CSS Chronicles (47th Issue) June 2024 Edition
CSS Chronicles (47th Issue) June 2024 Edition
CSS Chronicles (47th Issue) June 2024 Edition
ORG
JUNE
Quick Facts
Essay of the Month & Much More!
N
2024 EDITIO
CHRONICLES
1
Reasons To Choose
CSS with NEARPEER
2
TABLE OF
CONTENTS
1 National 05
2 International 17
4 Philosopher’s Corner 49
5 Wisdom Archives 53
3
VOLUME 4 NEW VOLUME
Gratitude is in style! A heartfelt thank you to all the dedicated CSS aspirants
whose unwavering support and enthusiasm have propelled us to launch
our 4th volume. Your passion for the craft fuels our journey, and we can't
wait to continue providing you with the latest trends, insights, and
inspiration in the world of CSS.
4
CSS Chronicles Volume 3 | Edition 11
NATIONAL
THE APPLICATION OF RENEWABLE ENERGY
RESOURCES IN PAKISTAN
5
THE APPLICATION OF
RENEWABLE ENERGY
RESOURCES IN PAKISTAN
Hamza Ahmad
6
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
with renewable energy Pakistan’s energy mix. The Board (AEDB) and the Na-
resources, including solar, country has a potential of tional Electric Power Regu-
wind, hydropower, and over 60,000 MW of hydro- latory Authority (NEPRA)
biomass. Harnessing power, primarily in the have been instrumental in
these resources can play a northern regions. creating a conducive
crucial role in addressing Large-scale projects like environment for renew-
the energy crisis and pro- the Diamer-Bhasha Dam able energy projects. Key
moting sustainable devel- and smaller policies include:
opment. run-of-the-river projects
are critical for meeting the • The Alternative and
1. Solar Energy: Paki- energy demands and Renewable Energy Policy
stan receives high solar managing water resourc- 2019: This policy aims to
irradiance, with an aver- es. increase the share of
age of over 5.5 kWh/m²/- renewable energy in the
day. This makes solar 4. Biomass Energy: total energy mix to 30% by
energy a highly viable Agriculture being the 2030.
option, especially in the backbone of Pakistan’s • Incentives for Inves-
vast arid regions of Ba- economy provides ample tors: Various incentives,
lochistan, Sindh, and biomass resources, such including tax holidays,
Punjab. The as crop residues and feed-in tariffs, and
Quaid-e-Azam Solar Park animal waste, which can streamlined regulatory
in Bahawalpur, with a processes, have been
planned capacity of 1,000 introduced to attract both
MW, is a testament to the domestic and foreign
potential of solar power in investment in the renew-
Pakistan. able energy sector.
7
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
• Economic Growth:
Investment in renewable
energy can spur economic
growth, create jobs, and
promote technological
innovation.
• Environmental Ben-
efits: Reducing the carbon
footprint and mitigating
climate change are cru-
cial environmental bene-
fits of shifting to renewable
energy.
Conclusion:
The transition to renew-
able energy is not just an
option for Pakistan; it is a
necessity. With the right
policies, investments, and
international cooperation,
8
REACHING FOR THE
COSMOS: SPACE FUTURE
OF PAKISTAN
Fareena Habib
Introduction
In today’s world, where countries in the digital arena are
making preparations to explore space, from reaching
Mars to scooping up lunar soil, Pakistan is not left
behind. With the successful launch of two consecutive
space missions, iCUBE-Qamar and PakSAT-MM1, in May
2024, Pakistan is poised to make significant strides in
technological advancements, innovations, and com-
munications. This achievement will also strengthen its
ties with its close friend, China, paving the way for future
9
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
chronicled that “The space economy is expected to be worth $1.8 trillion by 2035 as
new technologies become increasingly prevalent”. In 2023 alone, countries across
the globe increased their national space budget by $9 billion and this follows a trend
in increased governmental space funding with wider revenue gains.
2. Pakistan has stepped into the Space race to boost technological advancements
The Economic Times chronicled that “China and Pakistan’s lunar missions represent
significant milestones in space exploration”. It will lead to scientific breakthroughs,
fostering technology in this digital era and shaping the future of humanity. Recently,
the following space missions
of Pakistan have been un-
folded:
2.1. Pakistan’s iCube-Qamar
to examine lunar surface
10
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
shid, stated that the mission iCube-Qamar “will provide crucial data on crater loca-
tions, water, and traces of the ice on the moon’s surface”. It will offer opportunities
for universities, research institutes, and commercial entities to participate in space
missions and gather valuable data for scientific advancement and innovation.
11
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
Conclusion
Space technological advancements and communications via stronger Internet
connectivity can tackle many of Pakistan’s most pressing business and societal
challenges. The strategic partnership between China and Pakistan in space tech-
nology has the potential to be a positive sum game, driving innovation, economic
growth, cellular connectivity, and scientific progress in both countries while fostering
a stronger bilateral relationship.
12
HEAT WAVES, WILDFIRES,
DRYNESS, ETC. IS
PAKISTAN BEING HURT
EVEN MORE BADLY BY
CLIMATE CHANGE?
Sabeen
13
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
14
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
15
Click here to fill the form:
https://bit.ly/CSSIslamabad
CSS Chronicles Volume 3 | Edition 11
INTERNATIONAL
ROLE OF THE UNITED NATIONS IN THE PALESTINE
CONFLICT
ELECTIONS IN INDIA
7
ROLE OF THE UNITED
NATIONS IN THE
PALESTINE CONFLICT
Adnan Athangul
18
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
Additionally, the UN has enable rights of the Pales- criticized the UN’s ap-
deployed peacekeeping tinian people, and Security proach to the conflict as
missions to the region, Council Resolution 2334, one-sided and biased.
such as the United Nations which condemned Israeli After all these efforts the
Truce Supervision Organi- settlements in the occu- situation is getting worse
zation (UNTSO) and the pied territories as a viola- day by day. The United Na-
United Nations Disen- tion of international law, tions has been working in
gagement Observer Force have underscored the the Middle East region
(UNDOF), to monitor international community's around the clock to de-es-
ceasefires, prevent esca- support for a two-state calate the Israeli-Palestin-
lations, and facilitate solution based on the ian crisis by engaging key
negotiations between the pre-1967 borders. actors and providing
parties. While these mis- There have been instanc- emergency assistance to
sions have had varying es of contentious resolu- civilians on the ground.
degrees of success, they tions and disagreements However, they are unable
have often faced chal- in the UN, such as the U.S. to get the desired results
lenges due to the volatile veto of a 2011 resolution for long-lasting peace in
nature of the conflict and condemning Jewish set- the region.
the lack of political will tlements and the 2012 Assessing the Effective-
from the parties involved. report on Israeli settle- ness of the UN: Is It Failing
One of the central roles of ments leading to potential the Global Community?
the UN in the Israel-Pales- International Criminal • Enforcement Chal-
tine conflict has been ad- Court action. After Pales- lenges: A recurring criti-
vocating for the rights of tine’s admission as a cism of the UN is its limited
the Palestinian people. The non-member state in 2012, ability to enforce man-
General Assembly and the conflict may come dates, as its effectiveness
various UN agencies, under the jurisdiction of depends on member
including the United Na- the International Court. states’ cooperation, and
tions Relief and Works Israel has also expressed resolutions are often con-
Agency for Palestine Refu- reluctance to cooperate sidered recommenda-
gees in the Near East with UN investigations and tions.
