Display PDF

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

I

/
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD

TUESDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF IVARCH


TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO

PRESENT

SHARMA
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SATISH CHANDRA
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI

t.A.NO. 1 0F 2018|N/ AND W.A, NO: 275 OF 2018


r.A.NO.2 F20 18 IN/AND W .A.NO.276 0 F 2018
&
t.A .NO.4 0F 20 18IN/AND w.A.NO.278 oF 2018

wA NO.2 75 0F 2018
preferred against order dated
Writ Appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent
court'
z.a-oq-lol+in w.P No. 20287 o12013, on the file of the High

Between:
years-' Occ House Wife lt'4/s'
1 A. Sunitha, W/o. A. Mohan, Aged about 48Hitts, opp Peddamma Temple'
v;;;;;;brilders, Plot N".'ir6sfn' J,nitee
Hyderabad.
years, Occ House Wife M/s'
2. A. Teiasree, W/o A. Siva Giri sh Aqed about 27 Peddamma Temple'
Vamsiram Builders, Plot No. iios-"A,-Lrbilue Hilis, opp
Hyderabad.
-3. A. Savisree, D/o. A. Mohan, Aged about Hitts,22 vearc'peodamma
Occ Student M/s'
0;;"i#-ELirluir, Cr"i'i'ri,.'iids:A, Lroi opp remple'
Hyderabad.
58 years' Occ
-
4. G. Santhosh Reddy, S/o. G. Janardhan Reddy Aged about
B';ri;;, Mls.-viii,sil#-euiro-uisl Ftot No'' 11-oe-A' Jubilee Hills' opp
Peddamma TemPle, HYderabad'
5.M/s'VamsiRamBuilders,ApartnershipFirmhavinoitsofficeatFlatNo.60l, Hv*rabad^- 73'
Jvothi Estate, n.r.ro. s-a-i'r'd{tirirtr-,i.ioo.srinagir cotonv'
;#i;id"r',i;h;;i;; F;;;;-s'i. e. suor, Reddv,"S/o' B Gbpar Reddv' Aged
adouf +g years, ocb Business. ...Appe,ant#hir#arties
AND
50 years' Occ
P. Sudha Rani, W/o. Sri. P. Achyutha Ramaiah, Aged about
1

ir"iJJ'wii,llnLp uv r,"l. Gpn V.',iugendra Kumar, s/o Sri V'B R-ajendra


F/o. 102, surabhi Place, B-2-
ij;rr;;;"s-.jo ufuri 57 years, Busln!.ss,
erOTS/H, Hoad No. l4,Baniara Hills' Hyderabad'

2 I\,4r.G.Viiavanand,S/o.SriG.Venkatachary,Agedabout64years'Occ,
3!.i"C". 'Kiili;;b;i;;= s"-i."t Ltd., Resent ehambers' Nariman Point'
ffi;;;i zi, i6p.ov r,ii oiA v. vuseara KLlmar,go Sri V BPalace'B-2-
Rajendra
F;t;J. rg6o rno'ut 57 years, Busi"ness, R/o 102, Surabhi
bi675,[], H"j+r.ro. r+, 6anjiiJnitts, uvoeratad and.M srihari' S/o l\4JN
R;;, ;db, So*unigvi nrcJoe, noao t't'o' 1, Baniara Hills' Hvderabad - 34'
')

-
3. Smt. Vegulla Usha @ Usha Rani, W/o. Sri. V. Gopala Krishna Rao, Aged
about 62"years, OciHouse Wife, Rio. 102. Prasanth Towers, Srinivasa
Cot""v teitO, Hyderabad - 38, rep.by its GPA-V. Yugenta Kumar, S/o' Sri'
v.g. (aiendia Prasad, aqed about 52 years, Business, R/o 102, Surabhi
Palace,'8-2-316/3/H, Ro;d No. 14, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
4. Mr. G. Bhasker, S/o. Sri. G.V. Subbaiah, Aged about 55 years, Business, Rl'/o '

6-3-609/17, Ftai No.202, Prasanthi, Anand NagarColony, [hqlrtqbag'


