reduce costs, and increase
revenues. At the same time, competitive pressures require organizations to react
! faster to solve business issues and meet customer needs. To satisfy these demands
& & businesses must work smarter and be more agile if they are to survive in this tough
' ! business climate. Working smarter means providing executives and line-of-business
(LOB) users with easy access to the business processes and information they need to
make informed business decisions. Becoming more agile requires business
information be delivered to business users in a timely manner, so that they can react
rapidly to business needs and issues.
The objectives of this paper are to explain the importance of a framework for
integrating business users, processes, and information in a cost-effective and timely
manner, and to show how new and evolving technologies contained within such a
framework enable an organization to work smarter and become more agile.
The first section of the paper provides an overview of why an integrated environment
is essential for enabling the smart business. The second section looks at requirements
for smarter decision making, and reviews recent innovations in information and
collaboration technologies that support those requirements. The third section looks at
how business process, information and collaboration technologies can be integrated
into an overall framework, and reviews the pros and cons of using best-of-breed
products versus employing an integrated product suite from a single vendor. This
section also discusses how SAP NetWeaver supports such a framework. The last
section reviews how products from SAP are being used by Rohm and Hass Company
to create a smart decision-making environment.
BI Research 1
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
*+
) executives &
) LOB managers
external
information
collaborative
information
Business
collaboration
processes
plans, budgets
transaction forecasts
data historical data
integrated & metrics
master data near real-
Business Business time data
transaction intelligence
processes processes
BUSINESS PROCESSES
Business processes automate core business tasks. These tasks may involve business
transaction processes for managing day-to-day business operations, business
intelligence processes for analyzing and optimizing business operations, and
business collaboration processes that allow business users to communicate and share
information about business operations. When combined, these processes enable
business users to run, optimize, and communicate about all aspects of business
operations (see Figure 1).
BI Research 2
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
Business users employ their business expertise to evaluate the actionable business
information produced by BI performance management applications. Applying
business expertise to business information creates business knowledge. This
knowledge can be used to determine what actions (if any) need to be taken to align
business activities with business goals, and what business processes need to be
modified to support those actions. This creates a so-called closed-loop decision-
making and action-taking system for managing and optimizing business operations.
The need for organizations to be more agile, however, requires that this closed-loop
process also be employed to optimize day-to-day business activities. At present, most
data warehouses do not provide the near-real-time or low-latency transaction data
required for such processing. The solution is to use BI applications against live
transaction data, or to capture transaction data in-flight, and integrate it into a low-
latency data store (which may be an extension to an existing data warehouse). We
BI Research 3
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
will discuss low-latency data and near-real-time decision making in the next section
of this paper.
BUSINESS INFORMATION
Business transaction, business intelligence, and business collaboration processes
create a wide range of different types of structured and unstructured business
information. Business transaction processes store transaction data in data files and
databases, whereas BI processes employ data warehouses and low-latency stores to
handle integrated data transaction data and analysis results. Business collaboration
processes, on the other hand, encapsulate communications and business knowledge
generated by business users in documents, spreadsheets, e-mails, and so forth. These
various types of information are typically managed by a variety of file and database
systems that are dispersed throughout the organization.
( Business decisions may take some time to make, and may involve actions that cycle
round the closed-loop process several times. There is a need, therefore, for business
! users to be able to have a single tool that enables them to access and track various
types of business information over a period of time, and that also allows them to
! share business knowledge and collaborate with other users inside or outside of the
organization. This is important not only for managing the business effectively, but
also to be able to respond rapidly to legislative reporting requirements. Such a tool is
a called an enterprise portal, and is discussed in more detail in the next sub-section.
BUSINESS USERS
" To make rapid informed decisions, business users need access to personalized
& business content from any place at any time, using both office-based and mobile
! devices. An enterprise portal satisfies this need by providing business users with an
integrated and secure Web interface to enterprise-wide business content, including
! business transaction and BI applications, structured and unstructured data, and so
forth.
BI Research 4
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
Portals provide secure and single sign-on facilities that enable them to be employed
both inside and outside of an organization. Internal portals are frequently used to
improve the usability of corporate intranets by personalizing information and
increasing information self-service. External portals are used to enable the
interchange of business content with customers, suppliers, and other key business
partners.
