Dunn1988
Dunn1988
Dunn1988
The use of parenteral nutrition and a prolonged delay in nutrition may ameliorate these problems. Because these
starting enteral feeding has become standard care in many oral feedings do not contain sufficient calories to sustain
neonatal intensive care units. 18 However, intravenous
nutrition in the absence of oral feeding may be associated NICU Neonatal intensive care unit
with a variety of serious complications in the low birth NPO Nothing by mouth
PO Enteral feeding
weight infant, such as cholestatic jaundice, metabolic bone
GGT 3,-Glutamyl transferase
disease, and atrophy of the intestinal mucosa. 9"16 SGOT Serum glutamic-oxaloacetic transaminase
Evidence is mounting that even small volumes of enteral SGPT Serum glutamic-pyruvic transaminase
NEC Necrotizing enterocolitis
622
Volume 112 Early hypocaloric enteral feeding 623
Number 4
Our study was performed to test the hypothesis that Infants in the PO group received parenteral alimenta-
early hypocaloric enteral feeding would improve gastroin- tion according to the same schedule as the NPO group. In
testinal function and lessen the complications of parenteral addition, they received hypocaloric feedings of half-
alimentation among sick, very low birth weight infants. strength Enfamil Premature Formula (Mead Johnson &
Co., Evansville, Ind.), which were initiated at 48 hours.
METHODS The volume fed was 15 to 20 m l / k g / d . Feeding intervals
This study was conducted at Rainbow Babies and were every hour if the infant's weight was <1000 g and
Childrens Hospital, Cleveland, from September 1984 until every 2 hours if the infant's weight was > 1000 g. Therefore
January 1986. The protocol was approved by the hospital's actual volumes of individual feeding varied between 0.5
Institutional Review Board on Human Investigation. and 2.0 ml/per feeding, depending on the infant's birth
Signed parental consent was obtained for each infant in weight. All feedings were by intermittent gavage. Feedings
this investigation. All infants weighing 1500 g or less with were stopped if feeding intolerance developed, as defined
respiratory distress who required mechanical ventilation by emesis, ileus, marked abdominal distension, heme-
and placement of an umbilical arterial catheter were positive stools, or bile-stained residual. Small (<2 ml)
eligible for inclusion in the study. Criteria for exclusion nonbilious gastric residuals were refed and were not
were serious congenital anomalies and postnatal age >48 considered to be an indication for fasting. If feedings were
hours. tolerated for 48 hours, full-strength formula was intro-
Infants were enrolled in the study after being stratified duced. If the infant's clinical condition required fluid
to one of four weight categories: <750 g, 750 to 999 g, restriction, such as for treatment of a patent ductus
1000 to 1249 g, or 1250 to 1500 g. Within each category, arteriosus, only the intravenous fluid volume was reduced
the infants were randomly assigned by cards in paired accordingly. The volume of feedings in this group
envelopes to either the control group (standard nutritional remained constant for 7 days, or until the ninth day of
management, specifically, parenteral alimentation alone life.
[NPO]) or the experimental group (parenteral alimenta- At the end of the trial period (ninth day of life) the
tion plus hypocaloric enteral feeds [PO]). volume of feedings could be advanced for the infants in the
Infants in the NPO group received no enteral nutrition PO group, and enteral feedings could be introduced in the
until after 9 days of life. At age 48 hours of life, parenteral infants in the N P O group. Decisions regarding nutritional
nutrition was begun and was constituted as follows: Dex- management at this time were made by the clinicians,
trose was begun as 10% glucose in water (g/dL) if the except with respect to rapidity of feeding advancement.
