LSP Study-Final 29.3.16
LSP Study-Final 29.3.16
Abstract: This study paper describes the mechanism by which lightning is generated
and the ways by which high voltages produced by lightning discharges find their way
into instrumentation and communications systems. Detailed analysis on lightning and
surges occurring in Telecom Network and methods for providing protection from
lightning and surges to minimize losses/damages have been dealt in the paper.
When it comes to losses of electrical and electronic equipment, few events can
match the destruction caused by lightning and surges (transients). Since
microprocessor-based equipment functions with faster operating speeds and lower
operating voltage than other equipment, surges and electrical noise classified as
nonthreatening are significantly more damaging.
A Telecom Service provider can greatly reduce its risk of equipment damage,
component degradation and system disruptions with a robust surge protection system.
An electrical transient is a short duration, high energy impulse that is imparted on the
normal electrical power system whenever there is a sudden change in the electrical
circuit. The surges can originate from a variety of sources, both internal and external
to a network. The most obvious source is from lightning, but surges can also come
from normal utility switching operations, unintentional grounding of electrical
conductors (such as when an overhead power line falls to the ground).
The sky is filled with electric charge. In a calm sky, the positive (+) and negative (-)
charges are evenly spaced throughout the atmosphere. Therefore, a calm sky has a
neutral charge.
1
attracted to this stepped leader, so a flow of positive charge moves into the air. When
the stepped leader and the positive charge from the earth meet, a strong electric
current carries positive charge up into the cloud. This electric current is known as the
return stroke and humans can see it as lightning.
The current which moves upward causing heating effect on the atmosphere
produces the violent air expansion which is known as thunder clap. The initial leader
stroke and main return stroke are generally followed by subsequent leaders and return
strokes in rapid succession. Up to 42 strokes have been recorded as forming one
discharge. Strokes spacing is in tens of milliseconds and, physically, each follows the
initial leader track unless heavy winds or other disturbances can move the channel.
Lightning discharges rarely consists of one stroke only, although human eye runs
together multiple strokes into one persistent image.
Most of the ground strokes are negative strokes with respect to ground. When positive
strokes do occur, they are usually at the end of the active life of a particular
thundercloud, and a single stroke may discharge the whole of the upper positive cloud
charge centre in a stroke of exceptional severity
3.2 Direct Lightning strikes: The direct lightning strike is the phenomenon
occurring during the air-ground or ground-air discharge of static electricity. Direct
lightning strike is called, the encounter between a downward leader and the upward
leader from a natural seed. To protect direct lightning strokes, it is necessary to
achieve protection against Lightning Outdoor Installation (IEPF) with a thunderbolt
sensor i.e. the lightning rod. This is the first result of a lightning strike by the advantage
of the speed of light on other phenomena. Along the path plotters, overheated and
ionized gases form conducting plasma, which causes the emission of light is observed
2
and which is called "flash". The color of this flash depends on factors such as current
density, the viewing distance and the various particles present in the path of the tracer.
(i) The resistivity of the crossed materials is put into games. We witness these
materials to deformation, broken away, destruction, explosions.
(ii) The proximity of metallic masses next to the descents drivers creates the
passage of lightning current, major efforts by the magnetic phenomenon of
attraction / repulsion generated.
(iv) The electrical nature of the phenomenon and soil resistivity causes propagation
concentric waves of the lightning current into the ground and on the surface.
The mounted potential of surrounding masses causes significant currents,
where dangerous power lifts from the metal frames submitted.
(v) On current dissipation in soil, a phenomenon called step voltage can occur on
living beings. It causes burns, respiratory arrest, cardiac arrest. It is due to the
spread of currents by contact being on the floor.
3.4 Indirect lightning strike: The indirect lightning strike is the result of a direct
lightning strike unchecked. The resulting indirect lightning strike is called direct
lightning strike whose flow is not controlled. While lightning current, the path would not
be well channeled, can borrow any totally random way to reach the earth in its path
3
generating potential arcing (sparking). Surge (induced effects) appear between arrival
outside power lines and the equi-potential system of land structure. These surges
"penetrate" inwardly of the propagation structure (along the lines). Materials called
Arresters are used and placed on the grid for this Protection.
