ShopNotes #21 (Vol. 04) - Router Thicknessing Jig - Text
ShopNotes #21 (Vol. 04) - Router Thicknessing Jig - Text
EDITOR’S NOTE
Donald B. Peschke
EDITOR
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Douglas L. Hicks
Cutoffs
MANAGING EDITOR Richard S. Peters
ASSOCIATE EDITORS Tim Robertson
CONTRIBUTING EDITOR
Phil Totten
Mark A. Williams
T he blink of an eye. That's all it takes
for an accident to happen in the
workshop. And unfortunately, safety is
someone he offered his letter for
else,
publication, see the box below.
I must admit, I was deeply affected
one topic that just doesn't get much by Richard's letter. After writing and
CREATIVE DIRECTOR Ted Kralicek
ART DIRECTOR Cary Christensen advance thought. thanking him for sharing his story, I felt
SENIOR ILLUSTRATOR Kurt Schultz Sure, most woodworkers wear some compelled to do something about safety.
ILLUSTRATORS Roger Reiland And often use a SAFETY. In this issue, you'll find two
type of safety glasses.
Mark Higdon
push stick. But that just isn't enough. It articles that can make your shop a safer
PHOTOGRAPHER Crayola England
ELECTRONIC GRAPHICS Chris Glowacki has to be a part of everything you do. place to work. The first article gives a
DESIGN DIRECTOR Ken Munkel The problem is that safety is one of number of ideas to help prevent kick-
SENIOR DESIGNER Kent Welsh those things you usually don't do any- back —one of the most dangerous
SHOP MANAGER Steve Curtis thing about until something happens things that can occur in the shop.
SHOP ASST./FAC1LITI ES Steve Johnson
(often with disastrous results). And if The second is a set of plans for an
CIRCULATION
you wait for an accident to happen be- Not only does
adjustable featherboard.
New Bus. Mgr.: Sandy Baum
Mail Mgr.: Dir.
Troy Dowell, Asst.: Julie Greenlee •Newsstand fore you become serious about safety, it make work on your table saw or
Sales: Kent A. Buekton •Analyst: Shane S. Francis you could find your entire life changed. router table safer, adds precision
it also
CORPORATE SERVICES inner VOICE. That's what happened to every cut or joint you make.
Plan. Dir.: Jon Macarthy Controller: Robin to Richard Suabedissen, a reader from SAFETY FIRST. One final thought. The
Hutchinson Account. Laura Thomas Bkpr.:
Holly Lucas Prod Mgr.: Carol Quijano
. Pub.
Middlesex, New Jersey. He wrote to letter Richard sent spurred us into
Serv. Mgr.: Gordon C. Gaippe Artist: Cheryl L. me about the Cutoffs in issue 17 where making our shop a safer place to work.
Cynor Info. Serv. Mgr.: J oyce Moore Elect. Pub.
I talked about an inner voice that often I hope his letter gets you thinking
Cow'd.: Douglas M. Lidster Net. Adm .: Nick
Thielen •Admin. Assists.: Cheryl Scott, Julia Fish “speaks" to woodworkers about safety. about safety in your shop too.
Recpt: Jeanne Johnson* Bldg. Maint.: Ken Giiffith In it,suggested that the secret to
I
PROJECT SUPPLIES safety is listening to this voice every
AH Dir.: Cindy Jackson Catalog Products Mgr:
time you hear it. Richard didn't. And
Bob Baker Inv. Control/Prod. Mgr.: Mark Mat-
tussi- Pro?. Supplies: Linda Jones - Tech, SuppoH: with the hope that he could prevent an
David Stone Sys. Ope?\: Tammy Aldini Ship. accident like his from happening to
Supy'.:Nancy Johnson •Fulfillment Gloria Shee-
han, Chuck Carlson, Sylvia Carey, Lany Prine
CUSTOMER SERVICE
Mgr.: JennieEnos Team Leader: Karla Cronin
Customer Service Reps.: Jennifer Murphy, Joy
A Kickback Incident
Krause, Sara Kono, Anna Cox, Lonnie Algreen, Dear Don,
Adam Best, Kristi Andrews
I’ve been using my table saw for A split second later, the blade
over 45 years for all types of wood- kicked back the waste piece. Half of
COMPUTER BULLETIN BOARD FOR WOODWORKERS working and therefore am “experi- my left thumb was on the floor, and I
• Project plans and photos to download enced.” Late one day, I was in a was holding my totally severed left
• Woodworking HelpLine
hurry to rip a 2x4 in half to make index finger in my left hand.
• Indexes for Woodsmith & ShopNotes
• First month FREE for PC or MAC 1 V2" x 1 V2" x 9"-long
garden stakes. After thirteen grueling hours of
To log on to WoodNet, 1-615-245-9663. If
call I meant
a long length first
to rip microsurgery, the surgeons gave up
you have any questions, please give us a call:
(voice) 1-515-282-7000 M-F 9-5 CST. and then cut the pieces to size. But trying to save the thumb. There was
ShopNotes © (ISSN 1062-JK596) is published bimonthly with my mind on a later phase of the no chance at all for the index finger.
(Jan., March, May, July, Sept., Nov.) by Woodsmith Cor-
Grand Ave., Des Moines, IA 50312.
poration, 2200
project, I cut them to length first. Please emphasize in your column
ShopNotes ® is a registered trademark of Woodsmith Corp.
©Copyright 1995 by Woodsmith Corporation. All
An “inner voice" told me that it again the need to “listen to the inner
rights reserved. wouldn’t be too wise to rip these voice every time you hear it.
