Chapter 5
Chapter 5
Chapter 5: Waterjetting
Objectives
When this module is complete, you will have knowledge and understanding of:
• Standards
• Equipment and systems
• Operations
• Operator technique considerations
• Special considerations
• Inspection concerns
• Inspection checklist
5.1 Introduction
Waterjetting: NACE WJ-1/SSPC-SP WJ-1, NACE WJ-2/SSPC-SP WJ-2, NACE WJ-3/SSPC-
SP WJ-3, NACE WJ-4/SSPC-SP WJ-4 describe the use of a high-energy water stream to strip
off existing coatings and remove contaminants on a substrate being prepared prior to coat-
ings application. When compared to abrasive blasting, this method has certain advantages
particularly for safety and environmental control. Respiratory protection requirements are
less stringent and waste (abrasive) disposal is not an issue because water is the medium.
The term waterjetting denotes the use of “water only,” without the addition of solid particles
such as sand or garnet in the water stream. Modern waterjetting equipment produces pres-
sures of up to 90,000 psig. However, as technology improves, equipment with higher operat-
ing pressures may be developed.
This cleaning method is particularly well suited to the marine, process and utility (power
plants) industries, where high-performance coatings require extensive surface preparation
and/or surface decontamination with minimal effect on surrounding equipment and the
environment. In the marine industry, waterjetting is widely used to remove marine growth,
depleted antifouling coatings, and surface preparation of tank/ hold interiors. Data also
proves it is effective in removing marine growth on offshore structure's jackets (submerged
sections).
It is very important to remember that while waterjetting will remove contaminants and
millscale at varying pressures, it will not create an anchor profile, which plays a critical role
in coatings adhesion. In maintenance and repair operations, waterjetting exposes the exist-
ing anchor profile (if there is one).
Waterjetting NACE WJ-1/SSPC-SP WJ-1, NACE WJ-2/SSPC-SP WJ-2, NACE WJ-3/SSPC-
SP WJ-3, NACE WJ-4/SSPC-SP WJ-4 also addresses water cleaning which is basically the
same process at lower pressures. It is important for inspectors to understand these terms and
the working pressures associated with them.
In comparing water cleaning with waterjetting, these definitions apply:
Low-Pressure Water Cleaning (LP WC): Cleaning performed at pressures below 34 MPa
(5,000 psig). This is also called “power washing” or “pressure washing.”
High-Pressure Water Cleaning (HP WC): Cleaning performed at pressures of 34 to 70 MPa
(5,000 to 10,000 psig).
High-Pressure Waterjetting (HP WJ): Waterjetting performed at pressures from 70 to 210
MPa (10,000 to 30,000 psig).
Ultrahigh-Pressure Waterjetting (UHP WJ): Waterjetting performed at pressures above
210 MPa (30,000 psig).
5.2 Standards
The joint NACE/SSPC standards for abrasive blast cleaning are complete and clearly
define the surface conditions to be achieved. However, when and if specifications are being
written for surface preparation utilizing waterjetting, the 4 standards (WJ-1, WJ-2, WJ-3,
WJ-4) which replaced NACE No. 5/SSPC-SP-12 should be referenced.
Clean to Bare Substrate (WJ-1) is the waterjet cleaning equivalent to the International
Organization for Standardization (ISO)(1) 8501-12 degree of cleanliness Sa3, cleaning to
bare metal. ISO 8501-43 notes the use of various common terms for methods of waterjet
cleaning: waterjetting, water blast cleaning, hydrojetting, aquajetting, hydroblasting, aquab-
lasting, and “cleaning by directing a jet of pressurized water onto the surface to be cleaned.”
Within the hierarchy of degrees of surface cleanliness achieved by waterjet cleaning, Clean
to Bare Substrate (WJ-1) is intended to be similar to the degree of surface cleanliness of
NACE No. 1/SSPC-SP 5,4 except that stains are permitted to remain on the surface. Section
2.1.2 of the standard states, “Gray to brown-black discoloration remaining on corroded and
pitted carbon steel that cannot be removed by further cleaning is allowed.”