4.0 The Lightning risks: The study of the phenomenon highlights 3 large families of
risks from lightning strikes:
4.1 Risks due to Direct lightning strike: The main feature of direct lightning strike
is the flow of a huge electric current circulating in the matter causing extensive damage
to structures.
4.2 Risks due to Indirect lightning strikes: The power electric currents involved
causes induced phenomena and electromagnetic fields that cause the destruction of
electrical and electronic equipment.
4
4.3 Risks due to Conduction phenomena: During a lightning strike on the
ground, we see that the electric charges are dissipated in the ground and create a rise
of electric potential. The potential difference (voltage) between two given points in the
ground or surface will allow current flow.
5.0 Lightning protection (Direct and Indirect): The basic principle for protection of
an installation against the risk of lightning strikes is to prevent the disturbing energy
from reaching sensitive equipment. To achieve this, it is necessary to:
Capture the lightning current and channel it to earth via the most direct path
(avoiding the vicinity of sensitive equipment);
Perform equi-potential bonding of the installation; This equi-potential bonding is
implemented by bonding conductors, supplemented by Surge Protection Devices
(SPDs) or spark gaps (e.g., antenna mast spark gap).
Minimize induced and indirect effects by installing SPDs and/or filters: Two
protection systems are used to eliminate or limit over-voltages: they are known as
the building protection system (for the outside of buildings) and the electrical
installation protection system (for the inside of buildings).
5.1 Lightning protection system:
The role of the building protection system is to protect it against direct lightning
strokes. The system consists of:
5
5.2 Building Protection Systems: Three types of building protections are used
6
iii) The lightning conductor with meshed cage (Faraday cage)
This protection involves placing numerous down conductors/tapes symmetrically all
around the building. (see Fig. 6). This type of lightning protection system is used for
highly exposed buildings housing very sensitive installations such as computer rooms.
As a consequence, the building protection system does not protect the electrical
installation: it is therefore compulsory to provide for an electrical installation protection
system 50% of the lightning current discharged by the building protection system rises
back into the earthing networks of the electrical installation (see Fig. 7): the potential
rise of the frames very frequently exceeds the insulation withstand capability of the
conductors in the various networks (LV, telecommunications, video cable, etc.).
Moreover, the flow of current through the down-conductors generates induced over
voltages in the electrical installation.
7
The main objective of the electrical installation protection system is to limit over-
voltages to values that are acceptable for the equipment. The electrical installation
protection system consists of:
8
6.0 Surges: If lightning strikes on or near overhead electric power or telephone line, a
large current will be injected into or induced in the wires, and the current can do
considerable damage both to the power and telecommunications equipment and to
anything else that is connected to the system. Surges can have many effects on
equipment, ranging from no detectable effect to complete destruction … electronic
devices can have their operation upset before hard failure occurs. The semiconductor
junctions of electronic devices are particularly susceptible to progressive deterioration;
few solid state devices can tolerate much more than twice their normal rating.
Furthermore, data processing equipment can be affected by fast changes in voltage
with relatively small amplitude compared to the hardware-damaging over-voltages. For
large surge currents, this diversion is best accomplished in several stages. The first
diversion should be performed at the entrance to the building … a second protective
device at the power panel.
These are some of the most prominently featured specifications which define a surge
protector for AC mains, as well as for some data communications protection
applications.
6.2 Primary components: Systems used to reduce or limit high voltage surges
can include one or more of the following types of electronic components:
The first six methods listed operate primarily by diverting unwanted surge energy away
from the protected load, through a protective component connected in a parallel (or
shunted) topology.
The last two methods also block unwanted energy by using a protective component
connected in series with the power feed to the protected load, and additionally may
shunt the unwanted energy like the earlier systems.
i) Metal oxide varistor (MOV): A metal oxide varistor consists of a bulk semiconductor
material (typically sintered granular zinc oxide) that can conduct large currents
(effectively short-circuits) when presented with a voltage above its rated voltage.
