Tidal LOw Land Reclamation
Tidal LOw Land Reclamation
Tidal LOw Land Reclamation
net/publication/343283502
CITATIONS READS
10 118
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Analysis on Water and Carbon Balances Analysis of SRI Paddy View project
All content following this page was uploaded by M Edi Armanto on 21 December 2021.
ABSTRACT
The main problem for agriculture at tidal lowland swamp is low soil quality and high acidity of soil and
high water. The research objective was to investigate how far the effort in increasing tertiary canal
network to improve water quality (increasing pH and reducinf iron) in channel and tertiary plot. Field
study was conducted at Bandarjaya Village of Jalur 25, Delta Sugihan Kanan, South Sumatra. Field
activities were consisted of network investigation land use and farm enterprise system which located at
Primr 13 of Sugihan Kiri and Primer 25 of Sugihan Kanan. The network improvement perfomance was
conducted by constructing micro water management (installed the tertiary gate and developen quartey
canal) at tertiary plot which consisted of collector channel, sub tertiary channel and control plot which
was outfall at quarterly channel downstream end. Water gate having goose neck pipe system was
constructed to control water table in tertiary channel. Results of field study showed that land use at the
study area was still dominated by rice crop with magnitude of 83% and the rest of 17% was used for
rubber plantation, orange planation and mix plantation. The depth of phyrite layer was in the range of 60
to 100 cm below soil surface. Water table surface in October was in the range of 10 to 35 cm. Field
adaptation showed that water gate was operated in closed condition (water retention) during vegetative
phase. Water retention showed significant to improve rice yield in which water table since November had
increased from -10 cm to flooding condition of 15 cm in January. This condition provide sufficient water
for rice crop which was similar as the result found at irrigation area. The addition of ameliorant
substances such as coconut fiber, and sand semen block at outfall of tertiary and kuartely channels also
increase water quality in which water pH was increased from 2.95 to 3.7 and iron concentration was
decreased from 4.01 to 0.32 mg/liter. Rice yield was increased from average production of 2 ton/ha to 3
ton/ha. This low production was due to land flushing process which need longer time process for at least 2
to 3 years from current condition as well as other production inputs such as fertilization and ameliorant
substances.
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
millions ha of saline land based on land water management which in turn can be
typology (Nugroho et al., 1993; Suriadikarta constructed as improvement
and Sutriadi, 2007). recommendation. According to Imanudin
Agricultural Food Security Agency (FSA) and Bakri (2014), the problem of farm
of Indonesia in 2017 had reported that enterprise at swamp area was due to water
Indonesia government will increase domestic status condition. Water is frequently not
rice production target from 72 million tons in available in proper quantity, quality and site
2016 into 77 million tons in 2017. Indonesia according to crop water requirement.
government will not import rice due to 5 Improper condition of drainage system
millions ton increase of rice production. results in under optimum of toxic substances
The production increase from previous years flushing process which subsequently
requires proper strategy, expansion program accumulated within roots zone. Therefore,
for planting area with new paddy field the key point is water management effort at
development or increasing the planting micro and macro levels of tidal lowland. In
itensity into two times per year for the addition, according to Meijide et al. (2017),
existing paddy field. South Sumatra is one of water table drawdown can increase carbon
mainstay province in supporting national rice release rate. Proper water management for
production. It had extensive area for rice rice crop with an objective to increase soil
cultivation especially with the land clearing water surface can decrease carbon release
of tidal lowland swamp since 1969. There rate. Reported by Kima et al., (2014), that
was currently about 370,000 ha of tidal maintenance water depth at 3 cm is produce
lowland swamp that had been opened for high yield of rice and promotes good water
food agriculture, but only 20% of this area quality by increasing pH and lowering iron
that implemented two times planting content in the root zone.
