Celebrity and Health Promotion Media Role Cance
Celebrity and Health Promotion Media Role Cance
Celebrity and Health Promotion Media Role Cance
It is well-known that celebrities can influence the mass public, helping to shape behaviours and
attitudes. The goal of this research is to understand the impact of a celebrity’s cancer news on Brazilian
society. Our hypothesis is that news about celebrities with cancer attracts much public attention, but
the media squander the chance to educate, inform and enlighten the public about this disease. We
studied the news published in online newspapers about the Brazilian actor Reynaldo Gianecchini, who
was diagnosed with lymphoma in 2011. We selected news published during specific periods – those
during which there was a surge in searches on Google, according to Google Trends tool. This study
shows that the public is interested in seeking information about cancer when a celebrity is diagnosed
with the disease. Although the public has shown interest in knowing more about the disease, the media
gave greater focus on celebrity itself. Journalists provide content with a more emotional and dramatic
bias – especially when it comes to celebrities.
INTRODUCTION
A public person is promoted from the status of ‘ordinary ple, ‘organized health promotion has long understood that
person’ to ‘celebrity’ from the time when the media starts by engaging a celebrity with a health issue … coverage
not only to show interest in his or her professional of the issue de jour can be increased to levels that would
accomplishments, but also to investigate the individual’s otherwise require stratospheric campaign budgets’
private life (Turner, 2004). The American historian Daniel (Chapman and Leask, 2001; Chapman and Lupton,
Boorstin originated one of the most famous aphorisms on 1994).
the subject: ‘The celebrity is a person who is well-known Likewise, when celebrities become ill or die, they are
for his well-knownness’ (Boorstin, 1961). able to generate massive nationwide or even worldwide
More than just entertaining the masses, celebrities can mobilization. Some remarkable cases include basketball
influence masses, helping to shape certain behaviours player ‘Magic’ Johnson’s contraction of HIV (Kalichman
and attitudes (Mashable, 2006; Turner, 2004). For exam- and Hunter, 1992), musician Kurt Cobain’s suicide
Author agree that this article remain permanently open access under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License 4.0 International License
42 J. Media Commun. Stud.
(Martin and Koo, 1997), Michael Jackson’s death (2009), when studying Brazilian media framing approach
(Sanderson and Cheong, 2010) after the indiscriminate concerning stem cells, state that “Brazilian media
use of prescription drugs, former US President Ronald analyzed […] presented evidence for and against
Reagan’s colorectal cancer (Martin and Potosky, 1990), research with stem cells, but it was biased in the
and Australian singer Kylie Minogue’s breast cancer. In selection of letters for publication and in the choice of
the last case, news coverage of Kylie Minogue's breast scenes included in newscasts".
cancer diagnosis caused an unprecedented increase in
mammography bookings in Australia (Chapman et al.,
2005); and more recently, in 2013, the case of Angelina METHODOLOGY
Jolie, a worldwide famous actress, which published a
News selection criteria
letter on The New York Times detailing what she called
“My Medical Choice”. She explained that she inherited a The sample period ranges from August 2011, when the disease of
faulty BRCA gene and decided therefore to undergo a Gianecchini was first diagnosed, to March 2012, when it was
double mastectomy. announced in the news that his cancer was in remission.
In general, it is observed that these episodes direct the We selected news published during specific periods – those
media coverage of related health and medical issues, during which there was a surge in searches on Google, the most
accessible search engine in Western countries (Haucap and
raising awareness and encouraging public debate on the Heimeshoff, 2013). To this purpose, we used the Google Trends
subject matter (Levy et al., 2012; Martin and Potosky, tool, which shows – within a specific time period– the search
1990; Metcalfe et al., 2010; Sanderson and Cheong, frequency of particular terms. This tool does not provide absolute
2010). numbers, but it builds a graph showing relative measures of
In August 2011, Brazilian soap opera’s actor Reynaldo Internet activity. According to Segev and Baram-Tsabari:
Gianecchini was diagnosed with lymphoma, a type of
Google Trends (GT) (www.google.com/trends) first became
blood cancer; the revelation of his illness caused great available to the public in May 2006 to assist research on searches
national concern (Nascimento et al., 2012). Throughout in Google Search and news articles collected in Google News. GT
August, all Brazilian media covered the actor’s illness analyzes and displays the proportion of searches for terms
extensively. It is important to emphasize that television is compared to the total number of searches made on Google over a
the dominant means of communication in the country. defined period of time (between 2004 and the present). GT also
shows how frequently topics have appeared in Google News stories
According to Brazilian Media Research (2015), 95% of and in which geographic regions people have searched for them
the Brazilians watch TV regularly and 74% watch TV the most. (Segev and Baram-Tsabari, 2010)
programs every day. “In Brazil, soap operas – broadcast On Google Trends, we searched for the terms ‘Gianecchini’ and
firstly in radio and later in TV – became one of the most ‘linfoma’ (‘lymphoma’ in English). During the period of data
popular TV programs, reaching huge audiences, collection, there were four points of sudden increase in searches for
sometimes overcoming the index of 50% of the whole the first term, and two for the latter. Each point represents a period
of one week. We started from the assumption that these points
population” (Massarani and Moreira, 2002). It is common resulted from times when the media had published news about the
that soap opera’s actors, such as Gianecchini, become actor that had caught the public’s attention and consequently, more
national idols. people had searched for these terms on Google. We restricted our
Considering this phenomenon, our hypothesis is that analysis to the news published in these peak periods.
