Forwards Problems 2
Forwards Problems 2
f0 = p0 + c
The Pricing of Forward Contract
Following Cost is carried by future contract
Storage
Insurance
Transportation
Financing
Opportunity
Forward = F = S0 ert
Example.
• Consider a forward contract on a non-dividend paying share which is available at Rs 70, to mature in
3-months’ time. If the risk-free rate of interest be 8% per annum compounded continuously, the
contract should be priced at?
Problem
• .
Problems
• On a non-dividend paying share, a 4-month forward
contract is entered into, when it is selling at Rs 72. If
the risk-free rate of interest with continuous
compounding is 12 per cent per annum, what would
the forward price be?
• Calculate the forward price on a 6-month contract on
a share, expected to pay no dividend during the
period, which is available at Rs 75, given that the risk-
free rate of interest be 8% per annum compounded
continuously
Case 2: Securities Providing a Known Cash Income
•F = S0 e(r – y) t
Example
• Assume that the stocks underlying an index provide a dividend
yield of 4% per annum, the current value of the index is 520 and
that the continuously compounded riskfree rate of interest is
10% per annum. To find the value of a 3-month forward
contract,
• A stock index currently stands at 350. The risk-free interest rate
is 8% per annum (with continuous compounding) and the
dividend yield on the index is 4% per annum. What should the
futures price for a 4-month contract be?
Problems
• A stock is expected to pay a dividend of $1 per share in 2 months and in 5 months.
The stock price is $50, and the risk-free rate of interest is 8% per annum with
continuous compounding for all maturities. An investor has just taken a short position
in a 6-month forward contract on the stock. What are the forward price and the initial
value of the forward contract?
Open interest is the total number of outstanding futures contracts available for delivery at that time,
and it is the sum of all long positions or all short positions. Open interest is important in futures trading
because it is an indication of the trading in the contract as well as the liquidity of the contract. An
increase in the open interest indicates an increase in the number of contracts available for delivery,
and a decrease in the open interest indicates a decrease in the number of contracts available for
delivery. This is an indication of the liquidity of the contract. When the open interest is high and if a
trader wants to close the position, it will be comparatively easier to do so as compared to the situation
where the open interest is very low.
Example
Consider the following transactions in ICICI single-stock futures that took place in one of the
exchanges. On January 2, when the contract started trading, Megafund took a long position in 10
contracts, Minifund took a long position in 12 contracts, Ram took a short position in 7 contracts, and
Interfund took a short position in 15 contracts.
On January 3, Megafund took a short position in 5 contracts, Minifund took a long position in 8
contracts, Ram took a long position in 3 contracts, and Interfund took a short position in 6 contracts.
On January 4, Megafund took a short position is 10 contracts, Minifund took a short position in 5
contracts, Ram took a long position in 8 contracts, and Interfund took a long position in 7 contracts.
Relation between Future and Spot Prices
• Since the futures price is the price at which the
asset will be exchanged, the parties to the
contract expect either the spot price at the
maturity of the contract to be equal to the futures
price or the current futures price to be equal to
the expected spot price at maturity. However, the
futures price may not always be equal to the
expected spot price, because the estimates of
futures spot prices vary from one market
participant to the other
The Basis
• Divergence of Futures and Spot Prices
Basis = Pt – P0
• In a “normal market”, the futures price would be
greater than the spot price and, therefore, the
basis will be positive, while in an “inverted
market”, the reverse holds. In an inverted market,
the basis is negative since the spot price exceeds
the futures price in such a market.
Convergence
• Generally, the longer the time to maturity, the greater
the carrying costs. As the delivery month approaches,
the basis declines until the spot and futures prices are
approximately the same. This phenomenon is known as
convergence.
Expected Basis
When uncertainty is introduced, however, the relationship
between the futures prices and the expected spot prices
at a future date is not unambiguous. In case of
uncertainty, there are three hypotheses to explain the
expected basis. They are:
1. Normal backwardation
2. Contango
3. Expectation principle
Expected Basis
1. Normal backwardation: According to this hypothesis, the
expected basis is negative as the futures price tends to be a
downward estimate of its spot price in the cash market at the
contract’s maturity date. The theory is thus dependent on the
assumption that speculators usually buy, i.e., net long, the
contracts while the hedgers usually write, i.e., net short, the
contracts.
2. Contango: This hypothesis assumes the other possibility—the
hedgers generally buy the contracts, while the speculators
generally sell the contracts.
3. Expectation principle: This theory postulates that the
expected basis would be equal to zero. This is based on the
argument that futures prices are an unbiased estimate of
expected future spot prices, as would be expected in an efficient
market. Thus, there is no room for any excess returns for either
How to Trade in Futures
Step 1: First, the trader will contact a broker who is authorized to trade in futures. The order can be either a market
order or a limit order.
