LM1 Options Strategies IFT Notes
LM1 Options Strategies IFT Notes
1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ 3
2. Position Equivalencies .................................................................................................................................... 3
Synthetic Forward Position ......................................................................................................................... 3
Synthetic Put and Call .................................................................................................................................... 7
3. Covered Calls and Protective Puts .......................................................................................................... 10
Investment Objectives of Covered Calls ............................................................................................... 10
4. Investment Objectives of Protective Puts ............................................................................................ 13
5. Equivalence to Long Asset/Short Forward Position........................................................................ 15
Writing Puts .................................................................................................................................................... 16
6. Risk Reduction Using Covered Calls and Protective Puts .............................................................. 17
7. Spreads and Combinations ........................................................................................................................ 19
Bull Spreads and Bear Spreads................................................................................................................ 19
8. Straddle ............................................................................................................................................................. 23
Collars ............................................................................................................................................................... 25
Calendar Spread ............................................................................................................................................ 26
9. Implied Volatility and Volatility Skew ................................................................................................... 27
10. Investment Objectives and Strategy Selection ................................................................................ 29
The Necessity of Setting an Objective ................................................................................................... 29
Criteria for Identifying Appropriate Option Strategies.................................................................. 29
11. Uses of Options in Portfolio Management ......................................................................................... 30
Covered Call Writing ................................................................................................................................... 30
Put Writing ...................................................................................................................................................... 31
Long Straddle ................................................................................................................................................. 31
Collar.................................................................................................................................................................. 33
Calendar Spread ............................................................................................................................................ 33
12. Hedging an Expected Increase in Equity Market Volatility ........................................................ 34
Establishing or Modifying Equity Risk Exposure ............................................................................. 34
Summary................................................................................................................................................................ 36
This document should be read in conjunction with the corresponding reading in the 2024 Level III
CFA® Program curriculum. Some of the graphs, charts, tables, examples, and figures are copyright
2023, CFA Institute. Reproduced and republished with permission from CFA Institute. All rights
reserved.
Required disclaimer: CFA Institute does not endorse, promote, or warrant the accuracy or quality of
the products or services offered by IFT. CFA Institute, CFA®, and Chartered Financial Analyst® are
trademarks owned by CFA Institute.
Version 1.0
1. Introduction
A derivative is a financial instrument that derives its value from the economic performance
of the underlying (stocks, interest rate, etc.). Options are contingent-claim derivatives. The
two main types of options are call options and put options.
• A call option gives the holder a right but not the obligation to buy the underlying
asset at a particular price.
• Similarly, a put option gives the holder a right but not the obligation to sell the
underlying asset at a particular price.
Section 2 of this reading covers position equivalencies – how two or more securities can be
combined to create another security. Sections 3 -6 cover the two most widely used options
strategies – covered calls and protective puts. Sections 7 and 8 cover other popular options
strategies – spreads and combinations. Section 9 discusses implied volatility embedded in
option prices and volatility skew. Section 10 discusses how to select an appropriate option
strategy to achieve a particular investment objective. Sections 11 and 12 cover the uses of
options in portfolio management.
2. Position Equivalencies
In this section, we will outline how certain combinations of derivatives are equivalent to
other assets/portfolios. At earlier levels, we covered two important position equivalence
relationships:
• Put-call parity: A fiduciary call is equivalent to a protective put.
i.e. S0 + p0 = c0 + X/(1 + r)T
• Put-call-forward parity: Here we replace S0 with a forward contract to buy the
underlying. The forward price is given by F0(T) = S0(1 + r)T, therefore the put-call
parity formula changes to:
F0(T)/(1 + r)T + p0 = c0 + X/(1 + r)T
Synthetic Forward Position
Synthetic Long Forward Position
Buying a call and writing a put on the same underlying with the same strike price and
expiration creates a synthetic long position (or, a synthetic long forward position). This can
be demonstrated by looking at the payoffs of the three alternatives:
1) Buy a call and write a put. Both options have the same expiration date and the same
exercise price of $50.
2) Buy a stock for $50.
3) Buy forward/futures at 50.
Hence, we can conclude that: Long put + Short call = Short stock = Short forward/futures
At the expiry of the forward contract, if the stock price is below 200.35p, the owner of the
long put will exercise his option, and the market maker receives the 10,000 Vodafone shares
for £20,035. She then delivers these shares to the client and receives £20,035.
Synthetic Put and Call
Synthetic Put
A synthetic long put position consists of a short stock and long call position in which the call
strike price equals the price at which the stock is shorted.
