Multihole Probe
Multihole Probe
: TPN / 13138
Project Proposal On
Submitted to:
Submitted By
Project Investigator:
Dr. C Ramprasadh
SASTRA UNIVERSITY-Thanjavur
Part 1 : General Information
General Information:
2. State Tamilnadu
4. Category: General
Proposed Work
The current proposal aims at
•Design and Fabrication of Multi-Hole Micro Air Data Probe
•Setting up of a calibration facility for the calibration of Multi-hole probes.
•Calibration of the Micro Air Data Probe
•Developing an indigenous Air Data Computer system for in-flight measurement of flow
angles.
•Flight Testing of the air data system and
•Validation of the flow angle measurements
Importance of Angle of Attack measurement
The angle of Attack is an important measurement as far as UAVs are concerned because
it directly affects the aerodynamic performance of an aircraft. The coefficient of Lift and
coefficient of Drag are directly affected by the Angle of Attack. Lift increases with increase
in Angle of Attack up to a limit called stall Angle of Attack then decreases sharply due to
large flow separation. This phenomenon is called “Stall”, and after that the aircraft
becomes unstable. Thus measurement of Angle of Attack gains importance as to know
about the Aerodynamic parameters. It would significantly enable designing and develop
control laws for flying UAVs in unconventional missions.
Importance of Five hole probe
As mentioned above in the introductory statement, there are a few methods available to
measure the Angle of Attack. They are, by using
•Five hole probe
A Five hole probe is a common type of multi-hole probe employed for flow angle
measurements. It is a type of pitot-static probe used to measure the pitch and yaw angle.
The angles are calculated using the pressure difference measured between the holes.
•AOA vane probe
The Angle Of Attack vane is a device capable of measuring the Angle of Attack and side
slip angle. This vane is a dynamic device which deflects due to the flow, and a
potentiometer will measure the deflection. The accuracy of measurement is low when
compared to five hole probe.
•Estimation Algorithms
The Estimation Algorithms are a set of algorithms which are simulated using Matlab
software to estimate the Angle of Attack. These Algorithms are still in validation stage.
Therefore, the five-hole probe is the best method to measure the Angle Of Attack.
Since there are no well-established methods of flow angle measurement in UAVs due to
the size and weight constraint of such vehicles, the need for the design and development
of the Air Data Computer gains significance. Meanwhile, few methods involving state
estimation techniques are studied by the Principal Investigator. In the recent past, the
following research has been carried out by the principal investigator.
As part of his PhD work at IIT Bombay, which was also supported by ARDB the
Estimation of Aerodynamic Angles in MAV using Sensor Fusion was reported. A simple
method for estimation of aerodynamic angles has been published in the thesis. His thesis
has contributed the following to advance the current state of the art.
1.Design of a simple algebraic method of estimation for AOA and SSA ES1
2.Design of EKF estimation algorithm with Pseudo-measurements of AOA and SSA
3.Robustness Analysis
4.Estimation of Aerodynamic Angles using Simplified Aerodynamic Model
Also, all the above estimation techniques are presented with a simplified aerodynamic
model structure. The results show that the estimates of the algebraic method in high AOA
region exhibit bias due to the way in which the aerodynamic model was simplified. The
other two schemes perform well with the simplified aerodynamic model.
Apart from the above, the research work also claims the following as minor contributions
to state of the art.
1.Design of a Complementary Filter technique for estimating AOA using the Newton
Raphson steady-state solution of AOA. It could be considered as another variant of the
algebraic method.
2.Estimation of AOA and SSA using estimated aircraft parameters. A separate offline
EKF algorithm was developed to identify the aircraft parameters which were used for
estimation of aerodynamic angles.
3.Study on the inclusion of the effects of wind turbulence in the estimation schemes.
4.A complete analysis of different cases and combinations of estimation schemes and
available measurements from resource availability point of view.
5.A standard EKF estimation scheme ES2 was also designed to verify and compare the
quality of estimated AOA and SSA.
As part of the next step towards flow angle measurement/estimation, the validation of the
estimation algorithm has been taken up. Currently, an ongoing project funded by the
ARDB on “Validation of Alpha Estimators in Mini Aerial Vehicles” has been carried out.