(UNRWA), have provided
humanitarian assistance
to Palestinian refugees
and supported efforts to
address their plight.
Moreover, the UN has
repeatedly affirmed the
right of the Palestinian
people to self-determina-
tion and the establish-
ment of an independent
and sovereign state. Reso-
lutions such as General
Assembly Resolution 3236,
which reaffirmed the inali-
19
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
20
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
21
ELECTIONS IN INDIA
Imaima Mazhar
22
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
Majorly in the post-2019 era, the BJP government has sanctioned many policies in line
with its Hindu Nationalist vision including the revocation of the special status of Azad
Jammu and Kashmir and the passage of the Citizen Amendment Act. This and many
other bellicose measures against the Muslims in India and its neighbor, Pakistan, are
a testament to the truculent Hindutva ideology of the Modi-led BJP.
Considering their previous record, it was not surprising to observe the vicious an-
ti-Muslim rhetoric propagated by BJP leaders during the electoral campaign. More-
over, Modi and his party cadre did not show any restraint in employing a tirade
against Pakistan to stir the nationalistic sentiments of voters. Many observers view
this conduct as a tool to ramp up the electoral campaign while sidetracking the
public from a burgeoning economic crisis in the country. Such an approach has
proven effective in the past but with time proved to be more than just a hollow talk to
gain favor among voters. After coming into power, the Modi government took strin-
gent actions which indicated an aggressive approach toward national security and
foreign policy.
After a brief rapprochement during his first term, the mutual relations between the
two states have been on a downward spiral, particularly after the Uri and Pulwama
attacks and the resultant terrorism-related allegations targeted at Pakistan by its
eastern neighbor. Additionally, the tampering with the special status of occupied
Jammu and Kashmir, despite multiple international legislations to the contrary,
proved to be the final nail in the coffin for the normalization of relations between the
two countries. This triggered the diplomatic standoff, prompting Pakistan to recall its
high commissioner from India and vow to break off any economic and trade relations
with India.
23
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
With an eye to the future, there are varied speculations concerning the future of Paki-
stan and India's relations during the third consecutive term of Modi. This time, the po-
litical landscape has shifted, as the BJP has been unable to secure a majority on its
own and has had to rely on the two regional allies, the Telugu Desam Party in south-
ern Andhra Pradesh state and Janata Dal (United) in eastern Bihar state, to establish
control at the center. This political scenario introduces a new dynamic, and leading a
coalition government will not be smooth sailing, particularly for the domineering and
flamboyant Modi, who is accustomed to prevailing over the decision-making pro-
cess.
While being dependent on allies calls for a more consultative and deliberative ap-
proach, many argue that coalition partners often have little interest in external rela-
tions as they are more interested in strengthening their political base within a do-
mestic setting. To elaborate, historical patterns show that coalition partners prefer
domestic matters over foreign affairs. Regional parties within the NDA, such as the
TDP and the Janata Dal (United), are typically concerned with state-level governance
and local issues. This grants Modi and the BJP's core leadership significant leeway for
directing foreign policy, particularly in challenging relationships like the one with
Pakistan.
Moreover, the political narrative of the BJP has always stressed taking a firm stand for
national security, which is highly appealing to its support base. Given the party's de-
pendence on nationalist rhetoric to rally support, its ideological commitment to a
hardline posture is unlikely to change. Added to that, preceding incidents like the Bal-
akot airstrike in 2019 and the surgical strikes in 2016 have strengthened Modi's reputa-
tion as a leader who acts emphatically against perceived threats from Pakistan. From
a political standpoint, these moves have helped Modi's reputation at home and have
justified his assertive approach. Given this, it is reasonable to presume that Modi's
third term in office will entail the continuation of his confrontational policies against a
Western neighbor
However, given India's economic crisis—which includes high inflation and a lack of job
opportunities—the coalition government may advocate for establishing trade con-
nections with Pakistan to maximize the potential for trade between the two countries.
The economic issues confronting India may drive the coalition government to seek
pragmatic solutions that will stimulate growth and generate employment opportuni-
ties. Normalization of trade with Pakistan may have a positive impact on the econo-
my by opening up new markets, lowering transportation costs, and stimulating
border economies. According to the World Bank Report 2018, removing economic
restrictions and normalizing relations between India and Pakistan might result in
bilateral trade worth up to $37 billion per year.
Similarly, the stakeholders in Islamabad might welcome a friendly gesture from India
given the changed attitude of the coalition government. The domestic crisis within
Pakistan could be alleviated if external threats are reduced, allowing resources to be
focused on improving the condition of the populace. Enhanced trade relations could
lead to economic growth, job creation, and regional stability. Hence, both states
could benefit from normalization and success in building confidence across the
border, fostering a more peaceful and prosperous South Asia.
24
SAUDI-IRAN RELATIONS
POST-RAISI
Farooq A. Solangi
25
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
entirety. The power to for- cil is also laid down in the Though the president of
mulate foreign policy rests same article as follows: Iran presides over the
on the shoulders of the The Supreme Command meetings of SNSC, he,
Supreme National Security Council of the Armed however, cannot make
Council (SNSC). Finally, the Forces chief, the officer in unilateral decisions. The
supreme leader holds the charge of planning and decision has to be
power to veto any decision budget affairs, two repre- reached with a majority
of the SNSC. sentatives nominated by vote.
the Leader, the heads of The Council has been de-
Supreme National Securi- the three branches of gov- signed in such a way that
ty Council ernment, the ministers of all the policies made to
Article 176 of the Iranian foreign affairs, interior, and counter Iran’s internal and
Constitution information, a minister external threats are con-
The function of the
Supreme National Security
Council (SNSC) is to devise
strategies and manner of
execution with regard to
matters of national securi-
ty, ensuring policies align
with national security and
defense from internal and
external threats.
