3a Practical
3a Practical
Some of the AS notes are relevant to the practical paper. These are given below.
Content
The ampere (A) for electrical current, the candela (cd) for luminous intensity, the kelvin (K)
for thermodynamic temperature, the kilogram (kg) for mass, the metre (m) for length, the
mole (mol) for amount of a substance, the second (s) for time.
Joule = kg.m2.s-2, watt= kg.m2.s-3. These units can be derived from equations i.e. From the
equation p=fv, where the unit of power is the newton. F=ma so F=kg.m.s-2, so kg.m.s-2
multiplied by ms-1 (which is the “v” from p=fv) equals kg.m2.s-3. So these are the derives SI
units of power which has the unit of the watt.
marksphysicshelp 1
Above is a table of the SI prefixes and values, with their respective symbols. The symbols
can be used in place of using standard form, however sometimes you will be required to use
standard form, which can be done as follows…
marksphysicshelp 2
3.1.2 limitation of physical measurements
Content
• Students should be able to identify random and systematic errors and suggest ways to
reduce or remove them.
• Students should understand the link between the number of significant figures in the
value of a quantity and its associated uncertainty.
• Students should be able to combine uncertainties in cases where the measurements
that give rise to the uncertainties are added, subtracted, multiplied, divided, or
raised to powers. Combinations involving trigonometric or logarithmic functions
will not be required.
A random error is one which is always present in data, and is due to readings that vary
randomly, with no recognizable trend or bias. A random error could be caused by a faulty
instrument, human error or a poor technique.
A systematic error is one which follows a pattern/trend, or a bias, and results in readings
that systematically differ from the true mean reading. Systematic errors could be caused by a
non-zero reading at the beginning i.e. on a voltmeter/ammeter. There could also be a
consistent error in a technique used, or a calibration error in the instrument.
Uncertainty
marksphysicshelp 3
Absolute, fractional and percentage uncertainties represent uncertainty in the final answer
for a quantity.
The absolute uncertainty is the size of the range of values that the ‘true’ value lies. For
example in a measurement of 10.0m, the uncertainty is ±0.1m. So the absolute uncertainty
would be 10.0m ± 0.1m, as this is the range of values that could be the ‘true’ value. If you
have a range of results ie 0.4, 0.5 and 0.6, the uncertainty is the range of results divided by 2.
Also, anomalies must be ignored in these situations.
Fractional uncertainty is simply the calculating by dividing the uncertainty by the value of
the data. For example: 1.2 s ± 0.1s, the fractional uncertainty would be equal to 0.1 / 1.2
= 0.083̇.
Percentage uncertainty is just the fractional uncertainty multiplied by 100. So for the
fractional uncertainty given above, the percentage uncertainty would be 8. 3̇%. So this tells
us that the value of 1.2 can deviate by ± 8.3̇%.
1. If you add or subtract the two (or more) values to get a final value
The absolute uncertainty in the final value is the sum of the absolute uncertainties. For
example:
2. If you multiply one value with absolute uncertainty by a constant the absolute
uncertainty is also multiplied by the same constant. For example:
3. If you multiply or divide two (or more) values, each with an uncertainty you add the
% uncertainties in the two values to get the % uncertainty in the final value. For
example:
This is
10.0 ± 1% x 4.0 ± 2.5%
4. If you square a value, then you multiply the % uncertainty by 2. If you cube a value,
then you multiply the % uncertainty by 3. If you need the square root of a value, you
divide the % uncertainty by 2.
marksphysicshelp 4
In the question to the right, you are told to find the
absolute and percentage uncertainty in the value of
s when using the equation s = ut + at2/2. This is
done by combining the uncertainties of ut, and
at2/2.
To determine the uncertainty in the gradient of a graph you simply simply add error bars to
the first and last point, and then draw a straight line passing through the lowest error bar of
the one points, and the highest in the other and vice versa. This gives two lines, one with the
steepest possible gradient and one with the shallowest, we then calculate the gradient of each
line and compare it to the best value. The figure below shows how this is done.
marksphysicshelp 5
To determine the uncertainty in the y – intercept we do the same thing as when calculating
the uncertainty in gradient. This time however, we check the lowest, highest and best value
for the intercept by drawing the different possible intercepts from the different gradients.
marksphysicshelp 6
Individual points on the graph may or may not have associated error bars.
marksphysicshelp 7
3.1.3 Estimation of Physical Quantities
Content
• Orders of magnitude.
