2024 - DomesticWorkerReport - Final (Compressed)
2024 - DomesticWorkerReport - Final (Compressed)
2024 - DomesticWorkerReport - Final (Compressed)
2024
7TH ANNUAL REPORT
ON DOMESTIC WORKER
PAY AND WORKER
CONDITIONS
Table of Contents
Executive Summary 2
Introduction 3
Pay & Work Conditions of Currently Employed Domestic Workers 4
Domestic Worker Demographics 5
Family Structure 6
Education & Aspirations 7
Employment Dynamics 8
Work Days & Commute 9
Earnings Analysis 10,11
Earnings vs. Minimum Wage 12
Expenditure Breakdown 13,14
1
Saving Habits & Financial Security 15,16
Debt Levels & Repayment 17
Abuse in the Workplace 18
Mental Health 19
Life After Domestic Work 20
Employment After Domestic Work 21
Unemployment 22
Conclusion 23 - 25
Key Recommendations 26,27
Addendum 28
Executive Summary
The 2024 SweepSouth Report paints a complex picture of The mental well-being of domestic workers is significantly
the domestic work sector in South Africa, drawing on survey impacted, with 16% reporting a decline in the past year,
responses from over 5,600 workers. This year's report primarily due to unemployment, financial stress, and
spotlights the struggles faced by domestic workers amidst family problems. Access to professional mental health
high unemployment, rising living costs, and the lingering treatment remains limited, leaving many to cope without
effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. For the first time, we've adequate support.
explored what life looks like after domestic work and how this
sector can be a stepping stone towards economic For those who transitioned to different jobs, encouragingly,
freedom in South Africa. 39% reported better pay and 70% experienced improved or
Introduction
sector, although it's important to note that this Report on Pay and Working Conditions for
figure still reflects a nearly 15% decrease in Domestic Work in South Africa provides
domestic work jobs since before the COVID-19 valuable insights. As an online platform
pandemic. Currently, domestic work accounts connecting domestic workers with
for 5.2% of South Africa's total employment and employers, a core aspect of SweepSouth's
The 2023/2024 period has been particularly challenging for a significant 11% of employment for women mission is advocating for improved working
domestic workers. While all South Africans have felt the impact of nationally.* Understanding the key statistics of conditions within the domestic work sector.
the stagnant economy, marginal growth, and geopolitical instability, South Africa's domestic work sector is crucial, Our Annual Report offers a comprehensive
it is those at the lower end of the economic spectrum who are most but the numbers alone don't reveal the daily look at the financial circumstances and
vulnerable to these hardships. This year's report highlights the realities faced by those employed in this field. working conditions experienced by domestic
immense financial pressure faced by domestic workers, with 83% workers in the country.
serving as the primary breadwinners for their households and *Stats SA (2024) Quarterly Labour Force Survey
supporting an average of four dependents. 2024, Quarter 1
Survey Design
This year's survey was distributed via SMS We received a total of 5,617 responses in
and WhatsApp to a broad sample of South Africa. The analysis mainly focuses
domestic workers in South Africa, both on respondents who are currently
within and outside the SweepSouth platform. employed as a domestic worker, but also
examines those respondents who have
Approximately 36 000 domestic workers worked as a domestic worker in the last
were invited to participate, including 20 000 year but lost their job (after May 2023),
who had never used SweepSouth, 10 000 as well as respondents who worked as a
who previously found work through domestic worker longer than a year ago
SweepSouth, and just over 6 000 were but are now either unemployed or have a
currently active workers on the platform. The different job. This makes our survey the
survey was conducted online, which would largest and most detailed of its kind in
generally require respondents to have access Africa, and offers a comprehensive view
to a smartphone. of the declining mental health and other
socio-economic burdens of domestic
workers in the country.
Pay & Work Conditions
of Currently Employed
Domestic Workers
Domestic Worker Demographics
The primary focus of the
2024 survey is individuals who
are currently employed as a
domestic worker.
Women
Other/Prefer
not to say
92%
7%
1%
NATIONALITY
59% Zim
37% SA
3% Malawi
1% Lesotho
1% Other
5
The regional distribution of
respondents remains broadly
37
unchanged to past years.
Median Age
Which province
of South Africa 56% 37% 6%
do you work in? Gauteng Western Cape Other
Family Structure
5
The average number of dependents
supported financially, as well as the
percentage of respondents who are the 4
breadwinners in their household, has
remained relatively stable compared to
2021, 2022, and 2023 after they 3
increased significantly at the height of
the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.
