GP 06-20 Materials
GP 06-20 Materials
GP 06-20 Materials
GP 06-20
Applicability IMSL
Date 12 November 2007
GP 06-20
Foreword
This is the first issue of Engineering Technical Practice (ETP) GP 06-20. This Guidance on Practice
(GP) is based on parts of heritage documents as follows:
IMSL
GS 136-1 Materials for Sour Service March 1997 (Amendment 1 – October 2001).
Page 2 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Table of Contents
Page
Foreword............................................................................................................................................2
Introduction.........................................................................................................................................6
Material types.....................................................................................................................................6
Cracking susceptibility and avoidance...............................................................................................6
Service failures...................................................................................................................................6
Oil flow line HIC failure of carbon steel pipe - 1972..................................................................6
Downhole tubular string SSC failure of Alloyed 13% Cr steel - 2001......................................6
Failure by SOHIC of carbon steel spiral welded pipe (Saudi Aramco) - 1998..........................7
Failure by SSC/SOHIC of carbon steel pressure vessel (Unocal) - 1984.................................7
Responsibility.....................................................................................................................................7
General outline of a sour service plan................................................................................................7
1. Scope........................................................................................................................................9
2. Normative references................................................................................................................9
3. Terms and definitions..............................................................................................................11
4. Symbols and abbreviations.....................................................................................................12
5. Factors affecting cracking.......................................................................................................13
5.1. General materials factors.............................................................................................13
5.2. General environmental factors.....................................................................................13
5.3. Factors affecting SSC..................................................................................................14
5.4. Factors affecting SZC..................................................................................................14
5.5. Factors affecting GHSC...............................................................................................14
5.6. Factors affecting HIC/SWC and blistering...................................................................15
5.7. Factors affecting SOHIC..............................................................................................15
5.8. Factors affecting SCC..................................................................................................16
6. Distinction between Upstream (oil and gas) and Downstream (refining)................................16
6.1. Different environments for Upstream and Downstream...............................................16
6.2. Upstream (oil and gas) NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156....................................................17
6.3. Downstream (refining) NACE MR0103........................................................................17
7. Upstream requirements (oil and gas)......................................................................................18
7.1. Upstream (oil and gas) - Qualification of cracking-resistant carbon and low alloy steels
and cast irons (for SSC, SZC, HIC and SOHIC resistance) (NACE MR0175/
ISO 15156 – Part 2 and Part 1)...................................................................................18
7.2. Upstream (oil and gas) – Qualification of cracking-resistant CRAs and other alloys for
SSC, SCC, and GHSC (NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 – Part 3 & Part 1)......................21
8. Downstream (refining) – Materials resistant to Sulfide Stress Cracking in corrosive petroleum
refinery environments (NACE MR0103).................................................................................24
8.1. Overview......................................................................................................................24
Page 3 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Page 4 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
List of Figures
Page 5 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Introduction
Material types
Numerous types of material are used in sour service including carbon steel, low alloy steels, corrosion
resistant alloys and other alloys. This has resulted in an extensive amount of satisfactory service
experience.
Materials need to be chosen with care however, since they are potentially susceptible to various
cracking mechanisms, the particular type depending upon the specific material. For satisfactory
service therefore, it is necessary to understand both the environmental conditions and also the
metallurgical condition of the material that gives rise to the maximum resistance to cracking.
Service failures
Despite much satisfactory service experience, the oil industry, including IMSL has seen a number of
failures caused by exposure to wet H2S environments, affecting different equipment and spanning
many years. Such failures can potentially be very costly and have severe health, safety, and
environmental consequences. The following are some examples of failures:
Page 6 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Failure by SOHIC of carbon steel spiral welded pipe (Saudi Aramco) - 1998
a. Spiral welded pipe can be particularly susceptible to SOHIC.
b. SOHIC failures on spiral-welded pipe occurred in the Middle East, and SOHIC cracking
was found on three out of 39 joints.
c. Residual stresses are very high in spiral-welded pipe and the pipe was subject to a high
hydrogen charging rate.
d. The material that had suffered SOHIC had a threshold stress of 17 ksi, whilst non-failed
material had a higher threshold stress of 30-35 ksi.
e. Conventional longitudinally welded pipes were also present in the line and exhibited HIC
but not SOHIC.
Responsibility
The responsibility is now placed on the Equipment User by both NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 (Oil and
Gas Production) and NACE MR0103 (Refining) to ensure that the materials used in sour service are fit
for purpose.
The different oil & gas production and refining standards reflect the different operating conditions,
with higher pressures and more acid conditions (lower pH) being present in oil and gas production
plant, often making the conditions more onerous.
