Project Management V2.9
Project Management V2.9
MANAGEMENT
V2.9
Mar 2024
Agenda
• Project Management Overview
• PMI Framework & Knowledge Areas
• Project Manager Roles & Responsibilities
• Project Lifecycle (Project Planning, Estimation, Scheduling, Networks)
• Project Risk Management
• Metrics in Project Management
• Project Tracking and Monitoring
• Project Management Techniques
• Project Methodologies
• Project Management Challenges
• References
2
PROJECT MANAGEMENT
What is a Project?
What is a Project?
• A project is defined as a “temporary endeavour with a beginning and an end and it
must be used to create a unique product, service or result”
• End results have specific goals – Time, Cost, Performance & Quality
4
Attributes of a Project?
Attributes of a project:
• An established Objective
• A defined life span with a beginning and an end
• Creation of a unique product, service or a result
• Involvement of several professionals and departments
• Typically doing something that has never been done before (Solve a problem,
address a pain area)
• Constraint on resources – Budget
• Specific need for project risk analysis and management
• End results have specific goals – Time, Cost, Performance & Quality
5
What is Project Management?
What is Project Management?
• Project Management involves the Planning, Monitoring, and control of the
People, Process and the Events that occur as project evolves from a preliminary
concept to an operational implementation
Knowledge
Project
Management
Profitability
Project
Manager
People
Customer
Management
Satisfaction
6
Project Management & the 4 P’s
Effective Project Management focuses on the 4 Ps:
The People
• People must be organized into effective teams, motivated to do high quality
work
The Product
• The requirements / pain areas must be communicated from Customer to
developer, partitioned into logical parts, and positioned for work by the project
team
The Process
• A common framework with an appropriate process engineering paradigm to
come up with a set of tasks
The Project
• The project needs to be organized in a manner that enables the team to
succeed
7
PMI and Framework Overview
About PMI?
• The PMI was founded by Ned Engman (McDonnel Douglas Automation), James Snyder and Susan Gallagher
(SmithKline & French Laboratories), Eric Jenett (Brown & Root) and J Gordon Davis (Georgia Institute of
Technology) at the Georgia Institute of Technology in 1969 as a non-profit organization
PMI Objectives:
• Foster recognition of the need for professionalism in project management
• Provide a forum for the free exchange of project management problems, solutions and applications
• Coordinate industrial and academic research efforts
• Develop common terminology and techniques to improve communications
• Provide interface between users and suppliers of hardware and software systems
• Provide guidelines for instruction and career development in the field of project management
PMI Services:
• Development of standards, research, education, publication, networking-opportunities in local chapters,
hosting conferences and training seminars, and providing accreditation in project management
• PMI has recruited volunteers to create industry standards, such as "A Guide to the Project Management
Body of Knowledge", which has been recognized by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI). In
2012 ISO adapted the project management processes from the PMBOK Guide 4th edition
PMI India:
• PMI India office was established with the sole goal of advancing project management profession and
inculcating a project management culture within the establishments across government, academia, and
industry -- https://pmi.org.in
8
PMI Framework -- Key Knowledge Areas
Scope Risk
Management Management
PMI
Time Communication
Management Management
Human
Cost Quality
Resources
Management Management
Management
9
Integration Management
Develop Project Charter
• Authorization for the project
• Provide Authority to the PM to apply organization resources to the project
Develop Project Management Plan
• Define, prepare, coordinate, and integrate all subsidiary plans into a comprehensive Project
Management Plan
Direct & Manage Project Work
• Leading and performing the work defined in the PM plan to achieve project objectives
10
Scope Management
Plan Scope Management
• Creation of a Scope Management Plan that documents how the scope will be defined, validated , and
controlled
Collect Requirements
• Process of determining, documenting, and managing stakeholder needs and requirements to meet
project objectives
Define Scope
• Detailed description of the project and product
Create WBS
• Subdivision of project deliverables and project work into smaller, more manageable components
Validate Scope
• The process of formalizing acceptance of the completed deliverables
Control Scope
• Monitoring the Scope and managing changes to the scope baseline
11
Time Management
Plan Schedule Management
• Process of planning, developing, managing, executing and controlling the project schedule
Define Activities
• The process of identifying and documenting specific actions to be performed to produce the project deliverables
Sequence Activities
• The process of identifying and documenting relationships among the project activities
Develop Schedule
• The process of analysing activity sequences, durations, resource requirements, and schedule constraints to create the
project schedule model
Control Schedule
• The process of monitoring the status of project activities to update project progress and manage changes to the schedule
baseline to achieve the plan
12
Cost Management
15
Communications Management
Identify Risks
• The process of determining which risks may affect the project and documenting their characteristics
17
Procurement Management
18
Stakeholder Management
Identify Stakeholders
• The process of identifying the people, groups, or organizations that could impact the
project and analysing and documenting relevant information regarding potential
impact on the project success
19
Project Initiation
Project Life Cycle:
Initiating Planning
Monitoring
& Executing
Control
Closing
Disadvantages:
• Lack of Focus – sometimes project responsibilities can be pushed aside to meet primary
objectives
• Poor Integration across functional units
• Slow pace – It may take longer to complete
• Motivation could be low due to temporary assignment on the project
21