This can be demonstrated by looking at the payoff associated with the two alternatives.
Stock price at expiration: 40 50 60
Alternative 1: Short stock at 50 and Long 50-strike call
Short stock payoff 10 0 -10
Long call payoff 0 0 10
Alternative 1 payoff 10 0 0
Alternative 2: Long 50-strike put
Alternative 2 payoff 10 0 0
We can also look at the payoff diagrams of the two alternatives.
Payoff of Long put
Hence, we can conclude that: Long put = Short stock + Long call
Synthetic Call
A synthetic long call position consists of a long stock and long put position in which the put
strike price equals the price at which the stock is purchased.
This can be demonstrated by looking at their payoff diagrams.
Payoff of Long call
Hence, we can conclude that: Long call = Long stock + Long put
Example: Synthetic Long Put
(This is Example 2 from the curriculum.)
Three months ago, Wing Tan, a hedge fund manager, entered into a short forward contract
that requires him to deliver 50,000 Generali shares, which the fund does not currently own,
at €18/share in one month from now. The stock price is currently €16/share. The hedge
fund’s research analyst, Gisele Rossi, has a non-consensus expectation that the company will
report an earnings “beat” next month. The stock does not pay dividends.
1. Under the assumption that Tan maintains the payoff profile of his current short forward
position, discuss the conditions for profit or loss at contract expiration.
2. After discussing with Rossi her earnings outlook, Tan remains bearish on Generali. He
decides to hedge his risk, however, in case the stock does report a positive earnings
surprise. Discuss how Tan can modify his existing position to produce an asymmetrical,
risk-reducing payoff.
Solution 1:
If Tan decides to keep the current payoff profile of his position, at the expiry date, given a
stock price of ST, the profit or loss on the short forward will be 50,000 × (€18 – ST). The
position will be profitable only if ST is below €18; otherwise the manager will incur in a loss.
Solution 2:
Tan decides to modify the payoff profile on his short forward position so that, at expiration,
it will benefit from any stock price decrease below €16 while avoiding losses if the stock
rises above that price. He purchases a call option with a strike price €16 and one month to
maturity at a cost (premium) of €0.50. At expiration, the payoffs are as follows:
• On the short forward contract: 50,000 × (€18 – ST)
• On the long call: 50,000 × {Max[0,(ST – €16)] – €0.50}
• On the combined position: 50,000 × {(€18 – ST) + [Max[0,(ST – €16)] – €0.50]}
If ST ≤ €16, the call will expire worthless and the profit will amount to 50,000 × (€18 − ST + 0
− €0.50).
If ST > €16, the call is exercised, and the Generali shares delivered for a maximum profit of
50,000 × (€18 − €16 − €0.50) = €75,000.
3. Covered Calls and Protective Puts
Option Greeks:
• Delta is the change in an option’s price for a given small change in the value of the
underlying instrument, all else equal. Delta for long calls is always positive and delta
for long puts is always negative.
• Gamma is the change in an option’s delta for a given small change in the value of the
underlying instrument, all else equal. Gamma for long calls and long puts is always
positive.
• Vega is the change in an option’s price for a given small change in volatility of the
underlying, all else equal. Vega for long calls and long puts is always positive.
• Theta is the daily change in an option’s price, holding all else constant. Theta for long
calls and long puts is generally negative.
Consider Exhibit A showing the premium for options on IFT stock which currently sells for
$16.
Exhibit A: IFT Option Premiums: Current IFT stock price = 16.00
Calls Exercise Puts
SEP OCT NOV Price SEP OCT NOV
1.64 3.00 3.44 15 0.65 1.00 1.46
0.94 2.00 2.90 16 1.14 1.50 1.96
0.51 1.00 1.44 18 1.76 2.00 2.59
With respect to terminology, when we say ‘IFT October 15 call sells for 3.00’, the expiration
is October, the exercise price is 15, the option is a call, and the call premium is 3.00.
Investment Objectives of Covered Calls
A covered call is an option strategy in which an investor who owns a stock, sells a call option
on that stock. It is known as a covered call because the short call position is ‘covered’ by
owning the underlying stock. Hence: Covered Call = Long Stock + Short Call.
• an opportunity loss also occurs if the stock rises sharply above the exercise price and is
sold at a lower-than-market price.
