Management of The Acute Serious Strokes in Sub-Saharan Africa: Case of Togo
Management of The Acute Serious Strokes in Sub-Saharan Africa: Case of Togo
Management of The Acute Serious Strokes in Sub-Saharan Africa: Case of Togo
Citation: Josué Euberma Diatewa, Kossivi Apetse, Marleine Djobosse, et al. Management of The Acute Serious Strokes in Sub-
Saharan Africa: Case of Togo. Neurol Res Surg. 2019; 2(1): 1-7.
ABSTRACT
Introduction: Serious strokes are a particular evolutive form of strokes. They present significant diagnostic and
therapeutic challenges.
Methods: A prospective cohort study was carried out from January 1st 2015 to December 31th 2016 (2 years)
at neurology department of University Hospital Campus. It included patients with acute serious strokes. Clinical
features, brain imaging findings, therapeutic measures and outcome were evaluated.
Results: Of the 1964 strokes diagnosed, there were 163 cases of acute serious strokes (8.3%). Among of the latter,
it was noted 100 (61.3%) hemorrhages and 63 (38.7%) arterial infarcts. Supra tentorial damage location was
predominant (77.3%). Main etiologies of hemorrhages and arterial infarcts were, respectively, hypertension
(83.5%) and atherosclerosis of large arteries (84.1%). Rates of patients hospitalized within 4:30 hours (arterial
infarcts) and 8:00 hours (hemorrhages) were, respectively, 20.6% and 40%. In the same time ranges, rates of
CT scan performing were 4.8 and 6% in patients with arterial infarcts and hemorrhages, respectively. Minimum
resuscitation measures and active therapies were implemented in patients. Mortalities in 7 and 15 days were,
respectively, 32.5% and 12.3 %. Overall mortality (44.8%) was correlated with diagnosis and treatment delay, and
active therapy limitations, in addition to the predictive factors of mortality.
Conclusion: Real problems of acute serious strokes management remain in Togo. They have a negative effect on
the vital and functional prognosis. Because of that, it is important to strengthen therapeutic management resources
and preventive measures.
Keywords intensive care unit. Their management requires the use of targeted
Serious strokes, Diagnosis, Treatment, Sub-Saharan Africa, Togo. active therapies, such as thrombolysis/thrombectomy and
endovascular treatment, in addition to resuscitation measures [3,4].
Introduction
Severity of strokes is variable. Serious stroke is defined as a stroke Only a small ratio of patients with serious strokes is hospitalized
that is life-threatening and/or will cause disabling sequelae [1,2]. at intensive care unit and neurovascular intensive care unit [3].
Management of targeted active therapies is limited and carried out
Serious strokes have some peculiarities that can justify the at neurology departments. This management is often encouraged
admission of patients at the intensive care unit and neurovascular by parents who take into account unfavourable vital and functional
Neurol Res Surg, 2019 Volume 2 | Issue 1 | 1 of 7
prognosis. Palliative approach observed in nearly 53% of cases is Stroke Score; arterial pressure and temperature at hospital
decided within 24 hours [5]. admission; information from brain imaging. In the case of the
variable "information from brain imaging", it was noted:
In sub-Saharan Africa, palliative approach is almost systematic and - in the case of hemorrhages: the anatomical localization
global, because neuro-diagnostic (CT scan, MRI and angiography) (meningeal or parenchymal); the extension in height (cortico-
and therapeutic (neurovascular intensive care unit, thrombolysis subcortical or to the brainstem if sus tentorial location; bulbar,
and/or thrombectomy) resources are limited [6,7]. Because of protuberant or peduncular if localization at the brainstem); the
that, challenges related to acute serious stroke management are possible presence of complications (ventricular contamination or
numerous. flood, axial involvement, hydrocephalus). Extent of parenchymal
lesions was determined using volume and maximum transverse
In sub-Saharan Africa, serious stroke data reported in literature diameter;
result from search released at intensive care units [6,8]. Those - in the case of arterial infarcts, the topography according to the
which come from neurology departments without neurovascular affected arterial territory. Carotid artery infarct was defined as
intensive care unit are missing. a homolateral occlusion simultaneously present in the middle
cerebral artery and anterior cerebral artery.
In this paper, we focus on acute serious stroke management at
neurology department of University Hospital Campus of Lomé. Inclusion criteria were: age over 18 years old; diagnosis delay
Our department has not a neurovascular intensive care unit. The lower 8 days; patient’s parents who agreed to take part in the study
purpose of this study is to describe diagnostic and therapeutic after informed consent.
aspects.