The ongoing research project sanctioned by the ARDB is being executed with the
technical support of the MAV Division of the National Aerospace Laboratories NAL
Bangalore.
Validation of three different estimation schemes is being carried out. All the necessary
sensor data are recorded including the direct measurement of the angle of attack using a
miniature vane probe Smart miniature vane. Then a post-flight algorithm is executed for
estimation of the angle of attack whose output was compared with the vane probe
measurements.
Part 2: Particulars of Investigators
Principal Investigator:
State: Tamilnadu
District: Thanjavur
City/Place: Thanjavur
Gender: Male
Address: Thirumalaisamudram,
Thanjavur, Tamil Nadu
613401, India
Pin: 613401
Mobile: 9489550188
Phone:
Fax:
Category: General
Co-Investigator:
Part 3: Suggested Refrees
Suggested Refrees:
Mobile: 9443923485
Email: [email protected]
Academic Area:
Application Area:
State: Tamilnadu
District: Tiruchirappalli
City: Tiruchirapalli
Mobile: 9900583971
Designation : Professor
Email: [email protected]
Academic Area:
Application Area:
State: Karnataka
City: Bengaluru
3. Name: Rajanna
Mobile: 8022932270
Designation : Professor
Email: [email protected]
Academic Area:
State: Karnataka
City: Bengaluru
4. Name: G Ramesh
Mobile: 9482732616
Email: [email protected]
Kanakapura Taluk,
Ramanagara District
Bangalore, Karnataka
India -
State: Karnataka
City: Bengaluru
Address: Dr G. Ramesh
Director (Retd.), MAV
Division, National Aerospace
Laboratories Bangalore,
Visiting Professor,
Jain University,
Bengaluru.
Financial Deatils:
Registration No : 73/2001
Designation :
Reg Multiple : 2
FCRA Registered : No
FCRA Registration No :
Valid upto : NA
District : Thanjavur
Pincode : 613401
Res. Phone : -
Mobile : 9894999747
Email : [email protected]
Website : http://www.sastra.edu
Pan No : A********C
1. Name: S VAIDHYASUBRAMANIAM
Designation: Trustee
Email : [email protected]
2. Name: S SWAMINATHAN
Designation: Trustee
Email : [email protected]
3. Name: R SETHURAMAN
Designation: Trustee
Email : [email protected]
2. Biodata
3. Certificate from PI
4. Conflict of interest
Name of
S.No. Author(s) Title Volume Page Year
Journal
A Monte Carlo
Analysis of Sensor International
Fusion Algorithm for Journal of
C.Ramprasadh, Volume:
4. Hemendra Arya
the Estimation of Micro Air 35-47 2011
3 issue: 1
Aerodynamic Angles Vehicles
in a Mini Aerial (SCIE)
Vehicle
Factor of Publications: Cumulative Impact Factor of Publications = 2.318
Refereed Conference Publications
C.Ramprasadh, Hemendra Arya, “Estimation of Aerodynamic Angles in a Mini Aerial
Vehicle” 5th International Conference on Theoretical, Applied, Computational and
5.
Experimental Mechanics, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur. 26th – 29th Dec -
2010.
C.Ramprasadh, Hemendra Arya, “A Multi-Stage Fusion Algorithm for the Estimation
6. of Aerodynamic Angles in a Mini Aerial Vehicle”, 49th Aerospace Sciences Meeting,
Orlando, USA. 4th – 7th Jan - 2011.
C.Ramprasadh, Hemendra Arya, “Estimation of Aerodynamic Angles in a Mini Aerial
7. Vehicle under Turbulent Atmosphere” AIAA Atmospheric flight Mechanics
Conference, Portland, USA. 8th – 11th Aug - 2011.
L.Sankaralingam, S.Prem. C. Ramprasadh, "Validation of Complimentary Filter
Algorithm for Angle of Attack Estimation using wind tunnel Measurements", National
8. Conference on Wind Tunnel Testing (NCWT-05), Jointly organized by Anna
University, Madras Institute of Technology Campus and CSIR-SERC, Chennai. 16th –
17th Mar - 2017.
