CGO Filters
CGO Filters
1 Introduction
- We will not repeat the importance of filtration in industrial environments and particularly in cement plants.
- Filtration, which is also known as dedusting system, pursues several objectives in the cement grinding plants:
* To keep equipment clean to prevent mechanical problems (clogging, blocking ...) and process complications
* To collect materials that are either added to the finished product or return to the grinding circuit
* To send to the atmosphere a clean air that meets government standards of each country
- The table below gives an idea of the size of the particles to recover depending on the type of application:
- There are many types of filtration:
- The table below gives an idea of the areas of application of these different types of filtration:
- Here below, one can compare different types of dust removal according to the operating parameters and costs:
- In the case of a grinding plant, we are interested in the following 3 types:
* Cyclones
* Electrostatic precipitators
* Bag filters
- Cyclones have already resulted in a presentation that can be seen at the following link:
http://www.thecementgrindingoffice.com/cyclonesdevelop.html
Filters
2 Electrofilters
This document provides basic elements.
For details, consult specialized books!
2.1 Definition:
- In two words the electrostatic precipitator - also known as ESP - is a dust extraction device of laden gases by e
ionisation.
2.2 Constitution:
The electrostatic precipitator is mainly composed of:
- A large metal casing.
- Of wires, also called discharge electrodes, installed vertically.
- These wires receive an electrical current with a high negative charge and a high voltage of 30-100 kV.
- The discharge electrodes are located and suspended between parallel plates.
- There are different types of discharge electrodes available:
- The plates are mounted in parallel and vertical and are most often made of stainless steel.
- These plates are connected to the ground at potential 0 and are also called collecting electrodes (with a positive
- The distance between wires and plates can vary from 150 to 250mm depending on the nature of gases.
- The plates usually have a maximum height of 9m.
- There are different types of collecting plates available:
- Regarding the resistivity of cement dust, here's a chart showing its relationship with humidity and temperature:
- It should be noted that the resistivity of the raw meal is very high (up 10¹⁴Ω.cm) and the dust has sometimes d
to precipitate.
- Suitable devices can provide, for many industrial emissions, an overall efficiency of dust removal > 99%.
- The commonly used formula to calculate the efficiency of an electrostatic precipitator looks like this:
where:
η is the efficiency
ω is the migration velocity of the particles in m/s
S is the collecting surface in m2
Q is the quantity of gas in m3/s
- This equation is called formula of Deutsch.
- After, it was found that the efficiency was much more influenced by the variability of the rate of migration
of the particles, especially the finest, and the Deutsch formula has been modified as follows (Allander, Matts
and Ohnfeldt):
- With a coefficient called m, between 0,4 and 0,7 (0,5 being the standard value generally accepted).
Filters
3 Bag filters
This document provides basic elements.
3.1 Definition:
- They are composed of a metal casing in which are arranged filter bags that when they are traversed by the gas
retain dust.
3.2 Constitution:
- A dust removal system which is the most frequently an endless screw such as electrostatic precipitators.
- There are three types of bag filters according to their cleaning method:
- The trend today is to use rather long vertical bags (> 5 m), with a pulsed air filter cleaning system, a capture of
dust by the external side and with an air flow from the bottom to the top.
- Today, the reverse air and pulsed air systems are the most used in cement plants.
- The dust laden gas enters the filter from the top or bottom of the box.
- The gases pass through the filter bag from outside to inside (outside absorption) with a speed of about 1,5 m/s
- In an alternative system, the gas can also pass through the filter bags from the inside to the outside (inner absor
- The number of installed bags of course depends on the gas flow to be treated.
- With time therefore, it forms a kind of cake around the dust filter bags.
- And the cake of material helps, unlike what one might think, to improve the filtration because it is porous and
- The pressure drop across the filtration surface increases with the deposition of solids retained and when it
reaches a limit, the gas flow is interrupted and the bag is cleaned and sends the dusts in the bottom of the recov
hopper.