PRINTED IN U.S.A.
blade with my left hand. Richard H. Suabedissen
2 ShopNotes No. 21
ISSUE TWENTY-ONE
* Contents
Projects & Techniques
Avoiding Kickback 4 Featherboard page 6
Safety is no accident. Here’s a close-up look at some of
the causes of kickback and what you can do to prevent it.
Weatherboard 6
A unique design lets you adjust this shop-made feath-
erboard to use on many of the tools in your shop.
Lap Peek. 11
This compact lap desk provides space inside to organize Tongue & Groove page 8
pencils and paper and a large stable surface to write on.
Thickneeeing Jig. 16
You don't need a planer to thickness stock accurately. All it
Departments
The Small Shop
Fower Toole_ 14
Which power tools are best for the small shop? Full-size,
benchtop, or combination tools?
Great Tips
Thicknessing Jig page 16
Glue-Up Tipe 20
A collection of our best tips that includes everything from
choosing the right glue to the best way to apply it.
Selecting Tools
Table Sawe 22
Our team tests six popular table saws and offers practical
suggestions on selecting a saw that will suit your needs.
ReadersTips
Shop Solutiona 28
Shop-tested solutions from our readers on their most
common woodworking problems. Plus two quick tips.
Lumberyard
Softwood Grades 30
Building a project out of softwood? Understanding the
different lumber grades can affect its cost and appearance.
Finish Room
Water-Saeed Top Coate 31
A durable finish that’s easy to use. And no messy cleanup.
All this makes water-based top coats worth a close look.
Table Saws page 22
No. 21 ShopNotes 3
SHOP SAFETY
Avoiding
Kickback
have a friend who has a piece getting pinched between the ure between the fence and one of
I of wood embedded in the wall blade and fence. Or the saw kerf the miter gauge slots — at both
behind his table saw. It's a re- closing up around the blade. In ends of the fence, see Fig. 1. (This
minder to others entering his either case, the blade grabs the assumes your saw blade is paral-
shop not to stand directly behind workpiece and propels it back- lel to the miter gauge slot.)
often the result of a workpiece allel to the blade, I simply meas- prevents the saw kerf from closing
4 ShopNotes No. 21
SHOP SAFETY
Anti-kickback Sits
you try to remove too much wood Less wood, less chance of kickback.
CMT Tools
in one pass. And even if the bit hits MULTIPLE PASSES. And one of 300 -531-5559
a knot. So it's a good idea to first the simplest ways you can reduce Anti-kickback Bits. A bit Leichtung
carefully inspect the workpiece kickback is to nibble away at the with less cutter surface ex- 300 - 321-6340
Woodworker’s Oupply
before turning on the router. wood by taking a series of shallow posed lessens the likeli-
300 645-9292
- '
Also keep in mind the other passes, see detail B below. hood of kickback.
rules for a router table. Rout in a
right-to-left direction — whether
you're using a fence or a bit with
a bearing, see drawing. Never
backrout —
this is very dangerous.
With backrouting, there's al-
ways a chance the router bit will
grab the workpiece and pull it,
along with your fingers, into the
sharp cutters.
Never rout with the workpiece
between the bit and the fence.
And always keep your fingers
safely out of the way.
ANTI-KICKBACK BITS. You can
also reduce your chances of get-
ting kickback by using anti-kick-
No. 21 ShopNotes 5
JIGS & ACCESSORIES
Featherboard
OVERALL
DIMENSIONS:
4/2"Hx34"
1
L x2}/z"D
5/w"
THREADED
WASHER KNOI3
adjustable
most other feather-
boards, this one has two identical,
hold-downs. Each
slot or
Safety Note:
deep kerf or
the height of the base.
all
When
the
cutting a
way through,
yourself is to use a featherboard. hold-down attaches to the base don’t use the second hold-down as
Afeatherboard can help you by way of a pair of carriage bolts it can pinch the kerf closed.
hold a workpiece firmly against that fit in a T-slot in the base, see base. The base of the feather-
the table top or fence. It can also drawing above. board is just a piece of 34" ply-
prevent a workpiece from kicking By loosening two knobs, each wood with a piece of Vi'-thick
back at you if the blade or bit hold-down can be positioned any- Masonite glued to one side, see
happens to grab hold of it. where along the length of the T- Fig. 1. But before gluing the Ma-
6 ShopNotes No. 21
JIGS & ACCESSORIES
Since these are going to take a lot drilling holes for the slots.
of abuse, I made them from V£'- Then remove the waste with a
thick hard maple. band saw or sabre saw and attach
To make' the hold-downs, first the hold-downs to the base with
cut two blanks to finished width the mounting hardware.
Indexing Jig
Cutting evenly-spaced kerfs on a gauge, it’s best to have the blade
featherboard hold-down is quick in this kerf so the jig is perfectly
and easy with this indexing jig. If aligned with the blade.
you’re at all familiar with how a To cut the first kerf, clamp the
box joint jig works, then you’re workpiece to the backing board
already familiar with how this so it’s tight against the pin, see
particular jig works. detail. Then make the first pass.
The jig has two saw kerfs that After the first kerf is cut, un-
are spaced Vg" apart, see drawing. clamp the workpiece and shift it
One kerf has a hardwood pin over onto the index pin. Then re-
glued in it. The other kerf lines up clamp the workpiece and take an- Perfect Kerfs The index pin makes it easy to
.
with the saw blade. Note: When other pass. Repeat this process to cut evenly-spaced kerfs. Just index the work-
screwing the jig to the miter complete all the fingers. piece on the pin between each pass.
No. 21 ShopNotes 7
TECHNIQUE
T
still
here's a good reason
many hardwood
why so
floors are
as strong and flat today as
additional glue surface.