MOVs typically limit voltages to about 3 to 4 times the normal circuit voltage by
9
diverting surge current elsewhere than the protected load. MOVs may be connected
in parallel to increase current capability and life expectancy, providing they are
matched sets (unmatched MOVs have a tolerance of approximately ±20% on voltage
ratings, which is not sufficient).
A TVS diode is a type of Zener diode, also called an avalanche diode or silicon
avalanche diode (SAD), which can limit voltage spikes. These components provide
the fastest limiting action of protective components (theoretically in picoseconds), but
have a relatively low energy absorbing capability. Voltages can be clamped to less
than twice the normal operation voltage. If current impulses remain within the device
ratings, life expectancy is exceptionally long. If component ratings are exceeded, the
diode may fail as a permanent short circuit; in such cases, protection to their relatively
limited current capacity, TVS diodes are often restricted to circuits with smaller current
spikes.
10
v) Carbon block spark gap overvoltage suppressor
A telephone network connection point with spark-gap overvoltage suppressors. The
two brass hex-head objects on the left cover the suppressors, which act to short
overvoltage on the tip or ring lines to ground.
A spark gap is one of the oldest protective electrical technologies still found in
telephone circuits, having been developed in the nineteenth century. A carbon rod
electrode is held with an insulator at a specific distance from a second electrode. The
gap dimension determines the voltage at which a spark will jump between the two
parts and short to ground. The typical spacing for telephone applications in North
America is 0.076 mm (0.003").[29] Carbon block suppressors are similar to gas
arrestors (GDTs) but with the two electrodes exposed to the air, so their behavior is
affected by the surrounding atmosphere, especially the humidity. Since their operation
produces an open spark, these devices should never be installed where an explosive
atmosphere may develop.
Series Mode (SM) surge suppressors devices are not rated in joules because they
operate differently from the earlier suppressors, and they do not depend on materials
that inherently wear out during repeated surges. SM suppressors are primarily used
to control transient voltage surges on electrical power feeds to protected devices. They
are essentially heavy-duty low-pass filters connected so that they allow 50/60 Hz line
voltages through to the load, while blocking and diverting higher frequencies. This type
of suppressor differs from others by using banks of inductors, capacitors and resistors
that suppress voltage surges and in rush current to the neutral wire, whereas other
designs shunt to the ground wire. Surges are not diverted but actually suppressed.
The inductors slow down the energy. Since the inductor in series with the circuit path
11
slows the current spike, the peak surge energy is spread out in the time domain and
harmlessly absorbed and slowly released from a capacitor bank.
Experimental results show that most surge energies occur at under 100 Joules, so
exceeding the SM design parameters is unlikely. SM suppressors do not present a fire
risk should the absorbed energy exceed design limits of the dielectric material of the
components because the surge energy is also limited via arc-over to ground during
lightning strikes, leaving a surge remnant that often does not exceed a theoretical
maximum (such as 6000 V at 3000 A with a modeled shape of 8 x 20 microsecond
waveform specified by IEEE/ANSI C62.41). Because SM work on both the current rise
and the voltage rise, they can safely operate in the worst surge environments.
SM suppression focuses its protective philosophy on a power supply input, but offers
nothing to protect against surges appearing between the input of an SM device and
data lines, such as antennae, telephone or LAN connections, or multiple such devices
cascaded and linked to the primary devices. This is because they do not divert surge
energy to the ground line. Data transmission requires the ground line to be clean in
order to be used as a reference point. In this design philosophy, such events are
already protected against by the SM device before the power supply. NIST reports that
"Sending them [surges] down the drain of a grounding conductor only makes them
reappear within a microsecond about 200 meters away on some other conductor." So
having protection on a data transmission line is only required if surges are diverted to
the ground line.
In comparison to devices relying on 10 cent components that operate only briefly (such
as MOVs or GDTs), SM devices tend to be bulkier and heavier than those simpler
spike shunting components. The initial costs of SM filters are higher, typically 130 USD
and up, but a long service life can be expected if they are used properly. In-field
installation costs can be higher, since SM devices are installed in series with the power
feed, requiring the feed to be cut and reconnected.