(LWMTL, 2006). If two times planting can The study results by Imanudin and
be done with average rice production of 3 Armanto (2012) showed that water status
ton/ha, then there will be rice production diversity was affected by land
increase with magnitude of 1.1 million tons. hydrotopography, rainfall and high tide
This condition was fulfilled merely from water potential. Every areas have different
tidal lowland swamp area. Therefore, the conditions so that they have different
proper policy is by increasing the planting objective in term of water managment
time into two times for the currently opened (Imanudin and Susanto, 2015). Water table
land. In addition, production for first depth is also highly depended on the existing
planting season should be increased from drainage system, rainfall input, crop growing
average of 3 ton/ha to 5 ton/ha. Areas that stage and water gate operation (Mercau et
should be developed in term of rice al., 2016). Zimmermann et al. (2017) had
production and planting intensity are delta mentioned that contribution from capillary
Sugihan Kiri at Banyuasin District and water movement was very important to
Sugihan Kanan at Ogan Komering Ilir fulfill crop water requirement and its
District. Average rice production in these magnitude is highly depended on position of
areas was only 2.5 ton/ha with one time water table depth. The above condition
planting (Imanudin at al., 2017). By requires different objective in term of water
application of proper water management, management. The current mistake problemis
average rice production at tidal lowland applying similar option of water
swamp could achieved 5-6 ton/ha such as management and even water table control
found at delta Telang I and II (Imanudin et structures. Therefore, water management
al., 2010; Imanudin and Bakri, 2014). objective can not be achieved and resulting
Therefore, the field study is still needed to in improper function of water structures.
investigate current condition of land and This paper will present results of study and
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 94
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
field application in term of perfomance water and soil quality in crop cultivation
improvement efforts for tertiary network effort. Data was also obtained through direct
through development of micro water interview with farm land owners/managers at
management at farm area and development tertiary plot in term of farm enterprise
of water table control structures. opportunity for second planting after rice
Development was conducted by involving crop.
farmers through participative approach. The second phase was field expriment.
Some advantages can be achieved through This activity was conducted to compose
this approach such as low cost of structures recommendation for water management
and farmers can build proper structures improvement according to field condition
because they have sense of belonging. This and farmers role. The improvement design
pattern should be developed in the near for water managment network was consisted
future. of :
Collector channel development (the
METHODOLOGY location is border on secondary
channel embankment);
Field study to investigate problems of Sub-tertiary channel development
farm enterprise and water management which border on tertiary channel;
system was conducted at Beringin Agung
Quarterly channel development (as
Village Primer 13 Sugihan Kiri of Banyuasin
land ownership border) and to carry
District and Bandar Jaya Village Jalur 25
water during high tide water period
Sugihan Kanan of Ogan Komering Ilir
from tertiary channel as well as to
District. Field expriment in term of micro
drain product of land leaching into
water management improvement was
tertiary channel;
conducted at Tersier 4 plot located at Bandar
Box control development at outfall of
Jaya Village Jalur 25 Air Sugihan of Ogan
quarterly channel, and
Komering Ilir District, South Sumatra. This
study was conducted from September 2016 Tertiary water gate development at
to February 2017. outfall which was directly related into
Materials used in this study were secondary channel.
construction materials for water gate Illustration of water structure design in
development which consisted of sand, tertiary channel can be seen in Figure 1. The
cement, paralon pipe, elbow, steel, bamboo, different in water surface height will be
gelam wood, brick and wooden board. controlled by height of goose neck pipe.
Equipments were consisted of water vessel, There was minimum limit of water height
carpentry tools and hoe. Survey was done by that should be retained in tertiary channel.
using questioner materials and Tertiary channel has function as water
administratitive equipments. storage (long storage) so that water table
depth was not quickly dropped. There was
The activity phases were as follows: mud settling pond in inner section
(downstream) before entering tertiary
Activities in first phase were directed to channel in which its base equipped with
obtain initial condition of network system, conblock (ameliorant); water plants were
water structure facility, water quality and planted at water surface that capable to
land use. Focused discussion with farmers increase pH of water and decrease iron
community was also conducted in these concentration. These water plants were
activties to explore information related to bordered with float to prevent them from
farm enterprise as well as problems related to flowing due to water current (Figure 2)
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
Water
Ameliorant
substance
Goose neck pipe
Dam
secondary
ykunderr
Figure 2. Cross section of water flow and purification system in secondary channel
tertiary channels was not connected into
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION secondary channel. One side of tertiary
channel was connected into Village Supply
General Description of Primer 13 Sugihan Channel (SPD), whereas the other side was
Kiri not connected into secondary channel as the
main drainage. The channel which connected
Agriculture at Beringin Agung Village
into Main Drainage Secondary Channel was
P13 Sugihan Kiri was located within area of
also not connected into Village Supply
Banyuasin District. Land use was dominated
Channel (SPD). Condition of the
by rice crop with magnitude of 80% and the
unconnected tertiary channel can be seen in
rest was mix plantation (coconut, perennial
Figure 3a, whereas the connected tertiary
trees, rubber and oil palm).
channel can be seen in Figure 3b.
