Category local coursebook global coursebook global coursebook

"English" by Alla Nesvit "Solutions Third "Roadmap" 2020 by

2017 Edition A2" 2018 by Lindsay Warwick, Damian
Oxford University Press Williams
Content The textbook covers a wide This textbook covers a This textbook offers an
range of topics related to variety of topics related interesting approach to
the English language, to English language and learning English, focusing on
including grammar, culture, integrating communicative skills and
vocabulary, reading authentic materials for cultural understanding. It
comprehension, and writing practical application. It integrates authentic materials
skills. However, it tends to provides a good balance such as authentic texts,
be more theoretical and dry between language skills videos, and interviews to
in content, lacking practical development and cultural connect language learning
application and real-world understanding. with real-life situations and
context. Additionally, it contexts.
focuses predominantly on
Ukrainian culture, which
may limit its relevance for
learners outside of Ukraine.
Skills and It offers strategies for It focuses primarily on The emphasis is on
strategies developing all language developing speaking developing speaking and
skills, but it lacks well- skills through understanding skills in real-
developed group and pair communicative activities life situations, providing
interaction activities, which and strategies for strategies for practical
are crucial for language effective communication. application. It offers a
practice and However, it may lack holistic approach to language
communication skills emphasis on grammar learning, including grammar
development. explanations and drills and structured language
structured language practice. It may provide
practice. This could relatively less emphasis on
potentially hinder grammar drills and structured
students' mastery of language practice. While
grammar rules and usage. communicative activities are
valuable, a balance with
structured grammar practice
could enhance language
proficiency.
 Activities The textbook includes The textbook contains The textbook contains
various activities such as various activities such as various interactive exercises
games, role-plays, and role-plays, interactive and tasks, promoting hands-
creative tasks, but the exercises, and group on learning experiences and
opportunities for interaction projects, encouraging facilitating active
and collaboration among active participation and engagement among students.
students are not well engagement among
emphasized. students.

Language The language used is It uses standard language It uses accessible and
accessible and adapted to adapted to the needs of understandable language,
the students' level of 8th-grade students, with simplifying the learning
learning, with clear explanations and process, with language
explanations and examples instructions presented tailored to the comprehension
provided in simple clearly and concisely. level of learners.
language.
Layout The layout is clear and The layout features a The layout features an
organized, with illustrations modern design with attractive and modern design
to aid comprehension, but it bright illustrations and with illustrations and graphic
may lack visual appeal graphical elements, elements, making the
compared to more modern enhancing visual appeal material visually engaging
designs. and accessibility. and user-friendly.

User- While the textbook is It is intuitively It is intuitively

friendliness intuitively understandable understandable, with understandable, with clear
for both students and clear instructions and instructions and prompts,
teachers, it may have prompts for seamless facilitating the teaching and
limited access to audio navigation and learning process for both
resources, which are comprehension. students and educators.
essential for language
learning.
English Language by Alla Nesvit
The textbook "English Language" by Alla Nesvit for 8th-grade students offers a comprehensive
coverage of various topics related to the English language, including grammar, vocabulary, reading
comprehension, and writing skills. The content is supplemented with a bit of “dry” materials to provide
practical context. However, the book has a theoretical and dry nature, which can make it less engaging
for students. Its primary focus on Ukrainian culture may limit its relevance for learners from diverse
backgrounds. The textbook includes diverse activities such as games, role-plays, and creative tasks, but
it lacks well-developed group and pair interaction activities, which are crucial for developing
communication skills. The language used in the book is accessible and adapted to the students' level,
with clear explanations and examples. The layout is clear and organized, featuring illustrations that aid
comprehension, but it may lack the visual appeal of more modern designs. Although the book is
intuitively understandable for both students and teachers, it has limited access to audio resources, which
are essential for effective language learning.
Solutions Third Edition by Oxford University Press
"Solutions Third Edition" by Oxford University Press is a well-rounded textbook that covers a variety of
topics related to the English language and culture. It integrates authentic materials, such as audio
recordings and real-world texts, to enhance practical application and engagement. The textbook focuses
primarily on developing speaking skills through communicative activities and strategies for effective
communication. However, it may lack emphasis on grammar explanations and structured language
practice, which could affect students' mastery of grammar rules. The activities in the textbook include
role-plays, interactive exercises, and group projects that encourage active participation and engagement.
The language used is standard and adapted to the needs of 8th-grade students, with clear and concise
explanations and instructions. The layout is modern and visually appealing, with bright illustrations and
graphical elements that enhance accessibility. The textbook is user-friendly, with clear instructions and
prompts that facilitate seamless navigation and comprehension for both students and teachers.

Roadmap by Lindsay Warwick and Damian Williams

"Roadmap" by Lindsay Warwick and Damian Williams offers an innovative approach to learning
English, focusing on communicative skills and cultural understanding. The textbook is enriched with
authentic materials such as texts, videos, and interviews that connect language learning with real-life
situations. It emphasizes developing speaking and understanding skills in real-world contexts, providing
strategies for practical application. However, it may provide relatively less emphasis on grammar drills
and structured language practice, which could require supplementary materials for thorough grammar
coverage. The activities in "Roadmap" are interactive and hands-on, promoting active engagement and
practical use of language skills. The language used is accessible and tailored to the learners'
comprehension level, making the learning process simpler and more effective. The layout is attractive
and modern, with illustrations and graphic elements that make the material visually engaging and user-
friendly. The textbook is intuitively understandable, with clear instructions and prompts that facilitate
the teaching and learning process for both students and educators.

