Problem Set 9
Problem Set 9
450
Problem Set 9
This problem set reviews the old procedure of estimating closed-loop stability by the Bode
method, as well as tuning by gain and phase margins. The pretext is a change of controlled
variable for the stirred reactor of Lesson 6; you will use the linearized model of Lesson 6 to do
the engineering for this change. It should provide a striking illustration of the effect of
nonlinearity on our linear models.
Again, use the spreadsheet “exothermic reactor for pset8.xls” to calculate steady-state conditions.
(1) Take reference conditions for the linearized model at the hot steady state in the PSet 8
spreadsheet. Set TI to 3 s, TD to 0, and find the controller gain Kc (units are %out %in-1) that
meets GM = 2 and PM = 30° limits.
(2) Then assume that you choose to operate at the cold steady state. For better accuracy, you
adjust the linear model parameters to this new reference condition. However, you leave the
controller tuned as in (1). At what GM and PM are you now operating?
(3) In Lesson 6, we found that the temperature control loop was intrinsically stable. Why can the
composition loop, for this same process, be made unstable?
(4) Would you recommend retuning the controller for the cold condition? Please explain.
(6) How can the sensor we specified possibly work at both hot and cold operating conditions?