Urban and Slum
Urban and Slum
Urban and Slum
M.A. SOCIOLOGY,
IV SEMESTER
All rights reserved. No part of this publication which is material protected by this copyright notice
may be reproduced or transmitted or utilized or stored in any form or by any means now known or
hereinafter invented, electronic, digital or mechanical, including photocopying, scanning, recording
or by any information storage or retrieval system, without prior written permission from the
Alagappa University, Karaikudi, Tamil Nadu.
SYLLABI – BOOK MAPPING TABLE
34943 A - URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Syllabi Mapping in
Book
BLOCK I: URBAN COMMUNITY: MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS, CITY -
MEANING, CLASSIFICATION, URBANIZATION & URBANISM
UNIT I Pages 1-5
Urban Community: meaning, characteristics, rural urban linkages
and contrast
UNIT II Pages 6-14
City - meaning, classification, trends in urbanization process
UNIT III Pages 15-25
Urbanization & Urbanism: meaning, theories of urbanization,
characteristics of urbanism
BLOCK II: SLUMS – DEFINITION, APPROACHES, URBAN
PROBLEMS AND URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
UNIT IV Pages 26-42
Slums – definition, approaches, theories and classification and
culture of slums
UNIT V Pages 43-60
Urban problems: housing, drug addiction, juvenile delinquency,
prostitution, and pollution.
UNIT VI Pages 61-68
Urban Community Development: definition, concept,
objectives and historical background
BLOCK III: APPROACHES, PRINCIPLES PROCESS AND METHODS OF URBAN
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
ADMINISTRATION
UNIT VII Pages 69-83
Approaches, principles process and methods of urban community
development, welfare extension projects of central social welfare
board, urban development planning.
UNIT VIII Pages 84-93
Legislation Related To Urban Development: urban land ceiling
act, town and country planning act, nagarpalika act and Tamil
Nadu slum clearance and improvement act) community planning,
and community participation
UNIT IX Pages 94-105
Urban Development Administration: national, state and local
levels; structure and functions of urban development agencies
BLCOK IV: URBAN SERVICES AND URBAN DEFICIENCIES, ROLE OF
VOLUNTARY AGENCIES IN URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, URBAN
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMMES
UNIT X Pages 106-114
Urban services and urban deficiencies; metropolitan development
authorities, Housing and Urban Development Corporation
(HUDCO) and United Nations Centre for Human Settlement
(UNCHS); housing board.
UNIT XI Pages 115-118
Role of voluntary agencies in urban community development
UNIT XII Pages 119-128
Urban Development Programmes: five year plans and urban
development; Madras Urban Development Projects (MUDP) I & II
BLOCK V: TAMIL NADU URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT, TAMIL NADU
SLUM AREA ACT 1971
UNIT XIII Pages 129-135
Tamil Nadu Urban Development project (TNUDP); Urban Basic
Services Programmes (UBSP), Nehru Rozgar Yojana (NRY), etc.
UNIT XIV Pages 136-156
Tamil Nadu Slum Area (clearance and improvement) Act 1971,
and problems in implementation of urban community development
programmes; role of development worker – application of social
work methods in urban development.
CONTENTS
BLOCK I: URBAN COMMUNITY: MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS,
CITY - MEANING, CLASSIFICATION, URBANIZATION &
URBANISM
UNIT- I URBAN COMMUNITY: MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS, 1-5
RURAL URBAN LINKAGES AND CONTRAST
1.0 Introduction
1.1 Urban Community
1.1.1 Meaning
1.1.2 Characteristics
1.1.3 Rural and Urban Linkages and Contrast
1.2 Let us Sum Up
1.3 Check Your Progress
1.4 Answer to Check Your Progress
1.5 Suggested Readings
UNIT- II CITY - MEANING, CLASSIFICATION, TRENDS IN 6-14
URBANIZATION PROCESS
2.0 Introduction
2.1 City
2.2 Meaning
2.3 Classifications
2.4 Trends in Urbanization Process
2.5 Let us Sum Up
2.6 Check Your Progress
2.7 Answer to Check Your Progress
2.8 Suggested Readings
UNIT-III URBANIZATION & URBANISM: MEANING, THEORIES 15-25
OF URBANIZATION, CHARACTERISTICS OF URBANISM
3.0 Introduction
3.1 Urbanization & Urbanism
3.1.1 Meaning
3.1.2 Theories of urbanization
3.1.3 Characteristics of Urbanism
3.2 Let us Sum Up
3.3 Check Your Progress
3.4 Answer to Check Your Progress
3.5 Suggested Readings
BLOCK II: SLUMS – DEFINITION, APPROACHES, URBAN
PROBLEMS AND URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
UNIT - IV SLUMS 26-42
4.0 Introduction
4.1 Slums
4.2 Definition
4.3 Approaches
4.4 Theories and classification
4.5 Culture of slums
4.5 Let us Sum Up
4.7 Check Your Progress
4.8 Answer to Check Your Progress
4.9 Suggested Readings
UNIT – V URBAN PROBLEMS 43-60
5.0 Introduction
5.1 Urban problems
5.2 Housing
5.3 Drug addiction,
5.4 Juvenile delinquency
5.5 Prostitution
5.6 Pollution
5.7 Lets Sum Up
5.8 Check Your Progress
5.9 Answer to Check Your Progress
5.10 Suggested Readings
UNIT- VI URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 61-68
DEFINITION, CONCEPT, OBJECTIVES AND HISTORICAL
BACKGROUND
6.1 Introduction
6.2 Urban Community Development
6.3 Definition
6.4 Concept
6.5 Objectives
6.6 Historical background
6.7 Lets Sum Up
6.8 Check Your Progress
6.9 Answer to Check Your Progress
6.10 Suggested Readings
BLOCK III APPROACHES, PRINCIPLES PROCESS AND METHODS
OF URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND URBAN
DEVELOPMENT ADMINISTRATION
UNIT -VII APPROACHES 69-83
7.1 Introduction
7.2 Approaches
7.3 Principles
7.4 Process
7.5 Methods of urban community development,
7.6 Welfare extension projects of central social welfare board,
7.7 Urban development planning
7.8 Lets Sum Up
7.9 Check Your Progress
7.10 Answer to Check Your Progress
7.11 Suggested Readings
NOTES
MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS, CITY -
MEANING, CLASSIFICATION,
URBANIZATION & URBANISM
UNIT I URBAN COMMUNITY:
MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS,
RURAL URBAN LINKAGES AND
CONTRAST
Structure
1.0 Introduction
1.1 Urban Community
1.1.1 Meaning
1.1.2 Characteristics
1.1.3 Rural and Urban Linkages and Contrast
1.2 Let us Sum Up
1.3 Check Your Progress
1.4 Answer to Check Your Progress
1.5 Suggested Readings
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The World is urbanizing very fast and more than 45 per cent of the World‘s
population today is residing in urban areas. According to UN estimation, the
Wold population is expected to increase by 72 percent by 2050, from 3.6
billion in 2011 to 6.3 billion in 2050.Customarily urbanization means
increasing population living in cities and suburbs cities of a country. In 19th
and 20th century, majority of the cities in the world are undergoing growth of
urban population. In India also urban population which was 0.37 percent in
1951 has risen to 27.81 percent in 2001 and 31.16 percent in 2011 and is
increasing day by day. According to Asian Development Bank, the national
increase and net migration are the major contributory factors to urban growth.
The share of world‘s population living in urban areas has increased from 39
percent in 1980 to 48 percent in 2000. However, urbanization without proper
planning has given rise to several problems such as housing, sanitation,
education, provision of safe drinking water, unemployment, etc. particularly
in underdeveloped countries. This unit on ―Urban Community : Meaning and
Characteristics ‖ will provide you information and knowledge regarding
Urban Community, its trends, impact and idea about sustainable urban
development. After reading this unit, you will be able to:
1.1.1 MEANING
Urban and Urbane are both derived from the Latin word Urbanus meaning
"belonging to a city" and these were once synonymous in meaning. Urbane
was borrowed first, from the old French term urbain, and it preserves the
French pattern of stress. Subsequently, Urban was borrowed directly from
Latin word urbanus. Urbane conveys the meaning of being "specialized,
refined, polite or elegant". These desirable qualities were considered to be the
characteristic of urban rather than country folk. Urban refers to a city or town,
which is directly opposite to village or country. A resident of a village is
known as a folk and of a city is known as an Urbanite.
1.1.2 CHARACTERISTICS
Definition of urban area: In the Census of India 201 1, the definition of urban
area adopted is as follows: a) All statutory places with a municipality,
corporation, cantonment board or notified town area committee, etc.; b) A
place satisfying the following criteria: Population is more than 5000. 75% of
the male population engaged in non-agricultural occupations. A density of
population of at least 400 per sq. km.
___________________________________________________________
Manohar).
Khan, Iqtidar Alam, (1976) ‗The Middle Classes in the Mughal Empire‘,
Social Scientist, Vol. 5, No. 1, August.
5 Self-Instructional Material
City
NOTES
UNIT II CITY - MEANING,
CLASSIFICATION, TRENDS IN
URBANIZATION PROCESS
Structure
2.0 Introduction
2.1 City
2.2 Meaning
2.3 Classifications
2.4 Trends in Urbanization Process
2.5 Let us Sum Up
2.6 Check Your Progress
2.7 Answer to Check Your Progress
2.8 Suggested Readings
2.0 INTRODUCTION
Cities have challenged human imagination ever since they came into existence.
From the smallest to the largest, the earliest to the latest, cities have been the
greatest points of concentration of humans and their social relationships. We
wish to enquire about the Indian experience of urbanism. We shall begin with a
study of the origin of urban centres. 'This will be followed by brief descriptions
of cities in ancient, medieval and modern India. Urban centres emerged in
ancient lndia around 2500 BC.
The impressive ruins of cities like Harappa and Mohenjodaro are a mute
testimony to this remarkable development. However, we have not been able to
decipher their script. So, our understanding of the structure of urbanism is
limited. We do not know whether the rulers of Harappa were traders, priests or
warriors. That is why we intend to take up the study of a city from the sixth
century BC usually referred to as the period of second urbanization.
For the study of city in ancient lndia we shall focus on Ujjain, a city located in
the state presently known as Madhya Pradesh. This will be followed by a case
study of Shahjahanabad i.e., old Delhi. For the modern period we shall study
the structure of the city of Kolkata, the modern capital of West Bengal. These
case studies are presented to show the similarities as well as the dissimilarities
in their structure.
2.1 CITY
Since the mid-nineteenth century, cities have been naturally associated with
modernity. Indeed, the main prisms through which the making of the ‗modern‘
has been viewed – whether it is industrial capitalism, bureaucratic rationality
or ‗governmentality‘ – have frequently focused on the city as a primary site.
By the turn of the twentieth century, there emerged other kinds of association
betweenmodernity and the city. The spectacular capital cities of Western
Europe such as London,Paris, Berlin, Vienna and Stockholm and New York
in the USA – stood forth as symbolsof urban modernity. Many of these cities
were reconstructed (e.g. ‗Paris‘, with urbanspace recreated ‗as a visual
spectacle, opening up the monumental vista whilesimultaneously rendering
the city a site of consumption, of window-shopping,promenading and
surveillance.‘ (Gunn, 2006: 123)
Urban modernity was, however, not merely reflected in the built form of the
city or its governance. The city also became a site for novel forms of urban
interaction and sociability made possible by the emergence and consolidation
of a new domain mediating between state and society: what is broadly
referred to as the ‗public sphere‘. Equally, the unprecedented density of
people, technologies, commodities, institutions and information within cities
generated new encounters and experiments, both individual and collective,
that were distinctively ‗modern‘. And, as the nineteenth-century French
romantic poet Charles Baudelaire was quick to grasp, many of the
fundamental aspirations and anxieties associated with modernity were most
intensely experienced in the city.
These forms and ideals of urban modernity came to be adopted in many parts
of the globe during the age of ‗imperial globalization‘ presided over by
Europeans. Cities across the colonial world took their spatial, technological
and social cues from the imperial West. However, as a growing body of
scholarship has begun to show, they also developed in ways that were not
prefigured by the experience of the metropolitan contexts.
2.2 MEANING
A city is a large human settlement. It can be defined as a permanent and
7 Self-Instructional Material
City densely settled place with administratively defined boundaries whose
members work primarily on non-agricultural tasks. Cities generally have
NOTES extensive systems for housing, transportation, sanitation, utilities, land use,
and communication. Their density facilitates interaction between people,
government organisations and businesses, sometimes benefiting different
parties in the process, such as improving efficiency of goods and service
distribution. This concentration also can have significant negative
consequences, such as forming urban heat islands, concentrating pollution,
and stressing water supplies and other resources.
Other important traits of cities besides population include the capital status
and relative continued occupation of the city. For example, country capitals
such as Abu Dhabi, Beijing, Berlin, Cairo, London, Moscow, Paris, Rome,
Seoul, Tokyo, and Washington D.C. reflect their nation's identity. Some
historic capitals, such as Kyoto, maintain their reflection of cultural identity
even without modern capital status. Religious holy sites offer another
example of capital status within a religion, Jerusalem, Mecca, and Varanasi
each hold significance. The cities of Faiyum, Damascus, and Argos are
among those laying claim to the longest continual inhabitation. In terms of
relative age, the oldest cities in the Americas are Cholula near Puebla, Florés
in Petén, and Acoma near Albuquerque, while the oldest capital cities in the
Americas are Mexico City, Santo Domingo, and San Juan.
2.3 CLASSIFICATIONS
There are very few sociological terms on whose definition experts agree. The
concept of the city is no exception. In defining the city we encounter
numerous problems which are known to all sociologists. Mumford (1948)
also mentions this fact in his article on City: Forms and Functions in
International Encyclopedia of Social Sciences, he writes "Although the city as
a form of human settlement dates back to the beginnings of civilisation, it
long escaped scholarly scrutiny; and its very definition is still under debate.
Levi - Strauss's attack on the ambiguities of "totemism" would apply equally
to the term "city" but with less justification, since the city has undergone
many changes without losing its architectural and institutional continuity."
Everybody seems to know what a city is but no one has given a satisfactory
definition. Since English lacks a neat vocabulary to distinguish the succession
Self-Instructional Material
8
of urban forms from embryo to adult, their purely quantitative aspect is best City
rendered in German: Dorf, Kleinstadt, Mittelstadt , Grosstade, Millionenstadt.
In English, eopolis, polis, metropolis, megalopolis, and conurbation have NOTES
been proposed as equivalent series, with regional city and regional urban grid
as possible emergent forms (Mumford ibid. ).
Like many other sociological categories, the city is at1 abstraction, but the
elements of which it consists-residents, structures, means of transportation,
installations, and so on - are concrete entities of varying nature. What makes a
city is the functional integration of its elements into a whole (Bergel, 955).
Yet a city has not merely a single function but rather an assortment of many
functions and not all of them are present in every city. These may vary from
city to city and time to time. There are different ways to define city such as
legal, statistical, density, occupation, sociological and economical. Let us
discuss all of them in detail one by one.
The city in many countries has been defined in legal terms. A place is legally
made a city by a declaration, called a charter, which is granted by a higher
authority. In India the State Government has the responsibility of sranting
municipal/civic status to a settlement or notifying it as a town. Such towns are
known as statutory towns. The procedure is very clear but the bases of
identification are not uniform across the states and extremely unsatisfactory.
It is an explanation ex post facto. A place is not a city because it has received
a charter; the grant of the charter is recognition that it has become a city. The
definition disregards the fact that many eastern cities have never had a charter
and that in the West the legal distinction between cities and rural places
evolved at a rather late date.
Statistical Basis
Basis of Occupation
The census of India has defined urban /town by combining legal, population,
occupation and density, which is clear from the definition given below:
There was wide gap in the level of urbanization between the more
developed regions, which had 72.7 per cent of the population as urban
population, and the less developed regions, with only 33.9 per cent of
urban population. Among the continents Europe, Oceania and Latin
America had a very high level of urbanization with 73.1, 70.9 and 72.3
per cent of their population as urban population respectively. In contrast,
Africa with 34.5 per cent of its population as urban population and Asia
with only 29.9 per cent of its population as urban population were the
least urbanized among the continents. Again, among the Asian regions
Western Asia is more urbanized (with 58.2 per cent of itspopulation
living in urban areas) than Eastern Asia (29.4 per cent), Southeastern
Asia (29 per cent) and South Asia (27.8 per cent) (for details see Mitra,
1994: 48). Thus South Asia, of which India is a part, is one of the least
urbanized regions of the world.
11 Self-Instructional Material
City According to 1991 census only 25.72 per cent of India‘s population was
living in urban areas, which again is less than the South Asian standard.
NOTES
The annual growth rate of urban population in India has declined from 3.1 per
cent during 1981-91 to 2.7 per cent during 1991-2001. The decade 1971-81
had recoded the highest annual growth rate of 3.8 per cent but the last two
decades have recorded decelerating growth rates in India. The percentage of
urban population has gone up from 23.73 in 1981 to 25.72 in 1991 and finally
to 27.78 in 2001. The slow growth of urban population in India goes against
popular notions of ―urban explosion‖ and against the most expert predictions.
The Planning Commission (1983), the Expert Committee for Population
Projections for the Eighth Plan, and the UN Study of World Urbanization
Prospects (1995, 2001) had predicted 3 – 4.4 per cent annual growth of urban
population in the 1980s and 1990s. The UN projection of 3.2 per cent growth
during 2000-10 and 2.8 per cent during 2020-25 also seem to be unrealistic.
Keeping in view that the growth rate of total population is expected to be less
than 1 per cent according to UN projection it would require a very high rate
of rural-urban migration to meet the projected level of urbanization.
Available data suggest that natural increase accounted for 61.3 per cent and
59.4 per cent of the total increase in urban population in 1971-81 and 1981-91
decades respectively.
Judging the current trend it is projected that by 2015 around 40 per cent of
India‘s population would be living in urban areas and a large majority of this
population would inhabit the large cities. At present nearly 38 per cent of
total urban population is considered poor and about 35 per cent live in slums.
About 44 per cent of urban families manage with one room, between 70 and
80 lakh urban population are homeless; 52 per cent of urban population do
not have access to healthy sanitation; only about 24 per cent own sanitary
latrines; a large section of urban population does not have access to safe
drinking water; every year environmental pollution hands over untimely
death to about 40,000 urbanites. When there is an estimated need of twenty
thousand crore rupees to provide the minimum urban amenities to its people
the Indian Government is downsizing the budgetary allocation for urban
development. In 1951 the budgetary allocation for urban development was 8
per cent but in 2005 it has been reduced to 2.6 per cent (Bhattacharya, 2005:
56-83)
2. The city in many countries has been defined in legal terms. A place is legally
13 Self-Instructional Material
City made a city by a declaration, called a charter, which is granted by a higher
authority. In India the State Government has the responsibility of sranting
NOTES municipal/civic status to a settlement or notifying it as a town. Such towns are
known as statutory towns. The procedure is very clear but the bases of
identification are not uniform across the states and extremely unsatisfactory.
It is an explanation ex post facto. A place is not a city because it has received
a charter; the grant of the charter is recognition that it has become a city. The
definition disregards the fact that many eastern cities have never had a charter
and that in the West the legal distinction between cities and rural places
evolved at a rather late date.
10. Kabeer, Naila 2001, Bangladesh Women Workers and Labour Market
Decisions: The Right to Choose, New Delhi: Vistaar Publications/ Sage.
Self-Instructional Material
14
Urbanization & Urbanism
UNIT III : URBANIZATION & NOTES
URBANISM: MEANING, THEORIES OF
URBANIZATION, CHARACTERISTICS
OF URBANISM
Structure
3.0 Introduction
3.1 Urbanization & Urbanism
3.1.1 Meaning
3.1.2 Theories of urbanization
3.1.3 Characteristics of Urbanism
3.2 Let us Sum Up
3.3 Check Your Progress
3.4 Answer to Check Your Progress
3.5 Suggested Readings
3.0 INTRODUCTION
Urbanization, indeed, is the process of becoming urban, moving to cities,
changing from agriculture to other pursuits common to cities, such as trade,
manufacturing, industry and management, and corresponding changes of
behaviour patterns.
It is the process of expansion in the entire system of interrelationships by
which a population maintains itself in its habitat (Hawley, 1981). An increase
in the size of towns and cities leading to growth of urban population is the
most significant dimension of urbanization. The urban centers are essentially
non-agricultural in character. In ancient times there have been great many
cities such as Rome or Baghdad but ever since industrialization and
increasing industrial production and territory level production cities have
grown phenomenally and now urbanization is very much apart of our
contemporary life.
What exactly constitutes, urban and what is the process of urbanization will
be dealt with in the following sections. We will also talk about various
theories associated with urbanization. We will discuss the growth of cities
and some of the problems associated with urban centers as well.
15 Self-Instructional Material
Urbanization & Urbanism (rural) and gesellschaft (urban) communities in terms of social relationships
and values.
