Chapter 2 Era of One Party Dominance
Chapter 2 Era of One Party Dominance
Chapter 2 Era of One Party Dominance
3. Four statements regarding one-party dominance are given below. Mark each of
them as true or false:
(a) One-party dominance is rooted in the absence of strong alternative political
parties
(b) One-party dominance occurs because of weak public opinion.
(c) One-party dominance is linked to the nation’s colonial past.
(d) One-party dominance reflects the absence of democratic ideals in a country.
Answer: (a) True, (b) False, (c) True, (d) False
4. If Bharatiya Jana Sangh of the Communist Party of India had formed the
government after the first election, in which respects would the policies of the
government have been different? Specify three differences each for both the
parties.
Answer: 1. Bharatiya Jana Sangh:
The policies of Bharatiya Jana Sangh were based on the principles as follows:
(a) It replaced secular concept by the ideology of one country, one culture and one nation.
(b) No cultural and educational rights as this party opposed the granting of concessions to
religious and cultural minorities.
(c) It focused on the reunity of India and Pakistan under the concept of Akhand Bharat.
2. Communist Party of India:
Communist Party of India would have been different on the principles as follows:
(а) It worked for proportional representation in the govern-ment.
(б) This party followed communist ideology in various policies.
(c) It emphasised on a control over electronic mass media by an autonomous body or
corporation.
5. In what sense was the Congress an ideological coalition? Mention the various
ideological currents present within the Congress.
Answer: The Congress Party became a social and ideological coalition for it merged
different social groups alongwith their identity holding different beliefs:
1. It accommodated the revolutionary, conservative, pacifist, radical, extremist and
moderates and the rights and the left with all other shades of the centre.
2. Congress became a platform for numerous groups, interests and even political parties
to take part in the national movement.
Ideological currents present within the Congress:
(a) In pre-independence days, many organisations and parties with their own constitutions
and organisational structures were allowed to exist within the Congress.
(b) Some of these like “Congress Socialist Party” later seperated from the Congress and
became on opposition party.
8. What would you consider as the main differences between Mexico and India
under one party domination?
Answer: There was a difference between one party domination in India and Mexico. In
Mexico, this was a one party system only not dominance because:
1. In India, the Congress party dominated on behalf of popular consensus but Institutional
Revolutionary Party (PRI) (in Spanish) ruled on behalf of perfect dictatorship.
2. In India, free and fair elections took place, where the losing of election was also fair but
it Mexico, elections were based on malpractices, dominated by PRI.
2. Which political party of India had leaders like A.K. Gopalan, E.M.S.
Namboodiripad, and S.A. Dange?
Answer: Communist Party of India.
4. In which year was the Election Commission of India set up and who was the first
chief Election Commissioner of India?
Answer: 25 January 1950, Sukumar Sen.
5. Name the founder president of the Congress Socialist Party. What name was
given to this party after 1948?
Answer: The founder president of the Congress Socialist Party was Acharya Narendra
Dev and after 1955 it came to be known as Socialist Party.
7. When and why was the electronic voting machine used in India for the first time?
Answer: The electronic voting machine was used in India in 1990 for first time for more
accuracy and fair dealing while counting as well as it helps to check Booth capturing and
other malpractices.
9. Define faction.
Answer: Faction are the groups formed inside the party i.e. coalitions made in Congress
created various factions which were based on either ideological considerations or personal
ambitions.
3. Explain the major difference of ideology between that of Congress and the
Bharatiya Jana Sangh.
Answer: The major difference of ideology between Congress and the Bharatiya Jana
Sangh was that Bharatiya Jana Sangh emphasised on one party country. One culture, one
nation i.e. a Hindu nation or Hindutva whereas Congress formed ideological and social
coalitions accommodating social diversities.
5. How has the method of voting changed from the first General Election of 1952 to
the General Election of 2004?
Answer: 1. In the first General Election a box was placed inside each polling booth for
each candidate with the election symbol of the candidate. Each voter was given a blank
ballot paper to drop into the box, they wanted to vote for.
2. After first two elections, this method was changed. Now ballot paper carried the names
and symbols of candidates and the voter stamped against the name of candidate to vote
for.
3. In 2004, Electronic Voting Machine were introduced to press the button according to
choice of the voter containing the name of candidate and symbol of political party.
7. “India’s experiment with universal adult franchise appeared very bold and risky”.
Justify the statement.
Answer: Because:
1. Country’s vast size and electorates made these elections unusual.
2. The year 1952, it was a big test for poor and illiterate country.
3. Till then, democracy had been existed only in the prosperous countries mainly in Europe
and North America where everyone was almost literate.
8. Mention the aims and goals of Socialist Party of India. Why the party could not
prove itself as an effective alternative to the Congress?
Answer: Aims and goals of socialist party of India:
1. The Socialist Party believed in the ideology of democratic socialism to be distinguished
from Congress and Communists both.
2. It criticised Congress for ignoring the workers and peasants.
It became difficult for socialist party to prove itself as an effective alternative to Congress
because Congress Party declared its goal to be the socialist pattern of society in 1955.
9. What were the reasons for dominance of one party system in India?
Answer: The dominance of Congress in India was due to following reasons:
1. Congress was identified with the freedom struggle for building national unity and
solidarity.
2. Congress was associated with Mahatma Gandhi’s name.
3. It had a broad based manifesto to include the various section of society.
4. Congress bore a popular appeal of charismatic leader like Mahatma Gandhi, J.L. Nehru,
Sardar Patel, Indira Gandhi etc.
5. Congress focused on building role of the party.
10. How did India’s first general elections of 1952 become a landmark in the history
of democracy all over the world?
Answer: Because:
1. These elections were competitive among various parties.
2. The participation of people was encouraging also.
3. The results were declared in a very fair manner, even to be accepted by the losers in a
fair manner.