STRENGTH. Even without glue,
a tongue and groove joint offers
the lap desk on page 12), the
breadboard ends help keep the
panel from warping.
the day they were laid down — plenty of mechanical strength. TWO TOOLS. While there are a
they're held together with Take the back of a cabinet that's number of different ways to cut a
tongue and groove joints. Even made up of a number of wood tongue and groove joint, I use a
though I don't install a lot of hard- slats for instance. To keep the simple method that's as depend-
wood floors, I still find a tongue slats flush, tongue and groove able as themorning paper.
and groove joint useful on many jointsform a strong, interlocking All it is two tools: a
takes
of the projects I build. panel, see drawing B. router to cut the tongues, and a
alignment. For example, when BREADBOARD ends. Another table saw for the grooves, see
gluing hardwood edging to a ply- way to take advantage of this photos above. The nice thing
wood shelf, it automatically strength is to attach a “bread- about this method is it doesn't
aligns the two pieces, see draw- board” end to a panel, see draw- require a special router bit or saw
ing A below. And it provides me- ing C. Whether the panel is solid blade. (I use a Vz" straight bit and
chanical support as well as wood or plywood (like the top for a combination saw blade.)
joint automatically aligns strips of strength of a tongue and groove joint flat,
hardwood edging on a plywood shelf, keeps the slats on this cabinet flush. with a tongue and groove joint.
8 ShopNotes No. 21
TECHNIQUE
The Tongue
I usually start
by cutting the
tongue. Typically,
it's centered on
the edge of the
workpiece by cut-
ting two rabbets —
one on each
face. In most cases, you can do
this quickly and easily on a
router table. But for large work-
pieces, a hand-held router
works best, see the left-hand
box below.
THICKNESS. Either way, youTl
need to adjust the depth of cut to
establish the thickness of the
tongue. A simple rule of thumb is
to make the tongue about one third
the thickness of the workpiece.
LENGTH. Another considera-
tion is the length of the tongue. ness and length of the tongue, tongue. Once you're satisfied
This is determined by the posi- more thing to do. To
there's one with the setup, you can make the
tion of the fence. The exact length hold the workpiece down flat on tongue on the “real” piece. Just
isn't critical. I usually make the the table and ensure the tongue rabbet one side of the workpiece,
tongue so it's not more than twice isa consistent thickness, clamp a see Fig. la. Then flip it over and
as long as it is thick. featherboard to the fence, see rabbet the opposite side, see Fig.
featherboard. Before mak- Fig. 1. (Plans for this feather- lb. Note: For a tip on making clean
ing a test cut to check the thick- board are shown on page 6.) cuts, see right-hand box below.
use a hand-held router and a rabbet bit than to man- (or cross-grain in hardwood) is I don't always get a
handle the workpiece on the router table. clean cut. Scoring the shoulder of the rabbet with a
Here again, the idea is to cut a rabbet on each face. knife helps, but it's hard to make this cut accurately.
But instead of a fence, the router is guided by a bearing To do this, I make a simple guide. It's just a scrap
on the bit that rides against the edge of the workpiece. piece that's routed with an identical rabbet. This rabbet
By changing the size of the bearing (or bit), you can positions the edge of the scrap along the shoulder so
vary the length of the tongue. you can score an accurate line on the workpiece.
No. 21 ShopNotes 9
TECHNIQUE
The Groove
With the tongue
complete, the
groove can be
cut to fit. In most
cases, the groove
is centered on
Assembly
There are several ways to assem- SOLID WOOD. But when join- by “pinning” a small dowel
ble a tongue and groove joint. ing two solid wood pieces, you’ll through the tongue. (I glue an Vs"
PLYWOOD. The simplest way is need to allow for movement dowel in a stopped hole.)
when one of the pieces is ply- caused by changes in humidity. SAND FLUSH. Now just sand
wood. To attach a hardwood strip To do this, apply glue only to the surfaces flush. A sanding
(or breadboard end) to the ply- the middle third of the tongue, block gives good control to avoid
wood, just glue the pieces together. see Fig. 3. Then lock each end in cross-grain scratches, see Fig. 4.
10 ShopNotes No. 21
Lap
Desk
This easy to build lap desk
organizes pencils and paper
and provides a sturdy
uniting surface as well.
C
desk.
ompact yet functional. That's
what I like about this lap
A shallow tray organizes
enough to make it comfortable to
write on, but not so steep that
paper slips around on the desk.
stand getting knocked around.
The
pieces of
solution is to combine thin
writing (or drawing) materials, Finding the best writing angle and 1
/2 -thick maple) with V4"-
see Exploded View below. And a was just a matter of experiment- thick plywood. While a single piece
top serves as a writing surface. ing abit. But the real challenge of plywood provides plenty of
To provide access to paper and was making the desk lightweight strength for the bottom, the top
pencils, the top is hinged to the so it's easy to carry (even for a isbuilt up from two layers to pro-
tray. And it's slanted — just child). Yet sturdy enough to with- duce a stable writing surface.
No. 21 ShopNotes 11
W E E K E N
Tray
The tray is just a simple wood box
that'sused to store writing and
drawing materials.
SIDES. To provide a comfort-
able writing position when the
top is added, the sides (A) of the
tray are angled, see Figs. 1 and 2.
12 ShopNotes No. 21
WEEKEND PROJECT
Squaring Up a Panel
Edges. With an overhanging edge running against the rip Ends. To trim the ends square, carpet-tape a framing square
fence, the first step is to trim the oppositeedge straight. to the panel so the short leg is flush with the back edge and
Then, after repositioning the fence, use the edge you just the long leg overhangs the end slightly. Once one end is
cut as a guide to trim the panel to final width. squared up, remove the square and cut the opposite end.