NOTES
The former is one in which social bonds are based on close personal ties of
kinship and friendship, and the emphasis is on tradition, consensus and
informality, while in the latter, impersonal and secondary relationships
predominate and the interaction of people is formal, contractual and
dependent on the special function or service they perform. Other sociologists
like Max Weber (1961) and George Simmel (1950) have stressed on dense
living conditions, rapidity of change and impersonal interaction in urban
settings.
In India, the demographic and economic indexes are important in defining
specific areas as town or city. The census definition of ‗town‘ remained more
or less the same for the period 1901-1951 but in 1961, a new definition was
adopted. Up to 1951, ‗town‘ included:
1) An inhabited locality with a total population of not less than 5,000 persons;
2) Every municipality, corporation and notified area of whatever size; and
3) All civil lines not included within municipal limits.
Thus, the primary criteria for deciding whether a particular place is a town or
not was the administrative set-up rather than the size of the population.
Because of this definition many of the towns in reality were nothing more
than over-grown villages.
In 1961 ‗town‘ was redefined and determined on the basis of a number of
empirical tests:
a) a minimum population of 5,000,
b) a density of not less than 1,000 per square mile,
c) three-fourths of the occupations of the working population should be
outside of agriculture, and
d) the place should have a few characteristics and amenities such as newly
founded industrial areas, large housing settlements, and places of tourist
importance and civic amenities. As a result of the new definition of ‗town‘
was a reduction in the total number of towns in India between 1951 and 1961.
The 1961 basis was adopted in the 1971, 1981 and 1991 censuses too for
defining towns.
Sociologists do not attach much importance to the size of population in the
definition of city because the minimum population standards vary greatly. A
city is an administratively defined unit of territory containing ―a relatively
large, dense and permanent settlement of socially heterogeneous individuals‖
(Wirth, 1938). Urban refers to a set of specialized, non-agricultural activities
that are characteristic of, but not exclusive to, city dwellers. A ruling class
with a capacity for taxation and capital accumulation and writing and its
application to predictive sciences, artistic expression, and trade for vital
Self-Instructional Material
16
materials are the kinds of specialized activities necessary to the definition of Urbanization & Urbanism
the emergence of a truly urban place (Childe, 1950).
NOTES
Urbanization
Urbanization as a structural process of change is generally related to
industrialization but it is not always the result of industrialization.
Urbanization results due to the concentration of large-scale and small
scale industrial and commercial, financial and administrative set up in
the cities; technological development in transport and communication,
cultural and recreational activities. The excess of urbanization over
industrialization that makes it possible to provide employment for all
persons coming to urban areas is, in fact, what sometimes leads to over
urbanization. In India, a peculiar phenomenon is seen: industrial growth
without a significant shift of population from agriculture to industry and
of growth of urban population without a significant rise in the ratio of the
urban to the total population. While in terms of ratio, there may not be a
great shift from rural to urban activities, but there is still a large
migration of population from rural areas to urban areas. This makes
urban areas choked, there is lack of infrastructural facilities to cope with
this rising populations.
Urbanism
Urbanism has been defined by various scholars as patterns of culture and
social interaction resulting from the concentration of large populations
into relatively small areas. It reflects an organization of society in terms
of a complex division of labour, high levels of technology, high mobility,
interdependence of its members in fulfilling economic functions and
impersonality in social relations (Theodorson, 1969).
Urbanism as way of life, Louis Wirth believes, may be empirically
approached from three interrelated perspectives:
• As a physical structure with a population base, technology and
ecological order;
• As a system of social organization with a structure and series
of institutions (secondary contacts, weakening of kinship ties
etc.);
• As a set of attitudes, ideas and constellation of personalities
(increased personal disorganization, suicide, crime, delinquency
and corruption).
3.1.1 MEANING
The idea of urbanization may be made more precise and meaningful when
interpreted as aspects of diffusion and acculturation. Urbanization may be
manifest either as intra-society or inter-society diffusion, that is, urban culture
may spread to various parts of the same society or it may cross cultural or
national boundaries and spread to other societies. It involves both borrowing
and lending. On the other side of the diffusion coin is acculturation, the
process whereby, individuals acquire the material possessions, behavioral
patterns, social organization, bodies of knowledge, and meanings of groups
whose culture differs in certain respects from their own. Urbanization as seen
in this light is a complex process (Gist and Fava: 1933).
b) the rise and fall of cities with changes in the political order;
c) the growth of cities based on new productive processes, which alter the
economic base of the city; and
d) the physical spread of cities with the inflow of migrants, who come in
search of a means of livelihood as well as a new way of life.
Louis Wirth shows two kinds of forces operating in urban society: the force
of segregation and the melting pot effect; which has many unifying aspects
like uniform system of administration etc. However, he concludes that urban
society is based on a means-to-end rationality, which is exploitative and
where the individual is isolated through anonymity. Wirth believed that the
density of life in cities produced neighbourhoods, which have the distinctive
characteristics of traditional communities.
Wirth‘s theory is important for it‘s recognition that urbanism is not just part
19 Self-Instructional Material
Urbanization & Urbanism of a society, but expresses and influences the wider social system. However,
Wirth‘s observations are based on American cities, which are generalized to
NOTES urban centers everywhere, where situations are different.
Like Harvey, Castells stresses that spacial form of a city is very much related
to the larger process of the society. Castells further adds the dimension of the
struggles and conflicts of various groups who make up the cities. He gives the
example of gay community who have reorganized the structure of San
Francisco city. He believes that it is not only big corporations, businesses and
government which influence the shape a of a city but also the communities
and groups who live in cities.
M.S.A. Rao (1970), analysis urabinasation and urbanism keeping in mind the
larger social structures of Indian society. For him, urbanism is a
heterogeneous process and hence there can be many forms of urbanisms
giving rise to many types of urbanization. Rao states that the dichotomy
between cities and villages is incorrect as both have the same structural
features of caste and kinship and are parts of the same civilization. Moreover,
urbanization and westernization are not identical and should not be confused.
Urbanization does not lead to the breakdown of traditional structures of caste
and joint family. The traditional and modern structures coexist in the urban
milieu because of which various types of urbanisms exist – post-industrial,
preindustrial, western, non-western etc. Further, urbanization is seen in
relation to social change and no real social transformation is associated with
it. However, due to urbanization new forms of social organization and
association have emerged. Thus, for Rao, urbanization is a complex
multifaceted process comprising of ideological, cultural, historical,
demographic, comparative, traditional and sociological elements. Rao defines
a city as a center of urbanization and urban way of life. Urbanization is a two
way process. Urbanization in India is not a uniform process but occurs along
different axes - administrative, political, commercial, religious and
educational - giving rise to several types of urbanisms. These different axes
give rise to different types of contact which the city has with the villagers
leading to distinct patterns of urbanization.
Only when these are combined, it will be possible to analyze the process of
urbanization in India. Bose used the concepts of towns and cities
interchangeably.
A. Economic Development
The relative importance of manufacturing and services the does not just
characterize an urban settlement but more importantly, by a high density of
population. Much of manufacturing is cheaper when produced on a large-
scale because of the economies of scale.
Also, there are ready availability of inputs like skilled labor, repair services
etc. from which profit is earned by the producer. People like to live near
places of work.
The bigger cities have one advantage. Most businesses are subject to
fluctuations. In big cities, one may switch from one employer to another in
case of need or any other reason since there is a wide choice. In that way, a
wage laborer is better off in migrating to a big city rather than a small city,
where (big city) he is likely to be more fully employed. All these factors
increase the density of population in the cities.
Self-Instructional Material
22
Primary production and urban growth: Primary production has to do with Urbanization & Urbanism
agriculture, fishing, forestry, and mining. It is well-known that, particularly
since AD 1850, a large number of mining towns have emerged in India. The NOTES
entire coal region of Bengal, Bihar, and Orissa has a number of, mining
towns; the chief among which are Jharia, Ranigani, Keonjhar and Asansol.
Unlike mining, fishing and forestry have not generated many urban places in
India.
With the rise in urbanization, many events like rapid population growth
because of natural increase, migration from rural areas to urban areas,
classification of rural areas as towns because of the changing
demographic character of the rural regions pose a challenge.
23 Self-Instructional Material
Urbanization & Urbanism resulting in deterioration of the quality of urban life. These problems are
visible in most of the cities in India.
NOTES
Hence, the level of urbanization is regarded as an index of economic
development, as financial growth results in the shift in demand and
therefore to a reallocation of resources –land, labor and capital- out of
agriculture into manufacturing and services.
25 Self-Instructional Material
Slums
NOTES
BLOCK II: SLUMS – DEFINITION,
APPROACHES, URBAN PROBLEMS
AND URBAN COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT
UNIT IV : SLUMS – DEFINITION,
APPROACHES, THEORIES AND
CLASSIFICATION AND CULTURE OF
SLUMS
Structure
4.0 Introduction
4.1 Slums
4.2 Definition
4.3 Approaches
4.4 Theories and classification
4.5 Culture of slums
4.5 Let us Sum Up
4.7 Check Your Progress
4.8 Answer to Check Your Progress
4.9 Suggested Readings
4.0 INTRODUCTION
It is a fact that slum is basically an area of the worst form of struggle for the
basic needs of life. The slum is the complex product of many products as it is
true of many other social phenomena but poverty is the foremost one. It is
interplay of objective economic facts and subjective group standards. Low-
income forces people to live in slums. This paper presents a sociological
analysis of the urban problems called slums, especially focusing on the
various aspects such as nature and characteristic of the slum. In the first
section this paper tries to examine the basic nature of the slum, which is not
just an area of substandard housing condition, but it refers to the actual living
conditions of the people in an urban area.
The characteristics of the slum has been presented under various subheadings
like housing condition, overcrowding and congestion, poor sanitation and
health, apathy and social isolation, deviant behaviour and the culture of the
slum, that is, a way of life. In brief, this paper also tries to understand various
functions of the slum, which met various needs and had served several useful
functions for certain social groups like poor and migrant workers etc. under
the section ‗A brief historical perspective on the slum,‘ this paper traces the
socio-historical analysis of slums starting from the slums of ancient Roman
cities, the Jewish ghetto, British slums of 19th century to the slums of U.S
Self-Instructional Material
26
before the World War-II. This paper also undertakes a systematic study of the Slums
socio-economic profile of Indian slums and also illustrates with a case study
like Dharavi of Mumbai. The final section deals with various theoretical NOTES
approaches related to the solution of slum problems. The most prominent
ones discussed here are the traditional welfarist approach, the developmental
approach, the Marxist or socialist approach and humanitarian approach.
The slums constitute the most important and persistent problem of urban life.
They are the chief sources of crime and delinquency, of illness and death
from diseases. Slums are of all shapes, types and forms. Mumbai has its
packed multistoried chawls, New York- its Harlem and its East side, Chicago-
its black belt, London- its east end. Families in Bangkok crowd together in
‗Pile villages‘ composed of poorly constructed wooden shacks, bamboo hubs
and straw hovels along the small lanes of Kolkata, Dacca and Lagos, which
stream with the high humidity and stink from open drains. Impoverished
shantytown or squatter shacks constructed from junks cover the hillside of
Rio de Janeiro, Lima, Hong Kong and other Asian, African and South
American cities. Even the most affluent nation in the world have slums. At
least one fifth of urban population of U.S lives in poor or sub standard
housing. Like U.S, other capitalist nations of the world have slums. These
nations have progressed on other fronts but the shelter problems have eluded
solutions. Even in socialist countries where massive urban renewal programs
have taken place and where private ownership of land does not exists, slums
do exist. The developing countries or the underdeveloped countries, which
have chosen the capitalist path of development, are often referred to as the
Third World, where the trends of urbanization since the Second World War
have been interesting, instructive and alarming.
Steaks of contrasts in all spheres of life characterize Third World. Some of
these contrasts assume the form of contradictions. For instances, in Mumbai
where perhaps some of the worst slums in the world can be found the skyline
is getting changed by an eruption of skyscrapers of the most modern
dimension, accommodating airline companies, five star hotels, officers of
multinationals and the affluent few of the metropolis. The slum offends the
eyes, nose and conscience but it exists all the same. We somehow learnt to
live complacently with such contradictions, which eloquently proclaim our
distorted sense of priorities. It would not be too sweeping to say that the slum
has become an inevitable and expanding feature of cities in developing
countries.
Shelterless people grab every patch of vacant spot to pitch a makeshift shack.
In Mumbai besides a few lakh who lives in slums and sleeps. In the streets,
one can see tiny, shaky dwellings made of tin sheets, mud, wood, and rags
even under the trees.
4.1 SLUMS
Slums may be characterized as areas of substandard housing conditions
within a city. A slum is always an area. The term housing conditions refers to
actual living conditions rather than mere physical appearance of the area. The
27 Self-Instructional Material
Slums substandard is to be taken not in an objective or technological but rather in a
relative social sense i.e. compared with the recognized standard at a given
NOTES time in a specific country. The cave dwelling of prehistoric people, the
dugouts etc. of pioneers are all substandard according to our notion, but they
do not create slum conditions. Slum word has a long and a negative
connotation. It has been almost an epithet, implying evil, strange and
something to be shunned and avoided. It is being apparently derived from
―slumber‖ as slum were once thought by majority to be unknown, back streets
presumed to be sleepy and quite. (The oxford universal dictionary.1995. New
York, Oxford University Press) There is a disagreement over whether people
make slums or slums make people. Are substandard housing conditions due
to social standards behavior of certain groups or vice- versa? The slum is a
complex product of many products as it is true of many other social
phenomena. But poverty is the foremost one, interplay of objective economic
facts and subjective group standard. Low-incomes forces people to live in
slums. Slum residents are negligent and do not mind dirt. They have neither
money nor time to their area clean or clean if themselves. Lack of basic
infrastructure, like drains, drinking water, electricity and location gives the
slums a very ungainly picture.
There are three main types of slums – (i) The first type is original slum. It is
an area which from the very beginning, consisted of unsuitable buildings,
these sections are beyond recovery and need to be razed. The example of this
type is the Mexican slum in Wichita. (ii) The second type of slumsconsists of
slums created by the departure of the middle class families to other sections
and subsequent deterioration of the area. The example of this type is South
End slum in Boston. (iii) The third type is the most unpleasant type of slum. It
is mainly a phenomenon of transition. Once the area around a main business
district has become blighted, physical and social deterioration spreads rapidly.
This kind of slum teams with accommodation for the destitute, home of
prostitution, beggars, homeless men, habitual criminals, chronic alcoholics
etc. This type of slum clearly requires defines rehabilitation.
4.2 DEFINITION
The definition of what constitutes a slum, like that which constitutes an urban
area more generally (Dorélien et al., 2013), differs by country (United
Nations, 2014), state (Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation,
2008) and even city (O‘Hare et al., 1998). Recent research has also indicated
that slums may be more heterogeneous than is often assumed (Goli et al.,
2011, Chandrasekhar and Montgomery, 2009, Agarwal and Taneja, 2005);
many poor people like pavement dwellers do not live in slums and are
therefore not ―counted‖ by the standard definitions (Agarwal, 2011).
The UN operationally defines a slum as ―one or a group of individuals living
under the same roof in an urban area, lacking in one or more of the following
five amenities‖: 1) Durable housing (a permanent structure providing
protection from extreme climatic conditions); 2) Sufficient living area (no
more than three people sharing a room); 3) Access to improved water (water
Self-Instructional Material
28
that is sufficient, affordable, and can be obtained without extreme effort); 4) Slums
Access to improved sanitation facilities (a private toilet, or a public one
shared with a reasonable number of people); and 5) Secure tenure (de facto or NOTES
de jure secure tenure status and protection against forced eviction) (UN-
HABITAT, 2006/7).
While this definition of what constitutes a slum was used by the UN to
evaluate whether target 7.D had been met, it is quite different than those
which are used by individual countries for their own policy and planning
purposes. Uganda, for example, in a document outlining a slum upgrading
strategy and action plan from 2008, defines slums as having one or more of
the following attributes: 1) Attracting a high density of low income earners
and/or unemployed persons with low levels of literacy, 2) An area with high
rates/levels of noise, crime, drug abuse, immorality (pornography and
prostitution) and alcoholism and high HIV/AIDS prevalence, or 3) An area
where houses are in environmentally fragile lands, e.g. wetlands (Ministry of
Lands, 2008).
4.3 APPROACHES
Slums vary from one type to another, but certain general patterns of slums are
universal. Although, the slum is generally characterized by inadequate
housing, deficient facilities, overcrowding and congestions involve much
more then these elements. Sociologically, it is a way of life, a sub culture with
a set of norms and values, which is reflected in poor sanitation and health
practices, deviant behavior and attributes of apathy and social isolations.
People who live in slums are isolated from the general power structure and
are regarded as inferiors. Slum dwellers in turn harbor, suspicions of the out
side world.
Some of the features of slums are:
1. Housing conditions
In terms of the physical conditions and housing standards it is important to
keep in mind the comparative nature of the definitions. A slum should be
judged physically according to the general living standards of a country. Slums
29 Self-Instructional Material
Slums have commonly been defined as those portions of cities in which housing is
crowded, neglected deteriorated and often obsolete. Many of the inadequate
NOTES housing conditions can be attributed to poorly arranged structures, inadequate
lighting and circulation, lack of sanitary facility, overcrowding and inadequate
maintenance.
2. Overcrowding and congestion
A slum may be an area which is overcrowded with buildings or a building
overcrowded with people or both. Density does not always result in
unfortunate social consequence, the issue is primarily one of overcrowding.
Congestion is again a judgment about the physical condition of the building in
terms of high density per block, acre or square mile. William. F. Whyte (1943)
in his well known sociological study, Street Corner Society situated in
Boston‘s north end, stressed upon the importance of overcrowding as a
criterion for measuring slum conditions. Some slum areas like in Delhi, have
40, 00,000 people per square mile.
3. Neighborhood facilities
A poor slum is invariably associated with poor facilities and community
services. Along with shabbiness and dilapidation, schools are of poor quality
and other public facilities are often insufficient. Streets and sidewalks often go
unrepaired and rubbish and garbage are infrequently collected adding to the
undesirable environment. Shortage of water, electricity and sanitary facility
are common in most of the slums.
4. Poor Sanitation and Health
Slums are generally been dirty and unclean places which is defined largely in
terms of the physical deterioration, stressing particularly unsanitary conditions
and lack of sufficient facilities like water and latrines. These factors have
resulted in high rates death and disease. These factors have always been
typical of slum areas where overcrowding and presence of rats and other pest
complicate the problem of health and sanitation. In slum areas of developing
countries, the rate of disease, chronic illness and infant mortality are
exceptionally high.
5. Deviant Behavior
A high incidence of deviant behavior- crime, juvenile delinquency,
prostitution, drunkenness, drug usage, mental disorder, suicide, ill legitimacy
and family maladjustments have long been associated with slum living. It is a
fact that vice may be found in slums but is by no means confined only to the
slums. Due to the lack of money and power often slum dwellers are prove to
be pressurized by the goons of upper classes to commit crime. It is a vicious
cycle for the sum dwellers.
6. The Culture of the Slum- a way of life
Slums differ widely with respect to the social organization of there Inhabitants.
They range from the slums in which the inhabitants are strangers to one
another, to the family slums in which there is a wide acquaintance between the
Self-Instructional Material
30
inhabitants. Slums
Slums inhabited by immigrant groups may have a firm social organization. NOTES
Culture might be defined as system of symbols or meanings for the normative
conduct of standards, having three distinct properties. It is transmittable, it is
learned and it is shared. The slum has a culture of its own and this culture is
the way of life. This way of life is passed from generation to generation with
its own rationale, structure ad defense mechanism, which provides the means
to continue in spite of difficulties and deprivation. It is the habits, customs and
behavior pattern people have learned and which they hold that move them to
act in a particular way. Although, these cultural patterns are typical of the
slum, form ethnic groups to ethnic groups, from own society to society to
another.
7. Apathy and Social Isolation
Every residential area within the modern city tends to be socially isolated from
others, partly by choice and partly by location. The slum is especially so, as it
is inhabited by the people of the lowest status. The chief link with rest of the
community is their identification with labour market, but there may be an
additional link through politics. A slum also has an image in the eyes of the
larger community. There is a societal reaction to slum dwellers. The non-slum
dweller often associates the physical appearance and difficult living conditions
of the slums with belief in the ―Natural inferiority‖ of those who live in slums.
This reaction has important consequences in the social isolation of slum
dwellers and their exclusion, from power and participation in urban society.
The slum dwellers often lack an effective means of communication with the
outside world. Because of apathy, lack of experience in communicating with
outsiders and their own powerlessness to make their voice heard. William. F.
Whyte (1943) stated that although the north end slum studied in his work on
street corner society was a mysterious, dangerous and depressing place to an
outsider, it provided an organized and familiar environment for those who
lived in it.
