PHILO - Q2 - Mod4 - Reflections About Life
PHILO - Q2 - Mod4 - Reflections About Life
Department of Education
National Capital Region
DIVISION OF CITY SCHOOLS – MANILA
Manila Education Center Arroceros Forest Park
Antonio J. Villegas St. Ermita, Manila
Introduction to the
Philosophy of the
Human Person
Reflections About Life
Quarter 2
Module 4
1
HOW TO USE THIS MODULE
Before starting the module, I want you to set aside other tasks that will disturb you
while enjoying the lessons. Read the simple instructions below to successfully enjoy the
objectives of this kit. Have fun!
1. Follow carefully all the contents and instructions indicated in every page of this
module.
2. Write on your notebook the concepts about the lessons. Writing enhances
learning that is important to develop and keep in mind.
3. Perform all the provided activities in the module.
4. Let your facilitator/guardian assess your answers using the answer key card.
5. Analyze conceptually the posttest and apply what you have learned.
6. Enjoy studying!
Expectations - These are what you will be able to know after completing the
lessons in the module.
Pre-test - This will measure your prior knowledge and the concepts to be mastered
throughout the lesson.
Looking Back to your Lesson - This section will measure what learnings and
skills did you understand from the previous lesson.
Brief Introduction - This section will give you an overview of the lesson.
Discussion - This section provides a short discussion of the lesson. This aims to
help you discover and understand new concepts and skills.
Activities - This is a set of activities you will perform with a partner.
Remember - This section summarizes the concepts and applications of the
lessons.
Check your understanding - It will verify how you learned from the lesson.
Post-test - This will measure how much you have learned from the entire module.
2
EXPECTATIONS
You will enumerate the objectives he/she really wants to achieve and to define
the projects he/she really wants to do in his/her life.
PRETEST
Directions: Write T if the statement is correct and F if the statement is wrong. Write
your answers on a separate sheet of paper.
1. Heidegger interprets death as an event constantly occurring in the world.
2. Epicurus claims that death is nothing because when it arrives, he is gone. This
means that death cannot be bad because the dead person can no longer have
painful experiences.
3. According to the deprivation account, death is bad because it deprives an individual
of a more valuable life.
4. When we say death is impending, it is something that can happen at any moment.
5. From a Christian point of view, death signifies the end of a person’s life.
6. We can find meaning in death.
7. According to whole-brain approach, someone is considered dead when his/her
entire brain has irreversibly ceased to function.
8. Dying is something that every human being should take upon himself at the time.
9. Cardiopulmonary approach states that a person is dead when his/her heart-lung
ceases to function.
10. Socrates describes death as a “Dreamless sleep.” This means that death is not bad.
Great, you finished answering the questions. You may
request your facilitator to check your work.
Congratulations and keep on learning!
3
LOOKING BACK TO YOUR LESSON
To prove your understanding of the past lesson, you should be ready to
accomplish this task.
In the previous lesson, you were presented with the different social contract
theories as a basis of forming a more humane society. Explain how these theories
influence you to become a better member of the society. Write your answer on a
separate sheet of paper.
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
BRIEF INTRODUCTION
DISCUSSIONS
Lesson
What is Death &
1 Why it Matters?
You probably recall the first lockdown sometime in March last year because of
the Novel Corona Virus-19. Maybe you were doing your stuff, chatting with your friends,
while others were browsing the Newsfeed on your social media accounts, or even calling
4
your loved ones informing them that there is an imminent danger ahead of us. Many of
us feared what this invisible enemy can bring, which prompted us to respond differently.
People flocked to grocery stores to buy necessary supplies and other items needed to
sustain their needs. This event brought everyone in shock and confusion, thinking that
the life we treasure dearly is on the brink of extinction. This uncomfortable feeling is
described by Sheldon Solomon, a social psychologist and professor at Skidmore College,
as an "existential anxiety caused by reminders of our own mortality." It is also related to
what Archbishop Vicencio Paglia, president for the Pontifical Academy for life, Vatican
City, when he says, “despite humanity’s so-called progress in science and economics, in
the “blink of an eye” the coronavirus “brought everything to its knees” and forced
everyone to confront their own mortality” (Esteves, 2020). In short, this event has opened
the eyes of many to face the reality that we usually avoid- the inevitability of our own
death.