news about celebrities with cancer attracts much public
attention, but the media squander the chance to educate,
Analysis of the social network Twitter
inform and enlighten the public about this disease,
because they instead focus on glamorizing the personal In addition, we decided to only look at news that reached a
life of the individual. minimum level of popularity on the social network Twitter. Twitter is
To investigate our hypothesis, we have employed the a microblogging platform whose main goal is to let people know
theory of media framing (Goffman, 1974; Tuchman, 1978; what is happening ‘right now’. In rankings by country, Brazil has the
fifth-highest number of active users in this social network (Statista,
Gitlin, 1980; Entman, 1989, 1993, 2004; Reese, 2001; 2014). Moreover, Portuguese is the fifth most spoken language on
Crawley, 2007) to analyse the most popular news on this platform (Mashable, 2006).Twitter allows users to share
Gianecchini's case, seeking common aspects among messages of up to 140 characters, which their followers can read
them. ‘Framing’ suggests that news media are not immediately. The profile displays a user's posts – or 'tweets' – in
impartial, as they make certain public issues more chronological order, with the latest additions appearing at the top of
noticeable than others, while also providing a specific the profile. Users can follow one another's content without recipro-
cal obligation (Marwick and Boyd, 2011). Twitter is used extensively
news angle that characterizes those events (Crawley, by major newspapers and magazines as a complementary way to
2007). Frames call attention to some aspects of reality publish news. In general, this takes the form of short news
while obscuring other elements, which might influence headlines followed by a hyperlink that directs the reader to the
audiences’ reactions (Entman, 1993). Jurberg et al. corresponding newspaper or magazine’s website, where the full
Biancovilli et al. 43
Figure 1. Google Trends graph showing surges on searches for the terms ‘Gianecchini’ (in blue) and ‘linfoma’ (in red).
Source: http://www.google.com.br/trends/ .
None of these news stories contained infographics; two he declared he had ‘a very rare and complicated cancer’.
quoted experts; two explained the disease and seven The interview was entirely recorded on video and posted
included metaphors on cancer, all of them including the on the website YouTube, causing great commotion
word ‘fight’. because he cries several times (numerous copies of this
The two stories that explain the disease have the video are available on YouTube, the most popular of
following titles: ‘Cover of magazine “Veja” shows which has about 80,000 views). Of the 27 stories, three
Gianecchini bald’, from the Internet “Portal Terra” (often discussed this interview.
accessed by those seeking information on celebrities), Another highlight of the period related to rumors that
and ‘Magazine shows Reynaldo Gianecchini’s head Gianecchini had once again been hospitalized. In fact,
shaved’. Importantly, the weekly magazine “Veja” has the such news was released by a fake Twitter profile of the
largest national circulation in Brazil. In both cases, the actor, and was immediately contradicted by his press
explanation of lymphoma is not contained within the body office. Three of the news stories from this period refer to
of the text but in a hyperlink that redirects the reader to this fact.
another page on the same site, where it is possible to find
more detailed information about the nature of lymphoma
and how it is treated. Fourth surge in searches - ‘Gianecchini’
friends and even strangers. power to shape habits and health behaviour among the
general public. According to Hoffman and Tan (2013), the
influence of a celebrity’s status is a deeply rooted
Google Trends and interests of the audience process that can be harnessed for good or abused for
harm, especially with regard to health issues.
Analysis of the graph produced by Google Trends shows Considering the most popular news on Twitter about
that the public interest in Gianecchini’s lymphoma tended Reynaldo Gianecchini’s lymphoma, in the week of the
to decrease over subsequent months. This is probably diagnosis, we found that 11 of the 55 studied news items
because the actor's health condition had steadily provided explanations of the disease, and nine quoted
improved over the months, showing no relapse. experts, which shows that media framing in that week did
The first surge in searches for the term lymphoma (6– not have a prominent scientific and informative bias.