Slums have been in existence since the time of cities and their presence has
long been documented in the literature (e.g., Booth, 1903). The word ‗slum‘
has mainly been used to describe people living under substandard conditions
and squalor. For example, Cities Alliance (2006) describes slums as ‗neglected
parts of cities where housing and living conditions are appallingly poor‘. Often
the terms ‗slum‘ and ‗informal settlements‘ are used interchangeably in the
literature (UN Habitat, 2012). However, some would argue that there is a
distinct difference between slum and informal settlement (e.g., Hurskainen,
2004; Rashid, 2009). (Readers interested in this debate are referred to Gilbert
(2007) for a more thorough discussion). This paper adopts the view that slums
and informal settlements are one in the same and, therefore, can be treated as
one. Usually, as argued by UN-Habitat (2003), most characteristics of these
environments, whether slum or informal settlement, are not found in isolation,
leading to multiple levels of deprivation for slum dwellers. Whether slums and
informal settlements are viewed separately or as a single entity, they represent
disadvantaged communities continuing to have large impact on the physical
and economic landscapes, as will be discussed below.
The vast majority of the slums are located in less developed countries, and
most of the growth in slum populations is expected to occur in such countries.
However, just as the term ‗slum‘ can have multiple connotations, so does the
term ‗developing country‘. For the purpose of this paper, we adopt the United
Nation‘s definitions of ‗less developed country‘ and ‗developing country‘ for a
country where the majority of the population makes significantly less income
and has weaker social indicators than the population in highly industrialized
countries (UN-OHRLLS, 2016). Furthermore, in such countries there is lack
of basic public services. Although alternative terms have been used to describe
less developed countries (e.g., ‗emergent nations‘), much of the literature on
slums that is reviewed here has used the terms ‗less developed‘ and
‗developing country‘ to refer to areas most impacted by slums.
The impact of slums
The growth of slums is expected to have major consequences on both humans
and the environment, which are inextricably linked. On the one hand, the
conditions that exist in slums such as living under physical threat from natural
and manmade disasters and improper housing have direct impacts on their
residents (Napier, 2007). This is mainly due to the low capacity of slums
dwellers to recover from disasters, such as floods and earthquakes, compared
with more formal communities (Ajibade & McBean, 2014; Ebert, Kerle, &
Stein, 2009). On the other hand, slum residents themselves can impact their
environment due to lack of basic services, which results in contaminated soil
and polluted air and waterways. This results in a perpetuated cycle of decline
for both slum dwellers and the environment (Ali & Sulaiman, 2006), with the
possibility of impacts extending to communities beyond the slums (e.g.,
flooding). The growth and expansion of slums can therefore threaten
33 Self-Instructional Material
Slums sustainable urban development at local, national and regional scales (Patel,
2012).
NOTES
Growth and expansion of slums can also impact the national and regional
economy, both negatively and positively. For example, the negative aspect of
slums relates to the fact that they are often burdened with high transaction
costs, including increases in transportation expenditures because of inadequate
infrastructure, and disease burden on urban dwellers because of the large
number of people living in slums (Fox, 2008). In addition, ambiguous property
and tenancy rights can reduce the efficiency of urban land and housing
markets, and may discourage investment or reduce participation in urban
labour markets (Marx, Stoker, & Suri, 2013a). This may potentially impact a
country or a region‘s overall economic outlook in the global economy, making
it less competitive in the worldwide arena (Gambo, Idowu, & Anyakora,
2012).
Less often mentioned in the literature is the economic good provided by slum
dwellers. Slum dwellers subsidize the middle classes and the business world
by providing a comparatively cheap source of labour (Brugmann, 2010;
Malecki & Ewers, 2007). Furthermore, it has been argued that their low
economic standing and general lack of education forces them to accept low-
paying jobs that may not be readily accepted by middle- and upper-class
people (Pawar & Mane, 2013). Slum dwellers often find jobs in the informal
sector, which is usually linked very closely to the needs of surrounding formal
communities (Opeyemi, Olabode, Olalekan, & Omolola, 2012). In some cases,
this informal economy has positively impacted the country‘s gross domestic
product (GDP). Slums in Dharavi, India, for example, employ as many as 70%
of its residents (Gruber et al., 2005) with current economic output estimates of
US$700 million annually (Chege & Mwisukha, 2013). Other places such as
Delhi, Bangalore and Kolkata, all in India, also depend heavily on the informal
sector for supporting much of their day-to-day manufacturing activities
(Benjamin, 2004). Some researchers (e.g., Brugmann, 2013; Saglio-
Yatzimirsky, 2013) suggest that if such economic benefits were to be
considered alone, places such as Dharavi would no longer be considered a
slum.
Lastly, the poor conditions that exist in slums and daily struggles that slum
dwellers face continues to be recognized as a global and ethical challenge.
Many governments, regional and international non-government organizations
(NGOs) have put in place legislation or systems recognizing the need to
protect and improve the lives of slum dwellers (e.g., the Rajiv Awas Yojana
programme in India; MHUPA, 2013). Likewise, Target 7D of the United
Nations Millennium Development Goals (UN MDG) aims to improve
significantly the lives of 100 million slum dwellers worldwide by 2020
(United Nations, 2015a). This target was further advanced with Goal 1 of the
UN‘s Sustainable Development Goals, the MDG‘s successor. Goal 1 aims to
reduce at least by half the population of all people living in poverty in all its
dimensions according to national definitions by 2030 (United Nations, 2015b).
Failure to take part in such global initiatives may have negative impacts on
Self-Instructional Material
34
countries that depend on others for financial and political support. These Slums
impacts highlight the critical need for managing slum populations worldwide.
To achieve this goal, it is necessary to understand the factors that have led to NOTES
the emergence and persistence of slums over time. We would argue that such
issues must be dealt with for any future intervention to be successful.
Factors influencing the growth of slums
Many factors have been linked to the growth of slums. This section highlights
several of these factors, specifically those relating to locational choice factors,
rural-to-urban migration, poor urban governance and ill-designed policies.
Those factors chosen for discussion have been identified as those most often
discussed by others for the growth and persistence of slums based on an
extensive review of the literature.
Locational choice factors
The emergence of slums has been linked to a number of socio-cultural,
economic and physical factors. For example, Lall, Lundberg, and Shalizi
(2008) examined the residential locational decisions made by slum dwellers in
Pune, India, and found that locational decisions were made around theories
relating to socio-cultural and economic factors such as commuting costs (e.g.,
Alonso, 1964), access to local public goods (e.g., Tiebout, 1956) and
individual preferences for community or neighbourhood composition (e.g.,
Schelling, 1978). In addition to these classical models, they found that the
locational choices made by slum dwellers was also guided by housing quality
and neighbourhood amenities. Similar findings have been reported in other
studies (e.g., Abramo, 2009; Takeuchi, Cropper, & Bento, 2006). Social ties
related to common culture, language and similar income-generating activities
have also been found associated with the locational choices of new immigrants
(e.g., Barnhardt, Field, & Pande, 2014; Kombe, 2005). It has also been found
that people born within or in close proximity to slums tend to remain in them
or move to them (UN-Habitat, 2003), while some slum dwellers are of the
belief that places outside of slums are out of their reach (e.g., Ahmed,
Brookins, & Ali, 2011). This suggests that any efforts to address the issue of
slums must also consider their surroundings and their social structures.
With respect to physical factors impacting the location of slum dwellers, the
availability of land has been highly cited in the literature. It has been shown
that slum dwellers typically inhabit marginal locations such as riverbanks,
steep slopes or dumping grounds (e.g., Sietchiping, 2004). This is mainly due
to the low purchasing power of slum dwellers in formal land markets when
compared with high-income groups (Ajibade & McBean, 2014; Praharaj,
2013). Slums in South America, for example, Rio de Janiero in Brazil and
Lima in Peru, are notoriously known for building on steep slopes (Fernandes
et al., 2004). Such locations are usually unsafe, posing a risk to human life
because of the occurrence of natural disasters such as landslides. Furthermore,
slums are also found both within and on the outskirts of cities (UN-Habitat,
2003). These unique physical characteristics of slums and the complex
interplay with the various socio-economic factors pertaining to their growth
35 Self-Instructional Material
Slums and persistence represent a challenging task that has yet to be holistically
addressed.
NOTES
Rural-to-urban migration
Within the literature, rural-to-urban migration not only has been the driver for
the growth of cities, but also it has been identified as one of the primary
drivers for the growth of slums. In less developed countries the current rapid
and immense net movement of the rural population to urban spaces has
intensified (Malecki & Ewers, 2007; Srivastava & Singh, 1996). This is due to
several factors: those pertaining to the pulling of rural people to cities and
push factors driving population away from rural areas. Often cited in the
literature with respect to pull factors include the relative perception of better
economic opportunities (e.g., Glaeser, 2011) and provision of basic services
such as education and healthcare within cities (e.g., Khan, Kraemer, &
Kraemer, 2014), or the freedom from restrictive social or cultural norms often
found in rural areas (e.g., Opeyemi et al., 2012; Ullah, 2004). Push factors
include rural poverty (e.g., Khan et al., 2014), excess agricultural labour
supply (e.g., Oberai, 1993), environmental hardships (e.g., Ishtiaque &
Mahmud, 2011), threat from natural disasters or conflict and war (e.g., Black,
Bennett, Thomas, & Beddington, 2011). While such events have pushed rural
dwellers to urban areas, there has been a lack of economic growth in many of
these countries and when combined has been touted for the growth and
persistence of slums, especially in African countries (Fox, 2012). Whether a
pull or a push factor, the net result of rural-to-urban migration is
overwhelming to the urban centres in less developed countries, which are not
equipped to support the additional population, especially when combined with
the socio-economic factors discussed above. Faced with nowhere else to go,
people turn to slums to meet their most basic housing needs (Vasudevan,
2015).
Poor urban governance
Other factors relating to the upward growth of slums in many less developed
countries is the use of rigid and often outdated urban planning regulations,
which are typically bypassed by slum dwellers to meet their housing needs.
This is a reflection of poor urban governance (Chiodelli & Moroni, 2014).
Many local and national governments are also unable to enforce planning
regulations due to lack of resources (Tsenkova, Potsiou, & Badyina, 2009). In
Cote d‘Ivoire, for example, high infrastructure cost and rigid building
standards have led to a slow pace of development, which resulted in
unaffordable housing for many large segments of the population (Mayo &
Angel, 1993). In Nigeria, official fees involved in the registration process to
acquire land can be as much as 27% of the property value (World Bank, 2005),
presenting a challenge for slum dwellers with limited finances. These
circumstances ultimately lead to high rates of insecurity of tenure and provide
conducive conditions that continue to drive the growth of slums due to poorly
functioning land markets.
Another issue in many less developed countries is the failure of governments
Self-Instructional Material
36
to incorporate slum dwellers as part of the overall planning process (Cities Slums
Alliance, 2014). This is often due to the inability of many governments to keep
abreast with urbanization because of the lack of resources and corrupt NOTES
governments (Fekade, 2000). Some governments also refuse to provide urban
services to slum dwellers in fear that this will only escalate the issue of slums
(Opeyemi et al., 2012), or lead to more established property rights, which
many governments are unwilling to provide (Fox, 2014). As discussed by
Werlin (1999), without more established property rights for slum dwellers,
governments lack the ability to force slum residents into paying for public
services and improving their homes. It is also the case that some governments
simply lack the political will to address these issues (e.g., Rashid, 2009).
Overall, one could argue that not enough attention has been given to the plight
of slum dwellers on the part of government, further enabling the continued
growth of slums.
Ill-designed policies
Closely related to poor urban governance are the inappropriate policies
developed by local and national governments, and regional led organizations
to curb the growth of slums. During the 1950s and 1960s, a time when
urbanization was viewed as a positive, with large labour forces needed to fuel
economic growth in cities (Fox, 2014), macro-policy intervention with respect
to slums was largely ignored, leading to the widespread growth of slums. To
tackle this issue, a sites and services approach was introduced in the 1970s.
This policy provided infrastructure at new sites (e.g., roads and electricity) and
slum dwellers were relocated to these sites (Fekade, 2000). Existing slums
were demolished and slum dwellers were expected to pay for the newly
developed serviced land as well as all home construction costs (Linden, 1986).
With limited finances, and the added challenge of competing with the greater
demand by higher income groups for the same available land, slums continued
to grow (Arimah, 2001).
The failure of the sites and services approach led to a new wave of thinking
during the 1980s, in which slums were upgraded with improved communal
infrastructure and services. This avoided the unnecessary demolition of
settlements (Gilbert, 2014) while lowering costs in many instances (e.g.,
Werlin, 1999). However, the slum-upgrading approach has been criticized at
four major levels: failed financial commitment, negative socio-economic
impacts, non-replicability of best practices and insecurity of tenure (Fekade,
2000). Subsequently, an enabling approach through security of tenure was
introduced in the 1990s. Legal occupational status was given to slum dwellers
in the hope that they would be more willing improve their own circumstances
(de Soto, 2002). This approach relied heavily on the assumption that most
slum dwellers owned the dwelling in which they lived. However, this was not
the case, as most slum dwellers did not do so (e.g., Gulyani, Talukdar, & Jack,
2010; Marx, Stoker, & Suri, 2013b), and this remains the plight of many slum
dwellers today. Further, some would argue (e.g., Desai & Loftus, 2013) that
security of land tenure adds an additional burden on slum dwellers since
landlords are more likely to increase rental prices and evict those slum
37 Self-Instructional Material
Slums dwellers unable to pay. Moreover, as de Souza (2001) argues, perceptions of
security of tenure may vary widely from household to household. Specifically,
NOTES their study showed that slum dwellers were more willing to invest in
improving their housing conditions irrespective of land tenure status. Such
findings further challenge the notion that security of land tenure alone would
be enough to motivate slum dwellers to improve their own living conditions.
The most recent approach, at least from a macro-policy viewpoint, to reduce
the growth of slums is the Cities Without Slums action plan, introduced during
the 2000s. This approach forms part of the MDG to improve the lives of 100
million slum dwellers by 2020 (United Nations, 2015a). Central to this idea is
the understanding that both poverty and slums are interrelated, with any
attempt to fix one having also to consider the other (Arimah, 2001). However,
several issues have been identified with the Cities Without Slums action plan.
These include little attention being given to other important poverty-related
variables (e.g., political instability and natural disasters) and the non-
comparability of metrics because of issues with data in many countries and the
unique characteristics of slums (Saith, 2006). Furthermore, as no metrics are
available for monitoring newly emerging slums, it has been suggested that the
goal of improving the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by 2020 is far
too modest to generate a meaningful reduction in slums globally (Sietchiping,
2004). Finally, the key terms used for measuring the improvement of slums
(e.g., ‗access‘, ‗improved‘ and ‗sufficient‘) are far too abstract for capturing
and monitoring change rigorously (Cohen, 2014).
As this section has discussed, the continued failure of implemented slum
policies has, in reality, facilitated the propagation of slums. One could argue
that this is due to the inability of governments to understand fully the needs of
slum dwellers and incorporate their needs when developing appropriate
policies (Fekade, 2000). In addition, the locational decisions of slum dwellers,
rural-to-urban migration and poor urban governance in general are all
interrelated factors that have contributed to the growth of slums. Taken
holistically, these various factors are all important for designing more
appropriate slum policies. Failure to do so will only lead to the continued
growth and persistence of slums. However, to grapple fully with the problems
discussed above, we would argue that one needs also to understand the various
operational challenges encountered when trying to address the issue of slums,
which we turn to next.
Classification of Slums
The case studies show that many cities do make distinctions between types of
slums. In general, there is a clear separation between slums proper, on the one
hand, and shanties or spontaneous housing and urban development, on the
other. This distinction is often made on the basis of combinations of physical
location and legality status of the built structure, urban zoning, land invasion
and informal construction.
The term ‗slum‘, or its equivalent local term, often refers to inner-city
residential areas that were laid out and built several decades ago in line with
Self-Instructional Material
38
the then prevailing urban planning, zoning and construction standards, but Slums
which, over time, have progressively become physically dilapidated and
overcrowded to the point where they became the near exclusive residential NOTES
zone for lowest income groups.
The term ‗informal settlement‘ often refers to illegal or semi-legal
urbanization processes, or unsanctioned subdivisions of land at the (then)
urban periphery where land invasion took place – often by squatters, who
erected housing units usually without formal permission of the land owner and
often with materials and building standards not in line with the criteria of the
local building code. This type of slum is usually referred to as a shanty, or
squatter settlement. Depending upon the local conditions, many local
authorities recognize derivatives of this form of informal shelter as separate
types of slums, such as informal settlements on vacant urban lots or on
precarious urban sites along canals, on road reserves or adjacent to landfill
areas.
Several of the cities without a formal slum definition nevertheless apply terms
or concepts that denote different types of slum housing depending upon the
construction type, location, legality status, etc. This is notably the case for
Beirut, Colombo, Havana, Los Angeles, Lusaka, Mexico City, Moscow and
Naples.
Self-Instructional Material
42
Urban problems
UNIT V URBAN PROBLEMS:
NOTES
HOUSING, DRUG ADDICTION,
JUVENILE DELINQUENCY,
PROSTITUTION, AND POLLUTION.
Structure
5.0 Introduction
5.1 Urban problems
5.2 Housing
5.3 Drug addiction,
5.4 Juvenile delinquency
5.5 Prostitution
5.6 Pollution
5.7 Lets Sum Up
5.8 Check Your Progress
5.9 Answer to Check Your Progress
5.10 Suggested Readings
5.0 Introduction
This study presents a sociological analysis of poverty, specifically focusing on
urban poverty the theoretical framework emphasises the main approaches,
which define poverty-the cultural perspective and the situational perspective.
The study not only tries to understand simply the human reality of what it
means to be poor, but also the central paradox of modern India, half a century
of democracy, economic growth and constitutional commitment to social
justice has not lessened the acute, mass poverty of the country. The first
section tries to examine the socio-historical analysis of poverty studies and
research of poverty in India. The early studies of poverty in Britain and also in
US focus largely on urban poverty. On the other hand in India much of the
research on poverty in the period since independence was driven in by the
concern for growth and development. Income and expenditure were
considered to be better measured of poverty which relied on data provided by
National Sample Survey (NSS). But several issues pertaining to urban poverty
in India still lie unanswered. Therefore this study tries to expand its framework
beyond the analysis of calorie consumption and include dimensions of well
being other than nutritional intake like housing, health, education, impact of
globalization, access to basic amenities etc. and it also tries to analyze the
label of facilities across different regions. This unit also undertakes a
systematic study of globalization and poverty as well as the changing policy
perspective on poverty. The recent focus on poverty has shown that in
individual countries poverty is caused by
(i) Paucity of resources or by failure of economic development
(ii) Failure of state
(iii) Transition from state control economy to market
43 Self-Instructional Material
Urban problems based economy.
NOTES
This paper attempts to first define poverty, identify poor geographical area and
tries to carry out systematic investigation with an open mind to understand the
phenomena of poverty and adjudge the strategies employed to combat it,
which will help building a new theoretical perspective.
5.2 HOUSING
Housing - Housing provision for the growing urban population will be the
biggest challenge before the government. The growing cost of houses
comparison to the income of the urban middle class, has made it impossible
for majority of lower income groups and are residmg in congested
accommodation and many of those are devoid of proper ventilation, lighting,
water supply, sewage system, etc. For instance in Delhi, the current estimate is
of a shortage of 3,00,000 dwelling units the coming decades. The United
Nations Centre for Human Settlements (UNCHS) introduced the concept of
"Housing Poverty" which includes "Individuals and households who lack safe,
secure and healthy shelter, with basic infrastructure such as piped water and
adequate provision for sanitation, drainage and the removal of household
waste".
Housing sector is a major contributor to GDP of a country. As per the Central
Statistical Organisation (CSO) estimates, housing sector‘s contribution to GDP
for the period 2003-04 is 4.5 per cent. Real estate is one of the fastest-growing
sectors in India, with the housing sector growing at 34 per cent annually,
according
to the data from National Housing Bank (NHB). It is estimated that 80 per cent
of the country‘s real estate market accounts for residential property.
In urban India, the share of rental housing is low compared to developed
countries, where it is between 40 and 50 percent. The share of rental housing
in urban areas is 30 percent, according to NSS 65th Round, 2008-09. In most
cities in India, over 30 percent of the population lives in slum like conditions.
India‘s urbanization is only around 30 per cent, while in other countries, it is
much higher. According to McKinsey Report 2010, 70 per cent of all jobs in
the next 20 years will originate in urban areas. Seeing the above facts, it can be
concluded that while it is very important to make investments in urban areas in
order to ensure better productivity, housing is an area which will need utmost
Self-Instructional Material
44
attention in the times to come. Housing is an integral part of town planning. Urban problems
Residential land use constitutes approximately
around 30 to 40 per cent of the total land use of the city, depending on various NOTES
conditions. Amongst all the land uses in the city master plan, residential land
use usually is the largest portion.