As per the constitution,
there are three functions
of the Council. They are:
Determining the defense
and national security poli-
cies of the country within with relevant experience, sensual.
the framework of general and the highest ranking Finally, It goes to the
policies determined by the officials from the Armed supreme leader. If the
Leader. Forces and the Islamic supreme leader approves
Coordination of political Revolution's Guards Corps of it, it becomes a part of
activities, intelligence, will make up the Council. the state’s policy. If the
social, cultural, and eco- Looking at the constitution supreme leader disap-
nomic fields relating to of the SNSC one can ap- proves of it, it is vetoed.
general policies of defense praise that the President of
and national security. Iran did not wield much Potential Display of Sau-
The exploitation of materi- authority over the making di-Iran Relations Follow-
al and intellectual of national security policy. ing the death of Ebrahim
resources of the country Article 176 of the constitu- Raisi
for facing internal and tion explicitly laid down the Foreign policy, particularly
external threats. premises of SNSC con- when it’s related to Iran’s
ductwhich is to counter archrival Saudi Arabia,be-
The composition of the the internal and external comes a National Security
Supreme National Coun- threats. issue. Sewered in 2016, Iran
26
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
and Saudi relations began been at loggerheads with developing, it seems un-
to shape positively follow- each other. Iran’s Islamic likely that these ramifica-
ing the thaw of March interpretation and Saudi tions will be very great. The
2023, while Ebrahim Raisi Arabia’s understanding of president of Iran does not
was the president. Rela- Islam are starkly contrast- have complete authority
tions between the two ing. This has been the core over the country's foreign
countries, as they appear issue of the conflict. policy, despite being a
at first glance, would . powerful figure. The
remain the same as per 2. Potential Leadership of Supreme National Security
the previous year’s accord. the Islamic World: The Council is responsible for
It can further be gauged Islamic world sees Saudi developing foreign policy
from the fact that Saudi Arabia as the leader of the (SNSC). However, areas
Arabia offered immediate Islamic world. Iran, due to such as Yemen and Syria
help to the Iranian authori- a different outlook on the paint grim pictures where
ties and after the news of Islamic creed and having both these countries try to
the president’s passing geopolitical ambitions, impose their way of gover-
away, expressed deepest aspires to replace Saudi nance and influence.
condolences. In interna- from this unofficial mantle.
tional politics, these ac-
tions can easily be inter- 3. Proxy wars: Word-torn
preted as a country’s ways Yemen and Syria are two
to maintain good relations regions where both Iran
with the other. and Saudi indirectly wres-
Viewing the situation from tle. In Yemen, the Houthi
the Iranian perspective, It group is supported by Iran
has to keep a good under- to fight against the Sau-
standing with Saudi di-backed government.
Arabia. Iran’s international Whereas, in Syria, the Asad
isolation due to US sanc- regime has Iranian sup-
tions and deteriorating port against the groups
peace in the Middle East funded by Saudi.
after Israel attacked Gaza,
in which Iran has a pivotal Conclusion
role, calls for Iran to have Over the past forty years,
as many friends as possi- Saudi-Iranian relations
ble, or at least, not to make have been severely
more enemies. strained. Both nations sev-
Prevalent Challenges ered their diplomatic ties
Despite recent cordial de- in 2016. That is until the
velopments two countries Chinese-brokered thaw
still have deep differences. occurred in 2023. The
Some of them can be passing of President Raisi
heighted as below. will undoubtedly have an
1. Shina-Sunni Rift: Since impact on Saudi Ara-
the Iranian revolution of bia;yet, given the way the
1979, both countries have two countries have been
27
3
CSS Chronicles Volume 3 | Edition 11
MONTHLY PRESS
REVIEW
29
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
The pro-choice move- Yet gloomy as this reversal Americans than any such
ment that could help Joe seems, it has also given uprising since Black Lives
Biden win rise to America’s most Matter in 2020 or the Tea
Published in The Econo- dynamic new political Party more than a decade
mist movement: a revolt of mil- ago. However, it is better
About ten thousand lions of Americans who organised and has clearer
women eligible to vote in think government has little goals. Its foot soldiers
this November’s elections business inserting itself carry clipboards. Tens of
were born before women into private decisions. For thousands of volunteers
won the right to vote. In the many women that move- have gathered millions of
century since then, Ameri- ment will restore or fortify signatures to put abortion
can women have steadily the freedom to choose. It rules to state referendums.
accumulated rights. In the could also, perhaps, sway The movement has
1960s the contraceptive the presidential election. already had success in
pill let women choose how Dobbs, the Supreme Court some surprising places,
many children they had. In decision that overturned such as Ohio and Kansas.
the 1970s no-fault divorce Roe, has been an own goal As many as 16 states could
laws and Roe v Wade gave for the anti-abortion hold abortion referen-
women more choices that movement. Surprisingly, dums on the same day
had been denied to their the number of abortions Americans will pick their
mothers. This progress has risen slightly since it next president.
seemed irreversible, and was announced. Though Only 24 of the 50 states
was often taken for grant- some states promptly allow citizen-led ballot
ed. Then, two years ago, banned the procedure, initiatives, so the patch-
the Supreme Court over- others made it easier to work of state campaigns is
turned Roe, throwing the obtain. Also, the federal a poor substitute for a fed-
question of allowing or drug regulator has eral law. But by the end of
disallowing abortion back allowed abortifacient pills 2024, if all the initiatives
to the states. It turns out to be prescribed by mail, make it onto a ballot, most
that rights can be taken giving millions of women American women of
away, too. (including some in an- reproductive age will have
A third of American ti-abortion states) easier had a chance to vote on
women aged 15-49 now access to early-term abortion since Dobbs. Flor-
live in states where abor- abortions than they had ida is crucial. It is the
tion is either illegal or im- before. However, for mil- third-most populous state
possibly restricted. Some lions of other women, get- and, until a strict ban
states have passed stat- ting a legal termination came into force in May, it
utes so severe and vague- has become much harder. was a place to which
ly drafted that doctors fear The result of the court’s many women came from
they may be forced to decision, then, has been to other states to seek termi-
choose between risking a assign people more or less nations, since the proce-
patient’s life—in the case choice depending on dure is illegal and sure to
of a dangerous miscar- where they live. remain so in much of the
riage or complicated Outrage has given rise to a South.
pregnancy—and risking grassroots political move- If the pro-choice move-
breaking the law. ment. It involves more ment’s only effect was on
30
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
American women’s health, vote for legal abor- This dynamic also explains
it would be worth taking tion—and for Mr Trump. why it took until two years
seriously. If it also helps Polls say that Mr Biden is ago to pass a federal
President Joe Biden win losing in the swing states. gay-marriage law, a
re-election, it will have That suggests voters can decade after Britain and
global consequences. separate their views on France had done so, and
Could the backlash abortion from their party also why states are going
against Dobbs keep the preference. If overall turn- their own way on marijua-
man whose judicial ap- out is high, abortion will na legalisation while Con-
pointments made it possi- matter less, because the gress dithers.
ble, Donald Trump, out of enthusiasm of pro-choice Sign here
the White House? voters will be drowned out. Thus, this new movement
Maybe. Few voters are If turnout is low they will shows a different side of
enthusiastic about Mr count for more, benefiting American politics. It is not
Biden. A mass movement Mr Biden. made up of keyboard war-
in support of a goal his For most of the world, the riors vying for attention
party shares ought to election is what matters: online, but of people giving
boost the turnout of Dem- billions are bracing for an- up their weekends and
ocrats. Abortion referen- other four years of Trumpi- evenings to try to per-
dums in Arizona and an fireworks. But for Ameri- suade their neighbours of
Nevada, two swing states, cans, it should be hearten- an idea they hold deeply. It
could spur marginal cen- ing that the pro-choice is participatory and local,
trist and left-leaning movement is tackling a the kind of thing that de
voters to make their way to central failure of American Tocqueville raved about
a polling station. Many politics. On many issues, after visiting the country
Americans believe the especially those related to back in 1831. It is how de-
economy is weaker than it the culture wars, American mocracy in America is
is and also blame the attitudes are little different supposed to work.
