BRF Module 2 Notes
BRF Module 2 Notes
A surety is a person who gives a guarantee to the creditor that he would make the debt
payment if the principal debtor makes a default
1. Co-extensive:- Section 128 of ICA1872, provides for surety’s liability which is co-
extensive with the principal debtor’s liability. It means that the surety has the same liability
as the principal debtor. A surety is liable to pay the amount owed to the principal debtor if he
makes a default in payment to the creditor.
2.The liability of surety in certain cases, where the original contract between creditor and
principal debtor is void or voidable, the surety will remain liable as if surety was principal.
For example, in cases where the principal debtor was a minor.
3.The liability of the surety is secondary. The liability of surety to pay arises only on the
default of principal debtor. The primary liability to pay money to creditor is cast upon the
debtor.
5.Death of principal debtor:- In case of the death of the principal debtor, any suit against him
would be void ab initio. However, the surety would not be discharged of his liability to pay
the amount.
6.Surety’s right to limit his liability or make it conditional:-The surety may put a restriction
on the extent of his liability in the agreement. He can expressly declare his guarantee to a
fixed amount and in such a case the surety cannot be liable for any amount beyond the fixed
amount.
The principal debtor owes a greater amount but it is not the responsibility of the surety to be
responsible for even a single rupee more than what was stated in the agreement.
Rights of a Surety
A surety has the following rights:
As per section 141, a surety is eligible to the benefit of every security which the creditor has against the
principal debtor. This holds true even if at the time of entering into the contract of guarantee the surety
was unaware of the existence of such a security.
Also, when the creditor losses or parts with such security without the consent of the surety, this
discharges the surety to the extent of the value of such security.
Once the surety discharges the debt, he obtains the rights of a creditor against the principal debtor. He can
now sue the principal debtor for the amount of debt paid by him to the creditor due to the default of the
principal debtor.
In a case where the principal debtor on discovering that the debt has become due, starts disposing of his
properties in order to prevent seizure by the surety, the surety can compel the debtor to pay the debt and
discharge him from his liability to pay.
When a surety pays more than his share to the creditor, he has a right of contribution from the co-sureties,
who are equally liable to pay. For example, Anthony, Barkha, and Chaya are the co-sureties to David for
a sum of ₹30000 lent to Erwin who made default in payment.
Thus, Anthony, Barkha, and Chaya are liable to pay ₹10000 each as between them. So, in this case, if
anyone of them pays more than ₹10000, he can claim the excess from the other two co-sureties so as to
reduce his payment to ₹10000 only. However, if one of the co-sureties becomes insolvent, the other co-
sureties shall contribute his share equally.
Discharge of a Surety’s Liability(Sec.130 – 144)
Discharge of surety’s liability means that the liabilities of the surety have come to an end and
he is no longer under any obligation. The circumstances in which the surety is discharged
from the liability are provided under Sections 130-144 of the ICA
A surety is considered as a favourable debtor and the liabilitity of a surety can be discharged or
released.
I. Discharge by Revocation
1. Revocation by Notice (Sec.130) :- Section 130 of ICA states that the surety, by giving a
notice to the creditor, can revoke a continuing guarantee for future transactions. The surety
should clearly state it in the notice. However, a specified guarantee for the liability already
arisen cannot be revoked.
2. Revocation by Death:- Section 131 of ICA states that in case of the the death of surety, he is
released from the liability and his legal heirs will not be made liable for the transactions on
behalf of the surety either continuing or in future ,unless it is provided so in the contract of
guarantee.
1. Variation in terms of contract:- Section 133 of ICA provides for the discharge of surety’s
liability if any variation in the terms of contract of guarantee entered upon by creditor
and principal debtor have been brought without informing or consulting the surety.
2. Discharge or Release of Principal Debtor:- Section134 of ICA incorporates a discharge
of surety, if the creditor releases or discharges the primary liability of the principal
debtor. As the surety only has a secondary liability, if primary liability is released,
surety’s liability also automatically discharges.
3. Compounding by creditor with Principal Debtor:-Section 135 of ICA says that when
the creditor makes an arrangement for composition or promises to give time or not sue
the principal debtor without surety’s consent, the surety will be discharged.
4. Impaired surety’s remedies:- Section 139 of ICA discharges the surety’s liability if the
creditor has done any act or omission which is inconsistent with the rights of the surety
5. Loss of Security:- Section 141 of ICA provides that if the creditor losses or parts with
any security without the consent of the surety, then the surety will be discharged from
his liability for the value of the security or parted with or lost.
III. Discharge of surety’s liability by Invalidation of a Contract
A contract in which the goods are handed over by one party to another party for a specific
reason, which is expressed or implied for a short period. The two parties involved in the
contract of bailment are the bailor and the bailee.
