)JOEBXJ 1VCMJTIJOH $PSQPSBUJPO

+PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH
7PMVNF  "SUJDMF *%   QBHFT
IUUQEYEPJPSH

3FTFBSDI "SUJDMF
&OIBODFE 1SPEVDUJPO PG $FMMVMBTF GSPN 1JOFBQQMF 8BTUF CZ
3FTQPOTF 4VSGBDF .FUIPEPMPHZ

1 4BSBWBOBO 3 .VUIVWFMBZVEIBN BOE 5 7JSVUIBHJSJ

%FQBSUNFOU PG $IFNJDBM &OHJOFFSJOH "OOBNBMBJ 6OJWFSTJUZ "OOBNBMBJOBHBS  5BNJMOBEV *OEJB

$PSSFTQPOEFODF TIPVME CF BEESFTTFE UP 1 4BSBWBOBO WJEIZBTBSBWBOBO!HNBJMDPN

3FDFJWFE  "VHVTU  3FWJTFE  /PWFNCFS  "DDFQUFE  /PWFNCFS 

"DBEFNJD &EJUPS 5JOHZVF (V

$PQZSJHIU ª  1 4BSBWBOBO FU BM ćJT JT BO PQFO BDDFTT BSUJDMF EJTUSJCVUFE VOEFS UIF $SFBUJWF $PNNPOT "UUSJCVUJPO -JDFOTF
XIJDI QFSNJUT VOSFTUSJDUFE VTF EJTUSJCVUJPO BOE SFQSPEVDUJPO JO BOZ NFEJVN QSPWJEFE UIF PSJHJOBM XPSL JT QSPQFSMZ DJUFE

0QUJNJ[BUJPO PG UIF NFEJB DPNQPOFOUT GPS DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO VTJOH 5SJDIPEFSNB SFFTFJ XBT DBSSJFE PVU ćF PQUJNJ[BUJPO PG
DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO VTJOH QJOFBQQMF XBTUF BT TVCTUSBUF XBT QFSGPSNFE XJUI TUBUJTUJDBM NFUIPEPMPHZ CBTFE PO FYQFSJNFOUBM EFTJHOT
ćF TDSFFOJOH PG OVUSJFOUT BOE UIFJS JOĘVFODF PO UIF DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO XBT TUVEJFE VTJOH B 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO EFTJHO "WJDFM
TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS ,) 10 BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU XFSF GPVOE UP IBWF UIF QPTJUJWF JOĘVFODF GPS UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF ćF TFMFDUFE
DPNQPOFOUT XFSF PQUJNJ[FE VTJOH SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF NFUIPEPMPHZ ćF PQUJNVN DPODFOUSBUJPOT BSF BWJDFM  H- TPZCFBO DBLF
ĘPVS  H- ,) 10   H- BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU  H- " NBYJNVN DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ PG  *6N- XBT PCUBJOFE VOEFS UIF
PQUJNJ[FE NFEJVN JO UIF WBMJEBUJPO FYQFSJNFOU

 *OUSPEVDUJPO DBQBCJMJUJFT PG 5 SFFTFJ ćJT JT BO FYUSFNFMZ DPNQMJDBUFE TZT

UFN NBOZ GBDUPST JOĘVFODF UIF PSHBOJTNT BCJMJUZ UP HSPX BOE
&O[ZNBUJD IZESPMZTJT PG DFMMVMPTF UP HMVDPTF JT DBSSJFE PVU QSPEVDF FO[ZNF < > 8JUI UIF JODSFBTJOH EFNBOE GPS BMUFS
CZ UIF FO[ZNF DFMMVMBTF B NVMUJFO[ZNF DPNQMFY NBEF VQ OBUJWF MJRVJE GVFMT XPSMEXJEF DFMMVMBTF JT CFJOH VTFE BT UIF
PG TFWFSBM QSPUFJOT $FMMVMBTFT BSF FO[ZNFT TZOUIFTJ[FE CZ QSJNBSZ FO[ZNF GPS FO[ZNBUJD IZESPMZTJT PG MJHOPDFMMVMPTJD
B MBSHF EJWFSTJUZ PG NJDSPPSHBOJTNT JODMVEJOH CPUI GVOHJ BOE CJPNBTT JO CJPFUIBOPM QSPEVDUJPO QSPDFTT *U JT LOPXO UIBU
CBDUFSJB EVSJOH UIFJS HSPXUI PO DFMMVMPTJD NBUFSJBM ćFTF UIF QSPEVDUJPO FDPOPNJDT PG CJPFUIBOPM JT MBSHFMZ EFQFOEFOU
NJDSPPSHBOJTNT DBO CF BFSPCJD BOBFSPCJD NFTPQIJMJD PS PO UIF DPTU PG DFMMVMBTF )PXFWFS IJHI DPTU PG UIF FO[ZNF
UIFSNPQIJMJD "NPOH UIFN UIF HFOFSB PG $MPTUSJEJVN $FM QSFTFOUT B TJHOJĕDBOU CBSSJFS UP UIF DPNNFSDJBMJ[BUJPO PG
MVMPNPOBT ćFSNPNPOPTQPSB 5SJDIPEFSNB BOE "TQFSHJMMVT CJPFUIBOPM ćFSFGPSF ĕOEJOH BO FDPOPNJD XBZ UP QSPEVDF
BSF UIF NPTU FYUFOTJWFMZ TUVEJFE DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDFST <> DFMMVMBTF IBT ESBXO HSFBU BUUFOUJPO BSPVOE UIF XPSME <> ćF
ćF GVOHVT 5SJDIPEFSNB SFFTFJ JT BO FďDJFOU QSPEVDFS PG DPTU PG FO[ZNFT JT POF PG UIF NBJO GBDUPST EFUFSNJOJOH UIF
DFMMVMBTF FO[ZNFT 8BTUF NBUFSJBMT GSPN B XJEF SBOHF PG FDPOPNJDT PG B CJPDBUBMZUJD QSPDFTT BOE JU DBO CF SFEVDFE CZ
BHSPJOEVTUSJBM QSPDFTTFT NBZ CF VTFE BT UIF TVCTUSBUFT GPS ĕOEJOH PQUJNVN DPOEJUJPOT GPS UIFJS QSPEVDUJPO *O PSEFS
NJDSPCJBM HSPXUI UIFSFCZ SFTVMUJOH JO VQHSBEJOH PG UIF XBTUF UP NJOJNJ[F UIF FO[ZNFT QSPEVDUJPO DPTU DPOTJEFSBCMF
PS UIF TZOUIFTJT PG WBMVBCMF CZQSPEVDUT ćF CVMLT PG UIF QSPHSFTT IBT CFFO NBEF JO TUSBJO EFWFMPQNFOU PQUJNJ[BUJPO
XBTUFT GSPN BHSJDVMUVSF PS GPPE QSPDFTTJOH BSF OPU TVJUBCMF PG DVMUVSF DPOEJUJPO NPEF PČFSNFOUBUJPO BOE NPEFMMJOH
GPS GPPE PS BOJNBM GFFE CFDBVTF UIFZ BSF UPP ĕCSPVT UP CF UIF QSPDFTT <> .JDSPPSHBOJTNT BSF DBQBCMF PG VUJMJ[JOH UIF
EJHFTUFE CZ NPOPHBTUSJD BOJNBMT <> IPXFWFS B TJHOJĕDBOU PSHBOJD NBUUFS JO XBTUFT CPUI BT B TPVSDF PG FOFSHZ GPS HSPXUI
QSPQPSUJPO o PG UIF ESZ XFJHIU PG UIFTF XBTUFT BOE BT DBSCPO GPS UIF TZOUIFTJT PG DFMM CJPNBTT <o>
BSF DBSCPIZESBUFT PUIFS UIBO DFMMVMPTF BOE BSF UIFSFGPSF %VSJOH QJOFBQQMF QSPDFTTJOH UIF DSPXO BOE TUFN BSF
SFBEJMZ BTTJNJMBCMF CZ NJDSPPSHBOJTNT <> 1SPEVDUJPO PG DVU PČ CFGPSF QFFMJOH ćF DPSF JT UIFO SFNPWFE GPS GVSUIFS
DFMMVMBTF FO[ZNF JO MBSHF RVBOUJUJFT SFRVJSFT VOEFSTUBOEJOH QSPDFTTJOH ćFTF XBTUFT QFFM DPSF TUFN DSPXO BOE MFBWFT
BOE QSPQFS DPOUSPMMJOH PG UIF HSPXUI BOE FO[ZNF QSPEVDUJPO HFOFSBMMZ BDDPVOU GPS  XX PG UPUBM QJOFBQQMF XFJHIU
 3962, 2013, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2013/979547, Wiley Online Library on [28/06/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
 +PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH

ćFSFGPSF XJUI JODSFBTJOH QJOFBQQMF QSPEVDUJPO QJOFBQQMF 5ĮįĹIJ  $PNQPTJUJPO GPS QJOFBQQMF XBTUF
XBTUFT BSF BMTP QSPQPSUJPOBMMZ JODSFBTJOH 8BTUF EJTQPTBM
SFQSFTFOUT B HSPXJOH QSPCMFN TJODF JU JT VTVBMMZ QSPOF $PNQPTJUJPO 1FSDFOUBHF
UP NJDSPCJBM TQPJMBHF BOE JU DBVTFT TFSJPVT FOWJSPONFOUBM &YUSBDUJWF 
QSPCMFNT ćF VUJMJ[BUJPO PG XBTUF XPVME CF BO JOOPWBUJPO )PMPDFMMVMPTF 
UP IBOEMF UIF HSFBU EFBM PG XBTUF GSPN QSPDFTTJOH 1JOFBQQMF -JHOJO 
XBTUFT BSF GPVOE UP IBWF QPUFOUJBM VTFT BT SBX NBUFSJBMT UIBU "TI 
DBO CF DPOWFSUFE JOUP WBMVFBEEFE QSPEVDUT *O BHSJDVMUVSBM 0UIFST 
XBTUF JT PDDBTJPOBMMZ VUJMJ[FE BT B GFSUJMJ[FS PS BOJNBM GFFE ćF
QFFM JT B SJDI TPVSDF PG DFMMVMPTF IFNJDFMMVMPTFT BOE PUIFS
DBSCPIZESBUFT *U IBT CFFO VTFE UP QSPEVDF QBQFS CBOLOPUFT
BOE DMPUI < >  XW 5XFFO XBT BEEFE UP FBDI GVOHBM TMBOU BOE
ćF DPSF XBTUF DPVME CF VTFE GPS UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG GSP[FO WPSUFYFE 4QPSF DPVOU XBT NFBTVSFE XJUI IBFNPDZUPNFUFS
QJOFBQQMF KVJDF DPODFOUSBUFT PS FYUSBDUFE KVJDF GPS BMDPIPMJD BOE BEKVTUFE UP  š  TQPSFTN- CZ BEKVTUNFOU PG PQUJDBM
CFWFSBHFT PS GPS WJOFHBS < > *O BEEJUJPO UIF XBTUF GSPN EFOTJUZ
QJOFBQQMF IBT CFFO VTFE BT B OVUSJFOU TVCTUBODF JO DVMUVSF
CSPUI < > BOE DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO < > .PSFPWFS
UIF QJOFBQQMF XBTUFT IBWF BMTP CFFO VTFE BT TVCTUSBUFT GPS UIF  4VCTUSBUF 1SFQBSBUJPO BOE 4UFSJMJ[BUJPO 1JOFBQQMF XBTUFT
QSPEVDUJPO PG NFUIBOF FUIBOPM DJUSJD BDJE BOE BOUJPYJEBOU XFSF DPMMFDUFE GSPN UIF MPDBM NBSLFU BU $IJEBNCSBN 5BNJM
DPNQPVOET <> OBEV *OEJB ćF DPMMFDUFE SBX NBUFSJBMT BSF ESJFE JO TVOMJHIU
-JHOJO JT BO VOEFTJSBCMF QPMZNFS BOE JUT SFNPWBM EVSJOH GPS  EBZT DSVTIFE BOE TJFWFE GPS EJČFSFOU NFTI TJ[F SBOHJOH
IZESPMZTJT TUFQ SFRVJSFT IJHI BNPVOU PG FOFSHZ BOE DIFN GSPN  NN UP  NN o NFTI BOE VTFE GPS GVSUIFS
JDBMT 1JOFBQQMF XBTUF IBT SFMBUJWFMZ MPXFS MJHOJO DPOUFOU TUVEJFT ćF DPNQPTJUJPO PG QJOFBQQMF XBTUF QFFM DPSF
XIJDI TVHHFTUT UIBU UIFTF NBUFSJBMT DBO VOEFSHP IZESPMZTJT DSPXO BOE TUFN JT HJWFO JO 5BCMF  XIJDI JT VTFE GPS DFMMVMBTF
TUFQ NPSF FBTJMZ XJUI UIF VUJMJ[BUJPO PG MFTTFS BNPVOU PG QSPEVDUJPO
DIFNJDBMT UIBO PUIFS XBTUF NBUFSJBMT TVDI BT CBOBOB TUFN ćF QSFUSFBUNFOU QSPDFTT EFDSFBTFT UIF DSZTUBMMJOJUZ PG
DPDPOVU XBTUF BOE PJM QBMN FNQUZ GSVJU CVODIFT <o> QJOFBQQMF XBTUF XIJMF SFNPWJOH MJHOJO BOE PUIFS JOIJCJUPST
)PXFWFS SFQPSUT PO UIF VTF PG QJOFBQQMF XBTUF GPS UIF QSP UIFSFCZ FOBCMJOH JUT FO[ZNBUJD IZESPMZTJT  H PG UIF XBTIFE
EVDUJPO PG JOEVTUSJBMMZ SFMFWBOU NFUBCPMJUFT TVDI BT DFMMVMBTF HSPVOE QJOFBQQMF XBTUF XBT USFBUFE TFQBSBUFMZ XJUI  N-
UISPVHI GFSNFOUBUJPO QSPDFTTFT BSF SBSF ćVT DVMUJWBUJPO PG  /B0) TPMVUJPO BOE BVUPDMBWFE BU ѩ $ GPS  NJO
PG NJDSPPSHBOJTNT PO UIFTF XBTUFT NBZ CF B WBMVFBEEFE ćFO JU XBT ĕMUFSFE XBTIFE XJUI EJTUJMMFE XBUFS BOE FYDFTT
QSPDFTT DBQBCMF PG DPOWFSUJOH UIFTF NBUFSJBMT XIJDI BSF BMLBMJ QSFTFOU XBT OFVUSBMJ[FE XJUI QIPTQIPSJD BDJE "HBJO