• Estimation of approximate values of physical quantities.
Orders of Magnitude
When making estimates, it is reasonable to give the figure to one or two significant figures
since the estimate is not supposed to be completely precise. For example, the mass of a car to
be 1000kg, or the length of a football pitch to be 100m. Or you could be asked to estimate the
area under a graph of a curved line. This can be done by drawing trapeziums in, so you can
calculate the area of regular trapeziums along the line. This is shown in the diagram below:
marksphysicshelp 8
Guide to good experimental methods and practice
• Clear method i.e. specific time intervals, values measured etc.
o Explain the method as if you are explaining it to someone with absolutely no
subject and experimental knowledge.
• Equipment required e.g. metre rule, stopwatch etc.
o How to use the equipment?
§ Are you going to use the metre rule vertically upright to measure
something? With a set square to ensure verticality…
• What variables must be controlled e.g. temperature, light intensity etc.
• How can you make results as accurate as possible?
o Reducing parallax error e.g. stand eye level to measuring equipment
o If liquid is involved, STIR the liquid regularly to ensure even distribution of
thermal energy (uniform heating) throughout.
o Repeat measurements and calculate a mean
§ For example, of diameter of a wire (using micrometer, vernier
callipers)
o Make sure equipment does not have a zero error.
o Take heat source away when making measurements (if there is one in the
question) and depending on context of question.
• Find uncertainty on measurements
• Can you plot a graph from your results?
o Can you find a relationship between your data that will yield a straight line
when plotted on a graph?
§ Find proportionality between variables
§ Compare to y = mx + c
§ Take natural logs to both sides
Guide to graphs
• Check units of graph
• If question asks for only the gradient, it will require no units as the gradient is just a
measure of how one variable changes with respect to another.
o If it requires the quantity, make sure to give units
• Check to see if graph starts at 0 when you are calculating the gradient
marksphysicshelp 9
Exam Questions
Question:
State what further measurements the student would need to take to determine the resistivity
of the wire. (in previous questions you gained results regarding length and resistance of the
wire)
Answer:
Remember it says measurement, not a calculable value, so you would need to MEASURE
diameter.
Exam tip:
marksphysicshelp 10
Edexcel Jan 2011 Unit 6 Q4bi)c)
Question:
Answer:
We were told Dq = Dq0e-kt in a previous question, so lnDq = -kt + lnDq0. If we compare this
with the equation of a line y = mx + c, you can see that the gradient is equal to ‘-k’. Since k is
a constant, your gradient will be a constant, yielding a straight line.
Exam tip:
Your teacher suggests using a temperature sensor and a data logger in place of the
thermometer and stop clock.
State an advantage of using a temperature sensor and a data logger in this experiment.
Answer:
Exam tip:
marksphysicshelp 11
Edexcel Jan 2011 Unit 6 Q2a
Question:
A student has an air track which has two trucks, A and B, supported by a cushion of air. He
does an experiment to see whether momentum is conserved when the two trucks collide.
Using an air track reduces friction on the trucks. State why this is important in a momentum
conservation experiment.
Answer:
Question:
The student uses two light gates as shown in the diagram. Truck A carries a card of negligible
mass and length l. A light gate records the time t taken by the card to pass through it.
Explain how you would show that the air track is horizontal before starting the experiment.
Answer:
marksphysicshelp 12
Check height of track above bench with rule and set square (1)
At both ends (1)
Question:
Truck B carries no card and is placed so that it is stationary between the light gates. Truck A
is set off towards truck B. As the card passes through the first gate it records a time t1. Truck
A then collides with truck B. They stick together and move through the second gate which
records the time t2
Both trucks have the same mass. Explain why t2 = 2t1 if momentum is conserved.
Answer:
Mass doubles
(So) velocity halves
allow mathematical proof which hides v ratio e.g. mu = 2mv then we know that u = l/t1, and v
= l/t2 so substitute these values in and solve for t2 = 2t1
Question:
Use this data to discuss whether momentum can be considered to be conserved in this
experiment.
