Sluaa 60
Sluaa 60
Application Report
Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780
Controller and UCC5304 Isolated Synchronous-
Rectifier Driver
ABSTRACT
This application report describes how the UCC28780 Active-Clamp Flyback controller can be paired with the
isolated driver UCC5304 to implement a Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback (ZVSF) power supply, delivering high
efficiency and high power-density at a competitive cost compared to the conventional Quasi-Resonant (QR)
flyback topology.
Table of Contents
1 Introduction.............................................................................................................................................................................2
2 Topology Overview................................................................................................................................................................. 3
3 Topology Differences vs. ACF and QR................................................................................................................................. 4
4 Simplified Application Diagram.............................................................................................................................................5
5 ZVSF Advantages and Benefits.............................................................................................................................................6
6 Use of UCC28780 + UCC5304 to Implement ZVSF...............................................................................................................7
6.1 UCC28780 Key Features .................................................................................................................................................7
6.2 UCC5304 Key Features ...................................................................................................................................................7
6.3 Key Specifications .......................................................................................................................................................... 8
6.4 Power Stage Parameters ................................................................................................................................................ 8
6.5 Schematic Detailed Description .................................................................................................................................... 8
7 PMP21552 EVM......................................................................................................................................................................11
8 PMP21552 Performance Results......................................................................................................................................... 12
8.1 Efficiency ....................................................................................................................................................................... 12
8.2 Stand-by Power ............................................................................................................................................................. 13
8.3 “Tiny-Load” (0.25 W) Efficiency ...................................................................................................................................13
8.4 Conducted EMI .............................................................................................................................................................. 14
8.5 Radiated EMI ..................................................................................................................................................................15
8.6 Switching Waveforms ................................................................................................................................................... 17
9 Summary............................................................................................................................................................................... 18
10 References.......................................................................................................................................................................... 18
Trademarks
USB Type-C™ are trademarks of USB Implementers Forum.
All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 1
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
Introduction www.ti.com
1 Introduction
Conventional fixed-frequency and quasi-resonant (QR) flybacks are limited in their power density and upper
switching frequency capability due to the switching loss and the dissipation of the transformer leakage
inductance energy. The active-clamp-flyback (ACF) overcomes these limitations by achieving zero-voltage-
switching (ZVS) and recycling of the leakage energy to the output. However, these benefits do not come for free,
the ACF requires some extra components to achieve the benefits – a second primary high-side switch, high-side
driver/level-shifter, bigger clamp capacitors, and so forth.
An alternative ZVS flyback (ZVSF) topology is introduced in this application note. This ZVSF topology achieves
ZVS only – that is, the leakage energy is not recovered. The power-loss saving realized by ZVS allows for
increased switching frequency and therefore smaller transformer size and higher power-density compared to QR
and fixed-frequency designs. This offers a simpler, lower component-count, moderate-performance alternative to
the ACF, that sits somewhere in between QR and ACF in terms of both performance and component-count
complexity.
The ZVSF topology is a good alternative to consider for medium-density high-volume applications, and this
application note shows how the ACF controller UCC28780 can be combined with an isolated driver UCC5304 to
implement ZVSF using secondary-side synchronous rectification (SR).
2 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com Topology Overview
2 Topology Overview
Figure 2-1 shows the overall topology architecture along with some typical waveforms.
(ZVSF) Passive-clamp + ZVS
Vbulk
Lk N:1
isec
im
SR
iclamp VSW
PWML
driver QL
driver
PWMH
Isolator
VSW
iclamp
im
isec
PWMH
In the same way as conventional QR or fixed-frequency flyback, the primary side uses a clamp snubber to limit
the Vds stress on the primary FET due to the leakage inductance, and much of the leakage inductance energy is
dissipated in the clamp. The clamp can be a TVS type, as Figure 2-1 shows, or an RCD snubber.
