Socail Stratification and Differentiation
Socail Stratification and Differentiation
Socail Stratification and Differentiation
Piachaud (2009): Argues that different causes of inequality within the UK include large
differences between people in terms of inherited wealth, education and access to the labour
market.
Status The amount of social standing somebody has. If someone is well thought of by
their community and peers, then they have a high social status.
Social stratification:
The idea that societies are divided into hierarchies.
The are made of ‘strata’ (layers).
Life chances: Opportunities that people have In their lives. Including: income, wealth,
education, health and quality of life.
Social class refers to the economic position you are in: occupation and income.
Marxists believe that your social class is ascribed because social stratification exists.
They argue that the proletariat are in a bad position and cannot move up the strata
because the barriers put by the bourgeoise, making the system closed.
Functionalists believe your social class is achieved. This is because they believe in
social mobility, the ability to move up the strata. If you work hard and get a good
education then you will have a better social class. Therefore, they say we live In an
open meritocratic system where social class can change.
Is Social mobility a myth?
Sociologists measure class in two ways:
One advantage is that this covers the whole adult population, including the unemployed.
Social mobility:
Refers to the movement of individuals or groups in social position over time.
Inter = Within a family (if a child has a different occupational classification than
their parents.
Sociologists:
Durkheim:
Inequality motivates people to want the top positions and these positions
must look desirable.
Top positions must be scarce and valued in society.
High status, generous salaries, bonuses and rewards motivate people to work
hard.
A system of inequality is necessary to attract talented people to the top and
rewards are given in a way that deemed fair.
EVALUATION:
Inequality has become bigger (migration, less opportunities, more people have
same jobs)
Marxists argue that capitalism makes inequality necessary because it socialises
us to be greedy.
Marxists also argue that the W/C work hard so why don’t they move up?
Ignores power and status (particularly ascribed status).
Murray:
Get rid of benefits as it encourages perverse incentives.
It creates poverty and an underclass which is even worse for society.
Saunders:
Best way to organise society is to have unequal rewards.
Middle class had the best occupations as they were naturally clever and
worked harder.
EVALUATION:
New right ignores positives of alternative family types.
Cutting benefits would lead to more poverty.
Not everyone on benefits is lazy
Capitalist society:
Weber and stratification:
Absolute poverty:
Income is insufficient to obtain the minimum things needed to survive.
Have access to basic necessities such as enough food, water, shelter, heating and clothing.
Globalisation:
The interconnectedness of society – countries, nations are brought together.
This includes internet, travelling transnationally and the global media.
Globalisation has only had positive effects on poverty. Do you agree? (9)
Positive Negative
The global trade had bought the work closer It has damaged job security - migration
together – boosts economy
This includes companies from all over the world Multinational companies have more people to
(more shops = more jobs) choose from and can easily move to another
country – No Job security
Children in the UK have a wider variety of food – Big companies want to pay lower wages and give
tackles material deprivation workers less rights which can lead to
unemployment and poverty.
International trade has flourished – boosts
economy
4 Features of poverty:
2. Cycle of deprivation
Poor Poorly
Educational Qualified
Achievement Adults
Poor
Health
Outcomes
Poor Poor
Educational Educational
Achievement Achievement
3. Welfare dependency
The state in which a person or household is reliant on government welfare benefits for their income for a prolonged
period time, and without which they would not be able to meet the expenses of daily living.
The poverty trap is a mechanism which makes it very difficult for people to escape poverty.
A poverty trap is created when an economic system requires a significant number of various forms of
capital in order to earn enough to escape poverty.
When individuals lack this capital, they may also find it difficult to acquire it, creating a self-reinforcing
cycle of poverty.
In order to escape the poverty trap, individuals in poverty must be given sufficient aid so that they can
gain the critical amount of capital necessary to raise/get out themselves out of poverty.
If those in poverty do not acquire the critical amount of capital, then they will simply remain/stay
dependent on aid indefinitely and regress if aid is ended.
The underclass:
Some sociologists argue that the poor are to blame for their poverty because of their culture. Do you agree? (9)
Marxism Agree:
Marx predicted inequality would get worse- and it has.
Rising crime levels of the underclass is a form of rebellion against capitalism.
It puts for the social justice view that the rich don’t deserve anything and the poor have nothing.
Marxism Disagree:
Some people are happy not to work and get benefits.
The revolution has not happened as Marx said it would. Therefore, their theory is inaccurate
It ignores other areas such as ethnicity and gender.
CLASS:
50% of lone parent families are on low-income families.
W/C are at a higher risk of poverty.
They perform less in education and have to find a secure well-paid job employment.
Initiative for fiscal studies reported in 2015 that families on middle incomes were now living like poor
people had lived in the past.
