2D Beam Structure Analysis
2D Beam Structure Analysis
MANUFACTURING Engineering
MAICHEW, Ethiopia
G.TAMRAT
Introduction
Beam is a machine element that can support transverse load on its axis.
When load is applied on it, its molecules may give translation and
rotary displacement .
The usual assumptions of elementary beam theory are:
The beam is loaded only transverse load (forces perpendicular to its
longitudinal axis)
Deflections of the beam are small in comparison to the characteristic
dimensions of the beam
The material of the beam is linearly elastic, isotropic, and homogeneous
The beam is prismatic and the cross section has an axis of symmetry in
the plane of bending
cont.
Considering a differential length dx of a beam after bending as in
shown in the figure below (with the curvature greatly exaggerated), it
is intuitive that the top surface has decreased in length while the
bottom surface has increased in length.
Hence, there is a “layer” that must be undeformed during bending.
Assuming that this layer is located distance from the center of
curvature O and choosing this layer (which, recall, is known as the
neutral surface) to correspond to y=0, the length after bending at
any position y is expressed as
ds ( y)d
The bending strain can be determined as
dx dx dx ' d ( y )d y
x
dx dx d
If v(x) represents the deflection curve of the neutral surface of the
beam. Then the radius of curvature of the planar curve of the beam
can be expressed using the small slop of the beam as
3
dv 2 2
1
dx 1
d 2v d 2v
dx 2 dx 2
Then the normal strain of the beam in the direction
2
of the longitudinal
axis can be written as x y y2 y d v2
d v dx
dx 2
The normal stress based on Hook’s law can be related to normal strain
as follow d 2v
x E x Ey
dx 2
This shows, at a given cross section, the normal stress varies linearly
with distance from the neutral surface.
Since the beam is loaded by transverse load and as no net axial force
is acting on the beam cross section, the resultant force of the
normal stress distribution in the x-direction must be zero.
Therefore, at any axial position x along the length, we determine
2 2
the force as F dA Ey d v dA E d v ydA 0 ydA 0
x x dx 2 dx 2
A A A A
It is obvious that the first moment of area is zero about its centroid.
This shows that the neutral surface of the beam passes through
the centroid of the beam.
Similarly, the internal bending moment at a cross section must be
equivalent to the resultant moment of the normal stress
distribution, so d 2v 2 d 2v
M z Fx y E 2 y dA E dx 2 I z
A dx A
Mz d 2v Mz y d 2v M y
E 2 Ey 2 x z
Iz dx Iz dx Iz
Element stiffness matrix of beam element
In order to determine the element stiffness of the beam, the
following assumptions should be taken
The element is of length L and has two nodes, one at each end.
The element is connected to other elements only at the nodes.
Element loading occurs only at the nodes.
For the beam element, the field variable of interest is the transverse
displacement v(x) of the neutral surface away from its straight,
un-deflected position.