Comparative Analysis

● Grammar
English Language by Alla Nesvit:
The grammar section in "English Language" by Alla Nesvit is thorough, covering fundamental aspects
such as verb tenses, sentence structure, and parts of speech. The explanations are clear and detailed, but
the content tends to be theoretical, with exercises focusing on rote learning rather than practical
application. This book primarily uses written exercises to reinforce grammar rules.
Solutions Third Edition by Oxford University Press:
"Solutions Third Edition" integrates grammar within its units, providing context through reading and
listening activities. It covers similar grammar topics as the Nesvit book but places a stronger emphasis
on practical usage. The exercises include more communicative tasks, such as pair work and group
discussions, which encourage students to use grammar in context. However, there is less focus on
explicit grammar drills.
Roadmap by Lindsay Warwick and Damian Williams:
"Roadmap" also covers key grammar topics but integrates them into broader communicative contexts.
Grammar is presented through dialogues and real-life scenarios, encouraging students to deduce rules
from context. This approach fosters practical understanding and usage but might lack the depth of
explicit grammar practice found in traditional exercises.

Vocabulary
English Language by Alla Nesvit:
Vocabulary in the Nesvit textbook is extensive, with lists provided for each unit. The focus is on
memorization through repetition and written exercises. While the vocabulary is relevant, the lack of
contextual usage limits students' ability to apply new words in real-life situations.
Solutions Third Edition by Oxford University Press:
Vocabulary in "Solutions" is introduced through thematic units and is reinforced through a variety of
exercises, including listening and reading tasks. The book includes interactive activities like games and
quizzes to make learning more engaging. This approach helps students remember and use vocabulary
more effectively.
Roadmap by Lindsay Warwick and Damian Williams:
"Roadmap" presents vocabulary in the context of real-life scenarios, promoting learning through usage
rather than memorization. Each unit includes practical tasks that require students to use new vocabulary
in speaking and writing exercises. This contextual approach helps students retain and apply vocabulary
in meaningful ways.

Reading Comprehension
English Language by Alla Nesvit:
The Nesvit book includes a variety of reading texts, such as short stories, informational articles, and
dialogues. While the texts are suitable for the 8th-grade level, the comprehension questions often focus
on factual recall rather than critical thinking or personal response.
Solutions Third Edition by Oxford University Press:
"Solutions" offers diverse reading materials, including fiction, non-fiction, and media texts.
Comprehension exercises in this book go beyond basic understanding, encouraging students to infer
meaning, analyze content, and express opinions. These activities help develop higher-order thinking
skills.
Roadmap by Lindsay Warwick and Damian Williams:
"Roadmap" features reading passages that are closely tied to real-life contexts and themes. The
comprehension questions are designed to engage students in critical thinking and discussion, often
linking the content to broader cultural and social issues. This helps students develop both language skills
and cultural awareness.

Listening
English Language by Alla Nesvit:
Listening exercises in the Nesvit textbook are limited and often lack accompanying audio resources,
making it difficult for students to practice this skill effectively. The activities that are included tend to be
straightforward, focusing on listening for specific information.
Solutions Third Edition by Oxford University Press:
"Solutions" includes a wide range of listening activities, supported by high-quality audio resources.
These activities vary in difficulty and include tasks such as note-taking, summarizing, and inferencing,
which help students develop comprehensive listening skills.
Roadmap by Lindsay Warwick and Damian Williams:
"Roadmap" integrates listening tasks into real-life scenarios, using authentic audio materials like
interviews, conversations, and news reports. These exercises are designed to improve students' ability to
understand spoken English in different contexts, promoting both linguistic and cultural competence.

Writing
English Language by Alla Nesvit:
The writing tasks in the Nesvit textbook are structured and focus on formal writing styles, such as
essays, reports, and letters. While these tasks help students practice structured writing, there is less
emphasis on creative and informal writing genres.
Solutions Third Edition by Oxford University Press:
"Solutions" provides a variety of writing tasks, including both formal and informal styles. Students are
encouraged to write essays, emails, stories, and reports. The book offers clear frameworks and
examples, helping students develop writing skills in different contexts.
Roadmap by Lindsay Warwick and Damian Williams:
"Roadmap" emphasizes practical writing skills, with tasks linked to real-life scenarios. Students might
write blogs, social media posts, or reports, reflecting the types of writing they are likely to encounter
outside the classroom. This approach helps students see the relevance of their writing practice.

In conclusion, each of these textbooks offers unique advantages and has specific drawbacks. "English
Language" by Alla Nesvit provides comprehensive coverage but lacks engagement and practical
application. "Solutions Third Edition" offers a balanced approach with a focus on communication but
may need more grammar practice. "Roadmap" emphasizes real-life skills and cultural understanding but
might require additional grammar resources. Teachers should consider these factors when selecting the
most appropriate textbook for their students.