Intercultural Aspects in Teaching Japane
Intercultural Aspects in Teaching Japane
Intercultural Aspects in Teaching Japane
Abstract: This article aims at presenting insights regarding the formation of students’ character education through the learning of
foreign language with intercultural insight. The primary focus of this study is to examine the extent to which students know and
understand the cultural differences between Japanese and Indonesian culture, especially in Japanese literature students in nonverbal
communication that will be able to form the character of the students themselves. Questionnaires were employed mainly to collect data.
The subjects participating in this study were thirty students of Japanese Literature. Findings revealed that on the basis of 10 questions
about the cultural knowledge, the respondents who know the Japanese culture were 50%. Only one question was known by 70% of the
respondents. More than 60% of the respondents do not know the eight out of ten questions. It can be concluded that based on the ten
questions, the respondents generally do not know the Japanese culture.
Defining intercultural competence is a complex task. At the Samani and Hariyanto (2011, p46) states character education
heart of intercultural competence is the preparation of the is a planned effort to make learners recognize care, and
cultural background (Sinecrope and Watanabe, 2012). Chick mengiternalisasikan values so that learners behave as human
(2009), states that Intercultural Competence is the ability to beings. In line with Mulyasa (2011, p9) argues character
move from an "ethnocentric" attitude to another culture's education emphasizes exemplary, environmental creation,
respectful attitude, leading to the ability to behave and habituation. Character education has a higher level with
appropriately in a different culture or cultures. Rather, it is education of understanding. This is shown by the scope of
defined in terms of the intercultural competence, which is implementation that is not limited to the learning process.
"the ability of a person to behave in a flexible manner when While Endang Sumantri in Rohinah (2012), in character
confronted with actions, attitudes and expectations of education there are six main ethical values as embodied in
Volume 6 Issue 12, December 2017
www.ijsr.net
Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY
Paper ID: ART20178681 DOI: 10.21275/ART20178681 712
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)
ISSN (Online): 2319-7064
Index Copernicus Value (2016): 79.57 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391
the aspen Declaration are: 1) trustworthy such as honesty A large-scale self-report survey was used to collect data for
and integrity, 2) treat others with respect (Treats people with this study (see Appendix A). This instrument was developed
respect), 3) responsible, fair, 5) caring, 6) good citizen by researchers based on information obtained from literature
Based on the opinion that has been stated previously, review in the field of learning / learning Japanese. Research
actually learning Japanese culture on Japanese literature question as a guide: The questionnaire is made by giving
students can be used as a means of character education that two choices of "know" and "do not know" answers. It
is very effective to give birth to students of good quality of contains 10 open questions. Participants were asked to
science and character. The learning of Japanese should be choose between two answers that the students felt.
integrated with a cultural understanding that can ultimately
lead the learner to understand deeper the culture he The available questions are in the guutman scale format, the
possesses and the culture he studies. cumulative scale. If the respondent accepts a heavier
weighted statement, he or she will affirm other less weighty
Indonesia is a very heterogeneous developing country from statements, consisting of several hierarchically sorted
the social and cultural side. While Japan is a developed questions, the Guttman Scale is used for clear and
country that still has a unique unique culture that is unambiguous answers EXAMPLE: Sure-no, True-false,
maintained by tradition. These cultural equations and Ever- not yet, Agree-disagree, Positive-negative.
differences should be able to provide an understanding that
affects the potential of the individual students of cognitive, To determine the validity of the contents of the instrument,
affective, conative, and psychomotoric. This target has not as stated by Gay, Mills, & Airasian (2006) as an instrument
been focused on Japanese literature students. This is one of that measures what is meant or claimed is measured, the
the tasks of science that can move the power of thought, researchers present it to a panel of experts, who are required
feeling, and motivation to act according to moral values that to validate the contents of survey instruments by ensuring
can be included in the planning of learning (Syllabus and the overall inclusivity all variables being investigated and to
SAP) learning courses of Japanese literature courses. verify that the question is addressed for all research
questions. Experts are also asked to review surveys for
Culture is the crystallization of values and lifestyles adopted things like unclear, confusing, ambiguous or repetitive
by a community. The culture of each community grows and instructions, and overly complex or difficult sentence
develops uniquely, because of the different patterns of structures. The researchers then revised the instrument based
community life. Differences in the communication culture on the constructive feedback received from the examiner. To
between Indonesia and Japan are numerous and may vary establish the reliability of the survey instrument used, the
widely perceived by each person and may also differ researcher used the re-test / retest method using 25 students,
according to the area of the culture as well as possibly the number of students in regular class size. These students
change over time. Although Japanese culture and Indonesian are not the subject of this reported study. The identical
culture is a hight context culture, there are differences in survey was completed by the participants twice. There is a
communication habits as well as in nonverbal one-week waiting window between the administration of the
communication (Setyanto, 2013:18-19). first and second instruments. In addition to the test / retest
method, the researchers also tested the Alpha Cronbach
2. Methods reliability. Cronbach Alpha values for various parts of the
instrument ranged from 0.893.