v( x) a0 a1x a2 x 2 a3 x3
The boundary conditions of the beam
v( x 0) v1, v( x L) v2
dv dv
( x 0) 1 and ( x L) 2
dx dx
By substituting the boundary conditions to the field variable or
displacement function, we can determine the constant values of the
equation
v( x 0) v1 a0 a1 (0) a2 (0) a3 (0) a0 v1
v( x L) v2 v1 a1L a2 L2 a3 L3 v2 v1 a1L a2 L2 a3 L
dv dv
a1 2a2 x 3a3 x 2 x 0 1 a1
dx dx
dv dv
a1 2a2 x 3a3 x 2 x L 2 1 2a2 L 3a3 L2
dx dx
Therefore, the constant values are
3 1 2 1
a0 v1 , a1 1 , a2 2 (v2 v1 ) (21 2 ) and a3 3 (v1 v2 ) 2 (1 2 )
L L L L
2 d 2 N 3 6 12 x
d N1
6 12 x
3 2
2 3
dx 2
L2
L dx L L
d 2 N2 4 6x d 2 N4 6x 2
2
2 2
dx L L dx 2
L L
Therefore, the total strain energy can be written as
2
EI 6 12 x 6x 2
L
4 6x 6 12 x
Ue
2
2 0 L
3 1
L
v
2 1 2
L L L
3 2 2
L
v 2 dx
L L
36 x 72 x 2 48 x 3 24 x 42 x 2 24 x 3 36 x 72 x 2 48 x 3 12 x 30 x 2 24 x 3
F1 EI 4 5 6 v1 3 4 5 1 4 5 6 v2 3 4 5 2
L L L L L L L L L L L L
Substituting L and 0 the integration
36 L 72 L2 48 L3 24 L 42 L2 24 L3 36 L 72 L2 48 L3 12 L 30 L2 24 L3
F1 EI 4 5 6 v1 3 4 5 1 4 5 6 v2 3 4 5 2
L L L L L L L L L L L L
12 6 12 6
F1 EI 3 v1 2 1 3 v2 2 2 F1 3 12v1 6 L1 12v2 6 L 2
EI
L L L L L
v1
F1 3 12 6 L 12 6 L 1
EI
L v2
2
U e EI d 2 N1 d 2 N4 d 2 N2
L
d 2 N2 d 2 N2
1
M1 2
2 0 dx 2
v1
dx 2
1
dx 2
v2
dx 2
2
dx 2
dx
6 12 x 6 x 2 4 6 x
L
4 6x 6 12 x
M 1 EI 2 3 v1 2 1 2 3 v2 2 2 2 dx
0
L L L L L L L L L L
L
24 84 x 72 x 2 16 48 x 36 x 2 24 84 x 72 x 2 8 36 x 36 x 2
M 1 EI 3 4 5 v1 2 3 4 1 3 4 5 v2 2 3 4 2 dx
0 L L L L L L L L L L L L
24 x 42 x 2 24 x 3 16 x 24 x 2 12 x 3 24 x 42 x 2 24 x 3 8 x 18 x 2 12 x 3
M 1 EI 3 4 5 v1 2 3 4 1 3 4 5 v2 2 3 4 2
L L L L L L L L L L L L
24 L 42 L2 24 L3 16 L 24 L2 12 L3 24 L 42 L2 24 L3 8 L 18 L2 12 L3
M 1 EI 3 4 5 v1 2 3 4 1 3 4 5 v2 2 3 4 2
L L L L L L L L L L L L
6 4 6 2 EI
M 1 EI 3 v1 1 3 v2 2 M 1 3 6 Lv1 4 L21 6 Lv2 2 L2 2
L L L L L
v1
M1
EI
L3
6 L 4 L2 2 1
6L 2L
v2
2
U e EI d 2 N1 d 2 N 4 d 2 N3
L
d 2 N2 d 2 N2
2 0 dx 2
F2 2 v1 1 v2 2 dx
v2 dx 2
dx 2
dx 2
dx
2
6 12 x 6 x 2 6 12 x
L
4 6x 6 12 x
F2 EI 2 3 v1 2 1 2 3 v2 2 2 2 3 dx
0
L L L L L L L L L L
L
36 144 x 144 x 2 24 84 x 72 x 2 36 144 x 144 x 2 12 60 x 72 x 2
F2 EI 4 5 v1 3 4 5 1 4 5
L L
v2 3 4 5 2 dx
L
0 L L L6
L L L L6