PUIFSXJTF DPOTJEFSFE UP CF XBTUFT JOUP WBMVBCMF QSPEVDUT JU XBT ĕMUFSFE BOE UIF SFTJEVF NBUFSJBM XBT ESJFE BU ѩ $ JO
UISPVHI QSPDFTTFT XJUI UFDIOPFDPOPNJD GFBTJCJMJUZ *O UIF B IPU BJS PWFO UP DPOTUBOU XFJHIU 5P UIF DFMMVMPTJD NBUFSJBM
QSFTFOU TUVEZ UIF TDSFFOJOH BOE PQUJNJ[BUJPO PG NFEJVN PCUBJOFE UIF TBNF WPMVNF PG EJTUJMMFE XBUFS XBT BEEFE BOE
DPNQPTJUJPO GPS DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO CZ 5SJDIPEFSNB SFFTFJ IFBUFE BU ѩ $ GPS  NJO ćF TVTQFOTJPO XBT ĕMUFSFE BOE
VTJOH 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO BOE 3FTQPOTF 4VSGBDF .FUIPEPMPHZ UIF TPMJE NBUFSJBM XBT ESJFE BU ѩ $ UP DPOTUBOU XFJHIU JO
34. XFSF DBSSJFE PVU ćF 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO TDSFFOJOH IPU BJS PWFO <> ćF ESJFE QJOFBQQMF QPXEFS XBT VTFE BT
EFTJHO JT BQQMJFE GPS JEFOUJGZJOH UIF TJHOJĕDBOU WBSJBCMFT UIBU B DBSCPO TPVSDF
FOIBODF DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO ćF DFOUSBM DPNQPTJUF EFTJHO
$$% XBT GVSUIFS BQQMJFE UP EFUFSNJOF UIF PQUJNVN MFWFM PG  &O[ZNF 1SPEVDUJPO VOEFS 4VCNFSHFE 'FSNFOUBUJPO 'FS
FBDI TJHOJĕDBOU WBSJBCMF 5P UIF CFTU PG PVS LOPXMFEHF UIJT JT NFOUBUJPO XBT DBSSJFE PVU JO &SMFONFZFS ĘBTLT  N-
UIF ĕSTU QBQFS PO DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO VTJOH QJOFBQQMF XBTUF XJUI  H PG QSFUSFBUFE QJOFBQQMF XBTUF QPXEFS TVQQMF
BT TVCTUSBUF CZ 5 SFFTFJ BOE UIFSF JT OP MJUFSBUVSF BWBJMBCMF NFOUFE XJUI OVUSJFOUT DPODFOUSBUJPO EFĕOFE CZ UIF FYQFS
PO UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF VTJOH UIF BCPWF TVCTUSBUF BOE JNFOUBM EFTJHO &BDI ĘBTL XBT DPWFSFE XJUI IZESPQIPCJD
NJDSPPSHBOJTN TP GBS DPUUPO BOE BVUPDMBWFE BU ѩ $ GPS  NJO "ęFS DPPMJOH UIF
ĘBTLT XFSF JOPDVMBUFE BU SPPN UFNQFSBUVSF BOE NBJOUBJOFE
 .BUFSJBMT BOE .FUIPET BU ѩ $ BU  SQN GPS  IPVST %VSJOH UIF QSFMJNJOBSZ
TDSFFOJOH QSPDFTT UIF FYQFSJNFOUT XFSF DBSSJFE PVU GPS  EBZT
 .JDSPPSHBOJTNT 5 SFFTFJ /$*.  XBT QSPDVSFE BOE JU XBT GPVOE UIBU UIF NBYJNVN QSPEVDUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF
GSPN /BUJPOBM $PMMFDUJPO PG *OEVTUSJBM .JDSPPSHBOJTN XBT PCUBJOFE PO UIF UI EBZ PG GFSNFOUBUJPO
/$*. /BUJPOBM $IFNJDBM -BCPSBUPSZ 1VOF *OEJB BOE
NBJOUBJOFE PO QPUBUP EFYUSPTF BHBS 1%" BU ѩ $ GPS TVCTF
 %FUFSNJOBUJPO PG &O[ZNF "DUJWJUZ $FMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ
RVFOU VTF BT JOPDVMVN
'1" XBT BOBMZ[FE PO ĕMUFS QBQFS BDDPSEJOH UP (IPTF <>
0OF VOJU PG FO[ZNF DPSSFTQPOET UP UIF BNPVOU PG FO[ZNF
 *OPDVMVN 1SFQBSBUJPO ćF GVOHBM DVMUVSF XBT HSPXO OFDFTTBSZ UP GPSN  ಯNPM PG HMVDPTF QFS N- QFS NJOVUF ćF
PO 1%" TMBOUT BOE UIF TQPSFT XFSF IBSWFTUFE BTFQUJDBMMZ SFEVDJOH TVHBST XFSF NFBTVSFE CZ UIF EJOJUSPTBMJDZMJD BDJE
GSPN EBZPME 1%" TMBOUT 4UFSJMF EJTUJMMFE XBUFS DPOUBJOJOH %/4 NFUIPE BDDPSEJOH UP .JMMFS <>
 3962, 2013, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2013/979547, Wiley Online Library on [28/06/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
+PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH 