This study employed the mixed method design which is the
combination of qualitative and quantitative approach to The researchers asked students in the selected classes to
collect and analyze data (Creswell &Clark, 2007). In recent participate in the study. Upon arrival to each class, the
years, integrating qualitative and quantitative methods researchers introduced themselves, explained the purpose of
becomes common in research (Bryman, 2006) because the visit, emphasized that participation was totally voluntary,
mixed method design can provide detailed and and then administered the questionnaire to the participants.
comprehensive data in order to achieve the research Voluntary participation was ensured both through explicit
objectives and answer the research questions. The question verbal and written explanations. The participants could
refers to Setyanto's research results (2013), with the addition withdraw from the study at any time and that their
of the researcher. It is also accompanied by observations and participation would in no way influence their academic
reference study systems to generate appropriate learning standing in the class where the questionnaires were
strategies that can shape the student's character. In this study, distributed. Participants were informed verbally and in
the variables were: 1. participants’ demographics, 2. writing that they could decline to answer any items on the
participants’ overallperceptions of Japanese facilitated questionnaire. The subjects gave their consent by completing
teaching/learning. and returning the questionnaire. Data analyses included the
used of summary descriptive statistics, cross tabulations, test
The accessible student population (classes) for the study was for equality of variance, t tests, correlations, ANOVA and
approximately 30 Japanese students. Researchers visited the post hoc tests.
selected class and asked all students to participate in the
questionnaire. In the end, 30 students participated in this 3. Result and Discussion
study, accounting for approximately 1/10 of the overall
population. In the questionnaire, the question given is a question to
know the extent to which students know some cultural
differences communicate between Japan and Indonesia by
Volume 6 Issue 12, December 2017
www.ijsr.net
Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY
Paper ID: ART20178681 DOI: 10.21275/ART20178681 713
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)
ISSN (Online): 2319-7064
Index Copernicus Value (2016): 79.57 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391
knowing the differences between the two cultures can affect answered by the student with the amount of 70%, while the
the character of students. other 8 questions answered by students with no Know with
value above 60%. From the results that have been found can
The descriptive results, question and t-values obtained as t- be concluded that the 10 questions given by researchers to
test results are presented in Table 1 below. The question of the average student does not know the culture of the
the questionare are; (1) do you know how the response of Japanese people completely. Actually, in the questionnaires
the Japanese when listening to other people talk? (2) do you filled with respondents were also asked to write what lessons
know how the Japanese people are, in terms of apologizing, can be taken by students from the question that have been
thanking and praising? (3) do you know some Japanese given, because in this study more focus on intercultural
gestures that are different from Indonesians? (4) do you Japanese in character education students. While for students
know whether ordinary Japanese or not touch the other who do not know about Japanese culture can be given when
person when communicating with others? (5) do you know the courses can be connected with Japanese culture.
in Japan the people introduce themselves with each other
name card? (6) do you know about the concept of time used When the t-score is examined, it is clear that there is a
by Japanese people? (7) do you know that in Japan applied a statistically significant difference between students who
moral education to their school? (8) do you know that know Japanese culture and students who do not know
students in Japan do not rely on gadgets in all situations? (9) Japanese culture, although this is not particularly obvious.
do you know that reading a book is an addiction to the One possible explanation of these findings is that Japanese
Japanese? (10) know how the Japanese appreciate others Literature students have not yet taught Japanese Culture in
who are talking. the process of pursuing; only still focusing on grammar only.