The ZVSF controller operates in transition-mode (TM) at heavy load, where the primary FET and secondary
synchronous rectifier (SR) are driven in complement to each other, with adaptive dead-time in between. The
primary on-time is adjusted by the control loop to adjust the peak primary magnetizing current, in order to
regulate the output voltage. The secondary SR on-time is extended beyond the normal zero-current point to
allow some negative magnetizing current to build up in the transformer. The energy associated with the negative
current discharges the total drain-node capacitance when the SR is turned off, and the next turn-on point for the
primary FET occurs when the drain voltage has dropped close to zero, for ZVS turn-on.
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 3
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
Topology Differences vs. ACF and QR www.ti.com
im im im
SR SR SR
iclamp VSW iclamp VSW
VSW
GND PWML
QR PWML
driver QL driver QL HB driver QL
Controller
controller driver controller
PWMH
PWMH PWML
Isolator
UCC28780
im im im
PWMH PWMH
Figure 3-1. ZVSF Topology Block Diagram and Waveforms vs QR and ACF
Figure 3-1 shows that the ZVSF power circuit and waveforms are more similar to QR than to ACF. For both QR
and ZVSF, the leakage inductance energy is not recycled, but is instead mostly dissipated in the primary clamp.
At minimum input voltage and maximum rated-output voltage, a QR design would usually already operate close
to ZVS due to the natural resonant ringing between the magnetizing inductance and the equivalent switch node
capacitance – assuming that the transformer turns ratio is designed for a reflected voltage approximately equal
to the minimum input voltage (typical QR design target).
However, at high-line input voltages, even when switching on the first valley of the resonant ring, the
instantaneous voltage is non-zero and actually quite significant. As a result, QR design can only achieve ZVS at
minimum input voltage (VIN). For wide output-voltage range applications, such as USB-C PD and PPS chargers,
ZVS can only be achieved at minimum VIN and maximum VOUT – at lower VOUT levels, the reflected voltage is
also lower – so valley-switching will occur at a finite non-zero voltage level, with no ZVS.
An existing QR design can be converted to ZVSF by transitioning from the QR controller to UCC28780, and by
changing the local secondary-side SR controller to the isolated SR driver UCC5304. The PWMH output of the
UCC28780 takes the place of the SR controller through the isolated driver. By building up just enough negative
current, depending on VIN and VOUT levels, the ZVSF topology can achieve ZVS across the full range of VIN and
VOUT, enhancing any QR stage into a ZVSF stage over the full operating range.
4 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com Simplified Application Diagram
DBD NP NS
VAC ~
VO
± +
Gate
Driver RUN
UCC27517
PWMH
NA Iso Driver
UCC5304
VDD PWML RUN CS PWMH
VS
HV startup &
NTC SWS ZVS Sense
GND UCC28780
HVG
RDM FB
The UCC28780 SWS pin indirectly senses the primary FET drain voltage, and the SR on-time extension is auto-
adjusted with changes in load current and bulk-capacitor voltage to achieve ZVS with minimal excess negative
magnetizing current, to maximize efficiency. A primary-side RCD snubber is used to clamp the primary FET VDS.
An external low-side driver is used to interface the logic-level PWML drive signal to the primary FET gate.
The UCC5304 isolated driver is used to drive the SR across the reinforced isolation barrier between primary and
secondary. The short propagation delay (28 ns typical) ensures short SR FET body-diode conduction time, to
help improve efficiency.