Step 2: The broker will access the order book of the NCDEX and key in the order placed by the trader. The market
orders have no price specified and specify only the quantity. The order will be matched by the computer at the
NCDEX/NSE/MCX. The order book has all the orders received from various brokers with the orders classified on the
basis of both price and time.
Step 3: If the order is executed, the broker will then have to get this order cleared by a CM of the Clearing Corporation
of the Exchange. The CM is responsible to the Exchange to fulfil the contract. The broker will approach the CM asking
for permission to clear the trade. Once the CM clears the trade, the Exchange will notify the broker that the order has
been cleared. When a CM clears a trade, they take responsibility to fulfil the contract at maturity, even though they have
not entered into the contract.
Step 4: In order to take the responsibility for the fulfilment of the contract at maturity, the CM will have to post a margin,
which is usually based on the volatility of the underlying asset price. The Exchange will notify the CM of the margin
amount that needs to be posted.
Step 5: Since the CM only clears the trade and takes no position in the trade, they will ask the broker to provide the
funds for this margin, which will be collected by the broker from the trader.
Step 6: The broker will maintain an account known as the margin account, which will be updated daily on the basis of
the settlement price of the contract on that day; this is known as marking-to-market.
Step 7: As long as the trader wants to keep their position in futures before maturity, the only responsibility for the trader
is to follow the instructions of the broker with respect to the margin account.
Step 8: At maturity of the contract, the contract will be settled. The trader’s broker will calculate the position of the
margin account on the basis of the settlement price. If the margin account shows a positive amount, this amount is the
gain for the trader from futures trading, and this amount will be given to the trader by the broker. If the margin account
shows a negative amount, it indicates a loss from futures for the trader, and the trader needs to pay this amount to the
broker.
Pricing of Futures
• Consider a 6-month gold futures contract of 100 gm. Assume
that the spot price is Rs 480 per gram and that it costs Rs 3 per
gram for the 6-monthly period to store gold and that the cost is
incurred at the end of the period. If the riskfree rate of interest is
12% per annum compounded continuously, the futures price is?
Pricing of Futures
• A stock index is currently at 820. The continuously compounded
risk-free rate of return is 9% per annum and the dividend yield
on the index is 3 per cent per annum. What should the futures
price for a contract with 3 months to expiration be?
Two Kinds
Long and Short Hedges
Example
On September 10, a wholesale merchant estimates that his company will require
30 MT of chana on February 20. The current spot price of chana is INR 1,912 per
quintal (100 kg), and the price of a February chana futures contract is INR 2,011
per quintal.
The wholesale merchant can hedge the price risk:
(i) by taking a long position in 30 chana futures contracts on September 10 at INR
2,011 per quintal, i.e., INR 20,110 per contract, and
(ii) by taking a short position in these contracts on February 20.
Consider the case where the chana price in the spot market on February 20 is INR
2,561. Since the delivery date is February 20, the futures price will be very close to
the spot price in order to eliminate arbitrage opportunities. Thus, the futures price
will also be INR 2,561.
If the spot market chana price on February 20 is INR 1,900, then the position of the
hedger will be:
Problem – Hedging
Barley Mart produces barley and sells it to wholesalers. On September 1, the spot
market price of Barley is INR 922 per quintal. Barley Mart wants to sell 50 MT of
Barley in December and is concerned that the price of Barley might fall in the
period between September and December. In order to eliminate the risk of possible
price decreases, Barley Mart wants to hedge the position using futures. Barley
futures are available in the NCDEX, with expiry on December 20 and a contract
size of 10 MT. Barley futures are priced in Indian rupees per quintal. The December
futures are selling at INR 840. Show that Barley Mart can fix the selling price of
barley by entering into a futures contract.
• Identify whether a long hedge or a short hedge is preferable
• Choose the appropriate futures and the number of contracts
• Decide the actions to be taken to hedge.
• Calculate the effective selling price for two different spot prices, one higher and
one lower, to show that the effective price is the same, irrespective of the spot
market price. Since the futures price contracted is INR 840, consider the case of
(i) spot market price of INR 880 and
(ii) spot market price of INR 820
Problem
Indian Silver produces silver jewellery and sells all over India. On January 1, Indian
Silver estimates that it will need 300 kg of silver on April 20 and is concerned that
the silver prices may increase in the meantime. On January 1, the spot market
price of silver is INR 27,175 per kg. In order to eliminate the risk of possible price
increases, Indian Silver wants to hedge its position using futures. Silver futures are
available in the NCDEX, with expiry on April 20 and contract size of 30 kg. The April
futures are selling at INR 28,450. Show that Indian Silver can fix the buying price of
silver by entering into a futures contract.
• Identify whether a long hedge or a short hedge is preferable
• Choose the appropriate futures and the number of contracts
• Decide the actions to be taken to hedge.