2
1
83% 67% 4.26 2.25 4.08
0
Average Number in Average Number Average Number
Household of Children “Of of Dependents
Breadwinners Single Parent Your Own” Supported
Household Financially
The proportion of respondents who have completed high school is 42%, with a further 15% having completed
further education including a certificate/short course, an undergraduate degree or diploma,
or ‘some tertiary education’.
When asked about currently furthering their education, just over a third of respondents (35%) indicated that
they are either studying through an academic institution, doing practical courses, or doing self-study. Just over
a quarter of respondents (27%) indicated that they use free online education resources to assist with their
education, and a large proportion of respondents (85%) expressed a desire to further their education if they had
the money and/or the time to do so.
Employment Dynamics
The majority of respondents work part-time for Do you work full-time for one client
multiple employers rather than full-time for 21% 79%
or part-time for multiple clients?
one employer (79% versus 21% respectively).
Full-time for Part-time for
The vast majority of respondents (96%) reported One Client Multiple Clients
that cleaning is one of their primary roles while
just just over one in four respondents (26%)
reported childcare as one of their primary roles. What are your primary roles as a domestic worker?
13% 9% 8%
8
*Care for a child or adult with
special needs, such as a mental or
I currently work on the SweepSouth platform (active SweepStar). physical disability.
Not currently on the SweepSouth platform, but still work as a domestic worker.
Yes Maybe No
Earnings Analysis
2019
R3 600
R2 400
Median earnings per month from domestic work*
2020
(from COVID-19 report)
R3 359
R2 814
2021
Currently a SweepStar*
R3 470
R2 730
Never a SweepStar
2022
R4 203
R2 963
2023
R4 999
R2 992
2024
R5 242
R3 404
10
SweepStar median earnings have
shown a modest increase of around
5% in 2024 despite our recent
increase of 8% to our enforced
minimum pay per job. While this
increase is positive, we do also see the
impact of continued economic
pressure on all consumers.
R3 349
GAUTENG
R3 059
Primary Roles
Cleaning
R3 348
Gardening
R3 128
Childcare
R3 324
R3 463
Special Care*
R3 352
R3 291
Number of Primary Roles
1 2 3 4
OTHER
R2 659 R3 259 R3 571 R3 500 R3 551
Given the above, it may be more accurate to look at hourly rates when estimating pay compliance. Our findings are mixed. While men earn
slightly more than women, there is little variation by nationality and all average hourly earnings exceed the current NMW of R27.58/h.
However, when breaking down hourly rates by individual worker, we found that while the bulk of workers earn above minimum wage (54%), an
alarmingly large number of workers earn less than the NMW (46%).
Average earnings
Earning below Gender per hour
minimum wage
Women R33.35
Average earnings
Nationality per hour
Other R33.90
2019
Food
1 100
Data/Airtime
115
Housing
1 136
Median monthly spend:
445 279
Other Items
-
TOTAL
EXCL.
SCHOOL
FEES
3 075
13
School Fees
62
TOTAL
INCL.
SCHOOL
FEES
3 137
Annual Increase
2023 vs. 2024 6% 3% 17% 10% 8% 43% 15% 23% 15%
Expenditure Breakdown
The total median expenses for housing (R1 268), food (R1 241), transport (R606), electricity (R357), data/airtime
(R96), and other items (R640) brings the basic cost basket to R4 207 per month. This shows a deficit between
domestic worker earnings and basic costs, and a surplus when comparing household income and basic costs.
While it is good to see that household income covers basic costs, these are median values and therefore many
domestic workers still cannot afford these expenses. In addition, given the large proportion of single parent
households and that domestic workers financially support on average four dependents, this means a larger financial
financial burden on them as well.
While it is encouraging to see that the new minimum wage in South Africa is above the reported basic expenses, a
minimum wage is only as good as its adoption and enforcement. It is also important to recognise that these are basic
costs only. When it comes to additional savings and investments, there is little left on the table.
R3 337
TOTAL COSTS
EXCL. SCHOOL
Median monthly
household income
is approx.
R5 001
Surplus/
Earnings Deficit
FEES
Food Data/Airtime Housing Transport Electricity Other Items
17
their repayment situation
Family 16% as "hopeless".
R3 462
Median owed debt amount
DEBT The level of debt and the perceived inability
to repay loans highlights the precarious
financial situation of many domestic
(out of those who have debt) workers in South Africa.