Profit and Loss at Expiration
The formulas in this subsection use the following terminology:
• S0 = Stock price when option position opened
• ST = Stock price at option expiration
• X = Option exercise price
• c0 = Call premium received or paid
The profit and loss relationships for a covered call strategy can be expressed as:
• Maximum gain = (X – S0) + c0
• Maximum loss = S0 – c0
• Breakeven point = S0 – c0
• Expiration value = ST – Max [(ST – X),0]
• Profit at expiration = ST – Max [(ST – X),0] + c0 – S0
Taking numbers from Exhibit A, currently S0 = 16.00, writing the IFT OCT 18 call for 1.00, X=
18.00, c0 = 1.00. If ST = 16.00 then:
• Max gain = 18 − 16 + 1 = 3
• Max loss = 16 − 1 = 15
• Breakeven point = 16 − 1 = 15
• Profit at expiration = 16 − 0 + 1 − 16 = 1 if ST = 16.00
Profit/loss diagram for the covered call
policy. Like traditional insurance, this insurance coverage also expires after a certain period
of time.
The investment objectives of protective puts are:
• Loss protection: Consider an investor who owns an IFT stock currently trading at 16.
His research suggests that there may be a negative shock to the stock price in the next
few weeks. To protect himself against a price decline the investor can purchase IFT
OCT 15 puts for $1.00. Thus, a protective put strategy will protect against losses
below 15 as long as the put does not expire before the occurrence of the expected
price shock.
• Upside preservation: Unlike a covered call strategy, a protective put strategy does
not limit the upside potential of the stock. If the stock price rises, the position fully
benefits from the appreciation, and the maximum gain is unlimited.
An important point to remember is that in a protective put, the put options provide coverage
for a certain period. After expiry, the investor has to purchase new put options for continued
coverage. If the investor continuously buys put options for protection, the amount spent on
the put premiums can significantly impact the return generated from the position. Therefore,
put options should be purchased selectively, only when an investor has a bearish outlook for
a short period.
Profit/loss diagram for protective put
• Breakeven point = S0 + p0
• Expiration value = Max(ST,X)
• Profit at expiration = Max(ST,X) – S0 – p0
Example: Characteristics of Protective Puts
(This is Example 4 from the curriculum.)
S0 = Stock price when option position opened = 25.00
X = Option exercise price = 20.00
ST = Stock price at option expiration = 31.33
p0 = Put premium paid = 1.15
1. Which of the following correctly calculates the gain with the protective put?
A. ST – S0 – p0 = 31.33 – 25.00 – 1.15 = 5.18
B. ST – S0 + p0 = 31.33 – 25.00 + 1.15 = 7.48
C. ST – X – p0 = 31.33 – 20.00 – 1.15 = 10.18
2. Which of the following correctly calculates the breakeven stock price with the protective
put?
A. S0 – p0 = 25.00 – 1.15 = 23.85
B. S0 + p0 = 25.00 + 1.15 = 26.15
C. ST + p0 = 31.33 + 1.15 = 32.48
3. Which of the following correctly calculates the maximum loss with the protective put?
A. S0 – X + p0 = 25.00 – 20.00 + 1.15 = 6.15
B. ST – X – p0 = 31.33 – 20.00 – 1.15 = 10.18
C. S0 – p0 = 25.00 – 1.15 = 23.85
Solution to 1:
A is correct. If the stock price is above the put exercise price at expiration, the put will expire
worthless. The profit is the gain on the stock (ST – S0) minus the cost of the put. Note that
the maximum profit with a protective put is theoretically unlimited, because the stock can
rise to any level and the entire profit is earned by the stockholder.
Solution to 2:
B is correct. Because the option buyer pays the put premium, she does not begin to make
money until the stock rises by enough to recover the premium paid.
Solution to 3:
A is correct. Once the stock falls to the put exercise price, further losses are eliminated. The
investor paid the option premium, so the total loss is the “deductible” plus the cost of the
insurance.
5. Equivalence to Long Asset/Short Forward Position
Delta measures the sensitivity of an option’s price to the underlying.
By definition, the delta for a stock is 1 and the delta for a long position in a forward contract
is also 1.
The portfolio delta depends upon its constituents. For example,
• A portfolio comprising 100 shares will have a portfolio delta of 100 x 1 = 100.