president for high prices, from those in other rich
so giving them an alterna- democracies, but federal Pakistan and the Global
tive reason to show up to lawmakers do a lousy job North’s Climate-linked
vote is helpful. In a tight of reflecting them. Most Trade Policy
race, even a modest boost Americans want abortion Published in The Diplomat
could be decisive, and to be legal early in a preg- Climate change has
abortion seems likely to nancy but illegal later on. become a harsh reality for
help the Biden campaign Yet extremist minorities in the world, with developing
more than it harms it. Congress block compro- economies at the epicen-
Yet the odds are still that it mise of this sort. So even if ter of its ruins. Historically,
won’t be enough. If Democrats were to win the developed countries in
pro-choice referendums presidency and both Europe and North America
pass, it will often be be- chambers of Congress in have contributed more to
cause pro-choice Repub- November (which is un- global temperature rise
licans, a group whose likely), they would still be than less developed coun-
opinions get squashed in unable to pass a national tries, yet it is the latter
their own party, showed up abortion law that aligns countries that are paying
to back them. Most will with public opinion. the heaviest price. A clas-
31
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
sic example was the 2022 te concern is the competi- origin. This raises ques-
climate-induced flash tiveness of its businesses tions about the ability of
floods Pakistan witnessed. on the international stage. Pakistani companies to
Adding fuel to this climate Without substantial measure, report, and verify
fire is the new wave of investment in sustainable emissions, and how car-
trade protectionism that and renewable energy, the bon-intensive their prod-
seems to be emerging, cost of products from ucts are compared to
with the European Union Pakistan’s export indus- competitors. Carbon pric-
and the United States at tries, especially those rely- ing could play a pivotal
the forefront of many of ing on coal-based power, role in Pakistan’s domestic
these energy conflicts. As will rise significantly over policies to mitigate these
Pakistan grapples with the next decade. This is challenges.
climate-induced disas- particularly critical as the Moreover, global consum-
ters, rising trade tensions EU, the largest bloc desti- er trends are shifting
are adversely impacting nation and second most toward sustainability, with
its efforts. However, these important trading partner a focus on reusing and
challenges posed by for Pakistan’s exports, is recycling textiles. EU
EU-U.S. climate-linked progressively using eco-design requirements
trade policies can also renewable energy as a are pushing for a reduc-
serve as crucial impera- trade barrier. tion in the environmental
tives for Pakistan to find an Initially targeting six sec- footprint of manufacturing
opportunity to move tors – cement, aluminum, processes, mandating
toward building climate hydrogen, iron and steel, exporters to establish sort-
resilience. fertilizer, and electricity – ing and recycling hubs,
The EU has begun phasing the CBAM will extend to all and to minimize the de-
in the Carbon Border Ad- industries, including tex- struction of unsold or
justment Mechanism tiles, which form the larg- returned textiles. Pakistani
(CBAM), which is a part of est portion of Pakistan’s exporters will need to dis-
the broader European exports. As the CBAM tran- close publicly the amount
Green Deal and the fit for sitions toward full imple- of product destruction and
55 plan. The CBAM aims to mentation, it is crucial for align their production with
prevent “carbon leakage” Pakistani exporters to un- dynamic consumer de-
by requiring companies derstand the timeline and mands.
importing goods into the potential obligations. Ac- While this market diversifi-
EU to report their emis- cording to the World cation could mitigate
sions. This mechanism, set Bank’s CBAM Exposure some losses, it risks leav-
to be fully implemented by Index, Pakistan’s exposure ing Pakistan behind in the
2026, applies to all coun- is moderate but notable, global trend toward sus-
tries, including the least especially compared to tainability, potentially hin-
developed ones, unlike the major exporters like India dering its green growth.
EU’s Everything but Arms and China. The stringent compliance
(EBA) scheme, which The carbon price payable costs for EU-based pro-
offered tariff and quo- to the EU will depend on ducers may also affect
ta-free access to imports the carbon content of them, creating a complex
from these nations. goods and the carbon dynamic that could pose
For Pakistan, the immedia- price in the country of significant risks for sustai-
32
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
nable economic develop- and tax credits are aimed can actually serve as a
ment in Pakistan; a perfect at U.S. domestic industries, catalyst for Pakistan to
recipe for the dependency leading to overproduction strengthen its climate
theory. of green technology in resilience. By leveraging
In order to stay competi- Europe and the United the pressures and incen-
tive and resilient, Pakistan States. This overproduc- tives presented by the
must balance its export tion in Global North could CBAM and IRA, Pakistan
strategies with robust lower green technology has a unique opportunity
investments in renewable prices, undermining the to revamp its climate poli-
energy and sustainable competitiveness of manu- cies, invest in sustainable
practices, but this is only facturing in Pakistan and practices, and align more
possible when the entire other developing nations. closely with global envi-
geopolitical situation is Additionally, the IRA could ronmental standards. This
understood. disrupt Pakistan’s export approach not only
The United States’ Inflation markets. As the U.S. and enhances Pakistan’s
Reduction Act (IRA), Europe ramp up their pro- export competitiveness
passed in 2022, has duction of green technolo- but also contributes to a
become a focal point in a gies, Pakistan may find it more sustainable and
transatlantic rift over elec- challenging to compete resilient economic future.
tric vehicles (EVs) and with the influx of cheaper, To navigate these chal-
green technology. This subsidized products. This lenges and seize the op-
policy, designed to boost situation is particularly portunities presented,
green technology and concerning for Pakistan’s Pakistan’s policymakers
climate investments manufacturing sector, must swiftly enact and
through tax credits and which may struggle to enforce targeted reforms
subsidies, aims for a 60 keep pace with the tech- to incentivize sustainable
percent carbon-free nological advancements practices and gain global
power sector by 2032. and cost reductions driven recognition and competi-
However, its emphasis on by IRA-supported initia- tiveness.
enhancing U.S. energy tives in the Global North. First, it is imperative to im-
security and domestic The EU’s unwavering com- plement fiscal and capac-
manufacturing has mitment to its green ity building measures. To
sparked international criti- agenda means limited encourage investments in
cism, particularly from concessions to interna- eco-friendly technologies
South Korea, Japan, and tional partners, which and processes, Pakistan
India, who are considering could increase trade dis- must implement fiscal
retaliatory protectionist putes and accusations of measures such as tax
measures. protectionism. This may incentives and subsidies.