No. 21 ShopNotes 13
THE SMALL SHOP
Power Tools
for the small shop
and then, go with a bench-top tool that can be stored nect to other tools with the
out of the way when not in use. same mated connector. And
Shown here are the power tools I’d buy (in order) many dust collectors also
if Iwere outfitting a small shop today. Note: For come with castors so you can
those working in a really tight space, you might easily roll it out of the way
consider a multipurpose tool, see box on next page. when it’s not being used.
1. Table Saw. If I could only have one power tool 3. Router Table. I never realized how much of a
in my shop, would be a contractor’s table saw
it necessity a router table was until I started using one.
(refer to the table saw review starting on page 24). The router table in our shop gets used eveiy day.
The table saw in our shop is used all the time to Not only is it used for routing decorative profiles,
rip, crosscut, and miter workpieces. It’s great for but it’s also great for routing rabbets, dadoes, and
cutting rabbets and dadoes. And the large table top box joints. And with special router bits, you can
makes it easy and safe to cut even rout raised panels.
a full-size sheet of plywood. Although in many cases a
Note: From time to time hand-held router could also
you may need to move the get the job done, I’m more
saw around to make certain comfortable with the control
cuts. So it’s a good idea to also the router table offers with
invest in a set of castors or a its larger table top, adjust-
mobile base. able fence, and miter gauge.
14 ShopNotes No. 21
THE SMALL SHOP
4. Drill Press. The next tool I’d buy would be a drill 6. Compound Miter Saw. A radial arm saw is a
press. And there are a couple of ways to go here. great power tool for crosscutting and mitering. But
If you’re only going to use a drill press for drilling they take up a lot of space. And they’re not portable.
holes, you might consider a small, bench-top model. A compound-miter saw on the other hand is both
When it’s not in use, you’ll be able to store it out of portable and compact. Miter saws have been used
the way in a corner or down under a workbench. primarily by trim and finish carpenters because of
But if you’re going to drill their portability and accu-
a lot of holes, mortises, or use racy. But they’re starting to
it for sanding, you might con- find their way into many
sider a larger, full-size model. workshops —
for the same
It won’t take up much more reasons. Although smaller,
space, and have a large
you’ll you’ll find that a compound-
table top and bigger motor to miter saw will cost about the
handle the extra work. same as a radial arm saw.
5. Thickness Planer. In the past few years, the 7. Band Saw. My final tool of choice for the small
cost of owning a thickness planer has dropped like shop is the band saw. A band saw is great to have
a tackle box sinking in a lake. around if you’re going to cut a lot of curves and
For less than $400, you can choose from a number circles. Or resaw lumber —
which can save you
of quality 10" and 12" bench-top thickness planers money when you’re working with thin stock.
that should handle most of your planing needs. Again, like the other power tools, determine how
A planer in the shop means much use a band saw will get.
you won’t be limited to the If you think you’ll use one a
lumber thicknesses available lot, go with a full-size model
Multipurpose Tools
Another space-saving measure
when you’re working in a small
shop is to select a power tool that
does multiple jobs.
Many of these machines, like
Robland TotalShop, Shopsmith
, ,
combined with a belt sander. space. (Farris Machinery: 800-872-5489) (Hitachi Power Tools: 800-362-7297)
No. 21 ShopNotes 15
FEATURE PROJECT
Router
Thicknessring Jig
A
skeptics
new
will
our workshop
jig in
always draw some
—
and this thicknessing
scraping, orheavy belt sanding.
special BIT. The secret to
such a smooth finish is the special
be thicknessed down to V4 ", see
photo A below.
WIDE PANELS. Another thing I
jig for the router was no excep- router bit we used. It’s a l"-dia. like about this jig is it can be used
tion. But all it took was a couple bottom-cleaning bit, see box on to thickness glued-up panels and
of passes of the router for every- opposite page. Though the jig is wide boards, see photo B.
one to realize that not only did it designed for this bit, you could FLATTEN STOCK. One last sur-
work — it worked better than we use a normal straight bit you — priseis how effective the thick-
had hoped. just won’t end up with a surface nessing jig is at flattening a
Sure, we
expected the jig to that’s quite as smooth. cupped or warped workpiece, see
quickly thickness a board. But we THICK & THIN. The jig is also photo C. Just create a flat on one
were really surprised at how designed to thickness both thick side of the workpiece as a refer-
smooth and flat the board was. So and thin stock. It easily handles ence. Then flip the workpiece
smooth that light sanding is all stock up to 1" thick. And with the over and rout the board to the
that’s necessary — no planing, workpiece shimmed up, stock can desired thickness.
16 ShopNotes No. 21
FEATURE PROJECT
#0 X %" Fh CARRIAGE
WOODSCREW
BACKING
BOARD
HOLD-DOWN BAR
CARRIAGE CARRIAGE GUIDE
RAIL (P)
V4"\
WASHER FIXED RAIL
(ET
Va" x 4"
HEX BOLT
ADJUSTABLE PLATE
Va"
THREADED'
V
\knob— #0xV2 " Fh
WOODSCREW
(D
ADJUSTABLE RAIL
PLATFORM
Hardware
• (3) Va"- 20 Threaded Knobs
• (4) Va" x 4" Hex Bolts
• (4) Va" x 2" Carnage Bolts
• (4) Va" T-Nuts
u
• (4) Va Hex Nuts
• (4) Va" Flat Washers
• (3) # x V2 ” Fh Woodscrews
• (70) # x %" Fh Woodscrews
• (<9) # x F/i Woodscrews
D Fixed Plate (1) 3/3x4- 473/4 straight bit. But it has an addi-
E Fixed Rail (1) 3/4X1V3-473/4 tional set of cutters on the bottom
F Carriage Guide P/16 x 473/4 - V4 Mas. that are designed to “plane” the
(1)
No. 21 ShopNotes 17
FEATURE PROJECT
Construction _
The thicknessing jig consists of
two main parts: a platform that
holds the workpiece, and a car-
riage that supports the router, re-
fer to Exploded View on page 17.