• A portfolio comprising 100 shares and 100 at-the-money long call options on the
same stock will have a portfolio delta of 100 x 1 + 100 x 0.5 = 150
Covered call delta: If we construct a covered call portfolio with 100 shares and short 100
at-the-money call options, then the portfolio delta will be equal to 100 – 0.5 x 100 = 50
Protective put delta: Similarly, if we construct a protective put portfolio with 100 shares +
long 100 at-the-money put options, then the portfolio delta will be equal to 100 – 0.5 x 100 =
50
Long stock/short forward delta: If we construct a portfolio with 100 shares + short
forward position on 50 shares, then the portfolio delta will be equal to 100 – 50 x 1 = 50
These examples show three different positions: an ATM covered call, an ATM protective put,
and a long stock/short forward position that all have the same delta. For small changes in
the price of the underlying, these positions will provide similar payoffs.
Writing Puts
When someone writes a put option, he has an obligation to buy the underlying stock at the
exercise price.
A cash-secured put is when an investor sells a put option and deposits an amount of money
equal to the exercise price into a designated account. The cash in a cash-secured put is
similar to a stock in a covered call strategy. The cash-secured put strategy is appropriate
when an investor is bullish on a stock or wants to acquire shares at a particular price.
Scenario: IFT stock is currently at 16.00. An investor wants to purchase the stock for 15.00.
To do so, the investor writes the SEP 15 put for 0.65 (Exhibit A). If the stock is above 15 at
expiration the put option will expire worthless and the investor pockets the put premium. If
the stock is below 15 at expiration, the put will be exercised and the option writer will
purchase shares at an effective purchase price (= exercise price – put premium = 15 – 0.65)
of 14.35.
rate by purchasing €1,000,000 for US$1,100,000. However, she will lose the premiums she
paid for the options. For the futures contract, she pays US$1.2052/€1 or US$1,205,200 for
€1,000,000 regardless of the more favorable rate.
7. Spreads and Combinations
An option spread is a strategy that involves two options of the same type which differ by
exercise price only. The term spread means the payoff is based on the difference, or spread,
between option exercise prices. For a bull or bear spread, the investor buys a call and writes
another call with a different exercise price or buys a put and writes another put with a
different exercise price. An option combination uses both types of options, for example, an
investor buys a call option and sells a put option.
Bull Spreads and Bear Spreads
Bull and bear spreads represent cost-effective bets on the direction of the underlying. A bull
spread increases in value when the underlying rises. A bear spread increases in value when
the underlying falls.
If a cash payment is required to establish a spread, then it is a debit spread. If a cash
payment is received as a result of the spread, then the spread is called a credit spread.
Spreads can be established with call options or with put options. For simplicity purposes, we
will use call options to construct bull spreads and put options for bear spreads.
Bull Spread
Investment objective: To benefit from an increase in price of the underlying while keeping
costs low.
Structure: Buy one call option with a lower exercise price and sell another with a higher
exercise price.
Scenario: Say the IFT stock is trading at $16 in August. If an investor believes that the stock
will not rise above $18 in two months, he can use an OCT 16/18 bull call spread strategy. It
will involve the following:
• buy the OCT 16 call option for 2.00
• sell the OCT 18 call option for 1.00
The cost, breakeven stock price, and the maximum profit for bull spread are given by:
• Cost = cL – cH
• Maximum profit = XH – XL – cost
• Breakeven price for a call bull spread = XL + cost
where:
XL = the lower exercise price, XH = the higher exercise price
cL = call with the lower-strike price, cH = call with the higher-strike price
Using the data given above, the net cost is 2.00 – 1.00 = 1.00
Breakeven price = 16 + 1 = 17.
Maximum profit = 18 – 16 – 1 = 1.
The payoff diagram for this strategy is:
The profit diagram for this strategy can be constructed by shifting the payoff diagram down
by 1 which is the cost of the strategy.
The profit diagram for this strategy can be constructed by shifting the payoff diagram down
by 1 which is the cost of the strategy.
3. What is the breakeven price with an OCT 45/50 bull call spread?
A. 46.10
B. 47.50
C. 48.88
Solution to 1:
C is correct. With a bull spread, the maximum gain occurs at the high exercise price. At an
underlying price of 50 or higher, the spread is worth the difference in the strike prices, or 50
– 45 = 5. The cost of establishing the spread is the price paid for the lower-strike option
minus the price received for the higher-strike option: 2.55 – 1.45 = 1.10. The maximum gain
is 5.00 – 1.10 = 3.90.
Solution to 2:
B is correct. With a bear spread, an investor buys the higher exercise price and writes the
lower exercise price. When this strategy is done with puts, the higher exercise price option
costs more than the lower exercise price option. Thus, the investor has a debit spread with
an initial cash outlay, which is the most he can lose. The initial cash outlay is the cost of the
OCT 50 put minus the premium received from writing the OCT 45 put: 6.80 – 2.92 = 3.88.