Wages are so low that W/C people might find themselves in poverty, when they are at work.
Functionalists argue that low wages are needed to kick start the economy.
Low wages mean that businesses can make profits, the low wages help society grow richer, but take time
for everyone to benefit.
Marxists argue that greed pushes poverty rates up. Rich get richer, Poor get poorer.
Age: Gender:
Women are more likely to live longer (around The average hourly earnings for men in 2006 was
5-6 years more) £11.71
Elderly people are more likely to be in The average hourly earnings for women in 2006
poverty as they retire and rely on pensions, was £10.24
which are being hit by cuts. Gap = £1.47 and this adds up
According to Big issue – ‘Material Yearly on average the difference is £3439.8
deprivation’ increased between 2014 and Men get best high paying jobs – patriarchy.
2020, including for another 140,000 children.
This means that around 1.7 million children SOCIOLOGIST: Miller:
total are forced to go without essentials. Points out that the 2 groups with the highest risk
and longest duration of poverty are lone mothers
Ethnicity: and older women living alone.
The EM group that is most likely to experience Women have a higher LE than men and are less
poverty is Pakistani. likely to have an occupational pension (but have
Examples: Language barriers, lack of jobs, state pension)
unemployment, migration and etc… Women are more likely to lead lone parent
The EM group that is least like to experience poverty families.
is Chinese.
Over 50% of LPF’s in the UK are on low incomes.
They don’t value: frivolous spending, they save up,
are educated and have different viewpoints on Women are more likely then women to work
things. part-time.
People living in UK households headed by someone
from a minority ethnic group are at risk of living in Feminists:
low-income households. Feminists argue that the reason why women are
in poverty is linked to patriarchy.
Lister (2004) Peter Townsend identified different groups of
Racism and discrimination are key factors in their female poor including pensioners living alone,
poverty levels. This is because they are generally lone mothers, low-income paid mothers and
disadvantaged in terms of unemployment pay and those whose main role was childcare.
quality of their job
They are also likely to have a low uptake of welfare
benefits, which they are entitled to.
Disability:
Ethnic pay gap: A factor which affects the chances of falling into
Some ethnic groups suffer from poverty & racism poverty
may result in discrimination hard to find a job and The Joseph Rowntree foundation found in 2015
quality work. that less than half of the disabled population
A 2016 report form the Joseph Rowntree are working, yet many more would like to work.
Foundation found that ethnic groups were up to Even when they had higher qualifications, they
twice as likely to live in poverty compared with were likely to be in low-paid jobs.
white people in the UK. It also found an ethnic pay
gap (on average 26%) and lower-paid occupations.
Who is likely to experience poverty?
The PSE (Poverty & Social Exclusion) survey found that poverty is higher among some
groups such as:
Households with no paid workers.
Families with children under 11.
Those who left school aged 16 or under.
Contemporary:
Today more than 1 in 5 of the population (22%, around 14.5 million people) are in
poverty.
8.1 million are working-age adults, 4.3 million = children and 2.1 million =
pensioners.
Agbeto (2006) Stated that black people were stereotyped into sport, entertainment
or crime.
Institutional racism:
Discrimination or unequal treatment on the basis of membership of a
particular ethnic group, arising from systems, structures or expectations that
have become established within an institution or organisation.
Most of the time it is indirect.
TONY SEWELL:
Generating genius programme – removed all racism and had 25 black boys in it and they achieved
amazing results.
At least 3 made it to Oxford and Cambridge.
The nursing times in 2015 argued that EM experience worse health life chances.
These are mainly linked to poverty.
In a British social attitudes survey from 2013, 30% of British people described themselves as
racially prejudice, which may factor into mental health also.
EM 15-50% more likely to die from covid.
Black people were more than twice as likely to die from covid than white people.
However:
EM’s are 2 and a half times more likely to be unemployed than White people
More likely to have an insecure job and inconsistent income.
Even when they had degrees. They earned 23.1% less on average.
THE ETHNIC PAY GAP: The difference in the average pay between staff from EM in a workforce compared to
white staff.
Legislation:
1976 Race relations act: Outlawed direct discrimination, indirect discrimination and victimization.
The Race relations amendment act 2000 was aimed at improving institutions and practices.
The establishment of the Commission for racial equality became the Equality and human rights
commission. Stated that the acknowledge that institutional racism within organisations such as the
MET police must be addressed.
2010 Equality Act aimed to bring together legislation to improve life chances.
However:
1963 - 1972 immigration laws made it hard for ‘non-white’ people to enter country.
The Terrorism act of 2000 gave police power to arrest suspects of terrorism without a warrant and
keep them in jail for 4 days – maximum 14 days.