Answer:
(We know that since t2 = 2t1 for conservation of momentum, t2/t1 = 2)
marksphysicshelp 13
Edexcel AS Specimen 1 Q11b
Question:
Scientist A measures this length with a metre rule, and scientist B measures this length with
calipers.
Scientist B claims that his measurement will produce a more accurate value for the length of
the tooth.
Answer:
marksphysicshelp 14
Edexcel AS Specimen 2 13b
Question:
The refractive index of glass may be determined by measuring angles of incidence and angles
of refraction for light passing into a glass block.
Explain how the choice of the width of the ray of light and the range of the angles of
incidence can ensure the accuracy of the result
Answer:
Exam tip:
WHEN ASKED ABOUT ACCURACY, TALK ABOUT HOW
UNCERTAINTY (PRECISION OF MEASURING
INSTRUMENTS FOR INSTANCE), WILL AFFECT THE
ACCURACY OF THE RESULT.
marksphysicshelp 15
Edexcel AS Specimen 2 Q17a)d)
Question:
The student wants to determine the mass of one of the rubber bands. He places five rubber
bands on a balance and obtains a reading of 2 g. He divides the reading on the balance by five
to determine the mass of one rubber band.
Answer:
• Balance measures to 1 g
• More rubber bands should have been placed on the balance to obtain a reading of at
least 10g
• To make the reading more precise thus reduce uncertainty on the measurement
Question:
The student thinks the calculated value of maximum velocity is too high because the band
does not travel as far as expected.
Explain how the student could determine the initial velocity with the use of a video camera
and why light gates would not be suitable
Answer:
• Video the band over a short distance so it determines the initial speed
• Or because its speed will rapidly reduce because of air resistance (1)
• Include a scale or object of known length in the area filmed (1) analyse the video to
determine the time taken to travel the known distance and calculate the speed using
the measured time in speed = distance/time (1)
• (Light gates would not be suitable because) the band is not sufficient in size to
interrupt the light gate beam
marksphysicshelp 16
OCR (A) A Level Specimen 1 Q17c
Question:
The cyclist continues to move up the slope at 6.0 ms-1 and approaches a gap of width 2.5 m as
A student has calculated that the cyclist will be able to clear the gap and land on the other
side. Another student suggests that this calculation has assumed there is no drag and has not
accounted for the effect caused by the front wheel losing contact with the slope before the
rear wheel.
Without calculation, discuss how drag and the front wheel losing contact with the slope will
affect the motion and explain how these might affect the size of the gap that can be crossed
successfully.
Answer:
• Drag reduces velocity or increases time to cross or some kinetic energy of cyclist
goes to heat. Very short crossing time
• Longer crossing time results in cyclist at lower point on other side of gap
• Moment on bicycle
• Rotation lowers height of front wheel
marksphysicshelp 17
OCR (A) A Level Specimen 1 Q18a
Question:
A group of scientists have designed an alloy which is less dense than copper but may have
similar mechanical properties. A researcher is given the task to determine the Young modulus
of this alloy in the form of a wire.
Write a plan of how the researcher could do this in a laboratory to obtain accurate results.
Include the equipment used and any safety precautions necessary.
Answer:
Measurements
Reliability of results
marksphysicshelp 18
Edexcel (IAL) Unit 6 June 2014 Q4b
Question:
Answer:
marksphysicshelp 19
Edexcel Unit 6 Jan 2011 Q3aii
Question:
(They were calculated to be 1.93 and 2.01 for 4.5V and 6V respectively)
Answer:
Question:
Estimate the uncertainty in your mean value of W when using the 4.5 V battery.
Answer:
Question:
Use these uncertainties to estimate the percentage uncertainty in the value of C obtained
using the 4.5 V battery.
Answer:
marksphysicshelp 20
Question:
Explain whether the unknown capacitor could be a 2200µF capacitor with a tolerance of 20%
Answer:
marksphysicshelp 21
Edexcel June 2010 Unit 6 Q4a
Question:
You are to plan an experiment to investigate the ability of gamma rays to penetrate lead. You are
then to analyse a set of data from such an experiment.