Not included in the study: patients whose serious stroke diagnosis
Methods was not confirmed by brain imaging; patients whose biological
This prospective cohort study focused on patients with acute serious examination (blood count; erythrocyte sedimentation rate;
stroke. It was conducted, from January 1st 2015 to December 31st plasma activity levels of aspartate aminotransferase and alanine
2016, at neurology department of University Hospital Campus of aminotransferase; plasma concentrations of glucose, urea and
Lomé. creatinine, serum creatinine; serological evaluation of human
immunodeficiency virus) and first-line check-up were incomplete;
Serious stroke was defined as a stroke in which: subdural hematomas; cerebral venous thromboses; post-traumatic
• National Institute of Health Stroke Score and Glasgow Score hemorrhages.
were, respectively, higher 17 and lower 9;
• neuroimaging revealed: Etiological research was performed using MRI and/or cerebral
- for the case of hemorrhages, the meningeal hemorrhage classified angioscan, cardiac echo-Doppler and supra aortic trunks,
as stages 3 and 4 according to the Fisher classification, posterior coagulation assessment, standard electrocardiogram (ECG) and
fossa hemorrhage, cerebral hemorrhage with ventricular flood and ECG Holter of 24 hours for patients whose strong suspicion of
mass effect/axial involvement; cardio embolic origin was retained despite the normal standard
- for the case of arterial infarcts, the damage of posterior fossa ECG. Arterial infarct etiologies were grouped according to the
structures and/or extensive cerebral damage related to the occlusion Toast classification [11].
of large arterial trunks with cardio embolic or atheromatous origin
[1,2,9-11]. For the therapies offered for patients, there were the targeted active
therapies, minimum measures of resuscitation (conventional
In addition, serious strokes were grouped into two classes: oxygenation, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, anti-edematous,
- very serious strokes in which ranges of National Institute of sedatives, hemodynamic balance), decision-making process
Health Stroke Score and Glasgow Score were, respectively, 17–20 (transfer to intensive care unit and palliative approach).
and 7–9;
- extremely serious strokes in which National Institute of Health In the case of arterial infarcts, active therapies were used according
Stroke Score and Glasgow Score were, respectively, higher 20 and to the protocols established in our department. On account of
lower 7. thrombolysis that is not available in Togo, following therapies were
offered for patients: intravenous aspirin at 1 g/day for 5 days, then
Diagnoses of serious strokes were based on neuroimaging and platelet antiaggregant relay at 250 mg/day if emboligenic heart
clinical features [1,2]. CT scan was released in all patients in the disease excluded, hospital admission before 5:00 hours, motor
first position. MRI without axial diffusion sequence owing to low deficit and moderate lesion extent, absence of prior arterial infarct,
magnetic field (0.5 tesla) was performed in delayed time. National Institute of Health Stroke Score range of 17–20 and age
under 80 years old; heparin with curative dose if emboligenic heart
Clinical variables were: clinical history; modifiable cardiovascular disease and HAS-BLED Score lower 3 for the case of extended
risk factors; inaugural symptomatology; depth of loss arterial infarct; decompressive hemi-craniotomy in the case of
consciousness; Glasgow Score and National Institute of Health extended middle cerebral artery infarct and carotid artery infarct
Neurol Res Surg, 2019 Volume 2 | Issue 1 | 2 of 7
for patients under 60 years old, hospitalized within 48 hours and Median hospital admission time determined from symptom onset
having no associated comorbidity. was 82 hours at least, with limits of: 1 and 720 hours. Of the 63
patients with arterial infarct, 13 (20.6%) were hospitalized within
In the case of hemorrhages, external ventricular drainage or 4:30 hours. Among the 100 patients with hemorrhages, 40 (40%)
sub-occipital craniotomy was indicated as an active therapy for (40/100) were hospitalized within 8:0 hours.
infra tentorial hematomas and stereotaxis for deep compressive
hematomas with or without hydrocephalus and if patients Hospitalization was mainly caused by motor deficit (76.1%),
hospitalized within 8:0 hours [4]. impairment of consciousness (62.6%) and headache (20.9%).