After reading this unit, you will be able to:
Explain housing concept, types and classification
Discuss factors influencing housing pattern and housing shortage
Describe affordable and inclusive housing
Analyse housing policies and plans
45 Self-Instructional Material
Urban problems ‗Institutional Household‘. Examples of Institutional Households are boarding
houses, messes, hostels, hotels, rescue homes, observation homes, beggars‘
NOTES homes, jails, ashrams, old age homes, children homes, orphanages, etc
d) Permanent House: Houses with wall and roof made of permanent
materials. Wall can be of G. I., Metal, Asbestos sheets, Burnt bricks, Stone or
Concrete. Roof can be made up of Tiles, Slate, G. I., Metal, Asbestos sheets,
Brick, Stone or Concrete.
e) Semi Permanent House: Either wall or roof is made of permanent material
(and the other having been made of temporary material).
f) Temporary House: Houses with wall and roof made of temporary material.
Wall can be made of grass, thatch, bamboo etc., plastic, polythene, mud,
unbaked brick or wood. Roof can be made of grass, thatch, bamboo, wood,
mud, plastic or polythene.
g) Serviceable Temporary: Wall is made of mud, unbaked bricks or wood.
h) Non-Serviceable Temporary: Wall is made of grass, thatch, bamboo etc.,
plastic or polythene.
Housing has many social, economic and political dimensions. Indian society
comprises of great diversities. India is a federal union of states comprising
twenty nine states and seven union territories. The states and territories are
further subdivided into districts and so on. The patterns of social
organisations vary across the country. There had always been a distinct
imprint on the nature of housing settlement structure in the past. Housing
design is often dictated by social requirements. Lots of literatures have
emerged in the country on the way housing design is done. Traditional spatial
patterns and settlement structure are governed
by social requirements. Both at the settlement level as well as within the
dwelling unit, space is organised in conformity with the social considerations.
In various cities of India, the location of neighbourhoods is made up of same
castes and professions. Similarly, caste grouping also takes place such as
‗Agraharam‘ or Agrahara is a neighbourhood, which comprises of Brahmin
quarter of a heterogeneous village or to any village inhabited by Brahmins in
South India.
The rural areas as well the social patterns of various communities, such as
landlords and tenants, workers and so on defines housing patterns and social
status, which is reflected in housing form. Economic factors also govern
housing patterns. It is obvious that the rich people have huge mansions, while
the middle income families have more modest homes and those at the bottom
Self-Instructional Material
46
of the pyramid struggle to live in small spaces. Further, to the national Urban problems
economy as a whole, housing is a major contributor. Investments in housing
have many tangible and intangible benefits. The housing industry has many NOTES
forward and backward linkages and there are as many as 260 industries which
are involved in the process.
Therefore, housing contributes greatly to the economy in terms of employment
generation and income generation. A large number of skilled, semi skilled, rural
and women workers gain employment through house construction. Rural folk
also get supplementary income by participating in construction activities. It also
contributes to national income and the GDP. The Income Tax Department
levies Capital Gains Tax on long term capital gains on sale of property- be it
residential or any other. Every year, the Union Finance Minister presents a
national budget in which various duties and levies as well as concessions are
announced. The entire housing finance industry which is a multi-crore business
is an outcome of the housing activity. Renting out of housing benefits, house
owner is also thereby a contributor to the micro economy. On the fiscal side,
housing contributes substantially to the finances of the urban local bodies by
way of ‗house tax‘ or ‗property tax‘. Housing has serious political connotations.
Housing being a basic need, it is high on political agenda and forms a key
element of political rhetoric. Political parties across the country want to win the
support of the industry by giving incentives and sympathy of the public,
especially the low income and the poor, by regularizing squatting and
unauthorized land colonization.
Influence of Climate, Materials and Technology
Housing form, technology and materials used for construction vary across the
country. It depends on physical factors, such as climate (including temperature,
humidity and rainfall) and availability of natural resources. In the coastal areas,
the climate is moderate and there is less of difference between the summers and
winters. Humidity is high and therefore, there is a need for wind flow in order
to attain thermal comfort. As there are incessant rains, so the traditional house
form here has emerged with spacious houses with central courtyard, large
windows for free passage of air and high gable roofs to withstand the rains.
Further, use of locally available stone, brick and timber is common. The
availability of clay has also ensured that burnt clay tiles are put to use. On the
contrary, in the arid climate of Rajasthan, where the summers are sweltering
and the winters are chilling, rains are also scanty, in this continental climate,
thick walls with small openings, shaded courts and narrow lanes to get as much
shade as possible and flat roofs are popular.
However, in the hilly areas it‘s quite different as it is very cold and sunshine is
always desirable, locally available stones are used, as against brick. There are
no courtyards as there is paucity of space on the hill slopes. Timber and tiled
roofs are common. Construction is often light in order to take care of
earthquakes which are quite common here. ‗Icra walling‘ and use of bamboo is
popular. One can see that traditional housing has always been in tune with
nature.
47 Self-Instructional Material
Urban problems
5.3 DRUG ADDICTION
NOTES
Any substance (usually chemical) which influences our bodies or emotions
when consumed may be called a drug, i.e. it is a chemical substance, that, when
put into your body can change the way the body works and the mind thinks.
These substances may be medicinal i.e. prescribed by a doctor for reducing
minor ailments or problems, e.g. lack of sleep, headache, tension, etc. but are
also
i) used without medical advice,
ii) used for an excessively long period of time,
iii) used for reason other than medical ones.
The use of such drugs is usually legal.
Some drugs may be no medicinal in nature. Their use is illegal e.g. heroin.
Another group of drugs are those that are legal, but are harmful for the person
if consumed in excess, regularly, e.g. alcohol. There are other substances like
cigarettes, coffee, tea etc. which can be termed as socially accepted legal
drugs. But these are not seen as harmful. Some drugs like alcohol, brown
sugar, etc. are dangerous and addictive. It is these drugs that will be discussed
in the next subsection.
Such ‗abuse‘ leads to addiction, i.e. inability to lead a regular life in the
absence of the drug/alcohol. It causes tolerance and dependence, and
withdrawal symptoms may occur in its absence. Explained simply, tolerance
means the need for more quantity and more frequent use of the drug to
produce the same effect as before. Dependence can be both physical and
psychological. Physical means that the body cannot function without taking
the drug. Psychological dependence means constantly thinking about the drug
and its use, continuously trying to get it and being emotionally and mentally
unable to lead one‘s regular life without it. Some drugs like cannabis produce
only psychological dependence while others like opium and heroin, produce
both physical and psychological dependence.
If the drug consumption is suddenly stopped after one became a dependent on
it, withdrawal symptoms occur. These range from mild discomfort to severe
Self-Instructional Material
48
vomiting and convulsions, depending on the drug being used. All drug addicts Urban problems
may not experience the severe withdrawal symptoms shown in TV serials and
films. The severity of these symptoms varies with. NOTES
i) The type of drug
ii) The amount regularly consumed
iii) The duration of taking the drug and the treatment provided in special
medical units, where such withdrawal is usually
managed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
___________________________________________________________
FACTS ABOUT NARCOTIC DRUGS
NOTES
Stimulants
Stimulants are popularly known as ‗uppers‘, pep pills or ‗speed‘ as they give a
feeling of excitement and elation. Amphetamines are the most common ones
in this category. They are used often by students and sportsmen to increase
alertness temporarily and give instant extra energy to study, or participate in
sport for long periods. The body can consume and tolerate large amount of its
intake. Stimulants are usually swallowed. Cocaine is the most dangerous
stimulant. Prepared from the coca plant in South America, Cocaine is snorted,
i.e. inhaled through the nose. ‗Crack‖ is another form of cocaine and heroin
that is becoming increasingly popular in the West. Though cocaine is
physically not addicting, it is highly additive psychologically. Some of its
effects include anxiety, depression and fainting. Long-term effects include
weight loss, feeling of being persecuted, loss of sleep and restlessness.
Depressants
Hallucinogens
These drugs are often all ―psychedelic drugs‖. They cause one to see and hear
things in a highly detailed but different way. The type of company has a great
deal of influence on the effects experienced. Intense emotions can be
experienced, sensations can be heightened, and lack of awareness of time, place
and identity can occur. LSD (Lysergic Aids Diethylamide) or ‗Aid‘ is the best
known of these drugs, the effect of which (called ‗trip‘) can last for several
days. A tiny amount of it is adequate to give a feeling of being ‗high‘. Mixed
with ‗speed‘, it can result in a ‗bad trip‘. Also, taken without proper guidance
from others, it has been known to lead even to death. In India, ‗datura‘ a plant,
is known to have even a stronger effect than LSD, sometimes leading to mental
instability. Datura can be smoked as dried leaves, eaten or drunk as an extract
of the stems, roots and seeds
Cannabis
Ganja, hashish (charas), and bhang are all known as cannabis drugs as they are
produced from different parts of the hemp or cannabis plant. These drugs are
the most widely used in the world. Ganja (known also as grass, pot, joint, weed,
Self-Instructional Material
50
marijuana, reefer and dope, etc.) is smoked with cigarettes while charas is Urban problems
prepared in black ‗golis‘ and is put into cigarettes for smoking or eaten with
food. Bhang is usually smoked or drunk and even eaten in a paste form. The NOTES
immediate effects of smoking cannabis are a sense of relaxation, and a
tendency to feel and see more sharply. It increases the current emotion and
lowers inhibition. More strikingly it may hang one‘s sense of time and
movement. It may damage one‘s ability to perform tasks that require
concentration, quick action and coordination. It may produce psychological
dependence. Its major danger, however, is that its consumption leads to taking
of stronger or ‗hard‘ drugs, after some time.
Opiates
There are three major types of opiate, viz. opium itself, heroin and morphine,
all of which come from the poppy plant. Opiates can be natural or produced in
the laboratory. Opium itself is commonly taken by villagers in India and does
not always cause social problems, if rarely consumed. However, for many, it
becomes an addiction, leading to mental and physical dependence. Morphine
which is used as a pain-killer is highly addictive. Heroin, however, is the most
devastating laboratory product of morphine, and the most commonly used.
Heroin is several times stronger than morphine, both in its effect and in the
addition that is caused. Pure heroin is expensive. Therefore, its unrefined form
viz. ‗brown sugar‘, ‗smack‘ or ‗gard‘ had become very popular. Its initial price
is cheap, making it easily available to the poor. It can be injected or smoked,
but is usually ―chased‖. i.e. it is placed on a spoon or silver foil and the smoke
that comes out when the foils is heated from below, is taken in through the
mouth. A highly addicting drug—both physically and psychologically—it is
the most abused drug in India these days. In addition to the above, there are
other artificially produced opiates known as ‘methadone‘ and ‗pethidine‘, the
former being used in the West to replace the more addictive substance i.e.
heroin for addicts.
5.5 PROSTITUTION
Trafficking
Self-Instructional Material
52
Urban problems
Trafficking has become the third highest income earner after the illegal arms
trade and drug trafficking. Kristof and Wudunn define trafficking, technically, NOTES
as taking someone (by force or deception) across an international border. They
quote that the U.S. State department has estimated that between 600,000 and
800,000 people are trafficked across international borders each year and 80%
of them are women and girls, mostly for sexual exploitation. According to
them, trafficking has increased because of three reasons. Firstly, when
Communism collapsed in Eastern Europe, the power vacuum was filled by
criminal gangs. As a result, capitalism not only created markets for rice and
potatoes but also for flesh trade. Poverty and international tourist industry
make millions of women and girl children cross national boundaries for
commercial sex where female bodies and labour are bought and sold.
Secondly, globalisation has increased the number of such sex slaves. Thirdly,
because of the fear of AIDS, customers prefer young girls so that they will be
less likely to be infected and also because of the myth that AIDS can be cured
by sex with virgin girls (Kristof and Wudunn, 2009, pp.10-12).
According to the UN Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish trafficking in
persons, especially women and children, trafficking is:
―…the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring of recipt of persons, by
means of threat or use of force or coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of
deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of giving
or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having
control over another person for the purposes of exploitation. Exploitation shall
include, at a minimum, the exploitation of the prostitution of others or other
forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or services, slavery or practices
similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs‖ (cited in Social
Development Notes, 2009, p.1).
Trafficking of women and children is under the control of insidious Mafia
groups in collision with local police. Statistics show that the number of girl
children trafficked is on the increase every year. Every day, one million
children are affected in Asia alone while two million are trafficked every year
across borders. Sex tourism has become a booming industry. Thailand‘s
economy thrives on sex tourism. Almost 49% of the tourists come for sex with
children and come mostly from East Asia, the United States of America, and
Europe.
Feminists like Kathleen Barry, Catharine MacKinnon and Laura Lederer hold
that prostitution is not a conscious and calculated choice of women.
Dr.V.Mohini Giri, who was the Chairperson of the National Commission for
Women, India, in her analysis on the Indian situation states that there are four
distinct ways why women enter into the flesh trade:
I) Girls are kidnapped, induced, allured and sold (in many cases by parents
themselves). Nearly 80-85 percent comes into prostitution through this
53 Self-Instructional Material
Urban problems pathway.
NOTES
II) About 10 percent are off-springs of the prostitutes- unwed or wedded. In
such cases, even though the mothers do not like their daughters to follow them
in their profession, the powerful nexus of Gharwalis (brothel keepers), pimps,
and pahalwans (musclemen) decide otherwise.
III) Then there is caste/community specific prostitution. Going from
generation after generation, this is the type of child-prostitution which is
practiced in specific areas in some communities under the gaze of the family
itself.
IV) And finally we have special types – the profession with links in some of
the religious customs. Instances are Devadasis in Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh,
Odisha and Maharastra, Bhavanis in Goa, Kudikars in West Coast, Johins in
Andhra Pradesh, Thevaradiyar in Tamil Nadu, Basavis in Karnataka and
Muralis, Jogateens and aradhinis in Maharashtra (refer Giri, 2001).
Liberal feminism which advocates individual‘s free will conceives prostitution
as a contract in a private business transaction. On the other hand, radical
feminism views a prostitute as a human being who has been reduced to a piece
of merchandise. The liberal contends that a woman is free to enter into
contracts. However, the radical feminist does not believe that a prostitute‘s
desire to enter into such a ―contract‖ is done of her own free will. Even if
prostitution has been an independent decision, it is generally the result of
extreme poverty and lack of opportunity, or of serious underlying problems,
such as drug addiction, past trauma (especially child sexual abuse) and other
unfortunate circumstances. Nicholas D. Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn ( 2009, p.
5) quote one 2008 study on Indian brothels and say that out of India and
Nepali prostitutes who started as teenagers, about half said they had been
coerced into the brothels; women who began working in their twenties were
more likely to have made the choice themselves, often
Commodified Bodies to feed their children. Those who start out enslaved often
accept their fate eventually and sell sex willingly, because they know nothing
else and are too stigmatized to hold other jobs.
Most suggest that valid consent to prostitution is impossible or at least
unlikely. It is found out that impoverished women, women at low level of
education, women from the most disadvantaged racial and ethnic minorities
are overrepresented in prostitution all over the world. ―If prostitution is a free
choice, why are the women with the fewest choices the ones most often found
doing it?‖ asks Catherine MacKinnon (1987). Most prostitutes are in a very
difficult period of their lives and most want to leave this occupation.
MacKinnon (1987) argues that ‗in prostitution, women have sex with men they
would never otherwise have sex with. The money thus acts as a form of force,
not as a measure of consent. It acts like physical force does in rape‘. For
radical feminists, this is because prostitution is always a coercive sexual
practice.
Decriminalisation
55 Self-Instructional Material
Urban problems To reduce the destructive impacts of sexual objectification and
commodification of women‘s bodies, one cannot depend on laws alone. Much
NOTES can be done by women and men, hand-in-hand in solidarity and by informed
and gender-sensitized individuals. Transformation should occur at all levels
to build a healthy on man-woman relationship: individual, social, economic,
political in collaboration with community, social bodies, governmental and
non-governmental institutions.
Think about what we can do in writing, arts, reporting, media production,
training, science and technology, school curriculum, socio-cultural practices,
legal status, policies and rights, collective movements, and in our personal
relationships and ideologies, to bring about positive changes in the
representations of women‘s bodies.
5.6 POLLUTION
Sources of Pollutants
Pollutants may originate from both the natural processes (such as forest fires,
volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, tsunami etc.) or through anthropogenic
activities (such as industrialization, transportatio~~ etc.). But the pollutants
from anthropogenic activities are more damaging because they are released in
the periphery of human settlements. So generally the environmental
contaminants that are resulted from the human activities are referred to as
pollutants. Some sources of pollutants, such as nuclear power plants or oil
tankers, can release very severe pollution when accidents occur. Some of the
more common pollutants are: chlorinated hydrocarbons, heavy metals like lead
(in lead paint and until recently in gasoline), cadmium (in rechargeable
batteries), chromium, zinc, arsenic and benzene.
Classification of Pollutants
Types of Pollution
57 Self-Instructional Material
Urban problems b) Classification according to the pollutants: The pollution caused by human
activities may be ofa number oftypes. For example, radioactive pollution,
NOTES sewage pollution, pesticide pollution, noise pollution, thermal pollution,
plastic pollution, marine pollution, smoke pollution, smog pollution, chemical
pollution, industrial pollution, metal toxicity pollution, drug pollution,
biological pollution, silt pollution, soap and detergent pollution, oil pollution
etc. To make the environmental pollution study easier it will be useful to study
different types of pollutions sphere wise.
1. Housing - Housing provision for the growing urban population will be the
biggest challenge before the government. The growing cost of houses
comparison to the income of the urban middle class, has made it impossible
for majority of lower income groups and are residmg in congested
accommodation and many of those are devoid of proper ventilation, lighting,
water supply, sewage system, etc.
2. Any substance (usually chemical) which influences our bodies or
emotions when consumed may be called a drug, i.e. it is a chemical
substance, that, when put into your body can change the way the body works
and the mind thinks. These substances may be medicinal i.e. prescribed by a
doctor for reducing minor ailments or problems, e.g. lack of sleep, headache,
tension, etc. but are also
ii) used for an excessively long period of time,
i) used without medical advice,
iii) used for reason other than medical ones.
The use of such drugs is usually legal.
3. A crime is termed ―juvenile delinquency‖ when committed by a young
person under a certain age. The age of the juvenile delinquent is not
consistently set around the world. In India, this age limit is set at 16 years for
boys and 18 years for girls. The other aspect in case of young persons is that
there are certain behaviour which would not be considered criminal in nature
if committed by adults, but they will be taken note of as crime if committed
by youth. For example, a person below the age of 16 years who:
i) is uncontrollable by his parents or guardians by reason of being wayward
or by being habitually disobedient.
ii) Habitually plays truant from school
iii) Lives without ostensible means of subsistence
iv) Habitually behaves in such a way as to endanger the morale or health of
himself/herself.
4. Pollution is classified in two ways either according to the environment
(air, water, soil, noise, thermal etc.) in which it occurs or according to the
pollutants by which they are caused.
a) Classification based on environment: They can be categorized as:
i) Air pollution
ii) Water pollution
iii) Soil pollutio~l
59 Self-Instructional Material
Urban problems
5.10 SUGGESTED READINGS
NOTES
Self-Instructional Material
60
UNIT VI URBAN COMMUNITY Urban Community
NOTES
DEVELOPMENT: DEFINITION,
CONCEPT, OBJECTIVES AND
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
Structure
6.1 Introduction
6.2 Urban Community Development
6.3 Definition
6.4 Concept
6.5 Objectives
6.6 Historical background
6.7 Lets Sum Up
6.8 Check Your Progress
6.9 Answer to Check Your Progress
6.10 Suggested Readings
6.1 INTRODUCTION
We have discussed the issues and challenges related to urban development in
the preceding Unit. But, the urban development issues and challenges can be
effectively
Addressed only through propzr policies and programmes of urban
development. In
India, the Ministry of Urban Development is responsible for formulating
policies,
supporting and monitoring programmes and coordinating the activities of
various Central Ministries, State Governments and other nodal authorities in
so far as they relate to urban development in the country. Hence, in the present
Unit we attempt to present to you a broad picture of the policies and
programmes of urban development and their relevance to addressing of the
issues and challenges of urban development in India
6.3 DEFINITION
6.4 CONCEPT
6.5 OBJECTIVES
Today urbanisation refers to population shift from rural to urban areas. In the
historical context, urbanisation also referred to the process by which the rural
world spawned a new kind of settlement called the city. The study of urban
history is an attempt to study both processes. Urban and rural do not refer to
separate and distinct processes. Once the city was invented, ‗rural‘ simply
represented a form of specialisation. Cities cannot be understood without their
rural hinterland and rural peasantry cannot be understood without discovering
Self-Instructional Material
64
its links with the city. So, the study of urban history automatically becomes the Urban Community
study of change in legal-institutional, demographic and cultural processes.