5ĮįĹIJ  /VUSJFOUT TDSFFOJOH VTJOH 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO EFTJHO

4 /VNCFS /VUSJFOUT DPEF /VUSJFOU .JOJNVN WBMVF H- .BYJNVN WBMVF H-
 " "WJDFM  
 # $PSO TUFFQ ĘPVS  
 $ .O40 Ԗ ) 0  
 % 'F40 Ԗ ) 0  
 & #FFG FYUSBDU  
 ' 4PZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS  
 ( ,) 10  
 ) $P$M Ԗ ) 0  
 * :FBTU FYUSBDU  

 0QUJNJ[BUJPO PG $FMMVMBTF 1SPEVDUJPO PG UIF JUI UFTU WBSJBCMF BU DFOUSF QPJOU BOE əਦ JT UIF TUFQ
DIBOHF ćF SFHSFTTJPO BOBMZTJT JT QFSGPSNFE UP FTUJNBUF UIF
 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO &YQFSJNFOUBM %FTJHO 1MBDLFUU#VS SFTQPOTF GVODUJPO BT B TFDPOEPSEFS QPMZOPNJBM
NBO FYQFSJNFOUBM EFTJHO BTTVNFT UIBU UIFSF BSF OP JOUFS
BDUJPOT CFUXFFO UIF EJČFSFOU WBSJBCMFT JO UIF SBOHF VOEFS ਙ ਙ ਙѣ ਙ
DPOTJEFSBUJPO " MJOFBS BQQSPBDI JT DPOTJEFSFE UP CF TVG ਎ ! ಥ  ဂ ಥਗ ਍ਗ  ဂ ಥਗਗ ਍ਗ  ဂ ဂ ಥਗਘ ਍ਗ ਍ਘ  
ĕDJFOU GPS TDSFFOJOH 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO FYQFSJNFOUBM EFTJHO ਗ! ਗ! ਗ! ਗ ਘ ਘ!
JT B GSBDUJPOBM GBDUPSJBM EFTJHO BOE UIF NBJO FČFDUT PG TVDI
B EFTJHO NBZ CF TJNQMZ DBMDVMBUFE BT UIF EJČFSFODF CFUXFFO XIFSF : JT UIF QSFEJDUFE SFTQPOTF ಥ DPOTUBOU BOE ಥਗ ಥਘ
UIF BWFSBHF PG NFBTVSFNFOUT NBEF BU UIF IJHI MFWFM  PG ಥਗਘ BSF DPFďDJFOUT FTUJNBUFE GSPN SFHSFTTJPO ćFZ SFQSFTFOU
UIF GBDUPS BOE UIF BWFSBHF PG NFBTVSFNFOUT BU UIF MPX MFWFM
UIF MJOFBS RVBESBUJD BOE DSPTT QSPEVDUT PG ਍ਗ BOE ਍ਘ PO
ѣ 
SFTQPOTF
5P EFUFSNJOF UIBU UIF WBSJBCMFT TJHOJĕDBOUMZ BČFDU DFMMV
.PEFM ĕUUJOH BOE TUBUJTUJDBM BOBMZTJT BOE UIF SFHSFTTJPO
MBTF BDUJWJUZ 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO EFTJHO JT VTFE /JOF WBSJBCMFT
BOE HSBQIJDBM BOBMZTJT XJUI TUBUJTUJDBM TJHOJĕDBODF BSF DBSSJFE
5BCMF  BSF TDSFFOFE JO  FYQFSJNFOUBM SVOT 5BCMF 
PVU VTJOH %FTJHO&YQFSU TPęXBSF WFSTJPO  4UBU&BTF
BOE JOTJHOJĕDBOU POFT BSF FMJNJOBUFE JO PSEFS UP PCUBJO B
*OD .JOOFBQPMJT 64"  ćF NJOJNVN BOE NBYJNVN
TNBMMFS NBOBHFBCMF TFU PG GBDUPST ćF MPX MFWFM ѣ BOE IJHI
SBOHFT PG WBSJBCMFT JOWFTUJHBUFE BSF MJTUFE JO 5BCMF   *O
MFWFM  PG FBDI GBDUPS BSF MJTUFE JO 5BCMF   ćF TUBUJTUJDBM
PSEFS UP WJTVBMJ[F UIF SFMBUJPOTIJQ CFUXFFO UIF FYQFSJNFOUBM
TPęXBSF QBDLBHF %FTJHO&YQFSU TPęXBSF WFSTJPO 
WBSJBCMFT BOE SFTQPOTFT UIF SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF BOE DPOUPVS
4UBU&BTF *OD .JOOFBQPMJT 64" JT VTFE GPS BOBMZTJOH UIF
QMPUT BSF HFOFSBUFE GSPN UIF NPEFMT ćF PQUJNVN WBMVFT
FYQFSJNFOUBM EBUB 0ODF UIF DSJUJDBM GBDUPST BSF JEFOUJĕFE
PG UIF QSPDFTT WBSJBCMFT BSF PCUBJOFE GSPN UIF SFHSFTTJPO
UISPVHI UIF TDSFFOJOH UIF DFOUSBM DPNQPTJUF EFTJHO $$%
FRVBUJPO
JT VTFE UP PCUBJO B RVBESBUJD NPEFM
ćF BEFRVBDZ PG UIF NPEFMT JT GVSUIFS KVTUJĕFE UISPVHI
BOBMZTJT PG WBSJBODF "/07"  -BDLPGĕU JT B TQFDJBM EJBH
 $FOUSBM $PNQPTJUF %FTJHO ćF DFOUSBM DPNQPTJUF OPTUJD UFTU GPS BEFRVBDZ PG B NPEFM BOE DPNQBSFT UIF QVSF
EFTJHO JT VTFE UP TUVEZ UIF FČFDUT PG WBSJBCMFT PO UIFJS FSSPS CBTFE PO UIF SFQMJDBUF NFBTVSFNFOUT UP UIF PUIFS MBDL
SFTQPOTFT BOE TVCTFRVFOUMZ JO UIF PQUJNJ[BUJPO TUVEJFT ćJT PGĕU CBTFE PO UIF NPEFM QFSGPSNBODF 'WBMVF DBMDVMBUFE
NFUIPE JT TVJUBCMF GPS ĕUUJOH B RVBESBUJD TVSGBDF BOE JU SBUJP CFUXFFO UIF MBDLPGĕU NFBO TRVBSF BOE UIF QVSF FSSPS
IFMQT UP PQUJNJ[F UIF FČFDUJWF QBSBNFUFST XJUI NJOJNVN NFBO TRVBSF UIJT TUBUJTUJD QBSBNFUFST BSF VTFE UP EFUFSNJOF
OVNCFS PG FYQFSJNFOUT BT XFMM BT UP BOBMZTF UIF JOUFSBDUJPO XIFUIFS UIF MBDLPGĕU JT TJHOJĕDBOU PS OPU BU B TJHOJĕDBODF
CFUXFFO UIF QBSBNFUFST *O PSEFS UP EFUFSNJOF UIF FYJTUFODF MFWFM
PG B SFMBUJPOTIJQ CFUXFFO UIF GBDUPST BOE SFTQPOTF WBSJBCMFT
UIF DPMMFDUFE EBUB XFSF BOBMZTFE JO B TUBUJTUJDBM NBOOFS
VTJOH SFHSFTTJPO " SFHSFTTJPO EFTJHO JT OPSNBMMZ FNQMPZFE UP  3FTVMUT BOE %JTDVTTJPO
NPEFM B SFTQPOTF BT B NBUIFNBUJDBM GVODUJPO FJUIFS LOPXO
PS FNQJSJDBM PG B GFX DPOUJOVPVT GBDUPST BOE HPPE NPEFM 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO FYQFSJNFOUT 5BCMF  TIPXFE B XJEF WBSJ
QBSBNFUFS FTUJNBUFT BSF EFTJSFE BUJPO JO DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO ćJT WBSJBUJPO SFĘFDUFE UIF
ćF DPEFE WBMVFT PG UIF QSPDFTT QBSBNFUFST BSF EFUFS JNQPSUBODF PG PQUJNJ[BUJPO UP BUUBJO IJHIFS QSPEVDUJWJUZ
NJOFE CZ UIF GPMMPXJOH FRVBUJPO 'SPN UIF QBSFUP DIBSU 'JHVSF  UIF WBSJBCMFT OBNFMZ
"WJDFM TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS ,) 10 BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU XFSF
਍ ਗ ѣ਍ GPVOE UP CF TJHOJĕDBOU XIJMF DPSO TUFFQ ĘPVS .O40 Ԗ) 0
ਦਗ !   'F40 Ԗ) 0 CFFG FYUSBDU BOE $P$M Ԗ) 0 XFSF DPOTJE
əਦ
FSFE OPOTJHOJĕDBOU POFT )FODF BWJDFM TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS
XIFSF ਦਗ JT UIF DPEFE WBMVF PG UIF JUI WBSJBCMF ਍ਗ JT UIF ,) 10 BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU XFSF TFMFDUFE GPS GVSUIFS PQUJ
VODPEFE WBMVF PG UIF JUI UFTU WBSJBCMF ਍ JT UIF VODPEFE WBMVF NJ[BUJPO UP BUUBJO B NBYJNVN SFTQPOTF
 3962, 2013, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2013/979547, Wiley Online Library on [28/06/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
 +PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH

5ĮįĹIJ  1MBDLFUU#VSNBO FYQFSJNFOUBM EFTJHO GPS OJOF WBSJBCMFT

3VO PSEFS " # $ % & ' ( ) * $FMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ *6N-

  ѣ ѣ   ѣ   ѣ 
  ѣ  ѣ     ѣ 
    ѣ ѣ   ѣ  
 ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ  ѣ  ѣ  
   ѣ ѣ   ѣ   
     ѣ ѣ   ѣ 
 ѣ ѣ  ѣ  ѣ    
  ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ  ѣ  ѣ 
   ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ  ѣ  
 ѣ  ѣ     ѣ ѣ 
 ѣ ѣ   ѣ   ѣ ѣ 
   ѣ   ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ 
 ѣ ѣ ѣ  ѣ  ѣ   
 ѣ   ѣ   ѣ ѣ ѣ 
 ѣ  ѣ  ѣ     
 ѣ   ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ  ѣ 
 ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ 
 ѣ     ѣ ѣ   
  ѣ   ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ  
  ѣ     ѣ ѣ  

5ĮįĹIJ  3BOHFT PG WBSJBCMFT VTFE JO 34.

7BSJBCMFT H- $PEF ѣ ѣ   

"WJDFM "     
4PZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS #     
,) 10 $     
:FBTU FYUSBDU %     

Pareto chart of the standardized effects ćF QSFEJDUFE BOE PCTFSWFE SFTQPOTFT BMPOH XJUI EFTJHO
(response is C14, = 0.05) NBUSJY BSF QSFTFOUFE JO 5BCMF   UIF SFTVMUT XFSF BOBMZTFE
2.228 CZ "/07"
A
F
ćF TFDPOEPSEFS SFHSFTTJPO FRVBUJPO QSPWJEFE UIF MFWFMT
G PG DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ BT B GVODUJPO PG BWJDFM TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS
I ,) 10 BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU XIJDI DBO CF QSFTFOUFE JO UFSNT
Term

B
D PG DPEFE GBDUPST BT JO UIF GPMMPXJOH FRVBUJPO
C
H ਎ !   "  #  $
E
0 1 2 3 4 5 6  % ѣ " Ѩ "
Standardized effect
ѣ # Ѩ # ѣ $ Ѩ $
'ĶĴłĿIJ  1BSFUP DIBSU TIPXJOH UIF FČFDU PG NFEJB DPNQPOFOUT PO
$FMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ ""WJDFM '4PZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS (,) 10 BOE ѣ % Ѩ % ѣ " Ѩ # 
*:FBTU FYUSBDU 
 " Ѩ $  " Ѩ %
 # Ѩ $  # Ѩ %
ćF MFWFM PG GBDUPST BWJDFM TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS ,) 10
BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU BOE UIF FČFDU PG UIFJS JOUFSBDUJPOT PO  $ Ѩ %
DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO XFSF EFUFSNJOFE CZ DFOUSBM DPNQPTJUF
EFTJHO PG 34. ćJSUZ FYQFSJNFOUT XFSF QSFGFSSFE BU EJČFSFOU XIFSF : JT UIF DFMMVMBTF ZJFME *6N- " # $ BOE %
DPNCJOBUJPOT PG UIF GBDUPST TIPXO JO 5BCMF  BOE UIF BSF BWJDFM TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS ,) 10 BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU
DFOUSBM QPJOU XBT SFQFBUFE GPVS UJNFT    BOE   SFTQFDUJWFMZ "/07" GPS UIF SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF JT TIPXO
 3962, 2013, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2013/979547, Wiley Online Library on [28/06/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
+PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH 

5ĮįĹIJ  $FOUSBM DPNQPTJUF EFTJHO JO DPEFE MFWFMT XJUI DFMMVMBTF ZJFME BT SFTQPOTF

3VO PSEFS " ' ( * &YQFSJNFOUBM DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ *6N- 1SFEJDUFE DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ *6N-
 ѣ  ѣ   
      
 ѣ ѣ ѣ   
  ѣ ѣ ѣ  
    ѣ  
  ѣ    
   ѣ   
      
  ѣ  ѣ  
      
      
      
  ѣ ѣ   
      
 ѣ     
 ѣ   ѣ  
      
 ѣ ѣ  ѣ  
 ѣ     
      
      
  ѣ    
 ѣ ѣ ѣ ѣ  
      
   ѣ ѣ  
      
   ѣ   
    ѣ  
 ѣ ѣ    
 ѣ  ѣ ѣ  

JO 5BCMF  ćF NPEFM ' WBMVF PG  JNQMJFT UIF NPEFM

JT TJHOJĕDBOU ćFSF JT POMZ B  DIBODF UIBU B i.PEFM ' 10
WBMVFw UIJT MBSHF DPVME PDDVS EVF UP OPJTF 7BMVFT PG iQSPC"'w 8
ity