12 August 2011) showed that the public wanted more Furthermore, none of the articles, even those that explain
information on the disease, not only on the celebrity. The the disease, cover the topic of cancer prevention. Some
point of a celebrity’s cancer diagnosis is, therefore, the measures can be taken to decrease the possibility of
best moment to clarify details of the disease, showing being affected by certain types of cancer. Diets rich in
how to prevent it, what the symptoms are and how the fruits and vegetables, for example, may have a protective
treatment works, among other things. Celebrity cancer effect against non-Hodgkin lymphomas. Exposure to
cases generate extreme public awareness of the disease; certain chemicals, including pesticides, solvents,
at this time more than any other, the media has great fertilizers, herbicides and insecticides, are related to the
46 J. Media Commun. Stud.
development of lymphomas (Instituto Nacional do on the cover of the magazine “Veja”, which is the most
Câncer, 2013). popular magazine in Brazil. The third surge of searches
Some studies show that the media could contribute occurred for various reasons, but the interview with the
greatly to disseminating preventive behaviours (Goffman, actor, which was widely publicized on social networks,
1974; Kalichman and Hunter, 1992; Martin and Potosky, drew widespread public attention. These events show
1990; Chapman and Leask, 2001; Chapman et al., 2005; that Gianecchini’s case continued to stigmatize the
Metcalfe et al., 2010; Bhatti and Redelmeier, 2014). negative aspects of cancer, such as physical changes
Theories of health information acquisition consider (hair loss) and distress (he cried a lot in his first
information-seeking to be an important mediator between interview). Also, the disclosure of the Gianecchini’s
a stimulating event and a subsequent initiation or change spiritual surgery achieved prominence in the media. A
in behaviour (Griffin et al., 1999; Niederdeppe et al., spiritual surgery is a complementary/alternative therapeu-
2008). According to Bhatti and Redelmeier (2014), the tic method carried out by mediums (De Almeida et al.,
case of Angelina Jolie: 2000). This reveals strong potential for sensationalism in
coverage of such methods. Accordingly, none of the
“…there was a large temporary surge in queries about news discussing this spiritual surgery told the story in a
genetics and treatment, a modest increase in queries skeptical way, or explained that it was not the correct
about general information and risk assessment, and a medical procedure of treating lymphoma. In short, this
rapid return to baseline after about one week. The news does a disservice to the population, because it
implication is that Angelina Jolie spurred significant opens up the dangerous possibility that some might be
information-seeking about breast cancer genetic testing encouraged to think that spiritual surgery could suffice for
for a short time.” (Bhatti and Redelmeier, 2014) medical procedures.
Another highlight is the large number of metaphors
Moreover, when the Australian singer Kylie Minogue was found in all periods analyzed – from the 100 news items
diagnosed with breast cancer in 2005, at the age of 36, studied in total, 60 used metaphors, especially those
the media in her country covered the event massively, containing the terms ‘struggle’ and ‘battle’. Until now, no
generating in the process a ‘Kylie effect’ (Chapman et al., Brazilian study set out to investigate the war metaphors
2005): a 40% increase in the amount of appointments for in discourse about cancer. Studies on cancer by Sontag
mammograms in the two weeks after the diagnosis was (1978), Clarke and Robinson (1999), Grant and Hundley
made public, plus a 101% increase in mammograms for (2009), Seale (2001a, 2001b), Hauser and Schwarz
previously unscreened women in the eligible age group of (2015) came to important conclusions. When relating
40–69 years. This effect was boosted by the way in which cancer to war metaphors and imagery, for example, ‘fight
the media presented the theme: Minogue was repeatedly against the enemy’, and ‘battle to be won’, media tends to
reported to have a good prognosis because the cancer strengthen an extremely negative stereotype of the
had been detected early, which boded well for her disease. According to Sontag (1978), cancer is
recovery and survival (28%). The importance of early spectacularly overloaded with trap metaphors, and this
detection was often stressed in news stories (8%), and has cost many lives in the past. Many years after the
26% of news items gave a more general prevention Sontag studies, we still note that cancer is referred to by
message. Journalists emphasized explicitly that vigilance media as a sort of punishment (Verjovsky and Jurberg,
and mammograms were relevant for all women 2012), instead of a relatively common disease that can
(Chapman et al., 2005). affect anyone. Moreover, according to Hauser and
A similar approach, focusing mainly on lymphoma, Schwarz (2015), Framing cancer in terms of bellicose
appeared prominently in the period in which Gianecchini enemy metaphors has unintended side-effects that may
was diagnosed with the disease, then faded with the impair efficient prevention strategies. Many behaviors
passage of time. Infographics appeared three times that reduce the risk of cancer require one to limit
among 55 news items in the first period: once in the third enjoyable activities, from sunbathing to drinking alcohol
period (among 27 stories) and once in the fourth period and eating red meats. Yet, limiting and constraining
(among seven stories). This tool should be used with oneself is not a concept closely associated with fighting
more emphasis by health journalists in order to hold enemies. Hence, a bellicose message frame that empha-
readers’ attention once it has been captivated by the sizes fighting an enemy may render these protective
subject (Tabakman, 2013). Another point of interest we behaviors less compelling than they might otherwise be.