• Calculate the effective selling price for two different spot prices, one higher and
one lower, to show that the effective price is the same, irrespective of the spot
market price. Since the futures price contracted is INR 28,450, consider the case
of
(i) the spot market price of INR 29,000 and
(ii) the spot market price of INR 28,000.
Single Stock Futures and Stock index Futures
• What is a Stock Futures Contract?
When a stock futures contract expires, it entitles an investor to buy or sell a specified number of shares of
the stock on which the futures are written at a price that is determined at the time of entering into the futures
contract. If the investor takes a long position in the stock futures contract, they agree to buy the specified
number of shares of the underlying stock on the futures expiry date at a price that is determine when the
investor goes long in the futures contract. If the investor takes a short position in the stock futures contract,
they agree to sell the specified number of shares of the underlying stock on the futures expiry date at a
price that is determined when the investor goes short in the futures contract. The price at which the investor
is willing to buy or sell is the futures price, and it is determined in the market for each trade on the basis of
the demand and supply of these contracts as well as on the basis of the expectations of the future value of
the stock price.
Example : ICICI Future = 1236.20 Spot on Settlement = 1105.85
On September 1, Ashok Leyland shares are selling at INR 40.35. Ashok Leyland futures have a contract
size of 9,550. The September futures expiring on September 28 are priced at INR 41.25, and the October
futures expiring on October 26 are priced at INR 41.54. The initial margin requirement is 5% of the contract
value. On September 28, the shares of Ashok Leyland are selling at INR 41.83.
• (i) If you buy one September contract, what is the value of the contract?
• (ii) How much money do you need to post as the margin?
• (iii) What would be the amount of cash settlement for a September contract?
Uses of Stock Index Futures
Long Position Risk Management
To illustrate the risk management in case of long position on stock, assume that an investor buys 2000
shares of a company at a price of Rs 500 per share on September 14, on analysis of company future
prospects. On this day, the stock price index, say Sensex, is ruling at 4480. Three weeks after he buys
shares, on October 4, the company declares half-yearly results which cause the share price to rise to a level
of Rs 534. But almost at the same time he fears that due to a decision of the OPEC members, the oil prices
are likely to increase sharply, causing hardships to the world economies. The stock markets are likely to be
adversely affected by their action.
To hedge against the likely fall in the index, he needs to take a short position in index futures. The portfolio
value on October being 534 * 2000 = Rs 10,68,000 for which protection is required. The investor learns
that the analysis of the last three months’ data reveals that this stock price, when regressed over Sensex, has
beta equal to 1.2. Accordingly, the short position required for covering Rs 10,68,000 portfolio is worth Rs
10,68,000 * 1.2 = Rs 12,81,600. Assuming the October futures is trading at 4520, he would short
1281600/4520 = 283.5 or 300 (assuming the market lot is 100) contracts. At the maturity of the October
futures if the index closes at, say 4130 and the price of the share in question be, say Rs 478, then the
position may be analysed as follows:
• Loss in the value of portfolio (534 – 478) * 2000 = Rs 112,000
• Gain in futures contracts: (4520 – 4130) * 300 = Rs 117,000
Uses of Stock Index Futures
Short Position Risk Management
To illustrate, suppose that an investor is short 1000 shares at Rs 690 and the beta of the
stock is 0.9, then the investor should hedge by taking a long position in the near-month
stock index futures for 690 * 1000 * 0.9 = Rs 621,000. If the one-month index contracts
are trading at 3620, then the investor would sell 621000/3620 = 171.5 or 200 contracts (if
the market lot is 100 contracts). By the expiry of this contract, suppose the market
recovers and the index becomes 4280 and the price of the underlying share becomes Rs
761. In this case, the investor’s position can be analysed as follows:
• Loss on position in share: (761 – 690)*1000 = Rs 71,000
• Gain on futures contracts: (4280 – 3620) * 200 = Rs 66,000
Hedging using Single Stock Futures
• What type of hedging is appropriate, long or short?
• What instruments to use?.
• How Many Contracts to Use?
Hedge Ratio
H = p * SDs/SDf
N = h * Na/Qf
On January 1, Rajesh owns 6,000 shares of IOC and is planning to sell
them on February 28. Each contract size is 600 shares of IOC. The price of
the February IOC futures contract is INR 790. The spot price of IOC is INR
777.30 on January 1. If the spot price of IOC shares on February 28 is INR
544.40, show how Rajesh can hedge the price risk and what will be the
result of this hedge?
Problem
A BHEL futures contract has a contract size of 375 and on
September 1, BHEL shares are selling at INR 2,330. You
own 750 shares of BHEL. October BHEL futures with
expiry on October 29 are selling at INR 2,352. Assume
that the spot price of BHEL shares on October 29 is INR
2,300. You plan to hedge your holding in BHEL shares.
