Chapter 3
Chapter 3
At its core, the structure of a state aims to establish a stable and functional system
of governance that serves the interests and meets the needs of its citizens. This
often involves the division of powers between different branches of government,
such as the executive, legislative, and judicial branches, each with distinct roles
and responsibilities. Additionally, states may adopt various forms of government,
ranging from democratic systems to authoritarian regimes, further influencing their
structural dynamics.
1|Page
The science of politics and the art of politics are two distinct branches of study,
and should he kept so; just as the science of mechanics is a very different matter
from the art of engineering. One may be an adept in the science, and yet utterly
unskilled in the art—quite unable to apply the conclusions of the science to the art.
Now the science of politics, by whatever name known, is very little studied at the
present day by our statesmen. They even affect to despise it. On the other hand
men of science, or as they have been styled, “cloistered economists,” are prone to
imagine themselves capable of solving all kinds of political problems simply by
the aid of scientific research, without any practical experience whatever of the facts
and conditions of the situation.
Moreover, the structure of a state is shaped by its legal framework, which defines
the rights and obligations of both the government and its citizens. This includes
constitutional provisions, statutory laws, and judicial interpretations that establish
the rules governing the exercise of power and the protection of individual liberties.
1. Top-Level Divisions:
This is the broadest level of division, often called states, provinces, regions, or
emirates.
These divisions have a significant degree of autonomy and may have their own
legislatures or executive bodies.
They handle broad functions like education, healthcare, infrastructure
development, and law enforcement within their jurisdiction.
2. Middle-Level Divisions:
These are subdivisions of the top-level divisions, known as districts, counties,
prefectures, or mandals.
They serve as intermediaries between the top level and the local level.
Their responsibilities often include implementing policies set by the top level,
overseeing local administrations, and collecting taxes.
3. Local-Level Divisions:
This is the most granular level, encompassing municipalities, towns, villages, or
communes.
These divisions are closest to the citizens and handle day-to-day matters like
sanitation, waste management, local permits, and community services.
They may have elected officials or representatives who report to the middle-level
divisions.
3|Page
The Peripheral Zone of administrative divisions
4|Page
own local governments, administrative bodies, or special development authorities
tasked with addressing the unique needs and challenges of these regions.
Devolution of power and resources to local authorities can enhance governance
and promote grassroots participation in decision-making processes.
Strategic Importance: Despite their peripheral location, these zones may hold
strategic importance for the state in terms of security, border management, or
geopolitical considerations. Ensuring stability and development in these areas is
essential for maintaining territorial integrity and fostering national cohesion.
The frontier zone of administrative divisions within a state typically refers to the
border regions that mark the outer limits of the state's governance and influence.
These areas often possess distinct characteristics due to their proximity to
neighboring jurisdictions or international boundaries. Here's a detailed description
of the frontier zone:
5|Page
Economic Activities: Economic activities in frontier zones are influenced by their
proximity to borders. Cross-border trade, smuggling, and informal economic
exchanges are common features, often driven by differences in pricing, regulations,
or availability of goods and services between neighboring jurisdictions.
Additionally, frontier regions may rely on specific industries such as agriculture,
mining, or tourism, which capitalize on their natural resources and geographical
advantages.
Security Concerns: Frontier zones frequently pose security challenges for state
authorities. They may be vulnerable to illegal activities such as smuggling, human
trafficking, or terrorism, necessitating heightened surveillance and law
enforcement measures. Moreover, border disputes or tensions with neighboring
states can occasionally escalate, requiring diplomatic efforts to maintain stability
and prevent conflicts.
The capitals of administrative divisions within a state or country are vital centers
for governance, culture, and often economic activity. These capitals typically serve
as the seat of government for the respective administrative regions. The discussion
of capitals can vary greatly depending on the country or region in question, so I'll
provide a general overview:
National Capital: This is the capital city of the entire country and is usually the
most significant in terms of political, economic, and cultural importance. Examples
include Washington D.C. in the United States, London in the United Kingdom, and
Paris in France.
State Capitals: Within a country, individual states or provinces often have their
own capitals. These capitals serve as the administrative hubs for the state
governments and are usually where the governor's office and state legislative
bodies are located. Examples include Albany in New York (USA), Mumbai in
Maharashtra (India), and Sydney in New South Wales (Australia).
6|Page
functions to state capitals but operate at a more regional level. Examples include
Edmonton in Alberta (Canada), Perth in Western Australia (Australia), and Munich
in Bavaria (Germany).
Each of these capitals plays a crucial role in the governance and administration of
their respective regions, and they often have unique histories, cultures, and
characteristics that contribute to their significance. Additionally, the relationships
between these different levels of capitals can vary depending on the country's
political structure and administrative organization.
Government
In political geography, the term "Government" refers to the system and institutions
responsible for the administration and governance of a particular territory or state.
It is the central authority that exercises authority, makes and enforces laws, and
provides essential services for the population within its jurisdiction. The
government's primary purpose is to maintain order, promote the welfare of its
citizens, protect the state's sovereignty, and manage relationships with other
nations.