Hvderabad, rep.by its GPA V. Yugendra Kumar, S/o. Sri. VE. Rajendra
piasaO, aged ibout 52 years, Business, Rl/o. 102, Surabhi Palace, B-2-
316/3/H, Road No. 14,Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
5. Mr. B. Harish Reddy, S/o. Sri. B. Laxma Reddy, Aged 39 years,.Business,
R/o. 48, Aditya ForlView, Near Puppalaguda Shivalayam, ft/anikonda,
Hyderabad.
6. Smt. l. Rajeswari, W/o. Sri. l. Raghava Rao-,-Age^d about 47 years, Occ
Housewifd, R/o. D.No. 8-3-960/1; Flat No. 201' Sneha Enclve, Srinagar
Colony, Hyderabad.
7. M. Srinivas, S/o. Lakshminaayana, Aged 52 years, Occ Business R/o -
iSego, Prestwick Cir. N. Northville, Ml-48168, llqA GpA V. Yugendra Kumar
Sio. Sii. V.B. Rajendra Prasad, aged 57 years, Business, R/o 102, Surabhi
ialace, B-2-316i3tH, Road No. l4,Baniara Hills, Hyderabad'
- T.
B. Narasimha Rao, S/o. T. Kodandaramaiah, Aged about 75 yeqr9, ^O-c9 . .

ausl;esi, R/o. 8'171, Lake Serene Drive, orlando, FL 32835, USA GPA v'
iuqend* Kumar, S/o. Sri v.B Rajendra Prasad, Aged about 52yrs,Occ
Buliness, R/o. 102, Surabhi Palace,8-2-316/3/H, Road No 14, Banjara Hills
Hyderabad.
9.
- M Sailesh, S/o. M.K. Viswandham, Aged, 38 years, Occ S-ervice, F/o,lOOr^.
Cnri.f iff Road, Chesters Springs, Pennsylva'nia-19425,USA' rep.by his GPA
M.k Vishwanadham, S/o. late ML Murthy, aged 64 yrs' occ Business, Ryo'
402, Jyothi Palace, Srinagar Colony,Hyderabad-78

... ResPondents/Writ Petitioners

1O.The State of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, (Revenue) Revenue


Department, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad.
11.The Special Officer and Competent Authority, Urban Land Ceiling
Department, Chandra Vihar, bpp Exhibition Ground, M.J. Road, Hyderabad'

...Respondents/SPofiEents

lA NO: 1 OF 2018

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
grant leave to the petitioners to file the Writ Appeal against the Order Dt'
28,4.2014 passed in W.P.No. 20287 of 20'1 3 without material papers filed by the
writ petitioners therein.
-l

lA NO: 3 OF 1E

; PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstated
pleased to
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be
.r.pLnJ order Dt. 28.4.2iil4 passed in W.P.No. 20287 ol 2013, till the disposal
of the writ apPeal.

Counsel for the Appellants: SRI P.VISHNUVARDHANA REDDY

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 9: Smt' A' ANASUYA

Counsel for the Respondent Nos'10 & 11: GP FOR REVENUE

WA NO: 276 OF 2018

writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent preferred against order dated
31-12-2013 in WP.No.23634 of 2009 on the file of the High Court'

Between:
Sunitha, Wio. A. lr,4ohan, Aged about 48 years, Occ House Wife
lV/s
1. A.
vamsiram Buitders, plot No 1109-A, Jubilee Hi1s. 6pilp"oo:ri-r,i iempre,
Hvderabad.
z' Siva Girish Aged about 27 years, occ. House wife M/s.
i]i""ir.L", W/o. A. proiruo.
Vr;a];;-briro"*, itosln Jubilee Hilis, opp Peddamma Temple'
Hyderabad.
g. A] Savisree, D/o. A. lr,4ohan, Aged about 22 years, Occ' Studert M/s'
" vr;;i;iliuitleis, Croi r.ro tioglR, Jubilee Hills,-opp Peddamma Temple'
Hvderabad
58 vears' occ'
' i]
4. S;;ir;;.h Reddy, S/o G Janardhan Reddv Aoed about
B;*";;.,t//s. Varisirari auiid-ets. Plot No.'1101-A, Jubilee-Hills' opp'
Peddarnma TemPle, HYderabad.
S Vi"Vamii nam guitdeis, A partnership Firm having its office at Flat No 601,
JVothi EState, H'No. 8.3-1 102, Flat No. 106' Srinagar Colony, Hy0era0ao.- /J'
;J;;;-rt;i;;rsins FirtneiSri. B. subba Reddv, S/o B Gopal Reddv' Ased
a6oui +9 years, Occ. Business.
.,.Appellants/Third Parties
AND