Condition of water management system in
this area was pair comb system in which
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
3a 3b
Figure 3. Tertiary channel condition at reclaimed area of Sugihan Kiri, Primer 13 Banyuasin
Water gate nowadays was installed at showed that it was unsuccessful. The given
village road (Figure 4). This road was used production input was improper because of
for transportation of agricultural machinery poor physical land condition. The initial step
and equipment as well as for transportation should be conducted by improving physical
of four wheel vehicles to carry agricultural land condition through improvement of
products. Water gate construction is macro and micro water networks.
improper because it was too small in size and Improvement of macro water network was
probably will be damaged. In addition, the important as the main drainage to flush toxic
installed valve water gate was no longer used substances from tertiary channel due to land
by farmers. This water gate was shown in flushing process. Improvement of micro
Figure 4. Water gate construction should be water network is important by developing
better developed by using box culvert. water management at land plot (Micro Water
Current condition of farm enterprise Management), sub-tertiary channel and
should be improved because land was only collector channel surrounding land to drain
cultivated one time using rice crop with low acid substance that accumulated at cultivated
average production with magnitude of 2.5 land. After channel flushing, channel should
ton/ha. Some land locations had peat depth retain rainfall water as maximum as possible
in the range of 30 to 50 cm. Soil maturity so that water table was not quickly dropped
process was still low because of poor and land can store rainfall water during wet
drainage system. Drainage process especially season. The concept used in this area was to
during wet season was not function properly retain rainfall water as maximum as possible.
because most of secondary channels were Water pumping from outside area was not
shallow due to sedimentation resulting in allowed because high tidal water had low
very low water flow pattern (Figure 4). On quality, containing acid substance during wet
the other hand, channels were dominated by season or middle season as well as frequently
the growth of water grasses. Therfore, had high salinity during dry season. At least
preliminary improvement for water two years was required to flush the land from
management system was needed and acid substance and heavy metals. After micro
agricultural program should be conducted water management was properly developed,
together with program from Public Work then liming application at initial stage is
Ministry. Agricultural inputs should be given required to improve soil fertility. In addition,
on area that had already have good water there was no water gate in secondary
management network at macro and micro channel. This water gate is important at least
levels. to retain salt water intrusion during dry
Evaluation on program of agricultural season and to retain rainfall water as
production cost input with magnitude of Rp. maximum as possible approaching the end of
3,000,000/ha given by Agricultural Ministry wet season.
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 97
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
General Description of Farm Enterprise perennial trees at paddy field ridge such as
Condition and Water Management at oil palm-rice of 11 ha, coconut-rice of 9 ha,
Bandar Jaya Village Jalur 25 Air Sugihan rubber-rice of 6 ha and orange – rice of 6 ha,
Kanan, Ogan Komering Ilir District respectively.
This land functional shifting had been
Areal condition at Bandar Jaya Village increased yearly resulting in the decrease of
had already showed land functional shifting paddy field land as the producer of main
such as indicated by farmers complaint in food. Although area of paddy field land was
term of low soil fertility and unpredictable still dominate in term of percentage (Figure
condtion of season. Functional shifting from 5) with magnitude of 83 % from total land
agricultural land into oil palm plantation available at the east block, but this land
covering area of 38 ha, rubber plantation of functional shifting had potential to decrease
38 ha and coconut plantation of 3 ha had area of paddy field land at Bandar Jaya
occurred at the east block of Bandar Jaya Village so that immediate action should be
Village. Intercropping method was also taken.