Outcome was evaluated by means of mortality in 7 days and Disease onset was abrupt and in successive shocks sequential during
mortality in 15 days. SPSS software version 21 was used for 24 to 48 hours in 156 (96%) and 7 (4%) patients, respectively.
statistical analysis. Qualitative and quantitative variables were There was no particular schedule for symptom onset in all patients.
assessed, respectively, by the frequencies and averages associated
with standard deviation. To demonstrate a significant difference At hospital admission, patients had a mean temperature of 37 ±
between two quantitative variables, Fisher’s test was used. 3°C, average arterial pressure of 170.6/170.6 ± 36/20.6 mm Hg,
Comparison of two groups was released by Pearson correlation average Glasgow Score of 10.03 ± 7.5 and average National
test. P value of < 0.05 was considered as statistically significant. Institute of Health Stroke Score of 22.8 ± 8.9.
Patients with arterial infarct (n = 30) and hemorrhage (n = 60), Diagnostic aspects
who presented edema, were treated with hypertonic solutes. CT scan used as a first-line examination for the positive diagnosis
of serious strokes in our study is very efficient. MRI is difficult
Heparin and platelet aggregation inhibitor were administered in to access in emergency state because of the limited financial
patients whose the origin of arterial infarct was not cardio-embolic resources of patients or their parents. Thus, it was performed in
(n = 53). Anticoagulation with heparin at curative dose followed delayed time in patients with CT scan not efficient. It also used
by vitamin K antagonists was used to treat the patients whose to search vascular malformation or bleeding tumor and follow-
the origin of arterial infarct was cardio-embolic (n = 5). Patients up patients with vertebrobasilar artery infarct or extended middle
with occlusion of large vertebrobasilar arterial trunks (n = 5) were cerebral artery infarct [7,17].
treated with aspirin.
In our study, rate of serious hemorrhages related to aneurysms
Surgical therapies (decompressive hemi-craniotomy, external and unspecified origin could result from the inadequate technical
ventricular derivation, sub-occipital craniotomy and stereotaxis) resources. Insufficiency of the latter does not allow carrying out a
did not implement in patients. complete and appropriate etiological search.
Mortality during the first 7 days was 32.5% (n = 53). Of the 53 Origin of serious arterial infarcts is most often cardioembolic [18].
deaths, there are 37 hemorrhages and 16 arterial infarcts. In 15 In our study, origin is poorly represented. This result could be
days, we noted a stabilization of the clinical state in 90 (81.8%) explained by:
patients and an aggravation with death in 20 (18.2%) patients. - the difficulty in confirming origin owing the coexistence of
Thus, overall mortality was 44.8%. atherosclerosis [11];
- the performing of 24-hour ECG only in patients strongly suspected
Overall Mortality was correlated with hematoma volume (p = of having a cardio-embolic arterial infarct, despite the variable
0.001), presence of encephalic complications (p = 0.003), high embolic risk of some patients. For this purpose, a long-term ECG
arterial pressure (p = 0.004), deep decrease of consciousness (average time: 3 days) and transesophageal echocardiography
level at hospital admission (p = 0.0001), treatment (minimum must be carried out in all patients with serious arterial infarcts. The
resuscitation measures) delay (p = 0.0003) and limitations of optimization of diagnosis of paroxystic atrial fibrillation, as well
therapeutic measures (p = 0). as the visualization of various cardiac abnormalities in absence of
cardiac history (thrombus of left atrium, foramen oval and/or atrial
Discussion septal aneurysm, aortic plaques) in a patient with sinus rhythm,
Epidemiology would be guaranteed [7].
Prevalence of serious strokes in the present study is lower than
those reported in literature (27%) [5]. This low prevalence could be Therapeutic aspects
explained by the exclusion of 53 patients who had not confirmation Elevated median times of hospital admission and radiological
brain imaging, choice of study department, early deaths before examination implicate a treatment delay, as well as a great
admission of patients at neurology department. However, our variability in the therapeutic management. This delay could be
prevalences of hemorrhages and arterial infarcts are situated in explained by the absence of mobile emergency units [17], serious
the ranges reported in literature: 46.6-78.7% for hemorrhages and state of patients which requires a stabilization, distance between
21.3-44.6% for arterial infarcts [8,12]. the department of medical imaging and that of neurology in
University Hospital Campus of Lomé, limited financial resources
Literature data reveal that annual incidence of hemorrhages is of patients.
higher than that of arterial infarcts [13]. This epidemiological
finding is also noted in our study. Use of minimum resuscitation measures in patients with serious
strokes is open to discussion. Artificial ventilation with intubation
The average age of our patients is lower than those reported in is more effective than conventional oxygenation [3]. Because of
Neurol Res Surg, 2019 Volume 2 | Issue 1 | 5 of 7
that, conventional oxygenation would be only performed in 5-8 therapeutic resources and limited financial resources of patients
% of cases [19]. In our study, conventional oxygenation is greatly or their parents. These problems have a negative effect on the
used (Table 2) because of the lack of neurovascular intensive care vital and functional prognosis. Because of that, it is important to
unit and/or decision of parents to limit active therapies that is strengthen therapeutic and preventive measures.
caused by the low yield of intensive resuscitation [3,6].