1 P. Viiava Jvothi, D/o. Dr. P. Muralinath Reddy, Rep'by her CpA *t pF


bonfiu'n#ii,vlo. oi. p. Muralinath Reddy' aled about 57 years,.F:/o -H, No'
e-i-zgsi1iiatlB, MLA's Colonv, Banjara-Hill-, Road No. 12, Hvderabad'
.. . ResPondenUWrit Petitioner

2 The State of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Revenue Department,


Secretariat, Hyderabad.
3 The Special Officer and Competent Authority, Urban Land Ceiling
Oepa-rimeni, CninOi, Vihar, bpp Exhibition-Ground, It/.J. Road, Hyderabad'

'..ResPondents/ResPonde nts
,+

;
lA NO: 2 OF 2018
in the circumstances stated in
petition under section 151 cpc praying that pleased to grant
in suppoii"t tn" ii[iJ"' ine"Hign-cour.t mav be
the affidavit filed Appear dg.r.t the order Dr.31
12'2013
reave to the petitioners ,"'tirl''ir,"'writ mJteriaL papers filed bv the writ
oassed in W.P.No zeoi+"ot''iOds'*th;'t
petitioners therein '

lA NO: 3 OF 2018
the circumstances stated in
petition under section 151 cpc praying, that in pleased to
flteo in suppJ; ;; il p"tition' int nlon Court mav be
the affidavit ''XIu i"vt i"'trri"g ttre writ ifpeal against the order Dt
condone the delav "'
Ir i?)ors pass"d in w P No' 23634 or 200e'
IAN O:4 OF 2018
stated in
petition under section 151 cpc praying. that, in the circumstances
i# p"[troi''-in" Hioh Court mav be pleased to
the affidavit filed in suppfii ;; disposal
susoend order Dt. 31 1'z;i;;;;"["in w.'p r'ro ziazq ot 200s' till the
of the writ aPpeal
REDDY
SRI P'VISHNUVARDHANA
Counsel for the Appellants:
SRI R'C'MiSHRA
Counsel for the Respondent No'1:
& 3: GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent Nos'2

WA NOI 278 OF 2018


order dated
under Clause 15 of the Letters- Patent preferred against
Writ Appeal or the Hish court'
li ]ii55ii ," w .i :"to:zoi-o{200e on tne rile
Between:
--
i I t t',iii^i ilt 33'1ft 3 :'d f'" ? ":'s}i"," I{3 #1s'
O,*+'1ft # A, Hsi ,'
{i, R

Hvderabad. "
,[|i1,i!f%n.Hj:;1,.,"11-31,,,"i,tef :,38i::'J[:%?f E?,!3['fi
"4'"'-S3,
HYderabad.
Aged .about 22 ye-a$ ' Occ' -
Student tr'4/s
3. A. D/o. A. Mohan,
nlrrtlopp Peddamma Temple'
Bu ilders, Plot No. 109-A, l'it"d
SaYisree' '1
Vamsiram

4 Sltj?i'i,l+ -"$lv:-?l:;Gij,il"1!1'B?"ii,11r,,1889o10.,]Y[f? 'fift!,1 3i3


-,,iFi}l".l M/s. Vamsiram
Business,
at No 60 1'
its o rrice at F
l:tlg
I

5 *il'J"J',!I|.:,.it;$.1"rhi q rJ'T
jlvitni E"i""'ti,, ri r.r o a s r r 6'{ g:
itX ;gd i:l f : Alf ry; #li"JA : i : i J"l
16o.bv its Managing Padn€
adoui +9 years' occ Business
Parties
"'Appellants/Third
5

AND
about 76 years, occ. Advocate, Fl/o
1 R.C . Ir/isra, S/o. late Dr.J.P. Misra, Aged
H,N o. 5-o-itz, Hyderguda. HYderabad
... ResPondenUWrit Petitioner

