Desalination Project
Desalination Project
Thesis by
Adeel Nawaz
2015-ME-303
Kashif Mehmood
2015-ME-341
Daniyal Kareem
2015-ME-352
October 2018
1
Abstract
The water plays an important role in any field of life. The decrease in the energy and
the drinking water in the modern era is because of advanced life style, overpopulation,
progress in the industries, the decrease in the harmful diseases, the advancement in the
agricultural sector. Distillation and the desalination of the brackish water to make it
drinkable has become an important and very impressive process to lessen the water
based problems in the present age due to its very less cost and the very low
maintenance. The traditional ways of the water desalination are based on the carbon
based fuels that produce carbon dioxide and other pollutants, the use of the solar energy
low cost, less maintenance, available energy due to sun and zero carbon based
pollutants. The increased use of solar energy in water desalination processes has
become very used to in the whole world especially in the oil rich countries. This study
is basically about the water distillation technique using renewable solar energy,
accomplished with parabolic trough collector (PTC), coupled with solar tracking
mechanism to increase the efficiency. The project is actually based on the purification
of the dirty and salty water to make it drinkable. Our intentions in this project are to
propose an idea to the people to make water drinkable and to get rid of water based
problems in Pakistan.
2
Contents
Chapter 1 ..........................................................................................................................6
1. Introduction ..............................................................................................................6
Chapter 2 ........................................................................................................................12
References ......................................................................................................................28
3
List of Figures
Figure 4: The relation between the inlet hot water and the fresh water production (water
Figure 9: Schematic diagram of solar still with flat plate collector [31]. .......................19
Figure 11: Effect of the production rate by volume water fraction [35]. .......................21
List of Tables
Table 1: Estimation of the conventional energy used for different water desalination
4
Table 3: Potential renewable energy (TWh/year) in different countries of the world [12]
........................................................................................................................................10
Table 4: Dimensions of the fiberglass parabolic reinforced parabolic trough [6] ..........24
5
Chapter 1
1. Introduction
With the decreasing water resources in the world day by day, the problems of the
drinking water and water for the irrigation purposes has become an alarming issue in
this modern era. To overcome the need of the drinking water and to purify the brackish
water, the water desalination techniques have gained a lot of importance. Today, we
have 71% water on earth, from which we have only 2.5% water that is drinkable[1].
Large desalination techniques those are being used now-a-days, are very energy
demanding and need a huge infrastructure. Therefore, these are so much difficult and
expensive. Therefore, the use solar powered heater or distillation plants are becoming
attractive day by day. Because they need a very easy structure and very less cost is
needed. Also, the lesser maintenance is required as compared to the other techniques.
Among the solar water desalination technologies, the water solar water stills cannot
compete with other techniques those are producing very large amount of the water. But
they are preferable for providing the drinking water for small communities. Therefore,
they are still popular in the communities [2]. The solar energy is pollution free and also
they are not producing carbon dioxide. The process of the water desalination can be
improved by using the solar tracking system. If we make the sun to shine on the solar
collector, the solar collector can be made more cost effective. This is done by moving
the solar collector to follow the sun all the day to increase the efficiency [3]
In the past, the people use the solar reflector that are fixed and are oriented at an angle
of 30 degree towards the south [3]. The researcher has analyzed that this is not the best
orientation for getting maximum output from the sun. To get maximum energy from
the sun, a more suitable way is to orient the solar collector in the direction of the sun all
6
the day using the single axis or double axis mechanisms. Hession in 1984 fabricated a
mechanism for the solar tracking in which the sun was tracked by using a photo
transistor connected to the 2.34 m² cylindrical parabolic collector. The whole assembly
was mounted on a very simple structure. Clifford in 2004 claimed that by using a solar
tracker mechanism, he increased the efficiency to about 23% as compared to the simple
fixed collector. Chin in 2011 made a simpler mechanism that was placed on a wall.