consider is the investigation of one aspect of the second Although the use of war metaphors when writing and
period studied (between 17 and 23 September 2011), talking about cancer is quite common, it is important that
when Gianecchini had appeared in public with a shaved journalists acquire a greater awareness of the negative
head for the first time. It is noteworthy that his photo was consequences that the use of this figure of speech can
Biancovilli et al. 47
bring to the audience. De Almeida AM, De Almeida TM, Gollner AM (2000). Cirurgia espiritual:
Uma investigação. Revista da Associação Médica Brasileira,
doi:10.1590/S0104-42302000000300002. 46(3):194-200
Entman RM (1989). Democracy without citizens: Media and the decay
Conclusion of American politics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Entman RM (1993). Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured
This study shows that the public is interested in seeking paradigm. J. Commun, 43(4):51-58.
information about cancer when a celebrity is diagnosed Entman RM (2004). Projections of power: Framing news, public opinion,
with the disease. The graph produced by Google Trends and U. S. foreign policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gitlin T(1980). The whole world is watching: Mass media in the making
shows that, especially during the first peak searches.
and unmaking of the new left. Berkeley, CA: University of California
Although the public has shown interest in knowing more Press.
about the disease, the media gave greater focus on Goffman E (1974). Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of
celebrity itself. Journalists provide content with a more experience. New York: Longman.
Grant JA, Hundley H (2009). Images of the war on cancer in the
emotional and dramatic bias – especially when it comes
associated press: Centering survivors and marginalizing victims. Am.
to celebrities. Commun. J. 11(4). Retrieved from
This is proven by the large number of metaphors of http://acjournal.org/journal/2009/Winter/Articles/110405%20Images%
battle and war, used repeatedly in such news stories, as 20of%20the%20War%20on%20Cancer%20in%20the%20Associated
%20Press.pdf
well as the exploration of themes such as spiritual
Griffin RJ, Dunwoody S, Neuwirth K (1999). Proposed model of the
surgery. Despite some limitations of our study, we believe relationship of risk information seeking and processing to the
that our results may contribute to the improvement of the development of preventive behaviours. Environmental Research, 80:
scientific journalism currently practiced in Brazil. New 230-245.
Haucap J, Heimeshoff U (2013). Google, Facebook, Amazon, eBay: Is
health communication strategies must be sought in order
the internet driving competition or market monopolization? DICE
to transform media into a non-formal educational tool that Discussion Retrieved from
assists to inform the population about cancer, and other https://www.econstor.eu/dspace/bitstream/10419/68229/1/73435858
medical and health conditions, in a clear and objective X.pdf. Pp.83.
Hauser D, Schwarz N (2015). The War on Prevention: Bellicose Cancer
way.
Metaphors Hurt (Some) Prevention Intentions. Personality and Social
Psychology Bulletin, Retrieved from
http://psp.sagepub.com/content/41/1/66.full.pdf+html Pp.41.
Acknowledgments Hoffman SJ, Tan C (2013). Following celebrities’ medical advice:
Meta-narrative analysis. Brit. Med. J. 347:7151f.
The authors would like to thank the financial support of Instituto Nacional do Câncer (2013). Linfoma Não-Hodgkin. Retrieved
Fundação do Câncer. Furthermore, we would like to from http://www.inca.gov.br/conteudo_view.asp?id=457
Jurberg C, Verjovsky M, Machado GOC, Affonso-Mittidieri OR (2009).
thank Vivian M. Rumjanek for suggestions and valuable
Embryonic stem cell: A climax in the reign of the Brazilian media.
opinions. Public Understanding of Science, 18(6):719-729.
Kalichman SC, Hunter T (1992). The disclosure of celebrity HIV
infection: Its effects on public attitudes. Am. J. Public Health,
Conflict of Interests doi:10.2105/APJH. 82(10):1374-1376.
Levy I, Petra T, DE Castro V (2012). Politica e Saúde ne blogosfera: a
polêmica sobre o câncer de Lula. Intercom – Sociedade Brasileira de
The author has not declared any conflict of interests. Estudos Interdisciplinaires da Comunicação.