Secretary' Revenue Department'


2 The State of Telangana, Rep'by its Principal
Secretariat, HYderabad
3 The Soecial Officer & Competent
Authority' Urban Land Ceiling' Chandra
Vihar,'M.J. Road, HYderabad
...Respondents/ResPondents

IA NO: 20 F 2018
in
praying that. in the circumstances stated
Petition under Section 15'1 CPC
the affidavit filed in suppJn "i ih-"
p"[ti"'t ih" High Court mav be pleased to
suspend order Dt. sr.rz.z6is"pa;I"i-in
w p No ' ziott of 2009' till the disposal
of the writ aPPeal

lA NOi 30F 2018

praying that.,in the circumstances stated in


Petition under Section 151 CPC
ir'u Higr' court may be pleased to
the affidavit filed in suppJn "i ir'" p"iti"t' writ ippeal against the order Dt.
condone the delay ot r +os iuv, ,
tiri"g ri-re
\\.li..zotz p".t"d in w P No 22077 of 2009'
lA NO: 4 oF 2018
praying that in the circumstances stated in
Petition under Section 51 CPC
'1

court may be preased to grant


the affidavit filed in suppori"tin" p"titr".,it'',u-Hign
igainst the Order Dt. 31 12 2013
teave to the petitioners .'fifl''if.r""WiiiRppeat
passed in W.P.No 22077 ;f without material papers filed by the writ
petitioners therein 'oO9
Counsel for the Appellants: SRI P'VISHNUVARDHAN
REDDY
ct
Counsel for the Respondent No'1: SRI V' JAGAPATHI
REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent Nos'2 & 3: GP FOR
JUDGMENT
The Court delivered the following: COMMON
1-

THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUS TICE SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA


AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHIN AND KUMAR SHAVILI

I.A.No.1 of 2O18 In/And W.A.No.275 of 2O18.


I.A.No.2 of 2018 In/And 1[I.A.No.276 of 2O18 &
I"A.No.4 of 2O18 In/And W.A.No,278 of 2O18

COMMON JUDGMENT, tPer the Hothte t"e Clue./Jrsrrce Salish Chandra Sharmal

Regard being had to the controversy involved in the


\
\ aforesaid cases, they were heard together and are being decided

by a common order.

The facts of W.A.No.275 of 2018 are reproduced as

under:-

The present writ appeal is arising out of the order dated

28.04.2014 passed by the learned Single Judge in


W.P.No.20287 of 2013.

The facts of the case reveal that the writ petitioners came

up before this Court being aggrieved by the orders passed under

the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, stating that the
proceedings were initiated against a dead person and in those
€i*
circumstances, the writ petition has been allowed. Now a writ

appeal has been preferred by certain persons claiming interest

in the same land.


In the considered opinion of this Court, title dispute
cannot be decided in writ appeal and therefore, liberty is
)

granted to take recourse to the other civil remedies available

under the law.

With the aforesaid, the present writ appeals and the leave

petitions stand disposed of.

Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand


closed. There shall be no order as to costs.

SD/.B.S.CHIRANJEEVI
JOINT REGISTRAR
// TRUE COPY //
SECTIO FFI CER

-o High Court for the State


of Telangana [oUT]
',. ,*o CCs to the GP for Revenue'
i3. il;66i" s' ry:ylfji[ti[:ill#t"3i""
One CC to Smt'A Ar
toPUC]

t. 3ffi 33 i::l n.:,U":,.1'i;,'#:,1"3"tt,


6. Two C.D CoPies
7. One SPare CoPY'
MRC
A.-

3*
HIGH COURT

DATED: 2910312022

1t Z ST41

k

\
COMMON JUDGMENT
3 13 JUL 2022
'h
I

(e,
|.A.NO.1 OF 2018 IN/AND W.A. NO: 275 OF 2018,
.OtSc? -i r..\ ,,11.)
I.A.NO.2 0F 2018 tN/AND W.A.NO.276 0F 2018 &
t.A.NO.4 0F 2018 rN/AND W.A.NO.278 0F 2018 i,l'

,EP

DISPOSING OF ALL THE lAs & WAs


WITHOUT COSTS

b
oA />
1 \:\o''

You might also like