Introductions and Conclusions
Introductions and Conclusions
An introduction has two main purposes – to catch the reader’s interest and to
indicate the subject of the paper. It needs to perform both of these purposed
smoothly, as an awkward introduction will only confuse your reader. Be sure to
engage your reader as quickly as possible and to orient them to your attitude toward
your subject. Your introduction should draw your readers into your paper and
―convince‖ them to continue reading it.
Your introduction should also, of course, include your thesis statement, as well
as set out a “roadmap” for your reader. Your thesis statement, usually the last
sentence or two of the introduction, should be a clearly articulated statement
outlining the specific argument that the rest of your paper will develop. Be the time
your reader finishes reading your introduction, they should know what you are going
to argue and should have an understanding of how you are going to prove your
argument.
Do not think of your introduction as an ―umbrella‖ paragraph under which all other
points of your essay must fall. Rather, think of your introduction as a “doorway”
to the more involved analysis and evidence you provide in the rest of your
paper. Make sure that the points that you raise in your introduction relate directly to
the subject of your paper. This is not the place to make broad generalizations about
society, the world, human beings, etc
If you find writing your introduction difficult, try writing it last – sometimes it is
easier to write your introduction after you have written the body of your paper.
Often, an effective introduction will be easier to write after you have developed your
ideas during the course of writing the paper itself.
Take a look at five different conclusions that could grow from the same introduction. How
has the author maintained continuity and/or developed the argument from the introduction?
How was the author developed a focus over the course of the essay? What impression does
each conclusion leave you with as a reader?
Introduction
We all know that textbooks dry history out completely, dehydrating the gripping stories and critical conflicts
of the past to a dusty piece of history leather—tough, nasty, and hard to digest. As I reviewed three
accounts of expansion in the western United States, I found some signs of life in the desert; compared to
the texts I reviewed for our last adoption, the new textbooks offered more complete accounts and stronger
analysis of the interactions between settlers and Native Americans, race and gender dynamics in the west,
and the role of the federal government in all phases of western settlement. We have a much more palatable
assortment of facts for our students to chew on, but is it any more substantial? Here, I question which of
these texts will allow us to teach not just the facts but the skills—reading, writing, questioning, and thinking
critically—which we as a committee have decided should take precedence in our classes.
Question
Which of these texts is best? The colorful pictures and graphics, the clear prose, the primary documents all
have their appeal. But these tasty morsels distract us from asking the real question—what are we teaching
for? If we want our students to think like historians, then Land of the Free’s liberal use of primary
documents, the very same documents historians use to construct the past, makes it our best choice.
Quotation
To inspire critical thinking, we need materials that can help us move beyond the textbooks and engage our
students’ creativity. Of the three texts I reviewed, only Oh Say Can You See included a variety of
supplementary materials to spice up our classes, from primary documents and historical film clips to art
slides and CD-Roms. In short, the variety of extra resources makes this textbook our best option, for it
allows us the potential to revise John F. Kennedy’s famous plea, ―ask not what your textbook can do for you,
ask what you can do for your textbook.‖
Vivid Image
I remember what made history matter to me; as a high school student, I found the diary my grandmother
kept during the depression. I carried that little leather-bound book with me everywhere, poring over its
contents, seeking connections between my family’s past, my country’s past, and myself. If we want to
inspire our students to move from memorizing facts to developing an interest in history, I recommend A
More Perfect Union as our choice. This text’s attention to emotionally touching photographs and personal
stories of the west offers us the best hope of enabling our students to make a personal connection with the
past.