TestReport BV

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 120

CAUTION

THIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY OF


IMC CO,LTD AND SUCH CLAIMS
TREATMENT AS A CONFIDENTIAL
DOCUMENT PRODUCTION,COPYING
TRACING,UTILiZATiON FOR PURPOSES
OTHER THAN AGREED,DISCLOSURE
TO A THIRD PARTY,ARE STRICTRY
SUB」 ECT TO PRIOR WRITTEN
AGREEMENT BYIMC

Scanttings approved for a rYlinirnum draught fonハ lard of 4.536m. In heavy


weather conditions the foMard draught should not be less than this vatue.if,
in the opinion of the Master, sea conditions are likety to cause regular
SiarYlrning, then other appropriate measures such as change in speed,
heading orincrease in draughtfonⅣ ard rィ lay also need to be taken.

BUREAU VERITAS Section .................... 26388K 26388K


BUREAU VERITAS Register : .............................
longitudinal strength
REVIEWED for ......................................... Document checked for STABILITY
................................................................... purposes under the conditions stated on the
................................................................... ATTACHED REPORT N•‹ 1315/LC

................................................................... Kobe, 10-Jun-2015


only for parts concerning Classification.
All particulars not shown on this drawing and concerning
[Electronic document]
Classification to be as per Rules.

Kobe, 10-Jun-2015

[Electronic document]
The plan approval office

0 9th June Prepared for"ABY PAOLAW く

2015 (」 MU SNO.5041) 孟A4L 纂


NO DATE DESCRIPTION DRAWN DESIGNED CHECKED APPROVED

SCALE
'IABY PAOLA''(JMU SNO.5041)
60,000 MTDW BULK CARRIER(F60)
Test Report
lST ANGLE
for
PROJECTiON
Loading Computerr stability Computer
3RD ANGLE
(SHIPMANACER‐ 88)
PROJECTION
JOB NO CLASS
SPSll13 BV
DRAWING NO. REV
IMCITsyStem Dept A1300020 0 1/120
IMC CO,,LTD
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
TEST REPORT

1. INSTRUCTION
2. PRINCIPAL PARTICULARS
3. TRIM, DRAFT AND WEIGHT CALCULATION FLOW
4. INTACT STABILITY CALCULATION FLOW
5. GRAIN STABILITY CALCULATION FLOW
6. WEATHER STABILITY CALCULATION FLOW
7. PERMISSIBLE STILL WATER SHEAR FORCES & BENDING MOMENT
8. PERMISSIBLE STILL WATER SHEAR FORCES & BENDING MOMENT FOR HOLD FLOODING
9. COMPARISON TABLES OF MAXIMUM SHEAR FORCE AND MAXIMUM BENDING MOMENT
10. COMPARISON TALBES OF SHEAR FORCE AND BENDING MOMENT AT EACH BULKHEAD POSITION
11. TEST CONDITIONS
1) LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449]
2) LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]
3) LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]
4) LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.
5) LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.
6) GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)
7) GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](TRIMMED)
8) LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION

#) ABBREVIATION.
⊙ COND. : LOADING CONDITION NUMBER.
NO.
⊙ YARD. : VALUES ON THE TRIM & STABILITY BOOKLET
(T/S BK.) MADE BY SHIPYARD
⊙ TM. : VALUES CALCULATED BY LOADING INSTRUMENT, SHIP MANAGER-88.
(SM-88)
⊙ DIFF. : DIFFERENTIAL VALUES BETWEEN YARD. AND TM.
(YARD -TM)
⊙ DIFF*100 : ON THE SEA-GOING CONDITION.
ALLOW THE RATIO OF DIFFERENTIAL VALUES : ALLOWABLE VALUES.
SEA
⊙ TM*100 : ON THE PORT CONDITION.
ALLOW VALUES CALCULATED BY LOADING INSTRUMENT : ALLOWABLE VALUES.
PORT
⊙ ALLOW : ON THE SEA-GOING CONDITION, ALLOWABLE VALUES
SEA ACCORDING TO RULES OF REGISTER OF SHIPPING.
⊙ ALLOW : ON THE PORT CONDITION, ALLOWABLE VALUES
PORT ACCORDING TO RULES OF REGISTER OF SHIPPING.

2
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
INSTRUCTION

1. ShipManager-88 calculates stability & longitudinal strength using pre-defined data such as
hydrostatic table, KN table(cross table), tank compartment table, bonjean table, flooding angle
table, tank calibration table etc. It's impossible to make amendment on these tables.

2. This program is based on the down flooding angle data of Trimmed.

3. It remains the Masters responsibility to ensure the appropriate characteristics of each loaded
cargo item are included in any assessment.

4. Because ShipManager-88 of this vessel calculates stability & longitudinal strength using trimmed
hydrostatic table & trimmed KN table, we calculates trim supposing that LCG and LCB is on straight
line and considering longitudinal distance between KG and KB.

5. The base position of longitudinal direction is Midship, transverse direction is centerline,


vertical direction is baseline. And from Midship to forward sign is marked positive(+), starboard
side sign is marked positive(+), upside of baseline is marked positive(+), and trim by stern sign
is marked negative(-).

3
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
PRINCIPAL PARTICULARS

1. GENERAL

Builder .................................................... JAPAN MARINE UNITED CORPORATION KURE SHIPYARD


Yard Hull No ........................................... 5041
IMO No ................................................... 9715830
Class ...................................................... BV
Type of Ship ........................................... BULK CARRIER

2. PRINCIPAL DIMENSIONS

Length, over all ........................................... abt. 198.000 m


Length, between perpendiculars ................. 195.000 m
Breadth(mld.) ....................................... 32.260 m
Depth(mld.) .......................................... 18.600 m
Summer load draft(ext.) ..................................... 13.036 m

4
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
TRIM, DRAFT AND WEIGHT CALCULATION FLOW

5
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
INTACT STABILITY CALCULATION FLOW

6
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

7
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

8
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
GRAIN STABILITY CALCULATION FLOW

9
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

10
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
WEATHER STABILITY CALCULATION FLOW

11
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

12
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

13
BUREAU VERITAS
StampedPERMISSIBLE
document, refer to STILL
1st pageWATER SHEAR FORCES & BENDING MOMENT

Permissible Still Water Shear Forces(kN) Permissible Still Water Bending Moments(kN-m)
FR. NO. Seagoing Harbor Seagoing Harbor
Positive Negative Positive Negative Hogging Sagging Hogging Sagging
21.000 22700.0 -22100.0 27800.0 -27700.0 237000.0 -82000.0 441800.0 -296900.0

30.000 ***** ***** ***** ***** 441000.0 -205000.0 755800.0 -535400.0

32.000 34100.0 -33400.0 42900.0 -42700.0 496600.0 -245800.0 836000.0 -602000.0

34.000 34300.0 -33500.0 43700.0 -43400.0 550000.0 -285000.0 912700.0 -665700.0

46.500 34300.0 -33500.0 47600.0 -47400.0 876500.0 -577000.0 1385600.0 -1111400.0

60.000 35900.0 -34700.0 50500.0 -50100.0 1175000.0 -804000.0 1842300.0 -1504300.0

64.500 48100.0 -46800.0 62700.0 -62200.0 1256500.0 -842500.0 1976500.0 -1598200.0

72.000 66900.0 -65500.0 81500.0 -80900.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

72.764 ***** ***** ***** ***** 1380300.0 -884000.0 2197700.0 -1741900.0

73.000 65500.0 -64100.0 80100.0 -79500.0 1383700.0 -896500.0 2203300.0 -1756700.0

77.125 48800.0 -47700.0 63200.0 -62800.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

83.500 48800.0 -47700.0 62400.0 -61800.0 1570000.0 -1594000.0 2512600.0 -2583200.0

97.000 45200.0 -45100.0 57100.0 -57100.0 1570000.0 -1594000.0 2670700.0 -2749200.0

108.375 56000.0 -56000.0 67800.0 -67800.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

112.000 59400.0 -59400.0 71100.0 -71100.0 1570000.0 -1594000.0 2681700.0 -2760700.0

113.000 56500.0 -56500.0 68200.0 -68200.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

123.000 56500.0 -56500.0 68200.0 -68200.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

130.000 31000.0 -31000.0 42900.0 -42800.0 1570000.0 -1594000.0 2694800.0 -2774500.0

131.500 42900.0 -42900.0 55200.0 -55100.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

148.000 42900.0 -42900.0 54800.0 -54700.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

150.000 47700.0 -47900.0 60000.0 -60100.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

151.000 47700.0 -47900.0 60000.0 -60100.0 1570000.0 -1594000.0 2623900.0 -2700100.0

154.500 44700.0 -44300.0 57100.0 -57300.0 ***** ***** ***** *****

169.000 43900.0 -44300.0 60200.0 -59900.0 1570000.0 -1594000.0 2563000.0 -2636200.0

179.500 43900.0 -44300.0 60600.0 -60300.0 1229000.0 -779000.0 2081300.0 -1673500.0

190.000 64100.0 -65500.0 80800.0 -81400.0 873300.0 -609400.0 1584900.0 -1356300.0

199.250 42700.0 -44000.0 59400.0 -59900.0 560000.0 -460000.0 1147700.0 -1076800.0

214.500 19200.0 -20300.0 32500.0 -32900.0 301000.0 -263500.0 684300.0 -665800.0

229.000 16900.0 -17400.0 23400.0 -23600.0 74300.0 -59900.0 263400.0 -258300.0

Scantling approved for minimum draught forward of 4.536 m (ext). In heavy weather conditions the
forward draught should not be less than this value.
If, in the opinion of the master, sea conditions are likely to cause regular slamming, then other
appropriate measures such as change in speed, heading or an increase in draught forward may also
need to be taken.

14
BUREAU VERITAS
StampedPERMISSIBLE
document, refer to STILL
1st pageWATER SHEAR FORCES & BENDING MOMENT
FOR HOLD FLOODING

Permissible Still Water Shear Forces(kN) Permissible Still Water Bending Moments(kN-m)
FR. NO. Flooded Flooded
Positive Negative Hogging Sagging
21.000 29500.0 -29100.0 238000.0 -270000.0

30.000 ***** ***** 452000.0 -555000.0

32.000 52100.0 -51500.0 511200.0 -645300.0

34.000 55800.0 -55100.0 568000.0 -732000.0

46.500 51200.0 -50100.0 928000.0 -1179500.0

60.000 51200.0 -50100.0 1278000.0 -1543000.0

64.500 63200.0 -62100.0 1379000.0 -1725000.0

72.000 86500.0 -85400.0 ***** *****

72.764 ***** ***** 1542400.0 -2015000.0

73.000 85200.0 -84100.0 1557900.0 -2022300.0

77.125 70600.0 -69600.0 ***** *****

83.500 70600.0 -69600.0 2424000.0 -2432000.0

97.000 53800.0 -53100.0 2424000.0 -2432000.0

108.375 63400.0 -63800.0 ***** *****

112.000 70600.0 -70600.0 2424000.0 -2432000.0

113.000 67800.0 -67800.0 ***** *****

123.000 67800.0 -67800.0 ***** *****

130.000 66600.0 -66600.0 2424000.0 -2432000.0

131.500 66600.0 -66600.0 ***** *****

148.000 66600.0 -66600.0 ***** *****

150.000 67900.0 -68000.0 ***** *****

151.000 67900.0 -68000.0 2424000.0 -2432000.0

154.500 61300.0 -62400.0 ***** *****

169.000 61300.0 -62400.0 2424000.0 -2432000.0

179.500 61300.0 -62400.0 1896500.0 -1539000.0

190.000 97600.0 -98600.0 1228400.0 -1178000.0

199.250 65200.0 -66300.0 640000.0 -860000.0

214.500 32000.0 -32900.0 329500.0 -385000.0

229.000 22400.0 -22900.0 78700.0 -96000.0

15
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

COMPARISON TABLE
of MAX SHEAR FORCE & BENDING MOMENT

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
COND. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

01 -15347 -15321 -26 0.08 0.06 45.7 35.3 -33500 -43400


06 -18960 -18498 -462 1.38 1.00 55.2 40.1 -33500 -46120
11 -63122 -63781 659 1.01 0.81 97.4 78.4 -65500 -81400
16 21974 22154 -180 0.52 0.39 64.6 48.4 34300 45728
19 -57256 -56418 -838 1.43 1.19 96.5 80.4 -58461 -70189
GRN01 27328 27136 192 0.33 0.27 46.0 38.4 58978 70690
GRN29 27004 26652 352 0.60 0.50 45.2 37.7 58978 70690
30 16370 16681 -311 0.91 0.72 48.9 38.9 34100 42900

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
COND. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

01 -610664 -613323 2659 0.17 0.10 38.5 22.2 -1594000 -2757633


06 -719186 -717855 -1331 0.08 0.05 45.0 26.1 -1594000 -2753800
11 1396319 1394877 1442 0.09 0.06 88.8 54.2 1570000 2573150
16 1103336 1119898 -16562 1.05 0.62 71.3 41.7 1570000 2683517
19 -1436446 -1426872 -9574 0.60 0.35 89.5 51.6 -1594000 -2763871
GRN01 498561 497001 1560 0.10 0.06 31.7 18.5 1570000 2684671
GRN29 556914 557678 -764 0.05 0.03 35.5 20.8 1570000 2686360
30 697231 705228 -7997 0.51 0.30 44.9 26.4 1570000 2672167

16
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449]

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -5077 -4993 -84 0.38 0.30 22.6 18.0 -22100 -27700
30.0 ***** -11146 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -13700 -13543 -157 0.47 0.37 40.5 31.7 -33400 -42700
34.0 -15347 -15321 -26 0.08 0.06 45.7 35.3 -33500 -43400
46.5 -12968 -12973 5 0.01 0.01 38.7 27.4 -33500 -47400
60.0 -10473 -10578 105 0.30 0.21 30.5 21.1 -34700 -50100
64.5 -9506 -9697 191 0.41 0.31 20.7 15.6 -46800 -62200
72.0 -8576 -8559 -17 0.03 0.02 13.1 10.6 -65500 -80900
72.8 ***** -9200 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -9329 -9227 -102 0.16 0.13 14.4 11.6 -64100 -79500
77.1 -8604 -8054 -550 1.15 0.88 16.9 12.8 -47700 -62800
83.5 -6745 -6092 -653 1.37 1.06 12.8 9.9 -47700 -61800
97.0 -2156 -2539 383 0.85 0.67 5.6 4.4 -45100 -57100
108.4 1143 764 379 0.68 0.56 1.4 1.1 56000 67800
112.0 337 126 211 0.36 0.30 0.2 0.2 59400 71100
113.0 382 408 -26 0.05 0.04 0.7 0.6 56500 68200
123.0 1389 2097 -708 1.25 1.04 3.7 3.1 56500 68200
130.0 2612 2983 -371 1.20 0.86 9.6 7.0 31000 42900
131.5 2874 3131 -257 0.60 0.47 7.3 5.7 42900 55200
148.0 5045 4517 528 1.23 0.96 10.5 8.2 42900 54800
150.0 4624 4325 299 0.63 0.50 9.1 7.2 47700 60000
151.0 3623 3653 -30 0.06 0.05 7.7 6.1 47700 60000
154.5 3751 3824 -73 0.16 0.13 8.6 6.7 44700 57100
169.0 5721 5838 -117 0.27 0.19 13.3 9.7 43900 60200
179.5 7451 6811 640 1.46 1.06 15.5 11.2 43900 60600
190.0 6826 6242 584 0.91 0.72 9.7 7.7 64100 80800
199.3 7267 7694 -427 1.00 0.72 18.0 13.0 42700 59400
214.5 10090 9817 273 1.42 0.84 51.1 30.2 19200 32500
229.0 12307 12227 80 0.47 0.34 72.3 52.3 16900 23400

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -14977 -14622 -355 0.43 0.12 17.8 4.9 -82000 -296900
30.0 -77484 -77070 -414 0.20 0.08 37.6 14.4 -205000 -535400
32.0 -98803 -98748 -55 0.02 0.01 40.2 16.4 -245800 -602000
34.0 -122201 -121203 -998 0.35 0.15 42.5 18.2 -285000 -665700
46.5 -264314 -264135 -179 0.03 0.02 45.8 23.8 -577000 -1111400
60.0 -391532 -389594 -1938 0.24 0.13 48.5 25.9 -804000 -1504300
64.5 -427490 -427573 83 0.01 0.01 50.8 26.8 -842500 -1598200
72.0 ***** -481908 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -486022 -487464 1442 0.16 0.08 55.1 28.0 -884000 -1741900
73.0 -487871 -489203 1332 0.15 0.08 54.6 27.8 -896500 -1756700
77.1 ***** -516109 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -557144 -551308 -5836 0.37 0.23 34.6 21.3 -1594000 -2583200
97.0 -605200 -600327 -4873 0.31 0.18 37.7 21.8 -1594000 -2749200
108.4 ***** -613312 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -604817 -611972 7155 0.45 0.26 38.4 22.2 -1594000 -2760700
113.0 ***** -611454 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -598379 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -587476 -581932 -5544 0.35 0.20 36.5 21.0 -1594000 -2774500
131.5 ***** -577818 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -525856 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -519950 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -517296 -516452 -844 0.05 0.03 32.4 19.1 -1594000 -2700100
154.5 ***** -505516 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -453973 -444021 -9952 0.62 0.38 27.9 16.8 -1594000 -2636200
179.5 -398642 -388853 -9789 1.26 0.58 49.9 23.2 -779000 -1673500
190.0 -332742 -331948 -794 0.13 0.06 54.5 24.5 -609400 -1356300
199.3 -281780 -278955 -2825 0.61 0.26 60.6 25.9 -460000 -1076800
214.5 -176210 -173316 -2894 1.10 0.43 65.8 26.0 -263500 -665800
229.0 -45912 -46122 210 0.35 0.08 77.0 17.9 -59900 -258300

17
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -5079 -4996 -83 0.38 0.30 22.6 18.0 -22100 -27700
30.0 ***** -11150 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -13703 -13622 -81 0.24 0.19 40.8 31.9 -33400 -42700
34.0 -17735 -17393 -342 1.02 0.79 51.9 40.1 -33500 -43400
46.5 -18572 -18318 -254 0.76 0.54 54.7 38.6 -33500 -47400
60.0 -14156 -14237 81 0.23 0.16 41.0 28.4 -34700 -50100
64.5 -11425 -12095 670 1.43 1.08 25.8 19.4 -46800 -62200
72.0 -8623 -9284 661 1.01 0.82 14.2 11.5 -65500 -80900
72.8 ***** -9772 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -10322 -9764 -558 0.87 0.70 15.2 12.3 -64100 -79500
77.1 -8868 -8273 -595 1.25 0.95 17.3 13.2 -47700 -62800
83.5 -6572 -6008 -564 1.18 0.91 12.6 9.7 -47700 -61800
97.0 -1564 -1773 209 0.46 0.37 3.9 3.1 -45100 -57100
108.4 2520 1853 667 1.19 0.98 3.3 2.7 56000 67800
112.0 -506 -306 -200 0.34 0.28 0.5 0.4 -59400 -71100
113.0 -209 121 -330 0.58 0.48 0.2 0.2 56500 68200
123.0 1754 2256 -502 0.89 0.74 4.0 3.3 56500 68200
130.0 3188 3604 -416 1.34 0.97 11.6 8.4 31000 42900
131.5 3495 3802 -307 0.72 0.56 8.9 6.9 42900 55200
148.0 6674 6311 363 0.85 0.66 14.7 11.5 42900 54800
150.0 5087 4772 315 0.66 0.53 10.0 8.0 47700 60000
151.0 2931 3375 -444 0.93 0.74 7.1 5.6 47700 60000
154.5 3717 4000 -283 0.63 0.50 8.9 7.0 44700 57100
169.0 6408 6952 -544 1.24 0.90 15.8 11.5 43900 60200
179.5 8429 8129 300 0.68 0.50 18.5 13.4 43900 60600
190.0 6380 6162 218 0.34 0.27 9.6 7.6 64100 80800
199.3 9656 9887 -231 0.54 0.39 23.2 16.6 42700 59400
214.5 13008 12697 311 1.62 0.96 66.1 39.1 19200 32500
229.0 12307 12226 81 0.48 0.35 72.3 52.2 16900 23400

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -15045 -14649 -396 0.48 0.13 17.9 4.9 -82000 -296900
30.0 -77588 -77124 -464 0.23 0.09 37.6 14.4 -205000 -535400
32.0 -98915 -98809 -106 0.04 0.02 40.2 16.4 -245800 -602000
34.0 -123975 -122036 -1939 0.68 0.29 42.8 18.3 -285000 -665700
46.5 -310347 -305491 -4856 0.84 0.44 52.9 27.5 -577000 -1111400
60.0 -492235 -485826 -6409 0.80 0.43 60.4 32.3 -804000 -1504300
64.5 -538447 -533893 -4554 0.54 0.28 63.4 33.4 -842500 -1598200
72.0 ***** -595009 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -599488 -600972 1484 0.17 0.09 68.0 34.5 -884000 -1741900
73.0 -601516 -602822 1306 0.15 0.07 67.2 34.3 -896500 -1756700
77.1 ***** -630633 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -672591 -665616 -6975 0.44 0.27 41.8 25.8 -1594000 -2583200
97.0 -716543 -709028 -7515 0.47 0.27 44.5 25.8 -1594000 -2749200
108.4 ***** -715979 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -706439 -713685 7246 0.45 0.26 44.8 25.9 -1594000 -2760700
113.0 ***** -713453 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -698032 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -686643 -676460 -10183 0.64 0.37 42.4 24.4 -1594000 -2774500
131.5 ***** -671113 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -609888 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -604118 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -601670 -600871 -799 0.05 0.03 37.7 22.3 -1594000 -2700100
154.5 ***** -590058 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -533978 -527059 -6919 0.43 0.26 33.1 20.0 -1594000 -2636200
179.5 -471678 -467820 -3858 0.50 0.23 60.1 28.0 -779000 -1673500
190.0 -396352 -395475 -877 0.14 0.06 64.9 29.2 -609400 -1356300
199.3 -337300 -333801 -3499 0.76 0.32 72.6 31.0 -460000 -1076800
214.5 -193897 -193347 -550 0.21 0.08 73.4 29.0 -263500 -665800
229.0 -45882 -46127 245 0.41 0.09 77.0 17.9 -59900 -258300

18
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -6315 -6293 -22 0.10 0.08 28.5 22.7 -22100 -27700
30.0 ***** -12986 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -15601 -15498 -103 0.31 0.24 46.4 36.3 -33400 -42700
34.0 -19967 -19445 -522 1.56 1.20 58.0 44.8 -33500 -43400
46.5 609 972 -363 1.06 0.76 2.8 2.0 34300 47600
60.0 32035 31548 487 1.36 0.96 87.9 62.5 35900 50500
64.5 43927 43136 791 1.64 1.26 89.7 68.8 48100 62700
72.0 61906 62125 -219 0.33 0.27 92.9 76.2 66900 81500
72.8 ***** 60776 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
* 73.0 60364 59923 441 0.67 0.55 91.5 74.8 65500 80100
77.1 45531 45074 457 0.94 0.72 92.4 71.3 48800 63200
83.5 32269 32172 97 0.20 0.16 65.9 51.6 48800 62400
97.0 4383 4563 -180 0.40 0.32 10.1 8.0 45200 57100
108.4 -19197 -18835 -362 0.65 0.53 33.6 27.8 -56000 -67800
* 112.0 -31470 -31771 301 0.51 0.42 53.5 44.7 -59400 -71100
113.0 -29637 -29619 -18 0.03 0.03 52.4 43.4 -56500 -68200
123.0 -10906 -10585 -321 0.57 0.47 18.7 15.5 -56500 -68200
130.0 2305 2685 -380 1.23 0.89 8.7 6.3 31000 42900
131.5 5140 5555 -415 0.97 0.75 12.9 10.1 42900 55200
148.0 36220 35876 344 0.80 0.63 83.6 65.5 42900 54800
150.0 37815 37311 504 1.06 0.84 78.2 62.2 47700 60000
* 151.0 35638 36029 -391 0.82 0.65 75.5 60.0 47700 60000
154.5 20971 20637 334 0.75 0.58 46.2 36.1 44700 57100
169.0 -10492 -10836 344 0.78 0.57 24.5 18.1 -44300 -59900
179.5 -33117 -33134 17 0.04 0.03 74.8 54.9 -44300 -60300
* 190.0 -63122 -63781 659 1.01 0.81 97.4 78.4 -65500 -81400
199.3 -41547 -40612 -935 2.13 1.56 92.3 67.8 -44000 -59900
214.5 -9149 -9326 177 0.87 0.54 45.9 28.3 -20300 -32900
229.0 11891 11834 57 0.34 0.24 70.0 50.6 16900 23400

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -26515 -26524 9 0.01 0.00 32.3 8.9 -82000 -296900


30.0 -100567 -100800 233 0.11 0.04 49.2 18.8 -205000 -535400
32.0 -125001 -125647 646 0.26 0.11 51.1 20.9 -245800 -602000
34.0 -153190 -154197 1007 0.35 0.15 54.1 23.2 -285000 -665700
46.5 -242984 -244148 1164 0.20 0.10 42.3 22.0 -577000 -1111400
60.0 -26721 -25046 -1675 0.21 0.11 3.1 1.7 -804000 -1504300
64.5 131917 130501 1416 0.11 0.07 10.4 6.6 1256500 1976500
72.0 ***** 490713 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 540322 536224 4098 0.30 0.19 38.8 24.4 1380300 2197700
73.0 554102 550057 4045 0.29 0.18 39.8 25.0 1383700 2203300
77.1 ***** 756496 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 1006377 999423 6954 0.44 0.28 63.7 39.8 1570000 2512600
97.0 1222198 1210701 11497 0.73 0.43 77.1 45.3 1570000 2670700
108.4 ***** 1073179 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 981209 969524 11685 0.74 0.44 61.8 36.2 1570000 2681700
113.0 ***** 939046 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 740996 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 708340 713846 -5506 0.35 0.20 45.5 26.5 1570000 2694800
131.5 ***** 719479 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 1031713 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 1094575 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 1137241 1134625 2616 0.17 0.10 72.3 43.2 1570000 2623900
154.5 ***** 1243089 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 1384452 1383173 1279 0.08 0.05 88.1 54.0 1570000 2563000
179.5 1176434 1175358 1076 0.09 0.05 95.6 56.5 1229000 2081300
190.0 710299 708607 1692 0.19 0.11 81.1 44.7 873300 1584900
199.3 284299 285376 -1077 0.19 0.09 51.0 24.9 560000 1147700
214.5 -56838 -54843 -1995 0.76 0.30 20.8 8.2 -263500 -665800
229.0 -43832 -44423 591 0.99 0.23 74.2 17.2 -59900 -258300

19
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 13394 13665 -271 1.19 0.97 60.2 49.2 22700 27800
30.0 ***** 21044 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 21570 21905 -335 0.98 0.78 64.2 51.1 34100 42900
34.0 21511 21789 -278 0.81 0.64 63.5 49.9 34300 43700
46.5 21492 21683 -191 0.56 0.40 63.2 45.6 34300 47600
60.0 17917 17783 134 0.37 0.27 49.5 35.2 35900 50500
64.5 16169 16117 52 0.11 0.08 33.5 25.7 48100 62700
72.0 13205 13611 -406 0.61 0.50 20.3 16.7 66900 81500
72.8 ***** 13772 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 13087 13810 -723 1.10 0.90 21.1 17.2 65500 80100
77.1 11637 11872 -235 0.48 0.37 24.3 18.8 48800 63200
83.5 9252 9230 22 0.05 0.04 18.9 14.8 48800 62400
97.0 4545 4233 312 0.69 0.55 9.4 7.4 45200 57100
108.4 611 520 91 0.16 0.13 0.9 0.8 56000 67800
112.0 -261 610 -871 1.47 1.23 1.0 0.9 59400 71100
113.0 -241 329 -570 1.01 0.84 0.6 0.5 56500 68200
123.0 -2936 -2969 33 0.06 0.05 5.3 4.4 -56500 -68200
130.0 -4635 -4878 243 0.78 0.57 15.7 11.4 -31000 -42800
131.5 -4986 -5255 269 0.63 0.49 12.2 9.5 -42900 -55100
148.0 -8742 -8882 140 0.33 0.26 20.7 16.2 -42900 -54700
150.0 -9122 -9024 -98 0.20 0.16 18.8 15.0 -47900 -60100
151.0 -9030 -8675 -355 0.74 0.59 18.1 14.4 -47900 -60100
154.5 -9418 -9258 -160 0.36 0.28 20.9 16.2 -44300 -57300
169.0 -12129 -12508 379 0.86 0.63 28.2 20.9 -44300 -59900
179.5 -13749 -14188 439 0.99 0.73 32.0 23.5 -44300 -60300
190.0 -14796 -14244 -552 0.84 0.68 21.7 17.5 -65500 -81400
199.3 -15898 -15807 -91 0.21 0.15 35.9 26.4 -44000 -59900
214.5 -16605 -16813 208 1.02 0.63 82.8 51.1 -20300 -32900
229.0 -15741 -15624 -117 0.67 0.50 89.8 66.2 -17400 -23600

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 118286 119933 -1647 0.69 0.37 50.6 27.1 237000 441800
30.0 244402 250292 -5890 1.34 0.78 56.8 33.1 441000 755800
32.0 279336 285770 -6434 1.30 0.77 57.5 34.2 496600 836000
34.0 313964 320692 -6728 1.22 0.74 58.3 35.1 550000 912700
46.5 532860 540473 -7613 0.87 0.55 61.7 39.0 876500 1385600
60.0 748848 758244 -9396 0.80 0.51 64.5 41.2 1175000 1842300
64.5 810480 820173 -9693 0.77 0.49 65.3 41.5 1256500 1976500
72.0 ***** 909094 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 906239 918136 -11897 0.86 0.54 66.5 41.8 1380300 2197700
73.0 908872 920958 -12086 0.87 0.55 66.6 41.8 1383700 2203300
77.1 ***** 964135 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 1003586 1019117 -15531 0.99 0.62 64.9 40.6 1570000 2512600
97.0 1078534 1093730 -15196 0.97 0.57 69.7 41.0 1570000 2670700
108.4 ***** 1117626 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 1103120 1118953 -15833 1.01 0.59 71.3 41.7 1570000 2681700
113.0 ***** 1119536 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 1110284 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 1069753 1089588 -19835 1.26 0.74 69.4 40.4 1570000 2694800
131.5 ***** 1083507 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 989783 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 976310 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 953147 968484 -15337 0.98 0.58 61.7 36.9 1570000 2623900
154.5 ***** 944013 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 802664 816557 -13893 0.88 0.54 52.0 31.9 1570000 2563000
179.5 694319 704055 -9736 0.79 0.47 57.3 33.8 1229000 2081300
190.0 573106 580090 -6984 0.80 0.44 66.4 36.6 873300 1584900
199.3 460487 468520 -8033 1.43 0.70 83.7 40.8 560000 1147700
214.5 261310 265476 -4166 1.38 0.61 88.2 38.8 301000 684300
229.0 70627 69558 1069 1.44 0.41 93.6 26.4 74300 263400

20
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 17310 17472 -162 0.71 0.58 77.0 62.8 22700 27800
30.0 ***** 22216 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 21920 22292 -372 1.09 0.87 65.4 52.0 34100 42900
34.0 20838 21185 -347 1.01 0.79 61.8 48.5 34300 43700
46.5 10433 10785 -352 1.03 0.74 31.4 22.7 34300 47600
60.0 -4680 -4644 -36 0.10 0.07 13.4 9.3 -34700 -50100
64.5 -10263 -10146 -117 0.25 0.19 21.7 16.3 -46800 -62200
72.0 -19543 -18964 -579 0.88 0.72 29.0 23.4 -65500 -80900
72.8 ***** -19491 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -20559 -19666 -893 1.39 1.12 30.7 24.7 -64100 -79500
77.1 -24598 -24027 -571 1.20 0.91 50.4 38.3 -47700 -62800
83.5 -30962 -30394 -568 1.19 0.92 63.7 49.2 -47700 -61800
97.0 -43998 -43491 -507 1.12 0.89 96.4 76.2 -45100 -57100
108.4 -54898 -54247 -651 1.16 0.96 96.9 80.0 -56000 -67800
* 112.0 -56439 -55579 -860 1.45 1.21 93.6 78.2 -59400 -71100
113.0 -51734 -51887 153 0.27 0.22 91.8 76.1 -56500 -68200
123.0 -26910 -26178 -732 1.30 1.07 46.3 38.4 -56500 -68200
130.0 -8698 -8273 -425 1.37 0.99 26.7 19.3 -31000 -42800
131.5 -4779 -4383 -396 0.92 0.72 10.2 8.0 -42900 -55100
148.0 37840 37544 296 0.69 0.54 87.5 68.5 42900 54800
150.0 41805 42357 -552 1.16 0.92 88.8 70.6 47700 60000
* 151.0 45210 45319 -109 0.23 0.18 95.0 75.5 47700 60000
154.5 42696 42159 537 1.20 0.94 94.3 73.8 44700 57100
169.0 31253 30576 677 1.54 1.12 69.6 50.8 43900 60200
179.5 23387 22742 645 1.47 1.06 51.8 37.5 43900 60600
190.0 16156 16594 -438 0.68 0.54 25.9 20.5 64100 80800
199.3 7897 7857 40 0.09 0.07 18.4 13.2 42700 59400
214.5 -3985 -4232 247 1.22 0.75 20.8 12.9 -20300 -32900
229.0 -11631 -11610 -21 0.12 0.09 66.7 49.2 -17400 -23600

