Ecsa Fire Specialist Feasibility Study
Ecsa Fire Specialist Feasibility Study
Ecsa Fire Specialist Feasibility Study
EXPERTISE TO GROW
SOUTH AFRICA
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................ 3
3. SOUTH AFRICA URGENTLY NEEDS CATEGORY FOR COMPETENT FIRE SPECIALIST ..... 5
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
1. INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this report is to motivate for the feasibility of a new specialist registration category
of Fire Specialist for people already registered as ECSA professionals Pr. (Eng/Tech/Techni) and
confirmed to be competent in all the areas of Fire Engineering based on further education, training
and experience.
ECSA has already approved the Fire Practitioners categories which could do design and
installation based on deem to satisfy SANS standards and guides but are not deemed to be
competent under the National Building Regulations Act, since they cannot register as Pr.
Eng/Tech/Techni and do not have the education or training to do complex fire rational designs
which require interdependence of multiple performance based parameters for fire safety. The Fire
Practitioners will be appointed as a FORM 3 as per Table C.1 SANS 10400-A
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Due to many ECSA professionals signing Form 2 as competent persons to comply to SANS10400-
A but without comprehensive experience or training in fire the Building Control Officers and Fire
Chief requested ECSA to do validation of registered Professionals as competent in Fire
Engineering designs. Unfortunately, this was done by interviews with experienced Engineers doing
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Number of Government buildings had Fires including death of 3 fire man in recent fire in
Johannesburg
Knysna Fires 7 deaths and R3bn more damage just for the one event in 2017
The SANS standards are dated and very limited but accepted for high risers and buildings
with large number of people which was not intended nor are the many practitioners
“Consultants” competent to do rational designs. Rational designs by competent Fire
Specialist (Fire Engineers) for all larger, higher. more complex or higher risk or industrial
very high risk is required to ensure a fire safe place is designed for public and employees
based on performance-based engineering science.
After the Great Fire of London in 1666, which destroyed more than 80 percent of the city, London
put its first fire protection regulations for buildings into place, requiring the use of brick and stone
exteriors to reduce fire spread.
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
In 1903, the Armour Institute of Technology created the first-degree program in fire protection
engineering.
Today, colleges and universities around the world offer varying levels of study in fire protection and
fire safety, but for South African there is limited education by courses and self-study available.
The three design references used for compilation of this report are:
Different regions have different definitions and incorporate a wider group of engineering
disciplines:
The definition of Fire Safety Engineering by the Institution of Fire Engineers of the
UK is:
"The application of scientific and engineering principles, rules (Codes), and expert
judgement, based on an understanding of the phenomena and effects of fire and of
the reaction and behaviour of people to fire, to protect people, property and the
environment from the destructive effects of fire."
Professor Colin Bailey’s, of the University of Manchester further explains on the university’s
website Structural Fire Engineering as:
Structural fire engineering is not widely understood by those outside the discipline. Many people
confuse structural fire engineering with fire protection engineering, and fire safety engineering. The
confusion may arise from the different terminology used by different people in different parts of the
world.
In principle, structural engineers should be aware of all the requirements relating to fire safety in the
building regulations. A very common performance requirement is that “Any building shall be
designed and constructed so that, in the event of fire, its stability will be maintained for a reasonable
period.”
So, it is important to understand the basic fire safety measures for buildings and learn the benefits
of applying Structural Fire Engineering to achieve these goals.”
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Structural Fire Engineering deals with specific aspects of passive fire protection in terms of
analysing the thermal effects of fires on buildings and designing structural members for adequate
load bearing resistance, i.e. the structural fire resistance.
The well-known practices include the provisions of fire protection systems to steel members and
additional concrete cover to reinforced concrete members.
The simplest procedure is given in most conventional building codes. Generally, building codes
specify the fire resistance required for structural members and classification of construction based
on the results of standard fire tests. Information on member dimensions and construction details
with respect to fire resistance ratings is provided. The key feature is to keep the structural members
“cool” from the heat of fires.
The designers need only apply specified construction features to satisfy the code requirements and
require little or no knowledge of fire and structural engineering. This procedure is prescriptive-
based.