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 5
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
ZVSF Advantages and Benefits www.ti.com
Wide-input-range adaptor Better high-line efficiency with high- QR @ 230 Vac 91.5~92%
frequency, small-size transformer due to ZVS
ZVSF @ 230 Vac ~93%
benefit
High-line-only or PFC front-end Better efficiency from ZVS vs. QR 1st-valley QR @ 230 Vac ~93%
switching
ZVSF @ 230 Vac ~94%
ACF-GaN @ 230 Vac ~95%+
Wide-VOUT PD or PPS Achieve ZVS across full VOUT range Commercial QR @ 230 Vac, 5 Vdc@15 W
~88%
Commercial ZVS-Aux IPD2105 @ 230 Vac, 5
Vdc@10W ~82%
ZVSF @ 230 Vac, 5 Vdc@15 W ~90%
Moderate-to-high-frequency designs for High-frequency QR designs → efficiency/ Low-frequency 65-W QR ~60 kHz needs
moderate density thermal limit at high-line RM10-size (or similar) transformer
ZVSF higher frequency and smaller ZVSF 65 W @ 180–200 kHz can use RM8-
transformer → same 90-V efficiency as QR, size transformer
but better high-line efficiency
Enables high frequency and medium power
density WITHOUT need for GaN
6 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com Use of UCC28780 + UCC5304 to Implement ZVSF
Figure 6-1. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Schematic (Partial) Using UCC28780 + UCC5304
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 7
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
Use of UCC28780 + UCC5304 to Implement ZVSF www.ti.com
Efficiency (target) η 93 %
N ps : 5
N ps u V OUT Vd
DMAX : 0.573
VDCin min N ps u V OUT Vd
DMAX 2 u VDCin min2 u 1
LM : u u 1 K RES 110.366 +
2 u VOUT u I OUT f sw _ min (1)
8 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com Use of UCC28780 + UCC5304 to Implement ZVSF
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 9
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
Use of UCC28780 + UCC5304 to Implement ZVSF www.ti.com
ratio to main secondary) provides power to Vdd_pri when VOUT is < 12 V, with the higher ratio chosen to boost
the auxiliary rail to ~12 V when VOUT is as low as 4 V.
The LDO Q3, R17, D5, C44, C16, and C22 is needed to limit the aux rail generated by the upper rail when VOUT
is > 12 V. D5 is chosen to set the LDO regulated voltage low enough to be back-biased by the direct feed from
the lower aux when VOUT is high enough, to increase overall efficiency.
6.5.10 Active-Ripple-Cancellation Circuit
Q9, R37, and R39 are used to add hysteresis to the FB pin in burst-mode, to help stabilize the burst-mode
operation and deliver consistent burst lengths.
10 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com PMP21552 EVM
7 PMP21552 EVM
Figure 7-1. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Reference Design PCB Assembly Using UCC28780 + UCC5304
PMP21552 is a released reference design for a 65-W USB-C PD adapter, using the UCC28780 and UCC5304
chipset in a ZVSF topology. The design supports 5 V/3 A, 9 V/3 A, 15 V/ 3A and 20 V/3.25 A in a compact 62-cc
size (open-frame dimensions 45 × 55 × 25 mm). Full-load efficiency is over 92.5% across the full universal
90-265 V AC range. The primary-side switch uses a Si super-junction FET, the transformer size is RM8, and the
design passes EN55022 level-B conducted and radiated emissions with margin.