Very Thorough Cleaning (WJ-2) is essentially equivalent to the International Organization
for Standardization (ISO)(1) 8501-42 degree of cleanliness Wa 2.5, very thorough cleaning.
ISO 8501-4 notes the use of various common terms for methods of waterjet cleaning: water-
jetting, water blast cleaning, hydrojetting, aquajetting, hydroblasting, aquablasting, and
“cleaning by directing a jet of pressurized water onto the surface to be cleaned.”
Within the hierarchy of degrees of surface cleanliness achieved by waterjet cleaning, Very
Thorough Cleaning (WJ-2) is intended to be similar to the degree of surface cleanliness of
NACE No. 2/SSPC-SP 10,3 except that tightly adherent material, rather than only stains, is
permitted to remain on the surface.
Thorough Cleaning (WJ-3) is essentially equivalent to the International Organization for
Standardization (ISO)(1) 8501-42 degree of cleanliness Wa 2, thorough cleaning. ISO 8501-4
notes the use of various common terms for methods of waterjet cleaning: waterjetting, water
blast cleaning, hydrojetting, aquajetting, hydroblasting, aquablasting, and “cleaning by
directing a jet of pressurized water onto the surface to be cleaned.”
Within the hierarchy of degrees of surface cleanliness achieved by waterjet cleaning, Thor-
ough Cleaning (WJ-3) is intended to be similar to the degree of surface cleanliness of NACE
No. 3/SSPC-SP 6,3 except that tightly adherent material, rather than only stains, is permitted
to remain on the surface; and to the degree of surface cleanliness of NACE No. 8/SSPC-SP
14,4 Industrial Blast Cleaning, which allows tightly adherent material to remain on the sur-
face.
Light Cleaning (WJ-4) is essentially equivalent to the International Organization for Stan-
dardization (ISO)(1) 8501-42 degree of cleanliness Wa 1, light cleaning. ISO 8501-4 notes the
use of various common terms for methods of waterjet cleaning: waterjetting, water blast
cleaning, hydrojetting, aquajetting, hydroblasting, aquablasting, and “cleaning by directing a
jet of pressurized water onto the surface to be cleaned.”
Within the hierarchy of degrees of surface cleanliness achieved by waterjet cleaning, Light
Cleaning (WJ-4) is intended to be similar to the degree of surface cleanliness of NACE No.
4/SSPC-SP 7,3 except that tightly adherent material, rather than only stains, is permitted to
remain on the surface.
An example of a specification statement is: “All surfaces to be recoated shall be cleaned in
accordance with NACE WJ-1/SSPC-SP WJ-1 Joint Standard. The method of HP WJ or UHP
WJ ultimately selected by the contractor will be based on his confidence in the capabilities of
the equipment and its components.”
If non visible contaminants are to be addressed the specifier, inspector, and contractor must
agree on the test methods to determine the amount of non visible contaminants that can be
left on the prepared substrate. Consult the manufacturer of the specified coatings to deter-
mine the coating's tolerance to the surface conditions after waterjetting, commensurate with
the in-service conditions.
The definition of visible and non visible contamination is as follows:
Non Visible contamination (NV) is the presence of organic matter, such as very thin films
of oil and grease, and inorganic and/or soluble ionic materials such as chlorides, ferrous
salts, and sulfates that remain on the substrate.
Visible surface cleanliness (VC) is the visible condition of the substrate when viewed with-
out magnification and after cleaning.
The degrees of cleanliness defined in WJ-1 through WJ-4 are defined as follows:
WJ-3 Thorough Cleaning: A metal surface after Thorough Cleaning, when viewed without
magnification, shall have a matte (dull mottled) finish and shall be free of all visible oil, grease,
dirt, rust, and other corrosion products except for randomly dispersed stains of rust and other
corrosion products, tightly adherent thin coatings, and other tightly adherent foreign matter.
The staining or tightly adherent foreign matter shall be limited to no more than 33% of each
unit area of surface and may consist of randomly dispersed stains of rust and other corrosion
products or previously applied coating, tightly adherent thin coatings, and other tightly adher-
ent foreign matter.