The concept of death can be viewed from different perspectives. First, it can be
considered historically in terms of how it is reflected in literature, poetry, or oral
traditions. Every culture or society in every part of the world plays a significant role on
how people perceive death. One of these is the Ancient Egyptian concept of death which
is characterized into two: First is the Osirian myth, an Egyptian god who could confer on
devotes the gift of immortality. Second is the concept of post-mortem judgment, in which
the ultimate fate of the dead rests on how he/she lived his/her life. These concepts are
also manifested on how they treat the body of the dead such as physical preservation of
the body since they believe that there is life after death. Another is from the Christian
point of view of death. According to this view, death came because there was an abuse
of freedom granted to Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. According to the scripture,
Adam and Eve sinned and fell not only from grace, but they also transmitted the sins to
their descendants: the sins of their fathers are visited on the children. For the wages of
sin is death, but the gift of God.
5
death is nothing to fear. Although it is not a compelling argument for most contemporary
philosophers, Epicurus’ views continue to engage us about the nature of death. He says:
“there is no time at which death could harm me, since, as I go out of existence at the
moment of my death, I do not overlap in time with my own death; thus, death cannot be
bad for me” (Bradley et al., 2012). Death is not bad for a person because so long as a
person exists, death is not with him/her, but when death comes, then he/she no longer
exists. Death is nothing because when it arrives, I am gone. To consider the badness of
death is to consider the Deprivation Account Theory, which states that death is scary for
someone if, and to the extent that, it deprives individuals of a more valuable life.
When philosophers offer answers to the nature of death, they may be said to be
defining death, and it is essential to ask, “when we can say that a human person is
dead?” Fred Feldman (1998), in his article “Death and the Meaning of Life,” says, one way
to understand the nature of death is to formulate the definition of death as ‘x dies at
t,’ such definition he says, would tell us what we mean when we say that something dies,
6
and thus reveal the nature of death. For him, it is important to have agreement on the
question of whether a person is dead or alive. Because in some instances, we do not
know whether a human person is dead. For example, consider a person whose brain is
irreparably damaged due to a car accident and is under a life-support mechanism. In
this case, it is unclear whether this person is dead or alive.
In the United States, they adopted a criterion for death modeled on the Uniform
Determination of Death Act (1981), which states that “an individual or person is
considered dead if he/she has sustained either (1) irreversible cessation of circulatory
and respiratory functions, or (2) irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain,
including the brain stem (Smith, 2014). In the United Kingdom, the accepted criterion is
brain stem death, or the “permanent functional death of the brain stem” (Pallis, 1982).
This module focuses on two approaches to death:
2. Whole-brain Approach - this states that a person is dead when his/her entire brain
has irreversibly ceased to function. This includes the higher brain and the lower
brain. The Higher brain consists of the Cerebrum (in-charge of our conscious
awareness) and the Cerebellum (in-charge in the coordination of voluntary muscle
movements). Another is the Lower brain, which includes the medulla, which
controls spontaneous respiration and the reticular activating system, a sort of
on/off switch that enables consciousness without affecting its contents. With this
view, we can say that a person is dead because he/she is no longer conscious.
But there are some instances wherein a patient exhibits breathing and heartbeat,
even though he/she is already dead. This is called a “brain-dead” patient or
7
patient in the so-called “persistent vegetative state” and a patient who is in a
“permanent, irreversible coma.” He/she can maintain breathing and heartbeat
without mechanical assistance.
One might insist that a person is dead when his/her Cardiopulmonary (heart-
lung) has irreversibly ceased to function. But one might also ask, why does the brain
play such great importance? According to the whole brain-approach, the human brain
plays the crucial role of integrating primary bodily functions, so only the death of the
entire brain is necessary and sufficient for a human being's death (Bernat, Culver, &
Gert, 1981). Although heartbeat and breathing, hormonal regulation, and other various
functions exhibit signs of life, they do not constitute life. It is the brain that makes these
vital functions possible.
Death as a Possibility
To know whether death is the end of one’s life or as an anticipation of another life
makes us reflect on the question, “what makes death a human possibility?” Suppose that
you are not going to die someday, would this affect your outlook in life? Will this influence
your values, priorities, and goals in life, knowing that you are no longer going to die?
Will you still go to your online classes and pursue your dream to become an engineer?
Will you still follow the rules or care about your actions in your dealings with your fellow
human beings? On the contrary, imagine that you have a terminal illness, and your
doctor told you that you have only 2-5 years to live, but the exact date remains unknown
to you, will this change your priorities in life?
