Transportation Published Paper
Transportation Published Paper
net/publication/378204692
CITATION READS
1 481
4 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Siddhartha Nepali on 14 February 2024.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.46610/JOCCE.2024.v010i01.003
e-ISSN: 2457-001X, Vol. 10, Issue 1 (January – April, 2024) pp: (22-31)
Received Date: February 06, 2024; Published Date: February 14, 2024
Abstract
This study addresses the prevalent issue of traffic congestion at critical intersections in urban
areas, leading to slowed traffic and increased queue lengths. The centralization of the
Kathmandu Valley has contributed to a gradual rise in population thus impacting the efficiency of
the traffic management system. This study focuses on three of the busiest intersections of the
valley i.e. Kesharmahal, Narayanhiti, and Khanibhivag intersections and aims to provide
insights into current traffic conditions and propose measures for enhancing traffic flow. Data
collected is analyzed to determine current traffic flow, saturation flow, existing capacity, Level of
Service (LOS), and intersection delay using the HCM Manual. The analysis involves assessing
present conditions and making comparisons with standardized data. Three days of traffic volume
data during peak hours and geometric features of the intersection were gathered. Results indicate
that the intersections are experiencing over-saturation, exceeding their capacity based on
existing geometry and signalization. Additionally, the vehicle replacement strategy showed
limited effectiveness in reducing saturation flow, with the flow persisting at an over-saturated
level. These findings highlight the need for targeted measures to address the challenges posed by
congestion and enhance the efficiency of traffic management at these intersections for smooth
traffic flow.
other independent variables that may include and geometry conditions in the designated study
road geometry (radius, grade, sight and setback area. It also aims to determine the capacity of
distance, presence of divider, etc.), road the intersection, exploring factors such as delay
pavement condition, vehicular condition and at different legs and lane groups. Through
road user characteristics need to be considered. simulation, the study seeks to recommend
According to Timalsena (2017), in suitable intersection types with the ultimate goal
Kathmandu, due to rapid population growth, of mitigating traffic congestion.
unexpected vehicular growth, especially private
vehicles can be seen, which is leading to various LITERATURE REVIEW
traffic problems such as undesirable levels of
congestion, pollution, safety problems and Common measures by which the
delays. Matighar- Tinkune road section is one of performance of an intersection may be evaluated
the major roads of the Kathmandu valley but include delay, stops, and queue length. Each of
due to a lack of suitable infrastructure, always these may be expressed as values, which
there is the formation of bottlenecks leading to represent totals or averages for the entire
traffic congestion and loss of human capital intersection or particular approaches or
hour. Timalsena (2017) found that a total of movements within the intersection. Averages are
6464.90 capital hours are being lost in the often expressed on a per-vehicle basis. Delay,
morning and evening peak hours of the working specifically the control delay is the measure used in
day due to the bottleneck in this road section. In the signalized intersection methodology of the 2000
this way total of 211.81 capital year is being lost HCM and the primary measure used in the number
due to bottleneck. of signalization optimization procedures.
Level of Service (LOS) serves as a Performance measures are a critical part of all
quality measure describing operational intersection design methodologies. To better
conditions within a traffic stream, encompassing investigate and understand delays involving right-
factors like speed, travel time, manoeuvrability, turning vehicles, some researchers took the
interruptions, comfort, and convenience. Six traditional approach of establishing right-turn
LOS categories labeled A to F, delineate a delay models. Zhang et al. (2015) suggested that
spectrum of operating conditions, with 'A' right-turn delay was caused mostly by pedestrian
representing optimal conditions and 'F' the least interference, but did not present situations in
favourable. Each level reflects a range of which pedestrians are compliant with traffic
operating conditions and the driver's perception controls. Guo et al. (2015) put forward a model
of those conditions, though safety is not for calculating delay caused by pedestrians
factored into the measures defining service passing through right-turning traffic and made
levels. an improvement to delay analysis by bringing
This research centres on the vehicle types into consideration.