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 194942 198757 -3815 1.61 0.86 83.9 45.0 237000 441800
30.0 341849 348087 -6238 1.41 0.83 78.9 46.1 441000 755800
32.0 378127 384289 -6162 1.24 0.74 77.4 46.0 496600 836000
34.0 412631 418490 -5859 1.07 0.64 76.1 45.9 550000 912700
46.5 574079 577612 -3533 0.40 0.25 65.9 41.7 876500 1385600
60.0 608912 611425 -2513 0.21 0.14 52.0 33.2 1175000 1842300
64.5 582497 584488 -1991 0.16 0.10 46.5 29.6 1256500 1976500
72.0 ***** 496333 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 481044 483791 -2747 0.20 0.12 35.0 22.0 1380300 2197700
73.0 476980 479837 -2857 0.21 0.13 34.7 21.8 1383700 2203300
77.1 ***** 405666 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 252353 256684 -4331 0.28 0.17 16.3 10.2 1570000 2512600
97.0 -191820 -192632 812 0.05 0.03 12.1 7.0 -1594000 -2749200
108.4 ***** -706609 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -885514 -893920 8406 0.53 0.30 56.1 32.4 -1594000 -2760700
113.0 ***** -943925 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -1308357 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -1425252 -1417010 -8242 0.52 0.30 88.9 51.1 -1594000 -2774500
131.5 ***** -1424685 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -1149163 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -1076560 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -1029090 -1028811 -279 0.02 0.01 64.5 38.1 -1594000 -2700100
154.5 ***** -883339 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -393414 -390077 -3337 0.21 0.13 24.5 14.8 -1594000 -2636200
179.5 -137827 -136297 -1530 0.20 0.09 17.5 8.1 -779000 -1673500
190.0 35807 36737 -930 0.11 0.06 4.2 2.3 873300 1584900
199.3 126131 129846 -3715 0.66 0.32 23.2 11.3 560000 1147700
214.5 148420 150961 -2541 0.84 0.37 50.2 22.1 301000 684300
229.0 52549 52680 -131 0.18 0.05 70.9 20.0 74300 263400

21
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -4891 -4866 -25 0.11 0.09 22.0 17.6 -22100 -27700
30.0 ***** -10776 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -13222 -13104 -118 0.35 0.28 39.2 30.7 -33400 -42700
34.0 -14477 -14284 -193 0.58 0.44 42.6 32.9 -33500 -43400
46.5 -7959 -7937 -22 0.07 0.05 23.7 16.7 -33500 -47400
60.0 -535 -738 203 0.59 0.41 2.1 1.5 -34700 -50100
64.5 2140 1855 285 0.59 0.45 3.9 3.0 48100 62700
72.0 5892 5950 -58 0.09 0.07 8.9 7.3 66900 81500
72.8 ***** 5521 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 5412 5565 -153 0.23 0.19 8.5 6.9 65500 80100
77.1 7592 7921 -329 0.67 0.52 16.2 12.5 48800 63200
83.5 11332 11738 -406 0.83 0.65 24.1 18.8 48800 62400
97.0 19621 19335 286 0.63 0.50 42.8 33.9 45200 57100
108.4 26423 26166 257 0.46 0.38 46.7 38.6 56000 67800
112.0 26159 26231 -72 0.12 0.10 44.2 36.9 59400 71100
113.0 24969 25068 -99 0.18 0.15 44.4 36.8 56500 68200
123.0 12099 12459 -360 0.64 0.53 22.1 18.3 56500 68200
130.0 3209 3502 -293 0.95 0.68 11.3 8.2 31000 42900
131.5 1310 1558 -248 0.58 0.45 3.6 2.8 42900 55200
148.0 -19635 -19645 10 0.02 0.02 45.8 35.9 -42900 -54700
150.0 -22520 -22356 -164 0.34 0.27 46.7 37.2 -47900 -60100
151.0 -23904 -23816 -88 0.18 0.15 49.7 39.6 -47900 -60100
154.5 -22306 -22347 41 0.09 0.07 50.4 39.0 -44300 -57300
169.0 -15126 -14891 -235 0.53 0.39 33.6 24.9 -44300 -59900
179.5 -9658 -9912 254 0.57 0.42 22.4 16.4 -44300 -60300
190.0 -5967 -6477 510 0.78 0.63 9.9 8.0 -65500 -81400
199.3 -2119 -2025 -94 0.21 0.16 4.6 3.4 -44000 -59900
214.5 4833 4818 15 0.08 0.05 25.1 14.8 19200 32500
229.0 11057 11044 13 0.08 0.06 65.3 47.2 16900 23400

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -13422 -14368 946 1.15 0.32 17.5 4.8 -82000 -296900
30.0 -73499 -75021 1522 0.74 0.28 36.6 14.0 -205000 -535400
32.0 -94020 -96024 2004 0.82 0.33 39.1 16.0 -245800 -602000
34.0 -116315 -117299 984 0.35 0.15 41.2 17.6 -285000 -665700
46.5 -229202 -230222 1020 0.18 0.09 39.9 20.7 -577000 -1111400
60.0 -275666 -275815 149 0.02 0.01 34.3 18.3 -804000 -1504300
64.5 -272670 -275305 2635 0.31 0.16 32.7 17.2 -842500 -1598200
72.0 ***** -252185 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -243755 -248253 4498 0.51 0.26 28.1 14.3 -884000 -1741900
73.0 -242656 -247026 4370 0.49 0.25 27.6 14.1 -896500 -1756700
77.1 ***** -223170 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -172950 -172180 -770 0.05 0.03 10.8 6.7 -1594000 -2583200
97.0 -5548 -6933 1385 0.09 0.05 0.4 0.3 -1594000 -2749200
108.4 ***** 195106 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 283191 271725 11466 0.73 0.43 17.3 10.1 1570000 2681700
113.0 ***** 292550 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 445529 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 495238 492378 2860 0.18 0.11 31.4 18.3 1570000 2694800
131.5 ***** 495858 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 377133 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 344906 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 325807 323836 1971 0.13 0.08 20.6 12.3 1570000 2623900
154.5 ***** 259674 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 43379 49043 -5664 0.36 0.22 3.1 1.9 1570000 2563000
179.5 -60519 -53127 -7392 0.95 0.44 6.8 3.2 -779000 -1673500
190.0 -120360 -119692 -668 0.11 0.05 19.6 8.8 -609400 -1356300
199.3 -150570 -149693 -877 0.19 0.08 32.5 13.9 -460000 -1076800
214.5 -133350 -133370 20 0.01 0.00 50.6 20.0 -263500 -665800
229.0 -40899 -41110 211 0.35 0.08 68.6 15.9 -59900 -258300

22
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -5945 -5784 -161 0.73 0.58 26.2 20.9 -22100 -27700
30.0 ***** -10882 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -13152 -12985 -167 0.50 0.39 38.9 30.4 -33400 -42700
34.0 -13937 -13578 -359 1.07 0.83 40.5 31.3 -33500 -43400
46.5 -6315 -6043 -272 0.81 0.57 18.0 12.7 -33500 -47400
60.0 2368 2184 184 0.51 0.36 6.1 4.3 35900 50500
64.5 5213 4935 278 0.58 0.44 10.3 7.9 48100 62700
72.0 8413 8387 26 0.04 0.03 12.5 10.3 66900 81500
72.8 ***** 7915 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 7819 7949 -130 0.20 0.16 12.1 9.9 65500 80100
77.1 9453 9998 -545 1.12 0.86 20.5 15.8 48800 63200
83.5 12786 13032 -246 0.50 0.39 26.7 20.9 48800 62400
97.0 20543 20128 415 0.92 0.73 44.5 35.3 45200 57100
108.4 26472 25981 491 0.88 0.72 46.4 38.3 56000 67800
112.0 25671 25674 -3 0.01 0.00 43.2 36.1 59400 71100
113.0 24475 24504 -29 0.05 0.04 43.4 35.9 56500 68200
123.0 11492 11776 -284 0.50 0.42 20.8 17.3 56500 68200
130.0 2465 2679 -214 0.69 0.50 8.6 6.2 31000 42900
131.5 531 698 -167 0.39 0.30 1.6 1.3 42900 55200
148.0 -20948 -21051 103 0.24 0.19 49.1 38.5 -42900 -54700
150.0 -23910 -23840 -70 0.15 0.12 49.8 39.7 -47900 -60100
151.0 -25342 -25333 -9 0.02 0.01 52.9 42.2 -47900 -60100
154.5 -23901 -23778 -123 0.28 0.21 53.7 41.5 -44300 -57300
169.0 -16289 -16112 -177 0.40 0.30 36.4 26.9 -44300 -59900
179.5 -10451 -10952 501 1.13 0.83 24.7 18.2 -44300 -60300
190.0 -7205 -7553 348 0.53 0.43 11.5 9.3 -65500 -81400
199.3 -3243 -2674 -569 1.29 0.95 6.1 4.5 -44000 -59900
214.5 5247 5112 135 0.70 0.42 26.6 15.7 19200 32500
229.0 11737 11666 71 0.42 0.30 69.0 49.9 16900 23400

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 -39074 -40041 967 1.18 0.33 48.8 13.5 -82000 -296900
30.0 -101979 -104496 2517 1.23 0.47 51.0 19.5 -205000 -535400
32.0 -122438 -125802 3364 1.37 0.56 51.2 20.9 -245800 -602000
34.0 -144326 -146714 2388 0.84 0.36 51.5 22.0 -285000 -665700
46.5 -247892 -247668 -224 0.04 0.02 42.9 22.3 -577000 -1111400
60.0 -268648 -266027 -2621 0.33 0.17 33.1 17.7 -804000 -1504300
64.5 -255005 -255310 305 0.04 0.02 30.3 16.0 -842500 -1598200
72.0 ***** -215528 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -207546 -210027 2481 0.28 0.14 23.8 12.1 -884000 -1741900
73.0 -205969 -208320 2351 0.26 0.13 23.2 11.9 -896500 -1756700
77.1 ***** -176969 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -121359 -115957 -5402 0.34 0.21 7.3 4.5 -1594000 -2583200
97.0 58625 63299 -4674 0.30 0.18 4.0 2.4 1570000 2670700
108.4 ***** 268215 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 351913 343798 8115 0.52 0.30 21.9 12.8 1570000 2681700
113.0 ***** 364174 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 512230 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 555025 554883 142 0.01 0.01 35.3 20.6 1570000 2694800
131.5 ***** 557354 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 423970 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 389576 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 367342 367151 191 0.01 0.01 23.4 14.0 1570000 2623900
154.5 ***** 297340 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 63211 65237 -2026 0.13 0.08 4.2 2.5 1570000 2563000
179.5 -49086 -45714 -3372 0.43 0.20 5.9 2.7 -779000 -1673500
190.0 -116656 -121541 4885 0.80 0.36 19.9 9.0 -609400 -1356300
199.3 -156592 -157527 935 0.20 0.09 34.2 14.6 -460000 -1076800
214.5 -144024 -142172 -1852 0.70 0.28 54.0 21.4 -263500 -665800
229.0 -43471 -43780 309 0.52 0.12 73.1 16.9 -59900 -258300

23
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION

SHEAR FORCE
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 9345 9286 59 0.26 0.21 40.9 33.4 22700 27800


30.0 ***** 15611 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 16370 16681 -311 0.91 0.72 48.9 38.9 34100 42900
34.0 16278 16553 -275 0.80 0.63 48.3 37.9 34300 43700
46.5 14738 14853 -115 0.34 0.24 43.3 31.2 34300 47600
60.0 11512 11483 29 0.08 0.06 32.0 22.7 35900 50500
64.5 10180 10125 55 0.11 0.09 21.0 16.1 48100 62700
72.0 7918 7959 -41 0.06 0.05 11.9 9.8 66900 81500
72.8 ***** 7759 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 7732 7674 58 0.09 0.07 11.7 9.6 65500 80100
77.1 6370 6210 160 0.33 0.25 12.7 9.8 48800 63200
83.5 4336 4253 83 0.17 0.13 8.7 6.8 48800 62400
97.0 602 521 81 0.18 0.14 1.2 0.9 45200 57100
108.4 -2229 -2319 90 0.16 0.13 4.1 3.4 -56000 -67800
112.0 -2840 -2748 -92 0.15 0.13 4.6 3.9 -59400 -71100
113.0 -2887 -2885 -2 0.00 0.00 5.1 4.2 -56500 -68200
123.0 -4765 -4805 40 0.07 0.06 8.5 7.0 -56500 -68200
130.0 -5823 -5852 29 0.09 0.07 18.9 13.7 -31000 -42800
131.5 -6029 -6056 27 0.06 0.05 14.1 11.0 -42900 -55100
148.0 -8027 -8061 34 0.08 0.06 18.8 14.7 -42900 -54700
150.0 -8170 -8052 -118 0.25 0.20 16.8 13.4 -47900 -60100
151.0 -8104 -7985 -119 0.25 0.20 16.7 13.3 -47900 -60100
154.5 -8208 -8304 96 0.22 0.17 18.7 14.5 -44300 -57300
169.0 -9013 -9046 33 0.07 0.06 20.4 15.1 -44300 -59900
179.5 -9104 -9136 32 0.07 0.05 20.6 15.2 -44300 -60300
190.0 -8612 -8593 -19 0.03 0.02 13.1 10.6 -65500 -81400
199.3 -8165 -8169 4 0.01 0.01 18.6 13.6 -44000 -59900
214.5 -6313 -6254 -59 0.29 0.18 30.8 19.0 -20300 -32900
229.0 -3777 -3562 -215 1.24 0.91 20.5 15.1 -17400 -23600

(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected SF)

BENDING MOMENT
DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%)
FRAM. YARD TM. DIFF. ALLOW ALLOW ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) SEA PORT SEA PORT SEA PORT

21.0 72980 74981 -2001 0.84 0.45 31.6 17.0 237000 441800
30.0 165020 170167 -5147 1.17 0.68 38.6 22.5 441000 755800
32.0 191423 197036 -5613 1.13 0.67 39.7 23.6 496600 836000
34.0 217674 223252 -5578 1.01 0.61 40.6 24.5 550000 912700
46.5 374570 379203 -4633 0.53 0.33 43.3 27.4 876500 1385600
60.0 518453 525898 -7445 0.63 0.40 44.8 28.5 1175000 1842300
64.5 557808 565882 -8074 0.64 0.41 45.0 28.6 1256500 1976500
72.0 ***** 620731 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 616751 626031 -9280 0.67 0.42 45.4 28.5 1380300 2197700
73.0 618320 627642 -9322 0.67 0.42 45.4 28.5 1383700 2203300
77.1 ***** 651526 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 669511 679539 -10028 0.64 0.40 43.3 27.0 1570000 2512600
97.0 696493 704797 -8304 0.53 0.31 44.9 26.4 1570000 2670700
108.4 ***** 696769 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 682550 689194 -6644 0.42 0.25 43.9 25.7 1570000 2681700
113.0 ***** 686949 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 655603 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 620901 625691 -4790 0.31 0.18 39.9 23.2 1570000 2694800
131.5 ***** 618545 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 525523 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 513395 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 502854 506178 -3324 0.21 0.13 32.2 19.3 1570000 2623900
154.5 ***** 483465 ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 380342 381979 -1637 0.10 0.06 24.3 14.9 1570000 2563000
179.5 304658 305368 -710 0.06 0.03 24.8 14.7 1229000 2081300
190.0 229462 229554 -92 0.01 0.01 26.3 14.5 873300 1584900
199.3 167852 166961 891 0.16 0.08 29.8 14.5 560000 1147700
214.5 79522 78516 1006 0.33 0.15 26.1 11.5 301000 684300
229.0 20105 19920 185 0.25 0.07 26.8 7.6 74300 263400

24
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449]

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(SHEAR FORCE)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 -1911 -1841 -70 0.24 6.3 -29100 21.0 -9458 -9320 -138 0.47 32.0 -29100
30.0 ***** -6805 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -17466 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -9041 -9119 78 0.15 17.7 -51500 32.0 -20648 -20455 -193 0.37 39.7 -51500
34.0 -10474 -10986 512 0.93 19.9 -55100 34.0 -22731 -22954 223 0.40 41.7 -55100
46.5 -7059 -6788 -271 0.54 13.5 -50100 46.5 -23014 -22370 -644 1.29 44.7 -50100
60.0 -3909 -4327 418 0.83 8.6 -50100 60.0 -23264 -23155 -109 0.22 46.2 -50100
64.5 -2804 -3505 701 1.13 5.6 -62100 64.5 -23189 -23265 76 0.12 37.5 -62100
72.0 -1816 -1563 -253 0.30 1.8 -85400 72.0 -23691 -23546 -145 0.17 27.6 -85400
72.8 ***** -2112 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** -23979 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -2599 -2110 -489 0.58 2.5 -84100 73.0 -24301 -23822 -479 0.57 28.3 -84100
77.1 -2021 -2190 169 0.24 3.1 -69600 77.1 -20670 -20658 -12 0.02 29.7 -69600
83.5 -449 -305 -144 0.21 0.4 -69600 83.5 -14246 -13738 -508 0.73 19.7 -69600
97.0 3299 2548 751 1.40 4.7 53800 97.0 43 -125 168 0.32 0.2 -53100
108.4 5582 4786 796 1.26 7.5 63400 108.4 11545 10816 729 1.15 17.1 63400
112.0 4369 3611 758 1.07 5.1 70600 112.0 12492 12077 415 0.59 17.1 70600
113.0 4282 3762 520 0.77 5.5 67800 113.0 12384 12210 174 0.26 18.0 67800
123.0 3800 3990 -190 0.28 5.9 67800 123.0 11906 12454 -548 0.81 18.4 67800
130.0 3799 3679 120 0.18 5.5 66600 130.0 12141 12378 -237 0.36 18.6 66600
131.5 3779 3551 228 0.34 5.3 66600 131.5 12196 12325 -129 0.19 18.5 66600
148.0 2394 1697 697 1.05 2.5 66600 148.0 12224 11844 380 0.57 17.8 66600
150.0 1517 885 632 0.93 1.3 67900 150.0 11574 11253 321 0.47 16.6 67900
151.0 236 -591 827 1.22 0.9 -68000 151.0 10437 9916 521 0.77 14.6 67900
154.5 -530 -797 267 0.43 1.3 -62400 154.5 10149 10172 -23 0.04 16.6 61300
169.0 -2663 -2754 91 0.15 4.4 -62400 169.0 10508 10618 -110 0.18 17.3 61300
179.5 -4306 -4774 468 0.75 7.7 -62400 179.5 11183 10830 353 0.58 17.7 61300
190.0 -8282 -8552 270 0.27 8.7 -98600 190.0 9597 9464 133 0.14 9.7 97600
199.3 -2623 -2050 -573 0.86 3.1 -66300 199.3 9271 10178 -907 1.39 15.6 65200
214.5 7836 8071 -235 0.73 25.2 32000 214.5 11035 10939 96 0.30 34.2 32000
229.0 15075 14794 281 1.25 66.0 22400 229.0 12576 12530 46 0.21 55.9 22400
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -4232 -4187 -45 0.15 14.4 -29100 21.0 -11865 -11558 -307 1.05 39.7 -29100
30.0 ***** -10151 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -20637 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -12659 -12678 19 0.04 24.6 -51500 32.0 -24267 -23822 -445 0.86 46.3 -51500
34.0 -14301 -14744 443 0.80 26.8 -55100 34.0 -26100 -25420 -680 1.23 46.1 -55100
46.5 -12093 -11697 -396 0.79 23.3 -50100 46.5 -17675 -17850 175 0.35 35.6 -50100
60.0 -10069 -10289 220 0.44 20.5 -50100 60.0 -7089 -7698 609 1.22 15.4 -50100
64.5 -9309 -9776 467 0.75 15.7 -62100 64.5 -3220 -3916 696 1.12 6.3 -62100
72.0 -8820 -8293 -527 0.62 9.7 -85400 72.0 2428 3263 -835 0.97 3.8 86500
72.8 ***** -8889 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 2770 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -9662 -8902 -760 0.90 10.6 -84100 73.0 1748 2718 -970 1.14 3.2 85200
77.1 -9299 -9206 -93 0.13 13.2 -69600 77.1 1573 1807 -234 0.33 2.6 70600
83.5 -8038 -7632 -406 0.58 11.0 -69600 83.5 2093 2572 -479 0.68 3.6 70600
97.0 -4859 -5287 428 0.81 10.0 -53100 97.0 4006 3709 297 0.55 6.9 53800
108.4 -2902 -3320 418 0.66 5.2 -63800 108.4 5219 5195 24 0.04 8.2 63400
112.0 -4177 -4551 374 0.53 6.4 -70600 112.0 3782 3914 -132 0.19 5.5 70600
113.0 -4278 -4412 134 0.20 6.5 -67800 113.0 3675 4048 -373 0.55 6.0 67800
123.0 -4837 -4253 -584 0.86 6.3 -67800 123.0 3266 3580 -314 0.46 5.3 67800
130.0 -4822 -4545 -277 0.42 6.8 -66600 130.0 3623 3947 -324 0.49 5.9 66600
131.5 -4831 -4662 -169 0.25 7.0 -66600 131.5 3713 3996 -283 0.42 6.0 66600
148.0 -5922 -6228 306 0.46 9.4 -66600 148.0 4299 4441 -142 0.21 6.7 66600
150.0 -6746 -6988 242 0.36 10.3 -68000 150.0 3735 3931 -196 0.29 5.8 67900
151.0 -7651 -8213 562 0.83 12.1 -68000 151.0 2651 2643 8 0.01 3.9 67900
154.5 -5176 -4942 -234 0.38 7.9 -62400 154.5 2538 3065 -527 0.86 5.0 61300
169.0 6523 7060 -537 0.88 11.5 61300 169.0 3783 4348 -565 0.92 7.1 61300
179.5 15124 14701 423 0.69 24.0 61300 179.5 5262 5317 -55 0.09 8.7 61300
190.0 20353 19640 713 0.73 20.1 97600 190.0 4617 4835 -218 0.22 5.0 97600
199.3 18007 18414 -407 0.62 28.2 65200 199.3 5231 5526 -295 0.45 8.5 65200
214.5 16104 15677 427 1.33 49.0 32000 214.5 8695 8779 -84 0.26 27.4 32000
229.0 14370 14183 187 0.83 63.3 22400 229.0 11749 11778 -29 0.13 52.6 22400
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -6825 -6705 -120 0.41 23.0 -29100
30.0 ***** -13761 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -16635 -16520 -115 0.22 32.1 -51500
34.0 -18498 -18804 306 0.56 34.1 -55100
46.5 -17532 -16993 -539 1.08 33.9 -50100
60.0 -16637 -16678 41 0.08 33.3 -50100
64.5 -16216 -16473 257 0.41 26.5 -62100
72.0 -16215 -15440 -775 0.91 18.1 -85400
72.8 ***** -16080 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -17107 -16107 -1000 1.19 19.2 -84100
77.1 -16927 -16622 -305 0.44 23.9 -69600
83.5 -15920 -15328 -592 0.85 22.0 -69600
97.0 -13173 -13397 224 0.42 25.2 -53100
108.4 -11464 -11588 124 0.19 18.2 -63800
112.0 -12454 -12621 167 0.24 17.9 -70600
113.0 -11714 -11541 -173 0.26 17.0 -67800
123.0 -3370 -2932 -438 0.65 4.3 -67800
130.0 2969 3373 -404 0.61 5.1 66600
131.5 4325 4649 -324 0.49 7.0 66600
148.0 18481 17568 913 1.37 26.4 66600
150.0 19214 18355 859 1.27 27.0 67900
151.0 18359 17489 870 1.28 25.8 67900
154.5 17904 17582 322 0.53 28.7 61300
169.0 17396 17184 212 0.35 28.0 61300
179.5 17268 16616 652 1.06 27.1 61300
190.0 14731 14327 404 0.41 14.7 97600
199.3 13445 14114 -669 1.03 21.6 65200
214.5 13461 13203 258 0.81 41.3 32000
229.0 13437 13318 119 0.53 59.5 22400

25
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449]

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(BENDING MOMENT)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 10363 12860 -2497 1.05 5.4 238000 21.0 -52472 -54923 2451 0.91 20.3 -270000
30.0 -24840 -23070 -1770 0.32 4.2 -555000 30.0 -155405 -159133 3728 0.67 28.7 -555000
32.0 -38869 -37736 -1133 0.18 5.8 -645300 32.0 -187856 -192168 4312 0.67 29.8 -645300
34.0 -54912 -53126 -1786 0.24 7.3 -732000 34.0 -222641 -226203 3562 0.49 30.9 -732000
46.5 -144392 -137110 -7282 0.62 11.6 -1179500 46.5 -451540 -448421 -3119 0.26 38.0 -1179500
60.0 -205740 -187958 -17782 1.15 12.2 -1543000 60.0 -701659 -685696 -15963 1.03 44.4 -1543000
64.5 -218427 -199701 -18726 1.09 11.6 -1725000 64.5 -785100 -767378 -17722 1.03 44.5 -1725000
72.0 ***** -214699 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -905993 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -233428 -217281 -16147 0.80 10.8 -2015000 72.8 -938857 -922445 -16412 0.81 45.8 -2015000
73.0 -233965 -218100 -15865 0.78 10.8 -2022300 73.0 -943697 -927500 -16197 0.80 45.9 -2022300
77.1 ***** -230042 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -1003617 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -249834 -242893 -6941 0.29 10.0 -2432000 83.5 -1107129 -1095637 -11492 0.47 45.1 -2432000
97.0 -235996 -227563 -8433 0.35 9.4 -2432000 97.0 -1183342 -1176875 -6467 0.27 48.4 -2432000
108.4 ***** -185326 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -1119515 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -180073 -170080 -9993 0.41 7.0 -2432000 112.0 -1091682 -1082825 -8857 0.36 44.5 -2432000
113.0 ***** -166893 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -1072880 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -133307 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** -971971 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -126428 -110018 -16410 0.67 4.5 -2432000 130.0 -917855 -900760 -17095 0.70 37.0 -2432000
131.5 ***** -105335 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** -885606 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -70897 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** -727530 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -70007 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** -711269 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -75713 -70099 -5614 0.23 2.9 -2432000 151.0 -710112 -701718 -8394 0.35 28.9 -2432000
154.5 ***** -71914 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** -672704 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -98405 -90748 -7657 0.31 3.7 -2432000 169.0 -562897 -547914 -14983 0.62 22.5 -2432000
179.5 -128868 -124320 -4548 0.30 8.1 -1539000 179.5 -471445 -457752 -13693 0.89 29.7 -1539000
190.0 -178382 -184860 6478 0.55 15.7 -1178000 190.0 -377890 -374094 -3796 0.32 31.8 -1178000
199.3 -221209 -220497 -712 0.08 25.6 -860000 199.3 -308947 -304361 -4586 0.53 35.4 -860000
214.5 -189899 -187664 -2235 0.58 48.7 -385000 214.5 -185102 -182776 -2326 0.60 47.5 -385000
229.0 -55917 -57062 1145 1.19 59.4 -96000 229.0 -47551 -47337 -214 0.22 49.3 -96000
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -8673 -8404 -269 0.10 3.1 -270000 21.0 -73348 -75313 1965 0.73 27.9 -270000
30.0 -64860 -65757 897 0.16 11.8 -555000 30.0 -197667 -199897 2230 0.40 36.0 -555000
32.0 -84631 -86188 1557 0.24 13.4 -645300 32.0 -235874 -238391 2517 0.39 36.9 -645300
34.0 -106528 -107433 905 0.12 14.7 -732000 34.0 -276246 -277101 855 0.12 37.9 -732000
46.5 -239834 -234889 -4945 0.42 19.9 -1179500 46.5 -496209 -491001 -5208 0.44 41.6 -1179500
60.0 -361064 -344622 -16442 1.07 22.3 -1543000 60.0 -630262 -626989 -3273 0.21 40.6 -1543000
64.5 -396318 -378533 -17785 1.03 21.9 -1725000 64.5 -648421 -648218 -203 0.01 37.6 -1725000
72.0 ***** -429380 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -647580 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -455732 -435994 -19738 0.98 21.6 -2015000 72.8 -647168 -646375 -793 0.04 32.1 -2015000
73.0 -457666 -438069 -19597 0.97 21.7 -2022300 73.0 -646777 -646038 -739 0.04 31.9 -2022300
77.1 ***** -471013 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -640481 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -534579 -517698 -16881 0.69 21.3 -2432000 83.5 -631548 -631314 -234 0.01 26.0 -2432000
97.0 -605192 -589458 -15734 0.65 24.2 -2432000 97.0 -597547 -596172 -1375 0.06 24.5 -2432000
108.4 ***** -625698 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -549865 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -649092 -635904 -13188 0.54 26.1 -2432000 112.0 -538408 -534428 -3980 0.16 22.0 -2432000
113.0 ***** -639765 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -531234 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -677054 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** -497617 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -718577 -703488 -15089 0.62 28.9 -2432000 130.0 -488123 -472945 -15178 0.62 19.4 -2432000
131.5 ***** -709437 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** -467667 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -790306 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** -414831 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -802227 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** -410029 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -808899 -809691 792 0.03 33.3 -2432000 151.0 -416958 -407296 -9662 0.40 16.7 -2432000
154.5 ***** -828967 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** -399190 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -822285 -812537 -9748 0.40 33.4 -2432000 169.0 -373732 -355430 -18302 0.75 14.6 -2432000
179.5 -732154 -718624 -13530 0.88 46.7 -1539000 179.5 -334922 -317170 -17752 1.15 20.6 -1539000
190.0 -574901 -572170 -2731 0.23 48.6 -1178000 190.0 -286679 -278518 -8161 0.69 23.6 -1178000
199.3 -434849 -430350 -4499 0.52 50.0 -860000 199.3 -250672 -242599 -8073 0.94 28.2 -860000
214.5 -228479 -223137 -5342 1.39 58.0 -385000 214.5 -165004 -161660 -3344 0.87 42.0 -385000
229.0 -53574 -54418 844 0.88 56.7 -96000 229.0 -44727 -44097 -630 0.66 45.9 -96000
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -30214 -31020 806 0.30 11.5 -270000
30.0 -109603 -111435 1832 0.33 20.1 -555000
32.0 -135676 -138090 2414 0.37 21.4 -645300
34.0 -163983 -165656 1673 0.23 22.6 -732000
46.5 -344860 -340073 -4787 0.41 28.8 -1179500
60.0 -530229 -513128 -17101 1.11 33.3 -1543000
64.5 -589452 -570859 -18593 1.08 33.1 -1725000
72.0 ***** -666741 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -695804 -678424 -17380 0.86 33.7 -2015000
73.0 -699211 -682074 -17137 0.85 33.7 -2022300
77.1 ***** -741262 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -839881 -829775 -10106 0.42 34.1 -2432000
97.0 -997206 -994029 -3177 0.13 40.9 -2432000
108.4 ***** -1110751 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -1141774 -1146797 5023 0.21 47.2 -2432000
113.0 ***** -1157250 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -1219546 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -1214475 -1214421 -54 0.00 49.9 -2432000
131.5 ***** -1208383 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -1054690 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -1028333 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -1010997 -1011801 804 0.03 41.6 -2432000
154.5 ***** -960923 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -757694 -751150 -6544 0.27 30.9 -2432000
179.5 -612274 -606362 -5912 0.38 39.4 -1539000
190.0 -472119 -475229 3110 0.26 40.3 -1178000
199.3 -369217 -366914 -2303 0.27 42.7 -860000
214.5 -205906 -202339 -3567 0.93 52.6 -385000
229.0 -50460 -50715 255 0.27 52.8 -96000