7|Page
1. Democracy: A system where power is vested in the hands of the people, either
directly or through elected representatives. Citizens participate in decision-making
processes, such as elections, referendums, and public consultations.
3. Monarchy: A system where a single ruler, often a king or queen, holds supreme
authority. Monarchies can be absolute (where the monarch has almost unlimited
power) or constitutional (where the monarch's powers are limited by a
constitution).
Types of Government
1. Anarchy
Definition: Anarchy is a stateless society without a centralized
government or authority. Instead, it relies on voluntary cooperation
and decentralized decisionmaking.
8|Page
Absence of Hierarchy: Anarchic systems aim to eliminate
hierarchical structures and power dynamics, seeking to create a
society based on mutual aid, voluntary associations, and individual
autonomy.
Challenges: Critics argue that anarchy may lead to chaos and lack of
social order, as there is no central authority to enforce laws or resolve
conflicts.
2. Theocracy
Definition: A theocracy is a system where religious leaders or
religious institutions hold political power, and the government is
based on religious principles.
Religious Authority: The government's policies and decisions are
influenced by religious doctrines, and religious leaders often play
significant roles in governance.
Challenges: Theocratic governments may face challenges related to
religious intolerance and potential infringement of individual
freedoms if the state's laws favor one particular religion.
3. Oligarchy
Definition: Oligarchy is a system where a small, privileged group
holds political power and decision-making authority.
Rule by the Elite: Political power is concentrated in the hands of a
few wealthy or influential individuals or families.
Challenges: Oligarchies often face criticism for perpetuating
inequality and prioritizing the interests of the ruling elite over those of
the general population.
4. Dictatorship
Definition: Dictatorship is a system where one individual, the
dictator, holds absolute power and authority over the state.
Authoritarian Rule: Dictators exercise near-total control over the
government, often suppressing political opposition and dissent.
Challenges: Dictatorships can lead to human rights abuses, lack of
political freedoms, and a lack of accountability.
5. Monarchy:
Definition: Monarchy is a system where a single ruler, often a king
or queen, holds supreme authority.
9|Page
a. Absolute Monarchy
In an absolute monarchy, the monarch has almost unlimited power
and authority, with little to no checks on their decisions.
b. Constitutional Monarchy
In a constitutional monarchy, the monarch's powers are limited by a
constitution, and the country is typically governed by elected officials.
6. Democracy
Definition: Democracy is a system where power is vested in the
hands of the people, either directly or through elected representatives.
Challenges: Democracies require active citizen participation, and
challenges may arise in ensuring equal representation and preventing
the concentration of power.
c. Direct democracy
In a direct democracy, citizens participate directly in decision-making
processes, such as voting on laws and policies.
b. Representative democracy
In a representative democracy, citizens elect representatives to make
decisions on their behalf in the legislative body.
7. Republic
Definition: A republic is a system where the country's political
leaders are elected by the citizens, and the government is based on the
rule of law.
Representative Government: In a republic, representatives are
elected to make decisions on behalf of the people in the legislative
body.
Challenges: Republics need strong institutions and an independent
judiciary to ensure the rule of law and protect individual rights.
8. Aristocracy
Definition: Aristocracy is a system where political power is
concentrated in the hands of a small group of noble or privileged
individuals.
Rule by Nobility: Aristocratic systems often prioritize the interests
of the ruling elite or nobility.
10 | P a g e
Historical Significance: Aristocracies were more prevalent in feudal
societies, where landowners held significant power.
9. Democratic republic
Definition: A democratic republic combines elements of democracy
and republicanism, where the country's leaders are elected by the
people.
Representation and Rule of Law: Democratic republics feature
elected representatives making decisions while adhering to the rule of
law.
Challenges: Balancing the principles of democracy with the rule of
law and ensuring accountability of elected representatives can be
complex.
1. Civil service
Here are several key aspects to consider when discussing civil service as a
government institution:
11 | P a g e
Professionalism and Expertise: Civil servants are expected to
possess expertise in their respective fields, whether it be law,
finance, healthcare, education, or engineering. They undergo
training and professional development to enhance their skills
and knowledge, enabling them to effectively carry out their
duties and responsibilities.
Service Delivery: Civil service plays a crucial role in delivering public services to
citizens, ranging from healthcare and education to transportation and social
welfare. Civil servants are responsible for implementing government programs,
enforcing regulations, and providing assistance to the public when needed.
2. Police
12 | P a g e
Here are some key aspects to consider when discussing the police as a government
institution in Bangladesh:
Challenges and Criticisms: Like police forces in many countries, the Bangladesh
Police faces challenges and criticisms. These may include allegations of
corruption, abuse of power, excessive use of force, lack of accountability, and
politicization. Human rights organizations and civil society groups have raised
concerns about extrajudicial killings, arbitrary arrests, and torture in police
custody.
Reforms: Efforts to reform the Bangladesh Police have been ongoing. Various
initiatives have been introduced to improve professionalism, transparency, and
accountability within the force. Reforms have included training programs, the
establishment of internal oversight mechanisms, and the adoption of technology for
better policing practices. However, progress in these areas may vary, and
challenges persist.
