Module 1
Module 1
policy in India:
Industrial Jurisprudence
Historical Context:
● The Industrial Revolution (18th19th centuries) highlighted the dire working conditions of
laborers, leading to the growth of trade unionism and demands for better labour laws.
Governments began to recognize the need for regulatory frameworks to protect workers from
exploitation.
● The welfare state emerged as a response to the excesses of laissezfaire, mandating state
intervention in regulating working conditions, wages, safety, and industrial relations.
1. Right to Form Unions: Workers have the right to form and join unions to collectively
bargain with employers. This is recognized both in national legislation and international
conventions (such as those of the ILO).
3. Tripartism: Involves the participation of workers, employers, and the state in resolving
industrial disputes. It promotes a more collaborative approach to labour relations.
● The origin of labour laws in India can be traced back to the colonial period, with the
British government's first interventions aimed more at controlling the native labour force than
improving their conditions.
○ The Factories Act of 1881 was one of the earliest labour regulations, focusing on
improving working conditions for factory workers but largely driven by pressure from British
industrialists seeking to eliminate unfair competition from Indian manufacturers using cheap
labour.
○ The rise of trade unions in the 1920s, alongside global movements for workers' rights, led
to key legislative enactments such as the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923, Trade Union Act,
1926, and Trade Disputes Act, 1929.
PostIndependence (19471990):
● After independence, India's Constitution (1950) laid down the framework for labour
rights through the Directive Principles of State Policy (Part IV). Articles like 39, 41, 42, 43, and
43A advocate social justice for workers, including equal pay for equal work, humane working
conditions, and participation in management.
○ The postindependence era saw the enactment of several landmark laws aimed at
improving workers' conditions, including:
■ Factories Act, 1948: Ensures safety, health, and welfare measures for workers in
factories.
■ Minimum Wages Act, 1948: Sets the minimum wage rate to protect workers from
exploitation.
■ Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948: Provides social security to workers, including
medical and cash benefits during sickness, maternity, or injury.
■ Maternity Benefit Act, 1961: Provides paid maternity leave and job protection during
pregnancy.
● India’s shift towards a market economy in the 1990s brought significant changes to
labour policy. With globalization, there was an increased focus on making Indian industries
competitive globally, often at the expense of workers' rights. Labour laws began to reflect this
shift, emphasizing flexibility in employment, contractual employment, and voluntary retirement
schemes (VRS). Despite this, the state continues to play a regulatory role in ensuring a basic
standard of worker welfare.
Constitutional Paradigm of Labour and Industrial Law
● Article 19(1)(c) (Right to Form Unions): Workers have the constitutional right to
form associations and trade unions to protect their interests and negotiate with employers.
● Article 39: Advocates for equal pay for men and women, ensuring that economic
resources do not get concentrated in the hands of a few.
● Article 41: Promotes the right to work and public assistance during unemployment, old
age, sickness, and disability.
● Article 42: Calls for just and humane working conditions and maternity benefits.
● Article 43: Mandates the state to ensure a living wage and decent standards of living for
all workers.
● Article 43A: Calls for the participation of workers in the management of industrial
undertakings, promoting industrial democracy.
1. Social Justice: Labour laws ensure that workers are treated with fairness and justice,
safeguarding their basic rights. This includes laws like the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 and
Maternity Benefit Act, 1961.
2. Social Equality: Ensures there is no discrimination in the workplace based on gender,
caste, religion, etc. The Equal Remuneration Act, 1976 is a prime example, ensuring women
receive equal pay for equal work.
3. Social Security: Labour laws provide mechanisms to protect workers from the
uncertainties of life such as unemployment, sickness, and old age. Laws like the Employees’
State Insurance Act, 1948 and Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 fall under this category.
4. National Economy: The goal is to ensure that labour laws contribute positively to
national economic development by maintaining industrial peace and ensuring that workers are
healthy, productive, and fairly treated.
Principles
1. Social Justice
○ Objective: To protect workers from exploitation and ensure fair wages and working conditions.
○ Implementation:
■ Minimum Wages: Laws like the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, ensure that workers
receive a minimum standard of pay, preventing exploitation.
■ Working Hours: Regulations on working hours, overtime, and rest periods are
enforced to prevent overwork and ensure workers’ health and wellbeing.
■ Safety Standards: The Factories Act, 1948, mandates safety measures to protect
workers from industrial accidents and occupational diseases.
2. Social Equality
○ Objective: To eliminate discrimination in the workforce based on gender, religion, caste, etc.
○ Implementation:
■ Equal Remuneration: The Equal Remuneration Act, 1976, ensures that men and
women receive equal pay for equal work.
■ AntiDiscrimination: Various laws prohibit discrimination in hiring, promotion,
and other employment practices.
3. Social Security
○ Objective: To protect workers from social risks such as unemployment, injury, or illness.
○ Implementation:
■ Insurance Schemes: The Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948, provides health
insurance and medical care to workers.
■ Provident Funds: The Employees’ Provident Funds Act, 1952, ensures financial
security for workers postretirement.
4. National Economy
○ Implementation:
■ Investment Climate: Stable industrial relations and fair labor practices attract
foreign investment and boost economic development.
● Fair Wages: Legislation ensures that workers receive fair wages for their labor,
preventing underpayment and wage theft.
● Job Security: Laws provide job security by regulating termination procedures and
protecting against arbitrary dismissal.
● Improved Working Conditions: Labour laws mandate safe and healthy working
conditions, reducing workplace accidents and occupational diseases.