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 11
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
PMP21552 Performance Results www.ti.com
92%
90%
Efficiency (%)
88%
86%
84%
90 V
115 V
82% 230 V
264 V
80%
5 15 25 35 45 55 65
20-V Output Power (W) D001
94%
92%
90%
Efficiency (%)
88%
86%
84%
115 V Avg Eff
230 V Avg Eff
82% DoE Level VI
CoC Tier 2
80%
5 10 15 20
Output Voltage (V) D002
Figure 8-2. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Average Efficiency vs VOUT and Line
12 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com PMP21552 Performance Results
26 mW 30 mW
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 13
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
PMP21552 Performance Results www.ti.com
Figure 8-3. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF QP and AVG Conducted Emissions at 115 V, 20-V, 65-W, Earthed Load;
L1 (L) and L2 (N)
Figure 8-4. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF QP and AVG Conducted Emissions at 230 V, 20-V, 65-W, Earthed Load;
L1 (L) and L2 (N)
14 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com PMP21552 Performance Results
8.5.1 Passes EN55032 Level-B Vertical and Horizontal Polarization With Margin
Figure 8-5. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Radiated Emissions at 115 V, 20-V, 65-W, Earthed Load, Horizontal
Polarization
Figure 8-6. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Radiated Emissions at 115 V, 20-V, 65-W, Earthed Load, Vertical
Polarization
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 15
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
PMP21552 Performance Results www.ti.com
Figure 8-7. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Radiated Emissions at 230 V, 20-V, 65-W, Earthed Load, Horizontal
Polarization
Figure 8-8. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Radiated Emissions at 230 V, 20-V, 65-W, Earthed Load, Vertical
Polarization
16 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
www.ti.com PMP21552 Performance Results
Figure 8-9. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Waveforms at 264-V Input, 20-V, 65-W Output; Ch1: Pri Vgs; Ch2: Pri
Vrcs; Ch3: Pri Vds; Ch4: sec SR Vds
Figure 8-10. PMP21552 65-W ZVSF Waveforms at 264-V Input, 5-V, 15-W Output; Ch Pri Vgs; Ch2: Pri
Vrcs; Ch3: Pri Vds; Ch4: sec SR Vds
SLUAA60 – JULY 2020 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 17
Submit Document Feedback Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
Summary www.ti.com
9 Summary
For high-volume applications where higher efficiency and power-density are required, or higher switching
frequency and smaller size are required, the ZVSF topology is worth considering. It offers performance
advantages over QR and fixed-frequency single-switch flyback topologies. While it cannot deliver the same
efficiency and power-density performance as ACF, it does offer a simpler, lower component-count alternative.
The chipset of UCC28780 and UCC5304 are available from TI to implement the topology, along with a reference
design PMP21552 to help users get started.
10 References
• UCC28780 product folder: http://www.ti.com/product/UCC28780
• UCC5304 product folder: http://www.ti.com/product/UCC5304
• ZVSF reference design PMP21552 folder: http://www.ti.com/tool/PMP21552
• ACF-Si reference design PMP21479 folder: http://www.ti.com/tool/PMP21479
18 Zero-Voltage-Switching Flyback Using UCC28780 Controller and UCC5304 SLUAA60 – JULY 2020
Isolated Synchronous-Rectifier Driver Submit Document Feedback
Copyright © 2020 Texas Instruments Incorporated
IMPORTANT NOTICE AND DISCLAIMER
TI PROVIDES TECHNICAL AND RELIABILITY DATA (INCLUDING DATASHEETS), DESIGN RESOURCES (INCLUDING REFERENCE
DESIGNS), APPLICATION OR OTHER DESIGN ADVICE, WEB TOOLS, SAFETY INFORMATION, AND OTHER RESOURCES “AS IS”
AND WITH ALL FAULTS, AND DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS AND IMPLIED, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION ANY
IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR NON-INFRINGEMENT OF THIRD
PARTY INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS.
These resources are intended for skilled developers designing with TI products. You are solely responsible for (1) selecting the appropriate
TI products for your application, (2) designing, validating and testing your application, and (3) ensuring your application meets applicable
standards, and any other safety, security, or other requirements. These resources are subject to change without notice. TI grants you
permission to use these resources only for development of an application that uses the TI products described in the resource. Other
reproduction and display of these resources is prohibited. No license is granted to any other TI intellectual property right or to any third
party intellectual property right. TI disclaims responsibility for, and you will fully indemnify TI and its representatives against, any claims,
damages, costs, losses, and liabilities arising out of your use of these resources.
TI’s products are provided subject to TI’s Terms of Sale (www.ti.com/legal/termsofsale.html) or other applicable terms available either on
ti.com or provided in conjunction with such TI products. TI’s provision of these resources does not expand or otherwise alter TI’s applicable
warranties or warranty disclaimers for TI products.
Mailing Address: Texas Instruments, Post Office Box 655303, Dallas, Texas 75265
Copyright © 2020, Texas Instruments Incorporated