examination of traffic studies, traffic flow Chandra et al. (1996) studied the
characteristics, and the control and regulation of parameter to define the level of service for
traffic operations. The complexities of mixed traffic at signalized intersections. Due to
managing road traffic are particularly seen at many problems associated with the measurement
intersections. Therefore, it is essential to ensure and interpretation of delay at signalized
that intersections are thoroughly designed to intersections LOS parameters were redefined.
provide the necessary level of service for The degree of saturation and percent of vehicle
different road users. stopping in the approach were considered the
appropriate parameters.
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE AND SCOPE Timalsena (2017) conducted research
about the impact of traffic bottlenecks on urban
The objectives of this study encompass roads and from the extracted data, delay in the
a comprehensive analysis of the current traffic peak hour for different traffic was calculated
and then, by using volume and occupancy data, a program funded by The World Bank.
the total human capital hour delay of different Similarly, the Japan International Cooperation
types of vehicles was calculated for both the Agency (JICA) has demonstrated good safety
direction. practices as well as data keeping and analysis of
Pokhrel et al. (2023) conducted the road crashes along Banepa – Bardibas road and
study on the Jay Nepal Intersection, near the recently they are prioritizing road safety on some
Narayanhiti intersection in Kathmandu Valley of the major intersections of Kathmandu Valley.
and the results exhibited that the intersection was
over-saturated (DOS>1) and had a poor level of Study Area
service (F) in both morning and evening peak
hour. By incorporating left turn manoeuvres into The study is focused on the
signal-controlled intersections rather than Kesharmahal, Narayanhiti, and Khanibhivag
allowing free turns, it was more effective in intersections in Kathmandu, which are crucial
significantly reducing the average delay, and the intersections connecting to the Royal Palace and
queue length and improving LOS. the bustling tourist destination, Thamel as
Dhakal et al. (2023) studied the shown in Fig. 1. Due to extensive commercial,
Satdobato intersection of Kathmandu Valley industrial, governmental, and private activities,
and concluded that the optimization of the Kathmandu has become one of the world's most
signal time cannot change the LOS of the densely populated cities. However, the road
intersection but can decrease the average delay traffic facilities have not kept pace with this
and back of the queue including left turn population growth, resulting in persistent
movements under signal control instead of congestion, particularly at intersections. This
leaving for a free turn can significantly decrease congestion adversely affects road users. Given
the average delay and back of the queue. resource constraints, the study suggests that
Tiwari et al. (2023) concluded that The implementing effective traffic management
Department of Roads has improved the bridge techniques, such as the installation and
approaches in perspective of safety along the optimization of traffic signals, is a viable option
major highways of Nepal through the Second to alleviate these issues.
Bridge Improvement and Maintenance Program,
METHODOLOGY
The methods that have been adopted to accomplish this are shown in Fig. 2.
transportation. The systematic breakdown of scenario at the studied intersection during peak
data and categorization provided a foundation hours.
for a comprehensive analysis of the traffic
Bus,
4 Truck, 3 0 0 0 0 1 3 1 3 2 6
Tanker
Total 41 26.5 43 27 47 30 32 20.5 163 104
Thamel-
LT 42.333
Lianchaur
Calculation of Flow Volume at Lane Group of LT and RT/TH were calculated and the
values were obtained as in Table 4.
For lane group A, the average volume
Determination of Saturation Flow total signal time to serve all of the signal phases
including the green time plus any change
From the saturation flow table, for lane group A interval.
(L), the saturation flow was found to be
1581.447318 pc/hr/lane and the saturation ratio IMPROVEMENT ANALYSIS
was 0.883812558.
The computed cycle length under
Determination of Cycle Length, Green Time current conditions yielded a negative value,
and LOS indicating that the intersection is experiencing
oversaturation in terms of traffic flow.