Martin G, Koo L (1997). Celebrity suicide: Did the death of Kurt Cobain
influence young suicides in Australia? Archives of Suicide Research,
REFERENCES 3:187-198.
Martin L, Potosky AL (1990). The presidential effect: The public health
Boorstin DJ (1961). The image: A guide to pseudo-events in America. response to media coverage about Ronald Reagan’s colon cancer
New York: Vintage. episode. Public Opinion Quarterly, 54(3):317-329.
Chapman S, Holding S, Mcleod K, Wakefield M (2005). Impact of news Marwick A, Boyd D (2011). To be and be seen: Celebrity practice on
of celebrity illness on breast cancer screening: Kylie Minogue’s Twitter. Intl J. Res. Into New Media Technologies,
breast cancer diagnosis. Med. J. Australia, 183(5):247-250. doi:10.1177/1354856510394539 17(2):139-158.
Chapman S, Leask J (2001). Paid celebrity endorsement in health Massarani L, Moreira I (2002). Human cloning: A soap opera as a
promotion: A case study from Australia. Health Promotion science communication tool. Paper presented at 7th Conference on
International, 16: 333-338. the Public Communication of Science and Technology, Cape Town,
Chapman S, Lupton D (1994). The fight for public health: Principles and South Africa, December. Pp.4-7.
practice of public health media advocacy. London: Brit. Med. J. Metcalfe D, Price CL, Powell J (2010). Media coverage and public
Books. reaction to a celebrity cancer diagnosis. Journal of Public Health,
Clarke J, Robinson J (1999). Testicular cancer: Medicine and machismo 33:80-85.
in the media (1980-94). Health, doi:10.1177/136345939900300302. Nascimento P, Aguas R, De Lima D, Kong X, Osiek B, Xexéo G, De
3: 263-282. Souza J (2012). Análise de sentimento de tweets com foco em
Crawley CE (2007). Localized debates of agricultural biotechnology in notícias. Paper presented at XXXII Congresso da Sociedade
community newspapers: A quantitative content analysis of media Brasileira de Computação, Curitiba, Brazil, 16-19 July.
frames and sources. Science Communication, Niederdeppe J, Frosch D, Hornik R (2008). Cancer news coverage and
doi:10.1177/1075547006298253. 28:314. information seeking. Journal of Health Communication,
48 J. Media Commun. Stud.
doi:10.1080/10810730701854110 13: 181-199. Statista – The Statistics Portal. (2014, March.) Retrieved from
Pesquisa Brasileira de Mídia (2015, January). Retrieved from: http://www.statista.com/statistics/261402/distribution-of-twitter-traffic-
http://www.abradi.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Pesquisa- by-country/
Brasileira-de-M%C3%ADdia-PBM-2015-1.pdf Tabakman R (2013). A saúde na mídia. São Paulo: Summus Editorial.
Reese SD (2001). Prologue. In S. D. Reese, O. H. Gandy & A. E. Grant Tuchman G (1978). Making news: A study in the construction of reality.
(Eds.), Framing public life: Perspectives on media and our New York: Free Press.
understanding of the social world. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Turner G (2004.) Understanding celebrity. London: Sage.
Samano E, Goldenstein P, RIbeiro ., Lewin F, FIlho E, Soares H, Del Verjovsky M, Jurberg C (2012). Spotlight on the news: A critical review
Giglio A (2004). Praying correlates with higher quality of life: results of cancer disclosure. J. Med. and Comm. Stud.
from a survey on complementary/alternative medicine use among a doi:10.5897/JMCS12.020 4(8):150-158.
group of Brazilian cancer patients. São Paulo Med. J. Retrieved from:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S1516-31802004000200005. 122(2):60-63.
Sanderson J, Cheong PH (2010). Tweeting prayers and communicating
grief over Michael Jackson online. Bulletin of Science, Technology
and Society, 30(5):328-340. doi:10.1177/0270467610380010
Seale C (2001a). Cancer in the news: Religious themes in news stories
about people with cancer. Health, 5(4), 425-440.
doi:10.1177/136345930100500402.
Seale C (2001b). Sporting cancer: Struggle language in news reports of
people with cancer. Sociology of Health and Illness,
doi:10.1111/1467-9566.00254 23(3):308-329.
Segev E, Baram-Tsabari A (2010.) Seeking science information online:
Data mining Google to better understand the roles of the media and
the education system. Public Understanding of Science.
Doi:10.1177/096366251038756.
Sontag S (1978) Illness as metaphor. London: Penguin.