4. This experiment of India, proved the critics wrong also.
2. How was one party dominance of India different from the other examples of one
party dominance in the world?
Or
Examine the comparative analysis of nature of Congress dominance.
Answer: India is not the only country to have dominance of one party but we have some
other examples also for the same. But the dominance of one party in India does not
compromise democratic spirit of constitution whereas other nations have compromised it:
1. In countries like China, Cuba and Syria are permitted to be ruled by one party only by
the constitutional provisions.
2. Myanmar, Belarus, Egypt also experience one party system due to legal and military
measurer.
3. In India, Congress dominates on behalf of free and fair elections based on democracy
where the losing of other party is also fair.
3. “In India, hero-worship, plays a part in its politics unequalled in magnitude by the
part it plays in the politics of any other country But in politics, hero-worship is a
sure road to degradation and eventual dictatorship”.Babasaheb Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
Analyse the statement.
Ans: The above mentioned statement speaks of accommodating diversities by the leader
of India which was a challenging path to democracy. Our leaders wanted to represent
politics as a way of solution of problems in place of making politics a problem.
Questions
1. What do you mean by a faction?
2. How did coalition-like character affect the nature of Congress Party?
3. How did Congress avoided to increase number of ‘opposition’?
Answer:
1. Factions are the groups formed inside the party based on either ideological
considerations or on personal ambitions and rivalries.
2. Coalition-like character of Congress accommodated all social diversities and maintained
a balance on almost all issues. Even a proper space for the programmes and ideology of
opposite parties was also given. In such a way Congress showed greater tolerance
towards internal differences.
3. Alongwith its coalition-like character, Congress did not let the groups to leave the party
to become an opposition.
2. Read the passage given below carefully and answer the questions:
The socialists believed in the ideology of democratic socialism which distinguished
them both from the Congress as well as from the Communists. They criticised the
Congress for favouring capitalists and landlords and for ignoring the workers and
the peasants. But the socialists faced a dilemma when in 1955 the Congress
declared its goal to be the socialist pattern of society. Thus it became difficult for
the socialists to present themselves as an effective alternative to the Congress.
Some of them, led by Rammanohar Lohia, increased their distance from and
criticism of the Congress party. Some others like Asoka Mehta advocated a limited
cooperation with the Congress.
Questions
1. Mention the ideology of Socialists.
2. Name some leaders of the Socialist Party.
3. Why did it become difficult for socialists to present themselves as an effective
alternative to the Congress?
Answer:
1. Socialists believed in the ideology of democratic socialism to be distinguished from
Congress as well as from Communists.
2. Ram Manohar Lohia, Ashok Mehta and Acharya Narendra Dev, Jayaprakash Narayan
etc.
3. Because in 1955, Congress declared its goal to be the socialist pattern of society.
3. How was the one party dominance in India different from the one party system in
Mexico? In your opinion which of the two political systems is better and why?
Answer: There was a difference between one party domination in India and Mexico. In
Mexico, this was a one party system only not dominance because:
1. In India, the Congress Party dominated on behalf of popular consensus but Institutional
Revolu-tionary Party (PRI) (in Spanish) ruled on behalf of perfect dictatorship.
2. In India, free and fair elections took place, where the losing of election was also fair but
in Mexico, elections were based on malpractices, dominated by PRI.
In our opinion one party dominance¬like India is better because this sort of dominance:
1. Accommodates social diversities.
2. Encourage large number of parti-cipation.
3. Ensures democratic spirit as well as maintains the same.
4. Bear respect even for opposition.
4. How did opposition parties emerge in India? What was their importance?
Answer: Some of the diverse opposition parties had come into existence before the
first general elections in 1952 as non-Congress parties which succeeded to gain only a
taken of representation in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies. These parties maintained a
democratic character of the system:
1. These offered a criticism based on principles to keep ruling party under check.
2. These parties groomed the leaders also to play a crucial role in shaping the country.
3. In the early years, these was a lot of respect between leaders of Congress and
opposition parties i.e. interim government included even opposition leaders like Dr.
Ambedkar, Jayaprakash Narayan, Shyama Prasad Mukherjee into the cabinet.
Questions
1. What does the cartoon represent?
2. What does the term ‘Tug of war’ refer to?
3. Who has been shown on the branches of tree?
Answer:
1. Cartoon represents dominance of Congress which is being tug by opposition parties to
throw Congress out of power.
2. ‘Tug of war’ refer to pulling out the Congress by criticism and mentioning its weaknesses
in an honest and justified manner.
3. Pt. Jawahar Lai Nehru alongwith his colleagues in the cabinet.
Bl. In the outline political map of India given below, five States have been marked as
A, B, C, D and E. With the help of the information given below, identify them and
write their correct names in your answer book along with the serial number of the
information used and the related alphabet in the map.
Questions
(i) The State to which C. Rajagopalachari, the first Indian Governor-General of India,
belonged.
(ii) The State where the first non-Congress Government was formed by E.M.S.
Namboodiripad.
(iii) The State to which Rafi Ahmed Kidwai, the Union Minister for Food and
Agriculture (1952-54) belonged.
(iv) The State which faced the most acute food crisis in 1965-1967.
(v) The State which led the country to White Revolution through Dairy Cooperative
Movement.
Answer:
A — (iv) Bihar B — (iii) Uttar Pradesh C — (v) Gujarat D — (i) Tamil Nadu C — (a) Kerala
2. On a political outline map of India locate and label the following and symbolise
them as indicated:
Questions
1. Two states where Congress was not in power at some point during 1952-67.
2. Two states where the Congress remained in power through this period.
Answer:
1. (i) Jammu & Kashmir (ii) Kerala
2. (i) Uttar Pradesh (ii) Maharashtra