conducted by some farmers by adding
Figure 5. Land use percentage at East Block of Bandar JayaVillage at First Planting Season
in 2016
Source: Intreview results with head of farmer groups at Bandar Jaya Village
Observation on water quality in tertiary observation showed that phyrite layer depth
channel showed that it can be categorized as was in the range of 80 to 90 cm. Water table
acid with pH of 3 and water quality in depth during this observation was 45 cm
flooded water pond showed very acid level below soil surface.
with pH of 2.5. This water acidity was Rice seeds planting was conducted in
originated from phyrite oxidation process at October by using method of direct seeds
dry season which produce acid. Field spreading. It requires high quantity of seeds
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 98
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
with magnitude of 90 kg (18 sacks having retention process of high tidal water and
weight of 5 kg/sack) to plant 1 ha of rice water gate was opened to facilitate water
crop. Rice varities commonly used were IR inflow and outflow. The main objective
64, Ciherang, Ciliwung and PB. Upkeeep to during October was to maximize land
maintain soil fertility was conducted by leaching process and to drain acid substances
using fertilizers as follows: Urea dose of 200 in channels (flushing). Water table surface
kg/ha; Super Phospat 36 dose of 100 kg/ha was within roots zone as an impact from
and Phonska (Nitrogen fertilizers) dose of water inflow in tertiary channel. Soil water
200 kg/ha. Harvest yield per hectare was in was located at maximum of -21 cm and it
the range of 60 to 80 sacks (50 kg per sack). was located near soil surface (0 cm) during
The selling price of unhulled rice during high tide water period (Figure 6). Process of
harvest period was in the range of 7,000 to water surface drawdown (low tide period)
8,000 rupiahs. was occurred in relatively long period from
In general, there was three main problems 03.00 pm to 18.00 am or 16 hours. Water
of land that can be identified at the study surface drawdown tend to be followed by
location as follows: a) Water Management drawdown in tertiary channel in which peak
and Water Quality, b) Soil Fertility and 3) of water surface at 70 cm progressively
Crop Pest and Disease. dropped to the lowest point of 30 cm within
Water dynamics condition was observed 15 hours period and then it was increased
for 24 hours. Water surface fluctuation per again. Water table was at 18 to 20 cm below
hour in channels and water table on land was soil surface when water surface in tertiary
observed every hour such as shown in Figure channel was at 30 to 40 cm. This condition
8. This figure clearly showed that water showed that if tertiary channel regularly
surface in tertiary channel follows water receive water supply, then water table would
surface pattern in secondary channel with no dropped below phyrite layer.
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
surface in October period. However, soil was seeds spreading, some seeds had been grown
still moist at upper part of soil surface. having age of 14 days and some land had not
Rice growth condition at tertiary plot was been tilled yet. Description of land condition
diverse because farmers had done planting at can be seen in Figure 7.
different times. Some farmers had done
Figure 8. Micro water management at tertiary block of tidal lowland reclamation areas
The land was classified as rain fed land 2011). Land was potential to be flooded at
based on flooding type characteristics and least at puddling condition during rainfall
water table condition in which availability of occurrence and water can be retained for
rainfall water was very important for crop several days as well as not directly drained
evapotranspiration and land leaching. Water into channel. This condition was required
management concept is how farmers capable because rice crop needs constant wet soil
to maximize rainfall water (rainfall condition in order to depress weeds growth
harvesting) so that rainfall water was not and water stress would be occurred if water
quickly drained into tertiary channel and table was dropped at 20 cm depth for more
toward secondary channel. Therefore, the than 3 days.
main option for water management objective Field study showed that valve water gate
was water retention concept. Tertiary was not suitable for water retention option.
channel has function as rainfall storage pond Therefore, model of water table control was
(long storage) in order to maintain shallow done by using water structure that capable to
water table depth at teriary plot within 30 cm retain rainfall water and can be opened for
zone below soil surface (Imanudin et al., drainage operation. This controlled model
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 100
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
can be fulfilled by using system of goose culvert structure was installed using concrete
neck pipe. Two paralon pipes having protector. Elbow (L) was installed and was
diameter of 12 inches were installed within connected with pipe which resembles goose
tertiary structure. Process of water gate neck on outside pipe toward inside part
making from preparation stage to (Figure 9). Water can not outflow from
development stage can be seen in Figure 9. tertiary channel into secondary channel due
The operational principle of this system was to condition of goose neck pipe. If rice crops
very simple in which excess of rainfall water need no water or flushing operation will be
(surface flow from land) would flow into conducted in tertiary channel, then goose
tertiary channel. Water was held previously neck pipe was removed and water will be
in box control before flowing into tertiary drained into secondary channel during low
channel. Rainfall water can be stored as tide water. Goose neck pipe was operated at
maximum as possible in tertiary channel so installed condition which indicate that it was
that tertiary water gate was in permanently used to retain rainfall water (rain harvesting).
