Critiquing
Critiquing
OF NURSING
CRITIQUE PRESENTATION
SUBMITTED TO SUBMITTED BY
Dr. S.G Joshi Ms kajal more
Director, Professor (M.Sc Nursing 1st year)
SCON SCON
Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
a R T i c L e i n f o
a b s T R a c T
Keywords:
COVID – 19 This paper describes the psychological state of human from different ages, genders, and professions with the im-
Data analysis pact of COVID – 19 in their regular life in Bangladesh with simulated and visualized infographic images containing
Data visualization statistical analysis from a collected survey on real regular life which is based on their activities of regular life
Psychology
and internet uses. Literature has been reviewed with various COVID – 19 based psychological work and our
Psychological health
work on psychological state, anxiety reasons, and depression scale analysis. Secondly, a process of analysis
Depression
and statisti- cal format has been described through a specific methodology diagram, which contains the
Anxiety
Internet uses collected dataset’s overall data analysis process. Thirdly, a complete analysis report is given by the dataset
analysis, including every specific data collected. Fourthly, a discussion based on analysis and statistical
analysis with informative tables is described individually for different aspects. Finally, some unavoidable
limitations are initialized with reasons though every dataset collected from real regular life and internet use
impacts COVID – 19 in Bangladesh.
Introduction
quantitative report on the anxiety and depression scale based on a col-
COVID – 19 (Coronavirus Disease 2019) started spreading from the lected dataset from various professions on their regular lifestyle, choices,
capital of Hubei Province in the People’s Republic of China named and internet uses phone through simulations and statistical reports.
Wuhan in December 2019. In the past ten months, worldwide human- The contributions of this paper for Psychological health analysis in
faced many issues, including financial, economic, psychological, edu- COVID – 19 pandemics summarized below:
cation and many more. Several impacts have occurred in this situation (1) The literature has been reviewed with other works on di fferent
and this situation as pandemic declared by WHO (World Health Orga- psychological impacts in COVID – 19 based on its impact.
nization) in the second week of March 2020 at the same time when (2) Data Analysis and Data Visualization algorithms have been ap-
COVID – 19 attacked the whole human civilization with its worst range plied to the collected dataset to simulate the current conditions
in both physical and psychological way. People get panic by doubting are Psychological health.
themselves as COVID Positive, and many more occurrences occurred. (3) Statistical analysis has been considered a significant fact in this
In this pandemic, these psychological impacts can be introduced as work. It has also been done through the collect dataset.
weak or broken Psychological health due to COVID – 19. Weak
Psychological health can be initialized as Anxiety, Depression, Literature review
Insomnia, Mood Swing, Mind Diversion, and many more. Moreover, the
lockdown conditions are one of the most responsible reasons for this There are many systems on this topic worldwide. They have pro-
weak Psychological health condition. Lifestyle, social intimacy, success posed many more systems as they previously published. There are
or failure in life, human contact, social situations are responsible for some reasons and reviews discussed below for describing why our work
depression, anxiety in reg- ular times. However, in this pandemic, this is competitive with their system.
rate has been increased. A
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: mdmosfi[email protected] (Md.M. Rahman).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crbeha.2021.100037
Received 21 March 2021; Received in revised form 31 March 2021; Accepted 6 April 2021
2666-5182/© 2021 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
Rehman et al., 2020 The paper mainly focuses on the psychological distress of Our paper discusses not only depression and anxiety but also the
Indians. uses of the internet during the lockdown in Bangladesh.
Although the paper discusses the depression and anxiety ranges, In our paper, we did not use tables but also graphs for more
it does not have any graph representing it. convenience and easy view.
The whole dataset was converted to percentages to understand
the depression scale and the internet uses among males and
females.
Akhter and
Khalek, 2020 Although the paper contains many data, there is no graphical Our paper contains the graphical representation of many
representation. If it had any, it would be easier to understand. conditional statements of daily life with different internet sites.
This paper describes only people’s psychological condition using The paper is specified according to the recent pandemic that
the internet and measures the happiness and time spent on the reflects on the human mind and Psychological changes.
internet.
Wang et al., 2020 The paper contains an analysis of china and its different
provinces. As the paper contains many data, it lacks a visual We worked in the statistical representation using graphs for
contest for the statistical representation. daily activities of life during the lockdown.