For Pakistan, the IRA can drive Pakistan to seek These financial incentives
present significant chal- alternative markets with can significantly lower the
lenges to its energy transi- less stringent environ- barriers to adopting sus-
tion and participation in mental regulations, such tainable practices. Com-
the global green economy. as China, India, and the plementing this, capaci-
Like the CBAM, which sup- Middle East. ty-building initiatives are
ports EU’s domestic indus- However, these seemingly crucial. Training programs
tries, the IRA’s subsidies adverse circumstances focused on energy efficie-
33
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
ncy, waste management, And most importantly, will determine its ability to
and environmental stew- proactive engagement thrive in a rapidly chang-
ardship can empower and diplomatic efforts are ing global landscape. By
industry stakeholders, essential to negotiate embracing sustainability
equipping them with the favorable terms and and innovation, Pakistan
necessary knowledge and exemptions under CBAM can not only safeguard its
skills to implement and regulations. The EU and economic interests but
maintain sustainable U.S. play a pivotal role in also contribute meaning-
practices. supporting Pakistan’s fully to global climate
Next, leveraging pub- transition by extending resilience efforts.
lic-private partnerships is financial and technical
essential for marketing support, helping Pakistan The exponential growth of
sustainable Pakistani adopt greener technolo- solar power will change
products and processes gies and practices without the world
on an international scale. compromising economic Published in The Econo-
These collaborations can development. Moreover, mist
help enhance the global advocating for reforms It is 70 years since at&t’s
competitiveness of Paki- within international trade Bell Labs unveiled a new
stani industries. Strength- institutions, such as the technology for turning
ening negotiations for World Trade Organization sunlight into power. The
responsible contracting (WTO), to better integrate phone company hoped it
clauses between brands environmental sustain- could replace the batter-
and manufacturers can ability into trade rules is ies that run equipment in
also promote more sus- crucial. out-of-the-way places. It
tainable practices. By promoting policies that also realised that power-
Additionally, developing prioritize environmental ing devices with light
robust domestic waste protection and economic alone showed how sci-
management systems equity, and fostering part- ence could make the
and enhancing data nerships that enhance future seem wonderful;
gathering, reporting, and supply chain resilience hence a press event at
monitoring on key sustain- and sustainability, the which sunshine kept a toy
ability indicators, such as negative impacts of these Ferris wheel spinning
water, chemical con- climate policies on devel- round and round.
sumption, and carbon oping nations can be miti- Today solar power is long
emissions, are vital steps gated. Strengthening reg- past the toy phase. Panels
toward sustainability. Im- ulatory compliance and now occupy an area
proving compliance with enforcement mechanisms around half that of Wales,
the EU Corporate Sustain- is also imperative to and this year they will pro-
ability Due Diligence ensure adherence to envi- vide the world with about
Directive will further bol- ronmental standards, 6% of its electricity—which
ster Pakistan’s export po- safeguarding Pakistan’s is almost three times as
tential, ensuring the coun- export markets and pro- much electrical energy as
try can effectively navi- moting long-term sus- America consumed back
gate the complexities of tainable growth.Ultimate- in 1954. Yet this historic
new trade-linked climate ly, Pakistan’s response to growth is only the sec-
policies. these external pressures ond-most-remarkable
34
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
35
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
gas that come from un- with a boost to productivi- means for the world
stable or unfriendly parts ty. Anything that people Published in Arab News
of the world will be more use energy for today will In a profoundly unsettling
dependable. Still, although cost less—and that development that has
the Chinese Communist includes pretty much alarmed the international
Party cannot rig the price everything. Then come the community, Russian Presi-
of sunlight as opec tries to things cheap energy will dent Vladimir Putin and
rig that of oil, the fact that make possible. People North Korean leader Kim
a vital industry resides in a who could never afford to Jong Un have forged a for-
single hostile country is will start lighting their midable alliance. This
worrying. houses or driving a car. partnership was solidified
It is a concern that Ameri- Cheap energy can purify last week in Pyongyang,
ca feels keenly, which is water, and even desali- where the two leaders
why it has put tariffs on nate it. It can drive the signed a comprehensive
Chinese solar equipment. hungry machinery of arti- agreement that signifi-
However, because almost ficial intelligence. It can cantly escalated their col-
all the demand for solar make billions of homes laborative efforts against
panels still lies in the and offices more bearable Western powers.
future, the rest of the world in summers that will, for As reported by Russian
will have plenty of scope to decades to come, be get- state media, the agree-
get into the market. Amer- ting hotter. ment includes a pledge of
ica’s adoption of solar But it is the things that “mutual assistance” in the
energy could be frustrated nobody has yet thought of event of aggression
by a pro-fossil-fuel Trump that will be most conse- against either nation. In his
presidency, but only tem- quential. In its radical opening statement, Putin
porarily and painfully. It abundance, cheaper expressed profound grati-
could equally be energy will free the imagi- tude to Kim for North
enhanced if America nation, setting tiny Ferris Korea’s unwavering sup-
released pent up demand, wheels of the mind spin- port of Russia’s war in
by making it easier to ning with excitement and Ukraine. Putin’s very pres-
install panels on homes new possibilities. ence in Pyongyang, with
and to join the grid—the This week marks the his visit culminating in a
country has a terawatt of summer solstice in the marathon 11-hour dia-
new solar capacity waiting northern hemisphere. The logue, underscored the
to be connected. Carbon Sun rising to its highest seriousness with which the
prices would help, just as point in the sky will in de- two leaders regard this
they did in the switch from cades to come shine down burgeoning alliance.
coal to gas in the Europe- on a world where nobody Kim personally escorted
an Union. needs go without the Putin to his aircraft at
The aim should be for the blessings of electricity and Pyongyang airport, a ges-
virtuous circle of where the access to ture laden with symbolism
solar-power production to energy invigorates all and indicative of the new-
turn as fast as possible. those it touches. found solidarity between
That is because it offers them. Putin lauded the
the prize of cheaper What growing Rus- agreement as a monu-
energy. The benefits start sia-North Korea bond mental breakthrough, one
36
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
that signals an unprece- and the ongoing conflict in exacerbate the threat
dented level of coopera- Ukraine. posed by both nations and
tion. The potential for mili- Meanwhile, the North destabilize the delicate
tary-technical collabora- Korean regime’s nuclear balance of power in North-
tion with North Korea was ambitions and ballistic east Asia. Moreover, their
not explicitly ruled out, missile tests have further alliance serves as a stark
adding a sinister dimen- isolated the country on the reminder of their resilience
sion to the partnership. international stage. Under in the face of international
Both leaders framed this Kim’s leadership, North pressure and sanctions.
strengthened relationship Korea has conducted nu- Their ability to withstand
as a move toward peace merous missile launches, economic and political
on the Korean Peninsula, including intercontinental isolation and still forge
claiming that the pact was ballistic missiles capable powerful alliances indi-
purely defensive and of reaching the US. It has cates a troubling shift in
aimed at preserving their continued to develop its global dynamics.
nations’ sovereignty. “Re- nuclear weapons program In addition to military
lations between our two despite international cooperation, the partner-
nations have reached a sanctions and diplomatic ship could extend to other
new pinnacle of alliance,” pressure. strategic areas, including
Kim triumphantly declared This alliance heightens cyberwarfare, in which
at a joint press confer- regional tensions and both nations have shown
ence. poses a significant threat considerable capabilities.