WJ-4 Light Cleaning: A metal surface after Light Cleaning, when viewed without magnifica-
tion, shall be free of all visible oil, grease, dirt, dust, loose mill scale, loose rust and other corro-
sion products, and loose coating. Any residual material shall be tightly adherent to the metal
substrate and may consist of randomly dispersed stains of rust and other corrosion products or
previously applied coating, tightly adherent thin coatings, and other tightly adherent foreign
matter.
It goes on to explain that coatings, mill scale, and foreign matter are considered tightly adher-
ent if they cannot be removed when lifting with a dull putty knife.
A unit area of surface is an area approximately 5,800 mm2 [9.0 inches2] (i.e., a square 76 mm
by 76mm) [3.0 inches x 3.0 inches].
The inspector and contractor should know that surfaces prepared by LP WC, HP WC, HP
WJ, or UHP WJ do not exhibit the hue of a dry abrasive-blasted steel surface. After waterjet-
ting, the matte finish color of clean steel surface immediately turns to a golden hue unless an
inhibitor is used or environmental controls are employed. However, the use of any inhibitor
outside of the specification requirement is never encouraged. The use of any such inhibitor
without the written approval of the coatings manufacturer can result in the voiding of all
performance warranties from the manufacturer. On older steel surfaces that have areas of
coating and areas that are coating free, the matte finish color varies even though all visible
surface material has been removed. Color variations in steel can range from light gray to
dark brown/black.
Prepared steel surfaces show variations in texture, shade, color, tone, pitting, flaking, and
mill scale that should be considered during the cleaning process. Acceptable variations in
appearance that do not affect surface cleanliness include variations caused by type of steel or
other metals, original surface condition, thickness of the steel, weld metal, mill fabrication
marks, heat treating, heat-affected zones, and differences in the initial abrasive-blast clean-
ing or in the waterjet cleaning pattern.
The gray or brown-to-black discoloration seen on corroded and pitted steel after water-jet-
ting cannot be removed by further water-jetting. A brown-black discoloration of ferric oxide
may remain as a tightly adherent thin film on corroded and pitted steel and is not consid-
ered part of the percentage staining.
Additional technical considerations:
waterjet cleaned carbon steel is not the same as flash rust. Metals other than carbon steel can
manifest discoloration as well. Degrees of flash rust may be qualitatively described as fol-
lows:
No Flash Rust - A carbon steel surface that, when viewed (Slide) without magnification,
exhibits no visible flash rust.
Light (L) flash rusted surface: A carbon steel surface that, when viewed without magnifica-
tion, exhibits small quantities of a rust layer through which the carbon steel substrate may be
observed. The rust or discoloration may be evenly distributed or present in patches, but it is
tightly adherent and not easily removed by lightly wiping with a cloth.
Moderate (M) flash rusted surface: A carbon steel surface that, when viewed without mag-
nification, exhibits a layer of rust that obscures the original carbon steel surface. The rust
layer may be evenly distributed or present in patches, but it is reasonably well adherent and
leaves light marks on a cloth that is lightly wiped over the surface.
Heavy (H) flash rusted surface: A carbon steel surface that, when viewed without magnifi-
cation, exhibits a layer of heavy rust that hides original carbon steel surface completely. The
rust may be evenly distributed or present in patches, but it is loosely adherent, easily comes
off, and leaves significant marks on a cloth that is lightly wiped over the surface.
Appendix B of WJ-1 provides additional information on methods of assessing the degree of
flash rust.
Water cleaning (WC) is the use of pressurized water (<10,000 psig) discharged from a nozzle
to remove unwanted matter from a surface.
Standard waterjetting is using water of sufficient purity and quality that it does not impose
additional contaminants on the surface being cleaned and does not contain sediments or
other impurities that are destructive to the proper functioning of waterjetting equipment.
A commercial waterjet unit can be skid, trailer, or truck-mounted and usually consists of
pumps, hoses, a prime mover (diesel, electric, etc.), along with various tools such as guns,
nozzles, lances, etc.