To increase the efficiency more, some scientists have proposed an idea of double axis
systems that are more efficient as compared to the single axis mechanisms. Al-Soud in
inside the cooker. Abu-Malouh in 2011 prepared a dish type solar collector and he
It is noted that the conventional energy for water desalination is more as compared to
the solar energy which is free renewable and needs less cost and maintenance. The
effect of using conventional energy used in water desalination over the global warning
can be calculated by estimating the amount of fossil fuel required to produce certain
amount of drinkable water. Studies have shown that to produce 1000 cubic meters of
the water, the 5 tons of the crude oil are consumed which produces 10 tons of carbon
dioxide or in other words, it produces 5000 cubic meters of the green house gases. The
global survey has shown that from 2011 to 2015, the global warming gases have been
increased from 66.84 million cubic meters to 86.4 million cubic meters. Therefore the
world has taken steps to demolish the negative effects of the water desalination
techniques and use the solar renewable energy instead of the conventional heat energy
7
Table 1: Estimation of the conventional energy used for different water desalination
processes [5].
Typical unit size (cubic meter per day) 5000-7000 10000-35000 24000 100-2500
Electrical Energy Consumption (kWh m-3) 4-6 1.5 – 2.5 3–7 7-12
Thermal Energy Consumption (kJ kg-1) 190–390 145 – 390 None None
Electrical Equivalent for Thermal Energy (kWh m-3) 9.5-19.5 9.5 – 25.5 None None
1.1 Motivation
From the last few years, the researchers are focusing over the alternative way to the
carbon based crude oil fuels in order to get a clean renewable energy source to
demolish the pollution problems in the world. One reason is that the carbon based oils
are running out day by day and the second reason is that they are producing global
save the world from pollution and also to overcome the need of the energy whose
resources are getting lesser continuously [4]. Table 1 above also has shown the amount
of conventional non- renewable energy used in the water desalination plant. We are
running out of all the conventional resources day by day. So, there we need an
8
PSA Spain MED 72 Concentrating solar power
The world is getting more attracted towards renewable energy desalination (RED)
plant. Estimation has shown that about 130 RED plants have been installed in the last
few years[6]. Table 2 shows different RED plants, installed at different places[7] . The
renewable energy sources include tides, geothermal energy, wind energy and solar
energy. The biomass and hydropower are not suitable for the water desalination plants
because they require very large amount of the water and the water cannot be found in
the countries where the water problems are present. So, the solar energy source can be
the best source for the desalination. We can get about 500-1000 degree Celsius using
the solar techniques[8]. 70% of the water purification is done by using the solar energy.
The different techniques are suitable for different areas like solar energy collector are
useful in the places like deserts where sun shines for large time and the wind energy is
useful in coastal areas where wing blows with very high speed. The wing energy
sources are useful for those water desalination techniques which require electricity
instead of the heat[9]. The geothermal energy source requires a drill of about 5000
meters. So, it becomes costly and very restricted to some certain areas[10]. The tidal
energy is useful only in coastal areas. The world’s first wind energy desalination plant
was installed in the Perth, Australia[11]. We can use the water desalination plant in two
ways, one by- using direct energy or by using produced energy from the source[12].
Table 3 shows the annual renewable energy potential for selected countries. It displays
that a lot of countries are advancing towards the renewable energy production due to
the continuously depleting energy resources, especially solar energy. In this project,
9
same study of solar water desalination by using solar tracked solar collector to make
country some steps ahead in the race of energy, so that, the need of energy in the
[12].
In this project, we are going to study the water desalination technique using the
parabolic trough (PTC) collector that is coupled with solar tracking sensor.The
evacuated tube collector is basically used to take energy from the solar collector(PTC)
and convert it into heat energy to heat the water. The basic purpose of our study is that
we are going to make dump and salty water healthy and drinkable by using renewable
energy. The country is facing huge lack of water, so we have studied this field to
overcome the need of drinkable water from dirty dump and salty water to play our role
in this national progress. Figure1 shows the schematic diagram of our project.