The exact contours of this to global stability. The North Korea’s cyberat-
agreement remain mutual support clause in tacks, such as the 2014
shrouded in ambiguity. the agreement could lead Sony Pictures hack and
While it ostensibly involves to coordinated actions numerous attacks on
mutual support, it is un- that defy international financial institutions,
clear if this extends to po- norms and challenge the demonstrate its prowess
tential direct military inter- established global order. in this domain. A collabo-
ventions. Both countries For instance, Russia’s mili- ration with Russia, known
are already intertwined tary capabilities com- for its sophisticated cyber
thanks to the exchange of bined with North Korea’s operations against various
vital resources such as oil, advancements in nuclear countries, could increase
food and weaponry. technology could result in coordinated cyber threats.
The implications of this a powerful and unpredict- Furthermore, the econom-
pact are profoundly dis- able military partnership ic implications of this alli-
turbing. Russia’s demo- that threatens neighbor- ance cannot be over-
cratic institutions have ing countries and beyond. looked. Both countries,
been systematically dis- The potential for mili- facing sanctions and
mantled and dissent is tary-technical collabora- financial challenges,
silenced through impris- tion is particularly con- might leverage this part-
onment or assassination, cerning, given North nership to circumvent
while territorial expansion Korea’s ongoing develop- international restrictions.
has been aggressively ment of nuclear weapons North Korea’s ability to
pursued, as evidenced by and missile technology. provide labor and natural
the annexation of Crimea Such cooperation could resources, combined with
37
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
Russia’s technological and hold both countries ac- at home and abroad – as
industrial capabilities, countable for their viola- “naive”. But last week at
could lead to a mutually tions of international law is the G7 Summit in Apulia,
beneficial economic a crucial move. world leaders finally rec-
arrangement that under- An integrated strategy ognised that what is truly
mines the effectiveness of combining diplomatic, naive is to imagine that
international sanctions. economic, military and any strategy to end this
The international commu- informational tools, imple- horrific conflict can suc-
nity, led by the US, must mented with broad inter- ceed without people like
take decisive action to national cooperation, is us at the vanguard.
counter such a dangerous necessary to counter the Before this point, we had
partnership. Revitalizing threats the Russia-North grown used to being
diplomatic efforts to iso- Korea alliance poses, labelled “naive” for believ-
late Russia and North safeguarding global ing that more wars, pain,
Korea is essential, involv- peace and security. and loss won’t make any-
ing key players like China body secure or free. While
and India. Enhanced eco- When it comes to Isra- generals and militants
nomic sanctions targeting el-Palestine, true naivety who believe that one more
critical sectors and indi- is believing in endless war round of violence, and one
viduals will curb their ca- Published in Al Jazeera more generation of be-
pabilities. Strengthening We are an Israeli and a reaved and traumatised
military readiness through Palestinian who forged an people – after a century of
regional defense alliances “unlikely” friendship when nothing else but that, will
and joint exercises will also the world expected us to bring security or liberation
deter aggression. hate each other. – are feted as realists.
Cybersecurity measures One of us lost his parents Why, after so many years
should include robust on October 7, the other lost of this failed formula
international collabora- his brother in the first Inti- resulting in escalating vio-
tions and specific fada. It was this mutual lence, death and destruc-
countermeasures against loss, pain and shared tion, are its proponents not
cyber threats from these vision that brought us the ones branded as
nations. Intensifying hu- together. “naive” or worse?
manitarian and human We recognise that our loss, It is not naive to know that
rights initiatives can draw but also our friendship, is the only route to justice
global attention to the the result of the absence and equality is peace. The
situations in North Korea of peace. We’re unusual, route is straightforward.
and Russia. Also, restrict- but by no means unique. We must create hope
ing sensitive technology We are part of a commu- when hope is hard to find.
exports and developing nity of Israelis and Pales- We must amplify the
economic alternatives for tinians who have different voices of peacemakers.
nations dependent on nationalities, religions and We must show that we are
Russia and North Korea will narratives. But a shared not divided by nationality,
weaken their strategic po- identity: it’s called peace- ethnicity or race. We are
sitions. builder. divided by those who be-
Finally, utilizing interna- We have often been mar- lieve in justice, peace and
tional legal institutions to ginalised by many – both equality and those who
38
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
don’t – yet. ons to be the only lan- last week, the G7 released
Our plan includes letting guage spoken. We cannot their communique which
go of our bitterness, hate, stand by as thousands included unprecedented
and the desire for revenge. endure the same loss and new language prioritising
Both of us have embarked pain we have. Our voices civil society peacebuilding
on journeys of forgiveness. must be heard. We provide as a critical component of
Hatred is a corrosive force, an alternative vision for any diplomatic resolution
leaving one empty inside. this land from the river to to the Israeli-Palestinian
It breeds physical and the sea and know that it conflict.
emotional illness, with can be achieved within a Over the past month, we
nothing that can quench few years. joined the Alliance for
the thirst of such desire. We are fortunate to be Middle East Peace (ALL-
We’ve come to under- part of a community of MEP) in leading a global
stand that forgiveness, Israeli and Palestinian coalition united in calling
unlike reconciliation, is a peacebuilders – some of for this new approach
personal choice. It is a de- whom have experienced from the G7. The call,
cision we make not be- loss like us, all of whom are echoed by over 350 NGOs,
cause the perpetrators as earnestly committed as His Holiness Pope Francis,
deserve it, but because we we are – who have been members of the British
prioritise our shared hu- tirelessly working for a long and European parliaments
manity over animosity. We time. – was a simple one: do not
forgive because we refuse World leaders, who have, talk about peace without
to allow others to exploit for too long, allowed the those Palestinians and
our pain to justify harming status quo to fester from Israelis who have dedicat-
innocent individuals. afar, aware of the bub- ed their lives – as we have
While we are prepared to bling below the surface – to seeking peace.
forgive the past and pres- but distant enough to And, they listened. For the
ent, what we cannot for- ignore the smell of the first time in history, the G7
give is a bleak future smoke rising, would be released a communique
trapped in endless vio- naive to think that we can that centres on civil soci-
lence. We are not doomed return to conflict manage- ety peacebuilding and the
to an everlasting cycle of ment, provide weapons to vital work of local peace
violence. We believe that “keep the peace,” and NGOs, which are absolute-
we can alter our reality. build broken piers to feed ly crucial to help solve this
And it’s that hope that we the starving children. conflict.