The high-pressure hose, hose connections, and all other equipment, including the nozzle
control valve, lance, and nozzle, should have minimum burst strength of 2½ times the capa-
bility of its maximum-rated operating strength.
High-pressure hoses are fitted with a safety device known as a whip-lock or whip check.
This is a short length of cable or wire looped over each end of two hoses connected by a cou-
pling. The whip-lock or whip check prevents the ends of the hoses from whipping around if
the coupling breaks.
The section of hose next to the gun is fitted with a hose shroud, which usually is a short
length of heavy-duty hose placed over the high-pressure hose to provide instantaneous pro-
tection if the hose bursts. A hose shroud also can be used over other hose connections. The
shroud, however, does not form a permanent barrier to the flow of water from a damaged
hose or broken connection.
A unique features is that it collects in excess of 95% of the water, removed coatings and rust
(waste generated). The coatings and water are transported to a filtration bag, where the
waste is contained for future disposal. The water drains out at a clarity level generally accept-
able for treated sewers. However, check with area authorities before disposing untreated
waste in the sewage system.
A standard 40,000-psi direct-drive pump powers the unit. A vacuum system process that
provides suction, attaches the HydroCat® to the work surface where it conveys removed
coatings and water to the filtration bag mentioned earlier.
This unit is used on vertical surfaces such as ship hulls and tanks on horizontal surfaces such
as flat decks and on overhead surfaces such as the bottom of ship hulls. It also works well
over weld seams, doubler plates, lap joints and riveted seams, and moves easily in and
around keel blocks and other common obstructions. For straight-line work, it uses an “auto-
path” control feature.
5.5.1 Nozzles/Tips
As stated earlier, orifices or tips produce waterjets. Round jets are the most commonly used,
but other shapes are available. A reliable round jet can produce waterjets at 240 MPa (35,000
psig). Tips are available that emit multiple jets of water that rotate to achieve higher removal
rates.
The round jets are cutters, and fan jets are scrapers and/or pushers. The interchangeable
nozzle tips are what produce the desired streams. A typical water flow rate is 4 to 53 L/min
(1 to 14 gal/min).
5.5.4 Safety
Safety systems include hose shrouds to protect from
high-pressure hose bursts and “deadman” controls
to prevent the waterjetting system from being acci-
dentally activated.
Before beginning work, the waterjet team should
ensure that:
• The work area is properly barricaded with
appropriate warning signs.
Figure 5.12 Typical Braided Hose
• Electrical equipment is properly covered and
protected from the water.
• Electrical connections do not sit in water.
• All fittings and hoses are in good condition (not worn or damaged) and have the
proper pressure rating for the working pressure to be used.
• Nozzles are open and free of obstructions.
• The complete system is flushed clean and air removed from the system before install-
ing the nozzle.
• The dump system and all control systems are operational.
• All relevant moving equipment, such as conveyors, mixers, etc., are mechanically or
electrically disabled, with appropriate lock-out provisions including the determination
of confined space entry requirements.
As a practical matter all personnel involved with the waterjetting, washing, and cleaning
operation should obtain, study, and be familiar with, all regulations and safety procedures
that apply.
The waterjetting unit shall have a pressure-control relief valve (deadman valve), which
immediately interrupts the flow of water when the operator releases the trigger (this is simi-
lar to the deadman valve on a typical abrasive blasting hose). The operator may use a
shrouded foot valve to control the flow of water to gun.
As with all standards the inspector who will be working on a Waterjetting project should
become familiar and knowledgeable with all aspects of the Waterjetting standards (WJ-1
through WJ-4).
Key Terms Definitions
Non Visible Contamination (NV): The presence of organic matter, soluble ion materials,
and/or sulfates that remain on the substrate after cleaning that cannot be seen with the
naked eye.
Visible Surface Cleanliness (VC): The visible condition of the substrate, when viewed with-
out magnification, after cleaning.
Waterjetting: The use of standard jetting water discharged from a nozzle at pressures of 70
MPa (10,000 psig) or greater, to prepare a surface for coating or inspection.
Study Guide
1. Is the WJ-1 (Visual cleanliness) comparable to any abrasive blast cleaning standard?
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________