MFTT UIBO  JOEJDBUF UIBU NPEFM UFSNT BSF TJHOJĕDBOU 7BMVFT
Cellulase activ

6
HSFBUFS UIBO  JOEJDBUF UIBU NPEFM UFSNT BSF OPU TJHOJĕDBOU 4
*O UIF QSFTFOU XPSL MJOFBS UFSNT PG " # $ BOE % BOE BMM 2
UIF TRVBSF FČFDUT PG " # $ BOE % BOE UIF JOUFSBDUJPO FČFDU
0
PG # Ѩ $ XFSF GPVOE UP CF TJHOJĕDBOU GPS UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG
DFMMVMBTF ćF DPFďDJFOU PG EFUFSNJOBUJPO ਇ GPS DFMMVMBTF 2
BDUJWJUZ XBT DBMDVMBUFE BT  XIJDI JT WFSZ DMPTF UP  BOE 2
1 1
DBO FYQMBJO VQ UP  WBSJBCJMJUZ PG UIF SFTQPOTF ćF B: so
ybea
0 0
−1 −1
QSFEJDUFE ਇ WBMVF PG  XBT JO SFBTPOBCMF BHSFFNFOU XJUI
n cak icel
e flou
r −2 −2 A: av
UIF BEKVTUFE ਇ WBMVF PG  "O BEFRVBUF QSFDJTJPO WBMVF
HSFBUFS UIBO  JT EFTJSBCMF ćF BEFRVBUF QSFDJTJPO WBMVF PG 'ĶĴłĿIJ  % QMPU TIPXJOH UIF FČFDU PG BWJDFM BOE TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS
 JOEJDBUFT BO BEFRVBUF TJHOBM BOE TVHHFTUT UIBU UIF NPEFM PO DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ
DBO OBWJHBUF UIF EFTJHO TQBDF
ćF JOUFSBDUJWF FČFDUT PG WBSJBCMFT PO DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO
XFSF TUVEJFE CZ % SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF QMPUT BHBJOTU BOZ UXP DPOUPVS QMPUT GSPN UIF JOUFSBDUJPOT CFUXFFO UIF WBSJBCMFT
JOEFQFOEFOU WBSJBCMFT BOE JUT SFTQFDUJWF DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO XFSF TIPXO JO 'JHVSFT      BOE 
XIJMF LFFQJOH PUIFS WBSJBCMFT BU JUT DFOUSBM  MFWFM ćF % %VSJOH UIF GFSNFOUBUJPO QFSJPE UIF DBSCPO TPVSDF
DVSWFT PG UIF DBMDVMBUFE SFTQPOTF DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO BOE XBT GPVOE UP CF UIF NBKPS DPOTUJUVFOU GPS UIF TZOUIFTJT
 3962, 2013, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2013/979547, Wiley Online Library on [28/06/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
 +PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH

5ĮįĹIJ  "OBMZTFT PG WBSJBODF "/07" GPS SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF RVBESBUJD NPEFM GPS UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG DFMMVMPTF

4PVSDF 4VN PG TRVBSF EG .FBO TRVBSF WBMVF ৻ WBMVF ਅ WBMVF

.PEFM     
""WJDFM     
#4PZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS     
$,) 10     
%:FBTU FYUSBDU     
"#     
"$     
"%     
#$     
#%     
$%     
"     
#     
$     
%     
3FTJEVBM   
-BDL PG ĕU     
1VSF FSSPS   ৺ ѣ 
$PS UPUBM  

10 9
8
ity
ity

8
7
Cellulase activ
Cellulase activ

6 6
4 5
4
2 3
0 2

2 2 2 2
1 1 1 1
0
C: K
0 0 C: K −1 −1
0
e flour
H2 P −1 −1 icel H2 P −2 −2 n cak
O4 −2 −2
A: av O4 ybea
B: so

'ĶĴłĿIJ  % QMPU TIPXJOH UIF FČFDU PG BWJDFM BOE ,) 10 PO 'ĶĴłĿIJ  % QMPU TIPXJOH UIF FČFDU PG TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS BOE
DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ ,) 10 PO DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ

10 9
8
8
ity
ity

7
Cellulase activ
Cellulase activ

6 6
5
4 4
2 3
2
0
2 2
2 1 1
2 D: ye 0 0
1 1 flou r
xtrac −1
ast e −1
D: y 0 0 t −2 −2 n cake
east −1 −1 ybea
extra −2 −2 icel B: so
ct A: av

'ĶĴłĿIJ  % QMPU TIPXJOH UIF FČFDU PG BWJDFM BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU PO 'ĶĴłĿIJ  % QMPU TIPXJOH UIF FČFDU PG TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS BOE ZFBTU
DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ FYUSBDU PO DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ
 3962, 2013, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2013/979547, Wiley Online Library on [28/06/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
+PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH 

 $PODMVTJPO
9
ity

8
*O UIJT XPSL 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO EFTJHO XBT VTFE UP EFUFSNJOF
Cellulase activ

7
6 UIF SFMBUJWF JNQPSUBODF PG NFEJVN DPNQPOFOUT GPS DFMMVMBTF
5 QSPEVDUJPO "NPOH UIF WBSJBCMFT BWJDFM TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS
4
3 ,) 10 BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU XFSF GPVOE UP CF UIF NPTU
TJHOJĕDBOU WBSJBCMFT 'SPN GVSUIFS PQUJNJ[BUJPO TUVEJFT UIF
2 2 PQUJNJ[FE WBMVFT PG UIF WBSJBCMFT GPS NBYJNVN DFMMVMBTF
1 1
0 0 BDUJWJUZ XFSF BT GPMMPXT BWJDFM H- TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS
D: yeas −1 −1
t extra −2 −2 2P
O4  H- ,) 10  H- BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU H-
ct C: KH
ćJT TUVEZ TIPXFE UIBU UIF QJOFBQQMF XBTUF JT B HPPE TPVSDF
'ĶĴłĿIJ  % QMPU TIPXJOH UIF FČFDU PG ,) 10 BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU GPS UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF ćF NBYJNVN QSPEVDUJPO
PO DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ PG  *6N- PG DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO XBT PCUBJOFE VOEFS
UIF PQUJNJ[FE NFEJB ćF SFTVMUT TIPX B DMPTF DPODPSEBODF
CFUXFFO UIF QSFEJDUFE BOE UIF FYQFSJNFOUBM SVO

