Fbpo Final
Fbpo Final
Fbpo Final
PROCESSING OUTSOURCING 1
Table of Contents
CHAPTER PAGE
OVERVIEW ...............................................................................................................1
1. INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................2
iii
4. MANAGING OUTSOURCING TRANSITIONS........................................................ 29
4.1 Managing Outsourcing Transition ...........................................................29
4.2 Transition Success & Effectiveness .................................................................... 32
4.3 Document Readiness .............................................................................................. 33
4.4 Work-Shadowing ....................................................................................35
4.5 Readiness Assessment ..........................................................................36
4.6 Hand-Offs .................................................................................................................... 44
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................85
iv
OVERVIEW
1
MODULE I
INTRODUCTION
The word is definitely out – the Philippine is a major player in global IT-BPM.
The opportunity remains for the Philippine IT-BPM industry to capture a bigger
share, given the global offshoring services market is seen to more than double by
2016. The industry has the potential to bring in USD$25 billion in revenue, and employ
1.3 million individuals by 2016.
Offshoring and Outsourcing (O&O) is perhaps one of the most unique
developments in business and industry. Firms now adopt s truly global scope with the
opportunity to situate their Operations across the world.
Outsourcing is said to have first flourished in the run-up to the beginning of the
second millennium. IT processes and Operations were migrated to India as some
American and European companies focused on dealing with the Y2k problem.
2
IT-BPM Industry Snapshot in the Philippines
2016: Base Case vs. Accelerated Case Increases Jobs from 3.1 Million to 4.
3
Growth of IT-BPM Industry = Economic Growth of the entire Philippines
4
1.2. Introduction to the IT-BPM Industry
1. Capacity Management
2. Lower Cost
3. Better Performance
5. Part-based Activities
Capacity Management:
• Demand chasing (one day 50 employees needed, next day only 10 are
needed)
5
Lower Cost:
Use of specialized external providers which can deliver service with better
quality, innovation, in new platform:
Part-based Activities:
• Automobile components
• Cruise-ship rooms
• Airplane avionics
3. IT services
6
Support or Auxiliary Services
o Cafeteria
o Janitorial Service
o Copy Center
o Building Maintenance
o Trucking/Shipping
o Security
o Payroll
o Legal
IT Services
o Application development
o Helpdesk
7
1.5 Advantages and Disadvantages of Outsourcing
Advantages:
Disadvantages
Service Provider may have more expertise/ capability than the buyer
Example:
Technical Support -
Accounting -
Animation -
Example:
Technical Infrastructure
8
Human Resources
Technical Expertise
• Professional Growth
• Financial Independence
• Employee Assistance
• Enjoy your favorite food
• Cost can be higher
• Buyer does not have full control of resources doing work
Cost can be higher because provider may add premium for risk in case processes
are not well defined
9
o Solution: Do not use outsourced office assistant like your personal
assistant.
o Gives you the opportunity to pursue your passion and interest during the
day
10
MODULE II
FUNDAMENTALS OF OUTSOURCING
• No man is an island
• Everything is connected
• The nature of business is …
Third-Party:
• Owned by a service provider, a local entity or part of a global grou
• Providing services to clients of the service provider
11
2.2 Strategies for Outsourcing
1. Multisourcing
2. Crowdsourcing
3. Onshoring
4. Nearshoring
5. Offshoring
Example:
12
• Crowdsourcing: "...outsourcing to an undefined, generally large group of
potential officer’s in the form of an open call." (Jeff Howe)
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
Example: New York bank contracting start-up security service firm in New York.
Nearshoring: Vendor in a country “close” (geographic and/or cultural proximity) to
client's home country
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
13
• Transfer pricing/tax margin requirements
Example:
Advantages:
• Allows company to focus on core business
• Fast ramp-up/down at reasonable cost
• Opportunity to expand into new areas cost effectively
Disadvantages:
• Data privacy/confidentiality issues
• Lack of right business acumen/right market knowledge in offshore location
• Cultural differences leading to delays and miscues
• Risk of high attrition in service provider, weak staff selection/training.
