Corporate Governance Research Paper-1
Corporate Governance Research Paper-1
Corporate Governance Research Paper-1
SUBMITTED BY-
1. PRATHANA MOHANTY, 2182057, BBA-A, 6th
SEMESTER
2. PRACHITARA PATRA, 2182053, BBA-A, 6th SEMESTER
3. BIDIPTA MANDAL, 2182029, BBA-A, 6th SEMESTER
SUBMITTED TO-
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
LITERATURE REVIEW
METHODOLOGY
FINDINGS
DISCUSSION
CHALLENGES
STRATEGIES
CONCLUSION
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ABSTRACT
3
INTRODUCTION
4
LITERATURE REVIEW
Hogg, M. A., & Terry, D. I. (2000), Social identity and self-
categorization processes in organizational contexts
Social Categorization Theory:
The social-categorization theory proposes that persons belonging to various
social groups (e.g. nation, employer, or school). People classify themselves
into identification groups based on prominent traits, act in conjunction with
their categories, and choose situations that affirm group identification,
according to this theory. As a result, when compared to comparable persons,
dissimilar individuals are less likely to collaborate. As a function of positive
biases for in-group individuals and unfavorable biases toward out-group
individuals, social categorization may obstruct the elaboration of task-
relevant information1.
Schneider, S. K., & North craft, G. B. (1999). Three social dilemmas of
workforce diversity in organizations: A social identity perspective
Social Identity Theory:
According to social identity theory, people legitimize their social identities
by preferring their social category or intergroup over outgroups to which
they do not belong. People in a company are more comfortable working
with their identity group, which increases productivity. Employees in the
organization believe that persons from different intergroup will have
different perceptions and cause disputes. Being a member of a group can
foster a sense of belonging among its members. When group members
believe they are similar to others, trust and acceptance improve. Feelings of
inclusion and acceptance grow together. Perceiving connections among
group members is simply one component that leads to feelings of belonging.
Another facet of inclusion is being recognized and appreciated for one's
contributions to the group2.
1
Homan, A. C., van Knippenberg, D., Van Kleef, G. A., & De Dreu, C. K. W. (2007). Bridging Faultlines by Valuing
Diversity: Diversity Beliefs, Information Elaboration, and Performance in Diverse Work Groups. Journal of
Applied Psychology,
92(5), 1189–1199. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.92.5.1189
2
Brimhall, K. C., Mor Barak, M. E., Hurlburt, M., McArdle, J. J., Palinkas, L., & Henwood, B. (2017). Increasing
Workplace
Inclusion: The Promise of Leader-Member Exchange. Human Service Organizations Management, Leadership
and Governance,
41(3), 222–239. https://doi.org/10.1080/23303131.2016.1251522
7
[41] Roberson, Q. M. (2006). Disentangling the meanings of diversity and inclusion in organizations. Group and
Organization Management, 31(2), 212–236. https://doi.org/10.1177/1059601104273064.
9
METHODOLOGY
This research paper adopts a comprehensive approach to explore the critical
issue of diversity, equity and inclusion within the workplace. The methodology
is structured as follows:
FINDINGS
The findings provide an insight into what employees perceive as a diverse
and inclusive workplace by including the aspect of equity, how significant a
diverse and inclusive workplace is for employees, how diversity management
influences employee perception of a diverse and inclusive workplace and
whether or not employees feel their workplace is diverse and inclusive. This
research has revealed a wide range of diversity, equity, and inclusion challenges
across different industries and organizations. There is a significant
underrepresentation of certain groups in the workplace, such as people with
disabilities, LGBTQ+ individuals, and ethnic minorities. Moreover, there is a
lack of policies and practices that support inclusive workplace cultures. It was
discovered that the current state of DEI in the workplace needs improvement to
achieve better outcomes for employees and the organization.
The study discovered that the benefits of DEI in the workplace are numerous,
leading to a more productive, innovative, and engaged workforce. However,
significant challenges such as unconscious biases, lack of leadership support,
and the absence of cultural competency among employees can hinder the
effectiveness of DEI programs.