● Purpose: To regulate the relationship between employers and employees and manage
industrial disputes.
● Examples:
○ Trade Unions Act, 1926: Provides for the registration and regulation of trade unions,
granting them legal recognition and the right to negotiate on behalf of their members.
○ Industrial Disputes Act, 1947: Establishes mechanisms for the investigation and
settlement of industrial disputes, including conciliation, arbitration, and adjudication.
● Examples:
○ Mines Act, 1952: Provides for the health, safety, and welfare of workers in mines,
including measures to prevent accidents and occupational diseases.
WageRelated Labour Legislations
● Purpose: To set methods of wage payment and ensure minimum wages for workers.
● Examples:
○ Payment of Wages Act, 1936: Regulates the payment of wages to certain classes of
employed persons, ensuring timely and full payment without unauthorized deductions.
○ Minimum Wages Act, 1948: Provides for the fixation of minimum rates of wages in
certain employments, ensuring that workers receive a basic standard of living.
● Purpose: To provide social security benefits like insurance, compensation for injury, and
maternity benefits.
● Examples:
○ Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948: Provides health insurance and medical care
for workers, including benefits for sickness, maternity, and employment injury.
○ Maternity Benefit Act, 1961: Provides for maternity leave and benefits for women
workers, ensuring their health and wellbeing during and after pregnancy.
● Examples:
○ Beedi Workers Welfare Fund Act, 1976: Provides for the welfare of workers in the
beedi industry, including health, education, and housing benefits.
○ Plantation Labour Act, 1951: Regulates the conditions of work in plantations and
provides for the welfare of plantation workers, including housing, medical facilities, and
education for their children.
Employment Rights and Problems of the Working
Force
Employment Rights
● Right to Fair Wages: Workers have the right to receive fair wages for their labor, as
mandated by laws like the Minimum Wages Act, 1948.
● Humane Working Conditions: Workers are entitled to safe and healthy working
conditions, as provided by the Factories Act, 1948.
● Collective Bargaining: Workers have the right to form and join trade unions and
engage in collective bargaining, as per the Trade Unions Act, 1926.
● Social Security: Workers are entitled to social security benefits like insurance,
provident funds, and compensation for injuries, as provided by various social security
legislations.
Problems
● Exploitation: Despite legislation, workers often face exploitation in terms of low wages,
long working hours, and poor working conditions. This is particularly prevalent in the informal
sector, where labor laws are often not enforced.
● Unequal Wages: Wage disparities based on gender, caste, and other factors persist in
many sectors, despite laws aimed at promoting equality.
Conclusion
1. Distributive Bargaining: A winlose scenario where one party's gain is the other's loss
(e.g., wage negotiations).
2. IndustryLevel Bargaining: Common in sectors like textiles, jute, and tea plantations.
Agreements are made at the industry level and supplemented by regional agreements.
1. Preparation of Initial Demands: Both the trade union and management prepare their
objectives and proposals based on internal data analysis.
3. Agreement Drafting: Once both sides agree, a formal collective bargaining agreement is
drafted. This document legally binds both parties to the agreedupon conditions.
4. Implementation and Monitoring: The agreement is implemented, and both parties
monitor compliance.
5. Conciliation and Arbitration (if necessary): If the parties fail to agree, they can opt for
arbitration or conciliation through a third party.
1. Voluntary Agreements: Negotiated directly between unions and employers, binding both
parties.
1. Legal Framework: Although laws like the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and Trade Unions
Act, 1926 exist, the lack of compulsory recognition of agreements hinders effective
implementation.
2. Multiple Unions: In organizations with multiple unions, the negotiation process can
become complicated and inefficient.
2. Economic Stability
3. Adaptation to Change
Core Aims:
Role in Indian Labor Policy: The ILO has had a significant influence
on Indian labor laws and policies. Several key labor laws, such as the Factories
Act (1922), Mines Act (1952), and Workmen’s Compensation Act (1923), were
influenced by ILO conventions.
Collective Bargaining:
The ILO's core labor standards focus on protecting workers’ rights against
forced labor, discrimination, and child labor, while promoting the right to form
unions and engage in collective bargaining. These standards are enshrined in
the Fundamental Conventions.
Fundamental Conventions:
These conventions are essential for the functioning of the international labor
standards system:
Technical Conventions:
●
● GC- General Council: meets once a year, conference assisted by
governing body- budget, programme- adopts. International Labour
standards in form of convention, recommendations and provides form
fordiscussion.
● Governing Body- executive wing- since 1922. India- elective seat in GB.
1) ProgrammePlaning Administration
2) Freedom Association
3) Legal Issue and International Labour Standard
4) Employment and Social Policy
5) Technical Co-operation
6) Sectoral and technical meeting and related issues
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
Topic 1: Aim and Objective of the Act
● Introduction
The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 was enacted with the purpose of providing a permanent
mechanism for the investigation and settlement of industrial disputes. The Act aims to minimize
conflicts between labor and management and promote social and economic justice, ensuring
industrial peace, which is essential for uninterrupted production and national prosperity.
1. Promotion of Good Relations: The Act promotes measures to ensure amity between
employers and workers.
4. Relief to Workers: It provides for relief to workers in case of layoffs and retrenchment,
ensuring economic stability for the workforce.
1. Applicability: The Act applies to industries and certain categories of industrial workers.
4. Restrictions on Strikes and Lockouts: The right to strike by workers and lockout by
employers is regulated and not absolute.
5. Public Utility Services: The government can declare certain industries as public utilities,
which imposes additional restrictions on strikes and lockouts.