Solution to 3:
A is correct. An investor buys the OCT 45 call for 2.55 and sells the OCT 50 call for 1.45, for a
net cost of 1.10. She breaks even when the position is worth the price she paid. The long call
is worth 1.10 at a stock price of 46.10, and the OCT 50 call will expire out of the money and
thus be worthless. The breakeven price is the lower exercise price of 45 plus the 1.10 cost of
the spread, or 46.10.
Refining spreads: It is not necessary that both legs of the spread be established at the same
time or maintained for the same period. Based on market conditions, spreads can be
adjusted to capitalize on price movement and increase profits.
8. Straddle
Investment objective: To take advantage of an (a) increase (decrease) in volatility.
Structure: A long straddle is created by buying a call and a put. The call and put should be on
the same underlying asset. The exercise price of the call and put should be the same. The
party that writes (sells) the call and put options takes a short straddle position.
A straddle is a directional play on the volatility of the underlying. A long straddle has a
positive payoff if the true (actual) volatility of the underlying is higher than the expected
volatility (predicted by the market participants). A short straddle has a positive payoff if the
actual volatility of the underlying is less than the expected volatility.
Assume a stock sells for 50, and the straddle buyer invests in 30-day options with an
exercise price of 50. The call price is 3 and the put price is 2, for a total cost of 5. For the
straddle to be profitable, one of these two options must be profitable enough to recover the
costs of both the put and call.
The payoff and profit diagram of this long straddle strategy is:
The profit diagram is obtained by shifting the payoff down by 5 which is the cost of the
strategy.
The cost, max profit, breakeven and max loss of a long straddle are given by:
• Cost = c0 + p0
• Max profit = unlimited
• Breakeven = X + cost, X – cost (As can be seen in the profit diagram, a straddle has
two breakeven points)
• Max loss = cost
The risk of a long straddle is limited to the amount paid for the two option positions. The
movement in stock price, therefore, needs to be higher than the combined cost of the two
options for the position to be profitable. If an investor believes that the stock price
movement will not be significant to recover the cost of the combined option premiums, he or
she may write the options instead and take a short straddle position.
The Greeks for a straddle are shown in Exhibit 22.
The long straddle initially has a very low delta (+0.069 for this example) with a high gamma
(0.139). The portfolio is not very sensitive to initial small changes in the stock price, but this
sensitivity increases quickly once the stock starts moving in a particular direction.
The vega for the long straddle is +0.114, meaning the portfolio will profit by approximately
0.114 from increased volatility of 1% in the underlying.
Collars
Investment objective: To limit downside risk at a low cost
Structure: A collar involves long shares of stock, a long put with an exercise price below the
current stock price, and a short call with an exercise price above the current stock price.
Collars:
• provide downside protection through a put
• reduce the cash outlay by writing a call
Scenario: An investor previously bought a stock of XYZ company at $12. He now buys the
NOV 15 put for 1.46 and simultaneously writes the NOV 17 call for 1.44. Exhibit 24 shows
the profit and loss diagram for this collar.
As shown in the diagram, the position has a minimum gain of at least 2.98. This is because
the stock price had appreciated before establishing the collar. Investors typically establish a
collar on a position that is already outstanding.
The cost, max profit, and min profit of the strategy are given by:
• Cost = S0 + p0 – c0
• Max profit = X2 – cost
• Min profit = X1 – cost
A collar forgoes the positive part of the return distribution in exchange for the removal of the
adverse portion. The investor sells the right side of the return distribution by writing a call
but receives protection against the left side of the distribution and losses by buying a put.
The investment outcomes narrow, which is risk reducing, in exchange for limited return.
Calendar Spread
Investment objective: To take advantage of time decay.
There are two types of calendar spreads:
• Short calendar spread requires selling a longer-dated call and buying a near-term
call. This strategy is profitable when greater price movements are expected in the
near-term relative to price movements in the future.
• Long calendar spread requires selling a near-dated call and buying a long-dated call.
This strategy is profitable when investment outlook is flat in the near-term, but
greater price movements are expected in the future.
Instructor’s Note:
Calendar spreads can also be constructed using put options.