Project Management Structures…..2
Dedicated Teams:
• To create separate dedicated project teams which operate independent to the parent
organization
• A full time Project Manager is assigned to the project
• The Project Manager recruits necessary personnel from both within and outside the parent
organization
Advantages:
• More focus due to dedicated teams
• Fast pace – Response time is quicker
• Cohesive, High motivation and good synergy within the project teams
• Better cross functional integration as different specialists work together and no conflicts
Disadvantages:
• Overall the arrangement is expensive. Could result in duplication of efforts
• Internal strife and conflicts between teams and rest of the organization
• Self contained teams may inhibit maximum technical expertise to be leveraged on problems
• Difficult post project transition
22
Project Management Structures…..3
Matrix Structure:
• One of the biggest innovations to emerge in the last 50 years
• Hybrid organization form – A horizontal project management structure is overlaid on the
normal functional hierarchy
• Two chains of command – one along functional and the other along project lines
• Instead of delegation of project segments to different units, project resources report
simultaneously to both functional and project managers
Advantages:
• Efficient Management – Greater productivity
• Good focus due to strong hybrid structure
• Flexibility in the utilization of resources
• Easy post project transition – Normal career paths are maintained
Disadvantages:
• Dysfunctional Conflict – tension between Functional and Project Managers
• Infighting on sharing of resources and competition
• Stressful – Matrix Management violates management principle of unity of command
• Slow – Decision making can be delayed
23
What is the Right Project Management
Structure?
The best system balances the needs of the project with those of the parent organization. A
number of issues need to be considered at both the Organization and Project level
Organization Considerations:
• How important is Project Management. What percentage of core work involves projects?
• If over 75% of work is projects – a fully projectized organization can be considered
• If there are both standard products and projects – a matrix organization can be looked at
• Resource Availability?
• Where critical personnel cannot be tied up on individual projects, a matrix system would
be appropriate
• Need to access current practices and what changes are needed to more effectively manage
projects
Project Considerations:
• Size of the Project
• Strategic importance, novelty and need for innovation
• Environmental complexity (No. of external interfaces)
• Budget and Time constraints
• Stability of resource requirements
24
What is the Right Project Management
Structure?
Organization Culture:
• Member Identity – Degree to which employees identify with the organization as a whole
rather than at a personal level
• Team emphasis – Degree to which work activities are organized around groups rather than
individuals
• Management Focus – Degree to which management decisions take into account the effect of
outcomes on people of the organization
• Unit Integration – Degree to which units within the organization are encouraged to operate in
a coordinated or independent manner
• Control – Degree to which Rules, Policies, and direct supervision are used to oversee and
control employee behaviour
• Risk Tolerance – Degree to which employees are encouraged to be aggressive, innovative, and
risk seeking
• Reward Criteria – Degree to which rewards are based on performance rather than other
criteria
• Conflict Tolerance – Degree to which employees are encouraged to air conflicts and criticism
openly
• Means v/s end orientation – Degree to which management focuses on outcomes rather than
on techniques and processes used to achieve those results
• Open-system focus – Degree to which organization responds to changes in the external 25
environment
Project Initiation
Project Execution Approach:
• Need to establish a structured approach
• A disciplined and structured approach will ensure:
• Meet the needs of the stakeholders (Customer, Project Manager……)
• Measure performance against the strategic plan of the organization
Steps involved:
• Define Project Scope
• Establishing project priorities
• Creating the WBS
• Integrating the WBS with the Organization
26
Defining Project Scope
Project Scope:
• Defining the project scope sets the stage for developing a project plan
• Project scope is a definition of the end result or mission of the project, a product or service
27
Establishing project priorities
Project Priorities:
• Important to manage the trade-offs among
Time, Cost , and Performance
• Imperative to establish priorities
• Set up a priority Matrix
Priority Matrix:
Consider a project for developing a new WiFi
Router: Time Performance Cost
• Time to Market is important to sales –
Time can be enhanced – reduce Constrain
completion time Enhance
• In doing so, project going over budget is
acceptable Accept
• But original performance specifications
cannot be compromised
28
Work Breakdown Structure
What is a WBS?:
• A WBS is a deliverables oriented collection of project components
• It is a Categorization and Decomposition of the Project Scope Statement
• Breaking down the massive project scope statement into smaller more manageable components
30
Integrating the WBS with the Organization
1 Laptop
31
Coding the WBS. Process Breakdown Structure
Coding the WBS:
• To achieve max usefulness of a Breakdown Structure, a coding system is needed
• The codes are used to define levels and elements of the WBS, organization elements, work
packages, and budget and cost information
• The codes allow reports to be consolidated at any level in the structure
Process Breakdown Structure:
• The project is organized around processes
• Typical Information System projects
32
Responsibility Matrix
Linear Responsibility chart which summarizes the tasks to be accomplished and who is responsible for
what to achieve the project goals
Conveyor Belt Project:
Deliverables Design Development Assembly Testing Purchase Quality Manufacturing
Architectural
R S S C C
Design
Hardware
S R S C
Specifications
Prototypes A R C C C N
Integrated
A S R A A
Acceptance
Legend:
* R – Responsible
* S – Support
* C – Consult
* N – Notification
* A -- Approval 33
Project Planning -- Estimation
What is Estimation?
