Unit5Evaluation in Science
Unit5Evaluation in Science
Evaluation in Science
Evaluation - Different types of test items - merits and demerits. Construction and
administration of Achievement tests and Diagnostic tests.
Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation, Evaluation Criteria for Assignment, Seminar and
Project- Evaluation of non-cognitive areas like creativity, skill, and interest.
EVALUATION
Purpose of Evaluation
Provide direction to the teaching: Evaluation helps the teacher to know whether the teaching is in tune with the
objectives.
To assess the effectiveness of a particular instructional strategy: New methods of instruction are being
introduced day by day.
It diagnoses the strength and weakness of students.
Motivate the learner by providing feedback: Learner is eager to know his present position or status in the
group.
To now the usefulness of an instructional material: The curriculum and syllabi are being revised periodically.
The effectiveness of the instructional material are determined through evaluation.
Test items
Two parallel columns are used here. The stimuli are presented in the left column and the responses are given in
the right column. There should be more alternatives in the option column to reduce guess work.
Tips for better construction of Multiple Choice item
Give instruction for ‘how to match’ very clearly.
Should not give the same number of items in premises and options. There should be more alternatives in the
options column to reduce guess work.
The list should be not be too long.(5 items in the stem and 8 in the options ideal).
Complete items should appear on the same page of the question paper and not to be carried over to the next
page.
Double Matching
In double matching a list of stimuli are provided to test two areas of content knowledge. It includes three
parallel columns. In one column the stimuli are presented and responses are given in other two columns.
E.g . Double matching items based on Types of vitamins , Functions of vitamins and Deficiency diseases are an
appropriate example.
B] Supply Type
Merits
It is use full in evaluating the ability to interpret diagram, graph and sketches.
It is easy to construct , because it measures a relatively simple learning outcome.
There is no scope of guessing
It can be made more objective by carefully fixing value points.
A relatively large portion of the content can be covered in a test.
If carefully prepared, deep level objectives like understanding, application and problem solving skills can be
evaluated
Limitations of short answer type
3. It’s excessive use may encourage a student to memorise facts and develop poor study habits.
In Essay type items the examinee should write descriptively on a topic. It is a free response type test item.
This includes discussion, illustration, enumeration, analysis and evaluation. This type calls for long answers
covering a number of points and a variety of objectives. Essay type item are used to know the subject mastery
and the analytical ability of the students. It also tests the memory, communication skill and presentation. The
evaluation of higher order thinking is possible through answering essay items.
Merits
1. They are subjective in nature. If the same answer is evaluated by more than one examiner , normally the
marks allotted will vary widely.
2. They cannot comprehensively cover the content. Such questions require a lot of time to answer. There fore
in the limited time of three hours not more than 5 essay type questions can be answered. The result is that
the question paper can cover only a few topics of the syllabus.
3. The students are encouraged to read cheap notes and readymade answers instead of trying to gain
knowledge through self study. More stress is on memorization rather than reflective thinking.
4. Sience the number of items is limited , there is an element of chance. This leads to selective study on the
part of the students , which is not desirable.
5. The essay type examinations do not possess sufficient validity or reliability.
SUGGESTIONS TO IMPROVE ESSAY TYPE ITEMS.
Begin with words like critically evaluate, describe, illustrate, compare, etc.,
Divide the question in to subsections.
The wording of the question must be simple and clear.
CONSTRUCTION AND ADMINISTRATION OF ACHIEVEMENT TEST AND DIAGNOSTIC TEST
ACHIEVEMENT TEST
Any test that measures the attainments of an individual after a period of training or learning is called an
achievement test. Achievement test is designed to measure a person’s knowledge, skills, understandings in
a given field of taught in school. Achievement test helps the teacher to assess the progress of the child in
the desired direction.
Functions of achievement test
Number Questions
Total
1 LOTS
2 HOTS
1 Objective type
2 Short answer
3 Essay
Total
1 Easy
2 Average
3 Difficulty
Total
e) Scheme of option.
Scheme of option means the choices given to the students to select certain questions. It may be
External or Internal option.
In External option pupil can choose a given number of items from the total number of questions. For
instance, “attempt any ten questions out of twelve”.