Abuse in the Workplace
Our data continues to reveal a
concerning aspect of domestic work:
the issue of safety and abuse. The
survey results indicate that 6% of
domestic workers do not feel safe in
their employer's home, a statistic that
points to potential issues with working
environments or client interactions.
60%
40%
20%
Do you feel safe/comfortable working in your employer's home?
68%
27%
18
underscores the vulnerability of Foreign nationals are
5%
domestic workers and the urgent need 0.4% more likely to have
0%
for interventions to ensure their safety experienced
and well-being. This acts as a stark Yes - always Yes - mostly No - not often No - never verbal abuse
reminder that despite the essential role
domestic workers play, their work
environments can sometimes expose
them to unacceptable risks.
Delving into the critical issue of mental health What negatively impacts your
amongst domestic workers, a significant finding Women Men mental health the most?
is that 16% of workers reported a negative
impact on their mental well-being within the
YES
past year, with women being more affected than 16% 9% Unemployment 43%
men. This could be attributed to the multiple
pressures they face, including financial strain Debt / financial stress 25%
and balancing work and family responsibilities.
Of those whose
The primary stressors were identified as mental health has Family problems 23%
been negatively
unemployment, financial concerns, and family
affected, diagnosed
27%
problems, highlighting the interconnectedness Other 10%
with a mental illness
of these issues. It's encouraging to note that by a nurse or mental
many workers utilise coping mechanisms health professional. Yes
such as church involvement, exercise, How do you take care of your
and social connections. mental health?
If yes, what diagnosis did you receive?
However, access to professional mental health Church / religious
community 39%
treatment remains low, with only a quarter of
19
Depression 72%
those affected receiving a formal diagnosis, Exercise / spend
time outdoors 29%
predominantly for depression and anxiety. Anxiety 38%
This underscores the necessity for improved Spending time with
friends or family 29%
mental health support systems within this Trauma 10%
vulnerable population. Volunteering to
Bipolar 3% help others 9%
Is the pay better at your new job than when Yes 30%
you were a domestic worker?
No 26%
Yes 39% 31% No
About the same; I feel like I am treated as
well in my new job as when I worked as a 40%
domestic worker.
30%
About the same; I feel treated badly in
my new job and when I worked as a 3%
domestic worker.
About the same
Unemployment
Domestic workers
The 2024 data indicates that 21% of domestic who have lost 21%
workers report having lost their job in the last
year. The percentage of those who lost their
their jobs in the
jobs because their employer could no longer
last year
afford to pay them remained stable from the
previous annual surveys (25% in 2024
compared to 25% in 2023 and 24% in 2022).
Lost their jobs
There was a slight drop in the percentage who due to affordability 25%
lost their jobs because their employer moved
home, although still a significant increase over
the previous year (34% in 2024 compared to
40% in 2023 and 25% in 2022). Lost their jobs
due to dismissal 4%
Employers who moved home primarily moved
overseas (58%) while a significant portion
moved to a different city within South Africa
(23%). These trends have continued to be Lost their jobs
due to employer 34%
compounded by the accelerating emigration of moving homes
skilled professionals as well as the evolving
semigration trends seen during the COVID-19
pandemic due to remote work possibilities.
22
Of those respondents who were dismissed by Domestic workers UIF registered
their employer in the last year, 20% do not who lost their job domestic workers who
who were registered lost their job and
believe they were dismissed for a valid reason. for UIF submitted a claim
While a significant decrease from 2023’s annual
survey, this figure is still concerning and
warrants further investigation.
15% 64%
59%
Conclusion
Conclusion
Reflecting on the progress made since our stabilised at around 850 000 jobs, marking a 15% results of the 2024 general elections represent
2023 report, we observe a mix of reduction from its pre-pandemic peak. a crucial opportunity for South Africa to chart a
encouraging developments and persistent path toward a more equitable and prosperous
challenges, mirroring the situation in South This trend is particularly troubling given the sector's future. We must safeguard against political
Africa as a whole. The unprecedented importance for employment and the broader instability, corruption, and violence, which
levels of loadshedding (rolling blackouts) economy. Our findings underscore the potential of threaten to undermine economic recovery and
experienced in 2023 have subsided, domestic work to provide a pathway to a better disproportionately affect vulnerable
promising a positive economic impact and future for workers and their families. However, the populations. This demands accountability from
potential improvements in the lives of persistent threat of unemployment poses a our leaders and a commitment to driving
domestic workers. Concerns about unrest significant risk, impacting mental wellbeing and positive change at all levels of society.