In view of the propensity to failure of equipment in wet H2S environments, if not properly controlled,
it is imperative to have a sour service plan which covers the following:
a. Distinction between Upstream (Oil and Gas Production) and Downstream (Refining).
b. Environmental conditions.
Page 7 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Page 8 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
1. Scope
2. Normative references
The following normative documents contain requirements that, through reference in this text,
constitute requirements of this technical practice. For dated references, subsequent amendments to, or
revisions of, any of these publications do not apply. However, parties to agreements based on this
technical practice are encouraged to investigate the possibility of applying the most recent editions of
the normative documents indicated below. For undated references, the latest edition of the normative
document referred to applies.
Page 9 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
ASTM A516/A516M Standard Specification for Pressure Vessel Plates, Carbon Steel, for
Moderate- and Lower-Temperature Service.
ASTM A841/A841M Standard Specification for Steel Plates for Pressure Vessels, Produced by
Thermo-Mechanical Control Process (TMCP).
IMSL
GIS 34-101 Guidance on Industry Standard for ISO 10439 Axial Centrifugal Air
Compressors (API 617).
GIS 34-102 Guidance on Industry Standard for API 672 Integrally Geared Centrifugal
Compressors (ISO 10442).
GIS 34-103 Guidance on Industry Standard for ISO 13631 Packaged Reciprocating
Gas Compressors (Formerly API 11P).
GIS 34-104 Guidance on Industry Standard for ISO 13707 Reciprocating
Compressors (API 618).
GIS 34-106 Guidance on Industry Standard for API 619 Rotary Screw Compressors
(ISO 10440-1, DIS 10440-2).
GIS 34-107 Guidance on Industry Standard for API 617 Expanders.
GIS 34-108 Guidance on Industry Standard for API 617 Integrally Geared Process
Compressors.
GIS 34-201 API 610 Centrifugal Pumps (ISO 13709).
GIS 34-202 Guidance on Industry Standard for ASME B73.1 Centrifugal Pumps.
GIS 34-203 Guidance on Industry Standard for ASME B73.2M Centrifugal Pumps.
GIS 34-204 Guidance on Industry Standard for ISO 5199 Centrifugal Pumps.
GIS 34-205 Guidance on Industry Standard for ISO 15783 Seal-less Centrifugal
Pumps.
GIS 34-701 Guidance on Industry Standard for ISO 10438 Lubrication, Seal Oil, and
Gas Seal Systems (API 614).
GP 36-10 Guidance on Practice for Metallic Material Selection.
GP 36-12 Guidance on Practice for Metallic Materials for Amine Service.
GIS 36-102 Guidance on Industry Standard for Hardness Testing, Post Weld Heat
Treatment, Stress Relief, and Pickling for Pressure Vessels, Piping, and
other Components.
GIS 36-107 Guidance on Industry Standard for Integral Cladding, Weld Overlay, and
Limited Loose Lining of Pressure Vessels and Components.
GIS 42-101 Guidance on Industry Standard for Fabrication, Assembly, Erection, and
Inspection of Carbon, Carbon Manganese, and Low Alloy Steel Pipework
(ASME B31.3).
GIS 42-102 Guidance on Industry Standard for Fabrication, Assembly, Erection, and
Inspection of Austenitic and Duplex Stainless Steel, Cupro-Nickel,
Nickel Base Alloy, Titanium, and Zirconium Pipework (ASME B31.3).
GIS 43-331 Guidance on Industry Standard for Welding Exceptions for API 1104.
GIS 43-332 Guidance on Industry Standard for Welding Exceptions for ISO 13847.
GIS 43-333 Guidance on Industry Standard for Welding Exceptions for BS 4515.
GIS 46-010 Guidance on Industry Standard for New Pressure Vessels.
GP 06-60 Guidance on Practice for Coating of Metal Surfaces and Equipment.
GP 18-03 Guidance on Practice for Heat Exchanger Tube End Fixing (GS 118-8).
GP 52-10 Guidance on Practice for Materials for Thermal Insulation of Pipework
and Equipment (GS 152-1).
Page 10 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
For the purposes of this GP, the following terms and definitions apply:
(See NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 Parts 1, 2, & 3 – Section 3 for full details)
pH (measure of acidity/alkalinity)
Minus log of hydrogen ion concentration
Page 11 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Sour service
Exposure to environments that contain H2S and liquid water (H2O) and can cause cracking of materials
by the mechanisms addressed in this document
Hydrogen flux
Hydrogen atoms produced by corrosion that may diffuse into the steel resulting in various damage
mechanisms. This species is often referred to as nascent hydrogen and / or H 0
Hydrogen flux is defined as a flow of hydrogen per unit area and is typically measured in pico litres
(pl) of gaseous hydrogen at 20°C (68°F) per cm2 of steel surface, per second i.e. pl/cm2/s. Hydrogen
flux is affected by pH and pH2S and other factors such as the presence of cyanides and arsenic.