In the context of education, Japanese grammar learning
Table 1: Result of Questionnaire of should also be given a description of Japanese culture in
Question order to shape the character of the student especially with
t-value
N % students Japanase Literature. Thus, lecturers and students
1. Do you know how the Know 9 30% can improve the self character of the learning process.
response of the Japanese
0.256
when listening to other Don’t know 21 70% This research seeks to analyze Intercultural Aspects in
people talk?
Teaching Japanese as a Foreign Language In Indonesia as a
2. Do you know how the Know 7 23%
Japanese people are, in
Means of Character Education Of Japanese Literature
0.078 Students. the results of questionnaires distributed to 30
terms of apologizing, Don’t know 23 77%
thanking and praising? students of Japanese literature by asking 10 questions about
3. Do you know some Know 11 37% the cultural knowledge of Japanese people there is a
Japanese gestures that are question that answered students know by 50% and only 1
1.623
different from Indonesian Don’t know 19 63% question answered by the student with the amount of 70%,
gestures? while the other 8 questions answered by students with no
4. Do you know whether or Know 8 26% Know with value above 60%. From the results that have
not ordinary Japanese been found can be concluded that the 10 questions given by
touch the other persons 0.369
Don’t know 22 74% researchers to the average student does not know the culture
when communicating with
them?
of the Japanese people completely.
5. Do you know that in Know 15 50%
Japan you introduce Differences in the communication culture between Indonesia
1.723 and Japan are numerous and may vary widely perceived by
yourself with a mutual Don’t know 15 50%
name card? each person and may also differ according to the area of the
6. Do you know about the Know 12 40% culture as well as possibly change over time. Although
concept of time used by 1.434 Japanese culture and Indonesian culture is a high context
Don’t know 18 80%
the Japanese? culture, there are differences in communication habits as
7. Do you know that in Know 19 63% well as in nonverbal communication (Setyanto, 2013). In
Japan moral education is 1.658
Don’t know 11 37% some studies that have been done by previous researchers,
taught at school?
researchers take some cultural differences of communication
8. Do you know that Know 17 57%
students in Japan do not and custom between Japanese and Indonesian people, as
1.734 follows: (1) Distance and touch, when communicating with
rely on gadgets in all Don’t know 13 43%
situations? other people, people who cultured Japan including people
9. Do you know that reading Know 21 70% who do not normally touch the other person's body, in other
a book is an addiction to 1.534 words when compared with Indonesia kwantitas very little.
Don’t know 9 30%
the Japanese? In Indonesia with new people known not a few people who
10. Do you know how the Know 11 37% talk while touching other people's body parts, such as
Japanese respect other 1.548 holding the shoulders, pulling hands and others (Setyanto,
Don’t know 19 63%
people who are talking? 2013). In this example it can shape the character of the
student to be someone who can appreciate others. This is a
From the results of questionnaires distributed to 30 students form of moral education to the students to respect each other
of Japanese literature by asking 10 questions about the and treat people with respect). (2) time concept that exists in
cultural knowledge of Japanese people there is a question communication between cultures is the "monochronic time"
that answered students know by 50% and only 1 question that the execution of everything on schedule has been made,
Volume 6 Issue 12, December 2017
www.ijsr.net
Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY
Paper ID: ART20178681 DOI: 10.21275/ART20178681 714
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)
ISSN (Online): 2319-7064
Index Copernicus Value (2016): 79.57 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391
and the "polychronic time" which is more concerned with the people, caring for themrselves and others, and mutual
human relationships and other things compared to the respects among human beings.
schedule already available. Japan is a country with a
monochronic time pattern, while Indonesia tends to References
polychronic time (Akihito, 2010). The Japanese are
disciplined in any case, especially the time. Indonesians are [1] Atay, D., Kurt, G., Ersin, P., & Kaslioglu, Ö. (2009).
famous for their stalling habits, Japanese do not like to wait The Role of Intercultural Competence in Foreign
and waste time, because for them time is money. This is an Language Teaching∗. Journal of The. INONU
example of a good character for students, because as a UNIVERSITY JOURNAL OF THE FACULTY OF
student must have a character that can be an example to EDUCATION, 10(3), 123-136.
others, with respect to the time it will be able to finish what [2] Blake, R. J. (2009). The Use of Technology for Second
will be done well. It is a form of responsible character and Language Distance Learning. The Modern Language
self-discipline. (4) get acquainted, the thing to be noticed Journal, 93(2), 822-836.
