Baral, Charlene Anne C. BSC - 2204 LEA 103: Comparative Model of Policing
Baral, Charlene Anne C. BSC - 2204 LEA 103: Comparative Model of Policing
SKILLS AND ABILITIES • These steps aim to ensure candidates meet the
1. Ability to use good judgement and to solve problem. necessary physical, mental, and ethical standards for
2. Capacity for empathy and compassion law enforcement roles.
3. Capacity for multi-tasking
4. Ability to demonstrate courage and to take BASIC APPLICATION PRE-SCREENING
responsibility QUESTIONNAIRE
5. Ability to be resourceful and show initiative
6. Demonstrating assertiveness The initial application and pre-screening questionnaire
7. Possess and demonstrate integrity convey an applicant's interest and eligibility. Based on a
8. Capacity for engaging in teamwork and ability to review of this material, candidates are invited back to take
collaborate. the written exam of applicants to advance only those who
BASIC REQUIREMENTS are most qualified.
1. Citizenship Requirement: Written Exam/Entrance Test
U.S. citizenship or permanent resident alien status (in The written exam is typically a standardized test used to
some cases). assess general aptitude and does not require or assume
Residency within agency jurisdiction may be required by any knowledge specific to law enforcement. Written
some agencies. exams typically test an applicant’s
b.3. 3- Kilometer run (19 mins for male and 21 mins for Probation Period
female).
• Police recruits must complete recruit training, which
Background Investigation can last from several months to over a year,
depending on the department's requirements.
Conducted to ensure professional & personal issues; • Following academy training, recruits typically undergo
reviewing employment, character references, academic field training supervised by experienced officers.
records, residency, criminal, and credit history, fingerprint • Recruits remain on probation throughout training and
checks, and interviews. often for a period afterward, varying in length by
department.
Drug Test
• Promotion eligibility usually requires successful
To check illegal substances completion of the probationary period.
• The probationary period evaluates a recruit's job
Psychological tests performance and fit within the department; dismissal
may occur without cause.
physical and psychological fitness for a job through
• Damaging police property, excessive force, violating
psychological tests, which evaluate character, emotional
the chain of command, or negative comments about
makeup, and job suitability from a psychological
superiors can jeopardize probationary status.
standpoint, often supplemented by a psychologist’s • Upon successful completion of probation, officers
interview. gain more workplace protections, transitioning to civil
Polygraph status with varying rights and protections by
municipality and state.
polygraph, commonly known as lie detector, to verify
information submitted throughout the application process. Field Training
• Sergeant, Corporal, Lance Corporal (if the number of The Levels Of The Highest Ranks
people at this level is appropriately small), Officer /
Patrolman / Trooper/etc. Two things must be considered to determine the
appropriate levels for the highest ranks of a police/sheriff's
• Sergeant, Corporal, Officer/ Patrolman / Trooper / etc. department:
First Class, officer / Patrolman / Trooper / etc.
• The overall size of the department, to ensure that the
• Sergeant, Senior or Leading Officer / Patrolman / etc., head of the department doesn't rank too low.
Officer / Patrolman / etc. First Class, Officer /
The size of the largest command within the department
Patrolman / etc. (Trooper, being a military term, is
(being a command that isn't excessively large owing to a
excluded on the grounds that it therefore should be
poorly-conceived organizational structure), to ensure that
used in conjunction with Corporal.)
the head of the department outranks the head of this
Note: the second-lowest rank can be omitted. organization.
Middle Ranks, Number of Ranks If only the size of the largest organization in the
department were considered and it was just assumed that
There are six army ranks from Second Lieutenant to the head of the department must rank one level higher
Colonel, but these ranks encompass only four levels in a than the head of this organization, it's possible that the
typical military chain of command (platoon or equivalent, head of the department would rank lower than he/ she is
company or equivalent, battalion or equivalent, and entitled to.
brigade).
For example, the military rank commensurate with
A similar discrepancy exists in police/sheriff’s command of half a dozen Colonel level organizations is
departments. This means that it is feasible to omit several Major-General, not the rank between Colonel and Major-
of the corresponding police ranks non-consecutively General.
without diminishing the level of authority or responsibility
A police/sheriff's department might not be much bigger
of the remaining ranks. Small departments require fewer
than the largest organization within it (typically the
levels of command than others so they may omit more
territorial policing command), so it's possible that its head
ranks.
may be entitled to the same rank level as the head of the
Commisioner/Police/Sheriff Ranks department.
• Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner, To avoid the head of a department having the same rank
Assisstant Commissioner, Deputy Assistant as the head of the largest organization in it, either the
Commissioner former should be upgraded by one level or the latter
should be downgraded by one level, depending on the
• Chief, Deputy Chief, Assistant Chief, Deputy circumstances.
Assistant Chief.
For example, if the head of a department and the head of
• Sheriff, Undersheriff, Assistant Sheriff, Deputy the largest organization in it were equivalent to
Assistant Sheriff, Note; Lieutenant-General, but only marginally in the latter's
case, and the next most senior commanders were
• These arrangements match the best version of equivalent to Brigädier-General (with only the deputy
the arrangement used in most English-speaking head of the Largest organization at Major-General level),
countries would be best to downgrade the head and deputy head of
• Unneeded ranks are omitted in reverse order of the largest organization and leave the head of the
seniority department at Lieutenant-General level.
• Undersheriff is normally the title held by the Conversely, if there were no such gap, upgrading the
second-highest ranking member of a sheriff’s head of the department would be preferable, as it is better
department. ‘Deputy Sheriff’ is not used for this to over-rank only one person who isn't outranked by any
position. (Traditionally all members of a sheriff other member anyway than to under-rank several people.
department ranking below the Sheriff are This would probably be the correct option in most cases.
‘deputies’)
• A ‘Deputy Assistant’ rank is unlikely to be needed
in any US police/sheriff’s department (with the
possible exception New York City’s Police Commissioner
department
Deputy
Commissioner/Chief/Sheriff Ranks At/Or Below Commissioner
Colonel Level Assistant
Commissioner
It is common for small departments to have one or more
If the second-highest rank is limited to the deputy head of
commissioner/chief/ sheriff ranks at or below Colonel
the department and it’s at or below Colonel level, it
level, which is not ideal. It is possible to avoid such an
shouldn’t be a commissioner/chief/sheriff rank. For
arrangement by having a clear difference between the
example:
appointment and rank of the head of a department (e.g. a
person holding the appointment of Chief of Police might Commissioner
hold the rank of Lieutenant-Colonel).
Chief
However, this defies a strong trend and the existence of a
commissioner/chief/sheriff rank at or below Colonel level
Superintendent
though not ideal is a tolerable practice, being within the Superintendents
limits of what is customary (after all, we're not talking
Deputy Head of A Department Acceptance of glasses or contact lenses with an
optician's report required.
The second -highest rank is used in either of two ways. It
may be limited to be actual deputy of the head of a Unaided vision must not be worse than 6/36 in either
department (below, left), or it may be used for one or more eye.
other positions, including command position(below, right).
Aided vision must be better than 6/12 in either eye
or 6/6 with both eyes.
Commissioner
Deputy Near Vision
Commissioner Requirements are 6/9 with both eyes together when
Deputy aided.
Commissioner
Color Vision
DETECTIVES Severe deficiencies not accepted, but other
Some departments currently have an odd or deficiencies may be considered with adjustments.
unnecessarily complicated arrangement where ranks of
members of plain-clothed investigative organizations are Colour correcting lenses are not acceptable.
concerned. The best ways of dealing with this matter are: Corrective Treatment
Certain surgeries like RK or corneal grafts disqualify
'Detective' supplants 'Officer, 'Patrolman" and analogous
words in such ranks (e.g. Senior Detective is equivalent applicants.
to Senior Patrolman). Applicants who have undergone specific surgeries
For other members 'detective' is used as a prefix to the may be considered after a waiting period.
same ranks held by uniformed personnel (e.g. Detective
Lance Corporal, Detective Corporal, Detective Sergeant, Educational
and so on). No specific educational qualifications required.
Applicants must complete the Police Initial
'Detective' could be, but need not be, added to
commissioner/chief/sheriff ranks. Even if they're Recruitment Test.
experienced in detective work and in charge of detectives, Convictions
people who hold these ranks are almost always above the
levels where actual detective work is carried out. Recent convictions/cautions may disqualify
COUNTRY 2: UNITED KINGDOM applicants.