10
11
Chapter 2
2. Literature Review
The earth surface consists of 71% water. Saline water is about 97.5% of total quantity
water and only 2.5% represents fresh water, most of it as ice caps, glaciers and ground
water [1]. The desalination process is the process of converting salty and brackish
water to drinkable water. The chemical ion contribution in sea water salinity is by:
Fluoride and other minute quantities. The classification of saline water depends on the
Total Dissolved Salts (TDS). The TDS in sea is about 45,000 ppm[13]. The TDS of
The most popular techniques for water purification are Solar distillation
techniques and chemical treatments[15]. Solar energy run about 70% of renewable
desalination plants [1]. Solar desalination system can be divided into two types, one is
indirect and other is direct. In direct solar desalination, solar energy is directly used to
heat up the water. Solar still coupled with flat plate collector and integrated with glass
evacuated tube collector are the most representative technologies. In indirect solar
desalination, solar energy is used to produce heat first then this heat is used to further
12
Figure 2: The network of the water desalination processes[16]
condensing humid air. The moisture carrying capacity of hot air determine the
separation of saline and fresh water in HDH. The major parts of HDH process are
humidifier, dehumidifier and external heater [17]. Sharon et al.[18] classified the HDH
13
Figure 3: schematic diagram of solar HDH desalination system[19]
Experimental results were reported by Zamen et al.[20], production of the fresh water
increases at low cooling water temperature, high hot water temperature and low hot
water flow rate. The figure 4 shows the relationship between the inlet hot water and the
Figure 4: The relation between the inlet hot water and the fresh water production
14
2.1.1.1 Solar-powered MSF
In MSF desalination system consists of increasing the brackish water temperature more
than the saturation temperature by the help of brine water heater and then this water is
flashed in multiple stages. Vacuum pump is used to maintain low pressure in each stage
of vessel. The vapour in each stage are condensed in the condenser and at the same
The selection of solar collector and design of solar heating coil are considered as the
important for the complete application of the MSF technique. The efficiency of MSF
can be increased by taking high top brine temperature, increased number of stages and
15
In MED seawater is circulated in multiple cells at low pressure. In first effect energy is
provided. During the vaporization, the heat is supplied by the hot vapour, produced in
the previous stages, those in return condense in the condenser. MED is carried out at
lower top brine temperature (55–120 °C) and is more efficient thermodynamically [23].
The efficiency of MED plant depends on the top steam temperature, number of stages,
heating stream flow rate, temperature difference in final condenser. To achieve high
16
2.1.1.2 Membrane distillation
MD is separation process run by the thermal energy and it uses hydrophobic porous
membrane which has two sides, one side contains the sea water and the other side
contains hot vapours. In MD feed water is heated and is allowed to pass through
membrane. The hydrophobic membrane prevents the brackish water from flowing
through membrane pores and only allow vapour transfer to other side. The driving
The parameters on which the distillate yield in MD depends are thickness of air gap,
flow rate, membrane thickness, porosity, long term operation and thermal conductivity
of membranes [25].MD process are of four kinds: Direct contact membrane distillation,
air gap membrane distillation, vacuum membrane distillation and sweeping gas
17
2.1.2 Direct solar desalination
Solar still is direct solar desalination technology, also called direct still system. Solar
still works on the principal of greenhouse effect by using solar energy directly. Solar
still output depends on the parameters such as vapour leakage, thermal insulation, over
slope, shape material [29]. This system has low efficiency of about 3–4l/m2 per day
Solar still basin is blackened filled with saline water and closed by inclined glass. The
solar energy heated the blackened saline. Due to the difference of temperature and
pressure water vapour gets condensed along the class. Solar still can be classified in
two categories: passive and active solar stills. Passive solar still completely dependent
on direct solar energy while in active solar still devices are used such as vacuum fan,
18
The fresh water production of solar still can be enhanced by solar thermal collectors.
The flat plate collector consists of black flat heat absorber, a transparent cover, heat
transferring fluid and an insulating case. Solar still with flat plate collector increases
temperature of water to about 70°C. The tilted angle for flat plate collector is 35°. The
coupling of flat plate collector with still increases fresh water production up to
36%[31]. Figure 9 shows the solar still coupling with flat plate collector.
Figure 9: Schematic diagram of solar still with flat plate collector [31].
Evacuated tube collector (ETC) consists of vacuum-sealed tubes with the absorber
surface in the inner glass tube. ETC are designed in a way so that to entrap the solar
energy by not giving out, the inner surface is black in colour to entrap more energy.
ETC is classified in two categories: ‘Direct flow through’ and ‘Heat pipe’. A set of
glass tube is directly connected to shall or tank in direct flow through in ETC, a large
diameter glass tube surrounded each tube. Heat losses are reduced by evacuating the
19
Heat tube consists of tube of high thermal conductance contain small amount of
working fluid. The evaporation occur in heating section and condensation of vapour in
with evacuated tube and have efficiency of 33.8%. The outlet water temperature and
thermal efficiency of ETC increased to about 16.7% by using sun tracking mechanism
inclined at 35° and filled 80% with water. Fresh water Productivity increased up to 1.01
kg/(m2·h) by filling the tube with stainless steel wool [35]. Representation of ETC is in
figure 10.