infant was glucose tolerant. (Glucose intolerance was Infants weighing <1000 g would not reach full-volume
defined as serum glucose concentration over 175 m g / d L (150 ml/kg/d), full-strength enteral feedings in <10 days,
[9.7 mmol/L] and >- 2+ glucosuria by reagent test [Clin- and infants weighing <1500 g but >1000 g could not reach
itest].) If glucose intolerance was present, the dextrose full-volume, full-strength enteral feedings in less than 7
concentration was reduced until glucosuria resolved. If the days. After that time, decisions concerning response to
infant was glucose tolerant, the dextrose concentration was "feeding intolerance" or gastric residuals were not influ-
advanced to 12.5%. The protein concentration was begun enced by the investigators, but were recorded.
at approximately 1.5 g / k g / d and advanced to 2.5 g / k g / d Blood was drawn for liver function tests (total serum
if the blood urea nitrogen level was less than 20 m g / d L protein, albumin, SGOT, SGPT, alkaline phosphatase,
(7.1 mmol/L). Intravenous fat emulsion (Intralipid) was total and direct bilirubin, 3,-glutamyl transferase) at
withheld until the total bilirubin level was less than 6 enrollment and twice during the trial week. Liver function
m g / d L (102 t~mol/L). It was then begun at 0.5 g / k g / d was assessed weekly thereafter, until discharge.
and advanced to a maximum of 2.0 g / k g / d . Fluid volume Data on total fluid intake (both enteral and parenteral)
and electrolytes were given at the discretion of the house and daily weight and data pertinent to standard neonatal
staff and the attending physician on the basis of a stan- management were prospectively recorded for the duration
dard protocol and modified-as required by clinical con- of the hospital stay. Necrotizing entercolitis was defined by
dition. In our institution, fluid intake on day 1 of life is the presence of pneumatosis intestinalis, portal venous gas,
generally 80 m l / k g / d and volume is advanced by 20 or autopsy criteria in a patient with abdominal distension
ml/kg/d. The actual volume is modified on the basis of and hematochezia. Guidelines for the use of phototherapy
clinical evaluation, urine output, daily weight measure- in our institution are uniformly used and depend on levels
ments, and serum electrolyte values. By the end of the first of total bilirubin and the infant's birth weight. Photother-
week, the infant will generally receive between 150 and apy is used in an infant weighing _<1000 g if the serum
180 m l / k g / d . indirect bilirubin level is >--5 mg/dL, and in an infant
624 Dunn et al. The Journal of Pediatrics
April 1988
t-
-r 1.8 NPO
hi PO
-r 1.6
n,- /I f
rn
IJ-
o 1.4
I--
z
hi
0 1.2
LtJ
(2.
O0
i.O
t'--
3::
C9
Ld I I I I I I
0.8
0 20 40 60
DAYS OF LIFE
Fig. I. Average weight as percent of birth weight. Initial weight loss and subsequent weight gains were similar for both
experimental (NPO) and control (PO) groups.
of days with feeding intolerance requiring periods of being all occurring after week 2 of life. This is suggestive of a
on an N P O regimen for at least 12 hours per day did not diagnosis Of cholestatic jaundice. Only 6.7% of the PO
differ significantly, nor was the time to regain birth weight infants demonstrated this problem (P <0.01). Additional-
(Table III). Furthermore, there were no significant growth ly, the highest direct bilirubin value in the NPO gi'oup at
or weight differences between the two groups throughout any time during their hospital stay was significantly
the entire study (Fig. 1). The percent of calories by the greater than thai of the PO group (2.5 _+ 3.1 vs 0.7 ___ 0.8
enteral route during the first week was 20.7% in the PO mg/dL; P < 0.05).
group and, by definition, 0% in the NPO group. Thereafter Serum SGOT values did not differ significantly (data
the percent of total calories taken by mouth increased in not reported). None of the infants in the PO group had an
both groups during the second phase of the study. None- elevated SGOT value (normal defined as up tO 67 U / L ) ,
theless, the total caloric intake of the two groups did not including the infant who had direct hyperbiiirubinemia.