You have a source of radiation and a detector and counter. Describe briefly a simple experiment
to confirm that the source emits gamma radiation.
Answer:
Question:
You are provided with sheets of lead and apparatus to support them safely between the source
and the detector.
The thickness of lead affects the count rate. Describe the measurements you would make to
investigate this.
Answer:
One of:
marksphysicshelp 22
Edexcel (IAL) Unit 6 June 2016
Question:
When the switch is connected to terminal A the capacitor X is connected to the variable
power supply.
marksphysicshelp 23
Answer:
marksphysicshelp 24
Edexcel (IAL) Unit 6 Jan 2016 Q1bi
Question:
Answer:
• Holds top and bottom of bung between jaws (perpendicularly) or callipers are parallel
to h (1)
• Repeat at different orientations for mean
Or do not compress
Or check for zero error8
marksphysicshelp 25
Key exam tips:
• REMEMBER TO CONVERT TO KELVIN FROM CELCIUS WHEN
DEALING WITH NUCLEAR PHYSICS QUESTIONS!
o pV = nRT = NkT - The ‘T’ is in KELVIN not Celsius.
• CASSEGRAIN TELESCOPE - ENSURE RAYS DO NOT CROSS
BEFORE THEY LEAVE THE SECONDARY MIRROR! (SO, AS
THEY LEAVE.)
• GIVE SPECIFIC DETAILS IE CALCULATIONS OR FIGURES TO
PRESENT YOUR CONCLUSION! FOR EXAMPLE:
marksphysicshelp 26
• WHEN USING P = sAT4 REMEMBER THAT ‘A’ WILL BE 4pR2
(IF IT IS A SPHERE, FOR EXAMPLE AN IDEALISED STAR)
marksphysicshelp 27
And finally, some good old-fashioned notes…
Oscillations
• Perform 3 sets of measurements for each different oscillation, (you will get more marks if
you do 2 sets of repeats).
• Measure at least 30 periods in total.
• Preferably make each measurement 20 periods long.
• Precaution: minimise oscillations in any other plane other than the one being observed
("Careful release to avoid unwanted modes of oscillation"). Explain how you did this.
• Always write times to two d.p., never to the nearest second.
• Precaution: do small amplitude oscillations
• Precaution: say that you did several periods at once to minimise reaction time errors.
• Precaution: use a fiducial marker at the centre of the oscillation.
Moments
• Precaution: balance the ruler being used first.
• Use distances from the pivot of greater than 25 cm (250 mm).
• Weigh the unknown and known masses in your hands before using the ruler, and place the
lighter mass as far from the pivot as possible.
• Measure distances from the pivot to the centre of mass of the object.
• All measurements should be to 1 mm accuracy.
• To make sure the rule is balanced, pull each end down. If it comes up again then the rule
must have equal moments acting on it on either end.
Density Measurements
• When using a micrometer, one full rotation of the barrel is 0.5 mm (50 on the barrel scale).
• The micrometer reads to 0.01 mm accuracy.
• Vernier callipers can read to 0.05 mm accuracy. However, it is advisable to quote the
figure to 0.1 mm accuracy, as this will give a larger uncertainty, which will make
comparisons in later parts of the question easier.
• If measuring a very small dimension, measure several "thicknesses" of it. Remember to
divide by the number of thicknesses after the measurement!
• Precaution: check the zero error on the micrometer and/or Vernier callipers. Wipe the jaws
of the micrometer to remove grease.
• Give answers to 2 or 3 s.f. it is meaningless to write, for example, "density is 7785.654 kg
m-3"!
• Always take at least 3 readings for each measurement and take an average.
• When measuring string diameters or foil thicknesses (or similar), use a minimum of 10
thicknesses.
Miscellaneous
• With a measurement that varies substantially each time you test it, take at least 4 readings.
An example is sand falling from a funnel.
• For Experiment C, 8 readings are normally sufficient (sometimes even 6). Extra time at the
end can be used for writing up the other experiments or planning them.
• Show clearly on diagrams your measurements, e.g. to the centres of mass of objects when
doing a moments experiment.
• In any experiment that involves loading and unloading, state that you checked the original
height on unloading each time.