PG DFMMVMBTF ćF FČFDU PG DBSCPO TPVSDF BWJDFM PO DFMMVMBTF 3FGFSFODFT

QSPEVDUJPO IBT CFFO TIPXO JO 'JHVSF  JO XIJDI UIF DFMMVMBTF
<> 4 # 3JTXBOBMJ 1 4BSBWBOBO 3 .VUIVWFMBZVEIBN BOE 5
BDUJWJUZ JT JODSFBTFE XJUI JODSFBTF JO BWJDFM DPODFOUSBUJPO
7JSVUIBHJSJ i0QUJNJ[BUJPO PG OVUSJFOU NFEJVN GPS DFMMVMBTF
PG  H- BOE UIFSFBęFS DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ EFDSFBTFE XJUI BOE IFNJDFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPOT GSPN SJDF TUSBX B TUBUJTUJDBM
GVSUIFS JODSFBTF JO BWJDFM DPODFOUSBUJPO ćF TBNF USFOE XBT BQQSPBDI w *OUFSOBUJPOBM +PVSOBM PG $IFNJDBM BOE "OBMZUJDBM
PCTFSWFE JO 'JHVSF  JO XIJDI JU JT DMFBS UIBU BWJDFM BJEFE JO 4DJFODF WPM  OP  QQ o 
UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF 4JNJMBS SFTVMUT XFSF SFQPSUFE CZ <> ( ( #JSDI / #MBLFCSPVHI BOE , + 1BSLFS &O[ZNFT BOE 'PPE
)BP FU BM <> 1SPDFTTJOH "QQMJFE 4DJFODF -POEPO 6, 
ćF JODSFBTF JO UIF DPODFOUSBUJPO PG TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS <> " + 'PSBHF i*** 6UJMJ[BUJPO PG BHSJDVMUVSBM BOE GPPE QSPDFTTJOH
SFTVMUFE JO JODSFBTF JO UIF DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ VQ UP  H- XBTUFT DPOUBJOJOH DBSCPIZESBUFT w $IFNJDBM 4PDJFUZ 3FWJFXT
XIJDI JT TIPXO JO 'JHVSFT  BOE  'JHVSFT  BOE  TIPX WPM  OP  QQ o 
UIF EFQFOEFODZ PG DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ PO ,) 10  ,) 10 <> " ćPMVEVS ' 3BNJSF[ BOE % +BNFT .D.JMMBO i.BUIFNBU
IBT B TUSPOH QPTJUJWF MJOFBS FČFDU PO UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG JDBM NPEFMJOH BOE PQUJNJ[BUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF QSPUFJO QSPEVDUJPO
DFMMVMBTF ćFTF SFTVMUT BSF JO BHSFFNFOU XJUI SFTVMUT SFQPSUFE VTJOH 5SJDIPEFSNB SFFTFJ 3-1 w #JPUFDIOPMPHZ BOE #JPFOHJ
CZ "OVSBEIB +BCBTJOHI <> OFFSJOH WPM  OP  QQ o 
ćF NBYJNVN DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ XBT PCTFSWFE BU  H- <> : 4VO BOE + $IFOH i)ZESPMZTJT PG MJHOPDFMMVMPTJD NBUFSJBMT GPS
PG ,) 10  'JHVSFT  BOE  TIPX UIF EFQFOEFODZ PG DFMMVMBTF FUIBOPM QSPEVDUJPO B SFWJFXw #JPSFTPVSDF 5FDIOPMPHZ WPM 
BDUJWJUZ PO ZFBTU FYUSBDU ćF PSHBOJD OJUSPHFO TPVSDF ZFBTU OP  QQ o 
FYUSBDU VTFE JO UIF TUVEZ GBWPVSFE UIF TZOUIFTJT PG DFMMVMBTFT <> 3 4POJ " /B[JS BOE # 4 $IBEIB i0QUJNJ[BUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF
VTJOH 5 SFFTFJ JO QJOFBQQMF XBTUF ćF TVQQMFNFOUBUJPO PG QSPEVDUJPO CZ B WFSTBUJMF "TQFSHJMMVT GVNJHBUVT GSFTFOJVT TUSBJO
PSHBOJD BOE JOPSHBOJD OJUSPHFO TPVSDFT TUJNVMBUFE UIF DFMMV "." DBQBCMF PG FďDJFOU EFJOLJOH BOE FO[ZNBUJD IZESPMZTJT
MBTF ZJFME BOE BDUJWJUZ 6TF PG PSHBOJD / TPVSDFT SFTQPOEFE UP PG 4PMLB ĘPD BOE CBHBTTF w *OEVTUSJBM $SPQT BOE 1SPEVDUT WPM 
UIF QPTJUJWF DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ NPSF UIBO UIF JOPSHBOJD POFT OP  QQ o 
ćF SFTVMUT PCUBJOFE BSF JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI UIF SFTVMUT PG 3BZ <> 4 # 3JTXBO "MJ 3 .VUIVWFMBZVEIBN BOE 5 7JSVUIBHJSJ
i4UBUJTUJDBM PQUJNJ[BUJPO PG OVUSJFOUT GPS QSPEVDUJPO DFMMVMBTF 
FU BM XIP SFQPSUFE UIBU PSHBOJD OJUSPHFO TPVSDFT XFSF GPVOE
IFNJDFMMVMBTF GSPN SJDF TUSBXw "TJBO +PVSOBM PG #JPDIFNJDBM BOE
UP CF NPSF TVJUBCMF GPS PQUJNJ[JOH DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO CZ 1IBSNBDFVUJDBM 3FTFBSDI WPM  QQ o 
#BDJMMVT TVCUJMJT BOE #BDJMMVT DJSDVMBOT UIBO JOPSHBOJD TPVSDFT
<> + 5 8PSHBO i8BTUF GSPN DSPQ QMBOUT BT SBX NBUFSJBMT GPS
<> " NBYJNVN DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ XBT PCTFSWFE BU  H- DPOWFSTJPO CZ GVOHJ UP GPPE PS MJWFTUPDL GFFE w JO 'PPE 'SPN
PG ZFBTU FYUSBDU 8BTUF QQ o "QQMJFE 4DJFODF -POEPO 6,
<> 4 ,JN BOE # & %BMF i(MPCBM QPUFOUJBM CJPFUIBOPM QSPEVDUJPO
GSPN XBTUFE DSPQT BOE DSPQ SFTJEVFT w #JPNBTT BOE #JPFOFSHZ
 7BMJEBUJPO PG UIF &YQFSJNFOUBM .PEFM WPM  OP  QQ o 
<> ( " :PVTTFG BOE . . #FSFLBB i*NQSPWFE QSPEVDUJPO PG
7BMJEBUJPO PG UIF FYQFSJNFOUBM NPEFM XBT UFTUFE CZ DBSSZJOH
FOEPHMVDBOBTF FO[ZNF CZ "TQFSHJMMVT UFSSFVT "QQMJDBUJPO PG
PVU UIF CBUDI FYQFSJNFOU VOEFS PQUJNBM NFEJB DPNQPTJUJPOT 1MBDLFUU#VSNBO EFTJHO GPS PQUJNJ[BUJPO PG QSPDFTT QBSBNF
BWJDFM  H- TPZCFBO DBLF ĘPVS  H- ,) 10  UFST w #JPUFDIOPMPHZ WPM  OP  QQ o 
 H- BOE ZFBTU FYUSBDU  H- FTUBCMJTIFE CZ UIF SFHSFT <> " 1 #BSUPMPNÏ 1 3VQÏSF[ BOE $ 'ÞTUFS i1JOFBQQMF GSVJU
TJPO NPEFM 'PVS QBSBMMFM FYQFSJNFOUT XFSF QFSGPSNFE JO NPSQIPMPHJDBM DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT DIFNJDBM DPNQPTJUJPO BOE TFO
UIF PQUJNJ[FE NFEJB BOE UIF SFTVMUT BSF DPNQBSFE ćF TPSZ BOBMZTJT PG 3FE 4QBOJTI BOE 4NPPUI $BZFOOF DVMUJWBST w
NBYJNVN DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUZ  *6N- XBT PCUBJOFE GSPN 'PPE $IFNJTUSZ WPM  OP  QQ o 
FYQFSJNFOUT XIJDI XBT WFSZ DMPTF UP UIF DFMMVMBTF QSPEVD <> " 6 .BINPPE + (SFFONBO BOE " ) 4DSBHH i0SBOHF BOE
UJPO  *6N- QSFEJDUFE CZ UIF SFHSFTTJPO NPEFM XIJDI QPUBUP QFFM FYUSBDUT BOBMZTJT BOE VTF BT #BDJMMVT TVCTUSBUFT GPS
QSPWFE UIF WBMJEJUZ PG UIF NPEFM UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG FYUSBDFMMVMBS FO[ZNFT JO DPOUJOVPVT DVMUVSF w
 3962, 2013, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2013/979547, Wiley Online Library on [28/06/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
 +PVSOBM PG &OHJOFFSJOH