13 | P a g e
management, and implementing government policies related to security and crime
prevention. Additionally, the police often collaborate with other agencies, such as
intelligence services and the judiciary, to address various security challenges.
Legal Framework: The Bangladesh Police operate within a legal framework that
includes various laws, regulations, and codes of conduct governing their actions.
The Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), Penal Code, and other relevant laws
outline the powers and responsibilities of the police in conducting investigations,
making arrests, and maintaining public order. However, concerns have been raised
about the misuse of these powers and the need for greater adherence to legal
standards and human rights principles.
Here's a deeper dive into Bangladesh Bank's role and functions within the context
of being a government institution:
Issuance and Management of Currency: Bangladesh Bank has the sole authority
to issue currency notes and coins in Bangladesh. It manages the circulation of
currency, ensures its integrity, and works to combat counterfeiting.
15 | P a g e
Financial Stability and Crisis Management: Bangladesh Bank plays a crucial
role in maintaining financial stability within the country. It monitors systemic
risks, develops contingency plans, and intervenes when necessary to mitigate
financial crises and safeguard the stability of the financial system.
4. Election commission
16 | P a g e
Constitutional Mandate: The Election Commission of Bangladesh derives its
authority and responsibilities from the Constitution of Bangladesh. It is mandated
to conduct various types of elections, including national parliamentary elections,
local government elections, and elections for other statutory bodies.
- Ensuring Fairness: It is tasked with ensuring that elections are conducted fairly,
transparently, and without any undue influence or manipulation.
- Concerns have been raised regarding the accuracy of voter lists and allegations
of voter fraud and irregularities during elections.
- Efforts have been made to enhance the transparency and efficiency of the
electoral process through reforms such as the introduction of electronic voting
machines (EVMs) and voter education initiatives.
18 | P a g e
primary objective is to ensure that the recruitment process for civil service
positions is fair, transparent, and based on meritocracy.
Here are some key aspects of the Public Service Commission in Bangladesh:
Constitutional Mandate: The PSC derives its authority from the Constitution of
Bangladesh. Article 137 to 141 of the Constitution outlines the establishment,
functions, and powers of the Public Service Commission.
Regulation and Oversight: Apart from recruitment, the PSC also oversees the
proper implementation of rules and regulations related to civil service
19 | P a g e
appointments. It ensures that appointments are made in accordance with the law
and that the principles of equity, fairness, and transparency are upheld.
Advisory Role: The commission may also advise the government on matters
related to civil service reforms, including changes to recruitment procedures,
training programs, and personnel policies.
6. Census Commission
20 | P a g e
### Role and Functions:
Ensuring Data Accuracy and Integrity: The Commission ensures the accuracy,
reliability, and integrity of census data through rigorous data collection
methodologies, quality control measures, and verification processes.
Conducting Special Surveys: Apart from the decennial census, the Commission
may conduct special surveys on specific demographic, social, or economic aspects
to address emerging needs, monitor trends, or gather detailed information on
particular population segments.
### Structure:
21 | P a g e
Central Authority: The Census Commission operates under the authority of the
Ministry of Planning or a similar government body responsible for statistical
affairs and population census.
### Significance:
Basis for Policy Formulation: Census data serves as a fundamental basis for
formulating policies, programs, and development strategies in various sectors such
as education, healthcare, infrastructure, and social welfare.
22 | P a g e
International Comparisons: Census data provides benchmarks for international
comparisons, enabling Bangladesh to assess its demographic profile, development
progress, and socio-economic standing relative to other countries.
Conclusion
Understanding the structure of the state and the various types of government is
essential for comprehending the diverse political landscapes across the world.
Governments serve as the central authority in any given territory or state,
responsible for administration, law enforcement, and the provision of essential
services. Bangladesh, like many other nations, relies on a range of government
institutions to maintain stability and uphold democratic principles. These
institutions, including the civil service, police, central bank, election commission,
public service commission, and census commission, have specific roles in ensuring
governance, law enforcement, economic stability, and transparent elections. In a
democratic system, it is vital that these institutions remain impartial and free from
political influence to maintain the rule of law and the best interests of the nation
and its citizens.
23 | P a g e
References:
Urban Politics: Policy and Administration by David Healey and Mark Davies
Wikipedia.org
https://www.libertarianism.org/essays/structure-state
Libertarianism.org
Britannica.com
United Nations. (2013). Principles and Recommendations for Population and Housing Censuses.
https://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic/sources/census/docs/P&R%20publication/P&R2017.pdf
World Bank. (2004). Decentralization in Uganda: Explaining Successes and Failures in the Local
Government Reforms. Retrieved from
https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/15113/296470UG0Decen10Box3
45600B01PUBLIC1.pdf
Sharma, B. R. (Ed.). (2013). Decentralization, Local Governance, and Social Wellbeing in India:
Do Local Governments Matter? Springer.
24 | P a g e