Pressure
Where the NACE standards refer to pressure, this shall be taken as the design pressure.
For the purpose of this GP, the following symbols and abbreviations apply:
(See NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 Parts 1, 2 & 3 – Section 3 for full details)
CE Carbon equivalent
Page 12 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
UT Uniaxial tension
Where H2S conditions vary, peak transient conditions shall be used in design.
Page 13 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Page 14 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
7.1. Upstream (oil and gas) - Qualification of cracking-resistant carbon and low alloy
steels and cast irons (for SSC, SZC, HIC and SOHIC resistance) (NACE MR0175/
ISO 15156 – Part 2 and Part 1)
7.1.1. Overview
Qualification is required for the following:
a. SSC resistance.
b. SZC resistance.
c. HIC/SWC resistance.
d. SOHIC resistance.
Page 15 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
d. A full inspection of the equipment has been carried out after service.
7.1.3.1. General
a. The user is required when evaluating flat-rolled carbon steel products for sour service
(Part 2 – clause 8) to consider HIC/SWC if there is even a trace amount of H2S present.
Test procedures are given in Annex B, clause B5 and according to NACE TM0284 with
alternative environments (Table B.3).
b. Other products, such as forgings, castings and seamless products shall simply restrict the
sulphur content in the steel in line with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156.
7.1.3.2. IMSL specific requirements for flat rolled products (e.g. plate & submerged arc welded
(SAW) line pipe
a. Material selection - Materials with increased resistance to these cracking mechanisms shall
be specified by IMSL if HIC/SWC are considered, utilising one of the following three
approaches:
1. Z-quality steel (used in vessel manufacture, etc.) detailed in Annex A.1 of this
document.
2. HIC-resistant steel detailed in Annex A.2 that also refers to improvement in SOHIC
resistance.
3. Carbon steel internally clad with stainless steel/nickel based alloy.
b. IMSL special HIC test requirements (relevant to Annex A.2)
1. For H2S < 1 ppm - No consideration of HIC/SWC required.
2. For pH2S ≥ 0,3 kPa (0,05 psi)
a) HIC test in the following solution (Test solution A)
5%NaCl + 0,5% CH3COOH + pH2S 100 kPa (15 psi).
b) IMSL acceptance criteria unless otherwise agreed
CLR < 10%, CTR < 3%, CSR < 1%.
3. For intermediate H2S (> 1 ppm but < 0,3 kPa (0,05 psi), either:
a) Use mills/manufacturing routes with demonstrated capability of producing fully
HIC resistant steel or
b) Treat as for the pH2S ≥ 0,3 kPa (0,05 psi) case.
Note Recent experience within IMSL has shown that some HIC of
materials that are not designed to be fully HIC resistant can
occur, even under very mildly sour conditions. Therefore it is
not recommended that the route of application specific HIC
testing under ‘milder environment conditions’ than the
standard NACE Test Solution A be taken, until and unless
suitable acceptance criteria to replace the ‘no cracking’
criteria in NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156, have been
established.
c. Exceptions
1. There is experience within IMSL and elsewhere that under some conditions of very
high H2S levels, HIC has not been a problem, and therefore special precautions may
not be necessary.
Page 16 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
2. Due cognizance therefore may be taken of local experience when specifying special
requirements to prevent HIC.
a) If measures are not taken, details of the conditions and satisfactory experience
shall be fully documented within the Business Unit/facility in which it is being
applied.
b) Every situation should be considered on the merits of the long term experience.
7.1.4. Possible requirements for SOHIC and SZC testing (Part 2 Annex B, B4)
a. SOHIC and SZC testing should be considered for plate steels and products made from
welded plate (Part 2 – clause 7.2.2). This could involve either the following small-scale
tests (clause B.4.2) or a full pipe ring test (clause B.4.3).
b. Tests for SOHIC and SZC are not yet standardized, but evaluation can be carried out by
(Annex B, clause B.4):
1. Sectioning un-failed UT or FPB SSC test samples to check that there are no ladder-
like cracks > 0,5 mm (0,020 in) in the through-thickness direction or
2. Test remaining tensile strength (after hydrogen degassing) to confirm it is ≥ 80% of
original actual tensile strength of material.
c. IMSL specific requirements
In cases where SOHIC/SZC should be considered, IMSL may specify steel with increased
resistance to these cracking mechanisms. Annex A.2 mentions the benefits of TMCP and
Q+T steels in this respect.