closed condition. In order to prevent leakage,
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
accumulation in roots zone of crop that was was not flooded by this water. Therefore,
not maximally leached. This condition water management system on land and box
results in low water quality. Byproducts control at outfall of quarterly channel were
result from phyrite oxidation had produced required in order to prevent the effect of poor
acid substances that were drained into quality of surface water (Figures 10-11).
tertiary channel or water body. Therefore, This system could passively produce water
water purification was needed before it was purification through application of additive
drained or before it was entered into land substances in box control. Therefore, water
through high tide water. The study of water previously reacts with ameliorant substance
table status in the field showed that it was before entering quarterly channel which in
located at 45 to 50 cm below soil surface. turn could increase soil pH. On the other
This condition was very suitable for corn hand, drained water from land was also
growth. The evapotranspiration requirement previously flow into box control so that
can be fulfilled by capillary soil water acidity and solubility of toxic substances
movement at this water table depth were decrease before flowing into tertiary
(Imanudin and Bakri, 2014). Although channel. Water flow into tertiary channel
surface water in channel showed low pH of was connected with 5 inch pipe.
3, but it was not toxic to crop because land
Tertiary
Control
box cha
pengendali
chsier
Limestone or
ameliorant briquette
Figure kapur atau section
10. Cross briket of water flow system from tertiary channel into quarterly channel
amelioran
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
water had fulfilled the criteria as irrigation considered dangerous for aquatic organisms
water standard. This was in accordance to the life (Moore, 1991). In addition, poor water
study result by Yusuf (2014) which stated quality was also shown by sulphate
that Fe concentration in water can be concentration in water which exceed tolerant
considered suitable for irrigation water if its threshold limit. According to Scofield
concentration in water was less than 10 (1936), water is not suitable for irigation if
mg/liter. Low concentration of Fe was its sulphate concentration is higher than 20
probably due to rainfall during October- mg/liter, whereas Yusuf (2014) had stated
November period. However, Fe that water was suitable for irrigation if its
concentration higher than 1 mg/L was sulphate concentration is less than 7 mg/liter.
Table 1. Analysis results of water quality from channels at tidal lowland area of Jalur 25 of
Sugihan Kanan
Dates of sample taking
No. Parameters
20 October 2016 2 November 2016
Simple treatment had been done in capable to increase pH to 7.5 and to decrease
laboratory in order to decrease iron and iron concentration to 0.05 mg/liter. The best
sulphate concentrations as well as to increase result from conblock plus treatment had
pH of water. This test was conducted by produced alkaline pH and had decreased iron
addition of substances that had additive concentration. Increase of water pH in
characteristics. Treatment was consisted of conblock treatment showed relatively high
addition of rice straw ash and conblock plus neutralizing power of conblock so that dose
made of sand, cement, lime and rice straw of 1:4 volume ratio (1 part of conblock and 4
ash. Phytoremediation method was also liters of water) was too high. Therefore,
tested by planting of water hyacinth. treatment series were needed to obtain the
Analysis results of ameliorant substances optimum dose. Treatment of water hyacinth
addition for one week period showed was also effective in decreasing iron
significant effect in decreasing iron concentration and in increasing pH of water.
concentration and in increasing pH of water However, all treatments were incapable to
(Table 2). Addition of rice straw ash was decrease sulphate concentration in water
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
Table 2. Laboratory analysis results related to treatment effect on water channel purification
No. Parameters Dose treatment 1:4 unit of volume
Rice straw ash Water Conblock Plus
hyacinth
Study of Water Quality Change in Field water with magnitude of 4 mg/liter, whereas
iron concentration in treatment pond was
Environmental condition especially decreased to 0.32 mg/liter and it was very
drainage water was very acid at condition of suitable for irrigation. The decrease was also
acid soil. This was shown by pH of water found on sulphate concentration from 29.9
less than 3 found in tertiary channel. Acid mg/liter to 6.8 mg/liter which was suitable
soil condition causes the increase of iron and for irrigation water requirement.