Volume fraction of water in the tube played a typical role in the portable water
production. With 80% water volume fraction the production rate was 0.83% kg/(m2·h)
20
Figure 11: Effect of the production rate by volume water fraction [35].
steam generation and heating of water for different purposes. PTC have certain
advantages it will give a high temperature without any damage in the collector
efficiency.[36]
There are number of collector used we discuss three here. Parabolic trough
can use the PTC for solar tracking purpose but CPC and FPC cannot use for the
PTC have many advantage in usage over the FPC, here some advantage is discussed
21
1. Water get more heat in PTC rather than the FPC of same solar area because the
concentration power of PTC is Greater than the FPC. So, the efficiency of PTC
2. In PTC the sun light converges at ETC which reduced the heat loss area and
efficiency increased.
3. There is small material required to make the PTC, and the structure of the PTC
is enough simple than the FPC which reduce the cost of PTC.
Disadvantage of the PTC is that the concentration point is hard to locate and is
The main advantage of PTC is that its thermal efficiency is higher than the FPC so we
studied the efficiency. The efficiency is the ratio of the energy consumed and the
We can calculate the energy balance at the collector using these equations:
(eq1)
(eq2)
Here is the optical efficiency, from above Eqs it is the major factor which depend
22
To note the performance of the collector we are a graph between the thermal efficiency
and Delta T/I. by slope and intercept we can calculate the performance.
where
The relational are the same for FPC but the value of CR=1.[37]
The efficiency of the PTC will remain high as the temperature of water increased at
There are number of method used for steam generation using PTC but we will discuss
one here.
Here the water is heated and pressurized in the ETC and then separated by vaporization
method using flash vessel. This method is economical due to its simplicity and
stability[38].
23
2.2.2 Manufacture of fiberglass reinforced parabolic trough:
There is a method used for manufactured od PTC called Hand layup method. First, a
mould surface so the casting can be easily removed from the mould. PVA resin, a layer
of polyester and chopped strand fiberglass cloth was laid on the wax and allowed a
sufficient time to set. The layer of these materials should have a reasonable thickness
direction. Then again, the layer of chopped strand fiberglass cloth and polyester resin
is set and get a sufficient rigidity. After a reasonable time, the PTC was pulled from
mould[40] .
24
Figure 14: Schematic side view of PTC [41]
There are two loads which can act on the PTC loads by gravity and load due to the
wind. The load due to gravity act because the center of gravity does not coincide with
the axis of rotation due to which the gravitational force act on the PTC and tends to
rotate the PTC and applied load. The load will be maximum when the PTC will be in
The with load matter more than the gravity load. Wind load can be find by an
experiment in which we will measure the force which a define wind with certain
velocity apply on the PTC. We check the rigidity of the structure for this purpose we
take sand and calibrate it with the force calculated above. Then place the PTC in the
25
horizontal direction and set a deflection, measurement device under the structure[39] .A
enough amount of the sand is added and gradually increase the amount of the sand and
calculate the deflection corresponding to the sand weight. When the sand is equal to the
deflection is noted and see if it is increase the toughness of the material if not increase
We use FV to separate the steam from the heated water at the low pressure as shown in
Fig. 6. It consists of the vertical vessels in which the heated water is entered from the
1/3 height of the vessel. There in a blow down in the bottom. Diameter of the vessel is
adjusted in such a way that the steam flow in the vessel which is out from upper outlet
will not exceed the velocity of 3m/s. To ensure that all the water droplet is eliminated
from the steam and to ensure that a sound amount of the steam is generated a sufficient
height above the inlet is required. Cavitation is avoided by decreasing the size of the
outlet. When the heat up energy requirement is low maximum steam will generate.[37]
26
2. The water in the vessel should not below a certain level. Make water will be
27
References
28
[18] H. Sharon, K. J. R. Reddy, and S. E. Reviews, "A review of solar energy driven
desalination technologies," vol. 41, pp. 1080-1118, 2015.
[19] G. Yuan, Z. Wang, H. Li, and X. J. D. Li, "Experimental study of a solar
desalination system based on humidification–dehumidification process," vol.
277, no. 1-3, pp. 92-98, 2011.
[20] M. Zamen et al., "Experimental investigation of a two-stage solar
humidification–dehumidification desalination process," vol. 332, no. 1, pp. 1-6,
2014.