26
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(SHEAR FORCE)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 3986 4299 -313 1.06 14.6 29500 21.0 -16979 -17124 145 0.50 58.8 -29100
30.0 ***** 898 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -28461 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -36 -280 244 0.47 0.5 -51500 32.0 -32421 -32220 -201 0.39 62.6 -51500
34.0 -3398 -2975 -423 0.77 5.4 -55100 34.0 -37617 -36980 -637 1.16 67.1 -55100
46.5 -937 -824 -113 0.23 1.6 -50100 46.5 -45523 -44701 -822 1.64 89.2 -50100
60.0 5602 4919 683 1.33 9.6 51200 60.0 -48394 -48686 292 0.58 97.2 -50100
64.5 8689 8012 677 1.07 12.7 63200 64.5 -48034 -48531 497 0.80 78.1 -62100
72.0 11546 10383 1163 1.34 12.0 86500 72.0 -49046 -48729 -317 0.37 57.1 -85400
72.8 ***** 9788 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** -49908 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 9774 9762 12 0.01 11.5 85200 73.0 -50219 -49802 -417 0.50 59.2 -84100
77.1 10856 11002 -146 0.21 15.6 70600 77.1 -40938 -40278 -660 0.95 57.9 -69600
83.5 12395 12532 -137 0.19 17.8 70600 83.5 -26341 -25970 -371 0.53 37.3 -69600
97.0 14841 14602 239 0.44 27.1 53800 97.0 4625 3990 635 1.18 7.4 53800
108.4 15433 14584 849 1.34 23.0 63400 108.4 30480 29545 935 1.47 46.6 63400
112.0 11037 10239 798 1.13 14.5 70600 112.0 32643 32405 238 0.34 45.9 70600
113.0 10921 10287 634 0.94 15.2 67800 113.0 32530 32426 104 0.15 47.8 67800
123.0 8222 8745 -523 0.77 12.9 67800 123.0 30509 31217 -708 1.04 46.0 67800
130.0 5825 6396 -571 0.86 9.6 66600 130.0 29286 29756 -470 0.71 44.7 66600
131.5 5250 5747 -497 0.75 8.6 66600 131.5 29038 29366 -328 0.49 44.1 66600
148.0 -2690 -3082 392 0.59 4.6 -66600 148.0 26436 25913 523 0.79 38.9 66600
150.0 -5704 -5747 43 0.06 8.5 -68000 150.0 24230 23397 833 1.23 34.5 67900
151.0 -8730 -7995 -735 1.08 11.8 -68000 151.0 21707 21417 290 0.43 31.5 67900
154.5 -10739 -9945 -794 1.27 15.9 -62400 154.5 21366 21423 -57 0.09 34.9 61300
169.0 -20868 -20833 -35 0.06 33.4 -62400 169.0 19680 20070 -390 0.64 32.7 61300
179.5 -29384 -29691 307 0.49 47.6 -62400 179.5 18822 18413 409 0.67 30.0 61300
190.0 -41824 -42141 317 0.32 42.7 -98600 190.0 14137 14077 60 0.06 14.4 97600
199.3 -23019 -22608 -411 0.62 34.1 -66300 199.3 15294 15958 -664 1.02 24.5 65200
214.5 4363 4712 -349 1.09 14.7 32000 214.5 15695 15330 365 1.14 47.9 32000
229.0 21716 21210 506 2.26 94.7 22400 229.0 13082 13022 60 0.27 58.1 22400
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -2918 -2689 -229 0.79 9.2 -29100 21.0 -25581 -25188 -393 1.35 86.6 -29100
30.0 ***** -8504 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -38760 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -11101 -11013 -88 0.17 21.4 -51500 32.0 -45433 -45476 43 0.08 88.3 -51500
34.0 -15143 -14702 -441 0.80 26.7 -55100 34.0 -48905 -48455 -450 0.82 87.9 -55100
46.5 -16552 -16337 -215 0.43 32.6 -50100 46.5 -30249 -30946 697 1.39 61.8 -50100
60.0 -13536 -14072 536 1.07 28.1 -50100 60.0 -2160 -2779 619 1.24 5.5 -50100
64.5 -11433 -11942 509 0.82 19.2 -62100 64.5 8668 7890 778 1.23 12.5 63200
72.0 -9985 -9646 -339 0.40 11.3 -85400 72.0 24725 23787 938 1.08 27.5 86500
72.8 ***** -10964 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 23110 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -11932 -11213 -719 0.85 13.3 -84100 73.0 23388 22871 517 0.61 26.8 85200
77.1 -11491 -10739 -752 1.08 15.4 -69600 77.1 22056 21686 370 0.52 30.7 70600
83.5 -10862 -10400 -462 0.66 14.9 -69600 83.5 20253 19953 300 0.42 28.3 70600
97.0 -9816 -9151 -665 1.25 17.2 -53100 97.0 17369 16945 424 0.79 31.5 53800
108.4 -9745 -10681 936 1.47 16.7 -63800 108.4 15376 14623 753 1.19 23.1 63400
112.0 -14194 -13296 -898 1.27 18.8 -70600 112.0 10514 10256 258 0.37 14.5 70600
113.0 -14314 -13433 -881 1.30 19.8 -67800 113.0 10354 10258 96 0.14 15.1 67800
123.0 -16818 -16622 -196 0.29 24.5 -67800 123.0 8077 9051 -974 1.44 13.3 67800
130.0 -18824 -18047 -777 1.17 27.1 -66600 130.0 6909 7798 -889 1.33 11.7 66600
131.5 -19287 -18475 -812 1.22 27.7 -66600 131.5 6699 7476 -777 1.17 11.2 66600
148.0 -25372 -26248 876 1.32 39.4 -66600 148.0 5092 4691 401 0.60 7.0 66600
150.0 -28102 -27447 -655 0.96 40.4 -68000 150.0 3067 2745 322 0.47 4.0 67900
151.0 -29847 -29663 -184 0.27 43.6 -68000 151.0 660 1114 -454 0.67 1.6 67900
154.5 -22558 -22900 342 0.55 36.7 -62400 154.5 710 1516 -806 1.31 2.5 61300
169.0 7503 8342 -839 1.37 13.6 61300 169.0 1158 1529 -371 0.61 2.5 61300
179.5 29201 28765 436 0.71 46.9 61300 179.5 2363 1978 385 0.63 3.2 61300
190.0 44808 44434 374 0.38 45.5 97600 190.0 177 494 -317 0.32 0.5 97600
199.3 40216 40849 -633 0.97 62.7 65200 199.3 3893 4350 -457 0.70 6.7 65200
214.5 30207 29937 270 0.84 93.6 32000 214.5 9024 8792 232 0.73 27.5 32000
229.0 18267 18017 250 1.12 80.4 22400 229.0 10702 10859 -157 0.70 48.5 22400
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -9804 -9691 -113 0.39 33.3 -29100
30.0 ***** -18468 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -21599 -21603 4 0.01 41.9 -51500
34.0 -26213 -25780 -433 0.79 46.8 -55100
46.5 -30817 -30186 -631 1.26 60.3 -50100
60.0 -30666 -31223 557 1.11 62.3 -50100
64.5 -29391 -30231 840 1.35 48.7 -62100
72.0 -29061 -29201 140 0.16 34.2 -85400
72.8 ***** -30425 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -31131 -30644 -487 0.58 36.4 -84100
77.1 -31130 -30342 -788 1.13 43.6 -69600
83.5 -31104 -30697 -407 0.58 44.1 -69600
97.0 -31000 -31387 387 0.73 59.1 -53100
108.4 -31152 -31669 517 0.81 49.6 -63800
112.0 -34545 -35137 592 0.84 49.8 -70600
113.0 -32453 -32630 177 0.26 48.1 -67800
123.0 -11215 -10455 -760 1.12 15.4 -67800
130.0 3705 3856 -151 0.23 5.8 66600
131.5 6902 7155 -253 0.38 10.7 66600
148.0 41843 41245 598 0.90 61.9 66600
150.0 43659 42887 772 1.14 63.2 67900
151.0 42127 42385 -258 0.38 62.4 67900
154.5 41361 41934 -573 0.93 68.4 61300
169.0 37458 38232 -774 1.26 62.4 61300
179.5 34536 33575 961 1.57 54.8 61300
190.0 27401 27095 306 0.31 27.8 97600
199.3 26084 26828 -744 1.14 41.1 65200
214.5 21971 21595 376 1.18 67.5 32000
229.0 15308 15203 105 0.47 67.9 22400

27
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(BENDING MOMENT)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 70296 69127 1169 0.49 29.0 238000 21.0 -122674 -119300 -3374 1.25 44.2 -270000
30.0 93169 90140 3029 0.67 19.9 452000 30.0 -296184 -295258 -926 0.17 53.2 -555000
32.0 94599 90339 4260 0.83 17.7 511200 32.0 -347872 -347791 -81 0.01 53.9 -645300
34.0 92492 89110 3382 0.60 15.7 568000 34.0 -403939 -402473 -1466 0.20 55.0 -732000
46.5 70640 80350 -9710 1.05 8.7 928000 46.5 -825605 -806126 -19479 1.65 68.3 -1179500
60.0 95617 89336 6281 0.49 7.0 1278000 60.0 -1339047 -1311558 -27489 1.78 85.0 -1543000
64.5 122456 111446 11010 0.80 8.1 1379000 64.5 -1513076 -1483270 -29806 1.73 86.0 -1725000
72.0 ***** 173155 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -1765179 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 197091 181801 15290 0.99 11.8 1542400 72.8 -1830140 -1796877 -33263 1.65 89.2 -2015000
73.0 199153 184472 14681 0.94 11.8 1557900 73.0 -1840182 -1806550 -33632 1.66 89.3 -2022300
77.1 ***** 222574 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -1949228 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 295413 288675 6738 0.28 11.9 2424000 83.5 -2163019 -2110336 -52683 2.17 86.8 -2432000
97.0 447615 448723 -1108 0.05 18.5 2424000 97.0 -2281049 -2221736 -59313 2.44 91.4 -2432000
108.4 ***** 583685 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -2084427 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 631619 621878 9741 0.40 25.7 2424000 112.0 -2026253 -1998182 -28071 1.15 82.2 -2432000
113.0 ***** 630925 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -1972529 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 716497 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** -1720393 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 762115 765197 -3082 0.13 31.6 2424000 130.0 -1581882 -1551419 -30463 1.25 63.8 -2432000
131.5 ***** 773726 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** -1516377 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 789050 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** -1170395 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 777830 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** -1136924 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 782858 769932 12926 0.53 31.8 2424000 151.0 -1122667 -1117493 -5174 0.21 45.9 -2432000
154.5 ***** 742268 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** -1058395 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 578809 571916 6893 0.28 23.6 2424000 169.0 -826236 -819751 -6485 0.27 33.7 -2432000
179.5 371329 370911 418 0.02 19.6 1896500 179.5 -665380 -656806 -8574 0.56 42.7 -1539000
190.0 84387 80623 3764 0.31 6.6 1228400 190.0 -514666 -520409 5743 0.49 44.2 -1178000
199.3 -153533 -146787 -6746 0.78 17.1 -860000 199.3 -406768 -405800 -968 0.11 47.2 -860000
214.5 -254705 -247715 -6990 1.82 64.3 -385000 214.5 -214377 -209516 -4861 1.26 54.4 -385000
229.0 -91134 -92155 1021 1.06 96.0 -96000 229.0 -48168 -49292 1124 1.17 51.3 -96000
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 10373 13016 -2643 1.11 5.5 238000 21.0 -204488 -204474 -14 0.01 75.7 -270000
30.0 -32719 -33427 708 0.13 6.0 -555000 30.0 -457437 -454181 -3256 0.59 81.8 -555000
32.0 -49411 -51246 1835 0.28 7.9 -645300 32.0 -530436 -526129 -4307 0.67 81.5 -645300
34.0 -70013 -70735 722 0.10 9.7 -732000 34.0 -606486 -597622 -8864 1.21 81.6 -732000
46.5 -230730 -214429 -16301 1.38 18.2 -1179500 46.5 -1012420 -990713 -21707 1.84 84.0 -1179500
60.0 -395747 -375853 -19894 1.29 24.4 -1543000 60.0 -1196160 -1194103 -2057 0.13 77.4 -1543000
64.5 -440153 -421041 -19112 1.11 24.4 -1725000 64.5 -1185393 -1185376 -17 0.00 68.7 -1725000
72.0 ***** -481385 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -1084070 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -504655 -488599 -16056 0.80 24.2 -2015000 72.8 -1066666 -1069022 2356 0.12 53.1 -2015000
73.0 -506961 -490857 -16104 0.80 24.3 -2022300 73.0 -1061995 -1064419 2424 0.12 52.6 -2022300
77.1 ***** -526800 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -990881 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -601021 -579016 -22005 0.90 23.8 -2432000 83.5 -881089 -884663 3574 0.15 36.4 -2432000
97.0 -710077 -686727 -23350 0.96 28.2 -2432000 97.0 -681110 -683881 2771 0.11 28.1 -2432000
108.4 ***** -790995 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -544176 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -828182 -829870 1688 0.07 34.1 -2432000 112.0 -494658 -507590 12932 0.53 20.9 -2432000
113.0 ***** -841215 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -499797 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -959503 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** -426567 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -1060686 -1052351 -8335 0.34 43.3 -2432000 130.0 -374183 -382155 7972 0.33 15.7 -2432000
131.5 ***** -1073909 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** -373623 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -1369113 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** -311552 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -1411313 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** -309131 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -1438405 -1437571 -834 0.03 59.1 -2432000 151.0 -284411 -308181 23770 0.98 12.7 -2432000
154.5 ***** -1508507 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** -305813 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -1596660 -1581214 -15446 0.64 65.0 -2432000 169.0 -276331 -287524 11193 0.46 11.8 -2432000
179.5 -1440862 -1408809 -32053 2.08 91.5 -1539000 179.5 -263823 -268872 5049 0.33 17.5 -1539000
190.0 -1108254 -1096909 -11345 0.96 93.1 -1178000 190.0 -242299 -257375 15076 1.28 21.8 -1178000
199.3 -792308 -784397 -7911 0.92 91.2 -860000 199.3 -229424 -234512 5088 0.59 27.3 -860000
214.5 -355533 -352065 -3468 0.90 91.4 -385000 214.5 -149271 -146950 -2321 0.60 38.2 -385000
229.0 -73770 -73814 44 0.05 76.9 -96000 229.0 -36313 -36806 493 0.51 38.3 -96000
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -54199 -50813 -3386 1.25 18.8 -270000
30.0 -161466 -162466 1000 0.18 29.3 -555000
32.0 -195412 -197747 2335 0.36 30.6 -645300
34.0 -233505 -234935 1430 0.20 32.1 -732000
46.5 -522903 -509294 -13609 1.15 43.2 -1179500
60.0 -859476 -843154 -16322 1.06 54.6 -1543000
64.5 -967594 -951637 -15957 0.93 55.2 -1725000
72.0 ***** -1122840 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -1155900 -1141966 -13934 0.69 56.7 -2015000
73.0 -1162072 -1147930 -14142 0.70 56.8 -2022300
77.1 ***** -1245744 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -1423183 -1397086 -26097 1.07 57.4 -2432000
97.0 -1758008 -1727531 -30477 1.25 71.0 -2432000
108.4 ***** -2028694 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -2133732 -2130902 -2830 0.12 87.6 -2432000
113.0 ***** -2158313 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -2328979 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -2355574 -2342178 -13396 0.55 96.3 -2432000
131.5 ***** -2334297 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -2020385 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -1960537 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -1922528 -1922608 80 0.00 79.1 -2432000
154.5 ***** -1805518 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -1347992 -1342226 -5766 0.24 55.2 -2432000
179.5 -1045196 -1035171 -10025 0.65 67.3 -1539000
190.0 -771494 -774416 2922 0.25 65.7 -1178000
199.3 -573528 -569188 -4340 0.50 66.2 -860000
214.5 -275288 -267466 -7822 2.03 69.5 -385000
229.0 -59170 -58640 -530 0.55 61.1 -96000

28
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(SHEAR FORCE)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 1066 1209 -143 0.48 4.1 29500 21.0 -22545 -22400 -145 0.50 77.0 -29100
30.0 ***** -3528 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -36416 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -4671 -5083 412 0.80 9.9 -51500 32.0 -41052 -40718 -334 0.65 79.1 -51500
34.0 -8548 -8191 -357 0.65 14.9 -55100 34.0 -46887 -47600 713 1.29 86.4 -55100
46.5 14381 13701 680 1.33 26.8 51200 46.5 -35217 -34231 -986 1.97 68.3 -50100
60.0 47255 46729 526 1.03 91.3 51200 60.0 -12887 -13009 122 0.24 26.0 -50100
64.5 59387 58445 942 1.49 92.5 63200 64.5 -3942 -4434 492 0.79 7.1 -62100
72.0 77337 76605 732 0.85 88.6 86500 72.0 9282 9780 -498 0.58 11.3 86500
72.8 ***** 75519 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 11590 ***** ***** ***** *****
* 73.0 75718 74748 970 1.14 87.7 85200 * 73.0 11620 12135 -515 0.60 14.2 85200
77.1 60388 59475 913 1.29 84.2 70600 77.1 10651 9670 981 1.39 13.7 70600
83.5 46742 46387 355 0.50 65.7 70600 83.5 9368 9117 251 0.36 12.9 70600
97.0 17395 16604 791 1.47 30.9 53800 97.0 6786 6498 288 0.54 12.1 53800
108.4 -8368 -8366 -2 0.00 13.1 -63800 108.4 4346 4120 226 0.36 6.5 63400
* 112.0 -24325 -24836 511 0.72 35.2 -70600 * 112.0 2436 1572 864 1.22 2.2 70600
113.0 -22708 -22957 249 0.37 33.9 -67800 113.0 1214 1041 173 0.26 1.5 67800
123.0 -6542 -6183 -359 0.53 9.1 -67800 123.0 18655 19458 -803 1.18 28.7 67800
130.0 4436 4867 -431 0.65 7.3 66600 130.0 31140 31806 -666 1.00 47.8 66600
131.5 6746 7090 -344 0.52 10.6 66600 131.5 33839 34367 -528 0.79 51.6 66600
148.0 30953 30391 562 0.84 45.6 66600 148.0 63862 63289 573 0.86 95.0 66600
150.0 31641 31020 621 0.91 45.7 67900 150.0 65388 64358 1030 1.52 94.8 67900
* 151.0 28909 29243 -334 0.49 43.1 67900 * 151.0 63175 62861 314 0.46 92.6 67900
154.5 7291 8094 -803 1.31 13.2 61300 154.5 43381 42888 493 0.80 70.0 61300
169.0 -31550 -31188 -362 0.58 50.0 -62400 169.0 7276 6805 471 0.77 11.1 61300
179.5 -60485 -60405 -80 0.13 96.8 -62400 179.5 -18320 -18818 498 0.80 30.2 -62400
* 190.0 -96013 -97141 1128 1.14 98.5 -98600 * 190.0 -53468 -54400 932 0.95 55.2 -98600
199.3 -63601 -62110 -1491 2.25 93.7 -66300 199.3 -34562 -34224 -338 0.51 51.6 -66300
214.5 -14486 -14155 -331 1.01 43.0 -32900 214.5 -5829 -6162 333 1.01 18.7 -32900
229.0 18764 18251 513 2.29 81.5 22400 229.0 12934 12890 44 0.20 57.5 22400
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -3470 -3117 -353 1.21 10.7 -29100 21.0 -22133 -21746 -387 1.33 74.7 -29100
30.0 ***** -9330 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -34898 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -12190 -11944 -246 0.48 23.2 -51500 32.0 -40061 -39029 -1032 2.00 75.8 -51500
34.0 -16555 -15964 -591 1.07 29.0 -55100 34.0 -43978 -43357 -621 1.13 78.7 -55100
46.5 3366 4067 -701 1.37 7.9 51200 46.5 -9940 -10286 346 0.69 20.5 -50100
60.0 33056 32171 885 1.73 62.8 51200 60.0 37605 37444 161 0.31 73.1 51200
64.5 44147 42973 1174 1.86 68.0 63200 64.5 55011 54474 537 0.85 86.2 63200
72.0 60396 61826 -1430 1.65 71.5 86500 72.0 81931 83017 -1086 1.26 96.0 86500
72.8 ***** 60570 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 81940 ***** ***** ***** *****
* 73.0 58538 59745 -1207 1.42 70.1 85200 * 73.0 80482 81015 -533 0.63 95.1 85200
77.1 40554 41074 -520 0.74 58.2 70600 77.1 67366 66562 804 1.14 94.3 70600
83.5 25710 26321 -611 0.87 37.3 70600 83.5 51612 51145 467 0.66 72.4 70600
97.0 -6122 -5689 -433 0.82 10.7 -53100 97.0 19068 19177 -109 0.20 35.6 53800
108.4 -33913 -33591 -322 0.50 52.7 -63800 108.4 -8005 -7168 -837 1.31 11.2 -63800
* 112.0 -52592 -52633 41 0.06 74.6 -70600 * 112.0 -24440 -24381 -59 0.08 34.5 -70600
113.0 -51153 -50895 -258 0.38 75.1 -67800 113.0 -22901 -22508 -393 0.58 33.2 -67800
123.0 -36739 -36500 -239 0.35 53.8 -67800 123.0 -6837 -6435 -402 0.59 9.5 -67800
130.0 -26962 -26699 -263 0.39 40.1 -66600 130.0 4790 5483 -693 1.04 8.2 66600
131.5 -24907 -24437 -470 0.71 36.7 -66600 131.5 7316 8007 -691 1.04 12.0 66600
148.0 -3436 -3117 -319 0.48 4.7 -66600 148.0 35701 35083 618 0.93 52.7 66600
150.0 -3052 -2810 -242 0.36 4.1 -68000 150.0 37072 36610 462 0.68 53.9 67900
* 151.0 -4637 -4219 -418 0.61 6.2 -68000 * 151.0 34770 35390 -620 0.91 52.1 67900
154.5 -4435 -4878 443 0.71 7.8 -62400 154.5 18165 18496 -331 0.54 30.2 61300
169.0 -7638 -7526 -112 0.18 12.1 -62400 169.0 -14752 -14392 -360 0.58 23.1 -62400
179.5 -10114 -9910 -204 0.33 15.9 -62400 179.5 -37806 -37500 -306 0.49 60.1 -62400
* 190.0 -16064 -15967 -97 0.10 16.2 -98600 * 190.0 -67631 -67973 342 0.35 68.9 -98600
199.3 -3926 -3766 -160 0.24 5.7 -66300 199.3 -45785 -45387 -398 0.60 68.5 -66300
214.5 12361 12634 -273 0.85 39.5 32000 214.5 -12128 -12460 332 1.01 37.9 -32900
229.0 19912 19853 59 0.26 88.6 22400 229.0 10635 10752 -117 0.52 48.0 22400
No.3Hold Flooding
(Remark
21.0: The Mark(*)-9912
is corrected SF)-9641 -271 0.93 33.1 -29100
30.0 ***** -18101 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -21595 -21175 -420 0.82 41.1 -51500
34.0 -26365 -25886 -479 0.87 47.0 -55100
46.5 -8420 -8397 -23 0.05 16.8 -50100
60.0 20015 19556 459 0.90 38.2 51200
64.5 30885 30097 788 1.25 47.6 63200
72.0 47122 47609 -487 0.56 55.0 86500
72.8 ***** 46590 ***** ***** ***** *****
* 73.0 45318 45839 -521 0.61 53.8 85200
77.1 27719 28221 -502 0.71 40.0 70600
83.5 13139 13670 -531 0.75 19.4 70600
97.0 -17614 -17195 -419 0.79 32.4 -53100
108.4 -43690 -43181 -509 0.80 67.7 -63800
* 112.0 -50648 -50113 -535 0.76 71.0 -70600
113.0 -47780 -46956 -824 1.22 69.3 -67800
123.0 -17739 -17404 -335 0.49 25.7 -67800
130.0 3350 3878 -528 0.79 5.8 66600
131.5 7869 8293 -424 0.64 12.5 66600
148.0 57373 56345 1028 1.54 84.6 66600
150.0 60846 60907 -61 0.09 89.7 67900
* 151.0 58720 58834 -114 0.17 86.6 67900
154.5 48192 47860 332 0.54 78.1 61300
169.0 12902 13297 -395 0.64 21.7 61300
179.5 -12624 -12880 256 0.41 20.6 -62400
* 190.0 -48412 -49629 1217 1.23 50.3 -98600
199.3 -30029 -29486 -543 0.82 44.5 -66300
214.5 -2810 -3143 333 1.01 9.6 -32900
229.0 14165 13934 231 1.03 62.2 22400

29
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0]

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(BENDING MOMENT)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 41253 43017 -1764 0.74 18.1 238000 21.0 -173111 -169267 -3844 1.42 62.7 -270000
30.0 34634 35707 -1073 0.24 7.9 452000 30.0 -397941 -402818 4877 0.88 72.6 -555000
32.0 28092 28279 -187 0.04 5.5 511200 32.0 -463591 -472199 8608 1.33 73.2 -645300
34.0 17924 21773 -3849 0.68 3.8 568000 34.0 -533864 -541412 7548 1.03 74.0 -732000
46.5 56665 64280 -7615 0.82 6.9 928000 46.5 -942962 -931604 -11358 0.96 79.0 -1179500
60.0 433441 439334 -5893 0.46 34.4 1278000 60.0 -1176368 -1168249 -8119 0.53 75.7 -1543000
64.5 648692 637072 11620 0.84 46.2 1379000 64.5 -1190946 -1192718 1772 0.10 69.1 -1725000
72.0 ***** 1073112 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -1151985 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 1162330 1128788 33542 2.17 73.2 1542400 72.8 -1129395 -1141024 11629 0.58 56.6 -2015000
73.0 1179279 1145765 33514 2.15 73.5 1557900 73.0 -1126498 -1137695 11197 0.55 56.3 -2022300
77.1 ***** 1403553 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -1085492 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 1760931 1724157 36774 1.52 71.1 2424000 83.5 -1015620 -1013383 -2237 0.09 41.7 -2432000
97.0 2127872 2087597 40275 1.66 86.1 2424000 97.0 -898382 -892495 -5887 0.24 36.7 -2432000
108.4 ***** 2053993 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -822836 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 2021606 1976850 44756 1.85 81.6 2424000 112.0 -803734 -806716 2982 0.12 33.2 -2432000
113.0 ***** 1953169 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -801728 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 1809411 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** -668869 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 1835364 1803607 31757 1.31 74.4 2424000 130.0 -503035 -489225 -13810 0.57 20.1 -2432000
131.5 ***** 1811825 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** -441846 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 2099708 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 272714 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 2153085 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 374969 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 2215548 2186731 28817 1.19 90.2 2424000 151.0 431389 438062 -6673 0.28 18.1 2424000
154.5 ***** 2264006 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 615409 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 2253745 2213774 39971 1.65 91.3 2424000 169.0 987679 997618 -9939 0.41 41.2 2424000
179.5 1838116 1800200 37916 2.00 94.9 1896500 179.5 912942 924371 -11429 0.60 48.7 1896500
190.0 1093182 1063868 29314 2.39 86.6 1228400 190.0 548882 556458 -7576 0.62 45.3 1228400
199.3 438171 431683 6488 1.01 67.5 640000 199.3 189108 196958 -7850 1.23 30.8 640000
214.5 -94298 -91401 -2897 0.75 23.7 -385000 214.5 -85431 -84014 -1417 0.37 21.8 -385000
229.0 -74547 -75225 678 0.71 78.4 -96000 229.0 -47415 -48502 1087 1.13 50.5 -96000
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 5052 8248 -3196 1.34 3.5 238000 21.0 -170292 -168491 -1801 0.67 62.4 -270000
30.0 -44223 -43584 -639 0.12 7.9 -555000 30.0 -390240 -389735 -505 0.09 70.2 -555000
32.0 -62753 -63037 284 0.04 9.8 -645300 32.0 -454299 -456310 2011 0.31 70.7 -645300
34.0 -85268 -85961 693 0.09 11.7 -732000 34.0 -521420 -520458 -962 0.13 71.1 -732000
46.5 -142625 -126305 -16320 1.38 10.7 -1179500 46.5 -775489 -766024 -9465 0.80 64.9 -1179500
60.0 94217 111387 -17170 1.34 8.7 1278000 60.0 -556989 -553490 -3499 0.23 35.9 -1543000
64.5 254611 271596 -16985 1.23 19.7 1379000 64.5 -354120 -362117 7997 0.46 21.0 -1725000
72.0 ***** 634636 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** 115056 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 657193 678709 -21516 1.39 44.0 1542400 72.8 192064 179835 12229 0.79 11.7 1542400
73.0 670567 692069 -21502 1.38 44.4 1557900 73.0 210945 199593 11352 0.73 12.8 1557900
77.1 ***** 888834 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** 492236 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 1091034 1108802 -17768 0.73 45.7 2424000 83.5 854869 844393 10476 0.43 34.8 2424000
97.0 1219377 1227314 -7937 0.33 50.6 2424000 97.0 1255859 1237753 18106 0.75 51.1 2424000
108.4 ***** 962480 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** 1203450 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 807634 806927 707 0.03 33.3 2424000 112.0 1148171 1123382 24789 1.02 46.3 2424000
113.0 ***** 761217 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** 1098774 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 387730 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** 945227 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 200375 210986 -10611 0.44 8.7 2424000 130.0 950248 935166 15082 0.62 38.6 2424000
131.5 ***** 181498 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** 943900 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 29780 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 1262921 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 30347 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 1323799 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 17419 32094 -14675 0.61 1.3 2424000 151.0 1380285 1362428 17857 0.74 56.2 2424000
154.5 ***** 34171 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 1465431 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -31055 -16993 -14062 0.58 0.7 -2432000 169.0 1580122 1569109 11013 0.45 64.7 2424000
179.5 -111008 -94852 -16156 1.05 6.2 -1539000 179.5 1333351 1325582 7769 0.41 69.9 1896500
190.0 -232425 -225858 -6567 0.56 19.2 -1178000 190.0 825724 819980 5744 0.47 66.8 1228400
199.3 -318679 -312817 -5862 0.68 36.4 -860000 199.3 364338 368785 -4447 0.69 57.6 640000
214.5 -271035 -268706 -2329 0.60 69.8 -385000 214.5 -24846 -21787 -3059 0.79 5.7 -385000
229.0 -80332 -81577 1245 1.30 85.0 -96000 229.0 -37809 -38435 626 0.65 40.0 -96000
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -56765 -55398 -1367 0.51 20.5 -270000
30.0 -164937 -165584 647 0.12 29.8 -555000
32.0 -198979 -200293 1314 0.20 31.0 -645300
34.0 -237085 -239039 1954 0.27 32.7 -732000
46.5 -405162 -398904 -6258 0.53 33.8 -1179500
60.0 -306256 -288996 -17260 1.12 18.7 -1543000
64.5 -194558 -181508 -13050 0.76 10.5 -1725000
72.0 ***** 93487 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 117381 127381 -10000 0.65 8.3 1542400
73.0 128020 137590 -9570 0.61 8.8 1557900
77.1 ***** 290712 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 436304 444655 -8351 0.34 18.3 2424000
97.0 431797 440311 -8514 0.35 18.2 2424000
108.4 ***** 87751 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -101394 -91586 -9808 0.40 3.8 -2432000
113.0 ***** -142441 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -480146 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -556183 -537550 -18633 0.77 22.1 -2432000
131.5 ***** -528257 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -18542 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 84402 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 138154 150048 -11894 0.49 6.2 2424000
154.5 ***** 336990 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 768928 768921 7 0.00 31.7 2424000
179.5 742893 738072 4821 0.25 38.9 1896500
190.0 426862 418469 8393 0.68 34.1 1228400
199.3 105949 105039 910 0.14 16.4 640000
214.5 -118115 -116987 -1128 0.29 30.4 -385000
229.0 -53724 -53264 -460 0.48 55.5 -96000

30
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(SHEAR FORCE)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 14102 14301 -199 0.67 48.5 29500 21.0 11346 11640 -294 1.00 39.5 29500
30.0 ***** 23069 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** 16845 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 23894 23723 171 0.33 45.5 52100 32.0 16148 16464 -316 0.61 31.6 52100
34.0 24115 24335 -220 0.39 43.6 55800 34.0 15431 16062 -631 1.13 28.8 55800
46.5 25924 26193 -269 0.53 51.2 51200 46.5 11126 11469 -343 0.67 22.4 51200
60.0 24034 23880 154 0.30 46.6 51200 60.0 2861 2860 1 0.00 5.6 51200
64.5 22756 22579 177 0.28 35.7 63200 64.5 -455 -292 -163 0.26 0.5 -62100
72.0 20379 20492 -113 0.13 23.7 86500 72.0 -6009 -6189 180 0.21 7.2 -85400
72.8 ***** 20683 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** -5938 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 20296 20730 -434 0.51 24.3 85200 73.0 -6149 -5716 -433 0.51 6.8 -84100
77.1 18830 18901 -71 0.10 26.8 70600 77.1 -3664 -3543 -121 0.17 5.1 -69600
83.5 16340 16292 48 0.07 23.1 70600 83.5 13 72 -59 0.08 0.1 70600
97.0 11162 10806 356 0.66 20.1 53800 97.0 7864 7161 703 1.31 13.3 53800
108.4 6548 6095 453 0.71 9.6 63400 108.4 13961 13082 879 1.39 20.6 63400
112.0 5381 5756 -375 0.53 8.2 70600 112.0 14422 15287 -865 1.23 21.7 70600
113.0 5259 5347 -88 0.13 7.9 67800 113.0 14218 14772 -554 0.82 21.8 67800
123.0 933 543 390 0.58 0.8 67800 123.0 9372 9232 140 0.21 13.6 67800
130.0 -2108 -2665 557 0.84 4.0 -66600 130.0 6252 5862 390 0.59 8.8 66600
131.5 -2769 -3346 577 0.87 5.0 -66600 131.5 5603 5182 421 0.63 7.8 66600
148.0 -10472 -10923 451 0.68 16.4 -66600 148.0 -1374 -1497 123 0.18 2.2 -66600
150.0 -11367 -11585 218 0.32 17.0 -68000 150.0 -2116 -1955 -161 0.24 2.9 -68000
151.0 -11587 -11162 -425 0.63 16.4 -68000 151.0 -2237 -1400 -837 1.23 2.1 -68000
154.5 -13082 -13162 80 0.13 21.1 -62400 154.5 -3137 -2939 -198 0.32 4.7 -62400
169.0 -20829 -21181 352 0.56 33.9 -62400 169.0 -7764 -8268 504 0.81 13.3 -62400
179.5 -26552 -26854 302 0.48 43.0 -62400 179.5 -10651 -11206 555 0.89 18.0 -62400
190.0 -31820 -31080 -740 0.75 31.5 -98600 190.0 -12931 -12311 -620 0.63 12.5 -98600
199.3 -26513 -25665 -848 1.28 38.7 -66300 199.3 -14636 -14626 -10 0.02 22.1 -66300
214.5 -18215 -18371 156 0.47 55.8 -32900 214.5 -16073 -16278 205 0.62 49.5 -32900
229.0 -12167 -12406 239 1.04 54.2 -22900 229.0 -15727 -15599 -128 0.56 68.1 -22900
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 13554 13759 -205 0.69 46.6 29500 21.0 8879 9260 -381 1.29 31.4 29500
30.0 ***** 21462 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** 12600 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 21977 21825 152 0.29 41.9 52100 32.0 11341 11813 -472 0.91 22.7 52100
34.0 21936 22149 -213 0.38 39.7 55800 34.0 10212 10681 -469 0.84 19.1 55800
46.5 21911 22112 -201 0.39 43.2 51200 46.5 17869 17650 219 0.43 34.5 51200
60.0 17967 17888 79 0.15 34.9 51200 60.0 25691 25579 112 0.22 50.0 51200
64.5 16031 16018 13 0.02 25.3 63200 64.5 28115 27703 412 0.65 43.8 63200
72.0 12661 13079 -418 0.48 15.1 86500 72.0 31342 31264 78 0.09 36.1 86500
72.8 ***** 13184 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 31414 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 12463 13205 -742 0.87 15.5 85200 73.0 30991 31344 -353 0.41 36.8 85200
77.1 10659 10961 -302 0.43 15.5 70600 77.1 27773 27667 106 0.15 39.2 70600
83.5 7654 7773 -119 0.17 11.0 70600 83.5 22798 22473 325 0.46 31.8 70600
97.0 1445 1317 128 0.24 2.4 53800 97.0 13217 12610 607 1.13 23.4 53800
108.4 -3930 -3941 11 0.02 6.2 -63800 108.4 5392 5362 30 0.05 8.5 63400
112.0 -5293 -4403 -890 1.26 6.2 -70600 112.0 3280 3654 -374 0.53 5.2 70600
113.0 -5431 -4842 -589 0.87 7.1 -67800 113.0 3033 3174 -141 0.21 4.7 67800
123.0 -9845 -9837 -8 0.01 14.5 -67800 123.0 -2112 -1892 -220 0.32 2.8 -67800
130.0 -12877 -13065 188 0.28 19.6 -66600 130.0 -5279 -5298 19 0.03 8.0 -66600
131.5 -13527 -13739 212 0.32 20.6 -66600 131.5 -5922 -5971 49 0.07 9.0 -66600
148.0 -20900 -20958 58 0.09 31.5 -66600 148.0 -12578 -12256 -322 0.48 18.4 -66600
150.0 -21730 -21547 -183 0.27 31.7 -68000 150.0 -13261 -12630 -631 0.93 18.6 -68000
151.0 -21674 -20832 -842 1.24 30.6 -68000 151.0 -13344 -12806 -538 0.79 18.8 -68000
154.5 -19285 -18881 -404 0.65 30.3 -62400 154.5 -14067 -13853 -214 0.34 22.2 -62400
169.0 -10685 -10898 213 0.34 17.5 -62400 169.0 -17626 -17646 20 0.03 28.3 -62400
179.5 -4378 -4695 317 0.51 7.5 -62400 179.5 -19428 -19540 112 0.18 31.3 -62400
190.0 618 675 -57 0.06 0.7 97600 190.0 -20463 -19367 -1096 1.11 19.6 -98600
199.3 -3639 -4002 363 0.55 6.0 -66300 199.3 -20800 -20357 -443 0.67 30.7 -66300
214.5 -9715 -10074 359 1.09 30.6 -32900 214.5 -19628 -19587 -41 0.12 59.5 -32900
229.0 -13385 -13419 34 0.15 58.6 -22900 229.0 -16999 -16745 -254 1.11 73.1 -22900
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 12816 13087 -271 0.92 44.4 29500
30.0 ***** 19592 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 19710 19644 66 0.13 37.7 52100
34.0 19387 19661 -274 0.49 35.2 55800
46.5 17529 17664 -135 0.26 34.5 51200
60.0 11649 11520 129 0.25 22.5 51200
64.5 9091 9094 -3 0.00 14.4 63200
72.0 4757 5324 -567 0.66 6.2 86500
72.8 ***** 5346 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 4445 5341 -896 1.05 6.3 85200
77.1 2316 2696 -380 0.54 3.8 70600
83.5 -1159 -1045 -114 0.16 1.5 -69600
97.0 -8274 -8405 131 0.25 15.8 -53100
108.4 -14341 -14148 -193 0.30 22.2 -63800
112.0 -15672 -15154 -518 0.73 21.5 -70600
113.0 -14779 -14477 -302 0.45 21.4 -67800
123.0 -8687 -8478 -209 0.31 12.5 -67800
130.0 -4382 -4616 234 0.35 6.9 -66600
131.5 -3463 -3788 325 0.49 5.7 -66600
148.0 6353 5681 672 1.01 8.5 66600
150.0 6823 6286 537 0.79 9.3 67900
151.0 6779 7417 -638 0.94 10.9 67900
154.5 5759 5771 -12 0.02 9.4 61300
169.0 332 -274 606 0.97 0.4 -62400
179.5 -3361 -4010 649 1.04 6.4 -62400
190.0 -6587 -6145 -442 0.45 6.2 -98600
199.3 -9444 -9549 105 0.16 14.4 -66300
214.5 -13052 -13287 235 0.71 40.4 -32900
229.0 -14612 -14541 -71 0.31 63.5 -22900