alluminum solubilities. This would highly The decrease of iron concentration
depress other nutrients availability, (Table 3) at quarterly channel level showed
especially phosphorus at certain condition positive result because this water will be
(Panhwar et al., 2016). Therefore, directly used to irrigate crops at tertiary plot.
improvement of soil quality and water Iron toxicity was frequently found on rice
quality should be done at initial stage in cultivation at tidal swamp land (Sebastian,
order to increase pH value. A. and Prasad, 2015). Iron toxicity on rice
Water sampling in tertiary and secondary was due to high concentration of Fe in soil or
channels was done to determine the change within soil solution. Study results showed
of water quality as impact from addition of that Fe concentration in soil solution which
ameliorant substances. Processing effort in cause Fe toxicity on crops were highly vary.
the field was done by addition of synthetic Critical limit of Fe concentration in soil
additive substances in form of conblock solution which cause iron toxicity was in the
(mixing of cement, rice straw ash and lime) range of 100 ppm at pH of 3.7 and 300 ppm
at tertiary channel outfall and water was or higher at pH of 5.0 (Sahrawat et al.,
previously flown into treatment pond at box 1995). According to Asch et al. (2005), Fe
control before entering into quarterly concentration in soil solution which causes
channel. Analysis results showed relatively toxicity was highly vary in the range of 10 to
significant change of water quality in 500 ppm. The study results from Majerus et
quarterly channel. The increase of pH was al. (2007) and Mehraban et al. (2008)
only one digit so that it needs to be increased showed that Fe concentration in nutrients
at leat to pH of 5. However, pH of water in solution with magnitude of 250 to 500 ppm
the field was relatively good with magnitude and pH of 4.5 to 6.0 had significantly
of 5 as indicated by pH paper test. Oxidation increased Fe concentration in plant tissues
was probably occurred during analysis at and showed Fe toxicity symptoms for
laboratory. Significant decrease of iron sensitive plants. The study results from
concentration was found in tertiary channel Dorlodot et al. (2005) which used Fe
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 104
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
Figure 13. Operation condition of water gate and rice crop growth (18 December 2016)
Farmers effort to close water gate was of water table condition at land plot (zero
conducted during growth period of rice crop, runoff). Since the start of rainfall occurrence
especially at vegetative phase. Closed in the middle of October, water table was
operation of water gate had caused water in continously increased close to soil surface,
tertiary channel was at maximum level of 80- whereas flooding was occurred starting from
90 cm which capable to continously increase November and water flooding with thickness
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 106
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
Figure 14. Water table dynamics at land plot as affected by water gate operation
Condition of excess water volume (which field capacity condition (Supriyanto, 2013),
cause flooding) is frequently results in whereas water should available above field
aeration stress, whereas insufficient water capacity zone for maximum production of
volume results in dryness stress. For rain fed paddy field rice. The study by Fonteh et al.
rice, crop will experience decrease in growth (2013) had showed that continues flooding
and production if available water condition is treatment had showed no significant effect
less than field capacity level (Ahmed et than that of intermitten irrigation. Continues
al.,2014). Water should always available at irrigation (continues flooding with water
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 107
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
depth of 3 cm) had produced the same rice channel base or water body.
yield than that of intermitten irrigation Ameliorant substances were used to
(Hossain et al., 2016).. Moreover, Naharia et increase pH of water. Proper
al. (2005) added that continues flooding substances after laboratory test were
treatment with height of 5 cm gave yield of 5 rice straw ash, coconut fiber, compost
ton/ha. It was reported in Iran (Pascual and and soil from below of banana trees.