Urban history is an enquiry into the economic, political, social and spatial NOTES
systems that created this form of settlement. A city needs to be placed in its
regional, national and trans-national context.
The experience of community development has so far been limited to rural
areas. There is, however, a growin g realisation of the need for urban
community development. The pattern and content of such programmes for
urban areas have not yet been worked out although a beginning In this
direction has been made, notably in Delhi, where the Municipal Corporation
has set up a separate department of Urban Community Development wit h the
assistance of the Ford Foundation.
Rural community development ideally encompasses the entire village
community , even if in reality it results In greater benefits to the economically
better off section of the population. It is an integrated programme of
development covering all aspects of the farmers' life but mainly emphasizing
the economic. The programme is implemented through stimulation of local
effort and State assistance. It involves introduction of improved practices in
the field of production which yield tangible economic gains to the individual
peasant, stimulation of collective effort to meet both economic and non-
economic needs of the whole community and educational programmes for
social and cultural betterment. Successive reports of the Programme
Evaluation Organization have shown that people have responded mainly to the
economic aspects of the programme. Efforts to involve people in planning and
execution of programmes for their o wn benefit have included strengthening of
village panchayats by makin g them integral parts of the system of local self-
government.
Urban Conditions
Thus in rural areas work has been with h entire village communities and the
programmes have aimed to cover all aspects of village life. Villages moreover
are characterized, relatively speaking, by homogeneity, both social and
economic, and by common bonds and traditions, which have to some extent
created in the people a sense of belonging and loyalty to the village. In spite of
this the tas k of the rura l development worker has not been an easy one.
The situation in urban areas is substantially different. The city is not a
community . It is characterized by heterogenous population, by competing
groups, by wide disparities In income, by formal , impersonal relationships
and by relatively high spatial and class mobility. When we thin k of urban
communit y development we thin k of lower income groups, particularl y the
residents of .slum areas who live in sub-human conditions. It is thought that
the communit y development approach would be able to make an effective
contribution to the improvement of the livin g conditions of these people. The
lower income group, however, can be considered a communit y only in a
Marxist sense It is true that people in slum areas may be clustered together, if
not organized on the basis of religion or caste. Neither of these bonds,
65 Self-Instructional Material
Urban Community however, are sufficient from the point of view of community development
which is concerned mainly with neighborhood communities residing in the
NOTES same locality and having, therefore, some common interests and concerns
arising out of residence in the same area or neighborhood. Provision of Civic
Amenities In urban community development, therefore. Community is an
entity that we can take for granted much less than in rural areas. It has to be
cultivated and nurtured. The urban community development worker may have
to begin from the very beginning. He may have to draw boundaries and create
a community. The content of the urban community development programme
will also be different from rural community development programmes. Rural
community development, as has been stated earlier, Includes programmes for
economic betterment. Development of agriculture and rura l industries is an
important aspect of community development. The diversity and nature of the
urban community makes development programmes of economic welfare very
difficult.
__________________________________________________________
The scope of urban community development is consequently very much
_
restricted and it cannot possibly offer a total programme of development It
concerns itself mainly with seeking community interest and cooperation in the
provision of civic amenities and services and in enriching the social and
cultural life of the community. Probably the only possibility of bringing
economic benefit to the community is through the provision of part-time jobs
that could be undertaken by women with little or no training in their spare time
at home, and the organization of consumers' cooperatives. It is not easy to find
suitable jobs that women can do at home. A consumers' cooperative if run
properly may be of some benefit to the members in the long run.
67 Self-Instructional Material
Urban Community 4. Finley, M., (1977) ‗The ancient city: from Fustel de Coulanges
to Max Weber and Beyond‘ Comparative Studies in Society and
NOTES History, Vol. 19.
5. Fischer, Claude S. 1975 Towards a subcultural theory of
urbanism, Reprinted in J.J.
6. Macionis and N. Benokraitis (ed.) 1989 Seeing Ourselves
(pp367-373). Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
7. Hayden, Dolores, (1996) The Power of Place: Urban
Landscapes as Public History (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
8. Jacobsen T, Adams RMcC., (1958) ‗Salt and silt in ancient
Mesopotamian agriculture‘,Science, Vol. 128, pp. 1251-58.
9. Fried, Morton, (1967) The Evolution of Political Society (New
York: Random House).
10. Martindale, D., (1958) ‗The Theory of the City‘ in Weber,
Max, The City, Translated and edited by Martindale (New York: Don
and Neuwirth, G. Free Press).
Self-Instructional Material
68
BLOCK III: APPROACHES, Approaches
NOTES
PRINCIPLES PROCESS AND METHODS
OF URBAN COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT AND URBAN
DEVELOPMENT ADMINISTRATION
UNIT VII : APPROACHES, PRINCIPLES
PROCESS AND METHODS OF URBAN
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT,
WELFARE EXTENSION PROJECTS OF
CENTRAL SOCIAL WELFARE BOARD,
URBAN DEVELOPMENT PLANNING.
Structure
7.1 Introduction
7.2 Approaches
7.3 Principles
7.4 Process
7.5 Methods of urban community development,
7.6 Welfare extension projects of central social welfare board,
7.7 Urban development planning
7.8 Lets Sum Up
7.9 Check Your Progress
7.10 Answer to Check Your Progress
7.11 Suggested Readings
7.1 INTRODUCTION
Urban area is the most dynamic sector which requires the use of
multidisciplinary approaches for their planning and management. The
magnitude and dynamics of urban areas are major challenges for those
responsible for their planning and management. Formulating and implementing
effective planning and management approaches are a major challenge for both
developed as well as developing countries. In this unit, you will be learning
more about urban planning and planning processes.
After reading this unit you will be able to:
• Explain meaning, need and importance of urban planning
• Describe various types of planning required for urban development
• Narrate the thrust of urban planning in different five year plans in India.
69 Self-Instructional Material
Approaches
7.2 APPROACHES
NOTES
Due to the complex nature of the problem, there is need to approach it from
several directions. First, we are concerned with the relationship between the
city and civilization, with the fact that the modern literate man is integrally
wound up with urbanism and all that it implies. The task here is twofold: (1)
meaningfully to identify the city and (2) to trace the origins of modern city
life back to their antecedents. Cities have been seen in the wider context of the
history of civilization by many scholars such as G. Botero, A.F. Weber,
Spengler, Toynbee, Geddes, Ghurye, Mumford and Wirth. While Botero and
Weber sought more specific causes and conditions for the growth of cities in
different civilizations, Spengler and Toynbee generally considered world
history in terms of city history. Geddes viewed the city as a mirror of
civilization. Mumford and Ghurye have elaborated this idea in different
historical contexts. Wirth also maintained that the history of civilization
should be written in terms of the history of cities and that the city was the
symbol of civilization.
While these ideas remained general, more specific insights into
urbanism and urbanisation in the context of civilization were provided by the
set of - concepts worked out by Redfield and his colleagues. They developed a
different perspective in the study of cities, by constructing a typology of city
and working out its organisational and functional aspects. Distinguishing
between orthogenetic and heterogenetic process, they argued that primary
organisation consists in the transformation of the Little Tradition into the
Great Tradition, and that secondary urbanisation introduced the elements of
freedom from tradition.
Second, the physical mechanism as a preconditioning force requires
deliberation. This is the ecology of urbanism, a concern with the city as a
physical object composed of streets, buildings, facilities for communication
and transportation, and a complex of technical devices through which an area
is transformed into a human community. This ecological dimension, a
necessary approach, embraces those physical, spatial, and material aspects of
urban life distinguishable from will, consensus, and deliberate action of a
social psychological nature. The key question here is: Why do certain 14
human types, groups, races, professions, and physical utilities tend to move to
certain areas in the city, and how does the configuration of settlement enter
into social life? In case of Indian cities, especially in old cities like Delhi, Agra
and Amritsar. The inner parts of the cities can be divided into Mohallas or
traditional neighbourhoods which are exclkt5ively inhabited by a particular
occupational or caste qroup. All Indian cities have this pattern. The new or
more recent parts of cities may be called as colonial and post colonial parts of
the city. Usually these parts of the city are on the other side of the railway line,
these are entirely different from old ones, here, people are grouped on the
basis of income rather than caste or occupation. They are grouped on the basis
of plot size also. The socio-economic status of an area can be determined on
the basis of more . number of bigger plots in that area and wider roads and
available infrastructure. A poor residential area can be easily distinguished
Self-Instructional Material
70
from such richlposh residential areas due to its appearance and available ' Approaches
infrastructure.
Third is the form of social organisation. This perspective deals with the basic NOTES
forms of urban life that have evolved as a direct result of urbanisation.
Sociology as a discipline has probably made its largest contribution to this
dimension of the urbanisation process. The social organisation of the modern
urban community can be said to include a huge and complex network of
individuals, groups, bureaucratic structures, and social institutions, which is
further differentiated into a complex division of labour. The unit of analysis
can be ranked from the smallest and most simple to the largest and most
elaborate, as follows: The Individuals: The urban individuals can best be
described in terms of patterns of personality organisation and individual life
styles that are believed to have evolved in response to the conditions of urban
life. Much of the early writings on the urban individual was based on the idea
that the city produces distinct personality and behavioural characteristics that
set urbanites apart from their rural counterparts. But recent writing on urban
personality and life style has been more dynamic and has described
mechanism for coping with or adjusting to the urban complex, or the
techniques of urban survival (Lofland, 1973). The concern with the individual
also brings into focus many socio-cultural dimensions, such as the positive or
negative attitudes, values, beliefs, perceptions and symbolic attachments that
have come to be associated with urban life.
7.3 PRINCIPLES
Step 2: Develop and draft the different steps of the planning process via
workshop and interviews
Step 7: Use and discuss the upgraded scheme (also find a common
understanding with utilities and grid operators)
Self-Instructional Material
72
Approaches
Step 8: Link this scheme to decision trees for the energy supply
solutions for an area NOTES
7.5 METHODS OF URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Urban and regional development can be broadly divided into ―Urban
Development‖ and ―Regional Development.‖ The areas covered by and the
issues inherent in each differ, and therefore the approaches to development
also naturally differ. Because ―regional development‖ covers wide areas where
several cities and rural areas have organically combined, it needs to tackle
integrated problems such as regional disparities, depopulation problems, and
regional economic stagnation. Therefore, the various structures within the
region (the structure of spaces, industry structure, social structure, etc.) must
be properly understood, and the resolution of development issues must be
addressed from a more macro perspective.
On the other hand, although various issues are also involved in ―urban
development,‖ compared to ―regional development,‖ it covers relatively
limited areas, namely cities, and a more concrete set of problems such as
infrastructure improvements and the upgrading of residential environments.
The approach required here is one that utilizes the know-how of each
individual sector.Given the basic realization as discussed above that different
approaches have been taken for the ―urban development‖ and ―regional
development,‖ this report will take these two issues as respective development
objectives. With consideration given to the size of the range covered by each
of these development categories, we first deal with ―regional development,‖
and then follow with a discussion of ―urban development.‖
The Central Social Welfare Board obtained its legal status in 1969. It was
registered nder section 25 of the Indian Companies Act, 1956
The State Social Welfare Boards were set up in 1954 in all States and Union
Territories. The objective for setting up of the State Social Welfare Boards
was to coordinate welfare and developmental activities undertaken by the
various Departments of the State Govts. to promote voluntary social welfare
agencies for the extension of welfare services across the country, specifically
in uncovered areas. The major schemes being implemented by the Central
Social Welfare Board were providing comprehensive services in an
integrated manner to the community.
Many projects and schemes have been implemented by the Central Social
Welfare Board like Grant in Aid, Welfare Extension Projects, Mahila
Mandals , Socio Economic Programme, Dairy Scheme, Condensed Course
of Education Programme for adolescent girls and women, Vocational
Training Programme, Awareness Generation Programme, National Creche
Scheme, Short Stay Home Programme, Integrated Scheme for Women's
Empowerment for North Eastern States, Innovative Projects and Family
Counselling Centre Programme.
Self-Instructional Material
74
Approaches
NOTES
Over six decades of its incredible journey in the field of welfare, development
and empowerment of women and children, CSWB has made remarkable
contribution for the weaker and marginalized sections of the society. To meet
the changing social pattern, CSWB is introspecting itself and exploring new
possibilities so that appropriate plan of action can be formulated. Optimal
utilisation of ICT facilities will be taken so that effective and transparent
services are made available to the stakeholders.
many projects and schemes have been implemented by the central social
welfare board like grant in aid, welfare extension projects, mahila mandals ,
socio economic programme, dairy scheme, condensed course of education
programme for adolescent girls and women, vocational training programme,
awareness generation programme, national creche scheme, short stay home
programme, integrated scheme for women's empowerment for north eastern
states, innovative projects and family counselling centre programme.
The scheme of family counselling centre was introduced by the cswb in 1983.
the scheme provides counselling, referral and rehabilitative services to women
and children who are the victims of atrocities, family maladjustments and
social ostracism and crisis intervention and trauma counselling in case of
natural/ manmade disasters. working on the concept of people‘s participation,
fccs work in close collaboration with the local administration, police, courts,
free legal aid cells, medical and psychiatric institutions, vocational training
centres and short stay homes. over six decades of its incredible journey in the
field of welfare, development and empowerment of women and children, cswb
has made remarkable contribution for the weaker and marginalized sections of
the society. to meet the changing social pattern, cswb is introspecting itself and
exploring new possibilities so that appropriate plan of action can be
formulated. optimal utilisation of ict facilities will be taken so that effective
and transparent services are made available to the stakeholders.
Self-Instructional Material
76
7.7 URBAN DEVELOPMENT PLANNING Approaches
a) Urban Sprawl
77 Self-Instructional Material
Approaches Increased Traffic: Populations will begin to use their cars more often, which
means that there is more traffic on the roads.
NOTES
Environmental Issues: When you think about going out to develop these lands
you will have to worry about the wildlife that lives in these lands. You will be
displacing them, and it can really cause a ripple in the environment.
b) Individual Control or Small Parcels of Land
Private ownership of small parcels of urban land sometimes interferes with the
effective control of the space pattern of the city like the following:
If a private owner enjoys unrestricted right to use his/her land as he wishes, he
may build a shop or a factory in the residential area, thus decreasing the value
of the nearby residences.
If in a continuous residential area where two houses walls are shared, the
problem arises in such areas when one house owner is willing to renovate the
house and another is not in case of deterioration. They may develop conflict,
which may turn out to be a problem in the future.
d) Housing Affordability
Census population doubles which require more housing spaces, yet our goal to
meet the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future
generations to meet their own needs.
79 Self-Instructional Material
Approaches affordability.
NOTES
Here is ―Alejandro Aravena‖ comes with an innovative solution for Housing
Affordability through his architectural philosophy.
b) Zero-Carbon Cities
c) Green Roofs
Green Roofs (roofs with a vegetated surface and substrate) provide ecosystem
services in urban areas, including improved storm-water management, better
regulation of building temperatures, reduced urban heat-island effects, and
increased urban wildlife habitat.
Just imagine if this technology was applied to every building within your city, it
comes with unlimited benefits as following:
Storm Water Management and Water Retention since Green roofs can help with
controlling the stormwater runoff which is a major problem in many cities. They
have the ability to retain water at a rate of 50-90% depending on the design of
the roofs.
Improvement of Micro-climate as rainwater evaporates, it humidifies the air
above it, making the air cooler. This reduces the ambient temperature of the air
above rooftops, improving the micro-climate. Since the rooftop becomes cooler,
the efficiency of the building‘s AC units is improved.
Self-Instructional Material
80
Dust and Toxic Particles Binder where air pollution is a common phenomenon Approaches
in all major cities. Green roofs can play a vital role in filtering the air pollutants,
improving the quality of air. When the air flows, the foliar surface of green roof NOTES
reduces the speed of air flowing above it. This filters 10-20% of dust particles
from the air, thus, helping to purify the air.
Protection from Noise Pollution as green roofs can be of great advantage when it
comes to noise pollution. Urban areas are mostly subjected to sources of loud
sounds and noises particularly because of buildings being located under flight
paths, adjacent to nightclubs, markets, malls, and fairs and so on.
d) Sustainable Transportation
Transport has a major impact on the spatial and economic development of cities
and regions. The attractiveness of particular locations depends in part on the
relative accessibility, and this in turn depends on the quality and quantity of the
transport infrastructure.
The concept of sustainable transportation promotes a balance between
transportation‘s economic and social benefits and the need to protect the
environment.
In further articulating this idea, the Center for Sustainable Transportation has
defined a sustainable transportation system as one that:
Allows individuals and societies to meet their access needs safely and in a
manner consistent with human and ecosystem health, and with equity within and
between generations.
Is affordable operates efficiently, offers a choice of transport mode, and
supports a vibrant economy.
Limits emissions and waste within the planet‘s ability to absorb them
minimizes consumption of non-renewable resources, limits consumption of
renewable resources to the sustainable yield level reuses and recycles its
components, and minimizes the use of land and the production of noise.
Depending on modern-technology we can convert current polluting
transportation into an environmentally friendly one.
India is urbanising. This transition, which will see India‘s urban population
reach
a figure close to 600 million by 2031, is not simply a shift of demographics. It
places cities and towns at the centre of India‘s development trajectory. In the
coming decades, the urban sector will play a critical role in the structural
transformation of the Indian economy and in sustaining the high rates of
economic growth. Ensuring high quality public services for all in the cities and
towns of India is an end in itself, but it will also facilitate the full realisation
81 Self-Instructional Material
Approaches of India‘s economic potential. India‘s economic growth momentum cannot be
sustained if urbanisation is not actively facilitated. Nor can poverty be
NOTES addressed if the needs of the urban poor are isolated from the broader
challenges of managing urbanisation. Cities will have to become the engines
of national development. India cannot afford to get its urban strategy wrong,
but it cannot get it right without bringing about a fundamental shift in the
mindset which separates rural from the urban.
83 Self-Instructional Material
Legislation Related to Urban
Development UNIT VIII LEGISLATION RELATED
NOTES TO URBAN DEVELOPMENT: URBAN
LAND CEILING ACT, TOWN AND
COUNTRY PLANNING ACT,
NAGARPALIKA ACT AND TAMIL NADU
SLUM CLEARANCE AND
IMPROVEMENT ACT) COMMUNITY
PLANNING, AND COMMUNITY
PARTICIPATION
Structure
8.0 Introduction
8.1 Legislation Related To Urban Development
8.2 Urban Land Ceiling Act
8.3 Town And Country Planning Act,
8.4 Nagarpalika Act
8.5 Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance And Improvement Act)
8.6 Community Planning, Community Participation
8.7 Lets Sum Up
8.8 Check Your Progress
8.9 Answer to Check Your Progress
8.10 Suggested Readings
8.0 INTRODUCTION
The World is urbanizing very fast and more than 45 per cent of the World‘s
population today are residing in urban areas. According to UN estimation, the
Wold population is expected to increase by 72 percent by 2050, from 3.6 billion
in 2011 to 6.3 billion in 2050.Customarily urbanization means increasing
population living in cities and suburbs cities of a country. In 19th and 20th
century, majority of the cities in the world are undergoing growth of urban
population. In India also urban population which was 0.37 percent in 1951 has
risen to 27.81 percent in 2001 and 31.16 percent in 2011 and is increasing day
by day. According to Asian Development Bank, the national increase and net
migration are the major contributory factors to urban growth. The share of
world‘s population living in urban areas has increased from 39 percent in 1980
to 48 percent in 2000. However, urbanization without proper planning has
given rise to several problems such as housing, sanitation, education, provision
of safe drinking water, unemployment, etc. particularly in underdeveloped
countries. This unit on ―Urban Development: An Overview‖ will provide you
information and knowledge regarding urbanization, its trends, impact and idea
Self-Instructional Material about sustainable urban development. After reading this unit, you will be able
84
to: Legislation Related to Urban
• Explain meaning and trend of urbanization Development
The Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act was enacted in India in 1976
with a view to curbing land price increases and promoting low-income housing
through socialisation of urban land. This paper critically examines the stated
objectives of the Act and the major achievements after its implementation, and
finds that the Act has so far not lived up to its expectations. The paper begins
with an introductory background for the evolution of the Act and highlights its
major provisions. A careful examination of the limitations in the
implementation of this Act and its major implications as per experience is then
presented. The paper concludes with the necessity for a thorough reappraisal of
major policy instruments, search for alternative strategies and consideration of
the realities of the existing situation in the country for possible improvement.
The Urban Land (Ceiling And Regulation) Act, 1976
1. Short title, application and commencement.—
(1) This Act may be called the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976.
(2) It applies in the first instance to the whole of the States of Andhra Pradesh,
Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Orissa, Punjab,
Tripura, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal and to all the Union territories and it
shall also -apply to such other State which adopts this Act by resolution passed
in that behalf under clause (1) of article 252 of the Constitution.