Martin Heidegger’s notion of Dasein (human existence) as being-towards-death
can teach us why it is important to confront our own mortality. In his philosophical
hermeneutic of temporality, he says, what makes Dasein whole or meaningful is that we
are aware of our own mortality, that is, at some point, we will die. Because if, for example,
we do not have a death point, we would live our life to infinity. In this case, we would
not live a whole life because our existence is not within a temporal dimension. His
concept of death allows us to view it within a temporal dimension that without that point
(a time which we are going to die), we would not possibly live our whole life. In short, to
think how fragile our human existence, that any moment could be our last, makes us
confront the reality of our limited time on this planet and make the best out of it.
8
Certain, Indefinite, One’s ownmost, Non-relational, and Not to be outstripped (Mabacquiao,
2016): (1) it is certain because it will surely happen; (2) it is indefinite because though it
is certain that it would happen, it is still unknown to us when it will occur; (3) the term
One’s ownmost is used by Heidegger to signify that death is my own, I alone will die my
death; (4) it is non-relational, since only I can know what it means for me to die, death
cannot be shared by anyone; and (5) not to be outstripped refers to the inevitability of
death, it cannot be taken away from a person. As Heidegger would say, “death is
something that stands before us-something impending.”
It is important to note that for Martin Heidegger, the Being of human beings can
be established on a purely phenomenological basis without reference to a deity or to the
concept of immortality. Thus, his analysis of death is also based on experience, which
focuses on the existential significance of this impending sense of loss, not on how people
feel when they will die. However, it is also important to ask, “How are we going to talk
about the nature of death, if death is something that no one has experienced before?” What
kind of experience would give us phenomenological access to the phenomenon of death?
ACTIVITIES
ACTIVITY 1.1. WHAT DO YOU BELIEVE?
Objective: To cultivate learner’s concept about Filipino culture on funeral traditions
Directions: Identify at least three (3) Filipino funeral traditions in our country on how
they pay respect to their dead.
1. Include the following information in your narrative report: Funeral Practices such
as burials, mourning, and etiquettes.
2. Answer the guide question: Why is it important to pay respect to the dead?
3. Provide a separate paper for your answers.
Critical Thinking Question: What are your realizations and discoveries while and after
doing the task? Write your answer on a separate sheet of paper.
9
ACTIVITIES
ACTIVITY 1.2. MY BUCKET LIST
Objective: To help learners plan on their lives ahead
Directions: List 5 things that you want to do before you die. Explain why you want to
do such things by citing your reasons.
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
Explanation: ________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
10
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Critical Thinking Question: What are your realizations and discoveries while and after
doing the task? Write your answer on a separate sheet of paper.
REMEMBER
The concept of death can be viewed historically in terms of how it is reflected in
literature, poetry or through oral traditions wherein every culture or society in every
part of the world plays a great role on how people perceived death. And philosophical
perspective which gives rise to many different questions such as what is the nature
of death? Why does it happen? What does it mean? Is death final? What is the
meaning of life? Its purpose? Can life be meaningful if it ends in death?
There are two approaches to death: (1) Cardiopulmonary- a person is dead when
his/her heart-lung has irreversibly ceased to function; and (2) Whole Brain
Approach- a person is dead when his/her higher and lower brain has irreversibly
ceased to function.
Death as a possibility: Heidegger’s notion of Dasein (human existence) as being-
towards-death can teach us about why it is important to confront our own mortality.
11
POST TEST
Lesson
2 Life’s Meaning
EXPECTATIONS
You will reflect on the meaning of your life. Specifically, this module will help
you to:
12
PRETEST
Directions: Match the metaphor of life in column A with its meaning in column B.
Write your answers on a separate sheet of paper.
Great, you finished answering the questions. You may request your
facilitator to check your work. Congratulations and keep on learning!
1. Philosophical Perspective
___________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
2. Historical/Religious Perspective
___________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
3. Scientific Perspective
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
13
BRIEF INTRODUCTION
Defining life in a box is difficult if not impossible because life’s meaning depends
on one’s experience of life. Life’s encounter is unique for each individual. Each one finds
meaning for his own life. This meaning becomes the drive to the purpose of life.
DISCUSSIONS
Life According to Schools of Philosophy
14
Mohism. The Mohists believe in “Jian ai” 5th love people impartiality
or “inclusive love.’ It means that everyone Century
in society deserved to receive impartial BC
care from fellow human beings.
Solipsism. Solipsism proposes that what 5th be known only by one's
is real in this world is our minds. Century mind and not about
BC other beings.