Scenario: Suppose XYZ stock is trading at 45 in August. A trader believes that the stock will
be stable at the current level for the year but will rise by early next year. He has access to
options shown below (taken from the curriculum):
Calendar Spread Call Option Prices (August)
Exercise Price SEP OCT JAN
40 5.15 5.47 6.63
45 1.55 2.19 3.81
50 0.22 0.62 1.99
Based on his outlook on the stock, the trader executes a long calendar spread strategy. He
buys XYZ JAN 45 call for 3.81 and sells XYZ SEP 45 call for 1.55. The net cost is 3.81 – 1.55 =
2.26.
Assume that when the SEP 45 option expires, XYZ stock is at 45 and when the JAN 45 option
expires the stock is at 50. In this case, the SEP 45 call is worthless, but the JAN 45 option is in
the money.
In this example, the long calendar spread trader takes advantage of time decay. Time decay
is more pronounced for a short-term option than for a long-term one. The long calendar
spread trader exploits this by purchasing a longer-term option and writing a shorter-term
option.
• The underlying is trading at 19,000. Options with a strike price of 19.000 are ATM
options. Call options with strike prices higher than 19,000 are OTM. Similarly, put
options with strike prices lower than 19,000 are OTM.
• If the implied volatilities of both OTM puts and OTM calls are higher than the implied
volatilities of ATM options, the curve is U-shaped and is called a volatility smile
(since it resembles the shape of a smile.)
• However, the more common shape of the implied volatility curve is a volatility skew
where the implied volatility increases for OTM puts and decreases for OTM calls, as
the strike price moves away from the current price.
The extent of the skew depends on the following factors:
• Supply/demand: When investors are looking to hedge the underlying asset, the
demand for put options exceeds that for call options. The excess demand for put
options relative to the demand for call options, increases the put prices and their
implied volatilities. This demand/supply imbalance will increase the degree of the
skew.
• Investor sentiment: If investor sentiment becomes bearish, the demand for put
options will go up raising their implied volatilities and therefore the skew will
increase.
Measuring volatility skew: Exhibit 29 from the curriculum shows the levels of implied
volatility at different degrees of moneyness for options on a few equity indexes. The 90%
moneyness option is a put with strike (X) equal to 90% of the current underlying price (S);
thus X/S = 90%. Similarly, the 110% moneyness option is a call option with strike (X), where
X/S = 110%. The skew is calculated as the difference between the implied volatilities of the
90% put and the 110% call.
Risk reversal strategy: If a trader believes that the current skew in the volatility curve is
too high and expects the skew to reduce in the future, he can take a long position in a risk
reversal strategy. He will buy OTM calls and sell the same expiration OTM puts. This options
position is then delta-hedged by selling the underlying asset.
This strategy will be profitable if the implied volatility of OTM calls rises more relative to the
implied volatility of OTM puts. In other words, if the investor view is correct the volatility
skew decreases.
Term structure of volatility: Typically, for the same underlying and strike price, the
implied volatilities of options with longer maturities are higher than the implied volatilities
of options with shorter maturities. Therefore, the term structure of volatility is often in
contango.
Implied volatility surface: It can be thought of as a 3D plot, for options on the same
underlying asset, with days to expiration, option strike prices, and implied volatilities on the
X, Y, and Z axis respectively. It simultaneously shows the volatility skew and the term
structure of implied volatility.
10. Investment Objectives and Strategy Selection
The Necessity of Setting an Objective
Derivatives should be used to achieve a well-defined investment objective. Three high-level
objectives include:
1. Hedging
2. Taking directional bets
3. Arbitrage
Factors to consider when setting objectives include:
• Actual portfolio – For example, when using derivatives for hedging, we need to
consider the characteristics of the actual portfolio being hedged.
• Market outlook – This includes views on both direction and volatility.
• Timeframe – The time period required to execute the strategy.
• Benefits/limitations of derivatives – For example, close attention should be given to
Greeks, as they provide insights on how option prices may change.
Criteria for Identifying Appropriate Option Strategies
Option strategies are often based on the outlook on direction and volatility of the underlying
asset. Exhibit 32 of the curriculum outlines the appropriate strategy under different market
conditions.
Outlook on the Trend of Underlying Asset
Trading Range/
Bearish Bullish
Neutral View
Decrease Write calls Write straddle Write puts
Expected
Move in Remain Write calls and Calendar spread Buy calls and
Implied Unchanged buy puts write puts
Volatility
Increase Buy puts Buy straddle Buy calls
Strategy: To generate cash, Rivera should use the covered call strategy. Call options with the
170-strike price should be sold. This will generate cash of 5,000 x 6.45 = 32,250, sufficient
for the client’s requirement.