BRITISH POLICING All convictions, cautions, involvement in criminal
investigations must be disclosed.
SHORT HISTORY
Financial
Adverse financial history may affect application
British policing originated from early system of
depending on circumstances.
“Tythings”
Nationality
Tythings: group of people in a village
Must be a British Citizen, EU national,
Tything man: Leader or 10 people called tything
Commonwealth Citizen, or foreign national with no
Shire-reeve: Leader of 10 tything-mans, or 100 restrictions on stay in the UK.
people
Swimming
Bow Street Runners
Ability to swim is required; inability will result in
First official group responsible for investigating and
rejection.
apprehending criminals
Penalty Points
Established under metropolitan police act pioneered
by Sir Robert Peel Declaration of all penalty points required; serious
road offenses considered on an individual basis.
CRITERIA FOR JOINING
Maximum of 6 points allowed on license at the time
of application.
Age
Tattoo
Minimum age to apply is 18 with no upper age limit.
Offensive tattoos may prevent appointment; must be
Normal retirement age for Constables and
declared in initial application.
Sergeants is 60.
Images of tattoos may be requested for
Two-year probationary period for all new recruits.
consideration.
Sight
Residence
Home address must be approved by the Chief INTERVIEW WITH ASSESSOR
Constable of the force.
Four questions asked.
Application Form Information
The application form is the initial step in a rigorous Think before responding, consider past experiences
recruitment process. if applicable.
Failing at any stage means waiting six months Each question gets approximately five minutes for
before reapplying. response.
Deputy Chief Police Officer - Response: 3. Meeting the minimum requirements to proceed
through the recruitment gateways
Manages ACT Policing Operations:
The selection process involves:
Emergency Management & Planning
1. completing the online application
Traffic Operations
2. Meeting required standards at the Employment
North District and South District general duties Suitability Questionnaire
3. Successfully completing the pre-entry Physica
Director Corporate Services: lCompetency Assessment (PCA)
Oversees enabling services for frontline policing: 4. attending an assessment centre
Finance & Logistics 5. providing your fingerprints for a number of
operational and security reasons
Human Resources
6. having a medical examination and psychological
Media & Public Engagement
assessment
Ministerial & Operational Support
7. undergoing a urinalysis for illicit drug use
Exhibit Management Centre
8. Submitting required certificates (current certified
GENERAL QUALIFICATIONS copies of a Senior First Aid Certificate and the ability
to swim 100m (unaided)
10. Physically fit and healthy and able to undertake 6. the intelligence process
the physical requirements of training.
7. defensive skills
11. Have a senior first aid certificate (current for
8. firearms
entire training period).
9. driver training.
12. Year 12 education or year 10 with a trade
certificate or similar qualification. 13. Confirmation of On-the job training follows formal training and is
ability to swim 100 meters free style non-stop and generally conducted over a 12 Month period.
Unaided.
If you are an ACT Policing officer, you will be a
APPLICATION PROCESS Constable (in General Duties) for 12 months. The
The recruitment process is designed to ensure that instructors are a mix of sworn, unsworn and
the applicant's meet the suitability requirements and specialist members (i.e. fitness coach). Each has a
have the skils, attributes and values to meet the Certificate IV in Training and Assessment.
challenges and demands of a career in policing. The
application process involves: 2. Protective Service Officer Recruit
Training The AFP runs specific recruit training for
Protective Service Officers. This is a 13 week live-in
course at the AFP College in Canberra. Occasional
weekend and evening work is required including ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
exercises at the shooting range and night
operational simulations.
Theoretical components deal with the law and the
role of a Protective Service Officer. Practical
components include
a. firearms training,
b. defensive tactics (batons and handcuffs), crowd COUNTRY 4: CANADA
control (batons and shields ROYAL CANADIAN MOUNTED POLICE
Theoretical components deal with the law and the
role of a Protective Service Officer. Practical The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) is
components include a. firearms training, b. organized under the authority of the RCMP Act.
defensive tactics (batons and handcuffs), crowd
control (batons and shields The Commissioner leads the RCMP and operates
under the direction of the Minister of Public Safety
COURSE COMPONENTS Canada.