Peng et al., 2020 Though the paper contains the depression in the quarantined
population during COVID-19, it lacks visual content. We developed visual content and a percentage of regular life
and Psychological change through different plots.
Islam et al., 2020 This Survey indicates the levels of panic and generalized anxiety
of Bangladesh people during the relatively early stage of the Our Survey indicates the depression levels and scale after
COVID-19. staying at home for siX months during the lockdown.
The paper has no graphical representation for better We added graphs to understand the Psychological condition of
understanding. Male and females, described the uses of the internet among
them, and changed their Psychological conditions.
Odriozola-
González et al., The Survey was only one week after a lockdown on depression. Our Survey was after siX months after lockdown. So, we could
2020 So, there is a lack of data as the review was too early. scale the depression level and Psychological change correctly.
The Survey was done only at one university. Our Survey was on the overall people of Bangladesh.
Chen et al., 2020 The depression symptoms were not apparent in their paper.
They blamed the high-intensity mobile phone use for suicidal We have used answering questions of different depression
thoughts. symptoms to analyze the depression scale and used images to
get a clear view of their psychologically.
We tried to find the main reasons for suicidal thoughts. Then we
represented the depression symptoms that were blamed for the
suicidal thoughts and the internet’s uses.
Elhai et al., 2020 They just blamed smartphone use for depression in lockdown.
They just talked about the smartphone. We represented all the reasons for being depressed, including
internet use due to lockdown.
We described the internet sites that people often use for leisure
in daily life in lockdown.
We analyzed the visualized report to find the main points of
depressions.
Mol et al., 2020 The paper was on regular life base internet use. The paper has
few similarities with our paper. In our paper, we did not just show the internet usage but also
showed the depression scale of the human.
Ng et al., 2019 The Survey only on students.
They only showed the use of social sites for depression. We surveyed people of different professions.
There is a lack of clearance in their methodology. We not only showed the usage of social sites but also showed
the other sites.
We described our methodology step by step for more
convenience.
Zhai et al., 2020 There is no visualized report in their paper.
Depressive symptoms were not apparent. We have the visualized report in which we showed the
responses of the participants.
Our depressive symptoms were apparent.
2
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
Methodology secondly daily uses of the internet, and finally the third part of
understanding the psychological conditions for staying at home.
•
Data Collection: During this pandemic situation (COVID-19), we •
Development: As we collected only some questions and multiple-
shared a survey form to collect some opinions of some choices answers, we considered them as qualitative data. We
psychological facts and daily life on the internet. We surveyed needed to give a structural form to collect the qualitative data so
from 2020 July 20 to 2020 August 1. Questions and some that there are no missing values. Organizing the qualitative data,
multiple-choices were provided to collect the opinions of the male we had given it a structured form. After giving it a structured
and female. About 350 responses were collected from the survey form, we needed to delete or remove unnecessary data as they will
form. The report was gender (male and female) and age-based not provide any information for this Survey. So, we implemented
from age 1 to 60. The data was collected using simple words like algorithms to un- derstand better what we are working on in this
agree-disagree-normal and many more. Simple regular life-related study. As the dataset was qualitative, we needed to convert the data
questions were asked for this Survey. We even used images to find into a quantitative dataset for better understanding.
the reaction and the psychological conditions of humans. The •
Algorithm: We have used this algorithm to analyze male and fe-
survey form was divided into three parts to find the psychological male reports in percentages from different perspectives. To check
condition of humans. The first part was finding the depression in the opinions of males and females in different questions, we need
everyday lifestyle, then a
3
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
5
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
life on the internet. Very few people browse the internet once a day
(Fig. 1). Discussion
6
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
productivity
Productivity is the result of daily activities. According to the peo-
ple’s agreement, we can see that most of the people are facing
problems
7
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
Fig. 6. Irritability.
working all day long due to the lockdown. Every day’s task is taking
more and more time than usual. Most people agree with this case that so depressed that most of the Male and females think everything they
all the tasks are taking more time than usual. The lack of concentration do is a failure in life.