Solution:
In her earlier planning, the break-even points were 155.86 and 184.14 which would have
made the strategy profitable since she was expecting a change of 169 ± 10%. However, the
new breakeven points require the stock to move by 12% to be profitable. Hence, she should
not execute this straddle trade.
Example: Straddle Analytics
(This is Example 7 from the curriculum.)
Use the following information to answer Questions 1 to 3 on straddles.
XYZ stock price = 100.00
100-strike call premium = 8.00
100-strike put premium = 7.50
Options expire in three months
1. If Yelena Strelnikov, a portfolio manager, buys a straddle on XYZ stock, she is best
described as expecting a:
A. higher volatility market.
B. lower volatility market.
C. stable volatility market.
2. This strategy will break even at expiration stock prices of:
A. 92.50 and 108.50.
B. 92.00 and 108.00.
C. 84.50 and 115.50.
3. Reaching an upside breakeven point implies an annualized rate of return on XYZ stock
closest to:
A. 16%.
B. 31%.
C. 62%.
Solution to 1:
A is correct. A straddle is directionally neutral in terms of price; it is neither bullish nor
bearish. The straddle buyer wants higher volatility and wants it quickly but does not care in
which direction the price of the underlying moves. The worst outcome is for the underlying
asset to remain stable.
Solution to 2:
C is correct. To break even, the stock price must move enough to recover the cost of both the
put and the call. These premiums total to $15.50, so the stock must move up at least to
$115.50 or down to $84.50.
Solution to 3:
C is correct. The price change to a breakeven point is 15.50 points, or 15.5% on a 100 stock.
This is for three months. Ignoring compounding, this outcome is equivalent to an annualized
rate of 62% on XYZ stock, found by multiplying by 12/3 (15.5% × 4 = 62%).
Collar
Case facts: Bernhard Steinbacher has a client with a holding of 100,000 shares in Tundra
Corporation, currently trading for €14 per share. The client has owned the shares for many
years and thus has a very low tax basis on this stock. Steinbacher wants to safeguard the
position’s value because the client does not want to sell the shares. He does not find
exchange-traded options on the stock. Steinbacher wants to present a way in which the
client could protect the investment portfolio from a decline in Tundra’s stock price.
Discuss an option strategy that Steinbacher might recommend to his client.
Solution: In the over-the-counter market, Steinbacher might buy a put and then write an
out-of-the money call. This strategy is a collar. The put provides downside protection below
the put exercise price, and the call generates income to help offset the cost of the put.
Calendar Spread
Case facts: Ivanka Dubois is a professional advisor to high-net-worth investors. She expects
little price movement in the Euro Stoxx 50 in the next three months but has a bearish long-
term outlook. The consensus sentiment favoring a flat market shows no signs of changing
over the next few months, and the Euro Stoxx 50 is currently trading at 3500. Exhibit 37
shows prices for two put options with a strike price of 3500 that are available on the index.
Both options have the same implied volatility.
Solution: Option C is not appropriate, because it has a strike price of 70. If the stock reaches
70, there will be no payoff from the option.
The expected payoff from option B is 70 – 60 = 10. The profit is 10 – 3 = 7. The profitability is
7/3 = 2.3
The expected payoff from option A is 70 – 58 = 12. The profit is 12 – 4 = 8. The profitability is
8/4 = 2
Therefore, Option B is the most profitable.
Protective Put Position
Case facts: Eliot McLaire manages a Glasgow-based hedge fund that holds 100,000 shares of
Relais Corporation, currently trading at €42.00. He is concerned that the stock price will go
down by 10% to 37.80. Exhibit 43 provides information on options prices for Relais
Corporation.
Summary
LO: Demonstrate how an asset’s returns may be replicated by using options.
Buying a call and writing a put on the same underlying with the same strike price and
expiration creates a synthetic long position (or, a synthetic long forward position).
Selling a call and buying a put on the same underlying with the same strike price and
expiration creates a synthetic short position.
A synthetic long put position consists of a short stock and long call position in which the call
strike price equals the price at which the stock is shorted.
A synthetic long call position consists of a long stock and long put position in which the put
strike price equals the price at which the stock is purchased.
LO: Discuss the investment objective(s), structure, payoff, risk(s), value at expiration,
profit, maximum profit, maximum loss, and breakeven underlying price at expiration
of a covered call position.
Covered Call = Long Stock + Short Call.
The investment objectives of covered calls are:
• Yield enhancement
• Reducing position at a favorable price
• Target price realization
The profit and loss relationships for a covered call strategy can be expressed as:
• Maximum gain = (X – S0) + c0
• Maximum loss = S0 – c0
• Breakeven point = S0 – c0
• Expiration value = ST – Max [(ST – X),0]
• Profit at expiration = ST – Max [(ST – X),0] + c0 – S0
LO: Discuss the investment objective(s), structure, payoff, risk(s), value at expiration,
profit, maximum profit, maximum loss, and breakeven underlying price at expiration
of a protective put position.
Protective Put = Long Stock + Long Put
The investment objectives of protective puts are:
• Loss protection
• Upside preservation
The profit and loss relationships of the protective put are given below:
• Maximum profit = ST – S0 – p0 = Unlimited
• Maximum loss = S0 – X + p0
• Breakeven point = S0 + p0
Bear Spread
Investment objective: To benefit from a decrease in price of the underlying while keeping
cost low.
Structure: Buy a put option with a high exercise price and sell a put option with a low
exercise price.
The cost, breakeven stock price, and the maximum profit for bear spread are given by:
• Cost = pH – pL
• Maximum profit = XH – XL – cost
• Breakeven price for a put bear spread = XH - cost
Straddle
Investment objective: To take advantage of volatility.
Structure: A long straddle is created by buying a call and buying a put. The call and put
should be on the same underlying asset. The exercise price of the call and put should be the
same.
The cost, max profit, breakeven and max loss of a long straddle are given by:
• Cost = c0 + p0
• Max profit = unlimited
• Breakeven = X + cost, X – cost (As seen in the profit diagram, a straddle has two
breakeven points)
• Max loss = cost
Collars
Investment objective: To limit downside risk at a low cost
Structure: A collar consists of long shares of stock, a long put with an exercise price below
the current stock price, and short call with an exercise price above the current stock price.
The cost, max profit, and min profit of the strategy are given by:
• Cost = S0 + p0 – c0
• Max profit = X2 – cost
• Min profit = X1 – cost
LO: Describe uses of calendar spreads.
Calendar spreads are used to take advantage of time decay when volatility is expected to
change.
There are two types of calendar spreads:
• Short calendar spread: selling a longer-dated call, buying a near-term option. This
strategy is profitable when greater price movements are expected in the near-term
relative to price movements expected in the future.
• Long calendar spread: selling a near-dated call, buying a long-dated call. This strategy
is profitable when investment outlook is flat in the near term, but greater price
movements are expected in the future.
LO: Discuss volatility skew and smile.
• If the implied volatilities of both OTM puts and OTM calls are higher than the implied
volatilities of ATM options, the curve is U-shaped and is called a volatility smile
(since it resembles the shape of a smile.)
• However, the more common shape of a volatility curve is a volatility skew where the
implied volatility increases for OTM puts and decreases for OTM calls, as the strike
price moves away from the current price.
LO: Identify and evaluate appropriate option strategies consistent with given
investment objectives.
Outlook on the Trend of Underlying Asset
Trading Range/
Bearish Bullish
Neutral View
Decrease Write calls Write straddle Write puts
Expected
Move in Remain Write calls and Calendar spread Buy calls and
Implied Unchanged buy puts write puts
Volatility
Increase Buy puts Buy straddle Buy calls
LO: Demonstrate the use of options to achieve targeted equity risk exposures.
Long Call
Case facts: Armando Sanchez is a private wealth advisor working in London. He expects the
shares of Markle Co. Ltd. will move from the current price of £60 a share to £70 a share over
the next three months. He wants to use call options to benefit from this view. Prices for
three-month call options on the stock are shown in Exhibit 42. Determine which option will
be the most profitable.
Solution: Option C is not appropriate, because it has a strike price of 70. If the stock reaches
70, there will be no payoff from the option.
The expected payoff from option B is 70 – 60 = 10. The profit is 10 – 3 = 7. The profitability is
7/3 = 2.3
The expected payoff from option A is 70 – 58 = 12. The profit is 12 – 4 = 8. The profitability is
8/4 = 2
Therefore, Option B is the most profitable.
Protective Put Position
Case facts: Eliot McLaire manages a Glasgow-based hedge fund that holds 100,000 shares of
Relais Corporation, currently trading at €42.00. He is concerned that the stock price will go
down by 10% to 37.80. Exhibit 43 provides information on options prices for Relais
Corporation.
The expected payoff from Option C is 45 – 37.80 = 7.2. The profit is 7.2 – 3.46 = 3.74. The
profitability is 3.74 / 3.46 = 1.1
Therefore, Option B is the most profitable.