31
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(BENDING MOMENT)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 119762 120888 -1126 0.47 50.8 238000 21.0 108360 109564 -1204 0.51 46.0 238000
30.0 255128 259871 -4743 1.05 57.5 452000 30.0 209282 214968 -5686 1.26 47.6 452000
32.0 293537 298658 -5121 1.00 58.4 511200 32.0 235696 241936 -6240 1.22 47.3 511200
34.0 331988 337282 -5294 0.93 59.4 568000 34.0 261087 267595 -6508 1.15 47.1 568000
46.5 585463 591611 -6148 0.66 63.8 928000 46.5 397741 403452 -5711 0.62 43.5 928000
60.0 857992 874621 -16629 1.30 68.4 1278000 60.0 476151 488874 -12723 1.00 38.3 1278000
64.5 942237 961827 -19590 1.42 69.7 1379000 64.5 480678 495820 -15142 1.10 36.0 1379000
72.0 ***** 1094930 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** 482358 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 1083393 1107891 -24498 1.59 71.8 1542400 72.8 457107 478425 -21318 1.38 31.0 1542400
73.0 1087451 1111930 -24479 1.57 71.4 1557900 73.0 455884 477296 -21412 1.37 30.6 1557900
77.1 ***** 1175313 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** 461959 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 1241776 1261923 -20147 0.83 52.1 2424000 83.5 430859 449959 -19100 0.79 18.6 2424000
97.0 1390224 1413811 -23587 0.97 58.3 2424000 97.0 474147 491963 -17816 0.73 20.3 2424000
108.4 ***** 1491128 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** 584580 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 1488080 1507294 -19214 0.79 62.2 2424000 112.0 616534 626079 -9545 0.39 25.8 2424000
113.0 ***** 1511744 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** 638504 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 1534898 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** 737641 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 1513779 1528935 -15156 0.63 63.1 2424000 130.0 766353 782497 -16144 0.67 32.3 2424000
131.5 ***** 1525328 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** 789710 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 1431944 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 819539 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 1415021 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 817642 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 1397954 1404747 -6793 0.28 58.0 2424000 151.0 797644 816535 -18891 0.78 33.7 2424000
154.5 ***** 1370791 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 810542 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 1166666 1171220 -4554 0.19 48.3 2424000 169.0 726583 743935 -17352 0.72 30.7 2424000
179.5 967657 969408 -1751 0.09 51.1 1896500 179.5 649344 661624 -12280 0.65 34.9 1896500
190.0 719703 720719 -1016 0.08 58.7 1228400 190.0 548747 558159 -9412 0.77 45.4 1228400
199.3 504250 504175 75 0.01 78.8 640000 199.3 447437 450754 -3317 0.52 70.4 640000
214.5 232758 237523 -4765 1.45 72.1 329500 214.5 258654 259816 -1162 0.35 78.9 329500
229.0 56143 55840 303 0.39 71.0 78700 229.0 70693 69560 1133 1.44 88.4 78700
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 117722 119054 -1332 0.56 50.0 238000 21.0 94337 95463 -1126 0.47 40.1 238000
30.0 245351 250263 -4912 1.09 55.4 452000 30.0 170166 174923 -4757 1.05 38.7 452000
32.0 280826 286126 -5300 1.04 56.0 511200 32.0 189025 194218 -5193 1.02 38.0 511200
34.0 316018 321484 -5466 0.96 56.6 568000 34.0 206490 213177 -6687 1.18 37.5 568000
46.5 538806 544523 -5717 0.62 58.7 928000 46.5 348331 358591 -10260 1.11 38.6 928000
60.0 756934 772890 -15956 1.25 60.5 1278000 60.0 585130 595131 -10001 0.78 46.6 1278000
64.5 818185 837490 -19305 1.40 60.7 1379000 64.5 682367 689528 -7161 0.52 50.0 1379000
72.0 ***** 928969 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** 867838 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 911247 937090 -25843 1.68 60.8 1542400 72.8 881338 887858 -6520 0.42 57.6 1542400
73.0 913743 939620 -25877 1.66 60.3 1557900 73.0 887566 894042 -6476 0.42 57.4 1557900
77.1 ***** 977474 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** 989363 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 998751 1022079 -23328 0.96 42.2 2424000 83.5 1114369 1113947 422 0.02 46.0 2424000
97.0 1047837 1076417 -28580 1.18 44.4 2424000 97.0 1309089 1307633 1456 0.06 53.9 2424000
108.4 ***** 1064711 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** 1389026 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 1023128 1051587 -28459 1.17 43.4 2424000 112.0 1407429 1402194 5235 0.22 57.8 2424000
113.0 ***** 1047898 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** 1405533 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 988651 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** 1412566 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 894112 924460 -30348 1.25 38.1 2424000 130.0 1393867 1392232 1635 0.07 57.4 2424000
131.5 ***** 908377 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** 1385469 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 679613 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 1263550 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 647692 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 1244840 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 600428 628495 -28067 1.16 25.9 2424000 151.0 1235152 1233709 1443 0.06 50.9 2424000
154.5 ***** 573003 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 1198231 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 369040 400477 -31437 1.30 16.5 2424000 169.0 1012984 1016280 -3296 0.14 41.9 2424000
179.5 305727 332389 -26662 1.41 17.5 1896500 179.5 857857 859417 -1560 0.08 45.3 1896500
190.0 293901 310293 -16392 1.33 25.3 1228400 190.0 689185 691151 -1966 0.16 56.3 1228400
199.3 283316 290446 -7130 1.11 45.4 640000 199.3 537538 536329 1209 0.19 83.8 640000
214.5 200075 202538 -2463 0.75 61.5 329500 214.5 290007 290091 -84 0.03 88.0 329500
229.0 61208 60174 1034 1.31 76.5 78700 229.0 75324 74441 883 1.12 94.6 78700
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 114856 116707 -1851 0.78 49.0 238000
30.0 232699 238627 -5928 1.31 52.8 452000
32.0 264666 271108 -6442 1.26 53.0 511200
34.0 296020 302732 -6712 1.18 53.3 568000
46.5 484250 491072 -6822 0.74 52.9 928000
60.0 644578 657184 -12606 0.99 51.4 1278000
64.5 681992 696623 -14631 1.06 50.5 1379000
72.0 ***** 742355 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 725666 745196 -19530 1.27 48.3 1542400
73.0 726563 746079 -19516 1.25 47.9 1557900
77.1 ***** 756193 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 740878 755471 -14593 0.60 31.2 2424000
97.0 689884 705697 -15813 0.65 29.1 2424000
108.4 ***** 600029 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 543231 556191 -12960 0.53 22.9 2424000
113.0 ***** 544600 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 452220 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 400746 413655 -12909 0.53 17.1 2424000
131.5 ***** 409458 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 428451 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 438000 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 432504 444871 -12367 0.51 18.4 2424000
154.5 ***** 465396 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 485041 504294 -19253 0.79 20.8 2424000
179.5 472262 486506 -14244 0.75 25.7 1896500
190.0 428755 439321 -10566 0.86 35.8 1228400
199.3 370017 373620 -3603 0.56 58.4 640000
214.5 231077 232116 -1039 0.32 70.4 329500
229.0 66324 65021 1303 1.66 82.6 78700

32
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(SHEAR FORCE)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 22103 22174 -71 0.24 75.2 29500 21.0 8088 8307 -219 0.74 28.2 29500
30.0 ***** 30021 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** 8334 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 30868 30751 117 0.22 59.0 52100 32.0 6518 7147 -629 1.21 13.7 52100
34.0 30381 31135 -754 1.35 55.8 55800 34.0 4727 5154 -427 0.77 9.2 55800
46.5 23318 23062 256 0.50 45.0 51200 46.5 -9961 -9961 0 0.00 19.9 -50100
60.0 10838 10617 221 0.43 20.7 51200 60.0 -29381 -30250 869 1.73 60.4 -50100
64.5 5883 5471 412 0.65 8.7 63200 64.5 -36392 -37293 901 1.45 60.1 -62100
72.0 -2814 -3548 734 0.86 4.2 -85400 72.0 -48039 -48566 527 0.62 56.9 -85400
72.8 ***** -4122 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** -48666 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -3830 -4313 483 0.57 5.1 -84100 * 73.0 -55217 -54384 -833 0.99 64.7 -84100
77.1 -8047 -8874 827 1.19 12.8 -69600 77.1 -53002 -52701 -301 0.43 75.7 -69600
83.5 -14806 -15480 674 0.97 22.2 -69600 83.5 -49639 -49744 105 0.15 71.5 -69600
97.0 -29197 -29822 625 1.18 56.2 -53100 97.0 -42428 -42896 468 0.88 80.8 -53100
108.4 -42148 -42410 262 0.41 66.5 -63800 108.4 -36910 -36255 -655 1.03 56.8 -63800
* 112.0 -45026 -45322 296 0.42 64.2 -70600 * 112.0 -35648 -35219 -429 0.61 49.9 -70600
113.0 -42774 -42994 220 0.32 63.4 -67800 113.0 -25081 -25827 746 1.10 38.1 -67800
123.0 -20798 -21069 271 0.40 31.1 -67800 123.0 -2866 -2932 66 0.10 4.3 -67800
130.0 -4967 -5331 364 0.55 8.0 -66600 130.0 13606 13128 478 0.72 19.7 66600
131.5 -1578 -2027 449 0.67 3.0 -66600 131.5 17145 16562 583 0.88 24.9 66600
148.0 34269 33751 518 0.78 50.7 66600 148.0 55459 53951 1508 2.26 81.0 66600
150.0 37321 36872 449 0.66 54.3 67900 150.0 58985 58364 621 0.91 86.0 67900
* 151.0 36946 37771 -825 1.22 55.6 67900 * 151.0 59601 60054 -453 0.67 88.4 67900
154.5 30869 30664 205 0.33 50.0 61300 154.5 56245 55615 630 1.03 90.7 61300
169.0 14187 14635 -448 0.73 23.9 61300 169.0 41579 40566 1013 1.65 66.2 61300
179.5 1649 1782 -133 0.22 2.9 61300 179.5 31538 30696 842 1.37 50.1 61300
* 190.0 -20615 -19332 -1283 1.30 19.6 -98600 190.0 22166 22744 -578 0.59 23.3 97600
199.3 -16294 -15747 -547 0.83 23.8 -66300 199.3 12309 12308 1 0.00 18.9 65200
214.5 -9241 -9384 143 0.43 28.5 -32900 214.5 -1796 -2027 231 0.70 6.2 -32900
229.0 -4294 -4599 305 1.33 20.1 -22900 229.0 -11097 -11004 -93 0.41 48.1 -22900
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 18574 18512 62 0.21 62.8 29500 21.0 118 227 -109 0.37 0.8 29500
30.0 ***** 23721 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -2314 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 23726 23857 -131 0.25 45.8 52100 32.0 -5723 -6121 398 0.77 11.9 -51500
34.0 22652 23185 -533 0.96 41.6 55800 34.0 -7622 -6949 -673 1.22 12.6 -55100
46.5 11957 12270 -313 0.61 24.0 51200 46.5 -1170 -1220 50 0.10 2.4 -50100
60.0 -4093 -4039 -54 0.11 8.1 -50100 60.0 5782 5136 646 1.26 10.0 51200
64.5 -10094 -10006 -88 0.14 16.1 -62100 64.5 7920 7066 854 1.35 11.2 63200
72.0 -20250 -19776 -474 0.56 23.2 -85400 72.0 10609 10486 123 0.14 12.1 86500
72.8 ***** -20421 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 9989 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -21438 -20633 -805 0.96 24.5 -84100 * 73.0 9593 9642 -49 0.06 11.3 85200
77.1 -26163 -25548 -615 0.88 36.7 -69600 77.1 -6149 -7135 986 1.42 10.3 -69600
83.5 -33687 -32908 -779 1.12 47.3 -69600 83.5 -14214 -15004 790 1.14 21.6 -69600
97.0 -49512 -48378 -1134 2.14 91.1 -53100 97.0 -29994 -30223 229 0.43 56.9 -53100
108.4 -63056 -61417 -1639 2.57 96.3 -63800 108.4 -42740 -41622 -1118 1.75 65.2 -63800
* 112.0 -66129 -66053 -76 0.11 93.6 -70600 * 112.0 -46504 -46647 143 0.20 66.1 -70600
113.0 -63882 -63450 -432 0.64 93.6 -67800 113.0 -44360 -44336 -24 0.04 65.4 -67800
123.0 -41724 -41236 -488 0.72 60.8 -67800 123.0 -22563 -21837 -726 1.07 32.2 -67800
130.0 -25653 -25253 -400 0.60 37.9 -66600 130.0 -6114 -5820 -294 0.44 8.7 -66600
131.5 -22210 -21874 -336 0.50 32.8 -66600 131.5 -2540 -2370 -170 0.26 3.6 -66600
148.0 14765 13977 788 1.18 21.0 66600 148.0 36380 35772 608 0.91 53.7 66600
150.0 18035 18050 -15 0.02 26.6 67900 150.0 40019 40338 -319 0.47 59.4 67900
* 151.0 26544 27059 -515 0.76 39.9 67900 * 151.0 41490 42127 -637 0.94 62.0 67900
154.5 28644 27961 683 1.11 45.6 61300 154.5 38395 38312 83 0.14 62.5 61300
169.0 36389 36371 18 0.03 59.3 61300 169.0 25314 24891 423 0.69 40.6 61300
179.5 42143 41325 818 1.33 67.4 61300 179.5 16952 16714 238 0.39 27.3 61300
* 190.0 46012 46087 -75 0.08 47.2 97600 190.0 9530 10875 -1345 1.38 11.1 97600
199.3 26745 26773 -28 0.04 41.1 65200 199.3 1971 2746 -775 1.19 4.2 65200
214.5 6948 6975 -27 0.08 21.8 32000 214.5 -7796 -8065 269 0.82 24.5 -32900
229.0 -6946 -7068 122 0.53 30.9 -22900 229.0 -13258 -12904 -354 1.55 56.3 -22900
No.3Hold Flooding
(Remark
21.0: The Mark(*) is*****
corrected SF)
21135 ***** ***** 71.6 29500
30.0 ***** 28993 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 ***** 29825 ***** ***** 57.2 52100
34.0 ***** 30343 ***** ***** 54.4 55800
46.5 ***** 23982 ***** ***** 46.8 51200
60.0 ***** 14217 ***** ***** 27.8 51200
64.5 ***** 10675 ***** ***** 16.9 63200
72.0 ***** 5147 ***** ***** 6.0 86500
72.8 ***** 4985 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 ***** 4923 ***** ***** 5.8 85200
77.1 ***** 2189 ***** ***** 3.1 70600
83.5 ***** -1627 ***** ***** 2.3 -69600
97.0 ***** -8888 ***** ***** 16.7 -53100
108.4 ***** -14277 ***** ***** 22.4 -63800
* 112.0 ***** -21780 ***** ***** 30.8 -70600
113.0 ***** -21025 ***** ***** 31.0 -67800
123.0 ***** -14144 ***** ***** 20.9 -67800
130.0 ***** -9124 ***** ***** 13.7 -66600
131.5 ***** -8038 ***** ***** 12.1 -66600
148.0 ***** 3934 ***** ***** 5.9 66600
150.0 ***** 5507 ***** ***** 8.1 67900
* 151.0 ***** 6735 ***** ***** 9.9 67900
154.5 ***** 156 ***** ***** 0.3 61300
169.0 ***** -4606 ***** ***** 7.4 -62400
179.5 ***** -7160 ***** ***** 11.5 -62400
190.0 ***** -7901 ***** ***** 8.0 -98600
199.3 ***** -11215 ***** ***** 16.9 -66300
214.5 ***** -15024 ***** ***** 45.7 -32900
229.0 ***** -15009 ***** ***** 65.5 -22900

33
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP.

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(BENDING MOMENT)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 219938 224554 -4616 1.94 94.4 238000 21.0 119965 117005 2960 1.24 49.2 238000
30.0 413809 421411 -7602 1.68 93.2 452000 30.0 178550 179702 -1152 0.25 39.8 452000
32.0 464002 471292 -7290 1.43 92.2 511200 32.0 190007 191779 -1772 0.35 37.5 511200
34.0 512909 519609 -6700 1.18 91.5 568000 34.0 198958 201188 -2230 0.39 35.4 568000
46.5 784789 794290 -9501 1.02 85.6 928000 46.5 162281 168507 -6226 0.67 18.2 928000
60.0 971288 981516 -10228 0.80 76.8 1278000 60.0 -88713 -81626 -7087 0.46 5.3 -1543000
64.5 1001033 1009802 -8769 0.64 73.2 1379000 64.5 -226560 -218580 -7980 0.46 12.7 -1725000
72.0 ***** 1015194 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -504708 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 1007131 1012939 -5808 0.38 65.7 1542400 72.8 -553230 -539915 -13315 0.66 26.8 -2015000
73.0 1006363 1012173 -5810 0.37 65.0 1557900 73.0 -564417 -550764 -13653 0.68 27.2 -2022300
77.1 ***** 990307 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -726611 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 917386 921344 -3958 0.16 38.0 2424000 83.5 -1011112 -990061 -21051 0.87 40.7 -2432000
97.0 635599 630530 5069 0.21 26.0 2424000 97.0 -1516325 -1493263 -23062 0.95 61.4 -2432000
108.4 ***** 237851 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -1854543 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 94898 83189 11709 0.48 3.4 2424000 112.0 -1991276 -1959758 -31518 1.30 80.6 -2432000
113.0 ***** 41147 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -1986147 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -257780 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** -2129783 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -336018 -338027 2009 0.08 13.9 -2432000 130.0 -2166280 -2113838 -52442 2.16 86.9 -2432000
131.5 ***** -341724 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** -2096464 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -79107 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** -1581731 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -15239 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** -1485968 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 33435 26490 6945 0.29 1.1 2424000 151.0 -1453417 -1425275 -28142 1.16 58.6 -2432000
154.5 ***** 143989 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** -1241306 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 470749 454342 16407 0.68 18.7 2424000 169.0 -629265 -615713 -13552 0.56 25.3 -2432000
179.5 518697 500670 18027 0.95 26.4 1896500 179.5 -292785 -284220 -8565 0.56 18.5 -1539000
190.0 408888 395361 13527 1.10 32.2 1228400 190.0 -58767 -52453 -6314 0.54 4.5 -1178000
199.3 266681 266240 441 0.07 41.6 640000 199.3 69766 78204 -8438 1.32 12.2 640000
214.5 105463 109298 -3835 1.16 33.2 329500 214.5 131448 136085 -4637 1.41 41.3 329500
229.0 23945 24038 -93 0.12 30.5 78700 229.0 50466 50341 125 0.16 64.0 78700
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 201848 207450 -5602 2.35 87.2 238000 21.0 50848 51758 -910 0.38 21.7 238000
30.0 359152 369230 -10078 2.23 81.7 452000 30.0 37328 38843 -1515 0.34 8.6 452000
32.0 398166 408600 -10434 2.04 79.9 511200 32.0 29208 31136 -1928 0.38 6.1 511200
34.0 435352 445918 -10566 1.86 78.5 568000 34.0 18710 23166 -4456 0.78 4.1 568000
46.5 612710 624659 -11949 1.29 67.3 928000 46.5 -22475 -12573 -9902 0.84 1.1 -1179500
60.0 658006 666525 -8519 0.67 52.2 1278000 60.0 7701 23247 -15546 1.22 1.8 1278000
64.5 632483 639548 -7065 0.51 46.4 1379000 64.5 34394 48763 -14369 1.04 3.5 1379000
72.0 ***** 547186 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** 111614 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 528298 533826 -5528 0.36 34.6 1542400 72.8 101445 119111 -17666 1.15 7.7 1542400
73.0 524035 529603 -5568 0.36 34.0 1557900 73.0 103527 121310 -17783 1.14 7.8 1557900
77.1 ***** 449907 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** 143445 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 282200 287887 -5687 0.23 11.9 2424000 83.5 108917 126438 -17521 0.72 5.2 2424000
97.0 -212548 -208731 -3817 0.16 8.6 -2432000 97.0 -115108 -104101 -11007 0.45 4.3 -2432000
108.4 ***** -788163 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -490770 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -1004904 -1003196 -1708 0.07 41.2 -2432000 112.0 -652767 -648322 -4445 0.18 26.7 -2432000
113.0 ***** -1061930 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -691435 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -1527926 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** -1004670 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -1738349 -1724277 -14072 0.58 70.9 -2432000 130.0 -1108287 -1094925 -13362 0.55 45.0 -2432000
131.5 ***** -1752653 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** -1100337 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -1751694 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** -833065 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -1716209 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** -764695 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -1702105 -1691313 -10792 0.44 69.5 -2432000 151.0 -718195 -719755 1560 0.06 29.6 -2432000
154.5 ***** -1608842 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** -584234 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -1236457 -1219414 -17043 0.70 50.1 -2432000 169.0 -149062 -147690 -1372 0.06 6.1 -2432000
179.5 -899941 -879623 -20318 1.32 57.2 -1539000 179.5 56332 55443 889 0.05 2.9 1896500
190.0 -516654 -506860 -9794 0.83 43.0 -1178000 190.0 176216 176037 179 0.01 14.3 1228400
199.3 -223752 -217848 -5904 0.69 25.3 -860000 199.3 220591 225745 -5154 0.81 35.3 640000
214.5 27673 27970 -297 0.09 8.5 329500 214.5 183868 189360 -5492 1.67 57.5 329500
229.0 33976 34782 -806 1.02 44.2 78700 229.0 58074 59279 -1205 1.53 75.3 78700
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 ***** 229864 ***** ***** 96.6 238000
30.0 ***** 424432 ***** ***** 93.9 452000
32.0 ***** 473987 ***** ***** 92.7 511200
34.0 ***** 522180 ***** ***** 91.9 568000
46.5 ***** 796764 ***** ***** 85.9 928000
60.0 ***** 1004758 ***** ***** 78.6 1278000
64.5 ***** 1049570 ***** ***** 76.1 1379000
72.0 ***** 1095593 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 ***** 1098876 ***** ***** 71.2 1542400
73.0 ***** 1099872 ***** ***** 70.6 1557900
77.1 ***** 1110223 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 ***** 1104086 ***** ***** 45.5 2424000
97.0 ***** 1009082 ***** ***** 41.6 2424000
108.4 ***** 849591 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 ***** 785069 ***** ***** 32.4 2424000
113.0 ***** 767667 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 624482 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 ***** 558763 ***** ***** 23.1 2424000
131.5 ***** 548448 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 524014 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 531549 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 ***** 537487 ***** ***** 22.2 2424000
154.5 ***** 554812 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 ***** 574123 ***** ***** 23.7 2424000
179.5 ***** 543042 ***** ***** 28.6 1896500
190.0 ***** 481386 ***** ***** 39.2 1228400
199.3 ***** 410177 ***** ***** 64.1 640000
214.5 ***** 247667 ***** ***** 75.2 329500
229.0 ***** 67086 ***** ***** 85.2 78700

34
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(SHEAR FORCE)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 -1969 -1863 -106 0.36 6.4 -29100 21.0 -9128 -8972 -156 0.54 30.8 -29100
30.0 ***** -6675 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -16813 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -8924 -8941 17 0.03 17.4 -51500 32.0 -19943 -19722 -221 0.43 38.3 -51500
34.0 -9982 -10228 246 0.45 18.6 -55100 34.0 -21623 -21612 -11 0.02 39.2 -55100
46.5 -2511 -2131 -380 0.76 4.3 -50100 46.5 -17684 -16969 -715 1.43 33.9 -50100
60.0 5510 5080 430 0.84 9.9 51200 60.0 -12918 -13305 387 0.77 26.6 -50100
64.5 8309 7608 701 1.11 12.0 63200 64.5 -11106 -11618 512 0.82 18.7 -62100
72.0 12120 12506 -386 0.45 14.5 86500 72.0 -8743 -7685 -1058 1.24 9.0 -85400
72.8 ***** 12358 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** -8823 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 11608 12490 -882 1.04 14.7 85200 73.0 -9087 -8882 -205 0.24 10.6 -84100
77.1 13643 14519 -876 1.24 20.6 70600 77.1 -4075 -3608 -467 0.67 5.2 -69600
83.5 17103 17740 -637 0.90 25.1 70600 83.5 4105 4645 -540 0.76 6.6 70600
97.0 24583 24070 513 0.95 44.7 53800 97.0 21790 21698 92 0.17 40.3 53800
108.4 30472 29917 555 0.88 47.2 63400 108.4 36496 35998 498 0.79 56.8 63400
112.0 29862 29477 385 0.55 41.8 70600 112.0 37903 37804 99 0.14 53.5 70600
113.0 28550 28193 357 0.53 41.6 67800 113.0 36565 36496 69 0.10 53.8 67800
123.0 14303 14223 80 0.12 21.0 67800 123.0 22258 22482 -224 0.33 33.2 67800
130.0 4281 4151 130 0.20 6.2 66600 130.0 12412 12590 -178 0.27 18.9 66600
131.5 2121 1951 170 0.26 2.9 66600 131.5 10313 10450 -137 0.21 15.7 66600
148.0 -22112 -22868 756 1.14 34.3 -66600 148.0 -12705 -13178 473 0.71 19.8 -66600
150.0 -25419 -25869 450 0.66 38.0 -68000 150.0 -15810 -15983 173 0.25 23.5 -68000
151.0 -27061 -27508 447 0.66 40.5 -68000 151.0 -17326 -17499 173 0.25 25.7 -68000
154.5 -26289 -26651 362 0.58 42.7 -62400 154.5 -16130 -16229 99 0.16 26.0 -62400
169.0 -22903 -22896 -7 0.01 36.7 -62400 169.0 -10508 -10305 -203 0.33 16.5 -62400
179.5 -20553 -21332 779 1.25 34.2 -62400 179.5 -6058 -6710 652 1.04 10.8 -62400
190.0 -19963 -20865 902 0.91 21.2 -98600 190.0 -3296 -4041 745 0.76 4.1 -98600
199.3 -11225 -10901 -324 0.49 16.4 -66300 199.3 -188 319 -507 0.78 0.5 65200
214.5 2810 2589 221 0.69 8.1 32000 214.5 5742 5366 376 1.18 16.8 32000
229.0 13615 13386 229 1.02 59.8 22400 229.0 11316 11303 13 0.06 50.5 22400
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -4106 -4033 -73 0.25 13.9 -29100 21.0 -11528 -11210 -318 1.09 38.5 -29100
30.0 ***** -9772 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -19987 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -12257 -12236 -21 0.04 23.8 -51500 32.0 -23555 -23093 -462 0.90 44.8 -51500
34.0 -13509 -13708 199 0.36 24.9 -55100 34.0 -25010 -24596 -414 0.75 44.6 -55100
46.5 -7154 -6681 -473 0.94 13.3 -50100 46.5 -12561 -12651 90 0.18 25.3 -50100
60.0 -177 -455 278 0.55 0.9 -50100 60.0 2807 2127 680 1.33 4.2 51200
64.5 2302 1784 518 0.82 2.8 63200 64.5 8324 7551 773 1.22 11.9 63200
72.0 5638 6249 -611 0.71 7.2 86500 72.0 16665 17551 -886 1.02 20.3 86500
72.8 ***** 5308 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 16707 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 5074 5194 -120 0.14 6.1 85200 73.0 16245 16555 -310 0.36 19.4 85200
77.1 6912 7179 -267 0.38 10.2 70600 77.1 17518 17934 -416 0.59 25.4 70600
83.5 10087 10366 -279 0.40 14.7 70600 83.5 19936 20307 -371 0.53 28.8 70600
97.0 17047 16758 289 0.54 31.1 53800 97.0 25632 25464 168 0.31 47.3 53800
108.4 22583 22068 515 0.81 34.8 63400 108.4 30411 30071 340 0.54 47.4 63400
112.0 21887 21836 51 0.07 30.9 70600 112.0 29537 29949 -412 0.58 42.4 70600
113.0 20560 20538 22 0.03 30.3 67800 113.0 28197 28640 -443 0.65 42.2 67800
123.0 6218 6485 -267 0.39 9.6 67800 123.0 13943 14683 -740 1.09 21.7 67800
130.0 -3807 -3584 -223 0.33 5.4 -66600 130.0 4205 4897 -692 1.04 7.4 66600
131.5 -5961 -5777 -184 0.28 8.7 -66600 131.5 2138 2788 -650 0.98 4.2 66600
148.0 -29971 -30369 398 0.60 45.6 -66600 148.0 -20357 -20929 572 0.86 31.4 -66600
150.0 -33234 -33327 93 0.14 49.0 -68000 150.0 -23382 -23474 92 0.14 34.5 -68000
151.0 -34529 -34733 204 0.30 51.1 -68000 151.0 -24847 -24831 -16 0.02 36.5 -68000
154.5 -30704 -30605 -99 0.16 49.0 -62400 154.5 -23485 -23109 -376 0.60 37.0 -62400
169.0 -14333 -13744 -589 0.94 22.0 -62400 169.0 -17018 -16385 -633 1.01 26.3 -62400
179.5 -2410 -3134 724 1.16 5.0 -62400 179.5 -11796 -12060 264 0.42 19.3 -62400
190.0 6730 5474 1256 1.29 5.6 97600 190.0 -8126 -8538 412 0.42 8.7 -98600
199.3 7962 8026 -64 0.10 12.3 65200 199.3 -4109 -3323 -786 1.19 5.0 -66300
214.5 10477 10095 382 1.19 31.5 32000 214.5 3468 3265 203 0.63 10.2 32000
229.0 12993 12851 142 0.63 57.4 22400 229.0 10511 10571 -60 0.27 47.2 22400
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -7947 -7694 -253 0.87 26.4 -29100
30.0 ***** -15138 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -18343 -17977 -366 0.71 34.9 -51500
34.0 -19977 -19807 -170 0.31 35.9 -55100
46.5 -15918 -15685 -233 0.47 31.3 -50100
60.0 -11281 -11720 439 0.88 23.4 -50100
64.5 -9558 -10049 491 0.79 16.2 -62100
72.0 -7422 -7643 221 0.26 8.9 -85400
72.8 ***** -8149 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -8145 -8129 -16 0.02 9.7 -84100
77.1 -6914 -6555 -359 0.52 9.4 -69600
83.5 -4659 -3972 -687 0.99 5.7 -69600
97.0 423 996 -573 1.07 1.9 53800
108.4 4451 3603 848 1.34 5.7 63400
112.0 3928 4052 -124 0.18 5.7 70600
113.0 3935 4136 -201 0.30 6.1 67800
123.0 3827 4389 -562 0.83 6.5 67800
130.0 3813 4071 -258 0.39 6.1 66600
131.5 3810 3939 -129 0.19 5.9 66600
148.0 3577 2931 646 0.97 4.4 66600
150.0 2826 2450 376 0.55 3.6 67900
151.0 1793 1720 73 0.11 2.5 67900
154.5 2375 2577 -202 0.33 4.2 61300
169.0 5234 5366 -132 0.22 8.8 61300
179.5 7462 6974 488 0.80 11.4 61300
190.0 7819 7480 339 0.35 7.7 97600
199.3 8656 8392 264 0.40 12.9 65200
214.5 10712 10363 349 1.09 32.4 32000
229.0 13026 12842 184 0.82 57.3 22400

35
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(BENDING MOMENT)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 10324 11912 -1588 0.67 5.0 238000 21.0 -49626 -52530 2904 1.08 19.5 -270000
30.0 -24446 -23677 -769 0.14 4.3 -555000 30.0 -148787 -153040 4253 0.77 27.6 -555000
32.0 -38218 -38086 -132 0.02 5.9 -645300 32.0 -180073 -184919 4846 0.75 28.7 -645300
34.0 -53705 -52728 -977 0.13 7.2 -732000 34.0 -213382 -217296 3914 0.53 29.7 -732000
46.5 -117908 -110034 -7874 0.67 9.3 -1179500 46.5 -410260 -406168 -4092 0.35 34.4 -1179500
60.0 -103516 -85435 -18081 1.17 5.5 -1543000 60.0 -575677 -559253 -16424 1.06 36.2 -1543000
64.5 -79042 -60260 -18782 1.09 3.5 -1725000 64.5 -618639 -600833 -17806 1.03 34.8 -1725000
72.0 ***** -425 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -659130 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -9945 6196 -16141 1.05 0.4 1542400 72.8 -681896 -665768 -16128 0.80 33.0 -2015000
73.0 -7634 8254 -15888 1.02 0.5 1557900 73.0 -683693 -667759 -15934 0.79 33.0 -2022300
77.1 ***** 45635 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -691652 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 111259 116806 -5547 0.23 4.8 2424000 83.5 -704975 -695828 -9147 0.38 28.6 -2432000
97.0 335337 342228 -6891 0.28 14.1 2424000 97.0 -564341 -561712 -2629 0.11 23.1 -2432000
108.4 ***** 596639 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -290963 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 674768 686425 -11657 0.48 28.3 2424000 112.0 -186998 -180005 -6993 0.29 7.4 -2432000
113.0 ***** 709731 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -150055 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 881772 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** 87931 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 920230 934969 -14739 0.61 38.6 2424000 130.0 176252 187751 -11499 0.47 7.7 2424000
131.5 ***** 938974 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** 201907 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 803870 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 185677 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 766963 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 163436 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 732620 742528 -9908 0.41 30.6 2424000 151.0 139693 148202 -8509 0.35 6.1 2424000
154.5 ***** 666420 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 101462 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 370501 380670 -10169 0.42 15.7 2424000 169.0 -61736 -48325 -13411 0.55 2.0 -2432000
179.5 187193 195610 -8417 0.44 10.3 1896500 179.5 -130770 -117042 -13728 0.89 7.6 -1539000
190.0 20557 19401 1156 0.09 1.6 1228400 190.0 -163926 -158232 -5694 0.48 13.4 -1178000
199.3 -96205 -93250 -2955 0.34 10.8 -860000 199.3 -176790 -172591 -4199 0.49 20.1 -860000
214.5 -146744 -145828 -916 0.24 37.9 -385000 214.5 -141951 -141805 -146 0.04 36.8 -385000
229.0 -50313 -51097 784 0.82 53.2 -96000 229.0 -42501 -42140 -361 0.38 43.9 -96000
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -7319 -7758 439 0.16 2.9 -270000 21.0 -70495 -72889 2394 0.89 27.0 -270000
30.0 -61450 -63174 1724 0.31 11.4 -555000 30.0 -191013 -193782 2769 0.50 34.9 -555000
32.0 -80520 -82921 2401 0.37 12.8 -645300 32.0 -228050 -231126 3076 0.48 35.8 -645300
34.0 -101408 -102984 1576 0.22 14.1 -732000 34.0 -266961 -268201 1240 0.17 36.6 -732000
46.5 -206063 -200567 -5496 0.47 17.0 -1179500 46.5 -456073 -449851 -6222 0.53 38.1 -1179500
60.0 -246986 -230589 -16397 1.06 14.9 -1543000 60.0 -509040 -505109 -3931 0.25 32.7 -1543000
64.5 -243366 -226008 -17358 1.01 13.1 -1725000 64.5 -488517 -488028 -489 0.03 28.3 -1725000
72.0 ***** -199281 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -410839 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -215363 -196384 -18979 0.94 9.7 -2015000 72.8 -400943 -400291 -652 0.03 19.9 -2015000
73.0 -214347 -195485 -18862 0.93 9.7 -2022300 73.0 -397654 -397033 -621 0.03 19.6 -2022300
77.1 ***** -177512 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -341413 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -151950 -137641 -14309 0.59 5.7 -2432000 83.5 -245554 -247015 1461 0.06 10.2 -2432000
97.0 -5957 6252 -12209 0.50 0.3 2424000 97.0 1786 820 966 0.04 0.0 2424000
108.4 ***** 186957 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** 261241 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 240878 252806 -11928 0.49 10.4 2424000 112.0 347932 351735 -3803 0.16 14.5 2424000
113.0 ***** 269480 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** 375180 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 374756 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** 548255 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 371064 381016 -9952 0.41 15.7 2424000 130.0 592294 603123 -10829 0.45 24.9 2424000
131.5 ***** 374974 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** 607735 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 130589 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 489673 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 81500 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 456331 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 50497 50064 433 0.02 2.1 2424000 151.0 423925 434493 -10568 0.44 17.9 2424000
154.5 ***** -42682 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 367489 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -303672 -295908 -7764 0.32 12.2 -2432000 169.0 121907 139097 -17190 0.71 5.7 2424000
179.5 -374422 -361631 -12791 0.83 23.5 -1539000 179.5 1870 19964 -18094 0.95 1.1 1896500
190.0 -348143 -344143 -4000 0.34 29.2 -1178000 190.0 -75237 -64994 -10243 0.87 5.5 -1178000
199.3 -294641 -290818 -3823 0.44 33.8 -860000 199.3 -120077 -112296 -7781 0.90 13.1 -860000
214.5 -182669 -179440 -3229 0.84 46.6 -385000 214.5 -122344 -121186 -1158 0.30 31.5 -385000
229.0 -48219 -48784 565 0.59 50.8 -96000 229.0 -39721 -38969 -752 0.78 40.6 -96000
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -39967 -40183 216 0.08 14.9 -270000
30.0 -129490 -129519 29 0.01 23.3 -555000
32.0 -158301 -158541 240 0.04 24.6 -645300
34.0 -189154 -188077 -1077 0.15 25.7 -732000
46.5 -369606 -363984 -5622 0.48 30.9 -1179500
60.0 -517398 -501925 -15473 1.00 32.5 -1543000
64.5 -554938 -538741 -16197 0.94 31.2 -1725000
72.0 ***** -590230 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -609341 -595700 -13641 0.68 29.6 -2015000
73.0 -610955 -597407 -13548 0.67 29.5 -2022300
77.1 ***** -623244 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -665634 -654772 -10862 0.45 26.9 -2432000
97.0 -688591 -676085 -12506 0.51 27.8 -2432000
108.4 ***** -648266 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -652358 -633546 -18812 0.77 26.1 -2432000
113.0 ***** -630293 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -597130 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -596777 -567779 -28998 1.19 23.3 -2432000
131.5 ***** -561293 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -510987 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -508793 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -535534 -507881 -27653 1.14 20.9 -2432000
154.5 ***** -504661 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -486584 -465034 -21550 0.89 19.1 -2432000
179.5 -433327 -415833 -17494 1.14 27.0 -1539000
190.0 -363624 -356920 -6704 0.57 30.3 -1178000
199.3 -303210 -296925 -6285 0.73 34.5 -860000
214.5 -185233 -182882 -2351 0.61 47.5 -385000
229.0 -48866 -48685 -181 0.19 50.7 -96000

36
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(SHEAR FORCE)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 -2973 -3119 146 0.50 10.7 -29100 21.0 -10126 -10131 5 0.02 34.8 -29100
30.0 ***** -6745 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -16855 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -8716 -8768 52 0.10 17.0 -51500 32.0 -19797 -19537 -260 0.50 37.9 -51500
34.0 -9291 -9455 164 0.30 17.2 -55100 34.0 -20993 -20840 -153 0.28 37.8 -55100
46.5 -724 -467 -257 0.51 0.9 -50100 46.5 -15911 -15474 -437 0.87 30.9 -50100
60.0 8549 8763 -214 0.42 17.1 51200 60.0 -9884 -9650 -234 0.47 19.3 -50100
64.5 11548 11463 85 0.13 18.1 63200 64.5 -7912 -7893 -19 0.03 12.7 -62100
72.0 14920 15150 -230 0.27 17.5 86500 72.0 -6128 -5181 -947 1.11 6.1 -85400
72.8 ***** 14960 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** -7194 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 14318 15080 -762 0.89 17.7 85200 73.0 -6595 -7522 927 1.10 8.9 -84100
77.1 15812 16550 -738 1.05 23.4 70600 77.1 -2165 -2712 547 0.79 3.9 -69600
83.5 18855 18907 -52 0.07 26.8 70600 83.5 5560 4966 594 0.84 7.0 70600
97.0 25769 25596 173 0.32 47.6 53800 97.0 22649 22455 194 0.36 41.7 53800
108.4 30750 31406 -656 1.03 49.5 63400 108.4 36473 37066 -593 0.94 58.5 63400
112.0 29598 30201 -603 0.85 42.8 70600 112.0 37346 37155 191 0.27 52.6 70600
113.0 28275 28802 -527 0.78 42.5 67800 113.0 36002 35841 161 0.24 52.9 67800
123.0 13866 13623 243 0.36 20.1 67800 123.0 21586 21713 -127 0.19 32.0 67800
130.0 3664 3375 289 0.43 5.1 66600 130.0 11606 11684 -78 0.12 17.5 66600
131.5 1459 1130 329 0.49 1.7 66600 131.5 9473 9509 -36 0.05 14.3 66600
148.0 -23438 -23418 -20 0.03 35.2 -66600 148.0 -14072 -13865 -207 0.31 20.8 -66600
150.0 -26839 -26883 44 0.06 39.5 -68000 150.0 -17254 -17532 278 0.41 25.8 -68000
151.0 -28540 -29115 575 0.85 42.8 -68000 151.0 -18817 -19079 262 0.39 28.1 -68000
154.5 -27959 -28198 239 0.38 45.2 -62400 154.5 -17777 -17719 -58 0.09 28.4 -62400
169.0 -24299 -24357 58 0.09 39.0 -62400 169.0 -11714 -11567 -147 0.24 18.5 -62400
179.5 -21712 -22236 524 0.84 35.6 -62400 179.5 -6889 -7295 406 0.65 11.7 -62400
190.0 -21700 -22412 712 0.72 22.7 -98600 190.0 -4565 -5145 580 0.59 5.2 -98600
199.3 -12713 -12911 198 0.30 19.5 -66300 199.3 -1336 -903 -433 0.65 1.4 -66300
214.5 3113 3268 -155 0.48 10.2 32000 214.5 6143 6376 -233 0.73 19.9 32000
229.0 14407 14140 267 1.19 63.1 22400 229.0 11991 11942 49 0.22 53.3 22400
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -5164 -5214 50 0.17 17.9 -29100 21.0 -12372 -12250 -122 0.42 42.1 -29100
30.0 ***** -9841 ***** ***** ***** ***** 30.0 ***** -19855 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -12161 -12077 -84 0.16 23.5 -51500 32.0 -23203 -22722 -481 0.93 44.1 -51500
34.0 -12946 -12964 18 0.03 23.5 -55100 34.0 -24195 -24433 238 0.43 44.3 -55100
46.5 -5551 -5316 -235 0.47 10.6 -50100 46.5 -10737 -10606 -131 0.26 21.2 -50100
60.0 2667 3148 -481 0.94 6.1 51200 60.0 5695 6286 -591 1.15 12.3 51200
64.5 5332 5451 -119 0.19 8.6 63200 64.5 11304 11629 -325 0.51 18.4 63200
72.0 8176 8682 -506 0.58 10.0 86500 72.0 18984 19762 -778 0.90 22.8 86500
72.8 ***** 7698 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.8 ***** 18874 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 7509 7572 -63 0.07 8.9 85200 73.0 18450 18711 -261 0.31 22.0 85200
77.1 8793 8989 -196 0.28 12.7 70600 77.1 19221 18775 446 0.63 26.6 70600
83.5 11551 11300 251 0.36 16.0 70600 83.5 21258 21073 185 0.26 29.8 70600
97.0 17951 17898 53 0.10 33.3 53800 97.0 26427 26094 333 0.62 48.5 53800
108.4 22590 22926 -336 0.53 36.2 63400 108.4 30339 30462 -123 0.19 48.0 63400
112.0 21348 22026 -678 0.96 31.2 70600 112.0 28929 29265 -336 0.48 41.5 70600
113.0 20011 20639 -628 0.93 30.4 67800 113.0 27585 27952 -367 0.54 41.2 67800
123.0 5524 5648 -124 0.18 8.3 67800 123.0 13240 13900 -660 0.97 20.5 67800
130.0 -4665 -4588 -77 0.12 6.9 -66600 130.0 3380 3991 -611 0.92 6.0 66600
131.5 -6860 -6824 -36 0.05 10.2 -66600 131.5 1280 1849 -569 0.85 2.8 66600
148.0 -31478 -31383 -95 0.14 47.1 -66600 148.0 -21721 -22375 654 0.98 33.6 -66600
150.0 -34828 -34687 -141 0.21 51.0 -68000 150.0 -24820 -24994 174 0.26 36.8 -68000
151.0 -36170 -36513 343 0.50 53.7 -68000 151.0 -26332 -26382 50 0.07 38.8 -68000
154.5 -32469 -32245 -224 0.36 51.7 -62400 154.5 -25122 -24566 -556 0.89 39.4 -62400
169.0 -15491 -14960 -531 0.85 24.0 -62400 169.0 -18202 -17600 -602 0.96 28.2 -62400
179.5 -3039 -3741 702 1.13 6.0 -62400 179.5 -12601 -13248 647 1.04 21.2 -62400
190.0 5829 4917 912 0.93 5.0 97600 190.0 -9368 -9816 448 0.45 10.0 -98600
199.3 7107 7833 -726 1.11 12.0 65200 199.3 -5232 -4961 -271 0.41 7.5 -66300
214.5 11043 11382 -339 1.06 35.6 32000 214.5 3887 4097 -210 0.66 12.8 32000
229.0 13725 13521 204 0.91 60.4 22400 229.0 11193 11227 -34 0.15 50.1 22400
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -9022 -8919 -103 0.35 30.6 -29100
30.0 ***** -15284 ***** ***** ***** *****
32.0 -18313 -17904 -409 0.79 34.8 -51500
34.0 -19486 -19155 -331 0.60 34.8 -55100
46.5 -14409 -14832 423 0.84 29.6 -50100
60.0 -8570 -8292 -278 0.55 16.6 -50100
64.5 -6684 -6570 -114 0.18 10.6 -62100
72.0 -5098 -6282 1184 1.39 7.4 -85400
72.8 ***** -6936 ***** ***** ***** *****
73.0 -5933 -6959 1026 1.22 8.3 -84100
77.1 -5267 -6264 997 1.43 9.0 -69600
83.5 -3447 -4154 707 1.02 6.0 -69600
97.0 1040 1462 -422 0.78 2.7 53800
108.4 4145 3838 307 0.48 6.1 63400
112.0 3073 3104 -31 0.04 4.4 70600
113.0 3079 3090 -11 0.02 4.6 67800
123.0 2962 3042 -80 0.12 4.5 67800
130.0 2940 3224 -284 0.43 4.8 66600
131.5 2934 3085 -151 0.23 4.6 66600
148.0 2669 2645 24 0.04 4.0 66600
150.0 1914 1338 576 0.85 2.0 67900
151.0 851 587 264 0.39 0.9 67900
154.5 1256 1515 -259 0.42 2.5 61300
169.0 4464 4451 13 0.02 7.3 61300
179.5 6999 6791 208 0.34 11.1 61300
190.0 6847 7126 -279 0.29 7.3 97600
199.3 7740 7921 -181 0.28 12.1 65200
214.5 11240 11520 -280 0.88 36.0 32000
229.0 13745 13505 240 1.07 60.3 22400

37
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

JMU5041 / BULK / ABY PAOLA / 9715830 / FINAL / 4.0


GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S.G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

DAMAGED LONGITUDINAL STRENGTH (I)


(BENDING MOMENT)
FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW FRAME YARD TM. DIFF. DIFF*100 (%) TM*100 (%) ALLOW
NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW NO. (T/S BK) (SM-88) (YARD-TM) ALLOW ALLOW

No.1Hold Flooding No.4Hold Flooding


21.0 -15571 -16560 989 0.37 6.1 -270000 21.0 -74447 -75458 1011 0.37 27.9 -270000
30.0 -52769 -57160 4391 0.79 10.3 -555000 30.0 -176027 -177692 1665 0.30 32.0 -555000
32.0 -66302 -72060 5758 0.89 11.2 -645300 32.0 -207135 -209403 2268 0.35 32.5 -645300
34.0 -81187 -86495 5308 0.73 11.8 -732000 34.0 -239910 -242543 2633 0.36 33.1 -732000
46.5 -134787 -137848 3061 0.26 11.7 -1179500 46.5 -426364 -426369 5 0.00 36.1 -1179500
60.0 -93533 -87439 -6094 0.39 5.7 -1543000 60.0 -564668 -562859 -1809 0.12 36.5 -1543000
64.5 -57955 -52331 -5624 0.33 3.0 -1725000 64.5 -596540 -597852 1312 0.08 34.7 -1725000
72.0 ***** 23561 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -645677 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 30998 31536 -538 0.03 2.0 1542400 72.8 -640575 -651572 10997 0.55 32.3 -2015000
73.0 33842 34008 -166 0.01 2.2 1557900 73.0 -641878 -653340 11462 0.57 32.3 -2022300
77.1 ***** 77793 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -673980 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 170015 157287 12728 0.53 6.5 2424000 83.5 -647940 -668952 21012 0.86 27.5 -2432000
97.0 409484 398903 10581 0.44 16.5 2424000 97.0 -495141 -517840 22699 0.93 21.3 -2432000
108.4 ***** 664006 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** -242145 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 756097 755176 921 0.04 31.2 2424000 112.0 -114139 -131644 17505 0.72 5.4 -2432000
113.0 ***** 778694 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** -101986 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 952233 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** 132652 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 994879 1005501 -10622 0.44 41.5 2424000 130.0 239177 229404 9773 0.40 9.5 2424000
131.5 ***** 1009384 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** 242795 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 861406 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 214696 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 822220 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 190619 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 789456 796352 -6896 0.28 32.9 2424000 151.0 183338 174229 9109 0.38 7.2 2424000
154.5 ***** 715832 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 123993 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 403399 412876 -9477 0.39 17.0 2424000 169.0 -40541 -38212 -2329 0.10 1.6 -2432000
179.5 209000 215222 -6222 0.33 11.3 1896500 179.5 -118346 -114948 -3398 0.22 7.5 -1539000
190.0 30776 25034 5742 0.47 2.0 1228400 190.0 -159544 -164491 4947 0.42 14.0 -1178000
199.3 -99084 -97306 -1778 0.21 11.3 -860000 199.3 -182363 -183902 1539 0.18 21.4 -860000
214.5 -157454 -158870 1416 0.37 41.3 -385000 214.5 -152441 -152351 -90 0.02 39.6 -385000
229.0 -53122 -54315 1193 1.24 56.6 -96000 229.0 -45027 -44881 -146 0.15 46.8 -96000
No.2Hold Flooding No.5Hold Flooding
21.0 -33206 -34382 1176 0.44 12.7 -270000 21.0 -93523 -94728 1205 0.45 35.1 -270000
30.0 -90266 -94517 4251 0.77 17.0 -555000 30.0 -215113 -216238 1125 0.20 39.0 -555000
32.0 -109259 -114765 5506 0.85 17.8 -645300 32.0 -251629 -253114 1485 0.23 39.2 -645300
34.0 -129721 -134656 4935 0.67 18.4 -732000 34.0 -289688 -290664 976 0.13 39.7 -732000
46.5 -225285 -228075 2790 0.24 19.3 -1179500 46.5 -467126 -465951 -1175 0.10 39.5 -1179500
60.0 -241258 -234990 -6268 0.41 15.2 -1543000 60.0 -493438 -490675 -2763 0.18 31.8 -1543000
64.5 -227225 -221514 -5711 0.33 12.8 -1725000 64.5 -462462 -462628 166 0.01 26.8 -1725000
72.0 ***** -180555 ***** ***** ***** ***** 72.0 ***** -368329 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -180841 -176511 -4330 0.21 8.8 -2015000 72.8 -357411 -356360 -1051 0.05 17.7 -2015000
73.0 -179345 -175262 -4083 0.20 8.7 -2022300 73.0 -353685 -352668 -1017 0.05 17.4 -2022300
77.1 ***** -151957 ***** ***** ***** ***** 77.1 ***** -290371 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -101991 -105470 3479 0.14 4.3 -2432000 83.5 -187989 -191472 3483 0.14 7.9 -2432000
97.0 56413 49309 7104 0.29 2.0 2424000 97.0 70544 63589 6955 0.29 2.6 2424000
108.4 ***** 234534 ***** ***** ***** ***** 108.4 ***** 326336 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 307242 299801 7441 0.31 12.4 2424000 112.0 419755 415672 4083 0.17 17.1 2424000
113.0 ***** 316146 ***** ***** ***** ***** 113.0 ***** 438639 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** 417536 ***** ***** ***** ***** 123.0 ***** 606609 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 427140 420154 6986 0.29 17.3 2424000 130.0 653731 657268 -3537 0.15 27.1 2424000
131.5 ***** 413201 ***** ***** ***** ***** 131.5 ***** 660879 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** 154770 ***** ***** ***** ***** 148.0 ***** 528539 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** 103526 ***** ***** ***** ***** 150.0 ***** 493105 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 85425 70735 14690 0.61 2.9 2424000 151.0 466050 469960 -3910 0.16 19.4 2424000
154.5 ***** -26048 ***** ***** ***** ***** 154.5 ***** 398996 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -292157 -299087 6930 0.28 12.3 -2432000 169.0 141839 156366 -14527 0.60 6.5 2424000
179.5 -370721 -377001 6280 0.41 24.5 -1539000 179.5 13260 27973 -14713 0.78 1.5 1896500
190.0 -350121 -363894 13773 1.17 30.9 -1178000 190.0 -71638 -66544 -5094 0.43 5.6 -1178000
199.3 -304195 -311687 7492 0.87 36.2 -860000 199.3 -126217 -119949 -6268 0.73 13.9 -860000
214.5 -194463 -198418 3955 1.03 51.5 -385000 214.5 -133094 -129884 -3210 0.83 33.7 -385000
229.0 -50905 -51658 753 0.78 53.8 -96000 229.0 -42330 -41802 -528 0.55 43.5 -96000
No.3Hold Flooding
21.0 -65624 -67089 1465 0.54 24.8 -270000
30.0 -158308 -161600 3292 0.59 29.1 -555000
32.0 -187136 -191259 4123 0.64 29.6 -645300
34.0 -217666 -220763 3097 0.42 30.2 -732000
46.5 -389828 -391566 1738 0.15 33.2 -1179500
60.0 -513804 -510199 -3605 0.23 33.1 -1543000
64.5 -541433 -539480 -1953 0.11 31.3 -1725000
72.0 ***** -579081 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -578661 -583665 5004 0.25 29.0 -2015000
73.0 -579838 -585104 5266 0.26 28.9 -2022300
77.1 ***** -606964 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -621522 -634031 12509 0.51 26.1 -2432000
97.0 -634935 -647980 13045 0.54 26.6 -2432000
108.4 ***** -617723 ***** ***** ***** *****
112.0 -598302 -606622 8320 0.34 24.9 -2432000
113.0 ***** -604524 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 ***** -582447 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -555720 -560636 4916 0.20 23.1 -2432000
131.5 ***** -554549 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 ***** -509793 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 ***** -508457 ***** ***** ***** *****
151.0 -510142 -508092 -2050 0.08 20.9 -2432000
154.5 ***** -506491 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -476605 -472094 -4511 0.19 19.4 -2432000
179.5 -428776 -426307 -2469 0.16 27.7 -1539000
190.0 -364360 -371664 7304 0.62 31.6 -1178000
199.3 -311976 -313561 1585 0.18 36.5 -860000
214.5 -196784 -198680 1896 0.49 51.6 -385000
229.0 -51546 -51526 -20 0.02 53.7 -96000

38
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 1 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 11046.3 100.000 0.7645 -69.409 10.552 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 12118.8 100.000 0.7645 -38.932 10.372 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 12115.2 100.000 0.7645 -7.727 10.375 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 12119.2 100.000 0.7645 23.477 10.377 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 11107.1 95.343 0.7645 54.425 10.343 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 58506.6 99.081 -7.574 10.402 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -87.859 0.000 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 -5.375 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 5.375 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 -7.168 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 7.168 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 -7.194 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 7.194 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 -10.870 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 10.870 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.167 0.000 -6.966 2649.6(M)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.327 0.000 6.917 2711.1(M)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 -10.478 100.5(M)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 10.478 100.5(M)
A.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 89.479 6.424 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 6.835 0.841 -9.375 0.0(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 5561.7
CREW & EFFECT 3.2 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 5.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 22.2 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 1.4 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 14.4 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 2.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 1.9 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 2.2 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 3.1 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 5.4 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 10.8 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 5.8 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 2.9 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 10.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 11.5 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 15.4 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 10.7 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 13.8 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 9.7 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 7.9 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 12.6 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 26.2 80.900 8.290 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 36.8 -3.610 20.850 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 2.9 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 237.6 51.598 12.387 0.000 85.0

39
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 2 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 367.8 95.000 0.9500 23.979 0.797 -3.793 1090.6(M)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 373.5 95.000 0.9500 24.224 0.798 3.751 1122.0(M)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 430.3 95.000 0.9500 52.124 0.798 -0.005 3635.7(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 -11.708 23.8(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 11.708 23.8(M)
F.O.T. TOTAL 1589.9 95.000 46.154 4.454 0.003 5895.7
D.O.T.(S) 102.1 95.000 0.9000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7(M)
D.O.T. TOTAL 102.1 95.000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7
M.G.O.T.(P) 116.4 95.000 0.9000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7(M)
G.O.T. TOTAL 116.4 95.000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7
F.W.T.(P) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 -9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T.(S) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T. TOTAL 382.2 100.000 92.760 16.465 0.000 176.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

40
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 3 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 0.0 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 11046.3 14449.2


F.O. Tks 1589.9 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 12118.8 15852.1
D.O. Tks 102.1 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 12115.2 15847.4
G.O. Tks 116.4 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 12119.2 15852.7
F.W. Tks 382.2 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 11107.1 14528.8
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 237.6

OTHERS TOTAL : 2428.2 CARGO TOTAL : 58506.6

DEAD WEIGHT 60934.8 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 71360.8 Mt
LCG -3.033 m KMT 13.540 m
TCG -0.002 m KG 10.415 m
LCB -3.033 m GM 3.125 m
MTC 872.241 Mt-m GGo 0.165 m
TPC 60.264 Mt/Cm GoM 2.960 m
LCF 3.525 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 743254.281 Mt-m


FS. Moment 11759.750 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 13.036 m
FORE 13.034 m
MEAN 13.035 m
AFT 13.037 m

Trim 0.002 m
Heeling Angle -0.040 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 158.073 %

41
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 4 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 43.298 deg


Initial GoM 2.960 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 43.000 deg 25.000 deg YES
Maximum GoZ 1.710 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 1.528 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 0.427 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 0.709 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.283 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


3.85

3.46

3.08 GoM = 2.960 m

2.69

2.31

1.92
Max GoZ = 1.710 m

1.54

1.15

0.77

0.38

0 10 20 30 40 Af 50 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

42
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 5 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.027 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.040 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.532 deg < 15.280deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 20.407 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 43.298 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 0.782 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 0.205 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 0.777 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 3.800 >= 1
Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


2.05

1.54

1.03

0.51

-60.0 -50.0 -40.0 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
lw2 lw1 A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-0.51

a2
-1.03

-1.54
a0

-2.05

a1
-2.57

43
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 6 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 0.002 3.036 18.953


GoM 2.960 3.536 14.299
Draft 13.036 4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
10.024 2.000
13.036 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 2.960(m) 2.000(m) YES


Available Trim Range 2.925(m) > trim > -0.975(m)

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14 GoM= 2.960 m
Draft=13.036 m
Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10

6
Light service draft: 5.506 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

44
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 7 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

SF/BM & GRAPH


SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN-m)
(kN) SEA (+) (-) (kN-m) SEA HOG SAG

21.0 -4993 23 22700 -22100 -14622 18 237000 -82000


30.0 -11146 ***** ***** ***** -77070 38 441000 -205000
32.0 -13543 41 34100 -33400 -98748 40 496600 -245800
34.0 -15321 46 34300 -33500 -121203 43 550000 -285000
46.5 -12973 39 34300 -33500 -264135 46 876500 -577000
60.0 -10578 30 35900 -34700 -389594 48 1175000 -804000
64.5 -9697 21 48100 -46800 -427573 51 1256500 -842500
72.0 -8559 13 66900 -65500 -481908 ***** ***** *****
72.8 -9200 ***** ***** ***** -487464 55 1380300 -884000
73.0 -9227 14 65500 -64100 -489203 55 1383700 -896500
77.1 -8054 17 48800 -47700 -516109 ***** ***** *****
83.5 -6092 13 48800 -47700 -551308 35 1570000 -1594000
97.0 -2539 6 45200 -45100 -600327 38 1570000 -1594000
108.4 764 1 56000 -56000 -613312 ***** ***** *****
112.0 126 0 59400 -59400 -611972 38 1570000 -1594000
113.0 408 1 56500 -56500 -611454 ***** ***** *****
123.0 2097 4 56500 -56500 -598379 ***** ***** *****
130.0 2983 10 31000 -31000 -581932 37 1570000 -1594000
131.5 3131 7 42900 -42900 -577818 ***** ***** *****
148.0 4517 11 42900 -42900 -525856 ***** ***** *****
150.0 4325 9 47700 -47900 -519950 ***** ***** *****
151.0 3653 8 47700 -47900 -516452 32 1570000 -1594000
154.5 3824 9 44700 -44300 -505516 ***** ***** *****
169.0 5838 13 43900 -44300 -444021 28 1570000 -1594000
179.5 6811 16 43900 -44300 -388853 50 1229000 -779000
190.0 6242 10 64100 -65500 -331948 54 873300 -609400
199.3 7694 18 42700 -44000 -278955 61 560000 -460000
214.5 9817 51 19200 -20300 -173316 66 301000 -263500
229.0 12227 72 16900 -17400 -46122 77 74300 -59900
MAX -15321 46 34300 -33500 -613323 38 1570000 -1594000
(Num.) ( FR : 34.00 ) ( FR : 108.00 )
MAX 12227 72 16900 -17400 -46122 77 74300 -59900
(Per.) ( FR : 229.00 ) ( FR : 229.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612

29874 1017306

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 Max SF FR = 34.00 Max BM FR = 108.00 -1017306


Value = -15321 Value = -613323

-59749 -2034612

Sag(-)
-89623 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M

45
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 8 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (I)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5


Disp(Mt) 71360.8 74646.6 74853.4 74749.4 74770.6 74655.8
TAft(m) 13.04 12.26 12.80 13.39 13.98 14.47
TFwd(m) 13.03 14.99 14.49 13.82 13.20 12.61
Trim(m) 0.00 -2.73 -1.69 -0.43 0.78 1.86

SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -4993 -1841 -4187 -6705 -9320 -11558
30.0 -11146 -6805 -10151 -13761 -17466 -20637
32.0 -13543 -9119 -12678 -16520 -20455 -23822
34.0 -15321 -10986 -14744 -18804 -22954 -25420
46.5 -12973 -6788 -11697 -16993 -22370 -17850
60.0 -10578 -4327 -10289 -16678 -23155 -7698
64.5 -9697 -3505 -9776 -16473 -23265 -3916
72.0 -8559 -1563 -8293 -15440 -23546 3263
72.8 -9200 -2112 -8889 -16080 -23979 2770
73.0 -9227 -2110 -8902 -16107 -23822 2718
77.1 -8054 -2190 -9206 -16622 -20658 1807
83.5 -6092 -305 -7632 -15328 -13738 2572
97.0 -2539 2548 -5287 -13397 -125 3709
108.4 764 4786 -3320 -11588 10816 5195
112.0 126 3611 -4551 -12621 12077 3914
113.0 408 3762 -4412 -11541 12210 4048
123.0 2097 3990 -4253 -2932 12454 3580
130.0 2983 3679 -4545 3373 12378 3947
131.5 3131 3551 -4662 4649 12325 3996
148.0 4517 1697 -6228 17568 11844 4441
150.0 4325 885 -6988 18355 11253 3931
151.0 3653 -591 -8213 17489 9916 2643
154.5 3824 -797 -4942 17582 10172 3065
169.0 5838 -2754 7060 17184 10618 4348
179.5 6811 -4774 14701 16616 10830 5317
190.0 6242 -8552 19640 14327 9464 4835
199.3 7694 -2050 18414 14114 10178 5526
214.5 9817 8071 15677 13203 10939 8779
229.0 12227 14794 14183 13318 12530 11778
Max(Num.) -15321 14794 20342 -18804 -24243 -25420
Allow(%) 46 66 21 34 29 46
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 34.0 229.0 189.6 34.0 72.4 34.0
Max(Per.) 12227 14794 14183 13318 12530 11778
Allow(%) 72 66 63 59 56 53
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 229.0 229.0 229.0 229.0 229.0

46
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 9 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (II)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

BENDING MOMENT (kN-m)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -14622 12860 -8404 -31020 -54923 -75313
30.0 -77070 -23070 -65757 -111435 -159133 -199897
32.0 -98748 -37736 -86188 -138090 -192168 -238391
34.0 -121203 -53126 -107433 -165656 -226203 -277101
46.5 -264135 -137110 -234889 -340073 -448421 -491001
60.0 -389594 -187958 -344622 -513128 -685696 -626989
64.5 -427573 -199701 -378533 -570859 -767378 -648218
72.0 -481908 -214699 -429380 -666741 -905993 -647580
72.8 -487464 -217281 -435994 -678424 -922445 -646375
73.0 -489203 -218100 -438069 -682074 -927500 -646038
77.1 -516109 -230042 -471013 -741262 -1003617 -640481
83.5 -551308 -242893 -517698 -829775 -1095637 -631314
97.0 -600327 -227563 -589458 -994029 -1176875 -596172
108.4 -613312 -185326 -625698 -1110751 -1119515 -549865
112.0 -611972 -170080 -635904 -1146797 -1082825 -534428
113.0 -611454 -166893 -639765 -1157250 -1072880 -531234
123.0 -598379 -133307 -677054 -1219546 -971971 -497617
130.0 -581932 -110018 -703488 -1214421 -900760 -472945
131.5 -577818 -105335 -709437 -1208383 -885606 -467667
148.0 -525856 -70897 -790306 -1054690 -727530 -414831
150.0 -519950 -70007 -802227 -1028333 -711269 -410029
151.0 -516452 -70099 -809691 -1011801 -701718 -407296
154.5 -505516 -71914 -828967 -960923 -672704 -399190
169.0 -444021 -90748 -812537 -751150 -547914 -355430
179.5 -388853 -124320 -718624 -606362 -457752 -317170
190.0 -331948 -184860 -572170 -475229 -374094 -278518
199.3 -278955 -220497 -430350 -366914 -304361 -242599
214.5 -173316 -187664 -223137 -202339 -182776 -161660
229.0 -46122 -57062 -54418 -50715 -47337 -44097
Max(Num.) -613323 -245746 -841621 -1223622 -1177572 -654110
Allow(%) 38 10 35 50 48 35
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 108.0 87.0 160.5 125.5 96.0 68.5
Max(Per.) -46122 -69280 -223137 -78447 -73513 -63713
Allow(%) 77 60 58 54 50 47
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 228.0 214.5 226.5 226.5 227.0

(Remark : The Mark(* **) is not permission & corrected sf)


(Remark : The Mark(**) is not permission)

(Remark : The Mark(--) is over the allowable range)

47
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:06 PM Page : 10 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.1 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=46.93,S.G=0.76449] By :

CARGO MASS SUMMARY


Judgement : YES

HYDROSTATIC DATA
DEAD WEIGHT 60934.8 Mt FORE DRAFT 13.034 m
LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt MEAN DRAFT 13.035 m
DISPLACEMENT 71360.8 Mt AFT DRAFT 13.037 m
CARGO WEIGHT 58506.6 Mt TRIM 0.002 m

ONE HOLD(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 13.03 1839.93 11046.284 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12118.787 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 13.04 2009.45 12115.186 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12119.223 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 13.04 1930.00 11107.126 20269.00 YES

ONE HOLD(HARBOUR)
Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 13.03 0.00 11046.284 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12118.787 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12115.186 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12119.223 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 13.04 0.00 11107.126 20269.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 13.03 5662.06 23165.071 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 13.04 5911.59 24233.974 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 13.04 5912.21 24234.409 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 13.04 5795.84 23226.349 31091.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(HARBOUR)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 13.03 1117.06 23165.071 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 13.04 1156.59 24233.974 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 13.04 1157.21 24234.409 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 13.04 1131.84 23226.349 31091.00 YES

48
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 1 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 11061.0 25.517 3.0000 -68.803 4.341 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 12135.0 25.517 3.0000 -38.697 4.210 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 12131.0 25.516 3.0000 -7.481 4.211 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 12136.0 25.518 3.0000 23.720 4.211 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 11044.0 24.158 3.0000 53.468 4.416 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 58507.0 25.249 -7.572 4.274 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -87.859 0.000 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 -5.375 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 5.375 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 -7.168 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 7.168 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 -7.194 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 7.194 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 -10.870 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 10.870 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.167 0.000 -6.966 2649.6(M)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.327 0.000 6.917 2711.1(M)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 -10.478 100.5(M)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 10.478 100.5(M)
A.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 89.479 6.424 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 6.835 0.841 -9.375 0.0(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 5561.7
CREW & EFFECT 3.2 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 5.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 22.2 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 1.4 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 14.4 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 2.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 1.9 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 2.2 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 3.1 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 5.4 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 10.8 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 5.8 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 2.9 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 10.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 11.5 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 15.4 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 10.7 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 13.8 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 9.7 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 7.9 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 12.6 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 26.2 80.900 8.290 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 36.8 -3.610 20.850 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 2.9 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 237.6 51.598 12.387 0.000 85.0

49
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 2 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 367.8 95.000 0.9500 23.979 0.797 -3.793 1090.6(M)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 373.5 95.000 0.9500 24.224 0.798 3.751 1122.0(M)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 430.3 95.000 0.9500 52.124 0.798 -0.005 3635.7(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 -11.708 23.8(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 11.708 23.8(M)
F.O.T. TOTAL 1589.9 95.000 46.154 4.454 0.003 5895.7
D.O.T.(S) 102.1 95.000 0.9000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7(M)
D.O.T. TOTAL 102.1 95.000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7
M.G.O.T.(P) 116.4 95.000 0.9000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7(M)
G.O.T. TOTAL 116.4 95.000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7
F.W.T.(P) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 -9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T.(S) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T. TOTAL 382.2 100.000 92.760 16.465 0.000 176.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

50
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 3 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 0.0 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 11061.0 3687.0


F.O. Tks 1589.9 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 12135.0 4045.0
D.O. Tks 102.1 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 12131.0 4043.7
G.O. Tks 116.4 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 12136.0 4045.3
F.W. Tks 382.2 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 11044.0 3681.3
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 237.6

OTHERS TOTAL : 2428.2 CARGO TOTAL : 58507.0

DEAD WEIGHT 60935.2 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 71361.2 Mt
LCG -3.032 m KMT 13.540 m
TCG -0.002 m KG 5.391 m
LCB -3.032 m GM 8.149 m
MTC 872.247 Mt-m GGo 0.165 m
TPC 60.265 Mt/Cm GoM 7.984 m
LCF 3.525 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 384713.949 Mt-m


FS. Moment 11759.750 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 13.036 m
FORE 13.034 m
MEAN 13.036 m
AFT 13.037 m

Trim 0.003 m
Heeling Angle -0.016 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 158.084 %

51
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 4 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 43.296 deg


Initial GoM 7.984 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 43.296 deg 25.000 deg YES
Maximum GoZ 5.138 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 4.040 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 1.100 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 1.885 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.785 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


10.38

9.34

8.30 GoM = 7.984 m

7.27

6.23

Max GoZ = 5.138 m


5.19

4.15

3.11

2.08

1.04

0 10 20 30 40 Af 50 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

52
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 5 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.027 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.040 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.202 deg < 15.279deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 20.269 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 43.296 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 0.297 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 0.513 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 2.143 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 4.175 >= 1
Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


6.17

4.62

3.08

1.54

-60.0 -50.0 -40.0 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
lw2 lw1 A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-1.54

a2
-3.08

-4.62
a0

-6.17

a1
-7.71

53
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 6 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 0.003 3.036 18.953


GoM 7.984 3.536 14.299
Draft 13.036 4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
10.024 2.000
13.036 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 7.984(m) 2.000(m) YES


Available Trim Range 2.925(m) > trim > -0.975(m)

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14 GoM= 7.984 m
Draft=13.036 m
Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10

6
Light service draft: 5.506 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

54
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 7 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

SF/BM & GRAPH


SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN-m)
(kN) SEA (+) (-) (kN-m) SEA HOG SAG

21.0 -4996 23 22700 -22100 -14649 18 237000 -82000


30.0 -11150 ***** ***** ***** -77124 38 441000 -205000
32.0 -13622 41 34100 -33400 -98809 40 496600 -245800
34.0 -17393 52 34300 -33500 -122036 43 550000 -285000
46.5 -18318 55 34300 -33500 -305491 53 876500 -577000
60.0 -14237 41 35900 -34700 -485826 60 1175000 -804000
64.5 -12095 26 48100 -46800 -533893 63 1256500 -842500
72.0 -9284 14 66900 -65500 -595009 ***** ***** *****
72.8 -9772 ***** ***** ***** -600972 68 1380300 -884000
73.0 -9764 15 65500 -64100 -602822 67 1383700 -896500
77.1 -8273 17 48800 -47700 -630633 ***** ***** *****
83.5 -6008 13 48800 -47700 -665616 42 1570000 -1594000
97.0 -1773 4 45200 -45100 -709028 44 1570000 -1594000
108.4 1853 3 56000 -56000 -715979 ***** ***** *****
112.0 -306 1 59400 -59400 -713685 45 1570000 -1594000
113.0 121 0 56500 -56500 -713453 ***** ***** *****
123.0 2256 4 56500 -56500 -698032 ***** ***** *****
130.0 3604 12 31000 -31000 -676460 42 1570000 -1594000
131.5 3802 9 42900 -42900 -671113 ***** ***** *****
148.0 6311 15 42900 -42900 -609888 ***** ***** *****
150.0 4772 10 47700 -47900 -604118 ***** ***** *****
151.0 3375 7 47700 -47900 -600871 38 1570000 -1594000
154.5 4000 9 44700 -44300 -590058 ***** ***** *****
169.0 6952 16 43900 -44300 -527059 33 1570000 -1594000
179.5 8129 19 43900 -44300 -467820 60 1229000 -779000
190.0 6162 10 64100 -65500 -395475 65 873300 -609400
199.3 9887 23 42700 -44000 -333801 73 560000 -460000
214.5 12697 66 19200 -20300 -193347 73 301000 -263500
229.0 12226 72 16900 -17400 -46127 77 74300 -59900
MAX -18498 55 34300 -33500 -717855 45 1570000 -1594000
(Num.) ( FR : 42.50 ) ( FR : 103.00 )
MAX 12226 72 16900 -17400 -46127 77 74300 -59900
(Per.) ( FR : 229.00 ) ( FR : 229.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612

29874 1017306

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 Max SF FR = 42.50 Max BM FR = 103.00 -1017306


Value = -18498 Value = -717855

-59749 -2034612

Sag(-)
-89623 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M

55
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 8 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (I)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5


Disp(Mt) 71361.2 81397.9 80894.5 80667.7 80630.5 80799.2
TAft(m) 13.04 10.73 12.39 14.00 15.56 17.16
TFwd(m) 13.03 19.00 17.01 15.20 13.49 11.82
Trim(m) 0.00 -8.27 -4.62 -1.21 2.06 5.34

SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -4996 4299 -2689 -9691 -17124 -25188
30.0 -11150 898 -8504 -18468 -28461 -38760
32.0 -13622 -280 -11013 -21603 -32220 -45476
34.0 -17393 -2975 -14702 -25780 -36980 -48455
46.5 -18318 -824 -16337 -30186 -44701 -30946
60.0 -14237 4919 -14072 -31223 -48686 -2779
64.5 -12095 8012 -11942 -30231 -48531 7890
72.0 -9284 10383 -9646 -29201 -48729 23787
72.8 -9772 9788 -10964 -30425 -49908 23110
73.0 -9764 9762 -11213 -30644 -49802 22871
77.1 -8273 11002 -10739 -30342 -40278 21686
83.5 -6008 12532 -10400 -30697 -25970 19953
97.0 -1773 14602 -9151 -31387 3990 16945
108.4 1853 14584 -10681 -31669 29545 14623
112.0 -306 10239 -13296 -35137 32405 10256
113.0 121 10287 -13433 -32630 32426 10258
123.0 2256 8745 -16622 -10455 31217 9051
130.0 3604 6396 -18047 3856 29756 7798
131.5 3802 5747 -18475 7155 29366 7476
148.0 6311 -3082 -26248 41245 25913 4691
150.0 4772 -5747 -27447 42887 23397 2745
151.0 3375 -7995 -29663 42385 21417 1114
154.5 4000 -9945 -22900 41934 21423 1516
169.0 6952 -20833 8342 38232 20070 1529
179.5 8129 -29691 28765 33575 18413 1978
190.0 6162 -42141 44434 27095 14077 494
199.3 9887 -22608 40849 26828 15958 4350
214.5 12697 4712 29937 21595 15330 8792
229.0 12226 21210 18017 15203 13022 10859
Max(Num.) -18498 -42675 45183 43493 -50094 -48455
Allow(%) 55 44 47 64 59 88
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 42.5 189.8 189.6 150.6 72.4 34.0
Max(Per.) 12226 21210 29937 41934 -48686 -45476
Allow(%) 72 95 94 68 97 88
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 229.0 214.5 154.5 60.0 32.0

56
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 9 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (II)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

BENDING MOMENT (kN-m)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -14649 69127 13016 -50813 -119300 -204474
30.0 -77124 90140 -33427 -162466 -295258 -454181
32.0 -98809 90339 -51246 -197747 -347791 -526129
34.0 -122036 89110 -70735 -234935 -402473 -597622
46.5 -305491 80350 -214429 -509294 -806126 -990713
60.0 -485826 89336 -375853 -843154 -1311558 -1194103
64.5 -533893 111446 -421041 -951637 -1483270 -1185376
72.0 -595009 173155 -481385 -1122840 -1765179 -1084070
72.8 -600972 181801 -488599 -1141966 -1796877 -1069022
73.0 -602822 184472 -490857 -1147930 -1806550 -1064419
77.1 -630633 222574 -526800 -1245744 -1949228 -990881
83.5 -665616 288675 -579016 -1397086 -2110336 -884663
97.0 -709028 448723 -686727 -1727531 -2221736 -683881
108.4 -715979 583685 -790995 -2028694 -2084427 -544176
112.0 -713685 621878 -829870 -2130902 -1998182 -507590
113.0 -713453 630925 -841215 -2158313 -1972529 -499797
123.0 -698032 716497 -959503 -2328979 -1720393 -426567
130.0 -676460 765197 -1052351 -2342178 -1551419 -382155
131.5 -671113 773726 -1073909 -2334297 -1516377 -373623
148.0 -609888 789050 -1369113 -2020385 -1170395 -311552
150.0 -604118 777830 -1411313 -1960537 -1136924 -309131
151.0 -600871 769932 -1437571 -1922608 -1117493 -308181
154.5 -590058 742268 -1508507 -1805518 -1058395 -305813
169.0 -527059 571916 -1581214 -1342226 -819751 -287524
179.5 -467820 370911 -1408809 -1035171 -656806 -268872
190.0 -395475 80623 -1096909 -774416 -520409 -257375
199.3 -333801 -146787 -784397 -569188 -405800 -234512
214.5 -193347 -247715 -352065 -267466 -209516 -146950
229.0 -46127 -92155 -73814 -58640 -49292 -36806
Max(Num.) -717855 807596 -1594925 -2347046 -2224245 -1195356
Allow(%) 45 33 66 97 91 75
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 103.0 143.0 165.0 127.5 95.0 61.0
Max(Per.) -46127 -92155 -1198998 -2347046 -2224245 -862397
Allow(%) 77 96 94 97 91 85
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 229.0 187.0 127.5 95.0 42.0

(Remark : The Mark(* **) is not permission & corrected sf)


(Remark : The Mark(**) is not permission)

(Remark : The Mark(--) is over the allowable range)

57
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 10 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LAOD.6 HOMO.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

CARGO MASS SUMMARY


Judgement : YES

HYDROSTATIC DATA
DEAD WEIGHT 60935.2 Mt FORE DRAFT 13.034 m
LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt MEAN DRAFT 13.036 m
DISPLACEMENT 71361.2 Mt AFT DRAFT 13.037 m
CARGO WEIGHT 58507.0 Mt TRIM 0.003 m

ONE HOLD(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 13.03 1839.63 11061.000 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 13.03 0.00 12135.000 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 13.04 2009.45 12131.000 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12136.000 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 13.04 1930.00 11044.000 20269.00 YES

ONE HOLD(HARBOUR)
Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 13.03 0.00 11061.000 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 13.03 0.00 12135.000 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12131.000 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 13.04 0.00 12136.000 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 13.04 0.00 11044.000 20269.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 13.03 5661.57 23196.000 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 13.04 5911.42 24266.000 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 13.04 5912.39 24267.000 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 13.04 5796.00 23180.000 31091.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(HARBOUR)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 13.03 1116.57 23196.000 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 13.04 1156.42 24266.000 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 13.04 1157.39 24267.000 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 13.04 1132.00 23180.000 31091.00 YES

58
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 1 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 18586.0 42.877 3.0000 -69.027 5.831 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -38.215 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 20384.0 42.876 3.0000 -7.617 5.659 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 24.185 1.700 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 19536.0 42.734 3.0000 53.651 6.084 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 58506.0 25.249 -6.667 5.855 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -87.859 0.000 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 -5.375 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 5.375 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 -7.168 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 7.168 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 -7.194 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 7.194 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 -10.870 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 10.870 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.167 0.000 -6.966 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.327 0.000 6.917 0.0(A)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 -10.478 100.5(M)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 10.478 100.5(M)
A.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 89.479 6.424 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 6.835 0.841 -9.375 0.0(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 200.9
CREW & EFFECT 3.2 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 5.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 22.2 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 1.4 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 14.4 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 2.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 1.9 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 2.2 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 3.1 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 5.4 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 10.8 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 5.8 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 2.9 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 10.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 11.5 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 15.4 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 10.7 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 13.8 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 9.7 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 7.9 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 12.6 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 26.2 80.900 8.290 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 36.8 -3.610 20.850 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 2.9 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 237.6 51.598 12.387 0.000 85.0

59
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 2 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 367.8 95.000 0.9500 23.979 0.797 -3.793 1090.6(M)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 373.5 95.000 0.9500 24.224 0.798 3.751 1122.0(M)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 430.3 95.000 0.9500 52.124 0.798 -0.005 3635.7(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 -11.708 23.8(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 11.708 23.8(M)
F.O.T. TOTAL 1589.9 95.000 46.154 4.454 0.003 5895.7
D.O.T.(S) 102.1 95.000 0.9000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7(M)
D.O.T. TOTAL 102.1 95.000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7
M.G.O.T.(P) 116.4 95.000 0.9000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7(M)
G.O.T. TOTAL 116.4 95.000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7
F.W.T.(P) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 -9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T.(S) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T. TOTAL 382.2 100.000 92.760 16.465 0.000 176.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

60
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 3 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 0.0 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 18586.0 6195.3


F.O. Tks 1589.9 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
D.O. Tks 102.1 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 20384.0 6794.7
G.O. Tks 116.4 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
F.W. Tks 382.2 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 19536.0 6512.0
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 237.6

OTHERS TOTAL : 2428.2 CARGO TOTAL : 58506.0

DEAD WEIGHT 60934.2 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 71360.2 Mt
LCG -2.290 m KMT 13.558 m
TCG -0.002 m KG 6.688 m
LCB -2.290 m GM 6.870 m
MTC 875.015 Mt-m GGo 0.090 m
TPC 60.337 Mt/Cm GoM 6.781 m
LCF 3.623 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 477241.711 Mt-m


FS. Moment 6399.000 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 13.035 m
FORE 12.720 m
MEAN 13.024 m
AFT 13.328 m

Trim 0.607 m
Heeling Angle -0.018 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 162.772 %

61
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 4 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 42.270 deg


Initial GoM 6.781 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 42.270 deg 25.000 deg YES
Maximum GoZ 4.260 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 3.434 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 0.938 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 1.601 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.664 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


8.81

7.93

7.05 GoM = 6.781 m

6.17

5.29

Max GoZ = 4.260 m


4.41

3.53

2.64

1.76

0.88

0 10 20 30 40 Af 50 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

62
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 5 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.027 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.040 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.238 deg < 14.893deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 21.161 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 42.270 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 0.349 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 0.478 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 1.737 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 3.636 >= 1
Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


5.11

3.83

2.56

1.28

-60.0 -50.0 -40.0 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
lw2 lw1 A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-1.28

a2
-2.56

-3.83
a0

-5.11

a1
-6.39

63
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 6 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 0.607 3.036 18.953


GoM 6.781 3.536 14.299
Draft 13.035 4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
10.024 2.000
13.035 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 6.781(m) 2.000(m) YES


Available Trim Range 2.925(m) > trim > -0.975(m)

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14 GoM= 6.781 m
Draft=13.035 m
Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10

6
Light service draft: 5.506 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

64
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 7 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

SF/BM & GRAPH


* : CORRECTED SF
SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO NORM. CORR. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN-m)
(kN) (kN) SEA (+) (-) (kN-m) SEA HOG SAG

21.0 -6293 -6293 28 22700 -22100 -26524 32 237000 -82000


30.0 -12986 -12986 ***** ***** ***** -100800 49 441000 -205000
32.0 -15498 -15498 46 34100 -33400 -125647 51 496600 -245800
34.0 -19058 -19445 58 34300 -33500 -154197 54 550000 -285000
46.5 3778 972 3 34300 -33500 -244148 42 876500 -577000
60.0 36965 31548 88 35900 -34700 -25046 3 1175000 -804000
64.5 49424 43136 90 48100 -46800 130501 10 1256500 -842500
72.0 69851 62125 93 66900 -65500 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 68659 60776 ***** ***** ***** 536224 39 1380300 -884000
* 73.0 67855 59923 91 65500 -64100 550057 40 1383700 -896500
77.1 57266 45074 92 48800 -47700 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 39309 32172 66 48800 -47700 999423 64 1570000 -1594000
97.0 995 4563 10 45200 -45100 1210701 77 1570000 -1594000
108.4 -31423 -18835 34 56000 -56000 ***** ***** ***** *****
* 112.0 -39760 -31771 53 59400 -59400 969524 62 1570000 -1594000
113.0 -37198 -29619 52 56500 -56500 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 -14067 -10585 19 56500 -56500 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 2070 2685 9 31000 -31000 713846 45 1570000 -1594000
131.5 5555 5555 13 42900 -42900 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 42636 35876 84 42900 -42900 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 44839 37311 78 47700 -47900 ***** ***** ***** *****
* 151.0 44018 36029 76 47700 -47900 1134625 72 1570000 -1594000
154.5 33137 20637 46 44700 -44300 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 -9664 -10836 24 43900 -44300 1383173 88 1570000 -1594000
179.5 -40165 -33134 75 43900 -44300 1175358 96 1229000 -779000
* 190.0 -69584 -63781 97 64100 -65500 708607 81 873300 -609400
199.3 -45039 -40612 92 42700 -44000 285376 51 560000 -460000
214.5 -11483 -9326 46 19200 -20300 -54843 21 301000 -263500
229.0 11834 11834 70 16900 -17400 -44423 74 74300 -59900
MAX 70531 -63781 97 64100 -65500 1394877 89 1570000 -1594000
(Num.) ( FR: 190.00 ) ( FR : 166.00 )
MAX 57266 -63781 97 64100 -65500 1191134 96 1245238 -817810
(Per.) ( FR : 190.00 ) ( FR : 179.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612
Value = 1394877
Max BM FR = 166.00

29874 1017306

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 -1017306

-59749 -2034612

Max Corr SF FR = 190.00


Sag(-)
Value = -63781
-89623 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M
S.F CORRECTION

65
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 8 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (I)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5


Disp(Mt) 71360.2 78669.0 83578.1 77894.5 83922.5 78883.4
TAft(m) 13.33 11.60 12.41 14.00 16.69 16.60
TFwd(m) 12.72 17.08 17.59 14.24 13.31 11.76
Trim(m) 0.61 -5.48 -5.18 -0.24 3.39 4.84

SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -6293 1209 -3117 -9641 -22400 -21746
30.0 -12986 -3528 -9330 -18101 -36416 -34898
32.0 -15498 -5083 -11944 -21175 -40718 -39029
34.0 -19058 -7788 -15591 -25533 -47415 -42714
46.5 3778 16621 6774 -5836 -32890 -5623
60.0 36965 ** 52367 ** 37399 24501 -10420 46447
64.5 49424 ** 64989 ** 49041 35836 -1428 64924 **
72.0 69851 ** 84646 69283 54662 13473 95859 **
72.8 68659 83724 68178 53786 15358 95043
73.0 67855 ** 83003 67400 53080 15926 94199 **
77.1 57266 ** 72223 ** 54471 41343 15179 80295 **
83.5 39309 53849 34163 21351 14312 59185
97.0 995 12873 -9610 -21036 11027 15157
108.4 -31423 -21529 -47423 -56729 8090 -21348
112.0 -39760 -30970 -58001 -64245 5363 -31215
113.0 -37198 -28776 -55998 -60363 6836 -28992
123.0 -14067 -8857 -38950 -23564 25253 -9414
130.0 2070 4395 -27294 2791 37600 4957
131.5 5555 7090 -24634 8293 40162 8007
148.0 42636 35581 1061 68303 ** 69083 ** 40866
150.0 44839 36799 1865 74223 ** 70152 ** 43050
151.0 44018 35376 755 72966 ** 68655 ** 42225
154.5 33137 23061 -438 61589 ** 56758 31287
169.0 -9664 -29785 -6931 14584 8106 -13193
179.5 -40165 -68824 ** -12099 -20603 -26620 -44695
190.0 -69584 ** -106472 ** -18423 -54278 -59407 -74087
199.3 -45039 ** -69228 ** -5639 -33032 -38044 -50051
214.5 -11483 -17624 11721 -4872 -8023 -14733
229.0 11834 18251 19853 13934 12890 10752
Max(Num.) 70531 -107425 69986 75191 70558 97010
Allow(%) 106 110 81 111 104 112
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 72.2 189.8 72.2 150.6 150.6 72.2
Max(Per.) 57266 -68824 19853 75191 70558 80295
Allow(%) 117 110 89 111 104 114
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 77.1 179.5 229.0 150.6 150.6 77.1

66
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 9 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (II)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

CORRECTED SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -6293 1209 -3117 -9641 -22400 -21746
30.0 -12986 -3528 -9330 -18101 -36416 -34898
32.0 -15498 -5083 -11944 -21175 -40718 -39029
34.0 -19445 -8191 -15964 -25886 -47600 -43357
46.5 972 13701 4067 -8397 -34231 -10286
60.0 31548 46729 32171 19556 -13009 37444
64.5 43136 58445 42973 30097 -4434 54474
72.0 62125 76605 61826 47609 9780 83017
72.8 60776 75519 60570 46590 11590 81940
73.0 59923* 74748* 59745* 45839* 12135* 81015*
77.1 45074 59475 41074 28221 9670 66562
83.5 32172 46387 26321 13670 9117 51145
97.0 4563 16604 -5689 -17195 6498 19177
108.4 -18835 -8366 -33591 -43181 4120 -7168
112.0 -31771* -24836* -52633* -50113* 1572* -24381*
113.0 -29619 -22957 -50895 -46956 1041 -22508
123.0 -10585 -6183 -36500 -17404 19458 -6435
130.0 2685 4867 -26699 3878 31806 5483
131.5 5555 7090 -24437 8293 34367 8007
148.0 35876 30391 -3117 56345 63289 35083
150.0 37311 31020 -2810 60907 64358 36610
151.0 36029* 29243* -4219* 58834* 62861* 35390*
154.5 20637 8094 -4878 47860 42888 18496
169.0 -10836 -31188 -7526 13297 6805 -14392
179.5 -33134 -60405 -9910 -12880 -18818 -37500
190.0 -63781* -97141* -15967* -49629* -54400* -67973*
199.3 -40612 -62110 -3766 -29486 -34224 -45387
214.5 -9326 -14155 12634 -3143 -6162 -12460
229.0 11834 18251 19853 13934 12890 10752
Max(Num.) -63781 -97141 62490 61386 64764 84100
Allow(%) 97 99 72 90 95 98
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 190.0 190.0 72.2 150.6 150.6 72.2
Max(Per.) -63781 -97141 19853 61386 64764 84100
Allow(%) 97 99 89 90 95 98
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 190.0 190.0 229.0 150.6 150.6 72.2

67
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 10 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (III)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

BENDING MOMENT (kN-m)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -26524 43017 8248 -55398 -169267 -168491
30.0 -100800 35707 -43584 -165584 -402818 -389735
32.0 -125647 28279 -63037 -200293 -472199 -456310
34.0 -154197 21773 -85961 -239039 -541412 -520458
46.5 -244148 64280 -126305 -398904 -931604 -766024
60.0 -25046 439334 111387 -288996 -1168249 -553490
64.5 130501 637072 271596 -181508 -1192718 -362117
72.0 490713 1073112 634636 93487 -1151985 115056
72.8 536224 1128788 678709 127381 -1141024 179835
73.0 550057 1145765 692069 137590 -1137695 199593
77.1 756496 1403553 888834 290712 -1085492 492236
83.5 999423 1724157 1108802 444655 -1013383 844393
97.0 1210701 2087597 1227314 440311 -892495 1237753
108.4 1073179 2053993 962480 87751 -822836 1203450
112.0 969524 1976850 806927 -91586 -806716 1123382
113.0 939046 1953169 761217 -142441 -801728 1098774
123.0 740996 1809411 387730 -480146 -668869 945227
130.0 713846 1803607 210986 -537550 -489225 935166
131.5 719479 1811825 181498 -528257 -441846 943900
148.0 1031713 2099708 29780 -18542 272714 1262921
150.0 1094575 2153085 30347 84402 374969 1323799
151.0 1134625 2186731 32094 150048 438062 1362428
154.5 1243089 2264006 34171 336990 615409 1465431
169.0 1383173 2213774 -16993 768921 997618 1569109
179.5 1175358 1800200 -94852 738072 924371 1325582
190.0 708607 1063868 -225858 418469 556458 819980
199.3 285376 431683 -312817 105039 196958 368785
214.5 -54843 -91401 -268706 -116987 -84014 -21787
229.0 -44423 -75225 -81577 -53264 -48502 -38435
Max(Num.) 1394877 2315756 1241289 791219 -1193486 1592020
Allow(%) 89 96 51 36 68 66
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 166.0 160.5 93.5 173.0 65.5 164.5
Max(Per.) 1191134 2315756 -98786 -66756 -1011977 -605171
Allow(%) 96 96 85 56 79 72
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 179.0 160.5 228.0 227.9 50.0 37.0

(Remark : The Mark(* **) is not permission & corrected sf)


(Remark : The Mark(**) is not permission)
(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected sf)
(Remark : The Mark(--) is over the allowable range)

68
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 11 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.11 ALT.LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.G=3.0] By :

CARGO MASS SUMMARY


Judgement : YES

HYDROSTATIC DATA
DEAD WEIGHT 60934.2 Mt FORE DRAFT 12.720 m
LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt MEAN DRAFT 13.024 m
DISPLACEMENT 71360.2 Mt AFT DRAFT 13.328 m
CARGO WEIGHT 58506.0 Mt TRIM 0.607 m

ONE HOLD(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 12.81 1652.04 18586.000 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 12.91 0.00 0.000 15852.00 N/A
No. 3 HOLD 13.00 1977.66 20384.000 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 13.10 0.00 0.000 15853.00 N/A
No. 5 HOLD 13.19 1930.00 19536.000 20269.00 YES

ONE HOLD(HARBOUR)
Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 12.81 0.00 18586.000 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 12.91 0.00 0.000 15852.00 N/A
No. 3 HOLD 13.00 0.00 20384.000 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 13.10 0.00 0.000 15853.00 N/A
No. 5 HOLD 13.19 0.00 19536.000 20269.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 12.86 5352.31 18586.000 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 12.95 5761.62 20384.000 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 13.05 5913.00 20384.000 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 13.15 5796.00 19536.000 31091.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(HARBOUR)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 12.86 807.28 18586.000 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 12.95 1006.50 20384.000 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 13.05 1158.00 20384.000 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 13.15 1132.00 19536.000 31091.00 YES

69
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 1 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -68.430 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -38.215 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -7.015 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 24.185 1.700 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 53.761 1.700 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 1681.8 100.000 1.0250 -90.335 7.142 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 1468.7 100.000 1.0250 -69.554 6.370 -9.906 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 1468.7 100.000 1.0250 -69.554 6.370 9.906 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 1666.1 100.000 1.0250 -39.386 6.736 -10.928 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 1666.1 100.000 1.0250 -39.386 6.736 10.928 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 1666.5 100.000 1.0250 -8.204 6.737 -10.935 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 1667.2 100.000 1.0250 -8.198 6.734 10.934 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 1271.6 100.000 1.0250 22.976 8.578 -13.166 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 1271.6 100.000 1.0250 22.976 8.578 13.166 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 1352.2 100.000 1.0250 55.323 9.097 -12.132 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 1354.2 100.000 1.0250 55.346 9.084 12.117 0.0(A)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 -10.478 100.5(M)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 10.478 100.5(M)
A.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 89.479 6.424 0.000 10112.7(M)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 6.835 0.841 -9.375 0.0(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 16534.8 48.116 -18.545 7.381 0.001 10313.6
CREW & EFFECT 3.2 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 5.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 22.2 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 1.4 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 14.4 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 2.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 1.9 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 2.2 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 3.1 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 5.4 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 10.8 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 5.8 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 2.9 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 10.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 11.5 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 15.4 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 10.7 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 13.8 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 9.7 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 7.9 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 12.6 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 26.2 80.900 8.290 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 36.8 -3.610 20.850 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 2.9 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 237.6 51.598 12.387 0.000 85.0

70
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 2 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 367.8 95.000 0.9500 23.979 0.797 -3.793 1090.6(M)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 373.5 95.000 0.9500 24.224 0.798 3.751 1122.0(M)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 430.3 95.000 0.9500 52.124 0.798 -0.005 3635.7(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 -11.708 23.8(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 11.708 23.8(M)
F.O.T. TOTAL 1589.9 95.000 46.154 4.454 0.003 5895.7
D.O.T.(S) 102.1 95.000 0.9000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7(M)
D.O.T. TOTAL 102.1 95.000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7
M.G.O.T.(P) 116.4 95.000 0.9000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7(M)
G.O.T. TOTAL 116.4 95.000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7
F.W.T.(P) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 -9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T.(S) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T. TOTAL 382.2 100.000 92.760 16.465 0.000 176.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

71
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 3 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 16534.8 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0


F.O. Tks 1589.9 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
D.O. Tks 102.1 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
G.O. Tks 116.4 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
F.W. Tks 382.2 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 237.6

OTHERS TOTAL : 18963.0 CARGO TOTAL : 0.0

DEAD WEIGHT 18963.0 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 29389.0 Mt
LCG -2.721 m KMT 17.629 m
TCG -0.005 m KG 8.735 m
LCB -2.664 m GM 8.895 m
MTC 663.355 Mt-m GGo 0.562 m
TPC 54.693 Mt/Cm GoM 8.333 m
LCF -4.540 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 256705.447 Mt-m


FS. Moment 16511.650 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 5.755 m
FORE 4.839 m
MEAN 5.804 m
AFT 6.770 m

Trim 1.932 m
Heeling Angle -0.034 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 57.006 %

72
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 4 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 77.129 deg


Initial GoM 8.333 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 46.500 deg 25.000 deg YES
Maximum GoZ 4.618 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 4.096 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 1.156 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 1.914 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.757 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


10.83

9.75

8.67 GoM = 8.333 m

7.58

6.50

5.42
Max GoZ = 4.618 m

4.33

3.25

2.17

1.08

0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

73
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 5 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.088 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.132 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.634 deg < 16.000deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 26.297 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 50.000 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 0.934 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 0.914 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 2.592 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 2.834 >= 1
Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


5.54

4.16

2.77

1.39

-60.0 -50.0 -40.0 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
lw2 lw1 A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-1.39

a2
-2.77

-4.16
a0

-5.54

a1
-6.93

74
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 6 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 1.932 3.036 18.953


GoM 8.333 3.536 14.299
Draft 5.755 4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
5.755 4.929
10.024 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 8.333(m) 4.929(m) YES


Available Trim Range 2.925(m) > trim > -0.975(m)

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14
Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10

7
GoM= 8.333 m
Draft= 5.755 m
6
Light service draft: 5.506 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

75
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 7 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

SF/BM & GRAPH


SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN-m)
(kN) SEA (+) (-) (kN-m) SEA HOG SAG

21.0 13665 60 22700 -22100 119933 51 237000 -82000


30.0 21044 ***** ***** ***** 250292 57 441000 -205000
32.0 21905 64 34100 -33400 285770 58 496600 -245800
34.0 21789 64 34300 -33500 320692 58 550000 -285000
46.5 21683 63 34300 -33500 540473 62 876500 -577000
60.0 17783 50 35900 -34700 758244 65 1175000 -804000
64.5 16117 34 48100 -46800 820173 65 1256500 -842500
72.0 13611 20 66900 -65500 909094 ***** ***** *****
72.8 13772 ***** ***** ***** 918136 67 1380300 -884000
73.0 13810 21 65500 -64100 920958 67 1383700 -896500
77.1 11872 24 48800 -47700 964135 ***** ***** *****
83.5 9230 19 48800 -47700 1019117 65 1570000 -1594000
97.0 4233 9 45200 -45100 1093730 70 1570000 -1594000
108.4 520 1 56000 -56000 1117626 ***** ***** *****
112.0 610 1 59400 -59400 1118953 71 1570000 -1594000
113.0 329 1 56500 -56500 1119536 ***** ***** *****
123.0 -2969 5 56500 -56500 1110284 ***** ***** *****
130.0 -4878 16 31000 -31000 1089588 69 1570000 -1594000
131.5 -5255 12 42900 -42900 1083507 ***** ***** *****
148.0 -8882 21 42900 -42900 989783 ***** ***** *****
150.0 -9024 19 47700 -47900 976310 ***** ***** *****
151.0 -8675 18 47700 -47900 968484 62 1570000 -1594000
154.5 -9258 21 44700 -44300 944013 ***** ***** *****
169.0 -12508 28 43900 -44300 816557 52 1570000 -1594000
179.5 -14188 32 43900 -44300 704055 57 1229000 -779000
190.0 -14244 22 64100 -65500 580090 66 873300 -609400
199.3 -15807 36 42700 -44000 468520 84 560000 -460000
214.5 -16813 83 19200 -20300 265476 88 301000 -263500
229.0 -15624 90 16900 -17400 69558 94 74300 -59900
MAX 22154 65 34300 -33500 1119898 71 1570000 -1594000
(Num.) ( FR : 40.50 ) ( FR : 114.50 )
MAX -16736 91 17614 -18300 69558 94 74300 -59900
(Per.) ( FR : 224.50 ) ( FR : 229.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612

Value = 1119898
Value = 22154 Max BM FR = 114.50
29874 1017306
Max SF FR = 40.50

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 -1017306

-59749 -2034612

Sag(-)
-89623 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M

76
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 8 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (I)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5


Disp(Mt) 29389.0 33290.5 33347.1 33292.4 33913.8 34288.5
TAft(m) 6.77 5.47 6.41 7.36 8.48 9.59
TFwd(m) 4.84 7.37 6.54 5.65 4.82 3.86
Trim(m) 1.93 -1.91 -0.13 1.71 3.66 5.73

SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 13665 14301 13759 13087 11640 9260
30.0 21044 23069 21462 19592 16845 12600
32.0 21905 23723 21825 19644 16464 11813
34.0 21789 24335 22149 19661 16062 10681
46.5 21683 26193 22112 17664 11469 17650
60.0 17783 23880 17888 11520 2860 25579
64.5 16117 22579 16018 9094 -292 27703
72.0 13611 20492 13079 5324 -6189 31264
72.8 13772 20683 13184 5346 -5938 31414
73.0 13810 20730 13205 5341 -5716 31344
77.1 11872 18901 10961 2696 -3543 27667
83.5 9230 16292 7773 -1045 72 22473
97.0 4233 10806 1317 -8405 7161 12610
108.4 520 6095 -3941 -14148 13082 5362
112.0 610 5756 -4403 -15154 15287 3654
113.0 329 5347 -4842 -14477 14772 3174
123.0 -2969 543 -9837 -8478 9232 -1892
130.0 -4878 -2665 -13065 -4616 5862 -5298
131.5 -5255 -3346 -13739 -3788 5182 -5971
148.0 -8882 -10923 -20958 5681 -1497 -12256
150.0 -9024 -11585 -21547 6286 -1955 -12630
151.0 -8675 -11162 -20832 7417 -1400 -12806
154.5 -9258 -13162 -18881 5771 -2939 -13853
169.0 -12508 -21181 -10898 -274 -8268 -17646
179.5 -14188 -26854 -4695 -4010 -11206 -19540
190.0 -14244 -31080 675 -6145 -12311 -19367
199.3 -15807 -25665 -4002 -9549 -14626 -20357
214.5 -16813 -18371 -10074 -13287 -16278 -19587
229.0 -15624 -12406 -13419 -14541 -15599 -16745
Max(Num.) 22154 -31687 22591 19877 16887 31539
Allow(%) 65 33 42 39 34 37
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 40.5 189.1 40.5 31.2 31.0 72.2
Max(Per.) -16736 -15261 -13419 -14541 -15599 -16745
Allow(%) 91 57 59 63 68 73
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 224.5 223.5 229.0 229.0 229.0 229.0

77
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 9 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (II)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

BENDING MOMENT (kN-m)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 119933 120888 119054 116707 109564 95463
30.0 250292 259871 250263 238627 214968 174923
32.0 285770 298658 286126 271108 241936 194218
34.0 320692 337282 321484 302732 267595 213177
46.5 540473 591611 544523 491072 403452 358591
60.0 758244 874621 772890 657184 488874 595131
64.5 820173 961827 837490 696623 495820 689528
72.0 909094 1094930 928969 742355 482358 867838
72.8 918136 1107891 937090 745196 478425 887858
73.0 920958 1111930 939620 746079 477296 894042
77.1 964135 1175313 977474 756193 461959 989363
83.5 1019117 1261923 1022079 755471 449959 1113947
97.0 1093730 1413811 1076417 705697 491963 1307633
108.4 1117626 1491128 1064711 600029 584580 1389026
112.0 1118953 1507294 1051587 556191 626079 1402194
113.0 1119536 1511744 1047898 544600 638504 1405533
123.0 1110284 1534898 988651 452220 737641 1412566
130.0 1089588 1528935 924460 413655 782497 1392232
131.5 1083507 1525328 908377 409458 789710 1385469
148.0 989783 1431944 679613 428451 819539 1263550
150.0 976310 1415021 647692 438000 817642 1244840
151.0 968484 1404747 628495 444871 816535 1233709
154.5 944013 1370791 573003 465396 810542 1198231
169.0 816557 1171220 400477 504294 743935 1016280
179.5 704055 969408 332389 486506 661624 859417
190.0 580090 720719 310293 439321 558159 691151
199.3 468520 504175 290446 373620 450754 536329
214.5 265476 237523 202538 232116 259816 290091
229.0 69558 55840 60174 65021 69560 74441
Max(Num.) 1119898 1535147 1077924 758223 820576 1415272
Allow(%) 71 63 44 36 34 58
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 114.5 124.0 100.0 80.0 145.5 119.5
Max(Per.) 69558 504175 60174 65021 69560 74441
Allow(%) 94 79 76 83 88 95
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 199.3 229.0 229.0 229.0 229.0

(Remark : The Mark(* **) is not permission & corrected sf)


(Remark : The Mark(**) is not permission)

(Remark : The Mark(--) is over the allowable range)

78
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 10 / 10
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.16 NORMAL BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

CARGO MASS SUMMARY


Judgement : YES

HYDROSTATIC DATA
DEAD WEIGHT 18963.0 Mt FORE DRAFT 4.839 m
LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt MEAN DRAFT 5.804 m
DISPLACEMENT 29389.0 Mt AFT DRAFT 6.770 m
CARGO WEIGHT 0.0 Mt TRIM 1.932 m

ONE HOLD(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 5.13 0.00 1327.566 13625.45 N/A
No. 2 HOLD 5.43 0.00 1660.181 12843.91 N/A
No. 3 HOLD 5.73 0.00 1660.574 15739.91 N/A
No. 4 HOLD 6.04 0.00 868.204 13405.01 N/A
No. 5 HOLD 6.34 0.00 704.906 15672.21 N/A

ONE HOLD(HARBOUR)
Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 5.13 0.00 1327.566 16477.17 N/A
No. 2 HOLD 5.43 0.00 1660.181 15213.35 N/A
No. 3 HOLD 5.73 0.00 1660.574 18899.06 N/A
No. 4 HOLD 6.04 0.00 868.204 15773.47 N/A
No. 5 HOLD 6.34 0.00 704.906 18681.96 N/A

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 5.28 0.00 2987.747 24278.64 N/A
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 5.58 0.00 3320.755 25964.60 N/A
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 5.89 0.00 2528.779 26524.62 N/A
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 6.19 0.00 1573.111 26552.81 N/A

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(HARBOUR)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 5.28 0.00 2987.747 28807.94 N/A
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 5.58 0.00 3320.755 30702.35 N/A
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 5.89 0.00 2528.779 31261.41 N/A
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 6.19 0.00 1573.111 31091.00 N/A

79
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 1 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -68.430 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -38.215 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -7.015 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 24.185 1.700 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 53.761 1.700 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 1681.8 100.000 1.0250 -90.335 7.142 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 1468.7 100.000 1.0250 -69.554 6.370 -9.906 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 1468.7 100.000 1.0250 -69.554 6.370 9.906 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 1666.1 100.000 1.0250 -39.386 6.736 -10.928 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 1666.1 100.000 1.0250 -39.386 6.736 10.928 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 1666.5 100.000 1.0250 -8.204 6.737 -10.935 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 1667.2 100.000 1.0250 -8.198 6.734 10.934 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 1271.6 100.000 1.0250 22.976 8.578 -13.166 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 1271.6 100.000 1.0250 22.976 8.578 13.166 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 1352.2 100.000 1.0250 55.323 9.097 -12.132 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 1354.2 100.000 1.0250 55.346 9.084 12.117 0.0(A)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 317.6 100.000 1.0250 77.772 11.667 -13.226 0.0(A)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 384.8 100.000 1.0250 77.273 12.479 13.531 0.0(A)
A.P.T. 859.5 100.000 1.0250 93.444 11.737 0.003 0.0(A)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 16267.7 99.999 1.0250 -7.730 10.385 0.001 11432.9(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 34364.4 100.000 -8.661 9.009 0.030 11432.9
CREW & EFFECT 3.2 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 5.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 22.2 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 1.4 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 14.4 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 2.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 1.9 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 2.2 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 3.1 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 5.4 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 10.8 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 5.8 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 2.9 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 10.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 11.5 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 15.4 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 10.7 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 13.8 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 9.7 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 7.9 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 12.6 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 26.2 80.900 8.290 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 36.8 -3.610 20.850 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 2.9 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 237.6 51.598 12.387 0.000 85.0

80
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 2 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 367.8 95.000 0.9500 23.979 0.797 -3.793 1090.6(M)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 373.5 95.000 0.9500 24.224 0.798 3.751 1122.0(M)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 430.3 95.000 0.9500 52.124 0.798 -0.005 3635.7(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 -11.708 23.8(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 11.708 23.8(M)
F.O.T. TOTAL 1589.9 95.000 46.154 4.454 0.003 5895.7
D.O.T.(S) 102.1 95.000 0.9000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7(M)
D.O.T. TOTAL 102.1 95.000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7
M.G.O.T.(P) 116.4 95.000 0.9000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7(M)
G.O.T. TOTAL 116.4 95.000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7
F.W.T.(P) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 -9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T.(S) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T. TOTAL 382.2 100.000 92.760 16.465 0.000 176.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

81
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 3 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 34364.4 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0


F.O. Tks 1589.9 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
D.O. Tks 102.1 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
G.O. Tks 116.4 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
F.W. Tks 382.2 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 237.6

OTHERS TOTAL : 36792.6 CARGO TOTAL : 0.0

DEAD WEIGHT 36792.6 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 47218.6 Mt
LCG -1.503 m KMT 14.487 m
TCG 0.019 m KG 9.408 m
LCB -1.443 m GM 5.078 m
MTC 804.329 Mt-m GGo 0.373 m
TPC 58.532 Mt/Cm GoM 4.705 m
LCF 0.999 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 444239.626 Mt-m


FS. Moment 17630.950 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 8.955 m
FORE 7.713 m
MEAN 8.952 m
AFT 10.191 m

Trim 2.478 m
Heeling Angle 0.229 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 112.175 %

82
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 4 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 58.663 deg


Initial GoM 4.705 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 43.000 deg 25.000 deg YES
Maximum GoZ 3.656 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 2.903 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 0.695 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 1.280 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.585 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


6.12

5.50

4.89 GoM = 4.705 m

4.28

Max GoZ = 3.656 m


3.67

3.06

2.45

1.83

1.22

0.61

0 10 20 30 40 50 Af 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

83
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 5 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.050 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.075 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.859 deg < 16.000deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 20.556 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 50.000 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 1.168 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 0.322 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 1.849 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 5.737 >= 1
Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


4.39

3.29

2.19

1.10

-60.0 -50.0 -40.0 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
lw2 lw1 A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-1.10

a2
-2.19

-3.29
a0

-4.39

a1
-5.48

84
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 6 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 2.478 3.036 18.953


GoM 4.705 3.536 14.299
Draft 8.955 4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
8.955 2.733
10.024 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 4.705(m) 2.733(m) YES


Available Trim Range 2.925(m) > trim > -0.975(m)

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14
Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10 GoM= 4.705 m
Draft= 8.955 m
9

6
Light service draft: 5.506 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

85
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 7 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

SF/BM & GRAPH


* : CORRECTED SF
SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO NORM. CORR. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN-m)
(kN) (kN) SEA (+) (-) (kN-m) SEA HOG SAG

21.0 17472 17472 77 22700 -22100 198757 84 237000 -82000


30.0 22216 22216 ***** ***** ***** 348087 79 441000 -205000
32.0 22292 22292 65 34100 -33400 384289 77 496600 -245800
34.0 21185 21185 62 34300 -33500 418490 76 550000 -285000
46.5 10785 10785 31 34300 -33500 577612 66 876500 -577000
60.0 -4644 -4644 13 35900 -34700 611425 52 1175000 -804000
64.5 -10146 -10146 22 48100 -46800 584488 47 1256500 -842500
72.0 -18964 -18964 29 66900 -65500 ***** ***** ***** *****
72.8 -19491 -19491 ***** ***** ***** 483791 35 1380300 -884000
73.0 -19666 -19666 31 65500 -64100 479837 35 1383700 -896500
77.1 -25093 -24027 50 48800 -47700 ***** ***** ***** *****
83.5 -33108 -30394 64 48800 -47700 256684 16 1570000 -1594000
97.0 -49693 -43491 96 45200 -45100 -192632 12 1570000 -1594000
108.4 -63389 -54247 97 56000 -56000 ***** ***** ***** *****
* 112.0 -65500 -55579 94 59400 -59400 -893920 56 1570000 -1594000
113.0 -61346 -51887 92 56500 -56500 ***** ***** ***** *****
123.0 -31022 -26178 46 56500 -56500 ***** ***** ***** *****
130.0 -9886 -8273 27 31000 -31000 -1417010 89 1570000 -1594000
131.5 -5304 -4383 10 42900 -42900 ***** ***** ***** *****
148.0 44240 37544 88 42900 -42900 ***** ***** ***** *****
150.0 49918 42357 89 47700 -47900 ***** ***** ***** *****
* 151.0 53399 45319 95 47700 -47900 -1028811 65 1570000 -1594000
154.5 51333 42159 94 44700 -44300 ***** ***** ***** *****
169.0 36003 30576 70 43900 -44300 -390077 24 1570000 -1594000
179.5 25455 22742 52 43900 -44300 -136297 17 1229000 -779000
190.0 16594 16594 26 64100 -65500 36737 4 873300 -609400
199.3 7857 7857 18 42700 -44000 129846 23 560000 -460000
214.5 -4232 -4232 21 19200 -20300 150961 50 301000 -263500
229.0 -11610 -11610 67 16900 -17400 52680 71 74300 -59900
MAX -66414 -56418 97 58461 -58461 -1426872 90 1570000 -1594000
(Num.) ( FR: 111.11 ) ( FR : 133.00 )
MAX 51333 -54876 97 56627 -56627 -1426872 90 1570000 -1594000
(Per.) ( FR : 109.04 ) ( FR : 133.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612

29874 1017306

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 -1017306

-59749 -2034612
Max Corr SF FR = 111.11
Value = -56418
Sag(-)
-89623 Max BM FR = 133.00 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F Value = -1426872
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M
S.F CORRECTION

86
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 8 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (I)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5


Disp(Mt) 47218.6 55133.3 54857.1 36057.6 55151.3 56103.8
TAft(m) 10.19 7.99 9.60 8.78 12.49 14.49
TFwd(m) 7.71 12.63 10.95 5.26 8.03 6.34
Trim(m) 2.48 -4.64 -1.35 3.52 4.46 8.15

SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 17472 22174 18512 21135 8307 227
30.0 22216 30021 23721 28993 8334 -2314
32.0 22292 30751 23857 29825 7147 -6121
34.0 21185 31135 23185 30343 4735 -6894
46.5 10785 23062 12270 23982 -13003 -822
60.0 -4644 10617 -4039 14217 -36123 5905
64.5 -10146 5471 -10006 10675 -44111 7958
72.0 -18964 -3548 -19776 5147 -56943 11582
72.8 -19491 -4122 -20421 4985 -57214 11107
73.0 -19666 -4313 -20633 4923 -57042 10768
77.1 -25093 -9989 -26706 1365 -55990 2674
83.5 -33108 -18317 -35856 -3724 -54009 -9262
97.0 -49693 ** -36307 -55116 ** -13680 -49228 -33094
108.4 -63389 ** -51968 -71349 ** -21340 -44329 -51750
112.0 -65500 ** -53441 -74380 ** -22150 -37876 -55277
113.0 -61346 ** -50696 -71517 ** -21376 -28195 -52528
123.0 -31022 -24608 -46702 -14305 -2407 -25647
130.0 -9886 -5955 -28897 -9153 15679 -6564
131.5 -5304 -2027 -25128 -8038 19548 -2456
148.0 44240 ** 40621 15015 4247 61711 42915
150.0 49918 ** 44523 19576 5855 66667 48303
151.0 53399 ** 45889 28878 7104 68682 ** 50584
154.5 51333 ** 40005 35704 5212 63949 ** 46168
169.0 36003 15510 41694 -1615 45496 29538
179.5 25455 -3472 44896 -5664 33161 19038
190.0 16594 -21069 47906 -7901 22744 10875
199.3 7857 -17072 32633 -11215 12308 2746
214.5 -4232 -10030 9831 -15024 -2027 -8065
229.0 -11610 -4599 -7068 -15009 -11004 -12904
Max(Num.) -66414 -54430 -75235 30343 68902 -56106
Allow(%) 112 79 107 54 101 80
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 111.8 111.1 111.8 34.0 150.6 111.8
Max(Per.) 51333 -51968 -71349 21135 63949 -53576
Allow(%) 115 81 112 72 104 81
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 154.5 108.4 108.4 21.0 154.5 109.5

87
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 9 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (II)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

CORRECTED SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 17472 22174 18512 21135 8307 227
30.0 22216 30021 23721 28993 8334 -2314
32.0 22292 30751 23857 29825 7147 -6121
34.0 21185 31135 23185 30343 5154 -6949
46.5 10785 23062 12270 23982 -9961 -1220
60.0 -4644 10617 -4039 14217 -30250 5136
64.5 -10146 5471 -10006 10675 -37293 7066
72.0 -18964 -3548 -19776 5147 -48566 10486
72.8 -19491 -4122 -20421 4985 -48666 9989
73.0 -19666 -4313 -20633 4923 -54384* 9642*
77.1 -24027 -8874 -25548 2189 -52701 -7135
83.5 -30394 -15480 -32908 -1627 -49744 -15004
97.0 -43491 -29822 -48378 -8888 -42896 -30223
108.4 -54247 -42410 -61417 -14277 -36255 -41622
112.0 -55579* -45322* -66053* -21780* -35219* -46647*
113.0 -51887 -42994 -63450 -21025 -25827 -44336
123.0 -26178 -21069 -41236 -14144 -2932 -21837
130.0 -8273 -5331 -25253 -9124 13128 -5820
131.5 -4383 -2027 -21874 -8038 16562 -2370
148.0 37544 33751 13977 3934 53951 35772
150.0 42357 36872 18050 5507 58364 40338
151.0 45319* 37771* 27059* 6735* 60054* 42127*
154.5 42159 30664 27961 156 55615 38312
169.0 30576 14635 36371 -4606 40566 24891
179.5 22742 1782 41325 -7160 30696 16714
190.0 16594 -19332* 46087* -7901 22744 10875
199.3 7857 -15747 26773 -11215 12308 2746
214.5 -4232 -9384 6975 -15024 -2027 -8065
229.0 -11610 -4599 -7068 -15009 -11004 -12904
Max(Num.) -56418 -45322 -66053 30343 60404 -46647
Allow(%) 97 64 94 54 89 66
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 111.1 112.0 112.0 34.0 150.6 112.0
Max(Per.) -54876 22174 -61417 21135 55615 -46647
Allow(%) 97 75 96 72 91 66
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 109.0 21.0 108.4 21.0 154.5 112.0

88
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 10 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (III)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

BENDING MOMENT (kN-m)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 198757 224554 207450 229864 117005 51758
30.0 348087 421411 369230 424432 179702 38843
32.0 384289 471292 408600 473987 191779 31136
34.0 418490 519609 445918 522180 201188 23166
46.5 577612 794290 624659 796764 168507 -12573
60.0 611425 981516 666525 1004758 -81626 23247
64.5 584488 1009802 639548 1049570 -218580 48763
72.0 496333 1015194 547186 1095593 -504708 111614
72.8 483791 1012939 533826 1098876 -539915 119111
73.0 479837 1012173 529603 1099872 -550764 121310
77.1 405666 990307 449907 1110223 -726611 143445
83.5 256684 921344 287887 1104086 -990061 126438
97.0 -192632 630530 -208731 1009082 -1493263 -104101
108.4 -706609 237851 -788163 849591 -1854543 -490770
112.0 -893920 83189 -1003196 785069 -1959758 -648322
113.0 -943925 41147 -1061930 767667 -1986147 -691435
123.0 -1308357 -257780 -1527926 624482 -2129783 -1004670
130.0 -1417010 -338027 -1724277 558763 -2113838 -1094925
131.5 -1424685 -341724 -1752653 548448 -2096464 -1100337
148.0 -1149163 -79107 -1751694 524014 -1581731 -833065
150.0 -1076560 -15239 -1716209 531549 -1485968 -764695
151.0 -1028811 26490 -1691313 537487 -1425275 -719755
154.5 -883339 143989 -1608842 554812 -1241306 -584234
169.0 -390077 454342 -1219414 574123 -615713 -147690
179.5 -136297 500670 -879623 543042 -284220 55443
190.0 36737 395361 -506860 481386 -52453 176037
199.3 129846 266240 -217848 410177 78204 225745
214.5 150961 109298 27970 247667 136085 189360
229.0 52680 24038 34782 67086 50341 59279
Max(Num.) -1426872 1019183 -1823556 1111115 -2136414 -1101206
Allow(%) 90 69 75 54 88 45
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 133.0 69.0 139.5 79.0 125.5 132.5
Max(Per.) -1426872 224554 207450 229864 -2136414 59279
Allow(%) 90 94 87 97 88 75
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 133.0 21.0 21.0 21.0 125.5 229.0

(Remark : The Mark(* **) is not permission & corrected sf)


(Remark : The Mark(**) is not permission)
(Remark : The Mark(*) is corrected sf)
(Remark : The Mark(--) is over the allowable range)

89
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:07 PM Page : 11 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.19 HEAVY BALLAST FULL BUNKER DEP. By :

CARGO MASS SUMMARY


Judgement : YES

HYDROSTATIC DATA
DEAD WEIGHT 36792.6 Mt FORE DRAFT 7.713 m
LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt MEAN DRAFT 8.952 m
DISPLACEMENT 47218.6 Mt AFT DRAFT 10.191 m
CARGO WEIGHT 0.0 Mt TRIM 2.478 m

ONE HOLD(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 8.08 0.00 1327.566 16080.38 N/A
No. 2 HOLD 8.47 0.00 1660.181 15598.77 N/A
No. 3 HOLD 8.86 0.00 1660.574 18576.03 N/A
No. 4 HOLD 9.26 0.00 868.204 15853.00 N/A
No. 5 HOLD 9.64 0.00 704.906 18544.08 N/A

ONE HOLD(HARBOUR)
Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 8.08 0.00 1327.566 18929.06 N/A
No. 2 HOLD 8.47 0.00 1660.181 15852.00 N/A
No. 3 HOLD 8.86 0.00 1660.574 21104.00 N/A
No. 4 HOLD 9.26 0.00 868.204 15853.00 N/A
No. 5 HOLD 9.64 0.00 704.906 20269.00 N/A

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 8.27 0.00 2987.747 29482.72 N/A
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 8.66 0.00 3320.755 31552.71 N/A
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 9.06 0.00 2528.779 31700.00 N/A
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 9.45 0.00 1573.111 31091.00 N/A

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(HARBOUR)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 8.27 0.00 2987.747 30301.00 N/A
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 8.66 0.00 3320.755 31700.00 N/A
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 9.06 0.00 2528.779 31700.00 N/A
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 9.45 0.00 1573.111 31091.00 N/A

90
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 1 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 11508.9 100.000 0.8345 -69.409 10.552 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 12960.1 100.000 0.8345 -38.932 10.372 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 6097.0 47.053 0.8345 -7.630 5.922 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 12958.8 100.000 0.8345 23.477 10.377 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 12332.9 100.000 0.8345 54.448 10.760 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 55857.7 89.061 -6.699 10.010 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -87.859 0.000 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 -5.375 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 5.375 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 -7.168 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 7.168 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 -7.194 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 7.194 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 -10.870 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 10.870 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.167 0.000 -6.966 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.327 0.000 6.917 0.0(A)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 -10.478 100.5(M)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 10.478 100.5(M)
A.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 89.479 6.424 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 6.835 0.841 -9.375 0.0(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 200.9
CREW & EFFECT 3.2 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 5.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 22.2 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 1.4 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 14.4 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 2.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 1.9 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 2.2 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 3.1 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 5.4 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 10.8 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 5.8 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 2.9 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 10.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 11.5 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 15.4 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 10.7 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 13.8 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 9.7 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 7.9 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 12.6 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 26.2 80.900 8.290 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 36.8 -3.610 20.850 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 2.9 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 237.6 51.598 12.387 0.000 85.0

91
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 2 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 367.8 95.000 0.9500 23.979 0.797 -3.793 1090.6(M)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 373.5 95.000 0.9500 24.224 0.798 3.751 1122.0(M)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 430.3 95.000 0.9500 52.124 0.798 -0.005 3635.7(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 -11.708 23.8(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 209.2 95.000 0.9500 79.088 14.695 11.708 23.8(M)
F.O.T. TOTAL 1589.9 95.000 46.154 4.454 0.003 5895.7
D.O.T.(S) 102.1 95.000 0.9000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7(M)
D.O.T. TOTAL 102.1 95.000 72.722 13.298 12.156 20.7
M.G.O.T.(P) 116.4 95.000 0.9000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7(M)
G.O.T. TOTAL 116.4 95.000 72.805 13.507 -12.063 20.7
F.W.T.(P) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 -9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T.(S) 191.1 100.000 1.0000 92.760 16.465 9.387 88.0(M)
F.W.T. TOTAL 382.2 100.000 92.760 16.465 0.000 176.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

92
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 3 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 0.0 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 11508.9 13792.2


F.O. Tks 1589.9 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 12960.1 15531.4
D.O. Tks 102.1 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 6097.0 7306.6
G.O. Tks 116.4 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 12958.8 15529.7
F.W. Tks 382.2 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 12332.9 14779.7
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 237.6

OTHERS TOTAL : 2428.2 CARGO TOTAL : 55857.7

DEAD WEIGHT 58285.9 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 68711.9 Mt
LCG -2.147 m KMT 13.567 m
TCG -0.002 m KG 10.097 m
LCB -2.130 m GM 3.470 m
MTC 871.942 Mt-m GGo 0.093 m
TPC 60.254 Mt/Cm GoM 3.377 m
LCF 3.504 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 693812.113 Mt-m


FS. Moment 6399.000 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 12.596 m
FORE 12.124 m
MEAN 12.580 m
AFT 13.036 m

Trim 0.912 m
Heeling Angle -0.037 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 158.059 %

93
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 4 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 43.682 deg


Initial GoM 3.377 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 43.682 deg 25.000 deg YES
Maximum GoZ 2.141 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 1.837 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 0.490 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 0.839 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.349 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


4.39

3.95

3.51 GoM = 3.377 m

3.07

2.63

Max GoZ = 2.141 m


2.19

1.76

1.32

0.88

0.44

0 10 20 30 40 Af 50 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

94
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 5 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.029 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.043 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.503 deg < 15.878deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 20.770 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 43.682 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 0.740 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 0.239 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 0.943 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 3.944 >= 1
Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


2.57

1.93

1.28

0.64

-60.0 -50.0 -40.0 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
lw2 lw1 A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-0.64

a2
-1.28

-1.93
a0

-2.57

a1
-3.21

95
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 6 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

GRAIN STABILITY
< GRAIN HEELING MOMENT > ACTUAL HEELING MOMENT (Mt-m)

Displacement 68711.9 Mt NO.1 CARGO 4045.3


Corrected KG 10.191 m NO.2 CARGO 3054.6
Flooding Angle(Af) 43.682 deg. NO.3 CARGO 33590.2
Deck Immerse Angle 19.847 deg. NO.4 CARGO 3036.9
L0 = Total Actual Heeling Moment/Displacement 0.691 m NO.5 CARGO 3723.2
L40 = L0 * 0.8 0.552 m

<INTERNATIONAL GRAIN CODE CRITERIA> Available Required Check

Total Actual Heeling Moment 47450.202 Mt-m <= 53316.897 Mt-m YES
Initial GoM 3.377 m >= 0.300 m YES
Residual Dynamic Stability Area 0.483 m-rad. >= 0.075 m-rad. YES
Heeling Angle Due To Grain Shift(Ag) 10.807 deg. <= 12.000 deg. YES

Judgement : YES
Righting Lever (GoZ) In METER
2.57

2.31

2.06

1.80

1.54

1.28

1.03

0.77 L0 = 0.691m

L40 = 0.552m
0.51

0.26

0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Ag Af
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

96
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 7 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 0.912 3.036 18.953


GoM 3.377 3.536 14.299
Draft 12.596 4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
10.024 2.000
12.596 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 3.377(m) 2.000(m) YES


Available Trim Range 2.925(m) > trim > -0.975(m)

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14
GoM= 3.377 m
Draft=12.596 m Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10

6 Light service draft: 5.506 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

97
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 8 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

SF/BM & GRAPH


SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN-m)
(kN) SEA (+) (-) (kN-m) SEA HOG SAG

21.0 -4866 22 22700 -22100 -14368 18 237000 -82000


30.0 -10776 ***** ***** ***** -75021 37 441000 -205000
32.0 -13104 39 34100 -33400 -96024 39 496600 -245800
34.0 -14284 43 34300 -33500 -117299 41 550000 -285000
46.5 -7937 24 34300 -33500 -230222 40 876500 -577000
60.0 -738 2 35900 -34700 -275815 34 1175000 -804000
64.5 1855 4 48100 -46800 -275305 33 1256500 -842500
72.0 5950 9 66900 -65500 -252185 ***** ***** *****
72.8 5521 ***** ***** ***** -248253 28 1380300 -884000
73.0 5565 8 65500 -64100 -247026 28 1383700 -896500
77.1 7921 16 48800 -47700 -223170 ***** ***** *****
83.5 11738 24 48800 -47700 -172180 11 1570000 -1594000
97.0 19335 43 45200 -45100 -6933 0 1570000 -1594000
108.4 26166 47 56000 -56000 195106 ***** ***** *****
112.0 26231 44 59400 -59400 271725 17 1570000 -1594000
113.0 25068 44 56500 -56500 292550 ***** ***** *****
123.0 12459 22 56500 -56500 445529 ***** ***** *****
130.0 3502 11 31000 -31000 492378 31 1570000 -1594000
131.5 1558 4 42900 -42900 495858 ***** ***** *****
148.0 -19645 46 42900 -42900 377133 ***** ***** *****
150.0 -22356 47 47700 -47900 344906 ***** ***** *****
151.0 -23816 50 47700 -47900 323836 21 1570000 -1594000
154.5 -22347 50 44700 -44300 259674 ***** ***** *****
169.0 -14891 34 43900 -44300 49043 3 1570000 -1594000
179.5 -9912 22 43900 -44300 -53127 7 1229000 -779000
190.0 -6477 10 64100 -65500 -119692 20 873300 -609400
199.3 -2025 5 42700 -44000 -149693 33 560000 -460000
214.5 4818 25 19200 -20300 -133370 51 301000 -263500
229.0 11044 65 16900 -17400 -41110 69 74300 -59900
MAX 27136 46 58978 -58978 497001 32 1570000 -1594000
(Num.) ( FR : 111.60 ) ( FR : 133.00 )
MAX 11044 65 16900 -17400 -41159 69 74378 -59970
(Per.) ( FR : 229.00 ) ( FR : 229.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612
Value = 497001
Max BM FR = 133.00
Value = 27136
29874 Max SF FR = 111.60 1017306

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 -1017306

-59749 -2034612

Sag(-)
-89623 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M

98
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 9 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (I)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5


Disp(Mt) 68711.9 71760.5 71999.5 74377.6 72011.7 71935.1
TAft(m) 13.04 12.31 12.81 13.62 13.94 14.44
TFwd(m) 12.12 13.95 13.50 13.45 12.28 11.72
Trim(m) 0.91 -1.64 -0.69 0.17 1.66 2.72

SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -4866 -1863 -4033 -7694 -8972 -11210
30.0 -10776 -6675 -9772 -15138 -16813 -19987
32.0 -13104 -8941 -12236 -17977 -19722 -23093
34.0 -14284 -10228 -13708 -19807 -21612 -24596
46.5 -7937 -2131 -6681 -15685 -16969 -12651
60.0 -738 5080 -455 -11720 -13305 2127
64.5 1855 7608 1784 -10049 -11618 7551
72.0 5950 12506 6249 -7643 -7685 17551
72.8 5521 12358 5308 -8149 -8823 16707
73.0 5565 12490 5194 -8129 -8882 16555
77.1 7921 14519 7179 -6555 -3608 17934
83.5 11738 17740 10366 -3972 4645 20307
97.0 19335 24070 16758 996 21698 25464
108.4 26166 29917 22068 3603 35998 30071
112.0 26231 29477 21836 4052 37804 29949
113.0 25068 28193 20538 4136 36496 28640
123.0 12459 14223 6485 4389 22482 14683
130.0 3502 4151 -3584 4071 12590 4897
131.5 1558 1951 -5777 3939 10450 2788
148.0 -19645 -22868 -30369 2931 -13178 -20929
150.0 -22356 -25869 -33327 2450 -15983 -23474
151.0 -23816 -27508 -34733 1720 -17499 -24831
154.5 -22347 -26651 -30605 2577 -16229 -23109
169.0 -14891 -22896 -13744 5366 -10305 -16385
179.5 -9912 -21332 -3134 6974 -6710 -12060
190.0 -6477 -20865 5474 7480 -4041 -8538
199.3 -2025 -10901 8026 8392 319 -3323
214.5 4818 2589 10095 10363 5366 3265
229.0 11044 13386 12851 12842 11303 10571
Max(Num.) 27136 30446 -35035 -19807 38796 30875
Allow(%) 46 44 52 36 56 44
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 111.6 111.6 150.8 34.0 111.6 111.6
Max(Per.) 11044 13386 12851 12842 35998 28644
Allow(%) 65 60 57 57 57 48
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 229.0 229.0 229.0 108.4 104.5

99
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 10 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (II)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

BENDING MOMENT (kN-m)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -14368 11912 -7758 -40183 -52530 -72889
30.0 -75021 -23677 -63174 -129519 -153040 -193782
32.0 -96024 -38086 -82921 -158541 -184919 -231126
34.0 -117299 -52728 -102984 -188077 -217296 -268201
46.5 -230222 -110034 -200567 -363984 -406168 -449851
60.0 -275815 -85435 -230589 -501925 -559253 -505109
64.5 -275305 -60260 -226008 -538741 -600833 -488028
72.0 -252185 -425 -199281 -590230 -659130 -410839
72.8 -248253 6196 -196384 -595700 -665768 -400291
73.0 -247026 8254 -195485 -597407 -667759 -397033
77.1 -223170 45635 -177512 -623244 -691652 -341413
83.5 -172180 116806 -137641 -654772 -695828 -247015
97.0 -6933 342228 6252 -676085 -561712 820
108.4 195106 596639 186957 -648266 -290963 261241
112.0 271725 686425 252806 -633546 -180005 351735
113.0 292550 709731 269480 -630293 -150055 375180
123.0 445529 881772 374756 -597130 87931 548255
130.0 492378 934969 381016 -567779 187751 603123
131.5 495858 938974 374974 -561293 201907 607735
148.0 377133 803870 130589 -510987 185677 489673
150.0 344906 766963 81500 -508793 163436 456331
151.0 323836 742528 50064 -507881 148202 434493
154.5 259674 666420 -42682 -504661 101462 367489
169.0 49043 380670 -295908 -465034 -48325 139097
179.5 -53127 195610 -361631 -415833 -117042 19964
190.0 -119692 19401 -344143 -356920 -158232 -64994
199.3 -149693 -93250 -290818 -296925 -172591 -112296
214.5 -133370 -145828 -179440 -182882 -141805 -121186
229.0 -41110 -51097 -48784 -48685 -42140 -38969
Max(Num.) 497001 940331 385262 -678832 -698958 609941
Allow(%) 32 39 16 28 30 25
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 133.0 133.0 127.5 92.0 81.0 133.5
Max(Per.) -41159 -62105 -64733 -70200 -60921 -52187
Allow(%) 69 54 51 52 45 41
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 228.0 227.5 227.0 227.0 227.5

(Remark : The Mark(* **) is not permission & corrected sf)


(Remark : The Mark(**) is not permission)

(Remark : The Mark(--) is over the allowable range)

100
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 11 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.1 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING FULL BUNKER DEP.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](UNTRIMMED)

CARGO MASS SUMMARY


Judgement : YES

HYDROSTATIC DATA
DEAD WEIGHT 58285.9 Mt FORE DRAFT 12.124 m
LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt MEAN DRAFT 12.580 m
DISPLACEMENT 68711.9 Mt AFT DRAFT 13.036 m
CARGO WEIGHT 55857.7 Mt TRIM 0.912 m

ONE HOLD(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 12.26 1190.46 11508.868 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 12.40 0.00 12960.135 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 12.54 1562.52 6097.021 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 12.69 0.00 12958.758 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 12.83 1753.87 12332.929 20269.00 YES

ONE HOLD(HARBOUR)
Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 12.26 0.00 11508.868 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 12.40 0.00 12960.135 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 12.54 0.00 6097.021 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 12.69 0.00 12958.758 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 12.83 0.00 12332.929 20269.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 12.33 4427.23 24469.003 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 12.47 4884.68 19057.156 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 12.62 5150.20 19055.779 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 12.76 5307.17 25291.687 31091.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(HARBOUR)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 12.33 0.00 24469.003 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 12.47 128.91 19057.156 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 12.62 394.62 19055.779 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 12.76 643.36 25291.687 31091.00 YES

101
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 1 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 12057.2 100.000 0.8345 -69.409 10.552 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 13227.8 100.000 0.8345 -38.932 10.372 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 6097.0 46.106 0.8345 -7.630 5.922 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 13228.3 100.000 0.8345 23.477 10.377 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 12715.7 100.000 0.8345 54.448 10.760 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 57326.0 88.942 -6.899 10.024 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -87.859 0.000 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 -5.375 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 5.375 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 -7.168 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 7.168 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 -7.194 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 7.194 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 -10.870 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 10.870 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 14.0 1.034 1.0250 54.155 0.042 -7.105 2649.6(M)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 14.0 1.034 1.0250 54.308 0.042 7.057 2711.1(M)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 317.6 100.000 1.0250 77.772 11.667 -13.226 100.5(M)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 384.8 100.000 1.0250 77.273 12.479 13.531 100.5(M)
A.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 89.479 6.424 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 6.835 0.841 -9.375 0.0(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 730.5 2.126 76.607 11.649 1.377 5561.7
CREW & EFFECT 3.2 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 5.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 22.2 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 1.4 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 14.4 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 2.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 1.9 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 2.2 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 3.1 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 5.4 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 10.8 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 5.8 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 2.9 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 10.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 11.5 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 15.4 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 10.7 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 13.8 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 9.7 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 7.9 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 12.6 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 26.2 80.900 8.290 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 36.8 -3.610 20.850 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 2.9 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 237.6 51.598 12.387 0.000 85.0

102
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 2 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 38.7 10.000 0.9500 23.998 0.084 -3.795 1090.6(M)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 39.3 10.000 0.9500 24.224 0.084 3.751 1122.0(M)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 45.3 10.000 0.9500 52.135 0.084 0.000 3635.7(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 22.0 10.000 0.9500 77.494 11.097 -11.568 23.8(M)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 22.0 10.000 0.9500 77.494 11.097 11.568 23.8(M)
F.O.T. TOTAL 167.4 10.000 45.742 2.982 0.004 5895.7
D.O.T.(S) 10.7 10.000 0.9000 72.286 9.268 11.249 20.7(M)
D.O.T. TOTAL 10.7 10.000 72.286 9.268 11.249 20.7
M.G.O.T.(P) 12.3 10.000 0.9000 72.301 9.348 -11.288 20.7(M)
G.O.T. TOTAL 12.3 10.000 72.301 9.348 -11.288 20.7
F.W.T.(P) 19.1 10.000 1.0000 92.743 14.242 -9.405 88.0(M)
F.W.T.(S) 19.1 10.000 1.0000 92.743 14.242 9.405 88.0(M)
F.W.T. TOTAL 38.2 10.000 92.743 14.242 0.000 176.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

103
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 3 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 730.5 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 12057.2 14449.2


F.O. Tks 167.4 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 13227.8 15852.1
D.O. Tks 10.7 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 6097.0 7306.6
G.O. Tks 12.3 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 13228.3 15852.7
F.W. Tks 38.2 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 12715.7 15238.5
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 237.6

OTHERS TOTAL : 1196.6 CARGO TOTAL : 57326.0

DEAD WEIGHT 58522.6 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 68948.6 Mt
LCG -3.259 m KMT 13.540 m
TCG 0.014 m KG 10.192 m
LCB -3.259 m GM 3.348 m
MTC 867.524 Mt-m GGo 0.171 m
TPC 60.144 Mt/Cm GoM 3.177 m
LCF 3.344 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 702750.590 Mt-m


FS. Moment 11759.750 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 12.635 m
FORE 12.635 m
MEAN 12.635 m
AFT 12.635 m

Trim 0.000 m
Heeling Angle 0.251 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 151.592 %

104
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 4 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 45.056 deg


Initial GoM 3.177 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 44.000 deg 25.000 deg YES
Maximum GoZ 1.992 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 1.721 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 0.457 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 0.783 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.326 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


4.13

3.72

3.30 GoM = 3.177 m

2.89

2.48

Max GoZ = 1.992 m


2.07

1.65

1.24

0.83

0.41

0 10 20 30 40 Af 50 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

105
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 5 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.029 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.043 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.738 deg < 16.000deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 20.553 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 45.056 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 0.986 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 0.222 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 0.925 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 4.172 >= 1
Judgement : YES

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


2.39

1.79

1.20

0.60

-60.0 -50.0 -40.0 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
lw2 lw1 A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-0.60

a2
-1.20

-1.79
a0

-2.39

a1
-2.99

106
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 6 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

GRAIN STABILITY
< GRAIN HEELING MOMENT > ACTUAL HEELING MOMENT (Mt-m)

Displacement 68948.6 Mt NO.1 CARGO 2135.4


Corrected KG 10.363 m NO.2 CARGO 1931.1
Flooding Angle(Af) 45.056 deg. NO.3 CARGO 33590.2
Deck Immerse Angle 20.303 deg. NO.4 CARGO 1913.1
L0 = Total Actual Heeling Moment/Displacement 0.606 m NO.5 CARGO 2191.8
L40 = L0 * 0.8 0.485 m

<INTERNATIONAL GRAIN CODE CRITERIA> Available Required Check

Total Actual Heeling Moment 41761.589 Mt-m <= 50457.574 Mt-m YES
Initial GoM 3.177 m >= 0.300 m YES
Residual Dynamic Stability Area 0.469 m-rad. >= 0.075 m-rad. YES
Heeling Angle Due To Grain Shift(Ag) 10.337 deg. <= 12.000 deg. YES

Judgement : YES
Righting Lever (GoZ) In METER
2.39

2.15

1.91

1.67

1.43

1.20

0.96

0.72
L0 = 0.606m

L40 = 0.485m
0.48

0.24

0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Ag Af
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

107
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 7 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 0.000 3.036 18.953


GoM 3.177 3.536 14.299
Draft 12.635 4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
10.024 2.000
12.635 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 3.177(m) 2.000(m) YES


Available Trim Range 2.925(m) > trim > -0.975(m)

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14
GoM= 3.177 m
Draft=12.635 m Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10

6 Light service draft: 5.506 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

108
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 8 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

SF/BM & GRAPH


SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW SEA (kN-m)
(kN) SEA (+) (-) (kN-m) SEA HOG SAG

21.0 -5784 26 22700 -22100 -40041 49 237000 -82000


30.0 -10882 ***** ***** ***** -104496 51 441000 -205000
32.0 -12985 39 34100 -33400 -125802 51 496600 -245800
34.0 -13578 41 34300 -33500 -146714 51 550000 -285000
46.5 -6043 18 34300 -33500 -247668 43 876500 -577000
60.0 2184 6 35900 -34700 -266027 33 1175000 -804000
64.5 4935 10 48100 -46800 -255310 30 1256500 -842500
72.0 8387 13 66900 -65500 -215528 ***** ***** *****
72.8 7915 ***** ***** ***** -210027 24 1380300 -884000
73.0 7949 12 65500 -64100 -208320 23 1383700 -896500
77.1 9998 20 48800 -47700 -176969 ***** ***** *****
83.5 13032 27 48800 -47700 -115957 7 1570000 -1594000
97.0 20128 45 45200 -45100 63299 4 1570000 -1594000
108.4 25981 46 56000 -56000 268215 ***** ***** *****
112.0 25674 43 59400 -59400 343798 22 1570000 -1594000
113.0 24504 43 56500 -56500 364174 ***** ***** *****
123.0 11776 21 56500 -56500 512230 ***** ***** *****
130.0 2679 9 31000 -31000 554883 35 1570000 -1594000
131.5 698 2 42900 -42900 557354 ***** ***** *****
148.0 -21051 49 42900 -42900 423970 ***** ***** *****
150.0 -23840 50 47700 -47900 389576 ***** ***** *****
151.0 -25333 53 47700 -47900 367151 23 1570000 -1594000
154.5 -23778 54 44700 -44300 297340 ***** ***** *****
169.0 -16112 36 43900 -44300 65237 4 1570000 -1594000
179.5 -10952 25 43900 -44300 -45714 6 1229000 -779000
190.0 -7553 12 64100 -65500 -121541 20 873300 -609400
199.3 -2674 6 42700 -44000 -157527 34 560000 -460000
214.5 5112 27 19200 -20300 -142172 54 301000 -263500
229.0 11666 69 16900 -17400 -43780 73 74300 -59900
MAX 26652 45 58978 -58978 557678 36 1570000 -1594000
(Num.) ( FR : 111.60 ) ( FR : 132.50 )
MAX 11666 69 16900 -17400 -43832 73 74378 -59970
(Per.) ( FR : 229.00 ) ( FR : 229.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612
Value = 557678
Max BM FR = 132.50
Value = 26652
29874 Max SF FR = 111.60 1017306

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 -1017306

-59749 -2034612

Sag(-)
-89623 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M

109
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 9 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (I)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5


Disp(Mt) 68948.6 72111.3 72311.6 74711.4 72232.6 72105.4
TAft(m) 12.63 11.89 12.41 13.24 13.55 14.03
TFwd(m) 12.63 14.52 14.04 13.97 12.78 12.22
Trim(m) 0.00 -2.64 -1.63 -0.73 0.76 1.80

SHEAR FORCE (kN)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -5784 -3119 -5214 -8919 -10131 -12250
30.0 -10882 -6745 -9841 -15284 -16855 -19855
32.0 -12985 -8768 -12077 -17904 -19537 -22722
34.0 -13578 -9455 -12964 -19155 -20840 -24433
46.5 -6043 -467 -5316 -14832 -15474 -10606
60.0 2184 8763 3148 -8292 -9650 6286
64.5 4935 11463 5451 -6570 -7893 11629
72.0 8387 15150 8682 -6282 -5181 19762
72.8 7915 14960 7698 -6936 -7194 18874
73.0 7949 15080 7572 -6959 -7522 18711
77.1 9998 16550 8989 -6264 -2712 18775
83.5 13032 18907 11300 -4154 4966 21073
97.0 20128 25596 17898 1462 22455 26094
108.4 25981 31406 22926 3838 37066 30462
112.0 25674 30201 22026 3104 37155 29265
113.0 24504 28802 20639 3090 35841 27952
123.0 11776 13623 5648 3042 21713 13900
130.0 2679 3375 -4588 3224 11684 3991
131.5 698 1130 -6824 3085 9509 1849
148.0 -21051 -23418 -31383 2645 -13865 -22375
150.0 -23840 -26883 -34687 1338 -17532 -24994
151.0 -25333 -29115 -36513 587 -19079 -26382
154.5 -23778 -28198 -32245 1515 -17719 -24566
169.0 -16112 -24357 -14960 4451 -11567 -17600
179.5 -10952 -22236 -3741 6791 -7295 -13248
190.0 -7553 -22412 4917 7126 -5145 -9816
199.3 -2674 -12911 7833 7921 -903 -4961
214.5 5112 3268 11382 11520 6376 4097
229.0 11666 14140 13521 13505 11942 11227
Max(Num.) 26652 31463 -36748 -19155 38386 30522
Allow(%) 45 50 54 35 55 48
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 111.6 108.0 150.8 34.0 111.6 108.0
Max(Per.) 11666 14140 13521 13505 36954 11227
Allow(%) 69 63 60 60 59 50
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 229.0 229.0 229.0 108.0 229.0

110
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 10 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

HOLD FLOODING(DAMAGE) CONDITION SUMMARY (II)


2.4, Sec.3, Ch. 4 of CSR for BC Judgement : YES

BENDING MOMENT (kN-m)


Fr.No Intact NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 NO. 4 NO. 5
21.0 -40041 -16560 -34382 -67089 -75458 -94728
30.0 -104496 -57160 -94517 -161600 -177692 -216238
32.0 -125802 -72060 -114765 -191259 -209403 -253114
34.0 -146714 -86495 -134656 -220763 -242543 -290664
46.5 -247668 -137848 -228075 -391566 -426369 -465951
60.0 -266027 -87439 -234990 -510199 -562859 -490675
64.5 -255310 -52331 -221514 -539480 -597852 -462628
72.0 -215528 23561 -180555 -579081 -645677 -368329
72.8 -210027 31536 -176511 -583665 -651572 -356360
73.0 -208320 34008 -175262 -585104 -653340 -352668
77.1 -176969 77793 -151957 -606964 -673980 -290371
83.5 -115957 157287 -105470 -634031 -668952 -191472
97.0 63299 398903 49309 -647980 -517840 63589
108.4 268215 664006 234534 -617723 -242145 326336
112.0 343798 755176 299801 -606622 -131644 415672
113.0 364174 778694 316146 -604524 -101986 438639
123.0 512230 952233 417536 -582447 132652 606609
130.0 554883 1005501 420154 -560636 229404 657268
131.5 557354 1009384 413201 -554549 242795 660879
148.0 423970 861406 154770 -509793 214696 528539
150.0 389576 822220 103526 -508457 190619 493105
151.0 367151 796352 70735 -508092 174229 469960
154.5 297340 715832 -26048 -506491 123993 398996
169.0 65237 412876 -299087 -472094 -38212 156366
179.5 -45714 215222 -377001 -426307 -114948 27973
190.0 -121541 25034 -363894 -371664 -164491 -66544
199.3 -157527 -97306 -311687 -313561 -183902 -119949
214.5 -142172 -158870 -198418 -198680 -152351 -129884
229.0 -43780 -54315 -51658 -51526 -44881 -41802
Max(Num.) 557678 1010562 426056 -655570 -678165 661915
Allow(%) 36 42 18 27 30 27
Max. Fr.No(Num.) 132.5 133.0 127.0 91.0 79.0 133.0
Max(Per.) -43832 -67736 -86450 -80573 -65085 -55884
Allow(%) 73 57 55 55 48 44
Max. Fr.No(Per.) 229.0 227.9 226.0 226.5 227.0 227.5

(Remark : The Mark(* **) is not permission & corrected sf)


(Remark : The Mark(**) is not permission)

(Remark : The Mark(--) is over the allowable range)

111
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 11 / 11
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: GRAIN LOAD.29 HEAVIEST GRAIN LOADING MIN.BUNKER ARR.[S.F=43, S. By :
G=0.83445](TRIMMED)

CARGO MASS SUMMARY


Judgement : YES

HYDROSTATIC DATA
DEAD WEIGHT 58522.6 Mt FORE DRAFT 12.635 m
LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt MEAN DRAFT 12.635 m
DISPLACEMENT 68948.6 Mt AFT DRAFT 12.635 m
CARGO WEIGHT 57326.0 Mt TRIM 0.000 m

ONE HOLD(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 12.63 1506.88 12057.152 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 12.63 0.00 13227.802 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 12.63 1645.13 6096.998 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 12.63 0.00 13228.277 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 12.63 1579.58 12743.718 20269.00 YES

ONE HOLD(HARBOUR)
Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 HOLD 12.63 0.00 12057.152 19048.00 YES
No. 2 HOLD 12.63 0.00 13227.802 15852.00 YES
No. 3 HOLD 12.63 0.00 6096.998 21104.00 YES
No. 4 HOLD 12.63 0.00 13228.277 15853.00 YES
No. 5 HOLD 12.63 0.00 12743.718 20269.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(SEA GOING)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 12.63 4964.95 25284.953 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 12.63 5183.15 19324.800 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 12.63 5183.07 19325.275 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 12.63 5080.44 25971.995 31091.00 YES

TWO ADJACENT HOLDS(HARBOUR)


Compartment Draft(m) Min. Wgt(Mt) Act. Wgt(Mt) Max. Wgt(Mt) Judgement
No. 1 & 2 HOLD 12.63 419.86 25284.953 30301.00 YES
No. 2 & 3 HOLD 12.63 427.60 19324.800 31700.00 YES
No. 3 & 4 HOLD 12.63 427.52 19325.275 31700.00 YES
No. 4 & 5 HOLD 12.63 416.73 25971.995 31091.00 YES

112
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 1 / 7
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION By :

LOADING PLAN (I)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -68.430 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -38.215 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.3 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 -7.015 1.701 0.000 0.0
NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 24.185 1.700 0.000 0.0
NO.5 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.000 1.0000 53.761 1.700 0.000 0.0
CARGO H. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
F.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -87.859 0.000 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 -5.375 0.0(A)
NO.1 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -67.670 0.000 5.375 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 -7.168 0.0(A)
NO.2 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -39.328 0.000 7.168 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 -7.194 0.0(A)
NO.3 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 -8.173 0.001 7.194 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 -10.870 0.0(A)
NO.4 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 22.755 0.000 10.870 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.167 0.000 -6.966 0.0(A)
NO.5 W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 54.327 0.000 6.917 0.0(A)
AFT W.B.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 -10.478 0.0(A)
AFT W.B.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 70.299 4.820 10.478 0.0(A)
A.P.T. 0.0 0.000 1.0250 89.479 6.424 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.3 C.H.(W.B.) 0.0 0.000 1.0250 6.835 0.841 -9.375 0.0(A)
B.W.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
CREW & EFFECT 0.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
PROVISIONS 0.0 82.660 23.060 0.000 0.0
BOSUN STORE 0.0 -88.980 20.060 0.000 0.0
DECK STORE 0.0 6.190 20.060 0.000 0.0
STEER.GEAR ROOM 0.0 94.800 15.000 0.000 0.0
ACCOMMODATION 0.0 80.150 27.460 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (AFT BILGE WE 0.0 87.230 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (FWD BILGE WE 0.0 70.560 0.800 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN MACH.) 0.0 77.510 5.740 0.000 0.0
OIL&WATER IN E/R (IN PIPE LINE 0.0 72.280 10.500 0.000 0.0
D.O.SERV.T. 0.0 73.380 15.170 0.000 4.0
NO.1 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 0.0 83.910 15.950 0.000 1.0
NO.2 CYL.OIL STOR.T. 0.0 85.160 15.910 0.000 1.0
L.O.STOR.T. 0.0 82.240 15.960 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SETT.T. 0.0 75.600 12.860 0.000 1.0
H.F.O.SERV.T. 0.0 77.270 13.110 0.000 0.0
BILGE TANK 0.0 85.810 0.840 0.000 22.0
SEP.BILGE OIL T. 0.0 76.870 0.930 0.000 19.0
L.O.SUMP.T. 0.0 78.070 0.980 0.000 9.0
F.O.OVERFLOW T. 0.0 72.710 0.920 0.000 25.0
S/T COOLING W.SPACE 0.0 89.940 2.850 0.000 2.0
OTHER TANKS 0.0 75.060 8.570 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(NO.1~4 GRAB) 0.0 -3.630 21.470 0.000 0.0
SPARE & TOOLS(MACH.PART) 0.0 86.130 16.510 0.000 0.0
UNKONWN 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
DWT CONSTANT TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

113
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 2 / 7
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION By :

LOADING PLAN (II)


COMPART NAME WGT VOL. DEN. LCG VCG TCG FSM
(Mt) (%) (S/G) (m) (m) (m) (Mt-m)

NO.1 F.O.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 0.9500 23.998 0.000 -3.795 0.0(A)


NO.1 F.O.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 0.9500 24.224 0.000 3.751 0.0(A)
NO.2 F.O.T.(C) 0.0 0.000 0.9500 52.135 0.000 0.000 0.0(A)
NO.3 F.O.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 0.9500 76.311 10.212 -11.263 0.0(A)
NO.3 F.O.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 0.9500 76.311 10.212 11.263 0.0(A)
F.O.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
D.O.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 0.9000 72.147 8.594 10.918 0.0(A)
D.O.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
M.G.O.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 0.9000 72.147 8.595 -10.918 0.0(A)
G.O.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
F.W.T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 92.728 13.995 -9.381 0.0(A)
F.W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 92.728 13.995 9.381 0.0(A)
F.W.T. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0
GREY W.T.(S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 75.658 0.001 2.808 0.0(A)
SLUDGE TANK (S) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 73.713 7.643 6.760 0.0(A)
COLLECTING T.(P) 0.0 0.000 1.0000 74.904 13.981 -14.974 0.0(A)
E.T.C. TOTAL 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.0

114
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 3 / 7
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION By :

LOADING CONDITION SUMMARY


COMPART WEIGHT(Mt) CARGO WEIGHT(Mt) VOLUME(CuM)

B.W. Tks 0.0 NO.1 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0


F.O. Tks 0.0 NO.2 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
D.O. Tks 0.0 NO.3 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
G.O. Tks 0.0 NO.4 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
F.W. Tks 0.0 NO.5 CARGO HOLD 0.0 0.0
ETC Tks 0.0
CONSTANT 0.0

OTHERS TOTAL : 0.0 CARGO TOTAL : 0.0

DEAD WEIGHT 0.0 Mt


LIGHT WEIGHT 10426.0 Mt
DISPLACEMENT 10426.0 Mt
LCG 8.600 m KMT 38.400 m
TCG 0.000 m KG 11.070 m
LCB 8.752 m GM 27.330 m
MTC 551.215 Mt-m GGo 0.000 m
TPC 50.915 Mt/Cm GoM 27.330 m
LCF -5.147 m

SEA S/G 1.0250 Mt/m3 Vert. Moment 115415.820 Mt-m


FS. Moment 0.000 Mt-m

DRAFT at Perpendiculars
EQUIVALENT 2.168 m
FORE 0.768 m
MEAN 2.263 m
AFT 3.759 m

Trim 2.991 m
Heeling Angle 0.000 deg.
Propeller immersion ratio 8.429 %

115
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 4 / 7
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION By :

GZ TABLE & GRAPH

<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.2> Available Required Check

Angle of Flooding (Af) 90.000 deg


Initial GoM 27.330 m 0.150 m YES
Angle at Maximum GoZ 20.500 deg 25.000 deg NO
Maximum GoZ 5.224 m
GoZ at 30 Degree 4.905 m 0.200 m YES
Area to 30 Degree 2.166 m-rad 0.055 m-rad YES
Area to 40 Degree or Af 2.957 m-rad 0.090 m-rad YES
Area 30-40 Degree or Af 0.792 m-rad 0.030 m-rad YES

Judgement : NO

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


35.53

31.98

28.42 GoM = 27.330 m

24.87

21.32

17.76

14.21

10.66

7.11
Max GoZ = 5.224 m

3.55

0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Angle of Ship's Inclination in degree

116
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 5 / 7
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION By :

WEATHER CRITERIA TABLE & GRAPH


<2008 IS CODE Pt.A ch.2.3> Available Required

Steady wind Heeling Lever (Lw1) 0.262 m


Gust Wind Heeling Lever (Lw2) 0.392 m
Angle of Heel Under Action of Steady Wind (a0) 0.555 deg < 16.000deg
Angle of Roll to Windward to Wave Action (a1) 47.784 deg
Angle of Down Flooding or 50 deg or ac (a2) 50.000 deg
Angle of First Intercept Point(lw2<->GZ) 0.830 deg
Dynamic Roll Area [A] 3.730 m-rad
Dynamic Stability Area [B] 3.248 m-rad
Area [B] / Area [A] 0.871 >= 1
Judgement : NO

Righting Lever (Go Z) In METER


6.27

4.70

3.13

1.57
B

-60.0 -50.0 lw2 -40.0 lw1 -30.0 -20.0 -10.0 0.00 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
A
Angle of Ship's Inclination in Degrees
-1.57

a2
-3.13

-4.70
a0

-6.27

a1
-7.84

117
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 6 / 7
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION By :

ALLOWABLE MIN. GoM CURVE


VESSEL'S INFORMATION DRAFT (m) Allowable GoM (m)

Trim 2.991 2.168 18.953


GoM 27.330 3.036 18.953
Draft 2.168 3.536 14.299
4.036 10.710
4.536 7.822
5.036 5.430
5.506 5.100
10.024 2.000
13.036 2.000

<SOLAS 2009 Ch.II-1, Pt.B-1> Available Required Check

Allowable Min.GoM 27.330(m) 18.953(m) YES


Available Trim Range no limit

Draft (m)
16
STABLE ZONE

15

14
Deepest subdivision draft: 13.036 m
13

12

11
Partial subdivision draft: 10.024 m
10

6
Light service draft: 5.506 m

GoM=27.330 m
3
Draft= 2.168 m

1
UNSTABLE ZONE
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
GoM (m)

118
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page
ShipManager-88 Version:4.0 Date : 2015-06-05 02:08 PM Page : 7 / 7
ShipName : ABY PAOLA From :
IMO No.: 9715830 To :
Voy. No.: LOAD.30 LIGHT SHIP CONDITION By :

SF/BM & GRAPH


SHEAR FORCE BENDING MOMENT
FR.NO ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW PORT (kN) ACT. ALLOW(%) ALLOW PORT (kN-m)
(kN) PORT (+) (-) (kN-m) PORT HOG SAG

21.0 9286 33 27800 -27700 74981 17 441800 -296900


30.0 15611 ***** ***** ***** 170167 23 755800 -535400
32.0 16681 39 42900 -42700 197036 24 836000 -602000
34.0 16553 38 43700 -43400 223252 24 912700 -665700
46.5 14853 31 47600 -47400 379203 27 1385600 -1111400
60.0 11483 23 50500 -50100 525898 29 1842300 -1504300
64.5 10125 16 62700 -62200 565882 29 1976500 -1598200
72.0 7959 10 81500 -80900 620731 ***** ***** *****
72.8 7759 ***** ***** ***** 626031 28 2197700 -1741900
73.0 7674 10 80100 -79500 627642 28 2203300 -1756700
77.1 6210 10 63200 -62800 651526 ***** ***** *****
83.5 4253 7 62400 -61800 679539 27 2512600 -2583200
97.0 521 1 57100 -57100 704797 26 2670700 -2749200
108.4 -2319 3 67800 -67800 696769 ***** ***** *****
112.0 -2748 4 71100 -71100 689194 26 2681700 -2760700
113.0 -2885 4 68200 -68200 686949 ***** ***** *****
123.0 -4805 7 68200 -68200 655603 ***** ***** *****
130.0 -5852 14 42900 -42800 625691 23 2694800 -2774500
131.5 -6056 11 55200 -55100 618545 ***** ***** *****
148.0 -8061 15 54800 -54700 525523 ***** ***** *****
150.0 -8052 13 60000 -60100 513395 ***** ***** *****
151.0 -7985 13 60000 -60100 506178 19 2623900 -2700100
154.5 -8304 14 57100 -57300 483465 ***** ***** *****
169.0 -9046 15 60200 -59900 381979 15 2563000 -2636200
179.5 -9136 15 60600 -60300 305368 15 2081300 -1673500
190.0 -8593 11 80800 -81400 229554 14 1584900 -1356300
199.3 -8169 14 59400 -59900 166961 15 1147700 -1076800
214.5 -6254 19 32500 -32900 78516 11 684300 -665800
229.0 -3562 15 23400 -23600 19920 8 263400 -258300
MAX 16681 39 42900 -42700 705228 26 2672167 -2750733
(Num.) ( FR : 32.00 ) ( FR : 99.00 )
MAX 16461 39 41840 -41647 585916 29 2043540 -1641752
(Per.) ( FR : 31.23 ) ( FR : 67.00 )

Judgement : YES

89623 Shear Force [kN] Bending Moment [kN-m] 3051918


Hog(+)

59749 2034612

29874 Value = 705228 1017306


Value = 16681
Max BM FR = 99.00
Max SF FR = 32.00

73.0 131.5 190.0


0 0
32.0 112.0 151.0 229.0

-29874 -1017306

-59749 -2034612

Sag(-)
-89623 -3051918
ACTUAL S.F
ACTUAL B.M
MAX ALLOWABLE S.F
MAX ALLOWABLE B.M

119
BUREAU VERITAS
Stamped document, refer to 1st page

TECHMARINE S/W CO.,LTD.


Rm 1003, 10TH FL. TELEPHONE : +82-51-467-7003
The Korean Teacher's Credit Union TELEFAX : +82-51-467-7005
192 Jungangdaero, Donggu, Busan, Korea E-MAIL : [email protected]

You might also like