PLATFORM
The platform consists of a rectan-
gular-shaped base with two jaws.
One jaw is fixed; the other is ad-
justable, see Fig. 1.
18 ShopNotes No. 21
.
FEATURE PROJECT
Setup. To secure a workpiece in the Thickness. Place carriage on plat- Flatten. To flatten a workpiece, start
jig, first position the adjustable jaw. form and rout in a left-to-right direc- with the crown side up. Once you've
Then tighten the hex bolts to move the tion. Pull carriage back to clean up “leveled" the crown, flip it over and
jaw as you lock the hold-down bar. pass. Then index router and repeat. thickness the other side.
No. 21 ShopNotes 19
GREAT TIPS
Glue-Up
Tips
There's more to applying glue than
squeezing it out of a bottle. Here are a
few tips to make the job go easier.
White Glue. Use white glue in- Tether Cap. To avoid misplacing Glue Bottle. A clean, empty
stead of yellow glue to provide on the end of a glue
the tiny cap mustard bottle makes a great
more assembly time when work- bottle, tether it to the bottle with a glue bottle. It’s free, airtight,
ing with a complex project. wire brad and a piece of string. and has a handy twist cap.
Applicators
Forcing Glue. Getting glue into Glue Spreader. An old tooth- Glue Roller. To quickly and
a tight spot can be a problem. brush is the best tool I’ve found evenly spread glue out over a
To solve this, blow through a for spreading glue. It spreads it large surface, I use a small,
straw to force the glue in place. evenly and cleans up easily. short-napped paint roller.
20 ShopNotes No. 21
GREAT TIPS
Squeeze Out
Mask Comers. Taping off inside Glue Scooper. A straw works Glue Scraper. Use a plastic clip
corners before gluing and as- great for scooping away skinned- from a bread bag to scrape
sembly reduces the time spent over beads of glue that are away skinned-over beads of
later cleaning out the corner. trapped in tight corners. glue from a flat surface.
Contact Cement
There’s really no great mystery in working with
contact cement. All you basically have to do is
area since many brands of contact cement con- evenly. To do this, I use a small, hand-size piece
tain solvents that can cause respiratory problems. of plastic laminate as a trowel.
Non-Stick Barrier. Waxed paper between Emergency Release. In the event of a disaster,
workpieces gives you a chance to make last you can separate the two workpieces by flowing
minute adjustments. Once the pieces are a liberal amount of lacquer thinner between them
aligned, pull out the paper and apply pressure. and gently peeling off one of the layers.
No. 21 ShopNotes 21
Table Saws
Our team of testers includes
three people. Ken (left) is a
professional carpenter and
cabinetmaker while Steve (cen-
ter)spends most of his time
building projects for hishouse
and shop. Cary (right) is just
setting up his shop.
T—
shops
here’s one thing I’ve noticed
about most woodworking
a table saw usually occu-
we bought six table saws, see pho-
tos below. Then we asked three
woodworkers with different in-
Much better than having loose
parts rattling around in the box
like the Grizzly and AMT saws,
pies center stage. Not just its terests and skill levels to test [gj Did you find any damaged or
physical location. But the fact them. This way, you can identify missing parts?
that a table saw is at the heart of with one of these people based on Steve: The worst damage I
almost every project built. the type of work you do — and found was on the AMT. The shaft
That’s why selecting a table choose the saw that’s best for you. that controls the angle of the
saw issuch an important deci- To ensure reliable results, we blade was bent. And the threaded
sion. After all, it’s a big invest- bought identical carbide-tipped end was ‘"filed”down by a cast
ment in money. And a good blades for each saw. Then we had iron extension wing that rubbed
quality saw provides the ground- the same person (Steve) assem- against it in shipment.
work for making straight, accu- ble and tune up all the saws. As far as missing pails, both
rate cuts and tight-fitting joints. O First impressions count For AMT and Jet forgot to pack a mi-
To make this decision easier, example ivhat did you think of
,
ter gauge along with the rest of
Model G1022
AMT $375
Model 4572
$445
22 ShopNotes No. 21
.
SELECTING T
the saw. And the belt and pulley from vibrating loose. Maybe
guard was missing from the Jet. that's why it's so sturdy.
Fortunately, customer service But with the heaviest gauge
was helpful, and it only derailed metal of all of the stands, the
me a few days. Delta is also rock solid. (See photo
That gave you some extra time below.) At first, I thought the the Sears saw is much more complicated
to look over the manuals. Were closed panels on the Grizzly and to assemble than the other saws.
some more helpful than others? AMT stands might compensate
Steve: Some manuals (like the for their thinnergauge metal. sides the fact that adjusting the
Jet and Delta) were like having a But these stands wiggled even linkages on these arms is like
good road map —
clear illustra- after I'd assembled the saws. wrestling an octopus, they block
tions and easy-to-follow direc- ES One thing 1 noticed is the blade my sight of the blade.
tions. But using the AMT manual guard on the Grizzly is different The plastic guards on the other
required a lot of guesswork — than the rest? Is different better? saws are easier to see through.
especially when wiring the motor. Steve: Don't count on it. The And with the exception of the
Even was as
a manual that Grizzly guard has two metal arms Delta, they stay up out of the way
thick as a book didn't make it any that move independently. Be- when I'm changing blades.
easier to assemble the Sears saw.
(See photo above.) In fact, it took
me twice as long as the other saws.
One thing I appreciated is the
straightforward approach in the
Grizzly manual. It makes no bones
about the fact you might be short
a piece of hardware (as it turned
out, I wasn't) or that you may
have to file the sharp edges and
bun's (plan on doing some filing).