(i) What type of hedging is appropriate?
(ii) Explain how you would hedge?
(iii) What would be the result of your hedge, that is, what
is the effective price at which you would sell the shares?
How to write answer to sub point II
• In hedging, you need to decide the futures contract you should use,
the number of contracts you need to take a short position in, when to
take an open position, and when to close the position. Since the
shares you own are on BHEL stock, you would use BHEL futures. As
you are concerned about the risk on September 1, you would take
an open position in the futures on September 1. You plan to sell on
October 29 and, therefore, you would take a short position in the
futures contract expiring on October 29, i.e., in the October futures
contract. Since you own 750 shares and the contract size is 375, you
would take a short position in two contracts. Thus, on September 1,
you would take a short position in two BHEL October futures. You
would close your position on October 29 and sell the shares in the
open market at the prevailing market price.
Problem
You believe that the share price of Biocon is likely to increase from
its price of INR 238.50 on March 15. There are futures contracts
available on Biocon with expiry on June 30 at a futures price of
INR 245. The contract size for Biocon futures is 1,800 shares. You
plan to buy 9,000 Biocon shares on June 30. Since the price at
which you can buy the Biocon shares on June 30 is uncertain on
March 15, you plan to hedge using futures.
(i) What type of hedging is appropriate?
(ii) Explain how you would hedge?
(iii) What would be the result of your hedge, that is, what is the
effective price at which you would sell the shares if the price of
Biocon shares on June 30 is INR 260?
Problem
• You believe that the share price of Biocon is likely to increase
from its price of INR 238.50 on March 15. There are futures
contracts available on Biocon with expiry on June 30 at a futures
price of INR 245. The contract size for Biocon futures is 1,800
shares. You plan to buy 9,000 Biocon shares on June 20. Since
the price at which you can buy Biocon shares on June 20 is
uncertain on March 15, you plan to hedge using futures.
(i) What type of hedging is appropriate?
(ii) Explain how you would hedge?
(iii) What would be the result of your hedge, that is, what is the
effective price at which you would sell the shares if, on June 20,
the price of Biocon shares is INR 260 and the June futures price is
INR 262?
CASE
A ADANIENT on 07/02/2023 trading at 1640.60 and you want to buy
ADANIENT 1000 shares on 29/03/2023. ADANIENT futures with expiry
29/03/2023 is available at 1545.05 with the market lot of 250. on the
basis of above information answer the following questions
i) What type of hedging is appropriate?
(ii) Explain how you would hedge?
(iii) What would be the result of your hedge, if prices of ADANIENT
changes 1730.05, 1585.10 and 1670.40
(IV) Provide suitable reason whether you should go with hedging with
ADANIENT.
Cross Hedge
You hold 3,000 shares of Gram Bank selling at INR 300 on July 1. You plan to sell them on
August 28. You are concerned about a possible price decrease and you want to hedge this
price risk using futures. You find that there are no futures contracts traded on Gram Bank.
One of your friends suggests that you can use the futures on some other bank whose price
changes are highly correlated with the price changes of the Gram Bank shares. You have
found that August futures on the Canara Bank, with a contract size of 800, are selling for
INR 265 and have a standard deviation of 15, and the correlation between the price
changes of the Canara Bank futures and Gram Bank shares is 0.86; August futures on the
HDFC Bank with a contract size of 200 are selling for INR 2,500 and have a standard
deviation of 145, and the correlation between the price changes of the HDFC Bank futures
and Gram Bank shares is 0.95. The standard deviation of the price changes of Gram bank
shares is estimated as 22. Assume that the market price of the Gram Bank, Canara Bank,
and HFDC Bank shares would be INR 310, INR 280, and INR 2,550, respectively, on
August 28.
(i) What type of hedging is appropriate?
(ii) Explain how you would hedge?
(iii) What would be the result of your hedge, that is, what is the effective price at which you
would sell the shares?
Hedging using CAPM model
• Concept of Beta
The degree of movement in the price of a share of stock with respect to movements in the market,
that is, a stock price index, is measured in terms of beta, b.
OR
Example
For given data calculate beta
Day Share price index Price of share
1 1376.15 818.35
2 1388.75 811.75
3 1408.85 819.85
4 1418.00 836.05
5 1442.85 815.65
6 1445.15 804.30
7 1438.65 801.30
8 1447.55 792.30
9 1439.70 778.30
10 1427.65 740.95
11 1398.25 718.35
12 1401.40 737.50
Interpretation of BETA
• the bench-mark, the index beta, is equal to 1.0.
• If a stock has b > 1, it is riskier than the market. – for instance
1.25 of beta of ACC
• On the other hand, if a stock has b = 0.92,