differ significantly at any time during the study or during The only infants in the NPO group who had elevated levels
the remainder of the infants' hospital stay. of SGOT were the five infants who had elevated serum
The number of days in the N I C U (68 vs 57), in the levels Of direct bilirubin. Elevated serum GGT levels were
hospital (102 vs 98), with an endotracheal tube (34 vs 30), not associated with the presence of direct hyperbilirubi-
and with an umbilical arterial catheter (13 vs 10) did not hernia (data not reported). No differences in the GGT
differ significantly between the NPO and the PO groups, levels between the two study groups could be demonstrat-
respectively. ed. Among all infants With eholestasis, only one had an
The incidence of NEC did not differ between the NPO elevated level of GGT. However, six infants (three in the
and the PO groups (5% vs 16%), although the number of NPO group, and three in the PO group) had elevated GGT
patients is too small to avoid a type II error. These infants levels in the presence of normal direct bilirubin values. All
demonstrate the pattern of N E C that is common among of these infants were clinically well and receiving full
babies who weigh <1000 g in our hospital: onset late in the enteric feedings. In these well infants, the elevated serum
hospital course (day 18 to 90) and after the study values of GGT subsequently reverted to normal.
period. At no time during the hospital course were the serum
The PO group had an average of 2.7 fewer days under total protein and albumin concentrations different between
phototherapy than did the NPO group (Table IV), perhaps the two groups (data not reported). Alkaline phosphatase
because of a greater decline in the bilirubin concentration levels did, however, demonstrate a pronounced and signif-
during the first 2 weeks of life in the PO group. Of the 30 icant rise that began 6 weeks after birth in the NPO
infants who completed the study, 33.3% of the N P O infants (Fig. 2). In contrast, there were no consistent
infants had direct bilirubin measurements of >2.0 mg/dL, excessive elevations (levels >500 U / L ) of serum alkaline
626 Dunn et al. The Journal of Pediatrics
April 1988
NPO
8oor 9 p<o.o
600
20 ** p <.02
Z NPO N=5
o
O3
n-" I0
(..)
X
bJ
IJJ
O3
0 \
(J
:3 -I0 \
.J \
t.q \
x _ _ - e PO N=3
M I NUTES
Fig. 3. Glucose tolerance test results. The y-axis plots glucose excursion (in mg/dL) with baseline defined as value at
time 0. The x-axis illustrates minutes after bolus of glucosewas given. NPO group exhibited much greater excursion above
baseline, compared with PO group. At 30 and 60 minutes, differences between the two populations reached statistical
significanceof P < 0.05 and P < 0.02, respectively.
phosphatase activity among PO infants. (Normal alkaline for the elevated alkaline phosphatase levels, we examined
phosphatase values in our laboratory are 50 to 380 U/L; calcium, phosphorus, and vitamin D intake. Calculations
levels over 500 U / L warrant intervention.)Elevations of of intake were based on the recorded compositions of the
the enzyme occurred in 66% (10/15) of the NPO infants commercial formuia and parenteral alimentation fluid.
but in only 20% (3/15) of the PO group (P <0.01). In most The PO group received more calcium than the NPO
of the infants with elevated serum alkaline phosphatase infants during the first week (129 ___27 vs 66 + 2 4 mg;
Values, other liver function tests were normal. In three of P < 0.01) and cumulatively during,the first month of life
the patients in whom increased levels of alkaline phospha- (1.3 vs 0.8 g; P <0.05). However, after week 4, the calcium
tase were noted, the elevated enzyme fraction was from intakes were equivalent in the two groups, and at no time
bone. Two of these infants had radiographic evidence of were the phosphate intakes different. In addition, vitamin
pathologic fractures. D intake was calculated to be greater for the PO infants
To identify nutritional variables that may be responsible during the first (64 _+ 19 vs 30 ___ 12 IU; P < 0.01) and
Volume 112 Early hypocaloric enteral feeding 627
Number 4
second (114 + 30 vs 63 + 21 IU; P < 0.01) weeks of life. enteral feedings. Traditionally, these very low birth weight
Thereafter vitamin D intakes were similar. infants would not have received enteral alimentation dur'
For determination of the effects of enteral alimentation ing the acute phas e of their medical illnesses.1 The provi-
on glucose homeostasis, a pilot study of oral glucose sion of hypocaloric feeding was not associated with feeding
tolerance was performed on the ninth day of life in eight intolerance, aspiration pneumonia, ileus, or an increased
randomly selected infants. The NPO group had signifi- incidence of NEC. Moreover, hypocaloric enteral feeds
cantly greater increases of plasma glucose concentrations had beneficial effects on neonatal jaundice. The PO group
from the baseline at 30 and 60 minutes after an oral received fewer days of phototherapy than the NPO group.