Estimation is a process of forecasting or approximating the time and cost of completion of the project
34
Project Planning -- Estimation
35
Factors Influencing the Quality of Estimates
• Planning Horizon:
• Estimates of current events are close to 100% accurate but are reduced for more distant
events
• Project Duration:
• Longer the project it is difficult to estimate accurately
• People:
• Accuracy of estimates depends on the skills of the people making the estimates
• Project structure and Organization:
• Estimates are influenced by the project structure and Organization culture
• Padding Estimates:
• Estimates are padded for safety and Risks. The project costs and schedule may be seriously
overstated
• Other Factors:
• Equipment down time
• National Holidays
• Vacations
• Legal Limits
• Industry specific Standards and Guidelines
36
Estimating Guidelines
• Responsibility:
• Estimates should be done by people most familiar with the task. Draw on their expertise
• Several people to Estimate:
• Better chance of being reasonable and realistic when several people with relevant experience
and knowledge of the task are used (Crowdsourcing)
• Normal Conditions:
• Estimates should be based on normal conditions, efficient methods and a normal level of
resources
• Time Units:
• Need to have consistent time estimates (PD, MM, etc......)
• Independence:
• Treat each task as independent of the other tasks
• Contingencies:
• Do not include allowances for contingencies in work package estimates
• Add Risk Assessment:
• Include Risk assessment and plan for them to increase accuracy
37
Estimation – Top Down v/s Bottom Up
Top Down Approach: These are usually derived from someone who uses experience and /or
information to determine project duration and total costs
Bottom up Approach: Done at the work package level and then rolled up to major deliverables
38
Estimation – Top Down v/s Bottom Up
Bottom Up Different Approaches:
1. Template Methods:
Templates based on past projects are used. Differences in the new project can be noted and costs
and times are adjusted
2. Parametric Procedures
Similar to Ratio Method. Past data for specific tasks can be leveraged
3. Range Estimation:
This method is used when work packages have significant uncertainty associated with the time
and cost to complete the tasks. Three time estimates are used (Low, Average, High) to give a range
within which the average estimate will fall
Hybrid – Phase Estimation:
• This approach begins with a top down estimate for the project and then refines the estimates for
phases of the project as it is implemented.
• Phase estimating is used when an unusual amount of uncertainty surrounds a project and it is
impractical to estimate times and costs for the entire project
Level of Detail: Depends on several factors:
• Complexity
• Need for control
• Project size, cost, schedule 39
Estimation – Size by Function Points
Measurements Parameters Examples
• Weighting Factors
• Unadjusted FP
• Complexity Adjustment Factor
FP = UFP * CAF
40
Planning by Use of Baselines
Projects Size (FP) Actual Efforts Defects
(PDs)
Size
Pr1 100/118 = 0.847 Pr7 750/1071 = 0.7
Pr2 150/183 = 0.819 Pr10 4000/7273 = 0.549
Regression Equation
PDs = 1.559*FP – 28.85 = (1.559*1200 – 28.85)
= 1890 PDs
41
Estimation – Size by Function Points
International Function Points Users Group IFPUG
Size = 1000 FPs
= 1000 / 0.7
= 1428.57 = 1429 PDs (Efforts spread across the life cycle)
42
Planning by Use of Baselines
Productivity
10000
5000
118 7273
0 100 150 183 224
175 200 267 329 602 1071 1471 2419
250 500 4000
Pr1 Pr2 750 1000
Pr3 Pr4 1500
Pr5 Pr6 Size
Pr7 Pr8 Pr9
Pr10
Pr1 Pr2 Pr3 Pr4 Pr5 Pr6 Pr7 Pr8 Pr9 Pr10
Size 100 150 175 200 250 500 750 1000 1500 4000
Actual Efforts 118 183 224 267 329 602 1071 1471 2419 7273
Defect Density
15000
10000 14400
5000 200 330 420
0 100 150 175 540 725 1000 2250 5250
200 3200
250 500
Pr1 Pr2 750 1000 4000
Pr3 Pr4 1500
Pr5 Pr6 Pr7 Size
Pr8
Pr9
Pr10
Pr1 Pr2 Pr3 Pr4 Pr5 Pr6 Pr7 Pr8 Pr9 Pr10
Size 100 150 175 200 250 500 750 1000 1500 4000
Defects 200 330 420 540 725 1000 2250 3200 5250 14400
Size Defects
43
Estimation – Type of Costs & Refining
Cost Breakdown:
1. Direct Costs:
Cost of Labour, Material, Equipment, Others. These costs are clearly chargeable to a specific work
package
2. Direct Project Overhead Costs
Costs tied to project deliverables or work packages. Salaries….usually a ratio of the dollar value of
the resources
3. General & Administrative Overhead Costs:
These represent organization costs which are not directly linked to the project. These costs are
carried for the duration of the project. (Advertising, Accounting, Senior Management. Generally a
% of the total direct costs
Refining Estimates: Generally a % of adjustment is done over the original estimates
1. Interaction Costs: Time spent on interaction between departments for queries and issues
2. Normal conditions do not apply: Costs associated when project demonstrates variations from
normal assumed conditions
3. Things go wrong on the project: Design flaws, Extreme weather conditions, unplanned leaves……
4. Changes in Scope and plans: Major changes during execution and change management process
5. Overly optimistic: Tendency to overestimate completion of tasks and underestimate duration
6. Strategic misrepresentation: Underestimation of costs and overestimation of benefits in order to
win proposals 44
Risk Management Overview
What is a Risk?:
• An uncertain event or a condition that, if it occurs has a positive or negative impact
on one or more project objectives such as Scope, Schedule, Cost, and Quality
• A risk is a potential problem – It might happen, it might not
• If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles – Sun Tzu, a
Chinese general
• For the Project Manager, the enemy is the Risk!
45
Risk Management Process and Event Graph
The Project Manager will work with the Project Team, Key Stakeholders, SME’s, and Management to plan and
handle the Risks
47
Risk Management Tasks
Identifying the Risks:
• Review Project Documents
• Brainstorming
• Assumption Analysis
• Root Cause Analysis
• SWOT Analysis
• Delphi Technique
Analyze the Risks:
• The Risks have to be analyzed to determine how probable the risks are to occur and,
if the risks do occur, what is the impact of the risk
Qualitative Analysis:
• This is a high level approach and is subjective. The predicted probability and impact can be based on
past experience, gut instinct, and other subjective inputs
• It uses a Risk Matrix, also called Probability Impact Matrix to score the Risks on an ordinal scale
Quantitative Analysis:
• This approach quantifies the risk
• The risks are tested in a controlled environment whenever possible
Risk Responses:
• Avoidance – Create workarounds by changing schedule, reducing scope, etc.
• Transference – Transfer the Risk to a third party, usually for a fee
• Mitigation – To act in order to reduce the Risk probability and impact (Prototype Development 48
Risk Breakdown Structure
Project
Technical Project
External Organization
Management
Subcontractor Project
Requirements Estimating
s & Suppliers Dependencies
Performance Prioritization
Customer Communication
& Reliability
1 2 3 4 5
Project Objective
Very Low Low Moderate High Very High
Insignificant cost < 10% Cost 10-20% cost 20-40% cost increase > 40% cost
Cost
increase Increase increase increase
Insignificant time < 5% time 5-10% time increase 10-20% time increase > 20% time
Time
increase increase increase
Scope decrease Minor areas of Major areas of Scope reduction Project end item
Scope barely noticeable scope affected scope affected unacceptable to is effectively
sponsor useless
Quality degradation Only very Quality reduction Quality reduction Project end item
barely noticeable demanding requires sponsor unacceptable to is effectively
Quality
applications are approval sponsor useless
affected
Risk Assessment Form
4 User Interface
Backlash problems
Probability
3
2 System
freezing
• Failure Mode and Effects Analysis extends the Risk Severity Matrix by including ease of detection in the equation
• Impact * Probability * Detection = Risk Value
51
Risk Management Quantification and Impact
Risk Exposure:
54
Thank You