7.2. Upstream (oil and gas) – Qualification of cracking-resistant CRAs and other
alloys for SSC, SCC, and GHSC (NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 – Part 3 & Part 1)
7.2.1. Overview
Material shall be qualified for the following conditions:
a. SSC and SCC resistance, which is achieved by either:
1. Selection from pre-qualified material or
2. Laboratory testing under specific service conditions or
3. Based on satisfactory documented service experience.
b. GHSC resistance
This should be considered only if a specific problem is anticipated and previous IMSL
experience has been that this has been rarely considered.
c. Latest details of the capability of specific alloys should be checked, as changes have been
made to the pH2S/pH limits compared with earlier NACE MR0175 revisions, and some
alloys have been withdrawn or their use restricted.
Page 17 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
b) Welded equipment
For welded equipment, stabilized or low carbon grades shall be used, and shall
be heat treated in one of the above conditions as specified by IMSL.
c) Possible embrittlement
For pipework in low temperature service, or if the piping code includes notch
toughness requirements, welding procedure tests should be carried out to ensure
that PWHT does not result in unacceptable embrittlement.
2. Bellows
Austenitic stainless steels shall not be used for bellows or other components in the
cold worked or highly stressed condition. UNSN08825, among others, may be used
for this duty.
3. Crevices
The use of socket welded fittings, threaded couplings, or any other weld detail that
could result in a crevice on the process side is not permitted.
4. Overlays
Fusion-bonded overlays of Stellite or Colmonoy may be applied to stabilized or low
carbon grades of austenitic stainless steels, provided that the component is
subsequently heated rapidly to 900/950°C (1 650/1 740°F), held for 1 hour per 25 mm
(1 in) of thickness and cooled in still air.
5. Marine environments
Marine environments often promote external chloride attack. In such cases, the
following shall apply:
a) External protection
Austenitic stainless steels shall be protected externally if they are to operate at
temperatures between 40°C (100°F) and 120°C (250°F) in chloride-containing
environments, i.e. areas close to the sea.
b) Tropical areas
Stainless steels for use in tropical marine areas, as specified by IMSL, shall be
protected externally before transporting to site and the protection maintained
during construction and operation at site. Protection of welds and associated
heat-affected zones are most important. Any painting specification used in the
context of this clause shall be subject to IMSL approval.
c) Thermal insulation
Thermal insulation of pipework and equipment shall be as required by GP 52-10
and GP 06-60.
Page 18 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
b. Forgings and bar stock CRA materials commonly used in the manufacture of downhole
equipment for which domain diagrams have been produced include:
1. 13Cr Steel (AISI 410 and AISI 420 Modified).
2. Super 13Cr 95 ksi Alloys.
3. Super 13Cr 110 ksi Alloys.
4. 17/4PH Precipitation Hardening Stainless Steel.
5. Alloy 450 Precipitation Hardening Stainless Steel.
7.2.4.1. General
a. Materials properties shall be defined and documented
b. Service environment shall be defined and documented
c. Service experience shall be at least 2 years to give sufficient confidence
d. There shall have been a full inspection of the equipment after service
IMSL have some limits that are different from NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 and in some
cases a IMSL specific interpretation of NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 has been required,
e.g.:
8.1. Overview
a. This standard includes the following:
1. Material requirements for SSC resistance in sour petroleum refining and related
process environments.
Page 19 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
2. Hardness limits to resist SSC for carbon and low alloy steels, CRAs/other alloys.
3. Definition of sour conditions based on previous refinery experience.
b. Other forms of wet H2S cracking (i.e. HIC/SOHIC) are not covered so these are considered
separately.
Page 20 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
CE = C + Mn + Cr + Mo + V + Ni + Cu
6 5 15
b. Service conditions - If the severity of sour service conditions varies within equipment, the
whole vessel shall be designed to be suitable for the most stringent conditions.
c. SSC resistance - Material hardness requirements shall, as appropriate, comply with:
1. NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 (Upstream) or
Page 21 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
9.1.2. Austenitic SS, duplex SS, & nickel base alloys and internally clad carbon steel
Approval - IMSL specification approval is required.
9.2.2. Austenitic, duplex, & nickel alloys and internally clad carbon steel
The welding procedure qualification tests for these materials shall comply with GP 18-03.
9.3. Piping
Page 22 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
2. Where the hardness requirement cannot be met in the as-welded condition or the
applicable code requires PWHT, the requirements of GP 36-10 and GIS 36-102 shall
be taken account of.
3. Low alloy steel piping shall be subject to PWHT irrespective of pipe size or wall
thickness.
e. Fabricated piping - Fabricated piping shall comply with GIS 42-101, GP 36-10,
GIS 36-102.