Specifications:
Clamping voltage: This specifies what spike voltage will cause the protective
components inside a surge protector to divert unwanted energy from the protected
line. A lower clamping voltage indicates better protection, but can sometimes result in
a shorter life expectancy for the overall protective system.
Joules rating: This number defines how much energy an MOV-based surge protector
can theoretically absorb in a single event, without failure. Counter-intuitively, a lower
number may indicate longer life expectancy if the device can divert more energy
elsewhere and thus absorb less energy. In other words, a protective device offering a
lower clamping voltage while diverting the same surge current will cause more of the
surge energy to be dissipated elsewhere in that current's path.
12
Response time: Surge protectors don't operate instantaneously; a slight delay exists.
The longer the response time, the longer the connected equipment will be exposed to
the surge. However, surges don't happen instantly either. Surges usually take around
a few microseconds to reach their peak voltage, and a surge protector with a
nanosecond response time would kick in fast enough to suppress the most damaging
portion of the spike.
• Test levels 0.5 kV, 1.0 kV, 2.0 kV, 4.0 kV and X kV
• Test circuit and waveform 1.2/50 µs at 2 Ω
• Telecommunication lines are exposed to lightning either directly on the
equipment or due to induced effect because of ground potential change.
• In addition to these surges, a telecommunication line may also be disturbed by
either power induction or power contact with main AC lines. Depending on the
country, these surges have been mainly modeled in:
Telecordia GR-1089
• Telecordia GR-1089 core for America with 2/10 µs and 10/1000 µs surge
ITU K.20 and .21: Series for the rest of the world with 10/700 µs surges
• K20
• Test levels 1.0 kV, 1.5 kV, 4.0 kV, 6.0 kV along = 25 Ω resistance
• Test circuit and waveform 10/700 µs
• TIA-968-A/B
• UL/EN/IEC 60950-1
• UL497B
• YD/T-950-based on ITU K.20
• YD/T-993-based on ITU K.21
8.0 Difference between lightning protection and surge protection: The lightning
and surge protection are hardware protection against lightning with different
functionalities to the phenomenon of the lightning strike.
13
-Direct lightning strike and lightning protection vs Indirect lightning strike and
surge protection
3 The lightning conductor has the The arrester has the function to
function of capturing lightning avoid surges in the network it
strikes are susceptible directly protects.
hitting the structure it protects.
National and international product safety standards and guidelines are created to:
• Reduce risks to human health and safety.
• Improve the quality of manufactured goods and services.
• Promote interoperability, making it possible for equipment from one vendor to
function efficiently in coordination with equipment from other vendors.
• Improve the efficiency of constructing and equipping industrial, medical, and
commercial facilities.
• Result in consistent products and reliable manufacturing and safety processes.
• Improve environmental protection where standards compliant products are installed.
14
9. Electrical Ground System: An electrical ground system may be described as a
system in which at least one conductor or point is intentionally grounded to the earth
in a manner that limits the voltage imposed by lightning, line surges, or unintentional
contact with a higher voltage line and will act to stabilize the voltage to earth during
normal operation. The importance of designing and testing electrical ground systems
includes:
15
Fig 9 Safety is Prime Concern
Types of Grounding
Lightning Protection Grounding
Static Protection Grounding
AC System Grounding
Equipment Grounding
DC System Grounding
Noise Grounding
EMI/RFI Grounding
Earth Grounding
16
Figure 10: Sphere of Influence
Conclusion: These surges can also enter the premises via internet cable and
telecommunications lines. However, numerous studies have shown that exterior
sources account for only 20 percent of all electrical surges. The remaining 80 percent
can be accounted for by culprits within a network. Known sources of transients and
noise within a building or network include everyday things such as fax machines,
copiers, air conditioners, elevators, motors/ pumps, or arc welders, to name a few. In
each case, the normal electric circuit is suddenly exposed to a large dose of energy
that can adversely affect the equipment being supplied power.
Although surges and electrical noise can’t be totally eliminated, they can be mitigated
through an engineered approach, thereby reducing their damaging effect. This leads
to greater reliability and overall improved productivity. In this regard, surge protection
really is an inexpensive form of electrical system insurance.
17