But in Internal option, the choice is restricted within a question. For example, “Write an essay on
any one of the following.”
f) Scheme of section.
This means categorizing questions into separate sections. For example section A includes Objective type,
section B includes Short answer type and section C includes Essay type.
3. Preparation of the Blue Print.
A Blue print gives the details of the designs in concrete terms. Blue print is prepared as a three dimensional
chart indicating the distribution of questions with respect to----1) Thinking skills 2) content areas covered
and 3) the form of questions. Some people make it four dimensional including difficulty level also as one of
the dimensions. Blue print gives the frame work for the test and indicates the broad limit with in which the
test constructor has to work.
DIAGNOSTIC TEST
Special type of test that are devised to find out the weakness of students are called diagnostic test. Even
though achievement test has some diagnostic value, a diagnostic test differs from it. In achievement test , the
range of difficulty level is much wider. Questions ranges from easy to very difficult as its purpose is to grade
students and help to discriminate them. In a diagnostic test, the questions are mostly of low difficulty level as
the purpose of it is to locate their weakness and limitations. There is no time limit in diagnostic test as in
achievement test. In an achievement test, questions are often arranged of random whereas in a diagnostic
test ,questions are clustered around learning points which in turn are sequenced from simple to complex.
Diagnostic test are generally much larger than achievement test.
1. Planning - Normally a diagnostic test is prepared after administering an achievement test. The tester must
carefully plan the diagnostic test to identify the exact weakness of students. Planning of the diagnostic test
involves the identification of area of difficulty, deciding the number of questions to be asked and what type
of test items to use.
2. Identification of area of difficulty through question wise analysis chart.
The question wise analysis chart is a two way grid in which students’ name is listed in the vertical axis
whereas question number is listed on horizontal axis. The response for each question can be marked against
each students’ name as ‘ x’ for wrong answers and ‘ √ ’ for right answers. The analysis chart helps in locating
the questions which are made wrong by the majority students. Names Q.No.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Abin
Benoy
Bindhu
Dona
Emilie
3. Writing items.
There is no importance to difficulty of test items since the items are intended to identify the
weakness of pupils. Preparation of specific response to test items is essential. Item should have simple
language for easy comprehension. Normally a diagnostic test is a lengthier than achievement test. Normally
objective type test items or very short answer test items are used in a diagnostic test.
4. Providing directions
Clear directions should be given to a diagnostic test. There is no time limit for a diagnostic test. The
directions must aware the students that the test is not intended to measure the achievement of students. But
to identify the weak areas of the pupils.
5. Preparing the Scoring Key and Marking Scheme.
The answer book must be scored based on a prepared scoring key and marking scheme. It will help the
teacher to identify the deviations in the answers of each student from correct response.
6. Reviewing and editing the test.
A through revision of test items is necessary before administering the test. The test must enable the
teacher to identify the difficulty of the students.
7. Diagnostic Analysis.
After administering the diagnostic test a diagnostic analysis must be done based on the scores of
students. Identifying the questions from which the students cannot answer is important in finding out the
difficulties. The question numbers, types of test items, the correct answer of the test items etc. must be
considered while diagnosing the deficiencies of the students. It is the teacher’s sole responsibility to identify
the difficulties of students .
REMEDIAL TEACHING
Remedial teaching is followed by diagnostic testing. After locating the exact problem of students, the
teacher must plan the difficulty area accordingly. The instruction must be more individualistic in this stage.
Learning experiences must be suitable to overcome the difficulties of the students. Remedial learning
activities are to be more interesting and suitable to the mental level of each learner. Remedial teaching can
be done for students of learning difficulty after the school hours. In some schools there is a special period to
conduct remedial teaching. However, remedial teaching is a procedure carried on in the normal classroom
teaching learning process.
Continuous and comprehensive Evaluation.
Evaluation is a systematic process of collecting, analyzing and interpreting evidences of student’s progress and
achievement. The term continuous and comprehensive evaluation (CCE) suggests continuous assessment of
the total growth and development of pupils. Continuous evaluation means that evaluation is conducted
throughout the total span of instructional time. Comprehensive evaluation refers to the evaluation of the
total growth and development of the pupil – physical, mental, social, emotional and spiritual. Pupils are
evaluated in both the scholastic and co- scholastic areas in respect of different as aspects of development.