- To avoid stopping the flow of gas to be treated during the cleanup phase, the filter is usually performed in seve
sectors, each of which being subject to the cleaning step in rotation while the other are in phase of operation.
- Dusts are finally collected in an endless screw and are sent either to the finished product, or to the bucket eleva
- Below, we can see the two cases where the dust is absorbed outside or inside of the filter bag:
3.5 Filtration mechanisms:
- Gravity:
- Impact or inertia:
Solid particles entrained by the gas, due to their mass, do not follow the path of the gas when it follows a curve
to avoid an obstacle but go on the obstacle itself (predominant for particles > 1 micron).
- Interception:
The solid particles of the gas along the path around the obstacle and located at a distance less than their radius
with respect to the obstacle are intercepted (mainly particles between 0.2 and 1 micron).
- Brownian effect:
Very fine particles, due to their Brownian motion, may collide with other gas molecules, deviate from their pat
and may touch the obstacle (mainly for particles <0.2 m).
- Electrostatic forces:
The presence of an electrostatic charge on the particles and the filter can increase the capture of the dust.
- The obstacle is, of course, the filter bag coated of its cake of material already intercepted.
- The diagram below illustrates these filtering mechanisms:
Filtres
* Mechanical shock
* Oscillation
An illustration below:
- The reverse air system:
A jet of air at 6-7 bar is sent periodically within each bag and generates a pressure wave that causes the sudden
An illustration below:
- The tables here below give an idea of the general parameters of cleaning for the 3 types:
- The woven media consisting of regularly perpendicular woven wires, with an aperture of square meshes.
- Pressed media which is a set of small fibers arranged randomly (eg Teflon type).
- Felt example:
- The fabric retains relatively large particles forming a solid layer which also acts as a filter.
- Teflon, in addition to the surface action holds the particles inside the filter layer, which results in good efficien
- Cleaning Teflon is more difficult and has higher pressure drop, but in return it is more efficient.
- After the cleaning, the fabric loses a part of the dust adhering to the frame and a short time later, the cleaning
efficiency decreases.
- Different filter materials are distinguished by other key features such as:
- Advantages:
* Can use strong bags that can support the reinforced cleaning cycle
* Easy to use
- Disadvantages:
* Staff must enter the baghouse to replace bags, creating a significant risk
* May cause reduced efficiency of cleaning if there is a slight positive pressure inside the bags
- Advantages:
- Disadvantages:
* Staff must enter the baghouse to replace bags, creating a significant risk
- Advantages:
* Has a very good performance and minimal residual dust accumulation due to aggressive cleaning
* Can use resistant handles that can withstand a reinforced cleaning cycle
* Some models allow you to change bag without entering the filter
- Disadvantages:
3.9 Comparison:
- So we see that the pulsed air system is the most interesting because it is operating practically continuously
- This is probably the best known and no doubt the most important parameter.
- For this calculation, we consider the net filter area, we will see later what that means.
- The tables below provide filtration velocities typically used for various materials:
- For example
* Material: cement
- For pulse jet filters, an equation has been developed by the manufacturers:
With:
Constraints to respect:
For D outside this range, use either 0,8 or 1,2 if smaller or if greater than 100
- For example
Solution:
A = 10
B = 0,9
- One must calculate first the net filtration area, so that we need really.
- As filters having a cleaning system by shaking or reverse air have always a part offline
for cleaning, one must multiply the net area by a coefficient to determine the total area available for filtration.
- For pulse jet filters whose elements generally remain online during the cleaning phase, the net and gross filtrat
- Finally, to close this chapter, here is a table showing the number of sections required depending on the filter su
3.10.3 Pressure drop:
With:
- As the gas flow takes place at a low Reynolds number (Re = 1), we can apply Darcy's law (*) and we have:
With:
Dp is the depth or thickness of the material cake coating the filter medium
- As the pressure drop of the filter media is more or less constant, the total pressure drop of the filter depends
Filter
s
- The thickness of the dust layer increases progressively with the operating time elapsed.