" An enterprise portal is destined to become the business users’ desktop by providing
! all of the business content they require to do their jobs. A portal solves the problem
! ' of locating information because it personalizes and secures business content to match
each user’s role in the organization, making it much easier to find and access
information. A portal also solves the issue of relating different types of business
information (business transaction data, business intelligence, documents and reports,
e-mail, and so forth) since it employs a business taxonomy to provide an integrated
view of the many different types of business information that exist in an
organization.
& The above discussion outlines why business processes, business information, and
, business users need to be integrated to support a smart and agile business
organization. In reality, organizations today do not have the integrated business
decision-making and action-taking environment outlined here. Most of them have
instead deployed a variety of non-integrated information and collaboration
! technologies and products that cannot support the needs of a smart and agile
business. In the next section of this paper, we discuss this issue in more detail, and
review requirements for becoming a smart business.
BI Research 5
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
1. Business users find it difficult collaborate on and access the many different types
of business information they need to do their jobs. In most installations, this
information is scattered across many different systems, and involves a complex
web of security and logon procedures.
2. Business users find business intelligence applications both difficult and time
consuming to use. This is not only because of the complexity of many BI tools,
but also because the information produced by these tools is not tied directly to
business processes, is not immediately actionable, and often requires further
analysis by experienced users before it can be employed to make informed
business decisions.
3. Business users cannot use business information to make timely and near-real-
time decisions because the information is often inconsistent, inaccurate, and out
of date.
Most of these problems concern the currency and accuracy of business information,
and how information is accessed and processed by business users in the decision
making process. These issues must be resolved if the full value of an organization’s
information and employee assets is to be realized, and the organization is to become
a smart business. Each of these issues is discussed in more detail below, together
with suggestions on how new and evolving information and collaboration
technologies can assist in their resolution.
BI Research 6
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
Business users can employ a number of tools to access and collaborate on business
information, but often these tools are located on disparate systems, require different
logon IDs and passwords, and contain inconsistent data that is difficult to access and
search. A large bank, for example, discovered that call center support staff typically
had to access over forty different systems during the course of a day when handling
customer inquiries.
Information access is made more difficult by the need to expand the use of business
information to a wider audience of line-of-business (LOB) users who often have
! limited computer skills, or who have little time to use complex tools. Business
- information, therefore, needs to be made easier to access, and should be tailored to
! suit the needs and skills of individual business users. As we discussed in the first
, ,! section of this paper, an enterprise portal offers a solution to this problem.
A portal not only enables user collaboration and access to all types of business
information, but also provides business users with a single interface to enterprise-
wide business content that can be personalized to each user’s skills and role in the
organization. A portal not only supports desktop business users, but also mobile
workers, such as salespeople, who need to use wireless and mobile devices to access
business information.
/ ! As mentioned earlier, less use has been made of BI for managing and optimizing
day-to-day business operations. This is because most data warehouses contain
historic, rather than low-latency transaction data. A BI system, however, can be used
% , , for driving day-to-day business operations if the data warehouse can be enhanced to
! provide access to low-latency business transaction data. As shown in Figure 2, the
action time between a business problem occurring and a user taking action to resolve
it is dependent not only on how long it takes to analyze information about the
problem, deliver an alert to the user, and the user to take action, but also on the
latency of the information being analyzed. The lower the latency of data in a data
warehouse, the faster users can react to business problems.
+
(
Business Data ready Information Action
! event for analysis delivered taken
user action
time
When business user action times are not fast enough to meet business needs, rules-
driven decision-making applications can be used to automate the decision-making
1
This figure is based on a concept developed by Dr. Richard Hackathorn of Bolder
Technology.
BI Research 8
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
process. These applications receive alerts and use business rules to determine what
actions need to be taken. These action rules encapsulate a business user’s expertise
and are defined to decision-making applications by experienced business users. An
example of an automatic action would be to sell stocks if stock market activity is
causing an investor’s portfolio to exceed certain predefined risk levels.
( & The use of a low-latency data store in a data warehousing environment causes
, considerable confusion because this data may be used not only by BI processes, but
also by business transaction processes. The motivation in both cases for creating a
low-latency data store, however, is to integrate and cleanse transaction data, and to
put the data in a format that can be understood and used by business users.