hold onto every morning However – finally – this We want to thank these
and that gives us strength past week we saw a glim- leaders for, finally, doing
to achieve our mission. mer of hope. Hope that the the right thing. For finally
We are aware of the deaf- “free world” is finally listen- recognising the critical
ening language of bombs ing to us, and recognising role that grassroots
and the fear and anger on the urgency for new, inclu- organisations have to play
the streets. We are also sive ideas. in any long-term, sustain-
angry, but we transform After years of ignoring the able peace process.
our anger into a fuel for conflict, with four of the For making sure that
our activism. We cannot last five G7 communiques peace is not an after-
allow the sounds of weap- failing to mention it at all, thought. While every prev-
39
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
40
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
Modi will no longer be able in the way the Lower House climbing to a mere 52 in
to ride roughshod over his is run, with the BJP no 2019, winning 99 seats this
cabinet colleagues, chief longer able to silence op- time is a sign of a revival.
ministers, party members, position voices. Ahead of the elections, the
and indeed, the opposi- Modi will also have to Congress’s Rahul Gandhi
tion. make peace with the undertook two yatras –
He will have to adopt a Rashtriya Swayamsewak journeys – on foot across
more consensual ap- Sangh (RSS), from which it the length and breadth of
proach towards everyone, draws ideological inspira- the country. This helped to
and he will not, hopefully, tion. revive the base of an
be able to browbeat the In India, PM Narendra increasingly defunct party
bureaucracy or arm-twist Modi's alliance has and gave Gandhi the op-
those who head critical reached the 272-seat portunity to personally
institutions, such as the threshold to form a gov- convey his message to
investigative agencies, the ernment. However, his thousands of people.
judiciary and the Election Hindu Nationalist BJP party In the process, his person-
Commission. lost its outright majority, al popularity has risen. This
Modi will also have to heed falling far below its was evident in his con-
the wishes of his allies 400-seat target. vincing victories in both
from the Telugu Desam Political dynamics could the seats he contested –
Party (TDP), the Janata change if Modi's alliance Rae Bareli in Uttar Pradesh
Dal-United, and the two partners switch sides and Wayanad in Kerala.
splinter groups of the Shiv pic.twitter.com/7wl- Indeed, he has earned his
Sena and Nationalist Con- zAMm3ox spurs in this election and
gress Party, which have — TRT World (@trtworld) now has the stature of a
also aligned with the NDA. June 5, 2024 national leader.
Indeed, on June 5, less Its members traditionally The Congress and the
than 24 hours after the work for the BJP elections, regional parties that com-
results had come in, but this time, reports sug- prised the opposition INDIA
reports of the first gest that they have stayed bloc campaigned on a
post-election NDA meet- aloof in many places. BJP range of issues: they
ing indicated that the president JP Nadda made flagged economic dis-
allies had given their wish things worse when he said tress, caused by high un-
lists to Modi – the number in a recent interview: “In employment and rising
of ministerial berths as the beginning, we would prices, and the agricultural
well as the portfolios they have been less capable, crisis; they simultaneously
expected to be given. smaller and needed the highlighted the possibility
In addition, the TDP has RSS. Today, we have grown that if the BJP and its allies
demanded the post of Lok and we are capable. The crossed 400, as the party
Sabha Speaker, a powerful BJP runs itself.” had boasted, they might
constitutional functionary For the Congress that–af- amend the Constitution to
tasked with ensuring the ter leading a United Pro- end the system of quotas
smooth conduct of the gressive Alliance (UPA) for the Scheduled Castes,
lower House. government for a decade Tribes and Other Back-
If the last goes through, (2004-2014)–shrank to a ward Castes.
there will be a sea change paltry 44 seats in 2014 and Finally, they spoke of the
41
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
42
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
43
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
to serve the common Opinion polls now show wide is down to levels last
good. States like California that less than half of seen in 1985 — almost 40
are already leading the French voters see that as a years ago. According to
way. threat to democracy. In the report 71pc of the
the US, former president world’s population — 5.7
Ailing democracy Donald Trump is the billion people — live in au-
Published in Dawn front-runner in the presi- tocracies — an increase
AT a time when democra- dential election due in No- from 48pc 10 years ago.
cy across the world is vember. Barring any legal Similarly, the latest edition
under challenge, there impediment, he is poised of the Global State of De-
have recently been a to regain the presidency. mocracy 2023 report by
number of developments, In Britain, Nigel Farage’s the Stockholm-based
some that may shape its Reform party is expected International Institute for
future trajectory. Elections to make gains in next Democracy and Electoral
in India saw the BJP lose it month’s elections at the Assistance sees democra-
majority and its leader Na- expense of the Conserva- cies continuing to contract
rendra Modi cut down to tive party. globally with erosion in
size — a verdict widely The resurgence of the far checks and balances and
viewed as voters salvag- right in the West comes at constitutional freedoms in
ing India’s democracy a time when democracy is nominally democratic
from the authoritarian, au- already under threat states. It finds that for six
tocratic direction a popu- across the world. Demo- consecutive years “more
list demagogue was cratic regression is now a countries experienced net
taking the country in. India worldwide phenomenon. declines in democratic
may have started to buck Democratic backsliding processes than net im-
the global trend of demo- has been pervasive in provements”.
cratic erosion but else- countries facing challeng- Democratic weakening is
where developments have es from polarisation, intol- also the finding by the
reinforced this trend. erance, anti-minority sen- Economist Intelligence
Europe has just seen timent and toxic politics. Unit, which conducts an
far-right parties make This global trend has been annual survey of the
stunning gains in the Euro- recorded by many inter- health of democracy in 165
pean Parliament polls at national organisations. countries, assessing them
the cost of French Presi- In its annual Democracy across five measures. Its
dent Emmanuel Macron Report 2024, the Swedish report, published earlier
and German Chancellor V-Dem Institute finds de- this year, says conflict and
Olaf Scholz’s parties. mocracy has declined in polarisation have driven a
This prompted Macron to almost all regions of the new low for global democ-
call snap legislative elec- world with “the wave of racy. Its democracy index
tions in a high-stakes autocratisation” becom- shows less than 8pc of the
effort to contain Marine Le ing more pronounced. Its world’s population now
Pen’s National Rally party research shows a rollback reside in full democracies,
by turning it into a referen- of democratic rights and and that 39pc are under
dum on the far right. But institutions. It says the authoritarian rule — up
the spectre looms of Le level of democracy from 37pc in 2022. It desig-
Pen’s party winning power. enjoyed by citizens world- nates Pakistan as a coun-
44
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
45
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
46
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
which many observers see Many studies look at the th American Indigenous
as a warning on the secu- effect of climate change groups viewed fire as a
rity environment in Paki- on wildfires. However, this great assistance to land-
stan. study sought to under- scape management, the
“We need to improve stand the reverse — Europeans only saw it as a
security and the business whether large fires are destructive force that
environment. Security also changing the climate. needed to be avoided at
threats are the main haz- And it concluded, “It ap- all costs, and this led them
ards disturbing CPEC pears these fires are cre- to implement policies that
cooperation,” he ating their own fire weath- suppressed all fire. The
remarked. “As people er.” Therefore, facing a shift in attitude within the
often say, confidence is surge in wildfires, the US continent and suppression
more precious than gold. Government turned to of Indigenous culture
In the case of Pakistan, the native wisdom and ad- caused a significant loss in
primary factor shaking the vanced archaeology. After traditional fire knowledge
confidence of Chinese a sharp increase in un- and practices, leading to
investors is the security controllable wildfires ecological consequences
situation. Without security, across the northern U.S. and large wildfires. Red
the business environment, and Canada in recent de- pine forests, like those
the security of the country, cades, the Bureau of found in the Border Lakes
cannot really improve, Indian Affairs and the U.S. area, especially benefit
which may in turn under- Forest Service have been from this use of fire as their
mine the development in open to new approaches seeds require exposed soil
the long run,” he added. and ways to address the to grow. Moreover, a
This is perhaps for the first inherent weaknesses of greater balance between
time any Chinese leader their bureaucracies. Due woody and grassy/ her-
spoke publicly and frankly to their lack of historical baceous plants improves
about the dangers of the understanding of past fire food availability for live-
security situation under- management methods, stock, wildlife, and pollina-
mining Pakistan-China they turned to archaeolo- tors. Clearing dead or dry
cooperation. The message gists, who have collected vegetation in this manner
is loud and clear for Paki- information on more than also allows for fire-depen-
stan! 10,000 years of human ac- dent species and import-
tivity. For their approach, ant food sources to grow,
Burning Margalla these government agen- such as the blueberry in
Published in The Nation cies studied the perspec- the Great Lakes region.