9.4. Pipelines
a. Standards - Pipelines and associated fittings shall be subject to GIS 43-331, GIS 43-332, or
GIS 43-333.
b. IMSL approval
1. Material specifications shall be subject to approval by IMSL. ERW pipe is not
allowed for sour service unless there is specific IMSL approval.
2. HIC/SWC testing
a) Production control tests using the method of NACE TM0284 shall be carried out
on pipeline steels specified by IMSL to confirm that they are resistant to HIC as
detailed elsewhere in this document.
b) Other tests may be specified by IMSL for manufacturing procedure
qualification. Acceptance criteria for these tests shall be subject to approval by
IMSL.
c. SOHIC/SZC testing - SOHIC/SZC testing should be considered as detailed elsewhere in
this document.
d. Full diameter pipe testing - Full diameter pipe HIC/SWC/SOHIC testing may be required,
and if so, details will be specified by IMSL.
e. Mill and site welding - The mill and site welding procedures shall be carried out as
specified in clause 10.
f. Hardness test results - The specific service environment to which the pipeline will be
subjected will be taken into account by IMSL when assessing the results of hardness
surveys.
g. PWHT - PWHT of field girth welds of pipelines is not required unless specified by IMSL,
in which case the details shall be subject to IMSL approval.
Page 23 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
c. Concentration of chlorides.
d. Temperature.
9.6. Valves
a. Standards - Material selection and fabrication procedures shall be in accordance with, as
appropriate, either:
1. NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 (Upstream) or
2. NACE MR0103 (Downstream).
3. NACE RP0472 Downstream).
b. Contact with the environment
1. Valve parts that can be contacted by the sour environment shall conform to this GP.
2. Items that are not freely vented to atmosphere such as insulated and buried equipment
and bolts inside flange protectors, where leakage of the process stream could subject
the equipment to a sour environment, shall conform to this GP.
3. Valve parts not subjected to sour environment need not comply with this GP.
c. Plated components - Material on which plating is deposited shall conform to this GP.
1. The plating shall be resistant to sour service.
2. Cadmium and zinc plating shall not be used for this service
d. Welding and repairs – PWHT
1. Structural welding and weld repairs of any cast component in contact with sour
service shall be followed by PWHT for low alloy steels, martensitic stainless steels,
and other materials in which welding can produce unacceptable microstructures
and/or hardness.
2. Repairs to valve balls, gates, discs, plugs, etc. shall be subject to PWHT for low alloy
steels, martensitic stainless steels, and other materials where welding can produce
unacceptable microstructures and /or hardness.
e. Valve springs resistant to SSC
1. Valve springs shall be made from materials resistant to SSC. Acceptable spring
materials are given in clause 7.2
2. This requirement shall also apply to bellows-sealed safety or relief valves, which
discharge into a common header or piping system.
f. Protected valve springs
1. Suitably protected non-resistant materials may be proposed for approval for large
springs if the cost of resistant materials is high, and if failure is not critical. Typical
protection methods include:
a) Flexible 2-pack epoxy paint formulation for service up to 100°C (212°F).
b) Aluminium metal spray plus sealer.
c) Fluorinated polymer coatings applied by the fluidised bed process.
2. If coatings have been accepted, the complete spring shall be protected and special
attention shall be given to the half coils at the spring ends.
g. Internal bolting - Internal bolting in valves shall be resistant to SSC.
h. Packing
Page 24 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
9.7.1. General
a. Sour service SSC resistance - If H2S is present, rotating machinery shall conform to the
following. If H2S is present rotating machinery shall conform to the following:
1. NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 (upstream) or
2. NACE MR01013 (downstream) &
3. NACE RP0472 (downstream).
For reciprocating compressors, the presence of any level of H2S shall result in the
specification and use of suitable SSC resistant materials.
b. General material requirements
1. Materials selected and fabrication procedures and associated equipment shall comply
with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or NACE MR0103 as appropriate.
2. Items made from 11/13% Cr shall be double tempered.
c. Cast irons
1. These materials may be used for internal components if allowed by the equipment
standard and subject to approval by IMSL.
2. None of these materials shall be weld repaired.
d. Carbon steel for fabricated casings exposed to wet H2S - Plate shall be HIC resistant and
shall comply with Annex A.1 or A.2.
e. Shafts and piston rods
1. Shafts and piston rods in plain carbon, low alloy, medium alloy, and 11-13%
chromium steels shall be heat treated to minimise residual stresses, and shall have a
hardness not exceeding 248 HV10 (HRC22) and a yield stress not exceeding
620 N/mm2 (90 000 lbf/in2).
2. Shafts in austenitic and duplex stainless steel shall be in the solution annealed
condition.
3. Precipitation hardened nickel alloy shafts shall comply with NACE MR0175/
ISO 15156.