Core Activities-Tasks-Processes:
14
• Design
• Product Development
• Process
• “Recipe”
Examples:
15
• IT Outsourcing:
o IT Technical Support
o IT Application Development
o IT Application Management
o Data Center operations
o Software as a Service (SaaS)
o Cloud (On-line Storage) Services
o Cafeterias
o Copy centers
o Security
o Janitor Services
o Trunking/ Shipping
o Building Maintenance
16
• Routine activities or activities that can be automated at larger centers:
• Seasonal requirements/s:
o These are activities that are: routing, scheduled, with little uncertainty
o Automobile assembly
o Electronics assembly
o Packaging solution
o Handicraft or garments for mass production
Video conferencing:
• HP - Halo (8.5 min. video)
• Cisco - Telepresence
• Sun - MPK20: Project Wonderland
18
MODULE III
BPO ENGAGEMENT
Attributes
19
• A business process outsourcing (BPO) contract is a formal agreement between
a client and a service provider to take over a “pre-agreed portion” of the client's
business operations.
• The BPO contract, with all its attachments, assumptions, and documented
agreements, is referred to as the master services agreement (MSA)
Main elements:
A. Service to be provided
B. Performance management, issues, change management
C. Country laws
Groups (A) and (B) are the “operational” elements, used day to day. Group (C)
generally “just-in-case” terms.
Considerations:
• Can be similar to a “job order”
20
• Is generally an attachment/addendum to a Master Agreement, points to covering
terms
• May state that in case of terms inconsistency, the SOW or Master Agreement
supersedes
21
• In terms of type per duration; most contracts are typically multi-year contracts,
however and when deemed most effective, on-demand contracts may also be
put into effect
There are two pricing models that are commonly used in outsourcing contracts; (1)
fixed price, and, time and material.
1. Fixed Price:
- This pricing model is easy to plan and more predictable than other pricing
models.
- A fixed, pre-agreed price per unit is negotiated, (e.g., a fixed price per call of
a fixed price per transaction)
- Advantages for clients: provides greater cost certainty
- Disadvantages: several risks with capital requirements and lower flexibility
2. Time and Material:
- The price for service is based on the time and material that was used.
- Used when a service is very flexible and it is not predictable in terms of how
much time and material is needed.
- In some cases, a maximum price for the service is negotiated by the client /
customer to build in some control or safety level. In practice, it is often a mix of
the above-mentioned pricing models that is used.
22
3.7 BPO Contract Financials
23
1. Labor cost
o Compensation
o Benefits
o Bonuses
o Incentives
2. Direct costs
3. Indirect costs
2. Benefits: Training, Health and Life Insurance, Profit Sharing, Pension Matching,
Worker’s Compensation, Employer share of payroll and Social Security taxes
24
• Board of Investments (BOI)
• Bureau of Immigration
• Pag-Ibig Fund
• Board of Investments
• BOI Qualification
o A Philippine enterprise can register their project with the BOI if the
proposed activity is listed as a preferred project in the current IPP. Said
enterprise may engage in domestic-oriented activities in the IPP whether
classified as pioneer or non-pioneer
25
However, an activity which is not listed may still be entitled to incentives if the following
conditions are met:
o At least 50% of the production is marked for export (for 60% Filipino-
40% Foreign-owned enterprises); or
o At least 70% of production is marked for export (for more than 40%
Foreign-owned enterprises)
• For foreign-owned firms or those whose foreign investment exceeds 40% of the
outstanding capital stock who can engage in domestic-oriented activities, can
only be registered with the BOI if they propose to engage in an activity listed or
classified in the IPP as pioneer.
BOI Requirements:
26
PEZA, The creation of
• The development of Special Economic Zones throughout the country, and the
very competitive incentives available to investments inside PEZA Special
Economic Zones are embodied in the Special Economic Zone Act of 1995
(Republic Act No. 7916), a law passed by the Philippine Congress.