For BI processing, a low-latency store can be used for near-real-time action taking
(optimizing Web store-front product offers, for example), and for staging transaction
data into a data warehouse for strategic planning and tactical analysis. For business
transaction processing, a low-latency data store can be used for transaction data
reporting, and as a base for new business transaction applications, the staged
migration of older legacy applications, and the propagation of transaction data to
downstream applications.
• A business user portal can secure, access, manage, and tailor all the types of
business information to suit the needs and skills of individual business users, and
can be employed by desktop and mobile business users to collaborate and share
information with each other.
( A wide, and sometimes confusing, range of solutions are now offered by vendors to
0 enable an organization to become a smart business. When selecting a solution for a
& project it is important to base this decision not only on the features it provides, but
!0 & ) & also on its ability to satisfy business requirements, and on its capability to deliver a
( $ low overall total cost of ownership (TCO). The test of any new project is whether it
helps an organization achieve its business objectives, and whether can it do so with a
low TCO.
BI Research 9
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
1 Not all technologies are appropriate for all businesses. As with all new technologies
! the benefits need to be assessed carefully, and the benefits need to be implemented in
a phased manner to ensure successful deployment. Success will also be heavily
! dependent on whether business practices can be improved and business users trained
to exploit the benefits offered by the new capabilities.
Figure 3 illustrates a possible roadmap for implementing the new and enhanced
facilities identified earlier. As shown in the figure, one approach is to deploy these
technologies in the following sequence.
! &
Right-time and
Right-time
event-driven
processing technologies
Automated
Automated
decision-making
processing applications
BI Actionable BI
performance and business
management alerts
BI Research 10
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
Figure 3 is only one possible scenario. Many others exist, and the most appropriate
one to use will depend on business needs and the return on investment (ROI) to the
business of any given technology. As always, it is important to have a business
requirement for new technology, rather than to simply install technology for
technology’s sake.
( As new business information and collaboration technologies and products are added
) % to an IT system it is important that they are integrated and work cohesively with
! existing solutions. To minimize the integration effort, organizations need to design
an integration framework into which new business information and collaboration
! products can be plugged based on business requirements. Lack of an integrated
framework leads to stovepipe business applications and information silos. The next
section of this paper discusses such a framework in more detail.
BI Research 11
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
The four levels of IT integration are: user interaction, business process, application,
and data integration. Many technologies and products fit neatly into one of these
categories, but as we will see, there is a trend in the industry toward products
supporting multiple integration approaches, and as a result the dividing line between
these four levels of integration is not always clear cut.
# ! A key issue with integration at the user interaction level is that although the business
! user is given a single view of multiple disparate systems, this view often highlights
the lack of business process and data integration between those systems. This is why
portal vendors are now adding the ability to support composite business processes
that add a business semantic layer between the user interaction interface and
underlying business processes. A composite process interacts with both business
transaction and BI processes and applications, and thus removes the need for
business users to know which physical system contains what business information.
This semantic layer also enables collaborative workflow processes to be added into a
portal, which means that portals are beginning to support business process
integration (see discussion below) in addition to user interaction integration.
BI Research 12
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
# It is also important to point out that business process automation tools not only
manage the implementation of distinct applications, but also monitor the flow of
! business events between those applications, and between applications and business
users. Many process management tools are adding performance monitoring
capabilities into this flow for analyzing business performance. BI vendors are also
! beginning to tap into the business event flows so that their products can be used to
manage and optimize day-to-day front-office and back-office operations. It is
important, therefore, that the performance management solutions offered by
application integration and BI vendors work cohesively together.
+
" Desktop, mobile, and wireless devices
!
portal other content
content store Enterprise portal suite stores
Content management
Collaboration suite
suite
Business transaction processes and applications Business intelligence processes and applications
APPLICATION INTEGRATION
Application integration technology manages the interaction between business
transaction and BI applications that may reside within or outside of an organization.
BI Research 13
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
Many organizations, however, also use it to transfer data between applications. In the
data warehousing world, for example, many extract tools (sometimes called ETL
tools) work with application integration software to capture data from an application
workflow, and transform and load it into a data warehouse. To highlight this trend,
many data warehouse vendors now market their ETL products as a part of a data
integration suite.