4. 17Cr 4Ni precipitation hardening stainless steel shall comply with clause 7.2.
5. The straightening of shafts after completion of machining shall not be commenced
without prior approval from IMSL.
6. Machining errors may not be rectified by metal coatings without the specific approval
of IMSL.
f. Welds - Fabrication welds and repair welds shall be heat treated as follows:
1. Carbon steel – PWHT as per GIS 36-102
2. Low alloy steels: PWHT details shall be subject to approval by IMSL.
3. Martensitic stainless steel (11-13% chromium steel): Re-heat treat completely
including double temper.
4. Austenitic stainless steels: Do not normally require PWHT, any thermal treatment
shall be subject to IMSL review and approval.
Page 25 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Page 26 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
9.8. Instrumentation
a. Process line specification - Instrument piping shall be in accordance with the associated
process line specification.
b. Items that cannot be heat treated
1. Bellows, diaphragms, Bourdon tubes, items that cannot be heat treated after welding,
and components that cannot function in the softened condition shall be fabricated
from materials resistant to cracking in the hardened and/or cold worked or non-
heat-treated conditions as defined in NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or NACE MR0103
as appropriate.
2. UNS N08825 and UNS N04400 may be proposed for IMSL approval.
c. Compression fittings
1. Compression fittings in type 316L stainless steel may be used subject to NACE
MR0175/ ISO 15156 or NACE MR0103 as appropriate.
2. For relatively high temperature and high chloride service, IMSL may require the use
of more corrosion resistant alloys.
9.9. Bolting
a. Sour service SSC resistance - Bolting shall comply with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or
NACE MR0103 as appropriate if in contact with any concentration of wet H 2S.
b. Austenitic stainless steels
1. Austenitic stainless steels shall comply with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or NACE
MR0103 as appropriate.
2. If austenitic stainless steel bolts and nuts are required, these items shall be free from
cold work; they shall be solution treated after thread forming as follows:
a) Bolts shall be Class 1A of ASTM A193/A193M e.g. B8MA (Type 316 bolts
solution treated after all cold work including thread forming).
b) Nuts shall be of the ‘A’ suffix variety of ASTM A194/A194M e.g. Grade 8MA
(Type 316) solution treated after all hot or cold working.
Page 27 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
c. High strength steels - High strength steels for internal bolting and also for springs, bellows,
and parts of reciprocating compressors shall comply with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or
NACE MR0103 as appropriate if in contact with any concentration of wet H 2S.
9.10. Bellows
a. Sour service - Materials for bellows shall comply with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or
NACE MR0103 as appropriate if in contact with any concentration of wet H 2S.
b. Materials
1. Austenitic stainless steels shall not be used for bellows, but material selection shall be
made from the following depending on the process conditions:
a) Alloy 825 (UNS N08825).
b) Alloy 625 (UNS N06625).
c) Alloy 400 (UNS N04400).
2. Other materials may be proposed for approval by IMSL.
10. Fabrication
Page 28 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
2. Test coupons shall be ground smooth and macro etched to reveal the various zones of
the weld.
3. Hardness traverses shall be made as required by NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or
NACE MR0103/ NACE RP0472 as appropriate.
d. Hardness results
1. Results shall comply with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156 or NACE MR0103/ NACE
RP0472 and GP 36-10/ GIS 36-102 as appropriate.
2. Only the Vickers hardness test (5 kg or 10 kg load) shall be used for hardness traverse
measurements of welds unless otherwise agreed by IMSL.
e. IMSL approval of results - The results of the qualification tests plus welder qualifications
shall be submitted to IMSL for approval.
f. Quality assurance/control – Attention shall be given to quality assurance/control to ensure
that it is effective in ensuring that the fabrication welding is carried out in compliance with
the qualified procedure.
10.5. NDE
a. 100% WFMT shall be carried out of the internal welds of new vessels.
Page 29 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Page 30 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Area A Carbon steel may be used without stress relief unless there is contact with steam
tracing which could produce local temperatures above the bulk service temperature.
Area B Carbon steel shall be subject to stress relieving of the whole equipment including
welds and bends exposed to this service.
Area C Carbon steel is unsuitable in this area, and nickel based alloys shall be used instead.
Selection shall be for IMSL approval.
b. Materials for pumps - Materials for pumps in caustic service shall be subject to approval
by IMSL.
c. Other restrictions – Refer to GP 36-10 and GIS 36-102.
d. PWHT Temperature – If H2S is present and PWHT or stress relief is required, the higher
PWHT temperature/ time in GIS 36-102 shall be used.
Page 31 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
13. Inspection
Page 32 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Sectioning and testing in the laboratory is the preferred methodology and shall be used
whenever possible.
