Full Lecture
Full Lecture
Machine Learning:
A Comprehensive Comparison and Integration
From Full Sample to AI-based Econometrics
Dr Merwan Roudane
Overview
Introduction
Risk of overfitting
May not generalize well to new data
Difficulty in assessing out-of-sample performance
Less emphasis on predictive accuracy
Cross-Validation
K-fold cross-validation
Leave-one-out cross-validation
Stratified cross-validation
Time series cross-validation
Mean Squared Error (MSE) and Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE)
Mean Absolute Error (MAE)
R-squared
Accuracy, Precision, Recall
Area Under the ROC Curve (AUC-ROC)
Ensemble Methods
Bagging
Boosting
Stacking
Model averaging
Distributed computing
GPU acceleration
Online learning
Dimensionality reduction
Efficient algorithms
Methodological Differences
Model Specification:
Econometrics: Careful a priori specification based on theory
ML: Flexible, often automatic model selection
Sample Size:
Econometrics: Often works with smaller datasets
ML: Typically requires large datasets
Dimensionality:
Econometrics: Usually low-dimensional
ML: Can handle high-dimensional data
Statistical Inference
Econometrics:
Emphasis on hypothesis testing
Confidence intervals for parameters
Rigorous statistical theory
Machine Learning:
Focus on out-of-sample performance
Cross-validation for model selection
Less emphasis on formal statistical inference
Econometrics
Machine Learning
Dependent Variable
Label / Target Variable
Independent Variables /
Features / Predictors
Regressors
Models
Estimators
Weights / Parameters
Coefficients ()
Fitted Parameters
Estimated Coefficients ()
Errors
Residuals
Variance
Heteroskedasticity
Bias
Endogeneity
Feature Engineering
Instrumental Variables
Econometrics:
Primary focus on (beta hat)
Interpretation: Effect of independent variables on dependent variable
Example: In y = β0 + β1 x + ǫ, focus is on estimating and interpreting
β̂1
Machine Learning:
Primary focus on ŷ (y hat)
Interpretation: Predicted values of the target variable
Example: In a regression problem, focus is on how well ŷ predicts y
Terminology: Continued
Model Evaluation:
Econometrics: R-squared, Adjusted R-squared, F-test, t-test, p-values
ML: Accuracy, Precision, Recall, F1-score, ROC curve, AUC
Model Selection:
Econometrics: AIC, BIC, Likelihood Ratio Test
ML: Cross-validation, Holdout method, Grid search
Overfitting:
Econometrics: Often discussed as ”overparameterization”
ML: Explicitly addressed as ”overfitting”
Data Splitting:
Econometrics: Often uses full dataset for estimation
ML: Training set, Validation set, Test set
Fundamental Objectives
Methodological Approach
Econometrics
Machine Learning
Theory-driven
Data-driven
Models based on economic
Models learn patterns directly
theory
from data
Emphasizes model
Often ”black box” models
interpretability
Example: Using neural networks
Example: Using utility theory to
to recognize images
model consumer choice
Data Usage
Machine Learning
Econometrics Splits data into training and
Often uses entire dataset for testing sets
estimation Emphasis on out-of-sample
Focus on efficiency of estimators performance
Assumes data represents entire Uses cross-validation for model
population of interest selection
Example: Analyzing all available Example: Training a model on
data on housing prices in a city 80% of customer data, testing
on 20%
Handling of Uncertainty
Econometrics
Machine Learning
Emphasizes statistical inference
Emphasizes predictive accuracy
Focuses on confidence intervals
Often uses point estimates
and hypothesis testing
without formal inference
Example: Testing if education
Example: Using RMSE to
coefficient is significantly
evaluate prediction error
different from zero
Applications of ML in Econometrics
Causal Inference:
Econometric methods for identifying causal effects
Important for policy evaluation and decision making
Model Interpretability:
Econometric focus on interpretable parameters
Can enhance explainability of ML models
Handling of Endogeneity:
Instrumental variables approach for biased predictors
Relevant for ML applications with potential reverse causality
Theoretical Foundations:
Economic theory can guide feature selection in ML
Can improve model generalizability
Applications of Econometrics in ML
Structural Modeling:
Incorporating economic constraints in ML models
Can improve long-term predictions and counterfactual analysis
Selection Bias Correction:
Heckman correction and related methods
Relevant for ML applications with non-random samples
Panel Data Methods:
Fixed effects and random effects models
Can enhance ML models dealing with longitudinal data
Treatment of Time Series:
Econometric methods for handling non-stationary data
Relevant for ML applications in finance and macroeconomics
Econometrics Applications
Policy Evaluation
Economic Forecasting
Market Analysis
Labor Economics
Financial Econometrics
Development Economics
Recent Developments
Examples of Integration
Terminology Comparison
p0.3—p0.3—p0.3
Concept Econometrics Machine Learning
Outcome variable Dependent variable Label, Target variable
Explanatory variables Independent variables, Regressors, Covariates
Features, Predictors, Inputs
Model parameters Coefficients, Betas Weights
Model fit measure R-squared, Adjusted R-squared Accuracy, Precision,
Recall, F1-score
Error term Residual, Disturbance Loss, Cost
Data splitting In-sample vs. Out-of-sample Training set, Validation set,
Test set
Model assessment Hypothesis testing, p-values Cross-validation, Holdout
validation
Prediction Forecast Prediction, Inference
Variable importance t-statistics, F-test Feature importance, SHAP values
Model complexity control Adjusted R-squared, AIC, BIC Regularization,
Pruning
Nonlinearity Polynomial terms, Interaction terms Kernel methods, Neural
networks
Time series concept Autocorrelation, ARIMA Sequence models, LSTM
Causal inference
Dr Merwan Roudane Treatment effect,
Econometrics Instrumental
vs. Machine variablesComparison
Learning: A Comprehensive Potential
July 23, 2024
and Integration
38 / 69
Methodology Comparison
Fixed Effects
Random Effects
Difference-in-Differences
K-means Clustering
Hierarchical Clustering
Principal Component Analysis (PCA)
t-SNE
Lasso (L1)
Ridge (L2)
Elastic Net
Bagging
Boosting
Stacking
Machine learning techniques like Lasso, Ridge regression, and PCA can
help econometricians select relevant variables and reduce dimensionality,
addressing issues of multicollinearity and overfitting.
Causal Inference
Model Interpretability
Theoretical Foundations
Econometric methods for time series and panel data analysis can enhance
machine learning approaches to longitudinal and cross-sectional time series
data.
Automated Econometrics
Interpretable AI in Economics
Conclusion
Traditional and ML approaches each have distinct strengths and
weaknesses
The choice of method depends on research goals, data characteristics,
and practical constraints
Hybrid methods offer promising directions for combining the strengths
of both approaches
Continuous learning is crucial for effective economic analysis
The integration of traditional econometrics, machine learning, and AI
offers exciting opportunities for advancing economic analysis
By combining the strengths of each approach, researchers can develop
more powerful, accurate, and interpretable models for understanding
complex economic phenomena
This integration promises to enhance both the predictive power and
the causal understanding in economic research, potentially leading to
more effective policy decisions and economic insights
Dr Merwan Roudane Econometrics vs. Machine Learning: A Comprehensive Comparison
July 23, 2024
and Integration
67 / 69
Conclusion
Future Directions