can be blamed for it. Most of the people are agreeing with this topic
too. As people lose concentration, they are becoming depressed and Effect of depressed mood
think- ing that there is no hope for the future. For all of this, they As people are being depressed with their lives, it harms their daily
cannot make decisions. They face problems making decisions. Lack of lives. They are being irritated and having an angry reaction to simple
concentration is mainly responsible for this. Due to COVID-19, they things in life. They are reacting too much to a simple matter. They even
are facing many problems (Fig. 2). feel fatigued too. Their health condition is hampered too. Moreover,
that many people also lose or gain weight without any diet program
(Fig. 4). Medical science says that if a person is depressed, he/she loses
or gains weight without any diet program. Because it a ffects his/her
Depressed mood
health. As life is giving them too much trouble for lockdown and
From Fig. 3, we see that there is not much difference between
COVID- 19 anxiety, most males and females have suicidal thoughts.
agree- ing and disagree, but the number of agreements is a little more
Once seen, when people cannot control their anger, they become weak
than disagree. That is means about 50% of people are sad, and they are
and decide to attempt suicide.
feel- ing depressed. They are losing interest in everything in their life.
Most people think that there is no joy in their life. For that, they have
lost interest in everything. We can also see that depression is working Psychological change
at a very high level among that people. Since life is giving them a hard At present almost, every people have trust issues with others. It is a
time due to COVID-19, most people feel guilty for their daily lives. common issue. That is why many people have trouble with their rela-
They feel tionships, whatever the relationship is. Trust is a significant thing in all
8
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
9
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
male and 60 female)
1
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
uses chat rooms for communication, 72% (171 male and 81 female)
uses instant messenger to communicate and 39.1% (117 male and 20 to failure in something in life. About 36% agree (110 males and 42
female) play game every day. females) with this condition.
These have an impact on the mind. People are becoming more and So, by calculating the issues and the abnormal rating, we can say
more online addicted and distracting from social life. Nowadays, that on average, about 37.2% male and 49.8% female, and 42.78% of
people like online communication. As a result, people feel that there is people are depressed in their daily life.
no joy in their life. About 42% (95 males and 52 females out of According to people’s different perspectives, the use of the internet
350) agree with this. 52.6% of people (113 male and 71 females out of is:
350) are losing interest in everything. About 68.9% of people (160 Here from the table, we can see the percentage of di fferent people
male and 81 females out of 350) face a lack of concentration. It causes spending their time on the internet. Here, most people spend their
a decision- making problem. About 60% of people (128 males and 82 time on the internet on different social sites like Chat Room,
females) feel this way. The lack of concentration and decision-making Messenger, So- cial Networking Sites, Blogs, Gaming, Web Browsing,
problem leads Music, File Shar- ing, Shopping, News, Internet TV. According to this
Survey, males spend
11
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
Fig. 9. Continued
1
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
Table 1.1
The depression perspective of males and females.
1
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
Table. 1.2
The percentages on use of internet.
Topic Gender Once a day More than Once a Day Less than Once a Month Everyday
Table. 1.3
Spending time on the internet of males and female.
Use of the internet Gender Once a Week Once a Month More than Once a Month Less than Once a Month Everyday Never
Table. 1.4
The percentage of male and female going out in a day.
Topic Gender 0 1 2 2+
Table. 1.5
Image remarking.
most of their time in gaming and messenger (Table 1.1, Table 1.2 and day at home. They like to enjoy the outer world on their phone on the
Table 1.3). internet.
From the above Table 1.4, we can understand that since people For Table 1.5, we have two remarking based on survey data collec-
spend their maximum time on the internet, they cannot find enough tion respectively HFI Remarking belongs to Happy Face Image
time to go out to enjoy themselves. About 63.70% of females stay all Remark- ing and SFI Remarking belongs to Scary Face Remarking. In
this table,
1
Md.M. Rahman, Mohd. Saifuzzaman, A. Ahmed et Current Research in Behavioral Sciences 2 (2021) 100037
al.
we can see for males in average 16.65% and females in average 17.25%,
and in total average 16.85% people’s Psychological health is breaking References
down according to the image remarking system.
Akhter, M.S., Khalek, M.A., 2020. Association between psychological well-being and prob-
lematic internet use among university students of Bangladesh. J. Technol. Behav. Sci.
Conclusion doi:10.1007/s41347-020-00142-X.