Cynicism. For Cynics, happiness and 4th be self-sufficient
freedom are possible if persons are freed Century
from suffering in the age of uncertainty. BC
Hedonism. Hedonists believe that what is 4th have pleasure now
pleasurable is good, and we have to avoid Century
suffering to enjoy life. BC
Platonism. Platonism offers the idea that 4th pursue of knowledge.
abstractions such as "pure forms" exist. Century
In his theory of forms, Plato believes that BC
we only see the "shadows" of objects, and
their perfect forms exist in other realms.
Legalism (Chinese). Legalism believes 4th acquisition of skills that
that a strong government is needed Century make a person's work
because humans are naturally selfish BC valuable to the state,
and cannot be trusted to behave morally. which benefits society.
Epicureanism. Epicureanism believes 4th free yourself from pain
that tranquility and freedom from fear Century
help us to achieve meaningful pleasure. BC
Quietism. For Quietists, philosophy does 3rd ask for the meaning of
not offer answers to “big questions” in life. Century life, but it will lead to
BC confusion..
Aristotelianism. According to Aristotle, 3rd be a good person
in life, it is enough to be a good person. Century
BC
Stoicism. Stoicism believes that to act 3rd be dispassionate, pursue
justly, you need wisdom. In order not to Century perfection
violate the laws of nature, a sage will act BC through reason
rationally.
Modern Humanism. Our fate is in our late 1300s act in self-interest and
own hands. Humans are responsible for common good
their fate.
Subjectivism. There are various early set and achieve one’s
meanings to life. It can be determined 1600s goals
through a person's mental state.
Liberalism. Persons are free to do what 1689 defend individual liberty
they want without the consent of any
other person.
15
Kantianism. Kantianism suggests that a 1785 follow the universal
universal maxim or principle will judge principles
every human action.
Nihilism. Life has no meaning at all, 1862 do as you wish; life has
according to Nihilism or Pessimism. no meaning
Pragmatism. In Pragmatism, it is 1870s bring more value to
believed what is useful is more humans
significant than seeking the truth about
life.
Logical Empiricism. In Logical 1920s give a meaning to life
Empiricism, facts (scientifically verifiable
and observable) are the only type of
knowledge attainable by persons. It is
also called - Logical Positivism.
Existentialism. This philosophy believes 1940s make decisions and be
that life begins with "existential angst," positive
concern about our lives’ meaningless.
Absurdism. Questioning the meaning of 1942 stop trying to find
life is absurd because human mind fails meaning. Just live.
to give absolute meaning about
everything.
Source: https://blog.adioma.com/meaning-of-life-according-to-philosophy/
Analyzing the given meaning of life from different schools of philosophy, it can be
deduced that they can be generalized into four:
• life has an objective meaning;
• life has a subjective meaning;
• life has no meaning;
• life has a supernatural/unexplainable meaning.
Considering the chronological pattern of looking for life's meaning, man first look
for God and supernatural forces for divine intervention. They seek life's meaning within
the community, later they find it individually among themselves, and finally, they look
at humanity as a whole.
Life is a Metaphor
Life can be illustrated metaphorically. The images a person use to talk about life
define the meaning he/she finds, or do not find, in it. For example, if a person defines
life as “a game,” then he/she might not take life seriously, and that the best way to
live is to enjoy it. However, if a person sees life as “a gift from God,” then he/she thinks
that life is to be lived to the fullest at its worth because having worthwhile life is the
best way to thank the giver. In what follows, are some grand images of life that have
appeared in history?
16
Life is a disease. Life is viewed through the health metaphors and is perceived
as a fatal sickness because there seems to be no cure for it always ends in death.
Life is a comedy. It cannot be denied that life is full of humor, not so much in
our lives but about our lives, in the way we see our own faults and foibles.
Life is a story. It is obvious that life has a narrative, it has a beginning, a climax,
and a denouement, which is developed as one go along with life.
Life is altruism. Life is acting for the benefit of others, sacrificing even if there is
no benefit whatsoever to oneself.
Life is a game. Life is not about winning or losing, it is how you played it.
Life is a desire. Life is full of needs and wants that needed to be fulfilled. It is
something to yearn for.
Life is an adventure. Life is living the thrill “to the fullest,” Taking risks and
opportunities, facing challenges, and enjoying the rush of adrenaline.
Life is a metaphor. The meaning of life is not specific. It is unique for every
individual. It can only be illustrated using an image and it is a personal vision.