L L
36 x 72 x 2 48 x 3 24 x 42 x 2 24 x 3 36 x 72 x 2 48 x 3 12 x 30 x 2 24 x 3
F2 EI 4 5 6 v1 3 4 5 1 4 5 6 v2 3 4 5 2
L L L L L L L L L L L L
36 L 72 L2 48 L3 24 L 42 L2 24 L3 36 L 72 L2 48 L3 12 L 30 L2 24 L3
F2 EI 4 5 6 v1 3 4 5 1 4 5 6 v2 3 4 5 2
L L L L L L L L L L L L
12 6 12 6
F2 EI 3 v1 2 1 3 v2 2 2 F2 3 12v1 6 L1 12v2 6 L 2
EI
L L L L L
v1
F2 3 12 6 L 12 6 L 1
EI
L v2
2
U e EI d 2 N1 d 2 N4 d 2 N4
L
d 2 N2 d 2 N2
2
M2 2
2 0 dx 2
v1
dx 2
1
dx 2
v2
dx 2
2
dx 2
dx
6 12 x 6 x 2 6 x 2
L
4 6x 6 12 x
M 2 EI 2 3 v1 2 1 2 3 v2 2 2 2 dx
0
L L L L L L L L L L
L
12 60 x 72 x 2 8 36 x 36 x 2 12 60 x 72 x 2 4 24 x 36 x 2
M 2 EI 3 4 5 v1 2 3 4 1 3 4 5 v2 2 3 4 2 dx
0 L L L L L L L L L L L L
L
12 x 30 x 2 24 x 3 8 x 18 x 2 12 x 3 12 x 30 x 2 24 x 3 4 x 12 x 2 12 x 3
M 2 EI 3 4 5 v1 2 3 4 1 3 4 5 v2 2 3 4 2 dx
0 L L L L L L L L L L L L
L
12 L 30 L2 24 L3 8 L 18 L2 12 L3 12 L 30 L2 24 L3 4 L 12 L2 12 L3
M 2 EI 3 4 5 v1 2 3 4 1 3 4 5 v2 2 3 4 2 dx
0 L L L L L L L L L L L L
6 2 6 4 EI
M 2 EI 2 v1 1 2 v2 2 M 2 3 6 Lv1 2 L21 6 Lv2 4 L2 2
L L L L L
v1
M2
EI
3
6 L 2 L2 6L 4L
2 1
L v2
2
The systems of equations that relate the force with the
displacements are:
F1
EI
3
12v1 6 L1 12v2 6 L 2
L
EI
M 1 3 6 Lv1 4 L21 6 Lv2 2 L2 2
L
F2 3 12v1 6 L1 12v2 6 L 2
EI
L
EI
M 2 3 6 Lv1 2 L21 6 Lv2 4 L2 2
L
In matrix form it will be written as
F1 12 6 L 12 6 L v1
M
1 EI 6 L 4 L
2
6 L 2 L2
1
3
F
2 L 12 6 L 12 6 L v2
2
2
2
2
M 6 L 2 L 6 L 4 L
The complete stiffness matrix for the (beam) flexure element is then
written as
12 6 L 12 6 L
2
EI 6 L 4 L 6 L 2 L
2
ke 3
L 12 6 L 12 6 L
2
6 L 2 L2
6 L 4 L
Symmetry of the element stiffness matrix is apparent, as shown
above.
Again, the element stiffness matrix can be shown to be singular
since rigid body motion is possible unless the element is
constrained in some manner. The element stiffness matrix as
given by the above equation is valid in any consistent system of
units provided the rotational degrees of freedom (slopes) are
expressed in radians.
Example
The beam structure depicted below is statically in-derminate beam
which is subjected to a transverse load applied at the mid-span.
Using two flexure elements, obtain a solution for the mid-span
deflection.