Qualification
Requirements
27
3.12 Internal Regulatory Requirements – Industry
ARTICLE 34- (1) Banks shall take all necessary measures to ensure that their
internal audit units can inspect all activities and units of their consolidated partnership
without limitation
28
MODULE IV
29
➢ Needs to have strong project management skills, as the migration process
are complex projects that require expert management skills.
➢ Need to be comfortable in working in a cross cultural environment, as most
often the client teams are based overseas;
➢ Needs to have a though rough understanding of the existing business and
legal process and the current as well as emerging technologies as these
play a critical role in the offshoring of a business function. Generally, there
are two common strategies followed in migrating a function, these are:
➢ Generally, there are two common strategies followed in migrating a function,
these are:
➢ Lift and Shift and Re-engineer and Migrate
• Generally, there are two common strategies followed in migrating a function,
these are: Lift and Shift and Re-engineer and Migrate
Definition - This is the most common methodology used. When the process is
mature, the ’Lift and shift' approach is used for migrating.
Phases
2. Stabilize
30
➢ Negotiate elimination of unnecessary outputs
Items to Consider
1. Process change that will not affect process control points or output can be done by
service provider independently
➢ Transition phase can be easy especially if “people and processes” are moved;
may take 3 to 4 months only
➢ Risk that Onshore loses political will to reengineer processes after a while
• Training the new team is easier, as the process is well understood and
documented
• Existing employees at the donor location are available to support the process
in case of disruptions or instability
• A fresh set of eyes (the new team) look at the process from a fresh perspective,
often resulting in process improvements and enhanced controls
31
Items to Consider:
➢ Useful when the process is either broken and requires fixing, or is due to
undergo significant change in the near future (systems change or process
change)
➢ In such cases, it may be important to utilize the expertise of the existing team
(which is built over several years) to drive the change, before it is handed over
to the new team
➢ Company that outsource industry common processes to a market-leading
service provider will generally follow service provider processes
➢ Company transition changes its processes as part of to service provider
3. Training shortcuts
2. Manpower Readiness – state of the readiness of the operating staff; hired, trained,
and, skilled for the service processes
32
Transition Effectiveness can measure through:
1. Financial Benefits
• Costs related to moving the function to the new team should be tracked
separately as project costs.
• Inputs
• Replication ready
• Output
• Communication
• Supervision
33
• Timing of delivery quality assumptions, and work-around in case of failure in
delivery of some inputs
34
Document Readiness: Communication
4.4 Work-Shadowing
Phases:
• May be done at Onshore location with service provider staff travelling; may be
done at service provider location with Onshore staff travelling
35
• Service provider staff reviews documentation provided against actual activity
done by Onshore personnel
• Service provider performs the activity; Onshore personnel looks over and
gives close guidance
3. Go-live
36
b) Service providers adding “uncertainty” of process premium in their
proposals—not very clear what will be delivered, how, and by when
d) Long work shadowing period and high cost as service provider tries to
document required process
b) Without readiness assessment, the company will estimate the current cost
low, the receiving provider may incorrectly size the role, may have to initially
use 2 performers (with very structured steps) to do the same 1 FTE job until
knowledge is gained/documented
3. Resource sizing already includes the right level of quality assurance and
supervisory control
Adequate Documentation
1. Input
2. Process
37
3. Output
4. Communication
5. Supervision
2. Method of acquisition
3. Language of input
5. Dependencies
38
– Are inputs in same language as that of provider
b) Is there an input data timing condition (can be received only on Business Day x)
– Are the inputs received all throughout the month or do they peak on a single
day/period
39
– Input errors cost money in terms of re-work – Poor quality of input means prior
step to validate input must be added