"# 1 & An example of an APS is SAP NetWeaver (see Figure 5). The SAP NetWeaver
- Enterprise Portal capability (SAP EP) provides single sign-on for users of desktop,
mobile, and wireless devices. The delivery of information can be tailored to users’
3"# 4 roles in the organization, and users can further personalize their individual portals to
suit their needs and preferences. SAP EP works in conjunction with the SAP
NetWeaver collaboration suite and a content management suite (known as SAP
Knowledge Management). The collaboration suite includes shared e-mails,
calendars, and threaded discussions, and has a shared document store. The
knowledge management suite provides search tools, taxonomy development, content
management, publishing, and workflow management.
"# 5 ! The combined facilities of the business process management capability and
. , integration broker form what is known as the SAP Exchange Infrastructure (SAP
& ! XI). Adapters in the SAP XI, for example, allow the integration broker to
, communicate with databases, files, and messaging providers. Other adapters link the
integration broker to SAP and third party systems, such as Baan, Oracle, and
PeopleSoft, as well as to legacy systems, and thus enable integration at the
application level. SAP XI can be used to acquire real-time events for constructing a
low-latency data store in SAP’s data warehousing environment, SAP Business
BI Research 14
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
Information Warehouse (SAP BW), which is included with the SAP Business
Intelligence component of SAP NetWeaver.
SAP NetWeaver life-cycle management provides tools for developing, testing, and
deploying Web applications through the entire software life cycle. The composite
application framework of SAP NetWeaver includes the tools, methodology, rules,
and patterns that allow SAP and its partners to develop SAP composite applications
(SAP calls these xApps).
6
"# 1 &
People integration
Multi-channel access
Information integration
Process integration
Business process
Integration broker
management
Application server
J2EE ABAP
DATA INTEGRATION
Data integration technology has two primary objectives. The first is to provide
business processes and underlying applications with a single integrated view of
business information. The second is to provide facilities for copying and moving data
between different systems.
Several different technologies can be used for data integration, including low-latency
and master data integration tools, ETL tools, and more recently, enterprise
information integration (EII) software. The technology used depends on several
factors such as the type of processing, the data volumes involved, data currency
requirements, and the amount of data transformation needed.
7 Data integration suites of ETL, low-latency, and master data integration tools
dominate the BI marketplace for copying and moving data between systems, and are
used specifically to extract and transform transaction data for loading into a data
BI Research 15
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
warehouse. EII solutions, on the other hand, are beginning to gain attention as a way
of providing a single view of dispersed business information without having to copy
data. As discussed earlier, there is an increasing need in organizations for solutions
that can exploit BI processing for right-time decision making. Operational BI
processing enables an organization to be more responsive. This may involve the
querying and analysis of current or low-latency transaction data, BI-driven alerts and
automated action taking.
In SAP NetWeaver (see Figure 5), data integration is provided by a data integration
suite that is a component of SAP Business Intelligence (SAP BI). This data
integration suite supports both SAP and non-SAP data in addition to standard file
formats such as XML. As mentioned earlier, low-latency data can be acquired using
the services of SAP XI. The SAP Master Data Management (SAP MDM) facility of
SAP NetWeaver extends the capabilities of the data integration suite by providing a
facility for consolidating, storing, and augmenting master data such as customer
information.
"# SAP BI also provides a set of BI tools for reporting and analysis. The suite includes a
) user-friendly Web-based interface with a zero-footprint HTML client. It provides a
& variety of data analysis capabilities, including advanced statistical and mathematical
& functions. It also offers users the ability to leverage the familiar Microsoft Excel
interface for all reporting and analysis needs. SAP BI can schedule reports and alerts,
& and can deliver the results in a variety of formats including HTML and Microsoft
Excel. It can also deliver reports to wireless devices.
"# SAP BI is tightly integrated with other SAP NetWeaver components, including the
SAP Enterprise Portal, and the collaboration and content management suites. The
"# 1 & open framework of SAP NetWeaver enables third-party and in-house-developed BI
solutions to be incorporated into a SAP environment to supplement the facilities
provided by SAP Business Intelligence. More information on SAP NetWeaver and
SAP business intelligence can be found in the document Extending Business
Intelligence with SAP NetWeaver, which can be downloaded from the SAP Web site.
BI Research 16
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
The most effective solution for the rapid deployment of a smart business is to buy an
integrated platform from a single vendor, and integrate any missing features using
best-of-breed products. This enables projects to be deployed faster, and provides
better functionality and usability for business users. The single platform approach
also usually results in a lower total cost of ownership.
BI Research 17
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
Rohm and Haas identified five drivers for adopting SAP NetWeaver: provide more
efficiency in maintaining and accessing corporate content; enable more flexibility to
collaborate internally and externally; lower the barriers for access to select
application functionality, create easier interaction with the company’s password and
security system, and provide a complete picture of the business environment to unify
delivery of internal business data and external market data.
“We wanted to empower our employees with more information, and gain visibility
across all the business units,” explains Eric Soll, e-business technology manager at
Rohm and Haas. “People should be able to think around a business process. Now,
our people can see internal and external information, both structured and
unstructured, all in one place.”
BI Research 18
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
into the portal via highly filtered news feeds from about 8,000 sources about
competitors, customers, and selected market segments.
COLLABORATION
" The key to good collaboration is the ability to work effectively beyond the walls of a
! department or business unit. Rohm and Haas understood this requirement, and
! ! decided to use SAP NetWeaver as a tool to support collaborative efforts across the
enterprise. They are working to create a presence in the portal that maintains the
knowledge base for a group, regardless of their location or organizational
boundaries. Collaborative tools such as polls and discussion groups can be added to
the portal to build a more dynamic community. External information and business
intelligence can be integrated as well to bring all of the resources needed by the
group together in one place.
BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE
# & Providing managers with a consistent view of business operations was a challenge at
Rohm and Hass because of the global scope of the business, and the fact that there
& ! are many different ordering and purchasing systems with different definitions of key
business terms. Managers therefore had little confidence in the reliability of the data
behind their reports. To solve this problem, Rohm and Hass employed the
information integration facilities provided by the SAP Business Intelligence (SAP
BI) component of SAP NetWeaver.
Business transaction source systems feed an SAP BI 700 gigabyte data warehouse
that supplies information to a fast-growing base of 2,000 users. The SAP BI solution
consists of an initial staging area, about 30 operational data stores, the data
warehouse, and about 60 subject-area data marts. Major applications include order
processing, manufacturing, inventory management, supply demand planning,
procurement, and finance. Users range from business analysts to senior managers in
each area.
The portal is tightly integrated with the data warehouse and with business transaction
systems. The portal’s universal interface allows users to run everything from
corporate performance monitoring to advanced drilldowns and business-planning and
BI Research 19
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
simulation tools. Not only does the portal let users gain insight into the business
using the data warehouse right alongside operational reports, but it also gives them
access to related emails and other unstructured content.
8 ! On a broad scale, the portal and BI environment gives users a single source of the
! truth, which encourages business analysts and managers to use business intelligence
& - with confidence, and helps them make better and faster decisions. Specifically, they
are better able to manage the very complex supply chain, and are better able to
respond to customers on a global level. Managers, for example, are now able for the
first time to see the direct relationships between pricing and profitability.
FUTURE DIRECTIONS
Eric Soll believes there are other areas where an integrated business information and
collaboration environment can improve efficiency, for example, high-level metrics
and balanced scorecards, self-service budget and requisition processes, and order-to-
cash and purchase-to-pay processes.
: & The company has seen a shift in thinking as it integrates people, processes, and
); ): information. “I see a developing trend,” says Soll, “in moving away from an IT-
& system focus toward a business-process focus, facilitated through the portal. Right
(, now, people are increasingly interested, and I think the key is to keep going with
! , what we’ve done. We have more than 7,000 users today, with more to come. If
you’re enabling people and making their jobs easier, that really makes adoption a lot
easier. You really don’t have to sell it.”
BI Research 20
Building the Smart Business: Connecting People, Processes, and Information
About BI Research
BI Research is a research and consulting company whose goal is to help companies
understand and exploit new developments in business intelligence and business
integration. When combined, business intelligence and business integration enable
an organization to become a smart business.
BI Research
Post Office Box 398
Ashland, OR 97520
Telephone: (541)-552-9126
Internet URL: www.bi-research.com
E-mail: [email protected]