Large-scale wildfires and tives and wisdom of Indig- Blueberries used to prolif-
increasing temperatures enous peoples offered erate in the region due to
are also a global phenom- through shared oral histo- fire-based interventions
enon now. A new study by ries. from the Ojibwe commu-
the University of California, The arrival of European nity, who cleared patches
Riverside shows that soot settlers to the North Amer- of the forest floor and
from large wildfires in Cali- ican continent brought made them conducive to
fornia traps sunlight, about a turning point in berry bush growth. In ad-
making days warmer and the relationship between dition, reducing the
drier than they ought to be people and fire. While Nor- amount of dry vegetation
47
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
48
4
CSS Chronicles Volume 3 | Edition 11
PHILOSOPHY
CORNER
49
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
NAYAB NOOR
Ibn Khaldun, born in 1332 in Tunis, is considered one of the most promi-
nent Arab scholars, renowned for his pioneering work in history, sociolo-
gy, economics, and philosophy. His most significant contribution lies in
his book, the "Muqaddimah" (Introduction), where he lays the foundation
for the philosophy of history and social science. Ibn Khaldun's thoughts
reflect a profound understanding of human society and the dynamics of
civilizations, offering insights that remain relevant even today.
50
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
51
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
Conclusion
Ibn Khaldun's philosophical thoughts reflect a profound and nuanced
understanding of human societies. His theories on 'Asabiyyah, the cycli-
cal nature of history, and the interplay between economics and society
provide a comprehensive framework for analyzing the rise and fall of civ-
ilizations. His emphasis on empirical observation and critical thinking
continues to inspire scholars and remains a testament to his enduring
legacy in the realms of history, sociology, and philosophy.
52
5
CSS Chronicles Volume 3 | Edition 11
WISDOM
ARCHIVES
11
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
SPACE DIPLOMACY
USMAN ALI AWAN
54
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
55
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
Ending Notes
Space diplomacy fosters a con-
versation between different belief
systems and utilizes their distinct
perspectives to address not just
immediate technological obsta-
cles but also enhance the philo-
sophical, ethical, and cultural
aspects of space travel. This holis-
tic strategy guarantees that when
mankind ventures into space, it
does so with a profound under-
standing that encompasses a
wide range of perspectives, po-
tentially discovering solutions in
ancient wisdom that modern sci-
ence alone may not conquer.
56
6
CSS Chronicles Volume 3 | Edition 11
QUOTES FOR
YOU!
11
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
WORDS OF WISDOM
COMPILED BY SANIA SALEEM
CLIMATE CHANGE
Benjamin Franklin
“For all the immediate challenges that we gather to address-- terror-
ism, instability, inequality, disease -- there’s one issue that will define
the contours of this century more dramatically than any other, and that
is the urgent and growing threat of a changing climate.”
58
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
“If there is any doubt about loss and damage — go to Pakistan. There is
loss. There is damage. The devastation of climate change is real. Paki-
stan’s climate carnage is beyond imagination.”
59
7
CSS Chronicles Volume 3 | Edition 11
SCREENING TEST
ALERT
ISLAMIC STUDIES
CURRENT AFFAIRS
PAKISTAN AFFAIRS
61
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
PAKISTAN AFFAIRS
62
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
CURRENT AFFAIRS
63
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
ISLAMIC STUDIES
A) Jibril (Gabriel)
1. Which Surah is called the heart of B) Mikail (Michael)
the Quran? C) Israfil (Raphael)
A) Surah Al-Baqarah D) Azrael (Angel of Death)
B) Surah Yaseen
C) Surah Al-Ikhlas
7. How many times is the word
D) Surah Al-Fatiha
'Zakat' mentioned in the Quran?
2. The first revelation to Prophet A) 25
Muhammad (PBUH) was in the B) 30
cave of: C) 32
A) Hira D) 35
B) Thawr
C) Uhud 8. What is the name of the
D) Arafat Islamic law derived from the
Quran and Hadith?
3. How many verses are there in A) Sharia
Surah Al-Fatiha? B) Fiqh
A) 5
C) Fatwa
B) 6
C) 7
D) Sunnah
D) 8
9. The Hijra (migration) of
4. Who was the first Caliph of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
Islam? from Makkah to Madinah took
A) Umar ibn al-Khattab place in which year of the
B) Uthman ibn Affan Islamic calendar?
C) Ali ibn Abi Talib A) 1 AH
D) Abu Bakr Siddiq B) 2 AH
C) 3 AH
5. The Battle of Badr was fought in D) 4 AH
the year:
A) 624 CE
B) 625 CE
10. Who compiled the first com-
C) 623 CE plete written version of the
D) 626 CE Quran?
A) Umar ibn al-Khattab
6. Which angel is responsible for B) Uthman ibn Affan
delivering revelations to proph- C) Ali ibn Abi Talib
ets? D) Abu Bakr Siddiq
64
VOLUME 4
JUNE EDITION
1 A B B
2 A A A
3 B C C
4 B B D
5 C D A
6 A C A
7 C C C
8 C D A
9 A A A
10 A A B
Gratitude is in style! A heartfelt thank you to all the dedicated CSS aspirants
whose unwavering support and enthusiasm have propelled us to launch
our 4th volume. Your passion for the craft fuels our journey, and we can't
wait to continue providing you with the latest trends, insights, and
inspiration in the world of CSS.
19
CSS Chronicles Volume 4 | Edition 12
WINNER
66
20