40
➢ Using a specific standard is not important; it is important that a
standard is consistently used
– Are workflow and other technology tools properly referred to in the document
– Ideal that the process continues without waiting; only stop by exception
41
– Quick look at input receive and output delivery allows check of process ease
and staffing requirements
– Tight processing times (late input, early month output) shout out opportunities
for required technology/process improvement
2. Method of transmission
3. Language of output
42
4. Timing of the output
5. Dependencies
• Onshore
• Offshore
• Staffing, Equipment, Motivation
• Country Regulations
43
• In shared services, next stage of evolution is true centers of excellence where
work and supervision is done in another location
4.6 Hand-Offs
Definition - are transfers of the output to a different performer, an approver, for further
action prior to continuation
5. Payroll clerk looks at enriched pay record and calculates right withholding
tax
44
6. Payroll supervisor reviews the whole pay and approves
4.7 Scale
Scale Illustrated
Scale
• Service provider
• Client
45
Scale in Relation to Workforce
• Near self-contained roles have good potential for outsourcing – because more
FTEs covered
For Scale to work it must be considered to both sides client and service provider. In
each instance, both parties have to consider the following:
• End-to-end roles are ideal (start from external contact, ends with external
contact, with only 1 or 2 intermediate hand-offs for review/approval)
• Product P&L (profit and loss) starts with transaction data download and ends
with submission to regional/senior management, intermediate activities (market
price verification, calculation of mark-to-market value) are fully done by service
provider
• Buyer needs sufficient FTEs in outsource project to justify risk and executive
attention (sourcing management, finance/payments, legal)
46
• What is the amount saved. If it is too small, the cost of Onshore supervision
eats up the benefit
• Large and small engagements have near same “overhead” in support –except
for very large contracts
• Training
• Break down current onshore roles into individual tasks that have scale (high
number of FTE hours)
• Tool for task analysis can be - Follow the performer: consultant follows a
performer and tracks time spent in each task; called “stop-watch” method
because consultants carry timing devices
• Time-tracking into granular task buckets is good way to identify potential roles
for outsourcing
• Record how much time is spent each day in specific task groups
47
• Other “sub-filters”: (a) do not require complex market knowledge, (b) do not
have high financial or regulatory risk, (c) tasks which are self-contained (have
minimal hand-offs)
• Tempting to wait and do more granular time tracking and further analysis. Be
wary of analysis paralysis
• Finite
• Documented
• Sufficient of Scale
• Readiness assessment
48
Components of Readiness
49
MODULE V
➢ The main strategy that the BPO sector applies is what is called; “End-to-End
Service Level Management.”
➢ The Service Level Agreement (SLA), is a formal agreement between the client
and service provider for a common understanding on aspects including service
quality, responsibilities, performance metrics, penalties and commitments.
SLM is a regular and systematic review of service provider performance against the
agreements
50
5.2 BPO: Operations Management Six Components- Component 1
PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
51
5.4 BPO: Operations Management Six Components – Component 3
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
52
Value - lifelong learning, a sense of moral obligation, to maintain and improve
professional competence, enhance career progression, keep abreast of new
technology and practice, or to comply with professional regulatory organizations
Quality Specification:
➢ Customer Focus
➢ Total employee involvement
53
➢ Process-centered
➢ Integrated system
➢ Strategic and systematic approach
➢ Continuous improvement
➢ Fact-based decision-making
➢ Communication
Total Quality Circles means having organized Kaizen activities, involving everyone
in a company - managers and workers - in a totally systemic and integrated effort
toward improving performance at every level.
ISO 9001 is a very flexible quality standard that is readily applicable to many industries,
as well as to all sectors of IT-BPM industry, hence its popularity in the Philippines even
with small-scale business.