CCE helps to evaluate those objectives of learning which cannot be evaluated through year end written
examination. In CCE both process and product of learning are evaluated.
The two terms involved in the frame work of CCE are “ Continuous, Comprehensive Evaluation ’’.
Continuous: The term continuous refers to regularity in assessment. The growth of the child is a continuous
process. Therefore, it should be evaluated continuously which means that evaluation has to be completely
integrated with the teaching and learning process so that the progress of the students can be evaluated
regularly and frequently. Project works , practicals ,collections, assignments, seminars, internal
examinations etc.are to be considered while evaluating the students.
Comprehensive: The term comprehensive refers to both scholastic and non scholastic areas of pupil growth. The
function of the schools is not only to build up the cognitive capacities of the child but also to develop non
cognitive abilities. The comprehensive evaluation covers the whole range of student experience in the
context of total school environment which include aspects like physical, intellectual, emotional and social
growth. Students achievements in sports and games, arts and work experience etc. should give due
importance in evaluation. Personal and social qualities of the students also to be considered to evaluate the
student’s performance.
Evaluation: Evaluation is the process of finding out the extent to which the desired changes have taken place in
the pupils. Thus information gathering , judgment making and decision taking are the three phases of the
process of evaluation.
The common items used for CCE are ,Assignment ,Seminar,Project,Debate,Field trip,Practical,Class
test,Model preparation
1. Creativity.
Creativity is the capacity of a person to produce compositions, products or ideas which are essentially
new or novel and previously unknown to the producer.
Creativity and Mental abilities.
1. Fluency (the ability to produce large ideas).
2. Flexibility (the ability to produce a variety of ideas or approaches).
3. Originality ( the ability to produce uncommon responses ).
4. Re definition (the ability to define or perceive in a way different from the usual )
5. Sensitivity to problems (the ability to evaluate implications).
Evaluation or Assessment of creativity.
1. Word Association Test - Students are required to give as many definitions and number of different
categories into which they could be placed.
2. Uses of Things Test – The student is asked to give as many uses as he can for a common object.
3. Hidden Shapes Test – A student is required to find more complex form of figure on card in a simple
form.
4. Three Different Endings – Here a student is required to suggest three different endings to an incomplete
Short fable.
5. Make –up Problems – A student is required to make up as many mathematical problems he can on the
basis of information given in a complex paragraph.
6. Minnesota Tests of Creative Thinking.
7. Torrance’s check list
(Refer - Psycology Text Book)
2 Evaluation or Assessment of Skills.
b) Evaluation of Records.
Evaluation of students’ records of observation helps the teacher in assessing the observational skill of
students. The record works also give an idea about the students’ skill in drawing, provided such instances are
included in it.
c) Written Tests.
Generally, it is not possible to assess the skills using written tests. However , some skill related outcomes
can be tapped through writing. Using written tests, it is possible to assess mastery of some of the complex
knowledge that is prerequisites to perform the skill
For example if a student doesn’t know how the functions of different pieces of science lab equipment
relate to one another in an experimental context, there is no way that student will successfully complete the
lab work. The teacher could use a question in the written test to see if he had mastered the prerequisite
knowledge.
The assessment of drawing skills can also be carried out using written examinations.
3. Evaluation or Assessment of Interests
The following procedures are widely used to assess the interests including scientific interest.
a) Use of Interest Inventories.
Interest inventories are self reporting devices, generally in the form of questionnaires. Items may be
given in these inventories as questions for which the student has to give responses. In such inventories, the
teacher could inquire about student’s hobbies, what they do in their leisure time and what types of books
they read or they watch. From the responses of student to these items, the interest of the student can be
assessed.
Two popular Interest Inventories - Strong Vocational Interest Blank.
- Kuder Preference Record
b) Teacher observation and Record keeping.
A teacher can observe the students, activities and keep a record of these observations. To record
various activities of students the teacher can use audio/video recording devices also. These recordings may
provide hints to the teacher about their interests.
A student has to choose one activity from the three activities in a group.