References
Neurosedation reduces the sympathetic response and extent 1. Meyer BC, Hemmen TM, Jackson CM, et al. Modified
of ischemic damage. It can also damage the self-regulation of National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale for use in stroke
cerebral blood flow and make brain more vulnerable [20]. In our clinacl trials: prospective reliability and validity. Stroke.
study, its effectiveness is higher than those reported in literature 2002; 33: 1261-126.
(16.2–24 %) [8,12]. This practice would be justified by the volume 2. Weshler LR. Imaging evaluation of acute ischemic stroke.
of cerebral lesions and alcohol withdrawal syndrome [12]. Stroke. 2011; 42: 12-15.
3. Luzi A, Albucher J-F, Geeraets T. Infarctus cérébraux sus-
Anti-thrombotic treatment and anticoagulation implemented in tentoriels graves: prise en charge en réanimation. In: Albanese
our patients are in accordance with recommendations reported in J, Bruder N, eds. Accident vasculaire cérébral et réanimation.
literature [21-24]. Intravenous aspirin administration in patients Paris, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. Springer. 2013; 57-82.
with arterial infarct is an alternative therapy to thrombolysis. The 4. Cébula H, Turc G, Proust F. Traitement chirurgical des
latter is not available in most countries in sub-Saharan Africa [7]. hémorragies cérébrales. In: Mas JL, Leys D, eds. Accidents
vasculaires cérébraux: thérapeutique. Paris: John Libbey
Active therapy limitations are essentially passive in sub-Saharan Eurotext, doin. 2018; 153-163.
Africa, as compared with data reported in literature [12]. They 5. Crozier Sophie. Enjeux éthiques des limitations et arrêts
could be justified by the neurological severity and limited financial de traitements à la phase aiguë des accidents vasculaires
resources of patients or their parents, associated with inadequate cérébraux graves. Presse Med. 2012; 41: 525-531.
technical resources. Rate of no resuscitation guidelines, noted 6. Sene Diouf F, Mapoure NY, Ndiaye M, et al. Survie des
in our study, is lower than those reported in literature (10–30%) accidents vasculaires cérébraux comateux à Dakar (Sénégal).
[12,25]. This difference could be explained by the absence of a Rev Neurol. 2008; 68: 606-610.
law relating to patients' rights and life end, as well as education of 7. Diatewa JE, Kombate D, Dongmo JJ, et al. A Prognostic
the populations. Challenge of Brainstem Stroke for the Countries of Sub-
Saharan Africa: Case of Togo. Clinical Neurology and
Our mortality is higher than that reported in literature (33%) Neuroscience. 2018; 2: 61-67.
[6,8,12,26]. This mortality is related to the size of lesion, severity 8. Mahoungou-Guimbi KC, Ellenga Mbolla BF, Damba
of coma, presence of encephalic complications, factors related to Banzouzi BY, et al. Les accidents vasculaires cérébraux
stroke management (diagnosis and treatment delay, active therapy hémorragiques en réanimation. Rev Afr Anesth Méd Urg.
limitations and lack of inadequate technical resources) [7,12,27]. 2012; 17: 51-55.
9. Frankel MR, Morgenstern LB, Kwiatkowski T, et al.
Strengths and weakness of study Predicting prognosis after stroke: a placebo group analysis
This exhaustive collection of patients during two years allows us from the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and
evaluating primary and secondary management measures already Stroke rt-PA Stroke Trial. Neurology. 2000; 55: 952-959.
implemented. The other strengths of this study are the use of 10. Dufour M, Bouafe A, Bruder N, et al. Diagnosis in general
first-line CT scan for the positive diagnosis of serious strokes hospital and immediate care of patients suffering from severe
with high efficiency, description of decision-making process for subarachnoid haemorrhage. Ann Fr. Anesth Reanim. 2005;
acute serious stroke management, intravenous administration of 25: 715-720.
aspirin in patients with arterial infarct, in whom thrombolysis was 11. Lahlou I, Sekkali N, El Marjani H, et al. Le bilan cardiologique
indicated. d’un accident vasculaire cérébral ischémique. Le journal
marocain de cardiologie. 2011; 3: 11-18.