glucose challenge than did the PO group (Fig. 3). This effect may be the result of enhanced intestinal
motility and excretion of bilirubin in the stool of infants
DISCUSSION receiving hypocaloric feedings.Z4 The incidence of cholesta-
The philosophies for providing nutritional support to sis was also significantly lower in the PO group. The
premature infants have evolved over the past 50 years?. 4-s incidence of choiestasis in our control group is similar to
Initially, sma!l preterm infants were fasted for various that previously reported by Beale et al. 13(23% of 62 infants
periods for fear of aspiration pneumon!a, edema forma- who weighed <2000 g, and 50% of 14 infants <1000 g).
tion, and abdominal distension. 4'6 The next phase of Similar observations that enteral feeding protect against
neonatal nutritional practices was the result of investiga- hyperalimentation-induced cholestasis have been reported
tions that compared early versus late enteral or intravenous by Pallares et al. 9 In adult patients receiving parenteral
feedings.4 These studies demonstrated that infants receiv- alimentation, the addition of hyp0ca!oric oral feedings
ing fluid and calories (either enteral or parenteral) had less prevented the typically observed elevations of direct biliru-
hypoglycemia, dehydration, hyperbilirubinernia, azotemia, bin, alkaline phoSphatase, and alanine aminotransferase,
and fever than did totally fasted infants? With the advent which were noted to occur in the patients who received
of parenteral alimentation, many NICUs began to provide parenteral alimentation alone. The mechanisms responsi-
all fluid, mineral, caloric, and vitamin needs by the ble for the reduced incidence of cholestatic jaundice are
intravenous route. 7'8 unknown. O n e proposed mechanism relates to nutrient-
Parenteral atimentation has many potential complica- induced local intestinal hormone secretion, with concomi-
tions that are related to catheter placement, the nutrients tant stimulation of hepatic bile flow. Another possible
provided, and other undetermined variables. 7'9A2-15 Rager mechanism relates to the reduction of endotoxin produc-
and Finegold 19have hypothesized that fasting, rather than tion by the intestinal flora.9 Nonetheless, the present
the solutions given, contributes to the cholestatic jaundice investigation among newborn infants supports Rager and
associated with parenteral alimentation. Finegold's original hypothesis a9 that the cholestasis associ-
Fasting in adult mammals has also been associated with ated with parenteral alimentati0n may be due to fasting
intestinal flattening of villi and mucosal atrophy. 17-~s-:~ rather than to the toxic effects of intravenous nutrients.