This research further identified various types of DEI strategies that
organizations can use to achieve a more inclusive and equitable workplace.
These include leadership involvement, targeted hiring and recruitment,
assessment and development of current employees, communication and
awareness campaigns, and tangible incentives and recognition programs.
13
DISCUSSION
Among the Fortune 500 companies, 154 have proactively released reports
on diversity, equity and inclusion.
Diversity data in Purpose Brand’s second annual survey of corporate DEI
reports reveals a focus on women in corporate governance and top management.
Our review found 154 published diversity reports from Fortune 500 companies,
compared to 79 reports in our previous survey of diversity report examples.
Among these 154 reports, 132 companies recognized U.S. gender and racial
representation in their diversity reports, all but one of them as separate statistics
rather than combining women and people of color. Of the 131 companies
sharing data on Black, Indigenous and people of color, 105 noted POC
proportions in board, senior management or management roles.
In reporting gender representation, 112 reports stated the percentage of women
in top management; 46 reports indicated the positions these women occupy.
These corporate diversity statistics speak to greater corporate commitment to
gender representation in leadership roles.
Below the Topline, Fewer Signs of Inclusion
The DEI report data also brings to light areas for broader industry attention. For
instance, data on open positions being filled by women and POC was scarcely
reported, with only AT&T offering information on both metrics and Discover
Financial Services presenting the metric for female hires.
The focus on individuals with disabilities in the U.S, workforce also seems
limited, with only 19 companies sharing statistics. Veterans are represented in
the statistics of 27 companies.
In the realm of sexual orientation and gender identity, only 12 companies
reported their LGBTQ+ workforce composition. Boeing distinguished itself not
merely for leading percentages but also for its nuanced division between gender
identity (14%) and sexual orientation (12%).
Workforce trends around hiring were also less in evidence. Only 33 reports
showcased data about women as new hires. While 36 companies provided
statistics on POC as new hires, 12 hired over 50% POC.
A baker’s dozen shared their internal promotion statistics. Just three reached
gender parity, one counting only senior positions. For POC promotions, four
exceeded the 50% mark. AT&T and Discover disclosed open positions filled by
14
women; AT&T also noted the proportiton of POC candidates filling open
positions.
Why Reports Need Deep Dive into DEI Data
The analysis suggests varying degrees of inclusion across Fortune 500
companies
Most companies that share workforce data are showing improvement over the
U.S. population. A significant segment attributes value to DEI performance, yet
reporting across diverse categories is uneven, suggesting a lack of progress or
adherence to DEI commitments.
While gender representation commands significant attention, areas like
disability, veteran status and LGBTQ+ representation receive comparatively
little focus. Also, reporting is far from comprehensive in areas that indicate
transformative action, such as open positions being filled by women and POC.
2023 DEI Report Examples from Fortune 500 Companies
Walmart. Walmart's midyear Culture, Diversity, Equity & Inclusion report
communicates a commitment to fostering a culture of belonging. The retailer
presents data to show a significant representation of women and people of color
in officer roles and highlights an increase in diverse senior leadership. Walmart
emphasizes inclusion through different councils, employee resource groups
(ERGs), and community engagements.
Amazon. The retail and web services company reports U.S. workforce data by
field/customer service, corporate, people management and senior management
employees, suggesting objectives to diversify the entire organization. Videos
profile women in STEM roles and POC creators. In a message to employees,
Global DEI VP Candi Castleberry said a racial equity audit will evaluate U.S.
hourly operations.
ExxonMobil. ExxonMobil's sustainability report section Investing in People
indicates a focus on talent acquisition and retention to achieve leadership and
innovation goals. The report mentions initiatives to enhance the representation
of women and minority groups, aiming for a collaborative and continuously
evolving workplace.
Apple. The computer device maker and seller gives racial and gender
breakdowns of its U.S. workforce for tech, nontech, retail and leadership
positions. Apple recruiters engage with the company’s Diversity Network
Associations to build skills and promote open positions. Support of historically
15
Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) includes volunteer mentors and guest
lecturers.
UnitedHealth. The healthcare insurer expanded mental health support for
families with children, expanded paid parental leave, provided paid caregiver
leave and began a maternity and infant care program. UnitedHealth Group’s
sustainability report notes a DEI Innovation Lab event and a “relaunch” of
ERGs to understand employee experiences. Two-fifths of senior managers are
women.
CVS: CVS Health’s Diversity Highlights review outlines its drive to boost
diverse representation with specific, measurable goals, reportedly linked to
compensation. The company's report suggests an emphasis on leadership
development and revised hiring guidelines. Through partnerships like the one
with the United Negro College Fund, CVS Health offers scholarships aiming to
support students in healthcare fields.
Alphabet: The diversity annual report for Google, Alphabet’s primary
operating company, highlights its pledge to transparency, presenting a
comprehensive diversity dataset. The company points to the essential role of
managerial staff in fostering inclusivity. A DEI advisory board's
recommendations are said to guide reviews of DEI principles, centering on
education and technological solutions.
McKesson. An impact report lists the pharma company’s 11 ERGs and a
companywide awareness campaign. “We started with our leaders by taking an
inventory to understand where they are on their journey,” states an executive
team introduction, “and by doing so we were able to start developing their
competencies.”
Chevron. Chevron's corporate sustainability report claims to address racial
barriers through community partnerships, education, job creation and talent and
leadership development. The company claims that its partnership with the
Executive Leadership Council has led to leadership training for over 135 Black
employees. A section of the energy company’s career website highlights
engineering opportunities for women, neurodiversity hiring, Employee Network
Groups and diversity targets that can be tied to compensation.
AmerisourceBergen: According to AmerisourceBergen's Diversity, Equity and
Inclusion Report, the pharma company is dedicated to DEI within the global
healthcare context. Its strategy incorporates ERGs for insights. The company's
communications suggest an expansive DEI perspective, highlighting efforts to
promote equitable health outcomes.
16
2. Adani
3. Deloitte
4. Wipro
17
18
19
20
21
CHALLENGES
Resistance to Change: Some employees may resist diversity and
inclusion initiatives due to fear of change or feeling threatened by the
perceived loss of privilege or power.
Unconscious Bias: Implicit biases can affect decision-making processes,
including hiring, promotion, and team dynamics, leading to unintentional
discrimination.
Lack of Awareness and Education: Employees may not fully
understand the importance of diversity and inclusion or how to effectively
contribute to creating an inclusive environment.
Siloed Thinking: Departments or teams may operate in silos, hindering
collaboration and knowledge sharing across diverse groups.
Retention and Turnover: A lack of inclusivity can lead to
dissatisfaction among employees from underrepresented groups, resulting
in higher turnover rates and difficulty in retaining top talent.
Micro aggressions and Discrimination: Subtle forms of discrimination,
such as micro aggressions or exclusionary behavior, can create hostile
work environments and impact employees' well-being and productivity.
Inequitable Policies and Practices: Organizational policies and
practices that are not inclusive can perpetuate disparities and hinder the
advancement of diverse employees.
Tokenism: Being the only representative of a particular group can lead to
feelings of tokenism and pressure to represent the entire group, rather
than being valued for individual contributions.
Addressing these challenges requires a comprehensive approach that includes
leadership commitment, ongoing education and training, transparent policies
and practices, and fostering a culture of belonging and respect for all
employees.
22
CONCLUSION
Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) has become increasingly significant
in the modern-day workplace. In today's global economy, organizations
recognize that a diverse workforce provides a competitive edge in creating
innovation and meeting customer needs. This research paper aims to explore the
significance of DEI in the workplace and analyses strategies that can be
implemented to achieve and sustain a diverse workforce. Additionally, it
highlights the challenges organizations face in implementing DEI strategies.
Diversity in the workplace refers to the differences in characteristics,
backgrounds, and perspectives among employees. A diverse workforce can
increase creativity, better decision-making, and improve problem-solving.
However, diversity alone is not enough to achieve a fully inclusive workplace.
Diversity must be accompanied by equitable practices that provide equal
opportunities for all employees.
Equity in the workplace confirms that all employees are supplied with fair and
equal opportunities for growth and advancement, regardless of their background
or characteristics. It is essential to recognize that individuals face different
barriers to employment, such as systemic discrimination, and equity is
necessary to overcome these barriers. Without equity, a diverse workforce can
still result in unequal representation and opportunities.
Inclusion is creating a workplace environment where all employees feel valued
and included. It involves creating a culture where employees feel comfortable
communicating their opinions and ideas, regardless of their background.
Inclusive workplaces lead to higher employee engagement and retention rates,
increased job satisfaction, and improved performance.
DEI has become increasingly significant in the workplace due to several
reasons. Firstly, globalization has led to an increase in diversity in the
workforce. Secondly, research has shown that a diverse and inclusive workplace
improves performance and increases innovation. Thirdly, there is a growing
recognition that equity is necessary to overcome systemic discrimination that
exists in the workplace. Finally, DEI is becoming increasingly important due to
shifting demographics, as younger generations emphasize workplace diversity
and inclusion.
Organizations can implement several strategies to achieve and sustain a diverse
and inclusive workforce. Firstly, they can implement inclusive hiring practices,
such as eliminating bias in job descriptions and using diverse recruitment
26
sources. Secondly, they can provide diversity and inclusion training to all
employees, including management. Thirdly, organizations can implement
diversity and inclusion councils or employee resource groups to promote
diversity and inclusion within the workplace. Finally, they can create an
inclusive workplace culture by promoting work-life balance, providing flexible
work arrangements, and offering benefits that cater to diverse employee needs.
Implementing DEI strategies can present several challenges for organizations.
Unconscious bias can still exist, leading to unequal representation and
opportunities. Secondly, there can be a lack of understanding and awareness of
DEI issues among employees and management. Thirdly, implementing DEI
strategies can require significant time and resources, leading to resistance from
some employees or management. Finally, it can be challenging to sustain DEI
efforts, particularly if they are not embedded within the organization’s culture.
In conclusion, diversity, equity, and inclusion are critical components of a
successful and sustainable workforce. Organizations prioritizing DEI can reap
the benefits of improved performance, increased innovation, and higher
employee engagement and retention rates.
However, implementing DEI strategies can present several challenges, and it
requires a long-term commitment from organizations to create a culture that
prioritizes DEI. Ultimately, a diverse and inclusive workforce is essential to
meet the evolving needs of today's global economy.
Recommendations for future research
1. Longitudinal Studies:
Investigate the long-term impact of D&I initiatives on organizational
performance. Understand how sustained efforts influence employee
satisfaction and business outcomes.
2. Intersectionality:
Explore the intersection of multiple identities (e.g., race, gender, disability) in
D&I efforts.
3. Inclusive Leadership:
Study the role of leaders in fostering inclusive cultures. Identify leadership
behaviors that drive positive change.
4. Quantifying Intangible Benefits:
Develop metrics to measure the intangible benefits of D&I (e.g., creativity,
trust, employee morale). Quantify their impact on organizational success.
27
BIBLIOGRAPHY
SITES REFERRED-
https://www.iima.ac.in
https://www.goodera.com
https://www.jetir.org
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
https://www.mckinsey.com
https://www.achievers.com
ARTICLES REFERRED-
Harvard Business Law Review on Diversity & Inclusion Magazine
Pew Research Centre article on Diversity, Inclusion & Equity in
Workplace
IMA Report on current state of diversity in corporate governance
The Inclusion Imperative for Boards- Deloitte Insight
D&I for successful corporate governance- lexology