The second procedure involves the calculation of structural fire resistance based on the empirical or
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
The third procedure involves the assessment of three basic aspects comprising the likely fire
behaviour, heat transfer to the structure and the structural response. The overall complexity of the
procedure depends on the assumptions and analytical methods adopted to predict each of the three
design aspects. Although this procedure normally needs to be performed by experienced structural
engineers with the help of professional computer programs, it provides a platform for innovative
design and construction features.”
No matter the title used, the concept for this engineer is to identify risks related to fire and
determine ways to reduce the risks, as well as design ways of safeguarding against the
wrath of fire.
The principles when working with fire protection relate to protecting both people and
the environment, built and natural, from the hazards of fire.
This includes analyzing fire hazards; mitigating fire through building design and
construction; examining building uses and industrial processes; and design,
installation, and maintenance of fire detection and suppression systems.
Through the application of science and engineering principles, the engineer can mitigate,
detect, control, or suppress a fire with consideration of the reaction and behaviour of
people to fire,
Should a fire occur, post-fire investigation and analysis also fit within the fire protection
engineering domain.
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Looking at some of the roles a Fire Protection Engineer (FPE) can play helps to identify the
interdisciplinary nature of the field:
Developing Fire Specialist new registration for competent Rational Designer Pr. For:
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Lacking the formal registration as Fire Specialist there are many self-declared Fire Consultants
without any Engineering education practising Fire Engineer on large complex buildings at the risk
of the public.
Fire Practitioner (already ECSA approved and registrations done but not competent for rational fire
design only sub-areas detail design DMTS)
Sprinklers
Detection
Short Courses in Fire Safety topics by University of Stellenbosch, various training organizations in
specialist areas, Society of Professional Fire Engineers Technical handbook (4000 pages) and
international codes and standards as well as training with experienced companies.
Will be finalized with Education groups but typical in countries where fully established includes:
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Combustion Theory
Industrial Safety
Material Flammability
Firefighting systems and equipment (Fire hydrants, Fire hose reels, tanks, pumps,
pipes, etc.)
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Dr Richard Walls Pr.Eng. is a lecturer at University of Stellenbosch and has 20 post graduate
students doing Masters and PHD degrees in fire at this stage.
- Fire dynamics
- Structural fire design
There is also PHD research on informal settlement fires and testing which will be driven by industry
Fire safety research requirements.
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
PROPOSED COMPETENCIES
The Fire Specialist Competencies will be based on the Engineering Council 11 competencies and
set out the related skills and knowledge of the discipline of fire engineering.
The Fire Engineer is expected to apply South African Regulations and standards and for more
complex performance-based designs applies International more extensive codes standards like
UK: BS, EU: ISO or EN, USA: NFPA, etc. to be fully competent for alternative /rational fire safety
designs. The Fire Engineer must, however, have broad based experience and detail
knowledge/experience in some specialist categories of one or more aspects of fire engineering as
well as some knowledge of related aspects.
i. Professional Engineer;
Current incumbents must be registered under any of these categories and have and 3 years’
experience and fire post graduate and/or short courses and in-job training in Fire Engineering to
apply for Professional Registration on NRS. Qualifications in disciplines of Civil, Mechanical,
Electronic, Chemical will be typical candidates. Engineering Fire qualification does not exist in
South Africa and therefore will be an extension of existing disciplines in South Africa. International
qualification in fire will be validated by the relevant ECSA accreditation committee for registration
purposes on request.
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
Fire Departments, building control officers, and public will, with this registration have the assurance
that competent Engineering professionals are attending to Fire Safety designs. This includes
regulatory as well as life safety systems. It will drive the same professional conduct and stature for
Fire Specialist as other professional engineer categories. This registration will be available for all
engineering disciplines who are registered as Pr. and specialise in fire engineering.
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure
Document No.: Effective Date:
Revision No.: 1
N/A 29/01/2019
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
When downloaded for the ECSA Document Management System, this document is uncontrolled and the responsibility rests with the user to ensure that it is
in line with the authorised version on the database. If the ‘original’ stamp in red does not appear on each page, this document is uncontrolled.
QM-TEM-001 Rev 0 – ECSA Policy/Procedure