&O[ZNF BOE .JDSPCJBM 5FDIOPMPHZ WPM  OP  QQ o


<> 3 ćBOPOH i6UJMJ[BUJPO QJOFBQQMF XBTUF GPS GSP[FO QJOFBQQMF
DPODFOUSBUF w ,BTFUTBSU 6OJWFSTJUZ +PVSOBM WPM  QQ o

<> 4 3 $PVUP BOE . " 4BOSPNÈO i"QQMJDBUJPO PG TPMJE
TUBUF GFSNFOUBUJPO UP GPPE JOEVTUSZ" SFWJFXw +PVSOBM PG 'PPE
&OHJOFFSJOH WPM  OP  QQ o 
<> + / /JHBN i4JOHMF DFMM QSPUFJO GSPN QJOFBQQMF DBOOFSZ
FĒVFOU w 8PSME +PVSOBM PG .JDSPCJPMPHZ BOE #JPUFDIOPMPHZ WPM
 OP  QQ o 
<> + ' .PSUPO i0QUJNJ[BUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO CZ
"TQFSHJMMVT OJHFS BOE 5SJDPEFSNB WJSJEF VTJOH TVHBS DBOF XBTUF w
'SVJUT PG 8BSN $MJNBUFT QQ o 
<> 1 0NPKBTPMB + 'PMBLFNJ 1 0NPXVNJ BOE 4 " *CJZFNJ
i$FMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO CZ TPNF GVOHJ DVMUVSFE PO QJOFBQQMF
XBTUF w /BUVSF BOE 4DJFODF WPM  QQ o 
<> + / /JHBN i$POUJOVPVT FUIBOPM QSPEVDUJPO GSPN QJOFBQQMF
DBOOFSZ XBTUF VTJOH JNNPCJMJ[FE ZFBTU DFMMT w +PVSOBM PG #JPUFDI
OPMPHZ WPM  OP  QQ o 
<> , 5BOBLB ; % )JMBSZ BOE " *TIJ[BLJ i*OWFTUJHBUJPO PG
UIF VUJMJUZ PG QJOFBQQMF KVJDF BOE QJOFBQQMF XBTUF NBUFSJBM BT
MPXDPTU TVCTUSBUF GPS FUIBOPM GFSNFOUBUJPO CZ ;ZNPNPOBT
NPCJMJT w +PVSOBM PG #JPTDJFODF BOE #JPFOHJOFFSJOH WPM  OP
 QQ o 
<> " ,IBMJM i"QQMJDBUJPO PG DFOUSBM DPNQPTJUF EFTJHO CBTFE
SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF NFUIPEPMPHZ JO QBSBNFUFS PQUJNJ[BUJPO BOE
PO DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO VTJOH BHSJDVMUVSBM XBTUF w #JP 3FTPVSDFT
WPM  OP  QQ o 
<> "+VXBJFE " "MBNJFSZ ; "CEVNVOJFN BOE 6 "OBBN
i4UVEJFT PO UIF QSPEVDUJPO BOE BQQMJDBUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF GSPN
5SJDIPEFSNB SFFTFJ 2.  w +PVSOBM PG :FBTU BOE 'VOHBM
3FTFBSDI WPM  QQ o 
<> 7 4 #JTBSJB BOE 5 , (IPTF i#JPEFHSBEBUJPO PG DFMMVMPTJD
NBUFSJBMT TVCTUSBUFT NJDSPPSHBOJTNT FO[ZNFT BOE QSPEVDUT w
&O[ZNF BOE .JDSPCJBM 5FDIOPMPHZ WPM  OP  QQ o

<> 3 .VUIVWFMBZVEIBN BOE 5 7JSVUIBHJSJ i"QQMJDBUJPO PG DFO
USBM DPNQPTJUF EFTJHO CBTFE SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF NFUIPEPMPHZ JO
QBSBNFUFS PQUJNJ[BUJPO BOE PO DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO VTJOH BHSJ
DVMUVSBM XBTUF w *OUFSOBUJPOBM +PVSOBM PG $IFNJDBM BOE #JPMPHJDBM
&OHJOFFSJOH WPM  OP  QQ o 
<> 5 , (IPTF i.FBTVSFNFOU PG DFMMVMBTF BDUJWJUJFT w 1VSF BOE
"QQMJFE $IFNJTUSZ WPM  QQ o 
<> ( - .JMMFS i6TF PG EJOJUSPTBMJDZMJD BDJE SFBHFOU GPS EFUFSNJOB
UJPO PG SFEVDJOH TVHBSw "OBMZUJDBM $IFNJTUSZ WPM  OP  QQ
o 
<> 9 $ )BP 9 # :V BOE ; - :BO i0QUJNJ[BUJPO PG UIF NFEJVN
GPS UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG DFMMVMBTF CZ UIF NVUBOU 5SJDIPEFSNB
SFFTFJ 89 VTJOH SFTQPOTF TVSGBDF NFUIPEPMPHZw 'PPE
5FDIOPMPHZ BOE #JPUFDIOPMPHZ WPM  OP  QQ o 
<> 4 "OVSBEIB +BCBTJOHI BOE $ 7BMMJ /BDIJZBS i" OFX DPN
CJOBUJPOBM TUBUJTUJDBM BQQSPBDI GPS DFMMVMBTF PQUJNJ[BUJPO JO
"TQFSHJMMVT OJEVMBOT w *OEJBO +PVSOBM PG 4DJFODF BOE 5FDIOPMPHZ
WPM  OP  QQ o 
<> " , 3BZ " #BJSBHJ , 4BSLBS (IPTI BOE 4 , 4FO i0QUJ
NJ[BUJPO PG GFSNFOUBUJPO DPOEJUJPOT GPS DFMMVMBTF QSPEVDUJPO CZ
#BDJMMVT TVCUJMJT $: BOE #BDJMMVT DJSDVMBOT 51 JTPMBUFE GSPN
ĕTI HVU w "DUB *DIUIZPMPHJDB FU 1JTDBUPSJB WPM  OP  QQ
o