From the saturation table, Consequently, in designing signals for the
Y = ∑ =∑ =3.481389693 >1 intersection, it becomes imperative to anticipate
a flow level that ensures an acceptable level of
Xc = .9(Assumed), All red time (AR) =
service (specifically, LOS D as per HCM 2000).
(6.9+3*4*3.5+2*1*3.5)/ (35*1000/3600) =5.7
For this, various analyses could be carried out
sec.
thus to improve traffic flow at the intersection
L=2*4+5.7=13.7 sec., C = = referred to as improvement analysis or
∑
alternative analysis. The improvement
= -4.7764 sec. considered for the analysis of traffic flow
includes replacing the vehicles with large public
As the value of Y is greater than 1, cycle length transportation. The sample replacement analysis
happens to be negative which is not possible for lane group A(s) is shown in Table 5.
analytically as cycle length is composed of the
Table 5: % Replacement of car, bike and all micros at Kesarmahal intersection (Evening).
Total Bus
Leg
Bus
TH 710 308 0 47 355 308 0 30.286 77.286 1095.286 894.857 77.286
A(s) RT 80 59 0 1 40 59 0 1.714 2.714 141.714 107.143 2.714
LT 570 328 0 36 285 328 0 4.286 40.286 938.286 733.857 40.286
Calculation of Cycle Length transportation, and the cycle length was found to
be negative. But for 83% replacement, it was
Cycle length is calculated the same as rounded up to the nearest 5th decimal, found to
the existing condition. For each lane group, at be 595 seconds and positive thereafter for further
Narayanhiti intersections up to 82% of car, bikes percentage replacement.
and micros were replaced with large public
Table 6: Approach and Intersection Delay with % replacement of car, bike and all micros
(Narayanhiti).
Direction East West North Intersection
% Car, Bike and
Delay LOS Delay LOS Delay LOS Delay LOS
Micros Replaced
83 253.117899 F 141.733375 F 322.222591 F 219.229635 F
84 137.465657 F 76.8629483 E 181.946496 F 120.554528 F
85 100.564317 F 56.1755904 E 137.248691 F 89.0887563 F
86 83.9566272 F 46.7934293 D 117.172759 F 74.9046824 E
87 73.3852327 E 40.8767916 D 104.436932 F 65.9104617 E
88 67.4397896 E 37.3805035 D 97.2596882 F 60.7738357 E
89 62.5563703 E 34.6549063 C 91.4286094 F 56.6340833 E
90 59.1887027 E 32.7176479 C 87.4125385 F 53.7547652 D
91 56.3106525 E 30.8722711 C 83.8780893 F 51.1870084 D
92 55.0620048 E 30.3912748 C 82.5852662 F 50.2682723 D
93 53.6929157 D 29.5750791 C 80.9916836 F 49.0934462 D
94 50.3126733 D 27.2032505 C 76.6076608 E 45.9352512 D
95 49.7107042 D 26.8910865 C 76.016949 E 45.4635707 D
96 50.4796444 D 27.4821198 C 77.1908545 E 46.2430392 D
97 46.9423751 D 25.0757076 C 72.530449 E 42.9555929 D
98 49.5667284 D 26.8221093 C 76.1516774 E 45.4114329 D
99 45.8362134 D 24.3110393 C 71.2151727 E 41.9515483 D
100 52.0645268 D 28.4356688 C 79.4037261 E 47.6805968 D
After replacement analysis was done, replacement of cars only, bikes only and micros
changes can be seen in Delay and LOS for only leads to negative cycle length in the
different directions as per Table 6. calculation. Similarly, with the % replacement of
micros and cars, % replacement of bikes and
RESULTS micros, and, 100 % micros and %cars, the result
is unchanged. But, with the % replacement of
The replacement analysis (i.e. micros and cars, the cycle length is positive at a
replacement of bikes, micros &/or cars to buses) certain percentage. The LOS of each intersection
implies the intersection that Even 100 % is calculated individually. The minimum %