The person who delivers the goods is termed as Bailor whereas the receiver of the goods is
termed as Bailee.
The delivery of goods can be done in three ways: Actual Delivery, Symbolic Delivery,
Constructive Delivery. The Bailment is divided into two categories:
Definition of Pledge
The pledge is a variety of bailment in which goods are transferred from one party to another
party as security for the payment against debts owed by him.
The person who delivers the goods is known as Pawnor whereas the person who receivers
goods is known as Pawnee.
1. The delivery of possession: - The essential and important element of the bailment is
that the possession of goods must be delivered by the bailor to the bailee. Only
possession of goods transfers from bailor to bailee, not the ownership.
2. The delivery of goods should be on the basis of a contract: - The delivery of goods to
the bailee should be on the basis of some contract because the bailment is always
created on the basis of a contract. The contract may be expressed or implied.
3. The delivery should be for a specific purpose:- The goods should be delivered by the
bailor to the bailee for a specific purpose.
4. The delivery should be upon a condition to return the goods. It is agreed between the
bailor and the bailee that as soon as the purpose is achieved, the goods shall be
returned or disposed of according to the direction of the bailor.
1. The delivery of possession: - The essential and important element of a valid pledge is
that the possession of goods must be delivered by the pledger to the pledgee. Only
possession of goods transfers from one person to the other, not the ownership which
remains with the pledger.
2. The delivery of goods should be on the basis of a contract: - For a valid pledge, the
delivery of goods should be made with an intention to create a pledge.
3. The delivery should be for a specific purpose of security:- The goods should be
delivered by the pawnor to the pawnee as a security for the payment of a loan or for the
fulfilment of an obligation.
4. The delivery should be upon a condition to return the goods. It is agreed that the
goods shall be returned to the pawnor when such loan is repaid or the promise is fulfilled.
BASIS FOR
BAILMENT PLEDGE
COMPARISON
Meaning When the goods are temporarily handed over When the goods are delivered to act as security
from one person to another person for a specific against the debt owed by one person to another
purpose, it is known as bailment. person, it is known as the pledge.
Defined in Section 148 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Section 172 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
Parties The person who delivers the goods is known as The person who delivers the goods is known as
the Bailor while the person to whom the goods Pawnor while the person to whom the goods are
are delivered is known as Bailee. delivered is known as Pawnee.
Right to sell the The party whom goods are being delivered has no The party whom goods are being delivered as
goods right to sell the goods. security has the right to sell the goods if the party
who delivers the goods fails to pay the debt.
Use of Goods The party whom goods are being delivered can The party whom goods are being delivered has no
use the goods only, for the specified purpose. right to use the goods.
2 Legal heir’s right to redeem Right of Lien- Section 173 entitles the
pawnee with a right to retain goods
If a pawnor dies, his/her legal heir can pleged until he is paid back the debt,
redeem the goods on his behalf. interest and any other expenses
incurred for maintenance of such good.
3 Right to claim for damages Pawnee has a right to sell the goods after
and loss on the ground of giving reasonable notice and time to
conversion. pawnor.
4 Preservation and maintenance of Right of retainer for subsequent
goods- It is a right of the advances- Section 174 provides for a
pledger/pawnor that his goods presumption that if there are any
subsequent advances made by pawnee
are safely stored and maintained.
to pawnor, it will be included in the
original debt only. Therefore, the
pawnee has the right to retain the
goods until subsequent advances are
paid.
Law of Agency
Agency is the legal status of a person to act in the capacity of another.
In other words, agency is a relationship which arises where a person known as the
agent has the express or implied authority to act in the capacity of another person
known as the principal, and such act has the same effect as though it were in fact
performed by the principal.
There are basically two parties in an agency relationship which are the Principal and
the Agent.
The Principal: the principal is the party on whose behalf the agent carries out a
given duty.
The Agent: an agent is the party employed, engaged or contracted by the principal
to act for him in his capacity
The law of agency is when an agent is authorized to act on the behalf of the principal
and to create a legal relationship with a third party. An agent is a person employed by
principal in dealings and act on the behalf of principal with third persons. Principal is the
person for who is represented by the agent.
Creation of Agency
An agency can be created by:
Direct (express) appointment– The standard form of creating an agency is by direct appointment.
When a person, in writing or speech appoints another person as his agent, an agency is created
between the two.
Implication– When an agent is not directly appointed but his appointment can be inferred from the
circumstances, an agency by implication is created.
Necessity– In a situation of necessity, one person can act on behalf of another to save the person from
any loss or damage, without expressly being appointed as an agent. This creates an agency out of
necessity.