1. Testing of Sectioned Samples
This allows determination of the HAZ hardness as well as parent metal and weld
metal. This is the case with:
a) Welding procedure qualification tests.
b) Production test plates when these are required by the fabrication specification.
c) For small items e.g. small springs, pins, etc. that cannot be hardness tested
individually, the manufacturer shall conduct tests on a random basis by selecting
components and sectioning them for laboratory hardness testing to ensure that
the product complies fully with this GP. Procedures for doing this shall be
subject to the approval of IMSL. This does not apply to austenitic stainless steels
in the solution annealed condition.
2. Testing of Welded Items that cannot be Sectioned
If the hardness can be checked without damaging the component, the manufacturer
shall conduct hardness tests on parent metal and weld metal to ensure that the
hardness requirements of this GP are met. IMSL inspectors will carry out their own
random hardness checks.
b. Hardness testing procedure/ frequency
This shall be consistent with NACE MR0175/ ISO 15156, NACE MR0103/ NACE
RP0472 and GIS 36-102 as applicable.
1. The Vickers hardness test (5 kg or 10 kg) shall be used for determining hardness of
weldments that can be sectioned. The Rockwell (ISO 6508-1) using 15 N scale can be
used as an alternative by agreement only. Other hardness tests (e.g. Rockwell C) are
considered unsuitable.
2. For weld items that cannot be sectioned the hardness test method shall be agreed with
IMSL. Brinell hardness testing is frequently used for bulk components.
Page 33 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Annex A.1
(Normative)
Specification for Z-quality steel plate
A.1.1 Scope
This Annex defines the requirements to achieve enhanced resistance to wet H 2S service. It has
been found by experience that steel made with enhanced through thickness properties has
improved resistance to HIC. This type of steel is known as ‘Z’ quality steel.
A.1.2 Definition
A.1.3 Material
A.1.3.1 Standards
The plate furnished shall meet BS EN 10028-3 or equivalent steel grades.
b. The CE values used in the above Table shall be calculated by means of the IIW CE
formula as per 9.1.1.2.
c. The use of rare earth metals is not permitted.
Page 34 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Weld repair of plate surface defects is not permitted without IMSL approval and shall be subject
to an agreed repair procedure before the work is carried out.
Page 35 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Annex A.2
(Normative)
Specification for HIC resistant steel plate
A.2.1 Scope
a. This Annex defines requirements for the manufacture and testing of steel plates with
maximum resistance to HIC/SWC for pressure vessels.
b. For some less severe environments, as advised by IMSL, ‘Z’ quality plate may be
specified, in which case Annex A.1 shall apply.
A.2.2 Manufacturing
A.2.2.1 Standards
Plates furnished shall meet either BS EN 10028 Part 3, ASTM A516/A516M (normalized),
BS EN 10028 Part 6 (Q+T), or ASTM A841/A841M (TMCP) or equivalent standards.
A.2.2.2 Process
a. Steels shall be made by a low sulfur and low phosphorus refining process, for example in
an electric furnace with double de-slagging or in the basic oxygen furnace (BOF).
b. Steels shall be vacuum degassed while molten.
A.2.3 Testing
Page 36 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Page 37 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Annex A.3
(Informative)
Example of domain diagrams
ACCEPTABLE
5,5
0,03 bara
pH 4,5
3,5
UNACCEPTABLE
pH2S (bara)
ACCEPTABLE
5,5
pH 4,5
FURTHER ASSESSMENT
REQUIRED
3,5
UNACCEPTABLE
pH2S (bara)
Page 38 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Annex A.4
(Informative)
In-service issues
It is beyond the scope of this document to give detailed guidance on ‘In-Service Issues’ for material
operating in sour service. However, the following highlights some key issues that need to be
considered.
A.4.1 Inspection
There is a need to carry out inspection where possible in order to monitor the performance of
sour service materials. Clearly, some types of equipment lend themselves more readily to
inspection than others. The following are issues for consideration:
a. External inspection – Straight beam and angle beam ultrasonic testing and automated
ultrasonic testing are frequently used to inspect for cracking.
b. Global External Inspection – Acoustic emission can be used for external global inspection
to locate areas of active cracking, for further characterization by ultrasonic testing.
c. Internal inspection – Visual examination of the inside surfaces and weld areas is used to
identify the presence of any cracking. Other more sensitive techniques include wet
fluorescent magnetic particle inspection and alternating current field method.
d. NDE operators – Operators require appropriate training such as ASNT SNT-TC-1A or
equivalent to Level 1 and Level 2 for interpretation of data.
e. Risk based inspection (RBI) – RBI techniques can be used to prioritize inspection. This
takes account of both probability and consequence of failure.
f. Defects – Any defects that are found should be evaluated for fitness for service using
techniques such as those given in API 579. The possibility of continued crack growth shall
be considered. Remedial action may involve local grinding, weld repairs (after hydrogen
outgasing).