Chen, R., Liu, J., Cao, X., Duan, S., Wen, S., Zhang, S., Lu, J., 2020. The relation-
COVID-19 has a significant impact on mental health. It is creating a ship between mobile phone use and suicide-related behaviors among adolescents:
the mediating role of depression and interpersonal problems. J. Affect. Disord.
destructive mentality and increasing depression in regular life. As a re-
doi:10.1016/j.jad.2020.01.128.
sult, suicidal attempts are increasing. Life of people are becoming more Elhai, J.D., Yang, H., McKay, D., Asmundson, G.J.G, 2020. COVID-19 anxiety symptoms
irritable, and people have social anxiety. For COVID-19 social distance associated with problematic smartphone use severity in Chinese adults. J. A ffect. Dis-
ord. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2020.05.080.
has increased. So, physical contact is decreasing. Social colony break-
Hasan, M.T., Hossain, S., Gupta, R.D., Podder, V., Mowri, N.A., Ghosh, A., Is-
down is the main reason for this. As people have to stay at home most lam, N., 2020. Depression, sleeping pattern, and suicidal ideation among med-
of the time, they spend their leisure time on the internet. So, the ical students in Bangladesh: a cross-sectional pilot study. J. Public. Health
natural lifestyle of humans is being hampered. doi:10.1007/s10389-020-01304-0, (Bangkok).
Islam, M.S., Ferdous, M.Z., Potenza, M.N., 2020. Panic and generalized anxiety during the
COVID-19 pandemic among Bangladeshi people: an online pilot survey early in the
Limitations outbreak. J. Affect. Disord. 276, 30–37. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2020.06.049.
Mol, M., van Schaik, A., Dozeman, E., Ruwaard, J., Vis, C., Ebert, D.D., Smit, J.H., 2020.
Dimensionality of the system usability scale among professionals using internet-based
The collected dataset is from regular life in this pandemic based on interventions for depression: a confirmatory factor analysis. BMC Psychiatry 20 (1).
human internet uses and regular life schedule. Some limitations we doi:10.1186/s12888-020-02627-8.
had to face while doing this work. Only 350 people responded to our Ng, K.C., Wu, L.H., Lam, H.Y., Lam, L.K., Nip, P.Y., Ng, C.M., Leung, S.F., 2019. The
relationships between mobile phone use and depressive symptoms, bodily pain,
Sur- vey. Only those people who use the internet could get a response and daytime sleepiness in Hong Kong secondary school students. Addict. Behav.
to our Survey. Most of the responses were from the student. So, we had doi:10.1016/j.addbeh.2019.04.033.
a small number of data from other professions. Odriozola-González, P., Planchuelo-Gómez, Á., Irurtia, M.J., de Luis-García, R.,
2020. Psychological effects of the COVID-19 outbreak and lockdown among
students and workers of a Spanish university. Psychiatry Res., 113108
Declaration of Competing Interest doi:10.1016/j.psychres.2020.113108.
Peng, M., Mo, B., Liu, Y., Xu, M., Song, X., Liu, L., Zhang, X., 2020. Prevalence, risk factors
and clinical correlates of depression in quarantined population during the COVID-19
None.
outbreak. J. Affect. Disord. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2020.06.035.
Rehman, U., Shahnawaz, M.G., Khan, N.H., Kharshiing, K.D., Khursheed, M., Gupta, K.,
Data availability Uniyal, R., 2020. Depression, anxiety and stress among Indians in times of COVID-19
lockdown. Commun. Psychol. Health J. doi:10.1007/s10597-020-00664-X.
Wang, Z.H., Yang, H.L., Yang, Y.Q., Liu, D., Li, Z.H., Zhang, X.R., Mao, C., 2020. Preva-
The dataset related to this research paper is available via the lence of anxiety and depression symptom, and the demands for psychological knowl-
GitHub repository https://github.com/mdmosfikurrahman/Datasets. edge and interventions in college students during COVID-19 epidemic: a large cross-
sectional study. J. Affect. Disord. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2020.06.034.
Zhai, B., Li, D., Li, X., Liu, Y., Zhang, J., Sun, W., Wang, Y., 2020. Per-
Code availability ceived school climate and problematic internet use among adolescents: mediat-
ing roles of school belonging and depressive symptoms. Addict. Behav, 106501
All source codes are available upon request. doi:10.1016/j.addbeh.2020.106501.