(3) It shall come into force in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Haryana,
Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Orissa, Punjab, Tripura, Uttar
Pradesh and West Bengal and in the Union territories at once and in any other
State which adopts this Act under clause (1) of article 252 of the Constitution,
on the date of such adoption; and, save as otherwise provided in this, Act, any
reference in this Act to the commencement of this Act shall, in relation to any
State or Union territory, mean the date on which this Act comes into force in
such State or Union territory.
Town and Country Planning Act, 1047, has been called a skeleton Act; but it is
a singularly robust-looking skeleton. Its 120 ample sections and eleven
formidable schedules dwarf the more modest New Towns Act, its companion in
the new planning code. Nevertheless, so extensive are the powers of delegated
legislation conferred by the Act that it may be some years before its full
implications become clear.
Before the war only a small proportion of local authorities had planning
schemes in actual operation. Whilst this was due partly to the phenomenal
prolixity of the procedure necessary for putting any local scheme into
operation under the 1982 Act, there were also more serious obstacles. The
Self-Instructional Material bogey of compensation frightened many authorities into adopting a timid
86
approach towards planning. They also tended to think in parochial terms; in the Legislation Related to Urban
words of the Explanatory Memorandum to the 1047 Bill, ' the tendency was for Development
each authority to plan thcir arca in isolation from their neighbours '. Nor were
they obliged to prepare any scheme whatever ; and if they did take positive NOTES
action,. their powers were insufficient to ensure satisfactory development, as
distinct from preventing bad development. Further, the system was
fundamentally rigid; once a planning scheme obtained the force of law, the
rocedure for amendment was too complicated. In recent years the idea .that
physical planning should be conceived as a national, rather than a local,
responsibility, has gained ground. The establishment of a Ministry of Town
and Country Planning in 1043 was followed in the same year and in 1944 by
statutes which brought this goal nearer to fulfilment. But the main weaknesses
persisted. The 1947 Act seeks to cure them by
solving the financial problems of local authorities and ht the same time erecting
a new structure of planning machinery to ensure that planning will be centrally
co-ordinated and also effectively executed.
Constitution (Seventy Forth Amendment) Act, 1992 has introduced a new Part
IXA in the Constitution, which deals with Municipalities in an article 243 P to
243 ZG. This amendment, also known as Nagarpalika Act, came into force on
1st June 1993. It has given constitutional status to the municipalities and
brought them under the justifiable part of the constitution. States were put
under constitutional obligation to adopt municipalities as per system enshrined
in the constitution.
An Act to provide for the improvement and clearance of slums in the State of
Tamil Nadu.
Whereas the number of slums in certain areas in the State of Tamil Nadu is on
the increase and the slums are likely to become a source of danger to public
health and sanitation of the said area.
And Whereas under the existing law, it has not been possible effectively to
arrest the growth of slums, to eliminate congestion and to provide for certain
basic needs such as streets, water -supply and drainage in slums and to clear
slums which are unfit for human habitation.
And Whereas to obviate this difficulty, it is expedient to provide for the
removal of unhygenic and insanitary conditions prevailing in slums, for better
accommodation and improved living conditions for slum dwellers, for the
promotion of public health generally and for the acquisition of land for the
purpose of improving or developing slum areas, re - developing slum clearance
areas and rehabilitating slum dwellers:
And Whereas it is Directive principle of State Policy embodied in the
constitution that the State should regard the improvement of public health as
among its primary duties. Be it enacted by the legislature of the State of Tamil
Nadu in the Twenty -second year of the Republic of India as follows:
Preliminary
1. Short title, extent and commencement. - This Act may be called Tamil Nadu
Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1971.
2. It extends to the whole of Tamil Nadu. Self-Instructional Material
89
Legislation Related to Urban 3. It should come into force on such date as the Government may, by
Development
notification, appoint and different dates may be appointed for different areas
NOTES
and for different provisions of this Act:
Provided that any reference in any such provision to the commencement
of this Act shall be construed as a reference to the coming into force of
that provision.
In this unit, you have learnt the concept and definition of community and
community participation. The pattern of community participation in health,
nutrition and development programme in general and more specifically in
RCH/MCH programme have been discussed in detail with view to learn the
extent to which the community could take up the responsibilities in these
areas under the Target Free Approach, now named as Community Needs
Assessment Approach (CNAA). We have tried to delineate the policy issues
and operational aspects where the community can take direct responsibility
by organizing self help groups for RCH services to realize the goal of NPP,
2000; how the process of community consultation has been built up in the
preparation of the subcentre action plan and implementation thereof.
Examples of successfull programmes where community participation was
forthcoming have been enlisted and the various reasons of success
stories have been delineated for better understanding. Factors which
promote/retard the community participation have also been discussed.
Probable resources which community can marshal have been identified. The
list is not exhaustive and one can add more to this list. Efforts of various
available groups which can contribute in community organization and
community actions have been enunciated. Learners have been provided a
chance to check their progress and further readings have been suggested.
Self-Instructional Material
92
8.9 ANSWER TO CHECK YOUR PROGRESS Legislation Related to Urban
Development
1.The Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act was enacted in India in 1976 NOTES
with a view to curbing land price increases and promoting low-income
housing through socialisation of urban land. This paper critically examines the
stated objectives of the Act and the major achievements after its
implementation, and finds that the Act has so far not lived up to its
expectations. The paper begins with an introductory background for the
evolution of the Act and highlights its major provisions. A careful examination
of the limitations in the implementation of this Act and its major implications
as per experience is then presented. The paper concludes with the necessity for
a thorough reappraisal of major policy instruments, search for alternative
strategies and consideration of the realities of the existing situation in the
country for possible improvement.
2.A study of the practice of community planning in the various disciplines
leads to the conclusion that despite their similar means, and the fact that they
are influenced by the same social processes, almost no dialogue exists among
the various professions engaged in community planning. The diversified
activity, rather than contributing to an enrichment of this occupation, has led to
a dispersal of the knowledge, has made it difficult to create a significant mass,
and has interfered with efficient learning of lessons from experience.
Self-Instructional Material
93
Urban Development Administration
UNIT IX URBAN DEVELOPMENT
NOTES
ADMINISTRATION: NATIONAL, STATE
AND LOCAL LEVELS; STRUCTURE
AND FUNCTIONS OF URBAN
DEVELOPMENT AGENCIES
Structure
9.0 Introduction
9.1 Urban Development Administration
9.2 National
9.3 State
9.4 Local levels
9.5 Structure
9.6 Functions of Urban Development Agencies
9.7 Lets Sum Up
9.8 Check Your Progress
9.9 Answer to Check Your Progress
9.10 Suggested Readings
9.0 INTRODUCTION
99 Self-Instructional Material
Urban Development Administration Board, Water Supply Undertaking, Electricity Supply Undertakings,
Urban Development Authorities, etc.
NOTES
9.6 FUNCTIONS OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT AGENCIES
In this section, you will read about the role of government agencies in
development. Various government agencies play important roles in directing
the development activities to be pursued in both the short and the long run.
The role of a few important government agencies that play an important part in
development in India is discussed. These agencies are:
i) The National Planning Commission -
Dynamics of Development ii) The Finance Commission of India
iii) The State Planning Board
iv) The District Planning Boards Committees
The National Planning Commission Rudimentary economic planning by
government agencies first began in India in the 1930s under colonial British
rule. The colonial government of India formally established a planning board
that functioned from 1944 to 1946. Private industrialists and economists
formulated at least three development plans in 1944.After India gained
independence, a formal model of planning was adopted, and the Planning
Commission, reporting directly to the Prime Minister of India, was
established. Accordingly, the National Planning Commission was set up on 15
March 1950, with Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru as the chairman. The First
Five-year Plan was launched in 195 1. Now, the Eleventh Five Year Plan is
underway in the country.
A few important functions of National Planning Commission are:
a) To make an assessment of the material, capital and human resources of the
country, including technical personnel, and to investigate the possibilities of
augmenting those resources that are found to be deficient in relation to the
nation's requirement
b) To formulate a Plan for the most effective and balanced utilization of
country's resources
C) To determine the priorities define the stages of the implementation of the
Plan, and to propose the allocation of resources for due completion of each
d) To indicate the factors tend to retard economic development, and determine
the conditions which, in view of the existing social and political situation,
need to be established for the successful execution of the Plan
e) To determine the nature of the machinery, which will be necessary for the
successful implementation of each stage of the Plan, in all its aspects
f) To appraise, from time to time, the progress achieved at each stage of the
Plan, and to recommend the adjustments of policy and measures that such
appraisal may show to be necessary
g) To make interim recommendations based after considering the prevailing
economic conditions, current policies, measures, and development
programmes.
From a highly centralized planning system, the Indian economy is gradually
moving towards indicative planning, where the Planning Commission
Self-Instructional Material
100
concerns itself with building a long term strategic vision of the future, and Urban Development Administration
decides on the priorities of the nation. It works out sectoral targets and
provides promotional stimuli for the economy to grow in the desired direction. NOTES
The Planning Commission plays an integrative role in the development of a
holistic approach to the policy formulation in critical areas of human and
economic development.
The emphasis of the Commission is on maximizing the output by using the
limited resources optimally. Instead of looking for mere increase in the plan
Development Agencies outlays, the effort is to look for increase in the
efficiency of utilization of the allocations.
ii) Finance Commission of India
The Constitution of India provides for the establishment of a Finance
Commission for the purpose of allocation of certain resources of revenue
between the Union and the State Governments. The President of India
established the Finance Commission under Article 280 of the Constitution.
The qualifications, powers and procedures of the Commission itself are
regulated
by the Finance Commission (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1951. The
Finance Commission is constituted to define financial relations between the
Centre and ' the States. Under the provision of Article 280 of the Constitution,
the President appoints a Finance Commission for the specific purpose of
devolution of nonplan revenue resources.
Under Article 280 of the Constitution, the Finance Commission is required to
make recommendations to the President about The distribution of net proceeds
of taxes to be shared between the centre and the states, and the allocation
between the states of the respective share of such proceeds.
The principles which should govern the grants-in-aid by the center to states
Out of the Consolidated Fund of India. The measures needed to augment the
consolidated fund of a state to supplement the resources of the Panchayats and
the Municipalities in the State on the basis of the recommendations made by
the State Finance Commission.
Any other matter referred to it by the President of India, in the interests of
sound finance. .,
The Finance Commission has the following powers
The Commission shall have all the powers of the Civil Court, as per the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. It can call any witness, or, can ask for the
production of any public record, or document, from any court or office. It can
ask any person to give information or documents on matters as it may feel to
be useful, or relevant. It can function as a civil court in discharging its duties.
iii) State Finance Commission
The 731~ constitutional amendment envisages that in every five year, the state
government shall appoint a Finance Commission to review the financial
aspects
of the Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRI), and Urban Local Bodies (LILBs). The
State Finance Commission (SFC) will give recommendations with regard to
i) The distribution between the state and the Panchayats of the net proceeds of
taxes, duties, tolls and fees leviable by the state which may be divided between
101 Self-Instructional Material
Urban Development Administration them, and how allocation would be made among the various levels of
panchayats Dynamicsof Development ii) What taxes, duties, tolls and fees
NOTES
may be assigned to the panchayats
iii) Grant -in-aids to the panchayats.
The report of the commission together with the action taken report shall be
laid before the state legislature. Many states have appointed their third State
Finance Commission. The State Finance Commission reports are referred to
in the matter of the allocation of resources to different sectors in the states.
iv) State Planning Boards
The State Planning Boards were formed, primarily, to assist the Planning
Commission in allocating resources to states, to enable the state governments
to formulate development plans based on a scientific assessment of the
resources of the state, and the growth priorities. The boards were assigned the
task of preparing an Annual Economic Review to be presented, along with the
Budget Document to the state legislatures.
The main functions of the State Planning Boards are:
1. To assess the resources of the state, and to prepare schemes for their
effective Utilization
2. To assist the District Planning Officers in preparing district plan
proposals, so that they may be incorporated in the overall Plan
3. To ascertain the obstacles to growth of the state economy, and to
suggest measures for removing regional.imbalances.
4. To monitor the progress of Plan schemes, and to suggest changes in
developmental policies To decide Plan priorities.
v) District Planning Boards and Committees
The decentralized planning process started long ago in India, and, in 1969, the
. Union Planning Commission issued guidelines for preparing district plans.
Realizing that the planning machinery and competency were not yet
developed at the district level at the time, efforts were redirected, in later
years, to strengthen the state level planning process. In the early 1980s, a
Working Group, under the Chairmanship of Professor C.H. Hanumantha Rao,
was constituted to develop guidelines for district plans. Based on the
recommendations of this Committee, the Seventh Five Year Plan adopted
decentralized planning at the district level as one of the major strategies to
achieve plan targets.
Local self-government is the prime instrument of decentralization at the grass
root level. The intention of local self-government is to shift from bureaucratic
administration to democratic administration, and to formulate, and execute
development programmes through people's participation, and to instill
political consciousness among the people. They act as vehicles in carrying
back to the people the power that really belongs to them. They ensure self-
governance through directly elected representatives.
According to Dr. D.R. Gadgil, the primary requirements of district planning
are the knowledge of local conditions. and the association of local with
formulation, and the implementation of development plans. The well known
Development Agencies Economist, Gunnar Myrdal pointed out, way back in
1968, "The ideal has always been that the plan should come from the people
Self-Instructional Material
102
and meet their wishes and needs, and have their support in thought, as well, as Urban Development Administration
deed". The points put forth in favour of decentralized planning are it
facilitates the formulation of locally relevant programmes, with reference to NOTES
natural endowments, and felt needs of the people it makes bureaucrats more
accountable to the people it also facilitates the participation of ordinary
people in the planning and development process At the state level, the District
Planning Board, and, more recently, after the 73rd Constitutional Amendment,
the District Planning Committees have begun to function. The important
functions of District Planning Board are i) To formulate a long term district
perspective plan, and to evolve a strategy of planned development for the
district, on the basis of felt needs of the people, and local priorities ii) To
prepare a priority-wise list of schemes and programmes, taking into account
the resources available from the plan fund and community contribution, well
before the beginning of each year
iii) To take appropriate measures for the proper implementation of schemes
and programmes and projects
iv) To monitor the progress of projects, and for this purpose the District
Planning and Development Board may meet as frequently as necessary. The
Board will send performance reports to the State Planning Board at regular
intervals.
V) To encourage the panchayats and other local bodies to implementat
development projects themselves. They are responsible for the maximum
involvement of people, and for developing confidence in their leadership, and
in their ability to implement development work. The involvement should be
both in terms of ilnancial and physical parameters
vi) To make efforts to generate additional resources for developmental work
with the cooperation of people. NGOs, NRIs, and other agencies and; vii)
Any other related function that might be assigned by the State Planning
Board.
In the 73rd Constitution Amendment, Article 243 ZD envisages that there
shall be a District Planning Committee in every district to consolidate the
plans prepared by the panchayats and municipalities in the district. Now, in
most states, the District Planning Committees (DPC) have been constituted.
The Act envisaged that the chairman of the Zilla Parishad (the District
Panchayat) be the chairman of DPC. However, in many states, DPCs are
headed by District Commissioners. The function of the DPCs is more, or
less, equivalent to the District Planning Board. Recently, the DPC has been
instrumental in the preparation of District Agriculture Plan, District BRGF
(Backward Region Grant Fund) plan and District NREGS (National Rural
Employment Guarantee Scheme) now called MREGA (Mahatma Gandhi
Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme) Plan in mo4t of I hc states
2. Municipalities – They are setup by the Acts of state legislature for the
administration of small cities or towns. It also has three authorities. First the
municipal council is the legislative branch of the municipality, and is headed by
the Chairman, who in turn is assisted by a Deputy Chairman. The standing
committees facilitate the work of municipality in various fields such as health,
taxation finance etc. The third authority of the municipality is the Chief
Municipal Officer, who is appointed by the state government and is responsible
for the general administration of the municipality.
In 1998, the National Housing and Habitat Policy (NHHP) was announced
which specifically emphasized that housing construction in both rural and
urban areas should be left in the hands of the private sector and that the
government should restrict itself to the role of a facilitator. The Policy
promised ―Shelter to All‖ by the year 2001 but this promise was to be realized
through the invisible hand of the market which was supposed to ensure
affordable housing to all if all impediments to its efficient functioning were
removed. As a follow up to the recommendations of the NHHP 1998, the Two
Million Housing Programme was launched in 1998-99. It was a loan based
scheme promoting the construction of 20 lakh additional housing units every
year (13 lakh for rural areas and 7 lakh for urban areas). Out of this HUDCO
was to meet the target of 4 lakh dwelling units in urban areas and 6 lakh in
rural areas annually. In 1999, the Draft National Slum Policy was announced
which proposed the integration of slum dwellers in the mainstream of urban
life through in-situ up gradation. The Draft Policy included all underserviced
settlements in its definition of slums and proposed their up gradation and
improvement as opposed to eviction. It also spoke about granting tenure to
slum dwellers inhabiting government land apart from providing them with
basic civic amenities. The Draft National Slum Policy was never adopted,
however in 2001, a Rs. 20 billion subsidy based scheme called the
ValmikiAmbedkarAwas Yojana (VAMBAY) was started with the aim to
provide/ upgrade shelter to urban slum dwellers.
In the 9th Plan period two other major steps were taken to further the process
of liberalization of land and real estate markets. The first step was the repeal of
Self-Instructional Material
110
the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act in 1999. The second major step Urban Services and Urban Deficiencies
was taken in 2002 when the government allowed 100 percent Foreign Direct
Investment (FDI) in integrated townships, including housing, commercial NOTES
premises, hotels and resorts. FDI was also permitted in infrastructure projects
such as roads, bridges, mass rapid transit systems and for the manufacturing of
building materials. The minimum area to be developed was fixed at 100 acres.
The 2001 Census had shown that contrary to the expectations and
predictions of a wide array of actors, the rate of growth of urban population
was steadily declining. This has been attributed to cities becoming
inhospitable to poor migrants due to the promulgation of neo-liberal urban
policies. However, the 10th Plan celebrates this fact and attributes it to the
success of rural development programmes along with the limited availability
of land for squatting in central urban areas. The Plan identifies urbanization as
a key determinant of the economic growth in the 1980s and 1990s, boosted by
economic liberalization. The 10th Plan (2002-07) was prepared in the backdrop
of the Union Budget of 2002-03 which had announced radical measures to
push cities into carrying out comprehensive urban reforms. The overriding
thrust of the 10th Plan was to promote overhauling of the legislative,
governance and administrative structure of cities through a set of market-
friendly urban reforms and promotion of PPPs in urban infrastructure and
services. A lot of emphasis was placed on making urban local bodies
financially strong so that they have to rely less and less on state transfers. To
enable ULBs to raise their own resources the Plan advocated reform in
property tax, levying of user charges, increasing non-tax revenues, controlling
establishment costs, better utilization of municipal assets and
overhauling municipal accounting systems. These reforms, it was suggested,
would enhance the credit-worthiness of ULBs and make them capable to
mobilising funds from capital market and investors. The Plan also spoke about
substantially increasing investment in up gradation of urban infrastructure and
services but made it clear that central assistance in this regard would be made
conditional upon states and ULBs carrying out sector reforms, in particular
better standard of services and levying of user charges
Housing Board in India has been set up in most of the Indian states by the
government of India in order to promote the property market's expansion.
The board for housing in India sees to the proper development of the ideally
located and well-placed colonies. To boost housing projects all over the country
the Housing Boards in India have been formed in various states.
The objectives of the Housing Boards in India are:
To provide housing accommodation to needy citizens at reasonable prices
To construct houses and to allot them under the categories of high income
group, middle income group, and low income group
To select the sites for housing and decide the services to be provided
To formulate schemes for self financing that help the middle and high income
groups
To construct commercial complexes, multi-storied buildings, and shops and
then to lease them out in rent so as to secure financial resources for the boards.
Some of the various housing boards in India are as under:
Gujarat Housing Board
Andhra Pradesh Housing Board
Himachal Pradesh Housing Board
Orissa Housing Board
Madhya Pradesh Housing Board
Among Indian Housing Boards, the one belonging to Gujarat was been set up
Self-Instructional Material
112
on May 1st, 1960 and has constructed over 176,754 houses in the entire state. Urban Services and Urban Deficiencies
The Andhra Pradesh Housing Board was established on July 1st, 1960 and has
constructed projects under various categories such as low, middle, and high NOTES
income groups and built around 69,398 houses. The Orissa Housing Board
was set up in 1968 and it has built around 28,500 houses in the state. The
Madhya Pradesh Housing Board had been set up under the 1972 Madhya
Pradesh Griha Nirman Mandal Adhiniyam Act. It has constructed a lot of
houses all over the state. The Housing Boards in India have been instrumental
in providing accommodation for lakhs of Indians across the country. Housing
Boards in India have been successful to a large extent and the government of
India needs to ensure the availability of funds for the housing boards to ensure
that they continue with their projects.
Urban population of India is larger than the total population of many countries.