surrounding the 2024 national elections making workers vulnerable to exploitation.
have also proved unfounded. The global domestic work sector is expected to
However, the effectiveness of the This report serves as a vital tool for monitoring the experience significant growth in the coming
Government of National Unity (GNU) domestic work landscape and evaluating the years, driven by aging populations and evolving
in addressing the nation's significant effectiveness of initiatives aimed at improving lifestyles. As technology continues to transform
challenges remains to be seen. working conditions and compensation. While it's the nature of domestic work, it is imperative
disheartening to observe the stagnation or reversal that South Africa not only keep pace but also
The cost of living continues to be a major of certain positive trends, even incremental gains seize the opportunity to expand access to
concern for domestic workers and their must be carefully considered. For example, although benefits and protections for workers. This will
employers. While inflation has eased and earnings have increased, these gains may be offset require collaborative efforts among individuals,
interest rate cuts are anticipated, our data by inflation and remain insufficient to meet the cost the private sector, and the government to
reveals a substantial 15% increase in costs of living. Furthermore, the data does not fully foster a more equitable, sustainable, and
for domestic workers, far outpacing the 5% reflect the consequences of job losses, which prosperous domestic work sector that
rise in earnings. Housing costs, in particular, can push domestic workers and their families into recognises the invaluable contributions of these
have risen disproportionately, warranting precarious circumstances. workers to our society.
further investigation. The lingering effects of
the COVID-19 pandemic are also evident in Navigating the challenges ahead will require strong
the domestic work sector, which has leadership, collaboration, and decisive action. The
Conclusion
What are we doing to effect change at SweepSouth?
Earning Opportunities:
• Expanded Offerings: We've extended our services to other businesses and B2B2C partnerships, creating more job opportunities.
• Permanent Employment: We've partnered with various organisations to connect domestic workers with permanent employment opportunities.
• Data-Driven Approach: We're continuously raising minimum platform pricing and encouraging customers to contribute more, leading to higher
SweepStar earnings.
• Customer Success: Over 25% of our customers pay significantly more than the minimum platform rates, demonstrating our success in motivating
fair compensation.
• Industry Collaboration: We're working with industry players to establish minimum work standards and benefits for domestic workers.
Innovative Products:
• Same-Day and Express Bookings: These features increase booking flexibility and earning potential for SweepStars.
• Matching Algorithm: We connect SweepStars with multiple bookings per day, maximising their earning potential.
Cost-of-Living Reduction:
• Rewards Programme: We leverage partnerships with other brands to offer SweepStars discounts and benefits.
• Expanded Programme: Our cost-of-living reduction program is now available to domestic workers beyond the SweepSouth platform.
Public Awareness:
• Living Wage Education: We're raising awareness about what constitutes a living wage for domestic workers.
• Domestic Worker Experiences: This report sheds light on the lived experiences of domestic workers and supports us to encourage
employers and industry roleplayers to adopt better practices.
Conclusion
What can you as an employer of a domestic worker do to
effect change?
Respectful Treatment: Treat your domestic worker with dignity and respect.
Be mindful of their physical and mental wellbeing, recognising the additional
responsibilities many face as caregivers. Promote mental health awareness and
support access to resources like The Warrior Project
(https://thewarriorproject.org.za/) if they experience abuse.
Shared Resources: Consider sharing bulk food purchases with your domestic
worker. This can help alleviate their higher food costs due to limited buying power
and transportation options.
Community Engagement: Advocate for fair domestic worker pay within your
social circles and community. Share this report's insights and participate in
initiatives supporting economically vulnerable groups. Use your voice on social
media to raise awareness about the challenges faced by domestic workers.
Key Recommendations
Review and Expansion of Legal Protections:
• Prioritise enforcement: Government and labour departments must allocate resources to actively enforce
existing minimum wage and labour laws that safeguard domestic workers.
• Innovative solutions: Collaborate with technology partners to develop user-friendly solutions
that simplify compliance and make it easier for everyone to follow labour regulations in private households.
• Tailored legislation: Acknowledge the diverse nature of domestic work, often involving multiple employers
and irregular schedules, and adapt legal protections to reflect these realities and protect all workers.
2024
Authors
Luke Kannemeyer
Reut Agasi (Independent Consultant)
Design
Kelley Wayne
Caterina Toffoli-Metcalfe
www.sweepsouth.com