What about the metal stands
on the saws?
Steve: What sticks in my mind
is is held together
the Jet stand Stands Heavy-gauge metal and a wide stance create a stable
.
with forty bolts. And each bolt base for the Delta saw (left). But the Grizzly stand (right) tends to
has a lock washer to keep the nut wobble, even with solid panels on the front and back
Sears
Model 29336
$499
Model TWT5 10JF
$579
Powermatic
Model 63 $679
No. 21 ShopNotes
SELECTING TOOLS
Saw Tab\e
B&Each saiv has a heavy cast ,
the reason hit home. Instead of smoothly over the beveled edge der a straightedge reveal a
clunking against the edge of the on the Jet and Delta saw tables. “dish” in the Grizzly saw table.
saw miter gauge rides
table, the
smoothly over the bevel. 08 Speaking ofinseHs what ivere
,
screwed in place. But it drives me
05 Did you check out the flatness you looking for? nuts getting a screwdriver out
of the table top? Steve: One that’s sturdy and every time I change blades.
Ken: That’s not some- won’t flex — like the heavy- Cary: Something that bugged
thing that drastically gauge Delta and Jet inserts. me when I changed blades on the
AMT affects a cut. But a table These inserts also had more rib- Jet saw is the opening for the
that’s absolutely flat does bing for support than the AMT, insert is V4 " narrower than the
give me an idea of the overall Grizzly, or Powermatic inserts. other saws. So I had to scrunch up
quality of the saw. And I’m al- (See margin photos.) my hand to thread on the arbor
ways using my saw table as a ref- Cary: Another thing about nut — especially when I put on a
erence for establishing the flat- both the Delta and Jet inserts is full width dado blade.
ness of a workpiece. there’s a finger hole that makes it 05 One thing we haven't talked
So I like the dead on
flat tables easy to lift them out when I about is the extension wings that
the Jet and Sears saws. While change blades. The AMT and bolt to the saw tables.
there’s a slight hump in the Delta Grizzly inserts don’t have finger Steve: Originally, I was leaning
table, the other tables are holes. And they fit so tight I had toward the cast iron extension
“dished” in the middle. to poke a stick up through the wings on the Sears, Grizzly, AMT,
(See the right-hand back of the saw to pop them out. and Powermatic saws. (See pho-
Sears photo above.) Ken: My pet peeve is an insert tos below.) After all, the more
Steve: Also, the grind- that rattles when you turn on the mass the better when it comes to
ing on the Jet and Delta saw. The AMT and Powermatic dampening vibration.
was smoother than the
tables solve that problem with spring But when I pinched my finger
other saws. Especially compared clips that press against the sides in one of the openings as I was
to the AMT and Grizzly that were of the saw table around the open- sliding the rip fence, I started be-
gouged around the opening for ing. And there’s no vibration with lieving in stamped steel
the
the insert. the Sears insert either since it’s wings on the Delta and Jet saws.
Extension Wings. Heavy-gauge provide plenty of support when wings on this Sears saw (right),
stamped steel extension wings crosscutting a long board. And there are no sharp edges to ae-
on the Delta and Jet saws (left) unlike the open-grid cast iron cidentally “catch” your fingers.
24 ShopNotes No. 21
SELECTING T
Miter Gauge
Slots . A straight slot like on the Sears and AMT saws (left) makes it
easy to insert the bar on the miter gauge. But it doesn lock the miter
’t
gauge in the slot like the T-shaped slot on the other saws (right).
edge of the table. But with a large there’s no consistency from one
workpiece, the T-shaped slot on slot to the other either.
the other saws is a big help. 0 What about the adjustments
That’s because there’s a special /or the preset stops at 45° and 90°?
washer attached to the end of the Steve: Except for the Sears, all
bar that locks the miter gauge in the miter gauges use a metal tab
the T-slot —
even when I pull it as a stop. (See right-hand mar-
all the way back. As a result, I gin.) But there’s enough flex in
don’t have to worry about sup- the tabs on the Grizzly, AMT, and
porting the miter gauge and the Powermatic that it’s hard to re- screws on the AMT miter
workpiece at the same time. turn to the same setting over and gauge aren’t as handy. And a flimsy metal
Cary: I think the T-slots are a over again. The sturdier tabs on stop makes it less accurate.
hassle. Every time I use the mi- the Jet and Delta produced a
ter gauge, I have to slide the bar much more positive stop.
into the slot from either the front Ken: The Sears miter gauge
or back of the saw. So I’d just take has a different stop system —a
off the washer. pin that slips into a slot in the
ES Regardless of the shape what ,
back of the miter gauge. It’s a
did you notice about the fit of the good, solid stop. But I can’t adjust
bar in the slot? one stop without affecting all of
Ken: I was impressed by the fit them. And if I’m cutting miters
of the bar on the Grizzly miter for a frame where accuracy is
gauge —
like a well-machined critical, that’s a real headache.
No. 21 ShopNotes 25
SELECTING TOOLS
Rip Fence
Guide Rails. Regardless of the shape, the rails that aluminum channel on the Jet (left) and the round tube
guide the fence should be rigid and strong. In
rip on the Powermatic (center) provided a smoother
addition to being the most solid guide rails, the action than the angle rails on the Sears saw (right).