Animals can achieve positive nitrogen balance and grow We obtained GGT levels because of evidence25 that this
while receiving parenteral alimentation; however, intesti- enzyme is a very sensitive indicator of liver dysfunction
nal mucosal cell proliferation is reduced in animals receiv- during parenteral alimentation. In our study, elevations of
ing only parenteral nutrition. TM Enteral infusion of small GGT were not predictably related to direct hyperbilirubi-
quantities of nutrients can reverse the mucosal atrophy nemia but had a more sporadic occurrence, most typically
noted in animals during total parenteral alimentation. ~s2~ long after parenteral nutrition had ceased. Black et al. 26
lntraluminal nutrition stimulates the release of local intes- suggested that canalicular damage, as evidenced by an
tinal hormones, which may enhance enterocyte growth and elevated GGT level, occurred early in the course of
stimulate bile flow.2~ parenteral alimentation-induced cholestasis. Such a pat-
Experience among adult patients with sepsis or chronic tern was not seen in this study. GGT levels were neither
medical conditions has demonstrated a beneficial effect of sensitive nor specific for cholestasis in our population.
enteral alimentation. 22'23This method is not suitable for all In the majority of infants with a marked elevation of
patients. Nonetheless, enteral alimentation for sick adult serum alkaline phosphatase, results of liver function tests
patients has been found to be safe, efficacious, and were normal, suggesting a nonhepatic source of increased
economical compared with parenteral nutrition. 22'23 There alkaline phosphatase activity among those infants. In the
is little information about early hypocaloric enteral ali- patients in whom serum alkaline phosphatase activity was
mentation in very low birth weight infants. fractionated, it did prove to be of bone origin. In many
The present investigation of sick premature infants has patients, alkaline phosphatase activity did not revert to
also demonstrated specific beneficial effects of hypocaloric normal until vitamin D, with or without calcium or
628 Dunn et al. The Journal of Pediatrics
April 1988
after massive bowel resection. J PEDIATRGastroenterol Nutr 26. Black DD, Suttle EA. Whitington PF, Whitington GL,
1985;4:245-52. Korones SD. The effect of short-term total parenteral nutri-
21. Aynsley-Green A. Hormones and postnatal adaptation to tion on hepatic function in the human neonate: a prospective
enteral nutrition. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 1983;2:418- randomized study demonstrating alteration of hepatic cana-
27. licular function. J PEDIATR 1981;99:445-9.
22. McArdle AH, Palmason C, Moreney I, Brown RA. A 27. Chan GM, Mileur L, Hansen JW. Effects of increased
rationale for enteral feeding as the preferable route for calcium and phosphorus formulas and human milk on bone
hyperalimentation. Surgery 1981;90:616-23. mineralization in preterm infants. J Pediatr Gastroenterol
23. Heymsfield SB, Bethel RA, Ansley J, Nixon DW, Rudman Nutr 1986;5:444-9.
D. Enternal hyperalimentation: an alternative to central 28. Vernet O, Christin L, Schutz Y, Danforth E, Jequier E.
venous hyperalimentation. Ann Intern Med 1979;90:63-71. Enteral versus parenteral nutrition: comparison of energy
24. De Carvalho M, Robertson S, Klaus M. Fecal bilirubin metabolism in healthy subjects. Am J Physiol 1986;250:E47-
excretion and serum bilirubin concentrations in breast-fed 54.
and bottle-fed infants. J PEDIATR 1985;107:786-90. 29. Slagle T, Gross S. Feeding tolerance and necrotizing entero-
25. Steichen J J, Gratton TL, Tsang RC. Osteopenia of prema- colitis (NEC): effect of early feeding to stimulate gastrointes-
turity: the cause and possible treatment. J PEDIATR 1980; tinal (GI) function [abstract]. Pediatr Res 1987;21:438a.
96:528-34.
FELLOWSHIPS
Available fellowships in pediatric subspecialties and those for general academic pediatric training
are listed once a year, in May, in The Journal of Pediatrics. Each October, forms for listing such
fellowships are sent to the Chairman of the Department of Pediatrics at most major hospitals in
the United States and Canada. Should you desire to list fellowships, a separate application must
be made each year for each position. All applications must be returned to The C. V. Mosby
Company by February 15 of the listing year to ensure publication. Additional forms will be
supplied on request from the Journal Editing Department, The C. V. Mosby Company, 11830
Westline Industrial Drive, St. Louis, M O 63146/314-872-8370.