The amount of hydrogen generated by corrosion and thereby available as diffusible atoms is
important in assessing severity of service. Monitoring of hydrogen flux is therefore beneficial,
and the following techniques are available:
a. Intrusive Finger Pressure Probes measure the build up of pressure inside a tube inserted in
the environment, following diffusion through a membrane.
b. Patch Probes that measure hydrogen atoms diffusing through the equipment by the build
up of pressure in the cavity between a patch and the equipment.
c. An Electrochemical Cell involves diffusion of hydrogen through a metallic palladium
membrane, which forms the partition of a two-compartment cell. Emergent hydrogen
atoms are oxidized and are measured by a current flow in the cell.
d. Beta foil is a thin foil glued to the outside of the equipment and a vacuum is drawn
between the foil and the equipment. As hydrogen diffuses into this zone the pressure
increases and is monitored.
e. The Hydrosteel 6 000 uses a flexible metallic plate collector with a spiral pathway on the
surface to sweep up any hydrogen diffusing out of the vessel/pipe of interest, in a flow of
air, into the measuring equipment.
Page 39 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Several different remedial measures have been used in situations where hydrogen induced
cracking has been a problem. These include:
a. Improved materials have been applied with greater resistance to hydrogen induced
cracking.
b. Metal lining using a stainless steel type of liner has been used and this is produced either
by roll bonding or by weld overlaying.
c. Coatings have also been used, which minimizes corrosion and hydrogen flux. However,
attention needs to be given to the quality of the base material, in case of breakdown of the
coating at some stage.
d. The surface preparation that is used before carrying out internal inspection leaves the metal
surface in a condition where a high hydrogen flux can occur on re-commissioning. Some
temporary protection for the surface is desirable to minimize the hydrogen flux until a
protective sulfide film can form.
Page 40 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
Bibliography
[2] TM0103-2003 Laboratory Test procedures for Evaluation of SOHIC Resistance of Plate Steels
Used in Wet H2S Service.
[3] RP0296-2000 Guidelines for Detection and Repair and Mitigation of Cracking of Existing
Petroleum Refining Pressure Vessels in Wet H2S Service.
[4] 8X194 Materials & Fabrication Practices to be used in Wet H2S Refinery environments.
[5] 8X294 Review of Published Literature on Wet H2S Cracking of Steels through 1989.
[6] NACE 1981 Book, H2S Corrosion in Oil and Gas Production - A Compilation of Classic Papers Edited
by R.N.Tuttle and R.D.Kane.
[7] NACE Paper 01520 Corrosion 2001, Material Damage Implications of post weld heat treating H2
blisters in carbon steel. Jorge.L.Hau et al.
[8] NACE Paper #206 1990Carbonate Stress Corrosion Cracking of Carbon Steel in Refinery FCC Main
Fractionator Overhead Systems, J.H.Kmetz and D.J.Truax.
[9] NACE Paper 04480 Corrosion 2004, Development of Pressure Vessel Steels with Improved SOHIC
resistance, L. Coudreuse, V.Ligier, P.Bourges & A.Gingell.
[10] NACE Paper 01105 Corrosion 2001, Application of Normalized and Quench and Tempered Pressure
Vessel Steels as a function of Sour Service Severity, L.Coudreuse, C.Zmudzinski, P.Bocquet,
A.Gingell & A.Cheviet.
[11] NACE Paper 02554 Corrosion 2003, SOHIC Resistance of C-Mn Plate Steels Used in Refinery
service, M.S.Cayard, R.D.Kane & R.J.Horvath.
[16] EEMUA 194 Guidelines for Materials Selection and Corrosion Control for Subsea Oil and Gas
Production Equipment.
Page 41 of 42
12 November 2007 GP 06-20
Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service
IMSL
[19] GIS 02-201 Specification for OCTG Seamless Casing and Tubing.
[20] GIS 02-204 Specification for Sour Service Grade C110 and C125 Low Alloy Steel OCTG
Seamless Pipe.
[21] Report S/UTG/023/00 Guidelines for Selecting Downhole Tubular Materials for Oil & Gas
Production Wells: J. W. Martin, D. Harrop and W. Hedges.
[22] Report S/EPT/035/05, Best Practice for Selection of Materials for Downhole Equipment (Revision 2)
Report No S/EPT/035/05 J W Martin, T N Evans, A J Leonard and S Groves.
[23] Report BPA-D-003 Casing Materials Selection & Corrosion Guidelines: J. W. Martin: IMS Amoco
Report No BPA-D-003 September 1999.
Page 42 of 42