SI The rip fence can make or fences across the rails sounds like the saw table?
break a saw. So how do the fences you’re dragging a piece of iron Ken: That’s something I look at
stack up against each other? across concrete. And the Seal’s closely —
especially since I resaw
Cary: That’s where I noticed a fence lurches like a beginner learn- a lot of thick stock into thin boards.
big difference. Starting with how ing to drive a stick shift. And I can’t do it accurately if the
smoothly the fences on the Jet Steve: Even more important to fence isn’t square to the table.
and Powermatic glide across the me is whether the fence locks par- What I found is all the fences
guide rails. (See photos above.) allel to the blade. There’s nothing are flat and square except the
Although the fence on the more frustrating than having to Sears and Grizzly. Adjusting the
Delta saw doesn’t slide as easily, measure the distance from the guide rails is supposed to square
it’s definitely a step above the fence to the front and back of the up the Sears fence. But it’s a
AMT and Grizzly. Sliding these blade every time I make a cut. chore. Especially compared to a
The only fences I simple, built-in adjustment on
found that locked paral- the Powermatic.
Locking Mechanisms lel consistently are the [3 Hoiv accurately can you posi-
Jet, Delta, and Power- tion the Hp fence?
Some fences (like the Jet and Powermatic) lock only matic. There’s so much Cary: I got spoiled by how easy
on the front guide rail, see top drawing. While you’d slop in the locking mecha- it is to read the indicators on the
expect these fences to deflect when making a cut, nism on the AMT and Jet, Powermatic, and Sears fences.
they’re rock solid. And unlike most of the other fences Grizzly fences, I can’t rely (See photos below.) The pointers
that are secured on the front and back (bottom
rails on them. And it’s like spit- on the other saws aren’t quite as
drawing), they lock parallel to the blade every time. ting in the wind trying to accurate. And on the AMT and
keep the Seal’s fence ad- Grizzly, I can’t even see the num-
justed to lock parallel. bers on the scale because they’re
O What about the face of hidden by the casting that holds
the fence? Is it square to the fence on the rail.
26 ShopNotes No. 21
SELECTING TOOLS
Switches. Unlike the small toggle grope around to find the rail- Motors. An enclosed fambdbled motor
switch mounted on the Delta saw mounted switches on the Jet (left) protects against dust that can cause
cabinet (left), you don’t have to (center) or the Sears saw (right). overheating in an open motor (right).
RECOMMENDATIONS
Ken: Picking one table saw out of Steve: All through the test, two Cary: That's a tough one. I was
the bunch is easy for me —
I'd go saws kept coming to the top — impressed with the fence, the
with the Jet in a heartbeat. the Delta and the Jet. strong-running motor, and the
I especially liked the smooth The fit and finish of these saws dust-hookup on the Powermatic.
action of the fence and the alumi- is excellent. And the heft and ma- But the Jet has all that and
num guide rail. And since it locks chining of the parts told me more, so I chose it instead. Mainly
parallel to the blade every time, I they're built with quality in mind. because of its attention to detail.
can rely on it for accurate setups. But when push comes to shove, A sturdy base. The beveled front
Finally,with all the plywood I cut, the smooth, accurate fence on the edge on the saw table. Even a
its 30" rip capacity is a real bonus. Jet makes it my first choice. handy rail-mounted switch.
No. 21 ShopNotes 27
TIPS & TECHNIQUES
Shop Solutions
Small Piece Miter Gauge
I make a lot of small picture The runner rides in the miter
frames for gifts —
the challenge gauge slot for accuracy. And the
is mitering the ends of these workpiece can be clamped to
small pieces accurately. It’s diffi- either of the sides closest to the
cult to hold them when using my blade, see photo.
standard miter gauge. To make the jig, cut four pieces
To solve this problem, I’ve of stock for the sides. Simple rab-
made a jig designed for small bet joints help align the pieces
pieces. It’s nothing more than a during glue-up, see drawing.
shallow box attached to a runner. (Note: Size the box so it clears the
blade when it’s attached to the
runner, see detail in drawing)
SEE DETAIL
To strengthen the sides of the
box, glued a piece of V4 " Ma-
I
Centering Dadoes
The wobble type dado blade I width (usually V4 "). Then use a measurement to the insert and
use with my table saw does a combination square to measure mark or file a notch to indicate
great job of cutting dadoes. But from the miter gauge slot to the the centerline.
setting the rip fence to accurately center of one of the saw teeth, see Rex Lawrence
position the dado can be a real drawing. Finally, transfer this Heber City Utah ,
28 ShopNotes No. 21
HililllT
Drill Preee l-3eam
Drilling holes in small pieces is couple of wing nuts. Make sure
a problem on the drill press. you bolt it in at least two slots to
Small pieces are difficult to prevent the table from twisting.
clamp, and if you try to hold them Note: When the top gets chewed
with your hand, they want to spin up with use, just flip the table
when the bit breaks through the over and use the other side.
back side. To prevent injury, I Charles Broivnold
made an auxiliary table to hold Davis California
,
Glue Moat
Cleaning up excess glue from a
project can be time consuming.
Especially around molding. To
solve this problem, Til use a glue
“moat.” It’s just an extra saw kerf
cut on one of the strips of mold-
ing. This way when the pieces are
clamped together, any glue
squeeze-out collects in the moat.
David Dale
Murrieta, California
No. 21 ShopNotes 29
L U M B E R Y A R
*
Softwood Grades
I’m having a tough time making that there are seven organiza- beryards carry only two or three
sense out of all the different soft- tions softwood rules
writing grades of softwood lumber.
wood “lby ” lumber grades. One which regulate over 20 grading GRADES. Softwood that’s gen-
local building center cames Se- inspection agencies throughout erally knot-free with a consistent
lect , Quality and Standard pine.