6 L 24 6 L v1 f1 6 L 24 6 L v1 f1
(1) (1) ( 2) ( 2)
24 24
6 L 2 L2 6 L L2 (1) m(1) 6 L 2 L2 6 L L2 ( 2) m ( 2)
4 EI
1 1
4 EI
1 1
L3 24 6 L 24 6 L v2(1) f 2(1) L3 24 6 L 24 6 L v2( 2) f 2( 2)
6L L2 6 L 2 L2 (1) m(1) 6L L2 6 L 2 L2 ( 2) m ( 2)
2 2 2 2
The relation between the elemental displacement and force is
expressed as follow
v1(1) v1,1(1) 1, v2(1) v1(2) v2 , 2(1) 1(2) 2 , v2(2) v3 and 2(2) 3
f1(1) F1,m1(1) M1, f 2(1) f1(2) F2 , m2(1) m1(2) M 2 , f 2(2) F3 and m2(2) M 3
24 6 L 24 6 L v1 F1 24 6 L 24 6 L v2 f1( 2)
2 2
4 EI 6 L 2 L 6 L L 1 M 1 4 EI 6 L 2 L 6 L L 2 m1( 2)
2 2
3 (1)
L 24 6 L 24 6 L v2 f 2 L3
24 6 L 24 6 L v
3
3 F
2 (1) 2
6 L L 2
6 L 2 L 2 m2 6L L 2
6 L 2 L 3 M 3
The global stiffness matrix is obtained by adding the two elemental
stiffness matrix 24 6 L 24 6 L 0 0
0
6L 2 L2 6L L2 0
4 EI 24 6L 48 0 24 6L
K 3 6 L L2 0 4 L2 6 L 2
L L
0 0 24 6 L 24 6 L
0 0 6L L2
6 L 2 L
2
Now, relate the global nodal force with global nodal displacement
using the global stiffness matrix
24 6L 24 6L 0 0 v1 F1
0 1 M 1
6L 2 L2 6 L L2 0
4 EI 24 6L 48 0 24 6 L v2 F2
L3 6 L L2 0 4 L2 6 L L2 2 M 2
0 0 24 6 L 24 6 L v3 F3
0 L 6L 2 L 3 M 3
0 6L 2 2
0 0 24 6 L 24 6 L 0 F3
0 L 6L 2 L 3 0
0 6L 2 2
Reduce the matrix using the boundary conditions as follow
48 0 6 L v2 P
4 EI
4 EI
48v2 6 L3 P
L2 2 0
3
3
0 4 L2 L
2 L2
L 4 EI 1
6 L L2 3 0 4 L2
L 2
0 3
3 2 3 2
L 4
4 EI
L3
6 Lv
2 L2
2 2 L2
3 0 2
6
L
v2 2 3
1 6 24 24
3 v2 2 3 3 v2 8 3 3 v2
4 L L 7L
L L L L
v1 q( x) N1 ( x)dx 1 q( x) N 2 ( x)dx v2 q( x) N3 ( x)dx 2 q( x) N 4 ( x)dx F1v1 M11 F2v2 M 2 2
0 0 0 0
Therefore, now it is easy to equate the distributed load terms to the
nodal loads with each nodal displacements
L L
L L
F1 q( x) N1 ( x)dx M 1 q( x) N 2 ( x)dx F2 q( x) N 3 ( x)dx M 2 q( x) N 4 ( x)dx
0 0
0 0
2
2 2
F qL 2
F2
qL 2 6 L 2 L 6 L 4 L
2 M 2 2 2
2 qL
M2
qL2 qL 12
12
12
Example
The simply supported beam shown in figure below is subjected to a
uniform transverse load, as shown. Using two equal-length elements
and work-equivalent nodal loads, obtain a finite element solution for
the deflection at mid-span and compare it to the solution given by
elementary beam theory.