[21] M. Chandrashekara, A. J. R. Yadav, and S. E. Reviews, "Water desalination
system using solar heat: a review," vol. 67, pp. 1308-1330, 2017.
[22] I. J. Esfahani, J. Rashidi, P. Ifaei, and C. J. K. J. o. C. E. Yoo, "Efficient thermal
desalination technologies with renewable energy systems: A state-of-the-art
review," vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 351-387, 2016.
[23] P. Palenzuela, A. S. Hassan, G. Zaragoza, and D.-C. J. D. Alarcón-Padilla,
"Steady state model for multi-effect distillation case study: Plataforma Solar de
Almería MED pilot plant," vol. 337, pp. 31-42, 2014.
[24] C. Li, Y. Goswami, E. J. R. Stefanakos, and S. E. Reviews, "Solar assisted sea
water desalination: A review," vol. 19, pp. 136-163, 2013.
[25] M. T. Ali, H. E. Fath, P. R. J. R. Armstrong, and S. E. Reviews, "A
comprehensive techno-economical review of indirect solar desalination," vol.
15, no. 8, pp. 4187-4199, 2011.
[26] A. Alkhudhiri, N. Darwish, and N. J. D. Hilal, "Membrane distillation: a
comprehensive review," vol. 287, pp. 2-18, 2012.
[27] A. Cipollina and G. Micale, "Coupling sustainable energy with membrane
distillation processes for seawater desalination," in Nuclear & Renewable
Energy Conference (INREC), 2010 1st International, 2010, pp. 1-6: IEEE.
[28] G. Naidu, S. Jeong, Y. Choi, E. Jang, T.-M. Hwang, and S. J. D. Vigneswaran,
"Application of vacuum membrane distillation for small scale drinking water
production," vol. 354, pp. 53-61, 2014.
[29] R. Tripathi and G. J. D. Tiwari, "Effect of water depth on internal heat and mass
transfer for active solar distillation," vol. 173, no. 2, pp. 187-200, 2005.
[30] S. J. e. Kalogirou, "Survey of solar desalination systems and system selection,"
vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 69-81, 1997.
[31] O. Badran and H. J. D. Al-Tahaineh, "The effect of coupling a flat-plate
collector on the solar still productivity," vol. 183, no. 1-3, pp. 137-142, 2005.
[32] L. Ayompe and A. J. S. E. Duffy, "Thermal performance analysis of a solar
water heating system with heat pipe evacuated tube collector using data from a
field trial," vol. 90, pp. 17-28, 2013.
[33] K. Sampathkumar, T. Arjunan, P. Pitchandi, P. J. R. Senthilkumar, and S. E.
Reviews, "Active solar distillation—a detailed review," vol. 14, no. 6, pp. 1503-
1526, 2010.
[34] S. Kumar, A. Dubey, and G. J. D. Tiwari, "A solar still augmented with an
evacuated tube collector in forced mode," vol. 347, pp. 15-24, 2014.
[35] M. Shafii, S. J. Mamouri, M. Lotfi, and H. J. J. D. Mosleh, "A modified solar
desalination system using evacuated tube collector," vol. 396, pp. 30-38, 2016.
[36] L. M. Murphy and E. K. May, "Steam generation in line-focus solar collectors:
a comparative assessment of thermal performance, operating stability, and cost
issues," Solar Energy Research Inst., Golden, CO (USA)1982.
[37] S. J. A. E. Kalogirou, "Use of parabolic trough solar energy collectors for sea-
water desalination," vol. 60, no. 2, pp. 65-88, 1998.
29
[38] A. V. Arasu and T. J. I. E. J. Sornakumar, "Performance Characteristics of
ParabolicTrough Solar Collector System forHot Water Generation," vol. 7, no.
2, 2006.
[39] A. V. Arasu and T. J. S. E. Sornakumar, "Design, manufacture and testing of
fiberglass reinforced parabola trough for parabolic trough solar collectors," vol.
81, no. 10, pp. 1273-1279, 2007.
[40] S. Kalogirou, P. Eleftheriou, S. Lloyd, and J. J. R. E. Ward, "Low cost high
accuracy parabolic troughs construction and evaluation," vol. 5, no. 1-4, pp.
384-386, 1994.
[41] S. Kalogirou, S. Lloyd, and J. J. S. E. Ward, "Modelling, optimisation and
performance evaluation of a parabolic trough solar collector steam generation
system," vol. 60, no. 1, pp. 49-59, 1997.
30