• In any experiment involving, e.g. a funnel and sand, state that you kept the funnel vertical.
marksphysicshelp 28
• Precaution: with many experiments, you can state that you did something to avoid parallax
error.
• When measuring angles, measure from the underside of, e.g., the board you are measuring
the angle of, compared to the horizontal bench.
• To measure a height with a ruler and a set square, hold the ruler vertically using the set
square against the bench and the flat side of the ruler.
• Show any angles measured on diagrams, including ones of forces.
Uncertainties
• % Uncertainty =
• When multiplying or dividing quantities, add their % uncertainties together.
• When adding or subtracting quantities, add their absolute errors together, then divide by
the result of the addition/subtraction of the measurement, e.g. for , where
, and , the absolute errors added
= 0.102 mm. Therefore the % uncertainty is:
•
• If you have to calculate the error in, e.g. , the absolute error in d must be
multiplied by pi and then added to the absolute error in x. The percentage uncertainty
is this total error divided by the calculated and the result multiplied by 100.
• If a measurement is to be raised to a power, then multiply the % uncertainty in the
measurement by the power to get the % uncertainty in the overall term.
• If two values, for say, a density are available, calculate the % difference between them. If a
value is given by the examiner, then use this as the "correct" value, and calculate the
Electrical Experiments
• With capacitor discharges, either take readings every 5 seconds for the first part of the
discharge, or I think that every 10 seconds is sufficient.
• If a range is specified over which you should take measurements, do not exceed it: you will
be penalised.
• With an analogue ammeter, use the top scale. This reads (generally), from 20, to 0, to 10.
These are in fact divisions of 10 m A, and the meter actually reads from -20 to 100 m
marksphysicshelp 29
A. If you are out by a factor of 10, (e.g. you get a calculated cell voltage of 0.15 V),
check that you have read the meter correctly. Always remember that the polarity on
the meter must be correct.
• Any small discrepancy in your results can be explained by "electrical resistance at the
contacts in the circuit".
• With most electrical experiment where a curve will be obtained (e.g. the V/I characteristic
of a diode), 9 points on a smooth curve are sufficient.
Graphs
• With any graph, a minimum of 6 to 8 points are needed, and you must have at least 4
points on a curve.
• When measuring the gradient of a graph, carry your tangent on to the sides of the graph
paper, however big your graph. The triangle you use should be greater than 10 cm in
length and height, although in some mark schemes 100 cm2 is fine.
• Your graph does not have to go through the origin. If the data does not indicate that it does
so, do not force it to. Comment on the fact that there must have been a systematic
error.
• When choosing values to read of a graph, it is better to take them from the middle part of
the curve, as this is where you will have more points per change in y co-ordinate.
• When describing your "plan" in Experiment C, state that the graph you plot will be a
straight line through the origin (if this is the case!), of gradient = to an expression
which will help you confirm the relationship suggested by the examiner.
• Turning points on graphs require at least 4 points.
• If points near the origin deviate substantially from your line of best fit, point out that for
small measurements there is a greater uncertainty.
marksphysicshelp 30
Sources:
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/hframe.html
https://www.itp.uni-hannover.de/~zawischa/ITP/diffraction.html
http://www.cyberphysics.co.uk
http://www.bbc.co.uk/education
http://ibguides.com/physics/notes/measurement-and-uncertainties
http://www.doctronics.co.uk/voltage.htm
http://homepages.engineering.auckland.ac.nz/~pkel015/SolidMechanicsBooks/Part_I/BookS
M_Part_I/08_Energy/08_Energy_01_Energy_in_Deforming_Materials.pdf
https://www.kerboodle.com/app/courses/17892/modules/Home
http://www.met.reading.ac.uk/pplato2/h-flap/phys6_4.html
http://abyss.uoregon.edu/~js/glossary/radio_telescope.html
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/phyopt/raylei.html
http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/estatics/Lesson-4/Electric-Field-Intensity
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synchronous_orbit
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electric/dielec.html
http://www.physbot.co.uk/capacitance.html
http://www.physbot.co.uk/gravity-fields-and-potentials.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field#/media/File:Earths_Magnetic_Field_Confusion.
svg
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/magnetic/cyclot.html
marksphysicshelp 31