Despite this important fact, one has to accept that India with about 27 per cent
of its population living in its urban areas is less urbanised. Also the spread of
its urban population is not even. The large cities especially the metropolitan
cities have most of the total urban population. Small and medium towns have
not flourished. Poor migrants from rural areas bypass these towns and arrive at
large cities in search of employment. About 15 per cent of the total urban
population of the States of India lives inslums. The actual picture is grimmer.
Around 23 per cent of the urban population of the towns reporting slums was
living in slums in 2001. The cities with more than one million population have
high percentage of population living in slums. Urban basic services are poor in
urban India and are less than the requirement. Urbanisation is happening in
India. But it has its problems. Major problems of urban areas of India are
overcrowding, congestion, inadequate basic services and urban infrastructure,
lack of efficient transport facilities, air pollution, environmental pollution and
existence of slums.
1.Urban services and mobility are key to inclusive, safe, resilient and
sustainable cities and human settlements. The New Urban Agenda needs to
make concrete recommendations for cities and human settlements to become
inclusive, safe, resilient, and sustainable by including access for all to
adequate, safe, affordable, accessible and sustainable basic services and
infrastructure.
113 Self-Instructional Material
Urban Services and Urban Deficiencies 2.Building Partnerships and Solutions in an Urbanizing World The United
Nations Centre for Human Settlements (Habitat) was established in 1978, two
NOTES years after the United Nations Conference on Human Settlements, held in
Vancouver, Canada. The Centre serves as the lead agency for the human
settlements development activities of the United Nations family, as well as
for the global exchange of information about human settlements conditions
and trends.
10.9 SUGGESTED READINGS
Government of India (2007), ―National Urban Housing and Habitat
Policy‖, Ministry of Housing and Poverty Alleviation
HUDCO (2004), ―Trends and Gaps in Housing and Basic Amenities in
India, 2001, (mimeo)
National Housing Bank (2010), ―Report on trend and Progress of
Housingn India‖(mimeo)
Odeyar d.Heggade and Francis Cherunilam (1987), Housing in
India,Himalaya Publications, New Delhi
Bhole, Vijaya (1988),Housing and Urban Development in India,
Classical Publications, New Delhi
Htpp://India.gov.in/default.php
Self-Instructional Material
114
Urban Development Programmes
UNIT XI ROLE OF VOLUNTARY
NOTES
AGENCIES IN URBAN COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT
Structure
11.0 Introduction
11.1 Voluntary Agencies
11.2 Voluntary Agencies In Urban Community Development
11.3 Role of Voluntary Agencies In Urban Community Development
11. 4 Lets Sum Up
11. 5 Check Your Progress
11.6 Answer to Check Your Progress
11.7 Suggested Readings
11.0 INTRODUCTION
There is no doubt that voluntary agencies have been playing a pioneering role
in rural development activities. They have also exhibited the qualities of
flexibility of service, personal touch and proximity to the clientele. In addition,
they have demonstrated the capacity to initiate and experiment with new
programmes and showed sensitivity to meet difficult problems in ways that
cannot be adopted by the state. However, it is necessary to envisage the
following role for these bodies in the context of village base organisations.
a) The voluntary agencies have to supplement and not to compete with
government efforts. The government should not consider their activities as
duplication.
b) They act as eyes and ears of the people at the rural level and act as a source
of reliable feedback to government so that it can design the policies and
programmes accordingly.
c) It is possible for the voluntary agencies to reach a large number of people
and set an example for others.
d) Voluntary bodies, quite often, take initiative in the implementation of certain
acts such as Minimum Wages Act, Abolition of Bonded Labour Act etc., in
letter and in spirit. Through public interest litigation and administrative
measures, these bodies could activise the system and make it respond.
e) Dissemination of information is another potential area in which the voluntary
agencies is of immense use. It is quite often seen that information regarding
various schemes, programmes projects etc., do not reach the rural poor.
Self-Instructional Material
116
Information is power and the role of the voluntary body is to distribute such Urban Development Programmes
power and make it accessible to the rural poor.
f) Voluntary sector has been in the forefront in utilizing rural skills and talent. NOTES
Further, it is possible to minimis? the dependency syndrome through various
methods and a sense of self-reliance has to be instilled among the villagers.
In this lesson, various issues have been analysed. A number of issues and
problems indicate the wide ranging scope of the subject. Voluntary action is
looked upon by many as an instrument of mass mobilisation or involvement of
large number of people and, thus, help to reduce the chasm between the
'governed' and the 'governors'. Voluntary action in patnership with the
government is an important issue. The presence of healthy atmosphere and
goodwill between government and voluntary agencies is a basic prerequisite to
strengthen good relations between the two. At present, there appears to be
mutual suspicion and lack of trust in each other. On several occasions,
voluntary agencies have been valued so long as they function within the
existing "order" and follow directives of government. Any agency that
questions the existing order is normally treated as a subject of law and order
problem, demanding repressive action.
A proper measuring norm has to be developed to assess the working of
voluntary organisations in this country. Apart from this, distribution of funds
remain a controversial and sensitive subject. It became acute when funds came
from international bodies. Some critics point out that the foreign donors use
these voluntary bodies, to whom they donate money, as clever ploy to weaken
the power of the state as a part of the large game of global power politics.
Further, selflessness and selfishness cannot always be distinguished easily.
Organisations, functioning at different levels in different areas, suffer from
lack of coordination. In spite of these and other problems, with their
uniqueness of the operational abilities, the voluntary agencies have a crucial
role to play in rural transformation.
11. 5 CHECK YOUR PROGRESS
Self-Instructional Material
118
UNIT XII URBAN DEVELOPMENT Urban Development Programmes
NOTES
PROGRAMMES: FIVE YEAR PLANS
AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT;
MADRAS URBAN DEVELOPMENT
PROJECTS (MUDP) I & II
Structure
12.0 Introduction
12.1 Urban Development Programmes
12.2 Five year plans and urban development;
12.3 Madras Urban Development Projects (MUDP) I & II
12 4 Lets Sum Up
12. 5 Check Your Progress
12.6 Answer to Check Your Progress
12.7 Suggested Readings
12.0 INTRODUCTION
As per 2001 population census 285.35 million people reside in urban areas. It
constitutes 27.8% of the total population of the country. In post-independence
era, while population of India has grown three times, the urban population has
grown five times. The rising urban population has also given rise to increase
in the number of urban poor.As per 2001 estimates, the slum population is
estimated to be 61.8 million. The ever increasing number of slum dwellers
causes tremendous pressure on urban basic services and infrastructure. In
order to cope with massive problems that have emerged as a result of rapid
urban growth, the government of India has launched many programmes since
independence. One of the illustrious examples is JNNURM launched recently
to rejuvenate urban development in India.
After studying this unit you should be able to:
• Describe various urban development programmes launched in India since
independence.
• Discuss JNNURM.
ii) Low Cost Sanitation Programme (LCS): The goal of providing sanitation NOTES
facilities to eighty per cent of urban population was fixed in the early eighties
with the announcement of the UN Decadal Programme for Water Supply and
Sanitation. Accordingly, a centrally sponsored scheme was launched in 1980-
81, with the objective of eliminating manual scavenging through conversion of
dry latrines. It covered all the households, which have dry latrines and those
having no latrines including slum and squatter settlements.
Urban Development
Programmes in India Under this scheme, loan and Central subsidy were both
channeled through
HUDCO.
iii) Shelter and Sanitation for Pavement Dwellers (SSPD): This programme
was launched in large urban areas including metropolitan cities, having
sizable shelter less population. The Tenth Plan has pointed out that the
provision of subsidy under the scheme has to be adequate to make it feasible
for the NGOs to take up shelter construction. The grants per bed should also
be revised to achieve the objective of providing a sufficient number of nights
– shelters for the homeless women and children. The Pay and Use component
of this scheme is being merged with the Nirmal Bharat Abhiyan of
VAMBAY. iv) Accelerated Urban Water Supply Programme (AUWSP): This
is another centrally sponsored scheme launched during the Eighth Plan for
providing water to the towns having less than 20,000 population as per the
Census of 1991, operationally under the State PHED to be funded by the
Central Government, State Government and concerned ULBs on 50:45:5
ratio. The Centre met the entire cost in Union Territories.
v) National Slum Development Programme (NSDP): The NSDP initiated in
1996 as a scheme of Special Central Assistance for slum improvement, has
been providing additional central assistance to state governments to provide
water supply and sanitation among other facilities to the slums.
vi) VAMBAY (Valmiki-Ambedkar Awas Yojona): This scheme has been
launched in 2001-02 to provide shelter or upgrade the existing shelter of the
people living below poverty line in urban slums implemented in partnership
with state governments who will set up the implementation machinery,
arrange for land where required and for the credit component for housing.
The state funds under the scheme will be in proportion to their slum
population.
vii) Nehru Rozgar Yojana (NRY): In order to alleviate the conditions of
urban poor, a Centrally Sponsored Programme - Nehru Rozgar Yojana – was
launched at the end of the Seventh Five Year Plan (October 1989) with the
objective of providing employment to the urban unemployed and
underemployed poor. The Central Government indicated its overall
contribution while the essential task of identifying, earmarking and
121 Self-Instructional Material
Urban Development Programmes coordinating the relevant sectoral inputs was undertaken by the State
Governments. The NRY consisted of three schemes namely (i) the Scheme of
NOTES Urban Micro Enterprises (SUME); (ii) the Scheme of Urban Wage
Employment (SUWE); and (iii) the Scheme of Housing and Shelter
Upgradation (SHASU). During the Eighth Plan, 92% of the available funds
were utilized but for the shortfall in the number of dwelling units upgraded/in
progress under SHASU, the targets have been achieved under all the other
schemes. viii)Urban Basic Services for the Poor (UBSP): The UBSP
Programme was implemented as a Centrally Sponsored Scheme during the
Eighth Five Year Plan with the specific objectives of effective achievement of
the social sector goals; community organization, mobilization and
empowerment; and convergence through sustainable support system. The
expenditure on the Urban Development Plans,Policies and Programmes
Programme was being shared on a 60:40 basis between the Central and the
State Governments and UTs (with legislatures). Further, the per capita
expenditure on any slum pocket is Rs.75/- in the first year and Rs.50/- from
the second year onwards after the basic infrastructure is developed.
ix) Prime Minister‘s Integrated Urban Poverty Eradication Programme (PM
IUPEP): Recognizing the seriousness and complexity of urban poverty
problems, especially in the small towns, the PMI UPEP was launched in
November, 1995 applicable to all Class II urban agglomerations with a
population ranging between 50,000 and one lakh subject to the condition that
elections to local bodies have been held.
x) The Swarna Jayanti Shahari Rozgar Yojana (SJSRY): The Nehru Rojgar
Yojna (NRY) and Prime Minister‘s Integrated Urban Poverty Eradication
Programme (PMI UPEP) were two important direct poverty alleviation
programmes in urban areas. Although their thrust was on employment and
income generation for urban poor, these had components for provision of
basic services as well. PMI UPEP was launched in the year 1995-96 with the
objectives of employment generation, shelter upgradation, social development
and community empowerment. It may, however, be noted that during 1997,
the three programmes of UBSP, NRY and PMIUPEP have been merged into
a single employment generation programme called Swarna
Jayanti Shahari Rojgar Yojona (SJSRY).
The SJSRY is a Centrally Sponsored Scheme applicable to all the urban areas
with expenditure to be shared in ratio 75:25 between the Centre and
States/UTs. The programme has two sub-schemes namely: (a) Urban Self –
Employment Programme and (b) Urban Wage Employment Programme.
The self-employment and wage employment components of the NRY and
PMIUPEP have been re-organised under this single programme. The shelter
upgradation components of both NRY and PMIUPEP have been merged with
the National Slum Development Programme.
The SJSRY seeks to provide gainful employment to the urban unemployed or
underemployed poor by encouraging the setting up of self-employment
Self-Instructional Material
122
ventures or provision of wage employment. This programme is based on the Urban Development Programmes
creation of suitable community structures on the UBSP pattern and delivery
of inputs under this programme was devised through urban local bodies and NOTES
similar community institutional structures and rests on the foundation of
community empowerment. Community organisations like Neighbourhood
Groups (NHGs), Neighbourhood Committees (NHCs) and Community
Development Societies (CDSs) have been set up in the target areas based on
the UBSP pattern. The CDSs is the focal point for purposes of identification
of beneficiaries, preparation of applications, monitoring of recovery and
generally providing whatever other support is necessary to the programme.
The CDSs identifies viable projects suitable for that particular area.
1. One of the important objectives of the project was to redirect a significant NOTES
part of public investments in the key sectors of housing, employment, social
support services, water supply and transport, to directly benefit the low-
income population of the metropolitan area.
2. The second major objective of the project was to ensure full cost recovery
for replicability of the project and mobilization of local resources to cover the
additional expenditure required for the maintenance of the assets created under
the project, and to expand the services to meet the population growth in the
area.
3. The third major objective was to develop the capabilities of the Chennai
Metropolitan Development Authority (CMDA) and other agenciesinvolved in
urban development to formulate and execute similar projects on a continuing
basis. Under this, CMDA was expected to propose future development
programmes including capital budgeting for them. The concerned sectoral
agency would acquire expertise and skill for preparing detailed proposals and
on this behalf, CMDA would offer guidelines to agencies and would, review
all proposals for their economic and financial viability and for their
consistency with the development objective as identified in its strategy plan.
MADRAS URBAN DEVELOPMENTPROJECT - II
Local urban services which act as a link to a larger array of government and
private services such as schools, small businesses, markets, shops, police and
fire protection, religious, cultural and social welfare centres such as clinics,
employment agencies and day care of kindergarten schools.
MUDP-II was planned to provide 18267 shelter units at an estimated cost of
Rs.384.10 million over an extent of 291 ha. About 70% of shelter units are
meant to house EWS people along with necessary physical facilities, social
facilities, basic amenities provided in the schemes. It has been decided by the
planning authority to follow the same standards of MUDP I in implementing
the programmes under MUDP II.
(i) Advanced sale of prime land to generate resources for development, (ii)
Allotment ofsites sufficiently in advance to ensure early settlement, (iii)
Streamlining of procedures in respect of execution of lease-cum-sale
agreement, handing over of site, issue of planning permission, issue of cash
and material loans etc. again to help occupation of site, (iv) Provision for
maintenance of roads and services during the construction and occupation
period to ensure quick transfer ofmaintenance functions to local body, (v) It is
proposed to include a percentage ofunits for rehabilitation of slum dwellers
from objectionable slums, on easier terms, (vi) Adopting low cost sanitation
methods in preference to underground sewerage system in several of the sites.
TAMIL NADU URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT
1. Besides Madras for which a well conceived Urban Development
Programme is under implementation, Madurai, Coimbatore, Tiruchirapalli and
125 Self-Instructional Material
Urban Development Programmes Salem need the most urgent attention as they are the immediate next order of
big towns and growth poles considering the need of basic services in these
NOTES centres.
2. Population studies indicate that Madurai, Coimbatore, Tiruchirapalli and
Salem Planning Areas are expected to have a population of 2.27, 1.61, 1.33
and 1.07 million respectively by the turn ofthe century. All the four cities have
developed as focus of trade and commerce, Centres of Textile Mills and
Engineering Industries besides beingimportantseats ofadministration, higher
and technological education.
3. The four cities are geographically, centrally located and equi-distantfrom
one another and have a strong relationship with the surrounding hinterland,
and are served by a good net work both by broad and metre gauge lines of the
Southern Railways. They are also on the domestic airline map.
4. Administratively also, these cities are geared to take up the Urban
Development Programmes, having benefitted under the centrally sponsored
and state integrated urban development programmes in the fifth and sixth five
year plans.
5. To summarise, these cities have been selected for inclusion in the Tamil
Nadu Urban Development project because of i) Advantageous geographic
location vis-a-vis Madras and other Urban Centres and strong relationship with
surrounding hinterland.
ii) A fairly developed level of infrastructure including social infrastructure.
iii) A strong economic base which has potential for increasing employment
and incomes.
iv) The level of affordability for shelter and other services is comparatively
higher.
v) Being ‗near million cities‘ and having a long tradition of municipal
administration they are equipped to absorb investments through better
administrative and technical capabilities.
vi) The institutions that will implement such projects are Tamil Nadu Housing
Board, Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board, Department of Highways and
Rural Works, Public Works Department and they have all experience in the
implementation of MUDP, and have acquired the proper orientation for
undertaking such projects.
In TNUDP (World Bank 1988) project, 54 per cent of total investment went to
shelter programme, whereas it is 37 per cent for MUDP I and 62 per cent for
MUDP II. For transport sector 34 per cent of the total cost is allocated and for
MUDP I and II it is 35 per cent and 32 per cent respectively. 11 per cent of
investment goes to municipal services, water supply and drainage. In MUDP I
it is 21 per cent and in MUDP II it is only 3 per cent. Investment towards
technical assistance is maintained almost at the same level in all urban
development projects. It is 1.6 per cent under TNUDP, 1 per cent for MUDP I
Self-Instructional Material
126
and 2 per cent for MUDP II. Urban Development Programmes
NOTES
12 4 LETS SUM UP
This Unit has presented you an overview of urban development policies and
programmes. Here, we have discussed the types, structure, functions and
resources of urban local bodies. An attempt has also been made to emphasis‘
the importance and strategies of disaster management in urban areas. Further,
we have highlighted various on-going efforts in respect of urban reforms in
India. Urban development programmes with a focus on reduction and
alleviation of poverty, has been one of the objectives of five-year plans in the
country since the beginning of the planned era. This was, however, brought
into the core of planning exercise only during the Fifth Five Year Plan. In
order to cope with massive problems that have emerged as a result of rapid
urban growth, it has become imperative to draw up a coherent urbanization
policy/strategy to implement projects in select cities on mission mode. The
need for the mission also rose in order to harness the potential of reforms in
urban infrastructure, for National Level Reform-linked Investments, for
sustainable infrastructure development and efficiency enhancements. The
JNNURM is the outcome of the mission strategy and is in vogue since 2005
for fastening the process of urban development.
Self-Instructional Material
128
BLOCK V: TAMIL NADU URBAN Tamil Nadu Urban Development project
(TNUDP)
___________________________________________________________
13.3 NEHRU ROZGAR YOJANA (NRY), ETC
OBJECTIVES OF JRY
Self-Instructional Material
Jawahar Rojgar Yojana was started with a view to expand the coverage of
132
wage employment opportunities to all villages and to achieve the objective of Tamil Nadu Urban Development project
providing employment to all wage seekers in close proximity to their (TNUDP)
villages. Accordingly, the responsibility to implement the programme was
given to the Gram Panchayats. The primary objective of JRY was to generate NOTES
additional gainful employment for the unemployed and the underemployed in
rural areas.
The secondary objectives of JRY were: (a) to create productive community
assets for direct and continuing benefits to the poor and strengthening rural
economic and social infrastructure which would lead to rapid growth of rural
economy and as a result improve the income levels of the poor and (b) to
bring about improvements in the overall quality of life in rural areas.
SALIENT FEATURES OF JRY
We know that JRY came into being after the merger of NREP and RLEGP,
the two wage employment programmes, and its objective is also the same, but
there are some differences in the process of its planning and implementation.
The main features of the programme are as follows:
• Expenditure for the programme was shared by the Centre and states on 80:20
basis.
Poverty Alleviation Programmes – A Retrospect
• DRDA/Zilla Parishad were m
ade responsible for implementation at the district level and gram panchayats at
the village level. The funds were directly released to the DRDA/ZP.
• Six per cent of the total JRY funds were earmarked for Indira Awas Yojana
(IAY). Of the remaining, 20% were to be retained at the district level DRDA
ZP) for inter-block/ inter-district projects and 80% to be distributed to gram
panchayats.
• The works were to be executed by the village people and employment of
contractors was totally banned as in the case of NREP and RLEGP.
• Preference was given to SCs and STs.
• Employment opportunities for women were reserved up to 30 per cent.
• Food-grains as part of the wages could be provided at subsidized rates.
• Non-wage component or material component was not allowed to exceed
50% of the total project cost.
• Up to a maximum of 5% of the annual allocation was allowed to meet
administrative expenditure and 1/5 of it could be spent on training of the
officials/ non-officials involved in the implementation of JRY.
• Up to 10% of the total allocation of DRDA/ZP and gram panchayats was
meant for maintenance of the assets created under earlier programmes
(NREP/RLEGP) and JRY.
Self-Instructional Material
133
Tamil Nadu Urban Development project
(TNUDP)
13.4 LETS SUM UP
Jawahar Rozgar Yojana (JRY) was essentially a carry forward of the earlier
NOTES wage employment programmes like the Crash Rural Employment Programme
(CREP), the Pilot Rural Employment Programme (PIREP) and the Food For
Work (FFW) programme of the 1970s and NREP, RLEGP of the 1980s.
Initially most of these wage employment programmes were implemented in
isolation and had no practical links with any other rural development
programme. Later on, however, NREP and RLEGP were linked to various
MNP activities like social formats for producing fuel wood and fodder, rural
roads, rural housing, etc. Subsequently, the process of wage employment
under JRY took a concrete shape to support various poverty alleviation
programmes mainly to provide activity and group specific infrastructure and
assets to support the income generating activities of the beneficiaries under
various other programmes. Indira Awas Yojana for providing fully subsidized
dwelling units to the SCs/STs and the very poor of the other categories,
irrigation wells under million wells schemes and projects aiming at
continuing flow of income for the poor under IJRY were the specific features
of JRY, besides generating wage employment for millions of poor people in
the country. The programme also helped in the construction of community
assets like Panchayat Ghars, Common Work sheds, Schools and Anganwadi
buildings, etc. Now, JRY and EAS have been amalgamated into a single
programme called Sampoorna Gramin Rojgar Yojana (SGRY), which has
been designed to support the development of infrastructure for basic services
and natural and community resources to provide more opportunities for rural
livelihoods and also generate more wage employment.
13.5 CHECK YOUR PROGRESS
1. Write the meaning of Urban Basic Services ?
2. Write short note on NRY ?
13.6 ANSWER TO CHECK YOUR PROGRESS
1. Urban Basic Services for the Poor (UBSP): The UBSP Programme was
implemented as a Centrally Sponsored Scheme during the Eighth Five Year
Plan with the specific objectives of effective achievement of the social
sector goals; community organization, mobilization and empowerment; and
convergence through sustainable support system.
2. Jawahar Rojgar Yojana was started with a view to expand the
coverage of wage employment opportunities to all villages and to achieve the
objective of providing employment to all wage seekers in close proximity to
their villages. Accordingly, the responsibility to implement the programme was
given to the Gram Panchayats. The primary objective of JRY was to generate
additional gainful employment for the unemployed and the underemployed in
rural areas.
Self-Instructional Material
134
13.7 SUGGESTED READINGS Tamil Nadu Urban Development project
(TNUDP)
1. Fourth and Fifth Plan Documents, Planning Commission, Government
of India. NOTES
2. Annual Reports of the Ministry of Rural Development, 1989-90 to
1999-2000, GOI.
3. Rural Statistics, 1990 to 2001, NIRD, Hyderabad
4. Rajakutty, S., 2004, ―Self and Wage Employment Programmes for
Poverty Alleviation in India‖, Journal of Rural Development, Vol. 23, No. 2
(April – June, 2004)
Self-Instructional Material
135
Tamil Nadu Slum Area
UNIT XIV TAMIL NADU SLUM AREA
NOTES
(CLEARANCE AND IMPROVEMENT)
ACT 1971, AND PROBLEMS IN
IMPLEMENTATION OF URBAN
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
PROGRAMMES; ROLE OF
DEVELOPMENT WORKER –
APPLICATION OF SOCIAL WORK
METHODS IN URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Structure
14.0 Introduction
14.1 Tamil Nadu Slum Area (Clearance And Improvement) Act 1971
14.2 Problems in Implementation Of Urban Community Development
Programmes
14.3 Role Of Development Worker
14.4 Application Of Social Work Methods In Urban Development
14.5 Lets Sum Up
14.6 Check Your Progress
14.7 Answer to Check Your Progress
14.8 Suggested Readings
14.0 INTRODUCTION
Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board was established in September 1970 and has
been implementing various Housing, Slum Development and Rehabilitation
Self-Instructional Material
136
and Resettlement programmes to ameliorate the living conditions of the slum Tamil Nadu Slum Area
families in Tamil Nadu. The Board initially started its activities in Chennai and
its activities were gradually extended to other urban areas of Tamil Nadu since NOTES
1984 onwards in phased manner.
The motto of Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board is ―GOD WE SHALL
SEE IN THE SMILE OF THE POOR―. The Board has been implementing
various programmes like In-situ tenemental schemes, In-situ plotted and
infrastructure development and Rehabilitation and Resettlement schemes to
improve the environs of the slums and the living standards of the urban slum
families to achieve the Slum Free Cities Vision before 2023.
An Act to provide for the improvement and clearance of slums in the State of
Tamil Nadu.
WHEREAS the number of slums in certain areas in the State of Tamil Nadu is
on the increase and the slums are likely to become a source of danger to public
health and sanitation of the said area.
AND WHEREAS under the existing law, it has not been possible effectively
to arrest the growth of slums, to eliminate congestion and to prov ide for
certain basic needs such as streets, water -supply and drainage in slums and to
clear slums which are unfit for human habitation.
AND WHEREAS to obviate this difficulty, it is expedient to provide for the
removal of un-hygenic and insanitary conditions prevailing in slums, for better
accommodation and improved living conditions for slum dwellers, for the
promotion of public health generally nd for the acquisition of land for the
purpose of improving or developing slum areas, re - developing slum
clearance areas and rehabilitating slum dwellers:
AND WHEREAS it is Directive principle of State Policy embodied in the
constitution that the State should regard the improvement of public health as
among its primary duties. Be it enacted by the legislature of the State of Tamil
Nadu in the Twenty –second ear of the Republic of India as follows:
PRELIMINARY
1. Short title, extent and commencement:- This Act may be called Tamil
Nadu Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1971.
2. It extends to the whole of Tamil Nadu.
3. It should come into force on such date as the Government may, by
notification, appoint and different dates may be appointed for different areas
and for different provisions of this Act:
Provided that any reference in any such provision to the commencement of
this Act shall be construed as a reference to the coming into force of that
provision.
2. Definitions. - In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires. -
(a) ―Board‖ means the Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board, established under
section 34;
137 Self-Instructional Material
Tamil Nadu Slum Area (b) ―Building‖ includes a house, out-house, stable, latrine, shed, hut, wall and
any other such structure, whether or masonry, bricks, wood, mud, metal or
NOTES any other materials whatsoever, but does not include part or machinery
comprised in a building;
(c) ―Court‖ means -
(i) in the city of Madras, the Madras City Civil Court;
(ii) elsewhere, the Subordinate Judge‘s Court having jurisdiction and if there
is not such Subordinate Judge‘s Court, the District Court having jurisdiction;
(d) ―erection‖ in relation to a building includes extension, alteration or re-
erection;
(e) ―Government‖ means the State Government;
(f) ―land‖ includes building and benefits to arise out of land and things
attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything attac hed to the
earth or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth;
(g) ―occupier‖ includes-
(i) any person who for the time being is paying or is liable to pay to the owner
the rent or any portion of the rent of the land or building in respect of which
such rent is paid or is payable;
(ii) an owner in occupation of, or otherwise using his land or building;
(iii) a rent-free tenant of any land or building;
(iv) a licensee in occupation of any land or building; and
(v) any person who is liable to pay to the owner damages for the use and
occupation of any land or buildings;
(h) ―owner‖ includes any person, who is receiving or is entitled to receive the
rent of any land or building whether on his own account or on behalf and
others or as an agent, trustee, executor, administrator, receiver or guardian or
who would so receive the rent or be entitled to receive the rent, if the land or
building were let to a tenant;
(i) ―person interested‖ in relation to any land or building, includes any
personclaiming, or entitled to claim, an interest in the compensation payable
on account of the acquistion of that land or building under this Act;
(j) ―prescribed authority‖ means any authority or person authorized by the
Government in this regard, by notification;
(k) ―slum area‖ means any area declared to be a slum area under sub -section
(1) ofsection 3; (1) of section 3;
(l) ―slum clearance area‖ means any slum area declared to be a slum
clearance area under section 11;
(m) ―State Housing Board‖ means the Tamil Nadu State Housing Board
constituted under the Tamil Nadu State Housing Board Act, 1961 Tamil Nadu
Act XVII of 1961);
(n) ―work of improvement‖ in relation to any building in a slum area includes
the execution of any one or more of the following works, namely:-
(i) necessary repairs;
(ii) structural alterations;
(iii) provision of light points, water -taps and bathing places;
(iv) construction of drains, open or covered;
Self-Instructional Material
138
(v) provision of latrines, including conversion of dry latrines into water-borne Tamil Nadu Slum Area
latrines;
(vi) provision of additional or improved fixtures or fittings; NOTES
(vii) opening up or paving of Court-yards;
(viii) removal of rubbish; and
(ix) any other work including the demolition of any building or any part there
of which in the opinion of the pre scribed authority is necessary for executing
any of the works specified above.
14.2 PROBLEMS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF URBAN
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMMES
The Ministry for Public Service and Administration (2007) describes the
roles of CDWs as follows:• to assist in the smooth delivery of services by
identifying and removing obstacles• to strengthen the social contract
between government and communities• to link communities with
government services• to pass on communities‘ concerns and problems
to government structures• to support and nurture the increased
exchange of information• to improve government–community
networks.The above serve to emphasise the significance of government
working together with local communities. An observation can be made,
based on media reports, that communities are mostly feeling that
government is not communicating enough, and as such they are left
behind on matters affecting them directly. In essence, CDWs are formed to
bridge the gap between government and citizens in great need of services
provided by it. It is a complementary structure to existing structures in
municipalities.Advantages of community development workersThe former
President Mbeki on 14 March during the CDWs Indaba (Summit) in
Tshishonga and Mafema (2010: 574) argued that CDWP had brought
in a new category of professionalism in the local government sphere
and would assist and fast track service delivery. It had a structural
resource budgeted for its effective and efficient operations. The CDWP
was formed on the basis of the following strategic objectives and advantages:•
to assist in the removal of development and service delivery
Self-Instructional Material
140
bottlenecks• to link communities with government services and relay Tamil Nadu Slum Area
community concerns and problems to government• to support, nurture and
advocate for an organised voice for the poor• to improve government NOTES
community networks (The Presidency 14 March 2008 ‗SA: Mbeki:
Community Development Workers Indaba (Summit)‘ in Tshishonga and
Mafema, 2010: 574).The above advantages have been summarised by the
Forum for Australian Services for Survivors of Torture and Trauma (FASSTT)
in Tshishonga and Mafema (2010: 575) as a process which contributes to
the strength of a community by increasing its social capital, developing
self-reliance through encouraging cohesive relationships and external
partnerships, enhancing and harnessing community skills and resources,
and promoting participation in decision-making leadership to ensure
community ownership.Disadvantages of community development
workersAccording to Tshishonga and Mafema (2010: 575) the
disadvantages of CDWs during the stage of its formation are as follows:• The
CDWP is a cumbersome programme: it is based in the Department of
Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (COGTA), but is
overseen by the whole municipalities as the locus of their day-to-day
activities. Therefore, the CDWP was conceived without a policy direction.•
Communities did not trust the programme because of new
suspicion that the CDWs spy for the government, a legacy of the previous
oppressive government. The South African culture is built on suspicion of
top-down and state-led community development programmes as they
were used during the apartheid to control people.• The role and
responsibility of the CDWs are misunderstood by both local government and
communities, and it often causes conflict and tension (Gray and Mubangizini
2010; Tshishonga and Mafema 2010).• The issue of programme
accountability was an added challenge as councillors had an expectation
that CDWs were to report directly as councillors had an expectation that
CDWs were to report directly to them, thus there was confusion as to who was
in charge of them. This resulted in fragmented and uncooperative
relationships and networks between ward councillors and CDWs (Gray
and Mubangizini 2010; Tshishonga and Mafema 2010).• The Local
Government officials and Councillors felt threatened by CDWs‘
position and direct line communication to the COGTA. CDWs were
thus treated with suspicion in case they assumed the government and
councillor‘s roles.• The suspicions and infighting with political stalwarts of
the communities placed CDWs in a precarious position where they felt
exacerbated by the lack of a formal introduction of the programme,
particularly to the relevant stakeholders such as government departments,
the private sector and communities as targeted recipients of their services.
Community Organizing
Community organizing is a long-term approach where the people affected by
an issue are supported in identifying problems and taking action to achieve
solutions. The organizer challenges those he or she works with to change the
way things are—it is a means of achieving social change through collective
action by changing the balance of power. The tactics and strategies employed
by the organizer are similar to the processes of leadership including timing the
issue, deliberate planning, getting the attention of the populace, framing the
issue in terms of the desired solution, and shaping the terms of the decision-
making process.
Community organizing helps to bring out many voices to add collective power
and strength to an issue. Community organizing is a key part of an overall
143 Self-Instructional Material
Tamil Nadu Slum Area strategy to make changes in a community that are widely felt, and that reflect
the wishes of the people who are directly affected by alcohol-related
NOTES community problems. This requires the organizer to not only listen and be
responsive to the community, but also to help community residents develop
the skills necessary to address their own issues in an ongoing way.At the heart
of community organizing are inclusion, ownership, relationship building and
leadership development.
Conflict Resolution
Conflict means an adversarial relationship or a disagreement between two or
more persons, between groups, regions or even nation emanating from
different perceptions and interests. Such conflict may be intra-personal as
result of internal disagreement within a person. When one speaks of a conflict,
it is normally taken to mean chaos, wars or mutual suspicion or strained
relations, competition, hatred and many other associated ills. It is incorrect to
normally regard conflict as something very destructive which deserves
avoidance or denouncing.
In most cases conflict is as a result of the following:
- Different perception;
- Dierent behaviors or attitudes;
- Poor distribution of national resources;
- Lack of basic human needs or their frustration;
- Different interests;
- Ideological differences based on religion or political parties.
Types of conflict
Levels of conflict
Intrapersonal conflict: The type of conflict that occur within a person.
Examples : choice of partner, moral question or a decision to abandon a bad
practice, use of time, taking a decision etc.
Interpersonal Conflict: Conflict between two or more persons over an issue.
Intragroup conflict: An example is conflict between people within the same
group.
Intergroup conflict: One might cite conflicts between organizations, families,
or institutions.
Intranational conflict: This means an internal conflict between small groups
within the country.
International Conflict: This is conflict between two or more nations. This
could be for ideological reasons, territorial claims, natural resources or other
interests.
Advocacy
Advocacy can be called as the act of inducing and persuading the democratic
agencies to resolve various social issues. Advocacy is a Latin term. The word
‗Ad‘ means ‗in favour of‘ and ‗Voca‘ is to speak.... hence, the meaning of the
word ‗advocacy‘ is to speak in favour of someone. The lawyers are also called
advocates, as they stand in favour of a side or a party. In other words,
advocacy is to speak for, or support someone. Advocacy is essential for
helping the insignificant social elements, institutions, communities and
neglected public in acquiring their rights and in making the concerned
authorities aware of their issues. E.g. inadequate ration supply, diseases,
especially contagious diseases etc. Advocacy informs the common people in
such situations about the concerned authorities and where and how to
approach them. Such an organized and collective effort is advocacy. Every
nation has always tried to constitute the government policies in favour of the
poor and neglected ones.
The Aims of advocacy:
The final stage, evaluation, is often not reached, though it is important. Good
advocates assess the effectiveness of their past efforts and set new goals based
on their experience. Advocates and the institution that adopts the policy
change should periodically evaluate the effectiveness of that change.
Capacity Building
Community capacity can be seen as the capacity of the people in communities
to participate in actions based on community interests, both as individuals and
through groups, organisations and networks. It is not primarily about their
ability to act in their personal, family or employers‘ interest, which are catered
for in other spheres. However, many of the same skills are involved, and
people who are active in the community invariably benefit in other ways as
well.
The actions people and groups take can broadly be described as Community
Activity. This can be divided into three types of activity:
• Action to build social capital: building relationships, trust, shared norms and
networks. It involves people taking part in community initiatives, groups and
organisations, and those groups communicating with the wider population as
volunteers, members and participants.
• Delivering services: these can either be autonomous services provided by
communities, or specialist services provided by community or voluntary
groups, controlled by contracts or service level agreements with public
agencies.
Self-Instructional Material
150
• Involvement in governance: representing the interests of all local people or of Tamil Nadu Slum Area
particular groups in influencing decisions that affect the quality of local life.
NOTES
Community capacity building is defined as: Activities, resources and support
that strengthen the skills and abilities of people and community groups to take
effective action and leading roles in the development of
their communities. It is helpful to see community capacity building as three
main types of activity:
• Developing skills - learning and training opportunities for individuals and
groups, and sharing through networks and mutual support, to develop skills,
knowledge and confidence.
• Developing structures – developing the organisational structures and
strengths of community groups, communities of interest and networks.
• Developing support – developing the availability of practical support to
enable the development of skills and structures.
Community capacity building is normally undertaken to achieve a specific
purpose, whereas the community development process provides the wider
context. The key purpose of community development work is ‗collectively to
bring about social change.
Nine domains are identified on capacity building. These are areas where there
are opportunities for individuals and groups to mobilize themselves for greater
control over their lives. Considering these domains encourages strategic
planning, implementation and evaluation of programmes:
1. Improves stakeholder participation;
2. Increases problem assessment capacities;
3. Develops local leadership;
4. Builds empowering organizational structures;
5. Improves resource mobilization;
6. Strengthens links to other organisations and people;
7. Enhances stakeholder ability to "ask why";
8. Increases stakeholder control over programme management;
9. Creates an equitable relationship with outside agents.
The nine domains represent the organizational influences on the community's
capacity. They link the inter-personal elements of the community with the
programme's political, socio-cultural and economic context.
Implementing the Capacity Building approach
151 Self-Instructional Material
Tamil Nadu Slum Area Capacity building is always a process. The approach is not a substitute for
other elements of programme planning such as setting goals or objectives, but
NOTES helps programme staff ask themselves at all stages whether the programme has
helped to increase community capacity.
Self-Instructional Material
152
What are areas in which capacity building is done? Tamil Nadu Slum Area
The capacity building of communities increase the access of the communities NOTES
to:
• Skills
• Information
• Resources – natural, financial and intellectual
• Knowledge
• Technology
• Linkages
What are tools that can be used for Capacity Building?
The tools that can be used for capacity building are:
• Intensive trainings
• Focus group workshops, seminars, discussions
• Exposure and exchange visits to successful projects
PROJECT PLANING AND IMPLEMENTATION
Projects represent the commitment of human and physical resources to
produce specific outputs in a given time and budget framework. Projects vary
in scale, purpose and duration. They may be initiated within a community,
requiring modest inputs and producing tangible outputs within a relatively
short timeframe. At the other extreme, projects may require substantial
financial resources and only generate benefits in the long term. For example,
the former could be an adult literacy project in a village; the latter may be the
provision of universal primary education for all children of school age in a
country. Whilst the former needs one trainer and a few teaching materials, the
latter requires numerous schools, teachers, equipment and administration.
Projects may stand-alone or be integrated into a programme, with several
projects contributing to one overall goal. Despite the difference in scale and
nature of projects, there are aspects of sound project management that are
universal.
The phases of the project cycle can be described as follows:
During the Programming phase, the situation at national and sectoral level is
analysed to identify problems, constraints and opportunities which
development cooperation could address. This involves a review of socio-
economic indicators, and of national and donor priorities. The purpose is to
identify and agree the main objectives and sectoral priorities for development
cooperation, and thus to provide a relevant and feasible programming
In this Unit you have gained understanding about various career options that
would be available to you after successfully completing the course. The unit
described the settings, primary as well as secondary, for social work
intervention, talked about the roles and responsibilities of social work
professionals in these settings. The unit also mentioned about the process of
finding a suitable job, tips for preparing curriculum vitae, conduct in interview
and behaviour expected from a social worker at the work place.
Websites
Self-Instructional Material
156
MODEL QUESTION PAPER Tamil Nadu Slum Area
TIME: 3 HOURS MAXIMUM
MARKS: 75 NOTES
34943 A URBAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
SECTION – A (10 x 2 = 20 Marks)
Answer All Questions
1) Write the meaning of Urban Community?
2) Give the classifications of City?
3) What is Urbanism?
4) Enlist the approaches of Slums?
5) Bing out any four urban problems?
6) Give the objectives of Urban Community Development
7) What are the principles of UCD?
8) What are the legislations related to urban Development?
9) Write the meaning of HUDCO?
10) What do you mean by TNUDP ?
SECTION – B (5 x 5 = 25 Marks)
Answer All Questions
11. (a) Explain nature of Urban Community ?
(Or)
(b) Explain the meaning and Classifications of City ?
12. (a) Write down the Process of Urbanisation ?
(Or)
(b) Explain the theories of Slums
13. (a) Bring out the cause of Drug Addiction ?
(Or)
(b) Narrate the objectives of Urban Community Development?
(a) Write down the Urban Development Planning?
(Or)
(b) Explain the various structure of Urban Development Agencies ?
14. (a) Elaborate the functions of Housing Board ?
(Or)
(b) Write the functions of Madras Urban Development Project 1 ?
SECTION – C (3 x 10 = 30 Marks)
Answer Any THREE Questions
15. Explain the Trends in Urbanization Process ?
16. Elaborate the City
17. Discuss the role of Voluntary Organization in Urban Community
Development ?
18. Bring out the Urban Development Administration
19. Narrate the significance of Social Work in Urban Development
Programme ?