54
➢ Effective problem solving can only be achieved by data driven decision making,
and,
o Achieving and maintaining quality improvement requires an
organizational commitment that comes from senior management
➢ Measuring
➢ Comparison
➢ Identification
➢ Feedback
5S was invented in Japan, and represents five (5) Japanese words: Seiri, Seiton,
Seiso, Seiketsu, and Shitsuke
Benefits:
55
➢ Improve safety
➢ Decrease down time
➢ Raise employee morale
➢ Identify problems more quickly
➢ Develop control through visibility
Kaizen:
➢ Quality
➢ Effort
➢ Involvement of employees
➢ Willingness to change
➢ Communication
56
Lean is a process management framework and methodology derived mostly from the
Toyota Production System (TPS). It aims to optimize the flow or speed of producing
goods and services by removing the traditional "8 deadly wastes. “
“8 Deadly Wastes:
➢ Overproduction
➢ Transportation
➢ Motion
➢ Correction
➢ Over-processing
➢ Inventory
➢ Unused Employee Ideas and Talent
57
5.8 Business Process Mapping and Notation
58
Process Mapping & Notation: Basic Shapes – Event
Examples:
➢ Month-end date is an event that can start the month-end reporting process
➢ Email with an invoice attachment requesting payment can start the accounts
payable process
➢ Student grades arriving at the registrar office is an end event to the semester
teaching process
Examples:
➢ Extract account balances in SAP is an activity that will be performed at the start
of month-end
➢ Check for duplicate invoice is a task done at the first stage of the accounts
payable process
➢ Explain syllabus is a task performed by the teacher at the start of the semester
May be exclusive forking an “or”, depending on the answer to the question indicated
by the label. An “X” can be placed inside the shape (diamond) to denote a forking of
paths.
May be parallel flow an “and”, marked by a “+” sign inside the shape (diamond),
denoting concurrent activities.
Examples:
59
➢ Exclusive: Is invoice a duplicate? If yes, reject. If no, create accounts-payable
entry
➢ Parallel: After billing template is received;
o Accounts receivable entry is created in service center, AND
o Accounts payable entry is created in the Onshore unit
Flow – represents; sequence flow. Connects the tasks, shows/ indicates the flow
direction
Examples:
Data – represents; input data, output data. As an input can be via a submitted template
or data in a storage repository. As an output can be a report to be sent to a recipient,
can be a filled-up template to be used by the next process
Examples:
Group of Tasks – represents; a group of tasks. It is literally a visual indicator that the
included tasks are within a logical group
Examples:
Examples:
• Accountant checks for duplicate invoice and requests check payment. These
two activities are within the Accountant’s lane
• Approval by company head is done by a different person, hence in a different
swim lane (the company head’s lane)
61
62
MODULE VI
CRITICAL SITUATION IN BPO ENGAGEMENTS
63
3. Identify key business processes
5. Mitigate impact
7. Mitigate impact
64
Business Continuity Management Steps - Step 4
5. Mitigate impact
7. Mitigate impact
65
• Periodically test recovery plan to
o Validate effectiveness of plan actions (response, interim process,
resumption)
o Ensure availability of required equipment, and
o Develop people skills
• Perform success/failure assessment to improve plan
• Perform root-cause analysis to improve risk prevention measures
• Each process has a period within which interruptions will not affect achievement
of key business goal
• Beyond that period, business goal will be impacted and interruption becomes
extraordinary
• Business Interruption Event is triggered when the interruption on a key business
process exceeds the maximum allowable time
1. Extraordinary event
2. High impact
- In this course, we use Risk and Risk Event interchangeably with "business
interruption event"
• If cost effective
66
-Shifting of factory to an underground bunker to protect from tornado
damage may be cost prohibitive
Management Method
Definition
67
3. Lingering IT infrastructure issues causing problems in operations, e.g. delays
in processing of client's payroll
Entering a Critsit:
Declaring a CritSit
68
Situation: Heavy flooding caused by the Habagat phenomenon in August 2012
Impact to Business:
69
• Paid absences
• Counseling for those who were emotionally affected
• Fund derives organized by the employees as well assistance from other
centers/affiliate companies to support affected employees
Impact to Business:
70
Mitigating Actions done by the BPO:
• Meeting with Building Admin to review situation (what went wrong) and identify
Action Plans to increase prepared in the future
• Schedule monthly meeting with Building Admin to ensure actions are being
done as per agreed timelines
• Monthly/Quarterly audit/testing to ensure generator and other power
systems/tools are in good condition
Situation in the BPO: High Absenteeism due to widespread influenza and colds
Impact to Business:
• Delay in response time as there are not enough agents to take calls
• Turn Around Time of work/calls is no longer than required time as there is not
enough agents/employees to do the volume of work
• Other centers/countries who are receiver of Manila work output cannot do the
next process as work is delayed from Manila end
71
Mitigating Actions done by the BPO:
• Employees who can work from home (places where there is power and with
technical connectivity) were asked to work from home
• First call Resolution (FCR) which is a Key Service Level Measure in a Call
Center operation with a target of 85% is consistently missed for three months.