Estoppel– An agency can also be created by estoppel. In a situation where one person behaves in
such a manner in front of a third person, as to make someone believe he is an authorized agent on
behalf of someone, an agency by estoppel is created.
Ratification– When an act of a person, who acted as another person’s agent (on his behalf) without
his knowledge is later ratified by that person, this creates an agency by ratification between the two.
Types of Agent
1. Mercantile Agent: Mercantile agency is a type which creates a relationship
where the agent id authorized to makes sales on behalf of the principal in the
customary course of business. Buying goods from a mercantile agent transfers
ownership and title to the purchaser as tough it was in fact purchased from
the original owner himself, since a mercantile agent has the full authority of
the owner, he can therefore sell in his name.
2. Sole Agent: Sole agent is a distinct type of agency which implies that there is
only one person through which the transaction with the principal can be
perfected. Therefore, even if there are other sub-agents or other unauthorized
or self-acclaimed agents, the transaction must still be perfected through the
sole agent and his commission be paid thereon.
3. Estate Agent: an Estate Agent engages in buying and selling of landed
properties which includes lands, houses, and may in fact extend to the
marketing and selling of home use chattels. An estate agent is paid a
commission upon successful sales made.
4. Broker: A broker is an agent who negotiates agreement between a party and
another (the principal). A broker need not be in physical possession of the
goods which is the subject matter of the contract. A broker is paid a
commission known as brokerage.
5. Banker: A bank or banker becomes an agent of the customer in certain
relations. For instance, where a banker receives instruction from the customer
of which he is obliged to perform; such as paying in deposits, paying an
amount specified in a cheque in favour of the payee.
6. Auctioneer: An auctioneer is an agent employed for the purpose of selling
goods at auction sales. An auctioneer is required to be licensed. The law
imposes on him not to make sales below the reserved price and also not make
credit sales.
7. Del Credere Agent: A del credere agent undertakes to indemnify the
principal upon the breach of payment by a third party. A del credere agent can
be likened to a guarantor. He guarantees that upon default by a specific third
party, he is to be bound. A del credere agent is usually paid a commission
known as del credere commission.
8. Partners: In a partnership, each of the partners is regarded as the agent of
the other partners.
9. Dual agency refers to a situation in which a broker represents both a seller and buyer
at the same time. This does not constitute a conflict of interest as long as both parties
are aware of and consent to the arrangement. The dual agent is required to keep
information about price, motivation or terms confidential unless expressly instructed to
inform the other party about this information.
10. A sub-agency involves a situation where a potential buyer would like to look at a
property and his regular agent is unavailable. Sub-Agent-An agent appointed by
an agent. A sub-agent will walk the buyer through the property and provide him
customer service as if he were his own client. The difference is that a sub-agent is not
permitted to provide the buyer with any information or disclosures that could negatively
impact the seller.
11. Substituted agent:- When a person, in the capacity of an agent, is
asked to name someone for a certain task, the person who is named
does not become a sub-agent to the Principal, but a substituted agent.
12. Special Agent- Agent appointed to do a singular specific act.
13. General Agent- Agent appointed to do all acts relating to a specific job.
14. Co-Agent- Agents together appointed to do an act jointly.
15. Factor- An agent who is remunerated by a commission (one who looks
like the apparent owner of the things concerned)
Termination of Agency
An agency can be terminated or is terminated in 5 different ways:
1. When the agent’s authority is revoked by the Principal
2. When the agent renounces the business of the agency
3. When the business of the agency is completed
4. When either of the parties dies or becomes mentally disabled
5. When the Principal is adjudicated an insolvent
1. It can be revoked any time before the authority has been exercised.
2. If according to the terms of the contract between the two, the
agency has to continue upto a certain time, any prior revocation by
the Principal shall be compensated for, to the agent.
3. The termination does not take effect before it has been
communicated to the agent.
4. Termination of the authority of an agent terminates the authority of
all the sub-agents under him.
1. The Principal is bound to indemnify the agent against any lawful acts
done by him in the exercise of his authority as an agent.
2. The Principal is bound to indemnify the agent against any act done
by him in good faith, even if it ended up violating the rights of third
parties.
3. The Principal is not liable to the agent if the act that is delegated is
criminal in nature. The agent will also in no circumstances be
indemnified against criminal acts.
4. The Principal must make compensation to his agent if he causes any
injury to him because of his own competence or lack of skill.
Rights of an Agent
An agent has the following 5 rights:
According to Section 238, The Principal is liable for any fraud or misrepresentation made by his agent
during the course of his business, as if the fraud or misrepresentation was done by the Principal
himself.