The global nodal displacement is shown in the figure
0
M 2q q( x) N 4 ( x)dx q 2 dx
6L 2 L2 6 L L2 0 0 0 L L
4 EI 24 6L 48 0 24 6L
K 3 6 L L2 4 L2 6 L
x 4 2 x3 L4
L
L3 qL2
L 0 L2 q 2
0
M 2q q
24 6 L 24 6 L
2
0
L 3 L 0 16 L 12 L 48
0 0 6L L2
6 L 2 L
2
4 x 2 4 x3
L/2 L/2 L/2
x 2 4 x3 x 4 L2 L3 L4 qL2
M 1q q( x) N 2 ( x)dx q x
L
2 dx
L
M 1q q 2 q 2
0 0 2 3 L L 0 8 6 L 16 L 48
The relationship between the elemental nodal displacement and
elemental nodal forces and moments
6 L 24 6 L v1 f1 6 L 24 6 L v1 f1
(1) (1) ( 2) ( 2)
24 24
6 L 2 L2 6 L L2 (1) m(1) 6 L 2 L2 6 L L2 ( 2) m ( 2)
4 EI
1 1
(1)
4 EI
1 1
( 2)
3 3
L 24 6 L 24 6 L (1)
v2 f 2 L 24 6 L 24 6 L ( 2 )
v2 f 2
2 2
6L L 2
6 L 2 L (1) m(1) 6L L 2
6 L 2 L ( 2) m ( 2)
2 2 2 2
The relation between the elemental displacement and force is
expressed as follow
v1(1) v1,1(1) 1, v2(1) v1(2) v2 , 2(1) 1(2) 2 , v2(2) v3 and 2(2) 3
f1(1) F1q F1,m1(1) M1q , f 2(q1) f1(q2) F2q , m2(1q) m1(q2) M 2q , f 2( 2) F2q F3 and m2( 2) M 2q
qL
4 F1
24 24 6 L 0 0 v1 F F qL 2
6L
1q 1
2 L2 6 L L2 0 1 M 1q 48
6L 0
qL
4 EI 24 6L 48 0 24 6 L v2 F2 q
2
L3 6 L L2 0 4 L2 6 L L2 2 M 2 q
0
0 0 24 6 L 24 6 L v3 F F
2q 3
qL
0 0 6L L2 6 L 2 L2 3 M 2 q 4 F3
2
qL
48
Substitute the appropriate boundary conditions such as v1 =v3 =0
qL
4 F1
2
24 6L 24 6 L 0 0
0
qL
48
6L 2 L2 6 L L2 0 0 1
qL
4 EI 24 6L 48 0 24 6 L
v2
2
L2 L 2
2
L3 6 L 0 4L 6L 2
0
0 0 24 6 L 24 6 L 0
qL
0 0 6L L2 6 L 2 L2 3 4 F3
2
qL
48
Reduce the system of equations to determine the unknown nodal
displacements. The displacements can be determined for the system of
equations below
qL
2L 6 Lv L qL ..........(i)
2 2
4 EI
2 2
L3
1 2 2
48
2 L2 6 L L2 0 1 48
qL 4 EI
qL
4 EI 6 L 48 0 6 L v2 6 L 48 v 6 L ........(ii )
1 2 3
2 L3 2
L3 L2 4 L2 L2 2
0
0
0 6L L2 2
2 L 3
L3
4 EI 2
L 1 4 L2 2 L2 3 0..................(iii )
qL
2
48 4 EI
L3
6 Lv2 L 2 2 L 3
2 2
qL2
48
............(iv)
From system of equation (iii) we will get the relation as follow and
substitute to equation (i) and (ii) 1 4 2 3
4 EI
L3
2 2
7 L 2 6 Lv2 2 L 3
qL2
48
..........(v)
4 EI
24 L 2 48 v 2 12 L 3
qL
........(vi)
L3 2
From system of equation (vi) we will get the relation as follow and
substitute to equation (iv) and (v) 2 qL 2v2 3
3
qL4 192 EI L 2
8v2 3L 3 .............(vii)
48 EI
qL4
16v2 3L 3 ..........(viii)
12 EI
5qL4
By subtracting equation (viii) from equation (vii) we will get v2
384 EI
By substituting v2 in equation (viii) and Ɵ3 into Ɵ2 and Ɵ1 we will get
3 3
all the displacements as 3 qL , 2 0 and 1 qL
24 EI 24 EI
The reaction forces can be obtained by substituting the nodal
displacements
4 EI
6 L 1 24 v 2 6 L 2
qL
F1
4 EI
24 v 6 L 6 L
qL
F3
L3 4 L3 2 2 3
4
4 EI 6qL4 24 * 5qL4 qL 4 EI 24 * 5qL4 6qL4 qL
3
F1 F3
L 24 EI 384 EI 4 L3 384 EI 24 EI 4
qL 5qL qL
5qL qL
4 F1
qL
4 16 4 4 F3
16 4 4
qL 5qL qL
F1 qL qL 5qL qL
4 4 2 F3 qL
4 4 2
qL
F1 qL
2 F3
2