Should management call for a CritSit?
72
Medical Transcription - Specialist accuracy output consistency is below SLA
for 5 consecutive weeks.
Entering a Critsit:
73
Prepare
• Identify the Project Manager or Team Leader of the CritSit team. A good option
to lead this team is either a certified Project Manager of 6S Black Belt.
• Identify the team members of the CritSit and assemble the team.
• Ensure all administrative requisites of the CritSit are ready, e.g. meeting
schedules
• Establish a dedicated "war room" that will be used by the Critsit team
74
Assess
• Develop glide-paths for improvement on key metrics that will be monitored for
the duration of the CritSit
• Define and communicate to CritSit team members the entry and exit criteria of
the CritSit
• Conduct an in-depth analysis of the problems by scrutinizing thoroughly
historical data/ measures of the problem area (s)
• Use root cause analysis methods such as the Fishbone diagram, why-why
analysis or 8D problem solving techniques
Gain Commitment
• Get clients' buy-in and/or vote of confidence on the recovery plan if they are
aware of the CritSit in their contract/account
• Be sure that all stakeholders and team members involved in the process have
signed-off on the following:
75
-Resource allocation/requirement
Present to the stakeholders and client the improvement of the metrics per the glide
path
• Get the sign-off of the stakeholders and client to approve the exit from CritSit
and return to business as usual mode
• After implementation of the action plans and full recovery from CritSit, conduct
an evaluation of lessons learned and collate this for future reference
• Ensure to develop next steps that will prevent the CritSit from happening again.
This could be done by conducting another round of brainstorming session
• Celebrate with the team
76
The 8D Approach
Definition:
The 8D is at one time three different things that work together, these are:
-A problem-solving process
-A standard
-A reporting format
The 8D Approach:
77
• Clarify if the concern is not clear
Champion/Team Leader
Sets the stage and ensures that the team activities are in the right direction
78
Discipline 2-Describe the Problem
• Define and verify Interim Containment Action (ICA) to isolate the effects of the
problem from any internal/external customer until Permanent Corrective Action
is implemented
79
-State the results
• Identify all possible causes, which could explain why the problem occurred
-Ask "why" as many times as necessary to drive the process to root cause
- Use Cause and Effect Diagram, FMEA to list previously defined causes
• Isolate and verify the root cause/s by testing each possible cause against the
problem description and test data
• List all possible corrective actions to eliminate root cause/s
80
•Run Pilot Tests
• Artificially simulate the solution to allow the actual process or field evaluation
•Monitor Results
Once in production, monitor the long term effects and implement contingency actions,
if necessary.
81
Discipline 8-Congratulate Team
2. Root-cause Analysis
82
3. Escalation
1. Clear documentation
3. Approvals
4. Process Improvement
83
• Can identify changes in people skill/training, staffing level, technology,
or policy/processes
84
REFERENCES
➢ Book
• Wiley, John E., Essentials of Outsourcing, McGraw Hilll Publishing, Inc., 2006.
• Fundamentals of Business Process Outsourcing 101 (Teacher’s Guide)
85
Therefore, as a result of these relationship attributes, the BPO contract is a unique,
“tailor-fit” agreement captured in a document
that resembles a performance contract.
86