when acquainted with the Japanese is not shaking hands but [3] Bryman, A. (2006). Social Research Methods (2nd
bend first (Ojigi). Ojigi is also commonly used in various edition).. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
things such as martial arts, greeting members, honor [4] Chick, J. K. (2009). Intercultural Communication. In S.
members, apologize, say thank you, and others. The L. McKay, & N. H. Homberger, Sociolinguistics and
Japanese are very respectful of privacy so do not be careless Language Teaching (pp. 329-348). Cambridge:
talk should talk about light things. While the Indonesian Cambridge University Press.
people when they met each other shake hands. It is a form of [5] Creswell, J. W., & Plano, C. V. (2007). Designing and
character treats people with respect. (5) go to Visit, in Japan, conducting mixed methods research. . Thousand Oaks,
except when invited to a dinner party, or a drinking party, CA: Sage.
playing to a friend's house is unusual. For example, planning [6] Gay, L. R., Mills, G. E., & Airasian, P. W. (2013).
to play should contact first, and go to a friend's house Educational research: Competencies for analysis and
without notice is considered very disturbing. While in application, 10th Edition. . Boston: Pearson Education.
Indonesia go play to a friend's house or acquaintance [7] Gibson, K. (2008). Technology and technological
without promise or prior notice is a common thing. Like knowledge: a challenge for school curricula. Teachers
when out of town, if there are friends who live in the city, and Teaching: theory and practice, 14(1), 3–15.
then without notice to the friend's house is not a strange [8] Global Affairs Canada. (2017, May 22). Retrieved from
thing, maybe even friends will feel happy, and not feel Cultural Information - Indonesia:
disturbed (Setyanto, 2013). In the differences between these https://www.international.gc.ca/cil-cai/country_insights-
two cultures greatly affect the character of the students; this apercus_pays/ci-
can be used as a form of student character. By studying ic_id.aspx?lang=eng&_ga=2.198538479.1790290918.1
Japanese culture will lead the students to a better character. 510965946-1977769171.1510965946
By understanding these differences can form the character of [9] Gobel, K., & Helmke, A. (2010). Intercultural Learning
treats people with respect (setyanto, 2013). in English as a Foreign Language Instruction; The
Important of Teachers’ Intercultural Experience and
4. Conclusion Usefullness of Precise Instrutional Directive. Teaching
and Teacher Education. pp1572. Teaching and Teacher
To avoid misunderstandings of communication, especially Education, 26(1), 1571-1582.
misinterpretation of meaning, then the intercultural [10] Hockly, N. (2012). Digital literacies. ELT Journal,
competence of important languages is taught to Japanese 66(1), 108-112.
language learners as a foreign language. Intercultural [11] Jandt, F. E. (1998). Intercultural Communication, An
competence building in Japanese language teaching class as Introduction. London : Sage Publication.
a foreign language must be included in learning plan [12] Kaur, S. (2015). Moral Values In Education. Journal Of
(syllabus and lesson plan) of course study of Japanese Humanities And Social Science, 20(3), 21-26.
literary program. Through the cultural content presented, [13] Moloney, R., & Harbon, L. (2010). Making Intercultural
learners are trained to interact with native Japanese speakers Language Learning Visible and Asessable. Intercultural
who have deep cultural differences. The importance of Competence Conference (pp. 281-303). Tucson:
cultural understanding by language learners, so as to reduce CERCLL.
the misunderstandings that occur due to cultural [14] Mueller, A. K., & Nugent, K. (2014). Building
misunderstandings between language actors and by Intercultural Competence in the Language Classroom.
deepening the culture of the target language will itself shape Faculty Publications: Department of Teaching, Learning
the character of a student. Actually, the questionnaires filled and Teacher Education.
with respondents also asked them to write what lessons or [15] Mulyasa. (2011). Manajemen Pendidikan Karakter, .
value the students could take because this study focuses Jakarta: Bumi Aksara.
more on intercultural Japanese aspects in their character [16] Nguyen, T. T. (2017). Integrating Culture into
education. There are six cultural differences between Japan Language Teaching and Learning: Learner Outcomes.
and Indonesia in shaping the character of the students The Reading Matrix: An International Online Journal ,
namely, distance and touch, the concept of time, getting 17(1), 145-155.
acquainted, go visit, stunned the heads of others, and [17] Nida, E. A. (2009). Language and Culture.
speaking has good character values in guiding students to be ENTRECULTURAS, 1, 25-32.