- The mass of dust accumulated in the time t is equal to the volume flow rate multiplied by the time t and the
- However, this mass is also equivalent to the density of the material layer on the surface of the filter multiplied
- And:
With:
- The relationship between the total pressure drop and the superficial speed of filtration is known as the
- K1 is also related to Frazier permeability, which is the flow through a fabric in cfm/ft2 of fabric when the pres
- The problem is that the coefficients K1 and K2 are not easy to find.
- So we postulate:
With:
Ke is in Pa.min/m
Ks is in Pa.min.m/kg
- Ke and Ks Ke and Ks are determined empirically using pilot tests during which the pressure drop is measured
Ks is derived from a straight with a constant slope and varies only if there is change of gas, dust or quality of f
- At the beginning of the cycle, the gas flow through the filter cloth is not uniform and therefore the initial part o
- As time goes, the resistance increases linearly with the increase of the areal density up to the maximum strengt
allowable and then the cleaning of the clothes starts for a very short time.
- The linear portion of the curve is known as the effective filtration area.
- Data:
* Material: cement
- According to the chart on the previous page, we chose the filtration speed: 0,5 m/min
- After the tests, we have the following results of pressure with respect to time of operation:
- These cycles can be visualized on a diagram with coordinates (X, Y), with time on the abscissa X and the amo
gas and the pressure loss on the ordinate Y (for example a filter with 4 compartments):
- As we can see, the cleaning cycles are in the order: 1-4-3-2.
- The other compartments will have their gas flow increase to compensate.
- The pressure drop is minimum when the compartment 1 is online again and then increases.
- After a time tr, it is the turn of the filter 4 to be taken offline to be cleaned and for a time tc.
- Note that the maximum pressure drop Δpmax is reached at the end of the cleaning compartment 4.
- And so on.
- We have the following equation that links these three times and is the filtration time of a compartment
With:
And:
- During the time tj, the section has accumulated an areal density equal to:
QN-1 is the gas flow for one compartment when another compartment is offline
- And use a coefficient (called fN) based on the number of sections to know the actual speed of filtration of the
- Data:
* Material: cement
- According to the chart on the previous page, we choose filtration velocity: 2,5 ft/min
* Diameter d: 0,150 m
* Length l: 4,2 m
- Calculation of VN:
- Calculation of VN-1:
- Calculation of Sj:
- Calculation of Vj:
Filters
- During the online cleaning process of the bags of the pulsed air filter, only a small fraction of the dust coating
- The rest of the dislodged dust is redeposited on the bags by following the gas flow in the filter.
- It is clear that the redeposited dust has different characteristics of pressure drop than the dust previously depos
- A modelization of the online cleaning was developed by Dennis and Klemm and this has resulted in the follow
equation:
With:
- This model has the advantage that it can easily report the three filtration regimes of a pulse jet filter, ie:
- Considering the operating conditions, the values of Se, (K2)c and Wc can be assumed to be constant,
With:
- This equation describes the behavior of the pressure drop for a single filter bag but also determines the pressur
- The disadvantage of the model represented by the last two equations is that the constants, Se, (K2)c, andt Wc,
- For example, for the combination of Dacron felt with fly ash, the proposed formula is:
With:
V in ft/min
Pj is the pressure of the pulsed air, normally between 60 and 100 psig
ΔP in mmH2O
V in ft/min
Pj in psig (psi)
C in g/ft3
tf in min
- Data:
* V equals 7 ft/min
* K2 equals 10
* tf equals 40 min
- Solution:
- The formula, developed in the 70s by Dennis and David, shows that K2 depends on the average particle diame
μ20°C is the viscosity of the gas at the temperature of 20°C (1,81.10ˉ⁵ kg/m.s)
- K2 is in mmH2O/(m/s).(kg/m2) or in inH2O/(ft/min).(lb/ft2)
With:
η is the efficiency
3.11 Calculators:
We must also be careful with units which are Anglo-Saxon or in the international system (SI).
El
Parameters Pulsed air filter
pr
Quantity of gas required No limit N