Sexuality and inequality: Media:
Moonlight 2006 – Film about a young
Sexuality = Who you are attracted to. African American man grappling with
Transgender = Someone that feels the gender they are his identity and sexuality whilst
experiencing everyday struggles of
born into is wrong.
childhood, adolescence, & burgeoning
adulthood. Won 3 Oscars incl 1 for
Homophobia: best picture in 2017.
Fear of homosexuals.
Being prejudiced against people because of their sexuality The Danish Girl- 2015 – based on the
novel by David Ebserhose was a
The conservative and liberal democrats’ government in fictionalised account of the true story
2010 decided there would be 2 million pounds put into of Lili tube, one of the 1st trans women
HBT training on bullying and the use of derogatory to undergo gender reassignment
language in school. surgery.
New right:
Believe the modern attitudes towards homosexuality has gone against the traditional views on the family.
Religion has become less significant.
Heterosexual families are the best for society as a whole.
Have social norms changed?
1960s and 1970s gay men were treated as criminals.
Many kept it a secret like Alan Turing.
Unemployment:
Media: In 2007, 31% Of disabled adults
Often unrepresented between the age of 25 and retirement
Lucy Wood in Disability Planet in 2012 found 2% age were unemployed.
of media workers were disabled compared to A disabled adult is 2x as likely to be in
19% of who are registered being of working age. poverty than a non-disabled adult.
Colin Barnes found that they are often shown as
being isolated or unable to take part. Marxism:
Sometimes even as evil.. They are not valuable to the economy
therefore are treated as such.
Media and moral panics: They do not support capitalism.
Former CBeebies presenter Cerrie Burnell The social model of disability would
Faced calls from viewers of the BBC kids show to cost money that the economy doesn’t
cover up her stump and it was scaring the have to spend.
children.
9 people went to the length of lodging official Legislation:
complaints with the broadcaster. Disability Discrimination act 1996
Media creates moral panic relating to disabled Equality Act 2010.
people and their benefits
Benefit fraud: They are disabled to claim Key terms:
benefits.
Social inclusion: The attempt to meet the
needs of groups that may feel left out of
society and include all people fully in society.
making ramps, toilets etc.
Childhood
A hate crime Sociologist of somebodies
is a discrimination What they said Disabled people may feel this: Lack of
protected characteristics, e.g., sexuality, ethnicity, toilet facilities, lack of equipment, labelled,
gender and disability. It breaks the equality act of not given jobs, ramps, left out of sports etc…
2010, and you can be imprisoned as it is illegal.
Philippe Aries (1960) Argues that in the middle ages the idea of childhood did not exist, and children
were not seen as having a different nature from adults.
Edward Shorter (1975) High death rates encouraged indifference and neglect towards infants.
It was not unusual for parents to give a new-born baby the name of a recently d
sibling.
Postman (1994) Argues that childhood is disappearing at a dazzling speed. He identifies that chi
are now entitled to the same rights as adults.
Palmer (2006) Childhood is becoming toxic because of the medial and fast food.
Supported by the international youth tables: UK ranked highly for obesity, self-
harm, drug/alcohol abuse, violence and teenage pregnancy.
Childhood now:
1. The amount of time spent with children by parents has doubled since the
1960s.
2. Children welfare is of paramount importance.
3. Parents take more of an interest in their child’s lives and activities e.g.
sports days, graduations, parents evening and induction days.
Mods and Rockers – the original case study of Hoodies – a modern moral panic
labelling by the media On the 11th May 2005 they were banned
Hoodie became a symbol of delinquiency
Young people and Gang crime – why are Zero Hour contracts – used to exploit young
moral panics a lie? people
Stanley Cohen:
Deviancy amplification: When the media exaggerate the deviant behaviours
Moral panic – The process by which one social issue is made bigger by the media.
Folk devil – The group labelled as the cause of the social problem.
Youth and employment, the latest report form the Institution for public policy
research (IPPR):
868000 out of work 16- to 24-year-olds
247,000 have been looking for more than a year.
About 700000 young people have never had a job.
Love
Inequality beer
in the workplace: Only pretty
Inequality girls get prince
in education:
The glass ceiling: 1. In 2013 UCAS women are 1/3 more likely to enter
Invisible barrier preventing advancement (pay and higher education.
role). 2. In 2013 more women than men were accepted into
Worldwide, women hold 1 in 4 SL roles. English universities 134,097 women vs. 110,630 men.
12% of CEO’s are women. 3. Men and women achieve the same first-class honours.
When men do work in the same occupation, 4. Women achieve 9% more upper second- or higher-
women are more likely to be in the lower or class degrees.
middle level jobs, but men tend to have senior 5. In GCSES girls outperform boys by 73% to 64%
management jobs.