,
North America. color is assigned one of the “Se-
Another sells D-Select , #2, and #3 These inspection agencies pro- lect” or “Finish” grades, see top
Common pine. Their prices are vide a standardized system for photo below. Depending on the
competitive ,
but I’m confused. grading forest products pro- mill where the lumber was proc-
Am I missing something here? duced in their particular region. essed, you might see boards
C. M. Houghton This system keeps the saw- graded B& Better, Clear, Select,
Boston Massachusetts
,
mills in each region on the same C& Better, D-Select, or Finish.
playing field to ensure their cus- If you don’t mind knots (or
sounds to me like they’re
It tomers get a consistent product. that’s the look you’re after), then
both selling the same three For the most part, each agency go with a board graded “Com-
Softwood grades of lumber —
they’re just mon.” Of the “commons,” a #1 or
lumber grades going about it differently. The #2 Common board will have the
can be confus-
ing — unless
first building center is probably
attaching their own marketing aw fewest number of knots, see bot-
tom photo below. A #3 Common
name to each of the three grades. will have more knots, and so on.
you know what The other is selling the same (or (For more on softwood grades
to look for. similar) product under the grade send $2 to: Western Wood Prod- 1
name it was given at the sawmill. Grade Stamp. This Western Wood ucts Assoc., Dept SN, 522 5th Ave.
STAMP & TAG. What you’ll have Products stamp indicates this is S.W, Portland, OR 97204-2122.)
to do is compare the lumber your- a #2 & Better Common board SPECIES. Another thing to con-
self. The lower grades should that's ponderosa pine or lodge- sider is all softwood isn’t the same.
have a grade stamp on the face of pole pine. It came from mill #422 The stack at the lumberyard
each board, see photo at right. and was planed after it was dried. might be ponderosa pine, larch, or
Higher grades aren’t stamped, Douglas fir from Oregon or Wash-
but they might have a grade tag follows the same basic rules. But ington. It might be white pine
stapled to one end. many assign their own names to from New Hampshire. Or south-
Comparing the stamps (or the different grades. Also, each ern yellow pine from Georgia.
tags) and appearance, allows you uses a different grade stamp, In fact, the stack could be a
to compare apples to apples. which might explain why there’s mixture of different softwoods.
rules. But there is a catch some confusion at the retail level. It’s common for western sawmills
here. You need to keep in mind The good news is, most lum- to mix ponderosa pine with lodge-
pole pine. Lumber marketed as
SPF lumber can be a combination
Select or Finish (B&Btr., Clear, C&Btr., or D-Select) of spruces, pines, and some true
firs. And “white wood” can be a
•a > > .
30 ShopNotes No. 21
FINISH R
* Water-Based
Top Coats
W hen water-based top coats
first came out, I
an old dog learning new tricks.
After all, they looked and acted
was like
walnut or cherry. To get this am-
ber color, you can add small
amounts of water soluble aniline
dyes to the finish.
use a paint pad, see photo C.
thin coat. Whether you use a
brush or pad, the key is to apply
as thin a coat as possible. (If
differently than the solvent- RAISES GRAIN. Another thing you’re used to solvent-based
based finishes I’d been using. to be aware of is water in the products, it will feel like you’re
What surprised me the most is finish will raise the grain of the working too “dry.”)
water-based top coats dry incred- wood and leave a rough surface. The idea is to lay the finish on
ibly fast. Depending on the But easy to minimize this by
it’s in the direction of the grain.
weather, I can apply two or even sanding with finer grit sandpaper Then go back over it (one time
three coats in one day. Yet they than you normally would (up to only) in the same direction.
still produce a hard, du- Although it’s tempt-
rable finish. All it takes are a few simple tricks ing to continue to work
Another thing I like the finish, it’s best to
Sources
to get a professional-looking finish
about water-based top leave it alone. Any brush Woodworkers’ Store
coats is they don’t smell with water-based top coats. marks or bubbles that 300 -279-4441
JDad. And you can apply a form will soon disappear Woodcraft
fenish in a basement without wor- Then, after the first coat
220-grit.) as the finish levels out. 300 -225-1153
rying about the risk of fire. Even dries, knock off the “whiskers” ADDITIONAL COATS. After the Wood&mith Shop
300-444-7002
clean-up is easier — just use with 320-grit sandpaper. finish dries, I use an abrasive pad
warm water and soap. FILTER. Before applying the (like a Scotch-Brite pad) to re-
While I appreciate all these finish, it’s a good idea to filter it, see move any dust “nibs.” (Steel wool
things about water-based top photo A below. That’s because the can leave tiny splinters that will
coats, they do have a few quirks solids in the finish can form small rust.)Then wipe the surface with
that I had to get used to. lumps like curds in cottage cheese. a damp rag and apply another coat.
COLOR. Even though the finish APPLICATION. Since the finish BRANDS. There are a number of
appears milky when you pour it sets up fast, it’s important to brands of water-based top coats.
out of the container, it dries clear. work quickly when applying a Two brands that work well for me
The fact that it doesn’t “yellow” water-based top coat. A syn- are Carver Tripp (available at
light coloredwoods (like pine or bnish works well on
thetic bristle many hardware stores) and Envi-
maple) is great. But I miss the small projects, see photo B. But ronmental Friendly water-based
“warm” color on dark woods like to cover large surfaces quickly, I finishes, see margin for sources.
A. Filter. To strain out any lumps in the B. Brush. A synthetic bristle brush C. Pad. For large surfaces, a paint pad
finish, pour it through a paper paint (nylon or polyester) helps lay down a works best. It loads well and lets you
filter into a plastic (or glass) container. smooth coat of finish on small pieces. apply the finish quickly and evenly.
No. 21 ShopNotes 31
Scenes bom the Shop
A Can't decide which table saw to buy? Our team of A This adjustable featherboard attaches to your
woodworkers tests sixpopular models under $700 and router table (or table saw) to ensure a precision cut.
offers practical suggestions on what to look for. At the same time it reduces the chance of kickback.
,
A With a sturdy writing surface that as a handy drafting table. And its
and materials, this lap desk doubles the desk conveniently out of the ivay.