Wang, 2016) that water application depth of These substances were capable to
3 to 7 cm at irrigation area could produced increase pH of water from 2 to 5.
rice yield of 8.0 ton/ha. Therefore, water Conblock construction using mixture of
table control at paddy field plot with sand-cement-lime-rice sraw ash with
maximum depth of 5 to 10 cm was very volume ratio of (2: 2: 1: 3) showed
important to produce maximum rice yield at significant effect in increasing pH of
swamp area. water. Testing on channel water with
In addition to water quality improvement 1:4 volume ratio of concblock and
and water table control, production increase water could increased pH of water up
should also followed by ameliorant to 8.
substances addition in soil coupled with All ameliorant substances were
biofertilizer addition (Panhwar et al., 2016). generally capable to increase pH value,
to decrease iron concentration, but not
Acknowledgements all were capable to decrease sulphate
The authors gratefully acknowledge to concentration.
the provision of financial support ref. Tertiary channel improvement was
184.2/PL.040/H.1/09/2016 dated 13-09- conducted by constructing water gate
2016 from Agricultural Research and of goose neck type so that rainfall
Development Agency Ministry of water can be maximally retained in
Agriculture Republic Indonesia. tertiary channel and high tide water
from secondary channel having poor
CONCLUSION AND water quality could not enter into
RECOMMENDATION tertiary channel. Water gate opening
was done when water rainfall was in
Conclusions
excess quantity or height of goose neck
Low productivity at the study area was pipe can be regulated up to water
due to high level of soil and water maximum level above the highest
acidities, phyrite oxidation process water table height.
during dry season and acid substances Water gate was operated at opened
were not maximally leached due to low mode for initial period of wet season
perfomance of drainage network. Micro up to planting season (free water inflow
network at tertiary plot was unavailable and outflow) to accelerate leaching.
and tertiary channel was still connected Water gate was operated as rainfall
to secondary channel in one direction. water retention up to January and was
The study of land use showed that rice opened at approaching harvest period
cultivation was still very potential (February-March).
because land use for rice crop was 83 The study results of water qualty
% and the rest of 17% was for other improvement in the field showed that
usage, including plantation. there was significant change of water
Improvement of water quality at the quality between tertiary channel and
study area can be done by using quarterly channel. Water in quarterly
passive technology through channel had already showed the quality
improvement of biological process in which fulfill good irrigation water
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111 108
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
Hasibuan, S.H. 2010. Analysis of Irrigation Imanudin, M.S., M.E. Armanto, R.H.
Water Requirement at Paddy Field Susanto and S.M. Bernas. 2010. Water
Irrigation Area of Kampar District. Status Evaluation on Tertiary Block for
Journal of APTEK 3(1):97-102. Developing Land Use Pattern and Water
Management Strategies in Acid Sulphate
Imanudin, M. S., Bakri., Karimuddin, Y. Soil of Saleh Tidal Lowland Reclamation
2017. Maksimalisasi Panen Hujan untuk Areas of South Sumatra. Journal of
Penyediaan Air Bersih pada Budidaya Agriculturas Science – AGRIVITA Vol
Padi MT1 (November-Februari) di Lahan 32(3): 241-253. ISSN 0126-0537. Web-
Pasang Surut Tipologi B/C Daerah link:
Sugihan Kanan. Makalah disampaikan http://www.agrivita.ub.ac.id/index.php/ag
pada disampaikan pada Seminar Nasional rivita/article/view/16
Lahan Suboptimal Oktober 2017.
Imanudin, M.S. and Armanto, M. 2012.
Imanudin, M.S. and Susanto, R.H. 2015. Effect of Water Management
Intensive Agriculture of Peat Land Areas Improvement on Soil Nutrient Content,
to Reduce Carbon Emission and Fire Iron and Aluminum Solubility at Tidal
Preventation (A Case Study in Tanjung Low Land Area. Available online at
Jabung Timur Tidal Lowland www.sciencedirect.com. APCBEE
Reclamation Jambi). Proceeding The 1st Procedia 4 (2012) 253 – 258.
Young Scientist International Conference
of Water Resources Development and Kima, A. S., Chung, G.W., and Wang Y.M.