L. Sankaralingam, S. Prem, C. Ramprasadh, Ravi Doddamani, Parag Deshpande, Suraj
9. CS “A Simple Method for Estimation of Angle of Attack” ACODS 2018 Hyderabad
18th – 22nd Feb 2018.
c) Details of project being implemented/ completed as Principal Investigator/ Co-PI along with its
salient features.
The current work focuses on the validation of four different schemes of estimation
of Angle of Attack (AOA) that are developed for Mini-UAVs. All the necessary
measurements for estimation of AOA are recorded along with the actual
measurements (of AOA). Using the post flight data in a MATLAB program, the
estimation algorithms are validated by comparing the estimated and the actual
measurements of alpha and the performances of the estimation schemes are
evaluated.
11. Details of employment including current employment.
Name of the
S.No. Designation From To Pay Scale
Institute
1. Lecturer SASTRA 23.06.2004 18.07.2007 8250-250-10000
University
2. Assistant SASTRA 02.01.2012 31.03.2013 23800-700-28200
Professor III University
3. Senior Assistant SASTRA 01.04.2013 Present 28300-800-39500
Professor University
g. Details of Main experiments to be carried out along with what hypothesis and model it
will test:
The proposed work includes the following experiments to be carried out.
a. Design, fabrication and testing of micro multi hole probe.
b. Flow analysis of the multi-hole probe in a tabletop wind tunnel with LABVIEW data
acquisition.
c. Calibration of the multi-hole probe at various flow angles and airspeeds.
d. Generation of pressure calibration curves.
e. Development of a micro air data computer. Selection of a high resolution ADC and
pressure sensors for the calibration of the micro air data computer.
f. Experimentation of the multi hole probe along with the micro air data computer in a
mini UAV.
g. Validation of the results with the measurements available from a commercially
available probe.
h. Likely Impact of the results / outcome on fundamental understanding and applications
(if any):
The proposed will result in the calibration capabilities of our country as far as micro air
data and flow angle measurements are concerned. The development of micro probes and
light weight micro air data computer would greatly help the mini UAV research and
development of our country.
i. Likely Deliverables:
The likely deliverables are,
(i) Micro Air Data Probe capable of measuring flow angles along with
(ii) Light weight micro air data computer which could be mounted on mini
UAVs without breaching the weight constraint.
j. Novelty of the proposal:
The main novelty of the proposal is that this research work focuses on development of a
very light weight flow angle measurement system. This requires a capable calibration
facility to be shaped up. As the calibration of such micro hole probes are highly
expensive (as provided by few commercial companies such as Aeroprobe Inc. USA), this
research work proposes to attempt at developing a low cost solution for this application.
16. Details on applicant’s expertise, the research work engaged in at present, future plan,
prospects after the fellowship, how are these related to the strengthening of basic
research in the country etc.
Applicant’s Expertise
The principal investigator has a reasonably good experience in UAV dynamics, state
estimation and instrumentation and control. The PI has written his Ph.D. thesis in estimation
of angle of attack and the following research contributions have been reported.
As part of his PhD work at IIT Bombay (which is also supported by ARDB)
His thesis has contributed the following to advance the current state of the art.
1. Design of a simple algebraic method of estimation for AOA and SSA (ES1)
2. Design of EKF estimation scheme (ES2) using wind axes equations
3. Design of EKF estimation scheme (ES3) using body axes equations
4. Design of EKF estimation algorithm (ES3 aided with ES1 estimates) with Pseudo-
measurements of AOA and SSA
5. Robustness Analysis on the estimation schemes
6. Estimation of Aerodynamic Angles using Simplified Aerodynamic Model
His thesis has presented all the above estimation techniques with a simplified aerodynamic
model structure. The results show that the estimates of the algebraic method in high AOA
region exhibit bias due to the way in which the aerodynamic model was simplified. The
other two schemes perform well with the simplified aerodynamic model.
Apart from the above, his thesis claims the following as minor contributions to state of the
art.
1. Design of a Complementary Filter technique for estimating AOA using the Newton
Raphson steady-state solution of AOA. This could be considered as another variant of the
algebraic method.
2. Estimation of AOA and SSA using estimated aircraft parameters. A separate offline EKF
algorithm was developed to identify the aircraft parameters which were used for estimation
of aerodynamic angles.