The weakness of our study which do not allow us carrying acute 12. Crozier S, Santoli F, Outin H, et al. AVC graves: pronostic,
serious strokes management through are the limited financial critères d’admission en réanimation et décisions de limitations
resources of patients or their parents, delaying the performing of et arrêt de traitements. Rev Neurol. 2011; 167: 468-473.
radiological explorations and treatment, and insufficient therapeutic 13. Valery LF, Krishnamurthi RV. Global urden of stroke. In: Grotta
resources (neurovascular unit, rtPA for thrombolysis, intubation JC, Albers GW, Broderick JP, Kasner SE, Lo EH, Mendelow
equipment, electric syringes, external ventricular drainage, sub- AD, Sacco RL, Wong LKS, eds. Stroke: Pathophysiology,
occipital craniotomy, stereotaxis). diagnosis and management. 2016; 207-216.
14. Huttner, HB, Schwab S. Malignant middle cerebral artery
Conclusion infarction: clinical characteristics, treatment strategies, and
These results suggest that serious strokes management is mainly future perspectives. Lancet Neurol. 2009; 8: 949-958.
confronted with diagnosis and treatment delay, insufficient 15. Howard G, Cushman M, Kissela BM, et al. Traditional risk
Neurol Res Surg, 2019 Volume 2 | Issue 1 | 6 of 7
factors as the underlying cause of racial disparities in stroke: 1854-1856.
lessons from the half full (empty?) glass. Stroke. 2011; 42: 22. Haute Autorité de Santé. Recommandations de bonne pratique.
3369-3375. Accident vasculaire cérébral: Prise en charge précoce (Alerte,
16. Sudha S, Wolf PA. Modifiable risk factors and determinants phase pré hospitalière, phase hospitalière initiale, indications
of stroke. In: Grotta JC, Albers GW, Broderick JP, Kasner SE, de la thrombolyse). Saint-Denis La Plaine: Haute Autorité de
Lo EH, Mendelow AD, Sacco RL, Wong LKS, eds. Stroke: Santé. 2009; 10-15.
Pathophysiology, diagnosis and management. 6th ed. New 23. Schonewille WJ, Wijman CA, Michel P, et al. Treatment and
York: Elsevier 2016; 217-233. outcomes of acute basilar artery occlusion in the Basilar Artery
17. Ahanogbe KMH, Belo M, Beketi AK, et al. Problematics of International Cooperation Study (BASICS): A prospective
subarachnoid hemorrhage in developing countries: The case registry study. Lancet Neurol. 2009; 8: 724-730.
of Togo. Neurochirurgie. 2016; 62: 312-316. 24. Bosel J, Schonenberger S, Dohmen C, et al. Intensive therapie
18. Bruder N, Velly L. Accidents ischémiques sous-tentoriels des raumfordernden ischamischen Hemispharenin-farkts.
graves. In: Albanese J, Bruder N, eds. Accident vasculaire Nervenarzt. 2015; 86: 1018-1030.
cérébral et réanimation. Paris, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. 25. Alexandrov AV, Bladin CF, Meslin EM, et al. Do-not-
Springer. 2013; 83-94. resuscitate orders in acute stroke. Neurology. 1995; 45: 634-
19. Leker R, Ben-Hur T. Prognostic factors in artificially ventilated 640.
stroke patients. J Neurol Sci. 2000; 176: 83-87. 26. Bardet J. La prise en charge précoce des accidents vasculaires
20. Mirski MA, Muffelman B, Ulatowsky JA, et al. Sedation for cérébraux. Rapport de l’Office parlementaire d’évaluation des
the critically ill neurologic patient. Crit Care Med.1995; 23: politiques de santé. 2007; 475.
2038-2053. 27. Holloway RG, Benesch CG, Burgin WS, et al. Prognosis and
21. Montavont A, Nighoghossian N, Derex L, et al. Intravenous decision making in severe stroke. JAMA. 2005; 294: 725-733.
rt-PA in vertebrobasilar acute infarcts. Neurology. 2004; 62:
© 2019 Josué Euberma Diatewa, et al. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License