Environmental Protection, Malang, 2014. Improving Irrigated Lowland Rice
Indonesia, 5-7 June 2015. Water Use Efficiency under Saturated
Soil Culture for Adoption in Tropical
Imanudin, M.S. and Bakri. 2014. Corn Climate Conditions. Water 2014, 6, 2830-
Cultivation Study during Wet Season at 2846; doi:10.3390/w6092830
Reclaimed Area of Tidal Lowland in
Effort to Develop 300% Planting Index. LWMTL. 2006. Program of Land and Water
Proceeding of INACID National Seminar, Management of Tidal Lowlands
16-17 May 2014, Palembang-South (LWMTL) at Banyuasin District, South
Sumatra. ISBN 978-602-70580-0-2. Sumatra Province. June 2004-August
2006.
Imanudin, M.S. and M.E. Armanto. 2012.
Effect of Water Management Meijide, A., Gruening, Goded, Seufert, G.
Improvement on Soil Nutrient Content, 2017. Water Management Reduces
Iron and Aluminum Solubility at Tidal Greenhouse Gas Emissions in a
Lowland Area. APCBEE Procedia 4 Mediterranean Rice Paddy Field.
Journal of Wetlands Environmental Management
Vol 6, No 2 (2018) 93 - 111
http://dx.doi.org/10.20527/jwem.v6i2.165 108
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----
Available on line at: ISSN: 2354-5844(Print)
http://ijwem.unlam.ac.id/index.php/ijwem ISSN: 2477-5223 (Online)
Mansour MMF, Salama KHA, Ali FZM, Suriadikarta, D.A. and Sutriadi, M.T. 2007.
Abou Hadid AF. 2005. Cell and Plant Types of Potential Land for Agricultural
Repsonses to NaCl in Zea mays L. Development at Swamp Area. Journal of
Cultivars Differing in Salt Tolerance. Agricultural Research and Development.
Gen. Appl. Plant Physiol. 31(1-2): 29-41 No. 36(3): 115-122
Moore, J.W. 1991. Inorganic Contaminant of Sebastian, A. and Prasad, M.N.V. 2015.
Surface Water Springer Verlag, New Trace Element Management in Rice.
York. Agronomy 2015, 5(3): 374-404;
doi:10.3390/agronomy5030374
Naharia, O., Saeni, S.M., Sabihan, S. and
110
Burhan, H. 2005. Irigation Technology Susanto, R.H. 2007. Manajemen Rawa
and Soil Tillage at Paddy Field Rice Terpadu untuk Pembangunan
Cultivation for Methane Gas Mitigation Berkelanjutan. Prosiding Kongres Ilmu
(CH4). Biological News 7(4) Pengetahuan Wilayah Indonesia Bagian
Barat. Unsri-LIPI. Palembang Juni 2007
Nugroho, K., Suping, S. and Sarwani, M.
1993. Land Characteristics in Scofield, F.E, 1936. The Salinity of
Reclamation Research and Acid Sulphate Irrigation Water. Smith Ann. Rep. 1935:
Soil Tillage. Collaboration between Soil 275-283.
and Agroclimate Resarch Center and P3N
Project, Jakarta. 1−15 Utama, M.Z.H., W. Haryoko, R. Munir,
Sunadi. 2009. Screening of rice varieties
Pascual, J.V. and Wang, Y.M. 2016. Impact tolerant to salinity on swamp land, in
of Water Management on Rice Varieties, Pesisir Selatan Regency. J. Agronomy
Yield, and Water Productivity under the Indonesia 37: 101-106
System of Rice Intensification in Southern
Taiwan. Water 2017, 9, 3; Zimmerman, I., Fleige, H. and Horn, R.
doi:10.3390/w9010003. 2017. Longtime Effects of Deep
Groundwater Extraction Management on
Panhwar, A.Q., Naher, A.U., Water Table Levels in Surface Aquifers.
Shamshuddin, J. Radziah, O. and Journal of Soil and
Hakeem, R.K. 2016. Management of Sediment.17(1):133–143
Acid Sulfate Soils for Sustainable Rice
Cultivation in Malaysia. Yusuf, A. I. 2014. The Study of Irrigation
Soil Science: Agricultural and Water Quality Criteria. Journal of
Environmental Prospectives. pp 91-104 Irrigation. 9(1): 1-15
-----Accredited by Directorate General of Higher Education Indonesia, No. 21/E/KPT/2018, Valid until 9 July 2023-----