3. The inclusion of the effects of wind turbulence in the estimation schemes.
4. A complete analysis of different cases and combinations of estimation schemes and
available measurements from resource availability point of view.
5. A standard EKF estimation scheme (ES2) was also designed to verify and compare the
quality of estimated AOA and SSA.
Ongoing Project Details:
The principal investigator has an ongoing project funded by the AR&DB on the validation of the
estimation schemes of AOA. These schemes are currently being validated by performing post
flight analysis. All the sensor the data along with the direct measurement of AOA obtained from
Angle of Attack vane (Smart miniature vane) are recorded and used in a post flight analysis for
validation of the estimated AOA. The Smart miniature vane sensor is mounted on the Flight
vehicle. A data logger is used to log the data from vane sensor and the flight controller.
1
Estimated Alpha using combined ES1 and ES3
0.8 Estimated Alpha using ES1
Estimated Alpha using ES3
0.6 Measured Alpha from Flight test using Vane sensor
Angle of Attack (Rad)
0.4
0.2
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 x104
No of Iterations
0.8
Mean Error ( rad )
0.6
0.4
0.2
-0.2
0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
17. Detailed financial requirements with justifications for 5 years and phasing for each
year (Manpower, Consumables, Contingency, Travel National & International,
Equipment/s, Any other).
Detailed Justification for the proposed equipment/s. (Also kindly state if similar equipment is
available in the Institute and its usage.)
S.No. 1: The proposed research work involves wind tunnel calibration and characterization of
both the micro air data probe as well as the flight vehicle. It involves computing requirements
and data acquisition. Therefore a tabletop wind tunnel with necessary computational facility is
required.
S. No. 2: Aeroprobe Inc. manufactures and calibrates micro air data systems and supplies
commercially worldwide. One such probe is required for validation of the micro air data system.
S. No. 3: The proposed work involves development of light weight air data computer. This
requires pressure sensors, electronic circuitry such as high accuracy ADC, microcontroller and
signal conditioning units etc.,
S. No. 4: The proposed work involves data acquisition, programming of flight control boards
during flight testing phase. Thus two workstations are needed for executing the project work
smoothly.
S. No. 5: The proposed work involves fabrication of customized flight vehicle, This requires
aircraft components such as fuselage, motors, propellers, electronic speed controllers, connecting
rods, control horns etc.,
NIL
A – Endorsement from the Head of Institution (To be given on Institute letter head)
D – Biodata
***
Bio-Data
1. Name and full correspondence address Dr. C. Ramprasadh
Senior Assistant Professor
School of Mechanical Engineering
SASTRA Deemed University,
Tirumalaisamudram,
Thanjavur – 613401
2. Email(s) and contact number(s) [email protected]
9489550188
3. Institution SASTRA Deemed University,
Tirumalaisamudram,
Thanjavur – 613401
4. Date of Birth 30.06.1979
5. Gender (M/F/T) M
Name of
S.No. Designation the From To Pay Scale
Institute
1. Lecturer SASTRA 23.06.2004 18.07.2007 8250-250-10000
2. Assistant Professor III SASTRA 02.01.2012 31.03.2013 23800-700-28200
3. Senior Assistant SASTRA 01.04.2013 Present 28300-800-39500
Professor
11. Areas of Interests
Unmanned Aerial Vehicles, Flight Dynamics and Control, Sensor Fusion and State Estimation,
Mathematical Modeling, Stochastic Processes and Random Signals.
12. Funded Research Projects
Intramural Research Grant:
13. Publications (List of papers published in SCI / SCI-E Journals, in year wise descending order).
Name of
S.No. Author(s) Title Volume Page Year
Journal
Raja Vardhan Design of a
proportional-integral International
K Reddy, SM Volume:
controller to track Journal of
1. Sambasivam, S 9 15-24 2017
pitch angle in a mini Micro Air
Prem, C issue: 1
aerial vehicle Vehicles
Ramprasadh
A CFD Study on
Leading Edge Wing
International
Surface
Journal of
C. Ramprasadh, Modification of a Volume: 361-
2. Micro Air 2015
V. Devanandh Low Aspect Ratio 7 issue: 3 373
Vehicles
Flying wing to
Improve Lift
Performance.
3. C.Ramprasadh, Multistage-Fusion Journal of Volume 93-100 2012
Hemendra Arya Algorithm for Aircraft 49
Estimation of issue: 1
Aerodynamic
Angles in Mini
Aerial Vehicle
A Monte Carlo
Analysis of Sensor
International
Fusion Algorithm
C.Ramprasadh, Journal of Volume:
4. for the Estimation of 35-47 2011
Hemendra Arya Micro Air 3 issue: 1
Aerodynamic
Vehicles
Angles in a Mini
Aerial Vehicle
14. Publications (List of papers published in National / International Conferences, in year wise
descending order).
Refereed Conference Publications
C.Ramprasadh, Hemendra Arya, “Estimation of Aerodynamic Angles in a Mini Aerial
Vehicle” 5th International Conference on Theoretical, Applied, Computational and
5.
Experimental Mechanics, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur. 26th – 29th Dec -
2010.
C.Ramprasadh, Hemendra Arya, “A Multi-Stage Fusion Algorithm for the Estimation
6. of Aerodynamic Angles in a Mini Aerial Vehicle”, 49th Aerospace Sciences Meeting,
Orlando, USA. 4th – 7th Jan - 2011.
C.Ramprasadh, Hemendra Arya, “Estimation of Aerodynamic Angles in a Mini Aerial
7. Vehicle under Turbulent Atmosphere” AIAA Atmospheric flight Mechanics
Conference, Portland, USA. 8th – 11th Aug - 2011.
L.Sankaralingam, S.Prem. C. Ramprasadh, "Validation of Complimentary Filter
Algorithm for Angle of Attack Estimation using wind tunnel Measurements", National
8. Conference on Wind Tunnel Testing (NCWT-05), Jointly organized by Anna
University, Madras Institute of Technology Campus and CSIR-SERC, Chennai. 16th –
17th Mar - 2017.
L. Sankaralingam, S. Prem, C. Ramprasadh, Ravi Doddamani, Parag Deshpande, Suraj
9. CS “A Simple Method for Estimation of Angle of Attack” ACODS 2018 Hyderabad
18th – 22nd Feb 2018.
15. Factor of Publications
***
C - Conflict of Interest
Issues of Conflicts of Interest and ethics in scientific research and research management have
assumed greater prominence, given the larger share of Government funding in the country's R &
D scenario. The following policy pertaining to general aspects of Conflicts of Interest and code
of ethics, are objective measures that is intended to protect the integrity of the decision making
processes and minimize biasness. The policy aims to sustain transparency, increase
accountability in funding mechanisms and provide assurance to the general public that processes
followed in award of grants are fair and non-discriminatory. The Policy aims to avoid all forms
of bias by following a system that is fair, transparent and free from all influence/ unprejudiced
dealings, prior to, during and subsequent to the currency of the programme to be entered into
with a view to enable public to abstain from bribing or any corrupt practice in order to secure the
award by providing assurance to them that their competitors will also refrain from bribing and
other corrupt practice and the decision makers will commit to prevent corruption, in any form, by
their officials by following transparent procedures. This will also ensure a global acceptance of
the decision making process adopted by DST.
Conflict of Interest means "any interest which could significantly prejudice an individual's
objectivity in the decision making process, thereby creating an unfair competitive advantage for
the individual or to the organization which he/she represents". The Conflict of Interest also
encompasses situations where an individual, in contravention to the accepted norms and ethics,
could exploit his/her obligatory duties for personal benefits.
a) The provisions of the policy shall be followed by persons applying for and receiving
funding from DST, Reviewers of the proposal and Members of Expert Committees and
Programme Advisory Committees. The provisions of the policy will also be applicable on
all individuals including Officers of DST connected directly or indirectly or through
intermediaries and Committees involved in evaluation of proposals and subsequent
decision making process.
b) This policy aims to minimize aspects that may constitute actual Conflict of Interests,
apparent Conflict of Interests and potential Conflict of Interests in the funding
mechanisms that are presently being operated by DST. The policy also aims to cover,
although not limited to, Conflict of interests that are Financial (gains from the outcomes
of the proposal or award), Personal (association of relative / Family members) and
Institutional (Colleagues, Collaborators, Employer, persons associated in a professional
career of an individual such as Ph.D. supervisor etc.)
2. Specifications as to what constitutes Conflict of Interest.
Any of the following specifications (non-exhaustive list) imply Conflict of Interest if,
(i) Due to any reason by which the Reviewer/Committee Member cannot deliver fair
and objective assessment of the proposal.
(ii) The applicant is a directly relative# or family member (including but not limited
to spouse, child, sibling, parent) or personal friend of the individual involved in
the decision making process or alternatively, if any relative of an Officer directly
involved in any decision making process / has influenced interest/ stake in the
applicant’s form etc.
(iii) The applicant for the grant/award is an employee or employer of an individual
involved in the process as a Reviewer or Committee Member; or if the applicant
to the grant/award has had an employer-employee relationship in the past three
years with that individual.
(iv) The applicant to the grant/award belongs to the same Department as that of the
Reviewer/Committee Member.
(v) The Reviewer/Committee Member is a Head of an Organization from where the
applicant is employed.
(vi) The Reviewer /Committee Member is or was, associated in the professional career
of the applicant (such as Ph.D. supervisor, Mentor, present Collaborator etc.)
(vii) The Reviewer/Committee Member is involved in the preparation of the research
proposal submitted by the applicant.
(viii) The applicant has joint research publications with the Reviewer/Committee
Member in the last three years.
(ix) The applicant/Reviewer/Committee Member, in contravention to the accepted
norms and ethics followed in scientific research has a direct/indirect financial
interest in the outcomes of the proposal.
(x) The Reviewer/Committee Member stands to gain personally should the submitted
proposal be accepted or rejected.
# The Term “Relative” for this purpose would be referred in section 6 of Companies Act,
1956.
3. Regulation:
The DST shall strive to avoid conflict of interest in its funding mechanisms to the maximum
extent possible. Self-regulatory mode is however recommended for stake holders involved in
scientific research and research management, on issues pertaining to Conflict of Interest and
scientific ethics. Any disclosure pertaining to the same must be made voluntarily by the
applicant/Reviewer/Committee Member.
4. Confidentiality:
The Reviewers and the Members of the Committee shall safeguard the confidentiality of all
discussions and decisions taken during the process and shall refrain from discussing the same
with any applicant or a third party, unless the Committee recommends otherwise and records
for doing so.
5. Code of Conduct
(a) All reviewers shall submit a conflict of interest statement, declaring the presence or
absence of any form of conflict of interest.
(b) The reviewers shall refrain from evaluating the proposals if the conflict of interest is
established or if it is apparent.
(c) All discussions and decisions pertaining to conflict of interest shall be recorded in the
minutes of the meeting.
(d) The Chairman of the Committee shall decide on all aspects pertaining to conflict of
interests.
(e) The Chairman of the Committee shall request that all members disclose if they have any
conflict of interest in the items of the agenda scheduled for discussion.
(f) The Committee Members shall refrain from participating in the decision making process
and leave the room with respect to the specific item where the conflict of interest is
established or is apparent.
(g) If the Chairman himself/herself has conflict of interest, the Committee may choose a
Chairman from among the remaining members, and the decision shall be made in
consultation with Member Secretary of the Committee.
(h) It is expected that a Committee member including the Chair-person will not seek funding
from a Committee in which he/she is a member. If any member applies for grant, such
proposals will be evaluated separately outside the Committee in which he/she is a
member.
(a) The applicant must refrain from suggesting referees with potential Conflict of Interest
that may arise due to the factors mentioned in the specifications described above in Point
No. 2.
(b) The applicant may mention the names of individuals to whom the submitted proposal
should not be sent for refereeing, clearly indicating the reasons for the same.
While it is mandatory for the program officers to maintain confidentiality as detailed in point
no. 6 above, they should declare, in advance, if they are dealing with grant applications of a
relative or family member (including but not limited to spouse, child, sibling, parent) or
thesis/ post-doctoral mentor or stands to benefit financially if the applicant proposal is
funded. In such cases, DST will allot the grant applications to the other program officer.