The Commissioner has control and management
All components of the course are assessable over the Force and all related matters.
Weekly theory tests and regular progressive review
tests assess accumulated knowledge
The RCMP enforces laws made by or under the
Many required skills and competencies have authority of the Canadian Parliament across
inherent fitness elements Canada.
Officers required to maintain appropriate fitness Provincial governments are responsible for
level for re-qualification administering justice within their respective
Performance closely monitored provinces, including enforcing the Criminal Code.
Unsatisfactory performance may result in RCMP provides police services under policing
termination of employment agreements to all provinces (except Ontario and
Quebec), Yukon, Northwest Territories, Nunavut,
LATERAL TRAINING and 180 municipalities.
Lateral Transfer Training:
It operates uniquely as a federal, municipal, and
Length of training depends on contemporary policing provincial policing body.
experience and skill levels
As Canada's national police force, RCMP enforces
May involve: federal laws throughout the country.
Six-week live-in training program at AFP College in
Canberra Ontario and Quebec maintain their own provincial
forces, namely Ontario Provincial Police and Surete
Focused on-the-job training in state of deployment du Quebec, while RCMP has taken over policing
Mission-specific training for International responsibilities elsewhere.
Deployment Group service The RCMP is responsible for a wide range of duties.
Federal Police Lateral Programs designed for The federal operations of REMP include:
individuals with current policing experience from 1. Enforcing federal laws including commercial
state or territory jurisdictions crime. Enforcing laws including drug trafficking,
Course content focuses on adapting existing border integrity, organized crime and various other
knowledge of state legislation to AFP's legislative matters. Providing counter terrorism and domestic
framework security.
1. School-leaving certificate;
2. Driving license;
3. Proof of English language skills;
4. Qualifications;
5. Health Check;
6. Background Check
7. General thinking test
8. Concentration test
9. German spelling and Grammar test
10. Sport test
11. Medical Examination
12. Security test
FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES
2. You must be in excellent physical condition. 4. Ensure security on the German railways;
Female candidates must be at least
5. Provide counter-terrorism forces (GSG9)
163cm(5'3″)and Male candidates must be at least
1.65 m (5′4″) with a maximum on 195 cm(6′5″). 6. Ensure compliance with aviation security
Everyonemust undergo a physical exam by an standards at 13 German airports and
authorized police physician to determine suitably.
Must not be overweight or underweight as 7. Serve as air (or sky) marshalls
measured using BMI ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
3. All applicants must have a clean criminal record.
Misdemeanor, Felony, SentencingandProbation
are treated the same way. Anybody that has been
punished in court is ineligible.
4. The current age limit is a minimum of 16 years
of age to 24 years of age. If you are police
executive, you must not be older than 27 when
recruited. Your level of experience and training a
b. Judgment
COUNTRY 6: HONGKONG c. Knowledge
Hongkong Policing System
d. Confidence
1. At least 18 years of age in the recruitment. The duties of the police force shall be to take lawful
measures for:
2. Undergone complete Full-time National
1. preserving public peace;
Service. NATIONAL SERVICE is a common
2. preventing and detecting crimes and
name for mandatory service programmed
offenses;
that requires all male Singaporean citizens
3. apprehending all persons whom police
and generation permanent residents who
officers are legally authorized to apprehend;
have reached the age of 18 to enroll for
4. regulating processions and assemblies in
national service. After which they can choose
public roads, public places or places of public
either Singapore Air Force (SAF), Singapore
resort;
Police Force (SPF), oог the Singapore Civil
5. regulating traffic upon public thoroughfares
Defense Force (SCDF).
and removing obstructions therefrom;
6. preserving order in public places and places
3. All applicants must be physically fit.
of public resort, at public meetings and in
assemblies for public amusements for which
4. Good eyesight and have normal color vision.
purpose, any police officer on duty shall have
free admission to all such places and
5. At least passes in the General Certificate of
meetings and assemblies while open to any
Education (GCE) ordinary level or NITEC
member of the public;
from the INSTITUTE of TECHNICAL
EDUCATION. NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF
7. assisting in carrying out the revenue, excise, • TNPD headquarters located in Bangkok,
sanitary, conservancy, quarantine and Thailand.
immigration laws;
8. assisting in preserving order in any port,
harbor, train station and airport in Singapore; QUALIFICATIONS
9. executing summons, subpoenas, warrants,
commitments and other processes issued by
the courts and Justices of the Peace; Must first pass a very competitive examination.