17
ACTIVITIES
ACTIVITY 2.1. LIFE’S MEANING
Objective: To identify the schools of philosophy that explain the meaning of life
Directions: Using the table below, categorize the generalized meaning of life based on
the school of Philosophy they belong to, then provide explanation to your answers. Write
your answers on a separate sheet of paper.
Life has a
supernatural/unexplain
able meaning.
ACTIVITIES
ACTIVITY 2.2. SURVEY SAYS!
Objective: To generalize your family’s perception of life using a survey
Directions: Survey your family members about their beliefs to the following metaphors
of life. Answer the critical thinking questions on a separate sheet of paper.
18
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING
MY LIFE IN A SLOGAN
Directions: Formulate a metaphor that defines your perception of life. Illustrate your
metaphor of life using a slogan. Answer the critical
thinking questions on a separate sheet of paper. Illustrate your slogan here:
REMEMBER
Defining life in a box is difficult if not impossible because life’s meaning
depends on one’s experience of life.
The images a person use to talk about life define the meaning he/she finds,
or do not find, in it.
POST TEST
Directions: Select the keyword that best fits the statement in each item. Write the
letter of your answer on a separate sheet of paper.
1. And life itself, viewed through the health metaphors, is bound to seem like a
fatal disease, at least ultimately, because there seems to be no cure for it, and it
ends in death.
A. Life is an art.
B. Life is a book.
C. Life is a disease.
D. Life is an adventure.
2. It is not the end goal or outcome of life that gives life meaning but quality with
which one lives out and develops his or her role or roles in a plot.
A. Life is a game.
B. Life is a mission.
19
C. Life is a story.
D. Life is a tragedy.
4. Philanthropic people help others to give their own lives meaning, but they expect
nothing in return.
A. Life is suffering.
B. Life is an altruism.
C. Life is a desire.
D. Life is nirvana.
5. Some view life as a sport with rules to be obeyed, with a price to be won and with
virtues to be learned.
A. Life is a game.
B. Life is a mission.
C. Life is a story.
D. Life is a tragedy.
REFERENCES
Online Sources:
Esteves, J. (2020). Life and death: Pandemic forces world to confront its greatest fear.
Retrieved from: https://www.americamagazine.org/politics-
society/2020/06/03/life-and-death-pandemic-forces-world-confront-its-greatest-
fear
DiGerolamo, D. (2019). Accept death as ever present: How stoic philosophy teaches us
to live. Retrieved from: https://medium.com/stoicism-philosophy-as-a-way-of-
life/accept-death-as-ever-present
20
Feldman, F.(1998). Death. In The Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Taylor and
Francis. Retrieved from:
https://www.rep.routledge.com/articles/thematic/death/v-1.
Peach, F. (2000). Death, faith and existentialism. Retrieved from:
https://philosophynow.org/issues/27/Death_Faith_and_Existentialism
Solomon, R. and Higgins, K. (2010). The Big question: A short introduction to philosophy.
Retrieved from: http://elibrary.bsu.az/books_400/N_17.pdf
Vital, A. (2020). The meaning of life according to different philosophies. Retrieved from:
https://blog.adioma.com/meaning-of-life-according-to-philosophy/
Books:
Mabacquiao, N.B. (2016). Making life worth living: An introduction to the philosophy of
the human person. Quezon City: Phoenix Publishing House
Caraan, A.M. (2016), Diwa senior high school series: introduction to the philosophy of
the human person. Quezon City: Diwa Learning Systems Inc.
Smith, W. (2014, April 1). Total brain failure is death. Human life review, 40(2), 19.
Editor/s: Paciano B. Ferrer, Gener C. Irinco, Nastasia V. Besin, and Ernie Ronel T.
Mabahague (Content)
Mhilwin A. Esto (Language)
Writer: Gener C. Irinco, T III and Neofidel Ignacio B. Ramirez, MT II
21
REFLECTIVE LEARNING SHEET
Name ____________________________________________ Grade and Section ___________
School: ______________________ Date: _____________ Subj. Teacher: _______________
Reflective Questions:
1. What have I achieved in this life so far? Am I satisfied with these achievements?
Do I aspire for more?
2. What experiences in my life made me the person I am today?
3. Am I contented with my life right now? Am I happy?
4. Am I living the life? Am I alive?
5. What is the one thing I’d like others to remember about me at the end of my life?
22
ANSWER KEY
Lesson 1
PRETEST POST-TEST
Lesson 2
PRE-TEST POST-TEST
1. C
1. B
2. A 2. C
3. C 3. A
4. E 4. B
5. D 5. A
23