10. disseminating information to and advising the 1. High school graduates and a small group of
public and conducting prosecutions; policemen undergoing a four-year police education
11. protecting unclaimed and lost property and and training program at the Police Cadet Academy.
finding the owners thereof;
12. assisting in the protection of life and property 2. Law and political science degree graduates with a
at fires; six month police training course often called LPS
13. protecting persons from injury or death, and group.
public property from damage or loss, whether
3. Police Sergeants getting promoted known as
arising from criminal acts or in any other way;
Sergeant-becoming Lieutenant group.
14. attending the criminal courts and, if specially
ordered, the civil courts, and keeping order 4. Those with special knowledge or expertise in the
therein; law enforcement field who got transferred to be
15. escorting and guarding prisoners; officers and received six months of police training
16. executing such other duties as may by any which is called special group
written law be imposed on a police officer.
RECRUITMENT PROCESS
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
1. Application Individually assigned
identification date to submit the application
formto the recruitment staff.Each applicant
will be given an applicant's ID to carry
throughout the recruitment process.
2. Basic Knowledge Test
2.1. English Knowledge Test that involves
testing applicant's ability of Basic
English language skills: listening,
reading, writing and grammar.
1. Japanese citizen
2. Minimum Age Requirement Male Candidate-
19 years of age - Female-20 years of age
3. Must be physically and mentally healthy
4. Must have 20/20 vision ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
5. Must not have a criminal record - this
prohibition extend to an applicant's parent,
grandparent,siblings, aunts, uncles, and
cousins. The family of the spouse and the
family environment in which he was raised.
6. Does not have any left-wing political leanings
7. Does not have a Tainted background
8. Must have a good religion Gakki. Religion
should not compete with police duties for the
police officer's time such as the Sokka
Gakkai in particular that has practices, such
as shakufuku.
9. At least a high school Graduate.
10. For standards such as physique, there are
some differences by state. The Fukuoka
prefectural police, the condition of the
physique, in the men's height is 160 cm or
more, weight is 47 kg or more, and the chest
measurement is 78 cm or more.
11. For women, height is 155. cm or more,
weight is 45 kg or more.
RECRUITMENT PROCESS COUNTRY 11: PHILIPPINES
PHILIPPINE POLICING
1. All Japanese police recruits undergo a • Philippine National Police (PNP) originated from
standardized curriculum set by Japan's the Philippine Constabulary (PC) established in
National PoliceAgency 1901 under American regime.
• In 1975, Presidential Decree no. 765 established
2. High school graduates undergo 1 year of the Philippine Constabulary Integrated National
police school. Police (PC/INP) as the national police force.
• After the 1986 People’s Revolution, a new
3. After which, they are given "hands on" Constitution called for a national and civilian
experience through three months of field police force.
work. • Republic Act No. 6975 established the PNP
4. Once the 3 months are over, the recruits then under the Department of the Interior and Local
return for 6 more months of training and Government (DILG) in 1990, effective January 1,
discussions about what they experienced. 1991.
5. College graduates undergo a slightly • PNP became operational on January 29, 1991,
different system. While they must also with members from PC, INP, and selected
experience 3 months of field work, they only personnel from major service units of the Armed
attend police school for 8 months beforehand Forces of the Philippines.
and 4 months after. • Republic Act No. 8551, enacted in 1998, aimed
6. Anyone attending their first year of police to further reform and reorganize the PNP into a
school must live in a dormitory, even if they're highly efficient and competent police force.
married. For single officers, this requirement
QUALIFICATIONS
extends into their first 6 months of duty.
● Protecting life, person, and property 1. A citizen of the Philippines;
● Preventing, suppressing, and investigating crimes;
2. A person of good moral character,
● Apprehending suspects; traffic enforcement; and,
● Maintaining public safety and order 3. Must have passed the psychiatric/psychological, drug
and physical tests to be administered by the PNP;
5. Must be eligible: